Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 7 – Learning From a Place That is Not a Hot Steaming Mess
Transcript
- 0:00Andy: Hey, Jed.
- 0:01Good to see you.
- 0:02Jed: Hey, Andy.
- 0:03How you doing?
- 0:03How's your summer been?
- 0:04Andy: Mine's been good.
- 0:05I'll tell you about it, but start with you.
- 0:07How, what have you been up to since we were last together?
- 0:09It's been a minute.
- 0:10Jed: Well, I haven't had as much summer in terms of vacation.
- 0:14I'm saving things up.
- 0:15It's my wife's on my 25th and we're walking the Camino in Spain in the second
- 0:20half of September and October, so I basically been working straight through
- 0:24the summer, but most of the other time that I've had has been around my son and
- 0:29helping him with his college applications and trying to get in front of a college
- 0:34coach for his soccer team also trying to help a lot of his teammates who are
- 0:39similarly in the recruiting process.
- 0:41I know we want to keep it light and talk about the fun of summer, right?
- 0:44But this soccer recruiting and D3 sports and the gentrification of college
- 0:49athletics is something I'm experiencing up close and personal right now.
- 0:53But I guess the positive thing is a lot of Quentin's soccer friends, several of whom
- 0:58are first generation are actually going to end up going to good schools in the end.
- 1:02And so we feel terrific about that.
- 1:04Andy: Yeah, that's great.
- 1:05And they all end up like, you know, going to good schools.
- 1:07I think athletics can end up taking on like an outsized importance.
- 1:11We should maybe at some point do a Steve Messler, and I did one with Michael
- 1:16Horn in a podcast, we talked about that.
- 1:18We can put that in the show notes.
- 1:19We were talking about coming back with our daughters.
- 1:22All of us have, and Steve's daughter is younger.
- 1:25My daughters have both played competitive sports and just like, it's a lot for sure.
- 1:31Maybe we could do something on that.
- 1:33You're going to walk the way, where are you going to start and,
- 1:37and how far are you going to go?
- 1:38Jed: So we're going to start in Saint Jean in France and we'll go across the French
- 1:45Pyrenees there and do the entire distance.
- 1:47So we did a third of it eight years ago, when I was on sabbatical, and
- 1:53our little ones, our 10 and our 12 year old were with us at the time.
- 1:56But when we got to the end, Amy and I said, Hey, let's come back for
- 2:00our 25th and do the entire thing.
- 2:01So it's been this thing that's been an anchor there for a long time.
- 2:04We really had a good time.
- 2:05I don't know if you've done any part of the Camino or know very much about it,
- 2:07but it's getting to be super popular.
- 2:10It's overrun with tourists, but it's also quite a cool experience.
- 2:14And we're really looking forward to it.
- 2:15Andy: Yeah, we have friends have done it.
- 2:16I mean, a lot of what I know about honestly comes from that fantastic
- 2:20Emilio Estevez, Mark Sheen film.
- 2:23But I know a little bit.
- 2:26I had a little, a similar experience.
- 2:29I would say sort of a far more perhaps more secular experience.
- 2:34We were in Rome, we were riding our bikes in a way, and I didn't realize.
- 2:39You can actually just sort of self deploy and ride the whole thing if
- 2:43you want with a, you know, mountain bike, suspended kind of bike.
- 2:48And so now I'm like trying to figure out how far we could
- 2:51take it and ride into Rome.
- 2:54So that's now becoming, I have another Europe ride I want to do.
- 2:58And now that's on, that's on the list.
- 2:59Jed: So was that the first time for the family in Rome?
- 3:02Andy: It was first time as a family for us to be in Italy together.
- 3:04Yes, we went to, we were in Rome.
- 3:06Florence and Tuscany.
- 3:07So, you know, some history, a lot of food and wine and some good time
- 3:13outside to some good time together.
- 3:14We're at a similar point.
- 3:16My kids are 17, so we're trying to remind them that their parents are okay.
- 3:21So maybe they'll come back one day.
- 3:23Jed: Last summer, we were trying to pitch an idea for a trip together as a family,
- 3:27and I pitched all these different things.
- 3:29Let's go camping.
- 3:30Let's go to Canada.
- 3:32Let's go...
- 3:32and everyone was like, Why don't you and mom get some good quality time together?
- 3:37And then I pitched Rome and they're like, "Oh, let's do a family vacation!"
- 3:41Andy: So, yeah, Rome is great.
- 3:42It's a fun city.
- 3:43You can both have fun.
- 3:44There's the learning opportunities there.
- 3:47You could spend a decade there and not get through so much.
- 3:54It's a cool place.
- 3:55I was intrigued.
- 3:55Like we went to, we spent a bunch of time in Alaska last summer, which was amazing.
- 3:59And saw just a terrific education person up there, Jamie Rees.
- 4:03He's a high school teacher in Seattle.
- 4:04He used to teach in Baltimore, fantastic.
- 4:07He was a college athlete, played soccer for Harvard and just one of those really
- 4:12interesting people in our sector and spend some time with him up around Fairbanks.
- 4:16It was a great trip.
- 4:17And I wasn't sure that the kids like really love it or was it like
- 4:20nice, they're glad to be home, and interestingly, like when we're
- 4:24starting to work on the Italy trip, one of my daughters is like, "I wish
- 4:27we could just like go back to Alaska and be outside in Alaska again."
- 4:30I was kind of like, okay, that's not this summer, but that's cool.
- 4:33We will definitely, you know, I've been lucky enough to be up there a few times
- 4:37and we will definitely do that again.
- 4:39Jed: Yeah, so we have we have kindred spirits in all sorts of ways.
- 4:42We did a trip in Alaska and that is the kids favorite by far.
- 4:46They would go back to Alaska in a heartbeat.
- 4:48Andy: Yeah, it's an amazing place.
- 4:49It opens, you know, like Rome opens your, I think for my kids, they'd seen old
- 4:56stuff, but they hadn't seen, like, they think, like, I mean, they've been, you
- 4:58know, like, they've been nice and they've seen Viking stuff, things like that.
- 5:02I think that kind of blew their minds, and I think Alaska blows your
- 5:06mind, so geographically, just how big country can actually be, and
- 5:11just how remote and how you can just get out in the bush and be gone.
- 5:16So I think you need things like that when you're young, it kind of
- 5:18changes you, it opens your horizons.
- 5:21Well, what my girls, I'll tell you the truth, what they
- 5:23really wanted this summer.
- 5:24Cause you know, they're 17, they thought this was going
- 5:26to be sort of hot girl summer.
- 5:27And in fact, what we basically did in addition to dragging Italy, we
- 5:30dragged them to a lot of concerts.
- 5:32And so like I I'm telling them what they got was lot, they got lot girl summer.
- 5:37One of my daughters and I saw a great Neil Young show.
- 5:42I don't know if you and I talked about that.
- 5:43It was a fantastic Neil Young show at the Greek, right at the beginning of summer.
- 5:47And then They saw Dead & Company and which was their first time in that scene.
- 5:55So that was interesting.
- 5:56And Julie and I caught Tedeschi trucks and actually, just last night, we're
- 5:59filming, we're doing this on a Thursday and it'll go up in a day or two.
- 6:05We saw Bill Kreuzman's doing a tour with his band, just a two show tour,
- 6:10they're calling it Peer to Peer.
- 6:11So he's playing, uh, the peer in Baltimore and appear up in New York.
- 6:15And they were exceptional.
- 6:16He's got just a really good configuration.
- 6:20This woman, Kamika Moore came by and was sat in on vocals and she was amazing.
- 6:24He's got this new guy, Danny Donato's sort of a real creative player.
- 6:28So that was super fun.
- 6:31And so that it's been more lot girl summer than anything else.
- 6:34Jed: Well, the amazing thing is you've got your kids willing
- 6:37to go to concerts with you.
- 6:38That's a bridge I've never gotten over.
- 6:40And I don't think I ever will.
- 6:44Andy: We can make this whole episode.
- 6:45' We can name check interesting people.' A few years ago, Paul Herdman used
- 6:49to tell me, from Rodel in Delaware and formerly new America schools,
- 6:53and, it came up an hour bound.
- 6:56Paul's just a terrific person in the section lives in Delaware.
- 6:59And Paul used to, Tell me about going to concerts with his daughter.
- 7:02And I was like, so sort of jealous.
- 7:05And I was like, "Oh my God, that's so cool."
- 7:07like not bad jealousy, but just, "Oh my gosh, that sounds so great."
- 7:10and I was like, I don't know if that'll ever.
- 7:12And then like, it just sort of started happening and it's been cool.
- 7:16We're going to go get catch some Bruce shows, hopefully this fall.
- 7:21It's been interesting, but it just sort of happened.
- 7:24And it was something I watched other people do and I was like,
- 7:26"how do you make that happen?"
- 7:28And I don't think you can, it just has to sort of happen organically.
- 7:31Jed: Well, maybe my kids want to stay separate from me on recreational
- 7:34time because of things related to charter school obsession.
- 7:37For example, when we were in Alaska, I found out that there is a charter
- 7:42school in a place called North Pole.
- 7:44It's called North Pole Charter School, and so we're driving into North Pole,
- 7:49and the kids, where do they want to go?
- 7:51Santa's Workshop.
- 7:52And I was like, "shut up!
- 7:54We're going to the charter school first," right?
- 7:56So they wanted to go in a different direction there as far as charter
- 7:59schools go, and I think their tastes in music have stayed similarly.
- 8:03Andy: We were going to visit, but COVID got in the way, Laura Marcus, who ran
- 8:08the ARETE project now runs Tidelines, which is a really cool school in
- 8:11Gustavus, Alaska for college students.
- 8:15And there's a school out your way called Deep Springs and she wanted
- 8:19to start an all female version.
- 8:21I ended up doing this coed thing in Alaska, just another, we're going to keep
- 8:26name checking, just a really interesting person in the sector, kind of does things
- 8:29her own way, actually she just had a baby.
- 8:32She's just fantastic as an educator.
- 8:34And I was making my kids like we're in Glacier Bay, and like at the park services
- 8:40sort of incredible lodge up there on Bartlett Cove and we're hanging out and
- 8:44dad wants to make us go to a school and so we're looking at whales and they're
- 8:50like, yeah, we're going to go to a school.
- 8:51So they get that.
- 8:53Jed: Well, I did enjoy getting a couple of texts from you while you were in Rome.
- 8:58Thank you for allowing your vacation to be interrupted.
- 9:01There were several ocasions, over the last month or so, because it's been
- 9:05a while since we've done a recording.
- 9:07Where virginia stuff has come up that i've wanted to talk.
- 9:11Andy: Yeah, we should at some point.
- 9:12We should this isn't just it It wants to listen.
- 9:15It wants to listen to the podcast Jen and I are going to talk about our
- 9:17vacations and our families and then get weepy about being empty nesters That'll
- 9:21be that'll be great for the ratings.
- 9:24Yes, we should pivot we can talk about that before we do that I do want to...
- 9:27our next so we've sort of have been bullshitting a little bit but our
- 9:32next And we'll get into Virginia.
- 9:34That's just more serious.
- 9:35But our nextpodcast, at the end of the month, we have two really amazing guests.
- 9:41It went well with Mackey is one guest.
- 9:43So we figured why not do two?
- 9:45I'm not going to say who they are, but I think it's going to be a really
- 9:47fantastic discussion about sort of education, politics, advocacy,
- 9:53parent organizing and empowerment, and I'm just super excited about it.
- 9:59So that one, I would say tune in, but obviously it's a podcast,
- 10:02you can listen whenever you want, but that'll be the next one.
- 10:04And I'm just super looking forward to that.
- 10:07Jed: Yeah, I'm really looking forward to it as well and how
- 10:09this work is done authentically.
- 10:11There's times when you see folks bringing interesting efforts and it feels real,
- 10:16and there are others that it just doesn't, and I think the two people
- 10:19that we're going to have on in a couple weeks are really among those people that
- 10:23specialize in the authentic voice, right?
- 10:25Andy: Yeah, two, and we've been name checking people, we'll just name,
- 10:28there are two, two mystery guests who you will find out about soon.
- 10:33Hey, this reminds me, one more thing before we get to Virginia, do you
- 10:35know Steve Reese, School Wise Press, he does school data, journalism?
- 10:39Jed: Yeah, yeah, I know him.
- 10:40Andy: He is another one of these people who I was thinking, I saw
- 10:43Steve Reese and I was see about him.
- 10:44He came up in like Palo Alto and if you go to like that, they did that
- 10:50big Bill Graham, the music producer.
- 10:52Bill Graham, not Billy Graham, the evangelist, the other Bill
- 10:55Graham, the music producer.
- 10:57And like Steve's pictures were in that exhibit.
- 10:59He's got like, his work was used in like the Grateful Dead movie
- 11:03and he's got all these pictures.
- 11:05He gave me some pictures once and they're of like Jerry Garcia
- 11:08like, in like Palo Alto at these little places in the early 60s.
- 11:14And one day he sent me a warlocks poster.
- 11:16He's like one of the, he's another one of these people who like, you
- 11:18think you sort of know a little bit, and then like underneath there's
- 11:23like all this other stuff, you know?
- 11:26And I'm just, I was thinking about that the other day.
- 11:28It's like, you know, Shivam Shah, like who everybody thinks of education,
- 11:33education executive, but like she also owns a tequila company, which is not,
- 11:36Probably what you would necessarily or, you know, Becca Bracy's like,
- 11:39you know, really serious in the mountains, mountain biker and climber.
- 11:42Like we get these people who are, it's just interesting.
- 11:46And we, maybe one day we could do like some sort of thing on that.
- 11:50Cause you, they're the kind of people that surprise you.
- 11:52You learn a couple of things about them and you can't predict the other ones.
- 11:55Cause there's all this stuff out of left field.
- 11:57Jed: I'll leave it to Rotherham to get me to break one of my solemn vows.
- 12:02Because one has been never to discuss anything that I've done relative to the
- 12:08Grateful Dead in a professional setting.
- 12:13Cause believe me what happened at Grateful Dead shows needs to
- 12:16stay in Greateful Dead concert.
- 12:20But, I love the tour of all the people and the stuff that you saw this summer.
- 12:27Andy: Well now I'm going to make you break your back.
- 12:28Did you go to the shows out there with some shows out there this summer?
- 12:31Jed: No, I didn't go this year and I did have a very close friend that
- 12:34was going to Boulder and for one of the last shows with his daughter,
- 12:39and really wanted me to be there and I just could not make it happen with
- 12:43other family stuff that I had going on.
- 12:45Andy: Scheduling's tough.
- 12:47That does happen.
- 12:48I'm a little more porous on that role.
- 12:49I remember I took a couple of people from my team when I'm out in California,
- 12:52it's unfortunately closed, but Phil Lesh had that great club over in
- 12:55Marine that was just like, That's such a delightful place to spend time.
- 12:59And I would drag them over there.
- 13:01I remember I took a couple of them over there.
- 13:02One time, Phil was playing and with Phil Lesh's friends like Stu Allen
- 13:06and like some really good players.
- 13:07And yeah.
- 13:08You do have to kind of have the rule.
- 13:10Hey, you do whatever you do, whatever you want.
- 13:13Jed: And it will stay here.
- 13:17All right.
- 13:17Well let's pivot to Virginia.
- 13:21The way I've been thinking about this is.
- 13:24We've got a country that is, has about 50 hot steaming messes
- 13:29from a state policy standpoint.
- 13:31It just seems like, and they're all crazy for their own unique ways,
- 13:35but they are crazy at a level of craziness that is pretty unprecedented.
- 13:40And then you see Rick Hess write an article that quotes you and, you know,
- 13:46really dives deep into Virginia adopting some state content standards that
- 13:52seemed genuinely like really great ones.
- 13:55And so something substantive was able to get done in Virginia.
- 13:58And then I've done a few other, I just continue to read articles, there are
- 14:02some that come up that just stress the culture wars and all that stuff.
- 14:07But there's also this reasonability that's there.
- 14:10Some of the appointments to the state board, not just yourself,
- 14:12but Miche and others, suggest that maybe there's something that we
- 14:16should be learning from in Virginia.
- 14:18So I wonder if you wouldn't mind just like, setting the stage for us.
- 14:22Can you?
- 14:22Andy: Sure.
- 14:22And we'll put that in the show notes.
- 14:23It was actually an interview.
- 14:25Rick pulled a little bit of like a Tom Sawyer move.
- 14:28So it was actually an interview.
- 14:29So I did all the work, but he gets the byline and you know, but like Rick is
- 14:34of course prolific, like since then he's probably written like two books
- 14:37on Virginia since that interview.
- 14:38So that was back in like April.
- 14:40So yeah, but that we'll put that in the show notes.
- 14:43Look I don't know how to set the stage.
- 14:45I guess the big thing I would say about Virginia, and this has always been true
- 14:49I think just in public life and politics and so forth, like there's always like
- 14:53the narrative that people in these days, whatever people are saying on Twitter
- 14:57or X or whatever the hell we're calling it now, and in social media and even in
- 15:01some cases, like in the regular legacy media, and then there's, what's actually
- 15:06happening and what's actually going on.
- 15:08And those two things are often like, there's some variance.
- 15:11I think what's really pronounced now is in some cases just how
- 15:15substantial the variance is.
- 15:18And I don't think that's unique at all to Virginia.
- 15:21I think you see that around the country.
- 15:24And again, you always have, I just think it's a little bit more intense now.
- 15:27So I don't want to say like everything in Virginia is going swimmingly.
- 15:30We have intense partisanship.
- 15:31It's going to heat up.
- 15:32There's an election coming and all that.
- 15:33But like the point of Rick's, the interview was We did get
- 15:37something done on these standards.
- 15:39Everybody who reads them thinks they're pretty good.
- 15:41And I think it shows just like you can get things done and the
- 15:46thing about it, I don't think any one person deserves credit for it.
- 15:50It was a bunch of people working together and essentially just.
- 15:53Putting the interest of the Commonwealth and the kids of the Commonwealth ahead
- 15:57of like all the temporal expediency.
- 16:01Jed: So as far as additional context, I always go back to the election
- 16:05in 21 and it was seen as really a swing election where education proved
- 16:13to be the difference maker and the McAuliffe had, Randy Weingarten come
- 16:20at the last second and the thought was that maybe Weingarten would help.
- 16:23And the perception of at least pundits in the end was that that
- 16:26was exactly the wrong thing to do.
- 16:28Governor talked about that.
- 16:31We shouldn't be entrusting parents with, I don't remember exactly what
- 16:33the quote was, but a very radioactive comment about not trusting parents
- 16:40to operate our school districts or something like that and Youngkin wins.
- 16:44And when he wins, he makes his, you know, celebratory speech that first night, the
- 16:51word charter was the 60th word he uttered.
- 16:55We were going to get a charter school law done in Virginia.
- 16:59Andy: Only you, only you counted that.
- 17:01I like that.
- 17:01Jed: Oh yeah.
- 17:01Oh yeah.
- 17:02Well, you know.
- 17:03Andy: We probably tell me how many syllables in it.
- 17:05Jed: What I liked about it was though, that, you know, It
- 17:08signaled, I think, seriousness.
- 17:12I was hoping.
- 17:13And I think there was a very serious effort that was made.
- 17:18Ultimately, a charter school law was not able to get across the finish line.
- 17:22This lab school concept was, and I think a lot of drama and conflict happened
- 17:28those first early months, and then people stopped paying attention as much again.
- 17:33And I think it was after you know, that happened where perhaps some of these
- 17:39other substantive progress, examples of progress were able to happen.
- 17:44Andy: Yeah.
- 17:45Okay.
- 17:45So a lot there.
- 17:46I mean, let's start with like the political analysis.
- 17:49Education was obviously a factor in the race.
- 17:51So was voters turned out in certain parts of the state who
- 17:54hadn't turned out and so forth.
- 17:56I think one way you can see if you look at places like Loudoun County, Fairfax
- 18:00County, which stayed closed for a long time or sort of ground zero for some of
- 18:04the culture war stuff and still are, you saw a shift, you saw a distinct move.
- 18:09Now in terms of the political analysis, the thing, and I don't know if you and
- 18:11I have talked about in this podcast, I've talked about in some others, like
- 18:14it's easy to overstate people tend to look at the Biden election in 2020 and
- 18:18then the Youngkin can election in 2021 and are like, "Oh my gosh, look at
- 18:21this enormous 10 point kind of swing."
- 18:24I think the Biden election, Virginia is a state with a lot of military,
- 18:28a lot of civil servants, and a lot of people take government seriously.
- 18:33And so Biden performed well, and you had a lot of Republicans who voted
- 18:37Democratic at the national level in that election because of Donald
- 18:40Trump was on the ballot, right?
- 18:41And Youngkin did a masterful job keeping Donald Trump out of the race in 2021.
- 18:47And so I think the swing you have to look at is the swing from 2017, the
- 18:52previous gubernatorial election, where Ralph Northam, the Democrat won to 2021.
- 18:57And what you do see there is young can made inroads again.
- 19:01You know, substantial ones across the board, so I don't
- 19:03mean to like take anything away.
- 19:05He won the election in a state that a lot of people thought was out of reach
- 19:08for Republicans, and he did it by putting together a pretty interesting coalition.
- 19:13Much of his coalition was actually much more diverse, I think that
- 19:17people realize, and so I don't want to take anything away from all that,
- 19:22but it was not this 10 point swing.
- 19:24The national election, the state election are different.
- 19:27You got to look at 2017.
- 19:28And there you do see movement.
- 19:30And again, education, I think was a big part of it.
- 19:33And to your question, like, look, yeah, Randy coming in, it was like a finger
- 19:37in the eye to people who, and the thing you can't forget about this, is lots of
- 19:44people were talking in the fall of 2021.
- 19:47Like the school closure thing was in the past.
- 19:49Why did anybody care?
- 19:50Kids have been back in school since late that spring and all that.
- 19:53First of all, people were still upset about it.
- 19:55Second, a lot of people were still experiencing it.
- 19:57If you have a kid, for example, in special ed and there'd been, you know, there
- 20:01continues to be, you know, one of the school district state is in a compliance
- 20:05agreement now, around special ed services.
- 20:09There's a lot of.
- 20:10You know, other issues happening, other divisions.
- 20:13It's a big issue, and so people were still like, this was always
- 20:16talked about in the past tense.
- 20:17It was present tense for a lot of Virginians and McAuliffe just did not give
- 20:24voice to that, and again, if anything, it was like a stick in the eye, some
- 20:27of this stuff, and there was a price, there was a price to be paid for that.
- 20:30Now, and look on the charters and choice.
- 20:32Yeah.
- 20:32Look, Virginia is a tough state on charters.
- 20:34And I would ask you, like, I think it's a fascinating, you
- 20:37always, I run into people.
- 20:39And they talk about these states that still don't have charter laws
- 20:42or have really weak ones, and I would characterize Virginia's as very weak.
- 20:46And you hear like, "oh, people there just had a little more ganas, a little
- 20:50more hustle, worked a little harder."
- 20:53And they argue that, and that's certainly one line of argument, but I guess another
- 20:57one you have to ask yourself is maybe the places that don't have charter
- 21:00school laws that are at all are strong, don't have them for a reason, because
- 21:05like the politics there are really brutal and the governor cannot just
- 21:10wave a magic wand and create charter schools and create more school choice.
- 21:16You have to get through the legislature and this is always in the media like it's
- 21:20a left right thing, it's not, the politics are much more subtle and complicated.
- 21:24And so it's really hard.
- 21:26And so we're doing lab schools, which are these university
- 21:29affiliated, autonomous schools.
- 21:31There's some really cool proposals in the pipeline.
- 21:35I'm excited about that, Machea Ashton was just appointed to the Board of
- 21:40Education of Virginia, and yeah, so she obviously like she's forgotten more about
- 21:43charter schools than most of us know.
- 21:48We're making steps in that direction, but it is slow going and it's going to
- 21:53continue to be slow going just because the politics and in Virginia, there just
- 21:57are not robust parent groups organizing.
- 22:00Parents right now, the politics do sort of break down very much
- 22:04establishment driven on this stuff and until that changes, I don't see the
- 22:09choice situation changing, you know, dramatically and I wish I wish it works.
- 22:14I want to see parents in this commonwealth have more options and choices and
- 22:17more customization for their kids.
- 22:19Jed: Well, I think a lot of this comes down to in these states that
- 22:22have weak laws or no laws whatsoever.
- 22:26There is just a political calculus that needs to be made
- 22:29on the rural Republican side.
- 22:32Are we really going to exert pressure on these folks or not?
- 22:36Is it going to come from within the Republican Party or not?
- 22:40Or from within a political apparatus that is deeply embedded
- 22:43or working often with Republicans?
- 22:46In Texas, the advocates there saw opposition from rural Republicans
- 22:52on a number of things, everybody thought that they were going to be
- 22:54supporters of charters and when we got them to vote in the legislature,
- 22:5625 of them voted with the opposition.
- 22:59Then the political apparatus was put to work on rural Republicans
- 23:03in Texas, and they flipped back and we were able to get things passed.
- 23:07In Iowa, governor had the same thing.
- 23:09She tried to get an aggressive charter school thing done right away.
- 23:14Couldn't get it done.
- 23:15Raised her own money, got her own pack and said, I'm specifically going to be using
- 23:20this resources to hold accountable my own Republicans who didn't support this thing.
- 23:25She defeated a couple.
- 23:26And the next year she got the law passed.
- 23:28It's really a question of, are people, you know, Republicans
- 23:33usually in these kinds of contexts, willing to do that kind of thing.
- 23:38So I'm really fascinated to see what's going to happen with Youngkin now.
- 23:41I think We were well, we, whatever, I'm not Republican,
- 23:45but from a charter perspective.
- 23:48Andy: You and me, you and me both.
- 23:49But unfortunately, they're more vocal on choice these days.
- 23:52Jed: So, but, you know, the Republicans were one vote from having control of
- 23:58the Senate as well, which people think would have been enough difference for
- 24:02a charter school bill to get passed.
- 24:04So now, the question was, how are they going to get control of the Senate?
- 24:09Now, there was a special election that happened, probably January or
- 24:13February that was previously held by a Republican senator and that
- 24:18actually flipped back Democratic.
- 24:21Yes, I think people think that might have flipped back because of bad
- 24:25Republican positioning or positioning that is at odds with voters on abortion.
- 24:30I'm not sure of that.
- 24:30I'd love to see what your thoughts on.
- 24:32Andy: Abortion.
- 24:34I think, look, I'm not an expert on that race, but I will say two things.
- 24:36One, the Democratic candidate had a very attractive profile.
- 24:41It was just a terrific candidate.
- 24:43And then the abortion thing.
- 24:45Yeah.
- 24:45I mean, we saw, and we just saw again in Ohio, you know, Um, what last
- 24:49week, you know, the abortion thing.
- 24:51I mean, I know I thought that issue is more baked into the way
- 24:55people voted than it clearly is.
- 24:56And that like that is an albatross on the republicans and it's unclear
- 25:01what they do about it's kind of an interesting watching them run to the
- 25:06right in some ways on it, you know, DeSantis that bill he signed and so forth.
- 25:09I don't know what they're going to do, but it's become clear that the
- 25:14school of thought that row was lousy constitutional law, but a good rough
- 25:19approximation of where the country is.
- 25:21That school of thought seems to be correct.
- 25:23Like people, you know, people, , they were pretty comfortable with restrictions,
- 25:32late term, they did not want restrictions in the first trimester, and Dobbs
- 25:36upended that in a way that's just causing chaos, the republicans, and
- 25:40I don't know that they have a theory of the case for how they're going
- 25:42to So they get through that and per your point the elections in virginia.
- 25:46That'll be a major issue this fall and I asked yes five smart people around
- 25:52politics in virginia What's going to happen the elections in the fall and
- 25:54you're going to get five answers.
- 25:56Status quo seems to be something a lot of people think.
- 25:59So who knows?
- 26:00I don't feel like I have a good enough grasp on it to to prognosticate, but
- 26:04I do think you'll see the choice, the abortion choice issue will be a big
- 26:08issue, and it is an interesting thing.
- 26:10You can't miss the juxtaposition of the two parties on abortion and
- 26:14choice there and school choice.
- 26:16It is almost like reversed in a very peculiar way.
- 26:21Jed: Yeah, the idea that Dems are out of step with the swing voters on education
- 26:28issues and republicans are out of step with the swing voters on abortion issues,
- 26:35and how does this how does this play out?
- 26:38It's going to be absolutely fascinating.
- 26:39Andy: Well more than that though Jed, right?
- 26:41You've got and i'll probably get in trouble for like but the reality is
- 26:44like in this country if you have means Dobbs, you're going to be able to travel
- 26:48and so forth Like the people who are really now in a bad situation with
- 26:53Dobbs are like if you live in like rural Texas, you don't make a lot of money.
- 26:58You can't take time off from work.
- 26:59You can't travel because you're surrounded by states that have restrictions.
- 27:03That's where you start to it.
- 27:04And so, when you look at the data on who's going to be affected by
- 27:06this and the estimates and so forth, it's poor women disproportionately.
- 27:10And likewise on school choice, like if you're affluent, you can work around
- 27:15the dysfunction of the system and you can figure out, you know, people will
- 27:18figure out workarounds where they live or they send their kids to private school.
- 27:23Or even in a lot of these cities, you can find there's like, there are past
- 27:27there's clusters of schools and so forth.
- 27:29And if you're affluent, you can figure out how to take advantage of that.
- 27:32If you're poor.
- 27:34You're you know at the whim of fortune and so school choice becomes like a
- 27:39just an enormous issue for you, and so that juxtaposition also I just feel
- 27:42like people have to sit with this and both parties are in weird place, like
- 27:50the in terms of like their affinity for helping the poor on a particular issue.
- 27:57Those two issues together are very strange.
- 27:59Rick Hess could probably write a book about it this week.
- 28:01Jed: Yeah, well I think that in terms of, you know, not being a hot steaming
- 28:06mess, I'm not sure what exactly is making the ecosystem viable in Virginia,
- 28:12but we just see in so many other states where either the culture wars
- 28:16are just completely and utterly out of control, or there are some other things.
- 28:20Andy: I don't know, I mean, I hear that, but then I'm like, okay,
- 28:23like Tennessee obviously had tons of education culture war stuff.
- 28:26But they still got a new finance plan through that was really pretty good.
- 28:32And that happened with Billy and with all the stuff that was
- 28:37rolling around cultural wise.
- 28:39Maybe Arkansas will put this to the test cause they seem to be leaning in on
- 28:42some of the culture war stuff and their last legislative session, they passed
- 28:46an ambitious basket of education reform.
- 28:50So maybe they'll put this to the test.
- 28:52Can you sort of walk and chew gum?
- 28:55But I don't know that every the culture war stuff in every
- 28:58state has sort of ground.
- 29:03I think it's different in different states.
- 29:07Jed: Well, I think it'll be interesting to see, not just specifically on the
- 29:09culture war stuff, but when some of these breakthroughs have happened, and I don't
- 29:14think people have necessarily thought them through all in advance very well, and
- 29:18they don't have the system set up on the other side to take care of these things.
- 29:22A story that is going to be bigger and bigger is that those
- 29:25that went to universal vouchers.
- 29:27have huge challenges with the administration of their programs.
- 29:32All of the states that estimated how many parents would make use of a
- 29:36universal voucher, way underestimated.
- 29:38So Iowa, they have, I don't remember what it is, they have like more
- 29:42than twice as many people who have actually sought the charter.
- 29:46Now that's going to have a budgetary challenge for the state for one thing.
- 29:49But the other thing is just administratively, they don't know how to
- 29:53take care of the same thing in Arizona.
- 29:55Huge numbers, right?
- 29:57And so they're sending out voucher to program.
- 30:01And I'm not saying, "Oh, stop vouchers for this reason."
- 30:03I'm just saying that, when you have these kinds of major, major breakthroughs
- 30:08that happen, if you really, really care about vouchers, you would think
- 30:12that you also are thinking through, how are we going to make sure that the
- 30:15administration happens as effectively as possible in the early going?
- 30:18So we don't lose it because of scandal or some other, you know...
- 30:21Andy: We don't have that existential crisis though.
- 30:26It's amazing how much people want out and this should be, if you're a
- 30:34public school supporter and I am a public school sports, why I do a lot
- 30:37of what I do, like this is a crisis.
- 30:40And instead it's just all this bullshit about, you know, that we're hearing
- 30:45about what's going on and so forth.
- 30:47And like this, if you believe in public education as sort of
- 30:51a broadly supported cross class institution, this is like a really.
- 30:56perilous moment.
- 30:58And you know, everybody's like whistling past the graveyard.
- 31:04And like you just speak it, so Virginia on that one, I would not say things
- 31:07are going swimmingly, because like every time the governor points out
- 31:10that like our Nate, you know, scores plummeted because of pandemic policies,
- 31:14biggest drops in the nation that we have these huge achievement gaps.
- 31:18Every time we get a fight over that, is it really that bad or no, you know,
- 31:22he's ginning up a crisis and all this.
- 31:24And it's insane.
- 31:25You look at the data and you're like, this is an enormous problem for kids, but
- 31:28every time it's a big fight in the media.
- 31:31"Well, you know, who knows and get these stories.
- 31:33Well, maybe it's not so bad."
- 31:34I mean, you know, none of their kids are affected.
- 31:37And like so that part is not going swimmingly, let me tell you.
- 31:41And I feel like we need like, where are the groups to like help
- 31:47reset some of that conversation?
- 31:49I mean, the conversation we're basically having in Virginia is a conversation
- 31:52that 15 years ago, the education trust would have been at the vanguard of like
- 31:56we're talking about achievement gaps.
- 31:57We're talking about data.
- 31:58We're talking about how do we redo our accreditation system of schools
- 32:02so we can start to actually have?
- 32:03We don't have really have an accountability system in Virginia
- 32:05so we can start to actually have an accountability system.
- 32:08I mean, that is the conversation.
- 32:09And yet the groups, they are nowhere, none of the groups, and I'm not just,
- 32:14this is not like a critique of the trust in particular, just none of
- 32:17the groups and the institutions that used to be there anywhere to be found
- 32:21Jed: Moms for liberty..
- 32:22Andy: Driving that vacuum.
- 32:24And I think that's, and one thing I thought, like, come back to before
- 32:27we can talk about Moms for liberty, because people always seem to
- 32:29like, listen to us talk about them.
- 32:32You talk about rural charter schools, my kingdom for people just to
- 32:37organize more information about them, take people to them because it is
- 32:41still, I talk to you all the time.
- 32:43It is an article of faith.
- 32:45You cannot have charter schools and rural communities and you try to talk
- 32:49about like the exciting stuff happening in places like Idaho and so forth.
- 32:52And it's just.
- 32:53Like, there, there's just a lack of awareness and that, that complicates
- 32:57the already complicated rural politics that you gave voice to earlier.
- 33:01Jed: One of the things that we way underappreciate about rural
- 33:06charter schools is that you need to have different kinds of models
- 33:09to be able to go into those places.
- 33:10And often those models require a different regulatory framework.
- 33:15I would say that one of the strengths of the California charter school law is that
- 33:19we've always had this misnamed, but from a policy perspective, important status
- 33:26of non classroom based charter schools, non classroom based charter schools
- 33:30serve kids, provide less than 80% of their instruction in a classroom setting.
- 33:36So, a lot of these schools, the kids go to school 4 days a week,
- 33:383 days a week, 2 days a week.
- 33:40There are a lot of classrooms, but they're called non classroom, but a lot
- 33:43of them end up having these resource centers that serve a relatively small
- 33:48number of kids, hundreds kids here, 70 kids over there, 75 kids over here,
- 33:54but they are all in a network, and they're all supported with each other.
- 33:57And what happens in rural settings when you talk about a non classroom
- 34:00based school coming and setting up a resource center that might serve 60 kids.
- 34:05You're not going to kill off the entire school district, and so
- 34:09there's a receptiveness there.
- 34:11Andy: Even with the models where kids do have to drive, I'm struck how
- 34:14far, and you see this in urban areas, like you'll talk to kids and they're
- 34:17like, Oh yeah, I'd have to take the train here and I'm on it for, you
- 34:19know, an hour and 15 hour and a half.
- 34:21Their parents though, like, and I think this is where people.
- 34:24in the system think like a system and they're like, Oh,
- 34:27no one would want to do that.
- 34:28It's like, no, if things aren't working well for your kid, you
- 34:31will put them on a bus for an hour.
- 34:33You will do anything you can to get your kid into a better situation, whether
- 34:36that's because they're having issues at the school, you know, socially,
- 34:39whether that's because they're, you know, they're not being challenged.
- 34:43The school's not working for them.
- 34:44They're just not learning anything, whatever it is.
- 34:46Parents will, like, do a lot.
- 34:48And if you care about public schools, you should be thinking about, okay, how
- 34:51do we meet those parents where they are, instead of asking them to take on these
- 34:55heroic journeys, if you will, um, for their kids every day or five days a week.
- 35:01Jed: And I think that this non classroom based concept, which I
- 35:05think allows parents to do things.
- 35:07Without the same degree of driving and heroism, is
- 35:12missing in most of the country.
- 35:14And so I'm tipping a hand here.
- 35:16I've really worked within the non cluster based community in California.
- 35:19Will someone please write something saying we need something that like
- 35:22this across the whole country?
- 35:24It's amazing.
- 35:24I talked to Oklahoma.
- 35:25They like, they really want this right now.
- 35:27They don't have it.
- 35:28Texas is just getting it.
- 35:29Louisiana hasn't have it had it.
- 35:31A lot of other places don't have it.
- 35:33And then they have these problems with rural schools.
- 35:35I really think this is a foundational thing.
- 35:37If we got it into the landscape, if we got it into Virginia, I think it would
- 35:40change the discussion in rural settings.
- 35:42Andy: Yeah, I like that.
- 35:44And maybe there is like, that's, I mean we can pretend, we
- 35:49can play assignment editors.
- 35:50You can pretend we're not we can we play one on tv.
- 35:54They're like because that would be a great and just looking at rural
- 35:56charters in general And I mean, there's just like a lot of myth
- 35:59busting that can be done there.
- 36:03But you want to talk about Moms for Liberty, I read two articles since I
- 36:06last saw you, Robert, like they were, you know, they met up there in Philadelphia
- 36:11and Robert Pondiscio and all the presidential candidates, real cattle call.
- 36:14Jed: Yeah, great article.
- 36:16Thank you for sending that to me.
- 36:16Andy: I thought it was interesting.
- 36:18There was, there's two, two big things that I saw.
- 36:20I'm sure there was lots of other stuff written about it, but the two that
- 36:22I saw that came across my desk were.
- 36:25Pondiscio's piece, which was certainly friendly to them.
- 36:31And then there was, a Daily Beast piece, we can put both these in the show
- 36:36notes, that was decidedly less friendly.
- 36:38And I thought they were kind of an interesting juxtaposition.
- 36:41Robert's piece, we could talk about his comparison with TFA was interesting, I
- 36:45think that's what I liked that part of that's worth discussing, but I think
- 36:49he was exceptionally friendly to them.
- 36:52The Daily Beast was exceptionally harsh, and I think a lot of people
- 36:56might think, "wow, the truth probably lies, like, somewhere in between."
- 37:00I'm not saying Robert was untruthful, I just think his take was very rosier
- 37:06and more favorable than mine would be.
- 37:08I just thought it was interesting and it sort of, you know, we got some
- 37:14feedback last time we talked about Moms for Liberty, you know, some people
- 37:17were like, thanks for being nuanced, but some people were like, oh my
- 37:19God, how can you like, say anything, anything at all good about them.
- 37:25And it struck me that's kind of like the times we're in, right?
- 37:29Like there's just not that sort of gray is really hard.
- 37:35It's really hard to get at.
- 37:37Jed: Well, I thought the article was interesting for a lot of reasons
- 37:39but I particularly focused in on the conflict between the national
- 37:43parents union and Moms for Liberty and they're supposedly on opposite sides
- 37:47and they're talking trash about each other and all of that, okay, great.
- 37:50But if you look at the data that they're getting through their serving.
- 37:56They are finding that parents in general vote and voters are just completely and
- 38:01utterly fed up with public education.
- 38:02It's going back to the point that you just made earlier about the
- 38:04level of crisis that we have.
- 38:06NPU, I know they have some new data coming out, it may have come out this
- 38:12week, I'm not sure, I'm talking about Parents recognize, I don't remember
- 38:16the exact numbers strikingly high in the high sixties or something
- 38:20like that, believing that there is a crisis in public education.
- 38:23And then, interestingly, on the side, they also identified improving
- 38:28public education as the second most important issue to voters, which is
- 38:34something we just don't see very often.
- 38:35So they're coming at it from very different standpoints and there may
- 38:39be aspects of what both of them are doing that we don't like, but they're
- 38:42both tapping into something that feels very foundational and very true.
- 38:48Andy: Yeah, I think so, and maybe it's so hot and a lot of that, I watched
- 38:51a lot of that back and forth and it's like that just strikes me that
- 38:53that's a lot of that's adult politics.
- 38:55I have trouble seeing the through line to kids, just in the whole back and forth
- 39:02with, but there's more agreement out there on a lot of this stuff, and in some ways,
- 39:08maybe that makes the debate hotter, right?
- 39:11I mean, you and I talked about this, like, Moms for Liberty, their position,
- 39:15like, you know, schools shouldn't be concealing transitions of kids from their
- 39:19parents, like, That's like a very popular position in this country, like 80%.
- 39:24And I think the Democrats are starting to realize that they're
- 39:27way over their skis on that one.
- 39:30But so is treat kids, treat every kid with respect and dignity and
- 39:33try to have inclusion and tolerance.
- 39:36That's where people are.
- 39:37There's a hardcore group that's not there, but they're small.
- 39:40Thankfully.
- 39:41We've made a lot of progress in this country.
- 39:44You can go down the issues, whether it's, you know, sexual content in books,
- 39:50whether it's just a host of these issues, there's actually, you know, you look,
- 39:56there's just tons of common ground.
- 39:58And I will put in the show notes, we wrote a report called common ground that
- 40:01has lots of this data, but like there really is, you just look like people, you
- 40:04know, people don't need convincing that there's a problem with race and racism in
- 40:10America and historically like you get this hardcore group on both sides, like one
- 40:15side saying nobody actually believes that.
- 40:17And the other side, you know, saying it's not a thing, but those are the
- 40:20margins, like most Americans are there and it's issue after issue.
- 40:24And so a little bit that may add to the heat because there's fundamentally so much
- 40:29less disagreement there than people would think when you get outside the advocates.
- 40:34And so they're vying for these different groups are vying for slices
- 40:37of sort of elite coalitions and elite attention, and it's kind of divorced
- 40:41from what's actually going on in terms of how people are living their lives.
- 40:46Jed: One thing that we can return to in the future.
- 40:48I'd really love to pick your brain on this, given that we have this level
- 40:51of, I've been calling this the great disconnect, I saw this, you know, several
- 40:55years back, just that the overlap between what public education was offering and
- 41:00the bare minimum that parents would exist with would accept was becoming
- 41:05smaller and smaller such that there would be maybe no overlap whatsoever I think
- 41:09that's what we're, coming into and just many many parents just leaving right?
- 41:14Andy: With the pandemic I think did we can talk about this another time the
- 41:17pandemic did like, there's a thing that we called like, you know, path dependency,
- 41:23talking about political science.
- 41:24So when things are on, basically on a path, they tend to proceed on
- 41:28that path until they're disrupted and the pandemic disrupts.
- 41:31There's a lot of path dependency.
- 41:32People are like, "Oh, it might be nice to have a different school
- 41:34or do something different."
- 41:35But like, this is how our life is structured.
- 41:37This is what we do.
- 41:37This is the school.
- 41:38And the pandemic opened up like a lot of possibilities.
- 41:42For a lot of people, particularly people with means there's a obvious
- 41:46class overlay this whole thing.
- 41:48And I think we're seeing the effects of that in people's like,
- 41:53you can be more dissatisfied now you can actually act on that.
- 41:58I don't think the public school establishment has come to terms with
- 42:02that, they're still telling themselves these happy stories, they're picking
- 42:06these fights on other stuff and I don't think they are, I don't think
- 42:10they've actually really come to terms with what a perilous moment it is.
- 42:14Jed: And for people like ourselves who have pretty much anchored ourselves
- 42:18in our entire professional life around the support of public education, and
- 42:22there's some place beyond publicness that we just don't go, vouchers,
- 42:28I think, is going to be something we're going to have to revisit
- 42:32because this is just happening now.
- 42:35And if we want to say that we're interested in public education, but we
- 42:40have nothing to say about how vouchers and private quote unquote private
- 42:45education happens, we're just basically going to write ourselves out of the
- 42:49conversation for generations to come.
- 42:52This is the direction that things are going.
- 42:54And there are ways that these programs can be set up to be more or less public.
- 42:59The thumb on the scale of the kids who need better education more than others.
- 43:04And we can either, just wash your hands of it, and if we do, I think
- 43:08that will mean that these programs will evolve to be less supportive
- 43:12of kids who need it most, right?
- 43:15If we involve ourselves, I think, can make sure that these things
- 43:19actually, become a positive thing.
- 43:22But our voice is going to be needed for that kind of positive thing to happen.
- 43:28Andy: Yeah, we need, we need pragmatism, right?
- 43:29You remember when back in like 2000, Al Gore called himself a pragmatic idealist,
- 43:35and he got a load of crap because that guy could never catch a break, but it's
- 43:39actually, it's a great formulation.
- 43:40Like you want to, we should maintain our ideals and our idealism around this
- 43:44stuff, but you also need to be pragmatic.
- 43:45And you are totally right.
- 43:46Like where we are, we need to meet people where they are.
- 43:49And to the extent we don't.
- 43:51Public education is going to lose a lot of its supporters and the system still seems,
- 43:55you know, just really fixed on trying to alienate people and annoy them with
- 43:59just a host of policies that complicate what people want and how they want to
- 44:04live their lives and what they expect.
- 44:06And I just think it's incredibly ill timed right now with everything going on.
- 44:13And we didn't even get to like learning loss, you've got this like
- 44:16enormous backdrop of just catastrophe.
- 44:21For a lot of kids, people are also not sort of squarely looking at it.
- 44:25Jed: For sure.
- 44:26Well, lots of stuff to keep talking about.
- 44:28We'll be back together in a couple of weeks for our mystery guests.
- 44:30Andy: And yeah, and there we can really get into our mystery guests are
- 44:33going to like T us up to really get into some of these questions around
- 44:37parental empowerment and what's going on in some of these different groups.
- 44:41So their take on all this will be, I think they will bring interesting
- 44:47perspectives and it'll be fascinating.
- 44:49Jed: And so then we'll either take a hiatus.
- 44:51Or I'll join you from halfway through the Camino for one.
- 44:56Andy: Yeah, no, I'm going to want to hear about that.
- 44:57We may need to just do a special one on that.
- 45:00What an amazing experience.
- 45:01I'm so happy that you all can do that in 25 years.
- 45:04That's great.
- 45:05That's a huge accomplishment.
- 45:06Jed: Well, we're excited to be doing it.
- 45:08And I'm just delighted to have this chance to do this stuff with you, Andy.
- 45:12So I look forward to continuing and look forward to seeing you
- 45:15again in a couple of weeks.
- 45:16Andy: Yeah, I will too, Jed.
- 45:17I'll see you in two weeks.
- 45:19It was great to see you.
- 45:19Jed: Okay.
- 45:20Take care.
- 45:20Andy: See ya.