Latest / CXOTalk / Enterprise AI: A Board of Directors Perspective | #866
Transcript
- 0:00How are boards of directors approaching enterprise AI and AI
- 0:04adoption in the enterprise? And what should boards do about
- 0:09members who don't understand technology?
- 0:12Let's get into it on CXO Talk number 866 with Adriana
- 0:17Karaboutis. She's an independent board
- 0:20member across multiple industries who has also held
- 0:24senior leadership roles at companies like Dell, Biogen, A,
- 0:28National Grid. Where are we in terms of
- 0:33adoption of AI in the enterprise?
- 0:36What are what are you seeing right now?
- 0:38It is different by industry and different by company, but one
- 0:42thing that is absolutely consistent, it is permeating and
- 0:46growing by the day. Current state of adoption I
- 0:50would say is different by industry.
- 0:52Tech and software clearly leading the path.
- 0:55It's part of the fabric of what they're doing, Virtual
- 0:57assistants, chat bots, AI driven cloud services, etcetera.
- 1:03Financial services, another industry way up there relative
- 1:06to their adoption around fraud management, using it to check
- 1:10algorithms, healthcare being pressured and using it quite a
- 1:15bit. And then you see some of the,
- 1:16and you also have retail and manufacturing and then you see
- 1:19some of the, I wouldn't call them laggards, Michael, but I
- 1:22would call them a little bit slower to adopt your regulatory
- 1:26environments or governments and you know, maybe some of the
- 1:30agricultural components or industries in agriculture in
- 1:36terms of adoption inside the companies.
- 1:39In other words, as these companies and industries are
- 1:43trying to drive AI and really become consumers of it,
- 1:48internally, you still have about a 104040 ton split where it's
- 1:5310% experts, 40% kind of people that are experimenting or in the
- 1:58novice phase, and then 10% that are actually still very reticent
- 2:04to adopt. They're the laggards.
- 2:06Oh, we shouldn't use this, shut it down, etcetera.
- 2:09Some of that coming from lack of education or, or understanding
- 2:13of it, I would say, and some of it just coming from an abundance
- 2:16of being overly conservative and cautious.
- 2:19So there's quite a spread. But one thing's for sure and
- 2:22it's what I said at the start, the the adoption is going faster
- 2:26and faster and faster. We're moving quickly, Michael.
- 2:29When we talk about large organizations, what do you see
- 2:33as the drivers of AI adoption and also the obstacles or the
- 2:39roadblocks? The drivers is around
- 2:42competitive pressures companies, especially public and private
- 2:45companies, I shouldn't say especially public, but companies
- 2:48are always looking to do more with less to have higher
- 2:52quality, higher cost, customer satisfaction, employee
- 2:55satisfaction, returns for shareholders.
- 2:58So all the stakeholders are looking for better, more
- 3:03improved, etcetera. So those pressures that cause
- 3:06you to look at tools and capabilities that will help you
- 3:10achieve that. And so that's some of the
- 3:12drivers. And as peers in industries adopt
- 3:16more of these tools and are able to actually show more capability
- 3:21and more of the outcomes that we're looking for, then that
- 3:24drives competitive pressures to all the companies in that
- 3:27industry to stay abreast and continue to improve.
- 3:31Some of it is around newer products and offerings.
- 3:34Some of it is around, you know, getting a better bottom line,
- 3:37which is cost efficiency, reduced SGNA costs, etcetera.
- 3:43Some of the roadblocks is around, it is changed and there
- 3:48is just human nature and reticence to adopt.
- 3:51Michael lack of skills and understanding of the tools and
- 3:55technology. Risk aversion and boards in
- 3:58particular have a big, big role to play around risk management
- 4:03and making sure that the company is within what we call risk
- 4:08appetite and that anything that is adopted or happens stays
- 4:12within that risk appetite. Whether you're talking about
- 4:15cyber etcetera, and in particular with artificial
- 4:19intelligence and tools, there's ethical issues, there's privacy,
- 4:23there's security, there's ensuring there's no bias and
- 4:28fairness, etcetera. Regulatory compliance, legal
- 4:31compliance, all of those things are huge and, you know, could be
- 4:36seen as roadblocks to overcome, but certainly slow, slow us down
- 4:42in our thinking and sort of our foray into artificial
- 4:45intelligence. Andy, you talk a lot about risk.
- 4:52Of course, AI is all about innovation, and innovation
- 4:58implies something new that's changing and that's different,
- 5:02which of course is risk. And so as a board member, how do
- 5:08you see this balance? Boards are around governance and
- 5:14ensuring the company has the right strategy.
- 5:16Management teams do day-to-day operations and execute the
- 5:20strategy. So as board members, we concern
- 5:23ourselves with do we have the right strategy in order to meet
- 5:28our stakeholder commitments and the outcomes that we want,
- 5:31right. And so we, we have a unique
- 5:34position. It's not overlapping with
- 5:36management. It augments management.
- 5:38There's a trust and a relationship and A and A and a
- 5:41collaboration that needs to happen with management.
- 5:45Many have heard the expression noses in and fingers out that
- 5:48sort of is the layman's expression for a board.
- 5:51In other words, we ensure we govern, we oversight, etcetera
- 5:55and we ensure that risk management is, as I said before,
- 5:59within an appetite level that we that that we set for the
- 6:05company. So in that sense, boards
- 6:09increasingly recognize the impact of AI and everything that
- 6:13we do should be in line with our business strategy, our
- 6:17regulatory requirements, our legal requirements, etcetera.
- 6:22And so we always make sure that how a management team is going
- 6:27to execute to deliver a strategy is within those parameters.
- 6:31Can you dive into that tension between the desire to make use
- 6:38of that technology to achieve the organizational objectives
- 6:42and strategy versus the restraining factors due to the
- 6:48risks? I'll use a comparison that
- 6:51should make it clear. Sports teams don't just play
- 6:55offensive plays, they have defensive plays.
- 6:59So in order to win the game, you go on offense and defense, right
- 7:04offenses. We tried things new.
- 7:06We looked at technology to help us meet or exceed our business
- 7:12stated goals and objectives. And interestingly enough, when
- 7:16board directors were asked by an organization called North
- 7:19America Corporate Directors, what are the trends they worry
- 7:23about most? Tech, AI and cyber, we're in the
- 7:26top six along with geopolitical, climate, et cetera.
- 7:30So given that when we think about that, we we worry about it
- 7:34in a defensive play to ensure that as I said before, we're
- 7:38staying in position in order to stay within risk appetite.
- 7:42We also want to leverage those tools and we want to see our
- 7:45companies and management leveraging the tools to
- 7:49accelerate and or meet of the business strategy.
- 7:53So there's the offensive and the defensive.
- 7:55It's a 360 degree wide angle lens and it's critically
- 7:59important that boards don't fall into one which could if it's
- 8:04offensive, you could end up with a lot of privacy regulatory
- 8:08etcetera issues or the other where we're trying to preserve
- 8:11our way. We lock everything out.
- 8:14We don't let we say we don't want to bring, for example,
- 8:17generative AI tools into the company or machine learning,
- 8:21earning artificial intelligence because we don't want to run the
- 8:24risk. Nobody ever cost cut or risk
- 8:27avoided their weight of prosperity.
- 8:29So there is that balance and informed decision making is
- 8:33critical, making sure that parameters are understood for
- 8:38how is a company using AI? Do they have a group that says
- 8:42we're looking at the use cases for what we want to do, What are
- 8:46the risks of the use cases and what are the benefits of the use
- 8:50cases? Those are very important things
- 8:52for management and in large scale applications for boards to
- 8:56worry about as well. So it's that balanced, informed
- 9:00decision making, offensive and defensive place in order to win
- 9:04the game. Please subscribe to the CXO Talk
- 9:08newsletter. Just go to cxotalk.com,
- 9:11subscribe to our YouTube channel.
- 9:13We really have extraordinary shows that are coming up, great
- 9:16discussions and you should be a part of it.
- 9:19Folks. You know, to some extent it
- 9:22sounds like the the time of the beginning of social media.
- 9:26There needs to be a a kind of more thoughtful, in depth
- 9:31approach that addresses the reality of how people live and
- 9:35work. Technology is ubiquitous.
- 9:37We've heard that before. It is.
- 9:41We're led by what individuals do.
- 9:44I would say a great proportion of the population now, at least
- 9:48in the US are using, you know, ChatGPT, Dali, We've seen
- 9:53students at school, you know, you using this to write papers,
- 9:57etcetera. The exposure is there.
- 10:01Therefore, when people go to the office, we don't turn that off,
- 10:06right? And we look for tools enabled by
- 10:10the tech organization, etcetera to be able to help deliver the
- 10:14outcomes. I fundamentally believe people
- 10:16always want to do the right thing, but they want to be
- 10:18helpful and they want to be productive and they want to
- 10:21deliver the outcomes or I should say, and they want to be
- 10:24helpful, productive and deliver outcomes.
- 10:26These tools enable that. So organizations need to say yes
- 10:32and how versus no because right. And so how do you, and again, it
- 10:38goes back to my offensive, defensive play, but within these
- 10:41larger organizations, how do we deliver the capabilities to use
- 10:47generative AI to create new content, right?
- 10:51Text to photo, to create, you know, illustrations that could
- 10:55help new products, new services. So unfortunately, regulatory
- 11:01lags behind sometimes the infrastructure of these large
- 11:05companies, which is important by the way, to be able to renew and
- 11:08refresh so that you've got good clean, concise date, not
- 11:13concise, but good clean data accessible to be there.
- 11:18All of that has to be in place. And so we need to think about
- 11:21these tools are here, they are coming in.
- 11:23If we don't enable them within the enterprise, you know, the
- 11:27worst of all worlds is where people take data.
- 11:31And I'm not saying anybody's done this, but we did see it
- 11:33some years ago in with Samsung, you know, hopefully done it
- 11:37inadvertently where people take data to the outside into these
- 11:41tools to either create code or get insights and then bring it
- 11:44back in. You have now exposed potentially
- 11:48companies secure, secure information and confidential
- 11:51information to the outside. So it has to be how do we bring
- 11:55in not how do we create steel walls so people can't access
- 11:59these tools, you know, for a period of 10 or 20 days.
- 12:03I mean when I was at one of my former companies, I said we're
- 12:07going to lock down for a period of 10 or 15 days.
- 12:09But we let the workforce know this is coming.
- 12:12We just need to bring in our own instance to ensure that we keep
- 12:16the security and the safety end. And by the way, that is a really
- 12:19important point, Michael. Communication on how, when, how
- 12:24far, which data is available, etcetera, is super important
- 12:28because absent communication, employees may not know what they
- 12:33can or can't do or what they should or shouldn't do.
- 12:36And so all of that is critically important.
- 12:39I really like the not defaulting to know for so many years,
- 12:45enterprise technologists, CIOs, just simply the default answer
- 12:49if somebody wants something new is, well, no, we can't do it.
- 12:53And then later, you know, we can take a look and see, well, maybe
- 12:55we can do it, but but the default is no.
- 12:57And so I really like your approach.
- 13:01Why don't we jump to some questions from LinkedIn and
- 13:06Twitter. There's a bunch that are coming
- 13:08in and I encourage everybody who's watching ask your
- 13:13questions because literally when else will you be able to ask
- 13:18somebody like Andy Karaboutis pretty much whatever you want.
- 13:22So take advantage of it. OK, So the first question comes
- 13:26from Isaac Sokolik, who actually will be a guest coming up very
- 13:32soon on CXO Talk. And he says, where are the
- 13:36board's mindsets today on AI? Is it a gold rush for
- 13:41competitive advantage or are they looking for pragmatic ROI?
- 13:47Or how are boards relating to AI?
- 13:50Software tech companies, I think are rushing for advantage.
- 13:53No question. We're taking a look whether it's
- 13:55the Microsoft's, the the Googles, etcetera and and
- 13:59beyond. They're really taking a look at
- 14:01how they can leverage AI for competitive advantage.
- 14:04And I would imagine that the board conversations are full of
- 14:09discussion around the opportunity as well as the risk.
- 14:14But on that topic, as you move into what I would call the more
- 14:19traditional businesses, I think the discussions are still
- 14:22happening and some board members are quite bullish around what
- 14:27are the advantages, what can we use, how can it help us.
- 14:31That's the big thing. How does it help us top line,
- 14:34bottom line, customer sat, employee satisfaction, you know,
- 14:39job availability, etcetera. But it's an intellectual
- 14:43curiosity that is actually something that I think is
- 14:47necessary of any board member. And so the conversations are
- 14:51there. Most boards are asking for more
- 14:54training in some of the more traditional businesses, training
- 14:58and understanding. Now, they don't need to
- 15:00understand, you know, how you ingest data and all of the bits
- 15:03and bytes, but they do need to understand the fundamentals
- 15:06around, you know, what are the prerequisites.
- 15:09As I said before, your infrastructure needs to be
- 15:12simplified. Your data needs to be available.
- 15:14And by the way, this is a huge opportunity for the, you know,
- 15:19technical CIOCTOS in the room figure out and practice your
- 15:24game on how to communicate because boards are asking for
- 15:27the education. Please don't bury them.
- 15:30Stroke us in a bunch of tech speak around neural networks,
- 15:34etcetera, practice your game to really be able to explain these
- 15:39the, the, the technology, the capability, the risks and how we
- 15:44could help your specific company and industry.
- 15:47That may be the difference between true success and what
- 15:50I'll call quick, faster success and versus a prolonged sort of
- 15:56realization of value. So Isaac, it varies is what I
- 16:00would say. I really want to emphasize a
- 16:03point you just made around the importance of simple,
- 16:09straightforward, clear communication and how important
- 16:14that is. Absolutely, Michael, you know
- 16:17what my teams would would recognize and probably smile at
- 16:21the next phrase I'm going to make.
- 16:22I always say, please start me with the forest before you take
- 16:26me to photosynthesis, right? So understand the big umbrella,
- 16:30even if when it's explaining artificial intelligence, it's
- 16:33the overarching umbrella. And then there's machine
- 16:35learning and there's, you know, all of the categories they
- 16:38generative AI, gentic AI, et cetera.
- 16:41And so when you take a board that is noses and fingers out,
- 16:47that has to really figure out and synthesize a lot of
- 16:52information, comprehend it and come into insight, they need to,
- 16:56you have to ask yourself, what do they need to know?
- 16:59And you know, what do they need? What do they need for informed
- 17:03decision making? And so that's a big capability
- 17:06that, you know, I'll put my CIOCTO hat on.
- 17:10We as technology people need to work on in order to help the
- 17:13boards be supportive and be able to balance that offensive, you
- 17:18know, with defensive play. You know, I just this morning
- 17:21saw a segment from an interview with Sam Altman, the founder CEO
- 17:28of Open AI, and he said that among startup founders, 1
- 17:35consistent trait among every single successful founder is the
- 17:41ability to summarize and express what they're doing in 25 words
- 17:48or less in a really clear way. Absolutely right.
- 17:52You know, call it the elevator pitch, call it the, you know, in
- 17:5610 seconds you've lost my attention call, you know,
- 17:59whatever it is, but be very clear.
- 18:02And you know, there's the old advantage of what do I want to
- 18:05say versus what do others need to understand?
- 18:08And by the way, who are they? That's super important.
- 18:12So I can't emphasize enough and and it's with any big
- 18:17breakthrough tech or any big concept, even if it isn't tech,
- 18:21you have to be able to really communicate what are we trying
- 18:24to do? You know, how are we going to do
- 18:26it? And then I'll quote Simon Sinek
- 18:28and connect people to the Y, right.
- 18:31And so that doesn't, that doesn't change for board members
- 18:34either. Let's jump to the next question
- 18:37from LinkedIn and keep your questions coming on LinkedIn and
- 18:41on Twitter. And this is from Deepak Adina
- 18:45Reyana. And Deepak says, how do you
- 18:48measure the success of AI initiatives at the board level?
- 18:52And what metrics or indicators do you rely on to ensure these
- 18:58technologies are delivering both value and alignment to the
- 19:03company's long term vision? As with any initiative, major
- 19:09program or effort or transformation that we do at,
- 19:14you know, a major, bigger, big or small companies, there is an
- 19:18expected outcome. And when you embark on something
- 19:22like this, which is a huge investment for the company from
- 19:25and I don't just mean you know monetary, but resource culture
- 19:29change, effort, discomfort, etcetera, there's an outcome
- 19:34that's expected. So measures are very simple.
- 19:39Trident 2 return on investments, return on equity, return for
- 19:44what we said we're going to do. How do we measure the successes
- 19:47we're going KPISI know these are not, you know, big and sexy and
- 19:52different, but they're fundamentally when we're doing
- 19:55something that's that big of an investment, what is the return
- 19:59we expect? And are we getting it in the
- 20:02time frame in which we expected, right.
- 20:05So being able to measure your KPIs, your outcomes and output,
- 20:10the output steps to get to your outcome, etcetera, none of those
- 20:14things have changed. I wish I could give a a fancier
- 20:17answer than that, but fundamentally that's what we
- 20:19look for. But very important to be clear
- 20:23at the outset, what are we getting for this?
- 20:26And sometimes there are hard measures most often and
- 20:30sometimes there's also soft measures or soft outcomes, I
- 20:33would say improve satisfaction from employees.
- 20:36Those are real, they're important.
- 20:38So if we state them and do what we say and say what we do,
- 20:42that's where we look at these outcomes.
- 20:45And sometimes an outcome could be learning and saying only, as
- 20:49I said earlier, 10% of the organization is expert.
- 20:52We want to get to 20. That's an outcome.
- 20:56So it might not be monetary, but it is, you know, along the scale
- 21:00of what we said we want to do in order to adopt something that
- 21:03could then provide stronger returns.
- 21:06And this is from Cheryl Folks, Bendy.
- 21:09And she has a question about this relationship between
- 21:13management and the board, especially when it comes to AI.
- 21:18And she says this following on Deepak's question, are you even
- 21:22measuring AI initiatives discreetly or leaving that to
- 21:28the management team and sticking to business outcomes that AI
- 21:33might be a component of? When the initiatives are big and
- 21:39the investment is significant, or once again it's a significant
- 21:44change, like we're trying to drive a different culture,
- 21:47organizational, you know, adoption of AI.
- 21:51The board will get involved and we will take a look at it.
- 21:55And you know, overall we look at the maturity of artificial
- 22:00intelligence. What we don't do is go in and
- 22:03look at every artificial intelligence initiative and say
- 22:08how are each of these going percentage wise and things like
- 22:11that. That's for management to do.
- 22:13Again, I can't emphasize enough day-to-day operation and
- 22:17execution of initiatives to deliver on the strategy is the
- 22:20job of management. The Board assesses the risk, the
- 22:25Board assesses the progress to commitments and the outcomes,
- 22:29etcetera, as it relates to sort of, you know, the big
- 22:33overarching business strategy of the company.
- 22:36It's a clear distinction, but it can also be murky at times.
- 22:40And, and how do you decide when you need to kind of drill in
- 22:47more? Because at some point, you know,
- 22:50the board member may have to get involved, you may be able to
- 22:53offer advice or you know, if there could be many, many
- 22:58different reasons, how do you balance that?
- 22:59How do you make that choice? I get asked a lot about, you
- 23:03know, when do you know the difference and when to do it.
- 23:06It depends by company and by board, right?
- 23:10And it depends, it's steered by risk, right?
- 23:14So if it's not big enough to, for a board to, to, to, to worry
- 23:22about in comparison to other things on the agenda or
- 23:25happening, it's a very subjective, when is it time?
- 23:29You know, there a lot of people ask me how often should the
- 23:32boards get a review of AI initiatives?
- 23:39I don't know. It depends on are those AI
- 23:42initiatives integral and core to achieving the business strategy
- 23:47on the table. If that's the case and there's a
- 23:50time frame and a dollar amount and an importance level to it
- 23:53because it's, it's the pivot point that would that needs to
- 23:57be done to get us there, then I would say the board visits it
- 23:59quite a bit. But if it's not and it's sort of
- 24:03then we could get it in a pre read or we could get it just in
- 24:07an update or it could be infrequent.
- 24:10So it depends. I wish I could say there was a
- 24:13recipe behind it, but there isn't.
- 24:16Yeah, I can imagine there these are complex issues that will
- 24:20vary according to the company culture and the situation.
- 24:24That's right. In general, we're because we do
- 24:27track, are we staying abreast of technological advancement?
- 24:31So even if there isn't a specific initiative, we, we do
- 24:35we need to ask leading questions like how is the adoption of AI
- 24:39tools? What are we using it for?
- 24:42What are some of the use cases that we're going after?
- 24:45Is it inventory management, for example, and you know, in a
- 24:48retail space, are we using it to monitor manufacturing quality
- 24:55and adaptive learning? Certainly if you're in the auto
- 24:58industry, the autonomous vehicle, I would say those
- 25:01boards are probably, and I'm not on an automotive board.
- 25:04So it's an opinion, but I would say those boards are probably
- 25:08talking quite a bit about the artificial intelligence that is,
- 25:12you know, self learning around autonomous driving if they have
- 25:15autonomous vehicles. So again, it's it is a very
- 25:20subjective to the industry and the company.
- 25:24This is from Arsalan Khan. He's a regular listener to CXO
- 25:28Talk and he that says this, he says as tech becomes more and
- 25:36more a part of our lives, do boards need a tech advisor only
- 25:41or a permanent tech board member who is fit to do this?
- 25:46The CIO, the chief digital officer, the CTO.
- 25:51So if you can address that. And I think it also gets to the
- 25:54larger issue of technology capability on the board.
- 26:00The board of directors have what's called a skills matrix
- 26:03and I would say all public company and I think private
- 26:07company as well, boards have these.
- 26:09And a skills matrix is around a company assesses what do they
- 26:14need, what are the capabilities they need in their board.
- 26:16So for example, financial literacy, financial expertise is
- 26:22one of the metrics, right? It may be sales and marketing,
- 26:25it may be product development, etcetera.
- 26:28On the skills matrix, more and more we are saying
- 26:31cybersecurity, digital transformation, etcetera.
- 26:35I suspect we're going to start saying tech savvy, artificial
- 26:39intelligence and a a deepening of that.
- 26:42To have a token member on a board that says there is our
- 26:47digital tech person is a start, but it's not sufficient in my
- 26:53opinion because technology impacts every part of companies,
- 27:00whether it's from, you know, customer satisfaction
- 27:04measurement to product development to it is ubiquitous.
- 27:09So in my opinion, we have to have tech savvy board members
- 27:16sort of permeating the board. That doesn't mean that they need
- 27:20to know how to do microprocess, you know, programming or that
- 27:24they need to, you know, do a Python program.
- 27:27But what it does mean is they need to be abreast.
- 27:30We need to be abreast of what are the technological
- 27:33advancements, how do they disrupt, how do they augment,
- 27:38what risks do they pose, what opportunities and benefits for
- 27:43our company and industry. And that broad based technology
- 27:48as I call it, I think is imperative if not for every
- 27:52member of the board, for majority members of the board.
- 27:56And you know, it's at one point many years ago on another board,
- 28:00someone said, well, thank goodness we have Andy on this
- 28:02board because she's watching out for that.
- 28:04Well, that I'm not sure that that is, you know, it may be
- 28:08back then, but it's certainly not the right mindset now.
- 28:12So tech savvy is really important.
- 28:15And again, I'm going to reiterate, not everybody needs
- 28:17to go get a degree in computer science or computer engineering,
- 28:20but being abreast, staying in soon intellectually curious,
- 28:25learning, etcetera. I myself have joined, you know,
- 28:29the advisor of the awesome company called I cream tree dot
- 28:32AI. It's an artificial intelligence
- 28:34company that helps even though I have a computer science degree
- 28:38and I'm tech savvy, but you know, it's out there helping
- 28:42augment human intelligence for utilities industries.
- 28:46That's how I stay abreast. So even people that have the
- 28:50degree can be not tech savvy. So it takes, you know, I'll use
- 28:55it, takes a village. That's how I feel about it.
- 28:58What about the stereotype of board members who are old
- 29:05school, have very little comfort or understanding of technology,
- 29:12who are used to having secretaries maybe in the past?
- 29:17Who don't have the background? What?
- 29:20What do you do if you're a board and you have esteemed members
- 29:24who are in that situation? I'm an optimist and a glass half
- 29:28full, but I I would say they're retiring because the pressures
- 29:32are such that you can't really. And I'm honored and pleased to
- 29:37be on the boards I'm on because I hand on heart don't see that.
- 29:40But I think they're retiring because they you just cannot be
- 29:47an advocate for and do your duty of loyalty and duty of care that
- 29:51you need to do as a board member if you refuse to sort of stay
- 29:58abreast of your inner industry and the technology that could
- 30:02impact it. All right, so that problem is a
- 30:06problem that is taking care of itself over time, essentially.
- 30:11That's my view, yes. This would be an excellent time
- 30:16to subscribe to the CXO Talk newsletter.
- 30:19Go to cxotalk.com and subscribe to the newsletter and we'll
- 30:23notify you about upcoming events just like this, which we do all
- 30:27the time. So this question is from Chris
- 30:32Peterson. He's another regular listener,
- 30:34and he says for those mature AI adopters, how do they measure
- 30:40positive and negative impacts of the tool and product choices
- 30:46that they make? Tools and product choices are
- 30:49not a decision for the board. So I will just say right off the
- 30:54bat, the board may ask questions of, you know, why did you bring
- 30:58an instance of Chat GPTN or Dolly or, or, but it, it is not
- 31:03a question for the board. As for management and what they
- 31:07choose to adopt, I, you know, I can assume and believe that they
- 31:12make that determination based on the benefits, the availability,
- 31:16the costs for sure. And that is something, you know,
- 31:20boards will ask. It's how much we're allocating
- 31:22and, and the cost of, of AI tools, the risks and the
- 31:29openness. Is it open source or is it not?
- 31:33So for companies that are doing that, and I apologize, I'm, you
- 31:37know, sort of going between what the board would do and what
- 31:39management would do. I assume they're doing, you
- 31:42know, balancing the equation as we did whenever we bought other
- 31:46kinds of tools around all of those parameters, commercial
- 31:50relationship viability, durability, you know, as I said
- 31:55before, price performance, etcetera.
- 31:59Here's a question from Lisa Pratico.
- 32:02And she says AI used everywhere is showing a negative impact on
- 32:11sustainability with energy and water consumption.
- 32:14Our boards or to what degree are boards concerned about balancing
- 32:19the use of AI against negative ESG outcomes or to ensure that
- 32:27with that there are positive ESG outcomes?
- 32:30As with any new technology, Lisa, there is what I call
- 32:35swings and roundabouts. And so boards recognize that
- 32:40while we have our ESG commitments and they remain
- 32:43strong and we want to adopt the new technology, we have to
- 32:48monitor and understand both. And there may be a time where
- 32:52one is, you know, sort of, you know, usurping the other.
- 32:57But we monitor and we see growing pains and in this
- 33:02technology is inevitable. And so we I can't say that we
- 33:08sit and measure this is how much AI and compute power we're using
- 33:13and this is the offset. But we are in general terms
- 33:16watching that as board directors because we have ESG commitments
- 33:21and we have commitments on how to improve and do more with with
- 33:24less and provide better offerings.
- 33:26So it's not a one for one, but I think in the rounds it will all
- 33:32come back to we have a wide angle lens and a 360° view on
- 33:37these things. Andy, as a board member, you
- 33:42don't directly have your hand on the rudder of a ship.
- 33:49You are giving guidance and then there are then management is
- 33:54actually steering the ship in a in a more direct way.
- 34:00Is that frustrating for you at all, the fact that that you have
- 34:05this indirect role in terms of what the organization does as
- 34:10indirect role as opposed to a very direct leadership
- 34:13management role? When I stepped down from my last
- 34:16operational role, people said are you retiring?
- 34:19And I said, no, I'm rewiring. And good friend of mine actually
- 34:23coined that phrase, so I won't take credit for it.
- 34:25And when you rewire, you realize that you're going into a
- 34:30different set of roles. And by the way, I've been doing
- 34:32boards for 10 years. So it wasn't sort of, I stopped
- 34:35full time and went into boards. I've been doing them since 2015.
- 34:40But you, it's a different role. And with every new role, you ask
- 34:45yourself, what is my accountability, What is my
- 34:49responsibility? What is it that I'm bound to
- 34:53have? You heard me say duty of
- 34:54loyalty, duty of care, etcetera. And how do I best do that to
- 34:58show up well into my boards. Now, I will tell you, I went
- 35:03through growing pains. I've been quoted as saying if I
- 35:05could go back to my first board, I would give them all an apology
- 35:09because it was that transition of management where I wanted to
- 35:13know why are you doing this, etcetera to, you know, abort
- 35:16your position. I'm going to use your boat, your
- 35:19boat analogy. It was an excellent one.
- 35:21Management is driving boat, but the board is overseeing and the
- 35:28board doesn't come in, you know, way too late to find out.
- 35:33We thought management was in the Atlantic and they're off in the
- 35:36Pacific Ocean, right? It could be more, it could be
- 35:39slight course corrections. What the questions that we ask
- 35:43and the oversight that we provide are, are we on track
- 35:47for, you know, have we delivered, is the business
- 35:52strategy, are the financials the way that we expected them coming
- 35:56in? And we ensure that we're
- 35:59delivering to the commitments made and we help course correct.
- 36:04Whether it's succession planning, whether it's, you
- 36:08know, looking at the allocation of spends, whether it's we have
- 36:13to look at competitive pressures and things have changed.
- 36:16Therefore maybe we need to do a course correction.
- 36:19So there is the pilot that is piloting or the captain that is
- 36:24driving, but then there's also the control tower that is
- 36:27monitoring. And so it the control tower
- 36:30plays its position, knows what it does, and has to synthesize a
- 36:34lot of information quickly to be able to be helpful and stay in
- 36:39the role of the RIN. So staying in the role is a key
- 36:44part of success for a for a board and individual board
- 36:48members. Yes, yes.
- 36:51Mario Garcia asks. He says AI is a game changer,
- 36:56but aligning strategy with responsibility, that's the real
- 37:00challenge. What do you think companies are
- 37:03missing? First of all, understanding the
- 37:06true power of AI. So education, I don't know if
- 37:08they're missing, but certainly this is what companies need to
- 37:12truly understand artificial intelligence capability and
- 37:16tools and offerings from software and tech companies and
- 37:19what they could provide. Clear time of initiatives to the
- 37:25outcomes and the strategy of a company and what it's trying to
- 37:28achieve. Uber importance measuring and
- 37:32ensuring that you don't have to course correct cause course
- 37:36correction is good. Staying with the strategy or
- 37:39with the tool or capability that isn't working is just throwing
- 37:42good money after bad and sunk cost is sunk cost.
- 37:46So there's a clarity of your strategy, the deliverables to
- 37:52get to your strategy, the outcomes that must happen, the
- 37:57tools and the, and the programs that are going to help deliver
- 38:00that and what I call stringing the thread through all of that.
- 38:04I think if there's anything, and I'll go back to your direct
- 38:08question of what companies might be missing, it's really
- 38:11understanding the capabilities of AI since I mean given that
- 38:15topic and what can or can it not provide for the achievement of
- 38:20the business strategy of of the organization?
- 38:23Let's jump to another question, this time again on LinkedIn from
- 38:28Demetrios Berampas. And he says, and this is a
- 38:32really good question, he says, do board members face the AI
- 38:36change as an upskilling necessity or as a more holistic
- 38:41culture change? It is an upskilling.
- 38:45As I said before, I think as boards are evolving and sort of
- 38:50realizing the dramatic change that tech, cyber and AR are, are
- 38:56bringing, that board skills, board awareness and education
- 39:02need to also, you know, sort of move commensurately.
- 39:08It is also a big culture change. It is a culture change within
- 39:11the company. Technology is now not just for
- 39:14programmers, right? I'm not going to make a bold
- 39:17statement and say you never need programmers anymore, but you are
- 39:20moving further from that direction and away from the
- 39:23direction of programmers too. Anybody can be a citizen
- 39:27developer getting the output that they need or or more people
- 39:31can. I don't want to offend anybody
- 39:33here on viewership. So I think it's both.
- 39:36It's the composition, the focus of the board, it's the
- 39:39composition and focus education and management team, and it is a
- 39:44big culture change across the spectrum from employees all the
- 39:47way to the board. And this is a question from
- 39:51Lizbeth Shaw, who says How are boards helping their companies
- 39:55address the ethical use of AI and trustworthy AI, especially
- 40:02since doing so may cut into maximizing profit?
- 40:06I'm very proud and I'm not, you know, not just the boards that
- 40:09I'm on, but but most boards ethics Trump's profits, right?
- 40:15I will just say that it's it is a darn shame when we find the
- 40:19one or two unicorns that don't, you know, go operate that way.
- 40:23Ethics Trump's profits. So how do boards ensure ethical
- 40:28usage Through audits, through reviews, through stakeholder
- 40:33interviews, through third party assessments?
- 40:36It's, you know, we do this, you know, on many fronts around
- 40:39strategy, etcetera, around financial controls.
- 40:44You know, we have our internal audits, we have the three
- 40:46stages, first, second, third line of threat vectors of, you
- 40:51know, financial controls. Well, it's this, it should be
- 40:55the same. And I would say is turning in
- 40:58that direction of three lines of defense around AI.
- 41:01Some big organizations, I believe company Nestle, I
- 41:05believe does this where they have an AI ethics group.
- 41:09So the board asks these questions of management and make
- 41:13sure that these controls are in place.
- 41:16Do we have an Ethics Committee? What's the latest audit?
- 41:20Is our data secure? You know, how do we know we
- 41:23don't have biases in these programs by asking these
- 41:26questions and forcing sort of that the responses, that's how
- 41:30we ensure and make ourselves comfortable.
- 41:33And you know, we look at, we look at data associated with
- 41:37that, that in fact we're staying ethical.
- 41:40OK. And on a related question,
- 41:42Justin Menin on LinkedIn raises again the issue of the critical
- 41:49role of board involvement in navigating roadblocks to AI
- 41:54adoption while maintaining an appropriate risk profile.
- 41:58So can you just elaborate a little bit on this point, which
- 42:04really is how can boards ensure innovation while at the same
- 42:10time not taking the ostrich approach and hiding from change?
- 42:15The easiest way is we ask the question what will it take, What
- 42:19will it take to be able to adopt artificial intelligence and AI
- 42:24tools in order to achieve X outcome or Y outcome?
- 42:28And if and then the board tries to dedicate resource or helps
- 42:34management, supports management and dedicating resource or funds
- 42:39capital allocation to remove the roadblocks to achieve the
- 42:44outcomes not open-ended though, how do we get AI tools and is
- 42:48not something the board would say, right.
- 42:50But if for example, we are saying we want in you know, to
- 42:54improve inventory management and reduce shrinkage, for example in
- 42:59a retail company, we would say what would it take to bring
- 43:02tools and to do that management needs to be prepared and again,
- 43:06very much a two way St. Michael, but management needs to
- 43:09be prepared with our infrastructure is legacy.
- 43:12Here's what we need. This is what it would take, or
- 43:15these are the tools that we need to invest in or these are the
- 43:18resources that we need to go higher or get help with, right?
- 43:21But it's how do we achieve, what are the roadblocks we can help
- 43:25remove and then setting the support structure up for
- 43:27management to do that. But again, not just to bring in
- 43:31AI tools, but to achieve the outcome of what these tools
- 43:34could promise for the stakeholders.
- 43:36Correct me if I'm wrong, It seems in a sense what you're
- 43:39saying is the board's responsibility is to drive the
- 43:46organizational agenda at the same time balancing competing
- 43:52forces ultimately? It's to agree to the
- 43:55organizational agenda and the strategy of the company and then
- 44:03to see how the board, what is needed from the board to support
- 44:08removing those roadblocks while constantly monitoring that we
- 44:12stay within risk appetite. The way that you're describing
- 44:16it, if I can be totally blunt, it sounds like kind of corporate
- 44:20speak. That's pretty much what I said.
- 44:23Or am I missing? What am I missing here?
- 44:26You missed the risk appetite. OK.
- 44:28So you said the board will remove things, but the board
- 44:31will there's a check in. Look, I'll take the corporate
- 44:34speak out of it and just, I love that you called that out,
- 44:38Michael, but it is, there's checks and balances.
- 44:41So it's not. Yeah, go it's again, I'll go
- 44:44back to what I said 40 minutes ago.
- 44:46There's an offensive play, but we have to make sure that we
- 44:50stay within our regulatory, legal, ethical boundaries.
- 44:54And I'll always repeat that. Sorry that.
- 44:58Yeah. Very helpful.
- 44:59So checks and balances is a very essential element of this.
- 45:03Absolutely, absolutely. So if I, if I'm asked as a board
- 45:06member, Andy, would you give us your view and opinion on, you
- 45:09know, ChatGPT And it's great. It's this, it'll do this and
- 45:12what are we training and we used, you know, 6,000,000 data
- 45:16sets and all the rest of it. That's fantastic.
- 45:18But in the same breath, I'm going to say how, you know, what
- 45:20are we doing to ensure that corporate data does not get out
- 45:24as we're as we're delivering on this.
- 45:27I can't emphasize it enough. I know I've said it about 12
- 45:29times, so forgive me. Well, it's clearly an essential
- 45:33part of the the board role. And so it's great that you're
- 45:38emphasizing it. We have a number of questions
- 45:42left. I'm going to ask you to answer
- 45:43these really quickly because I want to have time to share
- 45:48advice on how technology leaders can become board members so
- 45:55very, very quickly From Twitter, from Arsalan Khan.
- 45:58Again, strategy without execution is hallucination.
- 46:03Sometimes execution is a fraction of what strategy
- 46:08wanted. What do boards do?
- 46:11We make sure that the plans for execution are sufficient and
- 46:17enough for to achieve the strategy.
- 46:21And by the way, some of those are not just tech plans or AI
- 46:25plans. So this goes to threading the
- 46:28needle strategy, strategic, you know, initiatives to achieve
- 46:35that strategy, that outcome execution being in line with
- 46:40those initiatives to achieve the strategy.
- 46:42I know I'm very something making it sound very simplistic.
- 46:46Quite often companies have strategic goals but don't have
- 46:50the right strategy to achieve them, which means they don't
- 46:54have the right execution focus and and programs.
- 46:59But it's it's a thread, the needle.
- 47:01Let's go back to LinkedIn very quickly from again from Isaac
- 47:06Sacolic. Are boards diving into how
- 47:08effective management is in investing in leaders and
- 47:13employees for training around AI and effectiveness on change
- 47:18management? Or is this left to be a
- 47:21management issue? If we have set up the outcomes
- 47:25and the commitments and the strategy again that we're trying
- 47:28to achieve, there is a set of capabilities, programs,
- 47:32initiatives, efforts, culture changes, etcetera that are
- 47:36deemed that are have been set forth to achieve that you
- 47:39measure if those things are being achieved.
- 47:42Boards will not go in and say you know just sort of out Hock,
- 47:47how many AI specialists do you have?
- 47:50We will say do we have enough specialists to achieve this?
- 47:54Do you have the workforce of the future?
- 47:56Are they located in the right places?
- 47:59Do they have the right reward mechanism?
- 48:02Are there objectives aligned? We will ask those questions.
- 48:06We don't go except for the chief executive.
- 48:09We don't hire and and you know sort of fire the, you know,
- 48:13management team etcetera. We have a lot of input, but we
- 48:16make sure that companies are resourced just the same way.
- 48:19We make sure that capital allocation on a financial
- 48:23perspective is done, you know, sufficiently to achieve the
- 48:26outcomes that we're trying to achieve.
- 48:29Again, you've got the the checks and balances to make sure that
- 48:34resources and people are in place who can carry through the
- 48:41the vision and the strategy of the organization.
- 48:43It's exactly right again, noses and fingers out, sniffing it,
- 48:47ensuring that sort of thing we don't execute.
- 48:51We have a question from Cheryl folks.
- 48:54Bendy again, who says What do you look for in a company when
- 48:59you're considering joining a board?
- 49:01First of all, is it an industry that I am interested in and can
- 49:05contribute to? Is it a company that I believe I
- 49:13could am interested in and can contribute to and can benefit
- 49:17from my expertise? Is it a board that I can work
- 49:21with? I look at by name and
- 49:24background, each board member to see is that a board that I can
- 49:30learn from and contribute to? Is it an ethical company?
- 49:35I look at the financials, you know, sometimes they're great.
- 49:38Sometimes you know, you, you can find opportunity to grow that,
- 49:40but that's not typically how I the, you know, a key criteria
- 49:44for, for assessing it. And so through that, you start
- 49:48realizing, is it a place where if I go play on that field, I
- 49:53can actually contribute and, you know, give good guidance, good
- 49:58insight and where my capabilities are needed.
- 50:01I consider it from my personal experience, I consider it a
- 50:05duty. And so and some, you know, an
- 50:08honor, if you will, to be on a board.
- 50:10And those are the things that I think about.
- 50:12What advice do you have to business leaders inside an
- 50:18organization on being effective in working with the board?
- 50:23So I have seen management teams that try to manage the board and
- 50:30to some degree there is a level in that collaboration where you
- 50:34need to manage each other's expectations, etcetera.
- 50:37But for me it's around collaboration.
- 50:40What does the board need to do to do their job?
- 50:43What does the board need to do to be effective at, you know,
- 50:47their oversight and governance and to help give us guidance?
- 50:51That's what I would look at as an in a management team.
- 50:54Quite often we look at board members when they ask questions.
- 50:57Oh my gosh, the board asked for this.
- 50:59Relax, right? Why is the board asking?
- 51:02What is the board looking for? And so just like this is going
- 51:06to sound very trite, Michael, but just like in a good
- 51:08relationship, you want to know if someone asks you something,
- 51:11don't go on the offensive or defensive, but what is it
- 51:13they're looking for and how do I help achieve that so that they
- 51:16can help me through oversight to deliver that?
- 51:19That's how I would view it. So really understanding, trying
- 51:23to understand the board members perspective.
- 51:26What do they need, and how can I, as a member of the leadership
- 51:31or the management of the company, help that board member
- 51:35achieve whatever it is that they're looking for?
- 51:36That's right. And it's quite often it's fair
- 51:38to say, why do you ask? Because it could be something
- 51:41completely different than they what they might interpret.
- 51:44It could be just a curiosity, it could be some other, other
- 51:47reason. Or the board member may say, you
- 51:50know, I, I can't really divulge or what I just, you know, I, I,
- 51:53I need to understand this, this bit of information.
- 51:56But typically we go through CEO for that.
- 51:58What advice do you have for technology leaders, CIOSCTOS and
- 52:04so forth who want to become a board member?
- 52:09Recognize there's no recipe. So if someone says to you go do
- 52:13this, go do this, go do this, right.
- 52:15I've seen that quite often it is not a recipe.
- 52:18There is chemistry to bring people on boards.
- 52:21There is experiences that that you know certain companies are
- 52:25looking for. I mentioned capability matrix,
- 52:27etcetera. But here is what I would
- 52:29recommend to every tech person, figure out business, understand
- 52:35if you're going for a particular company or in an industry, start
- 52:39understanding the industry. Your trade may be technology and
- 52:43that's what you bring, but you're going on a board from
- 52:45governance oversight, fiduciary responsibility, your, you know,
- 52:51financial literacy, etcetera. So hone those skills and bring
- 52:57yourself, you know, up sort of into that broader umbrella and
- 53:02lose the tech speak. Quite often we are so impressed
- 53:05with ourselves on all of the deep technology that we know and
- 53:09we should be very proud of it. But that is not the level that
- 53:13boards operate at. You know, occasionally your tech
- 53:17boards may want to go deep into things, but you really need to
- 53:21raise your game up a level. You mentioned this earlier can
- 53:25very quickly. Can you give us an example to
- 53:28make this point concrete? If I'm a CIACIO and I'm talking
- 53:34with the board, how much technical detail should I
- 53:38provide? Enough so that they get the
- 53:41picture of benefit risk required, you know, dollar
- 53:47allocation if that's what's being asked for, and so that
- 53:51they can do their job. So recognize the board's job,
- 53:55right? Recognize their oversight and
- 53:57governance. What do they need to know in
- 54:00order to do their their job well, right.
- 54:05And so I use a lot and I'll say something else.
- 54:08I use a lot of analogies and comparisons, right.
- 54:11You know, we were trying to describe threat vectors and you
- 54:15know how people can infiltrate what the bad actors do, for
- 54:19example, on cyber. And so, you know, draw some
- 54:22analogies. I used to say if you put a lock
- 54:25on the the front door, but the jewels are sitting on the table,
- 54:28then not good. So maybe you have a safe and
- 54:31then you have, you know it under a a, you know, the boards in the
- 54:35kitchen. That's defense in depth.
- 54:38So I would explain it in terms that they could.
- 54:40It's not dumbing it down. It's just relating it to
- 54:43something they know. That's an interesting point.
- 54:46It's not dumbing it down, but it's presenting it within the
- 54:50context of what's important to them and where their focus lies.
- 54:56Right. OK, well with that we are out of
- 55:00time. So I want to say an enormous
- 55:03thank you to Adriana Karabutis, who is a multi industry board
- 55:11member. She's held senior leadership
- 55:13roles at large organizations like Dell, Biogen and National
- 55:17Grid. Andy, thank you so much for
- 55:20being with us and sharing your expertise with us today.
- 55:23Thank you, Michael. It's a pleasure being here.
- 55:25I appreciate you having me back. And a huge thank you to
- 55:28everybody who asked such amazing questions and who we're who's
- 55:31watching today. Before you go, please subscribe
- 55:36to the CXO Talk newsletter. Just go to cxotalk.com,
- 55:40subscribe to our YouTube channel.
- 55:42We really have extraordinary shows that are coming up, great
- 55:45discussions and you should be a part of it, folks.
- 55:49Thank you so much everybody. I hope you have a great day and
- 55:51we will see you again next time.