Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / Why Warsh's Fed Is Forcing a Debt Rethink
Transcript
- Lucas: So, the Fed under Kevin Warsh is talking about raising rates again, and the bond market is basically saying — go ahead, we dare you. Luna: That's a bold way to frame it. What's the actual tension right now? Lucas: Well, look at the data from this week. The 30-year Treasury yield is at 5.19 percent, the 10-year at 4.67, and the federal debt to gdp ratio has climbed to 122.6 percent. But the Fed funds rate is still stuck at 3.63 percent. That's a huge gap between what the Fed controls and what the market charges the government to borrow. Luna: So the market is already pricing in a higher cost of money than the Fed is delivering. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the crux of this episode. Warsh has been signaling a more hawkish stance — he called for a 'quieter' central bank, less forward guidance, more data dependence. But his own colleagues are split. Hammack from Cleveland said 'now is the time to act' on rates. Meanwhile, the core PCE reading for July came in at 3.3 percent annually — still well above the 2 percent target. Luna: So if the Fed raises rates, does that actually make the debt problem worse? Because the Treasury has to refinance at those higher yields. Lucas: That's the paradox. The Fed hikes to fight inflation, but every basis point of increase raises the government's interest expense. We're already seeing it in the auction calendar — the Treasury is issuing more short-term bills to keep average maturities shorter, but that just means more refinancing risk down the road. Luna: And the yield curve is flattening. The 10-year minus 2-year spread is down to 39 basis points from 47 a week ago. That's a signal that the market thinks the Fed might actually be behind the curve. Lucas: Right. And when the curve flattens like that, it often precedes a slowdown. But here's the thing — the economy is still adding jobs, consumer spending is holding up, and the Atlanta Fed's GDPNow is still pointing to solid growth. So you've got this weird mix: strong real economy, but a bond market that's demanding a higher term premium because of the debt trajectory. Luna: So the market isn't just worried about inflation — it's worried about the sheer volume of Treasury supply. Lucas: Exactly. The federal deficit for fiscal year 2025 came in at $1.77 trillion — slightly better than the prior year's $1.82 trillion, but still enormous. And the debt total has climbed to $39 trillion. That's up about $550 billion in a single quarter. The Treasury has to sell a lot of paper to fund that, and the buyers are starting to demand a premium for the risk of holding long-dated debt. Luna: But wait — if the Fed is hawkish and rates go up, wouldn't that actually strengthen the dollar and maybe attract foreign buyers? Doesn't that help the Treasury? Lucas: In theory, yes. A stronger dollar can make U.S. assets more attractive. But the flip side is that the interest expense on the national debt eats up more of the federal budget. We're already seeing interest costs surpass defense spending on an annualized basis. And if Warsh raises rates another 25 or 50 basis points, that number goes even higher. Luna: So the Fed is stuck between fighting inflation and managing the fiscal burden. Lucas: That's the real dilemma. And Warsh's 'quieter' approach might actually make it worse. When the Fed communicates less, the market has to guess more. That adds volatility and can push term premiums higher. We saw a little of that this week — the 30-year yield ticked up from 5.18 to 5.19 after Hammack's hawkish comments. Luna: But isn't there an argument that the Fed needs to be less predictable to avoid fueling speculative bubbles? Lucas: Sure, that's the classic Warsh view. But right now, the debt market is the elephant in the room. When the Fed is vague, the market fills the vacuum with its own assumptions. And those assumptions tend to be more pessimistic when debt levels are this high. Luna: So what does this mean for the average listener? Why should they care about the term premium or the yield curve? Lucas: Because it feeds into mortgage rates, business borrowing costs, and even the interest you earn on savings. But more structurally, it's a constraint on fiscal policy. If the Treasury has to pay 5 percent on 30-year bonds, every dollar of new spending becomes more expensive. That limits what the government can do in the next recession. Luna: And we're already at 122.6 percent debt to gdp. There's not a lot of room. Lucas: Exactly. So the question is whether Warsh's Fed will actually follow through with a hike. Right now, Fed funds futures are pricing in about a 40 percent chance of a hike by December. But the bond market is already acting like it's happened. Luna: That's a disconnect. The Fed says one thing, the market does another. Lucas: And that disconnect has real consequences. If the Fed hikes, the short end of the curve goes up, but the long end might not follow if the market thinks the hike will kill growth. That would actually steepen the curve and make the debt burden even more painful. Luna: The bond market is essentially saying, 'We don't trust that the Fed can manage this without breaking something.' Lucas: Right. And you see that in the VIX, which is still elevated. But look, this is also a moment where listener support really matters. This show stays ad-free because a small group of listeners chips in monthly through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's not a big ask — it just helps us keep making these deep dives every day. Luna: And we're not selling anything or pushing a paywall. It's just a way to keep the podcast independent. Lucas: Exactly. So if you've gotten something out of these episodes, that's where you can support us — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, genuinely. Now, back to the debt picture — one thing I want to drill into is the Treasury's cash balance. Luna: Because that's been kind of a buffer, right? Lucas: Yes. The Treasury General Account has been drawn down this year, which helped smooth out the borrowing need. But that buffer is getting thinner. In July, we saw the deficit surge partly because of timing issues around tax receipts. And now, with the cash balance lower, the Treasury has to issue more to the public, which adds to the supply pressure we've been talking about. Luna: So the cash balance was masking the true level of borrowing demand. Lucas: Exactly. And now that it's lower, the market is seeing the real supply. That's a big reason why the 30-year yield is at 5.19 percent — not just inflation expectations, but pure supply and demand. Luna: So if Warsh does hike rates, we could see the 30-year push even higher. Is that your base case? Lucas: I think the path of least resistance is for long yields to stay elevated, possibly drift higher. But the bigger risk is if the Fed hikes and the economy slows faster than expected. Then you'd have a situation where the debt burden becomes even harder to manage, and the Fed would have to reverse course quickly — which would undermine its credibility. Luna: That's the nightmare scenario: high inflation, high debt, and a Fed that's forced to capitulate. Lucas: Right. And that's why the market is so nervous. It's not just about the absolute level of debt — it's about the policy mix. The Fed is trying to be tough, but the fiscal side is running a $1.7 trillion deficit. Those two things don't add up without consequences. Luna: So what should listeners watch for in the next few weeks? Lucas: Two things. First, the September FOMC meeting — watch the statement and the dots. If they signal a hike, expect the 30-year to test 5.3 or 5.4. Second, watch the Treasury's quarterly refunding announcement — they'll tell us how much longer-dated supply they're planning. If they increase the 30-year auction size, that's a clear signal that they're willing to lock in these higher rates. Luna: And if they don't, they're just kicking the can down the road. Lucas: Exactly. At some point, the Treasury has to extend maturities to avoid a rollover crisis. But doing that at 5 percent is a huge fiscal bet. We'll see if they have the stomach for it. Luna: It's a fascinating time to be watching this. Lucas: It is. And it's a reminder that the debt story isn't just about numbers on a chart — it's about the difficult choices that policymakers are going to have to make. Thanks for hanging with us today.