Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / From Appeal to Proposed Rule: How One Credit Union's Field of Membership Fight Reshaped NCUA Policy with Rick Mumm
Transcript
- 0:00Mark Treichel: Okay.
- 0:02Hey everyone, this is Mark TL with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:06I'm excited to be here with Rick.
- 0:08Mom.
- 0:08Rick, how you doing today?
- 0:10Rick Mumm: Doing great, mark, how about yourself?
- 0:11Mark Treichel: I'm doing fantastic.
- 0:13NCOA has been announcing a lot of what they're calling rounds of
- 0:17deregulation proposals, and a lot of those I've described as turning
- 0:22happy to glad or glad to happy.
- 0:25But there's a couple of them that actually make a difference or make
- 0:29a potential difference, and one of 'em ties into field of membership.
- 0:32And they made a proposal on that.
- 0:34When I saw, I thought, Hey Rick, I think you might know a lot about this.
- 0:38Maybe we should do a quick little podcast to, to clue people in.
- 0:42So with that, as a preface, maybe if you could it is been a while
- 0:45since I had you on the podcast.
- 0:47Maybe walk through what it is you did at NCUA and what it is you've been doing
- 0:51since NCUA in the credit union arena.
- 0:54Rick Mumm: Okay.
- 0:54Yeah.
- 0:55Thanks Mark.
- 0:55Yeah.
- 0:56As at NCUA I was there, what, a little over 34 years, and for about 26 of it I
- 1:02worked with field of membership, which meant bylaws, mergers, liquidations,
- 1:08and charter expansions, everything you know, and credit you wanna
- 1:14do with its fields of membership.
- 1:16I worked on, and since retiring, I have been helping credit unions
- 1:21with field of membership expansions community charters, underserved areas.
- 1:27They added a low income association for credit union.
- 1:31Done a couple, did a new charter, working with some other groups on new charters.
- 1:35So just.
- 1:37A little of the whatever, credit unions field of membership wise, I've been
- 1:41Mark Treichel: helping.
- 1:42That's what you've been doing.
- 1:43Yeah.
- 1:43And you've been helping, you've been, you, sometimes you help
- 1:45with my clients and then sometimes you do some stuff on your own.
- 1:47And there was one situation where I think you worked out an appeal
- 1:51that went to the NCA board.
- 1:52And we don't need to work, talk about the specifics of that particular
- 1:55credit union, but there's a.
- 1:58How do I wanna say this?
- 1:59There's a lot of rhythm or rhyme to what you helped this
- 2:03one credit union appeal to.
- 2:04What we're about to talk to talk about relative to.
- 2:08Rick Mumm: I don't know.
- 2:08Is it okay to name the credit union?
- 2:10They're okay with it.
- 2:11Mark Treichel: If, hey, if you're, if they're okay and
- 2:12you're okay let's let it roll.
- 2:14So with that I'll just turn it over to you.
- 2:16You can talk about.
- 2:17The proposal you can talk about the appeal or whatever you think
- 2:21makes sense to educate the public on this proposal on field membership.
- 2:26Rick Mumm: Okay.
- 2:26Yeah, so this the proposed rule change for FOM clarifies customer client
- 2:33relationship the customer client relationship for adding a field,
- 2:38a group to a field of membership.
- 2:39Currently if a group is customer, client related it is not eligible.
- 2:46For addition to a field of membership and.
- 2:52Customer client relationship just as a little could be like like good
- 2:57examples are Costco, aaa, they, you pay for a membership, but their
- 3:05customer client because the primary reason for those membership is to get
- 3:11auto services, or in case of Costco, you can buy enough stuff to, that
- 3:19you can will to your great grandkids.
- 3:21It'll still be left.
- 3:22I,
- 3:22Mark Treichel: Rick I went into Costco for blueberries and a
- 3:25thousand dollars later I had two carts full that ever happen to you?
- 3:28Rick Mumm: Y yeah.
- 3:33Mark Treichel: But I digress.
- 3:34Going to Costco's all about the good deals, it's not necessarily about it.
- 3:38It's the primary focus, I think is what we're getting
- 3:40Rick Mumm: to, right?
- 3:40Yeah.
- 3:41But it is a membership and so membership, associations in for credit
- 3:48union field of membership is based on membership, but it's, doesn't qualify
- 3:54because it is a customer client.
- 3:57You pay for the membership so you can get the good deals.
- 4:00There's other, there's other customer client relationships that are
- 4:06they may or may not be, like you.
- 4:09Join a zoo or a museum.
- 4:12Some of those are customer client relationships.
- 4:16Some may qualify.
- 4:18And then there's the other, which this case specifically relates to is fraternal
- 4:26organizations where you you buy insurance.
- 4:32I've worked.
- 4:33Jennifer, I, the CEO at POAM Federal Credit Union in Los Angeles contacted me
- 4:41about adding a fraternal organization.
- 4:45And I said it's gonna be iffy.
- 4:48'Cause it.
- 4:48It is a fraternal organization.
- 4:51And long story short, we took it all the way up to the NCUA board as an appeal.
- 4:58And this rule is the direct result of that appeal.
- 5:03Mark Treichel: And it was iffy because it basically, the old rule said
- 5:07if there's a client relationship.
- 5:09You can't do it.
- 5:10Rick Mumm: You can't do it.
- 5:11And it specifically said if it's a fraternal organization
- 5:15that sells insurance, it doesn't qualify, which this did, this does.
- 5:21But the chartering manual, even though it says that the chartering manual
- 5:28doesn't really define customer client, it doesn't define primarily, what is
- 5:36the field of, membership relationship?
- 5:39But the chartering manual also says that the Knights of Columbus specifically
- 5:45qualifies as an associational group.
- 5:49Mark Treichel: And that was your hook.
- 5:49And I think that was your hook, right?
- 5:51That was where you were able to pick your, get your dog under the tent, right?
- 5:55Rick Mumm: E, exactly.
- 5:56That was one of my.
- 5:58My hooks is that the chartering manual states, the Knights of
- 6:03Columbus specifically qualifies.
- 6:06It's a fraternal organization that sells insurance.
- 6:10So why can't, the fraternal organization, she wanted to add.
- 6:17Why exclude it?
- 6:19And the the interesting things is if you look at the Knights of Columbus,
- 6:25and there's also Thrivent, NCUA, chartered Thrivent, it converted from
- 6:31I think a mutual bank or whatever.
- 6:33I don't remember what it was.
- 6:34Mutual
- 6:34Mark Treichel: savings Bank.
- 6:35Yeah,
- 6:35Rick Mumm: bank.
- 6:35Yeah.
- 6:36But it converted to a credit union.
- 6:38And Thrivent is also a mutual insurance so I had Thrivent and Knights of
- 6:45Columbus doing the exact same thing.
- 6:48And when you look at Thrivent's website and information in Knights
- 6:53of Columbus, they are very much into the selling of the insurance.
- 6:58They're both highly rated.
- 7:00They have press releases about the insurance companies, everything else,
- 7:06and the group that Jennifer wanted to add, yeah they sold insurance.
- 7:13They didn't start out selling insurance.
- 7:15They started out trying to serve their group and then,
- 7:18eight to 10 years in, they.
- 7:21Wanted to help their very poor membership.
- 7:24And so they started offering insurance.
- 7:27So their primary focus was always the membership.
- 7:33They have tons of activities.
- 7:35They did tons of events.
- 7:37You go to their, I won't name the group, but you go to their website and it's
- 7:42all about the group and the insurance is just one of the things they offer.
- 7:49That was enough.
- 7:51Why, cure denied it.
- 7:54But the final appeal, the board denied it, but they also said they recognize
- 8:04that there are discrepancies in the rule and the task here to rewrite the rule.
- 8:14To allow it.
- 8:15So this is,
- 8:16Mark Treichel: so this is that, this is that proposal, this
- 8:19is that task coming coming
- 8:20Rick Mumm: fruition.
- 8:20This is that rewrite now in the appeal, it said they were supposed
- 8:25to do it within nine months and it's been almost, I think two years now.
- 8:30So didn't quite make that, but and to be fair to cure an NCA, I think the election
- 8:37came about and there was, rules, but
- 8:40Mark Treichel: the election and they're shrinking their staff and,
- 8:43Rick Mumm: And all of that, so yeah.
- 8:44Yep, yep.
- 8:46Down to one board member.
- 8:47Just there is some external things, but so yeah, so that's what this rule does is.
- 8:54Is address that appeal?
- 8:57What there was, because some of the other things that, going through the
- 9:02appeal and that was very interesting is they said it's customer, client.
- 9:08They required insurance, the purchase of insurance.
- 9:11So therefore that was the basis for the denial.
- 9:17But they did say if the group.
- 9:20Put in there that you didn't have to buy the insurance.
- 9:26Could be a member.
- 9:26They could.
- 9:27They could be We.
- 9:28They could add it.
- 9:29The field of membership, and both Knights and Thrivent have a thing in
- 9:33there that says you do not have to purchase insurance, which is how they.
- 9:40They're able to get at it to the field of membership.
- 9:43But the interesting thing about both of those, and that I brought
- 9:49out in the appeal is that if they don't buy insurance from either
- 9:54one, neither one have voting rights.
- 9:57Neither one are they're considered affiliates.
- 10:01So they're not full members and.
- 10:0590 I couldn't find a percent of what percent purchase insurance
- 10:10through them versus not.
- 10:12But if you look at their annual reports and the amount of insurance
- 10:17they sell is, my guess is 90 plus percent or more purchase the insurance.
- 10:25'cause I also couldn't see that they do a whole heck of a lot of other activities
- 10:29that would make you want to join.
- 10:32Otherwise.
- 10:33I'm thinking it's a very high percent.
- 10:36The interesting thing is the chartering manual gets into, you have to be
- 10:42a full member, a voting member.
- 10:44Affiliate members do not qualify for membership per the Chartering manual,
- 10:49and both Thrivent and Knights of Columbus consider anybody that doesn't buy the
- 10:56insurance to be affiliate of members.
- 10:58So under the Charting manual, those members don't qualify.
- 11:02Mark Treichel: Now they're not eligible to join.
- 11:04They're
- 11:04Rick Mumm: not eligible to join the credit union.
- 11:06Yeah.
- 11:06Now you and I both know that they're getting added.
- 11:09The credit unions aren't looking at that.
- 11:11The point is the chartering manual.
- 11:14States, they're not allowed to join or so they're not even
- 11:18eligible to join the credit union if they don't buy the insurance.
- 11:22So the only people eligible to join half the insurance are the
- 11:28ones that are buying insurance.
- 11:29So you're, so this group, 100% of everybody, yeah,
- 11:33they don't have that clause.
- 11:35You don't have to, but a hundred percent would be able to.
- 11:41Join the credit union because they have full voting rights, whereas not
- 11:48everybody has the full voting rights.
- 11:50So that was one of the discrepancies I brought out is that okay if they
- 11:56don't buy the insurance, they're not eligible to join the credit union
- 12:00anyway because the group requires them to buy it, to even have voting rights.
- 12:05And those.
- 12:07Affiliate members, the charting manual specifically states affiliate
- 12:12members do not qualify for membership.
- 12:15Mark Treichel: That's wild.
- 12:15And when you say the charting manual, it's the current one, not the proposal.
- 12:19We haven't we haven't even talked about what the propo,
- 12:21how the proposal structured yet,
- 12:23Rick Mumm: right?
- 12:23Yeah exactly.
- 12:24It's the current one.
- 12:25So you've got these discrepancies that.
- 12:29I brought out, and the board recognized that, but they still denied.
- 12:35The gr still denied the appeal.
- 12:37Mark Treichel: You got a proposed reg out of it.
- 12:39You got a commitment to make a proposed reg.
- 12:41And so let's and by the way I think this, I think you are the one, one and
- 12:46only former NCOA employee who helped the credit union appeal something.
- 12:51That led to a proposed reg change.
- 12:53Hopefully we can say this led to a final reg change and I think it will.
- 12:57If they proposed
- 12:57it,
- 12:58Rick Mumm: I, no I think I, I think it will.
- 12:59Mark Treichel: I think it will too.
- 13:00Yeah.
- 13:00But, so a congrats for being the only person to ever achieve that.
- 13:05And I know I haven't, 'cause I've never really appealed anything, help anybody
- 13:08appeal, anything like that, camel codes or things like that I've assisted on.
- 13:13But that's exciting.
- 13:14But let's pivot to what the proposal says and let's assume that as written,
- 13:19the proposal gets approved, right?
- 13:22If someone wants to, if someone wants to add someone like po a is
- 13:27contemplating what's, what would the new requirements be in order to get
- 13:32them added to the field of membership?
- 13:33Rick Mumm: The the new rule is very.
- 13:37Very sparse and I'm very excited for it.
- 13:42And I think ultimately we can go back to PO a and they'll be able to get
- 13:48what they want with the new rule.
- 13:51That said, I am, the new rule really doesn't address a lot of what.
- 13:58I brought out, in fact, it doesn't address any of it at all.
- 14:01It just says that and it, excuse me it just says that, nCA will now
- 14:10look beyond the character of what the customer client relationship is.
- 14:17And if it's incidental it'll prove it.
- 14:20So it doesn't change anything about who's eligible.
- 14:23It doesn't change voting rights.
- 14:25It doesn't change or even address any of that.
- 14:28And it's, I like the rule 'cause it's there and I, like you said, I feel like
- 14:34I have a big part of why it's there.
- 14:36Mark Treichel: Yeah, absolutely.
- 14:37Yeah.
- 14:37Rick Mumm: But it's also not what I had in, when the board in its.
- 14:45Denial stated, I, I guess I contemplate contemplated more than what's here.
- 14:52'cause it just, it eliminates the fraternal organization that offers
- 14:58insurance is not eligible for membership.
- 15:01It eliminates that and just basically says it'll look at the entire,
- 15:07Mark Treichel: the totality of the circumstances.
- 15:10Rick Mumm: Yeah.
- 15:10But it doesn't even say totality of circumstances doesn't
- 15:13Mark Treichel: so it comes down to the narrative.
- 15:15You put forward the facts that show that it's not like
- 15:17a Costco where it's all about.
- 15:19Buying stuff, that there's other things that the organization does
- 15:24that would make someone be a member.
- 15:27And it's kinda like defining beauty, right?
- 15:29You know it when you see it, and you'll you'll put the narrative in and
- 15:32then it say, we will eval, evaluate that, but then that creates an
- 15:36opportunity if they deny it to appeal.
- 15:39Rick Mumm: Yeah.
- 15:40So yeah.
- 15:41So it's a very minimalist, reg.
- 15:44And it, it just says they'll look behind the customer client.
- 15:49But it doesn't really give a whole lot of guidance on that, if, it'd
- 15:53be helpful if it actually said it'll look, if it meets the totality, the
- 15:57circumstances, otherwise it'll approve it.
- 16:00It doesn't.
- 16:01It doesn't say that.
- 16:02And given all the changes in cure, the fact that there is now very little,
- 16:11if any corporate knowledge, they
- 16:15Mark Treichel: lost a lot of te, a lot of people
- 16:16Rick Mumm: in the body, a lot of people.
- 16:18And they've promoted people into positions that.
- 16:23They hadn't even been in CURE for more than a couple years, and they're
- 16:27already in positions that it's huh.
- 16:31So I, so they, without the added guidance or putting something in, I'm concerned.
- 16:39With where it's gonna go?
- 16:41Or end up?
- 16:42Mark Treichel: The good news is, a glass half full will be, they made
- 16:45the change, so they're open to it.
- 16:47And when they finalize this rule you and Pom can be first in line to say,
- 16:53okay, here's what we think this means and here's why you should approve it.
- 16:57And then if they approve it, then there's a first standard that.
- 17:01NCA can go back to the next time somebody asks, says, oh yeah,
- 17:04we already proved one of these.
- 17:05Rick Mumm: Right.
- 17:05Mark Treichel: So you're,
- 17:06Rick Mumm: yeah, because
- 17:07Mark Treichel: you're paving a road, you're paving a road here, Rick, with
- 17:09with Olam and Ola is paving a road.
- 17:11I think that's gonna help some associations and some credit unions.
- 17:15Rick Mumm: No, I agree.
- 17:16And I think Jennifer, what I've talked to her is really happy.
- 17:20If.
- 17:21The group still wants to go through the process, who knows?
- 17:24But the group, other than that insurance, if you look at the totality of the
- 17:29circumstances for that particular group they met 'em all, and there's
- 17:34a lot of groups that you know.
- 17:39I worked with over the years that got approved that, they didn't
- 17:43meet all the totality, yeah.
- 17:44They met the totality, but, there's a lot of areas that they
- 17:49didn't, and we still approved it.
- 17:52And this group, other than the fact that, they were selling insurance
- 17:58or because they're a internal organization, that had been around.
- 18:02150 years or whatever.
- 18:05Yeah,
- 18:05Mark Treichel: yeah.
- 18:05Rick Mumm: They were selling the insurance before the IRS and all
- 18:08these rules even came into effect.
- 18:11That's funny.
- 18:11So they were, they are truly in every sense of the word, an
- 18:16association, they met everything, whereas a lot of associations don't,
- 18:23Mark Treichel: right.
- 18:24Rick Mumm: So I think that'll be.
- 18:26That'll be helpful.
- 18:27And I think, yeah, we'll get, should get approved if they want to go.
- 18:31Still wanna continue going forward.
- 18:35Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 18:35Makes sense.
- 18:36So a anything el anything else I should have asked you about this,
- 18:39Rick, about the proposal about what might be final or how this might work?
- 18:45I think we covered it, but I but
- 18:46Rick Mumm: Yeah.
- 18:46No I think we pretty much covered it.
- 18:48'cause the rule itself is just.
- 18:51Very straightforward.
- 18:52We it is the result of the appeal.
- 18:55Mark Treichel: Yep.
- 18:56Rick Mumm: That's finally they're going forward with.
- 18:59But I think, that's it.
- 19:00Now, if anybody else.
- 19:03Does have more questions as a result of this or reading it they're more
- 19:08than welcome to reach out to me
- 19:10Mark Treichel: and how, and if someone wants to, has listened to this and
- 19:12they go, Hey I want to talk to Rick.
- 19:14About about this part of field membership or quite frankly, any other type of
- 19:19field of membership, what's the best way for someone to be able to reach
- 19:21you?
- 19:21Rick Mumm: They can go to my email is rick@rcservices.com,
- 19:27or they can go to my website, www rc c services.com,
- 19:33all one word.
- 19:35And then there's this place in there where they can.
- 19:38Put their information in that'll get to me.
- 19:41Or the email either, either works and I'd be more than happy to
- 19:45discuss or talk to 'em about anything and everything they want, if they
- 19:49want more information on this rule change and encourage anybody that
- 19:57is, has ever wanted to add an association that.
- 20:03Had customer, client to write into the board make sure you get your comments in.
- 20:08Mark Treichel: That's a great point.
- 20:09Yep.
- 20:10Yeah.
- 20:10They ex, if you've got situations that apply point them out and that'll
- 20:15help maybe get this moved a little quicker than the two years more
- 20:17because you get the proposal up.
- 20:19Rick Mumm: Yeah.
- 20:19'cause I know I plan on.
- 20:21Sending in a comment and Excellent.
- 20:24And I know Jennifer is too,
- 20:25Mark Treichel: fantastic.
- 20:26Fantastic.
- 20:27Rick I wanna thank you for your time and as we're talking here, I think I can't
- 20:30remember when we had level one training at NCUA other than it was late 1986.
- 20:37Rick Mumm: It was.
- 20:38It was January of 87.
- 20:40Mark Treichel: Oh, Jan.
- 20:40Okay.
- 20:41So they let us run around in credit unions for a few months before
- 20:44that, because I started in October.
- 20:46Rick Mumm: Yeah.
- 20:46'cause when we started, there was no level one.
- 20:49It was
- 20:49Mark Treichel: just Oh, that's right.
- 20:50See, you're already reminding
- 20:51Rick Mumm: me.
- 20:51It was I, or I guess what, when we finally went.
- 20:55It was, they may have called it level one.
- 20:57Yeah.
- 20:57But I think now it's level, technically level two.
- 21:00Mark Treichel: Got it.
- 21:01Yeah.
- 21:01So we met January 1987.
- 21:03Almost seven.
- 21:04Yeah.
- 21:0439.
- 21:0539 years in a few months.
- 21:07Yeah.
- 21:07We'll have to celebrate our 40th anniversary of knowing each other.
- 21:11Come January of next year, I'll put it in my calendar.
- 21:14Rick Mumm: Oh, that's a great idea.
- 21:16Yeah.
- 21:16'cause I can remember old the first day Marty Kushner went in and said.
- 21:22We were there at a great time.
- 21:23It had been a real mild winter and we should really love DC and I think two
- 21:29days later they had a record snowstorm and we couldn't even get into the
- 21:32building 'cause they down the metro.
- 21:34Mark Treichel: I remember.
- 21:35I remember that.
- 21:35And I stayed back.
- 21:37That was the Giants in Bills Super Bowl year, if I remember right.
- 21:41And there was a group that went into the office and there was a group that didn't.
- 21:46And I stayed back with the.
- 21:49With the entertaining loud trainer that we had out of
- 21:54Boston who will remain nameless.
- 21:56But he was a great trainer and yeah, he was he argued with the
- 21:59other guy saying, I'm not coming in.
- 22:01And I figured that he would win the argument and I didn't wanna
- 22:04go in through all that snow.
- 22:06'cause I didn't, I left Minnesota.
- 22:08I didn't bring boots.
- 22:09I, it was supposed to be really good weather.
- 22:11So anyway.
- 22:11Yeah.
- 22:12Rick Mumm: I didn't even have any, 'cause I wasn't from a police.
- 22:14That's because you're from the west
- 22:15Mark Treichel: coast, right?
- 22:16Yeah ah,
- 22:17Rick Mumm: But I can remember we were in the office and they sent everybody
- 22:21home, but they didn't send us out and we stuck around another hour or two.
- 22:26And I think when they finally let us go, I think we were on one of the, if I
- 22:30remember right, one of the last metros that he was even allowed to leave.
- 22:33Mark Treichel: Wow.
- 22:34Yeah.
- 22:34And I think I never left the hotel that day, so I got lucky.
- 22:37All right, Rick, this has been a lot of fun.
- 22:39Thank you.
- 22:40Listeners, watchers, I want to thank you for listening or watching.
- 22:42I hope you'll do the same again soon.
- 22:45This is Mark Trekel signing off with flying Colors.