Latest / Office Hours with Fexingo: Daily Career Q&A, Workplace Questions, and Professional Advice / How to Ask for a Title Change When Your Responsibilities Have Grown
Transcript
- Lucas: So we got a question this week from a listener named Priya, and I think her situation is going to sound familiar to a lot of you. She's a marketing manager at a mid-sized SaaS company, been there about two and a half years. Her boss left nine months ago, and she's been effectively running the marketing team — managing a budget, overseeing two junior hires, reporting directly to the VP. Her official title is still 'Marketing Manager.' She wants to ask for 'Director of Marketing,' but she's worried it sounds like a stretch. Luna: Yeah, that's a really common spot. You're doing the job, but the org chart hasn't caught up. And the title matters — not just for ego, but for your next move. Lucas: Exactly. So let's talk about how you actually have that conversation. First thing I'd say to Priya: don't lead with the title. Lead with the scope change. Luna: Meaning you show the work first, then ask for the label? Lucas: Right. You want your manager to arrive at the conclusion themselves that the title is outdated. So you prepare a one-pager — nothing fancy — that lists your current responsibilities versus what your job description said when you were hired. In Priya's case, she's now managing a budget, hiring and firing, setting strategy. None of that was in the original Marketing Manager JD. Luna: And she should bring that to a one-on-one, not a separate meeting. Lucas: Exactly. Use the existing cadence. The framing is: 'I want to make sure my title accurately reflects the work I'm doing, so that I can be most effective externally and internally.' That's a reasonable, non-threatening ask. Luna: What about the pushback where they say, 'We don't have a budget for a title change' or 'Titles are tied to salary bands'? Lucas: Great question. First, title changes can happen without a salary change. You can separate the two conversations if you want. But if they say it's tied to bands, you ask: 'What would it take for me to qualify for that band? What milestones or outcomes would make that possible?' Then you've got a roadmap. Luna: So you're not demanding. You're asking for the criteria. Lucas: Right. And if they say, 'We just don't have director-level roles in this department,' then you have a different conversation — about whether there's a path to that title or if you've outgrown the company. But start with data. Luna: I like that you mentioned the external credibility piece. Because when you go to conferences or update LinkedIn, a 'Marketing Manager' applying for director roles elsewhere might not get past the screening algorithm. Lucas: That's a huge point. A title mismatch can cost you opportunities. So frame it as a business issue: 'I want to represent the company accurately when I speak at events or meet with partners.' That's hard for a manager to argue with. Luna: Let's talk about timing. When is the best moment to bring this up? Lucas: After a win. After you've delivered something concrete — a campaign that hit its numbers, a team that got recognized, a process improvement that saved money. You want to ask from a position of strength, not need. Luna: So Priya should maybe wait until after the next quarterly review or product launch. Lucas: If she can. But if she's been waiting nine months, I'd say don't wait much longer. Schedule a dedicated career check-in — not a performance review — and say, 'I'd like to discuss my role and how it's evolved.' Luna: And what about the actual language? What does she say in the meeting? Lucas: Here's a script I like: 'Over the past nine months, my responsibilities have expanded significantly. I'm now managing the full marketing budget, leading a team of two, and reporting to the VP directly. I want to make sure my title reflects that scope — for my own career development and so that I can represent the department effectively. I'd like to discuss updating my title to Director of Marketing.' Luna: That's clean. No waffling, no apology. Lucas: Exactly. And then stop. Let them respond. Don't fill the silence. Luna: One thing I'd add: if they agree in principle but say it has to go through HR, ask for a timeline and a follow-up meeting. Don't let it drift. Lucas: Great point. And if they say no, you ask for a development plan — 'What would I need to achieve in the next six months to earn that title?' Then you've got a clear target. Luna: What if they offer a different title, like 'Senior Marketing Manager' instead of Director? Lucas: That's a negotiation. You can say, 'I appreciate that. Can we talk about what the Director title would require? Because I want to understand the gap.' But honestly, Senior Manager might be a reasonable step if the company doesn't have director headcount. The key is to get a title that's a clear step up from where you were. Luna: And if they say no to any change at all? Lucas: Then you have a signal. It means the company either doesn't value your growth or doesn't see you as a long-term fit. At that point, you update your resume and start looking externally. But you do it professionally, without burning the bridge. Luna: Speaking of professional growth — you know, a lot of the listeners who write in tell us these episodes help them prepare for exactly these conversations. And honestly, that's why we keep doing them. Lucas: Yeah, and if you've found this episode useful, or any of the past ones, a small gesture goes a long way. A couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these shows ad-free and independent. You can head to buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo to help out. Luna: It really does make a difference. And we appreciate it. Lucas: Okay, back to Priya. One more thing I want to emphasize: don't underestimate the power of allies. If you have a peer who's a director elsewhere in the company, ask them how they got the title. That intel can help you build your case. Luna: And if your manager says, 'I'll look into it,' follow up in writing within 24 hours. A simple email: 'Thanks for the conversation today. As we discussed, I'm looking to update my title to reflect my current scope. I'll plan to check back in two weeks. Appreciate your support.' Lucas: That creates accountability without being pushy. Priya, if you're listening, you've got this. Just prepare the data, pick the right moment, and be ready for any answer. Luna: And remember, a title is a tool — it should serve your career, not define it. But getting it right opens doors. Lucas: Exactly. Alright, that's our time. Good luck out there.