Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / The First Amendment and the Late-Night Fallout: Legal Limits on Government Action
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the First Amendment and the late night
- 0:05fallout, Legal Limits on Government Action. Today
- 0:08we will talk about the legal principles offering
- 0:10critical insight for entertainment and media
- 0:12attorneys navigating the evolving intersection
- 0:14of law, politics, and speech in light of the
- 0:17recent events surrounding late night television.
- 0:19My name is John Baldivia. I'm a partner at Rossi
- 0:21Baldivia Klein Fine Inspector, and I will be
- 0:24moderating today's program. I'm going to try
- 0:26my best to avoid any political biases in the
- 0:28discussion, but due to the highly politicized
- 0:29nature of the topic, we'll see how that actually
- 0:31goes. I'm delighted to introduce our speakers.
- 0:35First and foremost, Professor Eugene Volokh is
- 0:37a Thomas M. Siebel Senior Fellow at the Hoover
- 0:40Institution. For 30 years, he was a professor
- 0:42at UCLA School of Law, where he taught first
- 0:47amendment law, copyright law, criminal law, tort
- 0:50law, and firearms regulation policy. He is a
- 0:52member of the American Law Institute and of the
- 0:55American Heritage Dictionary Usage Panel, and
- 0:57the founder and co -author of the Volokh Conspiracy,
- 0:59a leading legal blog. His work has been cited
- 1:02in more than 300 court opinions, including 10
- 1:05Supreme Court cases, as well as over 5 ,000 academic
- 1:08articles. Next, we have Doug Morell, who is a
- 1:10partner at Nolan Hyman LLP. Doug is a powerhouse
- 1:13litigator in the entertainment field and a lawyer
- 1:15who follows his conscience, representing celebrities,
- 1:19entertainment, entertainers, companies, guilds,
- 1:22media concerns, and others in litigation over
- 1:24the course of several decades and counting. His
- 1:27imprint can be found on hundreds of important
- 1:29entertainment -related issues that were resolved
- 1:31in the courts or that required legislative action.
- 1:34Specifically, Doug is a driving force in the
- 1:36First Amendment and entertainment industry lawsuits,
- 1:38anti -SLAP motions, copyright and trademark infringement
- 1:41actions, new and traditional media law issues,
- 1:44invasion of privacy and defamation claims, and
- 1:46publicity rights disputes. Last but not least,
- 1:50David Loy became the First Amendment Coalition's
- 1:52legal director in 2022. David is an experienced
- 1:56free speech and open government litigator. He
- 2:00has defended the First Amendment rights of reporters,
- 2:02photographers, bloggers, students, teachers,
- 2:05activists, protesters, musicians, Marines, and
- 2:08motorcycle club members. He has fought for public
- 2:11disclosure and governmental transparency for
- 2:13over 20 years. Before joining FAC, David served
- 2:16as a legal director of the ACLU foundation of
- 2:19San Diego and Imperial counties for almost 16
- 2:22years. Now, I was informed that FAC also has
- 2:26a hotline that is available on its website and
- 2:29it's open to the public for free speech and transparency
- 2:32issues. The link will hopefully post in the chat
- 2:38or somewhere in the materials for everyone to
- 2:39access. Now let's get started. I have a brief
- 2:43PowerPoint that I'm gonna go through and it's
- 2:47really intended just to lay down the foundation
- 2:50for the discussion. Just so everyone knows, this
- 2:54PowerPoint is available in the written materials,
- 2:56so I'm not going to spend too much time on it.
- 3:00But of course, the subject of today's discussion
- 3:03is the First Amendment, which says that Congress
- 3:05shall make no law respecting an establishment
- 3:07of religion or prohibiting the free exercise
- 3:09thereof or abridging the freedom of speech or
- 3:12of the press or the right of the people peaceably
- 3:14to assemble and to petition the government for
- 3:16a redress of grievances. Now, of course, there
- 3:19are limits to what is actually protected by the
- 3:22First Amendment, and we've got a list of different
- 3:26types of speech that have been evolving throughout
- 3:28the years. But absent these issues, or absent
- 3:33these specific scenarios, the law cannot restrict
- 3:38free speech, and that includes by means of coercion.
- 3:42Of course, with coercion, you know, we have a
- 3:45standard set by Bantam Books to be Sullivan back
- 3:47in 1963. More recently, we have this issue come
- 3:50up in NRI versus Volo and Murthy v. Missouri.
- 3:55Volo dealing with pressure against insurance
- 4:00companies and banks to terminate business relationships
- 4:02with the NRA. Murthy v. Missouri dealing with,
- 4:06of course, COVID -19 and pressure to remove information
- 4:09on Facebook. The question with coercion is, of
- 4:13course, whether based on the totality of circumstances,
- 4:16the government officials actions could reasonably
- 4:18be understood as a threat of adverse consequences
- 4:21aimed at coercing a private party to punish or
- 4:23suppress someone else's speech on the government's
- 4:25behalf. Now, separate from that, the FCC has
- 4:31certain rights to regulate speech that are made
- 4:37on broadcast networks. Again, we have a lot of
- 4:40this information included in the written material,
- 4:43so I don't want to spend too much time on it.
- 4:45But I just want to highlight that on the FCC
- 4:47website, there are pages that discuss regulating
- 4:53the broadcast of false information that causes
- 4:56substantial public harm. There are matters involving
- 5:00false content during news programming, and there's
- 5:02also the issue of broadcast news distortion.
- 5:06Doug, just to turn over to you, how do we look
- 5:13at whether something is a matter that's going
- 5:18to cause public harm? So I think the question
- 5:23generically goes back to the FCC's Prime directive,
- 5:29which is to operate, which is to ensure that
- 5:31broadcasters and let's recall here that we are
- 5:35talking about broadcast media, as opposed to
- 5:38things on the internet, that broadcast media
- 5:41operate in the public interest and That's an
- 5:46issue that has been around for quite some time.
- 5:48And indeed, as long ago as the JFK administration,
- 5:54when Newton Minow was head of the FCC, he spoke
- 5:58about this issue in the context of calling television
- 6:02broadcasting largely a vast wasteland. And when
- 6:07he did so, he actually was called on the carpet
- 6:11by none other than Sherwood Schwartz, who was
- 6:15the creator of Gilligan's Island, who named its
- 6:19shipwreck boat the S .S. Minow after Newton Minow.
- 6:25But that humorous aside, Minow himself said that
- 6:31if he meant that we, in response to what one
- 6:35editorialist wrote, he said that If that editorialist
- 6:41meant that we intend to enforce the law in the
- 6:44public interest, let me make it perfectly clear
- 6:47that he is right. We do. He then went on to say,
- 6:50if he meant that we intend to muzzle or censor
- 6:53broadcasting, he is dead wrong. And indeed, if
- 6:57you look at the FCC's own website today, you'll
- 7:01see a consumer guide that's posted in which it
- 7:05is stated that the FCC is barred by law from
- 7:08trying to prevent the broadcast of any point
- 7:11of view. It goes on to cite an opinion by the
- 7:17commission itself that the public interest is
- 7:21best served by permitting free expression of
- 7:24views. This principle ensures that the most diverse
- 7:27and opposing opinions will be expressed, even
- 7:31though some may be highly offensive. And then
- 7:34let me just add one other thing, if I might.
- 7:38The current chair of the FCC is a fellow named
- 7:41Brendan Carr, and he is the one who instigated
- 7:45the commentary around Jimmy Kimmel's broadcast.
- 7:53I note that back in 2019, he was responding to
- 7:59an op -ed that was published in USA Today that
- 8:03was authored by the Democratic -appointed FCC
- 8:07Commissioner Jessica Rosenmorsal. And she had
- 8:12called for restrictions on e -cigarette advertisements.
- 8:16But in response, Carr wrote the following, and
- 8:18I quote, should the government censor speech
- 8:21it doesn't like? Of course not. The FCC does
- 8:25not have a roving mandate to police speech in
- 8:28the name of the public interest. But I think
- 8:31the question that we need to address today is
- 8:34whether that is precisely what the FCC did when
- 8:40Brennan Carr made his statements that could indeed
- 8:46be considered a form of coercion. Great. Great.
- 8:50Thanks for that. um now let's let's kind of jump
- 8:53into that um actually actually before before
- 8:55that just just a reminder so the FCC does have
- 8:58approval over mergers and license transfers um
- 9:01in that whenever a a new um whenever somebody
- 9:07is is contemplating transferring an FCC license
- 9:10that of course is reviewed by the FCC and that
- 9:12kind of kind of that that brings in a little
- 9:14bit more the legal backdrop that we're that we're
- 9:17going to talk about today of course we have the
- 9:21announcement of the cancellation of the Late
- 9:23Show, which occurred this July. Colbert had made
- 9:31some comments regarding Paramount's settlement
- 9:34of a lawsuit with Trump for 16 million dollars.
- 9:38He called it a big fat bribe. And three days
- 9:40later, of course, the announcement came that
- 9:42the Late Show will be canceled after the season.
- 9:45Now, within the backdrop of that, of course,
- 9:47is the is that Paramount is seeking approval
- 9:51from the FCC for an $8 .4 billion merger with
- 9:54Skydance Media. And then we also have comments
- 9:59from CBS, which stated that this is purely a
- 10:04financial decision against a challenging backdrop
- 10:05in late night. It is not related in any way to
- 10:08the show's performance, content or other matters
- 10:11happening at Paramount. And then we have subsequently
- 10:16the Jimmy Kimmel Live suspension on September
- 10:2017, where Kimmel makes comments regarding Charlie
- 10:25Kirk's murder. One month prior, there had been
- 10:29an announcement by Nextstar Media Group that
- 10:31it was going to acquire Tecna, and Sinclair was
- 10:37also bidding for that purchase. The statement
- 10:42from Kimmel of course was that the MAGA gang
- 10:45desperately trying to characterize this kid who
- 10:47murdered Charlie Kirk was anything other than
- 10:49one of them and doing everything they can to
- 10:52score political points from it. Brennan Carr
- 10:55had made his own commentary after Kimmel's comments
- 10:58saying that it was appearing to directly mislead
- 11:00the American public about a significant fact
- 11:02that probably one of the most significant political
- 11:05events we've had in a long time for the most
- 11:07significant political assassination we've seen
- 11:09in a long time. Brendan Carr, of course, the
- 11:12chair of the FCC, he also wanted to say that
- 11:17we can do this the easy way or the hard way.
- 11:19These companies can find ways to change conduct
- 11:21to take action on Kimo or, you know, there's
- 11:24going to be additional work for the FCC ahead.
- 11:31He also said our goal is to make sure that broadcasters
- 11:34are serving the public interest. And if there's
- 11:36local TV stations that don't think that running
- 11:38that programming does it, then they have every
- 11:40right under the law in their contracts to preempt
- 11:43it. And we'll see how this plays out. Of course,
- 11:46there's some more statements that Brennan Carr
- 11:47makes. You know, there's official statements
- 11:52that were made by the president of Nextar basically
- 11:56saying that the the preemption was due solely
- 12:00to Jamie Kimmel's actions. A similar statement
- 12:04was made by Vice Chair Jason Smith. And then
- 12:11we have the Truth Social post from Donald Trump
- 12:14pretty much applauding the cancellation of Jimmy
- 12:16Kimmel and his comments on Air Force One. So
- 12:20all that is to set up the discussion for today.
- 12:27Eugene, I'm gonna turn to you. Given everything
- 12:30that we've seen publicly, just on its face, was
- 12:35there coercive action from the government here?
- 12:40It sounds like there was an attempt at coercive
- 12:42action by the government. Carr's statement, which
- 12:47you quoted and which I listened to, in context
- 12:50appears to be a threat of FCC retaliation. Now,
- 12:55if this were ever to come to court and the lawsuit
- 12:58was over damage caused by that statement, you'd
- 13:00have to show causation. You'd have to show that
- 13:02the reason that Kimmel was suspended was because
- 13:05of that statement. I can't speak with confidence
- 13:08about that. It's suspicious, but it's not proved.
- 13:13It's certainly possible that there was just solely
- 13:16business pressure, solely stemming from business
- 13:18concerns on the part of the network's business
- 13:22partners. But it's also possible that they were
- 13:25worried about the FCC's actions, especially actions
- 13:29that are possibly related to perhaps blocking
- 13:34mergers, as well as investigating for violation
- 13:37of FCC rules. Hard to know, and I don't think
- 13:40it's going to get to court. But it does sound
- 13:43like it was at least an attempt at coercion.
- 13:45In this respect, it is a nice bookend to a case
- 13:48called NRA v Vula, which you mentioned. So I
- 13:51should say I was the lawyer for the NRA. I was
- 13:56the counsel of record on the petition. I shouldn't
- 13:58say I was the lawyer. I was one of the lawyers
- 13:59for it. I was counsel of record on the petition.
- 14:02My time working on that case is done. I think
- 14:05the case still continues, but I'm no longer involved
- 14:07in it. It's an interesting and important case.
- 14:15The Cuomo administration in New York State didn't
- 14:21like the NRA any more than Trump likes, the Trump
- 14:25administration likes Jimmy Kimmel. And the allegations
- 14:29were, this came up in a motion to dismiss, so.
- 14:35The allegations were that they basically pressured
- 14:38financial intermediaries, insurance companies,
- 14:41for example, to cut off or limit their business
- 14:45relations with the NRA through the threat of
- 14:50various regulatory actions, regulatory enforcement
- 14:54actions against the insurance companies. And
- 14:56the court unanimously said that was enough to
- 14:58state a claim. To be sure, the government could,
- 15:03if it wanted to, investigate the insurance companies,
- 15:06if there was an adequate basis. Insurance companies
- 15:09could, if they wanted to, cut off dealings with
- 15:11the NRA, but the government couldn't threaten.
- 15:14the insurance companies with one as a means of
- 15:16getting the other. So it's an application of
- 15:20and probably broadening of the Bentham Books
- 15:22precedent from 1963, which you also cited. So
- 15:25I think that this is a pretty clear application
- 15:30of NRA -Vivulo, subject to again the requirement,
- 15:34as in NRA -Vivulo itself, that it's got to be
- 15:37proved that there was, in fact, causation here.
- 15:42One last thing I want to mention, just because
- 15:43it's an interesting touch or interesting fact
- 15:46about the case, the NRA -Vivulo case, is that
- 15:52the NRA was represented at the Supreme Court
- 15:55in oral argument by David Cole, who was at the
- 15:57time National Legal Director of the ACLU. Now,
- 16:00the ACLU does not agree with the NRA on much.
- 16:03But it does agree with them on the First Amendment
- 16:04issues, and I think that's one reason the ACLU,
- 16:08and David in particular, thought it was so important
- 16:10that ACLU step up for the NRA, because it could
- 16:15help set a precedent that... like all First Amendment
- 16:18presidents, or like First Amendment presidents
- 16:19generally, let's say, are usable by the left
- 16:22and by the right. He got a good deal of pushback.
- 16:24I think at least two ACLU chapters, the New York
- 16:27Civil Liberties Union and ACLU of New Mexico,
- 16:29kind of publicly dissented from the ACLU's decision
- 16:33to represent the NRA. But I think David and the
- 16:36ACLU leadership were entirely vindicated because
- 16:39now in cases such as this and in various other
- 16:42cases involving law, Trump administration's actions
- 16:45with regard to law firms, universities, and such.
- 16:48NRA Vivulo has become a major precedent in this
- 16:51instance in support of kind of the more liberal
- 16:54speakers. And that I think is exactly what David
- 16:59Kohler and the ACLU expected. Thank you for that.
- 17:03David, I meant to you, do you think that the
- 17:07statements made by Brennan Carr and the legal
- 17:10environment that's been kind of created by this
- 17:13administration where there's this kind of openly
- 17:19said but not openly said sentiment that if you
- 17:24do things that favor the administration, they'll
- 17:28do things that favor you in return. Combining
- 17:32that with the statements made by Brennan Carr,
- 17:36do you also agree that this is just too far attenuated
- 17:39to amounts of coercion? Yes, let me say I agree
- 17:45with Eugene that censorship or attempted censorship
- 17:49is one of the last bipartisan causes we have
- 17:51left and areas of true bipartisan agreement across
- 17:56the political spectrum, unfortunately. But yes,
- 17:59I agree that what Brendan Carr said out loud
- 18:05was very clearly an attempt to intimidate ABC.
- 18:10into taking Jimmy Kimmel off the air. Now, it
- 18:13ultimately did not succeed. Jimmy Kimmel was
- 18:15suspended and then later reinstated. And I'm
- 18:18not an expert in the economics of the broadcast
- 18:21industry, but I understand there may have been
- 18:24a strong business case for reinstating him. So
- 18:26at the end of the day, I think there was an attempt
- 18:32to intimidate ABC to take him off the air. It
- 18:34may have worked. It may have been confounding
- 18:36causation issues, as Eugene said. But yes, I
- 18:39do think there was an open and notorious attempt
- 18:41to intimidate ABC. And this is just the tip of
- 18:43the iceberg. Now, again, let me be clear, censorship
- 18:46is a bipartisan cause. And I have fought censorship
- 18:50from both the left and the right throughout my
- 18:52career and will continue to do so. But, you know,
- 18:55politics aside, this current presidential administration
- 18:59has been the most open and notorious in its attacks
- 19:04on press freedom and freedom of speech. of any
- 19:07administration living memory, at least. And all
- 19:10administrations have free speech problems. All
- 19:14levels of government, local, state, federal,
- 19:16left, right, red, blue, all have free speech
- 19:18problems. The difference here is the current
- 19:20administration is being open, notorious, and
- 19:23blatant about it across the board from the president
- 19:27on down in attempting to intimidate people into
- 19:30silencing themselves. So yes, the fact that there
- 19:35was pushback and Kimmel has reinstated from a
- 19:38free speech perspective is a good thing. But
- 19:40I don't think anyone should take comfort from
- 19:42the fact that they didn't get away with it in
- 19:45this instance. Because this administration is
- 19:50relentless in its attacks on freedom of speech
- 19:54and freedom of the press. And they're making
- 19:56no secret of it. If anything, at least we know
- 19:59what the issues are, there's no hiding the ball
- 20:01here. Right. Now, of course, they've been pretty
- 20:04transparent about what their goals and their
- 20:06interests are, at least with respect to late
- 20:08night television. But in these instances, we
- 20:11have the statement from CBS that said this was
- 20:13a financial decision, right? We had the statements
- 20:15from Next Star and Sinclair saying that they
- 20:18were opposed to the statements made by Jamie
- 20:19Kimmel. I'm not sure that ABC actually made a
- 20:22statement at the time of the suspension, but
- 20:25they did make a statement after Kimmel was reinstated.
- 20:28in this instance, again, talking about causation,
- 20:33are we really just pointing to CBS and Nextar
- 20:38and Sinclair as only bad actors in this case?
- 20:42Can I just speak to one issue? And that's the
- 20:45susceptibility to coercion, at least on the part
- 20:49of Nextar and Sinclair. The fact is, and I think
- 20:54the slides that you presented at the outset mention
- 20:57at least some of this. Nextar operates 32 ABC
- 21:02stations around the country and is seeking and
- 21:06has been seeking at the time that the Kimmel
- 21:09incident occurred FCC approval for a $6 .2 billion
- 21:15merger with Tecna. And at the same time as well,
- 21:19both Nextar and Sinclair have been lobbying the
- 21:23FCC rather relentlessly to repeal its broadcast
- 21:27ownership rule. And that limits any one company
- 21:31from collectively reaching more than 39 % of
- 21:35US households. So they clearly have an interest
- 21:39in currying favor. with the FCC, and I think
- 21:44as a result, were and are collectively susceptible
- 21:50to coercion. Great. Thanks for that point. Given
- 21:58the susceptibility of Nextar and the... Sinclair.
- 22:06Sorry. Sinclair. All right, escaping me. And
- 22:13with the statements that the administration makes
- 22:17with Brendan Carr, we've said that these statements
- 22:22might be too attenuated to lead to national coercion.
- 22:25But does that then mean that these statements,
- 22:29if they continue to make them throughout the
- 22:31remainder of this term, that they're permissible?
- 22:35Well, can I jump in for a second? Because it's
- 22:37important to distinguish between a couple of
- 22:39things. One is could you prove the elements of
- 22:43a coercion or retaliation claim in court? Right.
- 22:46And as Eugene said, you know, that's going to
- 22:48involve complex issues of causation. Are there
- 22:51other, you know, concurrent or intervening or
- 22:55independent independent causes? You know, that's
- 22:58that's an important legal question. But I want
- 23:00to step back. Let's set aside whether you could
- 23:03prove those in court. And I want to emphasize
- 23:07it's terrifying. that we have an administration
- 23:10that is showing such open contempt for the values
- 23:14of freedom of speech, that creates an atmosphere
- 23:17of terror. The risk is that people will begin
- 23:22to preemptively self -censor because they don't
- 23:26want to get to the point where they are actually
- 23:29threatened with concrete harm. That is authoritarianism
- 23:32in action. That is the authoritarian playbook
- 23:36to create such an atmosphere of intimidation
- 23:39and fear that people preemptively self -censor.
- 23:41So I want to make sure we step back from the
- 23:43narrow legal issues of, could causation be proved?
- 23:46Because as Eugene said, in any particular case,
- 23:48that can always be a contested issue of fact.
- 23:52But we're talking about the health of civil society
- 23:55and the value of freedom of speech in protecting
- 23:58robust civil society. I think civil society is
- 24:01under attack. in ways that are unprecedented,
- 24:04nearly unprecedented in this country. There are
- 24:06some historical analogies, so this is not completely
- 24:08a new thing, but certainly in living memory,
- 24:11certainly the last 50 to 60 years, this is terrifying
- 24:13for civil society and freedom of speech generally,
- 24:16even if you couldn't prove. And what's even more
- 24:19challenging, speaking of litigation, there are
- 24:22immense procedural challenges to suing federal
- 24:25officials. particularly. We don't get in, I don't
- 24:28want to turn this into a seminar on civil procedure
- 24:30and Bivens and the fact that Bivens actions are
- 24:32hanging by a thread in the Supreme Court. We
- 24:37should not be taking comfort from the fact that,
- 24:40you know, maybe we could or could not prove the
- 24:43elements of causation. This is an immense threat
- 24:45to values of free speech and free press. So if
- 24:48I could chime in, I agree with very much of what
- 24:51David is saying. And I also agree that this administration
- 24:55has been unusual in its approach to unusual as
- 25:00federal administrations go, at least in the last
- 25:02several decades with regard to its approach to
- 25:05free speech questions. I do think the Biden administration
- 25:08tried quite hard to get social media platforms
- 25:12to restrict certain kinds of speech online. But
- 25:14it is true that this administration appears to
- 25:17be acting more coercively than the Biden administration
- 25:23at least has been proven to have done, in part
- 25:27because I think it's viewing itself as facing
- 25:30kind of hostile entities in the media, whereas
- 25:34the Biden administration viewed itself as facing
- 25:37at least somewhat friendly entities in social
- 25:40media. But I will say as a general matter, If
- 25:44you go beyond just what the administrations do,
- 25:49and I totally agree that what the federal government
- 25:51does is especially important, but this is a variant
- 25:54of what people have been complaining about with
- 25:56regard to universities, for example, public and
- 25:58private, for a long time, that when a university
- 26:03punishes a faculty member for saying things that
- 26:08some people view as offensive on matters like
- 26:10race or gender identity or whatever else. or
- 26:13punishes students or allows the suppression of
- 26:17a speaker. The main effect is not on that one
- 26:22person, that's one person, maybe one group. The
- 26:25main effect is the message it sends to others,
- 26:27to faculty members saying, you know, I know you're
- 26:30maybe a little questioning views on a popular
- 26:35in your university, at your university with regard
- 26:39to say gender identity. or transgender athletes
- 26:42in women's sports, sort of the inner voice. I
- 26:45know you and I are kind of worried or not sure
- 26:49about that. Is it really a good idea to talk
- 26:51about that? Look at all the other things we could
- 26:53be talking about. We could be writing articles
- 26:55on all these other subjects. It's a lot safer
- 26:57to do that. Why even risk this kind of possibility
- 27:01of firing in some situations, suspension, even
- 27:05investigation? I mean, after all, what would
- 27:08have happened likely with regard to the FCC and
- 27:13Kimmel is even if they had launched an investigation,
- 27:16probably nothing much would have happened with
- 27:18regard to it, especially given the prospect of
- 27:21judicial review. I think the federal courts would
- 27:23have slapped that down. But even an investigation
- 27:26is something that is really quite restrictive.
- 27:28Or to give another example, I mean, this is the
- 27:30Beverly Hills Bar Association. California law,
- 27:34prohibits private employers from firing employees
- 27:37for their political activity. That's Labor Code
- 27:40sections 1101 and 1102. Political activity is
- 27:43defined very broadly. It's defined by California
- 27:46Supreme Court precedent, not just as focusing
- 27:49on, say, ballot measures or candidates, election
- 27:52-related activity. It's any candidate or cause,
- 27:56any ideological activity as well. Political speech,
- 28:01not necessarily politics in the electoral sense.
- 28:05Indeed, it is a crime for an employer to interfere
- 28:10with employees' political activity. How many
- 28:13people in Hollywood, which I think is fair to
- 28:16say is a relatively liberal institution in many
- 28:18ways, how many people in Hollywood are willing
- 28:21to speak their mind, express their views that
- 28:24are out of step with dominant views in their
- 28:28industry, especially when it comes to kind of
- 28:32hot button issues, again, maybe race, maybe sexual
- 28:34orientation, gender identity and such. Some are,
- 28:37but I think a lot of people say, look, you know,
- 28:40Why should I risk it? Maybe at some point if
- 28:43I get fired for this maybe I can sue and maybe
- 28:45eventually I can get some damages, but by then
- 28:48my career will be ruined, my job will be lost,
- 28:53even having been investigated again by an employer
- 28:57for something like, my speech might be something
- 29:00that is that is bad for my career. So I think
- 29:04these are very serious concerns. They're especially
- 29:07serious when the administration does it, but
- 29:09I think we have to remember that they're serious
- 29:11also when you see them at university campuses
- 29:14and employers among employers and others. Absolutely.
- 29:19For a brief footnote, prime example of this in
- 29:22the university context is a case that is now
- 29:25closed. It's all done, but it's reported in the
- 29:28Ninth Circuit. It's Koala. against COSLA, K -H
- 29:31-O -S -L -A. And it's a case I litigated when
- 29:34I was at ACLU against the UCSD administration.
- 29:37So look that up. I commend that to your reading.
- 29:40But that case is a prime example of exactly the
- 29:43kind of university -based censorship that Eugene
- 29:46was discussing. Thank you. Doug, I'm going to
- 29:51turn to you real quick again. Is there anything
- 29:56within the FCC? or this, you know, if anyone
- 30:00else wants to chime in as well, feel free to
- 30:02do so. Is there anything within the ambit of
- 30:06the SEC that would allow the administration to
- 30:10continue creating this atmosphere that David
- 30:14Lloyd was talking about in the sense that they
- 30:18want to do certain things for the public interest
- 30:21or to protect from broadcast news distortion
- 30:24or things of that nature? I think the answer
- 30:27to that question is no. You know, that operating
- 30:32in the public interest to the extent we understand
- 30:36what that is. The irreducible minimum is that
- 30:43we cannot be engaged in censorship. That's not
- 30:47what the FCC is there for. And, you know, the
- 30:51fact is that over the course of the years, it
- 30:55has undertaken specific actions to deal with
- 31:01specific types of situations. We've seen that
- 31:08with the Janet Jackson wardrobe malfunction case
- 31:12and with Howard Stern, the FCC. initially stepped
- 31:18in and talked about imposing fines for those
- 31:24kinds of incidents that have resulted in claims
- 31:32that fleeting expletives could be punished. Initially,
- 31:39the FCC's own rules precluded that. And indeed,
- 31:44that's why CBS was able to skate in the Janet
- 31:48Jackson Super Bowl wardrobe malfunction matter.
- 31:53They subsequently said, no, no, we're not going
- 31:56to make any exceptions for fleeting expletives.
- 32:00So when Cher and Nicole Ritchie speak to accepting
- 32:05awards at the Billboard Music Awards, you know,
- 32:08that's that kind of F bomb dropping is going
- 32:12to be punished. But those are very limited and
- 32:16they don't really speak to content discrimination,
- 32:20much less viewpoint discrimination, which is
- 32:23what the First Amendment in its pure form really
- 32:29does speak to and does preclude. OK, thank you.
- 32:34um go turning again to this this atmosphere of
- 32:38of fear of making certain um viewpoints uh that
- 32:44are their adversity administration when we're
- 32:46talking about wanting to actually do something
- 32:49about it you know in in the case of of uh the
- 32:55late show in the case of jimmy kim alive when
- 32:58you've got Paramount when you and next are in
- 33:02Sinclair making statements that none of this
- 33:04was actually the result of the FCC And let's
- 33:08assume that that even not with saying those those
- 33:10statements The the claimant is able to show that
- 33:16you know what this atmosphere did contribute
- 33:18to it there were there was coercion here Who
- 33:20actually has standing to sue in this instance?
- 33:25That's a really interesting question and just
- 33:27to If I can refine a bit what we mean by standing,
- 33:31we're talking about standing to obtain an injunction
- 33:34against the government to stop doing the bad
- 33:37thing. That's going to require someone with a
- 33:40concrete stake in the issue who is adversely
- 33:42impacted and can prove that the government's
- 33:46action caused them some legally cognizable harm,
- 33:49which is then redressable by a court. So the
- 33:52way that's typically done in First Amendment
- 33:54cases is to say, I'm the plaintiff, and the government's
- 33:57doing something that chills my speech, because
- 34:00typically you have to assert your own rights,
- 34:01not those of others, with some exceptions, and
- 34:04the government's action caused me to chill my
- 34:06speech, and a court order can fix that by making
- 34:08it stop. So the obvious example, like assume,
- 34:12for example, that Jimmy Kimmel were still off
- 34:13the air, and his speech is chilled. He would
- 34:17theoretically have standing to sue probably Brendan
- 34:21Carr in his official capacity or any other federal
- 34:23official up and down the chain of command that
- 34:25is implicated directly and say, what you did
- 34:30caused me cognizable harm by chilling my speech
- 34:33and the court should order you to stop it. Now
- 34:37that will get into causation issues that Eugene
- 34:39raised because to state the obvious, nobody has
- 34:41a First Amendment right to compel a private broadcaster
- 34:44or publisher to give you a platform. So I don't
- 34:47have a constitutional right to get my letter
- 34:49to the editor published. A reporter does not
- 34:51have a constitutional right not to get fired
- 34:53by their newspaper or to have any particular
- 34:56story published. Jimmy Kimmel does not have a
- 35:00first amendment cause of action against ABC to
- 35:02keep himself on the air. But that's how these
- 35:05cases would tee up if it were. Now, the fact
- 35:08that he's back on the air means he no longer
- 35:10has that standing because he's back on the air
- 35:11unless he could prove some imminent likelihood
- 35:14that they're going to do this again and threaten
- 35:16him with censorship. And sometimes you don't
- 35:19have to wait for the actual censorship to occur.
- 35:21You can say, I have a strong belief, a good reason
- 35:23to believe they're going to try to censor me.
- 35:25I'm asked the court to step in to stop it from
- 35:28happening. So with that idea of threatening future
- 35:34action, when we have the administration openly
- 35:37targeting people like Colbert, Kimmel, Fallon,
- 35:40The View, at what point does this cross the line?
- 35:46Because from what we've kind of discussed, it
- 35:49seems like you're not able to prove anything
- 35:53happened in court because the causation is just
- 35:56too attenuated here. And so you know what? There
- 35:58is no recourse for whoever's complaining about
- 36:00this. So what redress is there? Is there anything
- 36:04that can be done? Well, not all problems have
- 36:09a legal solution. Part of the problem adding
- 36:14to the points that David mentioned which I think
- 36:16are excellent points is Lots of people in Hollywood
- 36:20or in any business don't really want to sue For
- 36:25a variety of reasons one of which is it may burn
- 36:27professional bridges Let's say there was a way
- 36:33in which Kimmel could sue, maybe for damages.
- 36:35There is no damages remedy against the federal
- 36:37government for First Amendment violations because
- 36:40Congress, while it imposed such a remedy with
- 36:42regard to states, hasn't done that with regard
- 36:44to the federal government. But let's assume he
- 36:47had some means of suing. Part of his argument
- 36:53would be that this forced my employer to to temporarily
- 36:58take me off the air and maybe and therefore that
- 37:01they lied in the argument might end up being
- 37:04in denying that they were coerced into doing
- 37:07this. That's not going to be really good for
- 37:09his relations with his employer. And even if
- 37:11he decides to quit and move on to some other
- 37:14network. Maybe you don't want to get a reputation
- 37:17as a litigious ex -employee or even when you
- 37:21are somebody of Jimmy Kimmel's rank. So there
- 37:24are all sorts of reasons why a lot of injustices
- 37:27don't actually get. Get resolved in court. I
- 37:32I wish that there would be a way of suing the
- 37:36federal government The way that one could sue
- 37:40state governments neither the democrats when
- 37:42they were in control of congress nor republicans
- 37:45have been terribly eager about To do that, but
- 37:49it would be great if they did But but I think
- 37:53the real thing that needs to be done is what
- 37:55we've been seeing done, which is public pushback
- 37:58You have people who denounce the FCC for doing
- 38:02that, who point out that Carr is being inconsistent
- 38:04with his previous views, and the Trump administration
- 38:07inconsistent with their previous view statements
- 38:10about the First Amendment. I think it's very
- 38:13helpful that some people on the right have spoken
- 38:15out as well. Ted Cruz, I think, is to be praised
- 38:18for speaking out against Carr's statements. So
- 38:24I think this kind of political pushback ultimately
- 38:27Maybe the only game in town, but may actually
- 38:29be a pretty important tool for reining in what
- 38:32is, after all, political misbehavior. Can I camp
- 38:37on that for just a second? I think Eugene is
- 38:41absolutely right. And we've seen this movie before.
- 38:46We've seen what happened during the McCarthy
- 38:48era, the Red Scare, where people were intimidated
- 38:53and where networks bowed down to McCarthy's coercion.
- 39:02And the ultimate resolution of that wasn't the
- 39:06legal resolution. It was Joseph Welch telling
- 39:10McCarthy, have you at last no sense of decency.
- 39:14And that plus, you know, more general public
- 39:18pushback may be exactly what is necessary and
- 39:22may be the only thing that will ultimately cause
- 39:26a surcease in this kind of activity. Now, what
- 39:30about we've seen the states get involved on behalf
- 39:33of of of its citizens against the administration.
- 39:37Is there a way to states to get involved here?
- 39:39I mean, states sometimes have standing to bring
- 39:42suit like any other person in court. I think
- 39:46You know, if we're talking, first of all, I completely
- 39:48agree with both Douglas and Jean about the importance
- 39:50of civil society pushing back on threats to freedom
- 39:54of speech and press across the political spectrum,
- 39:57whether you're pushing back against the Biden
- 39:58administration or the Trump administration or,
- 40:00you know, the McCarthy red scare. Civil society,
- 40:04I believe, must and should always stand up to
- 40:06protect its rights to free speech and free press.
- 40:10But states can have standing to sue in federal
- 40:13court. But they, again, the state has to show
- 40:15a concrete harm to its own interests, more than
- 40:19just an abstract dispute of whether this is a
- 40:21good or a bad thing. And there's a whole, and
- 40:24this is actually outside the free speech context,
- 40:26this is sort of a issue of debate in the Supreme
- 40:28Court. And we're probably not gonna turn this
- 40:29into a seminar on Article III standing, but I
- 40:34think it has to be more than the state just,
- 40:36the state says our, Our citizens just don't like
- 40:40what the federal government is doing. There has
- 40:42to be concrete harm, for example. Has the state
- 40:44been required to spend money that it wouldn't
- 40:46otherwise have to? Has the state lost money it's
- 40:50otherwise entitled to? Is there concrete harm
- 40:52to the state's own interests as opposed to a
- 40:54generalized grievance? That's a whole other seminar.
- 40:59So good lawyer, I'll never say never. But that
- 41:02standing case strikes me a little attenuated
- 41:04just because you know, the state says our citizens
- 41:07don't like what the feds are doing about Jimmy
- 41:09Kimmel. Okay. And so just to turn briefly back
- 41:16to this idea of unprotected speech, I don't think
- 41:18that any of these points are really at issue
- 41:22here, but is there a case to be made that any
- 41:25of the statements made by Kimmel or by Stephen
- 41:28Colbert constitute Incitement or defamation in
- 41:32any matter that that would allow the government
- 41:33to step in and say no you can't do that Well,
- 41:36certainly not incitement or defamation. I mean
- 41:40Kimmel didn't say anything false about any particular
- 41:45person to damage their reputations. That's so
- 41:48it's not defamation. He didn't intentionally
- 41:52urge imminent lawless action, imminent and likely
- 41:56lawless action against any particular person.
- 41:58It's not incitement. What he did say is something
- 42:01that was pretty clearly false. He was saying
- 42:04that the MAGA crowd were trying to pretend that
- 42:15this was not one of theirs who did this, which
- 42:20the way the English works. That basically means
- 42:22he was saying that it was somebody from the right
- 42:26who murdered Charlie Kirk. Turns out that's false.
- 42:29Now thankfully, there is no general false statements
- 42:34on public matters, exception to the First Amendment.
- 42:39People have, people tried to some years ago,
- 42:42people tried to argue that there ought to be
- 42:46a general misinformation or disinformation ring.
- 42:49Some people have said malinformation exception.
- 42:52There was a lawsuit, for example, in Washington
- 42:55courts against Fox for supposedly spreading misinformation
- 42:58with regard to COVID. But courts have rejected
- 43:02that. on the strength of cases like Alvarez,
- 43:04like New York Times, V. Sullivan, and such. Now,
- 43:06one complication is for broadcast regulations.
- 43:10There have been more restrictions when it comes
- 43:15to broadcasting, that the court has maybe not
- 43:19exactly blessed, but in some measure blessed
- 43:22in cases like Red Lion. So there is the broadcast
- 43:25hoax rule. There is a news distortion rule. The
- 43:28Supreme Court has never again squarely dealt
- 43:30with them, but in Red Lion and upholding the
- 43:32fairness doctrine, it suggested that more can
- 43:34be, more restrictions can be imposed in broadcasting
- 43:36than on other things. My sense is that what Kimmel
- 43:40did probably wouldn't fit within those rules
- 43:43either. But it's a little complicated because
- 43:47both are vague and both are potentially broad.
- 43:53But certainly it wasn't defamation or incitement.
- 43:57Certainly it wouldn't be unprotected that it
- 44:00would be protected in a newspaper or on the internet
- 44:03or wherever else. And I think even under the
- 44:07special latitude that has been given to FCC regulations,
- 44:10it wouldn't be viewed as unprotected. What would
- 44:15it take for this to constitute news distortion
- 44:18such that the FCC can step in? I have a very
- 44:25hesitant and tentative answer, but I would love
- 44:27to hear what other people who know more about
- 44:28the subject can say. Well, I certainly don't
- 44:35think that there is a general requirement or
- 44:44a general provision in anything that the FCC
- 44:50controls that speaks to simple distortion. And
- 44:59that does not distinguish too between factual
- 45:02and opinion broadcasting. One thing I wanted
- 45:07to mention is that Since Eugene mentioned the
- 45:12Red Lion case, it's an interesting fact that
- 45:16among the cases that Clarence Thomas has within
- 45:20his sights that he would like to see repealed
- 45:24beyond New York Times versus Sullivan. the Actual
- 45:27Malice for Public Figures case and its progeny.
- 45:31He is also in the FCC versus Fox case that the
- 45:36Supreme Court decided in 2009. He wrote a concurring
- 45:40opinion in which he said that both Red Lion and
- 45:44the George Carlin seven -digit words case, FCC
- 45:48versus Pacifica ought to be overruled. you know,
- 45:53the question in my mind is how long are we going
- 45:58to have this sort of bifurcated notion where
- 46:02broadcasters are held to one standard, whatever
- 46:05that standard may be, and everybody else gets
- 46:09to say whatever they want, whenever they want,
- 46:12so long as it's not defamatory or inciting of
- 46:16that nature. Yeah, and just for those who might
- 46:19not know, I apologize. I mean, the whole The
- 46:21kind of restrictions that the Supreme Court,
- 46:24in theory, the Supreme Court is blessed on broadcast
- 46:26media through cases like Red Lion and Pacifica,
- 46:29they would be unthinkable under the First Amendment
- 46:32for virtually any other media, print, digital,
- 46:34books, you know, what have you. Very, very briefly,
- 46:39and others can correct me, I mean, the theory
- 46:41under which the Supreme Court upheld this authority
- 46:44of the FCC to regulate broadcast media in the
- 46:47so -called public interest is an artifact of
- 46:51history and largely obsolete history at this
- 46:54point. It was premised on the old idea that there
- 46:57was a scarcity of broadcast frequencies in the
- 47:01public airwaves. The broadcast frequencies were
- 47:03sort of a public trust, if you will. I apologize
- 47:06if I'm misleading my way I speak about it. But
- 47:10the idea was there's a scarcity of broadcast
- 47:12frequencies. The spectrum is limited. the FCC
- 47:15has to regulate this in the public interest.
- 47:17And so the Supreme Court approved the idea that
- 47:20the FCC could regulate that scarce resource in
- 47:24the public interest in a way it could never do
- 47:25for any other foreign media. Now, let's set aside
- 47:29whether that was correctly decided at the time.
- 47:32As a matter of historical fact and technological
- 47:35developments, that paradigm has just evaporated.
- 47:40There's a very strong case that those wherever
- 47:43you sit on the political spectrum, there's a
- 47:46very strong case that those decisions should
- 47:47be overruled because they were based, even if
- 47:50correctly decided at the time, they're based
- 47:52on a fundamentally obsolete view of the facts
- 47:56and technology. So I should say, I agree with
- 47:59what David is saying, but I think we have to
- 48:01acknowledge as lawyers that the current legal
- 48:04rule allows the government more authority. Regrettably,
- 48:09in my view, in most respects, but more authority
- 48:11to regulate broadcasting. There is a news distortion
- 48:15rule. So as I mentioned, I have a bit of an answer.
- 48:19It is mostly drawn from my colleague Stuart Benjamin,
- 48:23colleague, co -blogger Stuart Benjamin. He's
- 48:25a professor at Duke, and he actually writes extensively
- 48:28about federal communications law. I only dabble
- 48:30in it. And he actually had a very thoughtful
- 48:32post on the subject on our blog, which points
- 48:37out that the news distortion rule has historically
- 48:41been applied very narrowly. It has been applied
- 48:44only to news broadcasting. And while Kimmel and
- 48:49other shows obviously are trying to say something
- 48:52about current events. It's not just a game show,
- 48:55let's say. It's not just comedy. It's not the
- 49:00kind of news programming that the rule, I think,
- 49:04was created for. It also requires that the distortion
- 49:11be substantial. It be deliberately intended to
- 49:14slander, mislead, and involve a significant event
- 49:16and not merely a minor incidental aspect of a
- 49:19news report. Not clear that misstating the ideological
- 49:24affiliation of the shooter, of the murderer,
- 49:27even if even if it's viewed as. deliberate, and
- 49:32it's not clear that it is, would count. And beyond
- 49:37that, the other thing that Stuart points out
- 49:41is that there's been only one finding of a news
- 49:45distortion since 1982. And none of the eight
- 49:49cases since 1969 involved a revocation of a license,
- 49:52and mostly involved like a letter of admonishment,
- 49:54which is a common tool the FCC uses. So the implication
- 49:59that there would be serious punishment for it
- 50:02is, I think, even less justified, and Carr's
- 50:05implication, even less justified. So that's why
- 50:08I think the news distortion probably would not
- 50:11apply here, and it even would not justify any
- 50:14claim that there's a real risk of a loss of license
- 50:16for a minor error like this, even if it were
- 50:20found to be deliberate. Excellent points. I'm
- 50:22going to turn quickly because we have a few minutes
- 50:24left to some of the questions that were posted
- 50:26in our chat. A couple of these deal with fairness
- 50:29doctrine, equal time rule. The first question
- 50:31is, if prior regulatory doctrines such as the
- 50:34fairness doctrine, the equal time rule and personal
- 50:36attack rule are no longer constitutional as to
- 50:38broadcasters, why is even a public interest rule
- 50:41still constitutional? It seems vague, potentially
- 50:44manipulated, or is its constitutionality potentially
- 50:48subject to challenge? As I said, potentially
- 50:53subject to challenge, yes, someone wants to tee
- 50:56up a challenge to ask the Supreme Court to overrule
- 50:58Red Line and Pacifica. The court could take that
- 51:01up. But as Eugene mentioned, Red Line, Eugene
- 51:03and Doug mentioned, Red Line, Red Lion and Pacifica
- 51:06are good law. They are still currently binding.
- 51:09And so as Eugene said, all these FCC regulations
- 51:12are on the books and the FCC has this legal authority
- 51:15for the moment until or unless Red Lion and Pacifica
- 51:19are overruled. And let's just be clear too that
- 51:24the fairness doctrine which was initially adopted
- 51:27in 1949 was abolished as a policy by the FCC
- 51:33itself in 1987 and then as if to put the nail
- 51:38in the coffin the rule implementing that policy
- 51:41was uh removed from the federal register in august
- 51:46of 2011 so you know we're now uh almost we're
- 51:51now more than a decade uh passed uh when the
- 51:55fairness doctrine had any conceivable relevance
- 51:57yeah i mean the fairness doctrine is not in the
- 52:01books red lion the 1969 unanimous opinion upholding
- 52:05it is still on the books uh I'm glad that Justice
- 52:12Thomas spoke out against it. Some other justices
- 52:14have at times spoken out against it, too. It
- 52:18would be good if the court formally overruled
- 52:22it. But when we were talking about Red Line,
- 52:26it was as illustration of the court's holdings,
- 52:29which have not been yet overruled, that restrictions
- 52:33on broadcasting may be permissible even if they're
- 52:36not permissible on newspapers. And one example
- 52:39of such a restriction, not at issue in Red Line
- 52:41itself, but possibly could be upheld under the
- 52:45logic of Red Line, is the news distortion rule.
- 52:48There's another example, the broadcast hoax rule,
- 52:51which involves, I think, more serious and deliberate
- 52:54hoaxes. Now, what about viewership expectations?
- 52:57Can we discuss the right of citizens to expect
- 52:58a balanced presentation upon its airwaves and
- 53:02the FCC's historical obligation, example equal
- 53:04time requirements, to ensure a balanced representation
- 53:07of political views? Well, I can expect a lot
- 53:11of things, but it isn't very reasonable for me
- 53:13to expect things. I can't expect balanced presentation
- 53:17from, say, opinion magazines. In fact, the reason
- 53:23people subscribe to opinion magazines is precisely
- 53:26because they have particular ideological perspectives.
- 53:28One might expect some balanced presentation from
- 53:31newspapers simply to the extent that they say
- 53:34that they're providing balanced presentation.
- 53:37And you might kind of hold their feet to the
- 53:39fire if it turns out that they are not delivering
- 53:41what they're promising. But as to broadcasting,
- 53:46indeed, I entirely agree with Doug on this point
- 53:49that with the repeal of the fairness rule, I
- 53:52don't think there's any basis to expect balanced
- 53:55presentation. There may be liberal programs and
- 53:58maybe conservative programs, just like there's
- 54:00the New Republic and there is the National Review.
- 54:03And there are lots of other magazines that have
- 54:05particular viewpoints, likewise with broadcasters.
- 54:08Again, I think when broadcasters say that they're
- 54:11going to be balanced and they're not, then in
- 54:14that case, I think we should speak out against
- 54:16that. And even if they say they're going to be
- 54:17unbalanced, we might want to say, well, that's
- 54:20not good. We wish you were more balanced. But
- 54:22I don't think there's any legal entitlement,
- 54:24especially now with the demise of the fairness
- 54:26doctrine, to expect uh to expect balance in a
- 54:30world where people have views and are often often
- 54:34express those views and are generally free to
- 54:36express those views. And let's remember too you
- 54:40know that in the context of uh traditional expressive
- 54:43media there's Miami Herald Publishing versus
- 54:46Tornillo which stands for the proposition the
- 54:49state statute which required the Miami Herald
- 54:52to offer a right of reply to someone who was
- 54:56attacked was unconstitutional. And that absent
- 55:01this regulatory framework that currently exists
- 55:05for the FCC, that would be the rule across the
- 55:08board. All right, thank you. Turning to Jimmy
- 55:14Kimmel and Stephen Colbert specifically. What
- 55:19Jimmy Kimmel said is what MAGA was doing, the
- 55:23shooter was left wing, et cetera. That doesn't
- 55:25mean that what Jimmy said was false. It meant
- 55:28that the person who did the act was one of them,
- 55:31A .G. Maga. He just pointed out what Maga was
- 55:34saying. Do you have any thoughts on that? Here's
- 55:37what he said. Maga Gang was, quote, desperately
- 55:41trying to characterize this kid who murdered
- 55:43Charlie Kirk as anything other than one of them.
- 55:48As I understand the English language... Not my
- 55:51native language, to be sure, but I've spoken
- 55:53with it for quite a while, is that that's a way
- 55:56of saying that, in fact, the kid who murdered
- 56:00Charlie Kirk was one of them. You don't desperately
- 56:03try to characterize X as anything other than
- 56:06Y, unless X actually is Y. So in context, he's
- 56:11essentially saying that the murderer was one
- 56:15of the MAGA gang. Best we can tell that's not
- 56:18so. And even at the time he said it, the news
- 56:20account suggested it wasn't so. So I think he
- 56:24was he was not telling the truth there, whether
- 56:28he was saying a deliberate lie. I can't speak
- 56:30to that. But again, I think that notwithstanding
- 56:34even the news distortion rule, that's not a basis
- 56:37for for punishing him for for that kind of statement.
- 56:41With regard to Stephen Colbert, Paramount Skydance
- 56:44began layoffs today up to 2 ,000 jobs. They own
- 56:49CBS. They want to buy Warner Brothers. With the
- 56:53increased media consolidation in the broadcast
- 56:55arena, where do you see this is going? Broadcast
- 56:57media is dying and the FCC doesn't govern streaming
- 57:00in the same way. Do you expect the FCC powers
- 57:03to be broadened to capture stream? I don't think
- 57:06the FCC's powers could be broadened beyond broadcast
- 57:09because that would violate the First Amendment.
- 57:12The entire premise of the FCC's authority to
- 57:15regulate broadcast media is based on these cases,
- 57:17Redline and Pacifica, and premised on the idea
- 57:22of a scarcity of broadcast spectrum. That simply
- 57:26doesn't apply to newspapers, to digital, to the
- 57:28internet, to cable, to any form of media other
- 57:33than traditional broadcast. So, were the FCC
- 57:38to attempt to promulgate that rule, I would expect
- 57:42a very swift and hopefully certain uh very very
- 57:46swift challenge we filed and hopefully a very
- 57:48swift decision striking down any such attempt
- 57:50okay uh one final question for the for the record
- 57:55kimmel's offending statement was made before
- 57:58new evidence primarily revelation of the shooter's
- 58:01partner's statements thought foreclosed the theory
- 58:04that the shooter was on the right uh became public
- 58:07any thoughts on that comment I agree with Eugene.
- 58:14I mean, it's quite possible what Jimmy Kimmel
- 58:16said was, in fact, rejectively false. But that's
- 58:20almost a non -issue, because even if it was false
- 58:24or it wasn't, that's not a grounds to censor
- 58:27his speech, whether under FCC rules or the First
- 58:30Amendment. The only arena which falsity would
- 58:35be relevant for First Amendment perspectives,
- 58:37maybe not the only, the primary arena would be
- 58:39if you had an actual defamation lawsuit where
- 58:42an allegedly false statement of fact was made
- 58:45of and concerning a specific individual, and
- 58:47then a court can litigate was that statement
- 58:49false or not. Maybe false advertising cases,
- 58:52commercial speech, or other areas where courts
- 58:54have authority to adjudicate was a statement
- 58:56false, perjury trials. There's a number of legal
- 59:00avenues, legal arenas where Falsity of a particular
- 59:03statement is sort of irrelevant. This is not
- 59:06one of them, in my view. So I don't think we
- 59:08need to debate whether what Kimmel said was or
- 59:11was not false. What did he know or did not know
- 59:13at the time? What was the evidence or not the
- 59:15evidence? Assume it to be false. It's not a basis
- 59:18to censor his speech. Yeah, I entirely agree
- 59:21with David on this. I do want to mention, at
- 59:23least looking at the Washington Post, there was
- 59:27a statement, I think, or excuse me, an article
- 59:32that I think was supposed to be there Sunday,
- 59:33maybe Monday morning, which quoted the Utah governor
- 59:37that Sunday, which is to say I think the day
- 59:39before the Kimmel monologue, that Tyler Robinson
- 59:45had a, quote, leftist ideology, close quote.
- 59:48Now, maybe you can't take that to the bank either.
- 59:50You could say, well, the Utah governor was a
- 59:52Republican says this. I'm not sure I believe
- 59:54it. I totally understand. But Kimmel's statement,
- 59:59which again, I think is properly interpreted
- 1:00:02as showing real confidence that the shooter was
- 1:00:09one of the MAGA gang, had no foundation for it.
- 1:00:13And again, the information that was out there
- 1:00:15at the time suggested otherwise. The point though,
- 1:00:18and I think the deeper point, which is what David
- 1:00:20points out, is that thankfully, generally speaking,
- 1:00:25you can't punish speech just because somebody
- 1:00:27says with great confidence something they should
- 1:00:29have no confidence in at all, or something where
- 1:00:31really they ought to, given the facts, believe
- 1:00:33otherwise. This kind of misstatement is inevitable
- 1:00:37in public discussions, especially with fast -moving
- 1:00:41news stories, and I think it should not be punishable.
- 1:00:47And I think Kimmel himself has basically said
- 1:00:50that what he said was dumb and perhaps ambiguous.
- 1:00:56But, you know, I think that stupidity is protected.
- 1:01:03Speech. Thank God. Thank goodness. And, you know,
- 1:01:07if that's the greatest offense that he took,
- 1:01:11so be it. And let's remember, too, that he was
- 1:01:14talking about somebody who is If he was talking
- 1:01:20about Charlie Kirk, we cannot defame the dead.
- 1:01:27And that's another whole perhaps topic of conversation.
- 1:01:33But just let that be known. Great. Well, we've
- 1:01:40pretty much hit the end of our time. Just really
- 1:01:44quick, if you can share maybe closing thoughts.
- 1:01:47Is this the new relationship that we should expect
- 1:01:50between the federal government and broadcast
- 1:01:54media moving forward? I think whether it is or
- 1:02:03isn't depends on the level of pushback to it,
- 1:02:05right? I do think that some of the speech restrictive
- 1:02:10movements on campuses have from all I understand
- 1:02:15declined in some measure because there was pushback,
- 1:02:18because people spoke out in favor of free speech,
- 1:02:22people on both sides of the aisle spoke out in
- 1:02:24favor of, for example, a conservative speech,
- 1:02:26and the people who were implementing the restrictions
- 1:02:29realized that they were not winning as a result
- 1:02:32of this. So I think when politicians try to restrict
- 1:02:36speech, I mean, it's nice if you can bring in
- 1:02:39the courts to strike that doubt. Sometimes you
- 1:02:41can't. But they need to be taught that there
- 1:02:47are political consequences. There's a line I
- 1:02:49want to say from Everett Dirksen, perhaps, I
- 1:02:50think, former Senate leader, that when I feel
- 1:02:57the heat, I see the light. That's sort of the
- 1:03:00way politics works. He was talking, I think,
- 1:03:02in part for push back from his own constituents,
- 1:03:04but that's I think what we're talking about is
- 1:03:06there needs to be political heat and I'm glad
- 1:03:08that it is being produced. I'll just add to that
- 1:03:12and say autocracy depends on acquiescence. That's
- 1:03:16autocracy from the left autocracy from the right
- 1:03:18depends on acquiescence preemptive compliance
- 1:03:20for fear of retaliation or punishment. And it's
- 1:03:24all the more important to stand up and fight
- 1:03:26back against any form of censorship. wherever
- 1:03:29it comes from on the political spectrum. And
- 1:03:32I'll just add that on a going forward basis,
- 1:03:35perhaps we can take some solace in the fact that
- 1:03:38NRA versus Vullo that we talked about at the
- 1:03:41outset was a unanimous Supreme Court decision
- 1:03:45authored by Justice Sotomayor. It is increasingly
- 1:03:50rare that we see this court issuing unanimous
- 1:03:55opinions. And perhaps that's some light at the
- 1:04:01end of the tunnel, some glimmer of hope that
- 1:04:03in the future we will see more of that. Right.
- 1:04:08Well, Eugene, Doug, David, thank you very much
- 1:04:10for your time. We really appreciate the discussion.
- 1:04:12I thought it was great. I learned a lot. I hope
- 1:04:15everybody else felt the same. Thank you all.
- 1:04:19Thank you.