Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Why Smart Investors Fail: The Hidden Cycle That Destroys Wealth
Transcript
- 0:00You know, there's this seductive little piece of mental math and
- 0:03finance that I think we all just inherently trust.
- 0:06It's almost like a law of nature.
- 0:08It's comforting, isn't it? So comforting.
- 0:09It's called the Rule of 72. Yes, the classic cocktail party
- 0:14trick. The napkin math of the
- 0:16millionaire next door. Exactly For anyone who hasn't
- 0:19heard of it, or maybe just, you know, forgot high school Econ,
- 0:22the idea is simple you take the number 72, you divide it by your
- 0:26expected annual return right and that tells you roughly how many
- 0:30years it takes to double your money and so if.
- 0:32You think you're getting say, 7% A?
- 0:34Year then your money double S every 10 years it's meat it's
- 0:37tidy and it sells this beautiful dream just put your money in the
- 0:40market go to sleep and the compound interest magic just.
- 0:44Yeah, happens. It feels inevitable.
- 0:45Totally inevitable. It feels linear, like a
- 0:47staircase that just, you know, only goes up.
- 0:49You just have to stand on the escalator and wait.
- 0:51But that's the thing about physics, isn't it?
- 0:53Yeah, Gravity doesn't just work on the way up.
- 0:55Right. And when I was digging into the
- 0:57data we have for today's deep dive, well, my jaw just about
- 1:01hit the floor. Because sometimes that staircase
- 1:03doesn't just stop climbing. Sometimes it levels off.
- 1:06Sometimes it turns into a completely flat line for 17
- 1:09years. That is the reality check most
- 1:11investors, even seasoned ones, are just not prepared for.
- 1:14We call those the lost decades. I was looking at this historical
- 1:17data that's analyzed by the legendary investor Monish Pabrai
- 1:20and get this between 1965 and 1981.
- 1:24That is a massive chunk of time. That's an entire career for some
- 1:27people. An entire career.
- 1:28The Dow Jones Industrial Average of that period at around 870,
- 1:32and in 1981, seventeen years later, it ended at around 800.
- 1:36And 7017 years, zero index appreciation, not a penny.
- 1:40Zero. Imagine retiring in 1965
- 1:43thinking OK I'm set for life and then you watch your portfolio do
- 1:46absolutely nothing for almost 2 decades while by the way
- 1:49inflation is just eating your lunch.
- 1:50It's. A nightmare scenario.
- 1:51So I have to ask you, listening right now, what happens to your
- 1:54retirement plan when the market goes nowhere for 20 years?
- 1:57Because today we're going to shatter the buy and hold and
- 2:00ignore it myth. We are.
- 2:02The whole mission for this deep dive is to move beyond that
- 2:05blind faith. We need to actually understand
- 2:07the mechanics, the literal physics of why markets boom and
- 2:11why they inevitably bust. We're not just looking at lines
- 2:14on a chart today, we're trying to look at the machinery
- 2:16underneath exactly. And we have quite the stack of
- 2:18research to pull from. We're combining that empirical
- 2:21history from Monish Pabry, which covers about 125 years of market
- 2:26data. It's an incredible.
- 2:27With a theoretical framework that I can only describe as a
- 2:30sort of Grand Unified Theory of economic cycles.
- 2:33This comes from an analytical heavyweight known online as Mr.
- 2:36Brain. It's a really powerful
- 2:38combination. But Bray gives us the what?
- 2:40The undeniable historical fact of these flatlines, and Mr.
- 2:44Brain gives us the why, The physics, the constraints, the
- 2:47human inertia that drives these incredible swings.
- 2:50Now, before we really jump into the mechanics of this this
- 2:53pendulum, I have to admit something.
- 2:55The hardest part of all this, for me anyway, is knowing where
- 2:59we actually are in the cycle. Of course, hindsight is 2020.
- 3:03It's so easy to look back at 1981 and say, oh, that was
- 3:06obviously a bottom. It's much, much harder when
- 3:09you're in the messy middle trying to figure out if you
- 3:11should be greedy or if you should be fearful.
- 3:13Precisely. You need some kind of
- 3:15thermometer. You need to know the temperature
- 3:17of the market to know if we're freezing or if we're
- 3:19overheating. Because if you don't know the
- 3:21temperature, you have no idea how many layers to wear.
- 3:24And that actually brings us to a specific tool we wanted to
- 3:26highlight today, because this is a real problem for investors.
- 3:29It is. So to actually track this total
- 3:32market temperature yourself, you're welcome to search for and
- 3:35download the iOS App Buffett Indicator from the Apple App
- 3:38Store. It's a very, very useful tool
- 3:40just to visualize the extremes we're about to discuss.
- 3:42Yeah, it basically shows you when the market's total
- 3:45valuation has detached from the underlying economy.
- 3:48Which is usually the big warning sign, right?
- 3:50The sign that the pendulum is about to swing back hard.
- 3:53It's the fever breaking. Absolutely, but check that out,
- 3:56the Buffett Indicator app. Now we also have to get the
- 3:59legal stuff out of the way because we are diving deep into
- 4:02financial concepts and you know, we want to be responsible here.
- 4:05Right. So for the record, full deep
- 4:07value research reports can be found in the description links.
- 4:11All the analysis we're doing is based on publicly available
- 4:14sources and may be subject to revisions or differing
- 4:17interpretations. And this content is for
- 4:19educational purposes only. It does not constitute
- 4:22investment advice. You have to conduct your own due
- 4:24diligence before making any investment decisions.
- 4:27And if you want to listen to our full deep dive about this topic
- 4:30or access even more advanced contents, you're welcome to join
- 4:33a Deep Value Club membership or subscribe to us on Deep Values
- 4:37dot AI. OK, disclaimer done.
- 4:39Let's go back to the history books, because this idea that
- 4:42the market flatlining is some kind of rare glitch in the
- 4:44system. Turns out it's actually more
- 4:46common than the booms. For long stretches of time, it
- 4:50is the default state. Let's really unpack that 1965 to
- 4:541981 eriod you mentioned. OK, O the Dow starts at 870,
- 4:57ends at 870. But here is the crucial iece of
- 5:00context that Bebray highlights, and this is where people get
- 5:02really confused. the US economy didn't stop.
- 5:05It wasn't dead for 17 years. That's the bizarre part.
- 5:08We had growth, right? I mean, we went to the moon in
- 5:1069. There was a cultural revolution.
- 5:12People were buying cars, building houses, the whole 9
- 5:15yards. The economy grew significantly.
- 5:17GDP was way up. Corporate earnings were
- 5:20generally up. I mean, American companies were
- 5:22making a lot more money in 1981 than they were in 1965.
- 5:25But the stock market didn't. Care.
- 5:27The stock market did not care, and this is the first huge
- 5:30lesson. Economic growth does not equal
- 5:32stock market returns. That feels so counterintuitive.
- 5:35If the companies are making more money, why isn't the stock price
- 5:38going up? It's all about the starting
- 5:39valuation. In the mid 60s you had the era
- 5:42of the Nifty 50. These were the Big Blue chip
- 5:45stocks that were considered can't fail investments.
- 5:47The darlings of Wall Street. Exactly.
- 5:50People were so optimistic, so euphoric, that they bid the
- 5:54prices of these stocks up to the stratosphere.
- 5:56They effectively paid for the next 20 years of growth upfront.
- 6:00So they ate their dessert before dinner.
- 6:02A perfect analogy. And then they had to sit at the
- 6:04table for 17 years just waiting for their digestion to catch up
- 6:07with reality. You can have a booming economy
- 6:10and a totally dead stock market if the price you paid at the
- 6:13start was frankly delusional. That is just psychological
- 6:16torture. I mean imagine being an
- 6:18investor, then you see the news companies are growing, your
- 6:21neighbors getting a raise, but your account balance just will
- 6:24not budget for years. It would test anyones resolve,
- 6:27yeah, but then the pendulum swings.
- 6:30And when it swings, it swings hard.
- 6:32We enter the period from 1982 to 1999.
- 6:35The glory days. Oh yeah, this is when the stocks
- 6:38for the long run idea really took hold.
- 6:39The Dow goes from under 900 to over 12,000.
- 6:42That's a 15% annualized return for nearly two decades straight.
- 6:46And that's where the stocks always go up.
- 6:47Myth gets cemented in our brains, right?
- 6:50If you started investing in the 80s, you thought you were a
- 6:52genius. You thought 15% a year was just?
- 6:54Normal baseline. Exactly.
- 6:56And that created a whole generation of investors with
- 6:58complete unrealistic expectations.
- 7:01It totally broke their risk radars.
- 7:03And that euphoria, of course, culminatedinthe.com bubble.
- 7:06Where evaluations didn't just detach from reality, they like
- 7:09left the solar system. They were measuring things in
- 7:11eyeballs, not earnings. And then look what happens next
- 7:13in the data from the year 2000 to 2012.
- 7:16Another flat line, another lost decade.
- 7:19Even with a huge crash in 2008 and a subsequent recovery, if
- 7:22you just look at the start and end points of the S&P 500, it
- 7:25was a wash for equity investors. And Fabri points out something
- 7:28really, really scary about the NASDAQ during that time.
- 7:31The Tech Index. From 1980 to 2000, the NASDAQ
- 7:34was, as I said, a rocket ship. 20% growth a year.
- 7:37Everyone wanted tech. Then the bust hits.
- 7:39It drops 75. Percent 75% from a peak of 5000
- 7:43down to around 12150. Just a brutal, brutal collapse.
- 7:47And here is the stat that just haunts me.
- 7:49It took 16 years until 2016 for the NASDAQ to just get back to
- 7:55where it was in the year 2000. 16 years to break even.
- 7:59Now think about what happened in those sixteen years.
- 8:01This wasn't a period of technological stagnation.
- 8:03This was the golden age of the modern Internet.
- 8:07I mean, come on, this was the era where Amazon became the
- 8:09Everything store. Apple launched the iPod, then
- 8:12the iPhone and changed the world.
- 8:14Google became a verb. Netflix destroyed Blockbuster.
- 8:17All of the FA Ying stocks, the giants of today were born or
- 8:20came of age in that period. That's the aha moment right
- 8:23there. You could have owned some of the
- 8:24greatest, most innovative companies in human history,
- 8:27Apple, Amazon. But because the index itself was
- 8:29so wildly overvalued in 2000, the index as a whole went
- 8:32nowhere for 16 years. Even with those massive winners,
- 8:36the sheer weight of the starting valuation just crushed the
- 8:39returns for the average investor.
- 8:40It's such a sobering reminder that innovation doesn't
- 8:43automatically mean profit for the investor if the price you
- 8:45pay is wrong. It's the whole bowl game.
- 8:48If you pay 100 times earnings for a company and it grows its
- 8:51earnings by 10% a year for a decade, the stock price might
- 8:55not move an inch. Because the valuation multiple
- 8:58is just compressing back to sanity the whole time.
- 9:00Exactly. The air is coming out of the
- 9:02balloon. So that's the US story.
- 9:03Multiple lost decades. But if we really want to see
- 9:06what the mother of all bubbles looks like, we have to travel
- 9:09across the Pacific. We have to talk about Japan, the
- 9:11Nikkei. Index This is the ultimate
- 9:13cautionary tale. If you think the US market is
- 9:15somehow invincible, you have to look at Japan in 1989.
- 9:19It's a history lesson every investor needs to learn.
- 9:21So set the scene for us. It's the late 80s, early 90s.
- 9:24Japan is, economically speaking, taking over the world.
- 9:27They're buying Rockefeller Center, they're buying Hollywood
- 9:29Studios. Japan Inc is this unstoppable
- 9:33force. The euphoria was completely off
- 9:35the charts. The Nikki peaked in late 1989 at
- 9:38around 40,000. OK. 40,000 Now Fast forward 29
- 9:42years to 2019 Where is it? It's still at roughly half of
- 9:45that peak, about 20,000. 29 years later and you're down 50%.
- 9:50That doesn't just destroy the rule of 72.
- 9:52That's the rule of you're broke. It's generational wealth
- 9:54destruction. Yeah.
- 9:55And the symptom of that bubble, the specific detail that just
- 9:58blows the mind, is the real estate statistic that Pabrai
- 10:02always mentions. Oh, this is my favorite insane
- 10:05fact in all of finance. So in 1990, the grounds of the
- 10:10Imperial Palace in Tokyo. Just the palace grounds, not the
- 10:13whole city. Just the land the palace sits on
- 10:16was valued higher than all the real estate in the entire state
- 10:19of California. Let that sink in for a moment.
- 10:21I'm trying California. We're talking thousands of miles
- 10:24of pristine coastline. We're talking the entire
- 10:26agricultural heartland of America.
- 10:28Silicon Valley, San Francisco, Los Angeles, Hollywood.
- 10:32The redwoods. All of it.
- 10:33Beverly Hills. Malibu.
- 10:35Napa Valley. All of that was worth less than
- 10:37one single palace in Tokyo. It sounds physically impossible,
- 10:40Abre himself said. He found it so incredulous he
- 10:42had to go back and check the math himself.
- 10:44But it was true. That is what happens when a
- 10:46property bubble completely seeps into the equity markets.
- 10:49It's not just irrational, it's a complete distortion of reality.
- 10:53It's mass hysteria expressed in currency.
- 10:56And the hangover from a party that big.
- 10:58Lasts for decades. Yeah, exactly.
- 11:00The bigger the party, the greater the hangover.
- 11:02And there's a cultural nuance there, too, which Paprize points
- 11:05out is really important. In Japan.
- 11:06Yes, Japanese companies culturally are just different.
- 11:10They often hoard cash. They prioritize their employees
- 11:12and their societal stability far above shareholder returns.
- 11:16So they become these classic value traps.
- 11:18But you sentimente. You look at the balance sheet
- 11:20and say, wow, this company is trading for less than the cash
- 11:23it has in the bank. This is a bargain.
- 11:26But if they never give you the cash, if they never do a buyback
- 11:29or issue a dividend? It's an illusion.
- 11:32The value is locked away in a vault you can't access.
- 11:34It's like a museum exhibit of wealth.
- 11:36You can look at it, but you can never ever touch it.
- 11:38And it's not just Japan. Let's take a quick hop over to
- 11:41South Korea. The Cosby Index.
- 11:43Another fascinating case study from 1989 to 2019.
- 11:46That's a 30 year span. OK, 30 years.
- 11:48The index went from 1000 to 2000.
- 11:50So it doubled in 30 years. That's, I mean, that's terrible.
- 11:53What is that like 2% a year? Barely over 2% annualized
- 11:56return, you're probably losing money after inflation.
- 11:59And again, think about the narrative.
- 12:01This was the era of the Miracle on Mahan River.
- 12:04Samsung became a global dominant force in electronics.
- 12:07Hyundai cars are everywhere now. The entire Korean GDP just
- 12:12exploded. Massive economic growth.
- 12:14A true modern success story. But the passive investor who
- 12:17just bought the index? They got almost nothing for 30
- 12:20years of patience. It's the same lesson over and
- 12:23over again. The economy is not the stock
- 12:25market. So we've established beyond a
- 12:27doubt that linear growth is a lie.
- 12:29Markets overshoot and they stagnate for very long periods.
- 12:33But why? Why can't they just track the
- 12:34GDP nicely and go up a few percent a year?
- 12:37This is where we need to bring in the theoretical part of our
- 12:39deep dive. We need to introduce Mr. Brain
- 12:41and his framework, the physics of the cycle.
- 12:43This is where it gets really interesting for me, moving from
- 12:46the what to the why. This is where we get to the core
- 12:48mechanics. Mintra Brain uses a very simple,
- 12:51very elegant model from physics, the pendulum.
- 12:54OK, so let's visualize a pendulum, like a grandfather
- 12:58clock or a swing set at a park. A pendulum's movement is
- 13:02governed by two fundamental opposing forces.
- 13:05First, you have constraint. We can think of this as gravity.
- 13:08OK, gravity. Gravity is always pulling the
- 13:10pendulum back toward the center, toward its point of equilibrium.
- 13:13Right. And in market terms, that
- 13:14equilibrium is what fair value? Exactly.
- 13:18It's the price that accurately reflects the underlying
- 13:20fundamentals. But then you have the second
- 13:22force, inertia or velocity. The speed.
- 13:25Yes, When the pendulum reaches that center point, does it just
- 13:28stop dead? No, of course not.
- 13:29It's moving way too fast. It swings right past the center
- 13:32and all the way up the other side.
- 13:33Precisely. And in markets, these forces
- 13:35translate perfectly. Constraint is reality.
- 13:38It's limited resources, limited credit, limited demand.
- 13:41There is only so much oil on the ground.
- 13:43There are only so many people who can afford to buy a new
- 13:45iPhone this year. That's gravity.
- 13:47And the inertia, where does that come from?
- 13:48That's us. That's human psychology.
- 13:51It's the belief that it will keep going up forever.
- 13:54It's greed. It's fear of missing out, but
- 13:57also structural. It's things like corporate
- 13:59investment lag. Explain that lag.
- 14:02How does that create inertia? Well, think about a big mining
- 14:05company. They see copper prices are high.
- 14:09They decide to open a new mine, but that's a huge undertaking.
- 14:12By the time they raise the capital, get the permits, do the
- 14:14engineering, and actually dig the hole, it might be 567 years
- 14:18later. And by then the cycle might have
- 14:20already turned the. Price of copper might be in the
- 14:22gutter, but they have the momentum, the inertia of this
- 14:25massive project. So they finished the mine
- 14:27anyway, adding a huge amount of new supply to an already falling
- 14:30market, which makes the crash even worse.
- 14:32So they overshoot because the corporate brakes don't work
- 14:34instantly. They barely work at all.
- 14:36It's like trying to turn an aircraft carrier.
- 14:38Mr. Brain quotes that ancient Chinese historian Sima Kayan.
- 14:41Right. Yeah, I love this quote.
- 14:43No. Well through force, scant wealth
- 14:45through intellect, great wealth through timing.
- 14:47That is the essence of it, isn't it?
- 14:48You can be the smartest person in the room, you can work harder
- 14:51than anyone else. But if you fight the pendulum,
- 14:54if your timing is wrong and you fight the cycle, you lose.
- 14:57You lose every time. And this process creates a loop,
- 15:00doesn't it? A self reinforcing loop.
- 15:02Reflexivity. George Soros built his entire
- 15:04career on this idea. Absolutely.
- 15:06A positive feedback loop works like this.
- 15:09The economy is doing OK. People feel optimistic, so they
- 15:12go out and borrow and spend. That extra spending makes the
- 15:16economy better. Which in turn makes people more
- 15:18optimistic. So they borrow and spend even
- 15:20more. Prices go up, asset values go
- 15:23up. Everyone feels rich.
- 15:25It just feeds on itself. It overshoots to the upside.
- 15:27Until it hits a wall. Until the constraint hits.
- 15:29Maybe inflation spikes and the central bank has to raise rates.
- 15:32Maybe we run out of skilled labor.
- 15:33Something breaks, then the loop reverses.
- 15:36Negative feedback. Constraints hit.
- 15:38People have to pull back their spending.
- 15:40Pessimism sets in. So they start hoarding cash
- 15:42instead of spending it, which makes the economy even worse,
- 15:45which makes pessimism even deeper.
- 15:47It overshoots to the downside. So markets are never actually at
- 15:50equilibrium, they are just passing through it at high speed
- 15:53on their way to the next extreme.
- 15:55Mr. Brain calls it a second order differential equation, or
- 15:59a damp oscillation. It's a system that naturally
- 16:02oscillates. It cannot stay still.
- 16:04It's default state is to swing. OK, so we know it's swings, it's
- 16:08a pendulum, but are all swings the same?
- 16:11Because, you know, sometimes we have a little recession that
- 16:13lasts a year and sometimes we have the Great Depression.
- 16:16The swings seem to have different sizes.
- 16:17This is where the framework gets really interesting and really
- 16:20practical. Mr. Brain categorizes the cycles
- 16:23into four distinct clocks of the economy.
- 16:26They're all ticking at the same time, but at very different
- 16:28speeds. OK, let's break these down. 1 by
- 16:301 clock #1 the kitchen cycle. This is the shortest one.
- 16:34It runs for roughly 3 to 4 years.
- 16:36This is the inventory cycle. How does this one work?
- 16:38I always think of this as the bullwhip effect they taught us
- 16:41about in Business School. That's exactly what it is.
- 16:43It's a brilliant name for it. Imagine you run a retail store.
- 16:46You sell widgets. Sales start picking up.
- 16:49I say 5%. You think great things are
- 16:51looking up. I need more widgets on the
- 16:53shelves. I don't want to run out.
- 16:54So you overcompensate a little, you order 10% more just to be
- 16:58safe, right? And your wholesaler sees this
- 17:0110% jump and orders from you and all the other stores, they get
- 17:04excited, they order 15% more from the factory.
- 17:06And the factory sees a 15% jump and thinks a boom is here.
- 17:10They hire a whole 2nd shift of workers.
- 17:13Everyone is hiring. The economy feels great.
- 17:15But then sales at your store slow down just a tiny bit.
- 17:19Or maybe you just realize you ordered way too much.
- 17:22Suddenly your warehouse is full to the ceiling with widgets you
- 17:25can't sell. So you stop ordering completely.
- 17:27You stop ordering. Your wholesaler is stuck with a
- 17:30warehouse full of widgets. They cancel their orders from
- 17:32the factory. The factory has to lay off that
- 17:34entire 2nd shift. Those laid off workers stop
- 17:37spending money at your store. And boom, just like that you
- 17:40have a mini recession. Exactly.
- 17:42The constraint here is simple warehouse costs and working
- 17:45capital. You can't hold inventory
- 17:47forever. It takes about three to four
- 17:48years for the system to clear all that excess and start the
- 17:51cycle all over again. OK, that makes sense.
- 17:53That's the short term noise. What's cock #2 the juggler
- 17:56cycle? This one is a bit longer, 7 to
- 17:5811 years. This is the CapEx or machinery
- 18:01cycle. CapEx being capital
- 18:03expenditures, so big investments, why 7 to 11 years?
- 18:08What's special about that timeframe?
- 18:09Think about big physical equipment.
- 18:11A factory machine, a fleet of semi trucks, a building full of
- 18:14server racks. They don't last forever.
- 18:16They wear out, or more importantly, they become
- 18:18obsolete. And that happens roughly every
- 18:20decade. So companies have to replace
- 18:22them all at once. They tend to, yes.
- 18:24It happens in waves. During a boom, every company
- 18:26invests in new factories and new technology, right?
- 18:29That creates jobs. That creates overcapacity.
- 18:31Then for the next 5 or 6 years, they stop investing.
- 18:34They just wait for the machines to wear out and depreciate off
- 18:36the books. And that pause in investment is
- 18:38what causes those midsize recessions we see every decade
- 18:41or so. That's a major driver of them,
- 18:42yes. Got it.
- 18:43OK, clock #3 the Kuznet cycle. Now we're zooming out even
- 18:48further, 15 to 25 years. This is the real estate and
- 18:52construction cycle. And this one is tied to people,
- 18:54right? Demographics.
- 18:55Yes, biology is destiny here. This cycle is highly correlated
- 19:00with new household formation. When a big generation like the
- 19:04baby boomers or the millennials reaches the age where they move
- 19:07out of their parents house, get married and want to buy their
- 19:09first home, you get a massive, sustained wave of demand.
- 19:13But buildings last a very long time.
- 19:15A very long time. You build a house that stands
- 19:17for 50, maybe 100 years. You don't need to rebuild it
- 19:19every year. So supply comes in these very
- 19:22slow, very massive ways. I mean you overbuild.
- 19:25Overbuild housing, like we did in the US leading up to 2008.
- 19:29It takes a very long time, 15 years or more, to absorb all
- 19:32that excess supply. That's why real estate crashes
- 19:34are so deep and so painful. And finally, the big one, the
- 19:38grandfather clock of the economy, the Contrativ wave.
- 19:41The K wave, this is the long 150 to 60 years.
- 19:45This is the innovation cycle. It's driven by fundamental world
- 19:48changing technological revolutions.
- 19:50Like the steam engine? Exactly.
- 19:52The first wave was steam and textiles.
- 19:55Then came the age of steel and railways, then electricity and
- 19:58chemicals, then automobiles and petrochemicals, and most
- 20:00recently, the wave we've been riding is information
- 20:03technology. And how does this 50 year cycle
- 20:05work? A new technology emerges and it
- 20:08creates massive growth. It completely changes how we
- 20:10live and work. We spend decades building out
- 20:13the new infrastructure, laying the railway tracks, stringing
- 20:16the electrical wires, building the Internet backbone.
- 20:19But eventually it hits a limit. It hits market saturation.
- 20:21Everyone has a car, everyone has a smartphone.
- 20:24The explosive growth phases over the economy then tends to
- 20:28stagnate or even enter a depression until the next major
- 20:31technological breakthrough happens and the next wave
- 20:34begins. So we have these four clocks all
- 20:35ticking at once. Inventory, machinery, real
- 20:38estate and innovation. And this is where Mr. Brain
- 20:40brings in the nest and doll theory, which I think is a
- 20:42brilliant way to visualize it. Like those Russian matryoshka
- 20:45dolls? Exactly.
- 20:46These aren't 4 separate tracks running in parallel.
- 20:48They are nested inside each other, influencing each other.
- 20:50So what's at the very center? The smallest doll.
- 20:53At the very center is pure, raw human emotion, greed and fear.
- 20:59Even if resources were infinite and technology never changed,
- 21:02our own psychology would still create volatility.
- 21:05We play what Keynes called the beauty contest.
- 21:08We don't buy what we think is valuable.
- 21:10We buy what we think other people will think is valuable.
- 21:13So that's the rapid day-to-day noise of the market.
- 21:16Then wrapped around that emotional core is the next all
- 21:19explicit financial constraints. This is the world of credit
- 21:22cycles, debt limits and inflation.
- 21:25So this is where governments and central banks come in.
- 21:27Yes, governments loosen credit to stimulate the economy and
- 21:30fight a recession. But eventually they hit the
- 21:32constraint of too much debt or runaway inflation.
- 21:35Then they're forced to tighten policy, which causes the next
- 21:37recession. It's its own cycle.
- 21:39And the outer doll, the biggest one.
- 21:41Those are the fundamental constraints, things that are
- 21:42even bigger than finance political terms.
- 21:45The four year election cycle in the US incentivizes short term
- 21:49boosting of the economy, regardless of long term
- 21:51consequences and physical limits.
- 21:54How fast can we actually extract lithium from the ground?
- 21:57How many more transistors can we really fit on a microchip?
- 22:00So Mr. Brain talks about super resonance.
- 22:02That sounds cool, but what does it actually mean in this
- 22:04context? It's when the cycles align, when
- 22:07the different clocks all chime at the same time.
- 22:10The biggest, most euphoric booms and the deepest, most painful
- 22:13busts happen when these different cycles synchronize and
- 22:16reinforce each other. Can you give us a real world
- 22:18example? Absolutely.
- 22:20Look at the period from, say, 2009 to 2021.
- 22:23Think about what happened first, the financial cycle after the
- 22:262008 crisis. We had a decade of massive
- 22:28quantitative easing, 0% interest rates, basically free money
- 22:32everywhere. OK, so the credit cycle was on
- 22:33full blast. Full blast.
- 22:35Second, the Contrata pivot wave. We were in the steepest part of
- 22:38the mobile Internet explosion. Smartphones, the App Store,
- 22:41cloud computing. It was changing everything.
- 22:43And 3rd. The CapEx and inventory cycle.
- 22:46Everyone on earth had to go out and buy a smartphone.
- 22:49Companies had to build massive data centers.
- 22:51Telcos had to lay fiber optic cables.
- 22:54So you had free money meeting a revolutionary technology that
- 22:57required a massive build out of new infrastructure.
- 23:00It was a super resonance, a perfect storm for a massive bull
- 23:04market. But now I mean, everyone has a
- 23:06phone. And money isn't free anymore.
- 23:09The resonance is gone, the cycles are desyncing.
- 23:12Which leads us to a really important discussion because I
- 23:14hear people say this all the time, especially when the market
- 23:16gets choppy. They say, oh, I'm just going to
- 23:18buy safe stocks. You know the classic advice the.
- 23:20Cycle proof sectors. Exactly, people always need to
- 23:22eat so I'll buy consumer goods or tech is the future.
- 23:25It doesn't cycle so I'll just buy tech.
- 23:27Mr. Brain calls this the myth of cycle proof sectors.
- 23:31It's a dangerous fallacy. Let's bust the consumer goods
- 23:33myth first. Why isn't toothpaste and soap a
- 23:36safe bet forever? It's the fallacy of confusing a
- 23:40need with growth. Just because people need it
- 23:43doesn't mean the stock will go up indefinitely.
- 23:45Consumption is constrained by three very powerful forces.
- 23:48First, income. It's the wealth effect.
- 23:52When your house value drops by 20% and your stock portfolio
- 23:56drops by 30%, you feel poorer. And when you feel poorer, you
- 24:00change your behavior. You buy the generic brand of
- 24:02toothpaste, or you try to stretch that tube for another
- 24:05week. What's the second constraint?
- 24:07Debt. It's simple math.
- 24:09If you're paying off a massive mortgage and huge student loans,
- 24:11you have less discretionary income leftover to buy new
- 24:14things. And the third?
- 24:16This seems like the big one. Demographics.
- 24:18This is the slow moving killer for consumption growth.
- 24:21Older people consume less. It's just a fact.
- 24:23They already have their house, they have their furniture, they
- 24:25have their car. They aren't buying new stuff at
- 24:27the same rate as populations age, which is happening across
- 24:30Europe, Japan, China, and even the US.
- 24:32Overall consumption growth naturally has to slow down.
- 24:35South consumer goods are definitely not cycle proof.
- 24:38They have their own powerful constraints.
- 24:40But what about tech? The argument you always hear is
- 24:43tech is different. Tech is exponential.
- 24:45It doesn't cycle, it just zooms upward.
- 24:48Tech is exponential for a time, but it always, always runs into
- 24:53diffusion limits. Fusion limits.
- 24:55What does that mean? Think about the classic S curve
- 24:58of technology adoption. From roughly 2010 to 2020,
- 25:01mobile Internet went from, say, 10% adoption among the global
- 25:05population to nearly 100% in the developed world.
- 25:08That steep part of the S curve is where you get explosive high
- 25:11growth. But now.
- 25:12Now everyone who wants a phone has a phone.
- 25:15You can't go to 110% adoption. You've hit the diffusion limit.
- 25:18Growth has to slow down. Mr. Brain mentioned 5G in the
- 25:21source material. That was supposed to be the next
- 25:22big thing, the next growth driver.
- 25:24But what new use cases did it really bring for the average
- 25:27person? It just made your TikTok videos
- 25:29load a fraction of a second faster.
- 25:31It wasn't the paradigm shift. So we find ourselves in the
- 25:34stagnant period technologically waiting for the next big
- 25:37paradigm. Maybe it's AI, maybe it's
- 25:39something else. And until then, tech becomes
- 25:41cyclical. Deeply cyclical.
- 25:43We see it most clearly in semiconductors.
- 25:44Oh. Yeah, the chip cycle is brutal.
- 25:47The semiconductor cycle is the juggler CapEx cycle on steroids.
- 25:50When there's a shortage of chips, prices spike.
- 25:53So every company announces they're going to build new
- 25:55billion dollar chip plants. But by the time those plants
- 25:58were actually built, three years later, there's a massive glut of
- 26:00chips. Prices crash.
- 26:02It's clockwork. So nothing is truly safe.
- 26:05Everything cycles. This is starting to sound a
- 26:07little bit depressing. Is the answer just to put all
- 26:08your money under the mattress and wait for the apocalypse?
- 26:11No, absolutely not. Volatility isn't just risk, it's
- 26:15opportunity. The answer isn't to hide from
- 26:17the wave. The answer is to learn to surf.
- 26:20Surfing the wave. I like that.
- 26:23And Mr. Brain offers a very specific, very practical
- 26:26strategy for handling what he calls strong cyclical stocks,
- 26:29things like commodities, raw materials, shipping, energy.
- 26:33He uses lithium as the case study and it's a master class in
- 26:36cycle timing. OK, so challenge accepted.
- 26:38Let's get practical. How do we actually make money
- 26:41from these cycles without getting crushed?
- 26:43Mr. Brain outlines what he calls the three waves of a bull
- 26:47market. Let's walk through them step by
- 26:49step. All right.
- 26:49Stage 1 is called the capacity clearing.
- 26:51My favorite name for it is the Invisible Turn.
- 26:54Invisible because on the surface everything still looks terrible.
- 26:57The price is still going down. Exactly.
- 26:59The scenario is bleak. Product prices are at multi year
- 27:02lows. Companies in the sector are
- 27:04going bankrupt. The media is full of headlines
- 27:06saying the Lithium dream is dead.
- 27:07And this was literally the situation for lithium in
- 27:102019-2020. It was.
- 27:11The price had already dropped from highs of overall 150 KA ton
- 27:15down to $40,000 or $50,000 and it just kept crashing.
- 27:19Australian mines are closing down.
- 27:21All capital expenditure, all plans for new mines were
- 27:23cancelled. So everyone is fleeing the
- 27:25burning building. But this is where the signal is.
- 27:27You have to ignore the price, you have to ignore the
- 27:30headlines. You look for the supply demand
- 27:32inflection. Break that down.
- 27:33What does that mean in practice? You have to become a detective.
- 27:36You look at the hard data on the supply side, you see that supply
- 27:39is being actively destroyed, mines are closing.
- 27:42That's a very bullish long term signal.
- 27:45But what about demand? That's the other side of the
- 27:47equation. At the exact same time, EV sales
- 27:49were actually starting to accelerate, tensile was ramping
- 27:52up production in China. European emissions regulations
- 27:55were kicking in, forcing car makers to go electric.
- 27:58So you have supply destruction meeting demand creation.
- 28:01Precisely. Even if the news is terrible,
- 28:03even if the price is still dropping, the underlying physics
- 28:06make a shark turn inevitable. The rubber band is stretched too
- 28:10far in One Direction. That is when you buy.
- 28:13That sounds absolutely terrifying though, Buying when
- 28:15everyone you know is telling you it's over.
- 28:17It feels like trying to catch a falling knife, but it's actually
- 28:21the point of maximum financial safety because all the bad news
- 28:24is already priced in. There's no one left to sell
- 28:26then, and only then comes Stage 2.
- 28:28Which is volume and price rise. This is the sweet spot.
- 28:31This is when the turn becomes visible to everyone.
- 28:34The product price, lithium in this case, actually starts
- 28:37ticking up, sales volume explodes as the EV boom takes
- 28:40off and corporate profits just soar.
- 28:43But here you run into the valuation trap.
- 28:45OK, what's the trap in the sweet spot?
- 28:47It's the PE ratio, the price to earnings multiple.
- 28:50As earnings are skyrocketing, the PE ratio actually drops
- 28:53rapidly. So the stock looks cheaper on
- 28:55paper even though the price has already gone up a lot.
- 28:57So new investors look at it and they say, wow, this company has
- 29:00incredible growth and low PE, this is a bargain.
- 29:02I'm all in. And this is the easiest money.
- 29:05The wind is at your back. The trend is your friend.
- 29:07But you cannot get complacent, because that complacency leads
- 29:11you directly into the jaws of Stage 3.
- 29:13The performance release, or as I like to call it, the danger
- 29:16zone. A perfect name for it.
- 29:18The scenario now is the complete opposite of stage one.
- 29:21Prices are at all time highs. the PE ratios look incredibly
- 29:25low, maybe 5X or 6X earnings. The media is screaming super
- 29:29cycle. Lithium is the new gold.
- 29:31So why is this so dangerous? It sounds perfect.
- 29:33Low valuation, high growth. Great story.
- 29:36Because the supply response has finally arrived.
- 29:38Remember the inertia? All those new mines that
- 29:41companies started planning back in Stage 2, they are now finally
- 29:44opening. The floodgates are about to
- 29:46open. The floodgates open and if you
- 29:47see the product price stall or even dip slightly at the exact
- 29:51moment that massive new capacity is coming online, the cycle is
- 29:55over. Even if the PE is five, that
- 29:56feels so cheap. Especially if the PE is five.
- 29:59That low PE is a giant trap. It means the market knows that
- 30:02earnings are at a peak they can never ever sustain.
- 30:04The EE is about to collapse. So what's the action?
- 30:07The action here is simple and brutal.
- 30:09Sell. Ignore the low valuation.
- 30:11Ignore the great story. Don't look back.
- 30:13And Mr. Brain has a fantastic quote about regret minimization
- 30:16here. He says something like if you
- 30:17made 30X your money from stage 1 to stage 3, don't risk it all
- 30:21trying to squeeze out the last 10%.
- 30:23That is the discipline. Pigs get fat, but hogs get
- 30:26slaughtered. It's always better to leave the
- 30:28party a little bit early than to be the one stuck cleaning up the
- 30:31mess at 3:00 AM. This brings us to the final
- 30:33section of our deep dive. And honestly, this is the part
- 30:36of Mr. Brain's analysis that stuck with me the most.
- 30:39Because he pivots. He stops talking about stocks
- 30:41and commodities and starts talking about life.
- 30:43The philosophy of the through. Right.
- 30:45He argues that these same cycle dynamics apply to social class,
- 30:49to family wealth, to careers, not just to stock tickers.
- 30:52And he has this definition of what class or wealth really is
- 30:55that. Well, it's profound.
- 30:57He says that true wealth isn't defined by how high your peak
- 30:59is. Your peak can be luck, it could
- 31:01be leverage, it could be just being in the right place at the
- 31:04right time during a boom. Anyone can get lucky.
- 31:07True wealth, he argues, is defined by how high your through
- 31:10is. When the cycle inevitably turns
- 31:12against you, how far do you fall?
- 31:14What is your bottom? It's about resilience, not just
- 31:16peak performance. Exactly, and he compares 2
- 31:19famous Chinese real estate tycoons to illustrate this Shu
- 31:24Jian of the company Evergrand and Pan Shi of Soho, China.
- 31:27Shujin was the poster child for the peak.
- 31:29Right. The absolute poster child.
- 31:31At his peak, he was the richest man in China.
- 31:33He had private jets, championship football teams,
- 31:36immense political clout. He leveraged everything to the
- 31:40absolute maximum. He was always chasing the peak.
- 31:43And his trough? What was his bottom?
- 31:44Prison. His assets were seized.
- 31:46He's a complete 0. The cycle turned.
- 31:49The real estate market crashed and he had no floor underneath
- 31:51him. He fell all the way to the
- 31:53bottom. Now contrast that with Pan Shi.
- 31:55Pan Shi saw the clouds gathering on the horizon.
- 31:57He started selling off his prime real estate assets in 2014, way
- 32:01before the crash. He was criticized for IT.
- 32:03People probably called him foolish for selling too early
- 32:05and missing the final leg of the boom.
- 32:06What is through? He's living comfortably abroad
- 32:08with his family. He preserved his wealth.
- 32:10More importantly, he preserved his freedom.
- 32:12His personal bottom was higher than 99.9% of people's peaks.
- 32:16There's a reference in the material to the classic Chinese
- 32:19novel Dream of the Red Chamber. The line is white snow on clean
- 32:24earth. It's the idea that the higher
- 32:26the peak, the more spectacular and devastating the crash if you
- 32:30haven't managed the downside. The goal of investing, and
- 32:33really the goal of a well lived life, isn't just to maximize the
- 32:36highs, it's to consistently raise the floor of your lows.
- 32:39So that every time the pendulum swings back, and we know it will
- 32:42swing back, you land on a higher platform than you did during the
- 32:44last crash. Exactly.
- 32:45That is real progress. That is true compounding.
- 32:48Compounding isn't just about the percentage return, it's about
- 32:51never interrupting the chain with a 0.
- 32:53OK, let's try to tie all of this together.
- 32:54We've covered a massive amount of ground today.
- 32:56We have. Let's synthesize the key
- 32:58takeaways 1. Linearity is a lie.
- 33:01The market is not a staircase, It's a pendulum.
- 33:04It overshoots and it stagnates. 2 history is a warning. 17 year
- 33:08flat lines are not an anomaly, they are a feature of the
- 33:11system. Don't assume the index will
- 33:13always save you. Three, physics is real.
- 33:16You cannot argue with the forces of supply and demand constraints
- 33:20and inertia. They will win in the end. 4 The
- 33:24clocks are always ticking. You have to know which cycle you
- 33:27are playing. Are you in a short term
- 33:29inventory correction or at the end of a 50 year technological
- 33:32revolution? The strategy is completely
- 33:34different. And five watch the through.
- 33:38Build a portfolio and a life that is robust enough to survive
- 33:42the bust, not just one that maximizes the boom.
- 33:45And practically speaking, what this means is don't be a passive
- 33:47victim of the pendulum. Learn to read the signs.
- 33:50Look for the turning points. Buy when supply is being
- 33:53destroyed, not when the hype is at its peak.
- 33:55And use the tools available to you to gauge the temperature.
- 33:57Right. And seriously, check out that
- 33:59Buffett Indicator app on the iOS App Store.
- 34:01It's a great simple way to just get a reality check on where the
- 34:04pendulum is sitting right now. Are we near a point of rational
- 34:07equilibrium, or are we swinging wildly out to an emotional?
- 34:10Edge knowing that answer changes your entire perspective.
- 34:13And of course, for those who want to really geek out with us
- 34:15on this stuff, check out the community at Deep Values dot AI
- 34:18and the Deep Value Club. That's where we get into the
- 34:20nitty gritty details. Indeed I.
- 34:22Want to leave everyone with a final thought?
- 34:24We've talked a lot today about mechanics and physics and
- 34:27cycles. It can feel very deterministic,
- 34:31like we're all just cogs in a giant uncontrollable machine.
- 34:35It's easy to feel that way, yeah, but we aren't just cogs.
- 34:38We are the operators of our own little machines.
- 34:40Exactly. And we often feel like we are
- 34:42the masters of our fate. But if the greatest, most
- 34:44powerful economies in human history, the US, Japan, all the
- 34:48rising powers, are subject to the laws of financial gravity,
- 34:51then so are we. The question isn't will the
- 34:53winter come? The winter always comes.
- 34:56The cycle always turns. The only question that matters
- 34:58is how warm is your coat when it does.
- 35:01That's it for this deep dive. Thanks for listening and we'll
- 35:03catch you on the next swing of the pendulum.
- 35:05Stay warm everyone.