Latest / UNCHAINEDTV'S Truth Files with Jane Velez-Mitchell / UnchainedTV: VICTORY: Starbucks Drop Surcharge for Vegan Milks!
Transcript
- 0:00We have breaking news for you.
- 0:05Fasten your seatbelts.
- 0:06This is huge.
- 0:09Stop everything you're doing.
- 0:11Starbucks dropped their surcharge for the plant-based
- 0:14milks.
- 0:15Finally, do you know how long we've been
- 0:17asking for this?
- 0:18This is a huge victory for the vegan
- 0:21movement, for the animal rights movement, for organisations
- 0:23like PETA and Switch for Good.
- 0:25No one should be paying extra for making
- 0:27better choices for our planet, for themselves, and
- 0:30for the animals.
- 0:31It's a victory.
- 0:33Now, the inside story of how it happened.
- 0:38And it is making headlines around the world.
- 0:41There you see it, VegNews, Starbucks drops dairy
- 0:44-free surcharge, embracing all the ways our customers
- 0:47enjoy their Starbucks.
- 0:49This is a huge vegan victory.
- 0:51Starbucks drops surcharge for non-dairy.
- 0:54Starbucks won't charge extra for plant-based milk.
- 0:57Other companies should follow suit.
- 0:59So we've got representatives from two of the
- 1:02leading organisations that made this happen, PETA and
- 1:05Switch for Good.
- 1:07I want to start with one of my
- 1:09favourite people on the planet, Dotsie Bausch, vegan
- 1:12Olympian who has literally devoted her life to
- 1:16this issue.
- 1:17And that's why she started Switch for Good.
- 1:21So, Dotsie, tell us, what is the significance
- 1:24of this surcharge being dropped by Starbucks?
- 1:29Yeah, well, when we decided to go after
- 1:32the largest coffee chain in the world, we
- 1:36did it because we felt like if we
- 1:40go big and we are successful, we knew
- 1:43it was going to be a multi-year
- 1:45approach, that it would trickle down to all
- 1:48of the other coffee shops in the world.
- 1:51And we definitely think that it will.
- 1:53The reason behind it is simply to normalise
- 1:57plant food, normalise plant milk.
- 1:59We know that the 95% just wants
- 2:02normal, right?
- 2:04They want average.
- 2:04They don't want things to be weird or
- 2:06niche.
- 2:06And by charging extra money, which is also
- 2:09a certain form of dietary racism, which we
- 2:13brought to light in this campaign and really
- 2:15helped people to understand what that is, how
- 2:18it gets developed and how it's incredibly unfair.
- 2:22But it was all about normalising this plant
- 2:25milk.
- 2:25When something's normal and it's just on the
- 2:27menu alongside the cow's milk, because we all
- 2:30know the cow's milk is what should have
- 2:31had the upcharge, then people feel free, open,
- 2:35even excited to order a plant food, a
- 2:38plant milk, because it's just the same and
- 2:41they don't have to pay this niche extra
- 2:43upcharge.
- 2:44So it's about normalisation for us.
- 2:46PETA was one of the other organisations that
- 2:49led the charge.
- 2:50These two groups were working, you know, hand
- 2:53in hand, protests here, protests there.
- 2:55We're going to show you and you can
- 2:57hear some of these protests in a moment.
- 2:59But Amber, what would you say is the
- 3:02significance of this in the vegan movement, in
- 3:04the animal rights movement, the dropping of this
- 3:07surcharge?
- 3:09Yeah, thanks for having us on.
- 3:11PETA's been going after Starbucks for years.
- 3:15And, you know, in order to get animals
- 3:18out of these factory farms and out of
- 3:21the dairy industry, we need to normalise and
- 3:24make vegan foods more accessible.
- 3:26So getting one of the largest chains that
- 3:29is such a large seller of dairy products
- 3:33is a huge win and it will have
- 3:37ripple effects.
- 3:38You know, now the smaller coffee chains will
- 3:40have absolutely no excuse.
- 3:42So we are looking very closely toward the
- 3:45future on the ripple effects of this.
- 3:47All right.
- 3:48Well, one of the iconic moments of this
- 3:51campaign was when Succession and Babe star James
- 3:55Cromwell literally glued himself to a Starbucks counter.
- 4:00Let's watch it and then we'll talk about
- 4:01it on the other side.
- 4:02A single cow emits more smog, farming pollutants
- 4:06than a car.
- 4:08One cow on a dairy farm also requires
- 4:1150 gallons of water a day.
- 4:14So we're in the vegan upcharge now because
- 4:16they charge for vegan milk in there.
- 4:21It does damage to the planet.
- 4:23It does damage to people who ingest it,
- 4:26who can't metabolise it.
- 4:29And it's simple greed.
- 4:32Wow.
- 4:33Simple greed.
- 4:35Now, do you think these campaigns alleging that
- 4:39this was being done, this surcharge for simple
- 4:43greed, were what turned the corner?
- 4:46Or was it that Starbucks had started to
- 4:50suffer economically because they were charging extra?
- 4:55Because according to Starbucks' own account, the requests
- 5:00for vegan milks, oat milk, soy milk, almond
- 5:04milk, coconut milk, is the second most requested
- 5:07customisation right after an extra shot of espresso,
- 5:13which I could probably use right now myself.
- 5:15Oh, my gosh.
- 5:18Yeah.
- 5:19Well, about 10 weeks before they dropped the
- 5:24upcharge, we had been working with a whistleblower,
- 5:28with an informant who worked inside at Starbucks
- 5:31for some years.
- 5:33And we uncovered quite a lot, which we
- 5:37privately sent to Starbucks.
- 5:38And I think maybe was their final lever
- 5:42in the breaking to make this happen.
- 5:45What we uncovered was absolute egregious price gouging.
- 5:52Like we knew they made a lot of
- 5:53money on this, right?
- 5:54Because why else would they do it?
- 5:55But what we uncovered was that they make
- 5:59a 788% markup for almond milk, a
- 6:03566% markup on soy milk, and 185
- 6:07% markup on oat milk.
- 6:09We know that they made a billion dollars
- 6:11on these markups.
- 6:12They charge 80 cents.
- 6:14And almond milk, for example, that they charge
- 6:17nine.
- 6:18It costs nine cents and they charge 80
- 6:21cents.
- 6:22It's a 788% markup.
- 6:23So revealing that we uncovered those numbers, and
- 6:29then also revealing something that was almost even
- 6:32more egregious, them going back to 2019 and
- 6:36erasing and changing their climate baselines because they
- 6:39recognised they were not going to make their
- 6:412025 target.
- 6:43We have all of that paperwork and sent
- 6:47it to them.
- 6:47So those are two big surprises, I think,
- 6:52for them, that they didn't realise that anyone
- 6:55knew about either one of those.
- 6:56And I think that Brian Nickell trying to
- 6:58do the right thing, having to change and
- 7:00really turn this entire company around from it
- 7:03being in the toilet with the shareholders, didn't
- 7:07want this out, either one of these facts.
- 7:11And we invite Starbucks on any time.
- 7:14I think we can all say kudos to
- 7:16the new CEO, Brian Nickell, for making this
- 7:20change.
- 7:20So we applaud and congratulate him.
- 7:24What we're doing is talking about how and
- 7:26why it happened when it did, because the
- 7:30protest by James Cromwell was two years ago.
- 7:34So there have been protests for years demanding
- 7:37this.
- 7:38Let's take a look at some of the
- 7:39protests organised by Switch for Good.
- 7:42Put your money where your mouth is and
- 7:45stop the upcharge of the plant-based milk
- 7:48now.
- 7:55What the hell is up, you guys?
- 7:56My name is Jamie Logan, and we are
- 7:58here in Los Angeles outside of Starbucks.
- 8:01We are asking, we are demanding that they
- 8:03drop the surcharge on plant-based milk.
- 8:06And let's find out why.
- 8:08Extra charges aren't fair.
- 8:11Stop the upcharge, stop the green.
- 8:16Keep our prices what we need.
- 8:18So we are here because we have been
- 8:19working for two and a half years trying
- 8:22to get Starbucks to drop their plant milk
- 8:24upcharge.
- 8:24It's $0.70, $0.80, $0.80 at
- 8:26the top.
- 8:28Extra to have planet-friendly, animal-friendly, people
- 8:32-friendly, health-friendly plant milk.
- 8:35And as many of you know now, because
- 8:37we've been doing this work for so long,
- 8:3935% of Americans cannot digest dairy.
- 8:4380% of people of colour all over
- 8:46the world, it makes them sick, uncomfortable, and
- 8:49in some cases, unable to breathe.
- 8:51Yet that milk is free at Starbucks, and
- 8:55they're charging for planet-friendly plant milk.
- 8:58It's insanity.
- 9:00So all those were excellent arguments, but-
- 9:04I apparently had a lot of coffee before
- 9:05that.
- 9:06Wow.
- 9:10I think they cut you off.
- 9:12No more shots.
- 9:13Exactly.
- 9:14No more shots.
- 9:15And you know what?
- 9:16I've had this Starbucks coffee plastic cup for
- 9:20about six years, and so I use it
- 9:24every time I have to do an update
- 9:25on Starbucks.
- 9:26I haven't actually gone into Starbucks, however.
- 9:29That may change now that they've eliminated the
- 9:32upcharge.
- 9:33I would be happy to go there.
- 9:34Tomorrow.
- 9:36Yeah, we're celebrating this.
- 9:38So let me say this.
- 9:41Those were all great reasons.
- 9:44Climate change, suffering of animals, human health with
- 9:48the huge amount of lactose intolerance in the
- 9:51populace.
- 9:52In fact, there's even been lawsuits surrounding that
- 9:57issue.
- 9:57But those are not what were cited in
- 10:01news reports as the defining reason why this
- 10:04happened.
- 10:06It was more described as Starbucks is having
- 10:09some problems with sales and wanted to appeal
- 10:13to its customers.
- 10:14So is this still a case of follow
- 10:17the money at the end of the day,
- 10:19DOTC?
- 10:20And then we'll go to Amber.
- 10:22I mean, most definitely.
- 10:26And Amber and PETA know this even more
- 10:28because they've been campaigning for 50 years, right,
- 10:32that there is never a world where the
- 10:36major multinational public corporation says, thank you, activists,
- 10:41for letting us see our flaws.
- 10:42Thank you for exposing the price gouging.
- 10:44Thank you for exposing our corporate fraud and
- 10:46changing.
- 10:47Thank you for exposing the climate.
- 10:49I mean, et cetera, et cetera.
- 10:50So, you know, we're never going to know
- 10:54exactly.
- 10:56But I think because of all that both
- 10:59of us have done on this, they were
- 11:01done with the pressure.
- 11:02They were done with it.
- 11:04I mean, they just wanted to turn the
- 11:05corner.
- 11:06And I think that they didn't.
- 11:07I know for sure that Brian did not
- 11:09want the latest bits that we'd uncover revealed.
- 11:12And they didn't want the pressure from PETA
- 11:15anymore.
- 11:15They just didn't want it.
- 11:16Right.
- 11:17He wanted to turn a new leaf.
- 11:18He didn't want to deal with that.
- 11:19And he turned it into a kind of
- 11:21a conversation around its customisation season, the holidays.
- 11:24And so we're going to make customisation easier
- 11:26by not charging for plant milk.
- 11:28So that's how they spun it.
- 11:30And we were expecting nothing less.
- 11:31Right, Amber?
- 11:33Yeah.
- 11:34Yeah, I mean, PETA has been going after
- 11:39Starbucks on this issue through multiple CEOs.
- 11:43And, in fact, when Brian Nichol came on
- 11:47board, we suspended our campaign because we were
- 11:49so hopeful.
- 11:50With his past history at the other companies
- 11:53he worked at, you know, Chipotle having such
- 11:56great vegan options.
- 11:58You know, we were hopeful and it did
- 12:00pay off.
- 12:01And we're seeing now the massive PR move,
- 12:05positive PR for them, that the previous CEOs
- 12:08who are no longer with Starbucks really missed
- 12:12out on.
- 12:13And that really shows that doing the right
- 12:16thing, whether they did it for the right
- 12:18reasons or not, is a good business move.
- 12:22And do you think it will, Amber, inspire
- 12:24other companies to follow suit?
- 12:27Absolutely.
- 12:28We have been, you know, not just Starbucks,
- 12:31there are some other handfuls of chains and
- 12:34also individual coffee stores, right?
- 12:36So the small coffee shops who might still
- 12:38be charging extra maybe felt like they had
- 12:42to because the big guys were.
- 12:44And they needed to do that to remain
- 12:45competitive.
- 12:46So this is just showing that across the
- 12:47board it is, you know, affordable and accessible.
- 12:51And just the right thing to do for
- 12:53any company that, you know, is trying to
- 12:56appeal to customers who care about animals, care
- 12:58about their carbon footprints, and just doing the
- 13:00right thing.
- 13:01And, you know, PETA has worked with so
- 13:03many celebrities.
- 13:05James Cromwell, and there is a building named
- 13:08the James Cromwell Empathy Centre that is part
- 13:11of PETA's overall headquarters.
- 13:14In fact, Unchained TV just had a premier
- 13:16party at the PETA Empathy Centre, the James
- 13:19Cromwell PETA Empathy Centre.
- 13:21And, you know, there's no better activist than
- 13:24James Cromwell.
- 13:25He is out there on the front lines
- 13:27lending his fame and celebrity to this and
- 13:30other issues when it comes to animal rights
- 13:32and veganism.
- 13:33Let's take a look at PETA's now iconic
- 13:36commercial that they did to put pressure on
- 13:40Starbucks to drop the extra charge, which Starbucks
- 13:44has now done.
- 13:46Starbucks cares.
- 13:48We care about the world turning into a
- 13:50giant burning hellscape.
- 13:53And we care that you care that cow's
- 13:56milk production emits about three times more greenhouse
- 13:59gases than vegan milk.
- 14:01We care, but you care more.
- 14:04That's why we charge you up to 90
- 14:05cents extra for our vegan milk.
- 14:08Because when you really care, like you do,
- 14:11it's a small price to pay.
- 14:12And it's good that you pay, I mean,
- 14:15care, because we also have other things to
- 14:17care about.
- 14:18Like the $1.6 million cash sign-on
- 14:21bonus for our new CEO.
- 14:24We care about profits.
- 14:26Confused?
- 14:27We're not.
- 14:28You just keep caring about saving the world
- 14:30and we'll keep caring about our savings account.
- 14:34Because Starbucks cares about money.
- 14:37Heck, it's right there in our name.
- 14:40There you go.
- 14:41Drink that in.
- 14:42You take care now.
- 14:47What a sophisticated campaign.
- 14:49And the CEO he referred to is no
- 14:52longer there.
- 14:54Correct me if I'm wrong, replaced by Brian
- 14:56Nickell, who came over from Chipotle because they
- 14:59were struggling.
- 15:00I mean, do you think at the end
- 15:02of the day, it's just not smart business?
- 15:06Like everybody's praising Brian Nickell as a very
- 15:08smart business person.
- 15:10He did drop the upcharge.
- 15:13Is that the smart business move?
- 15:17Couldn't it be also not just good for
- 15:21the animals, good for human health, good for
- 15:23the planet, but also good for business?
- 15:26Why do those two have to be at
- 15:28loggerheads, Dotsie?
- 15:30Yeah.
- 15:31I mean, I think they'll win a lot
- 15:32of people over by doing it.
- 15:33I also do think it's, you know, interesting
- 15:38timing that it's customisation season and people want
- 15:40to try all sorts of, you know, different
- 15:43foofy drinks over the holidays and they'll make
- 15:47some of the money up during that.
- 15:49I won't be entirely shocked if the overall
- 15:51prices of their beverages start to creep up
- 15:54to make it back, because like I said,
- 15:57it was a billion dollars for them last
- 15:59year.
- 15:59So that's a lot of money to let
- 16:00go.
- 16:01So they might get new customers.
- 16:05That's where that exactly.
- 16:07Yeah.
- 16:07I used to go to Starbucks all the
- 16:08time.
- 16:09I just walk around with this thing for
- 16:11four or five years.
- 16:12Well, that's the question.
- 16:13I mean, how many people were boycotting Starbucks
- 16:15because of the plant milk?
- 16:16I mean, that's what we don't they don't
- 16:18know.
- 16:18Yeah.
- 16:20Boycotting, if not boycotting outright, just thinking, you
- 16:25know, one of the issues that I've had
- 16:27when I've gone in there.
- 16:28And by the way, again, we invite Starbucks
- 16:30on any time.
- 16:32As as we've said at the start of
- 16:34this broadcast, we applaud your decision.
- 16:37So this isn't like attack Starbucks day.
- 16:40This is applaud Starbucks day.
- 16:41But we're trying to understand it and we're
- 16:44trying to understand why it took so long
- 16:46and why these two organisations, Switch for Good
- 16:51and PETA, had to go to extreme lengths,
- 16:55like getting movie stars to record fake commercials
- 16:58and glueing themselves to a counter in order
- 17:01to make the case.
- 17:03For those who aren't animal activists, please know
- 17:07that all campaigns start out with polite letters.
- 17:10Right, Amber?
- 17:12All campaigns start out with here's the facts
- 17:14behind the scenes before anything public ever, ever
- 17:18happened.
- 17:19You know.
- 17:20Yes.
- 17:21Well, can you outline that?
- 17:22Because people sometimes say, oh, why are they
- 17:24protesting?
- 17:27Yeah, I mean, any time you see PETA
- 17:29has an action alert out against something, you
- 17:32know, we've attempted to resolve things.
- 17:35The best campaigns are the ones you never
- 17:37have to launch in the first place.
- 17:40And Starbucks previous CEOs, you know, just weren't
- 17:44were open to it at the time.
- 17:47It took a little bit of cajoling.
- 17:50I've still got a scar on my hand
- 17:51from the time I glued my hand to
- 17:53their headquarters countertop.
- 17:55But, you know, that scar is going to
- 17:58fade and eventually and we'll be moving on
- 18:01to, you know, on and on to the
- 18:03next victories down the road.
- 18:07And in fact, tomorrow, PETA is officially calling
- 18:10off our boycott that we've been having with
- 18:13support.
- 18:14Starbucks Vegan Coffee Day is going to be
- 18:16tomorrow.
- 18:17So go in and get those soy lattes
- 18:22and, you know, to keep working and keep
- 18:25that caffeine up.
- 18:26Well, I wanted to ask you what it
- 18:28was like to glue, because I did have
- 18:30questions about this.
- 18:31I'm like, we all know glueing yourself, super
- 18:34glueing yourself.
- 18:35That's painful.
- 18:36And how does it end?
- 18:38I never quite got the answer.
- 18:40Since you actually superglue yourself as well.
- 18:43Can you tell us, please?
- 18:44I went a little overboard and used an
- 18:48entire tube of the superglue at the Starbucks
- 18:53Reserve in their headquarters in Seattle.
- 18:58They didn't really know what to do about
- 18:59it.
- 19:00And the firefighters tried many things.
- 19:04A butter knife ended up being the main
- 19:08thing that worked to get me out.
- 19:10We were in there for a couple hours.
- 19:12Wow.
- 19:13It was an interesting experience.
- 19:15And I had one hand glued with the
- 19:17phone with the live stream the entire time.
- 19:21Wow.
- 19:22And you think it was worth it?
- 19:25Absolutely.
- 19:26Yeah.
- 19:27They filed some charges and never pursued them.
- 19:32So, you know, I was willing to go
- 19:34the full way, but they just wanted to
- 19:37get us out of there.
- 19:38Yeah.
- 19:38And I really think that's important because so
- 19:41many people, I've been working with PETA for
- 19:44decades now.
- 19:46And as a journalist, always there, always there
- 19:50saying, sure, I'll talk to you.
- 19:52Sure.
- 19:52I'll try to connect you with a celebrity
- 19:54who might care about this, whatever the case
- 19:56may be.
- 19:58And I really hate it when people say
- 20:00PETA.
- 20:01Oh, they throw blood.
- 20:02PETA hasn't thrown fake blood at anything in
- 20:05I don't know how long.
- 20:07I mean, that's got to be decades.
- 20:09But they like to do that to kind
- 20:11of dismiss.
- 20:13What I say is, you know, journalists should
- 20:16be covering this issue seriously and all the
- 20:18other issues that PETA raises seriously.
- 20:21But the truth is PETA has something like
- 20:2319 lawyers.
- 20:24They're filing Freedom of Information Act requests, holding
- 20:27news conferences, putting out news releases.
- 20:29But yet when they get the media attention
- 20:32is when James Cromwell glues himself to a
- 20:35supermarket, to a Starbucks counter or somebody gets
- 20:39naked or almost naked.
- 20:41In other words, these animal rights organisations are
- 20:45put in a situation where they're completely ignored
- 20:48when they're serious.
- 20:49And then when they in desperation become somewhat
- 20:52outlandish after begging for change politely, then they're
- 20:57attacked for being outlandish.
- 20:58Would you like to address that, Amber?
- 21:01Yeah, it takes everything.
- 21:03I mean, I've attended board meetings from giant
- 21:06corporations.
- 21:08And, you know, we've had Alicia Silverstone actually,
- 21:11you know, called into a Starbucks board meeting
- 21:15as well in the past.
- 21:17But it sometimes takes steps, stepping things up
- 21:21and taking some bold actions in a safe
- 21:24way.
- 21:25I mean, my hand was maybe in a
- 21:27little danger that day, but it all ended
- 21:29up fine.
- 21:31And, you know, at the end of the
- 21:33day, the planet is in crisis.
- 21:35The animals are in crisis.
- 21:37And, you know, we need to get active
- 21:39and keep doing what we need to do
- 21:42to keep these victories coming in, because the
- 21:46animals really, really need us to step it
- 21:49up.
- 21:49And the people.
- 21:51Let's hear a little bit more from the
- 21:53protests that Dotsie Bausch organised outside a Starbucks.
- 21:58I was there and her right hand man
- 22:02also spoke.
- 22:04Dairy and milk means stomach pain.
- 22:06Starbucks coffee is to blame.
- 22:09Plant based milk should not cost more.
- 22:11Starbucks green, we do have more.
- 22:13The intention of this campaign is to get
- 22:16them to finally drop the plant based milk
- 22:18upcharge.
- 22:18What they have already done in the United
- 22:20Kingdom, France, Chile, Germany, Japan and other major
- 22:25World Cup countries.
- 22:26They have resisted here in the US so
- 22:28far.
- 22:28This is their biggest market.
- 22:30They make over we've estimated they make over
- 22:31300 million dollars a year on the upcharge
- 22:35alone.
- 22:35Not just the drinks.
- 22:37The upcharge.
- 22:38Three hundred million dollars a year.
- 22:39So this is part of our ongoing Justice
- 22:41Cup campaign to get them to put their
- 22:43money where their mouth is and actually finally
- 22:45drop the upcharge for people, planet and the
- 22:48animals.
- 22:48That is why we are here today.
- 22:50Thank you guys so much for being here.
- 22:56All right.
- 22:57So again, we applaud Starbucks for finally dropping
- 23:01that surcharge for soy, almond, coconut and what
- 23:07is it?
- 23:07Oat milk.
- 23:08OK.
- 23:09And we have a lot of people saying,
- 23:11yes, I'm going to go back and start
- 23:13going to Starbucks.
- 23:15Let me ask you a question.
- 23:17Oh, that's quite a quite a comment there.
- 23:19Let me ask you a question.
- 23:20Do you think this is going to encourage
- 23:22more people who are not vegan, who are
- 23:24not plant based to try the vegan option?
- 23:27Because that's another benefit from this Stasi.
- 23:30It's not just people who are already drinking
- 23:33plant based milks who will say, oh, now
- 23:35I can go in there and and have
- 23:37my soy latte without paying extra.
- 23:40It's also people that maybe don't really try
- 23:44the plant based milks that might be encouraged
- 23:46to try them because they're not being charged
- 23:48more.
- 23:49Of course they will.
- 23:51Yeah.
- 23:51I mean, we know the stats.
- 23:52We know that 80 to 97 percent of
- 23:55people of colour just make some sick dairy
- 23:57milk.
- 23:58So absolutely.
- 23:58It's a huge celebration for them to be
- 24:00able to go in there and try these
- 24:01different plant based milks.
- 24:03And maybe some of them are, you know,
- 24:05who have not been going to Starbucks as
- 24:07well and and be able to enjoy their
- 24:09coffee without running the bathroom afterwards.
- 24:11I think it it will really encourage most
- 24:14people.
- 24:14I think curiosity alone, too, will encourage people
- 24:17who aren't lactose intolerant.
- 24:19What does that taste like?
- 24:20I've always wondered about it.
- 24:21People talk about it.
- 24:22I mean, we're up to 44 percent of
- 24:26U.S. households has plant make plant based
- 24:29milk in the refrigerator.
- 24:31We're close to reaching the tipping point of
- 24:3350 percent household penetration.
- 24:35I mean, some of those households may also
- 24:38have dairy milk, but that is a massive
- 24:40step forward.
- 24:41So they're drinking at home, is my point.
- 24:43So they are absolutely going to go to
- 24:46the coffee shop and be excited to be
- 24:48able to order it for free.
- 24:50And what I want to ask you is
- 24:52what can the rest of the plant based
- 24:55movement learn from the success of the dairy
- 24:59sector?
- 25:00I think it's fair to say and correct
- 25:02me if I'm wrong, but my observation is
- 25:04that the milk alternatives, the dairy free milk
- 25:08alternatives, soy milk, rice milk, almond milk, oat
- 25:12milk, the list goes on and on.
- 25:15I've seen hemp milk.
- 25:16I've seen all sorts of sort of even.
- 25:17But it's the most successful aspect of the
- 25:22plant based movement.
- 25:23I mean, it's taking over the supermarket shelves.
- 25:26When I check out, I'm always looking around.
- 25:28I'm seeing so many people, even in, you
- 25:31know, not like just fancy grocery stores.
- 25:35But I was just at Smart and Final
- 25:36two days ago.
- 25:37The guy behind me has got the plant
- 25:40based milks.
- 25:42What can we learn from the success of
- 25:45the plant based milk sector about what we
- 25:48need to do with other sectors, particularly meat
- 25:52alternatives?
- 25:54Yeah, well, I mean, we also know that
- 25:56that Gen Z, 49 percent of Gen Z,
- 26:00almost half of them are embarrassed to order
- 26:03dairy in public.
- 26:04So the younger generation, they get it.
- 26:07They get it for all the reasons.
- 26:08And they're certainly pushing hard.
- 26:10And I think what we can learn is
- 26:12I mean, that's why we focus on this
- 26:14from day one at Switch for Good, because
- 26:16I have and will always believe that dairy
- 26:19is the way in to a plant based
- 26:21vegan world.
- 26:22People are accepting the dairy alternatives.
- 26:25They like them.
- 26:26They're bringing them into their house.
- 26:28They make them feel great.
- 26:29We've already discussed how many people dairy makes
- 26:33feel terrible.
- 26:34And because of that, people have this almost
- 26:37like religious experience when they drop dairy and
- 26:41feel better in five days, six days, seven
- 26:43days.
- 26:43I mean, it's a really short period of
- 26:45time.
- 26:45And then they get excited about feeling that
- 26:47much better and their health improving.
- 26:48And then they start asking questions about what
- 26:50else could they do to make themselves feel
- 26:52better?
- 26:53Unfortunately, we don't have that with a chicken
- 26:56sandwich.
- 26:56Nobody feels better if they drop chicken.
- 27:00You drop all of it.
- 27:01Things start to change.
- 27:03But I think dairy is the way in
- 27:05to dropping all of the meat.
- 27:07And the more of us that recognise that
- 27:10and start to work on what is working
- 27:13and pushing that and finally breaking that lever
- 27:16of dairy, they're almost on their way out.
- 27:19They're not keeping themselves in business.
- 27:21Meat is keeping themselves in business.
- 27:23Our federal government is keeping dairy in business.
- 27:25Seventy three percent of their income comes from
- 27:27the feds.
- 27:28So they are teetering.
- 27:30And it's going to take all of us
- 27:32to push them over.
- 27:33And then we can go, you know, sector
- 27:35to sector to sector and win this.
- 27:38Well, I think you're absolutely right in terms
- 27:40of kids aren't just sitting down like out
- 27:43of a leave it to beaver TV show.
- 27:46You know, these are 60s and drinking an
- 27:48entire glass of milk.
- 27:49They don't do it anymore.
- 27:50So there's been a cultural shift and that's
- 27:54the kind of cultural shift we need in
- 27:57other sectors.
- 27:58Amber, do you have any thoughts on what
- 28:00we can learn from the success of the
- 28:02dairy alternative movement in terms of what we
- 28:07can do with other sectors in the plant
- 28:09based food market?
- 28:10Well, the other big thing with dairy, aside
- 28:14from Starbucks, you know, which we don't need
- 28:16to worry about anymore, is is is cheese
- 28:19consumption is still, you know, something that needs
- 28:24to be hammered on.
- 28:25And the you know, the vegan cheeses are
- 28:28getting better and better all the time.
- 28:31So that is the kind of secondary dairy
- 28:35related campaign that PETA has been focussing on.
- 28:38Just getting people to try it because the
- 28:42numbers of people trying it, they're more likely
- 28:44to be more comfortable picking it up off
- 28:47the grocery store shelf or the vegan burger
- 28:50that has vegan cheese on it at the
- 28:52restaurants.
- 28:53Vegan mac and cheese.
- 28:55It's, you know, it's all there ready to
- 28:57go.
- 28:58And that's that's kind of the next the
- 29:00next hurdle we're looking at.
- 29:02We've been giving away like tens of thousands
- 29:04of samples of vegan cheese, just getting people
- 29:06to try it because just like the soy
- 29:09and oat milk with your cookie or whatever
- 29:12we've been giving away at, you know, activism
- 29:14events and booths.
- 29:16We just need to get them to try
- 29:18it and say, hey, I had some misconceptions
- 29:20about that.
- 29:22If you're just joining us, we're celebrating a
- 29:24victory.
- 29:25Starbucks has ended its vegan milk upcharge in
- 29:29the United States and Canada after a powerful
- 29:31campaign.
- 29:33We have PETA and Switch for Good, the
- 29:35two leading organisations that worked very hard to
- 29:39make this happen.
- 29:41And there's just happiness all the way around.
- 29:44Stop everything you're doing.
- 29:46Starbucks dropped their surcharge for the plant based
- 29:49milk.
- 29:49Finally, do you know how long we've been
- 29:52asking for this?
- 29:53This is a huge victory for the vegan
- 29:55movement, for the animal rights movement, for organisations
- 29:58like PETA and Switch for Good.
- 30:00No one should be paying extra for making
- 30:01better choices for our planet, for themselves and
- 30:05for the animals.
- 30:06It's a victory.
- 30:08Now, the inside story of how it happened.
- 30:13And I have to play once again Dotsie
- 30:15Bausch at her protest because she was in
- 30:18fuego outside Starbucks.
- 30:20Put your money where your mouth is and
- 30:24stop the upcharge of the plant based milk
- 30:27now.
- 30:33What the hell is up, you guys?
- 30:35My name is Jamie Logan and we're here
- 30:37in Los Angeles outside of Starbucks.
- 30:39We are asking, we are demanding that they
- 30:42drop the surcharge on plant based milk.
- 30:45And let's find out why.
- 30:47Extra charges aren't fair.
- 30:49Stop the stopping doesn't care.
- 30:52Stop the upcharge, stop the greed.
- 30:54Keep our prices what we need.
- 30:57So we are here because we have been
- 30:58working for two and a half years trying
- 31:00to get Starbucks to drop their plant milk
- 31:02upcharge.
- 31:03It's 70, 80 cents, 80 cents at the
- 31:05top.
- 31:06Extra to have planet friendly, animal friendly, people
- 31:10friendly, health friendly plant milk.
- 31:13And as many of you know now because
- 31:16we've been doing this work for so long,
- 31:1735% of Americans cannot digest dairy.
- 31:2280% of people of colour all over
- 31:25the world, it makes them sick, uncomfortable and
- 31:27in some cases unable to breathe.
- 31:29Yet that milk is free at Starbucks and
- 31:33they're charging for planet friendly plant milk.
- 31:37It's insanity.
- 31:38So when you think about it and I'd
- 31:41like to get your response, both of you
- 31:43to this.
- 31:44Amber, shouldn't they be charging more for dairy?
- 31:49Right now we have equal price.
- 31:51Thanks to this breakthrough where Starbucks agreed to
- 31:55drop the surcharge for vegan milks like soy
- 31:58milk, oat milk, rice milk, coconut milk, whatever
- 32:01milks they carry in their various stores.
- 32:04I know they mixed it up quite a
- 32:05bit.
- 32:06But if you think about what Doxie said,
- 32:09the impact on the climate, the impact on
- 32:12human health with the high levels of lactose
- 32:14intolerance and obviously the cruelty as well.
- 32:17Wouldn't it be smarter to either eliminate dairy
- 32:20entirely or charge more for the privilege of
- 32:25drinking the breast milk of cows if that's
- 32:27what you really want to do?
- 32:29Yeah, we had suggested that, you know, to
- 32:32Starbucks in the past that, you know, the
- 32:36prices should even out.
- 32:37If you're going to stop upcharging for vegan
- 32:40milk, then balance it out with the non
- 32:45-vegan milks.
- 32:46As Doxie mentioned, there are, you know, major
- 32:49subsidies going on and PETA is working on
- 32:51the side on that as well with our
- 32:53food justice campaign, getting those subsidies out of
- 32:57dairy, meat and egg industries and, you know,
- 33:00promoting the healthy vegan foods that the government
- 33:04should be promoting.
- 33:06But absolutely, people are not paying that full
- 33:11cost, whether it's for the animals or the
- 33:15climate, human health, public health costs of all
- 33:19this heavy dairy consumption, that all adds up
- 33:22and it's not being reflected in that sticker
- 33:24price at the counters.
- 33:26You know, sometimes people are saying now, well,
- 33:31there was this huge move toward plant-based
- 33:34products when, for example, in 2019, Beyond Meat's
- 33:39IPO initial public offering was the most successful
- 33:42IPO since the 2008 financial crisis and everybody
- 33:46was just sort of going crazy over it.
- 33:49And now there's a bit of retrenchment and
- 33:51I always say nothing goes straight up.
- 33:53Even the most successful stock goes like this.
- 33:56But this is, I think, a marker of
- 34:01now we're back on the way up.
- 34:03I think this change, given that Starbucks is,
- 34:08according to you, and I believe you, and
- 34:11Starbucks you're invited on anytime again, but the
- 34:14largest purveyor of dairy in the United States
- 34:16aside from the U.S. government.
- 34:19And it is essentially acknowledging that vegan milks,
- 34:26soy milk and almond milk and coconut milk,
- 34:28should be on an even playing field.
- 34:30I feel that this is a moment of
- 34:33cultural shift.
- 34:34What say you?
- 34:36Yeah, I know it's been disappointing to see
- 34:40what's happened in the last year.
- 34:42But if we look back, we see that
- 34:44around 2019, as you mentioned, Meat & Dairy
- 34:49got together, the PR firm, and they've only
- 34:54had to spend about $2 million a year,
- 34:55which is not so much for them, only
- 34:59solely focussing on the ultra processed milk.
- 35:02And it's been working.
- 35:05And that's now what's in our hands to
- 35:08fight back with.
- 35:09And there's lots of options on how to
- 35:13fight that back, whether to fight directly against
- 35:15that or introduce a different concept about what
- 35:19is in Meat & Dairy.
- 35:21But it's working.
- 35:22I mean, we used to have the basketball
- 35:25players, the big NBA stars sitting courtside in
- 35:28their Beyond Meat hats.
- 35:30And now they won't even take sponsorship money
- 35:32from Beyond Meat.
- 35:33They're like, no, no, dude, it's ultra processed.
- 35:36So their campaigns worked.
- 35:38And I think we always had to know
- 35:41that they weren't going to just lay down,
- 35:43right?
- 35:44Of course, they were going to fight.
- 35:46So we have to band together and fight
- 35:50back against that, because that's really what you'll
- 35:52hear most people who are no longer eating
- 35:54vegan say.
- 35:56It's too processed.
- 35:57It's not good for you.
- 35:58Well, and oh, my gosh, I have so
- 36:00many arguments that I would love to hear
- 36:02from all the American people.
- 36:04But A, we just profiled Beyond Meat, and
- 36:08they have a new heart healthy version.
- 36:10Yes.
- 36:11Because Ethan Brown said, well, you know, we've
- 36:13come under attack by the incumbent industry is
- 36:16how he put it.
- 36:16So instead of fighting back with just words,
- 36:19we've decided we're going to make our product
- 36:20even healthier.
- 36:21And now it's certified by the American Heart
- 36:25Association.
- 36:26And it's much healthier.
- 36:28Not that it was unhealthy, but he responded
- 36:31that way, which I thought was so evolved
- 36:33of him.
- 36:34But you're absolutely right.
- 36:35There is, according to The Guardian, there's like
- 36:37a war room the size of a major
- 36:40network somewhere in Denver, Colorado, where they spew
- 36:43out all this stuff about how vegan meat
- 36:47alternatives are ultra processed.
- 36:49Now, mind you, you can always eat tofu,
- 36:53brown rice, kale, legumes, carrots, all the reason
- 37:00those items were created was because people said,
- 37:03no, I can't eat.
- 37:04Oh, I'm not going to eat whole food
- 37:06plant based.
- 37:07So they try to put you in a
- 37:09no win circumstance.
- 37:10If you say, look, whole food is there.
- 37:13You can eat it.
- 37:13It's super healthy.
- 37:14We've got gazillion studies that show that that's
- 37:18the route to disease prevention and longevity.
- 37:21Oh, no, I have to have my burger.
- 37:23I have to have my wings.
- 37:25I have to have my this, that and
- 37:27the other.
- 37:27OK, we're going to make you plant based
- 37:28versions.
- 37:29And then they say, oh, well, that's processed.
- 37:31So that's kind of trying to put you
- 37:34in a situation where you can't win.
- 37:35What I do say is processed meat is
- 37:40officially cancer causing, according to the World Health
- 37:43Organisation.
- 37:46Meat alternatives are not.
- 37:48And they have zero cholesterol.
- 37:50So they're automatically healthier.
- 37:52Amber, how does PETA make that case, given
- 37:55that there is this, I would call it
- 37:59a misinformation campaign out there against meat alternatives?
- 38:05Yeah, there have been so many new buzzwords
- 38:08that they have come up with in the
- 38:09past couple of years.
- 38:11We have a whole guide on our Web
- 38:13site about how, especially that buzzword regenerative agriculture.
- 38:18I just heard it on an ad for
- 38:21cheese, cheesy crackers or something like that this
- 38:24week.
- 38:24And I was like, really?
- 38:28But, you know, I think part of the
- 38:31fact that they've had to spend so much
- 38:34effort creating all these new buzzwords, all these
- 38:37humane labels that they have to slap on
- 38:40things, is a testament to how much the
- 38:43public does care about these issues that they
- 38:46have had to go on the offensive and
- 38:49go on the defensive to get people to
- 38:54stop going vegan in droves.
- 38:57And, you know, largely they are failing.
- 38:59It's still going to be a lot of
- 39:02work out there to counteract all of these
- 39:04false and misleading labels and marketing claims.
- 39:08Honestly, that's just more opportunities to talk about
- 39:11this issue and show how, you know, devious
- 39:15the meat, dairy and egg industries really can
- 39:17be.
- 39:17They're not just abusing animals, but they are
- 39:20relying on misleading and cover ups.
- 39:25You know, we shouldn't have to have ag
- 39:26laws.
- 39:27We shouldn't have to have undercover investigators who
- 39:30have to go in and show the real
- 39:31conditions behind these things.
- 39:33But we do.
- 39:35And that just, you know, is a testament
- 39:37to how cruel these industries are and the
- 39:40length that they need to go to to
- 39:42stay in business and keep people buying those
- 39:44products.
- 39:45And, you know, we are seeing so many
- 39:48people ordering the free vegan starter guides that
- 39:50we have on our website, accessing all the
- 39:53resources and the health resources from groups like
- 39:57Dotsies who are focused on, you know, health
- 40:00and fitness.
- 40:00All those resources are out there at people's
- 40:03fingertips and we're always there and available to
- 40:06help people get active and do what needs
- 40:09to be done to help get these animals
- 40:10out of these factory farms.
- 40:12And I think we're actually doing better than
- 40:14we give ourselves credit for.
- 40:16And if you look, a lot of the
- 40:19more successful brands have been bought up by
- 40:22big companies.
- 40:23So while yes, vegan restaurants might be struggling
- 40:28right now, well, all restaurants are struggling.
- 40:30There's been a cultural change since the pandemic.
- 40:33I myself don't go to as many restaurants
- 40:35as I used to.
- 40:37And so it's across the board with restaurants,
- 40:40not just vegan restaurants.
- 40:42But then if you look at the frozen
- 40:44food section in your average large supermarket, my
- 40:49gosh, the amount of plant based alternatives, the
- 40:53vegan wings, the vegan fish, the vegan burgers.
- 40:58I mean, it's all over the place and
- 41:00a lot of it is being adopted.
- 41:02So I think we have to keep it
- 41:03in perspective.
- 41:05A lot of these brands have been purchased
- 41:08by big, big companies.
- 41:11And interestingly enough, once they get purchased by
- 41:13the big companies, they don't seem to be
- 41:16targets anymore.
- 41:17It's kind of funny how that happens.
- 41:19Like it's the upstart companies that are not
- 41:23bought by international conglomerates that get a lot
- 41:26of hits.
- 41:27But once they're bought by international conglomerates, they
- 41:30don't seem to get that many hits.
- 41:32And they're filling up the supermarket aisle, at
- 41:34least my perspective.
- 41:36What are your thoughts, Dotsie?
- 41:39Yeah, I mean, I agree with you.
- 41:42It does seem to be that we have
- 41:44had a little bit of a surge in
- 41:46the last year with the products because it
- 41:49felt like there was a downturn.
- 41:50Like all of a sudden we had like
- 41:51three or four choices after 2019 when it
- 41:53had 20.
- 41:54But it seems to me that the major
- 41:56problem is how challenging it is to get
- 41:58shelf space.
- 41:59And that's why some of these smaller companies
- 42:02who've been bought by the bigger companies, sadly,
- 42:04many of them also distributing meat and dairy,
- 42:07have been able to get shelf space and
- 42:10stay in the grocery store.
- 42:11So I don't love how it's had to
- 42:13happen.
- 42:15But we're working with a new child-focused
- 42:22non-dairy milk that's made from chickpeas this
- 42:26past weekend at the New York City Marathon.
- 42:29We were in the expo.
- 42:30It is absolutely delicious.
- 42:32I mean, they have done the most beautiful
- 42:34job.
- 42:34I mean, it's an ingredient list that you
- 42:37can only dream of or a mother can
- 42:38only dream of for their children.
- 42:40But the shelf space, I mean, they just
- 42:45they're having such a hard time.
- 42:47Right.
- 42:47You can only hang in for so long.
- 42:49You know, you get that seed money and
- 42:51that is blown immediately making this incredible product
- 42:55because it's not cheap to make when it's
- 42:57that healthy.
- 42:59So it's shelf space to me, every food
- 43:02company I talk to and start up.
- 43:04That is their challenge.
- 43:06And I don't know how to change that,
- 43:08by the way.
- 43:08So I mean, right.
- 43:09I bet that's that's why it's so frustrating
- 43:11is because it's the depth of the large
- 43:15food companies, you know, like Nabisco and others.
- 43:19They have all the shelf space and they're
- 43:22not moving it.
- 43:23The grocery stores aren't wanting to move it
- 43:24around because they know what works.
- 43:27Wow.
- 43:28Well, yes, you're right.
- 43:29Shelf space is very important.
- 43:31And I'll tell you a funny story.
- 43:34When I was in New York, I would
- 43:36notice this one supermarket that the vegan products
- 43:40were always in the back in a horrible
- 43:42area.
- 43:43And I would get off work late and
- 43:45I would go back there and I'd move
- 43:47them to the front.
- 43:49And I was doing like rearranging the supermarket.
- 43:58And then one day that one night because
- 44:00I would be there like at 11 o
- 44:02'clock at night where nobody's paying attention.
- 44:03One night manager caught me and he's like,
- 44:06what the hell are you doing?
- 44:08I'm like, oh, I'm just rearranging a little
- 44:10bit.
- 44:11You're welcome.
- 44:12Yeah, exactly.
- 44:13Well, look, getting back to the reason that
- 44:17we're talking to you today, this this incredible
- 44:19news that has just been such good news.
- 44:24And we can talk about challenges, but let's
- 44:26celebrate our victories.
- 44:28This victory is absolutely extraordinary.
- 44:31Starbucks ending the vegan milk upcharge after a
- 44:34powerful PETA campaign and a campaign by Switch
- 44:37for Good.
- 44:39They are two of the most incredible organisations
- 44:42that are relentless.
- 44:45And James Cromwell led PETA's campaign, literally glueing
- 44:52himself to a Starbucks counter.
- 44:55And we'll just hear once again what he
- 44:59said.
- 44:59It's very short, but this got so much
- 45:04publicity that it really was worth it.
- 45:10The half an hour, hour or so really
- 45:14made headlines.
- 45:15A single cow emits more smog, warming pollutants
- 45:19than a car.
- 45:21One cow on a dairy farm also requires
- 45:2450 gallons of water a day.
- 45:27So we're in the vegan upcharge now because
- 45:29they charge for vegan milk in there.
- 45:34It does damage to the planet.
- 45:36It does damage to people who ingest it,
- 45:39who can't metabolise it.
- 45:42And it's simple greed.
- 45:45And again, the good news is that as
- 45:48a result of this campaign, the Dotsy Bausch,
- 45:51Switch for Good campaigns, and the fact that
- 45:55it was hurting their business, they have now
- 45:57stopped charging more for plant-based milks.
- 46:02So, you know, as we kind of try
- 46:06to understand the significance of this, Amber, in
- 46:10the big picture, I always say we never
- 46:13know what these big turning points are in
- 46:15any social justice movement.
- 46:18Wouldn't it be nice if we can all
- 46:20think of moments in history where one person
- 46:22did something and it ended up becoming a
- 46:25moment in history, but it may not have
- 46:28been obvious at the time.
- 46:30It became obvious in retrospect.
- 46:32Where does this Starbucks dropping the vegan upcharge
- 46:36in the United States and Canada rank in
- 46:39terms of groundbreaking change for the vegan movement,
- 46:43animal rights?
- 46:45Well, it's one of the probably first big
- 46:49barriers to hopefully in the very near future,
- 46:54where vegan milks and meat and eggs are
- 46:59the default, you know, that are just being
- 47:03served.
- 47:03And maybe then you have to ask especially
- 47:06for the cow's milk in your coffee if
- 47:09you really want it.
- 47:10And then eventually the dairy industry is just
- 47:13not going to be able to survive without
- 47:14the subsidies that they are getting and all
- 47:19of the, you know, unfounded money that they're
- 47:22getting from the school lunch programmes and things
- 47:25like that and from Starbucks.
- 47:26Because, again, Starbucks was, you know, is even
- 47:30with the roughly half of their customers who
- 47:33are already choosing the vegan milks despite the
- 47:37upcharge.
- 47:37That's another big thing is people were already
- 47:40largely choosing the vegan milks despite the upcharge.
- 47:43So, I mean, it remains to be seen
- 47:46how much more it's going to be now
- 47:49that people aren't facing this, you know, this
- 47:51upcharge that really raised the cost on things.
- 47:55It's just more accessible.
- 47:57And other coffee chains and coffee shops and
- 48:00restaurants and grocery stores, you know, it is
- 48:03going to have that ripple effect.
- 48:06Well, I certainly hope so.
- 48:08And one thing, I don't know if maybe
- 48:10some Starbucks executives might watch this.
- 48:12Who knows?
- 48:13We invite you on anytime.
- 48:14We would love to dialogue with you.
- 48:17But one thing I think that all the
- 48:18baristas should be informed of is what's vegan
- 48:21and what isn't.
- 48:22Because I was actually in a Starbucks recently
- 48:25and I saw that they had some kind
- 48:27of soy something or other or oat something
- 48:30or other, some kind of, it appeared to
- 48:32be, non-dairy.
- 48:33And I said, since it was not just
- 48:36a cup of coffee with a milk of
- 48:39whatever kind, it was sort of a fancy
- 48:41thing.
- 48:41I said, is that vegan?
- 48:43And they said, I don't know.
- 48:45So, and it said like oats.
- 48:49So, I think that all these baristas need
- 48:52to be informed of what drinks are vegan
- 48:55for their business.
- 48:56Not just to do me a personal favour,
- 48:59but because there's a lot of people like
- 49:01me going in and saying, is that vegan
- 49:03or does it, sometimes the powders have dairy
- 49:05in them.
- 49:06Because sometimes they'll have like a little powder,
- 49:08you know.
- 49:09And I don't want to take that risk.
- 49:11So, I just said, no, I'm not going
- 49:12to have it.
- 49:13But if I knew 100% it was
- 49:15completely vegan, I would have tried it.
- 49:20Now, let me say one other thing, because
- 49:22obviously Starbucks also serves food.
- 49:25Again, I want to say, full disclosure, I
- 49:27haven't been into a Starbucks to really look
- 49:30for anything or buy anything, except for that
- 49:32one incident in a long time.
- 49:34But I was in Switzerland, in Zurich.
- 49:37And I walked into a Starbucks and they
- 49:39had the most incredible vegan waffle.
- 49:42In fact, this one lady and I kind
- 49:44of, we kind of had a tug of
- 49:46war over it for a minute.
- 49:48The guy behind the counter said, oh, you
- 49:50know, these sell like hotcakes.
- 49:53And I thought, why the heck aren't we
- 49:55having this in the United States?
- 49:58I'd like to ask both of you.
- 49:59Why is it that a lot of countries
- 50:01in Europe, they didn't have the surcharge, but
- 50:06they had it here in the United States?
- 50:08And from my own personal observation, Starbucks in
- 50:11other countries like Switzerland are offering vegan options
- 50:16that are not available in the United States.
- 50:18Dotsie?
- 50:20Well, here's something that you really don't want
- 50:22to know.
- 50:23And the listeners don't really want to know.
- 50:25But one thing that we uncovered that was
- 50:27unrelated to the non-dairy milk upcharge with
- 50:31the whistleblowers, most of their sugary syrups at
- 50:35Starbucks have bone char.
- 50:39So if you're getting a vanilla latte like
- 50:41I used to, it has bone char in
- 50:44it.
- 50:45So there's not a lot of speciality drinks
- 50:49at Starbucks that are vegan.
- 50:51So that's just disgusting.
- 50:54I have to say legally, I can't independently
- 50:58confirm that.
- 50:59That's the first I've heard of it.
- 51:00So again, I would invite Starbucks on any
- 51:03time to respond to anything said by me,
- 51:06Dotsie or Amber or anybody.
- 51:09We would love to dialogue with you and
- 51:11set the record straight on all of this.
- 51:15But thank you for doing your investigations, Dotsie.
- 51:19So where do we go from here?
- 51:21We've only got two minutes.
- 51:23Final thoughts.
- 51:24Where do we go from here?
- 51:26Can I just take a day off?
- 51:29No.
- 51:30You sure?
- 51:32Oh, my God.
- 51:33We keep hammering.
- 51:35We don't stop.
- 51:36I mean, a coffee shop is a coffee
- 51:37shop, even though it's a multinational coffee shop,
- 51:40multi-international coffee shop.
- 51:42But we keep fighting with all the things
- 51:44that we're already fighting for.
- 51:46And after yesterday, I'm feeling a little bit
- 51:49down about our federal legislation.
- 51:51But that's not going to stop us, right?
- 51:53We fight.
- 51:54You fight.
- 51:54Amber fights.
- 51:55And we keep going.
- 51:57We can't not fight.
- 51:59When I wake up on mornings like this
- 52:01morning and feel like I don't know where
- 52:05we're going or what just happened, I always
- 52:08try and remind myself if I wasn't doing
- 52:10this, I wouldn't be able to live with
- 52:12myself.
- 52:12The three of us are incapable of not
- 52:15fighting.
- 52:16And Tom says put Dotsie on the team
- 52:18immediately.
- 52:19I said, Dotsie can put me on the
- 52:21team.
- 52:21We're on the same team.
- 52:21It's her team.
- 52:24I'm on the team.
- 52:25All right.
- 52:26We're all on the same team.
- 52:28Amber, what are your thoughts?
- 52:30What's next?
- 52:31Where do we go with this victory?
- 52:34PETA's motto, one of many, is never be
- 52:37silent.
- 52:37Every animal is someone.
- 52:39And we are just going to keep plugging
- 52:41away at that.
- 52:42Whether it's Starbucks or any other company that's
- 52:45exploiting animals, we don't stop.
- 52:47We just don't stop.
- 52:49We're going to keep going.
- 52:50And we need to get everybody on board.
- 52:52So come with us.
- 52:54I got the super glue.
- 52:58Yeah.
- 52:59And once again, I want to compliment both
- 53:01these organisations for being so relentless.
- 53:04I mean, if you look at some of
- 53:05these protests, this is not easy to pull
- 53:08off.
- 53:09These are difficult to pull off.
- 53:12They involve tremendous coordination.
- 53:14And the people here are almost exclusively volunteers.
- 53:21There I am, a volunteer, shouting.
- 53:23And there's one of the leaders of Switch
- 53:26for Good, along with Dotsie Bausch.
- 53:30People think, oh, are we doing all this
- 53:33because it's fun?
- 53:34No.
- 53:36There's plenty of other things that I would
- 53:38have rather done in a perfect world other
- 53:41than go and drive to a Starbucks and
- 53:43stand there and chant for an hour and
- 53:45a half.
- 53:46But we do it because the animals cannot
- 53:50speak for themselves.
- 53:52The planet cannot speak for itself.
- 53:55And humans need to know that there's an
- 54:00alternative to dairy that is zero cholesterol, that's
- 54:03better for them, better for the animals, and
- 54:05better for the planet.
- 54:07So I just want to say thank you
- 54:09both.
- 54:09I know you are very, very busy, busy
- 54:12people.
- 54:13And I can't tell you how much I
- 54:15appreciate you coming here today and just celebrating
- 54:20this victory.
- 54:21This is a major, major victory.
- 54:24Again, according to Dotsie, Starbucks is the leading
- 54:29purveyor of dairy in the United States aside
- 54:31from the U.S. government and government institutions.
- 54:35So it's a major breakthrough.
- 54:36I will say once again, thank you, Starbucks.
- 54:42We're going to sing your praises today for
- 54:44doing the right thing.
- 54:46And we invite you on anytime.
- 54:48Meanwhile, I urge everybody to download Unchained TV.
- 54:53We are the world's only vegan streaming television
- 54:56network.
- 54:57And we are mostly volunteer run.
- 55:00We are a 501C3 nonprofit.
- 55:03And check us out.
- 55:05So it's a vegan network.
- 55:07Okay, that's the craziest thing I've ever heard.
- 55:09I love Unchained TV.
- 55:10Unchained, Unchained TV.
- 55:12Your life will change.
- 55:13It's just that easy.
- 55:15Unchained TV has all sorts of content for
- 55:17everybody.
- 55:18Unchained TV changed my life.
- 55:20Unchained TV is crushing it.
- 55:23I love Unchained TV.
- 55:25Unchained TV is my go-to.
- 55:27Unchained TV, who knew?
- 55:30Unchained, baby, yay!
- 55:35So you can download Unchained TV on your
- 55:38phone.
- 55:39You can download it on any TV with
- 55:42Amazon Fire Stick, Roku device, or Apple TV
- 55:44device.
- 55:45It's also on all Samsung TVs and about
- 55:47to go on all LG TVs.
- 55:50And I tell you, there's about 2,000
- 55:52videos, including this one, that are a lot
- 55:54of fun to watch and highly educational.
- 55:56All free.
- 55:57We are a 501C3 nonprofit.
- 55:59Thank you very much, ladies.
- 56:01Rock on!
- 56:02Bye-bye, VAMPers!