Latest / Film And Whiskey / To Kill a Mockingbird (1962) / Tullamore DEW Irish Whiskey
Transcript
- 0:00In 1962, director Robert Mulligan and star Gregory Peck
- 0:05gave the world a book adaptation that sought to capture the heart
- 0:09of a man dedicated to justice for all.
- 0:13In 2024, we returned to a budget favorite from Ireland.
- 0:18The film is To Kill a Mockingbird.
- 0:20The whiskey is Tullamore Dew. And more.
- 0:23Review them both. This is the Film and Whiskey
- 0:28podcast. Welcome to the Film and Whiskey
- 0:48podcast, where each week we review a classic movie and a
- 0:51glass of whiskey. I'm Bob Book.
- 0:54I'm Brad G. And this week, we are revisiting
- 0:56the 1962 classic To Kill a Mockingbird.
- 1:01Brad, this has been one that I'm really excited to go back to.
- 1:04And folks, by the way, if this is your first time joining us,
- 1:07welcome into film and Whiskey. This season, we are revisiting
- 1:10all the films that we looked at in season #1 for our 10th season
- 1:15anniversary. It's been a really fun exercise
- 1:17so far. This is, I believe, episode 9 of
- 1:20Season 1 or of Season 10 rather. Brad, as I recall, our recording
- 1:25process from season #1 what we would do is we would kind of sit
- 1:29in a room. We get together once a month and
- 1:31we would knock out four episodes in succession.
- 1:33And it would take us like a full 8 hour day to do it.
- 1:37So this would have been our third recording.
- 1:39And I remember this was the one where we went to your friend
- 1:41Eric's house and recorded 4 episodes in his living room.
- 1:45Oh yeah. As well as a bonus episode with
- 1:49Have a Shot of Freedom. So we we recorded quite a few
- 1:52episodes of This Day Man. Yeah, and the audio quality of
- 1:56those episodes reflects that. It was echoey and we were
- 2:04getting a little schwasty because we were drinking a lot
- 2:07of whiskey. What a great time.
- 2:09I remember, I'm, I'm sure I've shared this before, but that was
- 2:12the day that I had just had my wisdom teeth out about a week
- 2:14before and the like. The pockets were still healing
- 2:18and it was the first time that I felt comfortable eating solid
- 2:21food. And we got pizza and a Shard of
- 2:24pizza crust went right down into one of those pockets and I blood
- 2:27everywhere. And then we had to go record
- 2:29some more and drink. Whiskey it was dude, the
- 2:32dedication that you have shown. Since the beginning.
- 2:35Life and limb on the line, my friend.
- 2:38Life and tooth, at least. Well, the film and whiskey
- 2:43audience thanks you for the sacrifice of your gums, Robert.
- 2:46Yeah, man, listen, this, you have to protect this voice and
- 2:50all of its, you know, attenuating things.
- 2:53Yeah, as much as you can. So let's not do that again is
- 2:56what I'm saying. Yeah, I am well over the days
- 2:59where we recorded for 8 hours straight.
- 3:01Me too. All right, man, let's turn our
- 3:04attention to To Kill a Mockingbird.
- 3:07A true American classic if ever there was one.
- 3:10This is, I think, ranked #25 on the more recent AFI Top 100.
- 3:16It is a beloved movie. Atticus Finch was named the
- 3:18greatest hero in American movie history by the American Film
- 3:22Institute. So we have a lot to kind of live
- 3:25up to here, Brad. And, you know, I did not go back
- 3:28and listen to our Season 1 review.
- 3:30Sometimes I'll go back and listen to the whole thing just
- 3:33so that I I try not to repeat myself.
- 3:35Sometimes I'll go back and just see what I generally thought of
- 3:38the movie and then turn it off. And then there's days like today
- 3:41where I just have not had time to go back and listen.
- 3:43So maybe I'll completely repeat myself, but I'm more interested
- 3:48in your impressions of the film nine seasons on, from the first
- 3:52time you watched it. Now remind me again, was season
- 3:55one the first time you saw the film?
- 3:57I think it was. I know that I read the book, you
- 4:03know, back in 9th grade, 10th grade, whenever.
- 4:06I don't think I ever actually saw the film until Season 1, but
- 4:10Season 1 has been so long ago that I I can't remember well.
- 4:15Hopefully you remember. Have you seen the movie since
- 4:17then? I have not.
- 4:19OK, so we're going to just go out on a limb and say that this
- 4:21is watch #2 for you. Sure.
- 4:24And yeah, that's a fair a fair guess given my history of the
- 4:27movie. Going to say, if I was a betting
- 4:29man, this seems like a safe bet to me.
- 4:32Now before we get into, Brad explains, I do want to kind of
- 4:35get your general impressions of the film.
- 4:38Don't spoil too much of what you think, but like, is it what you
- 4:41remembered it to be? Did you find it a more rich
- 4:43experience this time? Was it significantly worse than
- 4:46the last time? Where you at on this one?
- 4:48I, I feel like I remember the first time through we both were
- 4:53like, this is a decently average film with one of the best
- 4:57courtroom sequences we've ever seen.
- 4:59And the second time through, I think that I'm kind of in a
- 5:03similar place, but I would say this is a average to below
- 5:09average film with a one of the best courtroom scenes I've ever
- 5:15experienced. Oh man.
- 5:16OK, so that whole thing about hey, don't get into your spicy
- 5:19takes, let's bury the lead. That did not.
- 5:22That didn't take, apparently. I I mean I I guess not.
- 5:25All right, well, Brad thinks this is an average to below
- 5:27average film. There's your headline for today,
- 5:30and in order to justify that claim, I need to hear what Brad
- 5:33thought the movie was about. And that means it's time for,
- 5:36Brad explains. Brad's going to give us the
- 5:38movie plots with only 60 seconds taken on the clock, so let's go
- 5:42ahead and do your take with this little segment that we call,
- 5:45Brad explains. Brad explains is the part of the
- 5:48show where Brad breaks down the plot of the film that he has
- 5:51just seen for the second time. Now Brad, we are going to spoil
- 5:56this movie. So if you have not read the book
- 5:58or seen the film, I almost said American Sniper, To Kill a
- 6:02Mockingbird. I, I don't know, I was just
- 6:05thinking about shooting birds, you know, snipers.
- 6:07I. Don't know.
- 6:08Yeah, basically the same movie you.
- 6:10Know To Kill a Mockingbird. You should probably go do that
- 6:13and then rejoin us for the rest of.
- 6:15The A dog A dog is assaulted in both movies.
- 6:18True. Yeah, All right, man, You have
- 6:2260 seconds on the clock. Spoil this film and go.
- 6:25To Kill a Mockingbird is a film about Atticus Finch as seen
- 6:30through the eyes of his daughter, Scout Finch.
- 6:33She and her brother Jem are living in the Depression era
- 6:37Deep South in Macum, Alabama, and they watch as their father
- 6:44Atticus attempts to defend a black man who is on trial for
- 6:48the rape and assault of a young white woman in the town.
- 6:53Throughout the film, they experienced different elements
- 6:56of difficulty. They're tried to be taught by
- 6:59their father the values of decency and respect for all
- 7:03people, and they witness the unjust guilty verdict of the man
- 7:11that Atticus is defending. And somehow, Boo Radley plays
- 7:17into it all. Yeah, somehow this is a good
- 7:22starting point, Brad, because I want to talk about where I think
- 7:26the film really succeed. Not even the film.
- 7:28Let's talk about the story. So you know the book by Harper
- 7:31Lee, you and I have both read it.
- 7:34It's it's a classic. It's a Pulitzer Prize winning
- 7:36book that is since become like a lightning rod of controversy in
- 7:41the last 1015 years. Again, there are a lot of
- 7:44schools that have re banned this book and it's really funny
- 7:48because of, you know, originally the book was banned in a lot of
- 7:50places because those places were still very segregated and
- 7:53racist. And now they want to ban the
- 7:55book because it includes the N word.
- 7:58So we've come around to the complete opposite side of the
- 8:00spectrum and we're banning the book ironically for using racist
- 8:05language in its anti racist narrative.
- 8:09But that's beside the point. Let's talk about the narrative
- 8:12of the film itself. I feel like this is at the same
- 8:16time a story that feels very meandering and unfocused, and
- 8:23yet every metaphor or theme that is set up gets a payoff later in
- 8:30the movie. So I can't decide if it's like
- 8:33really brilliant or really unfocused.
- 8:37And I kind of feel like it's both.
- 8:40I feel like it's the latter, Bob.
- 8:43Now here's the thing, the film and the book, the story is told
- 8:49through the lens of a unreliable narrator, right?
- 8:53Like we're talking about a 6-7 year old child.
- 8:57I think she is supposed to be at like as our viewpoint, which
- 9:04necessitates the reality that the view we get on all these
- 9:09situations is very simple and black and white.
- 9:14And because of that we also get what a six year old would be
- 9:19interested in. And so a lot of the movie is
- 9:22focused on like, these small experiences of a child, which
- 9:28underplay the narrative of a man being unjustly tried for murder.
- 9:34And I think that the difference between those two prerogatives
- 9:41is like such a huge gap that I really wish they had just chosen
- 9:48one or the other to stick with and make a movie about that.
- 9:52I just found myself this time through being very bored because
- 10:00the movie didn't seem to be going anywhere specific.
- 10:03I don't disagree with you, and yet I'm going to to play devil's
- 10:07advocate. So let's put a pin in that for a
- 10:10second 'cause I do want to come back to that.
- 10:11And I think my overarching point is that this narrative,
- 10:16including the script for this movie, which wins an Academy
- 10:19Award, is better on paper than it is on film.
- 10:24I just think that like, you can see the themes more clearly.
- 10:27You can see the Chekhov's guns and the pay offs way more
- 10:30clearly when someone's explaining it to you or when
- 10:33you're reading it then when you're seeing it on film.
- 10:36Because in the film, everything has equal weight to it.
- 10:39And I think that's kind of gets to your point of like, some of
- 10:41these things seem way weightier than the other things.
- 10:44Why are we spending an equal amount of time on both of them?
- 10:47But I really do like how every character that's set up gets a
- 10:51payoff. Like the guy who is who has the
- 10:55entailment to Atticus Finch that's bringing him like the
- 10:58chestnuts or whatever, and then she beats up his son.
- 11:01But then they have a son over to dinner.
- 11:03And then that pays off later in the movie when he arrives with
- 11:06the angry mob and her appealing to him.
- 11:09His own indebtedness to her dad and to being friends with her
- 11:13son kind of gets Tom Robinson and Atticus out of some trouble.
- 11:17I like that. The whole thing about Tom
- 11:20Robinson not being able to use his left hand so that he
- 11:23couldn't be beating on Maela Yule's right side of her face
- 11:26actually comes back later in the movie when Jem is attacked at
- 11:30the end of the film and you see him laying in bed and his right
- 11:33eye is bruised. And so then when the sheriff
- 11:35walks in and sees which eye on Gem is beat up, they don't even
- 11:40have to say anything. It clicks with both of them that
- 11:43this guy was attacked by Bob Ewell.
- 11:44Like it? I really like those little
- 11:47moments throughout the film. I just want to be clear.
- 11:50Robert E Lee Ewell. Yes, yeah, yeah.
- 11:54If we weren't clear about what this man represents.
- 11:58The greatest thing about that name Brad is that he has 2
- 12:01middle names, one of which is a last name and the other of which
- 12:04is just the letter E Yes, his first middle name is E.
- 12:08Yes, his second middle name, Lee.
- 12:11It's incredible. To be clear, it is not
- 12:15incredible. The the naming convention is
- 12:19very funny. It it really is.
- 12:22So yeah, I I think that there are a lot of things in the
- 12:24script that pay themselves off really well, and they do them in
- 12:28very subtle ways sometimes. And I want to give that credit.
- 12:32However, in the course of watching this movie, the 1st 10
- 12:36minutes of the film, I was like, Oh my gosh, I forgot how good
- 12:40this is. I forgot how brilliant the setup
- 12:42of seeing these things through the eyes of a child can be
- 12:46because everything is given equal weight.
- 12:48And we've watched so many of these like white people
- 12:52interacting with black people and learning a lesson, movies
- 12:55for this podcast. And so often they get accused of
- 12:58being like white savior movies. This movie kind of miraculously
- 13:02has avoided getting that much pushback.
- 13:06And I think part of it is because it's a it's seen through
- 13:08the eyes of a child. But I think if you really wanted
- 13:11to, you could still give the movie push back and say, well,
- 13:14the black guy is only used as a tool to educate the white
- 13:17people. And like, if I guess if you
- 13:19wanted to do that, you could. But I really appreciate it in
- 13:22this film that, like everything is treated as something that a,
- 13:27a young child is inquisitive about, is curious about, is
- 13:30learning about. And it doesn't feel insensitive.
- 13:34It doesn't feel antiquated in the way that it portrays the
- 13:38racial politics of the South. And quite frankly, I also really
- 13:42liked that it didn't shy away from using really harsh, really,
- 13:48you know, denigrating language like the N word, which we've
- 13:52seen movies like The Help and Green Book won't even touch that
- 13:56word in in 20/20/2024. You know what I mean?
- 14:00Like I think it's more frank about race in 1962 than a lot of
- 14:04these other big Oscari race playing movies are in this day
- 14:08and age. And the reality is if you are
- 14:11going to set your movie in the Deep South of the 1930s, you
- 14:17have to, I mean, you don't have to, but you ought to, in my
- 14:21opinion, represent the time period well, which includes a
- 14:25lot of things like having the proper costumes and the proper
- 14:29stage sets being built and the proper accents being used.
- 14:34And, and that includes like using the words that they would
- 14:38have used in the time. And I, I think it's just
- 14:41important to portray history as accurately as possible so that a
- 14:47modern audience can watch a film like this and understand the
- 14:51brokenness that was going on in the system.
- 14:54So I, I'm with you there, man. I I think that the movie does a
- 14:58a fairly good job of honestly portraying what the Deep South
- 15:03might have been like for a young white child trying to understand
- 15:08what's happening in the world around her.
- 15:12I think overall the theme really does hit home too, of you have
- 15:17to learn as you grow up that the adults in your life or just
- 15:20whoever you might come into contact with are very flawed
- 15:24people and are often very wrong people.
- 15:26And in addition to this, Finch baby, well, in addition to that,
- 15:30like the people that they tell you are dangerous might not be.
- 15:33And the people that are embraced by society might be the
- 15:36dangerous ones. This movie does a really good
- 15:38job of that. I was going to say too, I think
- 15:41one of the best payouts of the movie or the best callbacks is
- 15:44at towards the end of the film when you find out that Tom
- 15:46Robinson is dead. And you know, it's implied that
- 15:49he was shot out of malice. But even if you don't think that
- 15:52he was shot out of malice, they call back to a scene earlier in
- 15:55the movie where Jem has been hounding Atticus about not
- 16:01letting him get a gun and he says that Atticus is basically a
- 16:04coward and he'd never use a gun. You find out Atticus is the best
- 16:07shot in the county when a dog with rabies wanders into the
- 16:11neighborhood and the sheriff hands the gun to Atticus and
- 16:15says, you do it, I can't shoot. And so like that comes back
- 16:18later in the movie where the sheriff and his deputies have
- 16:22bad aim. But the the phrase they used to
- 16:24describe how Tom Robinson supposedly ran away is he ran
- 16:29like a Mad Dog. And what, what really comes up
- 16:33in that moment is, was he running like a Mad Dog because
- 16:37he was put down like a dog. But we've already established
- 16:40the theme of killing a mockingbird, which is somebody
- 16:42who doesn't do anybody any harm. And So what they think they did
- 16:46was shoot a Mad Dog. And instead what they did was
- 16:48they shot a mockingbird. And I just, I, I really love,
- 16:51you know, that's directly from the book.
- 16:53But I think they do a good job of folding those things in into
- 16:56the movie in a way that's not like overly schmaltzy or calling
- 17:01attention to itself. Now we can get into what the
- 17:04movie doesn't do so well. But I did, I did want to set
- 17:07aside like it does a lot of things very, very well.
- 17:12I just don't know in the balance of things if those things shine
- 17:16as much as they need to. Yeah, and they, they don't shine
- 17:19quite as much because there's enough moments that feel really
- 17:24forced that I it, it feels like a very up and down type of
- 17:29movie. And so for me, like the moment
- 17:33when the lynch mob goes to the jail to kill Tom Robinson and
- 17:38Scout comes in and starts talking to, you know, the farmer
- 17:42and gets him to feel bad and call off the mob, it's moments
- 17:45like that that feel so fake and for like a variety of reasons.
- 17:51One of the reasons is that you can hear their voices.
- 17:55Echoing off of the set. Oh my gosh, dude.
- 17:58And this was so the director Robert Mulligan is not like a
- 18:01very famous director to this day.
- 18:04Like this is by far his most remembered film.
- 18:07And I will say that, like, again, in the 1st 10 minutes of
- 18:09the movie, I was like, the cinematography is beautiful.
- 18:13They put so much effort into this.
- 18:15There's actually a shot, one of the first establishing shots is
- 18:18when the guy that has the entailment, like, gets off of
- 18:21his cart and is walking with his bag of like nuts up to the side
- 18:25of the house. And the camera pans over with
- 18:27him and stops. And then Scout swings backward
- 18:30into the frame on a tire swing. And she's like narrating.
- 18:35I was six years old. And then you see her for the
- 18:37first time. It's a great little economical
- 18:39use of the camera. And you can tell in this movie,
- 18:43more than most movies we've done on this podcast, which scenes
- 18:47they put time and effort into and which scenes were like,
- 18:50either we're running out of time or we're running out of money.
- 18:53Because some of them are outdoors, some of them are like
- 18:56really well choreographed. And then you have sequences like
- 18:59this mob sequence where it is clearly a sound stage.
- 19:03The sound quality is awful, the direction is bad.
- 19:06Like they're not even directing the members of the mob very
- 19:09well. They're they're the most quiet,
- 19:10respectful group of men that want to lynch someone.
- 19:14I like. It's, it's unbelievable, dude.
- 19:16Yeah, 100%. And I think that was my
- 19:21frustration throughout the film, outside of the courtroom
- 19:26sequence, where it just felt like the quality of the
- 19:29filmmaking, whether it's the script, whether it's the
- 19:32cinematography, the sound design, it just felt like they
- 19:36were all at odds with one another throughout the movie.
- 19:40That you might have a great moment of the script, but the
- 19:42sound design isn't great. Or you might have a great moment
- 19:44of sound design, but the camera work isn't really up to par.
- 19:48And, and it just felt like a very uneven experience
- 19:53throughout. And then in the middle of all
- 19:55that, you have Gregory Peck just freaking knocking it out of the
- 19:59park with pretty much every line he's given, but especially as he
- 20:04is operating within the courtroom.
- 20:07Why don't we save the courtroom sequence for the second-half of
- 20:10the show? Because I think we're kind of on
- 20:12a roll here with identifying what's wrong with the movie.
- 20:15And I always like it when we suggest fixes for the movie,
- 20:18too. Because as everyone knows, if
- 20:20there's anyone who needs to fix a 60 something year old film
- 20:24that's considered one of the best of all time, it's Bob and
- 20:27Brad Obvious. That's what they call us in for.
- 20:29It's what we make the big bucks. For the fixers, the.
- 20:32Fixers, man. I do think a you need to lose 20
- 20:36minutes off this movie, and those 20 minutes all need to
- 20:39come from the sequences of them sneaking around the Radley
- 20:43house. There are way too many of them
- 20:45and there are only a few that are actually like germane to the
- 20:48plot of the movie in terms of, you know, he he picked up my
- 20:53pants and hung them up for me. Like literally that's the only
- 20:55part of that that you need to to establish that Boo Radley is not
- 20:58harmful and that he wants to leave presents for people.
- 21:01But there's like 3-4 different sequences of them sneaking
- 21:05around that house and they just get so repetitive that it really
- 21:10grinds the movie to a halt. There's a great sequence where
- 21:14the judge comes and assigns the case to Atticus and it it
- 21:18happens right after the kids are reminiscing about their dead
- 21:21mom. It's like a beautiful sequence
- 21:23of this film and the stakes are established.
- 21:25And then the very next scene is her like fighting with this kid
- 21:28Walter at school and then this extended sequence of him coming
- 21:31home for dinner. And man, those both of those
- 21:36scenes only exist to pay off that scene at the the lynch mob.
- 21:41But it's like you invested, what, 8 minutes of the movie
- 21:45into a 22nd payoff later. And I just don't know if the
- 21:48balance of that works out for me.
- 21:50Like you, you got to trim some of the kids sneaking around
- 21:53stuff. Tell me this Bob, does the movie
- 21:57change at all if you just completely get rid of Boo
- 22:00Radley? Like, obviously you have to
- 22:03change up the ending of the film a little bit.
- 22:05I don't think you have to do a lot of work to make it make
- 22:09sense. No, I think Boo Radley is
- 22:11necessary for the point of the movie to make sense.
- 22:14Like Tom Robinson is frankly dispatched with so quickly and
- 22:19so quietly, and it's because he, you know, he doesn't overlap
- 22:22with these children's lives. But then that principal comes
- 22:24back into play with Boo that like, they killed Tom Robinson,
- 22:28they killed a mockingbird. We're not going to do the same
- 22:31thing again with Boo Radley. He's a guy that doesn't harm
- 22:33anybody. And I like, it's the only hint
- 22:36of progress in terms of like the way people are thinking about
- 22:40others in the film. So I think you have to keep Boo
- 22:43Radley in it. I just don't know that you need
- 22:46to hammer it in that much of of him being a threat or him being
- 22:49spooky aside from one maybe 2 scenes.
- 22:53But the the problem is nobody in the movie changes like like
- 22:59Scout, even at the start, it's not like she's this racist
- 23:02little kid who needs to learn how to not be racist.
- 23:04Like, the sheriff is the only person who, like, maybe kind of
- 23:11a little bit changes, but like, they establish him early on as a
- 23:14generally good guy. And even when he's in the
- 23:18courtroom, he isn't presented as somebody who inherently believes
- 23:22that Tom Robinson did what he was accused of.
- 23:25So like nobody in the movie changes at all because of the
- 23:33court case, because of what happens because of the death of
- 23:36Tom Robinson. Like all of the black people in
- 23:39the top of the courthouse believed he was innocent and
- 23:42still believe he's innocent at the end.
- 23:45All of the white people in the town who are racist or presented
- 23:49as racist are racist at the end of the movie.
- 23:51Atticus Finch is not racist and he's not racist at the end of
- 23:55the movie. At like I just don't understand
- 23:57how the story can matter when nothing really changes.
- 24:05Yeah, but I mean, like the, I, I hear what you're saying, but
- 24:08think about a movie like The Help, which we've watched for
- 24:10this podcast. Now, nothing really changes in
- 24:12the social strata of that movie either.
- 24:14It's like little small victories on an individual level that are
- 24:18the emotional payoff of that movie.
- 24:20So I, I don't necessarily think that you have to have huge
- 24:24systemic structural change. I'm like everybody linking arms,
- 24:27if you know what I mean, Like, and I'm not suggesting that
- 24:30you're actually saying that, but I, I, I don't know, it didn't
- 24:32bother me that much. And I think that you can cut out
- 24:35so much of the kids being kids stuff as long as it doesn't
- 24:41directly pertain to a payoff later in the movie.
- 24:44And I think 90% of the fat on this movie is gone.
- 24:47And it's a quicker movie. It's a.
- 24:49You can draw through lines across the characters much more
- 24:52easily. In any case, I it's got to lose
- 24:55some time somewhere. Sure, I I guess I just feel
- 24:58like, you know, even your example of the help there are
- 25:02individuals who slowly change as the power of what's her name,
- 25:08Tilly. I think Hilly Holbrook.
- 25:12Hilly. Yeah, Hilly Holbrook like as her
- 25:14power is broken over the community, like individuals
- 25:19change and grow and thrive. And and you see the black women
- 25:22of that movie become more empowered as their story is
- 25:26given voice in this movie. I I just don't see any of that.
- 25:32I I actually care less about this is going to sound bad.
- 25:35Don't don't take this as a sound clip.
- 25:37I care less about the overall societal change within the
- 25:43structure of this movie. Like within just make them
- 25:46Alabama of this movie. I care more about individuals or
- 25:52an individual moving into a better place.
- 25:55Like, I almost wish that the movie, that the story was about
- 25:59an older scout who lived with her mother, who was
- 26:04extraordinarily racist, and the mother dies and she has to be
- 26:07returned to Atticus. And it's a story about her
- 26:10growing to respect and understand that black people are
- 26:14humans as well. Like like this sounds like the
- 26:17most problematic movie. I'm just picturing small scout
- 26:21Finch casually dropping the N word in this movie and I don't
- 26:25know if that if that's going to fly I I mean, I know what you're
- 26:29saying though. Yeah, like, like tell me it's
- 26:31not more impactful if the audience stand in, grows rather
- 26:36than is just a little kid the whole move.
- 26:40It sounds like you might be a fan of.
- 26:42So I think we talked about this a little bit in the first go
- 26:45around. Harper Lee, the only book that
- 26:48was ever published by her was To Kill a Mockingbird.
- 26:50It was long rumored that she had an alternate version of it that
- 26:53she wrote as a first draft upon her.
- 26:56I don't think she was dead yet, but she was like incapacitated
- 26:59and it threw some various sketchy circumstances signed
- 27:02away her rights to this book. And they released this book in
- 27:062015 as a ghost set A Watchman was the name of the book.
- 27:11And in that book, an older scout is reminiscing about her growing
- 27:15up in Make Em. And Atticus Finch is like a
- 27:19virulent racist, like very much so.
- 27:23And he's portrayed as both a good dad and a good guy and also
- 27:27real racist. And people really struggled with
- 27:30this book. I I mean, I've heard it's not
- 27:32that good anyway. But like, now you've taken a
- 27:34true American literary hero and made him this racist guy for
- 27:39whom I don't even know what his arc looks like or if he's just,
- 27:42if it's just accepted as fact that he like doesn't like black
- 27:45people. But it it does kind of sound
- 27:48like a little bit what you're suggesting that like you need to
- 27:51give the main characters something to overcome rather
- 27:55than just be like this tabula rasa and like impartially
- 27:59observing everything. Yeah, I I would much rather
- 28:03Atticus start the movie as a racist and through his
- 28:07interactions with Tom Robinson and Helen, his wife and his
- 28:12family grow to a place of not just believing that Tom didn't
- 28:17do it, but recognizing that black people in the South in the
- 28:2330s are real human beings with desires and brokenness and and,
- 28:29and the full range of the human experience.
- 28:32And by the end of the film, he has become a new person with a
- 28:37vigor for bringing about justice in the world.
- 28:40I think that's a way more fascinating film.
- 28:43And I think that if that was true of the first half of the
- 28:46movie, then that courtroom scene where he is defending this black
- 28:51man not just because he has to, but because he wants to and
- 28:56believes in the cause, tell me that that's not way more
- 28:59emotionally powerful than in a scene that's already incredibly
- 29:04emotionally powerful. Yeah, man, I I think what we're
- 29:08both arriving at is that this is a Great American story and it's
- 29:12an important one, but that this adaptation needs a little
- 29:15something to tighten it up a bit.
- 29:17And I think, Brad, when we get back, we're going to talk about
- 29:20the best part of the movie, which is that courtroom
- 29:22sequence, which I might have a spicy take or two about as well.
- 29:26But before we get there, what do you say we drink this Tullamore
- 29:29do? I am so excited, Bob.
- 29:32Let's get to it. All right, so today we are
- 29:39checking out Tullamore DO, which is labeled as Tullamore DEW.
- 29:45There's little periods in between each letter.
- 29:47I have never known exactly if you're supposed to pronounce it
- 29:49do or DEW, but I'm looking at the Wikipedia now and it it
- 29:53lists it as do. We're going to go with
- 29:55Tullamore. Do Brad.
- 29:57It also like the actual branding has all of the letters being
- 30:04capitalized in Tolemore and do. But if you see it in like press
- 30:09releases, Tolemore is spelled normally with a capital T in all
- 30:12lowercase and then do is all capitalized correct?
- 30:17But it's almost like they're yelling at you like Tolemore do.
- 30:22They want to compete with Mountain Dew.
- 30:24You know this is the Tolemore do, damn it.
- 30:27Don't get it confused. So this is one of the world's
- 30:31most famous Irish whiskeys. We've obviously reviewed it
- 30:35before back in Season 1. We've done a couple other little
- 30:37offshoots of Tullamore Do that were finished in different kinds
- 30:40of barrels. I believe one of them was called
- 30:42like the Tullamore Do Caribbean Cask or something like that.
- 30:45We really liked that one. I'm excited to dive back into
- 30:48Tullamore Do because we have long lauded Jamieson as our
- 30:53favorite mass produced Irish whiskey, but Tullamore has
- 30:56always given it a run for its money, literally because they're
- 30:59like the same price and just because you and I appreciate a
- 31:03good budget pour of whiskey. Yeah, 100% Tullamore DO was
- 31:07recommended to me long, long time ago, like before we ever
- 31:12started the podcast. I remember telling a friend that
- 31:14I really like Jamieson. Jamieson and Ginger was like my
- 31:18go to drink and he told me why don't you try Tolmore do some
- 31:22time. It's like at the time it was
- 31:24like a few bucks cheaper than Jameson and I remember trying it
- 31:28and being a fan of it. So I like literally from like
- 31:322015, I want to say I've always been a fan of.
- 31:36Telemardu So this is a triple distilled Irish blended whiskey.
- 31:40It's a blend of malt whiskey, grain whiskey and pot still
- 31:44whiskey which are the three major categories in Irish
- 31:47whiskey. It is proofed all the way down
- 31:49to 80 proof and it is non age stated.
- 31:52So we have no idea how old this is, although I believe it has to
- 31:55be at least three years of age. So Brad, let's go ahead and dive
- 31:58into it. What are you picking up on the
- 32:00nose of Tullamore? Doo Doo more Doo.
- 32:04The nose here has some really nice lemongrass.
- 32:07It's like a little bit earthy, a little bit citrusy.
- 32:11The honey is there. There's a really strong, like, I
- 32:15don't know if I'm going to ruin this for you, Bob, but once I
- 32:17realized it, it's the only thing I could smell.
- 32:20It's got a really strong apple juice element on the nose,
- 32:26really pleasant, comes across nicely, very soft and gentle as
- 32:31you would expect from an 80 proof Irish whiskey.
- 32:34I'm going to give it a 7 out of 10 here.
- 32:37Yeah, I like this a lot. And I will say that the, I hate
- 32:41to call it cheap, but the cheapness comes through after a
- 32:44little while on Irish whiskey, Brad and I almost always get
- 32:47these like bright citrus, apple leaf.
- 32:51We get melon and we get like Peach pear.
- 32:53Sometimes those are like the, the big notes we get on Irish
- 32:56whiskey. Sometimes we get those on
- 32:58blended scotches as well. And what I found is that if
- 33:01that's going to be like your baseline for the nose, then the
- 33:04mark of quality is how long can it hang on to those kind of much
- 33:09more gentle, subtle notes as you knows it.
- 33:12And this one, it's right there up front.
- 33:14And then for me, 30 seconds in the grain whiskey in this really
- 33:18starts to take over and it's like a it, it just gets a little
- 33:22bit of a funk to it that may be coming from some of that pot
- 33:25still whiskey, but it just kind of smells like unflavored,
- 33:29unseasoned grain. And it starts to tip into like,
- 33:33oh, now I'm getting the ethanol notes.
- 33:35Now this smells a little bit harsher to me.
- 33:37So it's good for what it is. But like I I think even in the
- 33:41blind I could tell this is not a super expensive whiskey.
- 33:44I'm going to give it a 7 out of 10 on the nose as well.
- 33:48I think the palate is pleasant without being impressive.
- 33:52The apple juice is really, really strong here.
- 33:55It's got some really nice floral notes.
- 33:57There's honeydew. It doesn't get into the nice
- 34:01honey flavors that yeah, I really hoped for.
- 34:06It's pleasant and bright. I actually do like it a little
- 34:10more than the nose. It is very simple so I'm going
- 34:14to I'll bump up a tiny bit to a 7 1/2.
- 34:17Yeah, I'm going to. I mean, I think in terms of just
- 34:19pure enjoyment, this is like an 8 1/2 for me.
- 34:21I'm going to give it an 8 on flavor.
- 34:23It's simple, but once you kick it to the back of your pallet
- 34:28and the sort of like cigarette ashy notes start to come up that
- 34:31we get a lot on Irish whiskey, it's a really nice transition.
- 34:34It fades you into it very, very well.
- 34:37And I expected it to be a lot harsher and a lot more sudden
- 34:39for those kind of bitter notes to come out on the back.
- 34:43It doesn't do that. I am going to Ding it on finish
- 34:47because that's where the bitter notes really take over for me.
- 34:50It's a long lasting finish, but it's really grain forward.
- 34:53And it's, it's like straight ash for a little bit, quite a bit
- 34:57more bitter than I would have liked it to be.
- 34:59I'm just going to give it a 7 out of 10 on finish.
- 35:02Yeah, I I actually am lower than you on finish.
- 35:05I'm going to give it a six out of 10 here.
- 35:07I literally my first note is cigarette ash, like the IT is so
- 35:12ashy on the finish. There's some green apple, but
- 35:17like kind of like a sour, almost like an apple.
- 35:21You wouldn't quite want to eat type of sour green apple.
- 35:26There's just it. It drops off on the on the
- 35:30finish Bob. See, and that would be more
- 35:32forgivable when we keep the value in mind.
- 35:36I know we're still getting into balance here, but like a lot of
- 35:38times we say, OK, it's well balanced for a $20 whiskey.
- 35:42It's no longer a $20 whiskey. So I have to keep that in mind
- 35:45as well. But as much as I can say in a
- 35:47vacuum, is this a well balanced whiskey?
- 35:49No, not really. I'll give it a 6.
- 35:52I feel like that's probably a little bit generous, but this is
- 35:55like this is a below average whiskey.
- 35:57This is not what you want. You know, I would recommend you
- 36:00buy like a $40 Irish whiskey over this.
- 36:03I will help it out when we get to value, but right now we're
- 36:07just talking about in general. Is it well balanced?
- 36:10Probably not Brad. Yeah, I'm at a 6 1/2 on balance
- 36:14It it's interesting, but it's not complex in any way.
- 36:17I think value wise, this is sitting at $29.00 in the state
- 36:20of Ohio. This isn't a whiskey that's
- 36:23going to get gouged across the country.
- 36:25So I'm guessing you're going to see it anywhere from 28 to $30.
- 36:30I'll give it a 7 out of 10 on value.
- 36:33I I still think it's a good whiskey worth drinking, but
- 36:38there are better options. And I love what you said, Bob.
- 36:41I would I would push you towards a lot of like 38 to $42.00
- 36:45whiskeys before I would say go drink Tullamore dude.
- 36:50You said it's $29.00 now. Yes, Sir.
- 36:53Yeah, that's a 4 or 4 1/2 five. I'll give it a 5 out of 10 on
- 37:00value. I mean like Jameson's the same
- 37:03price. I do think Jameson's better than
- 37:04this. If Tullamore do was undercutting
- 37:06them by 5 bucks, it'd be a great value.
- 37:10I'm sure this is a good mixer. I think if you wanted to throw
- 37:12it in with some like apple cider or something in the fall would
- 37:15be really, really good with those apple notes in it.
- 37:17But $30.00 for a mixer is kind of pushing the upper limits of
- 37:20what a mixer should cost. And at that point, if you're
- 37:23going to be doing that, I'm with Brad just, you know, save up 10
- 37:27more dollars and get something that's good meat.
- 37:29So that's taking me to a 33 out of 50.
- 37:32Brad, where are you at? A point higher I'm at 34 out of
- 37:3550. So that takes us to just a 67
- 37:38out of 100 or a 33 1/2 out of 50 on average.
- 37:44Do I recommend this? It's a soft no.
- 37:48Like I think I would pass and get something else.
- 37:50It's not like offensively bad. I I'm not offended by the price
- 37:54of it. I just think it's slightly
- 37:55overpriced for a slightly below average whiskey.
- 37:58Yeah, if you are experienced in the world of Irish whiskey, I
- 38:02would say pass on this. If you are looking to try Irish
- 38:05whiskey for the first time, check out what it's all about.
- 38:08Like you can find a 50ML of this for like $1.52 bucks.
- 38:15I'd say go buy a 50ML, pour it, enjoy it, try it out.
- 38:19It's going to be worth that. And if you like it then keep a
- 38:23bottle of it on your bar. It's not that expensive.
- 38:26All right, Brad, let's get back into talking about To Kill a
- 38:28Mockingbird. What do you say?
- 38:30Let's get to it. All right, everybody, That was
- 38:37Tola more. Do do do.
- 38:43You know what? You haven't been doing well at
- 38:45this this year, Bob. Do you know what it's time to do
- 38:49now? It's time for 2 facts and a
- 38:52falsehood, Brad. Is it's going to try to stump
- 38:56you ball 2 are right and what is wrong?
- 39:022 facts and a falsehood. 2 facts and a falsehood is the part of
- 39:05the show where Brad presents me with three items as fact about
- 39:09the making of this movie, one of which is a complete lie and I
- 39:13have to determine which one that is.
- 39:15Brad, you've gotten me a couple times this season.
- 39:19I I don't know about this one. There's a lot of directions you
- 39:22could go because it's very famous movie, won a lot of
- 39:26Oscars, but there's also the whole literary adaptation
- 39:29background. And I definitely didn't do
- 39:31enough research to cover all these bases.
- 39:33So you, you might get me today, dude.
- 39:36I am ready to do you in Bob. All righty fact #1 The watch
- 39:45used in the film was a prop, but Harper Lee gave Gregory Peck her
- 39:49father's watch, who she based Atticus Finch off of after the
- 39:53film was completed because he reminded her so much of her
- 39:57father. Fact #2A scouting agency was
- 40:00instructed to find as naturalistic of actors as they
- 40:04could find for the main children in the film and conducted
- 40:07interviews with over 400 children before settling on Mary
- 40:11Badham and Philip Alford as Scout and Jem Finch.
- 40:16Fact #3 Philip Alford told his mother that he did not want to
- 40:19go to the auditions for the part of Jem Finch, but when his
- 40:22mother told him that he would miss half a day of school if he
- 40:24went, he immediately decided to go.
- 40:30OK, they all sound very plausible so I will give you
- 40:34your kudos for that. Remind me real quick #1 again.
- 40:39The watch was a prop, but she gave the real 1.
- 40:45I'm gravitating towards either one or three as the lie.
- 40:49So if you're doing a little dance because number 2 is the
- 40:52lie you already have, you've gotten me already.
- 40:56I'm going to say I'm going to say #1 is the falsehood.
- 41:03But I have no basis for that other than it just seems like
- 41:06the most made-up PR thing that I could think of.
- 41:11Bob, you are wrong. That was a true statement.
- 41:17Number 2 was the falsehood. Oh wow.
- 41:19OK, there you go. I don't feel like I often just
- 41:22like so completely pull the wool over your eyes that you
- 41:25immediately are like, oh that falsehood totally a fact.
- 41:30It just seemed like, you know, the most asinine of the of the
- 41:33bunch. So yeah, 400 kids got
- 41:35interviewed. Cool.
- 41:37That's exactly what my high school teachers told me about
- 41:40me, the most asinine of the bunch.
- 41:42That was that was what you won in your yearbook as a senior,
- 41:45right? Most likely to be asinine.
- 41:49Of the bunch. Of the bunch, sure All right
- 41:52man, let's dive back into To Kill a Mockingbird now the most
- 41:56famous sequence of this movie, and arguably it's best, is the
- 41:59courtroom sequence in the middle.
- 42:02I guess the second third of the film.
- 42:03It's about 35 minutes long. It is a powerhouse of early 60s
- 42:09cinema. It's a great courtroom sequence.
- 42:12I said I'd have some spicy takes.
- 42:14I'll just kind of get this out of the way now.
- 42:16It's so completely changes the perspective of the film that it
- 42:22does kind of bother me that they don't cut away to the kids more
- 42:25often or have camera setups in the balcony looking down at the
- 42:29proceedings from their point of view more often.
- 42:32Yeah. And I think that that gets to
- 42:33your point, Brad, about kind of undermining that this is a story
- 42:36told through children's eyes because it is told literally at
- 42:40the eye level of Atticus Finch for 35 minutes in a row.
- 42:44And he becomes the actual, like, subject of the film.
- 42:48And I think that that really does bother me.
- 42:50Like if this is a movie about kids learning through the their
- 42:53own eyes what's around them, then you got to actually like
- 42:56put the camera in the point of view of the children more often.
- 42:59I mean, I would argue that Atticus Finch is the subject of
- 43:02the entire film, and I think that's why Boo Radley just kind
- 43:07of isn't a great addition to the story.
- 43:09I think at the end of the day, this movie is not interested in
- 43:14reality. It's interested in creating a
- 43:17mythological figure that we ought all to strive towards
- 43:22Aspiration. Yeah.
- 43:24Like Atticus Finch is a an Odysseus type character for
- 43:31modern Americans to strive towards in the way that they
- 43:35treat black people. Like if you are talking about
- 43:39the perfect person in regards to race relations, you have to talk
- 43:44about Atticus Finch. Now you're saying, like, let me,
- 43:46I don't mean to interrupt you, but like what you're saying is
- 43:49that's how the movie's putting him forth.
- 43:51Not necessarily that like Atticus Finch is Odysseus, but
- 43:54that the movie portrays him as that.
- 43:57Yeah, portrays him as a mythological aspirational figure
- 44:03that we should learn from and try to emulate in our own lives.
- 44:09And so for me, the the courtroom sequence not being shot from the
- 44:13children's point of view, while it is tonally a massive shift
- 44:18from the rest of the movie, I think it's like betraying what
- 44:22the movie is really about. Like, the movie's never about
- 44:25the kids. The movie has always been about
- 44:28Atticus Finch. OK, well, I think maybe that's a
- 44:32good place to kind of talk a little bit about Gregory Peck,
- 44:35who wins the Academy Award in 1962 for best actor.
- 44:39This is one of the most fondly remembered performances in
- 44:44American film history, and I think for good reason.
- 44:47There's a really a really good quote from Pauline Kael, who
- 44:50didn't love this movie. And she says Gregory Peck was
- 44:54better than usual, but in that same virtuously doll way.
- 44:58And I will say I kind of see where she's coming from a little
- 45:01bit. I don't find Gregory Peck to be
- 45:03a particularly charismatic actor.
- 45:06But what I do find is that in this movie, more than others, he
- 45:10has just the slightest little facial tics or expressions.
- 45:14Or can he glance sideways real briefly in a way that clues you
- 45:19into how knowing he is as a character?
- 45:22I do think it's just it's a phenomenal performance even from
- 45:26an actor that I don't really love outside of this movie.
- 45:30Oh, it's such an incredible performance.
- 45:32Like the amount of emotion that he lays into his speeches, his
- 45:38questioning that lies under the surface of a cool, calm,
- 45:43collected lawyer like it. It deserves every bit of
- 45:48recognition it gets as just a superb performance in a
- 45:53courtroom drama scene. And then it's undermined when
- 45:58the script asks him to like, gently consider a glass, an
- 46:04empty glass and throw it at his defendant Where I'm like, OK,
- 46:11come on. Here's my spicy, spicy take
- 46:13about the courtroom scene. I I got real bored during
- 46:17Atticus Finch's closing statements.
- 46:20I think that in 1962, like having a white man advocate for
- 46:26a black man is compelling stuff in general.
- 46:29But I'm like, as he continues to be like, you know, she was a
- 46:35Sinner and what was her sin? Why tempting a black man and why
- 46:40did she tempt a black man? Why?
- 46:41Because it was like, Oh my God, dude, just stop.
- 46:44Like make your point and sit down, bro.
- 46:46And and he has that real famous line where, you know, in the
- 46:50name of God, do your duty. It's great.
- 46:53It's fantastic. That's it's one line amongst a
- 46:57sea of exposition that I wish was shorter.
- 47:00I like there's just a couple moments, even in that courtroom
- 47:03scene that I think you could trim up if you really wanted to
- 47:06tighten up this movie a bit. Yeah, I, Bob, I am not
- 47:10disagreeing with you at all. I, I, I think that it's a great
- 47:15bit of acting. There's a lot of great moments,
- 47:17but once again, it just feels like Mulligan.
- 47:21As a director, Are you ready for this?
- 47:25Ought to have taken a few mulligans.
- 47:28And yet, Brad, to Mulligan's credit, I think that everybody
- 47:34that gets up on the stand in the courtroom sequence is like
- 47:38nominate this person for an Academy Award level performance.
- 47:43It's like the it's like the wife in network winning for like a 4
- 47:48minute scene. I mean, like Bob Yule, really
- 47:52villainous villain. You know, his face kind of
- 47:54reminds me a little bit of Robert Patrick, the guy that
- 47:57played the T1000 in Terminator 2.
- 48:00But like when he gets older and he's like the mean dad and walk
- 48:04the line, like, sure. I just think that if you're
- 48:06remaking this movie, Robert Patrick is Bob Yule.
- 48:09All of a sudden they come back with a not guilty verdict and he
- 48:12starts like morphing and shape shifting.
- 48:16I think that Maeela Yule, that is like you, you think that
- 48:21you've reached the pinnacle of like how powerful a performance
- 48:23can get because she's clearly lying.
- 48:25She's clearly under duress. And then she snaps at everybody
- 48:28with that, like, you know, it'll all be for nothing and storms
- 48:33off. And then they put Tom Robinson
- 48:35on the stand and Oh my gosh, what a heart wrenching 10
- 48:41minutes that is, man. Dude, like what a performance
- 48:46what it is. Brock Peters is so relatable and
- 48:53honest and open and vulnerable and kind and like if the goal of
- 49:00the movie is to present the image of how evil it is, To Kill
- 49:06a Mockingbird, he. Nails it.
- 49:09Yeah, it. I mean, it might be pound for
- 49:12pound, it might be the best performance in the movie.
- 49:14I I think it might actually be better than Gregory Peck.
- 49:17And Gregory Peck is fantastic, but Brock Peters on the stand
- 49:21when he is finally asked, did you rape Maela Yule?
- 49:24And he's breaking down crying, saying, I did not, Sir.
- 49:27Like, it is just that is, that is to me, that's the indelible
- 49:31image of this movie. And I think that once you leave
- 49:34that courtroom scene and you get the news about Tom Robinson
- 49:38dying, it's really crushing. And you're kind of wondering,
- 49:42where's the movie going to go from here?
- 49:45And it makes sense where the movie has gone 20 minutes later
- 49:49when it's over and they put a bow on what you've just watched
- 49:52for the prior 20 minutes. But that transition from Tom
- 49:56Robinson is dead to, like, Scout in a ham costume.
- 50:00I'm like, what are we doing? Why is this still going on?
- 50:04Wasn't that the end of the movie?
- 50:06And, and again, like, you get the closing 45 seconds of Scout
- 50:11narrating and that beautiful score, and, you know, her
- 50:15saying, like, I would look back on this summer and Tom Robinson
- 50:18and Boo Radley. And then it fades to Atticus in
- 50:21the window and he's hugging her. And it does get me.
- 50:24Like, it's an emotional moment. I cry at the end of this movie,
- 50:27but I cry because the filmmaking is so good in the last minute
- 50:30and a half, not because of the 20 minutes that have preceded
- 50:34it. Yeah, the, the final bit of this
- 50:38movie is terrible, Bob. It's it's not good the whole
- 50:42scene. And once again, I think
- 50:45Mulligan's hands are kind of tied here by the source material
- 50:49that she's in this stupid ham costume.
- 50:52And, and once again, we've returned to the, we're going to
- 50:55show this from her viewpoint, which means we can't really show
- 50:58any of the fighting. The, the whole thing isn't good.
- 51:04It's not good visual storytelling.
- 51:07Like you said, I think that in a book format, it makes a lot of
- 51:11sense. In a visual medium, it's boring
- 51:16and doesn't come across well. And I, I just, I really
- 51:20struggled with the final bit of this film because I'll go back
- 51:25to my main point. Nobody changes in the film.
- 51:28Everybody is who they are. And the the tragedy of the film
- 51:34is that Atticus Finch, the pinnacle of someone using
- 51:42whatever power and influence he has to defend those who are
- 51:46underrepresented, fails. And like that like, that's the
- 51:51brutality of the movie. And so to tack on this thing
- 51:55where, you know, Gem and Scout are attacked and, you know, Oh,
- 52:00well, now that now that Tom Robinson has been killed and the
- 52:07person who had him killed is killed, like that's just this
- 52:11baby. Like they got each other in the
- 52:13end. I, it just feels I, I don't
- 52:17know. I really did not like the ending
- 52:20of this film, despite the fact that Robert Duvall gives a great
- 52:24silent film performance. Good old Robert Duvall.
- 52:29All right, man. I think it's time for us to get
- 52:30to our last segment of the day, which we call Let's make it a
- 52:34double. We're near the end of the
- 52:36episodes of Things, listening to the film and Whiskey Show.
- 52:39Let's pair another film with this one.
- 52:41Even if it's struggling. It's the final segment of the
- 52:43day. Now let's make it a double.
- 52:45Let's Make It a Double is the part of the show where we pick a
- 52:48movie to pair up with this one to make the perfect double
- 52:51feature, Right. There's a lot of directions you
- 52:53can go here. I mean, we haven't really talked
- 52:55about the year in film. That was 1962.
- 52:58It is one of the best years in cinema history.
- 53:02I mean, we've we've only done a couple of films from this year
- 53:05on the podcast, but the big one that took all of To Kill a
- 53:08Mockingbird's awards away was Lawrence of Arabia.
- 53:12So if you just wanted to do a really, really long 1962 double
- 53:16feature, I guess you could pair it up with that 4 hour movie.
- 53:19But I'm really curious, man, where are you going to go with
- 53:21your? Let's make it a double today.
- 53:24Oh, this is a tough one, Bob. I I don't know, I like, there's
- 53:30a few places I could go. I, I think I'm going to go with
- 53:35a movie that I think takes what happens here in this movie and
- 53:39does it better. I'm going to go with 12 Angry
- 53:42Men. I like I texted you jokingly
- 53:46throughout the film when I was watching it and said I want to
- 53:50see the companion movie to this 12 Angry White Men about the
- 53:54deliberation that happens for the Tom Robinson case.
- 53:58I think at the end of the day, 12 Angry Men takes the same
- 54:02premise on what if somebody used their voice to give a voice to
- 54:09somebody who's underrepresented and somebody who general society
- 54:14views as lesser. Like 12 Angry Men does that in a
- 54:19really beautiful and raw and honest way, and it's way more
- 54:26concise about it. So I just, I think 12 Angry Men
- 54:31would be a really good companion piece to this film.
- 54:34This movie has one of the best remembered scores of any film.
- 54:38And I'm, I'm just wondering like we, we only really talk about
- 54:41the score of a movie when it's your boy John Williams.
- 54:46You know, there were moments in this movie where it really
- 54:48reminded me. This movie was scored by Elmer
- 54:50Bernstein. It reminded me of Leonard
- 54:53Bernstein's score for On the waterfront a little bit.
- 54:57And I thought that some of the more documentary feel elements
- 55:00would make a really good let's make it a 22.
- 55:02But I think ultimately what I was thinking about most was the
- 55:06narration part of the movie. And I hate the narrator of this
- 55:09movie. I hate the way she talks so much
- 55:11Brett, like from the very beginning when she goes make
- 55:15them was a tired Old Town. I'm like, oh God, I've been for
- 55:19two hours of this dude. But there's like this small
- 55:23subgenre of movies that are like movies that take place over the
- 55:27course of a summer or a year about a kid and and his older
- 55:33version or her older version is narrating it and it's.
- 55:35Like say, like my dog Skip. Yeah, it was actually my pick.
- 55:38My dog Skip is mine. Let's make it a double.
- 55:41Is it? It really was, because here's
- 55:44the only movies I could think of that fit in this small subgenre.
- 55:47It's To Kill a Mockingbird. There's a movie from the 80s
- 55:50called My Favorite Year. The Sandlot fits into this.
- 55:54A Christmas Story. They're all like the same cheesy
- 55:57narrator over children learning things.
- 56:00And I think the one that's closest to this is my dog Skip,
- 56:04where instead of, you know, weird racist lessons happening,
- 56:09it's just a dog. It's just a dog teaching your
- 56:11life lessons, so there. I can't believe you picked it
- 56:14before I even got to it, but that's my pick.
- 56:16That I feel prescient, Bob I 100%.
- 56:21All the movies that like, that's crazy dude.
- 56:27I did not know how I picked that out.
- 56:29I haven't thought about my dog Skip since I watched it as like
- 56:33an 8 year old. Oh man, I think that might be
- 56:40the best pick in our history of let's make it a.
- 56:43Double why thank you so much, Sir.
- 56:44Simply for the fact that I called it out.
- 56:48All right, man, let's give this movie some final scores.
- 56:50I'm going to give this an 8 1/2. I was at a 10 out of 10 for the
- 56:541st 10 minutes of the movie. It bounced back up to like a
- 56:57nine a couple times and then it just keeps tripping over itself
- 57:01on the way to the finish line. I feel like.
- 57:04And any time we're watching a movie that is at least 60 years
- 57:08old like this, you have to remember that it's only the good
- 57:11ones that have even survived this long.
- 57:13So yes, the pacing seems slow, but that's, I mean, that's just
- 57:17old movies, man. And I I'm not, I'm not usually
- 57:19the guy that talks about how old movies are different than new
- 57:21movies. But let's be real here.
- 57:24Even with that taken into consideration, you know, I
- 57:28mentioned On the Waterfront, I think On the Waterfront's a
- 57:30better movie than this. I think it accomplishes what it
- 57:32wants to do better than this. And it's eight years older than
- 57:35To Kill a Mockingbird. So with that caveat, that's an 8
- 57:391/2 for me, Brad. See, I I actually, I didn't even
- 57:43think about the pacing in the film.
- 57:44I like, I think the problem with the movie is way more
- 57:48structural, where the scenes themselves don't matter in a lot
- 57:54of ways. And so whether or not it's paced
- 57:57well doesn't really matter to me.
- 57:58I think that the movie struggles to understand what it's really
- 58:03about and the, the cinematography and the viewpoint
- 58:08of the camera and the viewpoint of the narration is like taking
- 58:13you away from what I think the script is actually trying to
- 58:17say. And so it just feels like the
- 58:19whole movie is a clash of, of, of visions of what they're
- 58:24trying to do. I am going to give this a 7 out
- 58:27of 10. 7 out of 10. OK, so that takes us to what, a
- 58:337.75 out of 10? On average, we are below the
- 58:38IMDb average on this movie, which is I believe an 8.3.
- 58:42So folks, this is probably our hottest take yet this season.
- 58:46I mean, I can't, I can't think of anything else that would be
- 58:48hotter unless you want to count Brad's many times that he has
- 58:52given Goodfellas like an 8 or an 8.5.
- 58:56But we want to know what you think.
- 58:57Is To Kill a Mockingbird still the classic that it's always
- 59:00been regarded as or is it closer to Brad's 7 out of 10?
- 59:04You can let us know at any of our social media accounts,
- 59:07Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tiktok or YouTube.
- 59:12Film whiskey or you can join the conversation on discord.
- 59:16We have an entire server dedicated talking about movies,
- 59:19whiskey, and anything else you really want to bring U.
- 59:22So if you would like to join that conversation, you can find
- 59:25a link to our Discord at the end of every single one of our show
- 59:28notes. Well, we have made it through
- 59:30the gauntlet of one movie about racism, and we're doing it again
- 59:33next week, Brad, because it's time for us to revisit that
- 59:37infamous Best Picture winner, Green Book.
- 59:41So we'll be back next week to talk about Green Book, but until
- 59:44then, I'm Bob Book. I'm Brad Gee.
- 59:46And we'll see you next time.