Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Negotiate a Raise Without a Competing Offer
Transcript
- Lucas: So the number one question we get in the inbox — and I mean by a wide margin — is some variation of 'How do I ask for a raise when I don't have another offer to wave in my boss's face?' Luna: It's a really uncomfortable spot. You feel exposed. Like you're asking for a favor instead of making a case. Lucas: Exactly. And most negotiation advice assumes you have leverage from a competing offer. But the reality is, most of us aren't job-hopping every two years. We're at our current company, doing good work, and we think we're underpaid. So what do you actually do? Luna: Well, you mentioned a case study in the prep — a marketing manager at a mid-size tech firm. Can we walk through that? Lucas: Yeah. Her name's Rachel — I changed the details — she'd been at a SaaS company for about three years, promoted once, consistently strong reviews. She looked at market data and realized she was about 15 to 20 percent below median for her title and experience in her metro area. Luna: And she didn't have an offer. She just had the data. Lucas: Right. And she was nervous. So she came to me asking for a script. I told her: the first thing you need is a document. Not a complaint — a case. She built a one-page PDF with three sections: her accomplishments over the past 18 months, her current comp, and then three independent salary sources showing the market range for her role. Luna: What did she use for the market data? Lucas: She used Levels.fyi for the tech-specific bands, Glassdoor for a broader cross-section, and then the Robert Half Salary Guide — which is actually pretty solid for marketing roles. She didn't cherry-pick the highest number. She took the median of the three and said, 'This is the market rate. I'm below it.' Luna: That's smart. It's harder for a manager to argue with three sources than with one. Lucas: Exactly. Then she practiced the framing. She did not say 'I need a raise.' She said 'I'd like to discuss aligning my compensation with the market value of this role.' That's a subtle difference but it reframes it as a business fairness issue, not a personal request. Luna: I like that. It's like you're on the same team, solving a problem. Lucas: She scheduled a 30-minute meeting with her manager, framed it as a career check-in. She started with gratitude — 'I really enjoy working here, I'm proud of what we launched in Q1' — then showed the document. Her manager looked at it, nodded, and said 'I agree you're below market. Let me take this to HR.' Luna: That's almost the best-case scenario. Did it work? Lucas: It took three weeks, but she got a 14 percent increase. Not the full 20, but close. And the manager told her later that the document made it easy for him to advocate for her because he had something to hand to the comp team. Luna: So the lesson is: make it easy for your boss to say yes. Lucas: Exactly. You are essentially giving them the ammunition to fight for you in the internal budget process. Without that document, they have to go to HR with 'My employee thinks she's underpaid.' With it, they go with 'Here's the market data, here's her performance record, here's the gap.' Luna: What about timing? When's the best time to have that conversation? Lucas: Ideally right after a win. A project wraps, you get positive feedback, you've just shipped something measurable. Avoid the week before annual reviews when budgets are already locked. And definitely avoid Mondays or Friday afternoons. Tuesday or Wednesday morning, when your boss is fresh. Luna: And if they say no? Lucas: You ask two things. One: 'What would I need to achieve to be at the level that warrants a raise?' Get specific milestones. Two: 'Can we revisit this in six months?' That keeps the door open and gives you a timeline. If they say no to both, that's a signal that the company doesn't value market alignment, and you might want to start looking. Luna: Yeah. And that's when a competing offer becomes useful — but not before. Lucas: Right. You don't want to bluff. You don't want to threaten. You want to present a case. And if the company won't meet market, you have your answer. Luna: So let me ask a practical question. How long should the document be? Should it include dollar amounts from the company's own financials? Lucas: One page. Bullet points. No fluff. And no, don't include company revenue numbers — that can feel like a threat. Focus on your contribution and the external market. Keep it professional. Luna: Good. And the conversation itself — how do you not get emotional? Lucas: Practice. Say it out loud in the mirror. Record yourself on your phone. You want to sound calm and factual. If you feel your voice shaking, pause and take a breath. It's okay to say 'I prepared some data I'd like to share.' That buys you composure. Luna: I think a lot of people also worry about seeming ungrateful. They like their job, they like their team, and they don't want to rock the boat. Lucas: That's real. And the way to handle it is to lead with appreciation. 'I'm grateful for the opportunities here. I want to continue growing with the company. And I also want to make sure my compensation reflects the value I'm delivering.' That's not ungrateful. That's professional. Luna: Yeah. And if the manager is reasonable, they'll respect that. Lucas: And if they're not reasonable, you've learned something important about the culture. But most managers — especially in tech and professional services — know that turnover is expensive. A 10 or 15 percent raise is cheaper than recruiting and training a replacement. Luna: That's the business case from the company's side. They should want to retain you. Lucas: Exactly. So to summarize: do your homework, build a one-page document with accomplishments and market data, time it after a win, frame it as alignment, and make it easy for your boss to say yes. And if they say no, get a roadmap and a revisit date. Luna: I think a lot of listeners are going to try this. I hope they'll let us know how it goes. Lucas: We'd love to hear. And if today's episode was useful to you and you want to keep it ad-free, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo helps. Luna: Yeah, it literally keeps the lights on. We don't run ads — that's a deliberate choice. Lucas: So if you value that, buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Even a couple of dollars a month makes a difference. Luna: Alright, back to the raise conversation. One thing we haven't touched on: what if you're in a non-tech role? Does the same playbook apply? Lucas: It does, but your market data sources might be different. For non-tech roles, use the Bureau of Labor Statistics for broad bands, industry association surveys, and sites like PayScale or Salary.com. The structure is the same. Luna: And for remote workers? Geography gets tricky when your company pays based on location. Lucas: That's a tougher conversation. If your company has a location-based pay policy, you need to show data for your own metro area. If you moved to a lower-cost area, they might argue the market rate is lower. Your best argument is that your output hasn't changed. But that's a harder sell. Luna: Right. And if you're fully remote and the company hires from anywhere, they might use a national average. Lucas: Yeah. In that case, you can argue that your value is not location-dependent. But you need a strong performance case. Luna: One last thing: how do you handle a situation where you know a colleague with the same title earns more? Lucas: Don't bring up a specific colleague's salary. It creates defensiveness and breaks trust. Instead, say 'Based on market data, I believe the role is valued at X. I'd like to be within that range.' That keeps it professional. Luna: Good. I think that's all the key points. Let's leave listeners with one actionable takeaway. Lucas: Start your document today. Even if you're not ready to have the conversation yet. Gather three sources of market data. Write down your top three achievements from the past year. By the time you're ready, you'll have a solid case. Luna: And you'll feel more confident just having it prepared. Lucas: Absolutely. Thanks for listening, and we'll be back with another question soon.