Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / 476 AD Is Wrong. Here's When Rome Actually Fell
Transcript
- 0:00Rome didn't fall in 476 AD, it ended in 410.
- 0:05The empire just spent 66 years pretending it hadn't.
- 0:09Most history wants to count the years of decline for you.
- 0:12The question I keep coming back to on this channel is different.
- 0:16I want to know what people stop believing because that's the
- 0:19clock that actually matters. The standard story gives you
- 0:23Alaric swords, 3 days of fire, a military event brief contained.
- 0:31And that's true. That's also not the story.
- 0:33For 800 years, Rome had been militarily inviolate.
- 0:37Not because the Solarium gate couldn't be broken, because no
- 0:40one believed it could. On August 24th, for 10, it
- 0:44opened from the inside. Stillico, Rome's master general,
- 0:48had been executed 2 years before.
- 0:51Allerick's payments, grain, land and recognition were cancelled.
- 0:553 sieges. The court at Ravenna did
- 0:58nothing. Physical damage to the city was
- 1:01modest. What collapsed wasn't stone.
- 1:04Alaric didn't conquer Rome. He walked through the door Rome
- 1:08left unlocked. By the end of this, you won't
- 1:11just understand August 410. You'll understand what it looks
- 1:15like when a civilization loses its nerve before it ever loses
- 1:19its territory. The armies break last.
- 1:22The belief it breaks first. Same playbook, different
- 1:26century. Welcome back to Hidden Forces in
- 1:46History. I'm your host, Jeremy Ryan
- 1:49Slate, the CEO of Command Your Brand, and you can check us out
- 1:53over at commandyourbrand.com. Now, our story before any of
- 1:58August 410 makes sense, You have to understand the man whose
- 2:02death made it inevitable. His name was Stillico, and by
- 2:06the time the Emperor Honorius had him killed, he'd spent 20
- 2:10years being the single reason the Western Empire still worked
- 2:13at all. He was the son of a Vandal
- 2:15cavalry officer and a Roman noblewoman, so half barbarian by
- 2:19blood, but completely Roman in terms of how he operated inside
- 2:23the system. He'd married the adopted niece
- 2:26of the Emperor Theodosius, his own daughter had married
- 2:29Honorius, and in every way that actually mattered who he was in
- 2:33the Empire. And I mean that in the most
- 2:35literal operational sense, not as the kind of flattery the
- 2:39court poets traded in silico ran the army.
- 2:42He negotiated the subsidies. He held together this impossible
- 2:46balancing act of a western empire that had been running a
- 2:49military shortfall for 60 years. There just weren't enough Roman
- 2:54born soldiers left to hold the frontier, which meant leaning
- 2:57more and more on Germanic Federati, which in turn meant
- 3:01you needed somebody who could speak both languages at once.
- 3:05This is the problem Peter Heather keeps coming back to in
- 3:07his work on the fall of the West.
- 3:10By this point, Rome couldn't find enough of its own men, so
- 3:13it was running its borders on Germanic manpower it didn't
- 3:16fully control. And Stilliko could speak both of
- 3:19those languages because he'd grown up right where they met,
- 3:23so he understood who Alaric actually was.
- 3:26This Visigothic king, who'd been pressing on the Italian frontier
- 3:30from around 401 and onward, had once been a Roman general
- 3:34himself. He'd commanded Visigothic troops
- 3:37under Theodosius. He'd fought for Rome, and he
- 3:40believed, with pretty good reason, that he was owed a
- 3:43permanent command land in the Balkans and a recognized place
- 3:47for his people inside the Roman military.
- 3:50When you look at it that way, it's a pretty reasonable
- 3:52request. It's exactly what a man asked
- 3:55for after he served the institution and expects it to
- 3:58hold up its end in return. Still, a Co got that the talks
- 4:02were hard and the terms were expensive and the politics back
- 4:06in Rome were brutal because every grain payment to the
- 4:09Visigoths could be spun as tribute, every humiliation as
- 4:13proof that Rome was basically paying Barbarians not to touch
- 4:17it. But he kept the thing running.
- 4:19The major Gothic invasions of Italy in those years all got
- 4:22halted. He turned Alaric back at
- 4:25Palentia and then again at Verona, and in a separate Gothic
- 4:28horde under ratagises was wiped out at Faisalai.
- 4:33The Silarian gate stayed shut, and then Honorius had him
- 4:37killed. The reasons were the usual mix,
- 4:40court paranoia, bad advisors, and that very particular failure
- 4:45you see in men who inherit power without really understanding how
- 4:49it works. Honorius was 23 in four O 8, and
- 4:53he was governing from Ravenna, a city he'd pick specifically
- 4:56because the marshes around it made it easy to defend.
- 5:00Which honestly tells you everything about how he saw the
- 5:03empire he was supposedly running.
- 5:05He'd been told by men who wanted Silico's job that Silico was
- 5:09cutting a private deal with Alaric, that he meant to put his
- 5:13own son on the throne using the Visigoths.
- 5:16There's no real evidence that any of that was true.
- 5:19What was true is that Silico was the most powerful man in the
- 5:23West, and powerful men attract accusations of ambition about
- 5:27the way marshland attracts mosquitoes.
- 5:30So on August 22nd, 408, almost exactly 2 years before Ulrich
- 5:35would come through the Silarian Gate, Silico was arrested in
- 5:38Ravenna, marched outside the walls, and executed.
- 5:42It happened without a trial and without any formal charge.
- 5:46The emperor simply issued A decree and it was done.
- 5:49And the men who'd served under him, the Gothic Federati, who
- 5:53were effectively the backbone of the Western Field Army, weren't
- 5:56offered reassignment or a pension or anything at all.
- 6:00They were massacred. Their families were massacred
- 6:03too. Somebody in Ravenna had decided
- 6:05this would solve the barbarian problem by getting rid of the
- 6:08barbarian soldiers. What it actually did was push
- 6:1210s of thousands of Gothic veterans straight into Alaric's
- 6:15camp. Our best source here is Zasimus,
- 6:18who puts it at 30,000. Historians treat that exact
- 6:22number with some caution, but the direction of it isn't really
- 6:25in dispute. In pure military terms, Hanorius
- 6:29had just handed the man besieging his capital and army.
- 6:32In institutional terms, he'd done something worse than that.
- 6:36He'd shown every Federati commander, every half Roman
- 6:39warlord, every barbarian general who'd bet his future on serving
- 6:43Rome, that Rome's commitments meant nothing, that loyalty
- 6:48could get you killed, and that the safer place to be was
- 6:50outside the walls instead of inside of them.
- 6:53This is the first of those invisible transfers that I keep
- 6:56talking about. The belief that Rome honored its
- 6:58contracts, that serving the institution, was the same long
- 7:03term bet that died on August 22nd, 408.
- 7:07The actual walls didn't come down for another two years, but
- 7:10the belief that had been holding the whole military arrangement
- 7:13together was already gone. Here's something the fire and
- 7:17sword version of the story always loses.
- 7:20Ulrich didn't besiege Rome because he wanted it destroyed.
- 7:23He besieged it three times, between four O 8 and 410.
- 7:26And across all three. What he kept asking for,
- 7:29consistently and on the record, was recognition.
- 7:33He wanted land in the Balkans for his people.
- 7:35He wanted a real Roman command, magister militum, the master of
- 7:39soldiers, the exact post silico had just left empty.
- 7:43He wanted the grain payments and the subsidies that have been
- 7:46promised and then cancelled by Ravenna after Stilico died.
- 7:51Basically, he wanted the things he'd already been half promised
- 7:54before. Then somebody went back on the
- 7:57deal. The first siege in late 408
- 7:59ended when the Roman Senate, acting on its own because
- 8:03Honorius was up in Ravenna being useless, negotiated a payment,
- 8:07and we actually still have the invoice for it.
- 8:09Zosimus, writing a bit over a century later but working from
- 8:13sources closely tied to the event itself, lists it out. 5000
- 8:18lbs of gold, 30,000 lbs of silver, 4000 silk tunics, 3000
- 8:25scarlet dyed hides, and 3000 lbs of pepper.
- 8:29And yes, pepper. They were paying part of the
- 8:32ransom. And Pepper, because at that
- 8:34point it was the most liquid, portable thing the city had
- 8:37left. Alaric took the deal, lifted the
- 8:40siege, and pulled back to negotiate with Ravenna.
- 8:44And Ravenna just wouldn't negotiate.
- 8:46Honorius's court stalled and delayed and eventually sent a
- 8:50delegation so obviously designed to humiliate him that Alaric
- 8:54broke off the talks and marched S again.
- 8:56That's the second siege in late Four O 9.
- 8:59This time he installed a puppet emperor, Priscus Attalus, who'd
- 9:04been the city's prefect of Rome, basically to give himself a
- 9:07formal Roman counterpart to deal with and to put pressure on
- 9:10Honorius to come to terms. It was theater, but it was
- 9:14sophisticated theater, because Olaric was still playing inside
- 9:18the rules of the Roman system, even though as those same rules
- 9:22were being turned against him, Horius held out anyway.
- 9:25Eventually Olaric got rid of his own puppet once it was clear
- 9:28Adilis was going to just be useless, and that second siege
- 9:32kind of fizzled out without resolving anything.
- 9:35The third one started in the summer of 410, and it didn't end
- 9:39in negotiation, it ended with the gates opening.
- 9:43Exactly how is still argued over.
- 9:45Maybe treachery from inside, maybe a slave revolt, maybe
- 9:49Gothic servants who'd been LED into the city coordinating with
- 9:52all the Ricks. People outside the sources don't
- 9:55agree on it. What nobody disputes is that on
- 9:58the night of August 24th, 410, the gate opened from the inside
- 10:03and then you get the three days we mentioned above.
- 10:06By the standards of how cities usually get sacked back then, it
- 10:09was restrained. Oliver could actually give an
- 10:12order is that the great basilicas of Saint Peter and
- 10:14Saint Paul were off limits. They were sanctuary and no
- 10:18killing was allowed inside them. The violence was still real.
- 10:22There was property taken, people enslaved, wealth stripped out,
- 10:26but the physical bones of the city mostly survived.
- 10:29The Kirkus Maximus wasn't burned, the forums weren't torn
- 10:33down, and the aqueducts, they kept running.
- 10:36Then Alaric headed South with his army, with a lot of movable
- 10:40wealth, with the Emperor's sister Gallup Licidia as a
- 10:44hostage, and without any real resolution are the things he
- 10:47wanted in the first place. He died of fever in Calabria
- 10:51about six weeks later, and the story of his burial almost tips
- 10:55over into myth. According to Jordanes, the
- 10:57Gothic historian writing in the 6th century, his men diverted a
- 11:01river. The bucento buried him in the
- 11:04dry riverbed along with a share of Roman plunder, let the water
- 11:07flow over him, and then killed the slaves who'd done the
- 11:10digging so the location could never be found.
- 11:14His brother-in-law, Athawolf eventually took the Visigoths
- 11:17into Gaul, married Gala Placidia, and spent a few years
- 11:21trying to build a kind of Romano Visigoth Kingdom that would keep
- 11:25Roman civilization going under Gothic military rule.
- 11:29So the physical event, relatively speaking, stayed
- 11:32contained. The psychological one didn't,
- 11:35and that's where the rest of this really lives.
- 11:38You can actually watch the shockwave move in real time.
- 11:42Because the literate world of late antiquity was a letter
- 11:45writing world, and people put that down on paper, what they
- 11:48felt about the news when it reached them.
- 11:51Jerome was in Bethlehem when the reports came in.
- 11:54He was an old man by then, in his 60s, one of the most learned
- 11:58people in the entire Latin world.
- 12:01The man who translated the Bible into the Vulgate that the church
- 12:04would lean on for the next 1000 years.
- 12:07He wasn't somebody prone to melodrama, and his letters tend
- 12:10to be almost forensic. And how precise they are.
- 12:13In letter 127, written in 412, he says my voice sticks in my
- 12:17throat and as I dictate, sobs choke my utterance.
- 12:21The city which had taken the whole world was itself taken.
- 12:25And what makes that line matter isn't really the emotion in it,
- 12:29it's the logic underneath it. Jerome saw the theological
- 12:32problem right away. Rome had taken the whole world.
- 12:36It was the Eternal City, and its permanence wasn't just a
- 12:40political fact. It was supposed to be the kind
- 12:42of a divine guarantee. Under the old religion, Rome was
- 12:46protected by the gods, and its survival proved they favored it.
- 12:50Under Christianity, it became the seat of the church, the
- 12:54capital of Christendom, the vessel God was working through
- 12:58in history. So if Rome could fall, which God
- 13:01had failed? That's the question Jerome
- 13:03couldn't get past. In 412, he wrote that he
- 13:06couldn't even bring himself to keep working on the commentary
- 13:10that he'd been writing, the one on the prophet Ezekiel who'd
- 13:14written about the fall of Jerusalem.
- 13:16The parallel was just too close to sit with.
- 13:19He spent decades explaining that Jerusalem's fall was an event
- 13:22full of theological meaning, and now he couldn't build the same
- 13:26frame around Rome, at least not yet.
- 13:29And he wasn't the only one frozen like that.
- 13:31Trust the Mediterranean, the surviving letters show you a
- 13:34world going through what we call a legitimacy crisis.
- 13:38The armies were still out there, still working in the provinces,
- 13:41still defending the frontiers in the name of Rome.
- 13:44But the authority behind those armies had quietly depended in a
- 13:48way almost no one had said out loud.
- 13:50On the assumption that Rome itself simply couldn't be
- 13:53touched, the pagans got out in front with an explanation,
- 13:57because they already had one ready to go.
- 13:59Rome had been protected for 800 years by the Old Gods, by the
- 14:03Capitoline Triad, the Vestal Virgins, the whole ritual
- 14:07calendar that kept going, the divine bargain since the days of
- 14:11the Republic, and Christianity had dismantled all of it.
- 14:15Theodosius had shut the temples in 391, and the Vestal Virgins
- 14:19have been disbanded. The old rites and old sacrifices
- 14:22and forms of protection have been outlawed and pushed
- 14:25underground. Now, 19 years later, the city
- 14:29had fallen. That Pagan argument had a
- 14:31serious intellectual position, not some fringe thing, and it
- 14:35carried real weight because it had one thing that tends to win
- 14:39arguments in a crisis, which is a clean cause and effect.
- 14:43The old protection gets removed, the new God fails to protect,
- 14:47and the timing alone seems to prove the point.
- 14:50And the Christian intellectual establishment for the moment had
- 14:54nothing to say back. To really get why the
- 14:56theological side of this wasn't some side issue, you have to
- 14:59understand what the word Rome even meant as an idea in 410,
- 15:03because that was the whole question.
- 15:05For about a century the empire had been officially Christian,
- 15:09The Emperor was Christian, the court was Christian, the army
- 15:12swore its oath in a Christian frame, and the legitimacy of
- 15:16imperial power had increasingly been explained in Christian
- 15:19terms. The Emperor as God's man on
- 15:22earth. The empire is the vehicle of
- 15:24Providence. Rome's success treated as proof
- 15:27that God favored the right religion, and that was the
- 15:30working doctrine of the whole order, not just pious talk.
- 15:34It was how Theodosius had justified stamping out the old
- 15:38religion, how the Church had justified piling up property and
- 15:41legal privilege, how bishops had turned into power brokers inside
- 15:45provincial government. The entire setup of the late
- 15:48empire rested on this claim, and Rome and Christianity were lined
- 15:52up together. That God favored Rome, that the
- 15:55Eternal City was the earthly shape of divine order.
- 15:59And August 24th 410 did more than just challenge that claim,
- 16:03it falsified it. If God favored Rome, Rome
- 16:06doesn't get sacked, and if Rome did get sacked, then either God
- 16:11didn't favor Rome, or Rome wasn't what everyone thought it
- 16:14was, or God was indifferent, or there was no God at all, or the
- 16:18pagans were right and Christians had stripped the city of the
- 16:21protection that had actually been keeping it safe.
- 16:25Every one of those branches was a catastrophe for somebody.
- 16:29The pagans grabbed the last one, and they pushed hard.
- 16:32Brutalist Nathamathis a Gallic aristocrat writing of 4/17, was
- 16:37still making the case openly that Rome's troubles came
- 16:40straight out of Christian mishandling of the relationship
- 16:43with the divine. So the Christian thinkers needed
- 16:45an answer that was rigorous, historically serious, and
- 16:50somehow able to rebuild a whole sense of meaning around the very
- 16:54event that looked like it had destroyed that sense of meaning.
- 16:57And one man actually built it. Augustine was 56 when Rome was
- 17:02sacked. He was the Bishop of Hippo
- 17:04Regius, a decent sized port city in what is now Algeria.
- 17:09He'd been a Bishop for 14 years, and he was already the sharpest
- 17:12theological mind in the Latin Church.
- 17:15When word of the sack reached North Africa, he was already
- 17:18taking in refugees. The wealthy families in Rome,
- 17:21the senators and aristocrats, and the literate class have been
- 17:25streaming out of Italy for months before the sack, and kept
- 17:28coming in in even bigger numbers afterward.
- 17:31Some of them ended up in Hippo and they showed up carrying the
- 17:34question he recognized as existential, which was if Rome
- 17:39can fall, then what holds? He started writing the City of
- 17:42God Diquitae Dei in 413 and finished it in 4/26/22.
- 17:49Books somewhere between 4 and 500,000 words.
- 17:53And it's far more than a book of consolation.
- 17:56It's a complete rebuilding of the entire logic of Christian
- 17:59civilization, written specifically to make the fall of
- 18:02Rome theologically beside the point, ripped down to how it
- 18:05works. The argument goes like this.
- 18:08There are two cities, the city of God and the city of man.
- 18:12The city of God is eternal and transcendent, defined by the
- 18:15love of God over love of self, and the city of man is temporary
- 18:19and corrupt, defined by the reverse.
- 18:23Rome had always been part of the city of man, the same as every
- 18:26other earthly power. There was nothing uniquely evil
- 18:30about it. All worldly orders belong to
- 18:32that category, and the rising and falling doesn't prove
- 18:36anything theologically in either direction.
- 18:39Empires come, empires go. God's purposes move through
- 18:42history, but they don't depend on the survival of anyone
- 18:46political form. So Rome didn't fall because God
- 18:49walked away from it. Rome fell because earthly cities
- 18:52always eventually fall, and the people who built their whole
- 18:56sense of meaning on the permanence of an earthly
- 18:59institution I've been building on sand.
- 19:01The Eternal City was never going to be Rome.
- 19:04It was never Rome in the 1st place, and anyone who thought
- 19:07that had just made a category error.
- 19:10This is a very sophisticated institutional argument.
- 19:13Wearing theological clothes. And it really helps to read it
- 19:16that way. Underneath the theology, what
- 19:19Augustine was doing was building a new load bearing structure to
- 19:23replace the one that had just collapsed.
- 19:25He was putting together the frame that would let the
- 19:27institutional church outlive the Western empire, carry its way of
- 19:31operating into the kingdoms that came after, and hold on to a
- 19:34sense of legitimacy and authority that no longer leaned
- 19:37on Rome being there at all. He was, in effect, future
- 19:42proofing Christianity for a world without Rome in it, and he
- 19:46pulled it off in 16 years between 4:13 and 4:26, while he
- 19:51was also running a diocese, biting the Donatus Schism, going
- 19:54up against plagiarism, handling a constant flow of refugees, and
- 19:59watching the Western Empire come apart province by province.
- 20:03He died in 430 during the Vandal siege of Hippo, with the sound
- 20:07of siege engines reportedly carrying all the way to his
- 20:10deathbed. The very thing he'd spent his
- 20:12life describing, the fall of an earthly city, showed up at his
- 20:16own door in his final weeks. His biographer Posidius, who
- 20:21knew him personally and wrote the Life not long after, says he
- 20:25wept through all through those last months, less from fear of
- 20:28any death and more from grief over what was bearing down on
- 20:32the people in his care. He built the intellectual
- 20:34scaffolding for a post Roman world and he didn't live to see
- 20:38anyone actually live inside it, though eventually they did.
- 20:42Here's the part that makes 410 genuinely hard to see clearly
- 20:46from the outside. The Western Roman Empire did not
- 20:49end in 410. It kept going for another 66
- 20:53years. Emperors were crowned and
- 20:56deposed, laws got issued, the bureaucracy kept functioning
- 20:59across most of the provinces most of the time, and the army
- 21:03kept fighting and recruiting and at least holding nominal control
- 21:07over real territory. The formal machinery of the
- 21:09empire just kept running. And that's not a footnote.
- 21:13It's actually the central fact of the usual story that we can't
- 21:17explain. If 410 was so decisive, why does
- 21:21the empire roll for more than six decades?
- 21:24The answer is that the institutional infrastructure
- 21:27carries its own momentum. The habits, the procedures, the
- 21:30titles, the legal framework, the administrative machinery, all of
- 21:34that keeps operating after the thing that animated it has died.
- 21:38For the same reason a fire keeps burning after the accelerant is
- 21:42gone. It burns down.
- 21:44It just takes time. The emperors who came after
- 21:46Honorius, and there's a long line of them.
- 21:49Valentinian, the Third, Petronius Maximus.
- 21:52Evidius. Majorian Libya.
- 21:54Severus Athamus. Julius Nepos.
- 21:58Romulus, Augustalus, They all governed A shrinking territory
- 22:01with shrinking resources, fighting the exact same
- 22:04structural problems that Stilico had been holding together.
- 22:08Not enough soldiers, too much frontier, and too much
- 22:11dependence on Germanic commanders who were starting to
- 22:14realize that the power to make an emperor was worth more than
- 22:18the title itself. Atheists, the one his admirers
- 22:21called the last of the Romans, spent the four 30s and four 40s
- 22:25running essentially the same diplomatic and military
- 22:29balancing act Steilaco had run. And he was also killed by his
- 22:32own emperor, Valentinian the third, in 454, in a throne room
- 22:37by Valentinian's own hand because the emperor was afraid
- 22:40of him. So you get the same thing
- 22:42happening all over again. The emperor fears the competent
- 22:46general more than he fears the Barbarians.
- 22:49The competent general gets eliminated and then nobody's
- 22:52managing the Barbarians anymore. Within a year of killing
- 22:55atheists, Valentinin the Third was assassinated and that same
- 23:00year 455 the Vandal sacked Rome. This was a far uglier thing than
- 23:06the restrained 3 day Visigothic sack.
- 23:09It ran for 14 days. It was more thorough.
- 23:12There were no special orders protecting the basilicas and
- 23:16Genseric loaded his ships with everything that could be moved
- 23:19and sailed back to Carthage. By that point, the shock just
- 23:23landed differently, more like an administrative incident than the
- 23:26end of the world. The belief was already gone, and
- 23:29what was left was mostly paperwork.
- 23:32Then on September 4th, 476, Odowacher, A Germanic warlord
- 23:37who'd been running the Western Field Army, deposed the last
- 23:40Western emperor, Romulus Augustalus, a teenage boy who'd
- 23:45been on the throne for 10 months, and he sent him off to a
- 23:48comfortable exile down in Campagna.
- 23:51And Odawaker didn't even declare himself emperor.
- 23:54He shipped the imperial regalia off to Constantinople and asked
- 23:58for the title of patrician, a senior Roman military rank plus
- 24:01the governance of Italy, And he got it.
- 24:04The Eastern Emperor Zeno, who needed somebody to run Italy
- 24:08while Constantinople dealt with its own crisis, granted it.
- 24:11So the formal end of the Western Empire was basically a paperwork
- 24:15request accepted without a fight and witnessed by nobody in
- 24:19particular. The Empire had survived
- 24:21Hannibal, civil wars, plague, the convulsions of the Crisis of
- 24:26the 3rd Century, and ended with a letter with a polite agreement
- 24:30about titles. Because the real ending had
- 24:33already happened 66 years earlier.
- 24:36The moment the Solarian Gate opened and the belief that made
- 24:39the whole thing function walked out with it.
- 24:42There's one person in all of this who seems to understand
- 24:45exactly what was happening while it was happening and acted on
- 24:49it. He doesn't get nearly enough
- 24:50attention. In the standard version, Galla
- 24:53Placidia was Hanorius's sister, a daughter of Theodosius, half
- 24:57sister to the Eastern Emperor Arcadius.
- 25:00About as dynastically central as a woman in the Western Empire
- 25:04could be. She was in Rome when all are
- 25:06exacted, and she was taken as a hostage when the Visigoths
- 25:10pulled out. She spent three years with them
- 25:13and she was treated as what she actually was, a diplomatic asset
- 25:18rather than a prisoner in a degrading sense.
- 25:21She travelled with Athawol, Ulrich's successor, through
- 25:24Italy and Gaul, and in 411 she married him, and it was
- 25:28willingly by most accounts. The sources that later tried to
- 25:31paint this as coercion are working backward from a need to
- 25:35protect her imperial dignity, not describing what really
- 25:38happened. And at this point Athawolf was
- 25:40trying to build something he actually spelled out in words.
- 25:43Words we have because Arosius preserved them, claiming to have
- 25:47heard the speech reported first hand.
- 25:50He come to believe the barbarian peoples were too unruly to
- 25:53replace Rome with an order of their own, So what he wanted
- 25:56instead was to restore Rome through Gothic military power,
- 26:00be the kind of general Silico had been, except openly Gothic
- 26:05rather than half denying A Vandal background.
- 26:07He named his son, born in Barcelona in 415, Theodosius,
- 26:12about the most Roman name available.
- 26:15The boy died in infancy. Ethel Wolf was assassinated by
- 26:18his own men only a few months after that.
- 26:21Gallup Licidia got sent back to Ravenna in a diplomatic
- 26:24exchange. She eventually married a Roman
- 26:26general named Constantius, became an Empress, and spent the
- 26:30four 20s and four 30s as the most effective political
- 26:33operator in the Western Empire, Regent for her son, who was the
- 26:37same Valentinian the Third who'd later killed atheists.
- 26:41What she'd understood out of all three years with the Visigoths
- 26:45was that the whole divide between Roman and barbarian had
- 26:48already collapsed. Ethel Wolf Gothic commanders
- 26:52were wearing Roman military Insignia, using Roman
- 26:55administrative forms, arguing about Roman theology and wanting
- 26:59Roman titles. The distinction the court in
- 27:01Ravenna was still trying to maintain the civilized inside
- 27:04against the barbarian outside was already fiction.
- 27:07The Visigoths were the system's own military apparatus by this
- 27:10point, operating with less and less formal acknowledgement of
- 27:14that point, not some force sitting outside it.
- 27:17By 4:15, the thing actually holding the Empire together had
- 27:20nothing to do with the Danube or the Rhine.
- 27:23The real walls were the institutional fictions that kept
- 27:26everyone pretending that the old category still meant something.
- 27:30Gallup Licidia had seen both sides of the wall close.
- 27:34She spent the rest of her career managing the fiction skillfully
- 27:37enough to buy the Empire another generation.
- 27:40So this is the Season 2 argument all the way through.
- 27:43What we've been doing all season is tracking how power actually
- 27:47moves inside an institution. Not the ceremonial moment, not
- 27:51the formal handover, but the shift that comes before all of
- 27:54that, the change in belief and legitimacy in the working logic
- 27:59that lets an institution function.
- 28:01The earlier shift always runs ahead of the visible one by
- 28:04years, sometimes by decades, and 410 is about the cleanest
- 28:08example of that gap. In the Western world, the
- 28:11invisible handover happened on August 24th, 410 when the city
- 28:15fell, and not because of the physical damage, but because of
- 28:19what people stop believing. They stopped believing Rome was
- 28:22eternal. They stopped trusting the whole
- 28:24order was load bearing that serving the empire was a sane
- 28:28long term bet. Jerome lost the ability to
- 28:30write. Augustine started his longest
- 28:32work, the pagans rebuilt their case for divine abandonment, the
- 28:36barbarian commanders recalculated where they stood,
- 28:39and the Eastern Empire quietly started treating the Western
- 28:42court as a client rather than an equal.
- 28:45None of that showed up in any formal document.
- 28:49No treaty, no abdication, no constitutional change.
- 28:54Just the belief draining out of the system like water leaking
- 28:57through a cracked foundation. The visible handover didn't come
- 29:00till 66 years later, when Odawaker sent a letter to
- 29:04Constantinople. For all 66 of those years, the
- 29:08Empire had been running on pure momentum, on habits and
- 29:11procedures and titles and legal frameworks that kept moving
- 29:15after the thing animated them died.
- 29:18And that's genuinely not nothing. 66 years of slow,
- 29:22controlled decline is a real testament to how durable that
- 29:25kind of infrastructure really is.
- 29:28The Roman machine was built to last, and it did last, even past
- 29:31the point where there was any coming back.
- 29:34But it had been running on empty since 4:10.
- 29:37Everything after that, every general, every campaign, every
- 29:41treaty, every emperor, was maintenance on a building that
- 29:44had already lost its structural integrity.
- 29:47So the shape of it is less about decline is some slow process
- 29:50that you can step into and reverse at any point.
- 29:52It's more like a threshold you crossed followed by a long tail
- 29:56of institutional inertia. The threshold was 410, the
- 30:00inertia ran until 476, and the historian who put the fall at
- 30:04476 are really just counting the tail.
- 30:07They're right about what happened on September 4th of
- 30:09that year, they're just wrong about when it actually became
- 30:13unavoidable. The question I always end on is
- 30:16the same one, same playbook, different century.
- 30:19So where are we right now? And the honest answer is that
- 30:22none of what's in this episode is actually medieval, or even
- 30:26specifically Roman. These are the things that show
- 30:28up in any large institutional order once it's running past the
- 30:32point where people still believe in it.
- 30:34The first one is this, When a complex system ends up depending
- 30:38on one or two genuinely capable people to keep functioning, and
- 30:42then the system destroys those people because it's more afraid
- 30:46of them and more afraid of their competence than failure, well,
- 30:49that's late stage behavior. A healthy system making a
- 30:52correction looks nothing like that.
- 30:55What you're actually watching is a system that started to
- 30:58optimize for the survival of the least of its capable members.
- 31:02Silica wasn't some singular genius, he was just a man who
- 31:05understood both sides of the wall, and the system killed him
- 31:09because it had lost the ability to tolerate that kind of dual
- 31:11fluency. And that alone should tell you
- 31:14something. The second one is about what
- 31:16actually happens when the belief holding an order together gets
- 31:19falsified by a single event. The institution doesn't fall
- 31:24right away. It keeps going on momentum, on
- 31:26habit, on the inertia of all the people who've built their lives
- 31:30around it continuing. But the gap between the
- 31:32institution claims about itself and what the evidence actually
- 31:35says starts to widen from that moment.
- 31:39And a gap like that, once they open, well, they don't close
- 31:43back up by themselves. They need an Augustine.
- 31:46They need somebody willing to spend 16 years rebuilding the
- 31:49load bearing frame on different ground, Somebody willing to say
- 31:53the Eternal City was never roam, so stop staking your sense of
- 31:56permanence on something that was never going to be permanent.
- 32:00Augustine's answer was theological, but the move
- 32:03underneath it was institutional. He cut the church's legitimacy
- 32:07loose from the survival of the empire and built something that
- 32:10could outlast the political order it had been living inside.
- 32:13And there's nothing medieval about that move.
- 32:15It's what anyone has to do when the container they're in is
- 32:18failing and they have to figure out what to build the next thing
- 32:21on and what to let go of. And the third one is those 66
- 32:25years, the long slow decline that follows the invisible
- 32:29handover. And this is the one I find
- 32:31genuinely dangerous, because it's the one that generates the
- 32:34most false hope. If the institution keeps
- 32:37working, if the mail still runs and the courts still sit and the
- 32:41currency still circulates, it gets very easy to decide the
- 32:44crisis pass and the system corrected itself that the alarm
- 32:49was overblown. What Rome shows you in the
- 32:51infrastructure can keep coasting A momentum for an entire human
- 32:55lifetime after the belief underneath it is gone.
- 32:59The kids born in 410 grew up inside a functioning, if
- 33:03shrinking, Roman world. Their kids were the ones who saw
- 33:06it end. That gap between the invisible
- 33:09handover and the visible one stretched long enough for two
- 33:12whole generations to live their entire lives inside it, in a
- 33:16world that looked like it was holding together and it just
- 33:19wasn't. And I wouldn't take that as
- 33:20reassurance. If anything, that long gap is a
- 33:24warning because by the time people stop believing the system
- 33:27holds, it's already failed. The formal collapse afterwards
- 33:31is just bookkeeping. The armies are always the last
- 33:34thing to break. What goes first is the belief
- 33:38this has been hidden forces in history.
- 33:40I'm Jeremy Ryan Slate, please like this video, leave us a
- 33:44comment, and smash that subscribe button if you want
- 33:47more hidden forces in history. This is the end of season 2.
- 33:51We're moving on to season 3 and looking at great power
- 33:55dynasties. We're going to be looking at the
- 33:57Wars of the Roses in the start of season 3.
- 34:01We have a great guest, the medieval scholar from X.
- 34:05So I look forward to seeing you in our next season.