Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [2009] Berkshire Hathaway Letter to Shareholders
Transcript
- 0:00Berkshire Hathaway, Inc to the shareholders of Berkshire
- 0:03Hathaway Incorporated. Our gain in net worth during
- 0:062009 was $21.8 billion, which increased the per share book
- 0:11value of both our Class A and Class B stock by 19.8%.
- 0:16Over the last 40-5 years, that is since present management took
- 0:20over, book value has grown from $19.00 to $84,487, a rate of
- 0:2720.3% compounded annually. Berkshire's recent acquisition
- 0:31of Burlington Northern Santa Fe B NSF has added at least 65,000
- 0:37shareholders to the 500,000 or so already on our books.
- 0:41It's important to Charlie M Unger, my long time partner, and
- 0:45me that all of our owners understand Berkshire's
- 0:47operations, goals, limitations and culture in each annual
- 0:52report. Consequently or state the
- 0:54economic principles that guide us.
- 0:57This year these principles appear on pages 89 to 94 and I
- 1:01urge all of you, but particularly our new
- 1:04shareholders to read them. Berkshire has adhered to these
- 1:07principles for decades and will continue to do so long after IMG
- 1:11One. In this letter, we will also
- 1:13review some of the basics so for business, hoping to provide both
- 1:17a freshman orientation session for our BNSF newcomers and a
- 1:21refresher course for Berkshire veterans.
- 1:24How we measure ourselves. Our metrics for evaluating our
- 1:27managerial performance are displayed on the facing page.
- 1:31From the start, Charlie and I have believed in having a
- 1:34rational and unbending standard for measuring what we have or
- 1:38have not accomplished. That keeps us from the
- 1:41temptation of seeing where the arrow of performance lands and
- 1:44then painting the bull's eye around it.
- 1:47Selecting the S&P 500 as our bogey was an easy choice because
- 1:51our shareholders, at virtually no cost, can match its
- 1:55performance by holding an index fund.
- 1:57Why should they pay us for merely duplicating that result?
- 2:01A more difficult decision for us was how to measure the progress
- 2:04of Berkshire versus the S&P. There are good arguments for
- 2:08simply using the change in our stock price over an extended
- 2:11period of time. In fact, that is the best test.
- 2:16But year to year market prices can be extraordinarily erratic.
- 2:19Even evaluations covering as long as a decade can be greatly
- 2:24distorted by foolishly high or low prices at the beginning or
- 2:28end of the measurement period. Steve Ballmer of Microsoft and
- 2:32Jeff Immelt of GE can tell you about that problem, suffering as
- 2:36they do from the Nosebleed prices at which their stocks
- 2:39traded when they were handed the managerial batten.
- 2:42The ideal standard for measuring our yearly progress would be the
- 2:45change in Berkshires per share intrinsic value.
- 2:49Alas, that value cannot be calculated with anything close
- 2:52to precision, so we instead use a crude proxy for it per share.
- 2:57Book value relying on this yardstick has its shortcomings,
- 3:01which we discuss on pages 92 and 93.
- 3:04Additionally, book value at most companies under states intrinsic
- 3:08value, and that is certainly the case at Berkshire.
- 3:11In aggregate, our businesses are worth considerably more than the
- 3:15values at which they are carried on our books.
- 3:18In our all important insurance business, moreover, the
- 3:21difference is huge. Even so, Charlie and I believe
- 3:25that our book value, understated though it is, supplies the most
- 3:28useful tracking device for changes in intrinsic value.
- 3:32By this measurement, as the opening paragraph of this letter
- 3:35states, our book value since the start of fiscal 1965 has grown
- 3:40at a rate of 20.3% compounded annually.
- 3:44All per share figures used in this report apply to Berkshires
- 3:47A shares. Figures for the B shares are
- 3:5011,500 TH of those shown for A. We should note that had we
- 3:55instead chosen market prices as our yardstick, Berkshire's
- 3:58results would look better, showing again since the start of
- 4:02fiscal 1965 of 22% compounded annually.
- 4:06Surprisingly, this modest difference in annual compounding
- 4:10rate leads to an 801,516% market value gain for the entire 45
- 4:16year period compared to the book value gain of 434,000 and 57%
- 4:22shown on page 2. Our market gain is better
- 4:25because in 1965 Berkshire shares sold at an appropriate discount
- 4:30to the book value of its under earning textile assets, whereas
- 4:34today Berkshire shares regularly sell at a premium to the
- 4:37accounting values of its first class businesses.
- 4:40Summed up, the table on page 2 conveys 3 messages, 2 positive
- 4:45and one hugely negative. 1st, we have never had any five year
- 4:49period beginning with 1965 to 69 and ending with 2005 dash 09 and
- 4:56there have been 41 of these during which our gain in book
- 4:59value did not exceed the S and PS gain.
- 5:02Second, though we have lagged the S&P in some years that were
- 5:06positive for the market, we have consistently done better than
- 5:09the S&P in the 11 years during which it delivered negative
- 5:13results. In other words, our defense has
- 5:16been better than our offense, and that's likely to continue.
- 5:20The big minus is that our performance advantage has shrunk
- 5:23dramatically as our size has grown, an unpleasant trend that
- 5:27is certain to continue. To be sure, Berkshire has many
- 5:31outstanding businesses and a cadre of truly great managers
- 5:35operating within an unusual corporate culture that lets them
- 5:38maximize their talents. Charlie and I believe these
- 5:42factors will continue to produce better than average results over
- 5:45time. But huge sums forge their own
- 5:48anchor, and our future advantage, if any, will be a
- 5:51small fraction of our historical edge.
- 5:54What we don't do? Long ago, Charlie laid out his
- 5:57strongest ambition. All I want to know is where I'm
- 5:59going to die, so I'll never go there.
- 6:02That bit of wisdom was inspired by Jacobi, the great Prussian
- 6:06mathematician who counseled Invert always invert as an A to
- 6:11solving difficult problems. I can report as well that this
- 6:14inversion approach works on a less lofty level.
- 6:17Sing a country song in reverse and you will quickly recover
- 6:21your car, house and wife. Here area a few examples of how
- 6:25we apply Charlie's thinking at Berkshire.
- 6:28Charlie and I avoid businesses whose futures we can evaluate,
- 6:31no matter how exciting they're products may be.
- 6:34In the past, it required no brilliance for people to foresee
- 6:38the fabulous growth that awaited such industries as autos in
- 6:421910, aircraft in 1930 and television sets in 1950.
- 6:47But the future then also included competitive dynamics
- 6:51that would decimate almost all of the companies entering those
- 6:54industries. Even the survivors tended to
- 6:56come away bleeding. Just because Charlie and I can
- 6:59clearly see dramatic growth ahead for an industry does not
- 7:03mean we can judge what its profit margins and returns on
- 7:06capital will be. As a host of competitors battle
- 7:09for supremacy at Berkshire, we will stick with businesses whose
- 7:12profit picture for decades to come seems reasonably
- 7:15predictable. Even then, we will make plenty
- 7:18of mistakes. We will never become dependent
- 7:21on the kindness of strangers. Too Big to Fail is not a fall
- 7:24back position at Berkshire. Instead, we will always arrange
- 7:28our affairs so that any requirements for cash we may
- 7:32conceivably have will be dwarfed by our own liquidity.
- 7:35Moreover, that liquidity will be constantly refreshed by a gusher
- 7:39of earnings from our many and diverse businesses.
- 7:42When the financial system went into cardiac arrest in September
- 7:452008, Berkshire was a supplier of liquidity and capital to the
- 7:50system, not a supplicant. At the very peak of the crisis,
- 7:54we poured $15.5 billion into a business world that could
- 7:59otherwise look only to the federal government for help.
- 8:02Of that, $9 billion went to bolster capital at 3 highly
- 8:06regarded and previously secure American businesses that needed,
- 8:10without delay, our tangible vote of confidence.
- 8:13The remaining $6.5 billion satisfied our commitment to help
- 8:17fund the purchase of Wrigley, a deal that was completed without
- 8:21pause, while elsewhere panic reigned. 4 We pay a steep price
- 8:26to maintain our premier financial strength.
- 8:29The $20 billion plus of cash equivalent assets that we
- 8:33customarily hold is earning A pittance at present, but we
- 8:36sleep well. We tend to let our many
- 8:38subsidiaries operate on their own without our supervising and
- 8:43monitoring them to any degree. That means we are sometimes late
- 8:46in spotting management problems and that both operating and
- 8:50capital decisions are occasionally made with which
- 8:52Charlie and I would have disagreed have we been
- 8:55consulted. Most of our managers, however,
- 8:58use the independence we grant them magnificently rewarding our
- 9:02confidence by maintaining an owner oriented attitude that is
- 9:06invaluable and too seldom found in huge organizations.
- 9:10We would rather suffer the visible costs of a few bad
- 9:13decisions than incur the many invisible costs that come from
- 9:17decisions made too slowly or not at all because of a stifling
- 9:21bureaucracy. With our acquisition of BNSF, we
- 9:24now have about 257,000 employees and literally hundreds of
- 9:29different operating units. We hope to have many more of
- 9:32each, but we will never allow Berkshire to become some
- 9:35monolith that is overrun with committees, budget presentations
- 9:39and multiple layers of management.
- 9:42Instead, we plan to operate as a collection of separately managed
- 9:46medium A sized and large businesses, most of whose
- 9:49decision making occurs at the operating level.
- 9:52Charlie and I will limit ourselves to allocating capital,
- 9:55controlling enterprise risk, choosing managers and setting
- 9:59their compensation. We make no attempt to woo Wall
- 10:02Street. Investors who buy and sell based
- 10:04upon media or analyst commentary are not for us.
- 10:08Instead, we want partners who join us at Berkshire because
- 10:11they wish to make a long term investment in a business they
- 10:15themselves understand, and because it's one that follows
- 10:18policies with which they concur. If Charlie and I were to go into
- 10:21a small venture with a few partners, we would seek
- 10:24individuals In Sync with us, knowing that common goals and a
- 10:28shared destiny make for a happy business marriage between owners
- 10:32and managers. Scaling up to giant size doesn't
- 10:35change that truth. To build a compatible
- 10:37shareholder population, we try to communicate with our owners
- 10:41directly an informative LY. Our goal is to tell you what we
- 10:45would like to know if our ositions were reversed.
- 10:48Additionally, we try to post our quarterly and annual financial
- 10:52information on the Internet early on weekends, thereby
- 10:55giving you and other investors plenty of time during a non
- 10:59trading period to digest just what has happened.
- 11:01A tour multifaceted enterprise. Occasionally SEC deadlines force
- 11:06a non Friday disclosure. These matters simply can't be
- 11:10adequately summarized in a few paragraphs, nor do they lend
- 11:13themselves to the kind of catchy headline that journalists
- 11:17sometimes seek. Last year, we saw in one
- 11:20instance how sound bite reporting can go wrong.
- 11:23Among the 12,830 words in the annual letter was this sentence.
- 11:28We are certain, for example, that the economy will be in
- 11:32shambles throughout 2009 and probably well beyond.
- 11:36But that conclusion does not tell us whether the market will
- 11:39rise or fall. Many news organizations
- 11:42reported, indeed blare the first part of the sentence while
- 11:46making no mention whatsoever of its ending.
- 11:48I regard this as terrible journalism.
- 11:51Misinformed readers or viewers may well have thought that
- 11:54Charlie and I were forecasting bad things for the stock market,
- 11:58though we had not only in that sentence but also elsewhere made
- 12:02it clear we weren't predicting the market at all.
- 12:05Any investors who were misled by the sensationalists paid a big
- 12:09price. The Dow closed the day of the
- 12:11letter at 7063 and finished the year at 10428.
- 12:16Given a few experiences we've had like that, you can
- 12:19understand why I prefer that are communications with you remain
- 12:23as direct and unabridged as possible.
- 12:26Let's move to the specifics of Berkshires operations.
- 12:29We have 4 major operating sectors, each differing from the
- 12:32others in balance sheet and income account characteristics.
- 12:36Therefore lumping them together as a standard in financial
- 12:39statements impedes analysis. So well present them as four
- 12:43separate businesses, which is how Charlie and I view them.
- 12:47Five insurance, our property casualty piece insurance
- 12:51business has been the engine behind Berkshires growth and
- 12:54will continue to be. It has worked wonders for us.
- 12:58We carry our PC companies on our books at $15.5 billion more than
- 13:03their net tangible assets, an amount lodged in our Goodwill
- 13:06account. These companies, however, are
- 13:09worth far more than they're carrying value, and the
- 13:12following look at the economic model of the PC industry will
- 13:15tell you why. Insurers receive premiums
- 13:18upfront and pay claims later. In extreme cases, such as those
- 13:22arising from certain workers compensation accidents, payments
- 13:26can stretch over decades. This collect now, pay later
- 13:29model leaves us holding large sums, money we call float that
- 13:33will eventually go to others. Meanwhile, we get to invest this
- 13:37float for Berkshire's benefit. Though individual policies and
- 13:40claims come and go, the amount of float we hold remains
- 13:44remarkably stable in relation to premium volume.
- 13:47Consequently, as our business grows, so does our float.
- 13:51If premiums exceed the total of expenses and eventual losses, we
- 13:56register an underwriting profit that adds to the investment
- 13:59income produced from the float. This combination allows us to
- 14:03enjoy the use of free money and, better yet, get paid for holding
- 14:07it. Alas, the hope of this happy
- 14:10result attracts intense competition so vigorous in most
- 14:13years as to cause the PC industry as a whole to operate
- 14:16at a significant underwriting loss.
- 14:19This loss, in effect, is what the industry pays to hold its
- 14:22float. Usually this cost is fairly low,
- 14:25but in some catastrophe written years the cost from underwriting
- 14:29losses more than eats up the income derived from use of
- 14:33float. In my perhaps biased view,
- 14:36Berkshire has the best large insurance operation in the world
- 14:39and I will absolutely state that we have the best managers.
- 14:43Our float has grown from $16,000,000 in 1967 when we
- 14:48entered the business to $62 billion at the end of 2009.
- 14:53Moreover, we have now operated at an underwriting profit for
- 14:57seven consecutive years. I believe it likely that we will
- 15:00continue to underwrite profitably in most, though
- 15:03certainly not all, future years. If we do so, our float will be
- 15:07cost free, much as if someone deposited $62 billion with us
- 15:12that we could invest for our own benefit without the payment of
- 15:15interest. Let me emphasize again that cost
- 15:17free float is not a result to be expected for the PC industry as
- 15:21a whole. In most years, premiums have
- 15:24been inadequate to cover claims plus expenses.
- 15:27Consequently, the industry's overall return on tangible
- 15:30equity has for many decades fallen far short of that
- 15:33achieved by the S&P 500. Outstanding economics exist at
- 15:38Berkshire only because we have some outstanding managers
- 15:41running some unusual businesses. Our insurance CEOs deserve your
- 15:46thanks. Having added many billions of
- 15:48dollars to Berkshire's value, it's a pleasure for me to tell
- 15:52you about these All Stars. Let's start at GEICO, which is
- 15:55known to all of you because of its $800 million annual
- 15:59advertising budget, close to twice that of the runner up
- 16:02advertiser in the auto insurance field.
- 16:04GEICO is managed by Tony Nicely, who joined the company at 18.
- 16:09Now 66, Tony still tap dances to the office every day, just as I
- 16:13do at 79. We both feel lucky to work at a
- 16:16business we love. Geico's customers have warm
- 16:19feelings toward the company as well.
- 16:21Pay raise Proof Since Berkshire acquired control of GEICO in
- 16:251996, its market share has increased from 2.5% to 8.1%, a
- 16:31gain reflecting the net addition of 7 million policyholders.
- 16:36Perhaps they contacted us because they thought our gecko
- 16:38was cute, but they bought from us to save important money.
- 16:42Maybe you can as well. Call 1-800-847-7536 or go to
- 16:49www.geico.com. And they've stayed with us
- 16:53because they like our service as well as our price.
- 16:56Berkshire acquired GEICO in two stages in 1976 to 80.
- 17:01We bought about 1/3 of the company's stock for $47 million.
- 17:06Over the years, large repurchase S by the company of its own
- 17:09shares caused our position to grow to about 50% without our
- 17:13having bought any more shares. Then on January 2nd, 1996, we
- 17:19acquired the remaining 50% of GEICO for $2.3 billion in cash,
- 17:25about 50 times the cost of our original purchase. 6 An old Wall
- 17:30Street joke gets close to our experience.
- 17:32Customer Thanks for putting main XYZ stock at 5.
- 17:36I hear it's up to 18. Broker Yes, and that's just the
- 17:40beginning. In fact, the company is doing so
- 17:43well now that it's an even better buy at 18 than it was
- 17:46when you made your purchase. Customer Damn, I knew I should
- 17:50have waited. Geico's growth may slow in 2010.
- 17:54US vehicle registrations are actually down because of
- 17:57slumping auto sales. Moreover, high unemployment is
- 18:01causing a growing number of drivers Togo uninsured.
- 18:04That's illegal almost everywhere.
- 18:06But if you've lost your job and still want to drive.
- 18:09Our low cost producer status, however, is sure to give us
- 18:12significant gains in the future. In 1995, GEICO was the country's
- 18:17sixth largest auto insurer. Now we are #3 the company's
- 18:22float has grown from $2.7 billion to $9.6 billion.
- 18:27Equally important, GEICO has operated at an underwriting
- 18:31profit in 13 of the 14 years Berkshire has owned it.
- 18:34I became excited about GEICO in January 1951 when I first
- 18:39visited the company as a 20 year old student.
- 18:42Thanks to Tony, I'm even more excited today.
- 18:45A hugely important event in Berkshire's history occurred on
- 18:48a Saturday in 1985. AJ Jane came into our office in
- 18:53Omaha and I immediately knew we had found a superstar.
- 18:57He had been discovered by Mike Goldberg, now elevated to Saint
- 19:00Mike. We immediately put A Jade in
- 19:03charge of National Indemnity, small and struggling reinsurance
- 19:06operation. Over the years he has built this
- 19:09business into a one-of-a-kind giant in the insurance world.
- 19:13Staffed today by only 30 people, A Jade's operation has set
- 19:17records for transaction size in several areas of insurance.
- 19:21AJ writes billion dollar limits and then keeps every dime of the
- 19:25risk instead of laying it off with other insurers. 3 years ago
- 19:29he took over huge liabilities from Lloyd's, allowing it to
- 19:33clean up its relationship with 27,972 participants names who
- 19:39had written problem ridden policies that at one point
- 19:42threatened the survival of this 322 year old institution.
- 19:46The premium for that single contract was $7.1 billion.
- 19:51During 2009, he negotiated a life reinsurance contract that
- 19:55could produce $50 billion of premium for us over the next 50
- 19:59or so years. AJ It's business is just the
- 20:03opposite of Geicos. At that company we have millions
- 20:06of small policies that largely renew year after year.
- 20:10AJ It writes relatively few policies, and the mix changes
- 20:14significantly from year to year throughout the world.
- 20:17He is known as the man to call when something both very large
- 20:21and unusual needs to be insured. If Charlie I and AJ It are ever
- 20:26in a sinking boat and you can only save one of us from to AJ
- 20:29It. Our third insurance powerhouse
- 20:31is General Ree. Some years back this operation
- 20:34was troubled. Now it is a gleaming jewel in
- 20:37our insurance crown. Under the leadership of T Admont
- 20:41Ross, General Ree had an outstanding underwriting year in
- 20:442009, while also delivering us unusually large amounts of float
- 20:49per dollar of premium volume. Alongside General residential PC
- 20:54business, Tad and his associates have developed a major life
- 20:58reinsurance operation that has grown increasingly valuable.
- 21:02Last year, General Rhee finally attained 100% ownership of
- 21:05Cologne Rhee, which since 1995 has been a he, though only
- 21:10partially owned part of our presence around the world.
- 21:13Tad and I will be visiting Cologne in September to thank
- 21:16its managers for their important contribution to Berkshire 7.
- 21:20Finally, we own a group of smaller companies, most of them
- 21:24specializing in odd corners of the insurance world.
- 21:27In aggregate, their results have consistently been profitable and
- 21:31as the table below shows, the float they provide us is
- 21:35substantial. Charlie and I treasure these
- 21:37companies and their managers. Here is the record of all four
- 21:41segments of our property, casualty and life insurance
- 21:44businesses underwriting profit, year and float in millions.
- 21:48Insurance Operations 2009 2008 2009 2008 General REE 477
- 21:57Dollars $342 Twenty $1014.00 Twenty $1074 BH Reinsurance
- 22:073491324 Twenty 6223 Two 4221 GEICO 649916 96138454 Other
- 22:21Primary 8421050614730 Nine 1559 Dollars 2792 Dollars 61,911
- 22:34Dollars $58,488 And now a painful confession.
- 22:40Last year, your chairman closed the book on a very expensive
- 22:43business fiasco entirely of his own making.
- 22:46For many years, I had struggled to think of side products that
- 22:49we could offer our millions of loyal GEICO customers.
- 22:53Unfortunately, I finally succeeded, coming up with a
- 22:56brilliant insight that we should market our own credit card.
- 22:59I reasoned that GEICO policy holders were likely to be good
- 23:02credit risks and assuming we offered an attractive card,
- 23:07would likely favor us with their business.
- 23:09We got business all right, but of the wrong type.
- 23:12Our pre tax losses from credit card operations came to about
- 23:15$6.3 million before I finally woke up.
- 23:19We then sold our $98 million portfolio of troubled receivable
- 23:24S for 55 on the dollar, losing an additional $44 million.
- 23:30Geico's managers, it should be emphasized we're never
- 23:33enthusiastic about my idea. They warned me that instead of
- 23:36getting the cream of Geico's customers, we would get the
- 23:39well, let's call it the non cream.
- 23:42I subtly indicated that I was older and wiser.
- 23:45I was just older. Regulated utility business
- 23:48Berkshire has an 89.5% interest in Mid American Energy Holdings,
- 23:53which owns a wide variety of utility operations.
- 23:57The largest of these are One Yorkshire Electricity and
- 24:00Northern Electric whose 3.8 million and users make it the UK
- 24:05dot S 3rd largest distributor of electricity. 2 Mid American
- 24:09Energy, which serves 725000 electric customers primarily in
- 24:14Iowa. 3 Pacific Power and Rocky Mountain Power serving about 1.7
- 24:19million electric customers in six western States and four Kern
- 24:24River and Northern Natural Pipelines, which carry about 8%
- 24:28of the natural gas consumed in the US.
- 24:31Mid American has two terrific managers, Dave Sokal and Greg
- 24:35Abel. In addition, my longtime friend
- 24:38Walter Scott, along with his family, has a major ownership
- 24:41position in the company. Walter brings extraordinary
- 24:45business savvy to any operation. 10 years of working with Dave,
- 24:49Greg and Walter have reinforced my original belief Berkshire
- 24:53couldn't have better partners. They are truly a dream team.
- 24:56Somewhat incongruously, Mid American also owns the second
- 25:00largest real estate brokerage firm in the US, Home Services of
- 25:04America. This company operates through 21
- 25:07locally branded firms that have 16,000 agents.
- 25:11Though last year was again a terrible year for home sales,
- 25:15Home Services earned a modest sum.
- 25:17It also acquired a firm in Chicago and will add other
- 25:21quality brokerage operations when they are available at
- 25:23sensible prices a decade from now.
- 25:26Home services is likely to be much larger. 8 Here are some key
- 25:31figures on Mid Americans operations.
- 25:33Consists of a breakup fee of $175,000,000 and a profit on our
- 25:38investment of $917 million. Includes interest earned by
- 25:43Berkshire net of related income tax off $38 in 2009 and $72 in
- 25:492008. Our regulated electric utilities
- 25:53offering monopoly service in most cases operate in a
- 25:56symbiotic manner with the customers in their service areas
- 26:00with those users depending on us to provide first class service
- 26:04and invest for their future needs.
- 26:06Permitting and construction periods for generation and major
- 26:09transmission facilities stretch way out, so it is incumbent onus
- 26:14to be farsighted. We in turn look to our
- 26:17utilities, regulate Tors acting on behalf of our customers,
- 26:21though allow use an appropriate return on the huge amounts of
- 26:24capital we must deploy to meet future needs.
- 26:27We shouldn't expect our regulators to live up to their
- 26:30end of the bargain unless we live up to ours.
- 26:33Dave and Greg make sure we do just that.
- 26:35National Research companies consistently rank our Iowa and
- 26:39Western utilities at or near the top of their industry.
- 26:43Similarly, among the 43 US pipelines ranked by a firm named
- 26:48Mast IO, our Current River and Northern Natural properties tied
- 26:52for second place. Moreover, we continue to pour
- 26:55huge sums of money into our operations so as to not only
- 26:59prepare for the future, but also make these operations more
- 27:02environmentally friendly. Since we purchased Mid American
- 27:0510 years ago, it has never paid a dividend.
- 27:09We have instead used earnings to improve and expand our
- 27:12properties in each of the territories we serve.
- 27:15As one dramatic example, in the last three years our Iowa and
- 27:19Western utilities have earned $2.5 billion, while in this same
- 27:24period spending $3 billion on wind generation facilities.
- 27:28Mid American has consistently kept its end of the bargain with
- 27:31society, and to society's credit, it has reciprocated.
- 27:36With few exceptions, our regulators have promptly allowed
- 27:39us to earn a fair return on the ever increasing sums of capital
- 27:43we must invest. Going forward, we will do
- 27:46whatever it takes to serve our territories in the manner they
- 27:49expect. We believe that in turn, we will
- 27:52be allowed the return we deserve on the funds we invest.
- 27:56In earlier days, Charlie and I shunned capital intensive
- 27:59businesses such as Public Utilities.
- 28:02Indeed, they best businesses by far for owners continue to be
- 28:06those that have high returns on capital and that require little
- 28:09incremental investment to grow. We are fortunate to own a number
- 28:13of such businesses and we would love to buy more.
- 28:16Anticipating however that Berkshire will generate ever
- 28:20increasing amounts of cash, we are today quite willing to enter
- 28:24businesses that regularly require large capital
- 28:27expenditures. We expect only that these
- 28:29businesses have reasonable expectations of earning decent
- 28:33returns on the incremental sums they invest.
- 28:36If our expectations are met, and we believe that they will be,
- 28:39Berkshire's ever growing collection of good to great
- 28:42businesses should produce above average, though certainly not
- 28:46spectacular, returns in the decades ahead. 9 Our BNSF
- 28:51operation, it should be noted, has certain important economic
- 28:54characteristics that resemble those of our electric utilities.
- 28:58In both cases, we provide fundamental services that are
- 29:02and will remain essential to the economic well-being of our
- 29:05customers, the communities we serve, and indeed the nation.
- 29:09Both will require heavy investment that greatly exceeds
- 29:13depreciation allowances for decades to come.
- 29:16Both must also plan far ahead to satisfy demand that is expected
- 29:20to outstrip the needs of the past.
- 29:23Finally, both require wise regulators who will provide
- 29:26certainty about allowable returns so that we can
- 29:29confidently make the huge investments required to
- 29:32maintain, replace and expand the plant.
- 29:35We see a social compact existing between the public and our
- 29:39railroad business, just as is the case with our utilities.
- 29:43If either side shirks its obligations, both sides will
- 29:46inevitably suffer. Therefore, both parties too, the
- 29:49compact should, and we believe, will understand the benefit of
- 29:52behaving in a way that encourages good behavior by the
- 29:56other. It is inconceivable that our
- 29:58country will realize anything close to its full economic
- 30:02potential without its possessing first class electricity and
- 30:06railroad systems. We will do our part to see that
- 30:09they exist in the future. BNSF results will be included in
- 30:13this regulated utility section. Aside from the two businesses
- 30:17having similar underlying economic characteristics, both
- 30:21are logical users of substantial amounts of debt that is not
- 30:25guaranteed by Berkshire. Both will retain most of their
- 30:28earnings. Both will earn and invest large
- 30:31sums in good times or bad, though the railroad will display
- 30:35the greater cyclical at Y overall.
- 30:37We expect this regulated sector to deliver significantly
- 30:41increased earnings over time, albeit at the cost of our
- 30:45investing many 10s, yes, 10s off billions of dollars of
- 30:49incremental equity capital, manufacturing, service and
- 30:53retailing operations. Our activities in this part of
- 30:56Berkshire cover the waterfront. Let's look though at a summary
- 30:59balance sheet and earnings statement for the entire group.
- 31:03Almost all of the many and widely diverse operations in
- 31:06this sector suffered to 1° or another from 2009's severe
- 31:11recession. The major exception was Mack
- 31:14Lane, our distributor of groceries, confections and non
- 31:18food items to thousands of retail outlets.
- 31:21The largest by far, Walmart. Grady Rosier LED Mack Lane to
- 31:25record pre tax earnings of $344 million, which Even so amounted
- 31:30to only slightly more than one cent per dollar on its huge
- 31:33sales of $31.2 billion. Mack Lane employs a vast array
- 31:38of physical assets, practically all of which it owns, including
- 31:423242 trailers, 23 O 9 tractors, and 55 distribution centers with
- 31:4915.2 million square feet of space.
- 31:52Maclane's prime asset, however, is Grady.
- 31:55We had a number of companies at which profits improved even as
- 31:58sales contracted. Always an exceptional managerial
- 32:02achievement. Here are the CEOs who made it
- 32:04happen. Company CEO.
- 32:06Benjamin Moore, Paint. Dennis Abrams.
- 32:09Borsheim's jewelry retailing. Susan Jacques, HH Brown
- 32:13Manufacturing and retailing of shoes, Gym Isler, CTBE
- 32:17agricultural equipment. Victoria Mancine, Lee Dairy
- 32:20Queen, John Gain or Nebraska Furniture Mart furniture
- 32:24retailing. Ron and Irv Blumkin, Pampered
- 32:27Chef, direct sales of kitchen tools.
- 32:29Marla Gottschalk. Cease manufacturing and
- 32:32retailing of candy. Brad Key, Insler, Star
- 32:35Furniture, Furniture retailing. Bill Kimbrellel.
- 32:38Among the businesses we own that have major exposure to the
- 32:41depressed industrial sector, both Marm On and his car turned
- 32:45in relatively strong performances.
- 32:47Frank P Tax Marm On delivered a 13.5% pre tax profit margin, a
- 32:53record high, though the company's sales were down 27%.
- 32:57Frank's cost conscious management mitigated the decline
- 33:00in earnings. Nothing stops.
- 33:02Israel based his car. Not wars, recessions or
- 33:05competitors. The world's two other leading
- 33:08suppliers of small cutting tools.
- 33:10Both had very difficult years, each operating at a loss
- 33:13throughout much of the year. Though his car's results were
- 33:17down significantly from 2008, the company regularly reported
- 33:21profits even while it was integrating and rationalizing
- 33:24Tong Alo Y, the large Japanese acquisition that we told you
- 33:28about last year. When manufacturing rebounds, his
- 33:32car will set new records. It's incredible.
- 33:35Managerial team of Eiden Wertheimer, Jacob Harp AZ and
- 33:40Danny Goldman will see to that every business we own that is
- 33:43connected to residential and commercial construction suffered
- 33:46severely in 2009. Combined pre tax earnings of
- 33:50Shaw, Johns, Manville, Acme, Brick and Metech were $227
- 33:56million on 82.5% decline from $1.295 billion in 2006 when
- 34:03construction activity was booming.
- 34:05These businesses continue to bump along the bottom, though
- 34:09their competitive positions remain undented.
- 34:12The major problem for Berkshire last year was Net Jets, an
- 34:15aviation operation that offers fractional ownership of jets.
- 34:19Over the years, it has been enormously successful in
- 34:22establishing itself as the premier company in its industry,
- 34:26with the value of its fleet far exceeding that of its three
- 34:29major competitors combined. Overall, our dominance in the
- 34:33field remains unchallenged. Net Jets business operation,
- 34:37however, has been another story. In the 11 years that we have
- 34:41owned the company, it has recorded an aggregate pre tax
- 34:44loss of $157 million. Moreover, the company's debt has
- 34:49soared from $102 million at the time of purchase to $1.9 billion
- 34:55in April of last year. Without Berkshire's guarantee of
- 34:58this debt, Net Jets would have been out of business.
- 35:01It's clear that I failed you in letting Net Jets descend into
- 35:04this condition, but luckily I have been bailed out. 11 Dave
- 35:09Sokol, the enormously talented builder and operator of Mid
- 35:13American Energy, became CEO of Net Jets in August.
- 35:17His leadership has been transforming.
- 35:19That has already been reduced to $1.4 billion, and after
- 35:24suffering A staggering loss of $711 million in 2009, the
- 35:29company is now solidly profitable.
- 35:32Most important, none of the changes wrought by Dave have in
- 35:35any way undercut the top of the line standards for safety and
- 35:39service that Rich St. Ali, Net Jet's previous CEO and
- 35:42the father of the fractional ownership industry, insisted
- 35:46upon. Dave and I have the strongest
- 35:48possible personal interest in maintaining these standards
- 35:52because we and our families use net jets for almost all of our
- 35:55flying, as do many of our directors and managers.
- 35:59None of USA reassigned special planes nor cruise.
- 36:03We receive exactly the same treatment as any other owner,
- 36:07meaning we pay the same prices as everyone else does when we
- 36:10are using our personal contracts.
- 36:12In short, we at our own cooking. In the aviation business, no
- 36:16other testimonial means more finance and financial products.
- 36:20Our largest operation in this sector is Clayton Homes, the
- 36:24country's leading producer of modular and manufactured homes.
- 36:28Clayton was not always #1A decade ago, the three leading
- 36:32manufacturers were Fleetwood, Champion and Oakwood, which
- 36:37together accounted for 44% of the output of the industry.
- 36:41All have since gone bankrupt. Total industry output,
- 36:44meanwhile, has fallen from 382,000 units in 1999 to 60,000
- 36:50units in 2009. The industry is in shambles for
- 36:54two reasons, the first of which must be lived with if the USDOT
- 36:59economy is to recover. This reason concerns you.
- 37:02S dot housing starts, including apartment units in 2009 starts
- 37:07where 554000, by far the lowest number in the 50 years for which
- 37:12we have data. Paradoxically, this is good
- 37:15news. People thought it was good news
- 37:17a few years back when housing starts the supply side of the
- 37:20picture, we're running about 2 million annually.
- 37:23But household formations, the demand side only amounted to
- 37:27about 1.2 million. After a few years of such
- 37:30imbalances, the country unsurprisingly ended up with far
- 37:33too many houses. There were three ways to cure
- 37:36this overhang. One, blow up a lot of houses, a
- 37:40tactic similar to the destruction of autos that
- 37:42occurred with the Cash for Clunkers program to speed up
- 37:46household formations. Buy, say, encouraging teenagers
- 37:49to cohabit aid, a program not likely to suffer from a lack of
- 37:53volunteers. Or three, reduce new housing
- 37:56starts to a number far below the rate of household formations.
- 38:00Our country has wisely selected the third option, which means
- 38:04that within a year or so residential housing problems
- 38:07should largely be behind us, the exceptions being only high value
- 38:11houses and those in certain localities where overbuilding
- 38:15was particularly egregious. Prices will remain far below
- 38:18bubble levels, of course, but for every seller A lender hurt
- 38:22by this, there will be a buyer who benefits.
- 38:25Indeed, many families that couldn't afford to buy an
- 38:28appropriate home a few years ago now find it well within their
- 38:32means because the bubble burst. The second reason that
- 38:35manufactured housing is troubled is specific to the industry, the
- 38:39punitive differential in mortgage rates between factory
- 38:42built homes and site built homes.
- 38:44Before you read further, let me under score the obvious.
- 38:48Berkshire has a dog in this fight and you should therefore
- 38:51assess the commentary that follows with special care.
- 38:54That warning made, however, let me explain why the rate
- 38:58differential causes problems for both large numbers of lower
- 39:01income Americans and Clayton. The residential mortgage market
- 39:05is shaped by government rules that are expressed by FHA,
- 39:08Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae. Their lending standards are all
- 39:12powerful because the mortgages they insure can typically BSE
- 39:16curitize zed and turned into what in effect is an obligation
- 39:20of the US government. Currently, buyers of
- 39:24conventional site built homes who qualify for these guarantees
- 39:27can obtain a 30 year loan at about 51 four percent.
- 39:31In addition, these are mortgages that have recently been
- 39:35purchased in massive amounts by the Federal Reserve, an action
- 39:38that also helped to keep rates at bargain basement levels.
- 39:42In contrast, very few factory built homes qualify for agency
- 39:46insured mortgages. Therefore, a meritorious buyer
- 39:49of a factory built home must pay about 9% on his loan for the all
- 39:53cash buyer. Clayton's homes offer terrific
- 39:56value if the buyer needs mortgage financing.
- 39:59However, and of course most buyers Duff difference in
- 40:03financing costs too often negates the attractive price of
- 40:07a factory built home. 12 last year it old UYR buyers,
- 40:11generally people with low incomes, performed so well as
- 40:14credit risks. Their attitude was all
- 40:17important. They signed up to live in the
- 40:19home, not resell or refinance it.
- 40:22Consequently, our buyers usually took out loans with payments
- 40:25geared to their verified incomes.
- 40:27We weren't making liar's loans and looked forward to the day
- 40:31they could burn their mortgage. If they lost their jobs, had
- 40:34health problems or got divorced, we could, of course, expect
- 40:37defaults. But they seldom walked away
- 40:40simply because house values had fallen.
- 40:42Even today, though job loss troubles have grown, Clayton's
- 40:46delinquencies and defaults remain reasonable and will not
- 40:49'cause a significant problems. We have tried to qualify more of
- 40:53our customers loans for treatment similar to those
- 40:56available on the site built product.
- 40:58So far we have had only token success.
- 41:01Many families with modest incomes but responsible habits
- 41:05have therefore had to forgo home ownership simply because the
- 41:08financing differential attached to the factory built product
- 41:12makes monthly payments too expensive.
- 41:14If qualifications aren't broadened so as to open low cost
- 41:18financing to all who meet down payment and income standards,
- 41:22the manufactured home industry seems destined to struggle and
- 41:25dwindle. Even under these conditions, I
- 41:28believe Clayton will operate profitably in coming years,
- 41:31though well below its potential. We couldn't have a better
- 41:34manager than CEO Kevin Clayton, who treats Berkshires interests
- 41:39as if they were his own. Our product is first class,
- 41:42inexpensive and constantly being improved.
- 41:45Moreover, we will continue to use Berkshire's credit to
- 41:48support Clayton's mortgage program, convinced as we are of
- 41:51its soundness. Even so, Berkshire can't borrow
- 41:54at a rate approaching that available to government
- 41:57agencies. This handicap will limit sales,
- 42:00hurting both Clayton and a multitude of worthy families who
- 42:03long for a low cost home. In the following table,
- 42:07Clayton's earnings are net of the company's payment to
- 42:09Berkshire for the use of it's credit.
- 42:12Offsetting this cost to Clayton is an identical amount of income
- 42:15credited to Berkshire's finance operation and included in other
- 42:19income. The cost and income amount was
- 42:22$116 million in 2009 and 92 dollars million in 2008.
- 42:28The table also illustrates how severely our furniture court and
- 42:32trailer XDRA leasing operations have been hit by the recession.
- 42:37Though their competitive positions remain as strong as
- 42:40ever, we have yet to see any balance in these businesses.
- 42:43At the end of 2009, we became a 50% owner of Burke A Gia
- 42:48commercial mortgage, formerly known as Cap Mark, the country's
- 42:52third largest service are of commercial mortgages.
- 42:55In addition to servicing a $235 billion portfolio, the company
- 43:01is an important originator of mortgages, having 25 offices
- 43:04spread around the country. Though commercial real estate
- 43:07will face major problems in the next few years, long term
- 43:11opportunities for Burke Adia are significant. 13 Our partner in
- 43:15this operation Al UC Adia run by Joe Steinberg and Ian Cumming,
- 43:20with whom we had a terrific experience some years back when
- 43:24Berkshire joined with them to purchase Find Nova, a troubled
- 43:27finance business. In resolving that situation, Joe
- 43:31and Ian did far more than their share of the work and
- 43:34arrangement. I always encourage.
- 43:36Naturally, I was delighted when they call me to partner again in
- 43:40the cap mark purchase. Our first venture was also Chris
- 43:43and Burkadia. So let's call this one son of
- 43:45Burkadia. Someday it'll be writing you
- 43:48about grandson of Burkadia Investments.
- 43:51Below we show our common stock investments that at year end had
- 43:54a market value of more than 1 billion dollars, 123,109
- 44:00percentage of company shares, company owned cost market.
- 44:04In addition, we own positions in non traded securities of Dow
- 44:08Chemical, General Electric, Goldman Sachs, Swiss Re and
- 44:12Wrigley with an aggregate cost of $21.1 billion and a carrying
- 44:17value of $26.0 billion. We purchased these five
- 44:22positions in the last 18 months. Setting aside the significant
- 44:26equity potential they provide us, these holdings deliver us an
- 44:29aggregate of $2.1 billion annually in dividends and
- 44:33interest. Finally, we owned 76777029
- 44:39shares, 22.5% of the NSF at year end, which we then carried at
- 44:4485.78 dollars per share, but which half subsequently been
- 44:48melded into our purchase of the entire company.
- 44:51In 2009. Our largest sales were in
- 44:54Konoco, Phillips, Moody's, Procter and Gamble and Johnson
- 44:58and Johnson, sales of the latter occurring after we had built our
- 45:02position earlier in the year. Charlie and I believe that all
- 45:05of these stocks will likely trade higher in the future.
- 45:08We made some sales early in 2009 to raise cash for our Dow and
- 45:12Swiss repurchase S and late in the year made other sales in
- 45:16anticipation of our BNSF purchase.
- 45:19We told you last year that very unusual conditions then existed
- 45:23in the corporate and municipal bond markets and that these
- 45:26securities were ridiculously cheap relative to you S
- 45:30treasuries. We backed this view with some
- 45:33purchases, but I should have done far more.
- 45:36Big opportunities come in frequently when it's raining
- 45:38gold reach for a bucket, not a thimble.
- 45:41We entered 2008 with $44.3 billion of cash equivalents and
- 45:47we have since retained operating earnings of $17 billion.
- 45:52Nevertheless, at year in 2009, our cash was down to 30 point $6
- 45:57billion, with $8 billion earmarked for the BNSF
- 46:01acquisition. We've put a lot of money to work
- 46:04during the chaos of the last two years.
- 46:06It's been an ideal period for investors.
- 46:09A climate of fear is their best friend.
- 46:12Those who invest only when commentators are upbeat end up
- 46:15paying a heavy price for meaningless reassurance.
- 46:18In the end, what counts in investing is what you pay for a
- 46:22business through the purchase of a small piece of it in the stock
- 46:25market and what that business earns in the succeeding decade
- 46:28or two. Last year, I wrote extensively
- 46:31about our derivatives contracts, which were then the subject of
- 46:34both controversy and misunderstanding.
- 46:37For that discussion, please go to www.berkshirehathaway.com.
- 46:42We have since changed only a few of our positions.
- 46:45Some credit contracts have run off.
- 46:48The terms of about 10% of our equity put contracts have also
- 46:52changed. Maturities have been shortened
- 46:54and strike prices materially reduced.
- 46:57In these modifications. No money changed hands.
- 47:00A few points from last year's discussion are worth repeating.
- 47:031 Though it's no sure thing, I expect our contracts and
- 47:06aggregate to deliver us a profit over their lifetime, even when
- 47:10investment income on the huge amount of float they provide us
- 47:14is excluded in the calculation. Our derivatives float which is
- 47:18not included in the $62 billion of insurance float I described
- 47:22earlier was about $6.3 billion at year end.
- 47:26Two, only a handful of our contracts require us to post
- 47:29collateral under any circumstances.
- 47:31At last year's low point in the stock and credit markets, our
- 47:35posting requirement was $1.7 billion, a small fraction of the
- 47:40derivatives related float we held.
- 47:42When we do post collateral, let me add the securities we put up
- 47:46continue to earn money for our account.
- 47:48Three, finally, you should expect large swings in the
- 47:51carrying value of these contracts, items that can affect
- 47:55our reported quarterly earnings in a huge way, but that do not
- 47:58affect our cash or investment holdings.
- 48:01That thought certainly fit 2009 circumstances.
- 48:04Here are the pre tax quarterly gains and losses from
- 48:08derivatives valuations that were part of our reported earnings
- 48:11last year. Quarter dollars gain loss in
- 48:13billions 11.51722.35731.73241.052.
- 48:23As we've explained these wild swings neither cheer nor bother
- 48:27Charlie and me. When we report to you, we will
- 48:30continue to separate out these figurices.
- 48:32We do realized investment gains and Los Sesso that you can more
- 48:36clearly view the earnings of our operating businesses.
- 48:39We are delighted that we hold the derivatives contracts that
- 48:42we do. To date, we have significantly
- 48:45profited from the float they provide.
- 48:47We expect also to earn further investment income over the life
- 48:51of our contracts. 15 We have long invested in derivatives
- 48:55contracts that Charlie and I think are mispriced, just as we
- 48:58try to invest in mispriced stocks and bonds.
- 49:02Indeed, we first reported to you that we held such contracts in
- 49:05early 1998. The dangers that derivatives
- 49:08pose for both participants and society, dangers of which we've
- 49:12long warned and that can be dynamite, arise when these
- 49:15contracts lead to leverage and or counterparty risk that is
- 49:19extreme. At Berkshire, nothing like that
- 49:22has occurred, nor will it. It's my job to keep Berkshire
- 49:24far away from such problems. Charlie and I believe that ACEO
- 49:28must not delegate risk control. It's simply too important.
- 49:32At Berkshire, I both initiate and monitor every derivatives
- 49:37contract on our books with the exception of operations related
- 49:40contracts at a few of our subsidiaries such as Mid
- 49:44American and the minor runoff contracts at General Rhee.
- 49:47If Berkshire ever gets in trouble, it will be my fault.
- 49:50It will not be because of misjudgments made by a risk
- 49:53committee or chief risk officer. In my view, a board of directors
- 49:57of a huge financial institution is derelict if it does not
- 50:01insist that it's CEO bear full responsibility for risk control.
- 50:06If he's incapable of handling that job, he should look for
- 50:09other employment. And if he fails at it, with the
- 50:11government thereupon required to step in with funds or
- 50:15guarantees, the financial consequences for him and his
- 50:18board should be severe. It has not been shareholders who
- 50:21have botched the operations of some of our country's largest
- 50:24financial institutions. Yet they have borne the burden,
- 50:28with 90% or more of the value of their holdings wiped out in most
- 50:32cases of failure. Collectively, they have lost
- 50:35more than $500 billion in just the four largest financial
- 50:39fiascos of them last two years. To say these owners have been
- 50:43bailed out is to make a mockery of the term.
- 50:46The CEOs and directors of the failed companies, however, have
- 50:50largely gone and scathed. Their fortunes may have been
- 50:53diminished by the disasters they oversaw, but they still live in
- 50:57grand style. It is the behavior of these CEOs
- 51:01and directors that needs to be changed.
- 51:03If their institutions and the country are harmed by their
- 51:06recklessness, they should pay a heavy price. 1 Not reimburse
- 51:10ABLE by the companies they've damaged, nor buy insurance.
- 51:14CEOs, and in many cases directors, have long benefited
- 51:18from oversized financial carrots.
- 51:20Some meaningful sticks now need to be part of their employment
- 51:23picture as well. An inconvenient truth.
- 51:26Boardroom overheating. Our subsidiaries made a few
- 51:29small bolt on acquisitions last year for cash, but our
- 51:32blockbuster deal with BNSF required us to issue about
- 51:3695,000 Berkshire shares. That amounted to 6.1% of those
- 51:41previously outstanding. Charlie and I enjoy issuing
- 51:44Berkshire stock about as much as we relish prepping for a Colon
- 51:48OS copy. The reason for our distaste is
- 51:50simple. If we wouldn't dream of selling
- 51:52Berkshire in its entirety at the current market price, why in the
- 51:56world should Wessel a significant part of the company
- 51:59at that same inadequate price? By issuing our stock in a merger
- 52:03and evaluating a stock for stock offer, shareholders of the
- 52:06target company quite understandably focus on the
- 52:10market price of the acquire Rs shares that are to be given
- 52:13them, but they also expect the transaction to deliver then the
- 52:16intrinsic value of their own shares, the ones they are giving
- 52:19up. If shares of a prospective
- 52:21acquire rare selling below their intrinsic value, it's impossible
- 52:25for that buyer to make a sensible deal.
- 52:27In an all stock deal, you simply can't exchange an undervalued
- 52:32stock for a fully valued 1 without hurting your
- 52:34shareholders. Imagine if you will, Company A
- 52:38and Company B of equal size and both with businesses
- 52:41intrinsically worth $100 per share.
- 52:44Both of their stocks, however, sell for $80 per share.
- 52:48The CEO of A, long on confidence and short on smarts, offers 11/4
- 52:54shares of A for each share of B, correctly telling his directors
- 52:58that B is worth $100 per share. He will neglect to explain,
- 53:03though, that what he is giving will cost his shareholders
- 53:06$125.00 in intrinsic value. If the directors are
- 53:10mathematically challenged as well, and a deal is therefore
- 53:14completed, the shareholders of B will end up owning 55.6% of A
- 53:19and BS combined assets, and as shareholders will own 44.4%.
- 53:24Not everyone at A, it should be noted, is a loser from this
- 53:28nonsensical transaction. Its CEO now runs a company twice
- 53:33as large as his original domain in a world where size tends to
- 53:37correlate with both prestige and compensation. 16 If an acquire
- 53:42Rs stock is overvalued, it's a different story.
- 53:46Using it as a currency works to the acquire Rs advantage.
- 53:50That's why bubbles in various areas of the stock market have
- 53:53invariably led to serial issuance S of stock by sly
- 53:57promoters. Going by the market value of
- 53:59their stock, they can afford to overpay because they are in
- 54:03effect using counterfeit money. Periodically, many air for
- 54:07assets acquisitions have taken place, the late 1960s having
- 54:11been a particularly obscene period for such chicanery.
- 54:14Indeed, certain large companies were built in this way.
- 54:18No one involved of course ever publicly acknowledges the
- 54:22reality of what is going on, though there is plenty of
- 54:25private snickering. In our BNSF acquisition, the
- 54:29selling shareholders quite properly evaluated our offer at
- 54:32$100 per share. The cost to us, however, was
- 54:36somewhat higher since 40% of the $100 was delivered in our
- 54:40shares, which Charlie and I believe to be worth more than
- 54:44their market value. Fortunately, we had long owned a
- 54:47substantial amount of BNSF stock that we purchased in the market
- 54:51for cash. All told, therefore, only about
- 54:5430% of our cost overall was paid with Berkshire shares.
- 54:58In the end, Charlie and I decided that the disadvantage of
- 55:02paying 30% of the price through stock was offset by the
- 55:05opportunity the acquisition gave us to deploy $22 billion of cash
- 55:10in a business we understood and like for the long term.
- 55:14It has the additional virtue of being run by Matt Rose, whom we
- 55:17trust and admire. We also like the prospect of
- 55:21investing additional billions over the years at reasonable
- 55:24rates of return. But the final decision was a
- 55:27close one. If we had needed to use more
- 55:30stock to make the acquisition, it would in fact have made no
- 55:33sense. We would have then been giving
- 55:35up more than we were getting. I have been in dozens of board
- 55:38meetings in which acquisitions have been deliberated, often
- 55:42with the directors being instructed by high-priced
- 55:44investment bankers. Are there any other kind?
- 55:47Invariably the bankers give the board a detailed assessment of
- 55:51the value of the company being purchased, with emphasis on why
- 55:54it is worth far more than its market price.
- 55:57In more than 50 years of board memberships, however, never have
- 56:01I heard the investment bankers or management discussed the true
- 56:05value of what is being given. When a deal involved the
- 56:08issuance of the acquire Rs stock, they simply used market
- 56:12value to measure the cost. They did this even though they
- 56:15would have argued that the acquire Rs stock price was
- 56:18woefully inadequate. Absolutely no indicator of its
- 56:22real value at a takeover bid for the acquire are instead been the
- 56:25subject up for discussion. When stock is the currency being
- 56:29contemplated in an acquisition and when directors are hearing
- 56:32from an advisor, it appears toned that there is only one way
- 56:36to get a rational and balanced discussion.
- 56:38Director should hire a second advisor to make the case against
- 56:42the proposed acquisition, with its fee contingent on the deal
- 56:46not going through. Absent this drastic remedy, our
- 56:50recommendation in respect to the use of advisors remains.
- 56:53Don't ask the Barber whether you need a haircut.
- 56:56I can't resist telling you a true story from long ago.
- 56:59We own stock in a large well run bank that for decades have been
- 57:03S tattoo Tori LY prevented from acquisitions.
- 57:07Eventually the law was changed in our bank immediately began
- 57:11looking for possible purchases. Its managers find people and
- 57:14able bankers not unexpectedly began to behave like teenage
- 57:18boys who had just discovered girls.
- 57:21They soon focused on a much smaller bank, also well run and
- 57:24having similar financial characteristics in such areas as
- 57:28return on equity, interest, margin, loan quality, etcetera.
- 57:32Our banks sold at a modest price, that's why we had bought
- 57:35into it hovering near book value and possessing a very low price
- 57:39earnings ratio. Alongside though, the small bank
- 57:43owner was being wooed by other large banks in the state and was
- 57:46holding out for a price close to three times book value.
- 57:50Moreover, he wanted stock, not cash.
- 57:53Naturally, our fellows caved in and agreed to this value
- 57:56destroying deal that we need to show that we are in the hunt.
- 58:00Besides, it's only a small deal, they said, as if only major harm
- 58:05to shareholders would have been a legitimate reason for holding
- 58:08back Charlie's reaction at the time.
- 58:10Are we supposed to applaud because the dog that fouls our
- 58:14lawn is a Chihuahua rather than a Saint Bernard?
- 58:1617? The seller of the smaller bank,
- 58:19No fool then delivered one final demand in his negotiations after
- 58:24the merger. He in effect said, perhaps using
- 58:27words that were phrased more diplomatically than these.
- 58:30And going to be a large shareholder of your bank, and it
- 58:33will represent a huge portion of my net worth.
- 58:36You have to promise me, therefore, that you'll never
- 58:39again do a deal this dumb. Yes, the merger went through.
- 58:43The owner of the small bank became richer, we became poorer
- 58:47in the managers of the big bank, newly bigger lived happily ever
- 58:51after. The annual meeting.
- 58:53Our best guess is that 35,000 people attended the annual
- 58:56meeting last year, up from 12 no zeros omitted in 1981.
- 59:01With our shareholder population much expanded, we expect even
- 59:05more this year. Therefore, we will have to make
- 59:08a few changes in the usual routine.
- 59:10There will be no change, however, in our enthusiasm for
- 59:14having you attend. Charlie and I like to meet you,
- 59:17answer your questions and best of all, have you by lots of
- 59:20goods from our businesses. The meeting this year will be
- 59:23held on Saturday, May 1st St. As always, the doors will open
- 59:28at the Quest center at 7:00 AM and a new Berkshire movie will
- 59:31be shown at 8:30. At 9:30 we will go directly to
- 59:35the question and answer period, which, with a break for lunch at
- 59:39the quest stands, will last until 3:30.
- 59:42After a short recess, Charlie and I will convene the Annual
- 59:46meeting at 3:45. If you decide to leave during
- 59:49the days question periods, please do so while Charlie is
- 59:53talking. Act fast, he can be terse.
- 59:56The best reason to exit, of course, is to shop.
- 59:59We will help you do that by filling the 194300 square
- 1:00:04foothold that adjoins the meeting area with products from
- 1:00:07dozens of Berkshire subsidiaries.
- 1:00:09Last year you did your part and most locations racked up record
- 1:00:13sales, but you can do better. A friendly warning.
- 1:00:16If I find sales are lagging, I get testy and lock the exits.
- 1:00:21GEICO will have a booth staffed by a number of its top
- 1:00:24counselors from around the country, all of them ready to
- 1:00:27supply you with auto insurance quotes.
- 1:00:29In most cases, GEICO will be able to give you a shareholder
- 1:00:33discount, usually 8%. This special offer is permitted
- 1:00:36by 44 of the 51 jurisdictions in which we operate. 1 Supplemental
- 1:00:42point. The discount is not additive if
- 1:00:44you qualify for another such as that given certain groups bring
- 1:00:48the details of your existing insurance and check out whether
- 1:00:51we can save you money for at least 50% of you.
- 1:00:55I believe we can be sure to visit the bookworm.
- 1:00:58Among the more than 30 books and DV DS it will offer are too new
- 1:01:02books by my sons Howard's Fragile, a volume filled with
- 1:01:06photos and commentary about lives of struggle around the
- 1:01:09globe and Peter's life is what You Make it.
- 1:01:12Completing the family trilogy will be the debut of My Sister
- 1:01:15Doris biography, a story focusing on her remarkable
- 1:01:19philanthropic activities. Also available will be Poor
- 1:01:22Charlie's Almanac K, the story of my partner.
- 1:01:26This book is something of a publishing miracle, never
- 1:01:28advertised, yet year after year selling many thousands of copies
- 1:01:32from its Internet site. Should you need to ship your
- 1:01:35book purchases, a nearby shipping service will be
- 1:01:38available. If you area big spenderer, for
- 1:01:41that matter, merely A Gawker, visit Elliott Aviation on the
- 1:01:44east side of the Omaha Airport between noon and 5:00 PM on
- 1:01:48Saturday that we will have a fleet of net jets.
- 1:01:51We'll get your pulse racing. An attachment to the proxy
- 1:01:54material that is enclosed with this report explains how you can
- 1:01:57obtain the credential you will need for admission to the
- 1:02:00meeting and other events. As for plane, hotel and car
- 1:02:04reservations, we have again signed up American Express
- 1:02:08800-799-6634 to give you special help.
- 1:02:13Carol Peterson who handles these matters does a terrific job for
- 1:02:17us each year and it Hank her for it.
- 1:02:19Hotel rooms can be hard to find, but work with Carol and you will
- 1:02:23get 118 at Nebraska Furniture Mart located on a 77 acre site
- 1:02:28on 72 in D Street between Dodge and Pacific.
- 1:02:32We will again be having Berkshire Weekend discount
- 1:02:35pricing. To obtain the Berkshire discount
- 1:02:38you must make your purchases between Thursday April 29th TH
- 1:02:42and Monday May 3rd Rd. inclusive and also present your meeting
- 1:02:46credential. The period Special pricing will
- 1:02:49even apply to the products of several prestigious
- 1:02:52manufacturers that normally have ironclad rules against
- 1:02:55discounting, but which in the Spirito for Shareholder weekend
- 1:03:00have made an exception for you. We appreciate their cooperation.
- 1:03:04NFM is open from 10:00 AM to 9:00 PM, Monday through Saturday
- 1:03:09and 10:00 AM to 6:00 PM on Sunday.
- 1:03:12On Saturday this year from 5:30 PM to 8:00 PM, N FM is having a
- 1:03:18Burk Wyville BBQ to which you are all invited.
- 1:03:20At Borschi IMS we will again have two shareholder only
- 1:03:24events. The first will be a cocktail
- 1:03:26reception from 6P dot m.to 10:00 PM on Friday, April 30th TH.
- 1:03:32The second, the main gala will be held on Sunday, May 2nd in D
- 1:03:37from 9A dot m.to 4:00 PM. On Saturday we will be open
- 1:03:42until 6:00 PM. We will have huge crowds at
- 1:03:45Borschi IMS throughout the weekend for your convenience.
- 1:03:48Therefore, shareholder prices will be available from Monday,
- 1:03:52April 26th TH through Saturday, May 8th TH.
- 1:03:56During that period, please identify yourself as a
- 1:03:58shareholder by presenting your meeting credentials or a
- 1:04:01brokerage statement that shows you are a Berkshire holder.
- 1:04:05Enter with rhinestones, leave with diamonds.
- 1:04:08My daughter tells me that they more you buy the more you save.
- 1:04:11Kids say the darndest things on Sunday in them all outside of
- 1:04:15Borschi IMSA blindfolded Patrick Wolf twice you S dot chess
- 1:04:20champion will take on all comers who will have their eyes wide
- 1:04:23open in groups of 6. Nearby, Norman Beck, a
- 1:04:27remarkable magician from Dallas, will be Wilder onlookers.
- 1:04:31Our special treat for shareholders this year will be
- 1:04:34the return of my friend Ariel Shing, the country's top ranked
- 1:04:38junior table tennis player, and a good bet to win at the
- 1:04:41Olympics someday. Now 14, Ariel came to the annual
- 1:04:45meeting four years ago and demolished all comers, including
- 1:04:49me. You can witness my humiliating
- 1:04:51defeat on YouTube, just type in Ariel Shing, Berkshire.
- 1:04:55Naturally, I've been plotting A comeback and will take her on
- 1:04:58outside of Borschi IMS at 1:00 PM on Sunday.
- 1:05:02It will be a three-point match and after IS often her up.
- 1:05:05All shareholders are invited to try their luck at similar 3
- 1:05:09point contests. Winners will be given a box of
- 1:05:11See's Candy. We will have equipment
- 1:05:13available, but bring your own paddle if you think it will help
- 1:05:16dot, it won't. Gorats will again be open
- 1:05:19exclusively for Berkshire shareholders on Sunday, May 2nd
- 1:05:23in D and will be serving from 1:00 PM until 10:00 PM.
- 1:05:27Last year, though, it was overwhelmed by demand, with many
- 1:05:31more diners expected this year, I've asked my friend Donna
- 1:05:35Sheehan at Piccolo's, another favorite restaurant of Menito,
- 1:05:38serve shareholders on Sunday as well.
- 1:05:41Piccolo's giant root beer float is mandatory for any fan of fine
- 1:05:45dining. I plan to eat at both
- 1:05:47restaurants. All of the weekend action makes
- 1:05:50me really hungry and I have favorite dishes at each spot.
- 1:05:54Remember to make a reservation at Gore Otts call 402551 3733 on
- 1:06:01April 1st SD, but not before and at Piccolo's call 402-342-9038.
- 1:06:10Regrettably, we will not be able to have a reception for
- 1:06:12international visitors this year.
- 1:06:14Our account grew to about 800 last year and my simply signing
- 1:06:18one item per person took about 21 two hours.
- 1:06:21Since we expect even more international visitors this
- 1:06:24year, Charlie and I decided we must drop this function.
- 1:06:28But be assured, we welcome every international visitor who comes.
- 1:06:32Last year we changed our method of determining what questions
- 1:06:35would be asked at the meeting and received many dozens of
- 1:06:39letters applauding the new arrangement.
- 1:06:41We will therefore again have the same three financial journalists
- 1:06:45lead the question and answer period, asking Charlie and me
- 1:06:48questions that shareholders have submitted to them by mail.
- 1:06:52The journalists and their e-mail addresses are Carol Loomis, A
- 1:06:56Fortune who may be emailed at See Loomis fortunemail.com,
- 1:07:01becky.quickofcnbc@berkshirequestionscnbc.com and Andrew Ross Sorkin of The
- 1:07:08New York Times at arsorkintimes.com.
- 1:07:11From the questions submitted, each journalist will choose the
- 1:07:15dozen or so he or she decides are the most interesting and
- 1:07:18important. The journalists have told me
- 1:07:20your question has the best chance of being selected if you
- 1:07:23keep it concise and include no more than two questions in any
- 1:07:27e-mail you send them. In your e-mail, let the
- 1:07:30journalist know if you would like your name mentioned.
- 1:07:32If your question is selected, neither Charlie nor I will get
- 1:07:36so much as a clue about the questions to be asked.
- 1:07:39We know the journalists will pick some tough ones, and that's
- 1:07:42the way we like it. We will again have a drawing at
- 1:07:458:15 on Saturday at each of 13 microphones for those
- 1:07:48shareholders wishing to ask questions themselves.
- 1:07:52At the meeting, I will alternate the questions asked by the
- 1:07:55journalists with those from the winning shareholders.
- 1:07:58We've added 30 minutes to the Question Time and we'll probably
- 1:08:01have time for about 30 questions from each group.
- 1:08:04At 86 and 79, Charlie and I remain lucky beyond our dreams.
- 1:08:10We were born in America, had terrific parents who saw that we
- 1:08:14got good educations, have enjoyed wonderful families and
- 1:08:17great health, and came equipped with a business gene that allows
- 1:08:21us to prosper in a manner hugely disproportionate to that
- 1:08:25experienced by many people who contribute as much or more to
- 1:08:29our society's well-being. Moreover, we have long had jobs
- 1:08:32that we love, in which we are helped in countless ways by
- 1:08:35talented and cheerful associates.
- 1:08:38Indeed, over the years our work has become ever more
- 1:08:41fascinating. No wonder we tap dance to work.
- 1:08:45If pushed, we would gladly pay substantial sums to have our
- 1:08:48jobs. But don't tell the comp
- 1:08:50committee nothing. However, it is more fun for us
- 1:08:53than getting together with our shareholder partners at
- 1:08:55Berkshire's annual meeting. So join us on May 1st SD at the
- 1:08:59quest for our annual Woodstock for Capitalists.
- 1:09:02We'll see you there. February 262010.
- 1:09:07Warren E Buffett, Chairman of the board.
- 1:09:10PS Come by rail.