Latest / Signal & Noise: Bringing Clarity to Media, Data, Tech and AI / The Sell-Side Strikes Back: Joe Root on AI, the Outcomes Era, and Rebuilding the Ad Stack from the Publisher Up
Transcript
- 0:03This is signal and noise, bringing clarity to data, tech
- 0:07and AI. Hey everybody, welcome back to
- 0:15Signal Noise. I'm Brett House, joined by my Co
- 0:17host Rio Longacre. Today we've got Joe Root and
- 0:22this is someone who's been thinking about the future of
- 0:25sell side long before it became fashionable in the industry.
- 0:29If you don't know who Joe is, he's the Co founder and CEO of
- 0:32primitive right, a University of Oxford and Imperial College of
- 0:37London grad. That's pretty impressive.
- 0:39Anybody can get into Oxford. And I was fascinated by your
- 0:42background because it went from like sales intern to CEOI was
- 0:47like, I want to hear about what happened in that transformation,
- 0:51in that sort of trajectory. And we'll talk about that in a
- 0:53minute. Right.
- 0:54But you were kind of the perfect combination English, you know,
- 0:57we we're kind of you know, I was a comparative literature major,
- 1:00Rio was involved in journalism. We both had that sort of English
- 1:03side of things and computing with a massive everything seems
- 1:07like the perfect combination. In life.
- 1:09I know seriously like you, you could you could talk and
- 1:12communicate and you could build stuff right, Which is which is.
- 1:15And he lives in New York. He's got it all.
- 1:17And he lives in New York, right? So I feel.
- 1:20So good now. For me to arguably is a platform
- 1:23built to help publishers take back control of their data
- 1:26monetization, sometimes been called the publisher DMP.
- 1:30And obviously we're at a time in the industry when it seems like
- 1:34a lot of the industry is moving in the opposite direction,
- 1:36right, with the buy side sort of grabbing control, you know, the
- 1:40open web sort of under threat by the walled gardens.
- 1:43You know, we've talked, we've all talked about this a lot.
- 1:47You know, really what I think makes this conversation super
- 1:49interesting is the thesis about how this is evolving in the age
- 1:52of AI. And I know that you've got some,
- 1:54you know, you've been talking about outcome outcomes era,
- 1:57right, which we've heard a ton in the last, you know, two years
- 2:01and a shift away from selling impressions towards delivering
- 2:04measurable results. So in sort of which, which you
- 2:07know, it's pretty interesting from a publisher perspective,
- 2:09stop selling impressions. It seems like you're leaning
- 2:11towards. So would love to hear, you know,
- 2:14a little bit about you. Did I get your bio right?
- 2:17How did you go from a sales intern to ACEO?
- 2:20And tell us a little about yourself, Joe.
- 2:22Yeah, you got you got the bio very on point.
- 2:25So yeah, me and my Co founder met in our first week at
- 2:29university of kind of college over here.
- 2:32So we were we were kind of going through a computer science
- 2:37degree. Both have become like really
- 2:39interested in the same era of research ranking distributor
- 2:42systems and machine learning. And also stumbled upon like this
- 2:47guy called Paul Graham and was writing these essays about
- 2:51starting a company and. Our combinator.
- 2:54Exactly, Y Combinator, and at this point in time we are.
- 2:57We just had no interest in going to work in at that point in time
- 3:01in London, like the only tech you could do was go and work at
- 3:04investment bank. We just like, we'll look at what
- 3:07you could do in America. It's just so much more exciting
- 3:10starting your own company. So at this point in time, Wide
- 3:13Combination is only a few years old and kind of being computer
- 3:18science graduates, like, Oh my God, I'm not going to be able to
- 3:21in any way start a company if I can't sell something.
- 3:25So met the guys at Gocardus who were kind of YC company in
- 3:29London and they said, hey, why don't you come along and learn
- 3:32how to sell things for a while. And yeah, I was picking up
- 3:35phones and wasn't the best salesperson in the world, but
- 3:38gave me good appreciation of the art that.
- 3:40And yeah, a few few months later we were at Y Combinator, and
- 3:44that was the journey into primitive.
- 3:46Yeah. And that's one, one thing I've
- 3:48taken away from a lot of execs and founders that I've I've
- 3:50talked to and CEOs is that when you can combine sales
- 3:54experience, whether you're really good at it or not, and
- 3:57product kind of subject matter expertise and like deep
- 3:59knowledge, that combination is just incredibly powerful,
- 4:03especially when you're a CEO, right?
- 4:05Plus, I mean, plus it's funny, Joe, like that and like what you
- 4:08said too, about having to pick up the phone and just call
- 4:10people. I mean, that is such an
- 4:11important skill to no one's naturally good at it when you
- 4:14first start. It just takes trial and error,
- 4:16dozens, hundreds, maybe thousands of phone calls to do
- 4:19that, right. I was actually my first job at a
- 4:20market in marketing. Yeah, a lot of it was market
- 4:23research, so. Yeah, it's terrible, but it went
- 4:26in thinking our sales is this kind of dark art and unlike this
- 4:30pure thing of computer science. But like a really good
- 4:33appreciation for like great salespeople have this process
- 4:36and methodology and the best ones are just relentless of
- 4:39following. Yeah, they're worth their weight
- 4:41in gold. A good salesperson, that's for
- 4:42sure. I like the end.
- 4:43You put up with a lot if for a good salesperson.
- 4:45Yeah, yeah, one of my favorite recent books is the unsold
- 4:48Mindset. I give you credit to Mark
- 4:50Sabatini and it's all about for, for reading that one.
- 4:53It's one of those great, like if you're on a, if you have a four
- 4:55hour drive ahead of you, you're going up north or something out
- 4:58of New York City that is. It's just a great like 3 or 4
- 5:01hour ride. And it's just all about how will
- 5:02you sell by not selling at all. You know, there's a little bit
- 5:05of this sort of seven secrets to highly effective living kind of
- 5:09stuff going on there. All these business books seem to
- 5:11have it. But it's about like, how do you
- 5:12actually sell authentically and forget all the fucking
- 5:16mechanisms and techniques and, you know, be authentic, be your
- 5:20authentic self and people will buy.
- 5:22That I think that's even more important now, Brett, right,
- 5:24with like all the AI like sloppets out there.
- 5:27And like, I mean, I posted about this morning, I ran a campaign
- 5:31for to this company. Last I remember we sent a
- 5:33thousands of emails. We got a bunch of opens, not a
- 5:35single clicker response. Just people are so just done
- 5:39with the deluge of content. They're overloaded.
- 5:41They don't want to white paper. They don't, they don't want to
- 5:44be a, you know, qualified, quote UN quote.
- 5:46I mean, it's I think the way that people sell and the way you
- 5:48have to market has really changed quite a bit.
- 5:50It's fascinating. So Joe, we were really excited
- 5:52to have you on this and you were on my previous podcast, first
- 5:54party pod, which is which is defunct.
- 5:57And then part of the reason why Brett and I decided to do this
- 5:59pod was we were looking looking for something to do.
- 6:02And you were on that one. We had a great discussion about
- 6:05where permit was the time. It's been about a year.
- 6:07So we're really stoked to get you back on this because all of
- 6:09the really interesting changes going on within AI and how
- 6:12that's impacting not only the the ad tech, let's say ad tech
- 6:17martech stack itself, but how that's affecting the balance of
- 6:21power. Brett mentioned this before,
- 6:23right? I think historically balance
- 6:25like I think it's easy to argue like the eyesight had a lot more
- 6:29power over sell side and publishers you have really have
- 6:33not done well the last 2025 years.
- 6:35I mean, you can you know, I think the joke is like no matter
- 6:37what happens, they always get hosed, right?
- 6:38So AIS may be changing that equation as decisioning was
- 6:42closer to data and if a lot of the most valuable data is on the
- 6:45sell side and maybe the center of gravity starts to shift.
- 6:49And I'm I'm starting to see some interesting things.
- 6:51So we're really keen to get your perspective.
- 6:52So your permitive, I really feel like you're probably in the
- 6:55center of this shift and really maybe accelerating a lot of it
- 6:58from centralized buy side optimization to distributed sell
- 7:01side intelligence that are really closer to the user and
- 7:04closer to where things are happening.
- 7:06So the question we're exploring today, I think it's pretty
- 7:08disruptive is like what really happens, as Brett mentioned
- 7:11earlier, when publishers move away from the race to the bottom
- 7:14and trying to sell impressions and start selling outcomes.
- 7:17And if we're the age of outcomes, they should be anyway.
- 7:19So I'm looking forward to this discussion.
- 7:21We're excited to have you on and let's let's kick off the Q&A.
- 7:24Yeah, So Joe, what? So what's what's changed?
- 7:26I mean, you know, you were on that first party pod with Rio.
- 7:29Seems like ancient history, right?
- 7:30A lot has changed since then. And you guys were talking about
- 7:32curation and probability? Curation was on the rage, yeah.
- 7:35Right. Yeah, Curation was the rage for
- 7:37a couple of years there. Now.
- 7:38Now it's really on helping publishers package and sell
- 7:41their data more effectively. Like what?
- 7:43What has really changed since now?
- 7:45And then what? Have you?
- 7:46What have you seen? So I think what's remained very
- 7:49true in that time has been this addressability crunch and loss
- 7:53of signal is huge. So I think in the year between
- 7:57just more and more agency and advertiser folk are recognizing
- 8:04the data. The things I used to make
- 8:06decisions on aren't scaling. And I'm experiencing that in my
- 8:09reach. I'm experiencing that in my
- 8:11outcomes and you can see kind of the market become much more
- 8:15literate around this. When we first went out two years
- 8:17ago, it wasn't really a thing like the fact that Rio.
- 8:20Now you kind of see this is such an essential part of the
- 8:23ecosystem. I think kind of shows the trend
- 8:26lines which which are starting to plan people just a lot more
- 8:29literate here. In parallel with that, I would
- 8:32say like the rate of disruption within kind of the agency
- 8:37business model has just been remarkable to watch from the
- 8:40outside. We just had we talked about.
- 8:42That a ton, yeah. Yeah, We had a really great,
- 8:46we've got really great agency. Zaku.
- 8:48She joined our board recently and she was saying kind of like
- 8:52we're talking to the last Friday.
- 8:53She's like, yeah, the disruption model for agencies used to be
- 8:56like every seven years there would be a disruption.
- 8:59And kind of the last couple is like that's narrowed down to two
- 9:02years. I wouldn't be surprised if it's
- 9:04nearer down to six months, it feels like.
- 9:06Yeah, we just the. Retail media thing just like
- 9:09finished disrupting now suddenly AI.
- 9:11You're right, it's like wave after wave every couple of
- 9:13years. Now, now the FTE model is sort
- 9:16of being called into question, right?
- 9:17The billable hours model, all that.
- 9:19Exactly. So that is such a tectonic shift
- 9:22that billable hours model to agencies because of AI, that
- 9:27billable hours model no longer works with clients.
- 9:31And what we're seeing at the agency level is, hey,
- 9:34increasingly that means agencies now need to find ways to make
- 9:37money from the budgets they trade versus that billable hours
- 9:41model. And and clients see a lot of
- 9:43benefits to that and a lot of good alignment there.
- 9:46But that now changes how media gets bought, how the agencies
- 9:49think about that. And when you pair that with kind
- 9:52of what's possible with AI, it's like, wow, we can rethink this
- 9:55whole ecosystem because there's such an urgent agency pressure
- 10:00to rethink these models. Yeah.
- 10:02So Joe, your recent conversations that a couple I
- 10:05really keyed on to was like 1 was with the AI Edge podcast
- 10:09with Miles and Shiv, you know, great discussion.
- 10:12I love great guys as well. Great guys.
- 10:14Yeah. In fact, Shiv was on one of the
- 10:16earlier guests in this pod and the last year.
- 10:20Yeah. With the, like, one thing you
- 10:22touched on a little bit was that with the shift towards like, AI
- 10:25as it's adopted and like, we're really like looking at who
- 10:28controls the stack, when did it click that?
- 10:31This is not just another gimmick.
- 10:33This is not just, you know, maybe not even another layer,
- 10:35but this is something fundamental and how it changes
- 10:37like the balance of power in the center of gravity.
- 10:39When did that start clicking? I think there are two things
- 10:43which we've really noticed and observed as we've.
- 10:45So the history of the businesses.
- 10:47We spent the first 7-8 years to exactly what you guys said.
- 10:51We went and built this data management platform on the
- 10:53supply side because we felt, hey, third party signals are
- 10:57disappearing. There's this abundance of signal
- 10:59on the supply side. And if you build the right
- 11:01infrastructure and technology, you can make that available and
- 11:04decisions could be made on that instead of this kind of
- 11:06declining signal which was available on the buy side.
- 11:10So with that, was that like a real focus on 1st party
- 11:12enhancing first party signal totally capturing that in a much
- 11:16richer way for for exactly so like really?
- 11:20Kind of publishers have this enormous volume of signal, but
- 11:24the pipes which sit in between the publisher and kind of the
- 11:27DSP on the other side really don't want to take too much
- 11:31signal into them because it kills the cost margins of that
- 11:34business. So DSPSSSPS, everyone's getting
- 11:38rid of inventory and bid and and bid impressions, they're getting
- 11:41rid of of signal. So actually by the time an.
- 11:43Impression. That's a compute based pro.
- 11:46Yeah, totally. Right.
- 11:47It's a computer bandwidth cost. Well, yeah, the amount of signal
- 11:50they're, they're only taking in a fraction of what's available
- 11:53to actually to, you know, for the bidding logic or any of
- 11:55that, right. I mean, it's, it's a lot of it's
- 11:58just missed entirely. Exactly.
- 11:59So by the time an impression makes its way over, often 70% of
- 12:04them have been stripped away anyway because there are these
- 12:07kind of limits the DSP places on what can be sent to them.
- 12:10And then when you observe the impression they'll have AID, but
- 12:14most of those third party IDs are missing and even things like
- 12:17the URL get stripped of all the parameters.
- 12:21So you're just buying a domain. So now you're making decisions
- 12:23on like barely any signal. And on the other side, you have
- 12:27this abundance of signal every interaction you tape what you're
- 12:30looking at which. Tells a little bit more about
- 12:32who you are and maybe what segments you belong in, right?
- 12:35Don't they say the average? Isn't the average consumer in
- 12:37like 36 or 37 different segments segments and like a traditional?
- 12:42Segments virtual signals too, right?
- 12:43So there's like there's both. So there's what we observe is
- 12:48this 2 to 3X order of magnitude more data on the supply side.
- 12:52Because it's not being leveraged, yeah.
- 12:54Not being leveraged at all. So you're talking about hundreds
- 12:56of 1000 X more signal available on the supply side, which just
- 13:00all disappears as you go through kind of this supply chain today.
- 13:04And that data is really powerful if you can leverage it to make
- 13:08decisions. But today, the way decision is
- 13:11done on the demand side kind of stops us from leveraging that.
- 13:14Yeah, so and that has and that has real world downstream
- 13:17impacts. And they like just as a as a
- 13:18funny aside, when I was at XL8, they had on their privacy page,
- 13:21you could actually type in kind of who you were from a profile
- 13:25perspective. I don't know if you threw in
- 13:26your e-mail address or, or, or a cookie idea, it's probably your
- 13:29e-mail address. And then it backed that hashed
- 13:31e-mail into all, everything that it knew about you.
- 13:34And then it was so far off. So it thought that I was a
- 13:37single female urban influencer living in like on by myself in
- 13:42New York City. I was a buried with young child,
- 13:48a different white man, not an urban influencer, you know, So
- 13:52it was just I always wondered like because.
- 13:54You're selling. Why am I getting all these
- 13:55cosmetics ads? Right.
- 13:56Yeah, You're selling the power of 1 to 1 and programmatic and
- 13:59automation and and audience segmentation and specificity.
- 14:04And yet it seems so diverse from reality.
- 14:06And to your point, it's because they're probably only capturing
- 14:08a small sliver. Either that or they.
- 14:10Just so then you're trying to, you're desperately trying to
- 14:14recreate from that tiny slither what a very complex data sets on
- 14:18the other side. So what you end up doing is like
- 14:20people take an IP address and try and turn that into a
- 14:24deterministic ID. But these things, like there's
- 14:26research out there, they're wrong 85% of the time, so.
- 14:29Then you get precise. Yeah, exactly.
- 14:32Anybody in the family can be on that IP address watching a show
- 14:35or whatever. And they're getting recycled all
- 14:37the time. You might be, depending on what
- 14:39network on or machine, you could show like show an IP in a
- 14:41different city entirely. Like I remember, like I think my
- 14:45work laptop sometimes shows up from Chicago.
- 14:47It's crazy exactly the way it's the way it's routed.
- 14:49So yeah, not precise at all. Yeah.
- 14:53So, yeah, that kind of loss of signal I think kind of
- 14:56transpired, Brett, to your point, right, like it has real
- 14:59meaningful business impact. And I suppose what we've seen
- 15:02and what's really started shift on mine is like when we
- 15:05originally started, we saw the impact on media companies.
- 15:07So you're a publisher, 70% of your inventory doesn't have a
- 15:12third party ID. So now the buy side, it's not
- 15:15even that they aren't bidding on it, they don't even see it.
- 15:17So you're getting paid nothing on this inventory?
- 15:20They'll prioritize the prioritized IDs first for sure.
- 15:23The ideas? Exactly, precisely that.
- 15:25But then the other side of it and what's been really
- 15:27interesting is hey, as agencies go through this business
- 15:31transformation which is like that FT model is known how they
- 15:34make money. A key part to how they make
- 15:37money as they build out their operating system and the
- 15:39principal trading business is the data businesses they've
- 15:42built and the impact this is having on their data businesses,
- 15:45which has been the re interesting piece.
- 15:47Like those data businesses are losing scale because they're
- 15:50relying on IDs, which would disappear, not because the data
- 15:53isn't amazing, but because kind of the current open RTB system
- 15:57isn't giving them what they need to be able to pen their data and
- 16:01that's make it. Really, Joe are actually like
- 16:04leveraging sell side signals, right?
- 16:06I mean, it's because you know, by side, you're right.
- 16:08They have, you know, massive, like we talked about this in our
- 16:11last episode, you know, they, you know, I think a lot of the
- 16:13legacy data businesses, you know, these were database
- 16:16marketing companies. They've built these.
- 16:17Massive databases. Hundreds of millions and some of
- 16:20them claim billions of users right over, you know, with all
- 16:22the all of these different data points they're capturing.
- 16:25But how many of them are leveraging like sell side
- 16:28signals, which I mean, I agree with you.
- 16:29Like it's like, not fully not leveraged enough certainly, but
- 16:34it contains some of that rich information for targeting that
- 16:36they should be using. Yeah.
- 16:38So what we've really seen is these companies are leveraging
- 16:42sell side signals, but they're doing it in a tactical way, not
- 16:45necessary yet in a strategic way and that's what's changing very
- 16:48quickly. So if you rewind a year ago,
- 16:51what we found is agencies are saying to their teams, hey, you
- 16:55need to go and fly X $1,000,000 against this, against our data
- 17:00sets with your client. And the client teams will be
- 17:03like, hey, actually I just can't get this spend away because the
- 17:07audiences aren't scaling well enough.
- 17:09And when that happens, what a lot of those teams that the
- 17:12client and at the trading level realizes, hey, well, actually
- 17:15there are a lot of these curators who have access to
- 17:17signal which is more ready available.
- 17:19Let me go and transact with them.
- 17:21And that's kind of given birth to and that's been a really
- 17:25powerful kind of leave of growth for us and our customers.
- 17:29And curation is aggregating various direct publisher
- 17:31relationship data signal into. Exactly.
- 17:35It gives a very neat way to start to kind of bring some of
- 17:39this signal together on the supply side into a package.
- 17:43So you can now buy it. Now you can.
- 17:45Scale your buy and it's and is it all premium inventory and you
- 17:48guys have direct relationships with like premium publishers?
- 17:51So that's where there's a whole kind of spectrum of people
- 17:54approach this in a different way.
- 17:55Our approach to the market has been kind of two things.
- 17:58One is we believe that the next year of buying really needs to
- 18:02focus on premium. When you focus on premium, a lot
- 18:05of the programmatic issues, fraud are non human.
- 18:08All that sort of stuff starts to disappear.
- 18:11Which is direct buy right, which is direct to but you, but you
- 18:14have to be able to scale that beat when considering the number
- 18:16of premium inventory providers there are.
- 18:18Exactly. So we're very well integrated
- 18:21into that premium market. So we bring those.
- 18:24Like what percent of the Joe? What percent of major publishers
- 18:28work with you guys? Just a high percentage, right?
- 18:30Yeah, 60% of media companies globally used permitted.
- 18:34So we have kind of very, yeah, quite a large share across that
- 18:39bit of the market because, I mean, I think you made a joke
- 18:43about kind of publishers regardless always lose.
- 18:46It was quite a contrarian bet when we went to market to go
- 18:49after publishers. But I think we really believe in
- 18:53that model and the mission they're on.
- 18:54So we, yeah, we kind of attacked a problem which I think not many
- 19:00people were thinking about at that point in time.
- 19:02Yeah. And you made a really good point
- 19:03about how you're actually it sort of filters out what is the
- 19:06fraud problem. We just talked to Doctor Foods.
- 19:09It was the second time he was on our show.
- 19:11And you know, every time he comes into the show, he just
- 19:13drops some, some data that he did and some controlled
- 19:17experiment with a client that just blows your mind, right?
- 19:20And, and a lot of what he was talking about the last time was
- 19:23sort of how you get this domain spoofing, right?
- 19:26And how SSPS will have spoof domains in the mix?
- 19:31Explain how they launder. The spoof domain and once they
- 19:33make one jump out of the SSP to other partner SSPS or whoever
- 19:38partners with them, it's laundered immediately.
- 19:41It becomes invisible and you can't track it back even though
- 19:44they're actually getting paid for that impression.
- 19:46You can't track it back to a fraudster if you don't catch
- 19:49them the first time around. And so exactly it sounds like
- 19:52you don't have that problem inherently when you're sort of
- 19:55managing direct buys and these curated.
- 19:58It's our belief and the whole host of reasons why, but we
- 20:01think agencies really need to get closer to the supply.
- 20:04And I suppose the offering we kind of take to market with
- 20:07agencies is, hey, we take you closer to premium supply and we
- 20:12also uniquely able to make the premium supply signals available
- 20:15to you because we manage those And still today the SSPS and the
- 20:21DSPS and others can't absorb that scale of signal, but
- 20:24because we run in the publisher environment.
- 20:27We can do your decisioning in their environment and then pass
- 20:30that through the supply chain. So as you're looking at.
- 20:32Agencies themselves, like you'd mentioned, you know, obviously
- 20:35with this, with this, the signal available from publishers,
- 20:38agencies are using it for, you know, for some curated deals for
- 20:41sure. But like, do you think like as
- 20:44there's, I mean, just we've been a lot of talk about this push
- 20:46towards more value based or performance based contracts.
- 20:50I don't think a lot of it's happening yet, but there's
- 20:51certainly interest and there's more discussion than I've ever
- 20:54seen. Whether that becomes reality or
- 20:55not, I think it's still kind of to be determined, but I think if
- 20:58someone could crack that code, it would they'd have a huge
- 21:01advantage. Like thoughts on like what
- 21:06you're doing, how would how it relates to that potentially and
- 21:08any trends you're seeing in agencies trying to move their
- 21:11businesses in that direction? Yes, totally.
- 21:13So I think what we're seeing is clients are putting all this
- 21:18pressure on the FTE model agencies.
- 21:21Yep. And what they're really saying
- 21:23to agencies is, hey, you should make your money by being the
- 21:26best possible investment partner for us.
- 21:29And what does a really good investment partner look like
- 21:31with a couple of pieces? 1 is like, hey, you need to
- 21:35invest my marketing dollars to drive the best possible outcomes
- 21:39for my business. That's a really key part being
- 21:41good investment. You should leverage the scale of
- 21:44who you are in order to go and negotiate really good rates.
- 21:47As a good investment partner for me, you should identify where
- 21:51opportunities in the supply exist for me and go and
- 21:54negotiate those. So there's all these parts which
- 21:57make a great investment partner, but almost all them are in that
- 22:01agency warehouse and strength of like, hey, if they can get
- 22:05really good signal, they can make really good decisions.
- 22:08They're really good at negotiating and and the
- 22:10principal trading business, which used to be be a dirty
- 22:13word, I think is very much back and forth because clients want
- 22:17that as well. Interesting, Rio and I have kind
- 22:21of been arguing against that in a sense.
- 22:24So I simply because of the the fact that, you know, with it's,
- 22:27it's a computer reach play, right.
- 22:30And so, so they're really going like, we need to fulfill these
- 22:33budget dollars. And so we're going to buy maybe
- 22:36more inventory that actually exists, right?
- 22:38Like as in real human inventory. And we're going to buy as much
- 22:42of this at scale as possible, which is kind of a race to the
- 22:45bottom because you start paying cheaper CPM rates, you're
- 22:49getting kind of fraudulent and shitty inventory, right?
- 22:53How does that support outcomes? Yes, I think outcomes are the
- 22:56counterbalance of principal trading.
- 22:59So the leverage the client has is, hey, here are the outcomes
- 23:03which you need to drive. How you drive those outcomes is
- 23:06down to you. And the principal trading part
- 23:09is really the agency saying, hey, you don't want me to
- 23:12execute on a client model, you want me to execute on an outcome
- 23:15based model. I need to be able to leverage my
- 23:17own strength to drive profit in this.
- 23:19And clients aren't like naive or stupid like they realize the
- 23:23agency needs to make money is how do you line the way the
- 23:26agency makes money to what we're doing?
- 23:28But I think like the agency takes a lot of risk in that like
- 23:32the agency is pre. Buying, yes.
- 23:34It's like they're sort of leverage in a sense.
- 23:36You're leveraging debt to invest in this because you haven't been
- 23:40paid. By the clients.
- 23:41Right. It's funny you say that too,
- 23:43because like when we like we've done some in housing exercises
- 23:46with big brands who wanted to bring maybe not the buying
- 23:48itself, but the platform licenses, you go on paper direct
- 23:52with them. Some of the analytics to
- 23:54measurement, first party data. We've done exercise like that.
- 23:57The hardest part in one of those, in one of those
- 23:59activities is the contracting because you have to explain to
- 24:02the brand you need to pay the platforms net 30, that's non
- 24:04negotiable. Meta, Facebook, Google, they're
- 24:08going to shut you down and say, well, we normally pay all our
- 24:11vendors net 90. That's just that's non
- 24:13negotiable. Well, it's like when the
- 24:16unstoppable forces, immovable objects, things got to give,
- 24:20right? And then guess what, like Google
- 24:21and that are not going to give. So that's the hardest part.
- 24:23It's funny you say that. Yeah.
- 24:24So I think really what we believe is that agency model is
- 24:30moving very quickly and actually AI enables them to do that and
- 24:35do that at scale if they can plug themselves into as much
- 24:39signal as possible to make good inventory based decisions and to
- 24:43make good outcome based decisions.
- 24:45And what does that, what does that architecture look like,
- 24:47right? And how do they I'm assuming
- 24:50this has got something to do with there's a clean room in
- 24:53here somewhere Yes, right. The reason why I say that
- 24:56because because you know the the the publishers want to
- 24:59completely anonymize or pseudonymize their data because.
- 25:03Their first party data. That's that's their golden
- 25:05goose. You can't just put that into
- 25:06another system. So you've got to do it through
- 25:08some sort of intermediary, which would be.
- 25:10Is that a? Is that a clean room in this?
- 25:11Case exactly. So what we see is you kind of
- 25:15need these two parallel pathways.
- 25:17You need a clean room for the agency to be able to bring their
- 25:21own data sets and pair that with all the publisher supply side
- 25:25signal and identify what supply side signal best represents the
- 25:29dates in the audiences the agency has.
- 25:31So if I've gone and built an autointender audience as an
- 25:34agency, I now need to go and find where that lives across the
- 25:38supply side signal which exists. So that's kind of layer number
- 25:41one. Layer number 2 is you then need
- 25:44to be able to go and activate that and today curation pipes
- 25:48and the wave point of integrates with that then allows them to
- 25:50take this insight from the clean room and very quickly turn that
- 25:54into single thing which they can go and activate in the
- 25:56bitstream. So and is there is.
- 25:58There an onboarding, is there an onboarding step in there in
- 26:00terms of, you know, The Dirty word onboarding where you have
- 26:04to take that signal. You've got X, you know, number
- 26:07of IDs for X amount of reach, and then suddenly that's cut in
- 26:11half because you're going through onboarding pipes when
- 26:13you bring it over to the DSPS. Exactly.
- 26:15So I think this concept of onboarding is changing very
- 26:19rapidly and I see this in our clients and our customers today.
- 26:24The old world of onboarding is, hey, I want this one to one
- 26:26match and I'm going to go and hit that onboarded audience.
- 26:29Yep, now you're onboarding that audience to go and find insight
- 26:32and which signal should I hit? So hey, I've got this
- 26:35autointender audience. Here's all the contextual
- 26:38content which they're consuming as they move across the open
- 26:41Internet. Here are the audiences which
- 26:43they belong in when they're on all these different media
- 26:46company properties and it's the the onboarding is like a much
- 26:51smaller part. It's not a one to one
- 26:53deterministic match for onboarding right anymore.
- 26:55It's it's more complex than that.
- 26:57Gone are those days because as soon as you do that, you have
- 27:00two problems. Your reach gets massively cut
- 27:03down. So like ultimately you can then
- 27:05only address like somewhere between 10 and 30% of consumers
- 27:09have an ID. All of a sudden, you lost all
- 27:11this reach and problem #2 is like that onboarding
- 27:15methodology. And when you do it with
- 27:17Facebook, Facebook, a parent with their own signals, and then
- 27:20finding your next set of consumers in your next set of
- 27:22consumers. But onboarding in programmatic
- 27:25and open Internet has always been to retarget those
- 27:27consumers. Yeah.
- 27:28And when all you're doing is retargeting, you're not growing
- 27:31your brand anymore because you're not finding kind of the
- 27:33next set of consumers in the next set of consumers.
- 27:36So that's kind of the second piece is like you solve this
- 27:38reach problem, but you also solve an incremental sales
- 27:41problem. Yeah.
- 27:42And so it sounds like you guys have got a real time signal of
- 27:47data. So a data flow that's going into
- 27:49the client's architecture, right.
- 27:50So it's going into their cloud data warehouse, whatever on the
- 27:53agency side, maybe on the brand side.
- 27:55Is it generally the use of? Yes.
- 27:57So it's, it's primarily on the agency side.
- 28:00We do this with brands as well. But yeah, agencies I think is
- 28:04what we've where we found kind of the biggest pain and business
- 28:08model change in needs. So that is, is, is which I
- 28:12wouldn't have made the bet on five years ago, but that is
- 28:14exactly where kind of the majority of growth comes.
- 28:17From so if that stream and so it's so and tell me if I'm
- 28:19describing this right. So it's pseudonymized.
- 28:21You get the stream of signal that's much richer than they
- 28:24have now because it's sell side signal, right?
- 28:26It's contextual, it's got all that stuff packaged into it.
- 28:28And then they and then there's you guys, I'm assuming you're
- 28:31powering kind of a predictive analytics model of some sort
- 28:35that's saying, hey, you know, based on specific outcomes,
- 28:38whatever the outcome is, we can start to find incremental
- 28:42audiences that you may not have seen that don't fit the sort of,
- 28:46you know, apples and orange description of like auto and
- 28:49Tinder. But it might be somebody that's
- 28:51doing which kind of lends itself to almost automated second party
- 28:54linkages. Exactly.
- 28:56So it's like hey, dot dot Tesla and Tender, while five weeks ago
- 29:00they were reading a review of Tesla across her store on Top
- 29:04Gear or wherever it might be. Now you aren't targeting the 70%
- 29:10of consumers reading that content who don't have an ID.
- 29:13We need to flip this principle kind of we need to kind of
- 29:16transpose this and actually you want to go and hit the consumer
- 29:20the intent signal, not at the ID.
- 29:22Signal. Yeah, yeah.
- 29:24Which is very contextual and in a sense, right.
- 29:27Very contextual, very behavioral in nature, but a whole lot of
- 29:32data which today the programmatic pipes just cannot
- 29:35tolerate without destroying their cost margins.
- 29:39So, Joe, this is the probabilistic targeting that
- 29:41you've been, you've been talking about quite a bit, which you
- 29:43know, it's, it's pretty powerful, right?
- 29:45I mean, and you're right, like people have not been taking
- 29:47advantage of this. But like if like let's say this
- 29:49does become more of the norm, right?
- 29:51Like what does this do? Like looking at SSPS, DSPS, what
- 29:55does the balance of power shift? Like what does it do to I mean,
- 29:58if decisioning a lot of this is starting to happen closer to
- 30:00sell side, it is taking away functionality that you, the DSPS
- 30:04do today to a certain extent, right?
- 30:06So sweet comments on that. Other thoughts?
- 30:08Yeah. So kind of four players we think
- 30:10about, right for the media company, while now the 70%, the
- 30:15inventory which was ignored is being bought and they see CPM
- 30:18scope. So when we see these deals being
- 30:20done, they typically say 2X increase in yield the like
- 30:24client downstream. Now you're reaching a bigger
- 30:27audience, you're seeing sales go up and you think CPA S go down.
- 30:30So we're seeing like somewhere between kind of 100 and 120%
- 30:34sales uplift and usually CPA is coming down by half for the
- 30:38agency. Now all of a sudden, scale of
- 30:40your audience has gone up. You're reaching more consumers,
- 30:43so you're able to make more money on the budgets you trade
- 30:45because ultimately Facebook's not taking a principal trading
- 30:49deal with you. You're only making it when
- 30:50you're going on the open Internet.
- 30:51So those three parties all benefit.
- 30:53You then have ad tech, which is kind of someplace benefiting
- 30:58some losing. So right now, I would say like
- 31:00objectively, the DSP is losing in curation and the SSP is
- 31:05winning, right? It's just a hard fact.
- 31:07It's like the trade Desk gets a lower take rate when this is
- 31:11being done in a deal ID and in a private marketplace and the SSP
- 31:15is able to charge more fees when it's being done in a private
- 31:18marketplace. So like we're seeing this
- 31:20transitioning as decisioning moves from buy to sell side.
- 31:25We're seeing a shift in in in effectively who is able to kind
- 31:28of take margin. But I think if you really zoom
- 31:32out really kind of agencies on the.
- 31:35QSP hold on, let's let's have it.
- 31:38So there's a shift in who's taking margin towards the SSP
- 31:41side. So so the trade desk for
- 31:43example, you know has open path. And sorry, yeah.
- 31:45They've sort of gone to that play.
- 31:47Do you see a future where, you know, DSPS and the traditional
- 31:51way we define them kind of go away because, you know, it kind
- 31:55of reminds me of the the take rate conversation we had with
- 31:57Doctor Fu Rio. Yeah, where he was saying that
- 32:00what's happening in the buy side is that the take rates are.
- 32:04They're just cranking it up. Yeah, they're cranking it up for
- 32:06basically every incremental penny on top of the the ask
- 32:11price, right? So let's say you ask 150, you
- 32:13sell for 3:50 and they take 99% of the.
- 32:16Insinuation is like they're having like OK new quarter we
- 32:19got hitter numbers you know like he was he and he was saying some
- 32:21of the major DSPS were able to just like raise the take rates
- 32:24dynamic, you know yeah point bread to to gobble up the
- 32:27incremental bids as they're as they're as they're moved up.
- 32:30So yeah, it's. Yes, not going to mean I think,
- 32:34yeah, I mean you're saying DSPS are going direct to supply SSPS
- 32:38going direct to agencies. You're kind of seeing that that
- 32:43I think the dicot like this kind of dicotomy or this kind of
- 32:46bifurcation of buying sell side that's kind of disappearing,
- 32:49right. And I actually were just saying
- 32:52there should be a single direct connection between the agency
- 32:54and between the publisher and both DSP and SSP are trying to
- 32:58do that, but there are. You've heard here at Signal
- 33:01Nose, Joe Rude is calling for an end of the middle men, right?
- 33:06A lot of the middle men, right? Direct connection.
- 33:08And no. But that's a topic that keeps
- 33:10coming up again and again and again.
- 33:12It's like the middle men are taking a cut and yeah, $0.40 to
- 33:15every dollar, $0.50 to every dollar, whatever it is.
- 33:17The toll takers, right? Yeah, they're toll takers.
- 33:20So I think, yeah, I think this is the piece which is really
- 33:23happening on one part is it's not like the DSP serves no value
- 33:29if it's not doing decisioning like to the point on net 30,
- 33:32right, Rio is like actually the DSPS are like lending to an
- 33:36entire ecosystem because the publishers getting paid in like
- 33:3930 days, the DSP is getting paid in 100 and. 20 play a role too,
- 33:43right? I mean, they don't play a role
- 33:45in delaying payments or facilitating payments.
- 33:48Like, you know they're the market makers, right?
- 33:50So I don't think we should underestimate like the
- 33:53non-technical role these folk play, which has a lot of value.
- 33:57But yes, the value equation is changing.
- 34:00And when you zoom out, agencies are under margin pressure, idiot
- 34:04companies are under huge margin pressure.
- 34:06And then objectively there's a 70% margin take in between those
- 34:10two, both sides that are saying, hey, how do we get more direct
- 34:14to each other so that we can find a margin opportunity
- 34:17ourselves. That is just a reality.
- 34:20Do you see a future where the sorry, do you see a future where
- 34:23the agency is moving kind of up the value chain in terms of the
- 34:29services they're offering? Because I think there's a
- 34:31there's a certain commoditization play when
- 34:33they're just doing the principal based media buying, right?
- 34:36Because a lot of that is being automated, right?
- 34:38And so to me, I'm seeing this picture kind of from your mind
- 34:43at your company, right, where if you're providing more signal
- 34:46pseudonymized. So it's not, you're not stealing
- 34:48the publisher data to the agency.
- 34:50The agency has I can layer on a lot of analytics and decisioning
- 34:54and strategic value on top of just the media buy right which
- 34:59which increases their value is a I.
- 35:01Think they have to do that? Yeah, yeah.
- 35:03Yeah. I mean, I think kind of, we
- 35:06really see agencies needing to take a lot more control over
- 35:11kind of how they invest and allocate that media and they
- 35:15need to make take more control as kind of custodians of their
- 35:21customers dollars. So these principal trading deals
- 35:24and negotiating rates like you're effectively looking for a
- 35:27really good investment partner. Now our belief is AI will enable
- 35:31them to do a lot of this stuff better.
- 35:33So like before, I need to staff a team of 100 people to manage
- 35:38all these publisher relationships where I could
- 35:40staff a team of 10 to go and execute in ADSP.
- 35:43Like that made programmatic just so much more scalable in that FT
- 35:49model type system. But now if you really look at
- 35:53what's happening, it's like, hey, agencies can leverage
- 35:56agents to do a lot of the direct buying and maybe we can get on
- 35:58to what we're seeing on the supply side with publisher
- 36:01agents. But I think agencies are going
- 36:03to start to build all their own agents and you're seeing that in
- 36:06their operating systems today as they all roll those out.
- 36:09Our job and our belief is we should.
- 36:11Provide good signal to this, yeah.
- 36:14So yeah, good pivot here. I love this topic, so we've
- 36:17talked about it a lot here. I actually wrote a series of
- 36:19articles about, you know, a gentic trading.
- 36:22Is it happening? What's how is it going to affect
- 36:24affect the ecosystem? Is it good or bad?
- 36:27I mean, it's I've spoke with people several the big hold Cos
- 36:30and I don't think anyone's actually doing.
- 36:32It's really not at scale yet, but there's a lot of testing.
- 36:34There's a lot of enthusiasm. Want to get your taking a couple
- 36:37of these #1 like state of the union, like is it happening?
- 36:40Do you think it's going to timeline?
- 36:41I think #2 would be like, if this really happens, like what
- 36:45is this do? Like does this, if a genetic
- 36:49trading is going to really focus on allocation, does this mean
- 36:52that agents are actually hammering out deals by
- 36:56themselves? Does this mean that that does
- 36:57it, what does this do to the auction?
- 36:59Does the auction, does this, does this happen pre auction?
- 37:01They're just planning, Is it more planning exercise or are
- 37:04they actually making deals that are, you know, with, with more
- 37:07like the old way with price sheets, but are happening at
- 37:09scale because agents are doing it And maybe the auction gets
- 37:11relegated to more like remnant inventory.
- 37:13I don't know. I mean, could really change
- 37:15things dramatically or could change things very not much at
- 37:17all. If I posted something the other
- 37:19day about, you know, that was kind of joking, like, well, if
- 37:23this, if a gender trading happens, what happens to DSPS?
- 37:26Will they be around? And I think Adam Heidlich from
- 37:28Chalice, he he he replied and said, well, you can't bid us
- 37:32something if you don't, you know, if you don't know the
- 37:33price. So which is a valid point as
- 37:35well. So, so like, like his point was
- 37:38the auctions going to still firmly be there because you need
- 37:40it right in the DSP and all of the bidding happens in the DSP
- 37:42levels. The thoughts.
- 37:43I know that was a lot, but thoughts on this Joe?
- 37:46Like what will happen in the really?
- 37:48Passionate about this topic? Yeah, Yeah.
- 37:51So I wish I had a crystal ball which predicts it perfectly.
- 37:53But obviously we have a company strategy which we make our
- 37:57investments and decisions on. So we have like a very strong
- 38:00POBI suppose in terms of like the story is like two, 2 1/2
- 38:05years ago. We're broadly Speaking of supply
- 38:07side business. All of our customers are
- 38:09primarily media companies, advertiser businesses rocketed.
- 38:12But you know the two year thing. So 2 1/2 years ago we started to
- 38:17realize, hey, we can make these like quality of life
- 38:19improvements using AI within the platform.
- 38:22We can like allow you to search better within the platform
- 38:25because it kind of better identifies kind of the actual
- 38:28meaning behind, for example, an audience or segment name.
- 38:31That was really interesting. And all of a sudden our
- 38:33customers were able to do things a little bit faster than around
- 38:37a year and a half ago. We realized, hey, actually like
- 38:40these agents could pretty intelligent now and can actually
- 38:45surface decisions back. And if we take this AI and turn
- 38:48it into agents, like what can be done differently?
- 38:51So we started to build agents for audience building, for
- 38:54campaign planning, for campaign optimization like weep for last,
- 38:58kind of speaking with one of our customers who now uses.
- 39:02Halo, right? Is that your agent?
- 39:03Halo, exactly. So we have this suite we call
- 39:05Halo, which we released across the cell side.
- 39:08They've gone from RFP taking them five hours sometimes, often
- 39:12kind of a couple of days to 15 minutes.
- 39:15So all of a sudden that's. That hyperbolic, that's like the
- 39:18real thing, right? That's just because you've got a
- 39:20memory system that you've built around how you how you, there's
- 39:23only so many ways to slice an RFP pie and you just train the
- 39:26system, which is hugely effective from that.
- 39:28What a time saver. Yeah, yeah.
- 39:30Exactly. So like even this morning I got
- 39:32a video from from one of our engineers who kind of built out
- 39:35a series of chord skills for our clients to respond to RFPs.
- 39:39He sent me over the demo, like start to finish, it was 10
- 39:41minutes. I put it on 2X, get through it
- 39:43quickly, but it's like it's crazy.
- 39:45Like he had a fully generated RFP response 10 minutes after
- 39:48kind of entering in all this detail and Chord is basically
- 39:51just going backwards and forth with punitive to assemble this.
- 39:55What it allows is like or another very good examples like
- 39:59this client was only optimizing 10% of their campaigns because
- 40:02that's all the ad OPS resource they have.
- 40:04We have these optimization agents which now surface up a
- 40:08load of decisions for them to make on a campaign by campaign
- 40:10basis and the ad OPS seems to be using that optimization.
- 40:14So all of a sudden. So it's basically it's taking
- 40:16something that would have taken like the limit was people doing
- 40:18it right because it's so time consuming and so labor
- 40:20intensive. But you're saying with AI you
- 40:22can just, you know, instead of doing 10%, you can do 100?
- 40:24Percent exactly. So now like the throughput which
- 40:27you can put through direct pipes, like all our publishers
- 40:31teams are dealing with this primary like direct sold stuff
- 40:34and all of a sudden you can put 102030X more through that for
- 40:39the same cost of headcount. So that means like on the sell
- 40:42side, you've got this capability to transact directly at a scale
- 40:46you would never thought was possible.
- 40:49And on the buy side, what agencies are doing with the
- 40:52operating systems, like you pay that for another 6-12 months
- 40:57from now and like, hey, you can meet these two worlds and now
- 41:00you've bypassed programmatic pipes and you're able to
- 41:03transact very directly. Yeah, so.
- 41:05It's interesting. So sorry, Brett, I-1 little
- 41:07point that I'll pass over to you.
- 41:09So that's interesting because remember, like Foo Brett, if you
- 41:11remember last time we're talking, yeah, we're talking to
- 41:15him. I mean, like, and he was saying,
- 41:16like his his thesis was these advertisers should be going
- 41:20directly to an agency should be going directly to the publishers
- 41:23through their portals, not through queues, basically saying
- 41:25don't go to these DSPS go straight to the the buying
- 41:28platforms themselves buys. And and I kind of my counter
- 41:31that was like, then you can have 1520 thirty places you're doing
- 41:34your buys. That's I mean that's so that's
- 41:36that's really difficult. All the swiveling and managing
- 41:38of that and then, you know, getting people to do it.
- 41:41And he and he said, well, an agency should be able to do it.
- 41:42I don't know. I mean, that's, that's, that's a
- 41:45lot. You could argue that 7080% of
- 41:46your buy is going to be across 5.
- 41:48Like the number of publishers is like you can count on two hands,
- 41:51right? But I think his, one of his big
- 41:53points was that if you plug AI into basically a polluted open
- 41:58web supply, right? Which he's claiming that the
- 42:01open web supply outside of the signal that you're talking about
- 42:04and I kind of want to lean towards that to say, hey, you've
- 42:07got a lot of authenticated traffic, right, people that have
- 42:10gone to these publishers they have they.
- 42:12Have premium publishers? Yeah, yeah, they're premium.
- 42:14Publishers, no, some of it's probably is it all premium or is
- 42:16it all authenticated? All premium, yeah, OK.
- 42:19So you don't have to worry about all of the, the fraudulent
- 42:22bullshit that's out there in terms of supply that are just
- 42:25like domain spoofs and all that other stuff.
- 42:27Because if you plug it, if you plug, if the agencies plug, you
- 42:30know, their agents into that sort of source of it's polluted,
- 42:34right? And it's and you're just going
- 42:35to scale nonsense, you're going to scale just empty impressions.
- 42:39Whereas you're saying you guys have an argument because your
- 42:42data source is authenticated in rich and deterministic, right?
- 42:48Exactly. So I think they're like a number
- 42:49of these factors which are converging on, hey, you want to
- 42:52go direct. So like our role in this and our
- 42:54bias is, hey, we can provide the signal for this next layer of
- 42:58kind of AI agents and we can also provide an interface which
- 43:02connects you directly into the supply.
- 43:03So I have a bias POV on the other side of this side.
- 43:10It sounds really compelling. Where do I decide the dotted
- 43:12line here? But the other side of it, right,
- 43:15So I think open, open Internet is very rapidly changing.
- 43:21And actually kind of a lot of these challenges were as we
- 43:24built these systems to buy across thousands and thousands
- 43:29of like publishers with search just sending so many people to
- 43:33random blogs and web pages. And it created like a very
- 43:37perverse incentive structure which fed a lot of fraud and all
- 43:41these other pieces. The reality is like AI search
- 43:44has killed the long tail of the open Internet, right?
- 43:46It's like you will go to your trusted sources, so you'll go to
- 43:51Financial Times or the BBC or whoever it is for the news and
- 43:55the content. Yeah, but all but everything
- 43:57else is happening directly through a chat experience.
- 44:00Definitely will down the number of websites I visit.
- 44:02Yeah, I mean, I used to have all these tabs open.
- 44:04Now I don't and I'll just have one or two.
- 44:05And you're right, the ones I always go to I still go to, but
- 44:07like the most of the other ones I was just randomly going to
- 44:10because of a search. Exactly.
- 44:12So like now if I'm a media company and I want to get reach
- 44:16in any given market, they're probably in 30 to 50
- 44:20destinations who I need to refocus my relationship on.
- 44:25And hey, the side effects of that as well is like 1.
- 44:27I can negotiate principal trading rates so there's an
- 44:30opportunity for me to make money.
- 44:31The inventory is much higher quality, so I'm not having to
- 44:34deal with fraud and all these other things.
- 44:36I get really rich signals so I can optimize towards better
- 44:39outcomes. Like there are a lot of very
- 44:41good things when you do that. Not because like programmatic
- 44:44and the way we did things was bad.
- 44:46It made sense at that point in time.
- 44:48But in the modern world, the way things have changed, it doesn't
- 44:51make sense to buy in that way in.
- 44:53This new model like who we're like sounds like you're working
- 44:57a lot with agencies and sound like the hold codes, Indies, all
- 45:03the above. Yes.
- 45:05And then you have these relationships with publishers.
- 45:08Are you working with buy side at all?
- 45:09You work with marketers, is that started?
- 45:11Yes. So we have, we have kind of two
- 45:14sets of of client on the buy side.
- 45:17One is agencies, the other is the actual advertiser.
- 45:21The reality is though, if the advertiser has the direct
- 45:24relationship with us is still the agency of going out and
- 45:27executing all that stuff day-to-day.
- 45:29So paperwork maybe with a different team, but nine times
- 45:33out of 10, the kind of folk who are working with all the agency
- 45:37folk in the day-to-day of it. And I think kind of what we see
- 45:41is I think we are most interested in how does AI
- 45:46transform business models because we think that's where
- 45:48there's the real opportunity to go and build.
- 45:51And this transformation, the agency business model is just so
- 45:55intense that it is a great time to go and build with these guys.
- 45:59OK, so questions. So the agencies are trying to
- 46:01build these like AI driven workflows that can aggregate
- 46:04let's say like their their scale demand across the different
- 46:07places they're buying media, right?
- 46:09I also see like the platforms are trying, they're also trying
- 46:11to build their own AI like a gentic layer on top of this.
- 46:15And then you see some brands are building their own agents.
- 46:18Like who wins the battle? Like like where does where does
- 46:21this actually where does the buying eventually take place?
- 46:23Or does it not matter? Yeah.
- 46:26So I suppose state of like play today as of like this very
- 46:29moment, agencies have gone and built these kind of operating
- 46:32systems for kind of planning all the way through to activation
- 46:37because it's part of like efficiency Dr. within these
- 46:39organizations. They're doing all that stuff
- 46:41today. It's just automating it.
- 46:42You know, automating what they already do.
- 46:44And where the bicep, some people argue that they're not really
- 46:47operating systems, the word OS is taking on a bad word.
- 46:50In some cases there might be they might be further ahead, but
- 46:52that it's just it's just a collection of point solutions
- 46:56with an AI wrapper on top. Is that is that what that's why
- 47:00Black Hat counterpoint to the the operating system argument,
- 47:04which I think makes sense from a positioning and slide where
- 47:07like, hey, we're bringing, you know, it's kind of like the
- 47:08marketing cloud talk like 1520 years ago, right?
- 47:11By these companies and we're smashing together, right?
- 47:13Yeah. Yeah, but is it how, how far do
- 47:15you see and how mature do you see that from your?
- 47:18The most mature bit we see within this kind of operating
- 47:21system stack is the data business, right, is in the whole
- 47:25gold codes, they've all gone and built them or they've merged to
- 47:28kind of bring the assets in like Axiom into Omnicom.
- 47:31Or alternatively, what you see in the indie landscape is kind
- 47:35of these partnerships like Horizon with TransUnion for
- 47:39Blue. Yeah.
- 47:40But regardless, kind of that is very real and exists today.
- 47:45And I think a lot of those workflows are being improved and
- 47:49made better by AI. But the output of that is
- 47:52basically a load of IDs which the agency then needs to go and
- 47:55activate. And the challenge they have is
- 47:57back to like the problems. We've been discussing a lot the.
- 48:01Problem of addressability right as they go to activate it and
- 48:04doesn't scale and then their client teams get frustrated and
- 48:07then they have to go and use data sets which are not part of
- 48:11the operating system and the off pricing.
- 48:13System lose. So it goes almost goes back to
- 48:15the same onboarding problem. We've got all these IDs, we've
- 48:17got a match to, to wherever our DSP, our sort of ad serving is
- 48:22exactly and you lose all the scale, yeah.
- 48:24So that's the problem we solve today.
- 48:26It's like, hey, we're just going to triple the reach of the
- 48:29output of your operating system by mapping it onto all the
- 48:33supply side contextual signals and behavioral signals so that
- 48:37you can keep all this working through that one operating
- 48:41system and flow. And that's kind of our value
- 48:43prop back. And that enables them to make
- 48:45those businesses much more robust and bigger, but it also
- 48:49gives them the foundations as they start to build out their
- 48:52own AI agents, as you see principal trading start to play
- 48:56a bigger role as you see them trying to go directly, well,
- 48:59hey, those same data foundations which are feeding your operating
- 49:03system can also feed your AI agents.
- 49:06And that's kind of a broader belief we have.
- 49:10It's like actually the agencies can read when if they start to
- 49:14do this. And the reality is, it's like
- 49:17they'll probably do so at the expense of some ad tech players.
- 49:22So looking at sell side, like looking at publishers that we've
- 49:25talked a lot about how they've you know, whatever has happened
- 49:29in media, they've gotten the short end of the stick, right.
- 49:31I don't I think that's an easy argument to make right when they
- 49:34go in. I think Craigslist launched,
- 49:35they lost what up to 40% of the revenue just from classified ads
- 49:39and then shift to digital. I mean, like, you know, the, you
- 49:41know, the equip was always traditional dollars for digital
- 49:45pennies, right? I mean, it's, it's been a tough
- 49:4725 years and now with AI, right? I mean, I've, I have had clients
- 49:50who've had seen reductions of 2025, thirty even up to 40% of
- 49:55the traffic's collapsed. And a lot of people who don't
- 49:57know the publishing business well don't realize that's
- 49:59actually money in their pocket that's being taken away as the
- 50:01traffic goes away. You know, it's a big revenue
- 50:04source, right? Is, is a monetization they have
- 50:06from their properties digitally. So like, I mean, this new
- 50:09paradigm that we're entering and what you're describing, what
- 50:11you're, you're trying to build, right?
- 50:13Like will this be better for publishers?
- 50:15Should publishers maybe is this a golden opportunity for them?
- 50:18And you know, like, or could they lose out again to like
- 50:22maybe new kind of toll takers who who swoop in and, and take
- 50:26and and begin to to monitor take away from their monetization?
- 50:29What do you, what do you predict for publishers and like, what
- 50:31would be your advice to them? Yeah.
- 50:33So broad rules done for a publisher today, if you're
- 50:36getting bought programmatically, you're probably getting bought
- 50:38at a dollar. If you're getting bought
- 50:40directly, yeah, you're getting bought between 10 and 20
- 50:44dollars. 80% of your inventory is likely being bought
- 50:48programmatically, 20% of it is likely being bought direct in
- 50:51some cases at 9010 turn that. So every publisher needs to grow
- 50:57directly and that is the number one strategy.
- 50:59So publishers are proponents and supporters of, hey, if agencies
- 51:04want to buy us more directly, we want to enable that.
- 51:07Now for a publisher looking to take control of this, why is an
- 51:11agency going to buy you more directly?
- 51:13They're going to buy you more directly if you help them with
- 51:18their data business. So if you can bring their data
- 51:20supply side and scale it well, hey, you can plug into that.
- 51:23They're going to buy you more directly if you deliver outcomes
- 51:26for their, their, their clients. So you need to start focusing on
- 51:29driving outcomes within your own direct campaigns and what do you
- 51:33need to kind of support this? Well, you need all the right
- 51:36signal available to better deliver on those two value
- 51:39propositions back, but you also need an agent LED to support it.
- 51:43Yeah, and you also, but you also need to prove outcomes.
- 51:45That's that's a, that's a caveat here because publishers have
- 51:49always struggled to prove outcomes because they don't
- 51:51control the point of sale. They, they once, once an
- 51:54audience, you know, bounces off of their site or their
- 51:56properties to somewhere else, it's hard to, you know, those
- 51:59are all living in different worlds, right?
- 52:00So is that a partnership play where they're working with
- 52:04incrementality, MTA, MMM, whatever measurement providers?
- 52:07ASAP so that the unfair advantage Google and Facebook
- 52:10have is the conversion API. So Google and Facebook get fed
- 52:14this measurement data and then they optimize all their systems
- 52:17towards that. Publishers have been in this
- 52:20really unfair. You could argue they fudge they
- 52:22fudge attribution a little bit. But keep going.
- 52:25And then and then the retail, we'll add the retail media from
- 52:28a walled garden perspective ad like the Amazons where they
- 52:30actually control in a lot of cases the point or Walmart's the
- 52:33point of sale. So outcomes are easier to prove
- 52:36for that type of advertising. But keep going.
- 52:38Exactly so. So the reality is, is publishers
- 52:42on as they go direct the big change of publishers really
- 52:46trying to make with their outcome stories become more
- 52:48strategic. So for a publisher, they'll have
- 52:51a series of endemic clients who they already have a very good
- 52:54relationship with them. The first port of call is, hey,
- 52:58actually let's start talking about the sales outcomes.
- 53:00Let's start talking about kind of the overall strategy you're
- 53:02trying to execute. And then you plug our conversion
- 53:05data, your conversion data in and we'll start to optimize.
- 53:09And that's what we're seeing with kind of the outcomes the
- 53:11the optimization agent, which primitive has, it's like you can
- 53:15feed that data in and now you can optimize towards an outcome
- 53:18that requires a change in like the sales team and the way you
- 53:21go to market and and all those pieces.
- 53:23Yeah, maybe, as long as you don't get tech.
- 53:24Team in a sense, and you're and you're sort of saying it's
- 53:26almost a platformization, so to speak, for lack of a better
- 53:29word, of the of the open publisher space or the
- 53:32publishers that is like you've got to compete against Meta,
- 53:35they've got to compete against Google, right?
- 53:37And there's some people that argue that the open web is just
- 53:40doomed, that everything's going to be walled garden, you know,
- 53:45publishers or, or platforms. But you're saying?
- 53:47Or gardens or hedge gardens. Yeah.
- 53:49If they start to re platform, which goes back to our very
- 53:51first podcast with Stephanie Laser, it was called the great
- 53:55re platforming and this is kind of leaning down that.
- 53:58Path yeah, I, I had AI was on with one of our CR OS last week
- 54:02who used exactly that language is like, hey, I we're building a
- 54:05platform here and it's a platform we need to deliver on
- 54:08outcomes. So I think that is totally right
- 54:11now. Five years ago we were saying,
- 54:14hey, publishers, you should execute wall garden strategy and
- 54:16publishers saying to us, hey, like this is good, we're selling
- 54:19more directly. But these agencies don't want to
- 54:21work with 50 walled gardens. They want to work with one AI
- 54:25anagentic. Buying breed changes that
- 54:28because like you don't want to work with 50 because that's
- 54:30fifty different walled gardens you have to manage.
- 54:34But now your agents can. You don't have to.
- 54:36They can do it at scale. Exactly.
- 54:38And even better now also if I'm the agency, if I can negotiate
- 54:41the right kind of training agreement with those publishers,
- 54:44actually those relationships can start making me money and
- 54:48they're much more efficient and effective to run.
- 54:50So it's kind of that business model change for us means that
- 54:54we are really invested in this agentic future.
- 54:58So I guess you know, that said basically answer the question
- 55:00from before, right? If we go to agentic trading, it
- 55:02could be, it could be very good for publishers, right?
- 55:04Because it enables them to have more direct so deals and allows
- 55:08them to be able to counter that argument of like of like, OK,
- 55:13you don't need to be, you don't need centralization anymore
- 55:15because because AI can automate this and do it at such a scale
- 55:18and such a pace that humans could never do it.
- 55:20But I mean, you can never have enough people to do it.
- 55:22You couldn't react fast enough. So so AI could do this?
- 55:25Yeah. It's going to go to where the
- 55:26signal is, right? It's going to go to where the
- 55:28rich signal is and gather as much Intel that that it can
- 55:32gather, right. Yeah.
- 55:33And you guys are sort of how do you, how do you make it visible?
- 55:36I mean, how do you, how do you, I mean, because it's all within
- 55:38your system, right? So this, yeah.
- 55:41So the the signal to your point, early on clean rooms, we surface
- 55:45the signal in two places. We surface it today inside the
- 55:49clean rooms for them to go and identify what signal they want
- 55:53and where. And then today we make that
- 55:55signal available in two places. We make it available in the
- 55:58programmatic pipes and we make it available in the AD server.
- 56:01And the question is, is, are the agencies going to continue to
- 56:05transact by those programmatic pipes or are they going to start
- 56:09to build agents which allow them to transact via those direct
- 56:12sold pipes? And time will tell us which path
- 56:17we go down. But I think there is a lot of
- 56:19financial incentive for both the publisher and for the agency for
- 56:24that to being a more direct relationship.
- 56:26And I think those financial incentives can drive a lot of
- 56:29behavior. Show me the incentives and I'll
- 56:32show you the outcomes. Of that quote, yeah.
- 56:36Shows Monger, yeah. Yeah, yeah.
- 56:38Why do we rob banks? That's where the money is.
- 56:42Sorry, but bad jokes. I won't use that one.
- 56:44But so should we go to Quick hits?
- 56:49Because I know, I know, Joe, you've got a meeting coming up
- 56:52and right before possible, so I'll start.
- 56:55Who actually controls the AI ad stack today?
- 56:58And we kind of talked about this, you have your vision buyer
- 57:01sell side today and where do you think that's going?
- 57:04I think we bifurcate agencies on one side, publishers on the
- 57:08other, AD set not really controlling that.
- 57:11Joe, what's the most overhyped and conversely the most under
- 57:14hyped use of AI in advertising right now?
- 57:17Question most overhyped is probably the use of cord in
- 57:23these LMS over hyped because no company we work with has that
- 57:29cord set up in a way in which they can actually leverage it
- 57:32properly Under hyped, like they don't have a core strategy under
- 57:35hyped in the sense that this is transformational to business
- 57:39workflows. And I really do believe like
- 57:44next is the capability of what these organizations can do.
- 57:47Yeah, 10X that that that might be underestimating that I.
- 57:50Think it's Yeah. It's yeah, like I think as you
- 57:52get more sophisticated with these things, we've had a bunch
- 57:54of these conversations, you start to get to like hard to
- 57:56quantify exactly, but anecdotally you can be like, no,
- 57:58it's not ten X anymore, It's more like 30X or 40X, right?
- 58:02It's incredible the when you set up the systems because it, it
- 58:04can be repeatable as long as it's governed properly, right?
- 58:09Which I'm kind of learning the hard way.
- 58:10I'm trying to get as technical as you were back in your
- 58:12computer science days. It's hard though, man.
- 58:14I was an English major. I mean, you know, you gotta
- 58:16change the way I talk about things.
- 58:18Full source. Degree has no benefit with this
- 58:22either. No, you're, you're, you're just
- 58:25as like, Yeah. Well, a lot of code now is just
- 58:28English, English I mean just your codes total at the concept.
- 58:31What is code? I mean, I, I'm glad I studied
- 58:34computer science, like up until I actually went through a couple
- 58:37of years in college, right? And like, I'm, I'm glad I didn't
- 58:39finish the degree. I regretted it over the years.
- 58:41But now I'm actually kind of glad.
- 58:42And I'm glad I I think being a journalist and learning how to
- 58:46write well and think well and reason and argue is probably as
- 58:49useful as anything these days. Yeah, I tell you, and I think,
- 58:52and I always talk to like product leaders and technical
- 58:53people and I'm like, you just learned that three months ago,
- 58:57like no time of my life until now.
- 58:59If I had my terminal open, right?
- 59:02GitHub, you know, codecs, Claude, right.
- 59:07Maybe like a Hermes or open call agent.
- 59:09Like it's just changed that. It's just a completely different
- 59:12world that we're kind of working through.
- 59:14And it just gives you all this ability and control that you and
- 59:18build the ability. You're not.
- 59:19You're less relying on other people to do some of this stuff
- 59:22for you, right? Yeah, I, I think we see the role
- 59:25of engineers is just changing so radically.
- 59:28But actually, once you can think like an architect, like 10X more
- 59:32effective, impactful. Yeah.
- 59:34So next quick hit, is curation still relevant in an AI driven
- 59:38world or is it going to be abstracted away so to speak?
- 59:42I think curation is a as a technological pipe, hugely
- 59:46valuable if if programmatic continues to be a thing,
- 59:51curation in its first generation of hey, I'm going to package up
- 59:54inventory and and and resell it. I I don't see that model as a
- 1:00:00long term model. Yeah.
- 1:00:03So if you like were to bet like would you say open web gets
- 1:00:07stronger or weaker because of these trends that we've been
- 1:00:09talking about and what's happening with AII?
- 1:00:12Think premium and that the market becomes stronger if they
- 1:00:16can just double the amount they direct sell they they grow
- 1:00:20revenue enormously through this period, let alone if they can
- 1:00:23turn that 20% into 60 or 70%, that is huge, huge growth for
- 1:00:29these businesses. Given that it's replacing
- 1:00:32primary $1.00 programmatic with $10 direct, I think long tail
- 1:00:37open Internet, I just don't see how it survives this era.
- 1:00:40So move towards subscriber based and then all all.
- 1:00:43If they want to survive, they've got to authenticate and have
- 1:00:46subscribers, whether it's. Authentication, subscribers,
- 1:00:50ultimately if you've got a depth of relationship with the
- 1:00:53consumer where they trust you and you are part of that
- 1:00:57consumers habit, you're in such a strong position.
- 1:01:00And I think so many media companies are part of the habit
- 1:01:03of the consumer. Yeah.
- 1:01:05And back to what we talked about, I think this concluding
- 1:01:07remark is that our our media consumption strategy or
- 1:01:10approaches have changed, right. And we tend to that.
- 1:01:13All that long tail stuff is now being siphoned off by the LLMS
- 1:01:17and you're going direct to a handful.
- 1:01:19Of the options. A handful of of CTV providers
- 1:01:22for basically all of your content and also.
- 1:01:25Like for a lot of our media companies, you may spend 10
- 1:01:29minutes with them each day getting caught up on the news,
- 1:01:33but you're spending three hours with them on podcast.
- 1:01:36So our media companies are just diversified so heavily into
- 1:01:40video, into audio. The large players everywhere,
- 1:01:44they're not just kind of web. Yeah, the old editorial model is
- 1:01:50is can't stand up on its own. Well, this has been phenomenal.
- 1:01:52I'm in any. Conversation.
- 1:01:54Yeah, that was great. Joe, you are a blast.
- 1:01:57The real super happy to meet you.
- 1:01:58It was just just a ton of fun. We should definitely meet up in
- 1:02:01the city sometime and we're going to get Rio to move back to
- 1:02:04New York City out of Denver. My wife wants to it's.
- 1:02:06Funny, she keeps I tell you, it's inevitable.
- 1:02:10I've been here for 25 years and I may never leave.
- 1:02:12And like I, I take the old Lou Reed quote.
- 1:02:15He's like, he's like, why would I ever go anywhere else?
- 1:02:17And I was like, yeah, that's kind of why I moved here.
- 1:02:20It was that new that Lou Reed out of New York, right?
- 1:02:23I was like that guy then. It's a great city.
- 1:02:26It's. A great city.
- 1:02:28I haven't seen you every. Yeah.
- 1:02:30Yeah. Well, hey, thanks for having you
- 1:02:31on. And thanks to the audience for
- 1:02:34joining us today and making it through the end.
- 1:02:36If you made it this far, join us at Deb Deb, Deb dot signal and
- 1:02:40Noise dot AI. That's where we publish all of
- 1:02:42our editorial video podcast content.
- 1:02:45We've got a bunch of executive contributors that contribute
- 1:02:48content as well. And we are on Yahoo.
- 1:02:52We're not on Yahoo. We're on YouTube.
- 1:02:54We're on YouTube, Spotify and Apple Podcast and wherever you
- 1:02:59listen to your podcasts or watch your videos.
- 1:03:01So thanks everybody. Thank you.
- 1:03:05So long.