Latest / Beyond The Horizon / Alex Acosta And His Epstein Interview With OIG Inspectors (Part 10)
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: What's up, everyone, and welcome to another episode of the
- 0:02Epstein Chronicles. In this episode, we're going to dive right
- 0:05back in to the alex Acosta interview with the OIG inspectors. Question, okay,
- 0:12the victim. You mentioned the victims coming into state court,
- 0:15and you talked about all the victims coming into state court.
- 0:18Do you have any idea what victims form the basis
- 0:20for the original charge that he was indicted on. Do
- 0:23you know whether it was one was it a felony
- 0:26assault of a non minor? Answer? Uh huh, question, it
- 0:30could have been. It was three instances to felonize it.
- 0:34You don't know whether it was one person three times
- 0:37or three people. Answer. I do not question. And you
- 0:41don't know whether that person was a minor or not. Answer.
- 0:44I do not question, all right. Answer. I would assume
- 0:47they were, but I do not question. Likewise, do you
- 0:51know who was the victim or who the victims were,
- 0:53who formed the basis for the seven nine to six
- 0:56dot three charge to which Epstein ultimately pled in June
- 0:59of twowo thousand and eight. Answer I did not at
- 1:02the time. I've read various accounts of that, but that's
- 1:05based on matters that I've read and not an independent recollection.
- 1:09Question and what's your understanding? Answer? My understanding is that
- 1:14there are some that there is at least some issue
- 1:17in the media over whether the right or the best
- 1:19victims were chosen from the prosecution's perspective. Question and do
- 1:24you know was there any indication of who the victims were?
- 1:28Do you know who the victims were who were the
- 1:30subject of the state charges? Answer which particular names? No,
- 1:34I do not question right. I'm not asking you other
- 1:38than names. I just want to know if you know
- 1:40who they are or how many there were? Answer, I
- 1:43do not question right. It could be one right for this,
- 1:47for the solicitation, it could be one. Conceivably both the
- 1:51charges could relate to one victim. Answer right. So those
- 1:54matters were very much a part of the negotiation that
- 1:57redacted and to some extent Andy were involved in. Question
- 2:02what makes you think that your people were negotiating which
- 2:06victims would form the basis? Answer fair point, fair point answer,
- 2:12fair point, I withdraw they may not have. I don't know.
- 2:15I don't know how in the weeds and how much
- 2:17our folks, as a federal system sort of interacted with
- 2:21the state in terms of what punishment. There's at least
- 2:25some discussion in the media regarding whether the punishment was
- 2:28a function of the victims and registration. And I can't
- 2:31speak to that question all right. Are you aware, just
- 2:35as a point of interest, that the public record of
- 2:37the preceding in the state court related to Epstein or
- 2:41utterly silent as to who or how many victims form
- 2:44the basis of the charges to which he pled. Answer no,
- 2:48I was not aware. Question Okay, So this idea of
- 2:51many victims coming forth in state court and so on
- 2:54or not is not It's not really in play, all right.
- 2:57So you have a two year two years has been
- 3:00a two year state deal has been announced by the team.
- 3:04Answer yeah, question with your knowledge and approval? Right, because
- 3:08he wouldn't do it otherwise? Is that right? Answer? Affair question,
- 3:12though at least one was surprised. Do you know what
- 3:15drove the timing of the plea offer? In other words,
- 3:18why did it have to be made at that point? Answer?
- 3:20I do not. Question. Okay, you know that redacted submitted
- 3:25his resignation on the twenty third of July. Answer I
- 3:30saw that in the documents. Question in the documents and
- 3:34he submitted that to you, among others. Answer yeah, question
- 3:39hr people, Well, when there was a July thirty first
- 3:43meeting at which the term sheet was presented, This document
- 3:46fifteen is the term sheet that was presented, as redacted
- 3:50indicated in her September sixth cover note. And you said
- 3:54you approved it. You happened to be copied and forwarded
- 3:57this answer. Let me let me be accurate. I approve
- 4:02these terms, whether it was this specific term sheet or
- 4:05another another document that might have been earlier that looked
- 4:08highly similar to this. My recollection is approving, you know,
- 4:12approving a resolution that had him pleading to certain state
- 4:15counts that had a binding two year plus recommendation and
- 4:19that provided for twenty two dot fifty five restitution. Question,
- 4:24but you don't know if it was this sheet of paper. Answer.
- 4:27I can't say, twelve years after the fact, whether it
- 4:30was a specific sheet or others. I based on the
- 4:34fact that this was in the email, I think it's
- 4:36safe to assume to assume that it was this. But
- 4:40it's possible that there was a slight difference. Question all right,
- 4:45In fact, this is the same document with a couple
- 4:49of additional bullets that had to do with the date
- 4:51of the entry of the plea is what was prepared
- 4:54by or redacted on or about the thirty first, on
- 4:58or before the thirty first of July. And this document,
- 5:01as indicated here along with the attached guidelines calculation, is
- 5:05what was provided to the folks who met on the
- 5:07thirty first of July. So on the thirty first of July,
- 5:11it was redacted left court, redacted Sanchez And the purpose
- 5:16of the meeting with Sloman, Menchell, Lori and redacted as
- 5:19well as the case agent's was to present the plea offer.
- 5:23And did you get briefed on how that plea offer went? Answer?
- 5:26I don't recall being briefed, but in the regular course
- 5:29I would have been question all right. And at that
- 5:32meeting there was an expression of concern by the defense
- 5:35team that Epstein wanted to avoid being incarcerated in the
- 5:38state system because of concerns for his physical safety, and
- 5:42that concern was accommodated to the extent that the US
- 5:45Attorney's Office team agreed to explore federal resolution. How does
- 5:49that square with your decision that a state plea is
- 5:52how this case was going to be decided? Answer? So
- 5:55I think that I indicated later that it's a little
- 5:57bit more fluid than a decision here, or a decision,
- 6:00you know, than binary situations. My recollection is we were
- 6:05very focused on this man should go to jail, and
- 6:07this man should register. The two year plea to the
- 6:11state charges seem reasonable and seemed a way to go.
- 6:14We can agree or disagree, reasonable in terms not in
- 6:18terms of what the most just outcome, but seem like
- 6:21a disposition that we would agree to. But ultimately, the
- 6:25focus was on getting him to jail. And if that
- 6:28meant exploring a three seventy one, it's at least worth exploring.
- 6:32And so I don't think that it was inconsistent because
- 6:34the focus really was on he needs to go to jail. Question. Okay,
- 6:38In this case, the pushback resulted in the agreement to
- 6:42explore a federal plea was because Epstein was afraid to
- 6:45be in prison. Why would the US Attorney's office accommodate that?
- 6:49And here we're getting to we're beginning to talk about
- 6:52a major point of criticism of the whole process and
- 6:55the outcome, and that is that it appeared that the
- 6:57US Attorney's Office was bending over backward to accommodate the
- 7:01concerns of Jeffrey Epstein, and in this case, he was
- 7:04uncomfortable going to federal or state prison. But all child
- 7:07sex predators who go to prison are going to face
- 7:11some challenges, right answer, right. And I remember along the
- 7:15way a heavy push that he'd be incarcerated at his
- 7:18home under some kind of home confinement. And my reaction
- 7:21to that was no way question right answer, And okay,
- 7:26and you don't like prison, but that doesn't mean you
- 7:29get to be incarcerated at your house. Which is interesting
- 7:32because subsequently, and so he gets cut off. Question because
- 7:38subsequently what you might as well finish answer well, because subsequently,
- 7:42the way that the state executed the terms of incarceration
- 7:46were not what I would have expected. And so again
- 7:49the focus from my perspective is he needs to go
- 7:52to jail. If the team agreed to explore it. You know,
- 7:55the three seventy one was on the table to the
- 7:57extent he had been on speculator. Now this is not
- 8:01to make the record clear. Question, Okay, thank you, answer,
- 8:06I'm speculating, not recalling. I can speculated three seventy one
- 8:10with a two year rule. Eleven had been discussed based
- 8:12on the contemporaneous record, and so to the extent it
- 8:16had already been discussed, even if it was not the
- 8:19direction we were taking, would it have been unusual for
- 8:22folks in the room to say, well, look, we discussed that,
- 8:25let's go back, you know, let's see where it goes.
- 8:30I can't fault to the extent it had been discussed.
- 8:32I can't fault anyone for saying, let's go back and
- 8:35look at it. I think that's distinguishable, at least from
- 8:38subsequent he gets cut off. Question all right. At that point,
- 8:43the defense was given two weeks to take it or
- 8:45leave it, and if not, you would indict. And there
- 8:48were several occasions when that kind of ultimatum was made.
- 8:52Did that mean, given all your concerns about barriers to
- 8:56what you would consider as successful federal prosecution, was that
- 8:59a blit answer? No question, It was not answer. It
- 9:04was not question. You were at some level at least
- 9:08prepared to approve the presentation of the presentment of the indictment. Answer.
- 9:13We should not have gone forward with these negotiations if
- 9:16we weren't ready to question. All right, answer to approve,
- 9:21whether in this form or a different form, And indictment.
- 9:24And I say that because it was very much a
- 9:26draft indictment that hadn't been reviewed fully by the chain.
- 9:29But it wasn't a bluff. Well by the time it
- 9:32had been reviewed, it had there had there been some
- 9:36efforts to begin revising. Answer, yeah, question it wasn't finalized. Answer, yeah,
- 9:43some efforts to begin question exactly. Okay. Looking at eleven am,
- 9:48this is a letter that redacted drafted to sort of
- 9:51actually respond to a counteroffer by the defense. The counter
- 9:55offer is presented in Exhibit ten B, which is a
- 9:58letter from redacted Sanchez, which we don't need to go
- 10:01into into detail because, as you've already pointed out, essentially
- 10:04it was home confinement and you know, very soft, very
- 10:08soft landing counteroffer. In eleven am, redacted tweaks redacted's letter.
- 10:13You're copied on this, and the date is August second, Thursday,
- 10:17and he notes that he hadn't discussed it in detail
- 10:20with you, but he wanted to and he hoped that tomorrow,
- 10:23Friday the third, he'd have a chance to. And what's
- 10:26notable here is that there are strong language that the
- 10:29office believes that the federal interest would not be vindicated
- 10:33in the absence of a two year term of state
- 10:35imprisonment for mister Epstein. That offer was not meant as
- 10:39a starting point for negotiation. It was the minimum term
- 10:42of imprisonment that will obviate the need for federal prosecution.
- 10:47Answer you're on paragraph two. Question one question. It's the
- 10:54first long paragraph. And then he also states that you
- 10:57in the last paragraph, the US Attorney Attorney Acosta has
- 11:01asked me to communicate that the two year term of
- 11:04incarceration is non negotiable. Answer, yes, question, that's pretty firm.
- 11:09That's a line in concrete that is setting right answer
- 11:14right question. And eleven B is the letter as it
- 11:17actually went out the next day. Answer and it's got
- 11:20the same language. Question, it's identical, it has the same language.
- 11:24It has one typo corrected. This is redacted the last
- 11:27day in the office. Answer yes, question, and he's got
- 11:32after that. Do you think that this was and or
- 11:35the appropriate timing to extend this offer or to set
- 11:38this as the minimum offer? Or was it something that
- 11:41you would have liked to have seen more fully developed
- 11:43in negotiations with defense counsel. Answer I'm sorry, I don't
- 11:48understand your question. When you say more fully developed question, well,
- 11:54you have two years. Would further consideration have led the
- 11:57US Attorney's Office to decide that, well, maybe the two
- 12:00years is too much of a giveaway, we should stick
- 12:03with a five year federal plan. Answer? Yeah, so I
- 12:06can't speculate this far after the fact whether waiting an
- 12:10additional time period and further discussion would have changed things.
- 12:13I can tell you how we came up with it.
- 12:16That's a lot of speculation. Question would you say that
- 12:19redacted was as the criminal chief was essentially the driver
- 12:24of the resolution presented in this letter? Answer? I can't. Again,
- 12:29you're asking me to speak on something from twelve years ago,
- 12:32I can't speak to it. I was aware of multiple prongs.
- 12:34I approved it. If we had you know, if at
- 12:37some point if your question is, if at some point
- 12:40there had been a let's sit down and reconsider a meeting,
- 12:44would we have gone in a different direction? Perhaps, But
- 12:47I can't twelve years after the fact speculate as to
- 12:50what may have happened if something had happened. Question all right, answer,
- 12:57that's just a lot of hypotheticals. Question understood. The question though,
- 13:01is whether Matt Mentchell, who was the author of this
- 13:04who first raised it with Lily Sanchez in an informal discussion,
- 13:09and who presented it to the US Attorney's Office team.
- 13:12Was this really is baby? Answer? I can he gets
- 13:15cut off? Question approved by you? Answer? I can't. I
- 13:18don't remember who I talked to about what, and so
- 13:21it wouldn't be fair for me. You know, I can't
- 13:23single out any one person as having a greater or
- 13:26lesser role. Question Well, you are not the architect of this,
- 13:30right you approved it as you've described it. Answer? No,
- 13:34I haven't said I wasn't the architect. What I said
- 13:37is I don't recall. Answer I recall approving it. Yeah,
- 13:41you know, I think what I'm trying to convey is
- 13:44these discussions are a bit more fluid than I think
- 13:47any one single architect. You've got multiple lawyers, they interact
- 13:50on a daily basis, they talk back and forth. To
- 13:54sort of put it in an OPR context, there's probably
- 13:57not going to be a single author of the report.
- 14:00You're all going to go back and forth, and there
- 14:02might be someone that maybe there is a single author
- 14:05who knows, But I think it's difficult to say that
- 14:07there's a single person. And ultimately I was us attorney,
- 14:11so I approved it. Question to your knowledge, did anyone
- 14:15in the chain of that five person chain or anyone
- 14:19else disagree with that offer? Answer? To my knowledge, I
- 14:24think Redacted at some time may have felt uncomfortable. But
- 14:27whether there was explicit disagreement or not, I don't recall
- 14:31in terms of my management chain, I don't recall any disagreement.
- 14:34Question that you were aware of, answer that I was
- 14:37aware of. I recall discussions. So for example, redacted might
- 14:42say I might proceed with a three seventy one with
- 14:44a two year cap under rule eleven. But then we
- 14:47move in this other direction, and I don't recall anyone
- 14:50saying let's take a time out, let's reconsider. Question. All right, answer,
- 14:56and let me just clarify. I think at various points
- 14:58in the case, and it's hard. It's hard to sort
- 15:01of single out the timeline misredacted was supportive or maybe
- 15:05I wish we'd go in a different direction, and that
- 15:07sort of went in and out a little bit. Question
- 15:11on her part. Answer, Yes, all right, folks, we're gonna
- 15:15wrap up right here, and in the next episode we're
- 15:17gonna pick up where we left off. All of the
- 15:19information that goes with this episode can be found in
- 15:22the description box.