Latest / Politics with Paul / How to Mobilize and Motivate Supporters for Your Cause w/ Bert Ralston | Politics with Paul #80
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul Podcast, your home for nonpartisan discussion of
- 0:04political science and civics.
- 0:06I am your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:08We have another great guest today, and for such episodes, I always add a disclaimer that do not
- 0:13take a stance for or against a guest's political views or groups they support, but our
- 0:18topics are always something that people across the political spectrum can learn from.
- 0:24Now when it comes to campaigning for anything, be it a candidate, a ballot measure, a bill, or
- 0:30a policy, arguably the most critical component to that campaign is rallying and motivating
- 0:36supporters and like minded people.
- 0:38But it's not as simple as saying, Hey, we agree on this thing.
- 0:41Come support our effort.
- 0:43And then boom, you have your coalition.
- 0:44No.
- 0:45You must be able to find who those people are, have the right message, the resources to reach
- 0:50them, and more.
- 0:51So what are some tips and tricks for you to learn so that you can more effectively mobilize
- 0:56support for whatever your cause is?
- 0:59Well, that's something today's guest, Burt Ralston, is an expert in and here to discuss.
- 1:04Burt is the founder of Vox Populi Communications, a government relations, public
- 1:09affairs, and crisis management consulting firm based here in My Homestead, Florida.
- 1:13He's had a long career engaged in voter turnout programs and in the creation and influence of
- 1:19public policy and opinion, working on a wide range of elections, including judicial,
- 1:24mayoral, congressional, and governor races.
- 1:27Bert has also authored legislation that has been passed at the state and local levels, is a
- 1:32published author and public speaker, then a featured analyst on various news networks, and
- 1:38lectured on communication strategy for several universities.
- 1:41Now, let's get Bert's insight and expertise on communication strategy, particularly in the
- 1:48realm of mobilizing and motivating support for campaigns.
- 1:52So please welcome Bert Ralston to the podcast.
- 1:55Bert, thanks for coming on.
- 1:56How are you?
- 1:56I'm fine, Paul, and thank you so much for having me today, and thank you for everyone in
- 2:02on the interweb that's listening to us today.
- 2:05So I I hope it's a lot of fun.
- 2:07Yeah.
- 2:07As much fun for them as it will be for us.
- 2:09Yeah.
- 2:10Yeah.
- 2:10Absolutely.
- 2:11Absolutely.
- 2:12So I like to get a little bit to the beginning for guests whenever I I start things off.
- 2:17So how did you get started in the world of campaign consulting and communication strategy,
- 2:22and why were you drawn to that work?
- 2:24Started as a volunteer when I was in high school on a school board race for our local
- 2:31school board member.
- 2:31Liked it, liked the action activity.
- 2:36I was involved in college Republicans, young Republicans.
- 2:41At some point, I was drawn out of what I was doing by a candidate for the state senate who
- 2:49said, you know, you can actually get paid to do this.
- 2:51And I had no idea, absolutely no idea that it was a calling like that.
- 2:57Followed that guy.
- 2:58He ran for governor.
- 3:00Lost in the primary.
- 3:02And at that point, decided to go to DC, manage some congressional races, worked on the hill.
- 3:07And my last gig in DC was as a regional political director for the National Republican
- 3:14Congressional Committee.
- 3:16At that point, my then girlfriend, now wife of almost twenty seven years, decided she wanted
- 3:22be an attorney.
- 3:23And it came down to Georgetown and the University of Florida.
- 3:26You know, Steve Spurrier was still in Gainesville, so that's something I could
- 3:30entertain myself with while she was studying torts.
- 3:33So we moved back to Florida and the rest is history, and I love it.
- 3:37It's been a great life, and it's the only political campaigns give me the same thrill
- 3:45that I got when I was playing high school basketball.
- 3:47It's just immediate.
- 3:48It's fun.
- 3:49You you know the result of your efforts, and and it's finite.
- 3:53And that's that's fun too.
- 3:55I am a big fan of of playing basketball as well, myself.
- 3:59I didn't play it, organized.
- 4:00I I play at pickup all the time, but I am not a campaigner myself, but I do really enjoy
- 4:06learning the inner workings of campaigns and and and how they work and imparting that
- 4:10information to other people who don't necessarily get as easy of an inside look at
- 4:15that.
- 4:16So I'm really appreciative that you're here to to demonstrate that.
- 4:19But it is cool.
- 4:19It it really also goes to show,
- 4:21you know,
- 4:22something that as simple as just volunteering for our campaign, you never know what that's
- 4:26gonna lead to down the line.
- 4:29And part of your background I didn't get to mention in the intro was that you've trained
- 4:32over 5,000 aspiring operatives, activists, and candidates on constructing political campaigns.
- 4:40So what are two to three of the common mistakes that you see people early in their campaigning
- 4:45careers make in terms of mobilizing and motivating supporters for their campaigns or
- 4:50causes?
- 4:51I think in any campaign, no matter what level they are, there are three areas that need to be
- 4:57focused on money, message, and manpower.
- 5:01And if you're out of balance, you likely are not going to win.
- 5:05I I see folks commit to a grassroots campaign, but they forget that they're limited in the
- 5:12amount of people that they can reach by knocking on doors or waving signs or phone
- 5:16banks or whatever.
- 5:18I've seen folks that commit to money, and they lose the personal touch.
- 5:22We had a mayor's race here three years ago where the losing candidate outspent the winner,
- 5:28I think, by four to one, And they just relied on money and nothing else.
- 5:32So balance is very important, and that's not my idea.
- 5:35That's one of my mentor's ideas.
- 5:37You just kinda have to keep that in focus.
- 5:39The other thing is if you are a local activist, to believe that the consultant doesn't know how
- 5:51things are done where you are.
- 5:53I have heard so many times, well, this is how we do things here.
- 5:59It's like, well, maybe that's how you do things, but it's also done that way somewhere
- 6:04else.
- 6:05But 85% of every political campaign is the same as every other political campaign.
- 6:13Now there may be 15% differentials.
- 6:16Yard signs are not a big priority in Northern Virginia, but I promise you, if you go into
- 6:21Clay County, Florida, you're gonna come to an intersection that has 30 or 40 campaign signs
- 6:28on there.
- 6:29Now I would argue that the stoplight would have to be about six minutes long for you to read
- 6:36every every yard sign that's up there, so therefore you're not effective.
- 6:41But as a consultant, I have made the mistake, and I think hopefully I've grown out of it, of
- 6:47not listening to the people on the ground and kinda dismissing it because I'm the smart guy.
- 6:54You know?
- 6:54I'm the guy that's done this a lot.
- 6:56Well, guess what?
- 6:56They know their community better than I ever will.
- 6:59So you have to strike that balance between the the three legs of any successful campaign, but
- 7:08also between what's coming up and what's coming down.
- 7:11And as an activist, you have an opportunity to learn something new.
- 7:17Listen.
- 7:18Twenty five years ago, no one had a website, not like we do now.
- 7:24We all had to learn and adapt.
- 7:27Ten years ago, no one was doing programmatic digital advertising.
- 7:32Now you absolutely have to.
- 7:34Even if you are running for something as small as the soil and water board in Duval County,
- 7:39Florida.
- 7:40What's the new thing?
- 7:42Connected television.
- 7:44Streaming TV, your Hulus, your Rokus, all that kind of stuff.
- 7:48Paramount.
- 7:49Guess what?
- 7:50A plurality of eyeballs on big screens are on streaming TV.
- 7:54In June '24, it overtook cable, which fifteen years ago overtook broadcast.
- 8:00Learn.
- 8:01Adapt.
- 8:02And the neat thing about streaming is is that you can target it the same way you would a
- 8:06direct mail piece.
- 8:08You can find your voter when they're watching TV.
- 8:11Everyone's not seen that.
- 8:12So I guess that's more than two things, but learning and adapting, listening upstream and
- 8:18downstream.
- 8:19And I guess the final thing is you are constantly checking your premise.
- 8:24You're testing your premise.
- 8:26If you believe that you are strong with a certain type of voter, you're gonna know pretty
- 8:30quickly whether you are or not.
- 8:32You highlighted a couple of things.
- 8:34Think really are good piece of advice for even outside of political context is the need for
- 8:40balance and and all the resources at your disposal and, you know, constantly refining how
- 8:47you approach things.
- 8:49You know?
- 8:49Like you said, and we'll talk about in a little bit.
- 8:51You know?
- 8:52I mean, obviously, money helps, and you can sometimes drown out the opposition.
- 8:55But if if it's a relatively competitive race and your message isn't there, then it's Yeah.
- 9:00You're you're probably gonna lose.
- 9:02Or and then, you know, you talked about, you know, people on the ground being more, you
- 9:07know, closer to the action, and you you do have to take that into account.
- 9:10But then, you know, at the same time, they have their own blind spots as well.
- 9:14So somebody who has it that more 30,000 foot view can also give their insight.
- 9:19And but like you said, you always have to be open to new information coming in, and that's
- 9:25even outside of the context of crafting your message just whenever you are debating things
- 9:31in politics, you know, it's obviously always good to at least entertain other possibilities,
- 9:38not just be set in your ways just for the sake of being set in your ways.
- 9:41But back to the point about you talking about how basically money is not the only thing,
- 9:48because it may not seem like this to the general public, but campaigns do have limited
- 9:52resources, even the most well funded ones.
- 9:54You can't you can't do everything that you could possibly wanna do in a campaign.
- 9:59Now, obviously, more money is a big advantage in a race, but there have been plenty of
- 10:04examples of campaigns across the levels of government where a less funded candidate wins
- 10:09the election because their communication mobilization strategies are better.
- 10:12You even look at 2016, for example, with Donald Trump being outspent, I think, three to one by
- 10:17Hillary Clinton, and he still wins.
- 10:19Now, obviously, he lost a popular vote, but he still won the presidential election.
- 10:23But how much can simply having more money for your campaign make up for flaws in your
- 10:29messaging strategies?
- 10:32Yeah.
- 10:32I mean, Trump did lose the popular vote, but
- 10:34Okay.
- 10:36Trump did lose the popular vote, but we don't win or lose presidential races because of the
- 10:42popular vote.
- 10:42And that's something you have to take into account.
- 10:45What are the rules?
- 10:49Are you in a 50% plus one scenario?
- 10:52Or like in our state legislative races, are you in oftentimes a plurality scenario?
- 10:57What are the rules?
- 10:58And that's how you get your vote target and you build your campaign around that.
- 11:03Money is important, but again, it's all about balance.
- 11:06If you are all about money, then where's your engagement with the actual voter?
- 11:12Where are you even a Potemkin strategy of going out, taking a picture in front of someone's
- 11:18door and then posting it on Facebook, that's limited in value because typically Facebook's
- 11:25organic and it's your friends and a couple of spies that are following you.
- 11:29So you have to commit to doing well at three different things, raising money, but enough to
- 11:38get your strategy out.
- 11:39Money alone is not going to win it for you, but having more than the other guy is not going win
- 11:43it for you.
- 11:43Ask Kamala Harris.
- 11:45But knocking on every door six times and not doing direct mail is not going to win it for
- 11:52you either.
- 11:52It just doesn't work that way.
- 11:54You have to have balance because you have to reach voters where they are.
- 11:57And we also know that Americans now having a lim a limited attention span.
- 12:02So I've got to be in front of them more than when I started thirty years ago in order to
- 12:08persuade someone you need five touches.
- 12:10We're eight to 11 right now.
- 12:13You really need to be in front of them in a multichannel approach.
- 12:17And a channel can be someone at your door.
- 12:19A channel can be direct mail.
- 12:21A channel can be pre roll.
- 12:23It can be a lot of different things, but you have to be out there.
- 12:26You basically are storming the field.
- 12:29You want people to think, man, this person's everywhere.
- 12:33That's the approach I try to take.
- 12:35And it's an approach that is difficult for some.
- 12:40Here's where it's difficult.
- 12:42This is really interesting.
- 12:44If you're a first time candidate, you're probably going to be very challenged by the
- 12:49notion that just because you've been involved in your local civic association or your rotary
- 12:54club or whatever, that everyone doesn't already know you.
- 12:59Okay?
- 13:00That's a challenge, and you've got to teach people to spread.
- 13:04But if you are moving up from, let's say, city council to state house, it is impossible to
- 13:16just do more of what you did before.
- 13:19You have to be smarter.
- 13:21You have to be better.
- 13:22You have to understand that the retention rate of most people is not nine months after you
- 13:30knocked on their door.
- 13:32You know?
- 13:34We our egos force us into that thinking.
- 13:37I think people remember me.
- 13:38I'm the most forgettable person on the planet.
- 13:41But you have to push and push and push a candidate and their people to understand that,
- 13:49yeah, I got to raise a little bit of money.
- 13:51Just because you made it to city council knocking on a bunch of doors, that's not
- 13:55enough.
- 13:56Stretching people, pushing people, helping them understand that it's more than just your your
- 14:03beaming massage and your dazzling personality that got you elected the first time.
- 14:08And that's that's always been a challenge for me when people are moving up, when they're
- 14:12trying to step up.
- 14:13And when they move to federal, they get it.
- 14:16Typically, it's local to state where that's the biggest challenge.
- 14:19You know, there's just kinda highlight of the something I've talked about with other guests
- 14:24that I've had on this podcast is the you just talked about how, you know, we think
- 14:28everybody's paying attention to us, is kind of obnoxious, really.
- 14:32It's like, no.
- 14:33No.
- 14:33And even if they want to pay attention, not even a matter of them being lazy or uninformed.
- 14:38It's just they have a whole bunch of other things going on in their lives.
- 14:42They have got to take care of their families.
- 14:44They gotta go to work, whatever the case may be, or they've got other hobbies that they they
- 14:48wanna do, which I can totally respect.
- 14:50I've got other hobbies that I I'm involved in.
- 14:52I've got other things I've got to do as well.
- 14:54But we can't just assume that these people know who we are just because we've been getting out
- 14:59there.
- 14:59There's not like a sign over people's heads that say, Oh, I've heard of you, and that could
- 15:04just rely on.
- 15:05And even if they have heard of you, sometimes you gotta constantly be on top of mind.
- 15:09Our mutual friend, former professor of mine, Roger Austin, talking about a couple times in
- 15:14class, like, why do Coke and Pepsi do ads?
- 15:18Almost everybody knows who they are.
- 15:19It's you stay on top of mind, and then you see an ad for Coke or Pepsi, you go, oh, yeah.
- 15:24You know what?
- 15:25I could go for one right now.
- 15:26It's a similar thing with with campaign ads, and I know I mean, it's frustrating for me to
- 15:31have to see all these campaign ads just bombard everybody one to two months before an election,
- 15:37but that's what they have to do to keep on top of your mind.
- 15:40So, you know, that's what you said just I mean, obviously a a a perfect highlight for that.
- 15:48But another aspect to the whole limited resources for campaigns, it's also imperative
- 15:53for campaigns to figure out so regardless of whether they they know who you are, it is
- 15:59imperative for campaigns to figure out not only well, this might actually be part of it.
- 16:03Not only who their potential supporters are, but which ones need more of a nudge to come out
- 16:09to support your campaign such as by voting, obviously.
- 16:12So how do you distinguish between these citizens who are ardent supporters of your
- 16:16cause and so therefore you don't really need to push them as much versus citizens who are solid
- 16:22supporters, but you'll need to advertise them a little bit more?
- 16:25And then those citizens who need a lot of pushing to come out to support you.
- 16:28How do you distinguish between those groups?
- 16:30Well, the modern age is gives us many benefits, and, you know, we've I've already dated myself,
- 16:38so I'm I'm not in any way I'm not afraid of doing so even further.
- 16:46Put it in perspective.
- 16:47When I first got started, we would go down to the supervisor of elections office.
- 16:54And you know those IBM dot matrix green and white report sheets that used to be out there,
- 17:01we'd get voter files that way.
- 17:04I mean, they were this big for a Now reason that was I prefer to subscribe to any of the,
- 17:16software packages or platforms that do daily updates, bless you, on who's and therefore I
- 17:26can target my resources, whether it be financial or human resources, to go after those
- 17:32folks.
- 17:33I know I I had an interesting conversation at an American Association of Political
- 17:38Consultants convention five years ago, six years ago with the senior vice president for
- 17:45politics for a company called L two.
- 17:47They're one of the big five data firms in in North America.
- 17:51And he said that if you're 35 years old plus with a combined household income of around
- 17:58$75,000 there are over 70,000 data points on you.
- 18:05Now, and that's a little overwhelming to comprehend.
- 18:09But within that, I can tell you every time you have voted in your life since you've been in a
- 18:18particular geographic designation.
- 18:21And from that, if you're a four four, if you voted four out of the last four that look like
- 18:26the election we're in, I know you're gonna show up.
- 18:30Okay?
- 18:31You're my first target because I wanna make sure that not only is my client's name ID where
- 18:38it should be with you, and we can talk about name ID, but that the attributes attached to
- 18:44you, to your client are there.
- 18:48Good that if you're a four four guy that has a concealed carry permit and my person's a two a
- 18:55absolutist, well, you're the first person I'm talking to.
- 19:00If you were a four four member of Greenpeace and my person is, all about the environment
- 19:08and, you know, whatever, then that's who I'm talking to there.
- 19:14So, so I know with a high level of certainty who you are and whether you're gonna show up.
- 19:19It's when we get to the two fours, the two out of the last four, elections, those are the
- 19:26people that take more time to persuade.
- 19:29Now they may be with you on the issues, but they're just, you know, for whatever reason,
- 19:35you know, they, they hate politics.
- 19:37They hate government.
- 19:38They hate whatever they hate.
- 19:40They are only show showing up when they are properly motivated.
- 19:44Those are the people that I'm sending someone to their door.
- 19:47Maybe the candidate, depending on the size of the race, you know, go out there and let's,
- 19:53let's have that, that, that beaming visage and that charming personality.
- 19:57And let's, let's get those votes.
- 19:58I know how to chase absentee voters.
- 20:01You know, we know that they're about 90% likely to vote.
- 20:06Early voting has made things interesting.
- 20:08You know, when I got started, campaigns were designed to peak, and they peaked on election
- 20:13day because that's the only time you got to vote.
- 20:17Now we plateau.
- 20:18You know, we have about a one month period where people have the opportunity to vote prior
- 20:23to election day.
- 20:24So we plateau by using primarily on, you know, people that have a history of early voting.
- 20:30We do a lot of digital.
- 20:31We do geotargeting where we'll put a fence around a particular precinct on the peak early
- 20:37voting days.
- 20:39So if you're in line and you're looking at your mobile device, my person's ad is showing up.
- 20:45We do a lot of things like that.
- 20:46I've actually won an award for doing that kind of thing down in Osceola County.
- 20:51And I'm just bragging.
- 20:52I'd no one really cares what awards I've won.
- 20:54I just like to brag about the fact that I won Apollo awards.
- 20:57It only took me thirty years.
- 21:01So you you and you know, with with absentee voters, there's a process where you request an
- 21:08absentee ballot.
- 21:09The overseas ballots go out first, so you have to chase them with mail.
- 21:12You can kind of build a dataset around them to hit them with digital.
- 21:17I don't like emails.
- 21:18People don't respond too well to them.
- 21:20Text messaging is limited in value.
- 21:22People believe it to be somewhat intrusive, but with Programmatic Digital, and I use a company
- 21:28called Republican Ads.
- 21:29In fact, I represent Republican Ads and they are, you know, on, they are the tip of the
- 21:35spear on technique and technology and just being incredibly good at what they do, at what
- 21:40we do.
- 21:41You can chase people around very efficiently.
- 21:44I can do a touch with the digital ad for about 7¢.
- 21:48With a direct mail piece, it's 80¢.
- 21:50Now I'm going to do both.
- 21:52I'm absolutely going to do both.
- 21:54For 80¢ in digital, I can touch you 10 times.
- 21:58I can wear you out.
- 22:00With texting, it's an event.
- 22:01It's not a process.
- 22:02You pay per text.
- 22:03So, those are the kind of things you do.
- 22:07And then on election day, you know, the ramp up the weekend beforehand, you're swarming people
- 22:12out there.
- 22:12Again, you've looked at your updated voter file.
- 22:16Most most supervisors update daily so you know who has voted.
- 22:22And I have the phone banks going.
- 22:24I have paid phones going.
- 22:26I have texts going.
- 22:27I have digital going.
- 22:28I have people showing up at the doors.
- 22:31I'm doing everything I can to get those folks that should be my voters to show up.
- 22:38Everything short and here's the the left is very good at doing, mass events.
- 22:45Okay.
- 22:48In many jurisdictions throughout the country, the, primarily African American churches do
- 22:53what's called souls to the polls.
- 22:55After church on Sunday, that's the big day, final day of early voting.
- 23:00Vans will be lined up and taking people down to vote.
- 23:04And it's a really big day.
- 23:05The right is not good at that.
- 23:06We are I've always felt it's because folks just kinda wanna be independent in nature on the
- 23:13right.
- 23:15But we're not very good at that.
- 23:16What we are good at is giving people a task to completion, whether it be a phone bank.
- 23:23And phone banking's gotten so much easier now.
- 23:25You can just download an app and a list shows up.
- 23:28You don't have to go to a a vacant office space where there, you know, eight foot plastic
- 23:34tables and metal chairs and two day old pizza and all that kind of stuff sitting out there.
- 23:39You can do it from home and you're tracked.
- 23:42I mean, whoever is managing that process will know if you're making those calls or not.
- 23:46So technology has really helped there too.
- 23:49My ramble's over, Paul.
- 23:50It can sound very silly.
- 23:51Oh, no.
- 23:52No.
- 23:52No.
- 23:52That's perfectly fine.
- 23:53Whatever whatever you gotta say to to get the answer out is is perfectly fine.
- 23:57But it it does it can seem very to people listening, you know, you hear all of that
- 24:02information that's at campaigns disposals.
- 24:05It can sound very scary.
- 24:06Like, wow.
- 24:07They know all these things about us, but it's it's just been a lot of refinement over time of
- 24:13campaign strategies.
- 24:13Now for those at home, voter rolls, I mean, it depending on state will tell you different
- 24:18different information.
- 24:19Not one state might have information that you wouldn't find in another state.
- 24:24The the campaigns also have a lot of other data that they don't necessarily have on voter rolls
- 24:29either.
- 24:29Like, if you're in specific, like like, a couple of examples that Burt just used, like
- 24:35Greenpeace or NRA.
- 24:37That those won't necessarily appear on a regular voter roll that you'd get from a local
- 24:42government, but the campaigns will have a lot of that information because of how you voted in
- 24:47the past and how they've targeted you before.
- 24:49So there is there is that information.
- 24:51It can be very scary that there that all that information is out there, but they can't
- 24:55actually see directly who you voted for.
- 24:57It's just based on certain behaviors.
- 25:00It's there's a pretty good chance that they can figure out who you voted for based on your
- 25:05interest and how you voted in the past and where you live and things like that.
- 25:09Yeah.
- 25:10We call it modeling, and modeling scales down to about a large state Senate race where we can
- 25:17pretty much put together who we think is going to be there, what we need to say to them, semi
- 25:24predictive in nature.
- 25:25It's predictive to the point where if you do what you're supposed to do based upon your
- 25:30model, then you should get the outcome that you hope for.
- 25:34Yeah.
- 25:36Every once in a while, of course, you will find somebody who steps out of the line that you
- 25:42expect them to be in, and those are always the kinds of people that I'm interest or I'm I'm
- 25:47interested in those kinds of people especially too.
- 25:49Like, if somebody has, like, coexist stickers and and Greenpeace and everything, but they
- 25:55happen to vote Republican a lot or, like, somebody who has a whole bunch of stuff about
- 25:59guns and and, you know, America, love it or leave it, but they tend to vote Democrat.
- 26:04Those are the kinds of people like, wow.
- 26:06Well, I I wanna know what makes those people tick just because they're just completely
- 26:09different than what you would expect from all the paraphernalia that they have.
- 26:14But that also is a good segue into this question.
- 26:17So all else equal, so let's just say we're not concerned about the the amount of money they
- 26:22have.
- 26:23They're they the manpower they have is fine.
- 26:25They've got a pretty capable group that is helping them campaign.
- 26:30All else equal, do you see any fundamental differences in mobilization and motivation
- 26:36strategies between Republican, Democratic, and independent campaigns?
- 26:41And if so, what would you say are one to two unique aspects to mobilization strategy for
- 26:45each of those groups?
- 26:47Yeah.
- 26:47I mean, let's talk about independents or NPAs right now.
- 26:51There is a strategy to attract them, but independent candidates historically have not
- 26:55done terribly well in The United States just based upon our system.
- 26:59Our system requires that you put on a jersey, unless it's a nonpartisan race.
- 27:03But you you are putting on either a red jersey or a blue jersey, and that's that's just gonna
- 27:08be what it's gonna be.
- 27:09And we've had some well pen well funded independent campaigns out there.
- 27:13John Anderson, Ross Perot, long gone are the days in the mid nineteenth century where we
- 27:18have five different parties out there being represented.
- 27:23It just doesn't work that way here anymore.
- 27:25Structurally, it's virtually impossible for ballot access.
- 27:28Now in terms of strategies and tactics that, are different between the left and the right, I
- 27:39will tell you that in the early two thousand teens, the left dominated in tech.
- 27:48We, on the right, don't quite have parity, but no longer are we five cycles behind.
- 27:53We're maybe one cycle behind.
- 27:55And I think that's primarily because most of the tech thinking happens in Silicon Valley and
- 28:01it's funded by the left.
- 28:02That's, that's going to be what happens less so than it used to be.
- 28:05I think the right is better in cause to action movements, getting people on the ground, doing
- 28:12things for free.
- 28:14We don't have to pay people to go out and do something.
- 28:18The left, it's been clearly demonstrated over the past at least year.
- 28:25But going back to COVID times, they pay people to get out on the street.
- 28:29Here's an interesting anecdote.
- 28:31I was I was in DC the day that the Supreme Court overturned Roe v.
- 28:37Wade.
- 28:38I happened to be at a place that was three blocks away from the Supreme Court and right
- 28:43across the street from the Capitol South Metro Station.
- 28:46We finished our coffee.
- 28:48We came outside, and within thirty minutes of the Supreme Court's ruling being released,
- 28:56people were swarming out of the Metro and on the streets and the surrounding neighborhood
- 29:03with signs, pro row signs.
- 29:05And that doesn't happen organically.
- 29:08That happens because there's a plan in place.
- 29:11This was 10:40 in the morning.
- 29:14They weren't all college students, unemployed, or stay at home fathers or mothers.
- 29:20This was their career.
- 29:22So you're seeing a lot more paid activism on the left.
- 29:24You're seeing much more organic activism on the right.
- 29:28You look at something like a turning point that is, in my opinion, one of the most impactful
- 29:35youth movements of my life.
- 29:37And I've seen a lot of them, but these people aren't paid to be there.
- 29:40These people aren't paid to start these chapters and they're they're everywhere.
- 29:44So I think that's the primary difference.
- 29:46I think the way we communicate to each other is a little different.
- 29:50The right and listen, don't get me wrong.
- 29:53And and I exist in the bubble of the right, but I find our language to be a bit more
- 29:57aspirational.
- 29:59Some is fear based, but the fear is based in aspiration.
- 30:05You know?
- 30:05If we got rid of this horrible thing, think how good we could be over here.
- 30:10The left has become more strident and fear based in their, in their messaging, at least
- 30:17since the Obama administration.
- 30:19I was on the Hilder and Clinton, and I thought what, you know, I thought Bill Clinton's great
- 30:24gift was his ability to make people think that together their lives could be better.
- 30:32Obama had a very fear based model.
- 30:34Biden, you know, if I were to offer an opinion of Biden, it would just be a bad joke.
- 30:39So I'm not gonna do that.
- 30:41But certainly now in the first thirteen months of the second Trump administration, the left
- 30:46has grown more more strident and fear based in in their in their messaging.
- 30:52Going back to the point you had about, you know, paid activists for or saying how the left
- 31:00has more paid activists versus the right.
- 31:04I wonder if that's partly because how based on trying to pull back from some of my studies
- 31:12back from grad school, how basically looking at, like, some of, like, the personality traits
- 31:18and stuff about Republicans versus Democrats.
- 31:21And I wonder if part of it is because Republicans tend to be a bit more uniform and
- 31:27cohesive in their a, they're they're the demographically, they're not as wide ranging as
- 31:34as Democrats, and then they tend to be a little bit more uniform ideologically.
- 31:39So I wonder if that is partly makes it easier for Republican groups like Turning Point you
- 31:45you talked about.
- 31:46Maybe makes it easier for them to convince young Republicans to, hey.
- 31:51Come be part of this cause.
- 31:53Whereas for Democrats, when they're inherently more of a coalition, it might be a little bit
- 31:59harder to convince some of them to work together just because there can be some level
- 32:04of competing interest.
- 32:05Do you do you see it that way, or do you think that's not really part of the equation?
- 32:10You know, Paul, I'm glad you brought that up because I remember back in the early being
- 32:17engaged in a conversation with a Democrat friend of mine, and, yes, I do have friends
- 32:23that are Democrats, asking him how they kept their coalition together of San Francisco
- 32:29social justice warriors and Midwestern steel workers and auto workers.
- 32:35How did they do that?
- 32:36What does that room look like?
- 32:38And it's a heck of a struggle.
- 32:39But on the right, we have always struggled with keeping those that are motivated and whose
- 32:47worldview is determined primarily by their faith, engaged with Wall Street interests or
- 32:53just larger business entities.
- 32:56So there are some balancing acts that have to occur there too.
- 33:00But I think you make a very good point in asking that question.
- 33:04Yeah.
- 33:04Yeah.
- 33:04Sure.
- 33:06Inherently, there is a little bit of a coalition to both parties.
- 33:09I mean, that's what parties are.
- 33:10They're basically giant coalitions.
- 33:12Maybe not quite the same as you'd see in some European countries where a lot of them have to
- 33:17have coalitions to govern, but they are big parties are still inherently coalition based,
- 33:22and so you do have to deal with one faction maybe at odds with another faction as well.
- 33:28So, I mean, that that's a good point too.
- 33:30Now while con people's concept though of campaign of a political campaign, it's
- 33:36typically individual candidates running for an office against each other, which obviously that
- 33:40makes sense.
- 33:40That's what most of these campaigns are gonna be, or at least the ones that we're talking
- 33:44about.
- 33:45There are several other types of campaigns too, and so I wanted to get your your take on
- 33:49mobilization strategies for them.
- 33:51And one of them is this trying to pass or defeat a state or local ballot measure.
- 33:57What would you say are two to three unique aspects to mobilizing and motivating voters to
- 34:03turn out to vote on a ballot measure as opposed to individual people, or do you really think
- 34:08that it's not all that unique comparatively?
- 34:12I know it's there there are some aspects that are different.
- 34:15I was involved in helping to defeat a couple of ballot initiatives last cycle, but I've been
- 34:20involved in trying to pass ballot initiatives.
- 34:22And, and again, and when you're trying to pass a ballot initiative, you are selling benefits.
- 34:30You are saying, this is why it is good for you to do this.
- 34:32Now they can be very personal benefits or they can be benefits that make you feel good about
- 34:38yourself.
- 34:38I was not a part of this, but when they were trying to sell the notion of decriminalized
- 34:44recreational marijuana, they were trying to sell the benefits of all the tax money that was
- 34:49going to come in.
- 34:50You know, you can get rid of organized crime and the cartels and all that.
- 34:55They were selling that benefit when they were twenty, thirty years ago getting rid of
- 35:01pregnant pigs in cages, that ballot initiative.
- 35:05They wanted people to feel good about themselves because they were protecting the
- 35:09pigs.
- 35:10And that's fine.
- 35:11And whatever, you know, if, if you are selling something like that, that's your job.
- 35:17Now, when you're working to defeat medical marijuana or, I'm sorry, recreational
- 35:23marijuana, you are selling the reasons why it's bad.
- 35:28Some used the term fear based earlier.
- 35:30Okay.
- 35:31I mean, it's all hyperbole on either side, but, you are letting people know why it is bad.
- 35:41And it's a binary choice and it's a very simple choice.
- 35:44It's a black and white choice.
- 35:45There's less nuance than when there are candidates involved for a specific office.
- 35:50Another thing that I remember back from back from grad school, I couldn't can't remember
- 35:57what his name was, but he'd been somebody who'd also been involved in a lot of ballot measure
- 36:02campaigns and something that he said in particular really stuck with me.
- 36:07It was basically, to paraphrase him, that all else equal, campaigning for the no side tends
- 36:14to be easier than the yes side.
- 36:17Basically, because in the no side, you just have to sow a little bit of doubt as to whether
- 36:21this ballot measure is more beneficial than not beneficial.
- 36:26Whereas for the yes side, you have to convince people, maybe not entirely that they need to
- 36:31vote for it, but at least that you have to convince them pretty handily that, yes, they
- 36:36need this ballot measure to be passed.
- 36:39Do you have you felt that way too from your experience?
- 36:43Well, first off, I think I know who you're talking about, it but sounds like an old friend
- 36:48of mine.
- 36:48But secondly, I'm in, I'm in total agreement.
- 36:51Listen, humanity is change adverse.
- 36:54We love keeping things the way they are and convincing ourselves that we can make better
- 37:01what already exists.
- 37:03I'm fine with that.
- 37:04It is those that have vision that scare people.
- 37:08It just absolutely terrifies folks.
- 37:11I think a lot of what you're seeing right now from the left, oddly enough, is fear of change
- 37:17to our federal structures.
- 37:22Many oxes are being gored right now.
- 37:25We all agree that government spends too much, but by golly, by gum, we don't want to go out
- 37:30and find out where it is and get rid of it.
- 37:33And that's caused a high level of disconcern amongst the left.
- 37:38But the right fears things too.
- 37:41We don't like change also.
- 37:43And I think that's why it's easier to beat down a ballot initiative than pass one.
- 37:48Yeah.
- 37:49And admittedly, I'm not necessarily the most amenable to change either.
- 37:54And, you know, the point you talked about with with the debt, I think that's I think the
- 37:57national debt and the deficit have a particular issue with that in the sense that whoever it is
- 38:05who is in power, you know, pretty much everybody's gonna say that this level of debt
- 38:10and deficit is not sustainable, and they're very willing to change other people's or
- 38:15spending on other people's programs, but they don't ever wanna cut the spending for their
- 38:19programs.
- 38:19And then so it's, you know, you don't really get to it's hard to make a serious dent in the
- 38:25debt if everybody is still stuck in, I'm not gonna cut any of my programs too.
- 38:30So I guess that's that kind of is a demonstration of that.
- 38:34But actually, guess that's kind of a good segue into this next point.
- 38:39And another type of campaign that people don't necessarily think of as a campaign is trying to
- 38:44rally the public to support or pass a bill being discussed in congress or a state
- 38:48legislature.
- 38:50So what are two to three unique aspects to mobilizing and motivating voters and citizens
- 38:56to pressure their legislators to vote on a bill in a certain way, whether it's yes or no?
- 39:01So, you know, it's interesting because that industry has really come into its own in the
- 39:07last ten years and technology has, it's doing amazing things.
- 39:11The old way was send a piece of direct mail to people that you think agree with you, urging
- 39:17them, or here's something novel.
- 39:20Take out a newspaper ad and get people to pick up the phone and call their representative for
- 39:26whatever body.
- 39:27Or we're all putting on the same color shirt and we're going down to the chambers and we're
- 39:33going to get loud and we're going to let them know how upset we are.
- 39:36Well, now through a couple of different forms, through programmatic digital, I can go find who
- 39:45cares about this type of thing, drop them in an ad, have them click through to a site, a
- 39:52landing page where they can either send an email, where they have there's one fascinating
- 39:58service called, CiviClick, where they give you, like, language that's standard, but they use AI
- 40:04to change it up a little bit.
- 40:06So you're not all sending the same letter.
- 40:08So it gets read once, and then they just count how many people did it.
- 40:11But you can send an email to your legislator.
- 40:15You can you you can do patch through phone calls that has whomever you're trying to
- 40:21contact.
- 40:21You get a text and and it's like, if you want to call representative so and so about such and
- 40:28such, press here.
- 40:29And they already have all your voter information there.
- 40:33They know who your rep is.
- 40:35And you're on the phone with their legislative, whoever's answering the phone.
- 40:38Typically, it's, you know, a 23 year old who's like, god, I'm having a bad day.
- 40:43I had to field 800 phone calls today.
- 40:45And that's a lot of fun because you can really bomb people in submission that way.
- 40:49And then we have, you know, we have, through Republican ads, done some really fun stuff with
- 40:55geofencing, just like we do on precincts, targeting state capitals with our message.
- 41:02We had a situation in North Carolina a couple years ago where a state senator literally
- 41:07called the people in opposition to a particular bill and asked him to please stop, that the
- 41:12bill was dead.
- 41:13Everyone's just tired of getting the ads.
- 41:15We're involved in a tax issue in Missouri right now through a third party doing the same
- 41:21settings.
- 41:21So that's a lot of fun.
- 41:22Yeah.
- 41:22People still show up for their legislative days and yes, there is value on that, but technology
- 41:28has really made it so much more efficient and, interestingly, create an opportunity for more
- 41:33people to participate in the process and get their thoughts across to their elected
- 41:39officials.
- 41:40Interesting.
- 41:41I wonder also if it's trying to think of how to phrase this question.
- 41:45Is it necessarily, like, how obviously you have, like, a voter role that you you go by?
- 41:50If we're talking about, you know, getting people to vote for a candidate, you have the
- 41:54voter role, and you have all the information about them about their voting habits and
- 41:57everything.
- 41:58Do you have something similar for people who I mean, I I guess it's a lot harder to, you know,
- 42:03log how how people are how many people are participating in some sort of rally against a a
- 42:09bill.
- 42:10But do you is there something sort of similar like that for getting people to rally for or
- 42:15against a bill or trying to influence their legislators to vote a certain way on a bill as
- 42:21opposed to trying to get those same people to come out to vote?
- 42:24There I mean, yes.
- 42:26It's a little different, but there are some large nationwide organizations that have their
- 42:31data, their files of people that have in whatever way engaged with them on particular
- 42:37issues.
- 42:38But you remember I was talking about the data broker that I met at a conference.
- 42:44Well, those 72,000 data points aren't all just where you buy your gasoline, where you live,
- 42:50and what part of your registered to.
- 42:52I'm going to know what from consumer data.
- 42:55I'm going know what kind of purchases you've made.
- 42:57Getting back to two way stuff.
- 43:00They're going to that consumer data.
- 43:03No, actually I'm not going to say two way stuff because I don't think that exists.
- 43:06If you have registered a weapon, if you filed for a concealed carry permit, I'm going know
- 43:11it's all public record.
- 43:13So if we have one of those types of issues, we had in Florida post Parkland, I'm going to
- 43:18rally folks against that.
- 43:19I was not involved in any of that just as a disclaimer, because I don't want, I don't wanna
- 43:25get doxxed and have my phone blow up.
- 43:27But, I but consumer information or social associations, whether you're a member of Rotary
- 43:38or Kiwanis, or you sit on any, any C three boards, it's all public record.
- 43:45I mean, you know, the salvation army has their local board of directors listed on their
- 43:50website.
- 43:52Are people out there gathering up all that information, doing matches and adding that
- 43:57little marker onto your file.
- 44:00It is fascinating how much is out there.
- 44:03I can literally make a request to a data broker and say, here's my geographic area, whether
- 44:10it's a political geography or a consumer geography.
- 44:14Here are my age parameters.
- 44:16Here are my, gender parameters.
- 44:19Here are my income parameters.
- 44:21And I want them, I want to know if they care about this in the same way I care about it and
- 44:26in the same way my client cares about it within roughly twenty four hours.
- 44:30And that's lengthy.
- 44:32I'm going to have a file that I can start communicating with.
- 44:35Gotcha.
- 44:36So, yeah, that is a it's it is just going back to what we talked about just how much data is
- 44:42available on here, just how incredible and somewhat intimidating, but it also just goes to
- 44:46show just how why big data is such a lucrative business now just knowing all these data points
- 44:53to make your campaigns or whatever it is you're doing even easier.
- 44:57I I wanna I do wanna move back since we are coming up close to the end.
- 45:03I do wanna go back to real quick the regular kind of elections that we need we typically
- 45:08think of.
- 45:09So it's a long standing reality that presidential elections get the highest turnout
- 45:13rates compared to midterms and odd years and special elections.
- 45:18But occasionally, you do see jumps in those non presidential turnout rates.
- 45:22My my let's just talk about midterms, though, just to to make it easier and and more narrowly
- 45:27focused.
- 45:28So what is it that motivates and mobilizes voters in those higher turnout midterm races
- 45:34compared to lower turnouts in in midterms, or is it really just a case by case kind of basis?
- 45:41That that's that's a really good question.
- 45:43And I've been thinking about that for about a day now, just from an academic standpoint.
- 45:50And typically what turns voters out is either the economy or social issues.
- 45:57Now, if there is a variable in there, I mean, look at the 94 when turnout was very heavy on
- 46:10the right.
- 46:11People were afraid of interestingly about Hillary care and the right really turned out
- 46:18because they did not want that type of thing to happen.
- 46:23In '98 turnout was down a little bit because people hated everybody.
- 46:30They they hated Clinton.
- 46:31They they they intuitively believed that something unseemly had occurred in in the Oval
- 46:37Office, but they also thought that the Republicans had overreached.
- 46:41So they just kinda stayed home.
- 46:43You do see spikes in congressional districts when there's a compelling race going on and
- 46:49maybe one person is overwhelmingly popular compared to the other person.
- 46:54But it's a struggle.
- 46:56There was an article that came out last year that defined the new swing boater as people
- 47:05that showed up sometimes because everyone is so we're on our sides right now.
- 47:11The middle has shrunk over the past decade or so, actually, to go along with that.
- 47:16But so now the swing boater that we always felt we chased and we are always looking for a new
- 47:22definition for was literally the person that voted every once in a while.
- 47:27So that's kind of the golden ring these days.
- 47:30And it goes to your question, how do you get them to vote?
- 47:34I think we find that it's different every cycle.
- 47:38I mean, we know what we know how to do, but there's some smart person out there, probably
- 47:43half my age that is coming out with a new way of figuring that out.
- 47:48And then we're all going to do it.
- 47:50And then there's gonna be an evolution into the next thing.
- 47:53That doesn't answer your question, but it's more of an observation.
- 47:57Well, I mean, it is, like you said, it's a tough question to answer, and I'd be curious to
- 48:04see if any more academic studies go into really the depths of that.
- 48:09Like, what exactly?
- 48:10I mean, obviously, there's some historical precedent like you talked about with 1994 and
- 48:151998, but having more concrete, you know, data points on all the possibilities for it, it will
- 48:24will definitely be interesting to see.
- 48:25And now especially with with this year, you know, with the economy not I mean, sometimes
- 48:31it's you know, some people obviously will argue whether your economy is doing well or not, but
- 48:35sometimes not even necessarily about whether the economy is doing well.
- 48:38It's whether people perceive it's doing well or whether it's doing well for them specifically.
- 48:42So economy is always working for somebody and then for somebody else, it's not working.
- 48:47But Yeah.
- 48:48Also, you talked about with social issues.
- 48:50Now, also, as you astutely pointed out earlier that over the course of nine months, a lot of
- 48:56things can change and people will will will forget a lot of things.
- 48:59But with what's going on with immigration right now with with ICE, interested to see how much
- 49:05of a role that plays in midterms this year, whether it leads to lower Republican turnout or
- 49:12higher Democratic turnout or even some crossover votes.
- 49:15Who knows?
- 49:16But that that'll that'll definitely be something very interesting to look forward to,
- 49:20and especially with whatever happens over the course of the next nine months, because nine
- 49:26months is an eternity in campaigning.
- 49:30So one last thing before I get to the random question of the day that I like to do with my
- 49:34guests.
- 49:34While I like to include as much practical and actionable information in these podcasts as
- 49:39possible, and you've already given a whole bunch away, which I'm obviously very thankful
- 49:43for, I always like to ask at least one specific question devoted to that.
- 49:49So what are two to three pieces of advice you'd give anybody who is trying to craft
- 49:54mobilization strategies for a campaign?
- 49:56Regardless of what the campaign is for or what the party is or anything like that, what are
- 50:01two to three pieces of advice you'd give?
- 50:04Know your audience.
- 50:05Very much know who you are trying to motivate.
- 50:08And in that, understand if what you want to do is attainable or not.
- 50:12Know.
- 50:14I mean, it's a really good question, Paul.
- 50:16And I wish I thought more about it, but yeah, you've got to know who you're and you have to
- 50:20know what your target is.
- 50:21I mean, what, what is your target number?
- 50:23If I'm going after X, but I need two X to get there.
- 50:27Well, clearly X is only a piece of it.
- 50:30So what else do I need?
- 50:32Know the difference between a fact and a problem.
- 50:35And I know that sounds a little hippy dippy, but I had a client once that said, well, this
- 50:43certain segment of the population likes me.
- 50:45I'm like, well, you know, there are two members of that population that look exactly like the
- 50:52population and you don't.
- 50:54And that's a fact.
- 50:56Now it's a problem if we spend a lot of money trying to chase these folks that are never
- 51:01gonna vote for you.
- 51:02And that that was a battle that took about three weeks.
- 51:06So understand understanding what the goal is.
- 51:10Understand who your people are and and how you build that coalition in order to get you to
- 51:15success.
- 51:16Understand what it's gonna take to get there and understand take opinion and emotion out of
- 51:22decision making and just go for what works.
- 51:26There are no style points in politics.
- 51:28People wanna believe that there are, but there are no style points.
- 51:31Just go out and win.
- 51:33So that's six, but they're all kind of the same, actually.
- 51:37I think those are all great pieces of advice.
- 51:39I like the one in particular about knowing the difference between a fact and a problem.
- 51:44My memory is a little hazy on it, but back at UF in grad school, I did a class in public
- 51:52policy analysis, which I thought was incredibly fascinating, and it kind of reminds me of that.
- 51:58I'm trying to remember basically, like, how you actually tell what is actually a policy
- 52:03problem.
- 52:04Mhmm.
- 52:04You
- 52:05if knowing the difference between what the problem is and then an effect of that problem,
- 52:11it can it can be a little bit challenging to really figure out which which is which.
- 52:15And I in a in a way, I guess you can kinda say that about fact versus problem too.
- 52:21You you know, it's Yeah.
- 52:24How you differentiate.
- 52:26I can't change facts.
- 52:28I can't change facts, but what I can do is influence problems.
- 52:33Now, maybe not to my satisfaction, but I can certainly change the dynamic of a problem.
- 52:41But a fact is a fact.
- 52:42I'm a 64 year old guy that lives in, that lives where I live.
- 52:47That's a fact.
- 52:48The problem is, is that I don't sleep well at night and I'm bald.
- 52:55Well, I might be able to change it.
- 52:57I don't know.
- 52:58If you listen to the ads on TV, they'll tell you you can.
- 53:01But so that that's there there are some things that are just facts.
- 53:05Yeah.
- 53:06Yeah.
- 53:06Absolutely.
- 53:07And I think I think that's a great way to put it.
- 53:09And really wanna thank you for all of this great information you've given us, Bert, but we
- 53:16are running up at the very end.
- 53:18So real quick, though, always like to end for those of you who are new to the podcast with my
- 53:22guests, I always like to end on a random question of the day.
- 53:26Something fun and nonpolitical.
- 53:27Not that the other stuff wasn't fun, but sometimes you need a little bit of a break from
- 53:31the political political, and I like to just get a different side of the guests.
- 53:37So, Burt, today's random question of the day for you is, which Winter Olympic sport do you
- 53:43wish you could win a gold medal in?
- 53:45Oh, man.
- 53:46That's so cool.
- 53:48Probably biathlon.
- 53:49Just think that the
- 53:50Okay.
- 53:52You know, you have two things that just shouldn't work together, cross country skiing
- 53:59and marksmanship.
- 54:00And yet it's the coolest thing ever.
- 54:02I would love to win a gold medal in that.
- 54:04Although Americans aren't terribly good at that.
- 54:06My second choice would be curling because it's, it's just cool.
- 54:12I mean, you're probably in Florida and it's not like you can go test drive whether you would
- 54:19ever want to be a curler or not, but I've seen it done.
- 54:22And it's, it's as impressive, perhaps more so in person than it is on TV.
- 54:27But, yeah, biathlon and curling.
- 54:29Yeah.
- 54:30Curling is like a really funny like, it looks like it it's one of those sports that looks
- 54:34like it's really easy, but it's obviously not.
- 54:37Otherwise, you know, more people would be Olympians.
- 54:39But it it is kind of funny just though it seems like it's shuffleboard or bocce ball
- 54:44Exactly.
- 54:45On on ice, basically.
- 54:46Yeah.
- 54:48But for me, though, I it's it's definitely gonna be hockey.
- 54:51It's a little bit easier for me to choose which Winter Olympic sport versus the Summer Olympic
- 54:55sport because there's a couple of summer sports I'm like, I would love to be able to do that.
- 55:01I I'm not a hockey aficionado.
- 55:03I'm not an expert in it, but I do like hockey.
- 55:05I like kinda funny.
- 55:06I guess last week actually mentioned something about in one of his answers about how he
- 55:11doesn't really know hockey, but he knows that people like it basically.
- 55:14So it was kinda funny to bring that up.
- 55:16But Hockey's kinda fun.
- 55:18Hockey would definitely be my first one.
- 55:19Because hockey hockey is very cool in person.
- 55:22I saw Gretzky play back in the nineties.
- 55:25And Oh, wow.
- 55:26Yeah.
- 55:27Yeah.
- 55:27It was it was pretty exciting.
- 55:28It was at the cap center.
- 55:30My my challenge with hockey is and love to be able to do it, but I can't skate.
- 55:35Can't skate either.
- 55:38Skateboards, broke a leg on a skateboard.
- 55:40I can't skate on old school skates, rollerblades.
- 55:44I've tried ice skating.
- 55:46Falling on ice skating is just awful.
- 55:48I I just but I love watching the game.
- 55:51It's it's a heck of a game.
- 55:52Oh, yeah.
- 55:52It's so exciting.
- 55:54Yeah.
- 55:55Ice skating, I've never done before.
- 55:56I I did go rollerblading years and years ago, and I fell right on my tailbone, and it hurt.
- 56:01I didn't break it, but it it did hurt quite a bit.
- 56:03So, yeah, skating is not my forte, but that would definitely be it for me.
- 56:07I I don't think I could do anything like skiing or bobsled or anything because that is that's
- 56:13way too fast for me.
- 56:15That's that's legit seems terrifying to do.
- 56:18So, I mean, not that hockey wouldn't be scary with, you know, skates and and getting shoved
- 56:23into boards, but I feel like it's a it's a I can deal with it.
- 56:27If I could skate, I could deal with it a little bit better than if I was bobsledding or skiing.
- 56:32But
- 56:33Bobsledding looks kinda cool.
- 56:35The four man would be fun as long as I wasn't the guy up front steering or the guy in the
- 56:40back braking.
- 56:41If I could just be one of the two in the middle that is leaning one way or another but didn't
- 56:46have to make any decisions, I think that would that would be where I'd wanna be on a bobsled.
- 56:51Yeah.
- 56:51If if I'm with you there.
- 56:52If I was gonna be bobsledding, that is definitely the place I would be.
- 56:56But I I need to watch more of the Winter Olympics.
- 56:58Haven't gotten to watch a whole lot of it yet.
- 57:00But in any case, though, Bert, really appreciate your time.
- 57:03Thank you for for coming on to the podcast.
- 57:06Real quick before I wrap things up, any links that you wanna share?
- 57:10You know, I'm a I'm a big newsie, so I I love the real clear politics side, during election
- 57:17season when they had their aggregator.
- 57:21I think that eyes over is really interesting.
- 57:25Chris Wilson is always doing smart stuff.
- 57:30He does sentiment tracking.
- 57:31He uses an algorithm and kind of gives real time sentiment tracking, the AI has fulfilled
- 57:38the promise of sentiment tracking that Yahoo told us we had ten, twelve years ago.
- 57:43The republicanads.com website for anyone that wants to look into digital advertising, it's
- 57:49designed for down ballot candidates.
- 57:51So any of your R people out there.
- 57:54And what else do I really like?
- 57:56Politico's fun.
- 57:58Lucienne's a fun aggregator.
- 58:00And Saturdays down south for SEC Sports, it is the gold standard.
- 58:08And if you're a basketball guy and a Florida guy, we're about 10 or a very fun month.
- 58:14There's nothing better than Yes.
- 58:16Than a March Madness run.
- 58:18I love them.
- 58:19Even when my team's not in it, my team's gonna be in it this year.
- 58:22But even when my team's not in it, I love March Madness.
- 58:25So, Saturdays down south is really cool.
- 58:28Nate Silver, it's a pay service, but he does some really interesting stuff.
- 58:34That's I I could go on and on.
- 58:36I'm go ahead.
- 58:38I'm sorry.
- 58:38I I'll definitely go ahead and no.
- 58:40No.
- 58:40No.
- 58:40You're good.
- 58:41I'll definitely share at least the the the first few.
- 58:43Yeah.
- 58:44Yeah.
- 58:44March Madness is always awesome.
- 58:46Hoping my my primary see if I could point to it properly.
- 58:50There we go.
- 58:50It might be hard to tell, but University of South Florida was my was my undergraduate alma
- 58:55mater.
- 58:55So they are my primary rooting interest.
- 58:57Obviously, I I will root for UF, but hoping USF makes it to the the big dance this year.
- 59:03We got a good team, but when you're not in a power four conference, it's it's hard to get in
- 59:08if you don't win your conference.
- 59:09So we we still got some work to do, but they have started coming on strong as of late.
- 59:14But The basketball.
- 59:15But yeah.
- 59:16So thank you so much, Bert.
- 59:17Yeah.
- 59:18Exactly.
- 59:19So, Bert, thank you so much for your time, for my links, my linkedin.com profile, I post on
- 59:24quite often.
- 59:25My Facebook, Paul Raider author and speaker.
- 59:28My email, Paul Raider writes at Gmail dot com.
- 59:31My book that I wrote on Amazon about independence and why they struggle so much in
- 59:36elections and how they could potentially make their chances better.
- 59:39Not arguing that they should or shouldn't, but that's just what they're facing.
- 59:44My five day educational email course about how we can all better mitigate polarization in
- 59:50politics and feel like I'm missing something.
- 59:54Oh, my medium.com profile that I write on from time to time.
- 59:56So that is gonna wrap things up for today's episode of Politics for Paul.
- 1:00:00Please like, comment, share, and subscribe.
- 1:00:02Thank you all so much for listening and for watching, and we'll see you next time.