Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Citi, Schwab, Nubank, & Aureo: The Global Bitcoin Race for 21 Million
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat poison?
- 0:17Probably rat poison squared. We need to get into the world of
- 0:21OK, this is actually foundational technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single network
- 0:29which can do a microtransaction to a giga transaction.
- 0:36The Internet is going to be one of the major forces for reducing
- 0:41the roller gun. The one thing that's missing?
- 0:44That will. Soon be developed is a reliable
- 0:47E cash. Thanks everybody for joining the
- 0:52most recent episode of Final Settlement.
- 0:55It was a great talk just going over everything in the market
- 0:57today as well as we had a special guest, Gustavo Flores of
- 1:02Oreo. We discussed a number of
- 1:04different things, including everything from Latin American
- 1:06Bitcoin adoption, how we think everything will play out, and
- 1:09then gave some updates around his business.
- 1:13There are some really exciting new announcements coming from
- 1:16early riders this entire week, so please stay tuned and
- 1:20subscribe to all of our research.
- 1:22We're really doing a lot there at earlyriders.com/research.
- 1:26And please feel free to reach out to myself directly at
- 1:29liam@earlyriders.com if any of this sounds interesting to you.
- 1:34Not on to the rest of the show. All righty, gentlemen.
- 1:37Welcome back to another episode of Final SETTLEMENT.
- 1:40Today is Monday, October 20th, 10:17 AM Eastern Time.
- 1:46I'm joined as always by Michael Tanguma, Liam Nelson and special
- 1:50guest today, Gustavo Flores, CEO of Arrayo.
- 1:54Some exciting announcements and news related to Gustavo's
- 1:58business coming later in the show, but lots of news and, and,
- 2:03and headlines to get to. We've got a long list.
- 2:06So going to kick things off here, talking a little bit about
- 2:10some developments going on really in, in this broader trend
- 2:14that we've been talking about for several weeks and months of
- 2:17both institutional allocators and also sovereigns getting
- 2:22interested in sort of the broader crypto space, but
- 2:24Bitcoin specifically and productizing these markets.
- 2:30So the first link I'm I'm bringing up here is some news
- 2:34from the UK that 21 shares Bitwise and Wisdom Tree will
- 2:38open UK retail access to Bitcoin and Ethereum Etps through FCA
- 2:42approval. I forget who brought this link,
- 2:45but any any thoughts on this one gentlemen?
- 2:51Yeah, I think it's a huge deal. I think BlackRock is also a part
- 2:55of that. I think UK obviously huge
- 2:58market. And then there was a whole slew
- 3:02of news from last week. We'll talk about globally that
- 3:04came to on inflows or on ramps across the board in the UK
- 3:10naturally being pretty antagonistic to digital assets.
- 3:15And there's there was the the notion that retail investors
- 3:19couldn't get exposure to spot Bitcoin, and that's where they
- 3:21ended up in dats and all these inferior products or how to go
- 3:23to MSTR. We'll increasingly, you know,
- 3:27month over month start to make less and less sense.
- 3:30The reality is these markets, the local financial service
- 3:35partners that run them, the local custodian requirements
- 3:38that the regulators will require will all be incentivized to have
- 3:42the assets closest to the client.
- 3:44And so you can expect this to transpire across the world.
- 3:48And so I think it's just a natural evolution of where the
- 3:51market's going, where you're going to have local financial
- 3:53services offering Bitcoin rails. Yep, and the banks just are all
- 4:00these asset managers who are providing the ETP saw how much
- 4:04money can be made in the US and what the demand looks like for
- 4:07them. So even if the government isn't
- 4:09necessarily super open to it, they're going to spend the time,
- 4:12money and resources lobbying them in order to educate them
- 4:15that, you know, people actually want this and they can make
- 4:18money off that. So it's just, you know, a no
- 4:20brainer that this is going to continue not just in the UK but
- 4:24all across the world. Yeah, there.
- 4:30There's a capital flight component as well.
- 4:33When you think about in the US first mover having all this
- 4:36money come in to the ecosystem and we can pull that up as well.
- 4:39We're Japan. It's not fully read in that
- 4:44they're approving this, but Japan's now discussing allowing
- 4:47banks to buy and sell crypto. And again, this just ties back
- 4:50to incentives. You don't want your capital,
- 4:53whether it's your local Fiat or, you know, hard asset like a
- 4:56Bitcoin or gold leaving your shores.
- 4:59And then ultimately you want those within your borders and
- 5:03you want to be able to offer financial services and products
- 5:05around that. And so I just expect to see this
- 5:07more and more where and this kind of makes sense when you go
- 5:11back to old school banking. We lost sight of it just given
- 5:14the way the world's been digitized.
- 5:15But there's a reason where every corner you generally drive down
- 5:18in the US city or town, there's a bank at the corner because
- 5:21that's just how relationships and banking work.
- 5:24And so it kind of, you can see this play out over the past 15
- 5:27years where you had to go or you know, 13 years ago to Mount Gox
- 5:30and then Mount Gox went to San Francisco and now you can go on
- 5:33each coast. Naturally, you can, you know,
- 5:35Texas has a few Bitcoin firms. You just start to get a more
- 5:38localized driven relationship with your banking partner.
- 5:42And so this is makes a lot of sense.
- 5:47Yep. And there was also a second
- 5:50headline out of Japan, I think more so related to stable coins.
- 5:55But this is just again, part of this broader trend of, you know,
- 5:59I think a lot of this is interesting as it relates to
- 6:01Japan because they've been historically sort of cautious or
- 6:06even antagonistic against the broader crypto space.
- 6:10But I think as people recognize, you know, I think the the
- 6:13signpost of BlackRock just having such success with the
- 6:16Bitcoin ETFI think did send some shock waves around the world,
- 6:20particularly to potential issuers like stratify incumbents
- 6:25around the actual opportunity around a lot of these things.
- 6:29And you know, as we know, they're going to take that in
- 6:32all the different directions outside of Bitcoin, whether it's
- 6:34stable coins or real world assets, the tokenization of, of
- 6:38everything and anything. But the broader construct is
- 6:43that they are, they are now open and willing to engage with this
- 6:47stuff because they see the monetary incentive of, of
- 6:49building products like this. That's sort of the take away for
- 6:52me is, is the incentives associated with, well, if we can
- 6:55make money from this, then let's let's issue everything under the
- 6:58sun here because there's, there's a real opportunity for
- 7:01us to to make money here. Yeah, I'd agree.
- 7:04But this this article in particular is talking about MFG,
- 7:09SMBC and Mizuho trying to issue yen and dollar peg stable coins.
- 7:14We've talked about this in the past before, but I do think this
- 7:17will end up more so like the BRICS type currency where there
- 7:22are a ton of different people with different incentives who
- 7:26are behind the asset and they won't.
- 7:29Just having different priorities at different times will probably
- 7:33make the like yen backed or dollar backed stable coin less
- 7:36successful than it would have been otherwise.
- 7:38Just because people are going to or the different banks will have
- 7:43disagreements on where they should prioritize this.
- 7:46And essentially having a committee of experts will
- 7:49necessarily slow you down. Especially with new product
- 7:52launches, while they have the distribution, it's going to be
- 7:55challenging in order to to scale this as much as they would like
- 7:59is kind of my base case. Yeah.
- 8:02Yeah. I guess I might be curious on
- 8:05your thoughts there and specifically what you've seen in
- 8:07Latin America, because I, I was initially pretty bearish on
- 8:11local Fiat stable coins. And now I'm a little less in the
- 8:16sense of like, obviously they all lose value and lose value
- 8:20relative the dollar, which loses value relative to gold or
- 8:23Bitcoin. But the, the reality is, and
- 8:25something we've just learned, you know, from building is the
- 8:29things that we understand versus the market or, you know,
- 8:33football field wide when it comes to even understanding a
- 8:36stable coin, let alone, you know, Bitcoin.
- 8:40And so that reality will exist. And then what Liam was saying,
- 8:43referencing the amount of bureaucracy.
- 8:46I I believe that to be true, obviously, but then the reality
- 8:49is all of these banks will overtime naturally need to be
- 8:52built out because of the way the system's set up.
- 8:54And so you can see how it's very similar with back during COVID.
- 8:57It's like how we're going to get dollars into, you know, citizens
- 9:01pockets. And then they figured it out
- 9:02whether it was Cash App to start and now we have stable coins and
- 9:05we talked about picks before we started recording.
- 9:08So just curious how you see that playing out, if you think
- 9:10they'll be that much bureaucracy or market forces will require
- 9:13them to basically vertically integrate or streamline that
- 9:17process from central banks to Fiat stablecoins for the local
- 9:21market? Yeah, totally.
- 9:23I mean, First off, there was, there's been a lot of pushback
- 9:27from governments in the region as it has been the case
- 9:30everywhere, less so now since probably the the Trump White
- 9:34House started. They just kind of have to adapt
- 9:36to new reality. I think the UK and Japan's news
- 9:39is kind of related to that too. But, and there's been definitely
- 9:43this year has been the year of the, of the local stable coin
- 9:47narrative in Latin America. A lot of projects in Mexico are
- 9:51doing that for, for multiple reasons, right?
- 9:541 is to be able to some, some have ideas to just move the
- 9:59economy towards a stable coin economy in order to to bypass
- 10:03some financial regulations. You know, let's say you pay
- 10:07your, your, your, your employees in stable coins, then you can
- 10:10bypass many, many regulations in Mexico.
- 10:14But, but it's, it's still an ongoing dance where like they,
- 10:18they pull and they push on this direction.
- 10:21You know, it's still, it's still hasn't fully settled at least in
- 10:25Mexico and Colombia. I know Brazil is definitely way
- 10:29ahead everyone else. So I, I think they're the first
- 10:32developments we're going to see and on this topic are going to
- 10:35come from Brazil specifically and Mexico and Colombia will
- 10:39just have no choice but to adapt to this new reality in, in, in
- 10:44maybe some a couple extra months or a couple extra years.
- 10:50Yeah. I mean, we've seen, was it last
- 10:52week, all the the inflows from Argentina and U.S. dollars that
- 10:58you can see over time, you just create the spigot, one of those
- 11:00like swap lines that existed where it becomes the incentive
- 11:04to streamline that and those flows will naturally turn into
- 11:07stable coins for treasury demand.
- 11:09So yeah, it feels like there's a lot of market forces that will
- 11:12be independent of like the demand.
- 11:15It'll be interesting to watch. Yeah.
- 11:18It's interesting you brought up Brazil, Gustavo, because another
- 11:22link that you'd shared related to Brazil was and, and I didn't
- 11:26even realize this, but I guess that there was some efforts
- 11:29around a Bitcoin reserve project in Brazil that now I guess
- 11:33apparently has been scrapped. Any other color on, on, on this
- 11:38one? Just in the sense of, you know,
- 11:40all of these countries now thinking about stable coins, Are
- 11:43they being distracted by the stable coin narratives and
- 11:46should they really just be focusing on on Bitcoin?
- 11:48I guess would be they're. Definitely distracted by the
- 11:50they're definitely, excuse me, they're definitely distracted by
- 11:53the Stableco narrative. I I think the Brazil case is, is
- 11:57particularly interesting because they've been quite bullish on
- 12:00Bitcoin so far. And that's surprising for
- 12:03particularly like left wing regime as as we have in in
- 12:07Brazil. But yeah, the stablecoin it's,
- 12:11it's, it's part of a bigger push from the fintech ecosystem too.
- 12:14You know, like everybody wants to issue their their stablecoin,
- 12:17all these big billion dollar fintechs once, once to get on
- 12:20board on that, right. So to allow themselves I, I
- 12:23think the, the, the fintechs and you have, you have in incentives
- 12:28from the fintech ecosystem, from the crypto ecosystem and from
- 12:31the government to push the stable coin narrative and to
- 12:35slow down the, the Bitcoin one. But it's, it's simply temporary,
- 12:39right? You, you know that once the, the
- 12:42Chohan horse has entered, there's, there's no going back.
- 12:46So I think we'll just see more and more of this pull and push
- 12:51type of flow, you know, mechanism and but ultimately
- 12:56we're we're just going in the in the good direction here.
- 12:59Yeah. There's a few other headlines I
- 13:03wanted to go to. There was the Coinbase News
- 13:07making an investment in Coin DCX.
- 13:11Liam, you had thoughts on this one?
- 13:14Well, this one's interesting for a number of different reasons.
- 13:18Coin DCX is an Indian slash Middle Eastern based exchange.
- 13:22They're actually a little bit larger than I thought.
- 13:25They have almost 150 million in revenue and over a billion
- 13:31dollars in their platform. They, I think the coin base just
- 13:35wants access to growing markets and that's why they made
- 13:39investments in the firm. I think that the they didn't
- 13:41actually specify what the investment is, but yeah, it's
- 13:47just the coins going to proliferate everywhere.
- 13:50And so it's only natural that you want to have your brand and
- 13:54access to financial services to proliferate everywhere as well.
- 13:57And offering a partnership with local based exchanges is an
- 14:01interesting way to do that. I think that they probably did
- 14:06this because I would assume they got a deal and there was because
- 14:11coin DCX, I think they lost $44 million earlier this year.
- 14:17They had the famous proof of reserves and then, you know, the
- 14:22next day they lost $44,000,000 because there was a hack of a
- 14:26hot wallet on the exchange. And so they probably are looking
- 14:30for somebody who can come in and make an investment in the firm
- 14:33because they probably had some holes.
- 14:35They said that they were able to close it by their balance sheet,
- 14:38but that doesn't necessarily mean like they could have taken
- 14:41on an additional loan in order to be able to close it with
- 14:44their own balance sheet. So I think that this is just
- 14:47interesting to see. I don't necessarily know know
- 14:50quite as much to know exactly why they do this other than just
- 14:53the fact that they probably were able to to get a really good
- 14:55deal. And it's a growing market.
- 14:58And eventually, just as we talked about earlier, like
- 15:02Bitcoin is just a better form of money.
- 15:04And so it's going to proliferate into all of these different
- 15:07corners of the world. And even though India has been a
- 15:09little bit more, you know, combative against digital assets
- 15:15and Bitcoin in particular, it seems like they're shifting that
- 15:18narrative a little bit like we talked about in the past.
- 15:21And so it just makes sense from both the timing and probably
- 15:25valuation perspective from Coinbase.
- 15:28Yeah, this one's super curious based on everything you said,
- 15:32but does add to the color around the losses, especially with a
- 15:36firm that you would imagine if they have a proof of reserves,
- 15:41it ties back to another notion of proof of reserves or a
- 15:44fallacy inherently because just because you can prove the
- 15:46reserves, the single custodians doing that the next day they're
- 15:49lost. What was the point?
- 15:52But the notion of if they're conservative by showing that and
- 15:54they weren't re hypothecating or do anything else, they don't
- 15:57necessarily have the same type of revenue profile of other
- 16:01companies like a Binance or, you know, different kind of trading
- 16:04platforms where they can't make up that hole.
- 16:07And so to Liam's point, they could have been really impaired
- 16:11and there's a number of other angles.
- 16:14Probably one of the most interesting outside of a deal is
- 16:17the Indian markets. My understanding while they're
- 16:20very, you know, antagonistic or have put certain, I think I
- 16:25don't know if it was India last week, it was the UK for sure was
- 16:28going after 50,000. I think it was the UK and India
- 16:30in the past two weeks have said they're going after like tax
- 16:33evasion for cryptocurrencies. Point being, it is it's very
- 16:39insular in who's running these markets and then the regulators
- 16:42that are deeming them OK. And so if Coinbase is able to
- 16:46effectively buy their way into that market, it is the second, I
- 16:49believe largest, you know, continent in the world, 1.2
- 16:51billion people. And so and then obviously the
- 16:55gold profile makes it a lot of sense that those citizens,
- 17:00they're one step removed from understanding Bitcoin, but it's
- 17:03still interesting Coinbase to get exposure into Asia Pacific
- 17:07effectively. And what does that look like in
- 17:08this coin? DCX run independent with their
- 17:11own brand or do they take on the Coinbase brand TBD?
- 17:14But yeah, I think it's it's a super interesting deal, someone
- 17:18that I didn't expect to. See in the markets.
- 17:20Do you already own Bitcoin on the balance sheet of your
- 17:22company or are you looking to get buy in?
- 17:25To adopt Bitcoin on the balance sheet, get in touch with us here
- 17:29at onramp. You can see here we just
- 17:31published a case study. You can find it on our website
- 17:33onrampbitcoin.com/products/business linked below.
- 17:38We helped Occam's Advisory go from no Bitcoin strategy to
- 17:42board approval and a live treasury in 30 days.
- 17:45So if you are a business and you are looking to either secure
- 17:50your existing Bitcoin held on balance sheet or you want to
- 17:52adopt A strategy that new, we're here to help.
- 17:56We can help with multi institution custody, Lloyd's of
- 17:59London insurance role based access controls and making sure
- 18:03that you have a secure plan for your Bitcoin now and to the
- 18:08future. So again, get in touch with us
- 18:10on rampant business just launched.
- 18:12We'd love to speak with you. Book a consultation on our
- 18:15website. Yeah, few other to just run
- 18:19through here. I think we alluded to this one,
- 18:22but another Black Rock headline to launch Genius compliant money
- 18:26market fund tailored for stable coin issuers.
- 18:29And then there was another stable coin related headline,
- 18:33Stripe stablecoin unit Bridge which they acquired months ago
- 18:36applies for a National Bank trust charter.
- 18:39Any thoughts on on either of these stablecoin announcements?
- 18:44The money market one, just calling out, I think it's, it's
- 18:48fascinating because we're just going to see the blending of
- 18:49stables and money markets in the movement and it's all going to
- 18:52get obfuscated in the background.
- 18:54Whether it's the rewards that people talk about to get more
- 18:57competitive on launching stable coins or the money market funds
- 19:02where you can deposit and effectively deposit stable coins
- 19:05in there to get around it. I think we see portfolio
- 19:09companies as well as external companies start to integrate.
- 19:14The, the one that was interesting, we didn't talk much
- 19:16about it. It's actually really interesting
- 19:17value prop minus who the CEO is of Galaxy 1, really interesting
- 19:23value prop around integration of equities next to crypto or
- 19:28Bitcoin, but then two different style cash or checking and
- 19:35savings account. So the checking account does a
- 19:374% interest rate pass through and it's using something similar
- 19:42to this. And then they have like the 8 to
- 19:449%, which is for accredited investors that go into the
- 19:47Bitcoin back lending product that they offer.
- 19:50And so point being is, I think you're just going to see more
- 19:52and more of this in Tri Fi launching crypto related
- 19:54services along with more incentives to pass capital or
- 19:58yield back to the user. And then digital asset firms
- 20:00also integrating more of the Tri Fi setup.
- 20:04And, and I think at the end of the day, it really all comes
- 20:07back down to Bitcoin though, and who offers the best Bitcoin
- 20:09financial services, meaning from custody to execution to client
- 20:13services and understanding because it if we believe that
- 20:16whether it's stable coins, private equity, public equities.
- 20:20In any other investment class, all are going to net settle and
- 20:22be denominated, but also benchmarked against Bitcoin.
- 20:26Well, then that's the logical progression.
- 20:28And it's fascinating because we'll talk about this with
- 20:29Gustavo, but that's the exact opposite.
- 20:31Everyone that we talked about here is focused on.
- 20:33They're all talking about the old world and how do they
- 20:35digitize it versus like what's this new base currency, Bitcoin
- 20:39and potentially gold. So yeah.
- 20:44Yeah, I'd add that it seems like everybody from the Bill Gurley's
- 20:47of the world, we can talk about the tempo race and a little bit
- 20:51too just $500 million before they have a product on mainnet,
- 20:55which is seems pretty high for their new blockchain in order
- 21:01for people to issue stable coins.
- 21:03But it's just everybody in the, you know, traditional venture
- 21:08world and is looking at this asset class as a way to kind of
- 21:12graft on what they've been looking for in the past, which
- 21:14is massive amounts of network effects as well as reduced fees.
- 21:18And I think that they've just been really turned off by the
- 21:22amount of scams in, you know, the product crypto space and
- 21:25just the the volatility of the tokens, which don't necessarily
- 21:28have sound fundamentals of underlying price to earnings
- 21:32ratios and everything that we see with ETH.
- 21:34And they can't quite wrap their head around Bitcoin yet just for
- 21:38whatever reason. So it's interesting to see that
- 21:41they're going to come into assets like this and they're
- 21:43going to try to professionalize them as much as possible.
- 21:47And they're just to, to your point, Michael, earlier too,
- 21:50they're going to proliferate this around the world because
- 21:54all of the countries outside of the US really need, you know,
- 21:59just better forms of money as well as, and the fact that the
- 22:02US needs all of them to, you know, have the dollar as well,
- 22:05because the stable coin issuers are going to be the one to
- 22:08actually buy the Treasury as we get more and more, you know,
- 22:12down the rabbit holes, debt and deficits.
- 22:15But I think that this is just a good way to see more people come
- 22:20into the space because they're not necessarily trying to scam
- 22:23people and pump their own tokens.
- 22:25It's it probably comes from a place of actually trying to
- 22:28understand, you know, why what's wrong with the payment network
- 22:32networks today and how can we reduce those costs?
- 22:35But naturally they're just going to all understand that, you
- 22:38know, Bitcoin can do many of what these things do at a better
- 22:42way of just securing your value and as well as just the
- 22:46different layers, we'll be able to share this value just as
- 22:50quickly as any of these other stable coins and and block
- 22:53chains that they're trying to develop.
- 22:56Yeah, the there's two aspects. I don't think, I think the
- 23:01strategic people know this, the amount of disintermediation this
- 23:04is going to do to local Fiat currencies, I'll come back to
- 23:08that because of Gusto. I'm curious on your thoughts or
- 23:10the other one though, is good money throwing away good money
- 23:15for bad or bad money for good? I know River was the one that I
- 23:19believe first did this where you could park your checking account
- 23:22via lead bank and then sweep those excess yield into Bitcoin.
- 23:28That's part of Galaxy 1's deal as you can basically auto
- 23:31convert that yield into Bitcoin or that, yeah, additional
- 23:34dollars, which I think is interesting for people that
- 23:36first want their exposure or if they're going to, you know,
- 23:38naturally have dollar liabilities, you have a cash
- 23:40account. So I think these things will
- 23:42naturally proliferate, which is just a better experience.
- 23:45But going back to the first point, Gustavo, I'm curious like
- 23:48how do you see that with stable coins and Bitcoin just
- 23:51disintermediating a lot of like local sovereign structures?
- 23:55Because I've talked to. Individuals in Latin America
- 23:57where certain countries have like 24% interest rates just to
- 24:01get dollars working capital for just a regular business.
- 24:05And so a lot of entrepreneurs that understand Bitcoin are
- 24:07starting to look at like, how do you bring Bitcoin into there?
- 24:09Whether it's lending their own Bitcoin capital to get dollars
- 24:12to lend back to businesses, which obviously has execution
- 24:15risk, or eventually when businesses hold some form of
- 24:17Bitcoin in their corporate treasury, that's a lot easier
- 24:20way to effectively get, you know, even if it's 8 to 12%,
- 24:23it's still much better than 24%. And you don't need local rails
- 24:26especially as well becomes dollarized.
- 24:29Just curious if you have any thoughts there what you're
- 24:31seeing. Yeah, No, you, you couldn't be
- 24:35more right on this MIC. Like I think in, in Mexico
- 24:39alone, the just the central Bank rate is, is about 9%.
- 24:43So business loans start at 20 minimum.
- 24:47And, and Mexico's is, is a stable country in comparison
- 24:50with like Venezuela, Argentina and Bolivia, where, where
- 24:54government rates have started at 80%, you know, so, so yeah, for
- 24:58sure the, the, the credit market is, is, is definitely having a,
- 25:02a big impact here. And it's going to have more and
- 25:04more, I think MIC multi institutional, multi
- 25:07institutional custody is, is required to have a, a secure way
- 25:12to to offer these build these credit markets on top of
- 25:14Bitcoin. And but, but yeah, definitely I
- 25:18think the most interesting case has been probably Bolivia were
- 25:21in the past year, stablecoins and Bitcoins have completely
- 25:26replaced the the country's financial system.
- 25:29Like even in the airport of the main city in Bolivia of the
- 25:33capital prices are now in USD T, you know, so it's just been a
- 25:37complete replacement of their financial system with with
- 25:42stablecoins and Bitcoin, which what what had been seen
- 25:45previously in Venezuela and Argentina has now taken full
- 25:49shape in, in Bolivia. So yeah, definitely something
- 25:53with big interest. Just hear a big narrative that's
- 25:55boiling up. We're going to hear a lot of
- 25:58that more soon. Yeah.
- 26:01And continuing along the the path of of Latin America and and
- 26:06adoption there, there was another headline around new
- 26:10bank, new bank applies for U.S. National bank charter.
- 26:15Gustavo, any, any thoughts on this one?
- 26:16Maybe you know, provide some context around new bank and and
- 26:19what this means. Yeah, Nubank is Brazil's biggest
- 26:24Fintech application and at this point, I think just biggest
- 26:27financial platform in in Brazil. It's also extremely popular in
- 26:33Mexico and in Colombia, I think at least 10% of Mexicans,
- 26:39Colombians, Argentinians have new bank in Brazil has to be
- 26:43more than than 25. So it's it's also a publicly
- 26:47traded company and it's been on the space for for a while,
- 26:50right. So it's it's jumping on on, on
- 26:52crypto. It jumped on on on crypto a
- 26:54couple years ago. Now they, they seem to have a
- 26:57more Bitcoin focused strategy with their latest hire, which
- 27:02maybe Michael, you can, you can add more context on that.
- 27:05But does this just natural evolution for them?
- 27:09And I think this was also this I'm speculating here, but I
- 27:13believe the Trump's White House has, has invited Nubank and
- 27:17other Latin American companies to come to the US.
- 27:19You know, we're, we're now open for business.
- 27:21Come build here too. I know that the CEO of Bizzo,
- 27:25which is the, the big like the Coinbase of Latin America, he
- 27:28was invited to the White House. So obviously Nubank would would
- 27:32have been too right. So this doesn't surprise me much
- 27:36and I think we'll see a lot more of this.
- 27:41Michael, anything on this one? Yeah, Nubank is incredibly
- 27:46fascinating. I think they're the largest,
- 27:50like fintech out after like anyone that would be in China.
- 27:54They've succeeded on a number of things.
- 27:56One is in Latin America, I think it's close to 650 million users
- 28:01or potential users. I think they have roughly 90
- 28:03million of them, which is already crazy.
- 28:07But there is an aspect that doesn't really get discussed
- 28:11and, and Gustavo referenced it. So it's my understanding that
- 28:15from a leadership perspective, specifically the CEO, he's a, he
- 28:18gets Bitcoin very deeply. And there's a lot of moves that
- 28:22they've done to signal that from being very early and getting
- 28:25involved with digital assets in Bitcoin to most recently, I
- 28:28think it was last week of the week before they brought on
- 28:30Michael Riani, who was formerly at Cash App and Square and then
- 28:34was leading Coinbase. I think his title was like head
- 28:36of Bitcoin or something related directly to Bitcoin and he
- 28:39joined. And that bank charter's
- 28:42fascinating to see the examples of whether it's we talked a
- 28:47little bit about this in Brazil, they pioneered something called
- 28:50the Pix, Pix network, which was just better integrations with
- 28:53the central bank to be able to deliver payment rails and
- 28:56capital flows. And so whether it's how they
- 29:00leverage that in the US given their scale and best practices
- 29:04all the way to when you think about remittances from the US to
- 29:08Latin America and vertically integrating that, leveraging
- 29:11crypto to do it. I think that's a huge thing that
- 29:14gets under discussed because we'll talk a little bit about
- 29:18the all the names are kind of start to merge together, but
- 29:23it's Spark launched. I forgot whatever.
- 29:27We'll we'll we'll reference the exact name of it.
- 29:28But the point being is that for years there's been a lot of
- 29:32crypto natives talking about payments and rails, but it's not
- 29:35necessarily that the the tech isn't there, it's that the
- 29:37distribution and consumer commercial behavior isn't there
- 29:43or hasn't been there. And so when you get somebody
- 29:45like Nubank with their total addressable market, and then
- 29:48also in a crypto friendly environment where they can get a
- 29:51a license, like every bank got it in like 6 weeks or whatever
- 29:54the time was, it starts to get really interesting on what is a
- 29:57digital application look like to manage one's wealth.
- 30:00So I think this is something very fascinating to pay
- 30:02attention to. And obviously Nubank is a huge
- 30:05giant after the major visas amexes of the world, I think
- 30:10their valuations closer to like $40 billion.
- 30:14Yeah. I would also add the one other
- 30:18thing too is just with them trying to get the OCC charter
- 30:21and we've seen a ton of different crypto firms now also
- 30:25try to branch out and try to get National Bank charters here in
- 30:28the US And I think Bridge just filed for that as well.
- 30:31We're just seeing a professionalization and a
- 30:34checking of the boxes of what all of the traditional financial
- 30:39players really want, right? And we've also seen on the other
- 30:43side, a, you know, more Bitcoin native side of what really
- 30:48Bitcoiners want, especially in the early days.
- 30:51But I think that there is still a gap out there of kind of
- 30:55bridging those two of deep Bitcoin understanding and
- 30:59offering the best products and services like a multi
- 31:02institution custody globally to, you know, not just adding on,
- 31:09you know, OCC charter on top of proof of reserves or something
- 31:12like that. And then saying, OK, we, we did
- 31:14it and satisfied all of the, you know, requirements and, and this
- 31:18is, you know, mission success. So I would say like that's still
- 31:24a big opportunity out there. But it just signals that because
- 31:28they're doing all of this with National Bank charters and OCC
- 31:30requirements, they are seeing a lot of interest for customers,
- 31:34or at least institutional customers, or at least like
- 31:37trying to court them pretty heavily.
- 31:40Yeah, that's well said. All right.
- 31:45We maybe just one more headline as it relates to sort of what
- 31:48we've been talking about here and you know, we've been focused
- 31:51sort of internationally, but back domestically in the US city
- 31:56targets 2026 launch for crypto custody service.
- 31:59There was another headline also related to Charles Schwab, very
- 32:02similar that they're going to launch, you know, the ability to
- 32:05trade and and custody digital assets in 2026, which I think
- 32:09that's actually the most interesting part about these
- 32:12couple headlines is just the, the longer sort of cycle for
- 32:17these things to play out, which may elongate the proverbial
- 32:21Bitcoin cycle. If you know, a lot of these
- 32:23things are getting turned on the plumbing, the access in 2026,
- 32:28that sort of flies in the face of what you know, people
- 32:32historically think about Bitcoin cycles and you know, the timing
- 32:36of such. So it's just interesting to see
- 32:38this play out because I think there will be all of this latent
- 32:43demand that continues to get unlocked, whether it's through
- 32:46ETFSCTPS, all these different products that are, you know, set
- 32:50to be launched next year. I I think that's just an
- 32:53interesting dynamic sort of juxtapose against historical
- 32:57cycle timing. Yeah.
- 33:00Well, maybe this will go to the transition.
- 33:02I think it's a great point, something we've been talking
- 33:06about, You know, whether it's public news or private news,
- 33:09everyone in this industry talks with individuals that are
- 33:11turning things on for mass market adoption.
- 33:15And so that effectively doesn't get priced in.
- 33:17And then this cycle, regardless, there's no shortage of ways to
- 33:21look at it from the price and the unlock from people selling
- 33:25to the demand that's come from these other pockets specifically
- 33:28like ETFs. City and Schwab as an example,
- 33:33are huge players to get in, came out the week before Vanguard,
- 33:37you know, naturally looking at letting their clients get
- 33:39exposure. I think this ties into what we
- 33:44brought Gustavo on to talk about.
- 33:46And but before that, I think this will tie into it.
- 33:51There's an I don't, I haven't fully figured out how to express
- 33:54this. We talk about it a lot where the
- 33:58market is still so early, there's only so many
- 34:01sophisticated players in it. And now what I mean players, I
- 34:04mean individuals. And the reason why is because
- 34:07very few people on the planet earth treat Bitcoin as money,
- 34:11like treated as money, treated as a savings technology.
- 34:14And because of that, we still, and there's there's a chicken or
- 34:20egg problem of like how can you treat it as money or savings
- 34:22technology if you don't have a good form of custody and good
- 34:24partners and financial services. And this is fundamentally the
- 34:27reason why majority of bitcoins sits in self custody on
- 34:31effectively ledgers. And I know that sounds crazy,
- 34:33but it's just empirically true. Ledger is the vast majority of
- 34:36market share from Harvard wallets and the vast majority of
- 34:38Bitcoins sits in those hardware wallets because you had to sever
- 34:41the Internet connection if you didn't want to get rugged by
- 34:43Celsius, blocked by Genesis, FTX, blah, blah, blah.
- 34:46So if you go down that progression, there's still such
- 34:50a small cohort that have exposure.
- 34:51And so whether it's new bank, Charles Schwab, Citi or whoever
- 34:55else, the first step like everyone is not to go 1025 fifty
- 35:00100% as a savings technology. It's just dabbling.
- 35:03It's dabbling either in crypto or in Bitcoin.
- 35:06And and so that leaves a huge opportunity because today on
- 35:11ramp, our portfolio companies, we treat the most sophisticated
- 35:14investors because they've naturally had to go through what
- 35:16we've learned. And they come out the other side
- 35:18realizing, oh God, like I value on chain, I value segregation of
- 35:24custody and cold storage, but I also value my life and I value
- 35:28the fact that I need access to financial services and I need my
- 35:30wife to be able to inherit this if I get hit by a bus.
- 35:34And so that's what we build for and invest in.
- 35:36And so maybe that's kind of like a dovetail to explaining why,
- 35:39you know, we're really excited about this opportunity.
- 35:41And I don't know, Brian, do you want me to share or do you
- 35:45should be like Gustavo? How do you how do you want to
- 35:47run the? Maybe, maybe you'd tee it up
- 35:49Michael, and then hand it to Gustavo to give more on his
- 35:52background and how it came to be.
- 35:54OK. So super excited about this.
- 35:56Gustavo and I have known each other for a few years now since
- 35:59he had been running Verify, which was acquired by Bull
- 36:02Bitcoin. And then for the past couple
- 36:04years he's been working on Swapito, which is a Latin
- 36:06American on ramp for Bitcoin. And Swapito was gaining traction
- 36:10looking for, you know, investment to really start to
- 36:13scale that business. And we started discussing maybe
- 36:16close to a year ago a little less about an opportunity to
- 36:19participate, but part of our mandate.
- 36:21And really what we look at our thesis is the best in class
- 36:24businesses in the future state, whether it's 2 to 5 to 10 years,
- 36:27will be built on multi institution custody for a number
- 36:30of reasons from Better Business economics, unit economics, all
- 36:34the way to better client experience so that they can buy
- 36:37larger amounts and hold it. And then just ultimately a
- 36:40better lifetime value with the client being able to custody
- 36:45those assets. And then as the market grows and
- 36:48Bitcoin financializes, to be able to offer financial services
- 36:51and not have that leakage. It's not to say that clients
- 36:54can't take self custody in the same way with on rim.
- 36:57And so when we met with Gustavo, we had brought up, you know,
- 37:00we'd love to invest and get involved, but multi institution,
- 37:03we feel like we'd have to play a huge part if we were going to
- 37:05invest because we thought Latin American best in class business
- 37:07would be built on it. And it was us being transparent.
- 37:11And but I and so we end up investing.
- 37:12But maybe Gustavo, after you tell your story, I'd love to
- 37:15hear if you can hear the, the anecdote, because I shared a lot
- 37:18where you went to your brain trust to present the idea
- 37:20because I think you thought it was interesting, but you still
- 37:22needed to validate it. And I think that really speaks
- 37:25to the the opportunity set that the folks you talked to had a
- 37:28certain insider lens into what we're building here.
- 37:32Certainly. Thank you so much, Michael for,
- 37:34for that introduction. So well, I, I've been in the
- 37:38Bitcoin space now for, for seven years.
- 37:41I am Peruvian, but I grew up in Montreal, Canada and I've been
- 37:46living in Mexico now for the past four years.
- 37:50Audio's my well swapito and now name as Audio is my third
- 37:55company. I had a first mining project
- 37:58that didn't go so well, was very inexperienced.
- 38:01Then they verify that was more successful.
- 38:03We, we had platform where you could buy, sell Bitcoin in in
- 38:07Canada and then it was Aqui out. We got Aqui hired by bull
- 38:12bitcoins. We all went to work there.
- 38:16I've worked at Wasabi and now I'm also a writer at Bitcoin
- 38:20Optech, which is a technical newsletter and I launched
- 38:23Schwapito over the past year as a solution that I needed for
- 38:27myself. I live on the Bitcoin Center for
- 38:30multiple years. Maybe that's a bit unusual, but
- 38:33for me it's, it's, it's been a, a great experience.
- 38:36And so I built Swapito as a ways that I could just live on
- 38:40Bitcoin easily in Mexico and I could pay people with like bank
- 38:43transfers, but I only had my lightning wallet.
- 38:46But it it had obviously a, a certain limit, right in, in
- 38:50terms of of of adoption, because like in Mexico, the, the first
- 38:55step is to actually get people to buy Bitcoin, which just
- 38:58hasn't been, but been the case in anywhere, but here even less
- 39:02so. Yeah, I think audio was born
- 39:06from that reception from the market, but it was then also it
- 39:12also came to life with conversations from all with all
- 39:15of you guys. I think multi institution
- 39:18custody is, is the only acceptable form of custody for,
- 39:23for self custody maximalist as I am, You know, I've been, I've
- 39:27been advising and helping people with, with self custody for,
- 39:32from, for almost a decade now. And, and I knew that though the,
- 39:37the there's been a lot of friction on the self custody
- 39:39experience and I wanted to provide a custodial experience,
- 39:43although I didn't feel extremely comfortable with, with the
- 39:45traditional custodial exchange single point of failure
- 39:51infrastructures, right? But I think multi institutional
- 39:54custody resonated with me for, for that reason.
- 39:58But also, as you mentioned, Michael, when I brought this
- 40:01idea to friends, clients in the region, in Mexico specifically,
- 40:07there's been great reception, you know, because first of all,
- 40:11because the region it has like specific security issues.
- 40:16That are just not part of an Americans or an Europeans
- 40:20lifestyle, you know hear people get kidnapped extorted very
- 40:26often you know and everybody's always very concerned about
- 40:29security. So as, as soon as I mentioned
- 40:33this to to many Mexican friends that both Bitcoiners and and non
- 40:38bitcoiners, this immediately resonated.
- 40:41So, so I guess I was looking for for for differentiator.
- 40:46I was looking for a custody model that made a self custody
- 40:51proponent like myself comfortable and be able to sleep
- 40:54at night. So it just makes total sense to
- 40:58to do this right. So thank you, Michael, Liam and
- 41:01Brian. I'm very excited to, to start
- 41:03this new journey. I think we're, we're going to be
- 41:05very successful in our market. We have everything we need to
- 41:09succeed. I've reunited the old verified
- 41:12team under Audio 2. Nate Kits is joining us as a
- 41:17fractional CTO. He works at Zaprite.
- 41:20Tristan Borges is joining us from Bitcoin.
- 41:22Well, he was head of design and he's joining us as CPO.
- 41:26And finally, Magic Sepnick, who was head of social media at Bid
- 41:30Refill, is joining us as CMO. So I'm very excited to to follow
- 41:35the next steps and thank you so much for for bringing me on on
- 41:38the show. Yeah, we're we're incredibly
- 41:42excited. I think as we talked about, I
- 41:46think it gets widely misunderstood and emphasize that
- 41:50Bitcoin is money and money requires financial services, but
- 41:53those are ultimately localized. And so you will not only need
- 41:57local presences, but then local custody in that market.
- 42:01And so this plays a huge part into the long term vision of
- 42:04building out on ramps and keys in different markets across the
- 42:06world. But then also a testament to you
- 42:09guys really being veterans in the Bitcoin space, but then also
- 42:15in the business building space, because something that we really
- 42:18tout and where the venture fund comes from and why we get early
- 42:22stage and also early riders in the name.
- 42:24Is that really the understanding of unit economics and building
- 42:29the right business from the ground up at the earliest stage
- 42:31is paramount. Because if you go too far
- 42:34without that, you kind of lose the the right foundation from
- 42:37business building. And this is something that you
- 42:39guys really talked about and embodied where just the
- 42:43understanding of trying to build the best company, the best
- 42:45economics to build a sustainable business with being very
- 42:49conservative and lean is something that really excited to
- 42:52see. I think we're getting more and
- 42:54more of that as people realize that all these deflationary
- 43:00tools and is like we usually talk about SAS and AI, but the
- 43:04thing that doesn't even get discussed a lot and maybe we can
- 43:07talk about later and you can share Gustavo is thinking about
- 43:09the amount of rails that come in from a liquidity perspective
- 43:12from local fiats, whether it's Latin America or US into BTC in
- 43:15the infrastructure was just not there before.
- 43:18So if you wanted to go get those licenses, you wanted to get
- 43:20onboarded would cost millions of dollars in time.
- 43:23And then even building out your own custody would have to cost
- 43:26millions of dollars in time. And it ultimately all looks the
- 43:28same versus being able to plug into something like multi
- 43:31institution offer differentiated service.
- 43:33So really excited about it. I'm sure Liam and and Brian also
- 43:36have some thoughts to share. No, I think that's very well
- 43:40said. I think it's also really
- 43:42exciting. You know, the team is is great
- 43:45and have enjoyed working with you guys thus far and love your
- 43:49background. If you know, both being very
- 43:51technically, technically strong across, you know, everything
- 43:55that you're doing on, on the Bitcoin Optec side and, and
- 43:58Nate's great as well, as well as the rest of your team.
- 44:01And, and just would also mention it's, it's an exciting time for
- 44:05distributed keys as well. Just having them globally across
- 44:08the world in, in areas where, you know, people have concerns
- 44:14about, you know, local confiscation risk, such as areas
- 44:18in Latin America and, and others.
- 44:20They you just want the fact that while, while you can have
- 44:24localized, you know, key signers and custodians in in different
- 44:28jurisdictions, it's also interesting in a really big
- 44:31value proposition to have, you know, the actual, the rest of
- 44:36the custodians distributed across the world in order to
- 44:38mitigate against local risks as well.
- 44:43But yeah, couldn't be more excited to announce this.
- 44:46And and Tabio is part of the team Gustavo.
- 44:50Yeah, the echo all that super exciting and you know, you can
- 44:55start to see, you know, if you squint the the sort of what Liam
- 44:59was alluding to around this network of keys around the
- 45:03world. And the adoption of this
- 45:05standard, I think is super critical and something that
- 45:09Gustavo picked up on super early in our discussions of, you know,
- 45:13effectively at the end of the day, like more custodians is
- 45:17better than one in some sense of if you can eliminate that single
- 45:21point of failure and distribute that counterparty risk, that's
- 45:24naturally advantageous to long term security.
- 45:28And you know, part of the story here too is, you know, a buy and
- 45:32sell exchange is interesting. But again, I think you know,
- 45:36what is often lost is the core value prop of Bitcoin today as
- 45:40we sit here is, is value preservation and storage.
- 45:43And so the ability to actually have a venue where not only can
- 45:47you buy and sell, but you can actually store those assets for
- 45:50the long term and access financial services is going to
- 45:53be really critical over this next, you know, call it decade
- 45:56to two decade, decade period, where people are saving in, in
- 46:01hard money, Bitcoin predominantly, and spending
- 46:04their dollars, whether it's stable coins or, or other forms
- 46:06of Fiat. That is, is, is sort of going to
- 46:10be the, the main method of, you know, financial services going
- 46:16forward. And, and the ability to have
- 46:19that distribution of risk while still having localized services
- 46:22is really what this is getting at.
- 46:24And so super excited to have this announced and out there.
- 46:29Go ahead, Mike. Yeah, Yeah.
- 46:31I think it's a great recap and I think something that is a a very
- 46:36large blind spot in this ecosystem, specifically Bitcoin
- 46:40only businesses building. The best example, it's not
- 46:44apples to apples, but is when I think about Uber and when they
- 46:48were out raising, a lot of VCs or people involved really passed
- 46:53because they looked at the total addressable market for cabs and
- 46:56they either saw that as a total addressable market or only Uber
- 47:00as a very high profile, high net worth product.
- 47:05And the thing that they discounted was the gaps in the
- 47:08market around just transportation in general.
- 47:11When you can offer a better experience.
- 47:12Well, that looks like 10 to 100 X market adoption or need.
- 47:17And I think of Bitcoin and Bitcoin custody as a very
- 47:20similar example where it's a blind spot in these Bitcoin only
- 47:24firms that just tell like everyone, they have to self
- 47:27custody and they don't offer either any custody offering or
- 47:30any differentiated because that'll always exist.
- 47:33If you're building the right business, everyone should have
- 47:35the option. But the thing that they discount
- 47:37is when a net new person buys Bitcoin and experiences, whether
- 47:41building previously or also just seen it first hand, somebody
- 47:46that you know, let's call an investor in a Bitcoin only
- 47:49company, you know, tells a friend you should go buy some
- 47:52Bitcoin and they go and buy anywhere between 100K to
- 47:55$1,000,000 and they take it and they put it in a Ledger or hard
- 47:59or hardware device. That's historically how it's
- 48:00worked. And most people say, well, that
- 48:03sounds great, I made some money. But the reality is that person,
- 48:05if they're worth 100, they're generally worth about $100
- 48:07million because nobody parks $1,000,000 in BTC on their first
- 48:11clip based on somebody saying unless they have a lot of extra
- 48:14capital. And what you're ultimately
- 48:17saying is A, you don't have any exposure to that underlying.
- 48:20B, you probably could have over time, if not there gotten larger
- 48:24clip of revenue fees and trading if you would have had a better
- 48:27experience. And then C, ultimately, there's
- 48:29only 21 million of these Bitcoin until you naturally want to be
- 48:34as close and provide as much value because that will
- 48:37ultimately be the leaders in the world.
- 48:39That's our thesis is that if you can provide services around that
- 48:42as Bitcoin monetizing, you'll have no shortage of ways to be
- 48:45able to generate revenue because it'll be a capital base for the
- 48:47new world. And so these are things that
- 48:49we've just seen as gaps. And while we still work with
- 48:52partners and are integrating other custodians, we also think
- 48:54ground up businesses will ultimately be able to leapfrog a
- 48:58lot of companies. And that's probably the most
- 49:00exciting thing for me because I don't think of audio as having a
- 49:03competitor in Latin America in the same way, I don't think we
- 49:05really have any competitors in the US.
- 49:07And if we do, it's BlackRock and infidelity because they have
- 49:09these 100 year old or Fidelity has 100 year old brand that you
- 49:12have to compete with, but nobody else does multi institution
- 49:15custody. Everyone else tells you you have
- 49:17to go parking a Ledger device. You have to go create a wallet
- 49:20config file and separate across the world or across your state
- 49:23and you have to bury it. And you have to worry about
- 49:25inheritance. You have to worry about title
- 49:26versus possession. Oh, and by the way, if the asset
- 49:28appreciates, you have to worry about somebody kidnapping your
- 49:30family. And then, oh, by the way, you
- 49:32also have to worry about if you need to sell it or take a loan
- 49:34out, you have to go to the secret places.
- 49:36You secured it. And now we have a solution for
- 49:39that. And so it's just an incredible.
- 49:41And what is that opportunity? Well, it's everyone because if
- 49:43all the money's going to come into Bitcoin on a long enough
- 49:45time horizon. Well, in that same analogy with
- 49:47Uber, you have to be able to offer the goods and services
- 49:50that meet the demand of a market that people can't see because
- 49:53they just, they think of these either ideological terms or, or
- 49:56whatever it is around either self custody or Coinbase will be
- 49:59the only ways to, to interact with this new financial asset.
- 50:05And it's just fundamentally not true.
- 50:08Couldn't agree more with everything you all of you said.
- 50:12I think the, to, to Liam's point about the risks of that, that we
- 50:17see a jurisdictional risk and just security risk we've been
- 50:21talking about these just couldn't be more important to
- 50:24the average Latin American investor than almost anywhere
- 50:27else in the world, right? Like jurisdictional risk is, is
- 50:30becoming, has, has been part of, of, of the Latin American
- 50:33experience and is becoming a trending topic.
- 50:36Now again, with all this political consolidation we're
- 50:39seeing and, and, and new regimes.
- 50:42So everyone is very concerned about that this, this provides a
- 50:45solution for that. And so, so I think it just makes
- 50:49total sense. And to the to the non custody,
- 50:52to the self custody experience, like I, I'm a big proponent of
- 50:56that. But just this week I had a call
- 50:59with with a lady that came to the meet ups that I organized
- 51:03back in 2019. And she's been in the big in
- 51:08like a bitcoiner for years. And she'd lost all her Bitcoin
- 51:13because she didn't understand that creating a new ad like she
- 51:17backed up a new seat and she just thought she had to grade
- 51:20and get a new address from their wallet.
- 51:22You know, like in Etherium, they have like one out one wallet
- 51:25equals 1 address. So she thought it was the same.
- 51:29And she just started by switching addresses.
- 51:31She was using a new wallet, but she was still on the old wallet.
- 51:35So she just lost all her her savings like that.
- 51:38So you hear these stories and you're like, no, some people,
- 51:42some some people just don't need this, this complication.
- 51:46Even if they've been in it for years, it still doesn't work.
- 51:49I think this provides a, a well balanced risk approach.
- 51:53MIC is is is that so I, I couldn't believe in this more.
- 51:58And on to the to the other point about being a lean startup, I
- 52:03think with AI in place today, we're, we're able to do that 10
- 52:08times the work we were able to do in our, in our previous
- 52:11startup, right? So it's not just the experience
- 52:14that we've gained since then, but also the, the tools that are
- 52:17at our our disposal to be able to be lean.
- 52:21I think that's more relevant than ever, particularly when you
- 52:24consider Bitcoin as the hurdle rate within this framework,
- 52:29right? Then then you just understand
- 52:31that only startups that are able to scale with and to remain lean
- 52:37and scale with AI tools are going to be the ones that are
- 52:40able to, to, to fit within the Bitcoin and hurdle rate
- 52:44narrative, right. So all of this combined just
- 52:48makes it clear that that this is the the approach to take.
- 52:52And I think already being Bitcoin only differentiates us
- 52:57in our markets where the the Chinko narratives have been way
- 53:01more present than almost anywhere else I've been.
- 53:06And adding multi institution custody and a white glove best
- 53:13in class brand to this just makes it so that I, I really
- 53:18don't, I, I see it the same way. I don't, I don't think I think
- 53:21we're in a legal part. I think customers are going to
- 53:23are going to see it that way. That's the reception I've been
- 53:25getting so far yet. So this is all very exciting.
- 53:29Yeah, that's a great point too on just the fact that everybody
- 53:33knows that there's jurisdictional risk too.
- 53:35And so while it's not necessarily, you know, immediate
- 53:39or actionable, there's a really nice opportunity here too that
- 53:42we also saw for Areo to be infrastructure partner to other
- 53:48local fintechs, banks and financial institutions who want
- 53:52to partner with multi institution custody.
- 53:54The reality is, just like how money goes from softer money to
- 53:59harder money over long enough time horizon, so does custody to
- 54:03go from the worst custody to the better custody.
- 54:06And so accordingly, those customers will be the ones on
- 54:10the edges who will seek out better custody.
- 54:12But there will inevitably be internal champions of your
- 54:16product or service within the largest local players.
- 54:19And then there's a a nice opportunity for you to offer an
- 54:22ability for them to plug in and, and offer all the legal and, you
- 54:27know, operational constructs around being key holders down in
- 54:30Latin America. So couldn't be more excited
- 54:33about this opportunity. And and there's just so much
- 54:35here. Yeah, it's a huge validation on
- 54:38our part. Gustavo, for you the team, think
- 54:41about Nate as an example who was at Unchained scene first hand.
- 54:45We just seen this, whether it's investors and early riders or
- 54:48clients of on Ramp and also now portfolio companies we've
- 54:52invested in, they're just frankly are and it sounds like
- 54:54we're talking our book. But the most sophisticated
- 54:56people in the market because they've had to go through and
- 54:59build and see the gaps in the market to come out the other
- 55:01side and realize what we're talking about here.
- 55:04And this is kind of the definition of alpha because the
- 55:06rest of the market is still saying a different thing and we
- 55:09can see it's really just price. Frankly, as the price
- 55:12appreciates, all of these things become incredibly paramount.
- 55:15I experienced this back in 2020, building and chain in 2021 as
- 55:18the price rose, everyone seeks better fault tolerant, redundant
- 55:22solutions because that's just rational sense.
- 55:24If you're storing your economic value in a digital currency, you
- 55:27cannot get knocked out of the game because your C phrase
- 55:30messed up or somebody kidnapped you or took your family.
- 55:34The other thing that's super fascinating that maybe we can
- 55:36spend a quick second on is really the notion of Bitcoin as
- 55:39a hurdle rate. This is something that, you
- 55:41know, we really kind of pioneered.
- 55:43We put out our white people two years ago.
- 55:45The denomination was really important because it was the
- 55:47right thing to do. Now it's obviously playing on
- 55:49hard mode because you have to return Bitcoin, which they don't
- 55:52make more of or they make very little annually for a while
- 55:55specific to dollars. But the point being, as I was
- 55:58listening recently to Luke Roman, who is just one of the
- 56:02greatest minds and not only understanding where we're going,
- 56:05but really the understanding of when you think about AI.
- 56:08And there was like this stat that came that he was
- 56:11referencing that by 2032, like the average worker from like a,
- 56:15a human, like manual production will be roughly $5 per hour,
- 56:22meaning that we will have robots being able to do so.
- 56:24We have like 6 years roughly where human robots will be able
- 56:29to do a lot of this work. So just insane deflationary
- 56:32forces, which will naturally put a huge strain on the global debt
- 56:35markets, business building. And so investors are
- 56:38increasingly going to wake up with this new kind of narrative
- 56:40around debasement trade and what what has happened with Bitcoin
- 56:43and gold that they're just going to naturally start denominating
- 56:46and requiring the denomination of their investments to be in
- 56:50hard assets. Because that's basically will be
- 56:54the heuristic if a company has the right long term opportunity,
- 57:00because if you don't have any dollars, you're ultimately in
- 57:02building a business like a traditional dollar VC backed
- 57:04firm. You're going to get out competed
- 57:07by the the companies that build and start from the ground up.
- 57:10And I think that's still widely misunderstood and misprice.
- 57:13It's just rational in the same way we talk about bitcoins,
- 57:15rational multi institution, rational building with Bitcoin
- 57:18or gold as your hurdle rate. It really simple.
- 57:21It just increases your cost of capital, which increases the
- 57:23discernment and efficiency of the entrepreneur.
- 57:27And that's the name of the game in business.
- 57:28People don't talk about business is ultimately war, like you're
- 57:30competing with somebody else and they're trying to become more
- 57:33efficient than you. And the person that has the
- 57:35right incentive model is ultimately going to outcompete
- 57:37the others if they have the right entrepreneurs, the right
- 57:40founders, but then the right underlying denominator.
- 57:43And so I appreciate you bringing up the hurl rate because it
- 57:45sounds like a novelty, but it's frankly the only way once you
- 57:48understand all this stuff to invest and build a business, if
- 57:51you're going to if you want to have a fighting chance to out
- 57:53compete the next company that comes with that same lens.
- 57:56Today we're kind of running circles because we're just
- 57:58already understand it. But you know, information leaks,
- 58:01people will do this and then naturally we'll have competitors
- 58:03and you want already have all of that market knowledge, tribal
- 58:07knowledge to be already building and then it compound while other
- 58:09people are just starting. Are you a Bitcoin treasury
- 58:12company? Are you a private company, a
- 58:14public company? Do you have Bitcoin on the
- 58:16balance sheet or do you want to acquire Bitcoin for your balance
- 58:19sheet? Well, we just launched on ramp
- 58:21business this week. The future of corporate treasury
- 58:24is here. You can see on the screen here a
- 58:26little bit more about it, but at the end of the day, we're
- 58:29solving for the biggest pain point in corporate adoption,
- 58:32which is custody. So you can use multi institution
- 58:35custody to secure the Bitcoin on your balance sheet.
- 58:38In addition to that, you have Lloyds of London insurance, you
- 58:41have role based access controls to build governance into your
- 58:45organization. You also have real time proof of
- 58:49reserves, 24/7 cryptographic proof of reserves for your own
- 58:52dedicated wallet. And really, this is solving for,
- 58:55at the end of the day, security of your Bitcoin for your
- 58:59business. Business continuity, which has
- 59:02often fallen short for many organizations, whether it's just
- 59:05managing keys internally or relying on a single institution.
- 59:09And maybe perhaps most importantly, eliminating single
- 59:12points of failure. If you are a business and you're
- 59:14relying on a single custodian, that is a significant amount of
- 59:18counterparty risk. And likewise, if you're managing
- 59:20keys internally, then there is a lot of room for error.
- 59:24So get in touch with us here at Onramp.
- 59:26We just launched our business solution and we'd love to speak
- 59:30with you. So head to our website
- 59:31onrampbitcoin.com and book a consultation to learn more.
- 59:37That's exactly right and really liked your comment to Gustavo
- 59:41and already living on a Bitcoin standard too, because it's
- 59:44important to actually, you know, be living it and see how it
- 59:48impacts your you from a personal perspective.
- 59:50And then the it's just natural for your business to use the
- 59:54same type of hurdle rate and living live that business on a
- 59:57Bitcoin standard as well. Just because you can understand,
- 1:00:00you know this, I've benefited from it at a personal level.
- 1:00:03Let me apply this to all their businesses and you know we've
- 1:00:05all tried to do that with our former.
- 1:00:07Businesses in the past to mixed degrees of success just because
- 1:00:11there, there will be some businesses that you know, are,
- 1:00:15are naturally a little bit more understanding and open to new
- 1:00:18suggestions and better opportunities.
- 1:00:20But there's just so much bureaucracy, compliance and
- 1:00:23stagnation in the current current way of doing things that
- 1:00:27it's it's very few companies at the beginning, but it's only
- 1:00:30going to be catch on more and more.
- 1:00:34Yeah, I'm brought. I'm glad you brought up the
- 1:00:36hurdle rate concept because it is fundamental to everything we
- 1:00:39do. And it's, it's just such a
- 1:00:41fascinating time right now with gold doing what it's doing and
- 1:00:45this idea of the basement being much more in the zeitgeist and
- 1:00:50less taboo than I think historically it was.
- 1:00:53You know, gold bugs for decades have effectively been telling
- 1:00:56the story around Fiat debasement and basically, yeah, you know,
- 1:01:00yelling into the clouds. No one was really listening to
- 1:01:02them. And I think this most recent
- 1:01:05gold move is, is opening a lot of people's eyes.
- 1:01:07And so you've seen, you know, what you consider more incumbent
- 1:01:11type type folks talking about this concept of debasement.
- 1:01:14You know, tweeting out charts that show equity returns
- 1:01:17denominated in gold or Bitcoin is just a, a, a pretty large
- 1:01:22pivot from where we've been historically in terms of people
- 1:01:24talking about these concepts. Because, you know, we've also
- 1:01:27talked at length about this, you know, the notion of nominal
- 1:01:30versus real returns, it's all related to this debasement
- 1:01:34trade, right? But when people historically
- 1:01:36think about nominal unreal, they're doing some adjustment
- 1:01:39for, you know, government issued CPI.
- 1:01:42And so that's how they're getting from nominal to real.
- 1:01:44I think the, the actual take away from what's happening is
- 1:01:47that we're going beyond just that, just looking at CPI as
- 1:01:50nominal versus real and actually going to well, what's the real,
- 1:01:54real, you know, level of inflation, level of debasement
- 1:01:57that's occurring. And for that you, you're, you
- 1:01:59know, you're better off looking at actual monetary units, M2
- 1:02:04creation of new money. And that rate starts to look a
- 1:02:06little bit more dramatic than the two 3% CPI.
- 1:02:11And so the, the extension of that is OK, if you're looking at
- 1:02:14the basement in terms of new monetary units, then you know,
- 1:02:18you should look at actual hard assets, hard money, gold or
- 1:02:21Bitcoin as what is quote UN quote real.
- 1:02:23And so that denominator shifts from saying, OK, we're going to
- 1:02:27price these things in dollars. Just, you know, the easiest
- 1:02:29example of looking at the S&P or the NASDAQ over the past 5 to 20
- 1:02:33years and instead pricing that in gold or or Bitcoin, like that
- 1:02:37is the new version of quote UN quote real relative to to
- 1:02:40nominal. And that is like a pretty
- 1:02:43fundamental and and radical shift.
- 1:02:45And just in terms of the discussion and the discourse
- 1:02:47around Fiat debasement, even the word Fiat, right, like for a
- 1:02:52long time was very taboo. And just these concepts being
- 1:02:55out there, I think is is a really positive proof statement
- 1:02:58for everything that we've put forth on the early rider side.
- 1:03:01Because again, this is fundamental to our thesis of,
- 1:03:04you know, people have been operating with the wrong
- 1:03:05denominator. And not only is that, you know,
- 1:03:09an issue for them in terms of how they're calculating their
- 1:03:12success, but it also leads to to worse outcomes, which we've
- 1:03:15talked a lot about. Like if you don't have these
- 1:03:17constraints of real money as your denominator, you are more
- 1:03:21prone to capital destruction. You're prone to wasteful
- 1:03:24spending, wasteful hiring because you don't have that that
- 1:03:28sound money anchor. So all of this is related.
- 1:03:30And I and I think just generally super exciting time where these
- 1:03:35concepts are, are being more, you know, digested more broadly
- 1:03:40and actually sort of palatable and OK to talk about.
- 1:03:48Yeah. I just want to say that my
- 1:03:50personal experience has been exactly that.
- 1:03:52Just living on the Bitcoin sensor makes you more frugal,
- 1:03:55makes you more cautious about your spending.
- 1:03:58So it obviously applies at a company level too.
- 1:04:03And on my previous startup, you always want to, well, maybe when
- 1:04:09you're inexperienced, you have this idea that to, to grow, you
- 1:04:11got to like hire people. You know, it's like, I don't
- 1:04:14know, now we're reaching your step.
- 1:04:15We got to hire people. I got to be more like a, a
- 1:04:18manager role. But then you're like, is this
- 1:04:21really capital efficient? Is this really the, the way to
- 1:04:24do it? So, but once you have the, the
- 1:04:26Bitcoin and sort of break mindset, then, then, then, then
- 1:04:29you can just every, every decision you make always brings
- 1:04:32back to this point, right? And, and you can, and you just
- 1:04:35make more rational positions, but I, I really think AI also
- 1:04:39plays a very important role here.
- 1:04:40And, and I, and I want to reemphasize that just because it
- 1:04:44has completely scaled my productivity and, and I'm sure
- 1:04:47of, of others too. And, and even like the
- 1:04:51popularization of of all these concepts, sometimes I wonder
- 1:04:55how, if you use AI properly, you can arrive at irrational answers
- 1:05:00and like like an exercise I did a couple of days ago was like,
- 1:05:04what does it look like? What does Bitcoin custody
- 1:05:07landscape look like in in 2035? Right.
- 1:05:10If Bitcoin is successful, it immediately is mentioned.
- 1:05:13OK, well, the, the Federal Reserve of the US is held in
- 1:05:17multi institutional custody by by several players, right.
- 1:05:20So, and this aligns with with the Bitcoin Policy Institute
- 1:05:24report that recommends multi institutional custody as, as the
- 1:05:29preferred way for, for strategic Bitcoin reserves by, by state
- 1:05:33treasuries. So this I think we're, we're
- 1:05:36just seeing an evolution of the landscape and, and the way
- 1:05:40people approach all these things and, and, and it feels like,
- 1:05:44like it's, it's slave, but it's still extremely early, right?
- 1:05:47And particularly in Mexico and particularly Latin America, it's
- 1:05:51just way more, it's way earlier than in the United States.
- 1:05:54So it it makes a lot of sense for us to to start building now
- 1:05:58and later be able to not just provide it to like services to
- 1:06:03investors, but infrastructure to other companies.
- 1:06:06Yeah, it's a it's a great point. And the beauty of all this is
- 1:06:10doesn't happen in a vacuum. How Brian was referencing the
- 1:06:14negative outcomes incentivized if you're raise a a dollar VC
- 1:06:19firm, you're you almost have a hammer and everything has to
- 1:06:22look like a nail because you need to deploy those dollars
- 1:06:24because you're sitting on them and they're losing purchasing
- 1:06:26power. The incentives.
- 1:06:29But then to your point around AIAI also in adoption doesn't
- 1:06:33happen in a vacuum where you see these large companies in the
- 1:06:35bureaucracy that exist and why they can't do them or they they
- 1:06:39don't have the best incentive to go and adopt the most efficient
- 1:06:42outcome versus if you're going to have to spend the Bitcoin to
- 1:06:45go, you know, hire somebody or leverage a tool.
- 1:06:48But then you realize, you know, going down B route is much more
- 1:06:51efficient. You get to retain more back when
- 1:06:53it's purchasing power. Yeah, it's it's an awesome spot
- 1:06:57to be in. We're still very early.
- 1:06:58The reason why you don't hear a lot about it, about this and
- 1:07:01again is the opportunity is they're very destructive to
- 1:07:06current narratives, current status quos and ultimately
- 1:07:10current capital markets. Because whether it's building
- 1:07:14like this, if you've raised in traditional dollar terms for
- 1:07:18Bitcoin, for AVC Finder, you've already started that process.
- 1:07:21Well, that's very hard to disrupt.
- 1:07:22It's very hard to allocate that capital.
- 1:07:25But then also if you're a legacy company, you've already built a
- 1:07:28certain narrative around custody.
- 1:07:29It gets very hard to adopt things like this.
- 1:07:32And that's really where the opportunity is building from the
- 1:07:34ground up. I know we have a little bit of
- 1:07:37time left. I wanted to do a quick, quick
- 1:07:38announcement of because we didn't get to cover it last
- 1:07:41week. We had the and Gustavo, this
- 1:07:43will tie into some of the stuff you guys are looking to do is we
- 1:07:45had the on ramp business launch last week and that ties directly
- 1:07:49into all the value prop for multi institution custody.
- 1:07:52But the reality is we've had all this Bitcoin and corporate
- 1:07:55adoption, I think 1.2 million coins the past year and ETFs and
- 1:07:58then public traded companies, but all that capital's
- 1:08:02ultimately gone to like Coinbase majority.
- 1:08:04And obviously there is there's a number of issues with that.
- 1:08:08But the reality is very few companies not only have multi
- 1:08:13institution, which is again just share protecting shareholder
- 1:08:15capital, right? The fact that one custodian for
- 1:08:17whatever reason, can't lose move those assets, But then you still
- 1:08:21need additional tooling, right technology on top of that to
- 1:08:25create the same experience that exists in the traditional
- 1:08:27markets around financial controls, meaning maker checker,
- 1:08:30multiple users, the ability to have read only access pulling
- 1:08:34reports. So we're really excited about
- 1:08:36this because we've seen an inbound increase in pubco's
- 1:08:39coming to use our services in companies and we released a case
- 1:08:43study with us, but it's still just kind of crazy.
- 1:08:45We're that early in Bitcoin that these controls don't actually
- 1:08:48exist that best exist proof reserves the single custodian.
- 1:08:52So wanted to give a plug to that.
- 1:08:54Anybody that's interested in learning more, please reach out.
- 1:08:59Yep, very well said. You can go to on
- 1:09:02rampbitcoin.com/product/business to learn more.
- 1:09:08Anything else gentlemen? I know we're a little over an
- 1:09:10hour. Any other things you wanted to
- 1:09:13highlight? Just wanted to mention that
- 1:09:18we're going to be, you know, pushing this announcement Live
- 1:09:21Today as well as investment memo.
- 1:09:23So check that out if you're interested in learning more.
- 1:09:25And I can hand it to Gustavo to, you know, point people in the
- 1:09:29right direction in case they are based in Latin America and want
- 1:09:32to learn more about everything that you're doing personally.
- 1:09:35And then and then the business with Rao as well.
- 1:09:38Thank you, Liam. So you can go on our website,
- 1:09:42audiobitcoin.com to learn more about everything we're doing.
- 1:09:46And so first of all, we still have our existing Swapito
- 1:09:50service to sell Bitcoin in Mexico that remains live.
- 1:09:54Very soon we're going to be adding the ability to buy
- 1:09:57Bitcoin in Mexico and our platform all automated and and
- 1:10:01very secure. We have as of today our private
- 1:10:05client services. So if you want to buy more than
- 1:10:09really if you want to buy more than $10,000 in in Bitcoin in
- 1:10:12Mexico, you should just reach out to me.
- 1:10:15You can go on our website and immediately book a call with me
- 1:10:19to talk about not only order execution and by large sums of
- 1:10:24Bitcoin, but also how we can onboard you to multi institution
- 1:10:27custody or advise for your for yourself custody stash so that
- 1:10:32you can have both and and every other type of white glove
- 1:10:37service that you that an investor requires in Mexico for
- 1:10:40for Bitcoin. We we can provide that.
- 1:10:42And finally, I just want to mention, yeah, that I mean, you
- 1:10:47can sign up to a newsletter to, to stay updated with everything
- 1:10:50we're doing. And I'm based in Mexico City.
- 1:10:53I'm part of a community called La Casa Satoshi.
- 1:10:56So if anybody listening is in Mexico and wants to join us at
- 1:11:00our physical community space, it's it's a very professional on
- 1:11:05secure securing an open space. You can reach out to me or you
- 1:11:09can go directly on, like I said, Satoshi's social media to to
- 1:11:13find our our latest updates. Awesome.
- 1:11:18Sounds great. All right, gentlemen, thanks for
- 1:11:22joining us, Gustavo. This is awesome.
- 1:11:24And if you want to learn more, check out those links in the
- 1:11:27show notes. Appreciate it Gustavo.
- 1:11:29Excited for everything to come and got a lot of announcements
- 1:11:33in the coming months of next year, so looking forward to it
- 1:11:36and also looking forward to getting down to Mexico City to
- 1:11:38visit. Yeah, big week.
- 1:11:40The rest of the. Week this week, too, so stay
- 1:11:42tuned for everything and sign up for the Early Writers newsletter
- 1:11:45if you haven't already. Thank you, boys.
- 1:11:49Thanks. Thanks everybody for tuning in
- 1:11:52this week. It was great to discuss all
- 1:11:55that's happened over the past week as it relates to business
- 1:11:58formation. Every new development that's
- 1:12:00happening in the digital asset space, as well as the
- 1:12:04opportunity for early riders to partner with Oreo.
- 1:12:07There is a really big opportunity for everything that
- 1:12:10they're doing down in Latin America and the opportunity to
- 1:12:13offer infrastructure for other businesses as well.
- 1:12:17I'd highly encourage anybody who found the conversation
- 1:12:19interesting to reach out to usdirectly@contactearlyriders.com
- 1:12:24and check out everything that's going out at our website.
- 1:12:28There's a ton of research that we're putting out and would
- 1:12:30encourage you all to follow along or reach out to me
- 1:12:34directly at liam@earlyriders.com.
- 1:12:37There's a lot more that we're going to be publishing this
- 1:12:39week. And really anybody who's looking
- 1:12:41at the Bitcoin space and trying to understand how they can fit
- 1:12:43in, either as a founder, operator, entrepreneur, or
- 1:12:47allocator would enjoy any conversations with those who are
- 1:12:51looking at the space in a serious way or connected with
- 1:12:53how we discuss and put out research and talk about deals
- 1:12:58that we discussed this week. So thanks again for tuning in
- 1:13:01and talk to you next week. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:13:04week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:13:06valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:13:09rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:13:11All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:13:13notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:13:16reminder that Onramp Media is for informational and
- 1:13:18entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:13:21investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:13:24your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:13:27Visit onrampbitcoin.com contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:13:31one of our private client advisors.