Latest / Why the Mongol Empire Split Apart So Quickly — Fexingo History / The Mongol Empire's Fall: A Civil War of Cousins
Transcript
- Lucas: So we've talked a lot about the pieces of the Mongol Empire after it broke apart, but I keep coming back to one question: how did it actually fracture so fast? I mean, in 1259, the empire stretched from the Sea of Japan to the edges of Poland, and within five years it was effectively four separate states at war with each other. Luna: It's hard to wrap my head around that speed. Lucas: It really is. And the hinge point is the Toluid Civil War, which kicked off in 1260. When Möngke Khan died in 1259, his brother Khubilai was leading a campaign in southern China, and his other brother Ariq Böke was holding the capital, Karakorum, in Mongolia. Neither waited for a full kurultai, the great assembly of the royal family, to decide the succession. Luna: So they just grabbed for it? Lucas: Pretty much. Khubilai called his own kurultai in his camp at Shangdu, in northern China, and got himself proclaimed Great Khan. Ariq Böke countered with a kurultai in Karakorum, which had more of the traditional princely blood, and he also claimed the title. So from day one, there were two rival Great Khans, each with legitimate claims under the Yassa, the customary law that Chinggis Khan had laid down. Luna: I remember that the Yassa was meant to keep the family united, though. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the irony. The Yassa said the kurultai decides, but it didn't specify how to gather a valid one when the empire was huge and the heirs were scattered. So both brothers could honestly believe they had the law on their side. And the rest of the family had to pick a side. The Chagatai Khanate, the realm in Central Asia, was the first to crack. Its khan, Alghu, initially backed Ariq Böke, but then he switched to Khubilai when Ariq tried to take his territory. Luna: So the first tear came from within the family. Lucas: Right. Alghu was a grandson of Chagatai, and he basically said, I'm not going to be a pawn. He expelled Ariq's tax collectors, and that cut off Karakorum's supply of grain and horses. Ariq Böke was then forced to march west to deal with Alghu, which gave Khubilai's armies the time they needed to push into Mongolia and take Karakorum itself in 1261. Luna: That must have been a shock for Ariq. Lucas: It was. But Ariq still had a lot of support among the traditionalists in the steppe, who saw Khubilai as too Chinese, too settled, too far from the old ways. So the civil war dragged on for another three years, with both sides raiding each other's territories, but Khubilai had access to the resources of China, and Ariq was starved of supplies. By 1264, Ariq finally surrendered in Shangdu, and Khubilai had him placed under house arrest. He died shortly after, supposedly of illness, though some say it was foul play. Luna: And that was the end of it? Lucas: As far as the Great Khan title, yes. But the damage was done. The western khanates never accepted Khubilai as their sovereign. And it's interesting, because the split wasn't just political, it was cultural and economic. The Golden Horde under Berke Khan, who ruled the Kipchak steppe and Russia, had already drifted toward Islam, and he was furious at Hulegu, the Ilkhan, who had sacked Baghdad and killed the Abbasid caliph back in 1258. So you had two Mongol states fighting each other over faith and territory. Luna: The cousins were literally at war. Lucas: In 1262, Berke and Hulegu clashed on the banks of the Terek River in the Caucasus. Berke's forces won a costly victory, but the death toll was enormous, and it essentially sealed the division between the western khanates. Meanwhile, Khubilai was busy consolidating his rule in China, and he had to decide whether to fund campaigns to reunite the empire or just pour everything into conquering the Song Dynasty. And he chose the latter. Luna: So he basically gave up on the west. Lucas: He did. He moved his capital from Karakorum to Shangdu, and then eventually to Dadu, which is modern Beijing. And that was a huge symbolic and practical shift. It meant the Great Khan was no longer a steppe ruler, he was an emperor of China. And the other khanates were happy to go their own way. So by the late 1260s, you have the Yuan dynasty in the east, the Chagatai Khanate in Central Asia, the Golden Horde in the northwest, and the Ilkhanate in Iran and Mesopotamia. And they're all squabbling over borders and trade routes. Luna: And that's when the Silk Road really started to fragment, right? Lucas: Yeah, the Pax Mongolica, that golden era of secure travel and trade, didn't survive the split. The routes were still there, but now you had to deal with multiple customs checkpoints and political rivalries. Some cities like Tabriz under the Ilkhanate, and Sarai under the Golden Horde, they still thrived as regional hubs, but the unity was gone. And that's something we've touched on in previous episodes, but the root cause of that fragmentation was this civil war between brothers. Luna: It's like the empire was a giant organism, and the first cut was self-inflicted. Lucas: Exactly. And that's something that often gets lost when we talk about the Mongol conquests, the sheer scale of the family drama. And you know, thinking about that, it reminds me of how much we rely on the support of listeners like you to keep this podcast going. We don't have a big network behind us, and we want to keep every episode free and ad-free, because we think these stories deserve to be heard without interruption. If you enjoy our deep dives into steppe history, you could help us out by buying us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's a small thing, but it really keeps us going. Luna: Yeah, and we're glad you're here with us for these stories. Lucas: Absolutely. So back to the split. One of the most telling details is how Khubilai and Ariq Böke used the title of Great Khan as a propaganda weapon. Khubilai styled himself as the true successor to Chinggis, while Ariq called him a traitor to the steppe traditions. And that fight over the meaning of the empire continued even after Ariq was defeated. Luna: How did that play out? Lucas: Well, the western khanates pretty much ignored Khubilai's claims to suzerainty. They kept using the Yassa and their own kurultais to legitimize their rules. For instance, when Alghu died in 1266, his successor was chosen by a regional kurultai, totally independent of Beijing. And in the Golden Horde, Berke's successor, Mengu-Timur, also called his own kurultai and was proclaimed khan without any reference to Khubilai. Luna: So the institution that was meant to unify them became a tool for division. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the deeper tragedy. The Mongol Empire was built on the idea of a single ruling family under the sky, and the Yassa was supposed to hold it together. But when you have a family that spans from Korea to Hungary, it's impossible to keep a shared identity. The khanates developed their own local interests, their own religious affiliations, and their own alliances. The Ilkhanate eventually became Persianized and adopted Islam, while the Yuan in China embraced Confucianism and Buddhism. The Golden Horde took on Turkic and Islamic influences, and the Chagatai Khanate remained the most steppe-like but still fractured over time. Luna: So the empire didn't just break politically, it broke culturally. Lucas: Right. And one of the most vivid examples is the rivalry between the Ilkhanate and the Golden Horde over the Caucasus. That wasn't just about territory, it was about who controlled the trade routes and who had the prestige of having defeated the Abbasids. Berke had actually converted to Islam before the sacking of Baghdad, and he saw Hulegu's destruction of the caliphate as an atrocity. So the Terek River battle in 1262 was as much about religion as it was about politics. Luna: I never thought of it as a religious war between Mongols. Lucas: It's a layer that's often overlooked. And after Berke's death in 1266, the conflict continued between his successors and the Ilkhans, with shifting alliances that sometimes even involved the Mamluks in Egypt, who were Muslim and thus natural allies of the Golden Horde against the Ilkhanate. So you had Mongol princes fighting each other with the help of non-Mongol powers. That's how far the unity had disintegrated. Luna: It's like the family bonds meant nothing. Lucas: Well, they still meant something on paper. They still exchanged envoys and sometimes even intermarried, but it was all about diplomacy, not brotherhood. And the real break happened so quickly because there was no institution strong enough to enforce a single authority. The kurultai had always been a meeting of the family, but with such a vast territory, it became impossible to convene everyone. And the Yassa didn't have a mechanism for punishing a disobeying prince, because who would do the punishing? Luna: So it was a constitutional crisis. Lucas: In a way, yes. And the consequences were lasting. The Yuan dynasty in China lasted until 1368, but the other khanates eventually fell to internal strife and external pressures. The Chagatai Khanate crumbled into smaller khanates, and the Ilkhanate disintegrated after the death of Abu Sa'id in 1335. The Golden Horde lingered but was eventually absorbed by the rising Russian states. And the dream of a unified Mongol Empire never really revived, not even under Timur in the 14th century, who was more of a conqueror than a unifier. Luna: So, in the end, the empire's own success was its undoing. Lucas: That's the tragic irony. The Mongols conquered more land than anyone before them, but they couldn't conquer the distance between their own family members. And that's something that still resonates today, when we see vast organizations or nations struggle to hold together under internal divisions. The story of the Mongol Empire is a reminder that unity requires constant effort and a shared vision, and even the mightiest can fall apart when that's lost.