Latest / The Vegan Report / The Best and Worst Pro-Animal Social Media Content | Science of Activism
Transcript
- 0:00This is Andrea Polanco with Faunalytics for The
- 0:03Vegan Report. Today, we're exploring a question
- 0:05that anyone who's ever posted a real, shared
- 0:08an article, or run an advertisement for animals
- 0:11has probably wondered about. What can one piece
- 0:14of digital advocacy actually do? If someone scrolls
- 0:17past your video about farmed animals, does it
- 0:20stick with them? Does it change what they eat,
- 0:22what they believe, or whether they speak up,
- 0:24two weeks later, three months later? Bonalytics
- 0:27just released a new study that takes on exactly
- 0:30that question. It's called The Effects of Digital
- 0:33Advocacy, What a Single Exposure to Digital Advocacy
- 0:36Can and Can't Do. Some of what we found is encouraging,
- 0:40some of it surprising, and a few findings might
- 0:42make you rethink who your content is really reaching.
- 0:46Before we dive in, connect with me. My email
- 0:49and social links are in the episode notes. I'd
- 0:51love to hear how you're using videos and articles
- 0:53in your own advocacy. You can find new episodes
- 0:56on Wednesday on this podcast. Please share this
- 0:59episode with your community, especially anyone
- 1:01who creates or shares advocacy content online.
- 1:05Alright, let's get into it. Let's start with
- 1:07the big picture. Animal advocacy has gone digital
- 1:10over the last couple of decades, and it's easy
- 1:12to see why. In the United States, 84 % of adults
- 1:15use YouTube, 71 % use Facebook, half use Instagram,
- 1:19and TikTok has nearly doubled its adult user
- 1:21base since 2021. It's not just where people spend
- 1:25time online that's changed, it's how. Short -form
- 1:28videos or reels have become one of the dominant
- 1:30formats on Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube. So
- 1:33naturally, they become a go -to tool for animal
- 1:36advocates too. And there's some reason for optimism
- 1:39here. One cost -effectiveness analysis estimated
- 1:42that digital meat reduction advertisements have
- 1:44about a 45 % chance of sparing roughly 3 .7 animals
- 1:48per dollar spent. That's promising. but the same
- 1:52analysis also estimated a 40 % chance that these
- 1:55campaigns don't reduce demand for animal products
- 1:57at all, which is a lot of uncertainty, and it's
- 2:00exactly why rigorous experiments matter. This
- 2:04isn't Phonolitic's first look at this question.
- 2:06Back in 2022, we tested 10 different advocacy
- 2:10tactics, things like news articles, videos, and
- 2:12static social media posts. We measured whether
- 2:15people were willing to sign a petition, how they
- 2:17felt about farmed animals right after seeing
- 2:19the contents, and what they reported eating two
- 2:22weeks later. Across the full sample, none of
- 2:25the tactics made a difference in this 2022 study,
- 2:28but exploratory analysis turned up some interesting
- 2:30patterns. Static social media posts and news
- 2:33articles about farmed animal suffering seemed
- 2:35to reduce animal product consumption among meat
- 2:37avoiders, that is, reduceterians and vegetarians.
- 2:40Protest videos, on the other hand, backfired
- 2:43among both meat eaters and meat avoiders. This
- 2:462022 study only looked at short -term effects,
- 2:49though. and social media has shifted a lot since
- 2:51then. So this new study focused specifically
- 2:54on the formats that dominate feeds today, which
- 2:56are short -term videos and articles shared on
- 2:58social media. Participants in the current experiment
- 3:01saw a single piece of content. Some saw an animal
- 3:04advocacy video or article, and others saw neutral
- 3:07content as the comparison group. The advocacy
- 3:10content covered a wide range of approaches. There
- 3:13were undercover investigation videos, educational
- 3:15videos, street outreach videos, sanctuary videos
- 3:18from Ndodo, and recipe videos. On the article
- 3:22side, these were news articles including some
- 3:24about lawsuits involving animal welfare violations,
- 3:28as well as articles about disruptive protests
- 3:30and opt -eds. We also tracked a much wider set
- 3:33of outcomes than before. We included people's
- 3:36emotions right after exposure, and at both two
- 3:39weeks and three months later we measured moral
- 3:42concern for farmed animals, which is how many
- 3:44farmed animals people feel they're morally obligated
- 3:47to care about, and we also measured support for
- 3:50farm animal policies like a cage ban, and we
- 3:52also measured advocacy and information seeking
- 3:54behaviors like searching online for vegan recipes
- 3:57or talking with friends and family about farm
- 3:59animal welfare. One important sign choice. The
- 4:02content did not include a call to action. There
- 4:05was no go vegan, no sign this pledge type of
- 4:09ask. We left this out on purpose so that we could
- 4:11isolate the effect of the content itself. Keep
- 4:14this in mind as we'll come back to it. So what
- 4:17happened? First, the good news. A single video
- 4:21or article absolutely moved people emotionally.
- 4:24Compared to neutral content, almost every video
- 4:26or article that discussed farmed animal suffering
- 4:29led to significantly higher feelings of anger,
- 4:32disgust, fear, anxiety, and sadness. Two formats
- 4:36stood out for sparking positive emotions, sanctuary
- 4:39videos, were the only tactic that increased happiness,
- 4:42and recipe videos were the only tactic that increased
- 4:45feelings of desire. Which honestly makes sense,
- 4:48a good recipe video is supposed to make you hungry.
- 4:52Some groups also reacted more strongly than others.
- 4:55Women and non -binary participants reported stronger
- 4:58negative emotions than men after watching undercover
- 5:01videos and educational videos and after reading
- 5:03news articles. Meat avoiders reacted more negatively
- 5:07to undercover videos than meat eaters did. and
- 5:09Democrats reacted more negatively to undercover
- 5:12videos than Republicans. So if your goal is to
- 5:15make people feel something, one piece of content
- 5:17can do that. Now for the finding that I think
- 5:20will get the most attention. Street outreach
- 5:23videos and articles about disruptive protests
- 5:25had a more negative effect on moral concern among
- 5:28two specific groups. Meet avoiders, again, which
- 5:31were vegetarians, pescatarians, and reducetarians,
- 5:35as well as women and non -binary participants.
- 5:37Compared to meat eaters and men, these two groups
- 5:40showed a more negative shift in how many farmed
- 5:42animals they morally considered. That showed
- 5:45up two weeks after exposure, and for most of
- 5:48these effects, it was still there three months
- 5:51later. Here's why that matters. Meat avoiders
- 5:54and women tend to be seen as natural allies for
- 5:58animals. They're often more sympathetic to the
- 6:00cause and more likely to take pro -animal actions
- 6:03based on previous studies. Which is why sometimes
- 6:06advocates call them the low -hanging fruit. Yet
- 6:09these confrontational formats, the ones that
- 6:11featured animal advocates interacting with the
- 6:13public like street outreach videos or articles
- 6:16describing disruptive protests, these tactics
- 6:19seem to push them in the wrong direction. Why
- 6:22would that happen? We have a few educated guesses.
- 6:25One is empathy burnout or activism fatigue. People
- 6:29who already care deeply may be more worn down
- 6:32by this type of content. Another is called the
- 6:35bystander effect. If allies see other people
- 6:38already out there intervening, they may feel
- 6:41less personally responsible. But we're clear
- 6:44that these are just hypotheses, not conclusions.
- 6:47These need real testing and possible interviews
- 6:49with people in these groups to understand what
- 6:52is going on. There was a bright spot though.
- 6:56Reading a news article about a lawsuit involving
- 6:58animal welfare violations had a positive effect
- 7:01on Democrats' moral concern three months later.
- 7:03Compared to Republicans, Democrats who read that
- 7:06article included more animals in their moral
- 7:08concern than those who saw neutral content. Independence
- 7:12showed a similar pattern, although that result
- 7:14was only marginally significant. There is an
- 7:17important caveat I want to flag here. When we
- 7:19looked at each political group separately, there
- 7:22weren't significant differences between the news
- 7:24article group and the control group, which may
- 7:26be because these subgroups were fairly small.
- 7:29So this is a promising lead, especially for litigation
- 7:32-focused framing, but it still needs more testing.
- 7:35Now let's talk about the limitations. Across
- 7:37the whole sample, none of the tactics produced
- 7:39significant changes in behaviors or attitudes
- 7:41weeks or months later. One exposure moved people
- 7:45emotionally, but on its own, it rarely changed
- 7:47what people believed or did. Part of the challenge
- 7:50is that advocacy behaviors were pretty uncommon
- 7:52to begin with in the sample. Depending on the
- 7:55behavior, somewhere between 1 -25 % of participants
- 7:59did it at each follow -up. The most common behaviors
- 8:02were ordering a vegan or vegetarian meal at about
- 8:0620 -25%, searching for vegan or vegetarian recipes
- 8:09at about 18 -22%, and searching for how -to guides
- 8:14like how to go vegan at about 16 -17%. The least
- 8:18common behaviors were attending a protest at
- 8:20just 1%, followed by volunteering at a farm animal
- 8:24charity, which was around at 1 -2%, and donating
- 8:27to a farm animal charity at 2 -3%. When so few
- 8:32people are doing something in the first place,
- 8:34it's really hard to detect a small increase after
- 8:36they see one video or read one article. We also
- 8:41spotted some early patterns that didn't hold
- 8:43up after we corrected for running lots of the
- 8:45statistical tests at once. For example, news
- 8:47articles showed some early signs of increasing
- 8:50moral concern and support for a higher welfare
- 8:52farm transition. Opt -eds showed some signs of
- 8:56increasing moral concern at three months. On
- 8:58the flip side, people who saw undercover educational
- 9:01or sanctuary videos or who read a protest article
- 9:03seemed less likely to talk to friends and family
- 9:05about farm animal welfare two weeks later. But,
- 9:08and this is important, none of these patterns
- 9:10are confirmed. We describe these as hypotheses
- 9:12for future studies, not findings to act on yet.
- 9:15So what should you do with all of this? Here
- 9:18are our four takeaways. First, be mindful of
- 9:23who you're trying to reach. If you use confrontational
- 9:26content like street outreach videos or protest
- 9:28style materials, think about whether it's likely
- 9:31to reach people who already care about animals.
- 9:33If it is, consider whether that format is the
- 9:36right choice or pair it with a clear call to
- 9:38action. Two, try positive. food forward content
- 9:43with allies. Recipe and sanctuary videos sparked
- 9:46desire and happiness. Meat avoiders and women
- 9:49and non -binary participants reacted more positively
- 9:51to recipe videos than meat eaters and men. That
- 9:54makes this kind of content a lower risk way to
- 9:57engage people who are already sympathetic. Three,
- 10:00consider news articles for politically liberal
- 10:03audiences. Litigation focused news stories showed
- 10:06promise with Democrats and independents. It's
- 10:08not a sure thing yet, but it is worth testing.
- 10:104. Give emotion a next step Every tactic that
- 10:14showed farmed animal suffering stirred up negative
- 10:16emotions, which is a real opportunity, but only
- 10:19if people know what to do with those feelings.
- 10:21Pair your content with practical next steps like
- 10:24how to start eating more plant -based meals.
- 10:27Specific, achievable asks, like a diet pledge
- 10:29or a meat -free challenge, tend to work better
- 10:31than asking people to change their whole lifestyle
- 10:33overnight. An easy, tasty rep... recipes and
- 10:37social support can help people stick with changes
- 10:39and avoid relapse. That goes for articles too.
- 10:42You might not have written the news story, but
- 10:45when you re -share it, you can add a clear call
- 10:48to action instead of just posting the link. Before
- 10:51we wrap up, it's worth keeping a few things in
- 10:54mind. This study intentionally left out a call
- 10:57to action, and it tested just one exposure, while
- 11:00real -world advocacy usually involves people
- 11:03seeing content again and again over time. So
- 11:06our results likely underestimate what advocacy
- 11:09can achieve in the real world. We also use statistical
- 11:12corrections to account for the many tests that
- 11:14we ran, which is good scientific practice, but
- 11:16it also means that some real effects may have
- 11:18gone undetected. For researchers listening, we
- 11:21suggest a few next steps. Test the early patterns
- 11:24from this study with larger samples and more
- 11:26focused designs digging into why some content
- 11:29backfired with allies and testing what happens
- 11:31when people see advocacy content multiple times
- 11:34over weeks or months. For advocates, we describe
- 11:37these findings as informed guidance rather than
- 11:39fixed rules. The takeaway isn't that digital
- 11:42advocacy doesn't work. It's that one video or
- 11:44one article is a starting point, and what we
- 11:47pair it with and who we share it with really
- 11:49matters. You can read the full report at phonolitics
- 11:53.org, and we will put the link in the episode
- 11:56notes too. Thank you for listening. I appreciate
- 11:59your interest and support. If this episode got
- 12:01you thinking about your own content, I'd love
- 12:03to hear from you. My email and social links are
- 12:06in the episode notes, and if you know someone
- 12:08who makes or shares advocacy videos, please pass
- 12:11this episode along. This has been Andrea Polanco
- 12:13for The Vegan Report. Thank you.