Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / AI Anxiety, Faith, and the Search for What’s Real
Transcript
- 0:00Coming up on the Together for Good podcast, everyone is
- 0:03talking about artificial intelligence.
- 0:06What does it mean? Should we be scared?
- 0:09And more importantly, I want to talk about what our faith might
- 0:12have to say about all these new advancements in technology.
- 0:16It's going to be a fun one. Here we go.
- 0:19Welcome to the Together for Good podcast, a podcast created by
- 0:22Bethany Lutheran Church in Cherry Hills Village, Co and
- 0:26hosted by me, Pastor Nate Pricinger and Together for Good.
- 0:30Our goal is to provide practical, engaging content that
- 0:34supports you without expectations.
- 0:36Whether you're feeling disconnected from traditional
- 0:38religion or simply exploring what faith means in your life,
- 0:42we are here to walk alongside you.
- 0:44No matter where you are on your journey of faith, we're glad
- 0:47you're here. Welcome to Together for good.
- 0:51So AI, artificial intelligence, it is everywhere that we look
- 0:56nowadays. And the topic of discussion and
- 0:59op eds in the newspaper, just everywhere you look, somebody's
- 1:04talking about the implications of this technology for the
- 1:07future of our world. And so obviously, if you're a
- 1:10thinking person of faith, you're wondering how does any of this
- 1:14fit in with my life of faith and what does it mean for those who
- 1:18don't fully understand? I don't know a lot about AI.
- 1:22I use it from time to time. Absolutely.
- 1:24It's an incredible tool. And just I'm going to give you
- 1:27the briefest history of what I know.
- 1:29In December of 2022, so just about 3 years ago now, one
- 1:35company really went public, shall we say, not in the stock
- 1:40trading sense of it, but with their technology.
- 1:42And so they've been working on this type of large language
- 1:46learning models for years and finally released it for the
- 1:50public to use. That was ChatGPT, which launched
- 1:53in December of 2022. There's been so many additions
- 1:59and iterations and other technologies, but it all is kind
- 2:03of very similar in the ways that it works.
- 2:06Basically, as I understand it, what ChatGPT can kind of do for
- 2:11you is it the way I heard it termed is that it's like a 15
- 2:15year old who's read the entire Internet.
- 2:18And so it takes all of the public information that's out
- 2:22there on the web, literally all of it, and it processes it and
- 2:27then predicts the words to put in order that will best satisfy
- 2:32your question. When you put it like that sounds
- 2:35really unremarkable and like it's not going to work.
- 2:37And yet they have fine-tuned this technology enough that when
- 2:41you ask it, hey, I have a gluten allergy and someone coming over
- 2:45who's a vegan, and these are the ingredients that I have in my
- 2:49pantry, what recipe can I make? It can do that for you just
- 2:53through this process of kind of guessing and determining with
- 2:57the highest probability what words should be pushed together
- 3:01in order to form an answer to your response.
- 3:04I know it's crazy. And yet you think about all the
- 3:08information that's out there on the Internet and if you could
- 3:10somehow access all of it in a moment, and then with incredible
- 3:15computing power process and determine what works best
- 3:19together based on all this data that's out there, you start to
- 3:22see, maybe you'll get a little glimpse of how AI works and why
- 3:27it's so powerful. The Internet really became
- 3:29mainstream when I was a kid and it happened, I would say when I
- 3:33was in fifth grade is the moment when all of a sudden we were
- 3:37told in classrooms to use the Internet for our work.
- 3:41Some of you are probably much older than I am, Pastor Gary,
- 3:45looking at you and so I know, but you also probably have a
- 3:49moment in your mind where the Internet really changed things.
- 3:54And we look now at how different our lives are post Internet to
- 3:57pre Internet. I'm pretty confident that AI is
- 4:00going to be a similar marquee moment in our life and in our
- 4:06history that we will remember what life was like before it
- 4:09became mainstream. And then after it became
- 4:12mainstream, I think about my kids and that this will be a
- 4:15real marking in their growing up process, just like the Internet
- 4:19was for my growing up process and just how differently I
- 4:22approached schoolwork, research, etcetera, etcetera, after the
- 4:29Internet came into my life. AI will be similar and it's
- 4:33going to change the way that we have to teach and then we have
- 4:35to learn all of this. But what are the implications
- 4:40for us as people of faith? Here's why I'm hopeful, OK?
- 4:46I think that with all of this technology creating more and
- 4:50more stuff that we no longer can know if it was from a human
- 4:55being or from a computer, I think that's going to force us
- 5:00and to make us long for real human connection, experiences,
- 5:06etcetera. I heard it on a podcast that I
- 5:09listened to recently where there was a a person wondering what
- 5:12they should do for their social media and the host of the show
- 5:15said like I don't know how much time and energy you should give
- 5:18to social media because I think in about 5 years people are
- 5:21really going to be done with it. Now that might be a little too
- 5:25optimistic, but in the same sense, we're quickly approaching
- 5:30the point where you don't want to see what's on the Internet
- 5:34anymore because you don't know if you can trust it.
- 5:38You don't know if it's real. And so you're going to want to.
- 5:41I'm again, my hopeful perspective is that people are
- 5:44going to want to be in person more and there will be a new a a
- 5:49renewed appreciation for retreats under renewed
- 5:53appreciation for in person town halls and workshops and keynote
- 6:00speeches. You want to quote Hamilton to be
- 6:03in the room where it happens because then you can know for
- 6:07sure this is a real thing and not some AI generated lie that
- 6:13just happens to look real and realistic.
- 6:18And with this, notice how this pushes us, this advent of AI,
- 6:23this hopeful picture that I have for our AI anxiety.
- 6:27Notice how it seems to be forcing us into the spaces and
- 6:32the ideas that frankly, the scriptures speak about from the
- 6:35very start. I think that community and human
- 6:40relationships have always been at the heart of the gospel in
- 6:45the very essential sense that we believe in the God who is
- 6:50incarnational, a God who became flesh Incarnate.
- 6:56And so that reality of Jesus, of God coming down and being born
- 7:00of a human mother for our sake to live and move and share life
- 7:03amongst us, shows us that God is intimately concerned with real
- 7:08life human experience. And not only that, but it shows
- 7:13that this is a part of God's hope for the world, for this
- 7:17creation, is that we would value relationships just as much as
- 7:22God values relationship with us. Yeah.
- 7:26And that in person, communal experience really was at the
- 7:30very heart of all that Jesus said and did.
- 7:33Not only was Jesus God Incarnate, God becoming close
- 7:37and in relationship and in community with us, but
- 7:41additionally, all of Jesus's ministry seem to try and point
- 7:46the people towards that hate. Pharisees don't value your laws
- 7:50and your rituals and rules more than you value the life and
- 7:54worth of a person. That was one of Jesus constant
- 7:58complaints. The parable of the Good
- 8:00Samaritan that everyone loves is about a Levite and a priest who
- 8:05passed by a man who is in need because they knew the laws that
- 8:10said touching this man on the side of the room would make them
- 8:13unclean. But along comes a Samaritan
- 8:16who's supposed to be the enemy, but he is the one who shows
- 8:20mercy. And that is what our call is, is
- 8:23to see real people in front of us and to to notice the ones who
- 8:29cross our path and to value human relationship more than our
- 8:36cooked up religious rules. More than that, I'm also always
- 8:41so struck by the ways that Jesus is healing.
- 8:44Miracles really seem to point to a valuing of relationship and
- 8:49community. It's not just that Jesus sees
- 8:53the people who are hurting and who have been cast out from
- 8:55society. But notice that in healing them,
- 9:00Jesus is not only restoring their health, but he's restoring
- 9:04their social participation as well.
- 9:08Because if you were a leper, you had to go live in the leper
- 9:11colony outside of the city, and you couldn't participate in the
- 9:15normal ways and rhythms of life. You just had to live with your
- 9:19other unclean people, completely separate from everything else
- 9:23that was going on in the town. When Jesus heals those people,
- 9:28they are now restored, not just physically, but socially.
- 9:32They're restored to the communal happenings of that town or of
- 9:36that village. They no longer have to live in
- 9:39on the outskirts, shunned and pushed aside, but they can fully
- 9:43reintegrate into the life of the community because that is so
- 9:48much of what God wants for the world.
- 9:51That is what Jesus is envisioning and bringing about
- 9:55when he talks about the Kingdom of God.
- 9:57It is a place where all can be 1, where relationships matter
- 10:03most of all, and where mercy is extended over and over again.
- 10:10Additionally, I think there's something very compelling about
- 10:13the way that Jesus told stories. It's not just that he did
- 10:16miracles. He also was a storyteller who
- 10:19who is constantly sharing these peculiar parables that are rich
- 10:23with depth and meaning. And he never told you exactly
- 10:28what it was about. Every now and then it'll tell us
- 10:30in the Scriptures that Jesus went and told the disciples
- 10:32privately what he couldn't say in front of the crowds.
- 10:36But I think what Jesus was also doing there is by telling these
- 10:39strange parables, he was inherently creating community.
- 10:45He was creating discussion and perplexity and interesting
- 10:50dialogue amongst the people as they tried to figure out what
- 10:53Jesus might be talking about and what this strange story might
- 10:56mean for their collective lives. He was creating conversation by
- 11:02not just giving them the answer directly.
- 11:06If you've ever had a professor or, or maybe a pastor who could
- 11:10do that as well, I think that's the heart of what Jesus was
- 11:13trying to do for us. Like, hey, look, let's create
- 11:15conversation here. Yeah, this being human thing is
- 11:19difficult. And yeah, where does God fit
- 11:21into our walk of life, of faith and these difficulties we face
- 11:25along the way? And Jesus is like, well, like,
- 11:27let me tell you a story about that.
- 11:29And he shares a story that's a little strange and has some odd
- 11:33details, and it gets people talking.
- 11:36OK What do you think he meant by that?
- 11:37Like we have. Well, here's how I hear it.
- 11:39Yeah. Well, here's how I hear it.
- 11:41As a Lutheran pastor, this is very much how we approach the
- 11:44study of Scripture. We really believe that the Bible
- 11:48needs to be read in community and studied with other people
- 11:53and not just pushed off alone by ourselves.
- 11:56Or Martin Luther's original critique was that it was just
- 11:59the priests who got the chance to tell you what the Bible said.
- 12:02No. This is a book that's supposed
- 12:04to create conversation. And in our dialogue, in our
- 12:09struggle with these stories, we will grow closer to
- 12:13understanding who God is and what that means for our life.
- 12:17And we can't just do that alone. We can't just do that with the
- 12:20answer, easy answers. It has to happen through
- 12:22dialogue. I don't fully understand what
- 12:25I'm about to tell you about, so you can ask AI and maybe that'll
- 12:31help. I know that the philosopher
- 12:34Hegel, who I brought up before, who I really don't fully
- 12:38understand his writings completely because it's complex
- 12:40stuff. But the more I dig into his
- 12:43philosophical thought, he talks about the dialectic process and
- 12:47just how important it is for things to like spiral dynamics,
- 12:52for things to continually evolve, for iron to sharpen iron
- 12:57in the dialectic process. The idea, again, very broad
- 13:00strokes, I'm not a doctor, I don't fully understand it, but
- 13:03it seems that you kind of come with an initial point and then
- 13:07someone provides the counterpoint, and then you
- 13:09provide the counterpoint to the counterpoint.
- 13:11And this back and forth process, struggling with thought in this
- 13:18spiral type of sense just gets us to a more generous, more
- 13:24complete whole through that dialectic process.
- 13:27And I really think that the study of Scripture is a part of
- 13:31that. I really think that Jesus's
- 13:32parables are a part of this dialectic process, too, in that,
- 13:37yeah, we as humans shouldn't just arrive at one answer and
- 13:40stick with it all the time, but recognizing that we've so much
- 13:43to learn from one another. Yeah, human relationship really
- 13:48helps us discover a more beautiful, more generous whole.
- 13:53A, a, a more in democracy, a more perfect union.
- 13:57Yeah. Democracy is built on the
- 13:58dialectic process of like, hey, this is going to take a long
- 14:01time and we're not going to agree, but we're going to
- 14:03compromise and we're going to, you know, debate about these
- 14:06different points. And through that struggle and
- 14:09that tension, maybe we will create a more perfect union as a
- 14:13result. That's that.
- 14:15That's a pretty good example, actually, of this dialectic
- 14:18process lived out. And again, I think it's what
- 14:21church community is for. I think it's what the parables
- 14:24were about. And with all this to say, I
- 14:27think it's what AI can't give us.
- 14:31Maybe you could use it to offer you counterpoints to ideas that
- 14:36you have. I guess that would be in the
- 14:38spirit of what I'm talking about.
- 14:39But I think the value of human relationship and conversation
- 14:43and disagreement and yet unity despite disagreement, that
- 14:48that's going to become exceedingly important because we
- 14:53can't just expect or or or hope to have all of our ideas
- 14:59affirmed all the time. And that's what AI can do for
- 15:01you. This is one of the most
- 15:02frustrating things I found in using the technology is I'll say
- 15:06like, Hey, what do you think about this idea?
- 15:08Here's what I'm thinking. And it's always so affirming.
- 15:10And at first I loved it because I just want to be told I'm doing
- 15:13a good job. But after a while, I was like,
- 15:17Oh my gosh, like, come on. Like, please, like, give me some
- 15:19pushback here. It's not a great idea that this
- 15:22needs some real help. And that's what I'm coming to
- 15:25you for, ChatGPT, and you're not giving it to me.
- 15:28But I think that this is where the technology will ultimately
- 15:32fall apart and potentially could ruin us, too.
- 15:35Not to feed into the anxiety, but the Scriptures are so clear
- 15:40that idolatry is one of the big things we need to be so careful
- 15:44of. The very original sin of Adam
- 15:47and Eve is that the serpent tells him if you eat that fruit,
- 15:51you will become like God. Because that's really the
- 15:55longing that lives within every human being, whether we want to
- 15:59acknowledge it or admit to it or not.
- 16:01It's like, yeah, like at the end of the day, I just want to be in
- 16:05full control. I want to be like God.
- 16:08But where that leaves you is that then you have to save
- 16:11yourself, which you can never do.
- 16:15And that's what the Bible is constantly telling us, like
- 16:18idolatry is the the chief sin of them all.
- 16:22When God lays out the 10 commandments, you shall have no
- 16:24other God before me was the very first one that got offered.
- 16:28And and if you look at it, the nine commandments that follow,
- 16:32if you keep the first one, you probably won't break any of the
- 16:37other nine. But the moment we shift into
- 16:40idolatry and starting to think that we are God and that we can
- 16:45save ourselves, that is the moment that we will inevitably
- 16:49find despair. We need a force outside of
- 16:54ourselves to save us. We can't do this on our own.
- 16:59And AI can give us the illusion now that that maybe we are gods
- 17:03unto ourselves. We can create universes with
- 17:06just a few keystrokes. Lovely.
- 17:09That will never fulfill us or save us in the end.
- 17:14We need something bigger than, yes, even a computer algorithm
- 17:18that's predicting the next possible word in a sentence.
- 17:22We need something stronger than that, and as I've been saying,
- 17:26how long we need each other too. Part of the importance of the
- 17:31dialectic process of our democracy being about
- 17:35conflicting views. But compromise and debate is
- 17:41that we have to then we, we need the other to point out to us the
- 17:46parts that we aren't seeing because it's powerful and
- 17:49intelligent as we think we are. There's always an angle that we
- 17:53haven't considered yet or a life experience that we haven't had
- 17:56yet. And, and so there's a blind spot
- 17:58there. And that's what community allows
- 18:01us to discover. It's like, Oh my gosh, I can
- 18:03learn so much from you about your life experience because
- 18:07it's completely different than mine.
- 18:09And I never saw the world in that way and I never thought
- 18:13that way, but I'm so glad to learn from you about this.
- 18:18This is one of the key pieces here at Bethany that we try and
- 18:21lean into is this idea of unity. And it's hard and it's messy,
- 18:26but it just seems so important in this day and age to be able
- 18:29to learn from someone who I don't agree with and to create
- 18:33an environment where that can continue to happen because
- 18:38there's so much out there that can just affirm all of my ideas.
- 18:41Yeah, I can find anything on the Internet that's going to tell me
- 18:44I'm doing a great job and I'm absolutely right.
- 18:47And I can also have ChatGPT create me a picture or a movie
- 18:52or an article that just reinforces everything that I
- 18:56believe. But where I'll really grow is
- 18:58when I talk to another human being and where I learned from
- 19:01their experience and where their unique perspective completely
- 19:06unsettles me and shifts me out of my perspective.
- 19:10Because that's just the thing that you, you can't shift
- 19:12yourself out of your own perspective.
- 19:14That's inherently, by definition, impossible.
- 19:17And so ANYWAYS, more than anything, though, this AI
- 19:22anxiety that we're all living with in different ways and
- 19:26worried about how it might replace us or change us.
- 19:29Yeah, I'm hopeful that it might drive us back to understanding
- 19:34the importance of human relationships again, because I
- 19:37think we've lost that in a lot of ways.
- 19:39And I think there's so much good that comes from learning from
- 19:43other human beings. And I think it's so much of
- 19:45God's message for us. So much of Jesus's ministry on
- 19:49earth was to teach us the value of relationships.
- 19:56But the other part to all this is that I think AI and in the
- 20:00way that it's going to make us way more productive than we've
- 20:04ever been, maybe it can also help us hang on to that spark
- 20:09that makes us human, which is that we are more than our tasks.
- 20:15AI can do so many tasks for us. It can complete so much work in
- 20:19such a short amount of time and. Will that hopefully help us
- 20:25distinguish ourselves from the machines?
- 20:28Because we do a bad job of that right now.
- 20:30I think we often have this mindset that we're just a
- 20:33machine, that we're a human, that we're a human doing and not
- 20:37a human being, as I've heard it said before.
- 20:39And we need to be reminded that we're so much more than the
- 20:42tasks we complete, that there is a spark of the divine within
- 20:47each of us, that we are created in the image of God, as it says
- 20:50in Genesis chapter 1. And so there's inherent value in
- 20:55each human being. And we're so much more than the
- 20:58tasks we do. It's why God commands us to
- 21:02remember the Sabbath day and keep it holy, because we need
- 21:05that reminder that we're not just the things that we
- 21:09accomplish in our fast-paced, driven world.
- 21:12I think that also might be a hopeful angle of this whole AI
- 21:17phenomenon. I shouldn't even call the
- 21:19phenomenon because I'm pretty sure it's not going anywhere
- 21:22just in, in reality of how much is accomplishing.
- 21:25But notice how all of these pieces of what AI can do for us.
- 21:29There is a hopeful angle here that it might push us back
- 21:32towards some of the truths of our life of faith that
- 21:35relationships matter and that we are more than what we
- 21:38accomplish. And if we can keep those things
- 21:41in mind. I, I, I really am hopeful for
- 21:44the future and where I want to kind of conclude all of these
- 21:47thoughts, it's just by saying that a belief in hope, a
- 21:53trusting in hope, a faith in hope is also so much of where we
- 21:59as Christians are continually called to reside.
- 22:03We believe that there is a God who has a much longer term plan
- 22:07than just this present moment. And so as anxiety ridden as this
- 22:12moment may feel for each of us for different reasons, we are
- 22:16called again and again to trust that God is already at work and
- 22:21that God has a more beautiful conclusion to this painful
- 22:26moment, right? God exists in a way that is
- 22:28completely outside of time. And so it's interesting to know
- 22:33that God is present with us in the struggles of this moment,
- 22:35but also God already knows how the story is going to end and
- 22:39where this is all leading. And there is a restoration and
- 22:43hopefulness that we can cling to, that that our faith invites
- 22:47us into. Even when things seem really
- 22:49hard, even when we're really worried about this or that or
- 22:52the next piece to it, there is an eternal promise that's so
- 22:56much bigger than the present moment.
- 22:59And as Christians, yeah, if things do get really bad, I'm
- 23:04also, I encourage us to trust in that deeper, longer term hope
- 23:10that's based on something eternal, not something
- 23:14temporary. So there's a lot of thoughts
- 23:18about AI anxiety and yet how our life of faith specifically
- 23:24speaks to this present moment and where it calls us forward.
- 23:27I hope this might be helpful to you.
- 23:29I hope I didn't mess up too much of my explanation of Hegel or
- 23:33large language models. Please send this to family
- 23:37members or friends who might be in need of a message of hope in
- 23:40the midst of this technology change in our world.
- 23:44And as always, friends, stay in peace.
- 23:46Thank you for listening to the Together for Good podcast.
- 23:49If you'd like more resources for your walk of faith, please visit
- 23:52our website bethany-denver.org or download our mobile app by
- 23:58searching Bethany Connect in your phone's App Store.