Latest / The Vegan Report / Breaking Bread With Farmers.
Transcript
- 0:00Hello everyone, my name is Ryan and you're listening
- 0:02to The Vegan Report. Today we're discussing a
- 0:06thought -provoking initiative that recently caught
- 0:09my attention. One Table. It's an online conversation
- 0:13series featuring animal farmers who oppose factory
- 0:17farming in dialogue with none other than Leah
- 0:20Garcés, a vegan and longtime animal activist.
- 0:24The first three episodes of the series are available
- 0:28now, link in the episode notes. I asked Leah
- 0:32what led her to launch this initiative, why there
- 0:37is resistance within the movement to talking
- 0:40with farmers instead of judging them, and whether
- 0:44there's a segment of the population will never
- 0:47persuade to go vegan. Her answers will surprise
- 0:51you. We also talked about her time at the helm
- 0:55of Mercy for Animals, why she chose compassion
- 0:59in world farming for the next chapter of her
- 1:02activism journey, what she thinks of PETA's white
- 1:05paper on cage -free campaigns, her thoughts on
- 1:09precision livestock farming or factory farming
- 1:122 .0, and much more. You'll also find links in
- 1:17the episode notes to learn more about compassion
- 1:20in world farming. and connect with their work.
- 1:24I have to say I've been genuinely impressed by
- 1:27the people I've met there. I've previously interviewed
- 1:30Joyce De Silva on World Religions and Matthew
- 1:33Dominguez on the Save Our Bacon Act and they've
- 1:37all struck me as thoughtful, engaging and deeply
- 1:40committed activists. As always I invite you to
- 1:44follow or subscribe to the show, share the episode
- 1:47with the vegans you know, leave a good review,
- 1:50And thank you so much for tuning in every week.
- 2:10I actually published an audio version of the
- 2:14debate you did on clean meat with United Poultry
- 2:19Concerns. I thought it was such an amazing, well
- 2:22done debate that I needed to share it with my
- 2:26audience. And maybe we could start with that.
- 2:30What did you think of that debate, you know,
- 2:33when you think back of the exchange and what
- 2:37are your thoughts on, you know, lab grown meat,
- 2:40cultivated meat nowadays. Yeah. And I was, that
- 2:45was quite a while ago. It was in Berkeley, right?
- 2:47And that was a very interesting audience that
- 2:51I had not really encountered quite before, but
- 2:54I continue to be very, um, in favor of cultivated
- 2:58meat. I continue to be hopeful. Uh, and I continue
- 3:02to think that at some point there'll be a tipping
- 3:05point for the technology as it develops. Um,
- 3:09what Yeah. What do you specifically, I can't
- 3:12remember the debate exactly. So what was, what
- 3:14highlight, what was a highlight for you? I think,
- 3:18you know, there is, there are people in the vegan
- 3:20community who are a doubtful of, you know, lab
- 3:25grown meat, cultivated meat, being successful
- 3:28at replacing meat. And then B there are people
- 3:32who just oppose that technology because they
- 3:36think of it as, you know, not being not natural
- 3:40would not be the world, but would be maybe not
- 3:45the best way forward for the food, the global
- 3:48food system. Yeah. I think, um, on the matter
- 3:52of whether it will work or it won't work. Um,
- 3:55actually recently spoke to Bruce Friedrich about
- 3:58this and it continues to be the case that the
- 4:01amount of investment in this technology is, it's
- 4:05so small. And it's really a couple of companies
- 4:08like Upside that are putting all the effort and
- 4:10all the money into developing this. If that were
- 4:13to be expanded and governments were to see this
- 4:16as a priority, I mean, for God's sake, we go
- 4:19to space. Like, I think we can handle developing,
- 4:24sell cultured meat. I think we can if we made
- 4:26it a priority. I honestly believe that if the
- 4:29investment was made, we could do it. It's just
- 4:33not a priority in terms of government funding.
- 4:35And it should be because for better, for worse,
- 4:39the amount of meat that is being eaten has not,
- 4:42it is not going down. The number of animals that
- 4:44are being killed is not going down. Like we have
- 4:46to be realistic about those figures and we need
- 4:50to throw all the spaghetti at the wall. Anyone
- 4:53who is working towards reducing the suffering
- 4:56of farmed animals, ending factory farming, all
- 4:59of those projects need to be supported. we don't
- 5:02know which one is going to be the breakthrough
- 5:03one and cultivated meat has a very good chance
- 5:06of being a very positive and It could cut through
- 5:12some of this cultural dilemma or Heritage ideas
- 5:18about eating animals and say well, we're not
- 5:21taking away your meat Here it is. It just doesn't
- 5:24cause suffering doesn't cause environmental damage
- 5:25doesn't cause all the other problems so I think
- 5:29in terms of Will it happen? Can it happen? I
- 5:31don't think it's been given a fair shot at this
- 5:34stage. In terms of the naturalness, the ethics
- 5:38of it, I don't think that's a relevant argument
- 5:43in terms of reducing the suffering of animals.
- 5:45If you ask a farmed animal who is suffering in
- 5:48a factory farm, would you want this developed
- 5:53or not developed if it would work because it's
- 5:55not natural or because it's not normal? It's
- 5:59not what we've done before. I think that chicken,
- 6:02that pig, that cow would say, whatever it takes,
- 6:04do it, do it, because I want out, I want out
- 6:07of this suffering. And I don't want future generations
- 6:10to have it either. And I think we have to always
- 6:13be putting ourselves in, in the, in the hooves
- 6:17and the claws of the animals, like what would
- 6:19they want? They would not want us arguing about
- 6:22is this natural? They would just want us to stop
- 6:25their exploitation. Yeah. I agree with you that
- 6:31governments are not only not funding cultivated
- 6:35meat, but they're also banning it. You know,
- 6:38I'm thinking of Italy. I'm thinking about the
- 6:41state of Florida. You know, so government officials
- 6:45are actively opposing that technology for whatever
- 6:49reason. Of course, we can think of ranchers as
- 6:53special lobbies that are putting pressure on
- 6:55those governments. But yeah, it's. Yeah. Yeah,
- 7:00if we look at companies like wild type, I had
- 7:03the opportunity to try wild type salmon recently.
- 7:07I was in Tufts University. They had a sampling
- 7:10of it at a talk I was giving and it was in a
- 7:14vegan cream cheese and it was like bagels and
- 7:17lox kind of concept. I tried it. I don't remember
- 7:21what salmon tastes like, but it was delicious
- 7:23and the biggest hurdle they have right now. Is
- 7:27scaling they don't have the money. They don't
- 7:28have the technology. They don't have the investment
- 7:30to scale if the governor would say, you know
- 7:32what? aquaculture like taking fish from the ocean
- 7:38is is Full stop got to stop and on top of that
- 7:43aquaculture is a disaster It's a disaster for
- 7:46the welfare of the animals a disaster for wild
- 7:48salmon. It's disaster for the the ecosystem We've
- 7:52got to stop it the only solution If people want
- 7:54to eat fish is to do this and we're going to
- 7:57invest in scaling it. I have no doubt it would
- 8:00happen and wild type is ready. They have a product
- 8:03that's approved by the FDA can be eaten in most
- 8:06places. Like you say, it can't be eaten in Florida,
- 8:08which is ridiculous, but it's ready to eat. It's
- 8:11been approved. It tastes good. The only thing
- 8:15that's stopping it is some investments and this
- 8:19kind of technology needs government buy -in,
- 8:23it needs that kind of scaling to happen by government
- 8:28support. Yeah, I mean, I think from the point
- 8:34of view of investors, they're thinking maybe
- 8:37there is a faction of the population that will
- 8:40never accept that kind of meat. And we're looking
- 8:45at a campaign of misinformation right now on
- 8:48social media about how lab -grown meat is disgusting.
- 8:52And we see more and more this issue being politicized
- 8:57and people more on the right side of the political
- 9:01spectrum, taking a position against it. So I
- 9:04think those are all red flags for potential investors
- 9:08in this technology. Yeah, I think we could have
- 9:12said that about EV cars. You know, we could have
- 9:14said that about the way that alternative Fuel
- 9:19has been developed or alternative cars have been
- 9:22developed at some point there was government
- 9:25investment that made it possible and There was
- 9:28a there's a realization that this was good for
- 9:31the country good for the economy At some point
- 9:34people said no people won't accept electric cars.
- 9:36There was there was the same like it factor probably
- 9:40and and now it's normal and people as we develop
- 9:44a economy that is at least in the United States,
- 9:48is completely saddled with the cost of fuel.
- 9:53People are looking at electric cars like it's,
- 9:56wow, this is so glad we did this, so glad we
- 9:59saw the crystal ball. The same thing is going
- 10:01to happen with me at some point. We're going
- 10:04to run out of arable land. We're going to have
- 10:07problems with importing and food sovereignty.
- 10:11Countries around the world are going to need
- 10:14to invest in this and the best time to plant
- 10:17a tree as they say is 20 years ago. So what we
- 10:22should be doing now for 20 years from now is
- 10:26investing in this because it will bear fruit
- 10:29for later when we don't have arable land left,
- 10:31when the clean water and air is gotten to the
- 10:34point where we can't squander it on factory farming
- 10:38and producing animals in factory farm settings.
- 10:43When I think of myself, you know, I I'm truly
- 10:47looking forward to trying cultivated meat. I'm
- 10:50really curious about it. I remember the first
- 10:52time Beyond Meat came to Canada and how, you
- 10:57know, I rushed to A &W, who at the time, you
- 11:00know, was the only restaurant distributing Beyond
- 11:03Meats in Canada. And I rushed there to purchase
- 11:07a burger, a Beyond Meat burger. And I've been
- 11:12a client of them since then, you know, so they
- 11:15acquired me. consumer. So yeah, I'm, I'm truly
- 11:19looking forward to trying it. I think I've been
- 11:22talking about it and thinking about it a lot
- 11:24without even trying the product, which is, is
- 11:27crazy to, to consider. Yeah. See, I think, I
- 11:32think that's great. And truly the product is
- 11:35actually not for you and I, you know, in, in,
- 11:38in truth, this product is for folks who I mean,
- 11:42we've already chosen alternatives. We already
- 11:44accept alternatives. We've created a lifestyle
- 11:46that looks for ingredients that are not animal
- 11:50products, let's say. But the world out there
- 11:54is not like that. Like, 5 % is like that, let's
- 11:57say. 95 % is not. And that doesn't seem to be
- 12:00changing right now. So we have to accept that
- 12:04we either change factory farming or we change
- 12:07what the meat products are. and what is available
- 12:11and what looks like meat to people. And that
- 12:13could be done through plant -based alternatives,
- 12:15which is great, but it also could be done by
- 12:17cultivated meat. And so it's not even for us.
- 12:19It's about other people getting access to this
- 12:23and for them not even caring about that difference.
- 12:27And the general strategy is price, taste, and
- 12:30convenience, I think. is the idea that if those
- 12:33things are resolved, then as long as it tastes
- 12:35good, it's price parity and it's convenient that
- 12:38people will come on board. I think there's, we
- 12:40have to be careful of what you were mentioning,
- 12:42like this kind of culture war. This cannot go
- 12:45into culture war. We cannot allow it to go into
- 12:48a culture war because if it goes into culture
- 12:50war, we're doomed. Then, then, then it's the
- 12:54issue. It becomes an issue like, like immigration
- 12:57or abortion. And it becomes something that is
- 13:01guarded by one side and, you know, rejected by
- 13:05the other. We can't let that happen. Definitely.
- 13:10I've, you know, I've noticed how factory farming
- 13:13is a big focus of your activism. And I was reflecting
- 13:17on that yesterday and talking about it with fellow
- 13:21activists. And I was telling to that person,
- 13:24you know, I don't think I would have become an
- 13:28animal rights activist. if it wasn't for factory
- 13:31farming, you know, if globally, there was no
- 13:34such thing as factory farming, but animal exploitation
- 13:37was still a thing. I don't think that would have
- 13:40I think I would have become vegan. Yes, but I
- 13:44would not have become like a full time activist
- 13:48for the animals. Do you feel the same way? I've
- 13:52never thought of it like that. But you might
- 13:54be right. You know, I started On a journey when
- 14:00I did up my master's degree in London in environment
- 14:03and development and It was there that I started
- 14:06to understand and it was real. I was really coming
- 14:09at it first and foremost I was already vegetarian,
- 14:11but first of all, I was I didn't think this could
- 14:13be a job I didn't understand this could be a
- 14:15job. So I was thinking about environmental protection
- 14:17I was thinking what can I do to protect the environment?
- 14:19I was very inspired by Greenpeace. You know,
- 14:21I grew up Watching green peace make changes and
- 14:25fighting wailing and things like that very inspiring
- 14:28so i want to do something like that i want to
- 14:29be an activist for the environment. So when i
- 14:33found out the impact. Start first and foremost
- 14:36it factory farming was having on the environment
- 14:38that that was my gateway in and then when i looked
- 14:42like open the doors of factory farm. I was so
- 14:46appalled by what it was doing to animals and
- 14:49as an educated with a math like getting a master's
- 14:51degree i was not aware i thought oh my god nobody
- 14:53knows nobody knows this. I just chose not to
- 14:56eat animals purely on ethics not because of factory
- 14:59farming you know i'm. Just couldn't eat my dog
- 15:02why would i eat a pig that was just like a purely
- 15:04ethical thing but to find out that there was
- 15:07this systemic abuse and it impacted the environment
- 15:10and it was exploiting people it was like a no
- 15:13brainer to me. I think, and when I looked at
- 15:17that whole picture, I think you're right, it
- 15:20was the animals. It was the animals that shocked
- 15:24me the most, that kind of got to my core passion
- 15:27and ignited my career, really, my path. So I
- 15:31think you're right. I've never thought of it
- 15:33that way, but I probably wouldn't. I might have
- 15:35gone more into environmental activism instead
- 15:39of animal activism. And I wouldn't have focused
- 15:41just on factory farming. I would have focused
- 15:43on oil and what have all the other mining and
- 15:46things like that and deforestation. But when
- 15:50I found out that the kind of root of the worst
- 15:54suffering to animals and to the environment is
- 15:58factory farming, it just was that's it. That
- 16:00was it. It was over. So I think you're right.
- 16:02Factory farming was the string that pulled me
- 16:04in for sure. When you think about when you remember,
- 16:10you know, taking that decision, that choosing
- 16:14that career path. And also when you decided to
- 16:17become vegetarian and then vegan, do you feel
- 16:21like you had agency in that? Because at first,
- 16:25you know, that's how I felt. I felt very much
- 16:28like I was making that decision and I could not
- 16:30understand why others were not also making that
- 16:34decision. But as time goes by, you know, I'm
- 16:39realizing how much I was just lucky to become
- 16:44vegan, to come across certain things and then
- 16:49those things affected me, affecting me in certain
- 16:52ways. And that creating like a sort of domino
- 16:56effect that made me into the activist, vegan
- 17:00activist I am today. Do you feel the same way
- 17:03about your journey? I think so. And I hear what
- 17:09you're saying that It can feel a bit random that
- 17:13you got exposed to certain material that then
- 17:16led you to think but also you were open to those
- 17:19material You know you Listen to that material
- 17:23you process that material that material turned
- 17:26into an action, which is that agency you talk
- 17:29about Because a lot of people that material goes
- 17:32by them and they let it go in one year out the
- 17:34other It doesn't fit with them. So I do think
- 17:37there is something about you something about
- 17:39activists who it doesn't pass through them it
- 17:44stays with them and they can't it's more than
- 17:48agency it feels like it's stirred something in
- 17:52you and you can't refuse to act you can't refuse
- 17:56it you have to do something and the most basic
- 17:59thing you can do as a human is choose not to
- 18:02eat these animals choose not to participate in
- 18:05a system that so many people are are almost not
- 18:09consenting to and until the moment that that
- 18:11material passes by you you're not consenting
- 18:14to it you're it's just the air you breathe it's
- 18:16part of you know the system is is everywhere
- 18:20it's just. How it is and until that material
- 18:23passes by you a video a person a booth that gives
- 18:28you a leaflet you're not really consenting but
- 18:32the minute you do see that you are consenting
- 18:34and. You chose to no longer consent to this,
- 18:38to have agency. And it takes a lot of courage
- 18:43because you have to go against all the cultural
- 18:45norms to do that. And sometimes people process
- 18:48that, and sometimes they're just so appalled
- 18:49and they go, I can't do it, I can't do it, I
- 18:51can't do it, I'm never doing it again. And it
- 18:55takes a lot of courage to do that because you're
- 18:57going against the norms around you. That's why
- 19:02there's only 5 % of people who are really dedicated
- 19:05to that. But it doesn't mean that everyone can't
- 19:07be participating in some way or the other. I
- 19:11think it's very important. You have a chance
- 19:13three times a day. Every time you choose differently,
- 19:16you are making a difference. And that's agency,
- 19:18too. And it's one of the few issues where you
- 19:21have agency all the time. And you can start at
- 19:24any moment. You can have agency three times a
- 19:27day, every time you eat. And it's, you can't
- 19:29say that about racism or misogyny or, you know,
- 19:33autocracy. It's like, you feel powerless in those,
- 19:36those, and you think, what can I do today? What
- 19:38can I do in this moment? And, and the way you
- 19:40eat is gives you incredible agency. It's one
- 19:44of those rare issues where you have incredible
- 19:46agency. And that's, that's a interesting way
- 19:53of framing things. What do you make of those
- 19:56people who are exposed to the footage of Slaughterhouse,
- 20:01who hear us, who can understand from an intellectual
- 20:07perspective where we're coming from, but are
- 20:10not translating those conclusions into actions
- 20:14in their life, into changing the way they eat.
- 20:19And through your initiative, One Table, you interview
- 20:22farmers who understand you. understand where
- 20:26you're coming from. And so I think lots of people
- 20:29who listen to those interviews are thinking,
- 20:33you know, why aren't they just connecting the
- 20:36dots? Like, it should be so simple. What do you
- 20:41make of that reaction? Yeah, I think, um, it's,
- 20:49I take a lot of, you know, inspiration from social
- 20:53justice leaders before me and what When you sit
- 20:56down with someone, you cannot expect, just like
- 20:59you said, not everyone is going to be exposed
- 21:02to the same material, the same upbringing, the
- 21:04same culture, the same families, the same experiences.
- 21:07So everyone comes to the table with a different
- 21:11perspective. And what I try to do is be curious
- 21:15about that perspective and then peel away the
- 21:19onion until we find the core, the common between
- 21:22us and build from there. What again I think about
- 21:27what would the animals want would they want me
- 21:29fighting this person? For just so I'm taking
- 21:33a stance. I don't think so I think they would
- 21:36want me to find any measure of reducing their
- 21:39suffering that I can and so Nobody likes to be
- 21:44told what to eat. Absolutely. No one likes to
- 21:46be told what to eat No one it never works. It
- 21:49never will work. Don't tell people what to eat
- 21:51So me sitting down with a farmer and telling
- 21:53them what to eat, how to farm when I'm not even
- 21:55a farmer is a ridiculous strategy. And it's important
- 21:58to differentiate stance and strategy. My stance
- 22:02is that I think it's unethical to eat animals.
- 22:04That is not my strategy to yell at a farmer and
- 22:06say it's unethical to eat, to use animals and
- 22:08farm animals. My strategy is to sit down with
- 22:11them and see where do we find common ground.
- 22:13We both want animals to suffer less. We both
- 22:15want, in this case with these farmers, for the
- 22:17animals to live natural lives. and for the most
- 22:21number of people to not choose factory farming.
- 22:25Those are our common building blocks. And if
- 22:29we can get all of that done, then maybe at some
- 22:32other future point, we can argue about the ethics
- 22:34of eating animals. But imagine the suffering
- 22:36we'd reduce if we could get all the pasture farmers
- 22:40on board and fighting right next to us to end
- 22:42factory farming instead of just focusing on that
- 22:47principle we disagree on, which is when and who
- 22:50gets to choose if the animals die. I think lots
- 22:54of activists have the assumption that if they
- 22:59say the right words, if they insist enough, if
- 23:02they do X and Y, at some point, they will be
- 23:07able to change that person. And I'm considering
- 23:12the idea that there might be a large segment
- 23:16of people who we will never be able to reach,
- 23:19who will never embrace veganism. Do you think
- 23:23I'm right in that assessment of things? I don't
- 23:31set out for the goal to be make everybody vegan.
- 23:34I set out to maximize how many animals are suffering
- 23:39and how they're suffering. It is very clear,
- 23:44like the data has been done, many, many polls.
- 23:47People love animals. And building on that common
- 23:53love of animals is the path. Building on the
- 23:56love of animals is the path. It is not telling
- 23:59people what to eat and what not to eat, and allowing
- 24:02people to come to conclusions themselves. I've
- 24:06done a lot of testing on social media on which
- 24:09reels work best. And it is always the ones where
- 24:13there's messages about the kind of inner lives
- 24:16of animals, messages about animal consciousness,
- 24:20animal sentience, or what they're thinking, what
- 24:23they're feeling, and having people think about
- 24:26that without telling them. And then at the end
- 24:29saying, well, what does this mean for our food
- 24:30and farming system? And leaving that door open
- 24:34so they can process it because people's behavior
- 24:36doesn't change when you tell them what to do.
- 24:38It changes when they make their own neural pathways,
- 24:41when they make their own connections in their
- 24:44own way, in their own words, in their own time.
- 24:48And so it's not about, you know, do I think or
- 24:52not think everyone will be vegan one day? It's
- 24:55about building on the common love that is that
- 24:59people have for animals. And if you ask someone,
- 25:02is a pig and a dog different? Most people actually
- 25:04say no. They will say they are intelligent, they're
- 25:08sentient, they can do tricks, they're smart.
- 25:11So a lot of my work is about trying to build
- 25:15on that messaging and creating those neural pathways
- 25:21for people, those door openers, and having them
- 25:27make that connection. I will also say... we cannot
- 25:31shop our way out of this problem. Factory farming
- 25:34and cheap meat exists because governments created
- 25:37it and corporations profit off of it. So the
- 25:40target of our anger needs to be not at individuals
- 25:43not turning bean, it needs to be at governments
- 25:45and corporations. They're the ones who are creating
- 25:49the system. Factory farming was created by governments
- 25:51through subsidies. Corporations profit off of
- 25:53this. That needs to stop and we need to get citizens
- 25:57for animals and that love of animals their love
- 26:00of animals, forcing governments and corporations
- 26:02to do better, to abandon factory farming. That's
- 26:05where my strategy is focused rather than thinking
- 26:08about what are people eating individually. It's
- 26:12instead targeting institutions and what they
- 26:15are creating. We can't shop our way out of this.
- 26:17We can't just expect people to at the cash register
- 26:21to make all the change. It's not going to work.
- 26:26Yeah, it's a very nuanced approach. And I would
- 26:30also add a mature approach to this issue. And
- 26:35I think for your average person, it's, it's quite
- 26:39tough emotionally, you know, to accept that.
- 26:44And because there is right away, you know, an
- 26:48us versus them, you know, perspective that I
- 26:52think psychologically comes in. And there is
- 26:56that, you know, psychological barrier to to things.
- 27:02What is your advice or recommendation for your
- 27:05everyday activists in this movement to address
- 27:10that, to embrace maybe a more nuanced and mature
- 27:14perspective on things? I know this is very hard
- 27:18for people who are passionate. I'm passionate.
- 27:23I also have been on the other side of angry vegans
- 27:28who have I felt like what it feels like when
- 27:34you're not doing it well enough that people are,
- 27:38it doesn't feel good. And it, if I wasn't so
- 27:41married and passionate about helping farm the
- 27:44animals, I might say, forget it. And I never
- 27:46want a person we're trying to feel, I never want
- 27:50a person that we're trying to convince to feel
- 27:53like that. I only say to people put yourselves
- 27:57in this, try to put yourself in the person's
- 28:00shoes. Really walk in their shoes rather than
- 28:05trying to win an argument. Try to win them over,
- 28:08not win over them. And it might mean a much more
- 28:15gentle and incremental approach. It might mean
- 28:21one meal you share with them, you bring to them.
- 28:26It might mean, you know, accepting that they're
- 28:32not going to be vegan overnight or ever, but
- 28:35they will share meals with you. They will accommodate
- 28:38you. They will go to vegan restaurants with you.
- 28:40And you're sharing that with them. And these
- 28:47are the strategy I'm telling you about is the
- 28:53strategies of successful social justice activists
- 28:57like Bernard Lafayette. or Martin Luther King,
- 29:01believe it or not. And it was being strong in
- 29:07your stance. You never have to confuse that.
- 29:10You never have to say by you, you always can
- 29:15hold your position, your stance of it's unethical
- 29:18to eat animals, but you can also try to understand
- 29:23and put yourself in the shoes of someone else
- 29:25and help them along their journey in as least
- 29:28judging as a way as possible. And Imagine what
- 29:32it would be like if a vegan were to tell you,
- 29:34you're not good enough because everyone is not
- 29:36good enough, right? Like we, we can all find
- 29:38faults in our veganism and our animal activism.
- 29:41And imagine if someone decided to shame you about
- 29:43it, how would that feel? It would feel awful
- 29:46because at the core of it, everyone does love
- 29:49animals and they don't want to hurt them. And
- 29:52it's shaming will only cause walls to go up and
- 29:56for you to be pushed away. So Melanie joy does.
- 30:01great work on how to talk about this. I think
- 30:06there's a lot of great resources about how to
- 30:10work in a nuanced and incremental way, in a gentler
- 30:14way. And I think that is the way, the gentle
- 30:21way is the way. And I think that's what animals
- 30:23would want. They wouldn't want us yelling at
- 30:25someone because it doesn't work. This reminds
- 30:31me of Madeleine Krasno. She's the founder and
- 30:35executive director of Justify. And she's all
- 30:38about, you know, humanizing and bridging, creating
- 30:43bridges with lab workers who have experienced
- 30:47immense distress from their line of work. And
- 30:52she always talks about, you know, putting yourself
- 30:56in their shoes and considering them as potential
- 30:59allies to, you know, become whistleblowers against
- 31:03that industry that made them do the awful things
- 31:06they did not want to do, but did to animals.
- 31:12And because of that, because of that stance,
- 31:15she received like a death threats from animal
- 31:19rights activists, the same animal rights activists
- 31:22that those lab workers are afraid of and avoid
- 31:26that all costs. And, you know, her situation
- 31:30reminds me of what you just said. Why is, is
- 31:34there, you know, inside our movement, this intolerance
- 31:38to talking with the enemy? You know, there's
- 31:41that expression, you know, making peace with
- 31:45your enemy. Like who else are you going to make
- 31:48peace with, with your allies? It's of course
- 31:51with the enemy, but why are they even enemies?
- 31:54You know, that's another question. we could ask,
- 31:58but you know, how do you explain that repulsion
- 32:02we have to reaching out to the other side and
- 32:06starting conversation with the other side? Well,
- 32:10I think when you're so passionate and it is,
- 32:14it is a displaced frustration where we feel helpless.
- 32:20We see so many animals suffering and there's
- 32:24a, there's a psychological word for it. I can't
- 32:26remembering, but it's, it's a displacement of
- 32:28frustration. When and it happens in democracies.
- 32:32It happens in other social justice Issues where
- 32:35instead of going after the large enemy you go
- 32:38after each other Because you're not getting anywhere
- 32:41with the large enemy because the large enemy
- 32:43ignores you and you seemingly have no impact
- 32:47So you have to put it somewhere and you put it
- 32:49on each other. And so I think it comes honestly
- 32:52from a place of deep pain and frustration That
- 32:57people feel and they don't know where to put
- 32:59it They're so upset and I get it. I'm very upset
- 33:04as well. I feel so frustrated as well and so
- 33:08it takes some inner work to take a deep breath
- 33:12and go but what works what does work and That's
- 33:19the work. I've been trying to do I have worked
- 33:21with factory farmers. I have sat down with them
- 33:24as allies gotten them to expose conditions in
- 33:28their farm. And I also received threats for talking
- 33:31to factory farmers in the same way. I've also
- 33:35worked with corporations trying to get them to
- 33:37make improvements. And the idea I think of this
- 33:43purity police within the vegan movement, it comes
- 33:47from a good place. Honestly, it comes from a
- 33:50place of frustration. And we just have to be
- 33:53mindful to not place it in the wrong person.
- 34:02And this is why I say, point it at the government,
- 34:06honestly. Point that anger together at the government
- 34:10because they're allowing this to happen and the
- 34:12corporations are profiting from it. And that's
- 34:15where we need to place that frustration. Don't
- 34:18give up that we can have influence on those big
- 34:21institutions. That's how we change factory farming.
- 34:24That's how we get rid of the suffering of animals.
- 34:26It's not by yelling at the person who cares about
- 34:29animals, but isn't doing it perfectly. It's by
- 34:32yelling at the government. It's by voting different.
- 34:34It's by shopping or influencing the companies
- 34:37differently and forcing their policies to change.
- 34:41Well said. And there's also something to be said
- 34:44about how those slaughterhouse workers and those
- 34:48lab workers, you know, are of the working class.
- 34:52They are usually people with not a lot of means,
- 34:56you know, they're not the super rich, wealthy
- 34:59people profiting from this big industry. And
- 35:04what about the potential for those people to
- 35:06become activists? And we have so many great activists
- 35:09in our ranks who were slaughterhouse workers,
- 35:13who were farmers. I even know an activist who
- 35:15worked for the Turkey lobby and became an animal
- 35:20rights activist. Why do we lose? hope for those
- 35:24people to join our ranks. Why do we have this
- 35:28instinct of making them the enemy instead of
- 35:32seeing the potential of gaining them as friends?
- 35:37I think that's changing a lot actually. I think
- 35:40especially on the slaughterhouse worker front,
- 35:42there's been a huge except change, a switch in
- 35:47mentality that slaughterhouse workers are also
- 35:51vulnerable. And factory farming feeds on vulnerability,
- 35:55right? It's a vulnerable farmer. It's a vulnerable
- 35:57workers, vulnerable communities, and of course,
- 35:59vulnerable animals. And it requires people who
- 36:05are not able to speak up to participate, to function.
- 36:09So in the United States, the majority of slaughterhouse
- 36:12workers are both documented and undocumented
- 36:17workers. And either way, They are citizens. If
- 36:22they are citizens, then they are citizens who
- 36:24have low social and political and economic power.
- 36:30They can't speak up. They don't have a lot of
- 36:32options. They may not speak the language. It
- 36:36requires these vulnerable people to work in such
- 36:38a horrific circumstance. There's a hundred percent
- 36:41turnover. And the ones that aren't documented,
- 36:44they're never participating in the political
- 36:45system. They can't vote out this system. It's
- 36:50intentional. It's very, very intentional that
- 36:53the people who work in this horrific system have
- 36:56no ability to ever speak out on it. It would
- 37:01put them at grave risk. And I actually went into
- 37:04Iowa and I interviewed slaughterhouse workers
- 37:06in Iowa. They were working in a Smithfield pig
- 37:09slaughterhouse and they were all women from Central
- 37:11and South America. And it was some of the most
- 37:13heartbreaking work I've ever done. talking to
- 37:16these women who would some of them had visas
- 37:19and paperwork to be there and some of them didn't
- 37:23and Regardless, they had injuries. They had carpal
- 37:26tunnel syndrome. They have been sexually harassed
- 37:28It was endless their suffering endless and yet
- 37:31they kept going because they didn't have another
- 37:33choice because and they were all working for
- 37:35their children to get out of usually dangerous
- 37:39situations in their home country And they were
- 37:42working for their future generation. They kind
- 37:44of were sacrificing their life And the slaughterhouse
- 37:48was the way to pay for that. And if all of that
- 37:52was above board and legal, it's now permitted
- 37:57for children, for minors, to work in slaughterhouses
- 37:59in the United States. And that their parents
- 38:02don't even have to approve it. So children as
- 38:05young as 14 can work in a slaughterhouse now
- 38:07because they're running out of options. It requires
- 38:11such vulnerable people. We have to remember that.
- 38:15Even the farmers are quite often in rural areas
- 38:19with little job little job options They get trapped
- 38:23in a cycle of debt and struggle they and so we
- 38:26have to show compassion and Imagine if we were
- 38:29able to join forces with the workers with the
- 38:32farmers and the animal activists all doing forces
- 38:33against the system It wouldn't stand a chance
- 38:36To me. It's the only strategy that we should
- 38:38be following. It's the strategy of uniting Everyone
- 38:43against a system that's harming everyone Yeah,
- 38:49well put. I mean, I remember a campaign that
- 38:52Oxfam, which is not an animal rights organization,
- 38:55launched. They were trying to shed light on the
- 38:58fate of, I think, deep sea fishermen in Asia
- 39:01and so many of them being exploited by the fishing
- 39:06industry. And they just had that gallery of photos
- 39:10of the hands of the fishermen and how many fingers
- 39:13were missing on those hands. you know, an image
- 39:17says a thousand words and those images are, you
- 39:21know, I still think about them. They've really
- 39:24left a mark on me. So yeah, I think, I think
- 39:28it's, I also believe it's the way to go. In that
- 39:32case, what do you make of the evolution of factory
- 39:36farms? You know, you've most likely seen the,
- 39:41all of the talks about factory farming 2 .0.
- 39:46One of the evolution of factory farming in the
- 39:50near or long term is for, you know, replacing
- 39:55those factory farm workers by robots that would
- 40:00not feel a thing, you know, killing animals.
- 40:04So what do you make of factory farming 2 .0 and
- 40:08the, you know, upcoming technological advancements
- 40:12in that area? Yeah, I think you're referring
- 40:16probably to livestock precision farming, where
- 40:18there's AI technology being used inside of factory
- 40:24farms. I'm actually headed next week to Hanover,
- 40:27Germany, to go to EuroTier. And EuroTier is the
- 40:30largest livestock conference in the world. And
- 40:34their focus this year is intelligence and animal
- 40:38farming. And they're going to be showcasing what
- 40:40the industry is pushing in terms of AI in animal
- 40:45farming. So I'm going to find out all about what
- 40:47they're doing. And it includes things on the
- 40:50agenda, which is open to the public to look at
- 40:52things like scream detection in piglets and early
- 40:59detection of pig bite, pigtail biting and looking
- 41:04at automated milking systems using robots. And
- 41:10at its face, you could think these are good things,
- 41:13right? These are good things if we can If you
- 41:16look at a factory farm, how could we ever hear
- 41:18the suffering of one individual animal in a sea
- 41:22of animals? We couldn't hear it. And so that
- 41:25on its face is good. But the question is, what
- 41:28do we do with that information and who has that
- 41:31data? Will that be public or will it be company
- 41:37owned? Will we ever know what is happening and
- 41:41what they do with it and why? If it's some kind
- 41:45of government minimum criteria, like you cannot
- 41:48have any pig screaming. And if the AI detects
- 41:52it, you're shut down. That would be amazing.
- 41:54I don't have a good feeling that that's where
- 41:56we're headed. Instead, I feel like it's going
- 41:58to be used to make the system more efficient,
- 42:02cheaper. And then you have these, this kind of
- 42:06paradox, which is known and I think it's called
- 42:10Javan's paradox. And it is where when commodities
- 42:15become cheaper, and I hate to use animals commodities,
- 42:17but that's how it's referred to. You think, oh,
- 42:20well, that will mean we have less, we don't have
- 42:23to produce as much because it's cheaper, but
- 42:25the opposite happens. More gets used, more ways
- 42:30of using it get invented, and it skyrockets.
- 42:33And that is potentially where we're headed with
- 42:36AI and animal farming. And so I think it's very
- 42:39important as animal activists that we are at
- 42:41the forefront of understanding what is the industry
- 42:43doing? Who's going to own that data? What are
- 42:45we going to be measuring? And ensuring there
- 42:49is a criteria there that this doesn't result
- 42:52in more animal suffering and more animals being
- 42:54killed. Those two important criteria. Are you
- 43:01going to videotape your visit? Yes. Oh, I'll
- 43:06be producing a lot of content. So, you know,
- 43:08it's open to the public. I just paid 95 euros
- 43:11for a ticket for two days and I plan to film
- 43:15and I'll do a lot of content afterwards. I'm
- 43:17going to produce a paper based on what I find
- 43:20out a sub stack article. And, you know, we, as
- 43:24a movement, we don't have a position on this
- 43:25very well thought through and we need to, because
- 43:28it is rapidly developing the fact that your tiers
- 43:31entire theme this year is about intelligence,
- 43:35AI intelligence in, in livestock farming. We
- 43:38are behind on it already. It is coming, whether
- 43:41we like it or not, and we need to be really shaping
- 43:45it in government policy, in corporate policy,
- 43:49and in the public mind. What prompted you to
- 43:54kind of all of a sudden creating more of a media
- 43:58presence? You know, I'm thinking of one table.
- 44:02Those are difficult conversations to have with
- 44:04those farmers, just from an emotional perspective.
- 44:09But then when you think of videotaping those
- 44:12conversations and then releasing them and making
- 44:15yourself, you know, exposed to all of those angry
- 44:20vegans out there to, you know, we talked about
- 44:23it. But yeah, what prompted you to launch that
- 44:27new chapter? Well, when I left Mercy for Animals,
- 44:30I received a grant from Coefficient Giving and
- 44:34it was a career planning grant. And I was Tasked
- 44:39I tasked with a research project, which was how
- 44:43do we build durable power in our movement? We're
- 44:45very good at winning short term campaigns, but
- 44:48we often backtrack or lose those wins because
- 44:52the opposition then, you know, opposes us and
- 44:55we don't have enough power to hold those. So
- 44:58I wanted to understand why and what do we need
- 45:01to build in order to hold our power and build
- 45:05our power? And I did an interview with over 50
- 45:11different leaders in the movement and outside
- 45:13the movement. So everyone from the labor movement,
- 45:16environmental movement, historians, but also
- 45:19funders and activists who are leaders in the
- 45:22space. And it's over 800 years of experience
- 45:25in terms of the interviews. And I created a whole
- 45:28report. It's on Substack. The number one thing
- 45:33we need to do to build durable power is invest
- 45:35in building political infrastructure, which we
- 45:37don't have. We don't have a party for the animals,
- 45:40except the Netherlands does, and somewhat in
- 45:42Europe they do, but we don't have that in the
- 45:45United States. In North America, we don't. So
- 45:48we need to build political infrastructure. But
- 45:49the second thing we need to build is a communication
- 45:53strategy. We need to have public debate. We're
- 45:57not even in the debates. We're not present in
- 46:00the conversations on podcasts and media. No one
- 46:03is thinking about this, and we have to build
- 46:05that communication strategy, that narrative strategy,
- 46:08if we want to have power in society and culture.
- 46:12And so that's what I'm now turning to, is trying
- 46:15to build that narrative power. I'm experimenting
- 46:19with which messengers work. Farmers are the most
- 46:23listened to after doctors, messenger in the country.
- 46:28People listen when especially when it comes to
- 46:30food and farming it's vets and farmers So we
- 46:33need to hear what they're saying and we need
- 46:35to shape what they're saying To people to citizens
- 46:38because what they say is what people listen to
- 46:40they don't listen to us vegans. They listen to
- 46:43farmers and So working with farmers is a critical
- 46:47critical strategy for changing our food and farming
- 46:50system and getting their voices to represent
- 46:53Ending factory farming for them to say it So
- 46:55I'm searching for those farmers. Those are the
- 46:57farmers I'm, I'm searching for is believable
- 47:00messengers who will be on our side and vocally
- 47:03speak. And the videos are about that. They're
- 47:05about finding alliances with other, with farmers
- 47:08who are also against factory farming. Well, I
- 47:13should say there is the animal protection party
- 47:15of Canada. We never elected someone. Yes, of
- 47:20course. Sorry. You're well, you're advanced on
- 47:23many levels. I would not go that far. Canada
- 47:30is not the best country for animals. Really not.
- 47:34But we do have that party. You know, I'm curious.
- 47:39You spent lots of time managing, leading one
- 47:43of the most important animal rights organization
- 47:46out there, Mercy for Animals. How do you think
- 47:49about your time there? what you've accomplished,
- 47:54the legacy that you've left behind. What is your
- 47:58reflection around that? Yeah, I'm proud of the
- 48:02work that we did there. We did over 50 undercover
- 48:05investigations, many of which led to corporate
- 48:08and government policy change. And we had a very
- 48:12strong corporate engagement team globally that
- 48:14was working on hundreds of cage -free policies,
- 48:18making broilers lives. better in terms of less
- 48:22suffering. We worked on corporate and government
- 48:26policies that measurably changed the lives of
- 48:29animals. And I think we also increased presence
- 48:33in other countries. So when I first started,
- 48:36there was only a handful of people in the Brazil
- 48:37office, and there's this huge movement in Brazil
- 48:40now. And Mercy for Animals office had a lot to
- 48:43do with that. Us being there, investing there,
- 48:45the same in Mexico, and they had an office in
- 48:48India, too. I think, you know, I also started
- 48:52TransFarmation as a project when I was there.
- 48:54And this was where we transitioned factory farmers
- 48:58into specialty crops. It was about eight to 10
- 49:02farmers per year. We'd work with them and handhold
- 49:05and help them transition out of factory farming.
- 49:08And we also did some really amazing public celebrations.
- 49:16So the galas we produced would... gather celebrities
- 49:19and media. We also had award -winning films like
- 49:23the film Henrietta Finds a Nest, which was an
- 49:25animation that I was the executive producer and
- 49:28was based on the story of me rescuing a chicken
- 49:30and the chicken coming to live with my daughter
- 49:32that won dozens of awards at film festivals.
- 49:37It's such a varied organization and it has measurable
- 49:41impact on animals and it raises awareness globally.
- 49:45And I think Probably the narrative work is the
- 49:48most important work it does, the work where it
- 49:50just clearly articulates the problems of factory
- 49:56farm and the reasons to protect animals and protect
- 49:59farm animals. I never shared that before with
- 50:04my listeners, but Mercy for Animals was the first
- 50:07animal rights organization I donated to. monthly
- 50:11donor, I would receive like that paper magazine.
- 50:14I don't know if it's still a thing. It does not.
- 50:18No, no, sadly. I mean, during my time it was
- 50:21when, you know, digital became all the, you know,
- 50:23we just, people didn't even want paper at the
- 50:26door. They don't like mail. So it was abandoned.
- 50:29Yes. But we had at one point a vision of having
- 50:31it in like Whole Foods, but people don't read
- 50:33magazines anymore. You know, it's sad. I would
- 50:35argue against that. I mean, I think people do
- 50:39read magazines. Like they, they, take some place
- 50:41at home, you know, and people pick them up. And
- 50:45I also remember when Mercy for Animals changed
- 50:47its logo. I was really mad about that. I loved
- 50:51the old logo. Oh, you were one of those. Uh,
- 50:54yeah, that was not fun. That was actually right
- 50:56when I started, they had already made the decision.
- 50:59I remember having to be the person who had I
- 51:02hadn't made the decision but I was the person
- 51:04who had to be like this is what we're doing and
- 51:06oh my gosh people felt very strongly about it
- 51:09but I do I did love the logo because you know
- 51:13it was something I could see at the UN like I
- 51:15had this vision of we started working in the
- 51:18United Nations we we we received our status at
- 51:22the UN And I said, this is a logo that that looks
- 51:26like it could be at the U .N. And that's what
- 51:28I envisioned. They had a target. It was a target
- 51:30for like change. It was also like the lens of
- 51:32an eye, a lens of a camera, but the eye of an
- 51:35animal. It was the world with two hands around
- 51:38it. So I think I know people people felt strongly
- 51:41about no longer having the animals in it, but
- 51:44they got over it. I mean, I now barely remember
- 51:50the old logo. With time, I think we forget those
- 51:55things. We don't even understand why we were
- 51:58mad at them. I need to ask about the cage free
- 52:03hands campaigns. Did you read the white paper
- 52:09published by PETA and what did you think about
- 52:13it, about their conclusions on cage free campaigns?
- 52:18I didn't read the paper, but I do know generally
- 52:20what their view is. I think my general answer
- 52:27to this is imagine you're a prisoner in death
- 52:33row and you're in a horrific, horrific prison.
- 52:39Would you want someone just fighting for the
- 52:41end of your death sentence or also improving
- 52:44the conditions of your prison while the longer
- 52:48work of getting rid of your dust substance is
- 52:52worked on. I think you want both, and I think
- 52:54that's what the animals want. I always try to...
- 52:56What do we do about the animals that are stuck
- 52:58in factory farms today? If you had right in front
- 53:04of you a choice of like, hey, you're standing
- 53:07in front of a factory farm, you're allowed to
- 53:10open the door right now, you can open the door
- 53:14for that cage. And yes, they'll still be in this
- 53:17warehouse, but at least they can move around.
- 53:19Would you just step away? Would you walk away
- 53:22from that? It's it's unethical to walk away in
- 53:27my mind the work of turning the world's vegan
- 53:31and there is absolutely no evidence that People
- 53:36when they eat K tree eggs feel better about that
- 53:40and then ignore it's quite the opposite people
- 53:42Begin to engage in the fact that animals are
- 53:45sentient that they have emotions that they're
- 53:48conscious and so it's quite the opposite And
- 53:52so I don't think it is a harmful act. I actually
- 53:56think it is not only helpful, but it's unethical
- 53:58to walk away from helping animals reduce their
- 54:03suffering today. And again, stance and strategy
- 54:06are different. My stance is it's unethical to
- 54:09eat animal. That is not my strategy to just scream
- 54:11that and just stand in that position until everyone's
- 54:15with me. You now have chosen Compassion in World
- 54:21Farming. You're a global ambassador and thank
- 54:24you for them. Why did you choose Compassion in
- 54:27World Farming? Yeah, it's a great question. Well,
- 54:30first of all, it's the place I got my first job.
- 54:34When I first left my master's degree in England,
- 54:38that was the place that I found my career, my
- 54:43life's path. So it's always had a very special
- 54:46place in my heart, um, in terms of it's an organization
- 54:50that's about to celebrate its 60th anniversary
- 54:52next year. And it's, it's the oldest organization
- 54:57that's been solely fighting against factory farming.
- 55:00That's impressive. And it has a kind of element
- 55:04to it, to me, that stands the test of time. And
- 55:09so I feel the strategy is one, which is it's
- 55:13pragmatic. It's incremental. It's one that aligns
- 55:16with my thinking. It gives also Philip Limbrey,
- 55:20who is the current global CEO, it's been a mentor
- 55:23to me since those early days in my first job.
- 55:26And he gives me space to do, to think, to have
- 55:31autonomy, to develop projects. So I have a lot
- 55:34of creative space right now to explore what I
- 55:40think will work, which I think we need right
- 55:41now in this world. With AI coming and so many
- 55:45changes happening, we have to be incremental.
- 55:48We have to be creative. We have to be iterative.
- 55:52We have to learn and be open to new ideas. And
- 55:55I have that ability in this position. And it's
- 55:58really a joy. And I love the compassion team.
- 56:03I love that they've stood against factory farming
- 56:06for 60 years. That means a lot to me. Yes, I
- 56:13agree so much with that. I always tell, you know,
- 56:17colleagues, people I work with, innovation, creativity,
- 56:22all of that is not a luxury. It's not a plus.
- 56:25Like in our world, it's a necessity. Like we
- 56:28need to think of it and make it a priority in
- 56:33what we do. And so it feels good to hear you
- 56:37say that. I think, you know, like protocols,
- 56:43traditions, all of that. it has its value, but
- 56:47the world is changing so fast and we need more
- 56:52flexibility. We don't have enough flexibility.
- 56:55Like organizationally speaking, I think, I wish,
- 57:00you know, funders would agree more with that
- 57:03too, you know, but what can you do? Yeah. I mean,
- 57:08you just, I think you have to experiment a lot.
- 57:12I mean, in terms of fighting a major social justice
- 57:17problem. We're only about a hundred years into
- 57:19this project of ending factory farming. We're
- 57:22at the beginning. I hate to say that, but we
- 57:24are kind of in the first third, let's say, of
- 57:27the work. We won't see it through in our lifetime.
- 57:30And so who knows what's going to work? So we
- 57:33should try everything and we should be excited
- 57:35to experiment. We need more experimenters. We
- 57:39need more pivoting. We need more creativity.
- 57:41What we've tried up until now will not get us
- 57:44to the next place. We just have to keep learning
- 57:47and being open to all the possibilities because
- 57:52factory farming is a massive problem and It's
- 57:54going to require a lot of different approaches
- 57:57and we don't even know what will work yet Do
- 58:01you still have hope that the future is vegan
- 58:05that factory farming will come to an end? Or
- 58:09and do you think that will happen soon? I try
- 58:13not to answer that question anymore. I really
- 58:16don't because it is very, I mean, there are so
- 58:20many parts of our world that I never would have
- 58:22thought of like AI. Or, I mean, even stupid things
- 58:26like using Google Maps and the smartphone, you
- 58:29know, these are not things that have been around
- 58:32very long. We haven't even had the internet that
- 58:34long. And look at how much changed so fast. We
- 58:36never know when the next breakthrough, the next
- 58:39invention is just going to change everything
- 58:40or the next... crisis is going to change everything.
- 58:43So I think I don't waste much time thinking when,
- 58:47how exactly. I just know I have to put one foot
- 58:49in front of the other and keep fighting and keep
- 58:52trying. And you just never know. You never know
- 58:56when your step, that next step is going to be
- 58:59the step that's a breakthrough. Amazing. I think
- 59:07that's it for me. Did you want to add something
- 59:10before we stop the recording? No, I love talking
- 59:13to you. You're so thoughtful. It was really a
- 59:16pleasure to get the chance to talk. Of course,
- 59:21me too. It was a pleasure. I have such a renewed
- 59:24respect for you after this conversation. Thank
- 59:27you so much for your activism and thank you so
- 59:30much for having taken the time to answer my questions.
- 59:33Of course. Yeah. Thank you for having me. Thank
- 59:36you everyone for listening. I kindly invite you
- 59:39to share this podcast with the vegans you know.
- 59:42let's encourage more people to take action. Again,
- 59:47thank you so much for caring and I will see you
- 59:49next Tuesday for a new episode.