Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 207 - The Man Who Privatised an American City | Oliver Porter
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 207 of the Free Cities podcast. Yes, hello.
- 0:38Welcome to Friday, people. I hope you had a wonderful week. I hope you were super productive.
- 0:44I was super productive and I'm going to get straight into all that production and what it
- 0:49was right now. I did tell you last week I made an announcement of an announcement last week,
- 0:55didn't I? Well here comes the announcement everyone. Now you may be noticing recently if
- 1:01you've got eagle eyes that I'm bringing on a number of new sponsors. The number of sponsors
- 1:07is sort of going up every week one by one. This week it was Blink Wallet. Blink started out as
- 1:15the Bitcoin Beach Wallet in El Zonte you may know in El Salvador. They're now a wallet called Blink
- 1:21which is well known and well liked, especially around the Latin parts of the Americas.
- 1:26Well, there's a reason why all these new sponsors are coming on board.
- 1:31And that's because the Free Cities podcast is becoming an actual business going forward.
- 1:37That's right. From the 1st of January, we're going out on our own.
- 1:42The podcast is becoming independent.
- 1:45What does this mean?
- 1:46Well, a rebrand for starters and a slight name change in the same vein as the fact the conference,
- 1:53that's the Free Cities Conference, changed its name from Liberty in Our Lifetime to the Free Cities Conference,
- 1:58just because everyone called it that.
- 2:00The new name of this podcast will just be Free Cities with yours truly, because that's what everyone says.
- 2:06In fact, in one corner of polite society, I'm just known as Tim from Free Cities.
- 2:12That's what everyone calls me.
- 2:13So, hey, why not just give in to the meme?
- 2:16Anyway, the Free Cities Foundation has been a phenomenal backer of this show for the last four years, for which I'm truly grateful.
- 2:23And we will be continuing our relationship going forwards, just in a slightly different way.
- 2:29I obviously have big plans for the show in the upcoming months.
- 2:34And we'll be spending much more time with the people actually building freer places to live around the world.
- 2:39I want to get out there and see what works, what goes wrong, what happens when ordinary people move in.
- 2:43and how to make a life there. And I will keep doing the long in-person conversations,
- 2:50but I'll be building out freecities.fm to a much bigger platform so there's somewhere
- 2:56to follow these stories between episodes. I'll certainly be covering a broader selection of the
- 3:03market of living together and that's mainly because I've seen just general interest in
- 3:08new places to live absolutely skyrocket over the last few years. And of course I predict that this
- 3:13trend will continue into the future. So what does this mean for you as a listener to the Free Cities
- 3:19podcast? Well if you're listening on a podcast app which I think you must be if you're listening to
- 3:25this because I don't do a spoken intro on the video version well you don't actually have to do
- 3:31anything. The RSS feed will be coming with me and pumping out the show as usual it will just have
- 3:37the new branding on it. If you watch on YouTube, however, unfortunately, I can't bring that channel
- 3:43with me. That belongs to the Free Cities Foundation and it has all their other videos on it too.
- 3:48So I'm starting my new channel. Please subscribe to the new channel now to give me a little bit
- 3:56of support in the preemptive month or two months up until we launch. That channel is
- 4:02at Timothy Allen. Very easy to remember. T-I-M-O-T-H-Y-A-L-L-E-N. That's where the new videos
- 4:11will be dropping from January the 1st. I've actually started putting some shorts on there
- 4:17in the meantime, just to pad it out before the changeover. And we're up to 943 subscribers
- 4:23when I just checked. So we're getting close to a thousand. And thanks to everyone who's already
- 4:29click the follow button but I've got basically two months to activate this channel so please
- 4:36subscribe to at Timothy Allen on YouTube but also just click on videos comment share them anything
- 4:44like that will be super helpful to sort of activate the channel before we go live the other channels
- 4:50that are coming with me well you can follow the pod on at free cities pod on x that's staying the
- 4:57same and follow me on x which is at mr timothy allen mr m-r-t-i-m-o-t-h-y-a-l-l-e-n that's where
- 5:06i be dropping all the videos really the timothy allen accounts are basically going to be the free cities accounts but I can change the name Too much hassle It doesn matter The TikTok account staying the same
- 5:18That's at Free Cities Podcast on TikTok.
- 5:21We're up to 2,400 followers there, so that's getting pretty good.
- 5:26All these links, of course, will be in the show notes.
- 5:29Those are, I think, all the channels that I'll be bringing with me.
- 5:32The only things, basically, I'm leaving behind are the Foundation's own channels
- 5:36that currently syndicate vids and needs and that's mainly x the foundation's x account and
- 5:43the foundation's youtube account which will be switching like i say over to the timothy allen ones
- 5:47on january the 1st 2027 so a recap as of january the 1st 2027 the new show will go live
- 5:57and also obviously watch this space for all the new things that will be coming with that
- 6:01I'm building it all out now you won't be disappointed I am beyond incredibly excited
- 6:07to start this new chapter of the pod and of course I will be extremely happy to have you
- 6:14guys come along for the ride and also just send me a message about this if you've got any ideas
- 6:20I am like an open book at the moment I've got funding and backers and sponsors now to carry
- 6:27this on into the future but I'm always looking for more if you're a product and you want to reach
- 6:31out to our audience, drop me a line. Or if you just think, you know what, I could help Tim grow
- 6:35that show because there's so much growth potential here. Drop me a line. Give me an idea. I'll get on
- 6:42a call with you. I'll talk to you. It's such a great asset, this show in the Free Cities world.
- 6:47And I've got so many great plans for it, but I'm obviously missing some of them. So if you've got
- 6:52that kind of entrepreneurial spirit and you want to come on board, drop me a line. I'm all ears.
- 6:57um one more quick favor as well this always it's always bugged me i don't know why but
- 7:02if you're listening on apple podcasts can you follow the show or give it click the
- 7:08star button or or just leave us a comment i've never quite understood why there's hardly any
- 7:15reviews on apple podcasts we've got like seven reviews for some reason like whereas on spotify
- 7:21I've got 50. I don't know what that means. I don't know whether this, but when I look at the stats,
- 7:28it does look like a lot of people watch on Apple or listen. It's just they, maybe they're just,
- 7:35maybe that's just Apple people. Maybe that's a character flaw in them. Actually, not a flaw,
- 7:41guys. Anyway, right, let's get on to the show. That's enough of that news for the time being.
- 7:46today's show well my guest is a gentleman by the name of oliver porter i sat down with oliver in
- 7:54prospera and we talked about a project which is one of the og projects from this space and it's
- 8:01about a city just north of atlanta called sandy springs now when sandy springs became a city back
- 8:08in 2005 it hired private firms to do most of the work that a local government would normally do
- 8:17itself that means roads parks planning finance etc the police and the fire stayed public but
- 8:23everything else was private and oliver helped put that whole model together
- 8:27and he sees it obviously as a forerunner to at least impart what prosperer is trying to do right
- 8:34now. Now what makes this story interesting is that Sandy Springs also kept changing the arrangement.
- 8:40It went from relying mainly on one contractor to then hiring several and later brought some
- 8:45services back in-house to the government blah blah blah. So it begs the question which bits of
- 8:51running a city actually benefit from competition and how do you know when it's time to change the
- 8:56deal? I'm not sure Prosper are actually thinking about that but Sandy Springs definitely had to.
- 9:01this is a great convo once again with one of the ogs of this space um and he's one of the pioneers
- 9:07who's still innovating right now he's on prosperous council as well still innovating there right before
- 9:13we get to oliver a bit of unfinished business from last week's show i had a few messages people
- 9:18didn't really understand what we were talking about i forgot to mention it in the intro if you
- 9:22heard me and joe quirk talking about a roast and wondered what the hell we were talking about
- 9:28long story short is I gave a talk at the conference this year and it was just a very tongue-in-cheek
- 9:35talk about I don't know even how to explain it but one section of it was called don't listen to
- 9:43joke work and it was a joke basically I went back through all my old interviews with Joe and other
- 9:49people and pulled out stories of people who listened to joke work and ended up doing really
- 9:54crazy and weird things basically and sort of juxtaposed it to a clip of Joe saying he'd retire
- 10:00once he secured a flag for a seastead which he did so he should be retiring number one and and
- 10:05then you know mentioned the people whose lives had been literally turned upside down by listening
- 10:13to Joe anyway The joke is of course and Joe took it very well that it harmless enough listening to him until basically you screw your life up completely Anyway it looks like that whole speech will actually be going live on the Free Cities Foundation YouTube channel at some
- 10:32point. I just saw it pop up in the unlisted video section. So at one point that'll go out. When it
- 10:38does, I'll point you to it if you want to have a bit of a laugh. Right, two quick bits of Free Cities
- 10:43news. First, Malaysia and Singapore's new joint ministerial committee met on Monday and reported
- 10:49nearly 89 billion Malaysian ringgit in approved investment for the Johor Singapore special
- 10:57economic zone. They said about 45% of that investment has been implemented. The thing I'll
- 11:02be watching is what happens at the border itself. If you know that border, I've traveled across that
- 11:07border many times. It's how you get from Singapore to Malaysia, basically. So I'll be watching that.
- 11:13can people actually get to work move goods and do business across it more easily after this
- 11:20another bit of free zone news in oman the al-mazuna free zone hosted a trade forum this week
- 11:27for businesses and officials from oman and yemen the zone sits right next to the yemeni border
- 11:34it's a different scale from johor but it raises a similar question how much trade can you unlock
- 11:39by making one crossing easier to work with.
- 11:43Slightly belated birthday this week as well to Sealand,
- 11:47which turned 59 on the 2nd of September.
- 11:50I forgot that one.
- 11:51Back in 67, as you know, a pirate radio broadcaster called Roy Bates
- 11:55declared independence on an old wartime seafort off the Suffolk coast.
- 12:01Do you know why he chose that date?
- 12:03That's right, it was his wife's birthday.
- 12:06Joan, I don't know what you got your other half last year, but Roy, well, he gave his principality,
- 12:14or at least half of it anyway. A reminder also about Bitfest. I'll be in Manchester from the
- 12:2019th to the 22nd of November. I'll be recording a few interesting conversations while I'm there
- 12:25for this pod. I'm also speaking at Freedom Fest on the Saturday at the Pendulum Hotel.
- 12:31a full bit fest ticket gets you into freedom fest as well and if you want a discount just tap in
- 12:39in all caps free cities when you buy your ticket and you'll get some money off and come and say
- 12:46hello if you come in as well right this week's value for value top five i'm going to go and
- 12:51reverse order this week why not fifth place rev hodl fourth nathan day nathan that's interesting
- 12:58nathan is actually organizing bit fest well done nathan a stalwart of the bitcoin and lost a
- 13:04community there uh number three bit uh muslim bitcoiner don't get many of them number two
- 13:10justin bianchi and at number one yawn yawn no i love you really and on and on thank you all five
- 13:16of you few comments this week and on and on joe is the goat talking about joe quirk and justin
- 13:25Bianchi he sent oh he sent 4,000 sats before listening to Joe and then come back afterwards
- 13:31with another zap and asked if we could do it again because he'd been hoping to hear more of
- 13:36Joe's quirky ideas. Fair enough Justin I did try in the episode to ask Joe if he ever thinks about
- 13:42anything other than seasteading because that was the fourth time we've talked and I think I've heard
- 13:47all the seasteading talking points at this point. So yes it's not easy to get anything else out of
- 13:54him even though he's written a number of really interesting books if we get around to a fifth one
- 13:59next year I promise I will dive deeply into all his other weird and wonderful ideas right Rev
- 14:06Hoddle also boost on the Tellerman episode another shout out to the 48 hours per week guys I think
- 14:13I've done my 40 hours this week I should post that really shouldn't I right before we get into the
- 14:19show our wonderful sponsors Veritas Villages first Oliver and I talk about what it takes to make a
- 14:26place work once people actually move in and there's a milestone I mentioned a couple of weeks ago
- 14:31from Veritas and I liked it exactly for this reason in September Sarah and Jason
- 14:37collected the keys to their new home in Coronado Panama and they were the first owners to get their
- 14:43keys there that's one of the new ones Veritas is building communities in Panama Costa Rica Nicaragua
- 14:49for people who want more say over how they live including opportunities to grow food and generate
- 14:56power if you're thinking about a second home a move somewhere to a plan b or a plan a you could
- 15:04be just get over to veritasvillages.com forward slash free cities i won't be mentioning blink this
- 15:11week i'll do a proper intro into who blink are next week amity age is another new sponsor
- 15:16and if you're interested in having more control over where your power comes from, well that brings
- 15:22me to Amity age of course, their project in Alberta, Canada is built around a simple idea.
- 15:28Take gas that stranded at the wellhead turn it into electricity on site and use that power to mine Bitcoin and possibly AI data centers in the future at some point The wells the land the equipment that generates the power they all part of the
- 15:43project and they're buying them all up this time. They're not renting them. They're not doing
- 15:46long-term leases. They're buying them at this time. And just remember, guys, Alberta isn't
- 15:52Ottawa. It's Canada's most pro-energy province. So when you hear the word Canada, this is in Alberta,
- 15:59a province with a very long history of getting energy projects built.
- 16:03If you're an accredited investor and you want to be a part of this incredible project,
- 16:08go to amityage.com forward slash free cities and request the details there, right?
- 16:14And finally, my wonderful and finally section.
- 16:18I had a look at what else is on in Sandy Springs at the moment.
- 16:22the city's art center has a show next thursday called atlanta's funniest priests six local priests
- 16:31are doing original stand-up and guess what guys it's sold out if you want to find out whether
- 16:36sandy springs made a success of contracting out city services well oliver can help you with that
- 16:42if you want to find out whether it's priests are funny well you'll have to queue for that one
- 16:48well done clanker for a little pun at the end there right let's get into it sit back please
- 16:54relax and enjoy my conversation with oliver porter
- 16:59there you go that's good and i hope you can have someone to interpret a southern drawl
- 17:15I think so I love the south whereabouts whereabouts in the south are you from
- 17:21well the Atlanta area um the city we started is on the northern boundary of Atlanta right
- 17:28so I like I said earlier I've done a I've done a a not I've done a no I wouldn't call it a deep
- 17:35dive into Sandy Springs but I've given myself just enough information to what to know roughly
- 17:40what it was and what the contract city model is.
- 17:47Obviously, maybe you could introduce yourself first just for people that won't know you.
- 17:53I've got a little biog here, but I'd quite like to hear it from yourself, if you don't mind.
- 17:56Okay.
- 17:57Well, Oliver Porter, originally from South Carolina, now reside in the city of Sandy Springs,
- 18:04just north of the, on the northern boundary of Atlanta.
- 18:07background wise
- 18:10I have an
- 18:12engineering degree from
- 18:14the University of South Carolina and an MBA
- 18:16from Georgia State
- 18:17I have
- 18:20retired
- 18:21I actually have been retired
- 18:24longer than I worked
- 18:25that's rather unusual but I retired as a vice
- 18:28president of AT&T
- 18:29with responsibility for
- 18:3114 states
- 18:33as we set up the new
- 18:36company after the government broke us up. And before that, I was in one of the Bell operating
- 18:42companies and moved through engineering, planning, the regulatory arena, finance,
- 18:50and ended up in marketing, which is vice president of marketing, which is a terrible thing to do to a
- 18:54good engineer. But maybe I wasn't that good an engineer, I don't know. But that's where I ended up.
- 19:00and I've had an extensive background in charitable work.
- 19:07I was a national chairman of the National Kidney Foundation Health Organization
- 19:13and actually founder of Combined Health Appeal of America,
- 19:18which was a federation of major health agencies.
- 19:21So that's kept me busy all through my career.
- 19:26Sounds like what I'd call an illustrious career.
- 19:29to me. I like the way
- 19:31I like the fact that you've been retired more than you've worked.
- 19:35That says something. That really does
- 19:37say something. I mean that really is quite
- 19:39incredible when you think about it. What have you been
- 19:41doing in your retirement then?
- 19:42I doubt that someone like you would really
- 19:45actually retire per se if you know
- 19:47what I mean. Yeah
- 19:48for about three years I ran
- 19:50the health charity to
- 19:52combine health appeal.
- 19:55After we founded it
- 19:56eight years earlier it had not done well.
- 19:58We were competing, for those of you who are from the States, with the United Way, which is a very powerful organization working with employee giving around the country.
- 20:10So they were not allowing our health agencies to be a part of them.
- 20:14So we had to go out and form our own, but it was a tough competition.
- 20:18And so after eight years, it hadn't been doing well.
- 20:20So when I decided to retire from my corporate life, I met with the board of that group and said,
- 20:26if you all will let me close it down and move it to Atlanta,
- 20:29I'll bring in some ex-corporate executives who know how to approach employees.
- 20:35And so short story, I told them I would give them two years,
- 20:38and if it wasn't working any better, we'd close it.
- 20:41I actually gave them three years, but at that time we were doing $50 million a year in annual giving.
- 20:46So I felt quite good about being able to step aside.
- 20:50After that, I helped a young man who was a friend of a friend to help start a company.
- 21:00He was an inventor and had a product he wanted to take to market,
- 21:04so I gave him a year of free service just for a piece of the company.
- 21:09Then I guess the next big thing was getting involved with the Sandy Springs,
- 21:15the starting of the new city of Sandy Springs.
- 21:18In between those parts, I'm an amateur artist, painter,
- 21:22and have become an author.
- 21:24Never thought.
- 21:26As I can see, you've got a book there.
- 21:27What kind of art, out of interest, what kind of things?
- 21:30Landscapes, that kind of stuff?
- 21:32You said you're an artist as well.
- 21:34What kind of stuff?
- 21:35Yes, primarily in oils, but I'm very eclectic.
- 21:40I do landscapes, I do still lifes, and I do portraits.
- 21:43let me tell you what i understand about sandy springs so you can and then you tell me you know
- 21:51take it from there basically because um first of all it's worth noting is it true you sit on the
- 21:57council of the council of prosper i am and in addition i'm on the board of directors of new way
- 22:02the parent company right because when i first started looking into this i'd never heard of
- 22:07sandy springs until someone put me on to you and when i looked at it and looked at what what sandy
- 22:14springs is or was it seems that prospera is kind of like a turbocharged version of sandy springs in
- 22:21a way exactly i look i look at sandy springs as a forerunner of a portion of the effort in prospera
- 22:28right okay so that that's a good starting point then i was i wanted to make sure i was it was
- 22:33Correct. So maybe you maybe can you just break down for us what the contract city model is, which is the model that you used at Sandy Springs?
- 22:44Yeah, I'd be very glad to. Basically, typical, well, almost unanimously across the country, we have bureaucratic local governments.
- 22:55That is, the council, the leadership hires all of the employees to provide the services.
- 23:01Sandy Springs differs 180 degrees from that.
- 23:06We actually started the new city of almost 100,000 people with only two employees.
- 23:13Everything else is contracted out.
- 23:16All services, all administration is contracted out and primarily to private industry.
- 23:22And that was a totally new concept at that time.
- 23:27so we we we call it a contract city or a public-private partnership I prefer contract
- 23:35city because public-private partnerships have different types have gained some degree of
- 23:42opposition from some people but this one was a totally looking to private industry to start the
- 23:50city put it on its feet and get it running now for those that aren't familiar and I wasn't it
- 23:56took me quite a while to work out how you privatize a city to begin with that that part
- 24:02i mean it wasn't that i just googled it and it told me quite simply um but okay break it down
- 24:08because it's it's not as yeah it's not a simple thing it's not and it's been done since am i
- 24:15correct um but but why don't you break down what actually happens like what is the city to begin
- 24:21with. Let me describe that. It is an existing community that's been there for over 100 years
- 24:27growing. It's part of Fulton County, which is the largest county in Georgia, stretches about 60
- 24:36miles, and we were at the very near the northern tip of it. We had been seeking, if I could go
- 24:43ahead and give you a little background on that, seeking to become a city, to be incorporated
- 24:49for over a quarter century.
- 24:52The legislature in Georgia
- 24:54controls cities.
- 24:56They can make them,
- 24:59break them, change them.
- 25:00Before you go on,
- 25:01can I just ask a question?
- 25:03What's the difference
- 25:04between a city and a non-city then?
- 25:05Is it to do with how big it is?
- 25:07Is it to do with what?
- 25:08No, it has to do with
- 25:09whether it's incorporated or not.
- 25:11You're a county.
- 25:13Everybody in Georgia is in a county.
- 25:15All cities are in counties.
- 25:17But you can then break down to the next level, you might say, of government and become a city or an incorporated entity.
- 25:25That is controlled by the state legislature.
- 25:29Another question. Sorry, I've got to get this straight in my mind first before I ask too many questions.
- 25:34So it's not the term city doesn't denounce anything to do with the size or what's going on there, whatever.
- 25:41It's already a city in that sense.
- 25:43It's a community.
- 25:44It's a community, right. But if I was to visit before you got city status, would I have thought I'm in a city? Did it seem like it was a city? Was it big enough?
- 25:53You might very well have thought you were You passed through Sandy Springs the next one north of us is Roswell It been a city for 100 years Roswell Yeah As in New Mexico Roswell Yeah but it Roswell Georgia Oh right okay So no UFO connection
- 26:09Right.
- 26:10So we wanted to basically separate from Fulton County in a sense.
- 26:16We're still in Fulton County.
- 26:18We still pay them more taxes than we paid to our city,
- 26:21and they provide a minimal amount of services,
- 26:23but we want it to be on our own.
- 26:27Right.
- 26:27So that's the main incentive to get city classification in this sense is to take control of where the money goes.
- 26:38Do you get a cut of the taxes in return or anything like that?
- 26:41Or do you get to choose where they go yourself?
- 26:43How does it work?
- 26:44Well, before we became a city, we were 11% of the population of the county.
- 26:52But we paid 22% of the taxes.
- 26:56So we often said you could hear the swoosh as the money left town,
- 27:00and no services came back.
- 27:02We were very poorly served, very heavily taxed.
- 27:05We wanted autonomy.
- 27:07We wanted to control our future.
- 27:09But the main reason we wanted autonomy was to control zoning.
- 27:13The county would let anything be built that would pay them some taxes.
- 27:17They didn't care what it did to our community,
- 27:19and our people really wanted to get control of our future.
- 27:23So that was a long-winded way to say, now, what is a city?
- 27:27A city basically in the states is normally composed of three levels.
- 27:33The, you might say, top level is the elected officials, a council and a mayor.
- 27:39They set policy.
- 27:41They establish the budget.
- 27:43The next layer down is a professional layer, a city manager or city administrator,
- 27:49who then carries out those policies.
- 27:52And in the normal bureaucratic city, then you have all the employees that are the workforce.
- 27:57That's the third level.
- 27:58All we have done is substitute for that third level, instead of an employee workforce, a private company contractor.
- 28:09The top level still sets all the policies.
- 28:13You still have a city manager to carry those out.
- 28:16He manages basically the contract.
- 28:18And then the workforce, which is this huge amount of people, is done with private industry.
- 28:25That's the innovation.
- 28:27And I suppose that that innovation is driven by the fact that you don't, without needing so many employees,
- 28:34then bringing the free market in means that you get better services cheaper with less people.
- 28:38Is that roughly speaking?
- 28:40That's a good way to sum it up.
- 28:42It's free market.
- 28:43It's competition because we have competition for these contracts.
- 28:47and then you get a level of service that's well beyond anything that goes on in the bureaucratic
- 28:54cities in in the uk but we i think everything the government wants to create or pay for they have to
- 29:01put it out to tender are you saying is that is it you know like so that it's potentially there is
- 29:06competition there they're building something um i think probably if i'm honest there's there's
- 29:12there's a lot of nepotism going on in that realm but you could say the same thing for a free market
- 29:19as well yeah so so what talk a little bit to that is there are there risks involved in this
- 29:24people uh initial knee jerk reaction was there would even be more uh nepotism more um of the
- 29:34bad doings going on in fact the matter and i can explain why it's far less than uh than is normal
- 29:41But that was a worry from the beginning.
- 29:45But it has not proven to be a problem at all.
- 29:49And who came up with this idea then?
- 29:53Well, I did.
- 29:54You did?
- 29:55I did.
- 29:55So, I mean, that seems like quite a big ask to sort of approach your county representatives or whatever and say,
- 30:08we'd really like to change what you do.
- 30:11I mean, how do you even go about that?
- 30:12I can understand once the model's in existence,
- 30:15I can understand how it works,
- 30:16but how do you start something like that?
- 30:17Well, as I said, for 25 years,
- 30:19we fought the battle with the legislature
- 30:21and that I did not lead.
- 30:23When I said I did,
- 30:24it was the public-private model that I created.
- 30:27But for so long, the South, for over 100 years,
- 30:32had been controlled by a Democratic Party.
- 30:34In Georgia, the governor, the Senate, House of Representatives were all controlled by the Democratic Party who opposed the idea of the city.
- 30:43And that was because of the heavy political influence of the city of Atlanta who wanted us.
- 30:49They wanted to annex us.
- 30:51We didn't want that.
- 30:52So in 2002, the Republicans finally took the governorship in the House, excuse me, in the Senate.
- 31:01and we thought maybe we'll now get our bill through.
- 31:05It didn't happen.
- 31:07And so 2004 the Republicans took the final element took the Senate and they told us that you going to be number one on our list of things to do
- 31:22And they came through, although they were very slow in doing it.
- 31:26So the political battle had waged.
- 31:29No one had ever thought of doing a contract city.
- 31:33We had two extremely significant problems and surprises, that when the draft of the bill came out, they had assigned the date of December 1 of 2005 as a start.
- 31:48Well, by the time we saw the draft, that was less than a year to start the city.
- 31:53But the really tough obstacle was that they gave no one in the new city any authority until the city council was seated, which would be December 1st.
- 32:06So we have no ability to hire anyone, to put in place any equipment systems, buildings, anything, until the council is seated.
- 32:16and at that moment they've got to have a fully operational city around them.
- 32:19How do you get from here to there?
- 32:23If I could just ramble on a minute.
- 32:25You can ramble on as long as you want.
- 32:26In January of that year, 2005, they had asked me,
- 32:31the committee that had worked all these years,
- 32:34asked me to take on the responsibility for starting the city,
- 32:37actually implementing it.
- 32:39To backtrack even further, some years back,
- 32:43when I had first come on the committee,
- 32:44which had been in existence a long time, I asked, you know,
- 32:47what kind of city is it that we are expecting?
- 32:50I mean, how will it be organized?
- 32:52How will it operate?
- 32:53And everyone said, well, we don't know, haven't thought about that yet.
- 32:58We're just trying to get the bill passed.
- 33:01So they said, why don't you form a charter commission
- 33:04to establish all of those rules of operation for the city?
- 33:10I did that.
- 33:11I brought in 12 people from all of the areas of the city and asked them to start from ground zero.
- 33:17We had not started a new city in Georgia in 50 years, so we didn't have any model to follow.
- 33:24And they were a great group of people.
- 33:26It was an amazingly interesting task.
- 33:29You could almost liken it to writing the U.S. Constitution.
- 33:34From ground zero, you're putting this thing together.
- 33:37Not quite that grandiose, but it was challenging to us.
- 33:40worked hard and came up with a charter, which the committee then passed,
- 33:44and it went on ice for several years.
- 33:48Later on, I said, well, okay, we've got a charter,
- 33:50but how are we actually going to start this city?
- 33:53And everyone said, we don't know.
- 33:56So I went home and took out a yellow pad and drew up a plan for starting the city,
- 34:02brought it in, the committee passed it.
- 34:04Nothing happened that year, and the next year we thought we might get it,
- 34:07and they proved it again, and nothing happened.
- 34:09and then finally we say we're going to get it.
- 34:13So in January of 2005, I formed a dozen task forces,
- 34:18volunteer task forces, numbered about 120 people altogether
- 34:21to work on 12 elements of service that I had outlined,
- 34:26everything from transportation to police, fire, roads, what have you.
- 34:31These task forces worked quite diligently for a couple of months,
- 34:35basically assuming they were trying to design a traditional city.
- 34:42I knew all along we couldn't.
- 34:46There was just no way to get from here to there.
- 34:49So at one point I said, maybe the corporate world is the answer,
- 34:55and I guess maybe my own background maybe led me to do that.
- 34:58Maybe it was my basic feelings about free enterprise and competition
- 35:03and so forth that led me to that.
- 35:04But I began to think about the idea of a contract city.
- 35:10So I, on my own, addressed a letter to 12 major corporations that I thought might have the capability of meeting our needs.
- 35:20And I asked them two simple questions.
- 35:23One, here's a matrix of the services that we need, the 12 services.
- 35:27where have you done these types of service for any sort of government,
- 35:33federal, state, local, military, whatever.
- 35:36Let me know if you can do that.
- 35:38And the second question was a real doozy, as we say in America.
- 35:42It said, would you be willing to spend the millions of dollars
- 35:45and resources necessary to start our city without a contract?
- 35:50Because no one can give you one until after the city is formed.
- 35:54and interestingly enough, I got 12 responses.
- 36:00Well, I got, I guess, responses from everyone, but half of them said no.
- 36:05The other half indicated where they had performed some services.
- 36:08Some of them, it was just one service maybe.
- 36:10I had a list of 12.
- 36:11Others, maybe several, multiple.
- 36:14No one had provided all of them, but between them all, I filled in my matrix,
- 36:19and I had someone who could provide all the services.
- 36:21So I moved forward once again retreated to my basement office and began to draft requests for proposals RFPs which asked the companies to propose what they can do for us and what the prices would be and so forth
- 36:39Spelled out that it was a competitive bid and spelled out what the qualifications we would be looking for and how we would rank them and so forth.
- 36:47and said this is what we will approach the private industry with this proposal, these RFPs.
- 36:55I could not issue those initially because no one even knew I had written them
- 37:02until the bill got through the legislature, finally House in April,
- 37:10the Senate later in the month, and then the governor didn't sign until mid-April.
- 37:15he delayed quite a while
- 37:19and so
- 37:20but even then we didn't have approval for a city
- 37:23the bill called for a
- 37:25referendum of the citizens
- 37:26of the community on whether they wanted
- 37:29a city or not and that would not take place
- 37:31until June 6th
- 37:32so still didn't have a go ahead to do anything
- 37:35almost
- 37:36except what I was doing in private
- 37:38the
- 37:40governor did sign
- 37:42we did have the referendum
- 37:44We got 94%.
- 37:45Yes.
- 37:46That's amazing.
- 37:47In America, you can't get 94% of the people say the sun comes up the east.
- 37:51I mean, that's a landslide.
- 37:56And we were now authorized to go forward.
- 37:59So I'm still grappling with a few concepts here.
- 38:03Sorry.
- 38:04So you said 50 years ago, 50 years prior, which is the first time that a new city had been found.
- 38:08Last time, yeah.
- 38:09Right, okay.
- 38:10What were the incentives 50 years prior?
- 38:12Yeah. Because I think what I'm understanding is the innovation that you guys came up with was the private companies.
- 38:21Right. Okay. So 50 years prior, when a city was incorporated, what was the benefit at that point to them?
- 38:30It actually was involved with the Atlanta airport mostly, which is on the southern end of Atlanta.
- 38:35Huge airport, busiest one in the world, I think, at this point.
- 38:39But a lot of pilots were interested in housing and having places that they could get to drive to the airport easily from.
- 38:47So they were a good bit of the impetus for forming a city called Peachtree City, South Atlanta.
- 38:54And they got the corporation and did establish a city.
- 38:59And their city was not, there was not much of a community there.
- 39:02It was more of a greenfields startup sort of situation.
- 39:06So it had done well over the years.
- 39:07But what was the advantage for them in the sense that you talked about these three layers, the council, then the management, then the employees.
- 39:17Are you saying that 50 years prior, when they got city status, they still had a workforce employed by the city?
- 39:26So your innovation was instead of employing however many people needed to be employed, you decided, right, we're just going to put it out to tend to private companies.
- 39:35Right. And of course, it's so much more than just the employees and the systems they bring to bear, the management skills and so forth.
- 39:42But yeah, they were, as I said, a startup, almost truly a startup.
- 39:47And so they had time and their build didn't constrain them as ours did.
- 39:52They had time to build a traditional city.
- 39:55We had no time. We had no authority.
- 39:58Right. OK. Another question.
- 40:01i like this one because this is one that's come up recently a lot with me when i'm thinking about
- 40:08free cities charter cities this kind of stuff you said at the beginning you were talking about the
- 40:14the bit prior to getting the city incorporated and you're saying look we're just trying to get
- 40:18the bill passed yes right the interesting thing is i've noticed that quite a lot with projects
- 40:25modern day projects prosper included other places that um their focus because it's such an uphill
- 40:32struggle and because there's so much opposition and because the focus is on just getting the thing
- 40:37you want and actually there's far less thought that goes into the point after that right i've
- 40:44seen it with large projects small projects and it's it's just come up recently again uh in my
- 40:50mind and then you mentioned it as well there what do you think about that is it is there is
- 40:55there truth to that? There is. I am the point after that. All of our committee was so heavily
- 41:04focused on the political side of the thing that they just really had not delved into. What is it
- 41:11going to be? And how are we going to implement it and then manage it? So that's the
- 41:20important thing, really.
- 41:22So you, but you, before
- 41:24you started thinking about that,
- 41:26were you just going to go down the normal government
- 41:28route? Absolutely, because we did not
- 41:30know the time constraints until
- 41:32the draft of the bill actually came
- 41:34out. We had no idea
- 41:36that there would be, we'd have
- 41:38so little time to start it.
- 41:40Remember, after the referendum, we had only five months to actually start the city,
- 41:44and nothing basically had been done except our task force work.
- 41:49So, yeah, it's very difficult to conceive yourself being in that situation with no authority in the time.
- 41:58I used to tell them that every tick of the clock sounded like thunder to me because the time was so short.
- 42:04But, I mean, there was, in a way, in a free market, you kind of want that kind of pressure, really.
- 42:09I mean, that's what gets the job done.
- 42:11I mean, it's the opposite of government in a sense.
- 42:13We could have taken two years to do the RFPs and the selection process
- 42:19and contract negotiation after that.
- 42:21In fact, you know, easily could have used that amount of time.
- 42:24We just didn't have it.
- 42:27So, all right, then.
- 42:28So you've got your contractors, I take it.
- 42:32I mean, I made that sound quite flippant.
- 42:34I'm sure it wasn't that easy.
- 42:36But you got them, and I take it the budget for doing what was previously done by a government office was a lot less.
- 42:48I mean, the amount you spent, sorry, the budget hopefully was the same.
- 42:51I had a budgeting finance committee, and they did a marvelous job, far better than I would have expected.
- 42:59In Georgia, the tax situation is such that you get about three quarters of your revenue,
- 43:07your whole year's revenue in the last quarter of the year.
- 43:10So you're very lean through the first quarter.
- 43:13And we, starting with a balance of zero, it's pretty difficult to get through those first eight to nine months.
- 43:22But we budgeted, and one of the RFPs additional that I wrote was for banks to have our business.
- 43:28Six banks issued bids.
- 43:32Part of what I wrote into the RFP was they had to loan us $10 million day one.
- 43:37Well, actually not day one, one month after that.
- 43:40In Georgia, another strange law is if you borrow for operating purposes,
- 43:46you have to pay it back December 31st.
- 43:47Even if you borrowed it December 30th, you have to pay it back December 31st.
- 43:51We have a lot of strange laws.
- 43:53So we waited until January 1 to borrow the money so we'd have the full year to pay it back.
- 43:57But we'd done such a really fine job of budgeting that we were able to take that money and spread it out over the first nine months.
- 44:07And in August, basically that money we thought would run out, and then our new money would be pouring in.
- 44:15Worked almost to the dollar.
- 44:17It was a beautifully done budget.
- 44:19And so we were able to survive on barred money for the first nine months of the year, paid back that $10 million on December 31st and have never barred again.
- 44:31And your average person living in Sandy Springs at that time, did they notice a change during the change?
- 44:38I mean, in two ways, I suppose.
- 44:40One, did they notice the services get better instantly or did they notice a time period where it was a bit chaotic?
- 44:46You know, that kind of stuff.
- 44:48They noticed immediately in some ways.
- 44:51In other services, slower.
- 44:53But for an example, permitting had been a terribly difficult process going through the county.
- 44:59It was just laborious.
- 45:01You'd wait for months.
- 45:03I happened to go over to the offices we'd set up the second day of operation.
- 45:09I walked into the permitting section.
- 45:11There were about six people sitting there.
- 45:13We had served them coffee.
- 45:15They were smiling.
- 45:16and they didn't believe that they were actually going to be serviced that quickly.
- 45:20And that was typical across the board of services.
- 45:24The contracting company, roads were a difficult problem.
- 45:31The county would have a pothole, and they'd send out six guys,
- 45:36and five of them would stand around, one would dig, you know, and so forth.
- 45:40And the contracting company surveyed every road in the city with laser-mounted, on the bumper, laser-mounted devices that characterized the need for work there, characterized them into five different categories.
- 46:02The ones that were worst, we have fixed immediately, and then it went down.
- 46:06That even worked to the benefit of the elected officials.
- 46:10because they're always getting complaints from everyone about potholes and problems,
- 46:15and they were able to say to them, look, we have you on the list.
- 46:21You're a priority three, so it will be three months, maybe whatever.
- 46:26We were saying priority, but it gave them an ability to not just have to smile at people
- 46:32and say, oh, yes, we'll fix that.
- 46:33It gave them an ability to give an answer to it.
- 46:37Are they bothering you?
- 46:39I was going to say, flick them up like that.
- 46:41It sounds a bit too good to be true when you think about it.
- 46:45That when the government did it very inefficient very expensive When the private sector did it it got done Yeah right okay now we all believe in that we all know that but is it really that simple like how is it that a government
- 46:59service like take your example of the the people doing the roads why is it that you get four people
- 47:05watching one person work and why do you not get that in the private sector well or maybe you do
- 47:11get it in the private sector i don't know maybe you don't all right no because it's a profit motive
- 47:16That's the key to the whole thing.
- 47:18There is a profit motive.
- 47:19The company is driven to be more efficient.
- 47:22It has a fixed contract.
- 47:24If it can be more efficient, it can be more profitable.
- 47:28If it can be A1 in service, the people like it, it's going to get its contract renewed.
- 47:35If it's not, we're going to find someone else.
- 47:39It was an annual contract, by the way, for six years, renewable for six years.
- 47:43but they had to be reviewed each year and told, you still have a contract.
- 47:48So, no, and by the way, we finally did agree to pay for the contract
- 47:52three weeks after the city was started.
- 47:55They had trusted us to do it that much.
- 47:58Presumably you knew these people, did you, or were they friends of,
- 48:01I mean, in communities on the whole?
- 48:03No, not at all.
- 48:03No, they were a company that was headquartered out in Colorado,
- 48:08which is a long way from Sandy Springs, an engineering firm.
- 48:13And we developed immediately a good relationship with them.
- 48:17They were one of the three finalists.
- 48:20I actually had, if I can digress a second, after issuing the RFPs, and I need to tell you who did finally approve those,
- 48:29but after issuing them, the company moved in immediately and started doing a number of things that would improve survey.
- 48:40We had surveyed our population, and the biggest issue in the population, 34% of the people said, was zoning.
- 48:50I mentioned that earlier.
- 48:50We've got to get control over zoning in this area.
- 48:53The next two, and there were 12% down the line, were traffic problems and public safety, police and fire.
- 49:05So the zoning issue was primarily in the hands of the elected officials.
- 49:10But the other things, police, fire, traffic.
- 49:14Traffic was a wonderful example of how they improved service.
- 49:20As soon as they got the contract, they began looking at all the traffic signals in the city.
- 49:26Traffic was a mess.
- 49:28Shouldn't have been.
- 49:2972% of the controls for those traffic signals were either inoperative or parts were even missing out of the boxes.
- 49:39They would just turn it on and off, but no timing of it or anything.
- 49:43I'm sorry, I've had to do that again.
- 49:46They not only fixed that, they put in place a world-class traffic management center
- 49:52where people sat, looked at all the intersections, could monitor them,
- 49:57changed them from the office to allow traffic flows to go,
- 50:02allow for emergency vehicles, all of that.
- 50:04But it was truly probably bunk cities as the best in the country initially.
- 50:11And that saved a lot of money.
- 50:14It didn't have people always going out trying to fix the lights.
- 50:17But most importantly, it saved our residents' time.
- 50:21The traffic flow improved immediately.
- 50:23They solved that immediately.
- 50:25So, yes, they did see improvements across the board.
- 50:29One of the ones you mentioned there was police and fire, like public safety.
- 50:34Am I right in understanding that you left those with the previous setup?
- 50:41You didn't use a privatized police force, let's say.
- 50:44At the beginning, day one, we didn't have the money to create a police force or a fire.
- 50:52So we had to go back to the county we had in hand and ask for a contract for them to continue providing police and fire service.
- 51:01They were not particularly kind to us at that point about that,
- 51:06but they did have to do it according to the state constitution,
- 51:10and we did get a contract with them.
- 51:12To show you, again, what changed for the population,
- 51:17the county had been providing four policemen on duty at any time
- 51:23in a city of almost 100,000 people.
- 51:26It was just like no service.
- 51:29So that meant with shifts, three shifts a day, 12 people in total were being provided.
- 51:34When we got to the point of building up our resources enough to do it, which was six months,
- 51:41our initial police force was 35 people, three times what they'd done.
- 51:46It now numbers about 135.
- 51:49So we have dramatically improved our police service.
- 51:55Fire it took us a year to get to the point we were ready to do our own fire Had to contract with the county for six months and then an additional six months and paid through the nose
- 52:10You want me to do something?
- 52:10No.
- 52:13We had three and a half fire stations.
- 52:16One served us and a joining community.
- 52:20The county wanted us to pay millions of dollars for those fire stations.
- 52:25We said no.
- 52:26We've been paying our taxes, too much taxes all along.
- 52:29We owned those things.
- 52:31Finally had to go to court, and the court ruled against us.
- 52:35We would have to pay a dollar for each station.
- 52:38We sucked it up and agreed to do that.
- 52:42So initially we did, and the reasons for not, it was possible maybe to contract for companies to provide police and fire.
- 52:55But it's not been very successfully done.
- 52:57And we felt that our citizenry really wanted us to have those under our wing as city functions.
- 53:07I mean, according to you then, are there any services that shouldn't be put out to the private sector, do you think?
- 53:15Like, had you been able to, would you have done private police and private fire?
- 53:22Probably would have, because the concept just makes so much sense.
- 53:26It works so well, but you also open companies up to liabilities if they're providing those things.
- 53:35It's going to make them very hesitant to give you a really good bid.
- 53:41They would want a lot of risk premium to provide those services.
- 53:47Are there any examples of that in the States?
- 53:48Are there any private police forces in the States?
- 53:50There are private police forces, but nothing on the magnitude of a city of 100,000.
- 53:54So they're more like security forces.
- 53:56Yeah, they'd have to build it.
- 53:58And they'd have to build in a risk, as I said, for themselves.
- 54:01And what, you think it would end up being too expensive?
- 54:03I do.
- 54:03Some kind of insurance policy against someone getting shot, someone getting whatever.
- 54:08Yeah, you can't imagine.
- 54:09How does it work then with the government police force?
- 54:14Well, the government is protected by itself.
- 54:19It passes its own laws that protect them from those sorts of things.
- 54:21You can still sue the government.
- 54:22You can still sue the police force, though, can't you?
- 54:24Yeah, you can sue it, but you're going to have a hard time collecting.
- 54:27Right, okay.
- 54:28Is it as simple as that?
- 54:29You're thinking in the free market, it's just far more fluid, far more easy to operate.
- 54:34So do you think that there won't be private police forces?
- 54:38I think probably not, again, just because of the risk factor.
- 54:42I don't see it proliferating.
- 54:45It's interesting, because in the UK, they started as private.
- 54:49They were all private, weren't they?
- 54:50No, I don't know.
- 54:51I didn't know that.
- 54:52Now you're telling me something.
- 54:53This is something I'm remembering from primary school here,
- 54:56when being a small child,
- 54:57but the first police forces in the UK were the Peelers,
- 55:03and I think the guy, somebody Peel was the guy.
- 55:06Yeah, I do remember that.
- 55:07And they were all privately funded.
- 55:09Yeah, yeah.
- 55:10And, you know, so, well.
- 55:14We ask so much more of our police today than yesterday.
- 55:19day, they become tremendously versatile in all the services they have to provide.
- 55:26Yeah. Okay, so really, given the choice, you would say there should be
- 55:33nothing given out, nothing that shouldn't be given out to the private sector. If you
- 55:38were designing, like Prospero for example, if you were designing a city from
- 55:43ground up, you would privatize everything. Yes, and in fact we are on
- 55:48our way to doing that in Prospera. I wrote the RFPs for Prospera to bid out for private services.
- 55:57Before we get on to Prospera, because obviously I want to talk about Prospera,
- 56:00there's a kink in the armor of this story, isn't there? Because in 2019, the city's status was
- 56:07reversed. Is that right? Yeah. So what's going on there then? Does it disprove the model or does it
- 56:13What happens?
- 56:16Well, first of all, let me say that after Sandy Springs,
- 56:19in the next several years, about three years,
- 56:22there were six additional cities came online,
- 56:25all following the Sandy Springs model.
- 56:29I know that because I was a principal advisor for all six of them.
- 56:33Since then, there are a total of 13 new cities in Georgia
- 56:38that have come online basically following the model.
- 56:42So the model hasn't disappeared, but Sandy Springs went through a period of change of elected officials.
- 56:51The initial elected officials were all on board with what we did.
- 56:54Didn't necessarily understand it, but they liked it.
- 56:59As time wore on and people sort of forgot what had happened and new people came on,
- 57:03They would say well maybe I ought to pull road paving out of the contract or pull parks and recreation out and give it a separate We think we can do better with a single contract And so they began to whittle away at the total contracting concept And as you did that you lost
- 57:24a lot of the efficiencies, the synergy that had given
- 57:28you your efficiencies. As you peel off pieces,
- 57:32that bundle of synergy, you get smaller.
- 57:36So that process of whittling away went on for
- 57:40then about appeared about another five or six years and then they had finally gotten down to
- 57:44the point well we might as well take it all we can do it but was there anything um about that that
- 57:51you thought was you know underhand or was that what do you think it was well-intentioned i do
- 57:57i think it was well-intentioned i think it was people who had always grown up in bureaucratic
- 58:03cities themselves and were just a little dubious of the idea of contracting.
- 58:10And over time, new ones were elected and they had new thoughts.
- 58:14And it just, again, no, I don't think there was anything underhanded.
- 58:18I think they meant well.
- 58:19I think they were wrong.
- 58:22One of the things I sort of promised myself when I did that year of work to create a city
- 58:28was that I was going to step away then.
- 58:33The elected officials were responsible.
- 58:36No more of my business.
- 58:39So I did step away from it.
- 58:42And maybe if I had stayed more involved,
- 58:44it maybe would have been a different decision.
- 58:46But I think I did the right thing.
- 58:48They were the ones that people had trusted to run the city, not me.
- 58:53And I think it has still done well.
- 58:56Could I tell you why I think it's done as well as it did as well as it did?
- 59:01After 10 years, we had not increased tax rates one penny.
- 59:08We had improved services across the board, as I've already mentioned.
- 59:15We had accumulated a surplus of $40 million,
- 59:19and we had zero long-term debt and liabilities.
- 59:26One of the major liabilities in the states is for unfunded liabilities for pensions.
- 59:37It's a terrible problem at state, federal, local level.
- 59:41Some cities have unfunded liabilities that exceed their annual budgets.
- 59:46And they're just as much debt as if they'd borrowed from the bank, but they don't carry it on the balance sheet.
- 59:53So people don't know what bad shape they're in.
- 59:56There was an existing city, South Atlanta,
- 1:00:00that asked me to come in and consult with them
- 1:00:02about the potential of shifting to the model.
- 1:00:06And one of the first questions I asked them was,
- 1:00:09what are your unfunded liabilities for pensions?
- 1:00:12And the mayor said, well, I don't know.
- 1:00:15Actually, she didn't even know what I was talking about.
- 1:00:17Referred me to the acting city manager,
- 1:00:20and when I asked him the question,
- 1:00:21and he did know what I was talking about, but he didn't know how much they were.
- 1:00:25Turned out they were almost as big as their annual budget,
- 1:00:29and so huge future problems.
- 1:00:32That's the sort of thing that exists across the country
- 1:00:36in cities that are not managed by professionals.
- 1:00:40Well, also in governments in general.
- 1:00:43Yeah.
- 1:00:43I mean, I think probably it's the downfall of...
- 1:00:47If you actually look at the way that governments set up currently,
- 1:00:50because they have to generate income from somewhere.
- 1:00:54And if tax isn't enough, they're going to issue debt.
- 1:00:57It's a self-perpetuating myth.
- 1:01:00And many governments around the world,
- 1:01:02I think the UK, my own included,
- 1:01:04the debt they're servicing is a phenomenal amount of their budget,
- 1:01:10which literally wouldn't be there in a private business.
- 1:01:13Most governments in Europe would be out of business,
- 1:01:17would have gone out of business a long time ago.
- 1:01:18and it's a very important incentive.
- 1:01:21Well, it's almost $40 trillion in the United States.
- 1:01:24It's unbelievable.
- 1:01:28We're going to have to face it someday.
- 1:01:30Well, you can't face it, really.
- 1:01:32And in fact, now, because it's so large,
- 1:01:35it affects everything that they do
- 1:01:38because they have to be careful
- 1:01:40that the price of their bonds don't go up too high
- 1:01:42because they literally can't service them then.
- 1:01:44So now they're doing all this nefarious activities,
- 1:01:47activities trying to reach into the market to say change this and change that it's it's all
- 1:01:52pulling of levers that it's just causing a complete mess you know um yeah it's it's a it's
- 1:01:57interesting you say that i i've i've not thought of it on those terms before that that that the debt
- 1:02:03the debt part of all this could be one of the most important things to get right
- 1:02:09in the first instance because it compounds and after 10 years you might have 40 of your budget
- 1:02:16disappearing before you've even done anything.
- 1:02:18Exactly.
- 1:02:19And what do you get for it?
- 1:02:20Nothing.
- 1:02:20So, you know, it's really interesting.
- 1:02:23Can I ask a question?
- 1:02:23Did taxes go up after the after the regime changed again?
- 1:02:29No.
- 1:02:30Not a dime.
- 1:02:32So how can you prove it was a success?
- 1:02:34Obviously, it was a success in the first instance.
- 1:02:37What's happened since?
- 1:02:37So since it's gone back to the old model,
- 1:02:39have you seen it drift back to the old ways,
- 1:02:42or is it better or worse?
- 1:02:45I can only say this.
- 1:02:50We ran the original city with a contract for $40 million.
- 1:02:54$5 million of that was startup costs.
- 1:02:57So basically an ongoing budget is $35 million.
- 1:03:00Today that budget, this year's budget, is $101 million.
- 1:03:05That's significantly worse than it was.
- 1:03:10Now you might say, well, there's been inflation.
- 1:03:12Well, I've calculated it out since the city.
- 1:03:16Inflation has gone up 65% over the 20 years.
- 1:03:19So that $40 million would have been $60-some-odd million in today's dollars, but it's really $101 million.
- 1:03:29So they're not doing it at a lower cost.
- 1:03:32Fortunately, the growth of the city has been such that even at the fixed rate that we had originally, not increasing it since the growth in that which is taxed has been such that it's produced the additional revenue that we have needed to offset it.
- 1:03:51So it's working well.
- 1:03:54We did finally, after about 10 years, incur a long-term debt.
- 1:04:00We had no real city center.
- 1:04:02If you went to the main street of Sandy Springs, you'd think it was built in the 40s or 50s, maybe 60s.
- 1:04:10There was no real city hall, any city center.
- 1:04:13So we have built a city center that houses the city hall, the police, arts, very nice art centers, parks, and so forth.
- 1:04:23And so we did borrow money to build that.
- 1:04:26But we had achieved such a wonderful financial rate.
- 1:04:29I'm told one of only 19 cities in the U.S. that has a AAA bond rating.
- 1:04:36Now, I have not confirmed that.
- 1:04:38That's what I'm told.
- 1:04:39But we do have it.
- 1:04:40All right.
- 1:04:40And to borrow money to build this city.
- 1:04:44So when you borrow money, you're not issuing your own debt, are you?
- 1:04:49You're borrowing from, right, okay.
- 1:04:51Not like a bond or anything.
- 1:04:52But the rate you have to pay relies upon that bond rating.
- 1:04:57Right.
- 1:04:57So we hit it at a wonderful low time anyway and had a wonderful bond rating.
- 1:05:03So the funding of that Civic Center is only at about 2.5% interest rate, which is phenomenal.
- 1:05:12Wow.
- 1:05:13But, okay, let's move on to Prospera then.
- 1:05:16Because, first of all, did Prospera notice Sandy Springs and then come and contact you?
- 1:05:23Or did you notice the ZAs and then come this way?
- 1:05:27They contacted me.
- 1:05:29I'm really not quite sure.
- 1:05:30There was an economist on staff at that time who was the first to contact me.
- 1:05:34He had read my book, and he had researched it,
- 1:05:37and he asked me to come on board as an advisor to the parent company, New Way.
- 1:05:43And I was happy to do that.
- 1:05:44I found it a very interesting concept and was happy to do that.
- 1:05:47And after about four months, they said, well, we'd like to have you be on the board.
- 1:05:52And I've been on board ever since.
- 1:05:53was far prior to Prosper actually being more than a gleam in our eye, maybe.
- 1:06:02So as we then invested in and began Prosper,
- 1:06:07they asked me to serve on the Council of Prosper,
- 1:06:10which is interesting because I don't speak the language
- 1:06:15of about half the people down here and all that,
- 1:06:17but it's been quite a ride.
- 1:06:19It has taken me into consideration and approval of a number of issues that I never even knew existed from a legal standpoint.
- 1:06:29Such as?
- 1:06:30Oh, almost everything.
- 1:06:35You know, we had to pass all of the statutes, the resolutions and regulations.
- 1:06:43For instance, we're very conscious of the environment here and wanting to maintain it at first rate.
- 1:06:51So we had to pass laws that had to do with cutting of reefs and that sort of thing, which I definitely would have thought of existing.
- 1:06:59we'll be dealing with an issue at the board meeting Saturday
- 1:07:05having to do with the approval of very long-term trusts.
- 1:07:14People who invest often would like to invest through a trust
- 1:07:18and they won't long intervals.
- 1:07:19So we're dealing with back and forth about how long.
- 1:07:23I never thought I would be even talking about such an issue.
- 1:07:26So it's just, you name it, it's been an interesting ride.
- 1:07:32Have you noticed anything that you learned from doing Sandy Springs that isn working here or is they doing it differently here and you think it should be another way Have you like as a sort of council member
- 1:07:48have you ever come up with a proposal and been sort of outvoted?
- 1:07:55I have.
- 1:07:56I probably shouldn't even say about it,
- 1:07:57but I have a fundamental problem with minimum wages.
- 1:08:02I think it's a terrible concept.
- 1:08:05Yeah, I agree.
- 1:08:06As a free market person, you know, I think that employers should be able to seek the best employees again for whatever price they negotiate.
- 1:08:15And they've got one in Prosper, haven't they?
- 1:08:17We do.
- 1:08:18That's probably more, I'm going to guess here, that's a PR move probably sometimes.
- 1:08:23I mean, you know, Prosper deal with a lot of bad PR.
- 1:08:27And things like minimum wage seem like, to the average person, seem like a really nice thing to do for your employees.
- 1:08:32I think if you're an economist, maybe like myself, we don't necessarily believe that.
- 1:08:39But I think on the surface, it looks quite good.
- 1:08:41Yeah, I agree with you that it is a communications issue, a government relations issue, a PR issue.
- 1:08:50But just fundamentally, it goes against my grain.
- 1:08:53So I abstain from voting in those things rather than even vote against it.
- 1:08:58Because I agree with you, it probably from a PR standpoint is the thing to do.
- 1:09:02but it's not necessarily more humane.
- 1:09:07I think to get the employees you need,
- 1:09:11you can pay, if you were, a free-ranging wage
- 1:09:15and still do it and be fair to everyone.
- 1:09:18But you asked for an example of when I had been out-noted.
- 1:09:21That's one that just pops into my mind.
- 1:09:23What about the model itself?
- 1:09:26I mean, like I alluded to earlier,
- 1:09:29it seems like Prospera is what you were doing in Sandy Springs times by 100 with more options to do more privately,
- 1:09:38to have more control over what actually happens in that place.
- 1:09:43I mean, because you're the council too, as well as being the person that looks for the services, etc.
- 1:09:51You get to choose which services are needed, which aren't, etc.
- 1:09:54Well, to be specific, I don't do that.
- 1:09:58We have an operating company, another operating company that does manage all the services.
- 1:10:04And, yes, Prospero was far-ranging in that, for instance, we had to buy land.
- 1:10:10I didn't have to buy land for Sandy Springs.
- 1:10:12We have to build buildings.
- 1:10:14I didn't have to build anything for Sandy Springs.
- 1:10:16People fall all over themselves to build things.
- 1:10:19So it is a more far-ranging group of services than we had there.
- 1:10:25But fundamentally, the 12 services that I outlined will all eventually be here and will be privately provided.
- 1:10:35Plus, like construction of buildings and that sort of thing.
- 1:10:40What do you think of, presumably, you know about Morizan and what Massimo's doing here.
- 1:10:44What do you think about his model?
- 1:10:45Well, I think it seems to be working all right.
- 1:10:49I understand that it's quite a different model, of course, built around the old mill company, textile mills in my own country.
- 1:11:02Entrecome, they call it.
- 1:11:03Yeah, and I understand that a lot of the private property homes
- 1:11:09that were provided by the Zeti there
- 1:11:12are now being bought by people who just view them
- 1:11:16as really good investments in housing for themselves,
- 1:11:20not as outside of the mill people themselves.
- 1:11:22But they can't buy them, though.
- 1:11:24They give them a long-term lease, I think.
- 1:11:26Yes, absolutely.
- 1:11:28Yeah, but that in itself is an interesting phenomenon,
- 1:11:30and actually because that's kind of what it's supposed to be.
- 1:11:35I think the point of a ZA is to create a better scenario
- 1:11:40within the ZA than you find outside.
- 1:11:45And Morazine are obviously doing that,
- 1:11:47and as a result, people want to go from the outside to the inside,
- 1:11:50regardless of whether they're working in one of the companies in there.
- 1:11:54Unfortunately, that's what a libertarian utopia is.
- 1:11:57it shouldn't probably have any libertarians in there it should probably just be people moving
- 1:12:04to a better place which is that's the idea you give the freedom to to within the zone to have
- 1:12:09services run better you know competition have all these things that we all agree are great
- 1:12:15and the result is people move there which is what you're seeing i think yeah and that's a good thing
- 1:12:21But I would say that the ZETI is more than that.
- 1:12:26We took it as our long-term objective to provide development to Honduras
- 1:12:35and to provide employment to Honduras.
- 1:12:40Marzon definitely provides employment, but beyond that, it's sort of self-contained
- 1:12:47and it not an outreach type of development as we would hope to be here So it a little different model I suppose one way to look at it might be that
- 1:13:00it's a sandbox in a way.
- 1:13:02Morazon's a sandbox and probably,
- 1:13:06I mean, take Chaloma,
- 1:13:07because it's the closest city nearby,
- 1:13:08which is by all accounts quite a dangerous place
- 1:13:12compared to, well, at least compared to Morazon.
- 1:13:15As people watch the sandbox working
- 1:13:17and try and move there and it gets full,
- 1:13:19Presumably it spreads out.
- 1:13:20Presumably, I suppose that's the idea that fits your model there.
- 1:13:25Absolutely.
- 1:13:26We would love to be all over the world in undeveloped countries.
- 1:13:29And we've had a good number of contacts with other countries.
- 1:13:34Eric Bremen, who you will talk with, the CEO, and really the guiding light of all of this,
- 1:13:40can share what he can share.
- 1:13:43He's not in confidence about that.
- 1:13:45But we've had a number of contacts with other countries in which we've tried to develop memorandums of agreement and so forth to build Prospera-type facilities.
- 1:13:56something i just thought of about the the sandy springs model um and i think i've i've i read that
- 1:14:05what about i can deduce this as well that the the the point of them of the sandy springs model is to
- 1:14:12take away the kind of um the the individuals in a way from from steering something in a in slightly
- 1:14:20in the wrong direction. Is that fair to say? It's more like you don't have a bunch of individuals
- 1:14:27in the government forcing a place in the wrong direction. Is there an element of that in it?
- 1:14:37I suppose. I don't think we sort of organized around that as a concept. But let me tell you
- 1:14:43where we went from. Fulton County, as I mentioned, is the largest county in Georgia.
- 1:14:46And we had one representative on the commission for every 180,000 people in the county.
- 1:15:00Most cities within the county didn't have a representative who even lived there.
- 1:15:06We didn't at one point in Sandy Springs.
- 1:15:08After we created the city, incorporated the city, we had one council person for every 12,000 people.
- 1:15:15and nobody lived more than two miles from their representative.
- 1:15:21And I used to say frequently that we will be able to get our hands around their necks
- 1:15:26because you're close to them in proximity.
- 1:15:31There are not that many.
- 1:15:32You can get to your council person and voice a concern or even praise maybe,
- 1:15:38but it's a far different relationship with individuals than it had been before.
- 1:15:45We looked at the county commission as being this far-off thing that didn't like us.
- 1:15:51And why is that then?
- 1:15:53Why would that be a function of the former system versus your system?
- 1:15:59Just because they're literally further away geographically?
- 1:16:04And in population, so many, so many, so few representatives per person.
- 1:16:09So we have fixed that.
- 1:16:10Our people feel they have good access to their leaders, and they use it.
- 1:16:19They really do.
- 1:16:21Do you think something like Prosper could ever happen in the States, then?
- 1:16:24In this degree?
- 1:16:27I mean, like I say, as it being a Sandy Springs-type scenario.
- 1:16:32I think it's highly unlikely.
- 1:16:34as I answer it our focus is on underdeveloped countries where we can bring development and
- 1:16:40employment that they need with all our faults in the states we're a pretty well-functioning
- 1:16:46society and there's not the same need for a prosper there but we have had conversations
- 1:16:54that's interesting because I would say that I agree that the states is a good well-functioning
- 1:17:02place. But I also think that the sort of the ZA model, for example, or the free market model,
- 1:17:10or whatever you want to call it, the charter model, that is a good model, actually. And it's
- 1:17:14actually better than a sort of possibly the centralized government model that you find in
- 1:17:20the States. I agree. So why wouldn't it arise there? It just would face so much of an inertia
- 1:17:30of people who...
- 1:17:32One of the things, my second book was about
- 1:17:35the conversion of existing cities to the model.
- 1:17:40Not starting cities, but here's an existing city.
- 1:17:42Why don't you adopt the model?
- 1:17:44Because it's more efficient, better service, lower cost.
- 1:17:50There's probably just an underlying fear.
- 1:17:53The existing leaders are in a position,
- 1:17:56they were elected, some of them have been elected many times,
- 1:17:58they don't want to rock the boat.
- 1:18:00Some of them are crooks a small percentage but there is corruption and some of them would be very afraid that that would be brought to light But I don want to emphasize that That a small percentage
- 1:18:12But most just are sort of satisfied that they don't want to take a chance.
- 1:18:17It's a risk.
- 1:18:18That's probably a function of the democratic system as well.
- 1:18:23One of the faults, like you say, is part of what drives you as a politician creating new regulation or whatever is that you want to stay in power.
- 1:18:32And you don't have that issue in the same way within a charter city.
- 1:18:41What you're scared of is people leaving, not you losing favor necessarily in the traditional sense.
- 1:18:48But even the most good-hearted and well-meaning leader sees it as a risk.
- 1:18:53It's something so different.
- 1:18:55They're going to have to sell it.
- 1:18:56They're going to have to stick their necks out to sell it.
- 1:18:59People are going to be dubious about it.
- 1:19:00And I think it's just that fear, risk, what have you, that I've done studies for a number of other cities and counties to determine the viability of the contract model in those cities.
- 1:19:17And invariably, it shows that they could do it at less cost, 10 to 40 percent in some cases less cost.
- 1:19:25But even with that in hand, and of course, it's concerned about who is this guy coming in here to do this?
- 1:19:32And is it in his best interest for us to do it, not ours?
- 1:19:36But with those sorts of savings and efficiency, you would think government officials would be jumping all over themselves to do it.
- 1:19:47And they're not.
- 1:19:49Yes, they're not.
- 1:19:50which brings me to another point actually do you think projects like prospera and sandy springs
- 1:19:56need a sort of obsessive person running them if you see what i mean well no do you know what i
- 1:20:03mean like like i because i there's another thing i notice i do notice this right you could say eric's
- 1:20:08that guy you could say you were that guy when it came to sandy springs what happens when those
- 1:20:13people go or or you know because a lot of people have an issue with that as well i mean especially
- 1:20:18in this world that we're in it one of the things people like is is decentralizing all that stuff
- 1:20:24and getting rid of leaders in the in and favoring the market for example but you can't help noticing
- 1:20:31that a lot of these projects have one pretty obsessive person that's like really pushing
- 1:20:34them along it's true and it will require that in a city that wants to convert it would require it
- 1:20:40if someone were trying to start up a green fields uh prosper it would it would require a lot of
- 1:20:47obsession. Do you think in the Sandy Springs case that the decline of the private model,
- 1:20:56was that anything to do with you being too exhausted to run it or people, the obsessive
- 1:21:01people that were running it, monitoring it, you know, etc.? If I had chosen to take a public stance
- 1:21:09on it and try to fight the thing, it might have come out differently. But I had by then stepped
- 1:21:15well aside.
- 1:21:17If you don't mind me asking.
- 1:21:18Why did I?
- 1:21:18Yeah.
- 1:21:19Well, I guess the beginning,
- 1:21:20almost everyone assumed
- 1:21:21I would take an elected office.
- 1:21:24Not the mayor,
- 1:21:25because we had a wonderful lady
- 1:21:27who had chaired this committee
- 1:21:28for 25 years.
- 1:21:30The most determined person,
- 1:21:32talk about obsession,
- 1:21:33most determined person I know,
- 1:21:35PhD in economics,
- 1:21:37great person.
- 1:21:39She wrote her own book
- 1:21:39and I suggested the title
- 1:21:41ought to be Bulldog and Lace
- 1:21:43because she was just that.
- 1:21:46Enough.
- 1:21:46But she was destined to be the mayor.
- 1:21:48Everyone knew it.
- 1:21:49But people thought I would run for council.
- 1:21:50I am not psychologically attuned to being a politician.
- 1:21:56For me, there is right and there is wrong.
- 1:22:00And this idea of horse trading or compromise on every issue that seems to occur in politics
- 1:22:06is just not something I want to be a part of, won't need to be a part of.
- 1:22:09And so I did not.
- 1:22:10And I made the promise to myself.
- 1:22:13I'm not going to try to be backseat driving this thing.
- 1:22:17These are the elected officials, not me.
- 1:22:19And I did basically step away from it.
- 1:22:21But I was also stepping into these other cities that I've talked about
- 1:22:25that followed right on the heels.
- 1:22:28So maybe there is an element of truth in that.
- 1:22:30Maybe if the obsessive person who really believes in the thing steps to the side,
- 1:22:37the tendency for something like that will be to drift back towards the political.
- 1:22:42I think so
- 1:22:43yeah
- 1:22:44I think so
- 1:22:45maybe there's
- 1:22:45do you think that's true
- 1:22:46of Prospera as well then
- 1:22:47do you think if
- 1:22:48someone like Eric
- 1:22:49or
- 1:22:49I know
- 1:22:50I suppose Eric is
- 1:22:51the
- 1:22:52he is that guy
- 1:22:53I know that there's
- 1:22:54lots of other people involved
- 1:22:55like Gabe and everyone
- 1:22:56but really
- 1:22:57when you look at it
- 1:22:59on face value
- 1:23:00I don't think you need to
- 1:23:01apologise for saying
- 1:23:02yeah that's
- 1:23:03so
- 1:23:03right
- 1:23:03so do you think if
- 1:23:05if someone like that
- 1:23:06decides to sort of
- 1:23:08move away a little bit
- 1:23:09then
- 1:23:09when the
- 1:23:11decentralised
- 1:23:11power
- 1:23:12comes in, it's not as effective.
- 1:23:16And it might start drifting towards a different incentive
- 1:23:19model actually. It's what it is I suppose. Possibly but I don't think so. I think we
- 1:23:28have built a foundation, tremendous legal foundation. We're still building in the
- 1:23:37political foundation but with the current administration it's far far more
- 1:23:41favorable and easy to deal with. We're working things out there. So I think and
- 1:23:45And then physical.
- 1:23:47This is quite a property, particularly now that this tuna building is the biggest building in maybe, I don't know, in Honduras or not.
- 1:23:55It certainly is.
- 1:23:56In Ritani.
- 1:23:56Yeah, and other beautiful properties.
- 1:24:00I'm writing a book, by the way, about Prospero.
- 1:24:03Oh, right.
- 1:24:03And I call it a tropical paradise, and I don't think I'm stretching that a bit.
- 1:24:09So I think we've built a financial base, a political base, and a legal base that would carry on beyond the current leadership.
- 1:24:20Something I was thinking this morning when I was thinking about, I was going to talk to Eric, I was trying to work out what we might talk about.
- 1:24:26And it did occur to me, going back to what I was saying about, earlier we were speaking about obsessing over just getting permission or getting the legislation or getting whatever.
- 1:24:38I often wonder whether Prospera will survive its success if you see what I mean not its failure
- 1:24:46most people are looking at how it might fail I think about that the success of Prospera say
- 1:24:53hundreds of thousands of people come to live here what does that place look like then are the same
- 1:24:58are the same incentives still operating with that many people you know that that's what I
- 1:25:05actually wonder about and I don't know what I don't know what the answer is I mean I think
- 1:25:10it like in the case of Sandy Springs you said that you know the political part of it was always
- 1:25:17trying to claw its way back in if you see what I mean yeah you kind of have to hold it at bay
- 1:25:22so what happens in a place like Prospera I don't know I guess I hadn't thought of the glass being
- 1:25:26that full yet uh we're still trying to work through all of these in Prospera yeah in Prospera sure I
- 1:25:32I agree with that, but I do think that you have to, as a thought experiment.
- 1:25:37Yeah, well, I think in reality, you know, it can't handle it.
- 1:25:42One of the things is we would intend, if we're having that much success,
- 1:25:47and Honduras is going to benefit from that success,
- 1:25:50that we would expand outward from where we are now.
- 1:25:53It could be in other areas of Honduras and all.
- 1:25:58It wouldn't have the same beauty as this, probably,
- 1:26:00but all of the employment and development could be there.
- 1:26:07You know, we do have a property on the mainland that we're reserving for heavy industry,
- 1:26:13not wanting to disrupt the tourism and fishing and so forth here in Prospera at all.
- 1:26:19We're very sensitive to that in trying to bring in industry,
- 1:26:24the clean industry and things like finance and IT, those kinds of things, medical.
- 1:26:30So we are building for the future, but the idea of us bursting at the seams, as it were, is not a priority with us now.
- 1:26:42And we also have an affiliated area on the northern end of the island that's virtually undeveloped yet to be, it could very well grow a great deal.
- 1:26:53I thinking more along the lines of the ideals that are in place in Prospera now The reason it was set up are they going to survive Those ideals will endure
- 1:27:09You think?
- 1:27:09Yeah, absolutely. I can't see every current leader would have to die, and everyone they
- 1:27:17chose to succeed would have to die before anyone would begin to whittle away at the
- 1:27:22ideals of this. I think it's that firmly ingrained in our DNA.
- 1:27:27What do you think the biggest challenge for Prosper is right now then, according to your
- 1:27:32experience of this kind of stuff?
- 1:27:34Probably solidifying the political relationship so that we don't have to go through the type
- 1:27:39thing we did for the four years of the previous administration.
- 1:27:42I think that's it.
- 1:27:43The other is very much a PR issue.
- 1:27:47We need to have people all over the world knowing about Prosper and what the advantages
- 1:27:54here are.
- 1:27:57I think we have not been able, maybe didn't have the resources,
- 1:28:02but not been able to tell our story as effectively as we might.
- 1:28:06I don't think it's the resources, I'll be honest.
- 1:28:09I've worked in the media for 25 years.
- 1:28:12I've worked at newspapers, I've worked at TV, I've done all that stuff.
- 1:28:16And I was watching last night, I watched the ABC Australia documentary about Prospera.
- 1:28:22And I could have told you what the next scene that was coming was.
- 1:28:26You know what I mean?
- 1:28:27It was so obvious.
- 1:28:29But there's an incentive model behind that as well.
- 1:28:32You can't come all the way from Australia to Prospera
- 1:28:35and not say billionaire utopia or, you know,
- 1:28:40like people disenfranchised locals or, you know, whatever.
- 1:28:46You can't do that.
- 1:28:47That's how the media works.
- 1:28:48You can't come here.
- 1:28:49Well, a few people have actually.
- 1:28:51A few YouTubers have come here and told the story
- 1:28:54in a very matter-of-fact way.
- 1:28:56and and shown that is actually a really interesting experiment that's succeeding
- 1:29:00but that's not really easy to sell especially not if you're abc or channel 4 or one of these big
- 1:29:07big companies it has to be there has to be some jeopardy there there has to be some
- 1:29:12you know i mean the abc documentary even ended up tying trump into it and and it was it was like
- 1:29:18really not it's an i find it annoying someone as as someone who's talked about this stuff for
- 1:29:25a lot of time now hundreds of hours you know yeah i wish people would stop making documentaries that
- 1:29:33are just just like fun they're just like they're gossip and this is that and just go straight to
- 1:29:41the the simple reason why it's here and then address that that would that would make me so
- 1:29:46happy well we we need a thousand a million people like yourselves i guess to tell the story but
- 1:29:54People don't want to hear that story, though.
- 1:29:55Honestly, honestly.
- 1:29:56I watched, when I watched the ABC one, I understand.
- 1:29:59It was good telly.
- 1:30:00It was good TV.
- 1:30:03Not for Prospera or for ZAs or for Freedom or for free markets,
- 1:30:08but for someone watching ABC, they probably would.
- 1:30:11Well, I looked at the comments on YouTube, and it's all like,
- 1:30:13oh, screw these billionaires.
- 1:30:15You know, it was just like, oh, my God, this is such a mess.
- 1:30:18You've got a film that's got so many half-truths in it,
- 1:30:22And you've got a comment section full of even worse.
- 1:30:27And it's just like, what is, this is just some weird entertainment show.
- 1:30:30It's not really, you know, because there's a lot of stuff to be mentioned here
- 1:30:35that is just overlooked because it's boring, basically.
- 1:30:39Well, I was hit right between the eyes with it yesterday.
- 1:30:41My family is here with me We went over to one of these little animal places where they have the sloths and the monkeys and all I was chatting with one of the managers afterwards for a little time there and I asked him are you familiar with Prosper
- 1:30:54Well, they're less than two miles from Prosper, from the Motney Bay, Pristine Bay area.
- 1:31:02And he said, no, not really.
- 1:31:04He said, all we hear is rumors.
- 1:31:07And I said, well, like what?
- 1:31:09Well, like you're doing experiments on human beings and cutting off their limbs and stuff like that.
- 1:31:15And I just, I don't know where or how it comes about.
- 1:31:21But that type, well, I know in part the previous administration fostered some of it.
- 1:31:26It was to their advantage, they thought.
- 1:31:28And the media then jumps all over it.
- 1:31:31But also people love a good story like that.
- 1:31:33I wouldn't even say there's some kind of conspiracy out here.
- 1:31:36I've heard some even more outlandish ones, babies being eaten.
- 1:31:41I've heard a lot, right?
- 1:31:43But you know what it is?
- 1:31:45It's a couple of people sitting on a Sunday afternoon going,
- 1:31:48oh, you never guess what's going on over there.
- 1:31:50They're doing this, that, and the other.
- 1:31:51And obviously the cloning human beings thing,
- 1:31:53you can see where it's come from the biotech stuff.
- 1:31:56It's kind of like, you know, it's turned into a bit of gossip
- 1:31:59that's fun to talk about, you know.
- 1:32:01I mean, I don't think you can stop that.
- 1:32:04I don't think you can change that.
- 1:32:06Well, one of our problems is that we are a secure facility, and people have to have a pass to come in and so forth, and that engenders all sorts of concerns.
- 1:32:15You asked me things that I have been overruled on.
- 1:32:17That's one of them.
- 1:32:18Oh, is that right?
- 1:32:19The legal folks initially presented about a 25-page document that someone had to sign to come in, and I said, you know, we're going to have cruise ship.
- 1:32:27People aren't going to sign.
- 1:32:28So we finally whittled it down to a one-page visitor thing, but I wish we didn't even have that.
- 1:32:34I think that locked door sort of thing just scares the heck out of people.
- 1:32:38Isn't that, because of the contracts, isn't that a necessity?
- 1:32:43Yes, that's the problem.
- 1:32:44Okay, but presumably there's a better way to do it, but at the moment it's kind of contracts.
- 1:32:49Right now we've come down as far as we could go, I think, in it,
- 1:32:53but the very idea of you're behind a closed door engenders fear, uncertainty, rumors, all of that.
- 1:33:03And so that's a bit of a problem, I think, that I don't know how we can get by it at this point.
- 1:33:10You need to, well, you can't really.
- 1:33:13But you need a border.
- 1:33:15You have to, I mean, by its nature, you need a contract.
- 1:33:18We found that out in the United States.
- 1:33:20It does help to have a border.
- 1:33:24I don't know.
- 1:33:25All right, let's wrap it up.
- 1:33:26We've been going a long time.
- 1:33:27Oliver, one last question then.
- 1:33:29So tell me, according to you, thinking about what you did at Sandy Springs and what's happening here at Prospera now,
- 1:33:38what lesson have you learned from the Sandy Springs experience, which is the most important thing Prospera needs to think about, according to you?
- 1:33:48Yeah, in the simplest terms, this is private industry is the way to go for service.
- 1:33:54Don't even think about not doing that.
- 1:33:57and I think that the rest of the leadership has agreed in that regard.
- 1:34:07But they are very different cities, very, very different.
- 1:34:13The fact that we existed in advance and we didn't have to build,
- 1:34:18the problems with having to build and all that goes into that.
- 1:34:22And even though the local county opposed us and basically for a long time the legislature we were never in the kind of political negotiations that we had to in Sandy Springs that have had to take place in Prospero
- 1:34:38So that's an added burden to work through.
- 1:34:43Possibly also a positive, though, being able to build from the bottom up.
- 1:34:48Oh, possible.
- 1:34:49I mean, there's no, in a way, you're starting, it's a clean slate.
- 1:34:53I mean, you had a clean slate in many ways in Sandy Springs
- 1:34:55because you could just, but you didn't start with,
- 1:34:59you started with a sewage system that probably might not work well.
- 1:35:02Right, right.
- 1:35:04Now that's one of the things we had to retain from the county.
- 1:35:07So yes, you're right.
- 1:35:10Well, anyway, look, thanks for talking.
- 1:35:13I'm fascinated.
- 1:35:14You're obviously thinking very positively about Prospera for the future, would you say?
- 1:35:23Absolutely.
- 1:35:24Bullish on Prospera.
- 1:35:25I mean, I am too.
- 1:35:27I've been coming here for a while now.
- 1:35:30This year I actually spent a month here to work,
- 1:35:33just after the law, you know, just after the government changed.
- 1:35:36I feel like maybe this year is a big year for Prosper.
- 1:35:40It certainly feels like it with the changing government, et cetera.
- 1:35:43Exactly.
- 1:35:43Are you feeling the same thing?
- 1:35:45Yeah, and there's some significant building projects on the,
- 1:35:48well, past the drawing board now.
- 1:35:49They're just about to start building here.
- 1:35:51several good sized buildings
- 1:35:54back behind the Tuna building
- 1:35:55residence buildings
- 1:35:56everything is
- 1:35:59at this moment seems to be pouring it in the right direction
- 1:36:02Absolutely
- 1:36:03well thank you for coming
- 1:36:05thanks for being a part of it
- 1:36:07in one small or large way
- 1:36:09that you've helped
- 1:36:11you know create this place
- 1:36:14and yeah
- 1:36:16I look forward to hearing your talk as well
- 1:36:17you're going to be giving a speech here
- 1:36:19Yeah, if I could find out when they've scheduled me, it would be nice.
- 1:36:22Here's an easy thing.
- 1:36:23Go on to freecitiesconference.com and click on your picture,
- 1:36:28and it will show you when you're speaking.
- 1:36:30You're not supposed to do it that way,
- 1:36:31but I've been using that method to work out when everyone's speaking
- 1:36:34because it's all linked up now, the schedule's on there.
- 1:36:38But anyway, Oliver, thanks for coming in.
- 1:36:40Thank you so much.
- 1:36:41Thank you.
- 1:36:44Right, you made it to the end of the show,
- 1:36:47So I'm going to go ahead and assume that you got some value out of this episode.
- 1:36:53If you want to help the show, please follow or subscribe right now.
- 1:36:57It takes only two seconds and it massively helps.
- 1:37:01If you've got another 30 seconds, well, leave a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
- 1:37:08Honest reviews apparently are the single best way to help new listeners find us.
- 1:37:13If you want more, you can get bonus episodes and early access to episodes on fountain.fm for the price of one coffee for a whole month.
- 1:37:24Or you can support the mission by streaming sats on any of the value for value platforms or use the Bitcoin and fiat donation links in the show notes.
- 1:37:34Every contribution to the show makes a real difference.
- 1:37:37Believe me.
- 1:37:38And one more thing.
- 1:37:39If you know someone who'd love this episode, share it directly with them.
- 1:37:43That personal share beats every algorithm in the book.
- 1:37:47All the links, the community and the newsletter are in the show notes.
- 1:37:51And jump on over to freecities.fm for a deep dive into all the episodes with descriptions and more.
- 1:37:59That's the new Free Cities podcast website, freecities.fm.
- 1:38:04Have a good week and see you next time.
- 1:38:13Thank you.