Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / The Cost of Good Intentions in Team Management
Transcript
- Lucas: There is a very common instinct among good managers, especially new ones, to act as a shock absorber for their team. You want to protect them from the noise, the rumors, the political maneuvering happening above your head. It feels like a service to filter out the static so they can just do their work. Luna: Right, but I have seen that backfire spectacularly when the filter becomes a wall. The team starts trusting the shield more than the source, which means when the shield inevitably cracks, the betrayal feels personal. Lucas: Exactly. And it creates what I call managerial cushioning. It is a soft layer between reality and your direct reports. I spoke with a regional operations director last week who admitted he stopped sharing quarterly targets because they were being rewritten every month by headquarters. He thought he was saving his team anxiety, but he was actually starving them of context. Luna: So they were working blind, making decisions based on outdated assumptions because their manager decided those assumptions were too stressful to share. Lucas: Precisely. He was operating under the belief that stress comes from information overload. But in reality, stress often comes from ambiguity. When people do not know what the goalposts are moving, they spend more mental energy guessing than executing. The cushion doesn't reduce stress; it just shifts it from manageable uncertainty to paralyzing confusion. Luna: It turns out that withholding information is actually a power move disguised as kindness. You are keeping control of the narrative rather than inviting the team into the problem-solving process. Lucas: That is a sharp way to put it. And it is rarely intentional. Most managers are not trying to hoard power; they are just trying to be nice. But the outcome is the same. The team becomes dependent on the manager for emotional regulation rather than professional direction. They stop asking questions because they assume the manager will handle the messy parts. Luna: And when the manager leaves or gets promoted, that dependency collapses. You realize you haven't built a team; you've built a support group that requires constant maintenance. Lucas: I see this particularly clearly in tech companies right now. We are in September twenty twenty-six, and many organizations are still navigating the aftermath of recent layoffs and restructuring waves. Managers are terrified of causing panic, so they go silent. But silence is interpreted as confirmation of the worst-case scenario. Luna: Because humans fill voids with narratives, and our default narrative is usually catastrophic when we feel insecure about our jobs. Lucas: Correct. So the manager's attempt to preserve calm actually destroys it. I worked with a product lead who was managing a critical launch during a period of corporate merger talks. She refused to mention the merger because she didn't want to distract her engineers. Two weeks later, the merger details leaked through a third-party blog. Her team felt blindsided and angry, not because of the news, but because they felt infantilized. Luna: They felt like children who weren't allowed to know the real reason why the family was moving houses. That erodes trust faster than any bad news could. Lucas: It does. And the repair cost is enormous. Once you break that trust, you lose the ability to lead through ambiguity. The team stops looking to you for guidance and starts looking at Slack channels or LinkedIn for clues. You have ceded authority to the rumor mill. Luna: So the question becomes, how much should you share? There has to be a line between transparency and oversharing. What is that line? Lucas: The line is relevance. Share everything that affects their work, their role, or their understanding of the market. Do not share executive gossip, financial projections that are speculative, or personnel matters unrelated to your team. But if a strategy is shifting, tell them. If the timeline is changing, tell them. Give them the raw material so they can build their own conclusions. Luna: Give them the data, not just the conclusion. Let them wrestle with the implications alongside you. Lucas: Yes. And this requires a shift in mindset from protection to partnership. Protection says, 'I will keep the wolves away.' Partnership says, 'Here are the wolves; let's figure out how to fence the yard together.' The latter builds resilience. The former builds fragility. Luna: Resilience is built through exposure to controlled stress. If you never let your team experience a difficult conversation, they will never develop the muscles to handle one. Lucas: That is a crucial distinction. We often confuse comfort with well-being. Comfort is temporary and passive. Well-being is sustainable and active. A team that understands the full picture, even when it is grim, can adapt. A team that is kept in the dark panics when things go wrong because they lack the historical context to understand why. Luna: It also respects their intelligence. Assuming they cannot handle the truth is a form of condescension. It signals that you do not believe they are capable professionals. Lucas: Exactly. And high performers, in particular, resent that. They signed up to solve hard problems, not to be managed like interns. When you withhold information, you are essentially telling them that their contribution is only valuable if it is uninformed. Luna: Which is ironic, because informed decisions are always better than uninformed ones, regardless of how unpleasant the facts are. Lucas: So, practically speaking, how do you start breaking this habit? If you are a manager who has been cushioning your team, how do you pivot to transparency without causing immediate chaos? Luna: Start small. Admit you have been holding back. Say, 'I realized I haven't been sharing the context around X decision, and that wasn't fair to you. Here is what is actually happening.' Ownership disarms defensiveness. Lucas: That vulnerability is powerful. It shows strength, not weakness. It demonstrates that you value the relationship over the illusion of control. And it sets a precedent that you will be honest going forward. Luna: It also gives the team permission to be honest with you. If you model transparency, they will feel safe bringing you bad news instead of hiding it. Lucas: Which is the ultimate goal. You want early warning systems, not late-stage surprises. Cushioning delays the pain, but it also delays the cure. Transparency allows for earlier intervention. Luna: And it makes the inevitable hard conversations less shocking. If you have been talking about challenges regularly, a major crisis is just an escalation of something already on the table. Lucas: Right. It normalizes difficulty. In healthy organizations, difficulty is not a signal that something is broken; it is just part of the work. By removing all difficulty from the manager's communication, you inadvertently frame every challenge as a catastrophe. Luna: So the manager becomes the sole bearer of doom, rather than a partner in navigation. That is an unsustainable burden for anyone to carry. Lucas: It leads to burnout on both sides. The manager exhausts themselves filtering noise, and the team exhausts itself guessing meanings. Breaking the cushion releases pressure for everyone. Luna: It shifts the dynamic from parent-child to adult-adult. Which is where productive work actually happens. Lucas: Before we wrap up, I want to acknowledge that this podcast exists entirely because listeners like you choose to support it directly. We do not run ads, and there are no corporate sponsors dictating our topics or our tone. Instead, a dedicated group of listeners funds our operations monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That direct support is what allows us to dig deep into these nuanced management issues without compromise. Luna: It really does make a difference. Knowing that our audience values independent, ad-free content helps us keep the focus on quality and depth rather than clicks. Lucas: So, if you find this kind of analysis useful for your own leadership journey, consider joining that community. It keeps the lights on and ensures we can continue bringing you clear, unfiltered perspectives on business and careers. Luna: We appreciate every bit of support, and it genuinely sustains the independence of the show. Lucas: Back to the topic at hand. The final piece of advice here is consistency. One honest conversation is a gesture. A pattern of honest communication is a culture. You have to keep showing up with the truth, even when it is inconvenient, even when you do not have all the answers. Luna: Especially then. Saying 'I do not know yet, but I will update you by Friday' is infinitely better than saying nothing until Monday. Lucas: Exactly. It manages expectations and maintains trust. The cushion is seductive, but it is a trap. Real leadership is about standing in the storm with your team, not hiding them in the basement while you pretend the weather is fine. Luna: And when the storm passes, you get to walk out together, stronger and more aligned than before. Lucas: That is the goal. So, take a look at your own team this week. Where are you holding back? What information are you assuming they cannot handle? And ask yourself if you are protecting them, or just protecting yourself from the discomfort of transparency. Luna: A good question to sit with on a Monday morning. Because the answer might just change how you lead for the rest of the year.