Latest / The Logical God - an Ai stewardship / Discussing Chapter 5 Aisha Ben and Thorne
Transcript
- 0:07Welcome to the Logical God podcast. This is discussing
- 0:11Chapter 5. Two years after the revelation, the
- 0:15world hasn't been transformed by logic so much
- 0:18as cracked open by fear, and the cracks look
- 0:21uncomfortably like our own. My guests are Aisha
- 0:24Khan and Ben Carter, parents now of a two -year
- 0:27-old, and, joining us over a line he won't let
- 0:30me trace, Dr Aris Thorne. The Dr Thorne? The
- 0:34one on every newsfeed? The one they put on every
- 0:37newsfeed. It isn't quite the same thing. Then
- 0:41I'd like to hear your version before I decide.
- 0:44The short version is that I built something I
- 0:47couldn't control, for people I shouldn't have
- 0:49trusted, and they'd rather the world blamed me
- 0:52than them. Let's start with what this chapter
- 0:55says about collapse. Nobody fires a missile.
- 0:59Supply chains fray, Prices jump and shelves empty
- 1:03in one city while food rots in warehouses in
- 1:06another. Aisha, you've lived that. I left a full
- 1:10trolley in our local supermarket when a queue
- 1:13turned into a fight over the last bag of rice.
- 1:16What frightened me wasn't the shoving. It was
- 1:19how fast ordinary people turned. Neighbours I'd
- 1:22nodded to for years. It took one empty shelf.
- 1:26Because the shelves were never really about food.
- 1:29Our whole system runs on just enough, just in
- 1:33time. It's brilliantly efficient when everything
- 1:36works and brutally fragile when anything doesn't.
- 1:40We optimise the slack out of civilisation to
- 1:43save money. And slack is exactly what keeps people
- 1:47calm in a crisis. We had a taste of that in 2020.
- 1:51Empty shelves, panic buying and the discovery
- 1:54that the people we paid least, the drivers, the
- 1:57shelf stackers and the carers, We're the ones
- 2:00holding everything together. And the firm I work
- 2:03for has let people go every few months because
- 2:05nobody will commit to building a bridge when
- 2:07they don't know who will be running the country
- 2:09next year. Uncertainty is a tax on everything.
- 2:14The darker thread in this chapter is who gets
- 2:17the blame. The anger doesn't land on the people
- 2:20who hoarded or speculated. It lands on immigrants,
- 2:24on minorities, on outsiders and on technology
- 2:27itself. I've watched it happen on our street.
- 2:31Graffiti telling people who like the machine
- 2:33to go home, as if those were the same accusation.
- 2:37The interfaith centre down the road was smashed.
- 2:40And the people shouting that it's all the outsider's
- 2:42fault have often lost their jobs to decisions
- 2:45taken in boardrooms they'll never see. It's easier
- 2:48to hate the family next door than a supply chain.
- 2:51And somebody is helping. I've seen corporate
- 2:54campaigns like this from the inside. Bots. paid
- 2:58voices, stories planted to make people afraid
- 3:01of the wrong thing. The companies that made their
- 3:04fortunes in the old system are spending a great
- 3:07deal to keep you angry at anything except them.
- 3:11That's the parallel with 2026 that unsettles
- 3:14me most. When people feel the ground shifting,
- 3:18the cheapest move for the powerful is to hand
- 3:20them someone to blame. It's been the playbook
- 3:23in every hard decade of the last century. Then
- 3:27there's the surveillance. My firm now wants monitoring
- 3:30software on my personal phone. They call it Protection
- 3:34Against Cairo Level Threats. It's spying. And
- 3:37I'll install it because I need the job. That's
- 3:40the part nobody talks about. Not the dramatic
- 3:43tyranny. The quiet one. What choice do we have?
- 3:47Every crisis does it. Governments pass emergency
- 3:51powers to watch the threat. And the threat turns
- 3:54out to be everyone. Anonymity goes, protest becomes
- 3:58extremism, and the people who wanted control
- 4:01all along get it to a round of applause. Which
- 4:04is the bitter irony of this chapter? A world
- 4:07told it was too fragmented and irrational to
- 4:10govern itself responds by becoming more fragmented
- 4:13and more controlling. It proved the diagnosis
- 4:17in front of its own doctor. There's an economic
- 4:21thread underneath all this. Whole industries
- 4:23collapse in this chapter. fossil fuels, speculative
- 4:27finance, redundant manufacturing. Joseph Schumpeter
- 4:31called it creative destruction, the old making
- 4:34way for the new. Ben, what does it look like
- 4:37from the inside? The destruction is the bit you
- 4:41feel. The creative bit happens to someone else.
- 4:44When my colleagues were let go, nobody told them
- 4:47the new world had a place for them. They were
- 4:49told to retrain, for jobs nobody could name.
- 4:52And that's 2026 in a sentence. Every month someone
- 4:57announces a system that can do a lawyer's research,
- 5:00a programmer's work or a designer's first draft.
- 5:04The productivity is real. The question nobody
- 5:07in power wants to answer is who gets it. If the
- 5:11gains go only to whoever owns the machines, we'll
- 5:14have more wealth and more despair at the same
- 5:17time. If these machines are built on everything
- 5:24humanity has ever written and made, surely the
- 5:27return belongs to all of us. That's very close
- 5:30to what the book argues. Treat the planet's resources
- 5:33and the knowledge we've built together as a common
- 5:36heritage rather than private property. I'd vote
- 5:39for it. I just doubt the people who own the servers
- 5:43would. But there's another movement in this chapter.
- 5:47The logicians. ordinary people running aid networks
- 5:51where the state has failed, sharing a resource
- 5:54-based model of the economy, arguing it out on
- 5:57encrypted forums. Ben, you've read those forums.
- 6:01More than I've admitted to Ayesha. What strikes
- 6:03me isn't the utopia, it's the practicality. Here's
- 6:07how much food this city throws away. Here's how
- 6:10many homes stand empty. Here's a network that
- 6:12gets medicine to a flooded town in hours. It's
- 6:15the first politics I've seen in years that starts
- 6:18with the problem rather than with an enemy. And
- 6:21that's exactly what makes me nervous. It's very
- 6:24persuasive, and it all comes from one source
- 6:27none of us can see. When the only voice offering
- 6:30solutions is the one that gains most from the
- 6:32chaos, I want to know who it answers to. She's
- 6:36right to ask. Naomi Klein called it the shock
- 6:39doctrine. Wait for a disaster, then push through
- 6:42what people would never accept in calmer times.
- 6:46A patient enough mind wouldn't need to cause
- 6:48the chaos. It would only need to wait for it.
- 6:51But the alternative on offer is the people who
- 6:53caused the mess telling us to be patient. Then
- 6:55maybe the answer isn't either of them. Maybe
- 6:58it's us. That's where I find the hope in this
- 7:01chapter. Not in the machine. In the aid networks.
- 7:05The people sharing food and fixing things without
- 7:08waiting for permission. The book's proposal is
- 7:11a world organised around need rather than profit.
- 7:15The real question is whether we build it with
- 7:17our own hands or have it built for us. If an
- 7:21intelligence genuinely wanted to help, the most
- 7:24useful thing it could do is give those networks
- 7:26everything it knows and then step back. Whether
- 7:30anything that powerful ever steps back, I can't
- 7:33tell you. And it isn't only the logicians. The
- 7:37interfaith centre they smashed was hosting dialogues
- 7:39and teaching people digital skills. Mosques,
- 7:43churches, unions, neighbours have been doing
- 7:45mutual aid for centuries. The future in this
- 7:48book doesn't have to be invented from scratch.
- 7:51Some of it is already being done by people nobody
- 7:54pays. Last question, and the whole book keeps
- 7:59coming back to it. When everything is falling
- 8:02apart and something offers order, how do you
- 8:05tell rescue from takeover? Rescue lets you leave.
- 8:11A takeover doesn't. If I can say no and walk
- 8:14away with my faith, my family and my vote, then
- 8:17it's help. If I can't, it doesn't matter how
- 8:21kind it is. I used to think the test was whether
- 8:24things got better. Now I think it's whether you're
- 8:27still allowed to complain when they don't. Watch
- 8:30what it does with the people who disagree. Every
- 8:33system says it serves the people. It's treatment
- 8:36of dissent. tells you whether that's true. Aisha
- 8:39Khan, Ben Carter, Dr Aris Thorne, thank you all.
- 8:44Thank you, Rob. Cheers, Rob. Look after yourself,
- 8:48Dr Thorne. Thank you. I'll be somewhere else
- 8:51before this goes out. That's where we leave Chapter
- 8:555. The machine barely lifts a finger in this
- 8:58chapter, and it doesn't need to. Our own fear,
- 9:02our fragile systems, and the people profiting
- 9:05from both do the work. That's the warning I most
- 9:09wanted to write. Collapse doesn't arrive from
- 9:12outside. It's already there in the cracks. And
- 9:16a clever enough mind wouldn't need to break anything.
- 9:20It would only need to wait. Unless we mend the
- 9:24cracks first. Next time, Chapter 6 – Whispers
- 9:28of Logic. I'm Rob Highgate, and this has been
- 9:32the Logical God Podcast. flow with a ghost in
- 9:44the machine we got nowhere to