Latest / The So What? / Elections 2024
Transcript
- 0:00Hello and welcome to the So What podcast in which political economic analyst JP Landman
- 0:11discusses the issues uppermost in the minds of South Africans. You can find a written
- 0:16version of this content on JP's website jplandman.co.za. I am Ruda Landman and I am your host.
- 0:29This episode goes with JP's newsletter dated the 26th of February 2024 and it is about
- 0:35the 2024 elections. The date has been announced for the 29th of May and off we go as you say
- 0:43in your newsletter off to the races. JP we seem to have dozens of political parties and
- 0:51they are a lot more as we go along. How many are actually presented in parliament at the
- 0:57moment represented and what is their support base like?
- 1:02Yeah it is a very interesting point. We have 14 political parties currently in parliament,
- 1:08the parliament that was elected five years ago in 2019 but really three of them the ANC,
- 1:15the DA and the EFF between them have got 89% of the vote or 89% of the parliament. The
- 1:22other 11 parties share the remaining 11%. So it is really a case of three big dogs and
- 1:27a lot of small dogs.
- 1:30And since those elections we have had local elections. Did things shift?
- 1:36Yes they did shift two and a half years later in 2021 and in those elections the ANC suffered
- 1:44quite a huge loss. They went from 57% of the vote which they got in 29 down to about 40-45%
- 1:54in 2021. Now the interesting thing is that drop in vote did not go to the other two big
- 2:00parties the DA and EFF. It went to a host of smaller parties. So the current lie of
- 2:07the land is that yes we have got three big parties. They have way more than 80% of the
- 2:13vote between them. We have got a host of smaller parties but it looks as if the smaller parties
- 2:19are gaining at the expense of the ANC and probably also at the expense of the other
- 2:25bigger parties.
- 2:26And since then, so that was 2021, so it is three years, is the information from polls
- 2:34or something that we can gauge the support from?
- 2:38Yes, look you are quite right one cannot compare local government election results with national
- 2:43government election results but that is the best we have got and we use that to determine
- 2:49the lie of the land. What we have in addition to those election results we now have a number
- 2:54of polls that have been conducted over the last 24 months. There are in total about 11
- 3:00of them and so what I have done is to average the results of those polls for the different
- 3:06political parties and then you get a certain reading and then what I have done also is
- 3:11to take away the highest and the lowest poll for each political party and average the balance
- 3:16and then you get a slightly different reading but by and large the same and that reading
- 3:21is 45% for the ANC, 23% for the DA, 13% for the EFF, about 5% for the IFP and about 4.6%,
- 3:334.5% for Action SA. So you can see essentially the ANC is not making up what they look like
- 3:41and they lost in 2021 but again that vote is not really going to the other two big parties.
- 3:47It is mainly going to the EFF, to the IFP and Action SA and no doubt a lot of the vote
- 3:53will also go to a host of other smaller parties. What about former president Zuma's MK party?
- 4:00There was one poll on that party which was done in January, results released in February.
- 4:06They have given quite a high support to the MK party in KwaZulu-Natal, 24%, which is a
- 4:15high number. Provincially.
- 4:16Provincially, yes, for KZN. In two by-elections that we have had in KZN since the party was
- 4:25formed they have actually done quite well. They have taken votes from the ANC, they have
- 4:31taken votes from even the IFP but it looks as if they have taken most of the votes from
- 4:36the EFF. So that will be an interesting dynamic, MK versus the EFF. You know I suppose it is
- 4:43a case of if you want to go to somebody you go to the one who is most authentic and Mr.
- 4:50Zuma is probably a more authentic figure of radical economic transformation than Julius
- 4:55Malema. But let's see how the numbers play out.
- 4:59What about all the other new parties that were in the headlines over the last three
- 5:04months or so?
- 5:05There are a number of, let's call them media headline parties. There is Rise Mzansi,
- 5:11from Songezo Zibi, there is BOSA, Build One South Africa, Mmusi Maimane, previous
- 5:18leader of the DA. There is Change Starts Now, CSN, Roger Jardim and then of course also
- 5:25Mr. Zuma's party. Those are the main ones. There are also a lot of other parties. Ace
- 5:30Magashule has got a party ACT, African Congress of Transformation. I suspect he will do quite
- 5:38well in the Northern Free State. But really these smaller parties are, you know, they
- 5:43are small fish, they are new kids on the block. One will have to see to what extent they can
- 5:47get traction with the electorate.
- 5:49But they can all register. So what will this mean for me as an individual voter on the
- 5:54day of voting?
- 5:56Well, it may mean that you won't get a ballot paper, but you will get a little ballot book.
- 6:03Because as you rightly say, there will be a host of parties. What is also new this year
- 6:08is that for the first time, independence can stand for election. So you will get three
- 6:14ballot papers. You will get one for the national government as in the past. This year the list
- 6:20will probably be much longer than what it was in the past. You will get a second ballot
- 6:24paper for provincial government and then you will get a third ballot paper for independence.
- 6:29And you have to wade your way through all three of them.
- 6:32And do we have to vote on each one or not?
- 6:35No, no. You can vote on one or two or all three or you can spoil your paper. It's a
- 6:42free option you can do as you wish.
- 6:44What do you think about the multi-party charter people saying there will be a new government?
- 6:51I think it's a misrepresentation. The multi-party charter cannot get more than about 35 to 40
- 6:59percent of the vote. Now, even if they get 40 percent, that's far away from 50 plus one.
- 7:05So I think that is a gross misrepresentation. Okay, you know, it is election season, it's
- 7:10the least season, people make promises and so on. One must allow for that. But I can't
- 7:14see in that sense a new government in the sense that there's a group of opposition parties
- 7:21that get more than 50 percent of the vote and can replace the ANC. I just don't see
- 7:25that. It's not in the realm of realpolitik. Can you see the EFF and the DA and the Freedom
- 7:33Front plus working together with MK to be anti-ANC? You know, it's simply a nonsense
- 7:39construct. It'll also be a frightfully unstable coalition. So no, I don't think that'll happen
- 7:48and it certainly won't be good for the country. What you will find is that ANC will still
- 7:53be the largest political party. It will lead a coalition. It will be the responsibility
- 7:58of the ANC to invite other parties to join them in a coalition government if they don't
- 8:04get to 50 percent. And as such, yes, there will be other people in government, but the
- 8:09ANC will still lead that government and therefore to talk about a whole new government is simply
- 8:14in my view a misrepresentation. What about the provinces? In the provinces it may play
- 8:20out differently, particularly in two provinces, kwaZulu-Natal and Gauteng. The ANC is not
- 8:26going to get 50 percent in Gauteng. They will probably get somewhere between 35 and 40,
- 8:32maybe just over 40. Now that'll leave them a good 10 percent short of the 50 plus one
- 8:38needed to govern the province. So the big question is then with whom will they make
- 8:43a coalition deal? Just this week we've had a report from the National Executive Committee
- 8:51of the ANC looking at the issue of coalitions, making it fairly clear that they're not going
- 8:58to do a coalition with the EFF, not even in Gauteng. Panja Zalusufi, the Premier of Gauteng
- 9:04and leader of the ANC in Gauteng, has referred to the EFF as unreliable partners. But they
- 9:15are in a partnership coalition in Johannesburg at the moment. Well, it's an Ekurhuleni.
- 9:21It's a kind of an arrangement and I suspect it won't last. If you look at these comments
- 9:26coming through, then you may even find that those municipal coalitions do not survive.
- 9:33Panyaza Lesufi is probably one of the more enthusiastic ANC members when it comes to a coalition with
- 9:39the EFF. Absolutely. Likewise, the leadership of the ANC down in kwaZulu-Natal are also
- 9:46sympathetic to the EFF, but they have also made it quite clear that they want to have
- 9:52stable coalitions and they don't see that with either the MK or EFF. So the question
- 9:57is, with whom will they go? I've written last year in August and earlier in the year,
- 10:04that in May, almost a year ago, that I hope for a DAA-ANC coalition. But whether that
- 10:11happens, we'll have to see. We as a country have had really bad experiences with coalition
- 10:20governments that just don't work. Where did those coalitions go wrong and how can it be
- 10:26made better? I think they went wrong on the very simple
- 10:30principles that the focus of the coalition governments in municipalities and metros,
- 10:38the focus was on who, not on how. Who is getting a job? Who will be the mayor? Who will be
- 10:45the speaker? Who will be the chairperson of committees and so on? It's about who. You
- 10:50just have to shuffle those letters around and get to how. How are you going to govern?
- 10:56How are you going to implement your election manifesto? That is where we went wrong. We
- 11:00focused on who and not on how. We don't have that culture of negotiating agreements on
- 11:07how coalitions were governed, but that may be changing. And I say that because in kwaZulu-
- 11:13Natal, an agreement was signed, agreed and signed between the IFP and the DA on how they're
- 11:20going to manage the local governments where they are in control. Currently, they control
- 11:25between them 13 councils in the kwaZulu-Natal province, and it seems to be going reasonably
- 11:32well. Now, what is that agreement? It's a nine-page
- 11:35agreement. It sets out what their values are. It starts with common values. It then has
- 11:40common ideals. It then focuses on objectives that they want to achieve in that local government
- 11:47in the term of office that is left. And lastly, how they're going to do it, practical steps.
- 11:53For example, one clause in the nine-page agreement is that the municipalities which they run,
- 11:59they will spend 8% of the municipal budget on maintenance. Now, it may sound like a very
- 12:04minor point, but we know about maintenance and infrastructure in particularly municipalities.
- 12:11So that kind of focus is a good thing. So it may be that we're now starting in South
- 12:15Africa with a culture of negotiating a coalition agreement focusing on the how, not the who.
- 12:22And this is of course the way it works in Europe. If you take a country like Germany,
- 12:26they have had coalition governments for a very, very long time. In the last election,
- 12:31it took three months between the election date and the date that the new government
- 12:35took office. Why? They needed three months to negotiate a coalition agreement. The English
- 12:41translation is about 127 pages. Now, we don't have to go as far as the Germans, you know,
- 12:47the detail and so on. But even the Dutch, the last Dutch coalition government had a
- 12:51coalition agreement of 57 pages, the English translation thereof. So there is definitely
- 12:57a need in South Africa to develop coalition agreements that focuses on or that focus on
- 13:04the how and not on the who. And if we can do that after the 2024 election where it is
- 13:10necessary, that'll be a major step forward. But our constitution puts us in a bit of a
- 13:16bind because it says, what, 14 days after the election? Yeah, absolutely. It's a very
- 13:22strong point. The coalition stipulates that a new parliament, the new parliament, which
- 13:27was just elected in the election, must meet within 14 days to elect a new president. From
- 13:33the date of the election? From the date that the election is certified. Now, the election
- 13:37is on Wednesday. It's normally certified by Saturday evening. So 14 days later, parliament
- 13:43must meet and elect a new president. And so if there's one party that's got 50% plus one
- 13:50of the vote, well, fine, then there's no problem. That party's candidate will become president.
- 13:54If that isn't the case, then your negotiation will have to be, your first round will have
- 13:58to be about who, which candidate will be supported. That'll be your first round of negotiation.
- 14:06And then once you've got a president, then he will have to extend it into a wider agreement
- 14:10about how that government will rule. And in the provinces, is it the same? In provinces
- 14:17it's the same. They also have to meet and elect a premier and get the show on the road.
- 14:24There's a lot of talk of policy uncertainty because there are so many question marks about
- 14:30how these elections will play out. Yeah, that's a standard item. Every time there's an election,
- 14:37the chattering glasses go into overdrive with policy uncertainty. The budget will be populist.
- 14:44There will be a splurge of expenditure and so on and so forth. These are hardy perennials.
- 14:49They always come back, except it never happens in real life. The splurges in spending is
- 14:54not during election times. It's between elections, if you look at our record in that regard.
- 15:01And we had a budget at the end of February. What did that indicate?
- 15:07Well, absolutely. You've seen the media coverage. It's a very conservative budget. It's holding
- 15:14the line. It is heavily criticized from the left for not spending more money on social
- 15:19grants. The social grant increases below inflation. The R350 COVID grant has not been increased.
- 15:29So there was absolutely no splurge in spending. That did not happen. It's a matter of factual
- 15:37observation that it didn't happen. As a policy uncertainty in general, what are now the most
- 15:43important policies for this country? Well, it's macroeconomic policy. That was confirmed
- 15:48by the budget. And then it is fixing electricity, it's fixing logistics, railways and ports,
- 15:56and it's fixing water. And in all three of those respects, the state of the nation speech
- 16:01early in February and the budget speech towards the end of February all made the same point,
- 16:07which is already in the public domain, that in all these spheres of where we have government
- 16:14monopolies like in energy, like in ports, like in railways, the private sector will
- 16:19be allowed into those sectors. So we're moving away from the model of a state-owned monopoly
- 16:27which run those network industries to a model where there will be state company, yes, like
- 16:32Transnet, like Eskom, but next to it, there will be private companies rendering a service
- 16:38in those industries, making capital investments, bringing management and so on. It's quite
- 16:43a profound change for South Africa. We have a tradition in this country which goes back
- 16:50150 years, where the state runs those kinds of industries. They're called the network
- 16:56industries. Now we're moving away from the state running them to the private sector coming
- 17:00in to help. It's a big change and it's happening. And you don't see that changing? There's no
- 17:06uncertainty around that? No, I don't see that changing. Absolutely not. And even if a coalition
- 17:12government is formed, it won't change that. What I do see and that we must be aware of,
- 17:18it takes government a long time to do things. They are not quick. You look at the deadlines
- 17:25that they set themselves by when they want to do things, they normally miss those deadlines.
- 17:30I think people simply underestimate how difficult it is to get things through the government
- 17:37processes. There are a variety of reasons for that, but that's the reality. It takes
- 17:42time. And so I think there's a problem with the speed of implementation, but not with
- 17:48the certainty of what is being implemented. That sounds like the first of your so what's
- 17:54actually at the end of your newsletter. But the other major point is no new government.
- 18:01No, I don't think I think the idea of a new government is really, as I've said, a misrepresentation.
- 18:06It's not going to happen. I think we can, even if we accept that the ANC will drop below
- 18:1250 at the national level and will not be able to rule on their own, govern on their own,
- 18:19they will still be the largest party. They will actually form the coalition. They will
- 18:23invite other people to come in. That will be the, that doesn't look to me like a new
- 18:28government. It very much looks like a continuation of a little bit of new blood coming in from
- 18:34opposition parties if they form part of a coalition.
- 18:38And the future of the big three in general, do you see more fragmentation?
- 18:43Yeah, I think we already see that in the polls and we also see it in by-election results
- 18:50that the smaller parties are all eating away from the three big ones. So it's in some,
- 18:56maybe they don't reduce the support level. For example, the EFF in the polls currently
- 19:01is getting about 13%. They used to be 11. So they're not losing support, but they certainly,
- 19:07there's a ceiling on how much support they seem to be getting. So yes, I think that fragmentation
- 19:13will continue. We will see the three big parties will not grow much. In total, they'll be less.
- 19:20And I think we will see a host of smaller parties each coming in with one or two seats,
- 19:26which will of course give us a parliament with more parties and will complicate the
- 19:32political scene.
- 19:34But you say that the major question in this election is about the provinces.
- 19:42Yes, I think that's where the action will be, particularly KwaZulu-Natal and Gauteng
- 19:47in both those provinces. It is very unlikely that the ANC will get to 50%. It is more likely
- 19:54that the multi-party charter people could get to 50%, particularly in Gauteng. It's
- 20:01not a prediction. I'm just saying, you know, there's a likelihood. So yeah, those are the
- 20:07two provinces to watch. And if the ANC doesn't get to 50 and the opposition parties don't
- 20:14get to 50, then the question is who will form a coalition with whom? And overall, I think
- 20:20the EFF is not going to be the coalition partner. But let's see how it plays out.
- 20:26Thank you very much. We can only wish all our listeners happy voting.
- 20:30Absolutely. Happy voting.
- 20:34Thank you for listening to the So What podcast. If you enjoy this content, please don't forget
- 20:39to leave a review and a rating and please consider subscribing so you don't miss any
- 20:44future episodes. Also, tell your friends. Remember, you can find a written version of all JP's
- 20:50content at jplandman.co.za.