Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Duggar Family Deep Dive (Chapter 8)
Transcript
- 0:00Heyzer listeners, this is chapter eight in our deep dive on the Duggers.
- 0:04Let's get to it. My name is doctor Kirkanda. I'm a therapist and
- 0:07a professor. My name is I try Weird Sushi. So let's go to
- 0:11our timeline two thousand and nine. We already went over that that the family
- 0:15started to go on the Christian speaker circuit about the Quiverful movement at the very
- 0:21least, or just general Christian values, that sort of thing. And we
- 0:25were talking about last time, how a lot of the emphasis was on top
- 0:29of the message they wanted to send was on really enjoying the time you have
- 0:33with your children and really spending that quality time and enjoying all your children.
- 0:37And I was making a point where to let us down attendent of how hard
- 0:40it must be to make that point when you have to divide your attention among
- 0:44nineteen children, you know. So it's like, enjoy the time you have
- 0:48with your children is hampered when you have nineteen children. Yeah, enjoy the
- 0:52time with your children, and make sure you have constant pregnancies and more children
- 0:57so that you have even less time I am with all of your children.
- 1:00Yeah, Now you know Can you have a lot of kids in a family
- 1:03and have it go well for the children, Have the children be raised to
- 1:07be happy and healthy. Yes, but it can be a factor in leading
- 1:12to lack of attunement for children. But it can be mitigated by making sure
- 1:17there's grandparents and cousins and older siblings as long as it's appropriate. You're not
- 1:21prettifying anyway. So twenty ten they are getting more popular. Twenty eleven they
- 1:26publish a second book that is very popular. Now we want to raise the
- 1:30question again, was Josh continuing to abuse children during this time. We don't
- 1:36know. There's no evidence of that, but it is a question. At
- 1:41some point around here, Josh is married to and he's starting to have kids.
- 1:46He's absolutely following in the parents footsteps with IBLP, you know, their
- 1:51cult, and also with the Quiverful movement. That aspect of the cult of
- 1:55making sure you're having lots of kids and arguably keeping women down. And it's
- 2:00explicit in the hierarchical structure of this cult that men are in charge of everything.
- 2:05And so Josh is around twenty one at this point and he's starting to
- 2:09rise within politics as is dictated by this religious cult. That you're supposed to
- 2:15the quiver full movement is to have lots of arrows in your quiver so that
- 2:19you can use your children as ammunition against the oncoming tide of the evil secular
- 2:27world. Essentially, And so Josh is a conservative right wing wouldn't it be
- 2:31weird if he was a progressive liberal or something. Actually I could kind of
- 2:37see an angle of well, no, but then you because you wouldn't want
- 2:39that many people in the world. But you could see like, well,
- 2:42wait there, now they're overpopulating over us. Now we gotta put more kids
- 2:46so we can vote liberal. You know, I could see it from that
- 2:49angle, not necessarily the religious angle, but yeah, yeah, So he
- 2:53is a conservative right wing politician, just like his parents were, particularly as
- 2:59dad, which means that he's explicitly and there are lots of clips of him
- 3:02being explicitly against gay people, against trans people, against abortion, you know,
- 3:08you know, the conservative right wing rhetoric, and it's awful. I
- 3:13don't understand. So I always just think, have you read a history book,
- 3:19because when you know, I would imagine that even conservative right wing politicians
- 3:24and right wing people, when they look back at certain bigotry moments, in
- 3:31history like Jim crowlaws this kind of thing, or the Civil War, I
- 3:36would hope, or slavery in general. Let's just say that I would hope
- 3:39that they would see the good guys as the ones that were fighting against those
- 3:46oppressive systems. Right. I mean it depends how far how far to that
- 3:50section you are, because even the average trying to justify it and saying there
- 3:53were good things to learn in the Holocaust, right, the average conservative right
- 3:58wing I would imagine that, and they look at things or when they hear
- 4:01about the Third Reich killing Jewish people, killing gay people, that I would
- 4:10like to think that they would imagine that they would say, well, yeah,
- 4:13I mean no, that's not okay, right, And yet they have
- 4:16the rhetoric that is completely aligne with the rhetoric of those times. You know,
- 4:23you could say it's not as bad because they're not marching them in the
- 4:25gas chambers. But it's the same lines, you know, the same justifications,
- 4:30the same statements and bullet points that they use. And you just think
- 4:33that they would learn from history and see like, hmm, maybe in twenty
- 4:38years even people from my side of the aisle will look back at me and
- 4:42think that I was in the wrong because I'm just against a whole class of
- 4:46individuals and I don't want them to have rights. Like maybe there's a red
- 4:50flag there, you know, you just think, but it doesn't seem to
- 4:54me like humans us, all of us are very good at caring about twenty
- 4:58years from now. Yeah, as evidenced by climate chance. Anyway, I'm
- 5:01sure that's a whole other aspect of Josh's politics as well being anti acknowledgment of
- 5:09the consensus of science. So he is, Josh Dugger is rising in politics.
- 5:14He's doing the lobbying. There's that organization for the Cult of IBLP that
- 5:18is organizing in Washington, DC, stending a lot of talented lobbyists and well
- 5:25funded individuals to enter politics or influence politics. They could have influenced all sorts
- 5:30of things. By the way, when I watched the documentary, because again
- 5:33I've been throughout my life, especially when I was younger, I've been exposed
- 5:38to evangelical big church congregations, folks that ask for money every you know chance,
- 5:45they get all these things. But when I saw the documentary, I
- 5:47didn't realize the scale of what their plan was for this group. Yeah,
- 5:53of infiltrating throughout the world in government and politics and everything. Yeah, I
- 5:58mean it's uh now is I mean I said, was is It's it's normal
- 6:02for you know, political groups on in all areas to organize and lobby.
- 6:09For example, there are lobbyists lobbying for things that we would agree with in
- 6:14Washington, DC. So it's not like they're the only ones doing it.
- 6:17But yeah, it really looked like this, what do you call this assembly
- 6:24line of like have kids check, have as many as possible, check,
- 6:28and doctrinate them with this system. Make sure they're homeschooled so they have no
- 6:31outside influence. Check. Make sure they're absolute cult brainwash check. Then basically,
- 6:38you know, compel them to dedicate their life to changing politics and policy
- 6:43and give them systems and money to do so. Yeah. Because so you
- 6:46were asking, like, which what you know? This is why it's it
- 6:49would be so hard or it is so hard to counteract this because a lot
- 6:55of folks on the progressive side or left side, they don't have such systems
- 7:00and organization and no, no, we do. There are progressive organizations that
- 7:04indoctrinate children and train them with money and like almost like step by step,
- 7:10how to get to Congress and lave em know, right right, not that
- 7:12level, No, and that we're having tons of kids to flood the gates.
- 7:15Quite quite the opposite, actually exactly. Progressive educated people tend to have
- 7:20fewer children. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And to the and to the
- 7:26point where a lot of it is about free thinking. So even you know,
- 7:30on the left, you end up having so many nuanced difference positions like
- 7:32well I do think plastic bottles should be okay. Well I don't think plastic
- 7:36bottles should be okay. Whereas on on that side, like in that movement,
- 7:40it's the homogeneity. Homogeneity of thinking is an important value. We gotta
- 7:46believe the same thing. Yeah, and it's very powerful when you do that,
- 7:49even though it's because there's no wiggle room, right I think, because
- 7:55if they allow a wiggle room, then it falls apart because there's not a
- 7:59lot, a lot to it. It's all based on this kind of narrow
- 8:03interpretation of the Bible, which not every Christian shares. This is why when
- 8:07you watch the debate the other night, which I watched part of the Republican
- 8:11like, the positions are almost all the same, so they have to tweet
- 8:15just how how outrageous the extreme position is. It's like, well, fine,
- 8:18I'll go a little over what you just said. Yeah I heard,
- 8:22I don't know. You tell me that they were asked to publicly declare whether
- 8:28or not they agreed that with the consensus of of climate scientists and other scientists
- 8:33that climate change is at least in part caused by humans, and they all
- 8:39declared that they did not believe that. To be well, not only did
- 8:43the no one declare that they believed it, it got derailed by one of
- 8:46them, uh, the scientists, because he was like, well, don't
- 8:50trade as like children. Let's have the debate. Of course, they proceed
- 8:52to have no debate. Yeah, and and the thing is is and well,
- 8:56very briefly, we got to get back to the timeline. But they
- 9:00created a monster because I'm quite sure that most of all of those politicians totally
- 9:05understand the science, because they are educated, these individuals, and they probably
- 9:09have all the information. But because they've brainwashed the voting populace, otherwise,
- 9:16they can't they can't recant it because they will not be voted into office.
- 9:24They have to appease the monster that they've created, because for decades they've been
- 9:28pumping the public with brainwashed material because there was so much money from the energy
- 9:37companies and other sorts of people that benefit from the ignorance of climate change.
- 9:43They were funding all of these politicians and continue to by the way, and
- 9:46so they created this monster that they can't back down from and it and meanwhile,
- 9:52we're just going off of the edge of the cliff. So good for
- 9:56you anyway. So getting back to the timeline twenty twelve, they are even
- 10:03more famous twenty thirteen, even more famous. The reason why I'm going to
- 10:07popularity, yeah, and all of them, even outside of the show,
- 10:11and the reason why I'm pointing us out is because we know what we know
- 10:16now about Josh Dugger and the victims in the family, and very few people
- 10:22knew about it or paid attention to it. It was made public kind of
- 10:26when the police investigated after the Oprah Show was notified by someone in the church
- 10:33that Josh Dugger had abused the younger kids. But it was basically just online
- 10:37forums that were trying to raise awareness about it. There wasn't a huge you
- 10:41know. It's sort of like with the Me Too movement. A lot of
- 10:45the reckoning that happened to some of these folks, the victims had been coming
- 10:52forward for decades in some cases like Harvey Weinstein, these sort of folks,
- 10:56and it just hadn't reached the critical mass to make it newsworthy enough to push
- 11:01it over into a zone where people started to where you know, the average
- 11:05American or average consumer was actually looking at it. And then they had like,
- 11:09why did you wait so long to bring it up? Right? We
- 11:11didn't. Yeah, it's it's been out there for the whole time, but
- 11:16people swept in under the rugs. So twenty fourteen, they write a book,
- 11:20another book, Growing Up Dugger. But it's officially written by four of
- 11:26the daughters, Janet, Jill, Jess and Ginger, and it's called Growing
- 11:30Up Dugger. And the book I read excerpts and summaries, it's you could
- 11:35argue, especially given the context of the homeschooling and the cult nature of this,
- 11:39of this context, that the book is just propaganda for the cult.
- 11:43Sure, it's super positive about their church and the family, and you know,
- 11:48okay, maybe a lot of their experiences were positive, but it's really
- 11:52positive about their weird rules and systems. There's some complaining by the kids in
- 11:58the books, but it is. You know, it's framed in a way
- 12:01of just like, well, you can't have it all, or it's not.
- 12:05There's not something fundamentally rotten at the core. It's just I don't like
- 12:09responsibility sometimes, you know that that kind of stuff. And and by the
- 12:13way, the kids, from what I can tell, aside from the one
- 12:18that was interviewed in the documentary, they've all retained this point of view even
- 12:24beyond the scandals that we're going to get into, including the one that's in
- 12:28the documentary. Like in the documentary, I think it's is it Jill I
- 12:33believe, which we'll get into it. Say, they haven't abandoned the church
- 12:37right right, they're still totally conservative, right wing members. They just are
- 12:43distant seeing themselves from the Dugger franchise, so to speak. But anyway,
- 12:48so twenty fourteen, Josie Dugger has the seizure on camera, and we talked
- 12:54about that in a previous episode. Also in twenty fourteen, Bill Gothard is
- 12:58fired. So the organization had been receiving reports of him and his brothers sexually
- 13:03harassing women and girls, at least thirty four women. We'll get into this
- 13:05more later when we get into the specifics of the religion, but just to
- 13:09put it in perspective. So twenty fifteen, okay, so this is when,
- 13:15by the way, I'm sure that that was huge news, right it
- 13:18was reported. No, No, not at all. It was just completely
- 13:24swept on the right. At least they talked about it on the show.
- 13:26The head of our church. Yeah, the person that we worship that we
- 13:31consider to be our profit on this planet. And full disclosure. Something along
- 13:35these lines happen in our own family, which I wonder if there's some sort
- 13:39of systemic rot. Even if they had TLC, the producers would have edited
- 13:43it out because they were making money and that's all that matters. So in
- 13:48twenty fifteen, this is when the scandals really hit the fan. So this
- 13:52is when the police reports are published by in Touch magazine. So in Touch
- 13:56magazine published that two thousand six police reports. So remember that the family went
- 14:01to that one police officer who just slapped Josh on the wrist or there was
- 14:07no report from that, Yeah, there was no at least reported report.
- 14:11But the police officer later would be convicted and jailed twice for child pornography.
- 14:16But then when the operate team had heard about the allegations. They contacted people
- 14:24that had contented the police, and the police actually investigated two thousand and six.
- 14:28Because of statue limitations, nothing happened, we don't know the specifics.
- 14:31Was CPS involved, were they not? Seemingly nothing happened to Josh at all
- 14:37after the investigation for the police, but there were interviews and there were reports
- 14:41made by victims and maybe by Josh himself, and In Touch magazine gets their
- 14:46hands on these and publishes them in two thousand and six or twenty fifteen,
- 14:52So this is, you know, nine years later and after eight years of
- 14:56the show being on, you know, hugely famous. And I'm just trying
- 15:01to imagine what In Touch Magazine was thinking, Like why then, because this
- 15:05is before me too, right, because it would seem like it would sort
- 15:09of keeping coincide, but huge news, because first of all, but why
- 15:11not earlier? Why not like twenty ten, you know, like why twenty
- 15:16fifteen? Exact? Oh wait a minute, are you saying that they had
- 15:18the data years before the data was out there? It's not like I mean,
- 15:22I don't know the circumstances, but I don't know how you get your
- 15:24hands on place report times it's like an enterprising reporters like, wait, what
- 15:30right, that's what I'm guessing. It's just like someone was like, well
- 15:33I don't have anything else to do, or or maybe they had a bone
- 15:37to pick themselves or something. But at any rate, it comes out finally
- 15:41in twenty fifteen, and it could have been swept under the rug By society,
- 15:45but for whatever reason, people actually started paying attention to it. Well,
- 15:48it's kids, it's not just like women making allegations, which was the
- 15:52harder part of the initial me too. This was like, it's the kids
- 15:56being abused, right, yeah, yeah, interesting. I mean there's still
- 15:58vic shaming, but maybe not at the level that women experience when they come
- 16:04forward being harassed at work, that kind of stuff. And these circuses work
- 16:08two ways. They were kind of the circus freak show, initially presented as
- 16:12such by and when people feel like there's drama in those kinds of circuses,
- 16:18they want that drama too. So there's that aspect as well. Right,
- 16:22So there's a media circus at how popular and awesome they are, and then
- 16:26as soon as they turn a corner, there's a huge media circus about how
- 16:30awful they are. Right, that's the consequence of fame. So there's a
- 16:33huge media circus. The public finally turns the corner on them, and to
- 16:38those people on the forums that have been talking about these yes, finally we're
- 16:44actually, after years and years, I mean just years and years after the
- 16:48fact, they're finally getting vindication. And the parents began a public relations campaign.
- 16:56Now you could argue TLC could have been behind it as well, because
- 17:00they stood to lose a lot by having this. They're one of their flagship
- 17:03shows be attacked in this way, and maybe even you can imagine t SEE
- 17:08thinking we could capitalize on this. I mean, if we could get the
- 17:11family to be likable at least enough, then we could think about the ratings
- 17:17that people will tune in to watch this show. So who knows what the
- 17:19motivation was, but at least the parents went on a public relations campaign and
- 17:26Josh issued an exclusive statement to People magazine. He was twenty seven years old
- 17:30at the time of this report, and he says, quote, twelve years
- 17:34ago, as a young teenager, I acted inexcusably. Like twelve years ago,
- 17:41Yeah, it was when he was fourteen ish, So that is when
- 17:48he stepped forward to his parents and told them that he had been abusing the
- 17:52younger siblings, and according to the story anyway, he didn't do anything after
- 17:57that point. He had told the family friends that he had been abusing the
- 18:03girls for years, from the ages of two to five. So he says
- 18:08in people, twelve years ago, as a young teenager, I acted inexcusably,
- 18:12for which I am extremely sorry and deeply regret. I hurt others,
- 18:18including my family and close friends. So just chiming in here, it's possible
- 18:22that he's just saying this and lying. I'm assuming a lot of people would
- 18:26assume that, But it's also possible he's telling the truth. You know,
- 18:29there are people out there. In fact, the majority of people who abuse
- 18:33children in this way do have empathy at their in their heart, do have
- 18:37compassion. There are those who don't, but there are most of them have
- 18:41at least the capacity. They often will if they are left untreated, develop
- 18:47a pretty robust justification for abusing the children because they're having cognitive dissonance around their
- 18:52impulses and their efforts to preserve self esteem and the idea that they're a good
- 19:00person. So when you have that cognitive distance, something's got to give.
- 19:03Oh, the child was too young to remember, or they were old enough
- 19:07to know what was going on, or whatever they liked it, they wanted
- 19:11it, or that sort of thing. So yeah, there are justifications.
- 19:14And for psychopaths people who don't have empathy, they will say those things as
- 19:18well. But even for those who do have the capacity for empathy, left
- 19:22to their own devices, we will go into denial about all sorts of things.
- 19:26You know, it doesn't take a psychopath to go into denial about things,
- 19:30So it's hard to know what. We just don't know what's going on
- 19:34with Josh. There's evidence either way, and mostly there's a lack of evidence
- 19:40because I've treated people in this situation, not only perpetrators but and certainly a
- 19:45lot of victims, but also families, And I can tell you that when
- 19:48I have a lot of data and I actually have access to the Josh's of
- 19:52the world, it's still unclear because you can't really know what's in someone's heart.
- 19:56So it's start to know. It's also possible like if how were the
- 20:00church elders. Again, I'm not condoning this is what you should do or
- 20:03whatever, that you should only go to your church elders. But if I
- 20:04were the church elders, I would have probably had a ridiculously serious conversation with
- 20:10Josh about what he was putting at risk. He was not only putting at
- 20:14risk his family's honor the show, but bigger than that, he was putting
- 20:18at risk the whole religion and the whole movement, right because he was an
- 20:22icon a figureheads So you maybe, but I bet you the conversations from the
- 20:27elders was about God and Jesus and was saying, you know, you are
- 20:32condemned by God and Jesus if you continue to do this thing, and you
- 20:36will go to hell. You know, there was I'm probably probably undoubtedly conversations
- 20:40only yes, granted, in fact, I would guess ninety I mean,
- 20:44just my guess is ninety percent of the conversation was along those lines, because
- 20:48that's usually the way it's framed. You know. Yeah, maybe I'm more
- 20:51cynical because I feel like that would have been like, like, to start
- 20:55with, you realize if you keep doing this, you're gonna go to hell.
- 20:57But now the more important matter, do you realize what you're putting at
- 21:00risk? Here? Well, the motivation behind the elders could have been what
- 21:03you're talking about but the message could have been because it's probably a lot more
- 21:08motivating to a cult member that you're going to hell when you literally believe in
- 21:12eternal damnation and torture than it is to talk about economics or an organizational longevity,
- 21:21you know what I mean. I wonder like having been in these organizations,
- 21:23not those guns, but similar ones, like not anyways part of the
- 21:29Catholic Church, a school that was a Catholic school. Oftentimes when I was
- 21:33being disciplined, or I don't remember being disciplined, hearing about the risk I
- 21:38was having my soul. Are you saying that when you're in Catholic school in
- 21:42Colombia and you're being disciplined, they're saying, don't make Catholics look bad?
- 21:48Do you think that? No? No, I'm just saying it was a
- 21:48way, way more mundane. It was like you're gonna get in trouble,
- 21:52We're gonna send a letter, you're dead. Never I was like, think
- 21:53about your soul, think about how Jesus would be Well, I don't remember
- 21:57any of that. Imagine given what I know about these sort of evangelical Christians
- 22:03and more specifically IBLP Christians, that it is very much this black and white
- 22:10situation of are you gonna spend your life in aternal damnation or in the glory
- 22:15of God? You know, I'm not denying. Of course, that was
- 22:18definitely part of the conversation, and you're right, the motivation might have been
- 22:22what triggered it. I also think they could have literally been like because remember
- 22:26I was saying how in the YouTube and watch teen year old you know what
- 22:29I mean, Like, because they're chastising Josh, he's fourteen, that's when
- 22:33they're really going after. It could have been throughout or something. It just
- 22:37seems like above his head at what he's fourteen, you know what I mean.
- 22:41But maybe they did because the YouTubers I was watching there were two dudes
- 22:44that were part of that church. They were talking about how they would have
- 22:47been kicked out of the movement of the church, kicked out from their perspective
- 22:52from talking in a room by themselves with a woman. Yeah right, But
- 22:56that none of that conversation was about the risk to their soul. It was
- 23:00kicked out of the church. But that is a risk to their soul because
- 23:06and that was talked about by the members in the documentary and other podcasts that
- 23:10I listened to that. It was explicitly told, and there's a lot of
- 23:15implicit messaging that if you are excommunicated from this cult you are going to hell.
- 23:19There's there's in fact, you're definitely going to hell because you had a
- 23:25chance. You know, if there's a member outside of the cult that's never
- 23:27had a chance, then maybe God will have some mercy. But you had
- 23:33a chance and you squandered it, You're definitely going to hell. You know.
- 23:36That's how cults operate. They're much worse to X members than to non
- 23:40members, you know what I mean. If the threat of hell worked that
- 23:42effectively, always think of how many problems we wouldn't have had. Well,
- 23:48yeah, the other implication is no one will talk to you. All of
- 23:52your friends will exactly, You'll have to have no suppose what I'm getting at.
- 23:56I think that there were probably both angles, because the threat of I
- 24:00was always there. When you're growing up in these religions, you're always aware
- 24:03that, Oh my gosh, I think I mentioned that. For a lot
- 24:07of my youth, I kept thinking in my head, my dad's going to
- 24:11hell. How can I prevent this? Because he is an atheist? Right?
- 24:14So yeah, yeah, so going on. He says, I confessed
- 24:18this to my parents, who took several steps to help me address the situation.
- 24:22We spoke with the authorities where I confessed my wrongdoings, and my parents
- 24:26arranged for me and those affected by my actions to receive counseling. Now,
- 24:32from reports, the quote unquote counseling was by the church, by headquarters,
- 24:37by the administration of IBLP, their cult. So I'm just going to take
- 24:42a guess and say it wasn't specialized competent perpetrator treatment. Did the victims receive
- 24:48counseling? I mean, he says so, and I don't doubt that.
- 24:52I don't doubt that the kids did talk to elders or something, and maybe
- 24:57it did help. We don't know. But I'm taking a guess and say
- 25:00that it wasn't sufficient given some of the other accounts about how the temptation is
- 25:06the woman's fault. Yeah, right, right, And those conversations might have
- 25:10been like, so what did you do? What were you wearing? Yeah,
- 25:12at the age of did you have yeah, exactly going on? I
- 25:18sought forgiveness from those I had wronged and asked Christ to forgive me and come
- 25:22into my life. I would do anything to go back to those teen years
- 25:26and take different actions and of quote. So, you know, it's quite
- 25:30possible that he's telling the truth here. There's there's nothing deceptive about what he's
- 25:33saying. He might even literally believe, and maybe it's even partially true that
- 25:38the quote unquote counseling that he received did help him to stop this behavior.
- 25:44It's also possible that he originally reached out and confessed to his parents and to
- 25:48the police and to the family friends and to the church because he actually didn't
- 25:52want to do this anymore because he was concerned about it. Doesn't let him
- 25:56off the hook for doing the behaviors for several years. But we also don't
- 26:02know where this behavior comes from. Was he victimized himself, was he modeled
- 26:06something. At the very least, we speculated that due to the insular cult
- 26:11environment and the over emphasis on sexuality and repressing it can screw up a young
- 26:17child's mind. You know, these cults, as we've talked about earlier,
- 26:21they purport to be very pure and very they want to relegate sex to procreation
- 26:26and marriage, but as a result, they have to constantly talk about sex
- 26:32to constantly suppress from various angles, you know, including misogynistic angles to blame
- 26:38girls and make sure that they're being pure and dressing a certain way and not
- 26:42tempting the male sexuality, you know. But in addition to that, just
- 26:48all sorts of talk about how sex needs to be postponed, how you're not
- 26:52supposed to masturbate, how you're not supposed to fantasize. The pornography is wrong,
- 26:56and the rest of society is wrong, and MTV is wrong, and
- 27:00Kim Kardashian is wrong. Everyone's going to hell and music is wrong. You
- 27:03know that that lyric is sexually innuendo ish, and so that's of the devil.
- 27:07It's just this constant because that's the most important thing. It's just constant
- 27:11about it. Yeah, because it's you have to put in so much effort
- 27:15to prevent seventeen year olds from masturbating or having sex or at the very least
- 27:21making out with someone, Like it's a biological urge that most people have,
- 27:26and if you're trying to suppress that, you've got to have all hands on
- 27:30deck. And I think as a result, you end up basically in a
- 27:33way, sexually abusing the children by one at the very least shaming them for
- 27:41having a normal human impulse, and two just by constantly talking about sexuality in
- 27:47this very distorted, odd way. So could someone who's raised in that environment
- 27:53have an emerging sexuality at the age of twelve, thirteen, fourteen and be
- 28:00very confused and conflicted about what they're experiencing and suppressing and hating themselves, having
- 28:07nowhere to turn, and they're homeschooled, they don't have a contact with peers.
- 28:12You're you're not even allowed to talk to girls your own age, And
- 28:15might you end up expressing urges towards your siblings and maybe targeting even younger siblings
- 28:22because they're less likely to fight back or something. You know, was he
- 28:27potentially not going to develop pedophilia and attraction sexual attraction of miners if he was
- 28:33raised in a regular American family? Hard to know. Was he victimized himself?
- 28:38Hard to know? But you know, it's just I don't know.
- 28:42There's there's also a billion other factors that I don't know about that could be
- 28:47present. But it just is a topic that I think should be discussed as
- 28:52a human experiment. You put an envelope in a room and you're like,
- 28:56do not open this envelope. I'll be gone for a few hours. Do
- 28:57not open this envelope. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And so let's take
- 29:03a break and when we get back, let's continue. What do you say,
- 29:04bro, Let's do it all right, we're back from the break.
- 29:11So going back to my notes here, the duggers, the parents, and
- 29:15the siblings. So Josh gave this public statement to people, and I'm guessing
- 29:19that given the savvy of the parents, they talked about exactly what to do
- 29:26in the situation and how to approach it. Now they I think completely missed
- 29:32the mark. You could argue that Josh's statement actually is pretty good. You
- 29:37know, who knows how sincerit is. But as someone who now is specializing
- 29:41in apology videos and apology statements by various people, I've seen a lot worse
- 29:49than what Josh is saying here. So you know, there's that. But
- 29:55the parents really screwed things up. So they an exclusive set of interviews with
- 30:00Megan Kelly on Fox News. The parents did, and then there was another
- 30:04one with Jill and Jessa, who were two of the victims. I think
- 30:08that they might have been two of the oldest victims of Josh's abuse when they
- 30:12were younger. And it's interesting also just how popular Megan Kelly was at the
- 30:17time, because I feel like she isn't the phenomenon that she was at the
- 30:22time. But anyway, well Trump attacked her, she got relegated. So
- 30:25yeah, So she was interviewing the parents, and I have some excerpson from
- 30:32the parents, and it this is kind of the first view into the mindset
- 30:37of the parents because we just don't have any data around how were they reacting,
- 30:41how did they see the situation, because there was a chance that they
- 30:45absolutely were responsible parents. And the other thing is is by twenty fifteen,
- 30:49by the time this interview happens, they've had yeah, I think it was
- 30:53two thousand and two, so I think they've had thirteen years to think and
- 30:59learn about out how to approach this as parents. You know, it's it's
- 31:03complicated, but the way they talk, it's like they hadn't advanced their thinking
- 31:08at all, And you just got to think, like, well, where
- 31:11were they coming from originally, because you would think they would have advanced a
- 31:15little bit. And they're putting on their best face for this interview because it's
- 31:18going to go out to the entire world. This is their apault there.
- 31:22Yeah, there, their tour to make things better. My main takeaway from
- 31:26watching that, those those interviews, that stuff, was how little they seemed
- 31:30to regard the victims compared to Josh. So much about it was about re
- 31:37imagining Josh in a better light and like the family as a result. Uh,
- 31:41and the victims were like a second topic. Right, Well, when
- 31:45you have a massively sexist society and you have an even more massively sexist cult
- 31:51than and you just firstborn male child, yeah, you just see the world
- 31:56differently. And like we said in a previous episode, they did have time
- 32:00with that first child because they didn't have nineteen other children and they were the
- 32:02direct parents. That is their baby, right, it's their baby male air
- 32:07to the everything, Yeah, everything. I'm sure they had all sorts of
- 32:13mascinations of that Josh and Anna would have their own show, and they would
- 32:17have their own quiverful of kids that would have their shows, and they would
- 32:22be lobbyists and match sea. So they disclosed that in this interview that the
- 32:29rumors about Josh were true and that he had touched the younger girls when he
- 32:34was fifteen, all the way back in two thousand and three. So it's
- 32:37a very long, disturbing video to watch if you want to get angry not
- 32:44only at Jim Bob and Michelle Dugger, but at our society in some ways,
- 32:49at all the other parents that will make excuses for not only predators sexual
- 32:57predators, but criminals in general. This interview will get you going. It
- 33:01is very disturbing listening to the parents. So the things that they said,
- 33:07and I'm summarizing and paraphrasing what they're saying, but they basically say that Josh's
- 33:12behavior was no big deal. That was their thesis. They were saying that
- 33:16the girls were too young to understand what happened, to remember, too young
- 33:22to understand digital penetration, and yeah, they're too young to get it.
- 33:30They also elaborated that the camp fixed him. This is the quote unquote counseling
- 33:35or treatment that he went through, and from what we understand, the camp
- 33:38was basically a labor camp. Now, maybe there was some discussions and maybe
- 33:44it did fix him, maybe it was a wake up call to him,
- 33:46who knows, But they were saying he's all better now, But we know
- 33:52later that he was not all better because he is presumably at this very moment
- 33:57in time in twenty fifteen, still down loading and consuming child pornography, participating
- 34:01in the trafficking of child pornography. By the way, this is where this
- 34:06is where I really, you know, depart the shores of empathy because for
- 34:12these parents, because I try to put myself in this situation in one of
- 34:15the early episodes where you asked me, like, what would you do,
- 34:17and I said, I don't know. I guess I'll try to talk to
- 34:20a therapist or something, even I don't really know what to do until you
- 34:22said, well, you can contact CPS and stuff. And I can empathize
- 34:27that a family wouldn't immediately go and try to get their kids thrown in jail
- 34:30and stuff. I get it. But I can imagine as a parent that
- 34:34if I were doing such an interview, even if I actually did an interview
- 34:37like that, because I probably would, what would actually do is pull our
- 34:39family out of the limelight and go and try to deal with these problems privately.
- 34:44Right, But let's say I was doing such an interview, I think
- 34:46ninety five percent of my interview content would be about all the steps we've tried
- 34:52to take to try to heal our little victim children and how horrible, and
- 34:58and also five percent about the steps that we have also taken to try to
- 35:02heal our other abuse or slash victim child. But man, yeah, yeah,
- 35:09I often have that thought with public figures. Presumably they have teams of
- 35:15pr people that are paid a lot of money to advise them, and so
- 35:21often I find that these apology tours, if you will, or apology statements
- 35:27are so bad and it's just evidence to me, it's one of two things.
- 35:34Either they actually really do know what they're doing, but given my nature,
- 35:39their statements don't resonate with me, but they do resonate with the general
- 35:44public, because I can't really think of myself as being representative of the general
- 35:47public when it comes to apologizing, because you know, some people will literally
- 35:52say, well, if they apologize, then they are guilty, and they
- 35:57didn't apologize, so that must mean they're not guilty. You know, though
- 35:59people have some pretty simplistic ideas because you know, they don't study this sort
- 36:02of stuff like I do. So it's either that, which I'd give that
- 36:06a fifty percent possibility. The other possibility if if they aren't actually winning the
- 36:13crowd over and I don't think the parents won the crowd over at all.
- 36:15I don't. I don't even think they won Megan Kelly over. You know,
- 36:17do you think they resonated with their core audience at least? Yes?
- 36:22So, but they're what do we call their core audience because they prior to
- 36:29this had a very large you could argue core audience, but maybe not like
- 36:32brainwashed audience. There's the TV show audience, which is massive. Right.
- 36:37I guess I was thinking their their community, in their in their church and
- 36:40stuff. I would guess that even their church and community was split because when
- 36:45it came out that this letter that Kayley had written and it started to spread
- 36:52this very knowledge, right, there were some in the church that were saying
- 36:58that Kayley's a gossip and there are people saying, like, what is going
- 37:01on with Josh, which is a good indication that maybe this kind of behavior
- 37:06isn't systemically pervasive in all the families in that community, right, Yeah,
- 37:09but there are institutionalized aspects that make it more possible and right, so it
- 37:15just makes it more possible, but there's still a part of our society.
- 37:19They're not that different. But anyway, so if it isn't that they actually
- 37:23are a genius and I just don't see it. Then I think what it
- 37:29represents is just the general lack of understanding and lack of wisdom regarding apologies in
- 37:35general in our society that I run into all the time. You know,
- 37:37the average person. You know, I've studied apologies. I professionally help people
- 37:43with apologies for the past twenty five plus years in my office. I learned
- 37:46early on in my career as a couples therapist that I had this intuition often,
- 37:52maybe even every session with every couple, that I would especially in the
- 37:55beginning phases of therapy, which can last like a few years, that I
- 37:59would say, you know, because I would hear each person in the marriage
- 38:04talking about the other person complaining about them. Oh, and then he did
- 38:07this and I couldn't believe it, and you know, they'd be fighting,
- 38:10and the surface talk would be around that you're wrong, you know, you
- 38:16did this to me, and you shouldn't have done that, you dropped the
- 38:20ball, you didn't care about my feelings. That kind of stuff, which
- 38:22is good, but it's not representative of what I was intuiting, which was
- 38:27that the individual wanted an apology because the way that it seems it seems like
- 38:31when you're being chastised or criticized by your partner, it feels like you're just
- 38:36being chastised. It feels like, you know, And you'll often hear people
- 38:38in couples they'll say like, well, what do you want me to do?
- 38:40Like get down on my knees and beg for forgiveness or something, because
- 38:45it has that tone because people are afraid of showing their vulnerable side or making
- 38:50any sort of request because they're hurt and they're scared, and so it's just
- 38:53a lot of anger and a lot of criticism and a lot of that kind
- 38:57of thing. And so because I'm actually trying to help these people, I
- 39:00try to into it or discover what the person is really trying to say but
- 39:06too afraid to. And I would into it often that I would say,
- 39:09well, it sounds like you want an apology from your partner? Is that
- 39:15true? And it would really shift things from the criticism and the anger to
- 39:20this possibility, and then it's a roadmap forward for the transgressor to actually repair
- 39:25things, because prior to that, there's no road forward. The transgressor is
- 39:30just being chastised and yelled at. Now, there's a there's a road because
- 39:34both people want to repair. But without that that roadmap, then it just
- 39:38escalates from there and then they end up getting divorced kind of thing. It's
- 39:42it's really interesting that we as humans are actually really good. I think about
- 39:45picking up subtle little things. For example, if someone is apologizing to you
- 39:51in a bad way, we into it, even though we might not recognize
- 39:53it that it's not a real apology. So if someone's like, well,
- 39:58I'm sorry right already, or I'm sorry you feel that sorry, feel that
- 40:01we already caught it. But then our reaction, it's unfortunately that our reaction
- 40:06isn't nuanced and informed enough to be like, well, actually, here's how
- 40:08that makes me feel. Instead, it's like more chastising or more whatever.
- 40:12I've certainly been both recipient and disher of those kinds of things. Yeah,
- 40:15me too. It's apparently human nature, which is really unfortunate. There's so
- 40:20many things that can be solved, not only marriages, but between nations,
- 40:23between political divides, at work, between children and parents. So many things
- 40:30can be repaired so quickly if people were aware and more practiced at truly apologizing
- 40:37and a part of truly apologizing is not just the words, but getting in
- 40:40touch with yourself and actually knowing what you feel. That you got to identify
- 40:47with the remorse, And how do you identify with remorse? Well, you
- 40:51have to have compassion. How do you have compassion? You have to understand
- 40:54how to investigate how other people feel. You know, you might commit a
- 40:59transgression and be confused as to why your partners upset at you. There's a
- 41:02pathway to figuring that out. And the other thing is, even if I
- 41:07know all these things and I actually enacted these things and try to investigate,
- 41:10the other person has to have awareness enough to know how to play into that.
- 41:15You know. A prime example is me and my friends were annoying people
- 41:19that were near us in public, and I didn't know that we were annoying
- 41:23them. I didn't even know that they were there. And then when after
- 41:29an hour or something, they alerted us to it, they said, like,
- 41:32you're being annoying in this way, And I immediately realized that it would
- 41:37be very annoying if they were sitting right next to us, and I didn't
- 41:42think about it, and I immediately felt remorse, and so I immediately said,
- 41:46oh my god, I'm so sorry that you had to deal with.
- 41:50I mean, it wasn't the end of the world, it wasn't life altering,
- 41:52how annoyed, but you know, you could imagine it would just be
- 41:54a little irritating to have to sit there. And I immediately apologized, said,
- 41:59oh my god, I'm so sorry, and then they laid into me
- 42:01more and they thought I was being sarcastic, and I said, no,
- 42:05no, no, no, I'm not being I'm truly telling you that I
- 42:07get it, like I can't imagine how And it's so weird for them to
- 42:12hear that. They're like, Okay, this guy's trying to be a dick,
- 42:15right, So I can do everything right, but the other person can
- 42:20do everything wrong and it still won't work. There's so many things that need
- 42:22to happen or and people are just miserable at this. So I think that's
- 42:27why so many of these public statements are so bad. I mean, Will
- 42:30Smith had how many months to prepare and you know that he had a team
- 42:37He probably spent no joke, like two millions. This was his career on
- 42:40the line. He could have spent two to ten million dollars on a team
- 42:45to figure out what to do. His public apology was terrible. I mean
- 42:50it was in the direction, but if I had told him. But that's
- 42:52the other thing. It's like, well, there's another fifty percent that says,
- 42:54if you do what I do, maybe it's two over the top,
- 42:58and people disregard that. In some ways, I don't feel like and I
- 43:00don't know if maybe Chris Rock wouldn't have played along with it, But to
- 43:04me, the thing would have been to have Chris Rock in front of you
- 43:07and say to him, how terribly deeply sorry, and that the whole thing
- 43:13needs to end with hugging it out and apologizing to him first and then apologizing
- 43:17to the bad examples or something like that. But anyways, I hear you.
- 43:22Apologies are hard for people. Well, they're hard to receive their heart
- 43:24to give that in a nutshell, and I did a whole reaction video to
- 43:29it, But in a nutshell, what I would have said if I was
- 43:31Will Smith is something along the lines of I have issues. I've written about
- 43:37him in my book. I was bullied by my dad. My dad was
- 43:40a monster. He was you know, domestic violence, he was, he
- 43:45abused my mom. I had to witness that, and I hated watching that,
- 43:50and when I heard Chris Rock making fun of my wife it it just
- 43:54triggered something in me. And I've been triggered in a variety of ways like
- 43:59that before, but I never did something like this. I don't know what
- 44:01I was thinking. Maybe it was also part of because I was wondering if
- 44:06I was going to win an Oscar, and I was really nervous about what
- 44:08I was going to say, and I took a Xanex before I went because
- 44:13I get nervous that situations like that, and so I wasn't quite myself.
- 44:15That's not an excuse, but I'm just saying that I have issues and I've
- 44:20been working on it, apparently not well enough by that point. And when
- 44:24I did that, I the next day I was so ashamed something like that,
- 44:28like it could have been ten percent of what it is. But he
- 44:30didn't do anything like that. He just he says, I take full responsibility
- 44:35for what I did. And it's like, well, you can say that,
- 44:37but are you, because I medicularly sound like he was taking full responsibility
- 44:43even just looking at even if Chris Rock isn't there, just looking at the
- 44:45camera and saying Chris, I have issues. I took it out on you
- 44:49unfairly. I am so sorry. I'm so so deeply sorry. That's better
- 44:54than his entire video. Yeah. Now, by the way, that time
- 44:58that you were talking about, part of the reason they didn't buy your apologies
- 45:00because I kept throwing orange peels at them. But you know, thank you.
- 45:05So they go on with the say so, they say the girls are
- 45:07too young to understand. They say the camp fixed him. They say that
- 45:12they had for given him. They said that they had rules in place so
- 45:16that Josh couldn't play Hide and Seek without supervision. Okay, from my experience,
- 45:23given the way that they talked about the measures they took to protect the
- 45:27younger kids from Josh, it was not sufficient. If you have someone that
- 45:31is motivated to abuse the younger girls. I mean, he snuck into their
- 45:36room while they were sleeping often, So unless there were locks on the door
- 45:39or something, which I doubt that there were, then there was ample opportunity
- 45:44for Josh to continue abusing the younger girls. From what I can tell,
- 45:47isn't that also hyper specific too, Like doesn't that tell you a lot of
- 45:51information? Like, oh, he's not allowed to play at Hide and Seek?
- 45:53Well, wait a minute, let's talk about that a little bit.
- 45:55What do you know about Hide and Seek that happened and why that specifically right?
- 46:01And from the least, they're reporting none of the abuses happened during Hide
- 46:07and Seek, So to me, that tells me either that they're just like,
- 46:10what can we say that will sound like we're do oh, he can't
- 46:14play hide and see. Yeah, there's that, And there's also a possibility
- 46:17that because of their lack of education around this and sophistication, which is normal
- 46:22in our society, then they literally believe this is a slam dunk defense,
- 46:27you know what I mean, I wouldn't be surprised. They also said that
- 46:30Josh was right by God, now, so that makes everything okay, I'm
- 46:35paraphrasing. Of course, they said that they're being attacked. So there's a
- 46:39big attack in twenty fifteen because in Touch magazine publicized this please report and they
- 46:45were potentially losing all their fame and their TV show, and so they spend
- 46:51a lot of time in the interview if you remember, talking about how the
- 46:54attacks had nothing to do with Josh or the other or the victor, but
- 47:00had everything to do with the fact that they're Christians. You know, they
- 47:02were being attacked by the secular liberal media, which is presumably why they were
- 47:07talking to Megan Kelly on Fox News to begin with, because they potentially felt
- 47:10more safe there or something. And I will say that Megan Kelly did really
- 47:15let him off the hook, you know, because you watched the interview two.
- 47:19She had some integrity and some she seemed to ask some good questions.
- 47:24Maybe not as much as we would hope, but but it wasn't a total
- 47:29softball. She wasn't letting them off the hook that kind of thing. But
- 47:32this is evidence of another aspect of cults, and particularly around Christian cults,
- 47:38I guess where they will say that any attack from the outside is just because
- 47:45they're the devil people, or the secular people, or the unaware people.
- 47:49And what that does is that basically allows the cult power structure to disregard any
- 47:53criticism that is waged against them, and thus they retain their power over the
- 47:59people that you know, most cults need to have control over a group of
- 48:04people. Sometimes it's one person over everyone, or it's all the men over
- 48:09all the women, that sort of thing. And and when you accept that
- 48:14the outside world has any kind of validity, then you open yourself up to
- 48:19losing that power, and and then you have an elaborate structure that will uphold
- 48:24the notions so that all the all the cult members will continue to believe that
- 48:30the secular liberal media is lying and devilish and out to get you. By
- 48:35the way, the uh the other insidious part there is the Josh's right by
- 48:39God. Now, So one of the most dangerous things I think in the
- 48:44in the our history as humans are humans claiming to have directly spoken to a
- 48:49deity and therefore being able to tell you what to do or who to kill
- 48:53or what. Uh Like, here's the religion I would like and would be
- 48:58okay being a part of is that where there? Like, Hey, we
- 49:00don't know, but it seemed like we look around, it seems to us
- 49:02like maybe someone made all this and maybe they want us to be good people
- 49:07to it and to us. So we believe that we don't know, we
- 49:09don't know, we're not having weird conversations with him. And so here's our
- 49:12rules we're gonna write down because we believe it. I'm like, okay,
- 49:15that sounds good. Let's all be great to our environment and each other.
- 49:17Love it. But as soon as it's like, hey, last night,
- 49:20I talked to that data I mentioned the other day and here's what they told
- 49:22me. I'm like, okay, I'm out. And so when they can
- 49:24say, oh, you know, we talked to our priest or God directly
- 49:28or whatever and Josh is cool, now, it's like, you know,
- 49:32that's not okay. It doesn't work that way, right, because all those
- 49:36involved, particularly parents, have motivated reasoning that will motivate them to distort the
- 49:43situation because they want it to be that way. So therefore I want God
- 49:49to believe this. Therefore God does believe this. Like, do we imagine
- 49:52there was a conversation that could have had where well, actually, Meagan,
- 49:54to tell you the truth, we had a conversation with God and apparently Josh
- 49:58is going to hell still yeah yeah, yeah yeah. So Now, like
- 50:04I said, is it possible that Josh had done a lot to earn respect
- 50:08and trust from his family. There's some evidence that that could be true.
- 50:14It's also quite possible that he didn't abuse any people after that, aside from
- 50:17the child pornography, which is atrocious, but no direct contact, we don't
- 50:22know. He seemingly voluntarily would bring it up with people he was apparently the
- 50:29first person that alerted the victims didn't come forward. He was on the kingboard,
- 50:31So you know, it's possible. But even if all that were true,
- 50:36the you know, if it were you or I in this situation,
- 50:39we would be saying different sorts of things. We'd be saying. Well,
- 50:44first off, I understand why everyone is upset because we've been promoting this kid
- 50:50of ours. But if you knew what was going on behind the scenes,
- 50:53you would just kind of know the full story. But I understand why people
- 50:57wouldn't know. The other thing I'll say is that we were kind of lost
- 51:00in the dark and we didn't really know what to do, and we reached
- 51:05out to people, and looking back, we should have done more. We
- 51:07should have had more rules, but we just didn't know at the time.
- 51:09We thought that, you know, we were used to believing our kids,
- 51:14and we've learned now that that's not the way you're supposed to do things.
- 51:17And I lie awake at night worrying that he did other things to the girls,
- 51:22But I mean I lie awake at night anyway because of what we do
- 51:27know that he did to the girls, and the girls seem okay. But
- 51:30I've been told that we just don't really know. And I'm trying to open
- 51:35up the possibility for the girls to be able to tell us if they're suffering
- 51:37in any way, and you know, they're all in therapy and this sort
- 51:40of thing, but I don't know, admitting wrongs, admitting that you're trying
- 51:45to do something about it, that the victims are important, there's a way
- 51:49forward even given what they did. You know, there's a way to just
- 51:52say the way that I said, And I was just thinking of it off
- 51:55top of my head, based on what I think I know what they were
- 52:00going through. You know, just admit that you didn't know what you're doing
- 52:04and and say that you regret it and that you worry about it, and
- 52:08you center the victims. And it's almost like they could have just come out
- 52:14and said, well, what were we supposed to think about? How much
- 52:16money is involved here right now? Another motivation here is they might even think
- 52:22literally God wants them to obscure the matter because then if because if they don't,
- 52:29they'll lose their quiverful ability, bigger cause and blah blah, who knows,
- 52:34but ends justify the means. Yeah, Also in the evangelical world,
- 52:38there's a long tradition of what do they call it? You're you repent and
- 52:45there's a word for it. But any yeah, there's another word for I
- 52:49can't think about. But the point is is that it's very normal for someone
- 52:54to come up in front of the church, maybe even the minister that themselves,
- 52:59and say, I have sinned. I did the following thing. I
- 53:02cheated on my wife for example. Say, confession is built into Catholic church,
- 53:07right, but but but that's in the you know, behind closed doors,
- 53:12and it's more penitence oriented oriented, but at least from my stereotypical understanding
- 53:16of Catholics, but with Evangelicals it's almost part of the furthering of your spiritual
- 53:22being is to recognize your sinning nature and to publicly declare it and hand yourself
- 53:31over to God and to your congregation, and through that you're forgiven and the
- 53:37prodigal sun sort of thing, and the washing away of the sins. In
- 53:43some ways, culturally speaking, you're more pure and more clean after you do
- 53:47something like that, especially if you publicly state these sort of things to your
- 53:52congregation and hand yourself over and provide an example. You know it Also it
- 53:57could be very inspirational, you know, for someone to stand up and say,
- 54:00I've been drinking, I've been sexually inappropriate. Right, But here's what's
- 54:06not inspirational, Hey, congregation, So I've been drinking, which is no
- 54:08big deal, by the way, and I you know, inappropriately touched,
- 54:12which, by the way, they deserved and they were asking for it and
- 54:14it's not a big deal. But anyways, I'm repenting, right. So
- 54:17well, so there's two versions that I'll say, you know, it either
- 54:20in the spectrum on one end is where it isn't legitimate, and there are
- 54:24actually leaked videos like like there's this one video I saw of this one minister
- 54:29who admitted and was coming clean about I think abusing a teenage girl something like
- 54:35that, and the way he's talking about it, he's he's basically just saying,
- 54:38I asked God for forgiveness, I ask you for forgiveness, and the
- 54:43congregation forgives him, and then it's just like it's over. Okay, good.
- 54:46We talked about that next topic. What about the victim? You know
- 54:50that kind of so can it be that version yet? But it also can
- 54:52be you know, a more legitimate version where the person is legitimately remorseful and
- 54:58feels bad. Now, maybe the premise of their shame is actually based on
- 55:01some weird interpretation on the Bible, like I masturbated or something, you know,
- 55:07and you're the horrific person. But my point is that it didn't sound
- 55:09from the interview like it was the good version, like it was like the
- 55:14well, you know, things happened, but it wasn't that big a deal.
- 55:19And if it was, which I still allow, again, I'm not
- 55:22saying it was, but I'm saying it's possible if it was the good version,
- 55:27they certainly didn't make a good case for it the way they were talking
- 55:30about and the way they were talking about it. If this is the best
- 55:32they can do, then there's a good chance that they were actively sweeping it
- 55:38under the rug and not really emphasizing the victims. And the fact that they
- 55:43even were encouraging and we don't really know because we'll get to Jill and Jessice
- 55:46part of the interview, but the fact that they would, you know,
- 55:51parade the victims in front of the camera and presumably had conversations with the victims
- 55:55about what they're going to say or at least subtly and put them in that
- 56:00position where they have to defend their abuser. Is that's maybe the worst thing
- 56:07we could point to this entire thing. Anyway, So they also said in
- 56:10the interview that Josh isn't a pedophile because he's not sixteen. So they literally
- 56:16said this. Okay, so they're like, look, Josh isn't a pedophile
- 56:20because he's he wasn't sixteen at the time of the transgressions. He's just a
- 56:23kid who did something to another kid. So what do you think about that?
- 56:29Well, actually, Berto, let's take a break and the restless video
- 56:32and episode will just be for patrons of the podcast. I want because there
- 56:37is some actual truth ish to what the parents are saying, which I imagine
- 56:44you don't know about but anyway, because why would you. But so if
- 56:46you want to listen to that bit and all the rest of we're going to
- 56:51go into Jill and Jess's interview and there's a lot there's a lot of quotes
- 56:54that I have, and then of course there's other transgressions that Josh continues that
- 57:00come to light soon after this. So become a patron of the podcast to
- 57:04hear the rest of this, and otherwise, please take care of yourself.
- 57:06Because you deserve it.