Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Guest Host Todd Caputo, Consumers Feel New Prices, The Rise of All-Terrain
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It is Monday, December 1st. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul J. Daly. We have a special guest today. It's been too long since he's been on the show.
- 0:08Todd Caputo coast- co-hosting, gonna tell us how to get back to basics, how to ha- make successful sales through the holiday season- [singing]...
- 0:15how to not get burnt out as a dealer operator, and everything else you ever wanted to know, Todd is ready to go. Todd, good morning. [singing] Oh, no. Can- I can't hear you. Oh, my gosh, he can't hear me. I'm back in.
- 0:27He didn't hear all the good things I just said about him. Um, let's see. If it's not something on my end, I don't think. Nathan, are you hearing me? Yeah. Chime in, Nathan. I'm hear- I'm hearing Paul fine.
- 0:39I'm hearing Todd fine. So let's, let's play a game. It's called what do you think the actual problem is? [laughs] He's gonna call you right now. Hold on. Yeah, he's, he's texting me. [laughs] All right. Okay.
- 0:50Well, while- Uh, do you mind if I rejoin real quick? What was that? Yeah, please. Okay. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, all right, so while Nathan's doing that, uh, well, I hope you had an amazing Thanksgiving season.
- 0:58We've just been here getting back into the office, checking back in with everybody, and everyone's saying kind of the same thing. They had a great Thanksgiving. The...
- 1:06We at More Than Cars, we were off on Friday to give everybody a little bit of an extended break. And people coming back into the office, you know, a little bit ready to go for December.
- 1:14Now, granted, me and the family came in over the weekend. We set up the Christmas tree here in the office. I wish I could set up a Christmas tree.
- 1:22It would be creepy, but, uh, you know, a big portion of our team is remote as well.
- 1:25So we have, uh, you know, probably close to 20 people coming into the office every day, and then we have, like, another 10 who are remote, and I couldn't... It'd be creepy if I set up a Christmas tree in their house.
- 1:35I'll let them get down to that. Um, but- Yeah... a few things going on today. Um, oh, Todd, we still can't hear us. Okay, Paul. Still in a... I don't know what's going on. Can't hear you. Can't hear me.
- 1:46I don't know, Nathan. Are we l- we're live streaming, right? We're live streaming. Yeah, we're live. This is- Here, why don't you let me run with the show? Okay. And, uh, maybe you can give Todd a call.
- 1:55And when- Yeah, I can try that... when you chime in- Sure... you can, you can jump into the show yourself, too. Whatever, whatever it takes. Okay, there we go. Okay, there we go. He re- he's, he's rejoined.
- 2:03We're gonna have Todd, Todd rejoin. Uh, we have a few things going on. Uh, tomorrow, December 2nd, we are gonna be on the ground at Merge 2026.
- 2:11This is an event that a lot of people probably haven't heard of, put on by the Alliance for Automotive Innovation. And this is going to be at the press... Oh, what's it called? The press room?
- 2:22No, it's not the press room. I'll remember- The National Press Club. The National Press Club. And it's right across-- like, pretty much right across the street from the White House.
- 2:31So, um, we're going to have a number of speakers, OEMs from all across, uh- I can't hear him again... all across the number, all across, all across the... I mean, probably from across the world.
- 2:41And we're gonna have some, uh, members of Congress. We're gonna have some senators. We're gonna have some Congress people. And we are gonna be going live to podcast, uh, there at the event. So you know how it goes.
- 2:51We'll be pulling people aside, having some in-depth conversations after they get off the main stage.
- 2:56Uh, much thanks to our friends at of Alliance for Automotive Innovation for inviting us, and John Bazalo, who is, um, pretty frequently on the show and on the content. And he's always fun to have.
- 3:07Uh, what else is going on? Oh, we have an upcoming SO2 Edge webinar on Wednesday, December 10th. This is, uh, one that you wanna pay attention to.
- 3:14We're gonna be talking about Lithia's blueprint, basically evaluing- evaluating and transitioning to varia- variable cost service transportation with our friends at Uber for Business.
- 3:25Um, we're gonna be talking with, uh, category manager of procurement, John Church, for Lithia.
- 3:31So, um, one of the things I love about this industry so much is that people are willing to share what they're doing because they know that a better experience makes the entire industry better.
- 3:42So we even have people like the head of procurement in the category for Lithia sharing why Uber for Business is actually helping them out.
- 3:50And one of the things we're gonna talk about on this is how to measure when it's time to look at maybe some other transportation options aside from the shuttles and the, the way we've been doing it.
- 4:01Because why would we do it the way we've always done it? We all know the market's changing. We all know people want something different. And,
- 4:08you know, scrambling to see what's new, or at least maybe not scrambling, but maybe just being committed and dedicated to seeing what's new next, is something that helps us get going.
- 4:18Um, we're gonna see if we can get Todd in here again. I mean, I could get into the first story. But you know what? I think I'm gonna get into the first story.
- 4:28And when Todd joins, we're gonna just, uh, we're just gonna get back into it. That's what we do. So check, this is The Wall Street Journal this morning.
- 4:34I think when we talk about Wall Street Journal articles, it's very important that this isn't something that we're talking about in a dealer-focused news, um, news outlet.
- 4:43This is The Wall Street Journal, so that means it has much more broader appeal, and it kind of talks to broader topics and broader sentiment, not in a bubble.
- 4:50And basically, what they're saying is American car buyers are finally tapping the brakes after years of paying whatever it took to get into a new car.
- 4:58Stretched consumers are hitting affordability ceilings and forcing both dealers and OEMs to rethink what demand really looks like heading into 2020, uh, 6.
- 5:08So shoppers are shifting down market, basically, is what they see happening.
- 5:11Buying used cars, taking longer loans, we know this already from the F&I desk, delaying purchases, that's the important part here, and gravitating toward lower price models like the Chevy Trax.
- 5:22Industry projections for '25 and '26 are softening as tariffs, inflation, and tighter labor markets cool big-ticket spending.
- 5:30Also, we're looking at a rising day supply prompting deeper discounting, while lower income borrowers are falling behind on payments, sometimes to historical levels.
- 5:39Some reports I've been seeing in overall vehicle spending dropping year over year is the prediction. Retailers reporting weaker new vehicle margins through service traffic.
- 5:48Uh, though service traffic is climbing as more owners are trying to stretch those aging vehicles. One dealer, Robert, uh, Plater, says, "People are asking, how can I afford this?
- 5:59There are people who are in debtLiving paycheck to paycheck. This is just a continuation of the things we've been seeing, the things that even our friend J- Jonathan Smoke called, called this bifurcated market.
- 6:11There are people that are doing fine. They're buying the full trims. They're buying the high-level stuff, and then there are folks that are just really struggling to figure out how they're gonna afford the new vehicle.
- 6:22You know, we see a lot of service departments pivoting and moving in this season to say, "All right.
- 6:27If people are keeping their vehicles longer," this s- this really should call us to an increased level of communication in our service departments and understanding when it is to pull that trigger, right?
- 6:38Because obviously, we don't wanna talk about keeping your car longer if we're trying to sell more cars.
- 6:43But at the same time, if someone cannot buy a new car, what we really wanna do is make sure that they can keep their car being serviced with us. Todd, are you hearing me? Yeah. Yeah, Todd. We got Taco Pudding back there.
- 6:56What the heck? I don't know. It's technology. It's December 1st. What are we supposed to do? [laughs] Good morning. Um, thank you so much for joining us. Good morning. You know what?
- 7:03Look, look, if that's the hardest part of the day, we're doing a great job already. Absolutely. So, um, Todd, you've been running around all over the place.
- 7:09I was just talking about this Wall Street Journal story where, um, affordability is just continuing to become an, be an issue. Uh, people are starting to fault on some payments on vehicles.
- 7:22They're prolonging purchase decisions. They're increasing the terms on their loans.
- 7:27You, um, when you ran your dealerships, you were an expert on trying to find the right car for the right person across all buying levels.
- 7:35Your, your used car business, your standalone used car business, just you stocked vehicles of all ranges, and it always... You got the shirt on today, Used Car King, which is, I love it, bringing, bringing me right back.
- 7:45Yeah. Yeah, all day. So how, how, how are you approaching the situation in this market, in this time when people are dealing- Well-... with these struggles?
- 7:52I can tell you what I'm seeing now, 'cause, I mean, obviously doing consulting, I'm still in dealerships quite a bit. Um, I mean, look it, when I was in business, times were... It was, it was different, right?
- 8:02It was 2020, 2019, '18, and things were just less expensive. Cars were not as expensive. Cost of living was not ex- as expensive. So here's what I think's gonna happen.
- 8:12Number one, um, I think you're gonna see leasing come back. It's got to. Um, I think you're gonna see the manufacturers probably get very aggressive with leasing, as they should, and it won't just be with EVs.
- 8:23Um, people can't afford... The average price of a used car is, like, 31, 32 grand right now- Mm-hmm... retail. The average price of a, of, of a new car is pushing, like, 50 grand. Oh, went over 50 grand this morning.
- 8:36Yeah, so I mean, come on. I mean, you, you know, the sweet spot for us when I was in business was $300 a month or less, right? Like, that was the sweet spot.
- 8:44That's what people can afford, and you don't see payments like that anymore. Nope. And if you're gonna buy a $300 a month used car, you're buying a 17, $18,000 used car, which doesn't get you much. No, it doesn't.
- 8:54It just doesn't. So, well, as, as a dealer, what do you gotta be able to do?
- 8:58Um, recondition, put together older trade-ins, be able to acquire older cars, um, off the street from your database, uh, from, from just consumers in your service drive, maybe cars that they own, um, that are not in the dealership that you're, you know, you're getting from a garage expansion through software.
- 9:17Like, there's a lot of ways to do it, but you gotta be able to have those cars to sell to people because, um, that's what people can afford. I mean, especially when it comes to a used car.
- 9:26When it comes to new cars, you're gonna have to be able to lease them because they're just, they're just too expensive, and um, the manufacturers are gonna need to figure something out.
- 9:34They're gonna need to find a way to cut costs or sell lesser expensive vehicles. You're probably gonna see all... Remember how sedans all of a sudden disappeared?
- 9:42All of a sudden they all got rid of these expensive sedans. Yeah. Yeah, we don't, no one wants a sedan anymore. People don't want them anymore. Right. They got rid of wagons. That's all, that- They got rid of sedans...
- 9:49I'm seeing those advertised so much, like, over the holidays, a lot of Honda Accords commercials. Yeah.
- 9:53Actually is what I saw during the football games where it's like, back to that, that price point that you were talking about. They're, they're... It's, like, 4,000 down and, like, 259 a month, right? Yeah.
- 10:04Back to a sedan. Well, who's, who's got four grand down this time of year? Yeah. It's Christmas. It's, that's- Right? Am I, am I buying Christmas presents, um, or, and, or am I going to, um, you know, get a car? Yeah.
- 10:15Am I... I will buy a car if my car is dead, and if my car's not dead, I'm probably gonna wait, right? This, especially this time of year, I will tell you- The hardest time...
- 10:24you're gonna get a lot of people that are just starting to look, um, and they're already thinking about what they're gonna get back for their tax return.
- 10:31And I sat in on a webinar from Jonathan, Jonathan Smoke about three weeks ago, and I've been reading about this.
- 10:37They are predicting that there's gonna be a lot of money out there in tax returns in the spring, and I've been telling everybody right now, the used car market has been dipping. Mm-hmm.
- 10:46And I'd be buying used cars right now if it was me because I think used cars are gonna be hot in the spring, and I think it's gonna be a really hot used car market because you're gonna see some serious tax return money coming back.
- 10:56In long-term follow-up, if you're a dealer right now, and I'm telling all my clients this, if I was still in business, I'd be very focused on long-term follow-up 'cause you're gonna get a lot of leads, a lot of people shopping now.
- 11:06Up unt- for the next 60 days or so, you're gonna get tax return people. "I'm waiting on my tax return." Well, we all know that a lot of dealers are not great at follow-up, especially long term.
- 11:16I would be very, very, very focused on that- Yeah, I-... because you will have down payments. So you'd be beefing up used car inventory now knowing- Oh, yeah... knowing that- Yeah...
- 11:24it's gonna be a bigger than it's been tax return year, right? Mm-hmm. Obviously, during COVID we had all this free money kind of walking around. It's been a little slim, but now there are...
- 11:33You're, you're like, "It's gonna be good. There's gonna be bigger checks this year." There will be bigger checks this year. I think interest rates are probably gonna come down as well, which will help.
- 11:41I think you're gonna see a lot of incentives from the manufacturers. They're gonna have to if they wanna move some inventory, which they're gonna need to do.
- 11:47Uh, I think leasing's gonna come back, uh, but I'm gonna tell you right now, you've got to learn how to follow up properly if you're a dealer, especially longer term, and also prospecting, mining your database, really working the service drive hard and being extremely disciplined, and be able to recondition older, higher mileage-Pre-owned cars, like, for sure But, yeah- The, the, the old, the, the old 60-day rule, we gotta get rid of a car in 60 days.
- 12:15I'd be holding it. Like, I would not just go cashing cars unless you really, really have to. So, I, that, it's, that is a huge indicator that times are changing because, you know, people were dying on that 60-day hill.
- 12:28But now you're saying look a little bit further over the horizon, especially heading into tax season, knowing that you might be holding onto some gold, and understanding which vehicles those are, and making sure they're ready to sell, and you already bought 'em right so you can kinda keep on holding 'em.
- 12:40I have one more question for you. Sure. Um, the talk about consumers staying in a car longer.
- 12:45How do you balance that a dealer communicating, dealership communicating to a customer that if, from a service lane angle, saying, "Hey, like, you wanna keep that car longer, great.
- 12:57We can help you make sure it's, it's riding great and it's in safe shape," and, like, how do you balance that communication from a service drive when you're also trying to sell them a new car?
- 13:05Well, I think at the end of the day, you just have to be transparent with people and see what they can afford, right?
- 13:12Um, you know, somebody comes in and they gotta spend two grand to keep their car to pass state inspection, especially in certain states. If there's a check engine light on, it won't pass inspection.
- 13:21If it's gonna cost 1,500 or two grand and the car's got 100,000 miles on it, you know, you know, this is what it's gonna cost you- Mm-hmm... right? These are future potential costs. We have all kinds of data right now.
- 13:31Mm. Right? We know that certain cars have certain things that fail. Certain year, make, model, trims, they, they fail for a variety of reasons.
- 13:40We can show that to a consumer and say, "All right, you can spend two grand now, but these are some of the common things in your car that could potentially fail in the next six months, year, two years."
- 13:51AI can easily do that, like, right now. You could do it in the, in the, in the drive with, with any AI. Mm-hmm. Um, show 'em that- Yeah...
- 13:57versus, okay, you can go into a, a newer, either a brand-new or later model, lower mile used car or even a 50- or 60- or 70,000 mile used car that has relatively current technology, that's safer, that has less of a fail rate.
- 14:11And then let them choose at the end of the day. Or be able to, if they wanna fix it, make sure you're really good at selling 'em, you know, a payment plan. There's a lot of companies out there that offer, you know,
- 14:23uh, y- Sure, the financing... so, so two grand- Yeah... you can pay by the, you know, pay over time. Right.
- 14:28Much, a much more feasible way to maybe keep your car longer is if you can pay it off over the next 6 to 12 months.
- 14:34And then that communication, as it grows and as the trust builds, right, like, you just make sure you're there when they need a new one. And you communicate them so when the time is right- Yeah... you're there for 'em.
- 14:43And it goes back to, like, look at it. If you're a technician, you really should do a good inspection of a car- Mm-hmm... a really good multi-point.
- 14:51You really should be using video, all the tools that we have that all the dealers pay a lot of money for. Mm-hmm. Photos, you know, uh, videos, communication with the customer back and forth. Mm-hmm.
- 15:01Um, being able to show them exactly what the car needs. And, you know, if you're a writer, same thing, right?
- 15:07Like, be able to communicate with the customer, build that trust and show them, you know, this is what your car needs.
- 15:12But on, on the flip side, right, have someone dedicated to the service drive or multiple drives if you've got a large store, um, where you can be making people offers on their cars. Got it.
- 15:23And that's, that to me, is really, really important because the auction game is still very, very competitive and will stay that way because used cars are just gonna be short for a long time. Yeah.
- 15:32S- since we get another year and a half of, of, of a shortage of used cars, if not longer. Man, that's, that's great insight first thing on a Monday morning, December 1st.
- 15:40We got one more story that I thought would be very, uh, very appropriate because of kind of how you're wired and the things you get into.
- 15:47Uh, the all-terrain SUV segment heating up as BMW and Audi both preparing to challenge icons like the Jeep Wrangler, um, Bronco, the G-Wagon, and the Defender.
- 15:57Looking to tap into this growing niche that's n- doesn't seem so niche at all. After all, the off-road segment seems to be booming. Nine core models totaled 371,000 sales through Q3 2025.
- 16:10On pace for a record post-pandemic. Wrangler and the Bronco remaining at the top.
- 16:15Audi's gonna be building its few, first true off-roader on the upcoming Scout Terra Traveler platform in South Carolina, offering both full EV and, uh, that E-Rev range-extending option with the generator.
- 16:28BMW has a G74 aimed straight at the G-Wagon. Uh, analysts are saying styling, not specs, are going to make or break the newcomers. Anything close, too close to the G-Wagon, uh, risks a little bit of immediate pushback.
- 16:42Here's a quote from S&P Mobility's Sam Fior- Fiorino, said, "Adding true off-road capability s- to SUVs will attract buyers, but whether that investment pays off is the challenge."
- 16:52You've sold a lot of Jeeps, a lot of Broncos. Um, you have a vari- you have a whole garage full of cars. You're, you're into this stuff. You have a van that's kitted out.
- 17:00What do you think of this emerging off-road trend we're seeing? Not just from the big makes, but, like, even, like, the Kias where you have these X- X Drive, uh, XLine Tellurides and things like that.
- 17:09What are you seeing in this market? I mean, at the end of the day, how many people are really taking these things off the road or just wanna look cool? Uh, very few. I mean, c- Yeah, 10%- I mean, right... or less.
- 17:20If you're driving down the highway or you go to a parking lot and you see a whole bunch of Wranglers, how many Wranglers or Broncos do you see that are all mudded up versus the ones that are clean?
- 17:29And who's driving them? Right. Right? They're going to the grocery store. They're, they're, they're, they're, they're back and forth to work.
- 17:34They look cool, but not very many people are taking those vehicles off the road. Will they sell? Yeah, they'll sell, 'cause people like to look cool. Yeah.
- 17:42If you got the, if you have the money, right, and you can have an off-road looking vehicle and wanna feel young again, like a guy like me who's gonna be [laughs] 54 and- Is that old now?...
- 17:53maybe in a week and a half or two weeks- Oh... right, I'll be 54. So totally, yeah, if you wanna- See, it doesn't seem old to me. That means I'm old. [laughs] Yeah.
- 17:58So if you wanna look cool, that's fine, but not that many people are taking them off-road.
- 18:01But, you know, look at, it's for, for some of the manufacturers that haven't really built those kind of off-road cars anymore- Mm-hmm... I mean, why not?
- 18:09If it's just a matter of adding some accessories onto a car-Doesn't really cost them all that much, and they could probably put quite a, quite a spread in there to make some money with them. Right.
- 18:17Like- People will buy them... no, no one really-- You're saying no one really cares about the off-road specs except for when they're on the sheet.
- 18:22I used to say, and I still say, there are two types of, of people, men who buy pickup trucks: men who are rugged and men who want to feel rugged. You know what I mean? And it's, that's, there's something about it.
- 18:33Like, and yeah, maybe you'll only ever haul three bags of mulch in the back of it, but boy, when you do, you feel, "Oh, let me pull around the pickup." Right? And so- I mean, look,
- 18:41look, pickup trucks come in handy, right? Um, you know, they, they got the- Except when you're trying to park them in a parking garage. Yeah. [laughs] You, you, you're right.
- 18:51Um, but I mean, let's, l- look at the Lexus GX, right? Look at this GX 550. Mm. Um, you still... There, there's a wait list for these. I know.
- 18:59You know, they c- they came out almost two years ago, and there's still a wait list to get a GX 550. If you want a Luxury Plus- Mm-hmm... or a Premium Plus, you're waiting. Yep. Um, there's people on wait lists.
- 19:08They're still getting sticker or better for them. Mm-hmm. I mean, why? No one, you know, they're not getting taken off-road. Um, but they look cool. They look tough. They look tough. They got that cool boxy look. Yeah.
- 19:18But that goes back to affordability, right? Who can afford 60, 70, 80, $90,000?
- 19:24There's a huge swing out there of people that really, you know, have the money, that can afford these kind of vehicles versus those that don't.
- 19:33And there's a lot more out there, in my opinion, where there's a market of the, let's call it the have-nots. And I hate to use that term, but it's the simplest way for me to explain it.
- 19:41It's the haves versus the have-nots. And the have-not market right now is being underserved. And I think you're gonna see the manufacturers come back because they're gonna realize that, um- That's where the volume is...
- 19:54they have to. Yeah. They, they, that's where the volume is, and that's where they have to. And it's not just building cars for rental car companies.
- 19:59They gotta build sedans, small SUVs that people can afford, and they gotta be able to lease them or put them on the street for between $300 and $400 a month with a couple grand down, maybe three grand tops, and that's all people can afford.
- 20:14That's it. If it's gonna be a new car.
- 20:16And if it's gonna be a used cars like we're talking about before, you gotta be able to source them, and you gotta be able to recondition them, and you have to be to, to market them and price them aggressively, like, quickly.
- 20:25Yeah. It's one of the hardest things and biggest challenges. It's easy to, to, to look at the OEMs and say, "You're not making what we need."
- 20:32But the OEM is, typically has to make cars for the today's market or a little bit yesterday's market, right? 'Cause they have to tool up to do it.
- 20:40So when we get in a situation like this, they can only react to it because they can't build cars for next year or two years from now.
- 20:46They have to build cars for today, but typically that means they're a little bit behind building cars for, like, six months and a year ago's market. And then they have to react. I think you're right. They're gonna react.
- 20:56Um, it's gonna be exciting to see leasing come back, and I think everyone's gonna be excited about that 'cause then that cy- Yeah... starts the whole cycle again.
- 21:02Todd, thank you so much for jumping in- Thanks for having me. Appreciate it... the day after Thanksgiving Day weekend. We're gonna have you on a lot. We wanna talk about your NADA session. But for now, back to basics.
- 21:10Pay attention to your numbers, and pay attention to the market. [upbeat music]