Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / To Be, or Not to Be: A Certified Mediator with the California State Bar
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to the Beverly Hills Bar Association
- 0:07ADR section meeting. We're very excited to have
- 0:10this meeting today. It's entitled to be or not
- 0:14to be a certified mediator with the California
- 0:16State Bar. I'm Robert Cohen and together with
- 0:20Jeffrey Kravitz we are co -chairs of this section.
- 0:24Today we seem to live in a world of existential
- 0:28questions and now there's a new one. Now mediators
- 0:32will be asked to decide whether or not they wish
- 0:36to be certified by the California State Bar.
- 0:39To address this question, we are honored to have
- 0:42two esteemed mediators here today. Meyer Sankary,
- 0:48a 60 -year member of the State Bar, a graduate
- 0:51of Harvard Law School, founder and president
- 0:55of the Mediation Center of Los Angeles. and still
- 0:59actively mediating litigated matters with more
- 1:02than 30 years of mediator experience. We also
- 1:06welcome John Derrick, a graduate of Oxford University
- 1:09and Berkeley Law, aka BOLT, a certified appellate
- 1:13specialist prior to becoming a full -time neutral.
- 1:18John is presently chair of the ADR committee
- 1:21section of the California Lawyers Association.
- 1:24Both gentlemen bring deep knowledge. and analysis
- 1:32to what presents us today with Senate Bills 940
- 1:39and 574. The views that they express are their
- 1:43own. The two speakers will discuss the current
- 1:50status of the legislation, its likely implementation,
- 1:55why mediators may wish to consider certification,
- 1:58and finally how impactful This certification
- 2:02program may be on all ADR professionals in California.
- 2:06So then, leading off our program with sympathy
- 2:09to the LA Dodgers is Meyer Sankary. And on deck
- 2:14is John Derrick. Gentlemen, please start to play
- 2:18baseball. Thank you. All right. Unfortunately,
- 2:21it doesn't look like the Dodgers are going to
- 2:23three -peat, but they had a great season, great
- 2:26players, really professional. It was sad to see
- 2:30them. sink into the West. Anyway, thank you for
- 2:34inviting us. This is a topic dear to my heart
- 2:38because of my long involvement with the State
- 2:41Bar. I've been on many committees with the State
- 2:44Bar. I helped, worked on the mandatory fee arbitration.
- 2:48I got to see firsthand how clients and lawyers
- 2:53dispute their fees, which brings up a whole host
- 2:56of issues relating to the conduct of lawyers.
- 3:00I've also been involved in the mediation community,
- 3:03as you said, for 30 years, past president of
- 3:08what was then the Southern California Mediation
- 3:11Association. And I started the Mediation Center,
- 3:15a nonprofit, back in 2013 after I served for
- 3:2010 years on the court's executive committee for
- 3:25the ADR program. which had over 10 ,000 mediations
- 3:29and 1 ,000 mediators. And my job was to review
- 3:34competency and maintain quality assurance for
- 3:38the court's ADR program. And as you know, there
- 3:43are an abundance of rules governing the ethics
- 3:47and competency of mediators, specifically if
- 3:52you are... working on any cases referred by the
- 3:57superior court of Los Angeles, as they now call
- 4:00them. We used to call it LASC. It's now Superior
- 4:04Court of Los Angeles. With that, I wanted to
- 4:12also point out that in my role as president and
- 4:16founder of the Mediation Center, for whom I am
- 4:19not giving any opinion. I do not represent their
- 4:22point of view. We haven't made any decision yet
- 4:24or recommendations. I can only tell you my experience.
- 4:32I'm kind of like the chief compliance officer.
- 4:34We don't have, quote, a complaint system. We
- 4:38have what's called a client satisfaction survey.
- 4:41After every mediation, we send out an email to
- 4:46the parties, the attorneys and the clients and
- 4:49say, here's the checklist of client satisfaction
- 4:53on a five star basis. Well, what that does, it
- 4:57gives the opportunity for people to compliment
- 5:00the service presented and also to write opinions
- 5:05that may not be a five star. And so it is my
- 5:10job to review all of that. And I get to see firsthand.
- 5:14the response of people who are either very satisfied
- 5:17or who are less than satisfied. I start with
- 5:22this because I think the word complaint system,
- 5:25which is embedded in SB 940 and 574, distorts
- 5:31the responses and biases the response. I start
- 5:37with this because when you give somebody a hammer,
- 5:40they do look for a nail that they will hammer.
- 5:43And unfortunately, when you tell people the state
- 5:47bar has a complaint system and in order to be
- 5:50certified, you have to have a complaint system.
- 5:53You're handing someone a hammer. There are a
- 5:56lot of people who are unhappy in mediations because
- 6:00of the conditions they found themselves. They
- 6:02don't like to be there. They may be very dissatisfied
- 6:05with the outcome of the mediation. Consequently,
- 6:10they are going to have some complaints. And if
- 6:13they go to the state bar who's going to listen
- 6:15to all these complaints, you will have things
- 6:17like, well, the mediator didn't do enough to
- 6:21coerce the other side to accept my point of view.
- 6:24The mediator was biased. The mediator did X,
- 6:28Y, and Z. The mediator did A, B, C. And we see
- 6:32these complaints. And they are complaints. But
- 6:35they're not legitimate in terms of when you balance
- 6:38it against the other side's point of view, which
- 6:41said, the mediator did a great job. I thought
- 6:44the mediator was professional. I thought the
- 6:46mediator reviewed all the documents. I thought
- 6:49the mediator understood the issues and was competent.
- 6:54Whereas the other side is complaining, oh, the
- 6:56mediator didn't review anything. They didn't
- 6:59understand the law, et cetera, et cetera. Well,
- 7:02you have two different points of view when you
- 7:05have a client satisfaction survey. But guess
- 7:08what? When you say you have a complaint system,
- 7:11now you've skewed the discussion to one side
- 7:15only and you don't hear the other side that balances
- 7:18it off. So that's kind of my introduction and
- 7:21my first stage of concern about the whole system.
- 7:25Now I'd like to tell you that I've spent weeks
- 7:28and weeks about doing some background research
- 7:30and how did this all come about? And it was a
- 7:34result of an unfortunate situation where the
- 7:37state bar failed to do its job with regard to
- 7:42a very famous and well -known attorney by the
- 7:44name of Thomas Gerardi. Thomas Gerardi was well
- 7:50-known in the illegal profession. He was an outstanding
- 7:55trial lawyer. He got results for victims of plane
- 7:59crashes. tort conditions and so forth. And he
- 8:05got millions and millions and millions of dollars
- 8:08that came into his trust account. And what did
- 8:11Mr. Girardi start doing? He decided, well, this
- 8:14is a piggy bank I could use to spend on myself
- 8:18rather than give the money to the victims. And
- 8:22so over a period of time, there were many, many
- 8:25complaints that were filed with the state bar.
- 8:28And unfortunately, Tom Girardi had a wonderful
- 8:32method of engaging the State Bar investigators.
- 8:39He would take them on trips. He would give them
- 8:41gifts. Up and down the line, he was very, very
- 8:46nice to these State Bar investigators. And guess
- 8:49what? In return, they turned a blind eye to these
- 8:54complaints. And I can cite to use a lot of articles
- 8:59and reports by the State Bar that actually said
- 9:04that the State Bar investigators dropped them
- 9:10off. They did not investigate these complaints.
- 9:14And then there were independent reports that
- 9:17the State Bar commissioned that resulted in a
- 9:23disclosure that there were many hundreds of complaints
- 9:27about Tom Girardi. And the State Bar investigators
- 9:31either were incomplete, they shut it down, they
- 9:35did not do their job. So the State Bar has a
- 9:40lot to answer for. I'm a very big fan of the
- 9:43State Bar. I've been a member 60 years, but it
- 9:46did cause a lot of disruption in the community
- 9:50when everybody found out that this very famous
- 9:53lawyer, who has done such a great job for his
- 9:58clients, was actually stealing and embezzling
- 10:01millions of dollars of their funds. So these
- 10:04victims never got the money that they wanted.
- 10:08And frankly, it was the State Bar who failed
- 10:11to investigate. And what happened was, along
- 10:17comes Senator Umberg. And there was a program
- 10:24on Monday night where Senator Umberg came and
- 10:27spoke for about 20, 30 minutes. And I was one
- 10:30of the questioners and I tried to get in a question.
- 10:33They gave me two minutes to ask Senator Umberg
- 10:38some questions. And so I pointed out to Senator
- 10:42Umberg that he was quoted in the Daily Journal
- 10:47as saying that his SB 940 and 574 was inspired
- 10:53by the failure of the state bar to protect the
- 10:56public from Tom Girardi's theft of client settlement
- 10:59funds. This is a quote from the Daily Journal.
- 11:02It went on to say, he said, the bill was inspired
- 11:06by revelations that now disbarred Los Angeles
- 11:09attorney Tom Girardi embezzled millions of dollars
- 11:12from clients, despite dozens of complaints to
- 11:16the bar over 40 years. Umberg said that one of
- 11:20the ways Girardi hid his thefts was by running
- 11:26the cases through arbitrators who did not track
- 11:30the plaintiff money very closely. Quote, Daily
- 11:34Journal, check it out, December 10th, 2024. That's
- 11:38what inspired this legislation. So we've got
- 11:42to understand the background to this legislation.
- 11:46And then we have to understand, why was it that
- 11:51all of a sudden mediators are conflated under
- 11:56the umbrella of arbitrators? I asked Senator
- 12:02Unberg, does he understand the difference? And
- 12:04he said, of course, I understand. I've been in
- 12:07many mediations. I've never been a mediator,
- 12:09but I've been in many mediations. And so I said,
- 12:13what complaints did you receive during the legislative
- 12:17hearings about mediators. Well, they're part
- 12:21of the ADR community. I don't know really what
- 12:25he said. It really didn't make sense because
- 12:27I don't think he really understood what mediation
- 12:30is about. But I think he felt a responsibility
- 12:34to his constituents that he had to do something
- 12:37And since the State Bar was the organization
- 12:41that was tainted by this wrongdoing, I think
- 12:43he needed to rehabilitate the State Bar where
- 12:46he has a lot of friends and relationships. So
- 12:48he went to the State Bar and said, hey, how about
- 12:51this legislation to certify and regulate ADR
- 12:55community, arbitrators and referees and mediators?
- 13:00They're all part of this scheme that, you know,
- 13:03Girardi foisted upon us and they're somehow responsible.
- 13:07He did not specify any complaints made about
- 13:11mediators. He did not distinguish mediation from
- 13:15arbitration or the legal community. What's interesting
- 13:19is if you go back, and this is what I try to
- 13:23do, is take a step back about 60 ,000 feet and
- 13:25say, what is the mission of the State Bar? Have
- 13:31we really thought about that? Do you know where
- 13:34the mission is stated? right on the front page
- 13:38of the State Farm website. And the mission is
- 13:43to regulate and license lawyers and to protect
- 13:47the public from any misbehavior of lawyers. You
- 13:52will not find anything that says that the mission
- 13:56is to regulate mediators. The definition of mediators,
- 14:01as we all know, in the law, defined by the courts,
- 14:05defined by the rules, Mediators are simply a
- 14:10neutral who is responsible for helping parties
- 14:15negotiate a settlement. The mediator must say
- 14:20that there are three things that the mediator
- 14:24must open with ethically. One, this is a voluntary
- 14:28program. You're not required to be here. And
- 14:31anything, any agreement that might be reached
- 14:35is entirely voluntary. You are not compelled
- 14:38or coerced to sign any agreement unless you understand
- 14:43it and agree to it. That's number one. Number
- 14:47two, and very importantly, the mediators responsible
- 14:52for saying that this mediation is entirely covered
- 14:55by the confidentiality laws, which are quite
- 14:59important. and that anything that you say or
- 15:03any information that's exchanged cannot be used
- 15:06in any further proceedings involving this lawsuit.
- 15:11Whether this is a settlement reached or not,
- 15:15nothing said in this proceeding can be used in
- 15:20any further proceedings. And this is important,
- 15:24particularly in the family law area. The LA County
- 15:28Bar head of the ADR section for family law wrote
- 15:34a very important letter to the legislators in
- 15:39pointing out that confidentiality for family
- 15:43law mediation is extremely important to protect
- 15:48the rights of children, of parents, and people
- 15:52involved in these types of mediations because
- 15:57Many of the family law mediations, as you know,
- 16:01are often unrepresented parties. And unfortunately,
- 16:06if a mediation and all the confidential information
- 16:11is shared with the state bar through a complaint
- 16:14system, then parties will not feel comfortable
- 16:18about disclosing information that they want to
- 16:22keep confidential. And the third thing is and
- 16:26this is really important. The mediator has to
- 16:29disclose that they are neutral, they are not
- 16:32biased, they don't represent either party, and
- 16:35particularly if you're an attorney, you are obligated
- 16:39to disclose that you are not representing either
- 16:43party and that your opinions are not legal advice.
- 16:49I think we all understand that. If you're a mediator,
- 16:52you take really of that statement is very important.
- 16:57We can share our views, we can share our opinions,
- 17:00but we do not give legal advice. Consequently,
- 17:06when we mediate, we are not acting as lawyers.
- 17:12I want that to sink in because what this legislation
- 17:17has done is basically given the impression that
- 17:24mediation and mediators are part of the legal
- 17:27profession and you will all be tainted or enhanced
- 17:33by that connection because the state bar does
- 17:39represent lawyers and Consequently, you will
- 17:44be part in the minds of the public. I'm afraid
- 17:48Part of the legal system you will even though
- 17:51you are not a lawyer You don't wish to be part
- 17:54of the legal system. You are a neutral mediator,
- 17:58but you will be forever connected to the legal
- 18:03system if you are a state bar certifier. Meyer,
- 18:07let me interrupt just for a minute. Okay. I think
- 18:10you've made some very excellent comments and
- 18:13I think you've given the backstory and the history
- 18:16so that I think our audience and attendees understand
- 18:20better how this came about. And I think it's
- 18:23time to move on now to John Derrick, who will
- 18:27talk about the implementation and current status
- 18:30of the legislation, because as is always the
- 18:35case, the devil is in the details. And I think
- 18:38that will really explain to our audience what
- 18:44is going on now, right now, and whether or not
- 18:48they should. give serious thought to be certified
- 18:52or to skip it. John, why don't you take it from
- 18:55here? Sure. The devil is indeed in the detail.
- 19:00Right now, however, we don't yet know what much
- 19:04of the detail involves, but at least we don't
- 19:06know for certain. The way in which SB 940 was
- 19:11set up was that the legislature passed the bill
- 19:17which kind of described in fairly broad brush
- 19:20terms that there was going to be this certification
- 19:23program, which covers, by the way, not only mediators,
- 19:27but also arbitrators. But today, our focus is
- 19:30on mediators. And it covers not only attorney
- 19:33mediators, in other words, mediators who are
- 19:35licensed attorneys, but also non -attorney mediators.
- 19:41You don't have to be a licensee of the California
- 19:45State Bar. in order to become certified as a
- 19:49mediator. So what the bill did was to, without
- 19:53really resolving a myriad of details of what
- 19:57certification would involve, it provided that
- 20:01there will be this program administered by the
- 20:03state bar, and it delegated to the state bar
- 20:06the task of working out all the detail. The State
- 20:11Bar in turn, I guess early 2025 this would have
- 20:16been, 18 months a bit more ago, set up a working
- 20:21group of about 20 people who were picked to deliberate
- 20:28on recommendations to the Board of Trustees of
- 20:33the State Bar about all of the details of what
- 20:37will be involved. Now this working group was
- 20:39made up of mediators, of arbitrators, people
- 20:44who are independents, people on the big panels,
- 20:47people from the courts, people from academia.
- 20:51They weren't all by any means avid supporters
- 20:56of SB 940. In fact, the working group contains
- 21:01some strong and vocal critics of SB 940. So the
- 21:06working group is a good group of people who've
- 21:10actually, they're called the working group. And
- 21:13from what I've seen following them, they have
- 21:16put in the work, you know, endless hours, reams
- 21:20of paper. I mean, it's an unbelievable effort
- 21:23to go through all the details, because it's one
- 21:24of these things where the more you get into the
- 21:26weeds, the harder it is to... the more problems
- 21:30occur. Now, right now, we don't know what their
- 21:33final recommendations are going to be. The most
- 21:36recent set of recommendations that was kind of
- 21:39made public in a kind of digestible form was
- 21:43an interim set in last spring, which was about
- 21:48100 pages long or something. And that gave rise
- 21:52to a period of public comment. Since last spring,
- 21:56they've been working on fine tuning their recommendations,
- 22:00but they haven't yet put out an integrated set
- 22:02of revised recommendations that I think will
- 22:05be coming out fairly soon. Then, however, it
- 22:10goes once the working group have done their stuff,
- 22:13it goes to the board of trustees of the state
- 22:16bar. They may just, you know, I hesitate to use
- 22:19the word rubber stamp, but they may just rubber
- 22:21stamp the working group's recommendations. or
- 22:24they may tinker with them a bit or conceivably
- 22:27they may make major changes to them because I'm
- 22:31sure that a lot of people including critics of
- 22:33SB 940 will be lobbying them. So I guess when
- 22:39people say well should I be certified or not
- 22:42you know my answer in part is a resounding don't
- 22:46know because you can't in a way make a decision
- 22:51before you know what is involved unless of course
- 22:54you take the view that the whole thing is so
- 22:57misguided from the inception that you simply
- 23:00don't want to be part of it whatever the detail
- 23:02is and there are certainly people who who take
- 23:05that view who take the view we shouldn't be having
- 23:08this and even if we are having a certification
- 23:10system the state bar isn't the right agency to
- 23:15regulate it. But like it or not, in a way that
- 23:18ship has sailed. The bill has been passed. At
- 23:22that event last Monday, which Maya referred to,
- 23:26I noticed that Senat Umberg sort of started talking
- 23:29about the possibility of corrective legislation
- 23:33to fix any problems. There's always a little
- 23:37worrying when the sponsor of a bill starts acknowledging
- 23:41that it may have to be fixed even before it's
- 23:43gone into effect. But either way, right now the
- 23:46ship has sailed. But as Maya pointed out, it's
- 23:50a voluntary process. So if you fundamentally
- 23:53are opposed to it, no one has to take part. You
- 23:56can carry on mediating and totally ignore SB
- 23:59940. Some people wonder, well, might there be
- 24:03future legislation making it mandatory? You know,
- 24:07everything is possible, but there's no sign of
- 24:09that. on the horizon. Although the devil is in
- 24:15the details and we don't know all the details,
- 24:16we do know a fair amount of stuff, though, about
- 24:19what it is likely to entail. And one thing I
- 24:22think we can say with some degree of confidence
- 24:25is that the threshold requirements to become
- 24:28certified are going to be pretty low. They kind
- 24:33of want to make this a big tent and to get in
- 24:36pretty well as many people as you know want to
- 24:40come in. The threshold requirements you know
- 24:44in terms of how many mediations you've done you
- 24:46only will have had to have done about I think
- 24:49six mediations in order to meet the experience
- 24:53required and even those I believe you could do
- 24:57co -mediating where you're kind of just helping
- 25:00another mediator to mediate a case in order to
- 25:02get to get experience and then there's some educational
- 25:06requirements in terms of training courses and
- 25:09whatever and it looks as though the rules are
- 25:12going to have kind of slightly different requirements
- 25:17depending on how long you've been mediating and
- 25:20how recently you've been trained. So there may
- 25:23be about three or four different sort of portals
- 25:28to get in but none of them are going to require
- 25:30a lot of experience. For people who do have a
- 25:33lot of experience they will have lower entry
- 25:40requirements in terms of the recency of training
- 25:42and those who have less experience will have
- 25:45to have more recent training. But either way,
- 25:49nobody is gonna have to be highly experienced
- 25:51to become a mediator. And this actually raises
- 25:54some interesting things because the term is certified.
- 25:59Now, when you buy a pre -owned car and it's certified
- 26:03pre -owned, or when you do all sorts of things
- 26:06that involve certification, there is an implication
- 26:09that there is a seal of approval. And I think
- 26:13this is one of the fundamental problems with
- 26:17the program as it is being enacted, which goes
- 26:21right back to the statute. Because SB 940, it
- 26:25actually says in the legislation that words to
- 26:29the effect that certification and the different
- 26:32tiers of certification, we can get onto that
- 26:34in a moment, do not reflect quality. But the
- 26:40question is, will the public, who are supposedly
- 26:44meant to be being protected by this new law,
- 26:47but who haven't spent hours of their leisure
- 26:50times tuning into seminars such as this, will
- 26:54they be aware of that? Will they understand that
- 26:57it doesn't reflect quality? and I'm not sure
- 27:00they will. So there is this fundamental problem
- 27:04that the state bar is setting up this scheme
- 27:09where people are going to have some sort of bling
- 27:11to hang on their wall in terms of certificates
- 27:13or the digital equivalent or whatever, which
- 27:16will be perceived by many as being an endorsement
- 27:21of competence, but which actually isn't because
- 27:25you just have to have minimal experience a little
- 27:29bit of training, and a commitment to ethical
- 27:32standards, and you have to pay some money, which
- 27:35we don't know how much by the way, and then you're
- 27:37in. So the confusion, and this goes to Maya's
- 27:45point about the state ball kind of regulating
- 27:49mediation, the confusion could also be how the
- 27:53public will perceive non -attorney mediators
- 27:56who are certified. Because Meier is right, mediators
- 28:00are not practicing as lawyers when they're in
- 28:03a mediation. But in some mediations, some knowledge
- 28:07of legal concepts can be quite helpful because
- 28:09you are trying to help the parties resolve legal
- 28:13disputes that are often actually in the courts.
- 28:19So there are excellent non -attorney mediators
- 28:24out there, but there is a possibility, and so
- 28:32what I'm about to say isn't a reflection on non
- 28:35-attorney mediators in general, but there is
- 28:37a possibility that the public will assume that
- 28:41any mediator who is certified by the state bar
- 28:46will have some type of legal training because
- 28:50it's not as though the state bar goes around
- 28:52certifying accountants or certifying plumbers.
- 28:56But yet you won't have to have any legal training
- 29:01whatsoever to become a state bar certified mediator.
- 29:06So that is an area that I just generally have
- 29:09a concern about. The confusion that it might
- 29:14cause among the public who supposedly this programme
- 29:18is meant to protect. John, if I may interrupt.
- 29:26So the way I interpret what you're saying is
- 29:29there may be several unintended consequences
- 29:33of this legislation. And I would just point out
- 29:37to you that I know of, I've heard of a mediator
- 29:40who is active, who is a disbarred attorney. And
- 29:44also, I believe he has a criminal record of significance.
- 29:49And I would assume, and I'd like your answer
- 29:53on this, that at least as far as you know, could
- 29:56he qualify for certification if he met the basic
- 29:59requirements despite his history? Well, we haven't
- 30:03seen, again, we haven't seen the final rules,
- 30:05but the earlier kind of draft rules did have
- 30:08some type of... some type of requirement for
- 30:14applicants to disclose kind of prior discipline
- 30:21in various professions or whatever. So I kind
- 30:24of suspect, although we don't know for certain,
- 30:27that a disbarred attorney wouldn't be able to
- 30:33become mediator. But it's a good question because
- 30:35we don't know for certain, and certainly the
- 30:38way the statute was written, there's nothing
- 30:41in the statute that would prevent that. So it's
- 30:44really just going to be up to the implementation
- 30:46and whether the state bar would allow that. I,
- 30:49by the way, have also encountered a disbarred
- 30:53attorney who set up shop as a mediator with a
- 30:56website saying something like, after many years
- 30:58of litigating in the trenches, I now realize
- 31:02how futile litigation is a way of resolving legal
- 31:07disputes. Therefore, I have seen the light to
- 31:08become a mediator, leaving out the bit that actually
- 31:11he had been disbarred, which is why he was no
- 31:14longer able to practice law. So there are areas
- 31:20where the public may be confused by this, but
- 31:24the focus of today's presentation is also to
- 31:26be or not to be. That was the title thought up
- 31:30by Bob, I believe. And so the question is, putting
- 31:34aside the public, what about us as mediators?
- 31:38And I think I can think of three categories of
- 31:42people who might be potential adopters. of certification
- 31:47among the ADR community. The first category I
- 31:53would say would be new and aspiring mediators,
- 31:56and also maybe non -attorney mediators who see
- 32:00this as providing some type of validation, at
- 32:03least some non -attorney mediators. I mean, I
- 32:06can think of some non -attorney mediators who
- 32:08have... very prominent and very vocal critics
- 32:12of SB 940, but I think some non -attorney mediators
- 32:15and some new or aspiring attorney mediators who
- 32:20are trying to break into this type of work will
- 32:23see this as a useful thing because they could
- 32:28put on their website, you know, I am certified
- 32:31by the state bar and this creates an aura of
- 32:35experience which might otherwise be absent. And
- 32:39so I can see why they rationally might say, yes,
- 32:43I'm going to be, you know, applying for certification
- 32:46on the morning when it opens. And by the way,
- 32:48as to when it will open, you know, when will
- 32:50this all go live? We don't know, but I suspect
- 32:53around about a year from now, I suspect is give
- 32:56or take is when it may all go live. You make
- 33:01a good point. And I'd like to read a specific
- 33:04piece of the legislation. Section 6173 states
- 33:10as follows, the levels or tiers do not reflect
- 33:14an assessment of the quality of a firm, provider,
- 33:18or practitioner. That's in the law. And so the
- 33:23question is, when they put up their certificate
- 33:26that I'm state bar certified, will they have
- 33:29a disclaimer that says this does not indicate
- 33:34any reflect assessment of quality of who I am
- 33:39or my competency, because that is not part of
- 33:43the state bar certification. Right. And I 100
- 33:46% agree with that. And I've actually have written
- 33:51before about what the bling should consist of,
- 33:55making precisely that point. It shouldn't be
- 33:57something with a golden seal or whatever, but
- 34:00it should have a lot of small print, but legible
- 34:02small print, explaining what this is all about.
- 34:06But let me go on. What this does, by the way,
- 34:08is I think it's misleading the public about what
- 34:13the meaning of certification is about. And that
- 34:16is one of the ethical rules. in the code of rules
- 34:20of court that you can't have misleading advertising.
- 34:25And I believe that this certification program
- 34:28violates those rules when you put up that I'm
- 34:32a state bar certified mediator that is going
- 34:35to run face to face with the rules of court that
- 34:40said you should not use misleading advertising
- 34:43because it does not certify anything other than
- 34:47I was willing to pay the fee and I told them
- 34:51I would abide by the ethical standards. And number
- 34:54three, I'm a mediator. And that I have a complaint
- 35:01system. I think those are the major things. One,
- 35:04that I have a complaint system. Number two, I'll
- 35:08abide by the ethical rules. And number three,
- 35:12I will pay the fee. Well, the complaint system,
- 35:15and maybe I'll come to that in a bit, is going
- 35:17to be administered by the state bar. Earlier
- 35:19there was a discussion that it would be administered
- 35:21by individual providers, but they moved away
- 35:24from that. So the state bar is going to do that,
- 35:26and that raises some issues, which we'll get
- 35:29to. But let me just quickly go over the other
- 35:32two of the three categories of people who might
- 35:34be adopters. The first, as you all call, were
- 35:37the kind of people, maybe new mediators and aspiring
- 35:41ones who want the validation. The second category
- 35:44is people who might have an established mediation
- 35:48practice, but who want to support the program
- 35:51simply because they think that it is a good thing
- 35:54for the profession overall. Now, you know, I'm
- 35:58not sure how large that category will be, but
- 36:01I think that is a constituency that the proponents
- 36:03of the bill are hopers out there, because without
- 36:08that constituency, this could get off to a pretty
- 36:11slow start. So I'm not saying I'm in that constituency,
- 36:15but that is a potential category of adopter,
- 36:18somebody who actually thinks, I think this is
- 36:20a great idea. And so I'm going to be in on it
- 36:23from the start, even though I've got an established
- 36:26practice. The third category is people who might
- 36:33at some point feel market pressures to become
- 36:36certified, because if they're not certified,
- 36:39they're not going to get work from certain quarters.
- 36:43Now, that might take time, and it may never come
- 36:46about. But let me give you one or two example.
- 36:50Many mediators, among other things, mediate real
- 36:53estate dispute. Real estate contracts in California
- 36:58have often a mediation before litigation requirement,
- 37:02and they may say that the mediator shall be a
- 37:05member or licensee of the California State Bar
- 37:08or whatever. What if some people like the California
- 37:11Association of Realtors in their forms, or, you
- 37:14know, I can think of tons of other examples,
- 37:16start putting in the mediator shall be certified
- 37:22by the California State Bar? as a mediator. So
- 37:27what, for example, if the courts, which have
- 37:31ADR programs, said, we want to have people who
- 37:35are involved in our ADR programs be state bar
- 37:38certified, what if insurance companies get to
- 37:41be in their bonnet about wanting to work with
- 37:43certified mediators? Now, none of that may ever
- 37:45happen. But if it does happen, then I think many
- 37:49mediators who might otherwise have been not inclined
- 37:53to be early adopters of certification may just
- 37:56go with the flow because the benefits of becoming
- 38:02certified outweigh the drawbacks. But again,
- 38:05when that occurs, if ever, is anyone's guess.
- 38:10Those are three reasons why some people might
- 38:13want to become certified, but there are also
- 38:15some specific things when you get into the details
- 38:17or the likely details that might weigh against
- 38:20it. And one of them, Meier's remarks kind of
- 38:24pointed to earlier when Meier talked about the
- 38:27whole complaint system, because if you are going
- 38:30to have a certification program, in a way, you've
- 38:34got to have some sort of complaint system, I
- 38:36suppose, because Otherwise, you know, there's,
- 38:39you know, you're not otherwise people just become
- 38:41certified for life and they can kind of do anything
- 38:44and still continue to have the bling on the wall.
- 38:47So in a way, I kind of understand why you need
- 38:50a certification system. But a big part of a complaint
- 38:55system, if you're going to have a certification
- 38:57system. But it does. And I think my this is the
- 39:00point that Maya was getting out earlier. raise
- 39:03serious questions to do with mediation confidentiality.
- 39:06Because if the state bar is going to be investigating
- 39:09complaints, often as Zemeier pointed out, complaints
- 39:13which may have been just brought about because
- 39:15somebody was subjectively unhappy with the outcome
- 39:19of a mediation, even though that mediation was
- 39:21a voluntary process, the state bar in a way,
- 39:25and I can see this from the state bar's point
- 39:27of view, they have to figure out, well, what
- 39:29exactly went on in this mediation. But the problem
- 39:31is that mediations are confidential. So you've
- 39:35got this tension between two kind of public policy
- 39:39objectives, the public policy favoring mediation
- 39:42confidentiality, which goes deep into California
- 39:45law, and the public policy of having effective
- 39:49regulation, if you're going to have any regulation
- 39:52at all. The working group voted down. a proposal
- 39:58which was strongly advocated by the State Bar
- 40:01that would have allowed the State Bar to obtain
- 40:05or have access to all confidential materials
- 40:09when investigating certified mediators. But after
- 40:15the working group had voted that down, Senator
- 40:18Umberg, the proponent of SB 940, then came up
- 40:22with this follow -up bill, SB 574, which, by
- 40:25the way, covers a ton of stuff besides what we're
- 40:28talking about today to do with the use of AI
- 40:31and litigation and arbitration, but which, among
- 40:35other things, as originally drafted, gave the
- 40:38state bar the power to intrude upon mediation,
- 40:41confidentiality, things when investigating complaints
- 40:48against certified mediators. And there was then
- 40:51this uproar amongst the mediation community.
- 40:56And many people, including the committee that
- 41:00I chair, lobbied against that and argued against
- 41:05it. And so this is very bad because it opens
- 41:09up mediation confidentiality in a way that undermines
- 41:15the whole process. At the very last moment, they
- 41:19did then narrow the bill so that the state, over
- 41:23the strong opposition of the state bar, by the
- 41:25way, they narrowed it so now the only intrusion
- 41:32into mediation confidentiality can occur in cases
- 41:36where one party at least Is is proper. And the
- 41:44reason for that was that Senator Umberg, I believe
- 41:51the main concern he has about what might what
- 41:56bad things might be taking place in the media,
- 41:59mediation profession have to do with unrepresented
- 42:03parties being as it were cajoles, maybe in mediation
- 42:08by. um neutrals who as a practical matter are
- 42:12beholden to repeat customer law firms and corporate
- 42:17interests you know we can debate whether or not
- 42:20that's a legitimate concern but that's why they
- 42:22kind of narrowed it down and with that narrowing
- 42:25down i i personally think that it's it's a lot
- 42:28better than what it would have been if the state
- 42:31bar could have intruded on intermediation confidentiality
- 42:35in all cases involving certified mediators But
- 42:38it also raises its own problems. Is this somehow
- 42:43discriminating against pro -pers? Well, the proponents
- 42:46of the bill say no, it is protecting pro -pers,
- 42:49but not everyone agrees with that. Other people
- 42:53say, well, certified mediators won't want to
- 42:56do mediations with pro -pers because that compromises
- 43:03confidentiality. You're going to have the state
- 43:04bar looking over your shoulder. you know, you
- 43:08can debate all the pros and cons, but that's
- 43:10how that turned out. So, Maya, did you want to
- 43:17add anything more on the whole complaints thing?
- 43:21Other than the fact is, I believe that they should
- 43:25modify it to say, client satisfaction survey,
- 43:31if they want to do it, because the word complaint
- 43:34absolutely biases the parties to feel that they
- 43:40have a way to get back at a mediator that they
- 43:45may be unhappy with. There are a lot of times
- 43:48when, and by the way, another big issue is this.
- 43:52I think it will chill the conduct and the speech
- 43:58of the mediator. Because if the mediator knows
- 44:02that a dissatisfied party will go to the state
- 44:07bar to complain. Will the mediator then have
- 44:11to modify their behavior in a way that might
- 44:15be less persuasive? When they go to the other
- 44:21party and say, here's what the other side is
- 44:25saying, and the party doesn't like it and feels
- 44:28you're biased, that gives the right to that party
- 44:31to go to the state bar and complain that you
- 44:35were biased. And all you're doing is carrying
- 44:37the message from the other side who is not convinced
- 44:41by the party's arguments. So the question is,
- 44:45this could be a very chilling effect on all mediators
- 44:50behavior and communications that could be very,
- 44:54very damaging to the mediation and make it less
- 44:58effective. One good question that Ronald Monitz
- 45:03has posted. And that is, can certified mediators
- 45:08destroy notes and communications of mediation
- 45:10after the mediation is over? Many mediators just
- 45:15eliminate everything about the mediation because
- 45:18they don't want to keep records. And then what
- 45:21does the state bar look to? And is that a violation
- 45:24of the complaint system? I assume that there's
- 45:27nothing about that in the working group. Yeah,
- 45:32I mean, I can't recall whether there is in the
- 45:34most recent set of recommendations anything about
- 45:36keeping records, but I know what you mean, because
- 45:39generally speaking, mediators don't keep records
- 45:42after a certain period of time, in part because
- 45:47this is confidential material which nobody should
- 45:49ever be able to get. There are, apart from the
- 45:56big picture problems of SB 940, there are some
- 45:59specific detailed issues which I think people
- 46:04are weighing up whether to become certified ought
- 46:08to think about. One is to do with disclosure
- 46:11requirements. I don't think anybody has got a
- 46:15problem with the general concept that one should
- 46:17disclose to parties and attorneys the types of
- 46:21things that obviously people might want to know
- 46:24about, namely anything that might reasonably
- 46:27raise a question as to your neutrality. But there
- 46:35are some burdens that will be put on certified
- 46:38mediators that could really impact their practice
- 46:43in a negative way, particularly if you go for
- 46:46one of the higher tiers. And if I ever became
- 46:50certified, and I'm not sure whether I will, but
- 46:52if ever I did, you know, instinctively, I'd want
- 46:55to be tier three. I wouldn't want to be tier
- 46:57one because tier three is being kind of, you
- 46:59know, that's kind of the... the gold standard
- 47:02and tier two, I guess, is silver and tier one
- 47:06is bronze. So if you're going to do it at all,
- 47:08I wouldn't want to be saying, OK, well, I've
- 47:10got my bronze thing and other people sort of
- 47:13flaunting around their gold things. But here's
- 47:15the problem with tier three. With tier three,
- 47:21you don't have to just disclose stuff involving
- 47:27repeat. Repeat parties or repeat law firms or
- 47:33repeat insurance companies you might be dealing
- 47:35with You don't have to trust disclose, but you
- 47:38have to get permission so in other words if I
- 47:43take a case of Smith v Jones with State Farm
- 47:49as the Carrier for Jones and then lawyers on
- 47:54each side. I have to then go to all of them and
- 47:58get them to give me affirmative permission at
- 48:02the outset to allow me to take another case involving
- 48:07Smith Jones State Farm or Smith and Jones's lawyers.
- 48:10while this mediation is still open and on calendar.
- 48:15And many of us schedule mediations quite a way
- 48:17out. And so although the mediation itself may
- 48:20take place during a day or two days or whatever,
- 48:23the whole process can be something involving
- 48:26months when it's an open case. And during that,
- 48:29so I can't then take any other case involving
- 48:32anyone in case A, unless everyone in case A,
- 48:37parties, lawyers, Other participants, such as
- 48:40insurance companies, have given me permission.
- 48:43Now, there are some areas of the law, for example,
- 48:45Song Beverly, and probably a bunch of others.
- 48:49And certainly, personal injury when it comes
- 48:51to insurance companies, where you're dealing
- 48:54with the same participants on an ongoing basis.
- 48:58Anyone who does PI mediations deals with kind
- 49:00of maybe half a dozen different insurance companies
- 49:03over and over and over again. So the notion that
- 49:07I have to go and ask permission to take more
- 49:11cases involving those participants. I find problematic.
- 49:15Partly, it's problematic at an administrative
- 49:17level. It's a pain in the neck to have to do.
- 49:20But aside from that, at a conceptual level, I
- 49:23think it actually compromises the role of the
- 49:25neutral. Because one of the most fundamental
- 49:27ethical rules of mediation is surely that you
- 49:30can't accept favors. from the parties. If during
- 49:34a mediation somebody sent me a case of wine or
- 49:37whatever and I accepted it, that I think would
- 49:39be a gross violation. So surely it is also a
- 49:44violation of neutrality. If I go to the lawyers
- 49:49and the parties and the insurance carrier and
- 49:52Smith v Jones and say, hey guys, would you sign
- 49:56off and give me permission to do more? to do
- 49:59other cases involving a participant in this case
- 50:02because that way they're giving me a favor and
- 50:05I'm asking for a favor and that just doesn't
- 50:08make sense to me and even at tier one although
- 50:12you don't have to get permission you have to
- 50:14do a lot of ongoing rolling disclosure so every
- 50:17time you get a new case offer which might overlap
- 50:21with anyone in another open case you have to
- 50:25go back to all your open cases and get updated
- 50:27disclosures So I guess when you when you're just
- 50:31debating whether to become certified look at
- 50:35the final detail when we see what the final detail
- 50:37is because you may just not like a lot of what
- 50:41it entails not because you're somebody who wants
- 50:44to have compromised ethics because I you know
- 50:48I think the overwhelming majority of mediators
- 50:51who I've met are highly ethical people but you
- 50:55may just not want to be burdened by this level
- 50:59of regulation and compliance? I have a question
- 51:05for both of you. So it appears that there are
- 51:08problems that you have pointed out and that will
- 51:12be pointed out to the working committee and possibly
- 51:16to the legislators. Now, Umberg, Senator Umberg,
- 51:20he's turned out. Who's going to carry this forward?
- 51:23Do you have any idea on that? Or does it stay
- 51:26the same? He responded. He said, I'm sorry, I'll
- 51:30be around and I'll give comments, but I have
- 51:33no authority to make any changes. There'll be
- 51:36other legislators that you can address. So I
- 51:42don't think anybody else is deeply involved and
- 51:45committed as he is to make sure this legislation
- 51:48gets through. This is his baby. This is his gift
- 51:51to the State Bar to kind of rehabilitate them
- 51:55for their wrongdoings regarding Gerard. So this
- 51:59is the law. The only question is whether other
- 52:02legislators will pick up the torch or want to
- 52:05be involved in cleaning it up or making it more
- 52:09equitable for those that are involved. That's
- 52:11right. Here's another question that was asked
- 52:13in the questions. Very important. Let's suppose,
- 52:16John, that State Bar looks at a complaint and
- 52:22they feel that this is serious enough to decertify
- 52:25this mediator. Now, what is the obligation of
- 52:29the mediator to disclose he's been decertified?
- 52:32Number one. Number two, what happens to his ENO
- 52:35carrier when he has to apply for ENO coverage
- 52:38if he wants to continue mediation and he's now
- 52:42does he have to disclose I was decertified for
- 52:45these reasons for bad behavior? Please explain.
- 52:50No, I agree. I mean, that is an issue. And sometimes
- 52:52when you fill out these forms, when you're applying
- 52:54to go onto this or that, or applying for insurance
- 52:57or whatever, you have to disclose not just whether
- 53:01you've ever been disciplined, but whether you've
- 53:03even been the subject of a disciplinary investigation.
- 53:07And if basically people can complain to the state
- 53:10bar just on grounds that the mediator wasn't
- 53:15responsive to me or whatever. Potentially, if
- 53:21you give disgruntled litigants this sort of access
- 53:24to this complaints procedure, you may find yourself
- 53:28the subject of an investigation which may go
- 53:31nowhere, but which could conceivably give rise
- 53:34to a duty to disclose when you have to give an
- 53:37awful lot of explanation to someone else later
- 53:40on. And here's the final thing, and we're getting
- 53:43to the end, but this is my biggest concern. The
- 53:47state bar has about 200 ,000 lawyers that they
- 53:51have to regulate. And the rules concerning client
- 53:56trust funds have been enormously expanded. And
- 54:01the state bar has about, I think, 300 investigators
- 54:06for 200 ,000 lawyers. and they receive approximately,
- 54:12from what I read about the state bar's disclosures,
- 54:15about 20 ,000 complaints a year, maybe more.
- 54:19Now, how are they going to take those 300 investigators
- 54:23and divert them to certifying mediators and investigating
- 54:31complaints by mediators? And we know that the
- 54:36state bar, the legislation prohibits the use
- 54:39of state bar fees to fund any of the work for
- 54:45mediation certification, which means that the
- 54:49entire certification program now can only be
- 54:54funded by the fees charged to jams, ADR, the
- 54:59big boys, signature, and even small non -profit
- 55:04organizations who will be burdened with having
- 55:06to be forced by market conditions to get certified
- 55:10in order to be able to continue the work that
- 55:14they're doing. What about all the volunteer mediators
- 55:18who work for the court like the MVP program for
- 55:21the LA County Court? What about all those people
- 55:25who don't make any money for mediation? And now
- 55:28if the court says, oh, everybody has to be state
- 55:31bar certified, Do you know what the fees might
- 55:34be upfront? They're supposed to be higher. Maybe
- 55:37later on they will be reduced. But they've got
- 55:39to figure out a way to fund this massive certification
- 55:43program, investigate mediators, set up a system
- 55:48for applications and investigations. I think
- 55:52that they have no idea what they're getting into.
- 55:55I know that when we investigate any applicant
- 55:59for our program, I do personal interviews. I
- 56:03check the state bar status. The court has requirements
- 56:07that they must be 10 years of good standing with
- 56:13the state bar, 10 years, and practice without
- 56:16any complaints. They have to have 40 hours of
- 56:20training. That is not any of the requirements
- 56:22for a mediator. In fact, I guess, John, if my
- 56:26plumber, my gardener, my student who's just finishing
- 56:31college, or not even finishing college, my high
- 56:34school kid, if they want to become certified,
- 56:38they could do so. Is that correct? Well, they
- 56:41would have to have a handful of mediations, you
- 56:43know, the six mediations under their belt. And
- 56:47they would have to have gone through some mediation
- 56:51training. But you're right. Where does it say
- 56:53how much training do they have to do? Well, that's
- 56:56in the You know, one of the appendices, I think
- 56:59it's a working groups thing. It's like my appendix
- 57:05that I have. It's basically basically that they
- 57:08need to do a 40 hour training program. um so
- 57:13so there there is that hoop it's like you know
- 57:16it's not as though there's going to be a pass
- 57:18there's going to be an exam at the end of the
- 57:20training program but they will have to have done
- 57:22the training program but but let me just make
- 57:26one point about the pricing i mean we don't know
- 57:29how much it's going to cost the problem the state
- 57:31bar has got is that the more expensive they make
- 57:33it fuel people are going to take part because
- 57:35there may be price sensitivity. But the fuel
- 57:39people who might not take part for other reasons
- 57:41means that they're going to have to make it more
- 57:44expensive just to pay the bills because, as Maya
- 57:46points out, it has to be self -funding. I actually
- 57:50am not one of these people who thinks that SB
- 57:52940 marks kind of kind of this huge dark cloud
- 57:58over the ADR world. And it's not because I'm
- 58:02a great fan of SB940, because I'm actually quite
- 58:04critical of it, but it's rather because I have
- 58:07a gut view that the whole thing might just actually
- 58:09flop. The take -up rate is going to be relatively
- 58:13low, because whenever I talk to mediators, nobody
- 58:16seems particularly keen on becoming certified.
- 58:20Maybe I'm just talking to the wrong sorts of
- 58:22mediators, because the types of people who join
- 58:24in these types of discussions that we're having
- 58:25today tend to be people who are against it, and
- 58:28there are tons of other mediators who are in
- 58:29favor. I don't know. But I have a feeling that
- 58:32the take -up rate isn't going to be huge, and
- 58:34that therefore it's not going to really be that
- 58:38impactful. And if you're not certified, none
- 58:41of these things that we're saying are terrible
- 58:43to do with intrusions into mediation confidentiality
- 58:46or whatever are going to come into effect. And
- 58:52then at some point after a few years, maybe at
- 58:55that point, the whole system will be rewritten
- 58:57once everyone has agreed both the proponents
- 59:01and the opponents that the scheme as initially
- 59:03introduced was not properly thought through.
- 59:07Well, I'd like to make one final comment. Yeah,
- 59:10go ahead. I'm asking the entire bar to go and
- 59:14ask major organization to have forums for people,
- 59:19for all of our members to have a discussion like
- 59:23this open forum with a way of feedback by asking
- 59:32parties, our participants, what do they think
- 59:35about joining or not joining this certificate?
- 59:38That's really what I'm asking. I think that's
- 59:42an excellent point. And read my paper that I
- 59:48attached, which is a summary. Right, right, right.
- 59:51So I want to thank you both. I think this has
- 59:54been a very interesting discussion. I think,
- 59:57in a sense, the horse is out of the barn or out
- 1:00:00of the trailer. But we really don't know what's
- 1:00:05going to happen. And we don't know how many people
- 1:00:07will get involved. And it sounds to me like Chances
- 1:00:12are those that are ignorant or new to the profession
- 1:00:15will be more likely to get involved. And Meyer's
- 1:00:19point is right on target that everybody needs
- 1:00:22to be fully educated. And Meyer, I thank you
- 1:00:24for taking the lead on that. And that's it for
- 1:00:28now and to be continued. So thank you all. Thank
- 1:00:32you. Thank you for inviting us and I hope this
- 1:00:34was informative for everyone. No, I think plenty
- 1:00:37of food for thought. in a sense disturbing like
- 1:00:41many other things in the world. And I have to
- 1:00:45say that I'm concerned about what the legislature
- 1:00:48will do in the future because we know that power
- 1:00:51begets power. And based on what John said today,
- 1:00:56which I was not aware of, the state bar is very
- 1:00:59gung -ho on this program. And it obviously seeks
- 1:01:03to make this a key function in the future. So
- 1:01:07thank you very much. Have a great day everybody
- 1:01:10and we'll see you around next time. Bye now.
- 1:01:14Thank you.