Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Persuasion Without Overpromising: Ethical Advocacy in Written and Oral Argument
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Persuasion Without Ur Promising, Ethical
- 0:07Advocacy in Written and Oral Argument. I'm Laurie
- 0:11Critt -Martin. certified family law specialist,
- 0:14and a former vice chair of BHBA's litigation
- 0:17section. I'm delighted to introduce our speaker,
- 0:20Chanel Bachikin. We were originally scheduled
- 0:22to have Christopher Frost join us today as well,
- 0:26but he's currently been pulled into trial. Chanel
- 0:28will be leading the entire presentation for us.
- 0:31Chanel Bachikin is an associate attorney at Frost
- 0:35LLP, where she handles complex commercial litigation
- 0:39involving class actions, consumer disputes, product
- 0:46liability, and regulatory matters. She previously
- 0:49practiced at one of the world's largest full
- 0:52service firms, focusing on high stakes, class
- 0:56action, and regulatory matters involving consumer
- 0:59products. She brings a distinctive ability to
- 1:02translate scientific and technical concepts into
- 1:05legal strategy. And she earned her JD from the
- 1:08University of Southern California School of Law,
- 1:12where she was a member of the Hale Moot Court
- 1:15Honors Program. And now let's get started. Thank
- 1:20you so much for that introduction. As stated,
- 1:24my name is Chanel. Hi. Thank you so much for
- 1:26joining us today. I do just want to state that
- 1:31this presentation is a part of a bit of a series
- 1:36that Frost LLP is doing. with the Beverly Hills
- 1:40Bar Association on Persuasion. Chris Frost and
- 1:43I previously presented a CLE on oral advocacy
- 1:46earlier this year, centered around the developing
- 1:51attorney's experience in the modern legal industry.
- 1:55So today we'll be discussing ethical advocacy.
- 1:59And this is meant to pair more senior partner
- 2:03level experience alongside a more developing
- 2:07associate's perspective. on building these skills
- 2:10surrounding persuasion. So although Chris isn't
- 2:14here today, he and I have discussed this issue
- 2:16at length in preparation for this. And our written
- 2:18materials are guided by the same dual perspective
- 2:21that we're trying to highlight in this series.
- 2:24Next slide. So today's topic centers around ethical
- 2:33advocacy, specifically how to advocate rigorously
- 2:37without compromising your ethical duties. And
- 2:40this affects all manner of communication to all
- 2:43types of audiences. So how you persuade your
- 2:45clients, how you persuade opposing counsel, and
- 2:48how you persuade the bench. And I'd also like
- 2:51to note for younger attorneys, because I don't
- 2:54think it's typically stated, if you're earlier
- 2:58in your career, the way you write, the way you
- 3:01argue, the way you even talk to clients is in
- 3:04flux. And every time you do anything, you're
- 3:06slowly building habits. It's really worthwhile
- 3:10to build those habits around developing credibility.
- 3:16in your career. It's far easier doing that at
- 3:19the outset rather than having to course correct
- 3:21later. And this isn't just a concern with external
- 3:25audiences, so clients or judges. It can also
- 3:29play out inside your firm. So a lack of credibility
- 3:32can result in partners who don't want to staff
- 3:35you on matters, colleagues who may not trust
- 3:37your work product, or even clients who may have
- 3:42inflated expectations based on what you've told
- 3:44them, and now your team members have to go and
- 3:47dampen down those expectations. So today we'll
- 3:50be discussing what all of this means in practice.
- 3:53Next slide. So firstly, I want to discuss what
- 3:59our ethical duties are as attorneys. There are
- 4:02various rules that govern this aspect of our
- 4:05practice, and I'm going to speak about a few
- 4:06today. The first is 3 .1, meritorious claims
- 4:10and contentions, and this just requires a good
- 4:13faith basis for every argument you make. A good
- 4:16faith can mean an argument supported by existing
- 4:19law or an argument for extending, modifying,
- 4:23or reversing existing law. So the rule doesn't
- 4:26require only to make uncontroversial arguments,
- 4:29but it requires that even a controversial argument
- 4:33be made in good faith. California also has a
- 4:37frivolity standard that California courts have
- 4:41defined. And that standard has two components,
- 4:44the objective component and the subjective component.
- 4:48So the objective component is just that any reasonable
- 4:51attorney would agree that the argument is totally
- 4:53and completely without merit. And the subjective
- 4:58component is that the argument was made for an
- 5:01improper purpose. So that could be to harass
- 5:03the other side, to delay proceedings, et cetera.
- 5:08Courts typically look at both of these together
- 5:11in total context. And this doesn't just mean
- 5:15that if you lose an argument that it was frivolous,
- 5:19it specifically has to meet the objective and
- 5:21subjective standard. Next rule that we'll discuss
- 5:25is rule 3 .3, candor to the tribunal, which just
- 5:30requires honesty with the court, including relevant
- 5:34facts, disclosing, controlling authority, regardless
- 5:37of how it supports or maybe is even adverse to
- 5:41your position. You just want to be honest. And
- 5:45lastly rule 3 .4 fairness to opposing party and
- 5:48council just governs how you deal with the other
- 5:50side so don't obstruct access to evidence no
- 5:57dishonest tactics just maintaining your professionalism
- 6:00when dealing with opposing council. And so I
- 6:05do want to discuss what our persuasive ability
- 6:07relies on and it. really relies on our credibility,
- 6:11which is just whether your listener believes
- 6:13what you're telling them. And this is why ethical
- 6:16rules are so foundational to our practice as
- 6:19attorneys. Every audience we speak to be speak
- 6:22to extends us a baseline of trust because they
- 6:26expect us to be operating within the sort of
- 6:29set of ethical rules. It's also why our profession
- 6:32is one that requires, you know, licensure and
- 6:35board oversight because our words carry weight
- 6:39and there's sort of a public expectation of candor
- 6:42that we need to maintain as we practice. And
- 6:46lastly on this program we're going to discuss
- 6:49what happens when we over promise and it's just
- 6:51we lose our believability as advocates. So, for
- 6:55example, I'm sure everybody in program today
- 6:58has threatened that they'll file suit against
- 7:03opposing party for 1 reason or another. If you
- 7:07tell that. party that you'll file suit the first
- 7:10time you know they really don't have any reason
- 7:12not to believe you that threat does carry some
- 7:16sort of weight however if you tell them 2357
- 7:21times that you're going to file suit and you
- 7:25never do each time you tell them that threat
- 7:29becomes weaker and weaker and eventually it carries
- 7:33no weight at all because your listeners learned
- 7:35that. those words doesn't actually predict your
- 7:39actions. I personally experienced a matter where
- 7:43the partner and I were engaged in a pre -litigation
- 7:47dispute in which we threatened suit more than
- 7:49once. And once the partner realized that over
- 7:54the course of a few months that we had threatened
- 7:55suit he explicitly told me that we needed to
- 7:59shift our strategy because that sort of the threat
- 8:03of legal action had been completely undermined
- 8:07by the fact that we hadn't filed suit yet and
- 8:09so we want to be careful. How often we say things
- 8:15either because they're inaccurate or just, you
- 8:18know, that there are threats that turn out to
- 8:20be empty. We want to make sure that we maintain
- 8:22our power and our credibility with the things
- 8:24that we say to our listeners. Next slide. So,
- 8:31yeah, just being persuasive is our job as attorneys
- 8:34and our credibility gives us license to persuade
- 8:37our listener. Next slide. So I do just want to
- 8:43give some examples of what over promising looks
- 8:46like. First is overstated certainty. We never
- 8:50want to pretend to be certain about anything
- 8:53because anything can happen in practicing law
- 8:58and litigation. You just don't know. This can
- 9:01affect clients, obviously, but this can also
- 9:04affect supervising partners and colleagues. You
- 9:07know, I'm a mid level associate and for any other
- 9:10sort of more junior team members out there, we're
- 9:14often the ones closest to the case law and the
- 9:17facts and the record. And so this proximity means
- 9:20partners rely on our read of the record. And
- 9:24so we never want to overstate how strong an argument
- 9:26is or how favorable a body of case law is. We
- 9:30want to be as grounded and accurate as possible.
- 9:34Is the second is ignored unfavorable authority
- 9:38accuracy and describing authority on an issue
- 9:41is critical and ignoring adverse authority or
- 9:45even over selling how favorable a mixed body
- 9:48of case law is can create real problems both
- 9:51ethically but also practically and for your own
- 9:55clients selling guaranteed outcomes you know
- 10:00this is primarily. affecting our clients. You
- 10:04can't tell them that you will win a trial or
- 10:06emotion will be granted. You will get the other
- 10:10side to settle for a certain amount. You just
- 10:13don't know. And it one is unethical to sort of
- 10:18sell that certainty to your client when you don't
- 10:20know. But also, you know, as I previously stated,
- 10:23it can it can create issues because if you don't
- 10:26get that result, you and your team members now
- 10:28have to deal with an unhappy client. who had
- 10:32inflated expectations based on your own words.
- 10:36And finally, rhetorical inflation. I noticed
- 10:40as a junior. I did this a lot sort of obviously
- 10:44our argument should prevail clearly the court
- 10:47must grant our motion. This is sort of a show
- 10:51don't tell thing. You want to be able to show
- 10:54whoever whomever is listening to you, whether
- 10:58that's a judge or opposing counsel, a mediator,
- 11:01etc. You want to show that your argument is superior.
- 11:04You don't want to have to tell them. that your
- 11:08argument is superior. Next slide. And I do just
- 11:15wanna restate that good credibility, good reputation
- 11:19is hard to earn and easy to lose. So you really
- 11:22wanna be careful because one overreach can completely
- 11:27demolish years of ethical practice. Next slide.
- 11:35I so the world within which we practice is smaller
- 11:40than we think. Especially for juniors it's a
- 11:45mistake to think you can operate outside ethical
- 11:47boundaries or you can take a shortcut here and
- 11:50there and no one is going to notice the world
- 11:53you're practicing in a small people talk people
- 11:56know each other and typically those conversations
- 11:59happen outside of you and you just never know
- 12:02how far reaching sort of a shortcut you try to
- 12:06take can be. You know in and around your network
- 12:10of colleagues. So judges you appear of can remember
- 12:15what you do opposing council that you go up against
- 12:18will remember what you do and once enough people
- 12:22have had experiences with you positive or negative
- 12:25and shared them with others you know it can create
- 12:28a record that is hard to clean up or get ahead
- 12:31of. For example, I'm sure everyone has received
- 12:35or seen an all firm email or an all department
- 12:39email asking if anyone has had experience with
- 12:43a particular attorney or if anyone has information
- 12:46about a particular firm. And because people love
- 12:50the reply all button, you often see quite a few
- 12:53responses come back. And I remember being awestruck
- 12:57at how How reputations have stuck with people
- 13:03and you know you see interactions with people.
- 13:08You know who respond to these emails saying oh
- 13:10yeah you know i i worked with this person one
- 13:13time five years ago when i remember they were
- 13:16super unprofessional or they were super rude
- 13:19or you know these people you know people in our
- 13:22network of practice. Can remember things and
- 13:26that's a perfect example of. you know, the display
- 13:30of how your reputation can precede you. And even
- 13:35people who you may deem to be total strangers
- 13:38remember their interactions with you and remember
- 13:40your work product. So don't assume people aren't
- 13:44noticing you or your actions. Consider every
- 13:48action you take to handle a matter as a building
- 13:51block that develops your reputation and hopefully
- 13:53in a positive manner. Next slide. So I do want
- 14:01to start discussing some particular ways that
- 14:05you can maintain your ethics and written advocacy
- 14:08you want to lean into persuasive framing and
- 14:12lean away from misleading omission so persuasive
- 14:15framing is just including true. relevant facts
- 14:19and choosing which to emphasize or how to order
- 14:22them, how to present them to support your client's
- 14:25position. Misleading omission is leaving out
- 14:28certain facts, not because they're irrelevant,
- 14:31but because they could potentially undercut your
- 14:33arguments. Obviously, we want to be selective
- 14:36in what we write and how we write it. You know,
- 14:39everything we write is persuasive, and so we
- 14:41do want to always put our best foot forward in
- 14:44persuading our audience on behalf of our client.
- 14:47However, you have to consider why you're being
- 14:50selective regarding certain facts and whether
- 14:53what you've left out would change how a reasonable
- 14:56reader would understand what you're arguing.
- 14:59So what I typically do is when I'm writing, especially
- 15:04at the outset, when I'm just including or considering
- 15:08what to include, I think about whether. If opposing
- 15:12opposing counsel statement of facts included
- 15:15a particular fact would it hurt my position.
- 15:19And if not you know you could argue potentially
- 15:22that the fact is irrelevant doesn't need to be
- 15:25included but if it could especially meaningfully
- 15:29that's probably a very solid argument as to its
- 15:34relevance and it's probably not a good idea to
- 15:37leave it out. So at that point, you should still
- 15:42include it. And your next step in strategizing
- 15:45is to consider how you want to frame it. If you
- 15:49want to maybe put that fact deeper into your
- 15:52statement of facts or explain it away. But you
- 15:56still have to deal with facts you don't like.
- 15:58They just need to be framed, maybe contextualized,
- 16:02explained. But you absolutely cannot ignore relevant
- 16:06facts just because they may undermine your position.
- 16:10Next slide. So this one is simple. It is what
- 16:20it sounds like. You know, we want to lean into
- 16:23accurate explanation of case law. We want to
- 16:25lean away from distortion of case law. You can
- 16:29emphasize favorable holdings and downplay unfavorable
- 16:32ones. You can definitely explain why you think
- 16:36any adverse authority isn't applicable to your
- 16:39facts by distinguishing the facts of adverse
- 16:43authority away from yours or highlighting favorable
- 16:47facts and distinguishing the facts between adverse
- 16:50authority. and supporting authority, but your
- 16:53framing should never change the reader's actual
- 16:56understanding of what the case says or how it
- 17:00should apply. And that is typically the easiest
- 17:03thing someone opposing your writing can do is
- 17:07go through and read the cases you've cited and
- 17:10be able to identify each instance in which you
- 17:13misquoted or misapplied case law. Now, obviously
- 17:17there can be Differences in opinion on how a
- 17:22case should be applied. Obviously, that's what
- 17:24a lot of argument regarding application of case
- 17:28law does, but you don't want something to be
- 17:32facially obvious that a case doesn't say this
- 17:35or shouldn't be applied in a particular way.
- 17:39Next slide. So we want to lead lean into quoting
- 17:47with required context we want to lead away from
- 17:50gerrymandering for anyone who doesn't understand
- 17:53what I mean by gerrymandering if you've ever
- 17:56seen. Voting maps. with counties and they're
- 18:01drawn in very bizarre shapes where people have
- 18:06tried to carve out sort of the perfect segment
- 18:10of constituents for a particular political party.
- 18:14That's what I mean. I mean approaching a quotation
- 18:17and carving around it to get a particular meaning
- 18:23out of what the quote says, even if in full context
- 18:26the quote actually doesn't mean what you're trying
- 18:28to make it mean. So we definitely don't want
- 18:32to do that again. It's very easy, low -hanging
- 18:35fruit for opposing counsel to go through the
- 18:39case law you've cited and identify what context
- 18:44a quotation is in. When I'm doing citation checks
- 18:50for My own writing or i'm writing an opposition.
- 18:56It's typically something that i do every time
- 19:00i just go and make sure that the quotes are in
- 19:02context and nothing meaningful is cut from them
- 19:05because that's the easiest thing in the world
- 19:06to point out to a judge to let them know that
- 19:09you know your opposing counsel is trying to mislead
- 19:12the court by removing quotations from decisions
- 19:17from their original context. Again, you can use
- 19:22a similar test as I previously discussed. If
- 19:25opposing counsel reads the quotation in full
- 19:27context, does it hurt you? If it doesn't hurt
- 19:30you or it doesn't change the way that the reader
- 19:34would understand your argument, then it's likely
- 19:38that you can get away with shortening a quotation
- 19:42and removing that context. But if it does hurt
- 19:45your position, it's likely that you shouldn't
- 19:47cut that context and you should instead include
- 19:50it, but find a way to explain why. You know the
- 19:56the quotation should have an alternate meaning
- 19:58or perhaps there's a better quotation for you
- 20:01to use elsewhere and you shouldn't force a quotation
- 20:06into your writing if it doesn't actually benefit
- 20:10your position. Next slide. So we want to always
- 20:17lean into confronting adverse authority. Generally
- 20:22speaking, you should always include controlling
- 20:24authority, whether it supports your argument
- 20:27or not. And if it doesn't support your argument,
- 20:31you should identify the ways you believe. That
- 20:33the authority doesn't apply to your case, but
- 20:36you shouldn't ignore it. It really undermines
- 20:39your position. If there's obvious if it's obvious
- 20:43that very important case law on a topic is missing.
- 20:46or you've cut out aspects of an analysis that
- 20:50need to be there because it doesn't benefit you.
- 20:53Firstly, ignoring adverse authority doesn't make
- 20:56it go away. It just creates an opportunity for
- 20:59the other side to raise it on their own terms
- 21:03within their own framing. It hurts the credibility
- 21:08of your own writing. The moment a judge identifies
- 21:10that you just like completely left out an important
- 21:14ruling and it also obstructs your own preparation.
- 21:18If this is in the context of emotion, that's
- 21:21going to have a hearing later on and you haven't
- 21:23confronted adverse authority on paper or the
- 21:28benefits to what the other side is arguing. You
- 21:33haven't actually worked out an answer. I'm too
- 21:36why that ever authority shouldn't mean that your
- 21:40position is. You know is wrong and so you really
- 21:46should try your best to work it out in writing
- 21:48first because you'll be less prepared to confronted
- 21:52an oral argument and if you haven't worked it
- 21:55out before you know it typically will mean that
- 21:58your oral argument on the topics not gonna be
- 22:00as strong so if you do have. controlling authority
- 22:04that's not great for you, confront it head on,
- 22:07state it accurately, and then argue why it doesn't
- 22:10undermine your position. It could be factual,
- 22:12it could be because there's other case law that
- 22:16rules in your favor and it's more of a mixed
- 22:19bag in your jurisdiction. So for example, if
- 22:23you're discussing a topic that requires In the
- 22:27court to analyze totality of circumstances don't
- 22:31just not talk about circumstances that are adverse
- 22:34to your position state them and then argue why
- 22:37they have less weight and why these other conditions
- 22:42or circumstances that benefit you should be weighed
- 22:44more heavily and in totality even with this sort
- 22:49of the sort of adverse circumstances in totality
- 22:52the judge should. Rule in favor of your position,
- 22:56but you can't you can't ignore it. It just it
- 22:58works against you ultimately. Next slide. And
- 23:07so I do want to talk about beyond writing beyond
- 23:12motion practice or beyond. Trying to persuade
- 23:18a judge. This. I think is not considered as important,
- 23:25but ethically is very important, just as important.
- 23:30Meet and confer letters, corresponding with opposing
- 23:32counsel, more informal correspondence to the
- 23:36court, it all matters and you still need to be
- 23:39accurate in this writing. You need to characterize
- 23:45your correspondence accurately. This is the kind
- 23:49of thing that can travel the fastest through
- 23:51your local network. So if you're working on a
- 23:55matter opposite opposing counsel and you mischaracterize
- 23:59what you all discussed in a meet and confer or
- 24:02you lie to get an extension or you do things
- 24:11in your informal communications. Those are the
- 24:15types of things that can really follow you. So
- 24:18one you know if for some reason someone asks
- 24:21that person about you and about your reputation
- 24:24they're gonna have negative things to say and
- 24:26that can precede you moving into your next matter
- 24:30opposite someone once again who to you may be
- 24:33a stranger but that person may have negative
- 24:36feelings about practicing against you because
- 24:39of how you've handled matters previously but
- 24:42it also in that. Exact matter would damage your
- 24:45working relationship with opposing counsel if
- 24:48you're. Difficult to work with and operate in
- 24:51bad faith. That can diminish opposing council's
- 24:55willingness to accommodate your needs on the
- 24:57case that could mean they're less likely to give
- 25:00you a discovery extensions if you need them they're
- 25:03less likely to meet and confer informally they
- 25:06may say you know what i can't trust that you're
- 25:09going to characterize our discussions accurately
- 25:12so we need to do everything by formal letter
- 25:14and that ultimately hurt you when it hurts your
- 25:17client because now. you've created this roadblock
- 25:20where opposing counsel needs everything to be
- 25:22formal in writing and they're unwilling to give
- 25:26you leeway because they don't trust that you're
- 25:29going to be a fair opponent in a matter and once
- 25:33again it only really harms you and it harms your
- 25:36client so informal writing and informal engagements
- 25:41are extremely important And you really want to
- 25:44make sure that everything you do is above board
- 25:47because any shortcut you think you're going to
- 25:50take typically will come and bite you. And it's
- 25:54genuinely not worth it. Next slide. So next we're
- 26:01going to move on to oral advocacy and the ways
- 26:04that you want to maintain your ethical duties
- 26:08when engaging in oral argument. Next slide. I'm
- 26:15so if you're arguing and you know that there's
- 26:19going to be unfavorable facts or case law to
- 26:22come up. You typically want to get ahead of it
- 26:27and this can depend on how important it is so
- 26:32for example if there's controlling authority
- 26:34that's adverse to your position unlikely that
- 26:38going to get away with not having to confront.
- 26:40that controlling authority so it's probably best
- 26:44to be proactive in conceding aspects of it and
- 26:50you know rather than waiting for opposing counsel
- 26:53to bring it up you you want to concede it first
- 26:57with your own framing that's positive for your
- 27:00client and for your position it's best not to
- 27:04be on the back foot with things like this typically
- 27:08because you know You don't want opposing counsel
- 27:12to have to set a narrative that you have to argue
- 27:14against. You want opposing counsel to have to
- 27:16argue against why your narrative is wrong or
- 27:20shouldn't control. And also this is typically
- 27:24a preparation thing as well. You know, as we
- 27:26stated in the written section, if you're not
- 27:31confronting adverse authority or adverse facts
- 27:34in the writing, it can mean that you haven't
- 27:38thought about them fully. And if you get in front
- 27:41of a judge not having considered that and now
- 27:45for the first time live before the judge and
- 27:49in front of opposing counsel you have to consider
- 27:50why these bad facts or an adverse authority shouldn't
- 27:54be considered unlikely that you're going to get
- 27:57a good result. So if there are peripheral facts
- 28:00that are great for you you more so can get away
- 28:03with not confronting them and keep you know keeping
- 28:06to. the more important facts or case law that
- 28:11support your argument. But if they're particularly
- 28:14relevant or in case law controlling, you typically
- 28:19just want to get ahead of it and frame it concisely
- 28:23in a way that benefits you and put opposing counsel
- 28:27on the back foot to defend rather than giving
- 28:29opposing counsel the opportunity to attack with
- 28:32it. Next slide. So you don't want to dodge difficult
- 28:42questions. You want to be direct. And again,
- 28:44this is often a preparation issue. When you're
- 28:48actually prepared, you typically have thought
- 28:50about every way that the judge or opposing counsel
- 28:54can bring something up that's unfavorable to
- 28:56you. And so it allows you to address unfavorable
- 29:00aspects directly and concisely. But when you're
- 29:03not prepared, you kind of are left with either
- 29:08I'm trying to wiggle out of the questions or
- 29:10be indirect in your answers so as not to just
- 29:13concede when something isn't great for you and
- 29:16this dodging you know being indirect can do two
- 29:20things both of them bad. First off it just makes
- 29:23you harder to understand and so with the judges
- 29:27try utilizing your. Your oral argument to make
- 29:30a decision and you're kind of being Weasley and
- 29:34hard to understand it can't just drag out the
- 29:38exchange and it keeps the court sitting on your
- 29:41weak points the weak points of your argument
- 29:43longer than they need to which. You definitely
- 29:48don't want to do you want to be concise direct
- 29:50and move forward to the strong points of your
- 29:53argument You don't want to have to be forced
- 29:55to sit in explaining The weak points of your
- 29:58argument, which you can do if you prepare sufficiently
- 30:01It also creates the impression that the unfavorable
- 30:04law or fact is potentially more damaging than
- 30:07it actually is Being indirect can sometimes signal
- 30:11weakness in the argument and you know can create
- 30:15An opportunity for the judge to ask more follow
- 30:17up questions because they're wondering why you
- 30:19can't just answer a simple question that's relevant
- 30:22to what you're there to talk about. It also creates
- 30:25the opportunity for opposing counsel to sort
- 30:27of sniff out the weakness in your argument and
- 30:30really hammer it home as opposed to being confident
- 30:33in the fact that yes, there's a weak point in
- 30:35my argument, but it's not dispositive and here
- 30:37are the reasons why. Next slide. So over confidence
- 30:47and word choice and tone I think is junior associates
- 30:51or at least for me I remember when I first started
- 30:55writing and I went into this a lot for some reason
- 30:59I'm not sure why but I think the. You know you
- 31:03want to be wary of words like obviously and undeniably
- 31:07when your position isn't actually obvious or
- 31:09undeniable and over confident attitude can certainly
- 31:13backfire especially if the underlying position
- 31:16isn't well supported but even if it is well supported
- 31:20that sort of. The acting as if your argument
- 31:25superiority is a foregone conclusion can turn
- 31:29off the listener I certainly seen in hearings.
- 31:33Judges be turned off by. Claiming that it's obvious
- 31:38that the judge needs to rule a certain way or
- 31:41even you know the judge must or has to rule a
- 31:45certain way when in actuality. based on the law,
- 31:49it just suggests that the court perhaps should
- 31:52rule a certain way, but there's certainly room
- 31:54for interpretation. And I've noticed that judges
- 31:59sometimes can be offended. Almost by that language
- 32:03you know it seems to suggest that a reasonable
- 32:06listener would have to come to some sort of conclude
- 32:10you know a particular conclusion and if the judge
- 32:13is already you know considering other ways to
- 32:17rule or you know is doubting your argument for
- 32:20some reason. Suggesting that you know they have
- 32:22to be unreasonable not to side with you in a
- 32:25particular way or obviously every reasonable
- 32:27person considering these sort of facts would
- 32:30rule a certain way it really can come off offensive
- 32:33i i certainly wouldn't suggest it. It also typically
- 32:39can create. heighten scrutiny in your listener
- 32:42so if your listener is noticing this language
- 32:45this obviously undeniably clearly you know the
- 32:48court has to rule a certain way etc. If it doesn't
- 32:53hold up based on the strength of the argument
- 32:55the delta between your overconfidence and the
- 33:00maybe moderate support your position has becomes
- 33:04a source of doubt and so. The listener or you
- 33:08know judges in this case can start to ask more
- 33:12questions because they're trying to figure out
- 33:14how the facts and case law that's presented in
- 33:18front of them as you see it is getting you to
- 33:21the court has to roll this way and it's obvious
- 33:24and you again you certainly don't want to be
- 33:27in a position where the judge feels as though
- 33:31they have to ask. More questions to understand
- 33:35what you're saying both directly you know verbally
- 33:40but also what you're saying in your attitude
- 33:42and your and your overconfident language. You
- 33:47never want the judge to ask more questions than
- 33:49necessary and so being overconfident can trigger
- 33:53heighten scrutiny from the listener and you typically
- 33:58want to avoid that. I'm so in my view, rather
- 34:03than using words like, you know, obviously undeniably,
- 34:06etc. It's best to just put all of that confidence
- 34:11in showing your argument and how robust and well
- 34:15supported it is. You shouldn't have to tell the
- 34:18judge if your argument is clearly superior. You
- 34:21shouldn't have to tell them that they should
- 34:23be able to suss that out on their own. And you
- 34:25just want to make sure that you're writing. is
- 34:28you know shows it but you want to avoid having
- 34:30to tell them that if you have to tell them it's
- 34:33perhaps a signal that the writing or the position
- 34:35isn't as strong as you thought you probably need
- 34:37to go back to the drawing board and figure out
- 34:40how to just show that to them next slide um so
- 34:47there are tons of consequences uh of over promising
- 34:52and These are just four that occurred to me,
- 34:57though there are plenty more. The first is that
- 35:01the listener forgets your good arguments and
- 35:04begins scrutinizing everything you say. So as
- 35:06I just sort of highlighted in the previous slide,
- 35:10when you approach a listener with overconfidence,
- 35:15It sometimes can create a need for heightened
- 35:18scrutiny and the person that's listening to you
- 35:20feels as though there's something missing so
- 35:22they start asking more questions to bridge the
- 35:25gap between your overconfidence and what may
- 35:27seem to be just a normal good argument but certainly
- 35:30not. One that's clear and obvious like you're
- 35:35describing and so you don't want the listener
- 35:38to start. scrutinizing everything you say trying
- 35:43to bridge that gap you want everything to be
- 35:46concise where things are strong you don't need
- 35:50to state they're strong you just need to show
- 35:52that they're strong by delivering a great argument
- 35:54but you you shouldn't need to state that. Secondly
- 36:00the judge and opposing council begin to discount
- 36:02your credibility. This is super problematic,
- 36:05especially in a matter. There are so many ways
- 36:09that one, for the judge, if you're caught ever
- 36:15exaggerating case law, if you're caught leaving
- 36:19certain things out of quotations or mischaracterizing
- 36:22what happens in a meet and confer, the judge
- 36:25will get the idea that they need to start double
- 36:29and triple checking your work. or needing input
- 36:34prior to taking your word for anything. So you
- 36:39really don't wanna create this relationship with
- 36:44your judge where you say things and they already
- 36:48approach you with a sense of doubt having had
- 36:52experiences with you where you were trying to
- 36:54sort of pull wool over their eyes or Take advantage
- 36:59of shortcuts to get a better result. Super super
- 37:05avoidable and not great same thing with opposing
- 37:09counsel you don't want opposing counsel to feel
- 37:11like they need to double and triple check everything
- 37:14you say because they can't trust you to be honest
- 37:16or accurate as I said previously and this is
- 37:21something now that I'm starting to run. matters
- 37:24and take control and ownership of matters, your
- 37:27working relationship with opposing counsel is
- 37:30vital. And if you start screwing that up, especially
- 37:35for no reason, it really only harms you. You
- 37:41and your relationship with opposing counsel really
- 37:43is set based on goodwill. And so if you start
- 37:48presenting This image to opposing counsel that
- 37:51you're untrustworthy and that they can't. Be
- 37:55flexible and lenient with you they can't work
- 37:57with you because they don't know if you're going
- 38:00to try and take advantage of their kindness or
- 38:03their flexibility they don't know if you're going
- 38:06to run back to the judge and mischaracterize
- 38:09what happened between you two so you just. You
- 38:12don't wanna ever build a wall between yourself
- 38:15and opposing counsel where it's not necessary
- 38:17because again it only harms you and it only harms
- 38:20your client. So you want to move forward in your
- 38:23career with a good sense of credibility and a
- 38:28good reputation. You don't want to screw that
- 38:31up with the judge and opposing counsel in particular
- 38:35because it just makes your matter impossible
- 38:38for no reason. There's also the practical risks.
- 38:43So risk of sanctions, the risk of bar complaints,
- 38:46the risk of malpractice complaints. We didn't
- 38:49speak too much about how this impacts your client,
- 38:52but you never want to create expectations with
- 38:56your client. And this can happen not only at
- 38:59the outset when you're trying to engage a client
- 39:02for representation, but you don't want to, you
- 39:06know, Inflate your client's expectations about
- 39:09anything. So that includes, you know, likelihood
- 39:12of settlement. That includes whether emotions
- 39:14are granted. You just want to be really accurate.
- 39:18And I would say err on the side of being conservative
- 39:20and not telling the client that anything in particular
- 39:23is going to happen unless it's happened already.
- 39:26So even something as simple as telling the client.
- 39:30You know, hey, I've sent you our draft responses
- 39:35to discovery requests. Technically they're due
- 39:39next week, but don't worry about them. I've got
- 39:41an extension. And you haven't yet asked for the
- 39:44extension or you've asked for the extension,
- 39:46but opposing council hasn't answered even something
- 39:49as simple as that can come off as. Unclear. And
- 39:55it makes you seem untrustworthy to the client
- 39:57if you tell them that and then 2 or 3 days later
- 40:00when opposing council denies your request for
- 40:02an extension, you have to come back and tell
- 40:04them that they need to hurry up and you need
- 40:07to quickly put these responses responses together
- 40:10because in fact, you actually didn't have an
- 40:12extension. It's just not worth it. So you you
- 40:16want your working relationship with your client
- 40:19to be solid because it can avoid things like
- 40:23malpractice claims Even you know things like
- 40:27bar complaints if you're working with opposing
- 40:29counsel and mishandling your dealings with them
- 40:32or sanctions It's again not worth it and it typically
- 40:36doesn't Or won't bolster your ability to get
- 40:40good results. You're just it's all risk and no
- 40:42reward And lastly, clients lose trust when promise
- 40:46outcomes don't materialize. So again, like I
- 40:49just said, you want your client to trust you
- 40:52as their advocate. You want them to trust what
- 40:55you say. And it really does become difficult
- 40:58working with a client who doesn't trust you.
- 41:00It's just not worth creating that difficulty
- 41:04in the representation litigation is difficult
- 41:06enough. You definitely don't want to add on to
- 41:09your problems. Next slide. So, you know, to bring
- 41:16it back, I wanted to just remind us all of our
- 41:19ethical obligations. We covered these more in
- 41:22depth at the start, but these rules are how we
- 41:26should move forward whenever you're doing anything,
- 41:30especially for juniors. Like I said, you're building
- 41:32habits now. So you want to remember. when you're
- 41:38ever engaging with the court at all, that everything
- 41:41you say or anything you write or submit to them
- 41:44is accurate to the best of your knowledge and
- 41:46ability, and that you can never be caught in
- 41:49a lie or even an exaggeration with the court.
- 41:55You want to ensure that all arguments you make
- 41:59are good faith arguments. If you find yourself
- 42:02needing to grasp at straws or stretch the truth
- 42:05to make an argument work. It means it doesn't
- 42:08work and you need to move on and find one that
- 42:10either does work or find another procedural way
- 42:13to move forward or proceed, but you definitely
- 42:17don't want to be someone who's known for making
- 42:21bad faith arguments. Not worth it and lastly
- 42:25you want to be fair to opposing party and counsel
- 42:28as I said working with opposing counsel is hugely
- 42:31important and so you don't want to create not
- 42:35only distrust between you but also a sort of
- 42:39tit -for -tat between you Where you know you
- 42:43make things difficult for opposing counsel and
- 42:45they fight back and try and make things difficult
- 42:47for you and ultimately the judge is disappointed
- 42:51in you both for you know for wasting their time
- 42:54and continually needing their intervention because
- 42:57you can't play nice with opposing counsel. So
- 43:01these ethical obligations are here for a reason.
- 43:04It's super important to ensure that everyone
- 43:08you're speaking to can trust what you say as
- 43:11an advocate. As I stated at the beginning our
- 43:14words carry weight as attorneys and so we want
- 43:17to be We wanna be mindful of that weight every
- 43:21time we speak to anybody. We don't wanna take
- 43:24that for granted. Next slide. So here are a few
- 43:30techniques that I try to employ just to make
- 43:34sure that when I'm writing or when I'm speaking
- 43:37with anyone that I'm operating within my ethical
- 43:40bounds. The first is to use calibrated language.
- 43:44You want to use language that is exactly accurate,
- 43:48not hopeful. So you should match your language
- 43:51to your actual level of certainty. So whenever
- 43:54you're writing a motion, you may think it's the
- 43:57strongest, most well -supported motion in the
- 43:59world, but you don't actually know if that motion
- 44:02is gonna be granted. It could be denied for a
- 44:04number of reasons legitimately. And so you want
- 44:09to, and that's true with a great case law that
- 44:13supports you, great facts or record that supports
- 44:16you. It doesn't typically, you know, nothing
- 44:20explicitly proves anything and nothing guarantees
- 44:23anything. So if you're writing and you have a
- 44:27fantastic record, you may want to say the record
- 44:31proves that you should prevail or the record
- 44:34proves your client X, Y, Z, but probably best
- 44:39to say that the record supports it. And again,
- 44:42if your record does in fact support it or even,
- 44:45you know, taps on proving it, that will be clear
- 44:48to the reader. Similarly, you don't ever want
- 44:52to suggest that a court has to or will do something.
- 44:56You should argue that they should do something,
- 44:59but never that they will because we don't know
- 45:01that. This avoids the rhetorical inflation and
- 45:05the overconfident tone that we discussed previously.
- 45:07That's just best to avoid. Again, we want to
- 45:14take preemptive concessions where necessary.
- 45:18If there are specific relevant facts or controlling
- 45:22authority that you absolutely have to. State
- 45:27it's best to just get ahead of it so if i know
- 45:30that there are weak points typically i'll outline
- 45:32first what supports my position and what undermines
- 45:37my position typically i just do charts of supporting
- 45:42case law supporting facts and adverse authority
- 45:46and undermining facts and i'll just distinguish
- 45:49with the case law why all of the reasons why.
- 45:53this case law could potentially not apply to
- 45:56the situation I'm arguing about or why those,
- 46:00you know, adverse facts shouldn't really be dispositive
- 46:04in the situation that I'm arguing about. And
- 46:08it typically is just better first, it gets ahead
- 46:12of the issue, allows you to frame it in as positive
- 46:16a way you can, but also doing that legwork at
- 46:19the outset gives you a good foundation when going
- 46:23into oral argument, especially because if you've
- 46:25included it in the writing and you have the benefit
- 46:28of a tentative ahead of the hearing, typically
- 46:32judges will interact with sort of points of controversy
- 46:36either in the record or in case law. And so you,
- 46:39you know, have put your argument out at the outset
- 46:42and you sometimes can see the judge's reaction
- 46:45to it ahead of the hearing. And that's super
- 46:48helpful. You want confidence in your argument,
- 46:51not in the outcome. You can and should argue
- 46:56with full conviction. The point of this is not
- 47:00to say to argue ethically, you have to be shy
- 47:04about your argument or your position. Argue rigorously,
- 47:08but... have confidence in the argument. You should
- 47:11never have confidence in the result because again
- 47:14litigation, but practicing law generally is very
- 47:20unpredictable. You just never know what's going
- 47:22to happen. And so you don't ever want to guarantee
- 47:25the result to anyone, not even yourself. You
- 47:28don't want to walk into a motion hearing believing
- 47:31that you're going to win because it's going to
- 47:33throw you off the minute the judge signals that
- 47:35they potentially aren't siding with you. Go in
- 47:39having full conviction in your position, but
- 47:43just avoid trying to guarantee the result. And
- 47:49then lastly, whenever you're writing or arguing
- 47:52orally, include everything that's necessary,
- 47:56good or bad, and then work on framing. So you
- 48:01never want your strategy to rely on you leaving
- 48:06Things out or ignoring certain things identify
- 48:10what's required for you to tell the judge or
- 48:13for you to tell. Opposing council you know whatever
- 48:17the writing is. And then just work on. The rest
- 48:22of it should just be framing how you explain
- 48:25it away or how you strategically place it so
- 48:28maybe the judge's eyes kind of skip over it but
- 48:31you absolutely cannot ignore it and pretend it
- 48:33doesn't exist ensure that you're not leaving
- 48:35out key information because again like i said
- 48:39if this is sort of in a brief and you do get
- 48:42the benefit of a tentative you also potentially
- 48:44lost the opportunity for the judge to give you
- 48:47a heads up on what they're thinking about. Regarding
- 48:51contrary, you know, or regarding adverse authority
- 48:56or undermining facts. And next slide. So lastly,
- 49:07I just wanna state again, our ethics and our
- 49:09credibility are the foundation of our ability
- 49:12to persuade. Again, particularly for junior attorneys,
- 49:17your reputation is arguing ahead of you, it precedes
- 49:21you. So you really want that to be a priority
- 49:24separate of everything else. You always want
- 49:28your colleagues and anyone working opposite you.
- 49:31to believe you to be credible and ethical. Again,
- 49:37remember, don't promise the outcomes, take your
- 49:40confidence in the strength of the argument and
- 49:42strive to be an advocate that cannot be caught
- 49:45in exaggeration or untruths. Ultimately, you
- 49:49just wanna make sure that as a legal practitioner,
- 49:52you are always above board and above reproach.
- 49:56If you... Stake that as the foundation of the
- 50:00habits that you build. You're ahead of a lot
- 50:04of folks and you never have to worry about having
- 50:07to clean up your reputation later. Next slide
- 50:12and with that happy to answer any questions.
- 50:23It looks like we do have a question. From Jack
- 50:28Russo, what do you do with a Rambo opponent who
- 50:31uses scorched earth approach? That's an awesome
- 50:35question because there are those people aren't
- 50:37there in my view. It typically is best to maintain
- 50:44an above board repro approach. It can be difficult
- 50:49to navigate with people like that, but I find
- 50:53that they. Create their own problems and you
- 50:56just have to wait for those issues to catch up
- 51:00with them so for example i was working on a matter
- 51:05opposite someone who i would describe as unreasonable
- 51:10and they were. It was approaching bad faith in
- 51:15the way that they were operating in the matter
- 51:18and the advice that I got from the partner was
- 51:22that we were just going to document absolutely
- 51:24everything and we were going to maintain the
- 51:27way we practice. So to avoid. us being roped
- 51:32into their sort of bad behavior and to avoid
- 51:36the judge being able to look at the events that
- 51:38had happened as a sort of both sides issue when
- 51:42in actuality, you know, we hadn't actually done
- 51:45anything. He just said, we're going to be even
- 51:48more professional and we're going to document
- 51:50absolutely everything and everything that we
- 51:52file with the court is going to have examples
- 51:56of. What's happening so for example, you know,
- 52:00there were quite a few discovery motions in that
- 52:03matter and alongside those discovery motions.
- 52:05We would attach our attempts to meet and confirm.
- 52:09So they would. Be super difficult, they would
- 52:13send us these discovery requests that had hundreds
- 52:17and hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of requests
- 52:19and we would try and meet and confirm. They would
- 52:22sort of say, you know. you know forgive my language
- 52:24but you know go screw yourself we're not interested
- 52:27you need to respond or else we're going to file
- 52:29a motion to compel and so whenever we did need
- 52:32court intervention we would just make sure that
- 52:34absolutely everything we did was through a formal
- 52:38letter and was written and we would just attach
- 52:40it to everything so we eventually built this
- 52:44record with the judge where they saw us as trying
- 52:47to maintain decorum and opposing counsel as.
- 52:52Trying to tear down decorum. So that's how I
- 52:57have been advised to handle it and I find that
- 52:59that's the best approach because typically you're
- 53:02not going to out Rambo. Those parties and so
- 53:07you know you just want to avoid being dragged
- 53:10down to their level especially if you're more
- 53:13junior i would not say get in a habit of going
- 53:16down to their level is again like i said you're
- 53:18building habits so if you're more junior and
- 53:21someone is being unreasonable do your best to
- 53:25identify. the ways that you can show the judge
- 53:28what's going on and that you're trying to maintain
- 53:30decorum. And hopefully the judge will be able
- 53:33to work it out in whatever way they can. In that
- 53:37case that I was a part of, they were sanctioned
- 53:40and they calmed down. So hopefully you get a
- 53:44result like that. Thank you. It looks like we
- 53:50do have another question here. Are there particular
- 53:53phrases in client emails, settlement, communications,
- 53:56briefs, or oral argument that you'd recommend
- 53:58attorneys avoid because they might create unnecessary
- 54:00ethical exposure? So for clients, anything that
- 54:06guarantees an outcome, I find that I, as well
- 54:11as my supervising partners, identify when we
- 54:15think we have strong arguments, but we do try
- 54:18and, you know, to be conservative, try and outline
- 54:21the risks and rewards. So if we think we have
- 54:25a good shot at, say, getting a motion granted,
- 54:27we let them know that case law seems to support
- 54:30our position on this issue. However, there is
- 54:33adverse case law, so the judge could go either
- 54:35way. With opposing counsel and with judges, I
- 54:41have found every time I've ever seen an attorney,
- 54:44and this is not even, when you go to court, you
- 54:47see other hearings, this is not even matters
- 54:48I've been a part of, every single time I've seen
- 54:51an attorney say, the judge must or the court
- 54:55must rule in this way, the court is required
- 54:59to rule in this way, they get pushback. every
- 55:02single time, a judge requires them on the record
- 55:06to state that it is actually not a requirement
- 55:08for the court to rule a certain way. I would
- 55:10avoid that, like the plague, it's always should,
- 55:14it's always should, should, should, or, you know,
- 55:16the record in law supports a finding. Please
- 55:19don't ever tell a judge that they have to rule
- 55:21a certain way. I've just never seen it work out
- 55:24well, so that's something that I always avoid.
- 55:26And just, you just... I think should and supports
- 55:30and then any other sort of more confident statement
- 55:34should just be shown in the in the strength of
- 55:38your argument, but I would just avoid. Having
- 55:41to say that your argument is good or is obviously
- 55:45superior etc and just state what proves it what
- 55:49supports it and then if the argument is strong,
- 55:51it should stand on its own. Alright, and it looks
- 55:58like we do have one more question here. Let's
- 56:03see. If a judge asks a question that exposes
- 56:08a genuinely damaging fact, what is the best way
- 56:10to quote unquote answer directly while still
- 56:13preserving the strongest framing of the case?
- 56:16So hopefully if a judge has asked you about a
- 56:19damaging fact, you see that it's coming and you
- 56:22know that it's coming and you've prepared for
- 56:24it. So. You know in accordance with going to
- 56:29a hearing you know emotion hearing to argue emotion
- 56:31or something like that you need to be fully prepared
- 56:34and you need to have outlined anything that could
- 56:37go wrong so hopefully you know before the judges
- 56:40brought it up you've been able to prepare for
- 56:42it i would say. That if it's a damaging fact
- 56:47as quickly and concisely as you can you can state
- 56:51the fact and then spend the rest of your time
- 56:54explaining. Why it doesn't apply or explaining
- 57:00reasons why it's not just positive and typically
- 57:03that's. That's the most common application is
- 57:07just saying yes, but it does it shouldn't determine
- 57:11your ruling here because and then you go into
- 57:14case law that supports you or facts that may
- 57:18attempt to undermine that bad fact but. Ultimately
- 57:23the goal is to have outlined that ahead of time
- 57:27and then just lean into your distinguishing that
- 57:32factor explaining it away or you know bringing
- 57:35up again positive case law that may support judges
- 57:39overlooking that fact just don't don't try and
- 57:45tap dance around it because again that that.
- 57:48to me draws more attention, both for the judge
- 57:50and for opposing counsel. Because if I'm opposing
- 57:52counsel and I see you tap dancing, I'm going
- 57:54to jump in and try and keep the conversation
- 57:57there as much as possible. It looks like that's
- 58:06it for questions. Chanel, do you have any other
- 58:08closing remarks that you'd like to make to our
- 58:10audience? No, thank you so, so much. I really
- 58:13appreciate everyone joining us and I hope you
- 58:16have a wonderful evening. All right, this concludes
- 58:20today's presentation. Thank you so much, Chanel,
- 58:22for an excellent presentation today. And thank
- 58:24you so much to our audience. Have a great day,
- 58:25everybody.