Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 158. Hope for Cynics: Building Trusting Relationships through Communication
Transcript
- 0:00Matt Abrahams: It doesn't take much to see how cynical we are in the world today..
- 0:04We doubt, we lack trust.
- 0:06What if we could develop hopeful skepticism where we trust loudly?
- 0:13My name's Matt Abrahams, and I teach strategic communication at Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:18Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:23Today, I look forward to speaking with Jamil Zaki.
- 0:26Jamil is a professor of psychology at Stanford and the director of the Stanford Social Neuroscience Lab.
- 0:32He studies empathy and kindness, both at the interpersonal and neuroscience level.
- 0:38He has a new book out that I really enjoyed.
- 0:41It's called Hope for Cynics: The Surprising Science of Human Goodness.
- 0:46Jamil, I am so excited for our conversation.
- 0:49We've had such great chats with some of your colleagues in the psychology department at Stanford, Jeanne Tsai, Alia Crum, Phil Zimbardo.
- 0:56Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart.
- 0:58Jamil Zaki: Oh, thank you so much, Matt.
- 0:59It's a pleasure to be here.
- 1:01Matt Abrahams: Awesome.
- 1:01Should we get started?
- 1:02Jamil Zaki: Let's do it.
- 1:03Matt Abrahams: Excellent.
- 1:04Trust is an important part of what you study.
- 1:06Can you define trust from your perspective and its impact on the relationships we have?
- 1:12Jamil Zaki: Trust I would say is one person's willingness to be vulnerable on the expectation that another person will step up and have our best interest in mind.
- 1:22So for instance, when you loan somebody money, but also when you decide to open up with a new acquaintance about a struggle that you're going through.
- 1:28When you allow a babysitter to watch your kids, all of these are acts of trust.
- 1:33And I would say that those acts are the bedrock on which relationships are formed.
- 1:38The only way that strangers become friends and friends become best friends, the only way that we can build partnerships in business is through a willingness to count on one another.
- 1:49So without trust, all of those relationships would disappear.
- 1:54Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 1:54How are some ways that you have seen or studied that people can actually develop better trust?
- 1:59And I'm assuming communication plays an important role in all of that.
- 2:02Jamil Zaki: Oh, absolutely.
- 2:03Trust is a matter of managing risk, it's a social bet.
- 2:07If you count on somebody and they betray you, you will lose.
- 2:11And if you count on somebody and they show up for you, you both win.
- 2:15I think that we might be too risk averse in our trusting relationships.
- 2:19Why is that?
- 2:20Well, that time that you're let down lives on in your mind for years or decades.
- 2:25We all remember the times that we've been betrayed.
- 2:28But the opportunities that we miss, because we didn't trust somebody who would have honored that trust, we don't think of as much.
- 2:36So I think that our risk calculation is off and we might want to take more leaps of faith on people.
- 2:42You asked about how this could matter in terms of communication, and I think that there's an important point here too.
- 2:47Because trust isn't just about what you do, it's about how you explain what you do.
- 2:52I really love the term trusting loudly.
- 2:55That is when you put your faith in somebody else, it's important to tell them that you're doing so and to tell them that the reason you're doing that is because you believe in them.
- 3:04You say, well, you know, I've been going through this.
- 3:06I want to tell you about it because I really trust you.
- 3:10That simple message has way more power than I think most of us realize.
- 3:14It's a gift to another person and makes it much more likely that they will reciprocate by stepping up and becoming trustworthy as well as strengthening the relationship.
- 3:24Matt Abrahams: I love that notion of trusting loudly, making it explicit.
- 3:29And in many ways, as you say, not only is it an invitation and a gift, but it also is a way of demonstrating vulnerability and saying, I'm open to that.
- 3:38In this notion of risk aversion, we've talked about before on the podcast, and we've had Dan Pink on who talked about regrets.
- 3:44And the regretting of not taking the act because of not trusting, I think looms large in my life and in others.
- 3:50I appreciate that.
- 3:51And I'm going to think a lot about trusting loudly as we move forward.
- 3:55Your new book focuses on cynicism.
- 3:58What is cynicism from your perspective?
- 4:00And what is what you call the cynicism trap?
- 4:03Jamil Zaki: Yeah.
- 4:04So cynicism can be thought of as a theory.
- 4:07A theory about the world and about humanity in particular.
- 4:10It's the theory that most people, at their core, are selfish, greedy, and dishonest.
- 4:16Now, that is not to say that a cynic believes nobody will ever do something kind.
- 4:21Rather, they think that those kind acts are a surface level performance of what we're supposed to be.
- 4:27But if you had a magnifying glass and could peer beneath the action into a person's soul, they're mostly looking out for themselves.
- 4:36This is a worldview that traps us in all sorts of ways.
- 4:40But the major form in which it traps us is that cynics lose all of the powerful benefits that we've just talked about when it comes to trust.
- 4:49Because if you believe that every act of trust is a social bet on another person, and you also have a theory that most people would lie, cheat, and steal if they could.
- 5:00Well then that bet is for suckers.
- 5:03And we see that in cynics actions and in their self report as well, right?
- 5:08They tell us in the lab and they tell researchers that they don't think it's a smart decision to trust almost anybody.
- 5:15And if you give them chances to trust others, both in the laboratory and if you measure how much they trust people in their lives, they're much less willing to take those chances.
- 5:26And that means that they often end up trapped in a smaller version of their lives than they might want to live in, right?
- 5:33So they might not be betrayed as much, but they also don't form as many friendships and partnerships.
- 5:40They lose access to the richness of social life, which I would argue is one of the best parts of being human.
- 5:47Matt Abrahams: Is it binary?
- 5:48Is it you're either a cynic or you're not?
- 5:50Is there a continuum?
- 5:51And what do you find in the work that you've done and the work others have done in terms of are most people towards the cynical side or are they more optimistic?
- 5:59And well, let me ask this, what's the opposite of cynicism?
- 6:01Jamil Zaki: First, cynicism is not a binary, it's a spectrum.
- 6:05So there's all sorts of tests where you can measure your own cynicism through answering questions like, do you agree that most people would lie if they could get away with it?
- 6:16Or do you think that most people only help others because they feel obligated to?
- 6:21There's fifty questions like that, you can find a cynicism test online.
- 6:25And people range and they vary enormously.
- 6:28I would add that it's not just that people differ from each other.
- 6:31We differ from ourselves at different times and in different environments, right?
- 6:36So at a poker table, it's perfectly natural to be pretty cynical about the people you're playing against.
- 6:42They probably do have their best interest in mind.
- 6:44At a charity drive, maybe that's not as smart an assumption.
- 6:48What's the opposite of a cynic?
- 6:50It depends who you ask.
- 6:51If you ask a cynic, then the opposite of a cynic is a gullible rube or chump or mark.
- 6:59The opposite of cynicism is being naive.
- 7:02I would argue, from a scientific perspective, being naïve and being cynical are actually quite similar to one another.
- 7:08A naïve person might credulously, unthinkingly put faith in everybody without evidence and end up being betrayed.
- 7:16A cynic credulously and unthinkingly takes away faith from everybody.
- 7:21And neither one of them uses much evidence.
- 7:24You can think of both naive trusters and cynics as sort of like lawyers in the trial against humanity, right?
- 7:30Where cynics are part of the prosecution and naive trusters are part of the defense.
- 7:36I would say that the opposite of cynicism is skepticism.
- 7:40That is, not having one assumption or the other about what people are like.
- 7:46But thinking instead of like a lawyer, thinking like a scientist and looking for evidence to support our claims.
- 7:52Skeptics, unlike cynics, are more open to learning from every single act of communication, every interaction that they have.
- 8:01And that I think makes them a lot wiser than either cynics or gullible people.
- 8:07Matt Abrahams: Thank you for that distinction.
- 8:09What are things we can do to foster what I think you call hopeful skepticism versus cynicism?
- 8:16How can we inculcate that?
- 8:17How can we teach that to others?
- 8:19How can we embody that in our own way and approach in situations where we might have a tendency to be cynical?
- 8:26Jamil Zaki: Yeah, it's a hard task because I think that our brains and minds are set up for cynicism.
- 8:33And actually, we've become more cynical as a population over the last fifty years, right?
- 8:39So in 1972, about half of Americans believed most people can be trusted.
- 8:44By 2018, that had fallen to a third of Americans, right?
- 8:47So we have cynical tendencies, I think, because we have what psychologists call negativity bias.
- 8:55That is, we pay more attention to threats than we do to opportunities or to beautiful things in the world.
- 9:01And that makes sense from a survival perspective, right?
- 9:04A hundred thousand years ago, the person who ignored a predator or a tsunami maybe wouldn't make it to pass on their genes.
- 9:13And the person who ignored the beauty of a sunset might be just fine, right?
- 9:17So, but that bias means that fighting cynicism is an uphill battle.
- 9:22But it's still a battle that we can fight and we can win.
- 9:24There's three steps that I suggest.
- 9:27The first is to think differently.
- 9:29So to acknowledge that we have negativity bias.
- 9:32And that might make us, as I was saying, too risk averse when it comes to trust and too negative in general about people.
- 9:39There's all sorts of evidence that people are more trustworthy, kinder, more compassionate than we realize.
- 9:47The average person underestimates the average person.
- 9:51So because of that, being skeptical about our cynicism can help.
- 9:56What I try to do when I find myself judging somebody, feeling suspicious, is to fact check my cynical beliefs.
- 10:03I say, well, wait a minute.
- 10:04Why do you think that?
- 10:06Why are you so sure that this person is going to betray you?
- 10:10Why are you so sure that what you're seeing in the news represents what people are really like?
- 10:15And that fact check can help me start in the journey of overcoming my own cynicism.
- 10:20Matt Abrahams: I think that self reflection, while hard, can be really helpful.
- 10:25We tend to seek out confirmatory experiences, which to me might be a bit of a challenge for this cynicism toolkit that you're providing.
- 10:35What advice do you have to broaden our worldview?
- 10:38Because it's very easy for me to say, oh see, that I was right, you know.
- 10:42Are there suggestions you have for managing that?
- 10:44Jamil Zaki: Absolutely.
- 10:45I think, first of all, I just want to co sign what you've said.
- 10:48It feels great to be right even if what you're right about feels terrible.
- 10:52A cynic might have a sort of bleak, bitter satisfaction when they see somebody act poorly.
- 10:59Because they say, aha, I've had their number all along, but we shouldn't be so ready to sit on our laurels as cynics, right?
- 11:07Instead, we might want to challenge ourselves, not just with what we think, but with what we do, right?
- 11:12We've talked about how we can be reflective and challenge our assumptions by fact checking them.
- 11:18I, as I said, I sometimes say, what evidence do you have to support this cynical idea?
- 11:22Oftentimes, my answer is, not much evidence at all.
- 11:25So the second step is to collect evidence.
- 11:28What does that mean?
- 11:29It means treat your life a little bit more like an experiment.
- 11:32If there is a person who you're considering trusting and you're sort of feeling yourself pulling away, maybe make the opposite choice.
- 11:40If you typically look at one news source because it confirms all of your expectations, try to check out a different one.
- 11:47Vary your experiences.
- 11:49Now, I want to be clear.
- 11:50I'm not telling people to put it all on the line.
- 11:53I'm not saying that you should send your bank information to a prince who's going to forward you fourteen million dollars or to an influencer who says that there's one weird trick that will give you passive income and clear up your skin at the same time, right?
- 12:06We don't need to be naive.
- 12:08We just need to be data driven, and when we are, pleasant surprises are everywhere.
- 12:13Matt Abrahams: I like that idea that it's more than just reflection and thinking, it's about the doing.
- 12:14In thinking about my own life, I know when something's going on that I am a bit cynical about.
- 12:14I'll seek
- 12:26others I know who will reinforce that cynicism.
- 12:28I have friends who will see the world the same way and we get together and rar together.
- 12:33But I also know there are times where I'm feeling cynical and I have some friends who are very optimistic and I'll seek them out just to get a difference of opinion.
- 12:39It's like being in a group and purposely having a devil's advocate to challenge you.
- 12:44It's not just what happens internally, it's also the people you surround yourself with.
- 12:47Jamil Zaki: Absolutely, we are fundamentally social creatures and the people you spend time with, choosing them is sort of like choosing who you will become.
- 12:57Because you're choosing your social environment and that environment shapes you, right?
- 13:00And I think that absolutely many of us crave confirmation of our negative assumptions and so we gravitate towards negative people.
- 13:10We also ourselves share a lot of negative information.
- 13:14There's a lot of temptation to go around giving life a one star review on Yelp.
- 13:18And that attracts a lot of attention on social media as well.
- 13:22Posting negatively gets you more clout, more, uh, notoriety than being positive.
- 13:28But this too is a trend we can fight.
- 13:30One by surrounding ourselves with people, as you said, this sort of team of rivals approach where you look for a challenge.
- 13:38But second, I also think that we can honor our influence over others and realize, you had asked earlier, is there something we can do to fight cynicism, not only in ourselves, but in the people we care about?
- 13:50One way to do that is through what I call positive gossip.
- 13:54We typically gossip most about the harm that people do.
- 13:58In my lab, we found that when we give people stories or show them examples of somebody acting selfishly, and then somebody acting generously, and we ask, which of these stories do you want to pass on to future participants?
- 14:11People are three times more likely to gossip about a selfish person than about a generous person.
- 14:17And again, there is a great reason for this from a survival perspective.
- 14:22We want to protect our communities from people who would hurt us.
- 14:25That's a beautiful instinct.
- 14:27But it doesn't always serve us, in fact, because we end up giving people an unnecessarily negative view of who's in the community.
- 14:36And so what I try to do in my life and what I encourage other people to do is to catch people in the act of kindness or of compassion or of open mindedness.
- 14:47And then talk about them, call them out for doing good things.
- 14:50Two things happen when you do that.
- 14:52The first is that you spread hopeful skepticism to the people in your lives.
- 14:57But the second is that you change yourself because of course, what we talk about becomes what we notice.
- 15:03And so a habit of speech around positive gossip turns into a habit of mind, which we could call positive noticing.
- 15:10Matt Abrahams: The notion of positive gossip and being strategic and very thoughtful about it, I think is a really important thing for us in our own lives.
- 15:18But I also think of within organizations and within other collectives, families, etcetera.
- 15:22I really appreciate that.
- 15:24You also study self fulfilling prophecies.
- 15:27Can you define what those are for us and perhaps give us an example or two of how we can leverage these to help us feel better and do better in the world?
- 15:36Jamil Zaki: It's a great question.
- 15:38And again, I think that a lot of us underestimate our power in the social world.
- 15:44My friend Vanessa Bohns studies this.
- 15:46She finds that much more than most people realize how we treat others changes who they become in our presence.
- 15:54And that, for cynics, I think leads to many toxic or sad self fulfilling prophecies.
- 16:00Cynics, for instance, are much more likely to micromanage, spy on other people, to threaten and browbeat them, to try to protect themselves from what they imagine is a selfish person on the other side of the interaction.
- 16:13Well, guess what?
- 16:14If you treat people that way, then they become more combative, aggressive, disrespectful, and selfish.
- 16:21And then the cynic says, aha, I was right all along.
- 16:25Matt Abrahams: And that's the self fulfilling nature of it is you've created the situation you expected.
- 16:28Yeah.
- 16:29Jamil Zaki: Exactly.
- 16:29That's exactly right.
- 16:31Now you asked not the gloomy version, but the brighter version.
- 16:35What can we do with it?
- 16:36And I would say that there are many cases where our instincts in an interaction is how can I protect myself?
- 16:42And that includes aggressive or even disrespectful action towards the other person.
- 16:47But watch out because if you focus too much on protecting yourself, you might damage the relationship and create that self fulfilling prophecy.
- 16:55Instead, we can remember that by acting positively, doing things like taking leaps of faith, trusting loudly, that those actions aren't just ways of showing who we want to be.
- 17:07They are also likely to bring out the best in the other person.
- 17:10This is what economists call earned trust, which is that when we treat somebody well, including treating them as though they are a trustworthy and kind person.
- 17:21We bring that side out of them people lower themselves to our expectations if we're cynical and they raise ourselves to our expectations if we are non cynical.
- 17:31Matt Abrahams: Using self fulfilling prophecy for good can have so many benefits and thank you for sharing.
- 17:36I first became aware of self fulfilling prophecies in my research on how to feel more confident in communication.
- 17:43And many of us set ourselves up for that gloomy doomy version where we see the one person who isn't paying attention and then say, oh, we're not doing a good job and therefore we end up doing a poor job.
- 17:53Jamil Zaki: Hmm.
- 17:53Matt Abrahams: And we can use that same self fulfilling prophecy mechanism for positive.
- 17:57Highlight the person who is engaged or think about the value.
- 18:00So I think self fulfilling prophecy is a tool we have in our toolkit.
- 18:04That many of us don't think of deploying to help us.
- 18:07Jamil, this has been a fantastic conversation.
- 18:09Before we end, I'd like to ask you three questions.
- 18:12One I create just for you.
- 18:13And two, I've asked everybody who's been on this podcast.
- 18:16Are you up for that?
- 18:16Jamil Zaki: Absolutely.
- 18:17Matt Abrahams: You have used just eloquent language and analogies.
- 18:22You've talked about toolkits, you've talked about being lawyers, you've talked about leaps of faith.
- 18:27How much time do you spend thinking about how you communicate these concepts?
- 18:32And what sort of drives that because you have such an eloquent way of helping us to understand.
- 18:38Is that conscious?
- 18:39What do you think about to do that?
- 18:40'Cause you do it so well.
- 18:42Jamil Zaki: That's very kind of you to say, Matt.
- 18:43A secret about me is that before I was ever a neuroscientist or psychologist, I dreamed of being a novelist.
- 18:50I love the written word and always have.
- 18:53And so turns of phrase matter to me.
- 18:56Metaphors matter to me.
- 18:58And the beauty of language matters to me.
- 19:00So when I write, do a lot of iteration and I look for linguistic moments that turns of phrase that feel resonant to me.
- 19:10But I also learn an enormous amount through dyadic conversation, right?
- 19:15I consider myself really a thinker on the page, but also a thinker in conversation.
- 19:20Oftentimes, in real time when talking to somebody, I'll come up with a way of describing something that I never would have if I wasn't with them, right?
- 19:27And being shaped by those conversations also helps me figure out what resonates with other people and what resonates with me.
- 19:35Matt Abrahams: I will absolutely read the novel you write when you take the time to do that.
- 19:39Thank you.
- 19:39And even in your description of what you do, you did so eloquently.
- 19:42A lot of us, I believe, in that conversation, in that dyadic exchange, a lot can be learned and just having a thought partner, maybe even if the person didn't know they were your thought partner, can be really helpful for those turns of phrase.
- 19:55Jamil Zaki: Yeah.
- 19:55You know, to build on that, I think a lot of us imagine thought to be something that occurs in our heads.
- 20:02I think thought happens in my hand when I'm writing and in the space between us when we speak.
- 20:07Matt Abrahams: I love that quote.
- 20:09Thought happens in the space between us.
- 20:11And I would actually suggest that many of the things you talk about, trust, empathy happens in that space between us, I like that.
- 20:19I'll be curious to get your answer to our second question.
- 20:22Who's a communicator that you admire and why?
- 20:25Jamil Zaki: Oh, there's so many.
- 20:26A person who immediately comes to mind for me is the psychologist, Dan Gilbert at Harvard.
- 20:32I was a longtime admirer of Dan's and I'm lucky to call him a friend now.
- 20:37Dan showed me what writing and speaking about the human mind could be, right?
- 20:43So I shared that I wanted to be a fiction writer and I always loved neuroscience and psychology.
- 20:49But one thing that I missed about it was the poetry of language and description.
- 20:54And Dan, more than almost anybody I've ever encountered, just naturally is able to access that.
- 21:01His way of thinking about even very esoteric pieces of social psychology is so intuitive and so natural that he makes these ideas come to life for anybody regardless of their background.
- 21:15Matt Abrahams: He is a great communicator.
- 21:17I'm a big fan of his written and spoken work.
- 21:20You remind all of us that we're not just translators for our material and our ideas, but we're also emotional conduits for it as well.
- 21:28Where the way we feel about it and what initiated our interest in it is something that's also important and he does a good job of it as you certainly do.
- 21:35Final question.
- 21:36What are the first three ingredients that go into a successful communication recipe?
- 21:42Jamil Zaki: I love this question.
- 21:43If I may, I want to talk about one type of communication that's been part of my lab's work recently, which is good disagreements.
- 21:52Disagreement, quite common, uh, in a lot of parts of our culture right now.
- 21:56And my lab and I have been really focused on, we bring people together to disagree about politics.
- 22:02And we ask ourselves, when do those conversations go well?
- 22:05What makes those disagreements useful?
- 22:07And there are three things that we see.
- 22:10The first is to agree about what we disagree about.
- 22:14Oftentimes, people bring so many assumptions to these charged, potentially threatening conversations that they never bother to figure out whether they have common ground.
- 22:25They imagine that the Venn diagram between their perspective and the other person's perspective is really just two circles.
- 22:31But if you actually were to measure these people's views, there'd be much more overlap.
- 22:36So good disagreement often entails actually figuring out what the disagreement is before jumping into it.
- 22:44The second piece that we find is that it's much more effective to share stories than to share opinions.
- 22:50People often feel attacked if you just tell them, no, you were wrong, these are the facts.
- 22:57They feel much more open if you say, well, tell me about how you started to feel this way.
- 23:02And let me share how I started to feel that way.
- 23:04That's a natural narrative form of communication that brings up trust.
- 23:10And empathy as well.
- 23:12And then the third piece is to be humble.
- 23:15I think a lot of us, especially in the context of disagreements, feel like we need to be confident to win.
- 23:22We're trying to battle this person to the ground.
- 23:26And it turns out that if we act that way and come into a disagreement that way, other people can tell and they don't react very well to it.
- 23:34That's a self fulfilling prophecy.
- 23:36If instead we enter a disagreement with the goal of accurately representing ourselves, but also learning from the other person.
- 23:44If we show that humility, if we admit when we're uncertain and ask questions of the other person, well, first of all, we actually do learn more from them.
- 23:53But second, that self fulfilling prophecy flips from something gloomy into something virtuous.
- 23:59That other person ends up listening to us more, opening up more.
- 24:04If you want somebody to pay attention to your perspective, one of the best things that you can do is show that you're paying attention to theirs first.
- 24:11Matt Abrahams: I am so glad that you are studying disagreement and good disagreement in our world today.
- 24:16It is such a big challenge.
- 24:18It's not surprising to me that you would end up studying that because I see it as sort of a crucible for all the things you're interested in.
- 24:24Cynicism and empathy and trust.
- 24:26The notion of figuring out what we agree on in our disagreement.
- 24:32The use of story, clearly something that's right in the bullseye of what we talk about.
- 24:36Jamil, thank you so much for your time.
- 24:39Super instructive.
- 24:40This notion of cynicism and how to bolster hopeful skepticism, the notion of trusting loudly, positive gossip, all of this is so helpful.
- 24:52Thank you for your time and best of luck on your new book.
- 24:55Jamil Zaki: Matt, this has been delightful and thank you for all you do to bring these great messages to so many people.
- 25:02Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 25:07To learn more about how we create our social reality, please listen to Episode 84 with Brian Lowery.
- 25:13And to better understand connection and deepening relationships, check out Episode 128 with David Brooks.
- 25:20This episode was produced by Jenny Luna, Ryan Campos, and me, Matt Abrahams.
- 25:25Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 25:27With thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 25:30Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 25:34Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 25:35Also follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram and check out fastersmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language learning content, and our newsletter.