Latest / Newcomer Pod / That's What the Money's For!
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome. Hey it's Eric newcomer with dead
- 0:16cat. I'm here with Tom and Katie.
- 0:19We are going to talk about Brian Armstrong, the coinbase CEO.
- 0:25He loves to communicate in tweet store but He wrote one.
- 0:31I think, you know, a year ago, basically talking about politics
- 0:36and companies sort of right after the black lives matter
- 0:39protest, trying to Stamp Out, you know, employee Revolution
- 0:43inside of coinbase. We're going to talk about that
- 0:46one. Which I think he recently took a
- 0:49Victory lap on sort of saying that he looks prescient.
- 0:54And then there's another one from October where he complains
- 0:59about see Is getting criticized. Tom, do you have it up?
- 1:02You have a better reading voice and I do or I can read them if
- 1:06semi some of the link I can do my best priority and then we'll
- 1:10back our way into the politics ones.
- 1:12This is from October 5th at Brian underscore Armstrong won.
- 1:17I do worry that as companies get to be more successful.
- 1:20The number of attacks from the Press politicians and trolls on
- 1:24CEOs and rounds of congressional testimony.
- 1:27Make the job not fun and they leave.
- 1:30And they leave from burnout Gates page, Bezos dot dot dot.
- 1:35To America, could be losing some of its best talent from this
- 1:38America and it has some parallels to what has happened
- 1:42to successful CEOs in China. You.
- 1:44Oh my God. Okay, I'll keep going through
- 1:45this. You didn't.
- 1:47I didn't read the second one, how could you?
- 1:49I'm sorry. How could you compare?
- 1:51What is happening to the CI Master?
- 1:52Is he talking about like, Jack Ma and, you know?
- 1:55Yes, yes, he is to set the content.
- 1:57Like, okay, I'm sorry, I'm sorry, I'm getting ahead of
- 1:59myself. You don't get moved to how he's
- 2:03lays it out. You don't get moved to house
- 2:04arrest in the u.s. No you don't you do not but it
- 2:08is. I'm not gonna laugh but it is
- 2:11our own version of it being something that gets me
- 2:13successful. Yeah, it's American house arrest
- 2:17is getting a tweet. Putting something that gets to
- 2:20successful in its place 3 parentheses, which doesn't seem
- 2:23very American. By the way, for real life course
- 2:27I'm going to finish this. I swear of course.
- 2:30Company deserves to have scrutiny and should take an
- 2:32honest look at what it's doing well, and not well, but the
- 2:35market solves, a lot of this for us, people vote with their
- 2:38wallet, choosing what to buy. And the best way to keep flawed
- 2:41companies in check is to have new startups, come disrupt them.
- 2:44So how do you build a company today?
- 2:45That is resistant to demoralizing attacks from
- 2:47trolls, the more successful it becomes, I'm not sure.
- 2:51But here here are a few ideas. First, hire employees, and build
- 2:55a board of independent thinkers who are insulated from bias,
- 2:58third-party script in their minds and knock you Late your
- 3:01supply chain. Second, give customers not just
- 3:04employees, a sense of ownership crypto is pioneered this?
- 3:08I think I can stop. Yeah, right.
- 3:09I mean, we don't, we don't know three simply the enemy
- 3:11descriptions. Yeah.
- 3:13Yeah. I mean Facebook would be facing
- 3:15a lot. Less hate if all their unique
- 3:17users owned a piece of the network, if people felt like
- 3:20everyone was growing together, there would be a greater sense
- 3:23of unity. I just think the last visit,
- 3:25this is actually not an oncoming why everybody's attacking
- 3:27Facebook. So I mean Facebook is Clearly a
- 3:31big subtext of this. I mean, we as the users we need
- 3:36to do on a piece of the network and we can choose to not use it
- 3:38anymore. Like so many people have what?
- 3:42I mean, I guess I just feel like welcome to being the CEO of.
- 3:46No, no, Jay P Morgan or Walmart or a Starbucks or any other
- 3:49company that's based real criticism by politicians
- 3:53reporters and consumers. I'm not really sure what his
- 3:57point is and it's not like the people, he chose base.
- 4:00Listen Paige had these like have these really tiny short-lived
- 4:04careers of their companies, because right, if they couldn't
- 4:07and besos owns the Washington Post, so it he's he's tweeted
- 4:12before that where said before, you know, CEOs need to have a
- 4:15tough skin. I mean, yeah, it does.
- 4:18If this seems like a very San Francisco complaint, you know,
- 4:23just like, oh, criticism sucks or at least people that still
- 4:26live in San Francisco. I complain.
- 4:28I just think I'm playing it. Was somebody who hasn't really
- 4:30He looked at any other industry before any other large impactful
- 4:34industry, I mean it's almost too easy to attack the logic behind
- 4:39the first one in that thread about you know, the the not
- 4:43making it fun anymore. So I almost don't want to spend
- 4:47any time on it because it's, you know, we're now like a week
- 4:49almost from that tweet and everyone is just destroyed it.
- 4:52But the idea of, you know, there being some sort of Market
- 4:55solution that is opposed to cancel culture was his effective
- 4:59what he's talking about. Is pretty hysterical because
- 5:01that's the same thing. I mean the point of cancelled
- 5:03culture as a concern. No one's forcing it like it's
- 5:06coming. It's a Grassroots movement.
- 5:09So if your point is like people can vote with their wallets as a
- 5:12way to correct, the mistakes that companies or people are
- 5:16making dude, that's canceled culture.
- 5:19I don't know how else to describe it is.
- 5:20You're actually out of a Kind by social media, the very industry
- 5:24and very, you know, if he's defending Facebook, I know that
- 5:27Facebook that allows cancel culture to List there would be
- 5:30no cancel culture if there weren't social media.
- 5:33Yeah, he wants to make it about the Press clearly and he says
- 5:36press politicians and trolls trolls.
- 5:39Trolls is a big area, stroll scape word because I feel like
- 5:43really it's the public, you know that to some degree, I think the
- 5:46Press is more Pro. These companies then at least
- 5:51the average Twitter user, which is I think the world he's
- 5:54communicating he's with Yeah, I mean again this this is like
- 5:59just drawing everything back to Twitter.
- 6:01I think even journalists will be more critical about companies on
- 6:05Twitter. It when you actually look at
- 6:06their work tends to be fairly even-handed if not pro company,
- 6:10a lot of the time. So there's a lot of
- 6:12extrapolation made unlike what, you know, the public is and
- 6:16what, you know sentiment is based on their unhappiness on
- 6:19Twitter, which, you know, dude, just get off Twitter.
- 6:21It's, it'll say, it sounds like if that's a huge part of your
- 6:24problem, you can solve that one. Pretty easy.
- 6:26It is. It seems like his Twitter
- 6:28specific problem. Like the New York Times is not
- 6:30writing about coinbase that much like they did a big
- 6:33investigation into it, but what's keeping it in the
- 6:37headlines or what's keeping him? Brian Armstrong's mind.
- 6:40Presumably is just people at tweeting.
- 6:43I'm right. I saw that.
- 6:45Brian chesky is going to be interviewed on axios this
- 6:49evening. We're recording this on a Sunday
- 6:52in which the snippet that I saw said, you know, they're like
- 6:55what are the biggest threats? Facing US tech companies.
- 6:58This these days and his response was something like the fact that
- 7:00the public hates it right now. And I've also seen, you know,
- 7:04it's an ex Facebook executive out there talking about how in
- 7:07San Francisco, you know, the public or politicians or
- 7:10whatever it is, is doing their best to destroy the network
- 7:13effects of the city because they hate these companies so much.
- 7:16And to me, it's just hard to look at any of these complaints
- 7:21and not see a, I'm sorry, use the word, but like a wine Enos
- 7:25on the fact that they're just not.
- 7:26Universally agile, aided by the public that there isn't like a
- 7:30complete sense of agreement with everything they stand for and
- 7:33everything they're literally just being treated like every
- 7:35other industry. Yeah.
- 7:37And people like to like tech companies, right?
- 7:39I mean, just I mean, the data is just like a little more people
- 7:43like thanks Amazon's one of the most trusted organizations in
- 7:47the world. I was just remarking to my
- 7:50girlfriend, you know, we were traveling internationally and
- 7:52you're dealing with like, terrible, passport
- 7:54infrastructure and governments and you're like, Oh this the
- 7:57government doesn't work that well, I mean, even as like a
- 7:59super cynical Tech reporter, this is gonna get me booed, I
- 8:04think, but if I had to trust any organization to move me around
- 8:07the world, I think it would be Amazon.
- 8:09You know, like that? That is my genuine.
- 8:11Sincere you a box here but we especially the packaging is
- 8:15quite waste. There are few, not
- 8:22understanding, why, or how she's like Amazon.
- 8:26Like, who do you really trust? You, they need to, like, do some
- 8:30sort of logistical feat. Yeah, and still, you know, I
- 8:35think we should spend most of our time as press scrutinizing
- 8:38Amazon, because that's sort of the basis sumption.
- 8:41That Amazon's huge is what we all rely on it.
- 8:44It's it's a big part of our society kudos to you.
- 8:48You know. I do we really need to say that
- 8:49all the time like that Simplicity.
- 8:51Well reason they get criticism is because they're so big.
- 8:54We think because they have power influence, Fluent right?
- 8:57Do they need a pat on the back to?
- 8:58It's like you got it. Like, you get the money, you
- 9:00know? You never say.
- 9:02Thank you. That's what the money is for.
- 9:04Yeah. But with also, the most
- 9:05concerning parts of Amazon, or the part that gets criticized,
- 9:08the most, by the press or whatever, by critics are things
- 9:11that usually happen behind the scenes, right?
- 9:13That their actions taking place in their warehouses or, you
- 9:18know, maybe the internal mechanisms of their lobbying
- 9:20efforts or, you know, hq2 and things like that.
- 9:24I mean, the reason Facebook probably is the most hated of
- 9:26all of these. Companies right now is because
- 9:27it's all laid out there in for public view like we as the
- 9:30public or participating in it. But also, you know, the
- 9:33unhappiness that we see politically socially right now.
- 9:37And then the part of it that we have attributed to Facebook is
- 9:40just so available. It's in this kind of like public
- 9:44view that we can find our anger in it placed.
- 9:47Very viscerally. Yeah, we were part of it.
- 9:49Yeah. Yeah.
- 9:50Where is like, you know, Amazon is probably the least of all of
- 9:54them. Right there are these cameras on
- 9:55just faces the same? Criticism that Starbucks or
- 9:58Walmart faces, Amazon faces, the criticism of any large employer
- 10:02that employs you know a lot of people with varying degrees of
- 10:06benefits, you know. So it's no it's really no
- 10:11different than the way that Walmart was criticized a couple
- 10:14of decades ago. Right.
- 10:15Let's start by right criticized. Well, Marty Trio for its for how
- 10:19its scheduled part-time employees.
- 10:20Basically destroying their lives in order to maximize, like a
- 10:24scintilla of profit for Starbucks, like there was The
- 10:27good that came out of that reporting, is that Starbucks
- 10:31decided that it was worth it, for whatever reason.
- 10:34I'm not going to get in their heads but it was worth it to
- 10:36change that system and ultimately it was a benefit to
- 10:38employees. I think the Amazon is actually
- 10:40criticized just like any other large corporate employer.
- 10:44Facebook is different. Facebook is very different.
- 10:47Yeah because you know better. Well yeah, I think that's a
- 10:50great distillation of it that Part of the issue with Facebook
- 10:54and why why it can feel like everybody has an opinion.
- 10:57Because so much of what they're doing wrong is self-evident.
- 10:59Like obviously there's a lot of good reporting on the internal
- 11:02workings and we learned some of that and that's all important
- 11:05and I don't want to under play that but it does feel like a lot
- 11:09of the problems with Facebook you can just consume it because
- 11:13that Saucy well the problems with face, right?
- 11:15Right. Yeah, I do wish like in the in
- 11:20the media critiques. Like this is talking about the
- 11:24Press first, the the Brian Armstrong thing they were
- 11:28pivoting around here II do? I wish we would just sort of
- 11:31like distinguish between like press reporters Gathering new
- 11:36information, like the stories, you're outlining on Amazon,
- 11:39where it's like stuff. We don't see where there
- 11:40actually were people are doing reporting but so much of this
- 11:44stuff they hate in the Press is just like yeah, how they
- 11:47manifest. At how the reporters behave on
- 11:49Twitter, op-ed columns, like I feel like we almost
- 11:53strategically as the media should get want to get to a
- 11:56point where we collapse, op-ed columns into just like that's
- 12:01just a person, you know, it's just like those should just be
- 12:03treated as people and not distinguished as press because
- 12:07like they're just mad. They'll like the public members
- 12:10of the public disagree. With what with what they're
- 12:13doing, you know, it's not real but largely yeah, yeah, no.
- 12:18And this all just seems to be boomeranging from the collapse
- 12:23of the mythology that a lot of tech Executives and Venture
- 12:27capitalists and people in the industry created over the last
- 12:30decade which is that we're going to do big industry, but we're
- 12:33going to do it different. We're going to find a way to
- 12:35inspire people. Not just to make a lot of money
- 12:38by building huge businesses that take over smaller businesses and
- 12:41all aspects of Our Lives. Lives.
- 12:42We're going to do it with the mission and we're going to do it
- 12:45in a way that is inspiring. The people that not only work at
- 12:48the companies but the people that use it and when it comes
- 12:51down to it, we're now like you know a decade two decades into
- 12:54that movement. We've seen that everything just
- 12:56kind of falls back into place of what you know the trajectory of
- 12:59big business and you may think you've done it differently and
- 13:02think you've built a completely new infrastructure like like
- 13:08social infrastructure around it, but it's it just ends up being
- 13:10the same thing and you're just going through You know, like
- 13:13Haiti can probably talk more to this than any of us about like
- 13:16what kind of happened with the banking industry in 2008.
- 13:19And obviously it hasn't destroyed, you know, the economy
- 13:22in the way that that did. But people just lost faith in
- 13:26you know, the positive aspects of this business and sort of see
- 13:28it as a an industry. That enriches a lot of people
- 13:31and that's because it is so embedded in our lives, we can't
- 13:34write, we can't walk away from JP Morgan or Citibank.
- 13:40We have to use them. And similarly, You can argue
- 13:43that social media has also been embedded in our lives.
- 13:45Like, we don't have to be on Twitter, but again, I've said
- 13:48this a million times. If you live in a rural part of
- 13:50the country, almost all of your services are on Facebook.
- 13:53So your city, Hall's website is a Facebook page.
- 13:57Your kids Elementary School website is a Facebook page.
- 14:00If you want to know what's going on at your church, it's a
- 14:02Facebook page. So there is a way in which it's
- 14:04really hard to walk away from a service like Facebook to.
- 14:08So it's more like how do we change the company because we're
- 14:11in many ways stuck. Stop with the company.
- 14:13We aren't the three of us. We can walk away from Facebook
- 14:16and Instagram but I just wonder where addicts, right?
- 14:20That's it. And when we when we all quit her
- 14:23job but it's funny even you don't
- 14:36have to be on Twitter for it to affect your lives, right?
- 14:39I mean in our now, trash cans Code, that was recording on
- 14:43Friday. You know, I always bring up my
- 14:46mom as like the perfect example of, like my mrs.
- 14:49Duck tongue. Yeah, as like the American who
- 14:51is incredibly influenced by the news that she consumes large you
- 14:55through CNN and I don't know, the chronicle and whatever else
- 14:58she is. Never been on Twitter.
- 14:59I think she briefly joined it during the 2016 election because
- 15:03there was so much talk of it. She's like, what's this about?
- 15:06And she main account, she got on and she's like, oh no, this is
- 15:09impossible to use in. This is scary but the opinion.
- 15:12That get discussed on Twitter, obviously influence.
- 15:16A lot of the mainstream news and it's almost like Twitter is the
- 15:19AWS of opinion making like you don't Nest, you don't know that
- 15:22it's there but it exists as this fundamental infrastructure layer
- 15:26to the way, the broader World works that opinions are being
- 15:30workshopped on it all the time to find most basically the most
- 15:34outrageous opinions, the stickiest ones.
- 15:36And then you have the ones that then breakthrough and land on
- 15:41Fox or on you know, MSNBC or whatever, right?
- 15:44It's like Don Lemon reads Twitter or his producers reach
- 15:47Twitter and then they help him. Formulate, the talking points
- 15:50that are going to eat a really stimulate the particular
- 15:53audience that still watches CNN and and yeah, I think like again
- 15:57it gets back to the idea that people are unhappy in a lot of
- 16:00ways right now. And Tech is behind so much of it
- 16:04just because of the tools and systems that they built, and
- 16:07these CEOs are going to have to just reckon with that.
- 16:10Like you can't just blame the press and say Were, you know,
- 16:13independently writing mean things about them.
- 16:17And if we just stopped doing it, everyone would feel better.
- 16:19Well, I think there is actually a good bridge between these
- 16:23tweet storms in what you guys have been saying.
- 16:26Because I mean we basically have the tech companies, particularly
- 16:29Google and Facebook setting themselves up as he's like
- 16:32world-changing companies and there's nothing that the Press
- 16:36loves more than when you set high standards for yourself over
- 16:39the breast and the public, you know, because you'll be measured
- 16:41against the standards. You Publicly articulate, so then
- 16:44you're not, you know, it's a backhoe company.
- 16:45Your this world-changing company you get held by heart high
- 16:48standards. And then we have Armstrong
- 16:51coming in and saying, actually, we're a company with a specific
- 16:55Mission. We shouldn't have politics that
- 16:57our company and so we're going to we're going to stick to the
- 17:00mission. We're not everything and
- 17:02anything. And so then you get this sort of
- 17:05tweet storm that is definitely maligned by the Press.
- 17:10I'm sure. I mean, I was super - about I
- 17:12still have some issues with it that we can expand on, but then,
- 17:16in a sort of Victory lap, September 30th.
- 17:21You know, he says, what was amazing was the contrast between
- 17:23the news, following my post and the reaction from employees.
- 17:27And people who spoke to me in private while the media reports
- 17:30were mostly negative and it even spawned some retaliatory and
- 17:34intellectually dishonest hit pieces, the reaction both from
- 17:36employees and people I spoke to in private, was overwhelmingly
- 17:40positive. In fact.
- 17:42Good. This is, of course, every single
- 17:51employee, who bothered to say, something to you said something
- 17:54positive. Yeah, it's amazing how people
- 17:55during their performance reviews were so complimentary about
- 17:58these lipids I put in place and I just think like, dude, if
- 18:01everyone is so complimentary about your policies behind the
- 18:04scenes, then why do you need the feel the need to in public
- 18:07defend them, just ignore it, clearly doesn't matter, it's not
- 18:09reflective of reality. So the fact that he Is taking
- 18:13this quote-unquote Victory lap. And and I would just like to see
- 18:16the data behind the positive, because there are ways to
- 18:19measure these sort of things, right?
- 18:20Attrition rates to, those go down after you implemented.
- 18:23These policies, to employee morale, surveys, which I know
- 18:26we're not the perfect measure, but at least it's something.
- 18:29Like, if you had pointed to those things I write, I mean, he
- 18:31says we meeting grown our headcount about 110 percent.
- 18:34While our diversity numbers have remained the same or even
- 18:37improved on some metrics, I mean, that's super thin.
- 18:40Well, that's actually kind of shitty, like, if you It doubled
- 18:43your employee size and only barely budged on right person.
- 18:45And that's especially when people are to say that's a big
- 18:48victory. I just, you know, I I don't
- 18:53disagree with the, I don't disagree with the idea that it's
- 18:56good to focus more on were than on.
- 18:59You know what people are angry about on Twitter, vis-à-vis
- 19:02politics. I don't think that's a bad
- 19:05message to an employee base, which is let's spend our
- 19:08husband, our work hours, working on work, but Why do you why do
- 19:13you think the Press with? So - at the time and now we're
- 19:16all just unhappy. I mean it was a say with such a,
- 19:20you know, tumultuous time I was going to say, it was an
- 19:22extraordinary time. It wasn't, it wasn't if if we
- 19:26could rewind and go back to sort of a pre covid moment and if a
- 19:33CEO, I said I really just think that we're all talking about
- 19:35politics too much. It's a distraction.
- 19:38I don't think it would have felt.
- 19:39I don't think people would have paid much attention.
- 19:41It just happened to come In this moment, we were dealing with a
- 19:43global pandemic, sort of this like bizarre.
- 19:49You know, the sort of like bizarre moment where the
- 19:51government was had forced us all to stay in our homes which I
- 19:54think most people could not have conceived of the United States
- 19:56until that minute. And then like really important
- 20:00conversations about race that were sparked by one of the most
- 20:03horrifying viral videos of a person being killed by another
- 20:06human being that any of us have ever seen in a really long time.
- 20:10So in that moment to say, I'm just really think that is weird
- 20:14to talk about politics. Felt weird in that moment we
- 20:17needed outlets, right? And and yeah, that was one of
- 20:19the first kind of communal things that had happened since
- 20:22the beginning of the pandemic. I remember as the protests were
- 20:25going, it was like that, in Tiger King, right?
- 20:28We're yeah, exactly. Two, two sides of the same but
- 20:33but you know what I mean? It was like, no, I'm not being
- 20:36sarcastic. Things revealed, dark aspects of
- 20:39our country. Think there's a degree to which
- 20:44Armstrong never makes the politics tweet storm.
- 20:47We're still getting to the same place.
- 20:48Like there's just a nature that movement sort of burn really
- 20:52hot, and then it's not like he convinced people.
- 20:55I think that, I mean, obviously, you know, there are some CEOs
- 21:00who, you know, set policies and cultural norms, that sort of
- 21:03discouraged employee Revolution. But I do think there's a degree
- 21:07to which these things just sort of play out and sort of The heat
- 21:12the heat was going to when I was going to go right down, generate
- 21:15taking credit for it or not is sort of outside of his control.
- 21:18I am very empathetic to if it is true that at coinbase and
- 21:22another company's there were intense and ongoing political
- 21:26discussions talking about larger, social issues,
- 21:29International politics, or whatever happening on slack that
- 21:32actually does sound hellish, that sounds completely
- 21:35destabilizing for a company and awful venue to do it and we can
- 21:38maybe explain eighties live with that.
- 21:40Well, I was going to say, I think I think The Daily Beast is
- 21:43extensively reported on how happened at the New York Times,
- 21:46so I can talk about it because it's public, but it was.
- 21:49No fun is the distraction. Yeah, I'm not.
- 21:54I'm not weighing in on the veracity of the arguments being
- 21:58made. I'm not and the legitimacy of
- 22:01them. I'm not criticize.
- 22:02My criticizing my colleagues for having strong opinions and
- 22:05sharing them in slack. I'm just saying that as it
- 22:08became as I move from slack out into To the public sphere,
- 22:13through the very dogged reporting of other reporters.
- 22:15Like Max. Hey, why?
- 22:16Haven't we hired, Max stuff. Anyway, so that happened, you
- 22:21were times Ombudsman. It's at Michael Pittman.
- 22:24It's really hard to argue that. That wasn't a distraction.
- 22:29I mean, it's impossible to say that it wasn't a distraction.
- 22:33Yeah. To the tech company.
- 22:34Specifically part of this is also just inevitable and a
- 22:37relation to this focus on Mission that we keep coming back
- 22:41to Is the way that these companies were pitch to.
- 22:44A lot of people is you can be a part of the change for good in
- 22:48the world. And if you believe that you're
- 22:50going to think that everything the company stands for has to be
- 22:53reflection of all of your social values.
- 22:55And if you've subsumed yourself to the company's Mission and
- 22:58your personal mission, then when things are going on in the
- 23:00world, that's your outlet to express it, like you've now
- 23:04created like your soul communal, you know spot where these things
- 23:09can be hashed out. And if you don't have anything
- 23:12else then like of course it's going to explode on slack
- 23:15because you've given up all other aspects of your Social
- 23:17expression technique scented of media companies and Mission
- 23:21driven company. You know, there's actually a
- 23:24strong and valid comparison between what's happening in some
- 23:28Silicon Valley companies, or some startups that were that
- 23:31consider this themselves mission-driven in some respect,
- 23:35and it was happening in some media companies.
- 23:37I'll just keep General. Yeah, because if the companies
- 23:41Have pitched themselves to their employees as a business.
- 23:45That also does something for the greater good.
- 23:47If you're sitting at home thinking a lot about, you know,
- 23:53protests that are happening around the country in the wake
- 23:56of George Floyd. We're thinking a lot about the
- 23:58fact that we are even home trapped in our houses, because
- 24:01of a global pandemic that we can't understand.
- 24:04But people have very do varying opinions on whether or not
- 24:07politicians are able to handle it.
- 24:09That does speak to a sense of you know outrage and it also
- 24:14speaks to a sense of what are we doing about it to some level?
- 24:17I want a company to mission-driven right?
- 24:19I should be cheering for. If companies want to take on
- 24:22maybe as a shareholder, I wouldn't but as sort of a member
- 24:25of the public it's good for companies to take on positive
- 24:29missions. It's just probably clarify and
- 24:31everybody involved if it's a narrow enough mission that
- 24:34people can understand it otherwise you're spending a ton
- 24:36of time soul-searching about it, all right.
- 24:39Don't know how was your articulate, like, shouldn't we
- 24:41as reporters be. Glad that Google at once said,
- 24:45you know, do no evil because then you can hold them to that.
- 24:47And that's better than a tobacco company that just says, like,
- 24:50fuck you or whatever, I don't know.
- 24:53The, I don't do disagree, or you're like so much on the level
- 24:57like, oh, the world would just be better if like, profit
- 25:00revamped. I just got distracted by, like,
- 25:02the nuclear submarine issue, Espionage issue.
- 25:04So, I just need to send like to emails really quick.
- 25:08All right, okay, I can, I Deal with that question?
- 25:10Yeah, yeah. I mean, Google has been slammed
- 25:12for y'all. Now, we're at a low low quality
- 25:15Harvard Business School, like is Mission.
- 25:18I mean, it may be out of our depth, but that's why I was
- 25:21trying to frame it or normatively just like, isn't it
- 25:24good for the public at least if they hold themselves to that and
- 25:26then we can hold hold them to some level of benevolence.
- 25:31Yeah, I mean, at some point, everything is just a reflection
- 25:34of are you happy with the products that you're
- 25:35participating in and buying let's put like this.
- 25:38I think it's It's a cheap shot at times for The Press to
- 25:42anytime something happens that is, you know, moderate to
- 25:46extremely evil in terms of Google's, you know, actions that
- 25:50you say home that doesn't sound like, don't be evil.
- 25:52Like I don't think it's a particularly intelligent way to
- 25:55cover a company. And I don't know, I mean Eric
- 25:57you wrote about boober through its most tumultuous period the
- 26:01cause of some of its tumult. I don't know what the company.
- 26:04Yeah, there. I don't think it was actually
- 26:07talks. There's an issue with you.
- 26:09Their points that we're going to be very big and very good at
- 26:11what we do, right? Yeah.
- 26:13I know. I don't think that was a case
- 26:16where the company sort of oversold, how good it was and
- 26:20then people were disappointed. I think, you know, just became
- 26:23so untenable but you know, right as public Revolt.
- 26:28Yeah. But missions are interesting
- 26:30because I just think that you can say what you want to be
- 26:34perceived as all you want, but the actions that you take and
- 26:38just the industry that you're You're part of and the larger
- 26:40capitalistic system that you participate in are going to
- 26:43ultimately take contrived. I don't know.
- 26:45I mean, like Nike like all these Brands like how what they tell
- 26:48us about who they are is much? I mean, people aren't like, oh,
- 26:53Nike is like a brand that manufacture, you know, it is
- 26:57very much like how they articulate themselves and adds
- 27:00like, I'm surprised, this is II. Don't think this is your real
- 27:03view here because what they say about themselves is what people
- 27:07tend to believe. I think people either like the
- 27:10products or they don't, you know, I mean people like Amazon
- 27:13because it gets them their stuff very quickly.
- 27:14Right? What seems like a reasonable
- 27:16price Facebook when they like it.
- 27:17It's because they can communicate with their friends.
- 27:20Google is like a very good tool to find the stuff that you want.
- 27:23And with YouTube, you know, an entertainment platform and then
- 27:27you know, we can go on down the list.
- 27:29So yeah, I agree. I mean products terribly because
- 27:32yeah, yeah, and I don't think that necessarily needs to be oh
- 27:35Apple, we didn't mention mean, apple is like they make stuff.
- 27:38You'd like, like it's as physical.
- 27:40Good of any of these things and people think they work well and
- 27:44they look nice. And I don't think it necessarily
- 27:47like the fact that these things are are not connected to a
- 27:50larger Mission necessary needs to be evil.
- 27:52And and I and and like a sign of hypocrisy.
- 27:54I just think like for a reporter.
- 27:56Anytime you're covering a company, you have to, you just
- 27:59have to move outside of that particular frame pretty quickly
- 28:03because it's just not that until in intelligent.
- 28:05Like, when you're talking to sources and, you know, So if
- 28:08you're covering ghoul, you're like mmm.
- 28:10That sounds like, that could be kind of easier.
- 28:12Yeah. Just just isn't isn't that
- 28:14useful? But I do think that, you know,
- 28:16like we were mentioning earlier episode, we're just at a period
- 28:19now where these companies their influence their power is never
- 28:23at a greater Point than has ever been and the implications of
- 28:26that are vast, which ties it back to Brian Armstrong's main
- 28:29problem, being he has to listen to General people on Twitter,
- 28:32right? I mean, if he was just talking
- 28:34to his customers, they would have different complaints, then
- 28:37sort of them, whatever. He's probably feeling when he
- 28:40opens up his Twitter feed and so then it makes his CEOs get too
- 28:45much criticism stuff is just like, don't read it.
- 28:48If you don't want, you don't want to see it, pay somebody to
- 28:51read it and tell you what, what actually matters, you know.
- 28:54I it's amazing that our media diets.
- 28:56I guess shape our brain so much and he even the CEO of, you
- 29:00know, this huge company is subject to that.
- 29:03So you know, we're recording this on a Sunday and the VP of
- 29:07communications at Facebook Look, Nick Clegg, former lib Dem prime
- 29:13minister. What was he?
- 29:14He was like a high-ranking, British officials embarrassing
- 29:16that I don't know the specific name, but, you know, he's making
- 29:19the rounds and getting kind of browbeaten by anchors at all the
- 29:22major cable networks over the Facebook whistleblowers,
- 29:25testimony, that happened last week, and I'm seeing a lot of
- 29:29complaints by reporters some reporters.
- 29:32I mean, I can mention, Kara Swisher, specifically, she has
- 29:34so many followers is very angry that he didn't.
- 29:38Speak to her. And, you know, the interviews
- 29:40that Facebook is doing right now are not with the beat reporters
- 29:44when I say Facebook. I mean, like, you know, zoc and
- 29:46or Nick Clegg. And people at that Echelon are
- 29:48not with the beat reporters. It's with these National cable
- 29:53news figures. I mean, do you think that's a
- 29:55valid criticism? Do you think it's important and
- 29:59why they're doing it? I'm sorry, I'm back.
- 30:00Sorry sorry. I've no, I understand why
- 30:04they're why they're doing it because they need to make their
- 30:06appeal to the General Public. Because they're not afraid of
- 30:10Regulation per se. They're afraid of people like,
- 30:12you and me no longer using their products.
- 30:15They're afraid of everybody deleting WhatsApp.
- 30:16So their appeal needs to go to the world of WhatsApp users.
- 30:21It doesn't need to go to, you know, the people who read
- 30:25business process to read Tech, press, they, whether if you're
- 30:29the I'm not saying I like the strategy and I'm not saying that
- 30:31I think the strategy is good. I'm just saying I really
- 30:34understand the logic behind it there.
- 30:36They need to appeal to your mom too.
- 30:40Who hates Mark Zuckerberg right now.
- 30:41Right. And then areas non-defined
- 30:43reasons so they need to go on. Good Morning America and make
- 30:46that argument for why you don't have to hate Mark Zuckerberg.
- 30:49And why the products aren't driving teenagers to kill
- 30:51themselves and making that argument to like the business
- 30:55pages of the New York Times or the Wall Street Journal is your
- 30:58mom reading that know, right. Exactly.
- 31:01Right. But it's beat reporter or like
- 31:03as Savvy instead of reporters. I do think it makes sense to
- 31:06cheer for Facebook to get Give interviews to the most
- 31:09sophisticated reporters and and yes, they're tactically going to
- 31:14try to give it to sort of simplistic TV, reporters.
- 31:18And I don't make sense for a care of.
- 31:21This is what the rough sea report.
- 31:23I don't think it's because the teeth, they think, the TV
- 31:25reporters, don't know what they're doing.
- 31:27I think they're thinking about the audience sure.
- 31:29Either way. It's Kara were to do the
- 31:31interview on Good Morning, America.
- 31:33I think they would do the interview with Cara if Cara work
- 31:36to the interview. And you know, like a widely
- 31:40watch platform on 60 Minutes. I think they would do it with
- 31:44her, right. But TV is a different kind of
- 31:46way I can print like print the wind, you still sort of have to
- 31:49convince her report earlier saying something smart since
- 31:52it's passing through them. Well II don't think that all TV
- 31:56is stupid. I don't I just don't agree with
- 31:58that argument. You're really think it's
- 31:59audience. I think if you want Tom's mom to
- 32:03not delete her Instagram account, you're not going to
- 32:05reach her in the business pages of the New York.
- 32:08Times you were you were going to reach her on 60 Minutes or
- 32:12you'll reach her on wherever the hell they've been talking.
- 32:14You know, if it's a thing, it's more audience and of course, you
- 32:19know, we saw this, we said a politician.
- 32:21So funny, because I think your take on this is really different
- 32:23when politicians to the Eric but we've seen politicians do it as
- 32:26well. In ways that infuriated me.
- 32:30Anyway, no, I always said it's good.
- 32:33I said it was good for them to do ferns but he won't sit for
- 32:36the Washington Post. It's like what's Or problem
- 32:38Obama, that sucks. But like I do understand that, I
- 32:42understand why even if I deeply disagree with it.
- 32:45Well, I'm politics. I'm were skeptical of a lot of
- 32:49the beat reporters than on. Well, I remember getting into an
- 32:53argument about that earlier. Oh, no, sorry, yes, softball
- 33:02interview. I don't know.
- 33:05Yeah, is Ashley Parker. You think I'm doing no.
- 33:08Is it a is? It Tony ROM, you think would
- 33:11throw those softballs they need to do you, are you telling me
- 33:14that Tech reporters have a better reputation for not being
- 33:17softball reporters? And political reporters are
- 33:20watching in post. I just think, you know, in a
- 33:23presidential campaign reporters want to frame the story around
- 33:27the storylines that they're like, breaking news on.
- 33:30I mean, if you saw enjoy way better student, Do this.
- 33:35Right. I mean they do but you know I
- 33:37just believe in some of the criticisms of Facebook more than
- 33:40I do. Sort of the angles played
- 33:43against. That's right.
- 33:44Because you hate it. When people critique Obama has
- 33:47he worked on his campaign as an intern?
- 33:51Yeah. But I certainly I believe in
- 33:55Obama. Like yeah, I'm down here.
- 34:00Next weekend. We can give Eric work.
- 34:03Evil. I want be true.
- 34:05Is to get thoughtful interviews, occasionally.
- 34:09I think that's good in politics and Tech.
- 34:11I believe that's important. And I think it's important that
- 34:14the institutions, whether it's a campaign or the apparatus of a
- 34:18company respond and engage with reporters, I couldn't believe in
- 34:22that more strongly, but you're just saying that it's really
- 34:25unlikely that a political reporter will get anything out.
- 34:28I just think reporting with them.
- 34:30Whereas you think that orders? Where's he think a tech reporter
- 34:32will actually get something out of Mark Zuckerberg sitting with
- 34:34them? But you don't think that a
- 34:36political reporter will get something out of, you know, a
- 34:40politician sitting with them. I agree with.
- 34:43I think in both cases with Zuckerberg and with a
- 34:47presidential candidate there, they end up going for like your
- 34:52get trying to get bad quotes. It's very similar to TV.
- 34:55I think, what's actually more substantive in a lot of these
- 34:58cases is that like to press secretary or that the actual
- 35:02company apparatus is engaging with like the factual responses
- 35:06and it's not so much. I like a single interview that's
- 35:11like the most important as as opposed to sort of like good
- 35:14faith sort of engagement on on the factual reporting.
- 35:18I don't know you disagree with that.
- 35:21I just think that that undermines the argument you just
- 35:24made but I do agree with. I just do.
- 35:29I think that you're sort of the way that you distinguish me in
- 35:33the tech press in the political process.
- 35:34Doesn't really make any sense to me.
- 35:37I think that anytime you're covering a beat, there are
- 35:42questions about how you're going to approach.
- 35:44Tough Quest tough lines of inquiry but I just, I guess I
- 35:49just don't understand This distinction we make between, you
- 35:54know, this ability for a tech reporter to really get a lot out
- 35:58of an interview with Mark Zuckerberg, but that you just
- 36:01don't think of political reporter could get a lot out of
- 36:03my Canada but I can, I can I interject here just to ask like
- 36:07what is get a lot out of in these circumstances and
- 36:10demeaning because you know, these people are incredibly
- 36:13coach, the best you could get from them is a slip-up is is a
- 36:16Mark Zuckerberg actually on Cara's podcast a couple years
- 36:19back, making a truly awful. Comparison about Lala fala good.
- 36:22I think, was on purpose. I mean, I write that was right.
- 36:25Wasn't even a slip-up that was just.
- 36:31It sounds to me, like, what is that?
- 36:36Political reporters will get played and that Tech reporters?
- 36:39No, no. I we're both getting played and
- 36:43that political reporters, just go for like this sort of like
- 36:45crass, gotcha, but Tech reporters would never do that.
- 36:49Oh no, I think they both go for the crash.
- 36:51Gotcha. I think it's I don't think
- 36:53there's a huge amount of value. And you know, whether it's a
- 36:55national news reporter or whatever, you know, like a TV
- 36:58anchor or morning news anchor or a tech reporter doing the
- 37:01interview with Mark Zuckerberg. I don't think there's going to
- 37:03be a lot gain from it other than whatever their coaching allows
- 37:07for if they're well trained. They will say things that are
- 37:10kind of meaningless and deflect from the quote, unquote hard
- 37:13questions. And if they're not well trained,
- 37:14they'll say something stupid. That makes maybe the new cycle
- 37:17lasts for a couple days longer but I I just don't like the
- 37:20great reporting that is come out, that has held Facebook and
- 37:22all these other tech companies feet to the fire have come not
- 37:25through these sort of exactly wasn't a woman.
- 37:27Run interview with Mark Zuckerberg.
- 37:29Exactly what I see people like care who I respect.
- 37:34You know and other reporters saying oh they're not giving me
- 37:37the interview I just think, okay, that's their choice
- 37:40because they're running a press campaign right now.
- 37:42Exactly, exactly. And it's so much more from
- 37:44getting people leaking to you and and, and getting them all
- 37:47messed up that way. Then like Bitching and moaning
- 37:50on Twitter about the fact that you didn't get the interview.
- 37:52I don't care. I don't know if I'd call it
- 37:53bitching and moaning but I mean because I understand the
- 37:55frustration when it comes to campaign, reporters are much
- 37:58more skeptical. It's because a lot of with the
- 38:00reporters are doing there is saying which stories matter and
- 38:06that fundamentally the Democratic process is there's no
- 38:08like super sophisticated version of it.
- 38:11There's like there's what the elites thinks is important.
- 38:14There's what regular people think is important to
- 38:16participating with beat reporters on when reporting
- 38:20you're giving it up to a certain set of people to say, oh, we're
- 38:23obsessed with Hillary Clinton's emails or whatever when that's
- 38:26just their view on what storylines matter the most.
- 38:29So I'm just much less deferential to campaign
- 38:32reporters about what stories matter that I am on something
- 38:35like the justice department or Facebook, where there's a level
- 38:38of like understanding an organization.
- 38:41The technicalities where I really do, respect the be
- 38:44reporters for really having a sophisticated View.
- 38:46And so I would like to support them and having more.
- 38:49Information to continue to develop that and I believe in
- 38:53that sort of elitism, that's my full View.
- 38:57The elitism of reporters who are very knowledgeable about their
- 39:00beats, that are not covering specific interest, like an
- 39:03academic to be but like, I can't paint.
- 39:06I just don't think you can have that.
- 39:07Like, sure, if it's like the factual matter of what's
- 39:10happening on a campaign, do I trust the campaign?
- 39:13We're, there's more to know on a personal level, but do I trust
- 39:16them more to decide that the Personnel level stuff of a
- 39:20campaign, is what we should care about most.
- 39:21Like should we have written Jimmy, Carter off more as much
- 39:25as he was because they were sort of.
- 39:27Of incompetent, or should we have cared more about sort of
- 39:29the general moral Vector of what he stood for relative to his
- 39:33opponents? Like the media is great at
- 39:36getting us to focus on weird competence stuff over the actual
- 39:39moral character of political campaigns.
- 39:42And that's why I'm super - on campaign report.
- 39:45Yes, I think we are still torn up about the 1980.
- 39:49Carter re-election campaign I didn't see the podcast go in
- 39:52this direction, you but you were not born.
- 39:57But Nikki is the only one I think was around to that cat is.
- 40:02Yeah. Yeah, no morning in America,
- 40:05with hard to hard to overcome. I think we can all agree.
- 40:08We can agree with that. Anyway.
- 40:10So we've really, really, well, I really was put on a back right
- 40:14there and I needed to sort of come up with my full full view.
- 40:18Well, I was worried that Katie when she was gonna come back
- 40:20from her, call was going to tell us like we have 10 minutes
- 40:22before the nuclear subs ballistic.
- 40:27Missiles. So I hate to cut the episode off
- 40:29early but your bunker is there? No, just some spies, I don't
- 40:34know where we go from there. A back to the reading text
- 40:37reporters other than if you're working at a tech company and
- 40:40you reach out to a reporter and say I would like to thank you.
- 40:44Yeah. Very different reception.
- 40:47Yeah. Well we're you know, like we
- 40:49said last week or two weeks ago now it's like we're in the age
- 40:51of whistleblowers, you know. There was like a handbook that
- 40:54came out last week led by I think the Pinterest
- 40:58whistleblower that are trying to encourage employees, you know,
- 41:01or instruct them on the right way to become a whistleblower,
- 41:04you too can become a whistleblower Madam.
- 41:06And I, I I'm interested to see where that's going to go,
- 41:10because it all to me, like, rolls back into this topic that
- 41:13we've been hitting on over and over again.
- 41:15The last couple of weeks, which is like whistleblowers are or
- 41:18leakers, whatever want to call them, are the results of a
- 41:21section of a Workforce that is not happy with the way the
- 41:25company is run and do not Leave internally that it can be fixed.
- 41:30That there are the infrastructure in place for
- 41:32these things to be repaired. And some of them may be just
- 41:34want fame, you know, we can debate that, but it seems like
- 41:38the upsides of that are much less than the downside of.
- 41:42Because once you get everything, what unquote like you don't want
- 41:45to work again. So your Snowden and Russia like
- 41:48it's manner or Chelsea Manning in prison.
- 41:50That's not great. I mean, I wanted to make another
- 41:54Point quickly. I mean, the just Just sort of
- 41:58how this latest Brian Armstrong tweet about, you know, the
- 42:03whining. One could come off well, in the
- 42:05future. I mean, I think like, in the few
- 42:08know, we could look back on it as just sort of Things are too -
- 42:13they're sort of Relentless, like, sort of whining about tech
- 42:18companies and it's like not doing anyone any good, which I,
- 42:22I mean, with the Facebook stuff. It's like, I'm personally
- 42:24exhausted of the stories I, but the problem is that, just like
- 42:31Facebook is not Democratic and so that the only way to really
- 42:36change Facebook is for such a heavy-handed Relentless Focus.
- 42:41Ice on it that then something happens.
- 42:44And it's like not enjoyable. Like to me the solution, I mean,
- 42:46I don't necessarily want companies to be Democratic.
- 42:48I don't know what the solution is.
- 42:49But the problem just in terms of like the TV show on Twitter is
- 42:55that these things take so long, you have to like be so
- 42:57heavy-handed about trying to change them even though like
- 43:01everybody who's in the know is like tired of hearing about
- 43:03Facebook or I don't know what your parents have a question for
- 43:05you? I mean, do you, do you think
- 43:07that given what's happening on Facebook?
- 43:10You know, venture capitalist and Boards in the future.
- 43:13It might be less willing to give the CEO 100% control and I could
- 43:18to how many, how many of these problems would have gone away
- 43:21already? When you say what happens, if a
- 43:23foot? Is something wrong.
- 43:41I mean, my right reason and your until we get way more back.
- 43:44Like I think the know some of the other people on the board,
- 43:46you know? But if they were the true, truly
- 43:49in control, there would be much more sort of effort, I think to
- 43:53get them personally. Accountable, if there's
- 43:57anything, we've learned from the Facebook trajectory these days,
- 43:59is that venture capitalist can invest in a company, give total
- 44:01control to the founder. The founder can become and make
- 44:04them insanely wealthy, and then you can spend the rest of your
- 44:07time complaining on Twitter about how no one likes.
- 44:09You don't. And what went wrong in the
- 44:11process, you're like sounds like it's a pretty good trade off for
- 44:15movies, what their personal incentives are.
- 44:16I mean, that does, of course, bring us out here, okay, that
- 44:22does bring us to that very fateful board meeting between.
- 44:26Yeah, the meeting is the moment. Post credit scene.
- 44:44What was it? Five years ago?
- 44:46The core unsealed these messages between Mark Zuckerberg and then
- 44:50board member Mark, andreasen. Whereas, Zuckerberg was trying
- 44:53to negotiate, basically, a class of stock that would allow him to
- 44:58do both sell and make a lot of money, but retain control.
- 45:02And I think that these text messages are so so present
- 45:08because this is what allowed Zuckerberg to maintain control.
- 45:12And And if Eric is correct and the lesson to be taken from,
- 45:16this is as a board member, you no longer have to have any
- 45:19responsibilities, and you can make a lot of money by creating
- 45:23like a complete dictatorship within a company with no board
- 45:26oversight. That's horrifying.
- 45:28Marc, Andreessen is supposed to be looking out for shareholders
- 45:31and extracting. Anything from Mark Zuckerberg in
- 45:37terms of negotiations over his voting control but from the
- 45:40text, it does feel like to me That and reason is clearly just
- 45:45trying to help Zuckerberg and Coach him through it.
- 45:48So, from from Business Insider, when the special committee
- 45:52approved the stock reclassification in mid-april
- 45:55Andreessen, cryptically texted Zuckerberg quote, the cat's in
- 45:59the bag and the bags in the river Zuckerberg then out, is
- 46:03that mean that cat's dead and dries and wrote mission
- 46:06accomplished and thus, the First Amendment and democracy were
- 46:11destroyed. That's what the name is created.
- 46:17So it's dead cat, right? Which is easier to say.
- 46:21Alright, I'm hearing literal would be chopped up and I think
- 46:24I've really overstayed my babysitting time of the Kelso.
- 46:27I'm probably have to lie. Sounds good.
- 46:30All right. Right.
- 46:31Thanks everyone. Goodbye.
- 46:34So work on Sally, goodbye. Goodbye.
- 46:43Goodbye. Goodbye, goodbye, goodbye.
- 46:46Goodbye.