Latest / Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques / 216. Wired for Words: A Neuroscientist’s Guide to Influence
Transcript
- 0:03Matt Abrahams: Relevance is critical to communication, relevance to
- 0:07yourself, and relevance to others.
- 0:09My name is Matt Abrahams and I teach strategic communication at
- 0:13Stanford Graduate School of Business.
- 0:15Welcome to Think Fast, Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 0:19Today I'm excited to speak with Emily Falk.
- 0:22Emily is a professor of communication, psychology and marketing at the
- 0:25University of Pennsylvania and the Vice Dean of the Annenberg School
- 0:29of Communication, where she directs the Communication Neuroscience Lab.
- 0:33Her latest book is entitled What We Value: The Neuroscience of Choice and Change.
- 0:39Welcome, Emily.
- 0:40I'm really excited for our conversation.
- 0:42I know we missed each other once when you were out at Stanford, and I'm excited
- 0:45that we're getting to talk in this way.
- 0:47Shall we get started?
- 0:48Emily Falk: Let's do it.
- 0:49Matt Abrahams: So in your lab and your research, you use neuroscience
- 0:52to explore communication.
- 0:54And a topic I, and many of our listeners, are fascinated by
- 0:58is persuasion and influence.
- 0:59And I know you've done a lot of work in this area and I'm curious if you
- 1:02can share with us how do our neuro responses to persuasive messages
- 1:07help predict real world behaviors?
- 1:10Can you share some of your findings and, and what we can do based on those?
- 1:13Emily Falk: Yeah, in our early research, a lot of my work was focused on
- 1:18persuasive messages that were designed to change people's behaviors, like to
- 1:22help people quit smoking or get more physically active or wear sunscreen.
- 1:26And as I've continued to do that work and found that neural activity and response to
- 1:31persuasive messages can help us understand behavior change, and also what people
- 1:37decide not only to change themselves, but also what they want to share with others.
- 1:41I've also gotten really interested in like, well, how do we choose what
- 1:43those behaviors are in the first place?
- 1:45So whereas in the early work, a lot of it was aimed at convincing people of
- 1:49stuff, in my more recent research program, I'm more interested in how do we help
- 1:54people develop a sense of agency and autonomy, and how do they successfully
- 1:59pursue goals that they want to achieve.
- 2:02Matt Abrahams: In some ways it's self persuasion you're talking about.
- 2:04How do we motivate ourselves?
- 2:06Emily Falk: Exactly.
- 2:07Matt Abrahams: So what have you found both in your prior research
- 2:10and in the new research that we can all take to heart when we try
- 2:13to persuade others and ourselves?
- 2:15Emily Falk: There are three core brain systems that our work has focused on.
- 2:18One, is the brain's valuation system that helps us calculate how valuable
- 2:24we anticipate any number of different choice options to be, and then to select
- 2:29the one that our brain anticipates is gonna be the most rewarding to
- 2:32us, and then to enact that choice.
- 2:35And that value system integrates lots of different inputs from many other
- 2:39brain systems, and two that really interest me are the brain self relevance
- 2:43system that helps us think about whether something is me or not me.
- 2:47It helps us think about our past experiences and make meaning
- 2:50of them and think about our own traits and what we're thinking.
- 2:54Then the social relevance system, which sometimes scientists talk about in terms
- 2:59of a theory of mind or mentalizing system.
- 3:01And I use social relevance as this kind of catchall for these thoughts about
- 3:05what other people are thinking and feeling, which also helps us predict
- 3:08what they're gonna do and how we might communicate successfully with them,
- 3:11or negotiate or win a game of chess.
- 3:14By extension, thinking about what are the ways that we can tap into those processes
- 3:19and think about making behaviors that we want to do or that are compatible
- 3:24with our long-term goals, feel identity congruent and socially valuable now.
- 3:30Matt Abrahams: So if we were to craft messages to try to motivate somebody to
- 3:34do something, that's in line with what we're asking, we have to factor in both
- 3:38the impact, or the recipient's identity, how they see themselves, but also the
- 3:44social value that that brings as well.
- 3:46Did I get that right?
- 3:47Emily Falk: Well, I don't know that you always have to do both, but those
- 3:49are two potential inroads to doing it.
- 3:51So for example, in research that we've done, looking at what motivates
- 3:55people to share information, when we gave them messages that were about
- 4:01things like health or climate change, headlines and teasers, and we just
- 4:05ask them to talk to other people about what this article's about.
- 4:09So they write a little social media post about what the article's
- 4:12about, and that's our control group.
- 4:13So that's kind of the baseline of like, how much are people
- 4:16motivated to share when they're just asked to share the information.
- 4:19And we compare that to when we give them the chance to make
- 4:22it relevant to themselves.
- 4:23So really simple prompts like, write about how this relates to you and
- 4:27things that you care about, or write about how this might be relevant
- 4:30to people in your social network.
- 4:32And in both of those conditions where we ask people to focus on the self
- 4:36relevance or the social relevance, it significantly increases people's
- 4:40interest in sharing that information.
- 4:42Matt Abrahams: So you were able to persuade them to be more motivated
- 4:45by asking them to focus on the relevance to themselves or the
- 4:48relevance to those they know.
- 4:50Emily Falk: Exactly.
- 4:50And there's a lot of other kinds of techniques as well that tap
- 4:53into those kinds of processes.
- 4:55So if message tailoring is an idea that's been around for a long time,
- 4:59where scientists have found that when they tailor persuasive messages to the
- 5:05recipients goals, values, things that they know about that person's history.
- 5:09For example, in research on tailoring smoking messages, if a smoker wants to
- 5:14quit because they're sick of spending all their money on cigarettes, then
- 5:18giving them messages that really focus on those cost issues can be more effective
- 5:22than focusing on, you know, maybe the long-term health effects if that's not
- 5:25the thing that they really care about.
- 5:27For a different person, let's say that they really are motivated to
- 5:30quit because they wanna protect the people in their family.
- 5:33They're worried about secondhand smoke in their kids, and so for
- 5:35that person focusing on cost may be less of a persuasive argument
- 5:40and focusing on keeping their kids safe might be the way to do it.
- 5:44So that's an example where a different route to tapping into self
- 5:48relevance is also then compatible with more successful influence.
- 5:53And one of the things that I really like about having a neuroscience perspective
- 5:57on all of this is that I think it can help boil it down to what kinds of systems
- 6:02many of these different interventions are tapping into, and then give us a
- 6:06way of just organizing that information.
- 6:08Matt Abrahams: I find it so fascinating that looking at how the brain functions
- 6:12in communication can really give insight into why and how things work.
- 6:17I find how you study communication to be really fascinating.
- 6:20What I'm hearing is that you really have to think about your audience and
- 6:23what might be motivational to them.
- 6:26So many of us in our communication just focus on broadcasting the information out,
- 6:30but if you can actually find the value and motivation and tailor the message,
- 6:35especially if it can be around what's relevant to the individual or to their
- 6:38social network or social environment.
- 6:41It can really make a difference.
- 6:42So we have to take the time to think about it, and in many cases, those
- 6:45of us who have the opportunity, we could test different messages it
- 6:48sounds like, to see which is our most relevant for which people.
- 6:51And I think that's so useful to being effective in the communication.
- 6:56Did I miss anything in that?
- 6:57Emily Falk: Yeah, so when we think about the way that these brain systems
- 7:00are working, one of the things that I find fascinating is that our value
- 7:05system tends to prioritize rewards that are psychologically close.
- 7:09And what does psychologically close mean?
- 7:12When we think about the way that the medial prefrontal cortex functions, there
- 7:17have been these beautiful papers led by people like Diana Tamir and Carolyn
- 7:21Parkinson that have shown something that wasn't at all obvious to me, which is
- 7:25that different kinds of psychological distance are encoded in similar ways.
- 7:30So something that happens far off in the future or geographically,
- 7:34the other side of the world, or to somebody who's socially really
- 7:38different than I am, those things all function in kind of similar ways.
- 7:42And so when we say that we want to make it relevant to the person, it's not
- 7:46only just like relevant to Matt, or relevant to Emily, but it's relevant to
- 7:50the person that's right here, right now.
- 7:53Like if we want to change some kind of behavior because it's gonna have a payoff
- 7:57that's several decades in the future, you might as well be talking about a
- 8:00different person who's gonna get that benefit from the brain's perspective.
- 8:04Or when we think about, you know, asking people to lend a helping hand or to make
- 8:08donations for folks that are all the way on the other side of the world, in other
- 8:13communities, without doing extra work to make that concrete and vivid and help you
- 8:18really imagine like, what are the rewards for somebody that I can connect with?
- 8:23Then it can be less motivating.
- 8:25And so I think that this way of thinking about psychological distance is another
- 8:29key ingredient that's relevant to the brain's value system has been
- 8:32really helpful for me in thinking about shaping these kinds of messages.
- 8:36Matt Abrahams: Absolutely.
- 8:36So relevance is not just in general, it's proximal or distal.
- 8:41I remember when I was in graduate school, I did some work with Phil
- 8:43Zimbardo on time perspective, and we looked at persuasive messaging that had
- 8:48long-term consequences versus short-term.
- 8:50So we looked at brushing your teeth, and we talked about how the distant goal was
- 8:54you'll have healthy teeth and you won't need to have dentures when you get older,
- 8:58which was nowhere near as successful in terms of messaging as when we talked
- 9:01about how you'll have fresh breath and your teeth will look white and clean.
- 9:04So this notion of thinking about relevance, not just generically,
- 9:08but in terms of how close it is to the real time, is fascinating to me.
- 9:13Beyond tailoring for relevance, what is the value of story in framing messages?
- 9:19Emily Falk: There are a lot of different ways that we can frame messages that
- 9:23increase their effectiveness, and so there's a large literature in
- 9:27communication and psychology, which shows that when we use stories to communicate,
- 9:33it can reduce people's defensiveness, make them more open to new ideas.
- 9:37Often people identify with characters in the story.
- 9:40And in our work we found that when people are given information in the form of
- 9:45stories, it also makes it easier for them to reason about the information.
- 9:50So for example, in a study that Jason Coronel led, when he was in my lab, he
- 9:54brought people who smoke into the lab and he presented them with information about
- 10:00a wide range of topics, including smoking.
- 10:03And sometimes that information was presented in the form of didactic facts.
- 10:08You know, if you smoke for several decades, it significantly
- 10:11increases your risk of lung cancer.
- 10:13And then for other folks, they got the information in the form of stories.
- 10:18So for example, John is a smoker who smoked for several decades.
- 10:23He developed lung cancer.
- 10:25And the twist in this study, that's different from some of the other
- 10:28behavioral science studies, is that people came in for two different sessions,
- 10:32and in one of those sessions we used a kind of brain stimulation technique
- 10:36called transcranial direct current stimulation, which changes the activation
- 10:40in particular regions of people's brains.
- 10:43So during one session they had this brain stimulation that like literally decreased
- 10:48activation in regions that help us reason.
- 10:51And during the other session they got a sham stimulation, where we
- 10:55hook them up to the equipment, and everything's happening in a similar
- 10:57way, but they're not actually having any alteration happening in their brains.
- 11:02And the finding there was that for people who got the information delivered in the
- 11:07typical didactic facts kind of way, when they were under brain stimulation that
- 11:11was decreasing activation within parts of lateral prefrontal cortex that help
- 11:16us reason, they were less able to reason, which is exactly what you would predict.
- 11:20On the other hand, when people were told that information in the form of a
- 11:23story, reasoning about an exemplar is something that we do from the time that
- 11:27we're really little kids, and it taps into different kinds of brain systems.
- 11:32So other research has shown that stories tap into these social brain systems.
- 11:36And even when we essentially reduced people's ability to use these parts of
- 11:41their brain, they were still able to reason about the stories just as well.
- 11:45So stories are one effective way of improving our communications.
- 11:50Matt Abrahams: Thank you for sharing the value of story and how even when
- 11:53you purposely impact, in a negative way, people's ability to reason
- 11:57stories still have great power.
- 12:00I find in my own life I learn best when people tell stories.
- 12:02One of the things I enjoyed so much about your book is that you have lots of stories
- 12:06that reinforce and support what you say.
- 12:08I want to turn to your new book, What We Value, and you dedicated a whole
- 12:12chapter of that book to brain synchrony that happens between people when we
- 12:17communicate, when we tell stories.
- 12:19Can you define what that synchrony means?
- 12:22Emily Falk: Neural synchrony happens when people's brain
- 12:25activation follows similar patterns.
- 12:28And so one of the kind of simplest ways of thinking about synchrony
- 12:32is that if activation in a given region in my brain and your brain are
- 12:36going up and down at the same times, that's something we call synchrony.
- 12:41Some of the early research on neural synchrony looked at how neural synchrony
- 12:46relates to shared understanding.
- 12:48And there have been a number of studies that have shown that when
- 12:51people's brains are more in sync, especially in the social relevance
- 12:55system and other brain systems, that is associated with making similar meaning.
- 13:00And what I mean by that is, for example, when one person tells a story and
- 13:05another person gets the main point or extracts the same facts from the
- 13:10story, then that's associated with their brains being more in sync.
- 13:14When we watch movies together, like if we watch a movie that's a powerful
- 13:18movie, then that external stimulus is gonna drive our brains to be in sync.
- 13:22So often audiences watching, you know, a really amazing Western or listening to
- 13:28a powerful political speech, their brain activation is gonna be driven up and
- 13:32down in similar ways at similar times.
- 13:35Matt Abrahams: Are there ways to bring about synchrony so that you
- 13:39can have that shared meaning, which can help accomplish many goals?
- 13:43I can imagine empathy is a critical component of shared meaning.
- 13:47It sounds to me like storytelling is one way.
- 13:49Are there other ways to bring about this kind of synchrony so you can get the
- 13:53benefit of shared reality, shared empathy?
- 13:56Emily Falk: Well, I think what you're saying sort of highlights one of the ways,
- 14:00when you're talking about shared reality.
- 14:01There's other research that has shown that when people have similar
- 14:06assumptions going into a communication that their brains are more in sync.
- 14:11So for example, a research study at Princeton showed that when people
- 14:16were given different back stories, before their brains were scanned, the
- 14:20people who are given the first back stories brains are in sync with one
- 14:23another, but out of sync with people who are given a different backstory.
- 14:27So making sure that we're on the same page about what kinds of
- 14:30assumptions we have is one thing.
- 14:33There have also been a handful of studies looking at what happens
- 14:36in the brains of partisans.
- 14:38So people in the US, for example, who tend to be more liberal or more conservative.
- 14:42And what that research has shown is that when people watch the same media
- 14:47clips, people who share ideological perspectives also tend to be more in
- 14:53sync with each other than with people who are part of the other group.
- 14:56And I think that that is also a function of the kinds of assumptions
- 15:00that people are bringing to the table.
- 15:01And behavioral research shows that the media play a large part in that.
- 15:05And you know, as Vice Dean of the Annenberg School for Communication and
- 15:09a communication scholar, like that's a piece of this puzzle that I think
- 15:12is so important for us to recognize is that the media that we consume
- 15:17fundamentally shapes so much about how we see the world, what we think and feel.
- 15:22There's this incredible study where political scientists randomized
- 15:25people to change their news viewing habits, and after changing their news
- 15:32viewing for a relatively short period of just a few weeks, the things that
- 15:36they thought were important, like what issues to focus on shifted.
- 15:40Their beliefs about those things shifted.
- 15:43And so of course, in day-to-day life, we don't usually make these major pivots,
- 15:49but if we want to understand where other people are coming from or checking
- 15:52our assumptions can be really helpful.
- 15:55And we can think about it in the workplace too.
- 15:56Like for example, if you come in and you're gonna make a big presentation and
- 16:01your boss is in the audience and they look kind of bored, maybe a little bit annoyed.
- 16:05Like one very reasonable assumption you might make is that they didn't like the
- 16:10presentation, but if you don't have access to the fact that like they slept badly,
- 16:15they hit every red light, they didn't get to have their coffee first, all of those
- 16:19things might be at play in their mind.
- 16:21And they thought your presentation was great, but you might be out of sync then
- 16:24when you have a conversation afterwards about what just happened, if you come into
- 16:28that conversation feeling a little bit defensive or a little bit like, oh, like
- 16:33what didn't they like about this, right?
- 16:34And they don't know that you're thinking that 'cause they weren't paying attention
- 16:37to what was happening on their face.
- 16:39Matt Abrahams: So much richness in what you just said.
- 16:42I just wanna put an exclamation point to the, the impact media can have on all of
- 16:46our communication and the way we interact.
- 16:48When I asked you the question, what are things we can do to bring about
- 16:51synchrony beyond storytelling, what I heard you say is that expectation
- 16:55setting that we can do in advance can prime people to be more in sync.
- 16:59So it could be what we call the meeting or what we put in the meeting invite,
- 17:04and all of that could help people get to synchrony more quickly because
- 17:08you're setting those expectations.
- 17:10But I also heard you say that we have to check our own self expectations,
- 17:14the assumptions that we have going in.
- 17:16This happens all the time where I see a student who looks disengaged
- 17:19in my class, and it turns out they're actually very engaged.
- 17:22It has to do with the bad day they had or, or some other situation.
- 17:26And once I learned that, it allows us to get back in sync.
- 17:29So very helpful that there are things we can do in advance to prime
- 17:33others, but also things we have to do to ourselves to set ourselves up.
- 17:36I appreciate that.
- 17:39Well, Emily, before we end, I'd like to ask three questions of all my guests.
- 17:42One I create just for you, and the other two are similar for everyone I interview.
- 17:46Uh, are you up for this?
- 17:47Emily Falk: I'm ready.
- 17:48Matt Abrahams: So in all of the fascinating research that you've done,
- 17:50I'm curious, is there one finding that stands out as something that's
- 17:54just really impacted how you do things, affected your communication
- 17:58or, or where you are in the world?
- 18:00Emily Falk: I'll tell you a little bit about some of the work that
- 18:02we're doing right now that is most exciting and on my mind.
- 18:06I'm doing this work with Diana Tamir and Shannon Burns, and a team of amazing
- 18:11postdocs that's about conversation, and we talked a little bit in our
- 18:15conversation here about neural synchrony.
- 18:17But one of the things that's been fascinating to me is that neural synchrony
- 18:22in and of itself seems like it's a starting point, not the end point you
- 18:26want to strive for in a conversation.
- 18:29And what I mean by that is in research that Lily Tsoi and Sebastian Speer led,
- 18:34when people have conversations where they're either talking with a friend
- 18:38or with a stranger, the friends quickly get in sync, and then they use the
- 18:42rest of the conversation to explore all different kinds of topics and ideas.
- 18:47Whereas the strangers often spend a lot of the time in that kind of small talk
- 18:51space where they're trying to establish common ground and getting in sync.
- 18:55And then maybe not surprisingly, the friends end up enjoying
- 18:58their conversations more, on average, than the strangers.
- 19:01But the good thing is that when the strangers do that pattern that the
- 19:04friends did of relatively quickly getting in sync, maybe do a little bit
- 19:07of small talk, but then they explore lots of different topics and lots of
- 19:12different mental space, they end up enjoying the conversations more too.
- 19:16That's something that's really intriguing me now and kind of pushing me in
- 19:19conversations with particularly people that aren't my best friends, try to be
- 19:23a little bit more adventurous, right?
- 19:24Not like inappropriate, but just like try to be more curious.
- 19:27Matt Abrahams: That's really interesting.
- 19:29And this notion of getting in sync quickly can free you up to do other
- 19:33things, and it speaks to the power of icebreakers and other things that
- 19:37can help people really get there.
- 19:38Thank you for sharing that and how it's impacting what you do.
- 19:42Question number two, who's a communicator that you admire and why?
- 19:45Emily Falk: Tonya Mosley, who I talk about in the book because
- 19:48she has this amazing capacity to connect different people and ideas.
- 19:54She is a radio journalist.
- 19:57She hosts Fresh Air.
- 19:58She has an amazing podcast called Truth Be Told, and she's done just incredible
- 20:03work, bringing together different kinds of expertise and providing context
- 20:07for what's happening in the moment.
- 20:10Like when we look around and we're baffled by the political moment or by, you know,
- 20:15just how we function as humans, she's somebody who I think is incredible.
- 20:20Matt Abrahams: Thank you for sharing that.
- 20:21Final question, what are the first three ingredients that go into a
- 20:25successful communication recipe?
- 20:27Emily Falk: I love this question and there are so many ways to answer it.
- 20:30I'm gonna focus on sort of the three ingredients that the book centers on,
- 20:35which have to do with our brain's value system, our brain social relevant system,
- 20:40and our brain's self relevant system.
- 20:41And so when we think about a successful communication recipe, I think about
- 20:46all of the myriad possible ways that we can tap into those systems.
- 20:50So I think the recipe sort of starts with understanding how our brains work.
- 20:54An analogy that I've been really liking is that many of us can cook a basic
- 20:58meal, but if you understand something about how chemistry works, then that
- 21:03can help you swap out ingredients if you don't have all the right ingredients.
- 21:07Or it can help you diagnose where something went wrong in a baking project.
- 21:11And likewise, if we understand how our brains are working, I'm hoping that
- 21:16that also helps people, A, make sense of like why we do the things that we do and
- 21:21have a little bit more compassion for ourselves, and for other people whose
- 21:25behavior does not make sense to us.
- 21:27And then also that maybe it can help us sort of diagnose
- 21:30places that we can intervene.
- 21:31Matt Abrahams: You have done a great job of that today, helping us understand
- 21:35how our brains work and how that informs the choices we can make as communicators
- 21:39and perhaps the habits that we have.
- 21:41I really appreciate your insights and your time, and I wish
- 21:44you well with your new book.
- 21:45Thank you for your time.
- 21:46Emily Falk: Thank you so much, Matt.
- 21:47It's such a pleasure to talk with you.
- 21:51Matt Abrahams: Thank you for joining us for another episode of
- 21:53Think Fast Talk Smart, the podcast.
- 21:56To learn more about neuroscience and communication, please listen to
- 21:59episode 39 with David Eagleman and episode 101 with Matt Lieberman.
- 22:04This episode was produced by Katherine Reed, Ryan Campos, and me Matt Abrahams.
- 22:09Our music is from Floyd Wonder.
- 22:10With special thanks to Podium Podcast Company.
- 22:13Please find us on YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.
- 22:17Be sure to subscribe and rate us.
- 22:19Also, follow us on LinkedIn and Instagram.
- 22:22And check out FasterSmarter.io for deep dive videos, English language
- 22:26learning content and our newsletter.
- 22:28Please consider our premium offering for extended Deep Thinks episodes,
- 22:32Ask Matt Anythings, and much more at FasterSmarter.io/premium.