Latest / Walk Talk: Faith in Motion / Mega Churches Part 3
Transcript
- Randy: All right. So in the past, we talked about the mega church pastors that were preaching the prosperity gospel. We got a couple of more that are in line with those, but we also have a couple other mega church pastors who are not preaching the prosperity gospel. So we're gonna talk about that and a whole lot more today. on the walk talk. All right, man. So hey, so yeah, we've gone through our list of the top 10. Let me just go through the list real quick again, just to remind everybody, because this is actually our third episode, focused on megachurches and specifically on the megachurch pastors that rank in the top 10 in the United States in terms of net worth. Okay. So number one, we had Kenneth Copeland, two, we had Joel Osteen. We skip Pat Robertson since he's deceased. We talked about Benny Hinn, number four, number five, Steven Furtick. and then today we're going to talk about TD Jakes. We also have Creflow Dalver on the list. I don't know if we're going to talk about him too much. I know he is in very much in alignment with some of these other ones. Same thing with Jesse Duplanis, who's number nine, but definitely Rick Warren and Andy Stanley, who are eight and ten, respectively. They seem to be a little bit different. They have a little bit of a different message. Actually, a lot different. because I think pretty much the rest of them kind of fall in that prosperity gospel. Name it, yeah, name it and claim it. whereas these other guys, not so much. So I think maybe we could jump around a little bit, but I do have something on TD Jakes that I want to start off with. Pj Verdin: Name it, claim it, name it, claim it. Randy: That gives us a little bit of his view on tithing because tithing seems to be a big part of the conversation. and they link tithing. These, these prosperity gospel preachers, they link tithing to your prosperity, right? All right. So let me share. Pj Verdin: Right. Which is funny because it's ultimately linked right back to their prosperity. You know what mean? Randy: 100%. 100%. Alright, so here we go. So this is gonna be a video from TD Shakes talking about tithing. So let's see. Broke anyway. Somebody. Let's be Poor people, you have to live by faith. You got no choice but to live by faith. You if you don't live by faith, you're gonna starve to death. I I I'm gonna pause it real quick. I just love the title down there at the bottom that that just popped up. Pa Bishop T D Jakes. It starts off with renowned entrepreneur. Even before pastor right now the entrepreneur. Pj Verdin: Yeah, yeah, well. Randy: What what businesses has he established? What what is he an entrepreneur in other than in church church planning? Pj Verdin: I don't know, because apparently, I mean, he's got quite the resume. He's a pastor slash coach of global leaders, global leaders. He's a award winning author and a film producer. I mean, what does he not do? And he sounds also that that that title matches his demeanor, which is just humble. You know what mean? Randy: He's got a lot going on. All right, let's see what else he's got to say. All right, let's keep going. Well On deals that were about to evolve. I started giving on the level of the deal that was dealing proxy. I started giving on that level so that God would owe me. Right there. Okay. So two things, two things that jumped out. One, he's giving so God will owe him. And how is he doing that? He's giving on the salary he wants to make, he's giving on the deal that he wants to close. Again, this is like to me. Pj Verdin: Wow. Wow. Wow. yeah. Randy: This is showing Pj Verdin: my... Randy: the linkage between the the secret and this prosperity gospel. What do you think? Pj Verdin: Oh man, I'm just flabbergasted, man. I can tell you, I immediately felt a type of way, personally, whenever he's like, get the Lord his cut. I'm like, his cut? Like man, we're not talking about a drug dealer. The Bible says that we're supposed to give the Lord our first, not his cut. You know what mean? Like, oh, here's your little piece of the pie. Like, no, like we're supposed to offer him our first. You know what I mean? Like, is this wild? I just, I don't know. Randy: Right. Right. Well, and and and just and but just keep in mind, even that mindset though, brother, that's still the old covenant where God says, you know, where God says to give me the first fruits, right? Under the new covenant, we never see in the New Testament any doubling down on tithing or offering of the first fruit. What we see is it should be a love offering based on your excess. Pj Verdin: 100 % 100 % well and just to clarify you know whenever I made that reference just now I wasn't even talking about Thailand like because I do believe in still giving the Lord your first like I believe you wake up in the morning and automatically like you like before my day gets busy before my feet hit this ground and you know my day gets going like God let me give you my first thank you for waking me up that kind of thing you know I mean that's that that's what I was referencing sorry Randy: Right, right. Sure, sure. No, I mean that's that and that's a good point. Good clarification, I should say. but but yeah, but you know, you don't you don't ever hear any of these guys talking about the New Testament approach, the new covenant approach, which is to give from the excess that God has blessed you and to give out of love based on what God has put on your heart. Now we're no longer following this old covenant law that says you gotta give the ten percent of the first fruits. Pj Verdin: No, absolutely not. Randy: Which by the way, which by the way, they also never talk about the fact that that ten percent went to the Levites, who were the priests who were not alone not allowed to own land and not allowed to have any other sources of income. They relied solely on that tithe. Mr. T D Jakes, you just talked about your multi million dollar book deals. You talked about your multi million dollar movie deals, and you are still telling people that they owe you 10% or they're robbing God? Pj Verdin: That is wild. Randy: That's not what the Levites did. Pj Verdin: Poof, man. Randy: right. Pj Verdin: That was a lot. That was a lot to to take in, man. Honestly, like it's it's crazy. What always has blown my mind, because I've I I wanna say it's T D Jakes, that I've also seen a video of where he said that he wanted like I don't even remember what it was, like a a a two thousand dollar offering or like don't even come up. And some lady goes up there with like eleven hundred dollars and he's like scolding her. He's like, What what did I say that the Lord needed? He was she was like $2,000 and and and he was like he was like well is this $2,000? It's like no it's $1,100. And she's like, all right, I'll go and get the other nine. And he's like, okay, you better do that. I'm like, what what are we what am I witnessing here? This is insane to me. Like, why would anybody allow themselves to be manipulated on this level? Listen, I get we, you know, wanting to. Randy: Wow. We got okay, if that's real, we gotta find that. Pj Verdin: to believe in in in something and and believing in God and being willing to do whatever it takes. But I mean at some point we can't be that foolish. You know what I mean? You can't be that foolish. Like it's just it's wild, man. And and and my heart, my heart really does go out to these people because they they are there. It's like, man, that that's a lot of faith, but it seems like it's it's it it's misplaced. You know what I mean? To to to just have I I don't know, man. It's wild. It's wild. Randy: Yeah. It is wild, man. And and you know, it's some people just, you know, they're easily succept susceptible to anyone with a title or a position. They see that authority and they just think this has to be from God and they need to use their discernment is what they need. Pj Verdin: hundred percent. A hundred percent man. And like I said, it's just man, I I feel from 'cause it's like, you know, you know that that what they're doing is is is coming from probably a good and genuine place. But what they're doing is is counterproductive to that. You know what I mean? They're they're basically allowing these people to see, well if if there's people gulli gullible enough to be manipulated in this way, then I'm gonna be the one to reap the the benefits of that, you know. Randy: Yeah. Well, I I don't see the video you're referring to, but I don't doubt that it's out there. But I did find an interesting one on you the good the good pastor from Louisiana, Jesse Duplana. So I gotta I gotta see this one and I gotta share it. So let me let me let me pull this up. Pj Verdin: Yeah. Randy: Let's take a look at what this is together. And I wasn't planning to go to Jesse DuPlantis, but I seen this title and I was like, my gosh, this is something we gotta check out. Alright, so let's see. One second, let me share. I turned off my video. Okay, share. Okay. this just seemed too good to pass up. Let me let me get this going. And you know, I'm very careful with this and I've had many people approach me and ask me to write a book. I've only talked about this three times. Many times I've been on TV and I haven't I mean I just handed to it little bit because I had a wonderful experience all my life growing up as a child, the Lord was close to me. I didn't know that. I had encounters with God, I didn't understand that. And all I ever wanted It was a God that I could talk to. If he was really real, sure. Then let me talk to him. But I went into the preaching ministry. To make a long story short, in in nineteen eighty eight I was doing a a revival for Magnolia Christian Center in Magnolia, Arkansas. The pastor was Paul Troco, and I was preaching a Sunday through Wednesday meeting, a four day meeting. And I had many encounters with the Lord. I've seen angels. I I I never forget about four years before that. I had pre I was preaching I preached in twenty-one churches in seven days. That's three different churches a day. And I was having chest pains. And I was just preaching beyond my body. My spirit could, and my body could. And I went, took my Bible one night, and I have to say this real quick so so I can get into the heavenly trip. And as I was reading my Bible, I was my mind before I go to sleep, let that work instead some of the junk going in there. And when I was reading the Bible and I looked up There was an angel of the Lord. He didn't have wings, but he was a blonde-headed man, look seven foot tall. It scared me. I I I I I literally, you know, I I jumped. And he said, I have been sent of the Lord, and the Lord has commanded It looks like a ski lift that was covered, you know, like a ski car, but not and that angel that had talked to me years before smiled at me. He said, You have an appointment with the Lord. Now I thought to myself, man. I mean, this is weird, you know, in myself. So we just when I come out, this thing just stopped. When I come out, I seen the prettiest place in my life. I have never, I can't tell you the colors of what heaven is. Give me a little tiny character, but well when I came out, you gotta watch what you say there. Did you see that I don't know who that woman was, but did you see that woman's face? She had this look on her face like, What is this guy babbling about? She ain't buying what he's selling. Pj Verdin: Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Randy: But he's basically telling people that he, at least on one occasion, if not multiple occasions, no kidding, was taken to heaven and met with God in heaven. On a ski lift with an angel that looked like a tall blonde man. Pj Verdin: On a ski l. Randy: And and the angel said Jehovah, the fight despite the fact that we know that Jehovah is the English, like basically bastardization of the real name of God. But anyway, he said Jehovah. He looked of great age. And I looked at him and he said, Hi Jesse. Call me by my name. And I said, Hello? He said, Are you thirsty? I said, Yeah. And he gave me some water out of it, looked like a golden goblet. And I said, Who are you? And I hang on when y'all say, I let you check it in the Holy Spirit. You of stuff. I I don't know, man. This guy, you know, it's a long video. Looks like it's about thirty minutes long. So I'm sure he spends the rest of this time talking about he probably met after Abraham, he probably met you know, Peter and James and John and Paul and and Jesus and God, and I'm sure he probably just goes on and on. But what what do you think about this guy? Pj Verdin: Man He's he's a character. I I re man, I you know I don't like I always say, I don't never put God in a box, man, but I do I I tell you, I feel like my discernment it kinda kicks in is like, I don't know, man. This this doesn't this doesn't jive right. There's it just i I I get an uneasiness about it. yeah, I I just I don't know, man. Randy: I mean, I guess this video looks old. It looks like it was probably recorded in the seventies or eighties. I guess back then, you know, but without the internet and social media and, you know, AI, it was easier for people to to just lie and pull the wool over people's eyes. But yeah, I'm I'm with you. I hear this and I'm like, man, I I don't put God in a box, but this none of this sounds like it has any truth in it to me. Pj Verdin: Yeah. Hey, so look, I did find this short of this video that I had seen and I I I apologize. It was it's not T D Jakes. I I'm not very familiar with T D. Jakes. I've only heard of him and and you know, I've never really seen him or took time to to watch him. and and I guess in in context I just assumed it was him. But but Ben, I just want I just want you to see this. It's it's it's wild. And just like the the so it's a it's a Randy: Who who was it? Who was it? Pj Verdin: Apparently a Detroit pastor named Marvin Wynins. Randy: Okay. I haven't heard of him. He's not on our list. Pj Verdin: So here here we go. That ain't what I asked you to do. Y'all not listening. Take look, she's like, let's go, let's get out of here. Now, now, mind you, just just to to you know, add some add some meat to these bones. She she goes up there and she states her contribution that she's she's given a thousand plus two hundred and thirty-five to receive her blessing. So this is one of those where it's like, hey, listen, you know what, you you want a blessing? Two thousand dollars, thousand plus a thousand. Randy: Wow. Wow. Pj Verdin: And then this dude like proceeds in front of everybody, like, y'all not listening to what I'm saying. This is only twelve hundred. This is go go get the rest. Like I it just, man, you know, I I I say that smiling and kind of laughing, but not because I think it's funny. It's because it's like it blows my mind. It blows my mind and and it it's so sad, bro. It's it's so sad. Randy: It it is sad because look, this woman that's a very specific amount, brother. Twelve hundred and thirty five dollars. That sounds to me like that's probably all she has left in her checking account, and she's given every dollar that she has. Why is it not just twelve hundred and fifty? Why is it not thirteen hundred? Twelve hundred and thirty five dollars. That t tells me that's probably every last cent that this lady has, and this guy is criticizing her and Pj Verdin: Or something, yeah. Randy: And and making her feel bad and embarrassed and ashamed and and and she's even s you know, saying, Well, I'm gonna go get the other eight hundred and he's basically even denying that. Give me a break. Pj Verdin: Yeah, like that's the yeah. Well and and so I guess, you know, what another thing that sparked it is like I think that that this guy's mentality started by by seeing the success of people like T D Jakes, like Kenneth Copeland, like Joel Olstein be able to monetize this thing. And and and it so they see the faithfulness of people and and like I said, they're like, well, i i if you got people here ripe for being taken advantage of, hey, I'll I'll I'll I'll be that guy. Like he 'cause the his the his whole demeanor, like his demeanor didn't even give off pastor to me. You know what I mean? It's it's not like, you know, like like Randy: It's he's trying to t he's picking up the mantle of these, you know, mega church pastors who tell people they have to tithe in order to receive blessings. He's picking up the mantle. He might not be a mega church pastor yet. He might not be in the top ten yet, but he's working on it. Pj Verdin: Well, if you can make somebody feel bad for giving you twelve hundred dollars, bro, you on your way. only twelve only twelve hundred, get out of my get out of my face. That's not what I said. Like what? Randy: Yeah. You and your way. Yep. And and let me just and let me just remind it sounded to me like he was basically selling a blessing to people. but but let me just remind people, you know, we quoted the verse, what was it from? I can't even remember what what book it was from that talked about, you know, bring all your tithe to the storehouse. I think it might have been Deuteronomy. Pj Verdin: Yeah. a hundred percent. Randy: and and this is the past, this is the verse these pastors like to use that says, This is only time God says to test me. Again, old covenant, that's not under the new covenant. But anyway, what people need to realize is that in in 2 Peter, it makes it very clear that we have been given everything that we need for life and godliness. Second Peter chapter one, Romans and and Colossians also dumble down on this, basically reemphasizing that look, God, there's no more blessings. We've received everything. We've been given the Holy Spirit. What more of a blessing do you need than that? The New Testament tells us we've been given everything we need for life and godliness. So don't listen to anybody who says, All you need to do is tithe, all you need to do is give me twelve, two thousand dollars and you're gonna receive a blessing. It's all just it's all fake. Pj Verdin: Right. Randy: It's all fake news. Pj Verdin: Yeah. It's just wow. Yeah, sorry. I I got us off I got us off a t topic. I just Randy: All right. So I do want to switch no, no, you're fine. This that's good stuff. He might not be in the top ten, but I'm glad we pulled it up because people need to see the kind of stuff that's out there. This is this is good. All right. I I do want to talk about a couple of these other passers though. So, unless you have any issue with it, I was gonna say let's just skip Crefoldaler. I believe he's right up, he's he's gonna be right. I the dude's name is Crefoldoller. He's he's literally gonna be in alignment with T D Jakes and the rest of these guys. Pj Verdin: A hundred percent. Yeah. And and and he is. So I mean it it I mean, it's almost like there's a factory with the mold and these guys all follow it. I'm I'm serious. I mean it th they got different names. Yeah, they got different names. They they pastor in different places, but I mean the the message is is is pretty standard textbook, you know. It's like and and and look, I I think I think on our last episode for Mega Church Pastors, I believe I did bring up Pastor Philip Anthony Mitchell, who I I I personally like a lot. Randy: They're f they're following the same playbook. Yeah. Pj Verdin: you know, I I think he he's a a a great pastor. but he's he's talked about and and he's not even nowhere near it on the list. You know what I mean? I I don't even know where where he sits as far as, you know, net worth or anything like that. I do know he does have a a a pretty big congregation and in and those things. but he he talks about candidly and openly about how, you know, he used to go to these conferences and they basically like they they outline like, okay, look, this is how you grow your church body, this is what you need to do, this is how you market, this is Like it and it's it it sounds exactly like that, like a step by step guide of how to grow and pastor a mega church. And he said that he was sitting there in in this cycle of of of being there and and he was like, Man, I realized at that point, like I'm I'm doing this for my own prideful reasons. you know, it's not it and he's like he's like I had to bring that out of me. You know what I mean? He's like and realize that this is not about Philip Anthony Mitchell. He's like, I'm just a steward. I'm just a steward of God's people and so I I I just Randy: Right. Right. Yeah, yeah. Pj Verdin: It it's crazy to hear like from the other side. Like this is not just us just talking like, I bet you this is what it's like. Like we've s have somebody who was there. Randy: There's a there's a playbook. There's a playbook and they've been trained to it. Okay. So let's keep going. So I do want to switch to topics slightly and talk about the two pastors on the list that don't follow this this same pattern. So Rick Warren, who a lot of people know as Saddleback Church, he's a pastor of Saddleback Church. He's also super popular because he wrote a really a really good best selling book. Pj Verdin: A hundred percent. Yes. Randy: I can't I don't mean to say good and in like I read it and it's a great book. I just mean like it was a a good selling, it sold a lot of copies. and and that book was called The Purpose Driven Life. You might have heard of it. I've seen it a lot, but I've never actually read it. And so I think some of his biggest criticisms has been, you know, he's known as America's pastor. He definitely has you know, been involved in politics. Pj Verdin: Okay. Randy: Both on the Democrat and the Republican side, he's, you know, done things for both parties. He's done things that have stirred up a lot of people, a lot of controversy because he had like a conference for LGPTQ parents of LGBTQ kids, which, you know, from my understanding, this is not something where he or his church is condoning homosexuality or anything like that, but he It it sounded like to me it was some sort of support group for the parents of these kids because he has come out over and over again and said, Look, we teach what the Bible teaches about marriage, and it's between one man and one woman in covenant in a covenant relationship with God. And, you know, I think you know, he's stirred up a lot of feelings because of that. And he's I I've personally heard him talking about this topic, saying that look, the Bible says what the Bible says, and even if we disagree with people, we still gotta be Loving and respectful towards them, which I also would agree with. Pj Verdin: Right. A hundred percent. Randy: So let's let's hear a little bit about Rick Warren. So I'm gonna share my screen here. Let's hear directly from him. This is actually from his YouTube channel, because he has a channel. And so even though this is gonna be a combination of him speaking along with some other clips built in, this is coming directly from his channel. So here we go. Exhausting, and eventually you get worn out. And what is the cause of this battle that's going on in you? You actually have two natures inside of you. You have your old nature, which you were born with, and you have a new nature that was given to you when you trusted in Christ, when you were born again, when you became a believer. And this new nature wants to do the right thing, but you still have the old nature inside of you. And these two natures are in constant conflict with each other. And that's the cause of the battle. You have two natures, not one, two natures inside of you. Paul says this. I love to do God's will so far as my new nature is concerned. But there's something else deep within me. My lower nature. That's my old nature. The Bible often calls it my flesh, or it calls it my carnal self, or calls it the old man. These are synonyms for the old nature. There's something else deep within me, my lower nature, that is at war with my mind and wins the fight and makes me a slave to the sin that is still within me. Now, even though I'm a Christian, my old nature is still alive. And I hate to tell you this, but you're gonna live with it the rest of your life. You don't get rid of your old nature until you go to heaven. Okay. So let me stop right there, because I would say in general, I would say I generally agree with everything that he's saying right there. and I think that's why it's so important that we do renew our minds, because we do have we are still in our flesh, and our flesh still is corrupted because until we get that new Spiritual body that Jesus had, then we're gonna always fight with that, even though we are no longer a slave to sin. Paul makes that very clear. We're no longer slaves, we're now actually slaves to righteousness. but like he said, we have been given a new nature when we die to the old person, to the old man, that old man is dead, it was crucified on the cross with Christ. We were given a new heart, and you know, we have a new spirit within us, the spirit of God. Pj Verdin: Heavenly body, yeah. Randy: But we still have that mind and we still have that flesh to contend with. So I would say I generally agree with what he's saying there. And by the way, like for this video, like I actually searched a couple of things before I found this one. The first thing I searched was with the same thing I searched for the other pastors that we reviewed, which was their message on tithing. Nothing came up. So I don't know if he has ever preached on tithing or it maybe it's just not a popular topic. So it didn't come up. I don't know. But I I was, you know, wanting to hear if he was in alignment with the prosperity gospel, and it doesn't appear that he is. in alignment with the prosperity gospel. So if he does have any teachings on tithing, they didn't show up in my search. And my guess is that they're probably a lot different than what we've been seeing from some of these other guys. All right, let's hear a little bit more. Or make myself better or you know exaggerate or whatever. That old nature is still there. And and the lust and the gossip and the lie and all that stuff there. Now let me tell you why the problem is your problem. Because willpower is not enough to defeat your old nature. And if you think that you can change simply by wanting to change or by learning about change, it isn't gonna happen. It'll happen for a little while, but then you're gonna get tired and you're gonna stop. Okay, I'm I haven't seen this far into the video. I'm just being totally transparent. I'm super interested to hear what he's about to say next. Is not enough to change you. If it was German. Pj Verdin: From all. Randy: You'd get it, you change in that area, and then we just go on to something else. But just because you know the right thing to do does not mean you do it. The next verse says this So you see how it is, Paul says. My new life tells me to do right, but my old nature that's still inside me loves to sin. what a terrible predicament I'm in. In in the original Greek, it literally means. The exhaustion of hard work. It means it sounds like he might be reading like the New Living Translation, because this doesn't sound like any version of the Bible I've read before. Pj Verdin: Yeah. I was gonna wait till you pause it to ask. I wish I wish I knew. This sounds like some way different like I'm like I don't recognize Paul saying these things in that way at least. You know what I mean? Randy: Yeah, I I'm sure if we looked it up it's I'm sure it's the New Living Translation or something very similar 'cause it sound it seems very modern. Pj Verdin: No, yeah, hundred percent. Randy: This is not a pretty picture. Romans 7 is the picture of a defeated, struggling Christian. And finally, he falls on his face out of exhaustion. And Paul goes, What's the cure? And then he tells us. And he says, God's battle plan for victory. And he tells us what the plan is. Now, let me get you started on a couple of advanced steps on how you start to win the battle going on inside you. You do three things initially. The first thing I need to do, God's battle plan for winning the battle inside me, is I must deepen my understanding of Christ. Now you already know Christ, it's you gotta deepen your understanding of Christ and what he did for you on the cross. Now, we're not talking about being an unbeliever here. You're a believer. Paul is a believer here. Jesus is already in you. In fact, that's why you have this battle. If you weren't a Christian, you wouldn't have this battle. Why? Because you'd only have one nature. And if you only got one nature, your old nature, you go ahead and do whatever you please and do the wrong thing, and you don't even care about it. So an unbeliever does not have this battle going on in them because they don't have the good nature battling. With the old nature. They just got the old nature says, do whatever you want to do. So the fact that you've got Jesus in you is what's causing the battle. But having Christ in you is not enough. He doesn't just want to be resident in your life, he wants to be president in I mean, my my general thoughts so far is like he sounds like he's pretty much preaching what most pastors generally preach, which is probably some hybrid of the new covenant and the old covenant, but nothing nearly as salacious as the prosperity gospel preachers, which were also on the top ten list. Pj Verdin: But yeah, I I mean, honestly, I'm I'm I'm I'm a little bit intrigued on how he he made it to the top ten with with a message like this because I mean it's not I it it's just it's just I don't know. It it's kind of I don't know. Randy: Yeah. It might be because of his book sales, honestly. I mean, we just remember we when we looked at this list, we looked at the top ten you know, church pastors net worth and it doesn't break it down based on salary and book sales, speaking engagement. So it it could be that it's the book sales carrying him to the top ten. Pj Verdin: Yeah. Yeah, maybe. And I mean, you know, he he started off with with some some valid points that I that I would say that I I can align myself with, but I w I was really kind of waiting to hear him land the plane to see where exactly he he he falls. Randy: Yeah. Yeah, I mean it sounds like the the path he's going down is what you would typically hear in most churches. Confess your sins, accountability partners, things like that. That sounds to me like where he was going. Which to me, what I would say is, you know, first of all, he said that that picture in Romans 7 was the picture of a defeated Christian. I would slightly disagree. I would say that to me that's that's not the picture of a d defeated Christian. That's the that's a picture of a of a of a Christian that is relying on their own works. Pj Verdin: You know. Yeah. Randy: And not on the work, the finished work of Christ. That's a Christian who thinks that they, you know, need to you know, do better instead of just rely on pa and God's grace. And ultimately that's where Paul goes. Paul's like, you know, I asked the Lord three times to take this thorn, and his he his response was, My grace is sufficient. So, in other words, like you're gonna struggle with some things despite confessing, despite denying the lies, this the the despite defining the truth. you're always gonna struggle with some things and just you gotta just rely on God's grace. And I don't know if that's where Rick Warren was gonna end. I felt like he was gonna end more on the accountability thing, which to me just puts him in the category of the majority of pastors. So Pj Verdin: Yeah. Well and I think that that that narrative does align I mean, like I've told you before in the past, myself, like I got to a point where, you know, I felt like, you know, I was worn down and I didn't know if I was doing it right. And and and I think that that's a lot of people's stories. So catering to that audience and that experience is is probably, you know, a a lot easier than than telling them, you know, the the other side of things. Randy: Yeah, a hundred percent. And and I would say that I feel like what he was saying, he's kind of going very closely but slightly around what I would have said. And and again, I'm we're no pastors, we're no priests, man. I'm just a average guy just telling my my view. But my view would be like I heard him saying to deny the lies and to to seek the truth. And I would say that what I my version of that would be we need to know who we are in Christ, the truth of our identity in Christ. Who we are Pj Verdin: Absolutely. Randy: and who we're not. The lies is what the devil is telling us that you know we're nothing, that God's mad at us, that He's we're out of fellowship because we sin. That you know, now we have a wall of separation between us and him because we've sinned. Yeah, all those things that you know we need to we need to do something to mend our relationship. Those are all the lies. I don't know if Rick Warren would agree with that, but those are all the lies. Pj Verdin: We have fallen from grace. Yeah. Randy: He may say no, that's the conviction of the Holy Spirit. I would say no, the Holy Spirit does not convict believers. Convicts are people who are sinners. Believers are not sinners, though don't get convicted. But he would probably disagree and say, No, that's the Holy Spirit. And I would say, no, that's Satan that's that's actually talking to you there. But anyway, it sounds like where he's going is where most pastors would go, which is not where I would typically go, but it's probably not that far off. It's just, it's just keeping a little bit of that old covenant lens on things. That that a lot of people just seem to just struggle so much with removing. Pj Verdin: Gotcha. Randy: All right. Let's go to let's go to the last one then on our list. so Andy Stanley, he's the last one on the list. So he was actually literally number 10 on the list. And like Rick Warren, he's not a he's not a mega church pastor that that focuses on the prosperity gospel. I could I didn't find anything about him that had to do with tithing or preaching, you know, double down, triple downing on the old covenant tithing. What I did see though was some videos on him claiming that he was a heretic. So let's let's take a look at these videos that claim that he is a heretic. so here's some shorts here. Let's see what we have to say. So this just is is titled More Heresies from Andy Stanley. Because the old covenant says stone her, and the new covenant says forgive her. That's what the Bible says. The old covenant says, pray for your enemies' death, and the new covenant just says, pray for your enemies. That's what the Bible says. Let me tell you a better question. What does the new covenant? What does the new covenant teach? What the, or let's be more specific, what does the new testament teach? Or even better, what does Jesus teach? What does Jesus teach? Andy, are you saying there's that the two covenants that the Bible is conflicts? Yes. Then you're denying the overall superintending power of God over his revelation. Now what that does essentially is say this. Judge Here's a question okay. So that was John MacArthur at the end there. And I'm only assuming that whoever put this video together actually had John MacArthur, who is someone I do have a lot of respect for. I I can only assume that he's actually commenting on Andy Stanley's teaching, and not just you know a clip taken out of context. But what do you what are your thoughts when you first initially hear this? Pj Verdin: Okay, so first and foremost, Andy, I as soon as I saw Andy, Andy Stanley, I thought about the character Stuart from Mad TV back in the day. Look what I could do. That's initially what popped into my head. And I was a little distracted by that. But no, man, I would say I would say that he had some some valid points. The only thing the way he ended it is is I wouldn't I wouldn't necessarily agree with Randy: That's funny. Pj Verdin: With the old covenant and the new covenant contradicting. Well, they they contra did he say that basically that the the covenants contradict each other? okay. Well, I can agree that the the the the covenants are contrary to each other. I I absolutely I just I just wanted to make the distinction that I don't believe that the Bible contradicts itself, but the the two covenants are very different, and God made that. Randy: He said they contradict. Yeah, he said they contradict. Yeah. Yeah. Right, right. Pj Verdin: Explicitly clear. He said this is not gonna be the same covenant that I made with your fathers whenever I led them out of Egypt. He he said that hundred percent. So yeah. I mean Randy: Right. And I and I like I like the way you put it. I I I I would I feel like it sounds a lot better and more truthful to my ears to say that they are contrary more than they contradict, because we know that Jesus fulfilled the law. He fulfilled the old covenant covenant. And I would say that, you know, when you have the iPhone six, it doesn't contradict the iPhone five. It's just a much better version of what was initially intended with the original. Right. And so Pj Verdin: Right? Correct. Randy: It to me, it wouldn't be a accurate to say that they contradict as much as it wouldn't be accurate to say the new iPhone contradicts the old one, if that makes any sense at all. Pj Verdin: Right, right, yeah. Yeah, yeah, no, no. Right. They just language like as far as the way it's it's worded, I I can see why why they would say, the here's here's heresy, because they he he he's delivering some valid points and all they hear is Bible contradict and and they mash those two together and and call him a heretic. Randy: Contradict, yeah. Well, and he said, and he says, stop asking what the Bible says. Like he he's saying, Well, what we should stop saying, and and and I, and that's that's a very salacious statement itself. he clarifies it to say, Well, we should be asking what the new covenant says, which I agree with, but that's also in the Bible. So we should just be specific. We should just say, look, let's see what the Bible says, but let's focus on the new covenant. Pj Verdin: Right, right, right, yeah. Well, in and see, so I feel like he does g kind of the same thing that we were talking about i in in some of the previous episodes, where it's like i in maybe almost in reverse. You know, like you you hear Steven you have s you hear Steve Furtick, you know, say this thing that it's like, well, that's kind of close, and then he'd like or he'll throw something out there and say, Well, I I am God Almighty, and you're like, What it it's wild. So he starts throwing out these things that are kinda like questionable bait to make a good point instead of throwing out like a good point to say something questionable. You know what I mean? Like it's kind of a a r a reverse take on that. Randy: Yeah, yeah. I s I see yeah, I see what you're saying. And then the last thing I do want to point out is John MacArthur, I look, I have a lot of love and respect. I've been a fan of John MacArthur for a long time, but he does I do disagree with a lot of things he says, he says because he does come from a very Calvinistic perspective on things. And you know, this is one of the few areas where I would actually agree with the Catholic Church, where the Catholic Church actually says they actually value the tradition. of the church as much as they value the Bible. And I'm not saying I think that that's right. What I'm saying is I appreciate the fact that they don't just read the Bible in a vacuum and that they actually read it through a lens of understanding that has been passed down. Now a lot of disagreements with the Catholic Church in the way in the lens that they put on the Bible. And I definitely don't think and I definitely don't think the Bible is equal to tradition. However, I do 100% agree that Pj Verdin: Right. Randy: You can't just let the Bible stand alone in a vacuum, which is what John MacArthur would say. That we have to not become the choosers ourselves and determine which law do we follow. We have to understand the whole picture. And the Bible makes it very clear that the old covenant was a shadow. It was a shadow of what was to come. So now we have what was to come. We got to focus on what was to come. So it's not us choosing between the old covenant and the new covenant and between, you know, Deuteronomy and between, you know, Acts or between, you know, Matthew. It's the Bible telling us that those things have been completed. They serve their purpose. They're done. And now we have, you know, very clear direction on what we're supposed to do. And it's people like John MacArthur that just refuses to see that. With all due respect to John MacArthur, he still does not see that. Pj Verdin: No. Man, yeah. Randy: All right, one more video from Andy Stanley. so I misspoke earlier. It wasn't Rick Warren who had the LGBTQ summit. It was Andy Stanley. Let's see if there's anything else on that. Atlanta. Andy has also pioneered North Point TV, a Christian television network. I don't think that's gonna give us no idea what Andy Stanley is hoping to accomplish in this clip. This is why so many pastors and this drives me nuts. This is why so many pastors talk Then Christlike. Big difference. Andy might be the only pastor in the world who says So okay, so I'll stop it there. So there's a couple clips on Andy Stanley. What I liked about him was in a lot of ways I seen him focusing on the new covenant. but he does seem like some of his teachings might actually be in alignment with the general population of of churches, not the mega church pastors that focus on the prosperity gospel, but just the kind of the blending of the covenants. Pj Verdin: I in in my humble opinion, I think it's it's hard to become a a a mega church pastor unless you're somewhat of a people pleaser. And we know that the the temperature of the society that we're in right now is just you know, you have those those who who lean more towards that that way of thinking. So Randy: Yeah. So that's that's all I had to share on, you know, the the rest of our top ten list, brother. So let's see, we talked about today we talked about T Djakes, Jesse Duplanis, Rick Warren and Andy Stanley. So we covered the last four that we wanted to talk about essentially, and it does seem like Rick Warren and Andy Stanley are a lot different. Pj Verdin: Yeah. And and and look, I I would just say this, just for anybody who's been wondering since we're talking about, you know, mega churches and and these all these these famous pastors and you know, their networks and all the things, like we can't not talk about Billy Graham, right? You you you can't. He's he's probably notably one of the the most famous pastors, preachers to ever have lived. s you know, like of our generation, obviously aside from Jesus and the apostles, i i is what I mean there. But but yeah, I guess technically he wasn't a mega church pastor, right? He I I don't know if if that was he he was alive and and and going before that was really a thing. I I I would wanna say, you know what I mean? but yeah, I mean he there is a lot of good stuff out there about him. very well known, did a lot of lot of good work, preaching gospel all over the place. And, you know, for the most part I I I do say that I can align with a lot of his views and a lot of the ways that that he preached. so yeah, I just wanted to note that. another thing that I'd like to note is now that we've we've kind of gone through, you know, what these mega churches look like, who their pastors are, what are they preaching there, what's the some kind of some of the the theology and and and stuff that they they believe and they teach. you know, noting somebody that's nowhere near on this list, but that I would highly encourage every one of you to to spend some time listening to and and and and and allowing, you know, j just hearing the messages that he shares, which if if y'all been keeping up with the show, Randy did a solo episode on them, Pastor Andrew Farley. because I I would I will tell you this, man, I I've been You know, since since that episode, I've been kind of looking into to him and and and you know the message that he shares. And I can tell you in my walk, it's it's been it's been phenomenal. It's like man, I I feel like a fire's been reignited. I feel like I'm rereading scripture for the first time. It it's so much louder and and and more profound and and and And uplifting and joyful and peaceful and confident. Like it's just it's all the things that you would expect the gospel to be. that I I'd never really experienced in that way before, even though like I, you know, though don't get me wrong, there's times where I've read my Bible and and certain passages that I hadn't, you know, paid attention to were stuck out a little bit more, but but but not in this way, man. And and in that same vein, I I I would say something that I I read this week. That just like, man, it hit me like a ton of bricks. is in Colossians. I I think it's Colossians two. and I mean that whole chapter i is is great. But I'll just I'll just start here in verse 13, if you don't mind. And and I'll just I wanna say this like it's it it it's it's the end of it that really caught caught me because I'm like, here we are. I feel like kind of holding ourselves or or feeling like We're we're allowed we allow ourselves to be held to this standard, which which I kind of feel like this this addresses a little bit. Randy: you Pj Verdin: So so yeah, obviously this is on Bible Gateway. And and and so this is the NIV version, which I I I I read it in in King James, but this is fine. So here you got it. When you were dead in your sins and in the ear uncircumcision of your flesh, God made you alive with Christ. He forgave us all our sins. Randy: Bible gateway. Yep. All right. Pj Verdin: Having cancelled the charge of our legal indebtness, which stood against us and condemned us, he has taken it away, nailing it to the cross. And having disarmed the powers and authorities, he made a public spectacle of them, triumphing, triumphing over them on the cross. Therefore, do not let anyone judge you by what you eat or drink, or with regard to a religious festival, a new moon celebration, or a Sabbath day. These are a shadow of the things that were to come. The reality, however, is found in Christ. Do not let anyone who delights in false humility and the worship of angels disqualify you. Such a person also goes into great detail about what they have seen. They are puffed up with idle notions by their unspiritual mind. They have lost connection with the head, from whom the whole body, supported and held together by its ligaments and sinews, grows as God causes it to grow. And so I'll just stop there, because I mean I feel like That's a lot to to sit in and and resonate with and it Randy: So what did so what did that speak to you when you read that this week? Pj Verdin: It it it just showed me that we do just that. Therefore do not let anybody judge you for you know what you eat, drink, don't you know, all your sins have been nailed to the cross. But what do we do? We beat ourselves up for the things that we we we feel like we don't get right, or or you know, like it it just like a and it's all according to what it's gonna look like to other people, right? It's like, man, if if somebody sees me still struggling with this after, you know, X amount of years in this walk. Randy: Uh-huh. Pj Verdin: Then they're just gonna look at me and be like, this dude, he just don't get it. He's not he he's not gonna get it. And and and it's like it's like adding weights to our feet and into our hands. And I'm like, man, like w why do we allow like it's just it's telling you right here, like don't let these these type of people judge you. Like I it's me. And I just told you, like, I've I've canceled the charge of of your your debt. Like, you know, I everything's been nailed to the cross, you know, and and and to me, you're you're Randy: Yeah. Yep. Yep. Pj Verdin: You're made whole. You're you're made alive in Christ. So why are you allowing people to make you feel like you're dead still? You're letting you're letting people. And and I like I like in in the New King James Version, it's because it specifically said like basically like man-made things. Like it's it here it is saying, like, look, this is what God did for you through Jesus Christ. And here you are with these like these these these rules of man, basically. Let me see what what's the actual word. Randy: Right. Pj Verdin: And so yeah, man, it just like I I I saw that and I just man, it stuck out to me like it just like you would not believe it. And I I guess it's because, you know, I I really have been looking at things more through the the lens of of the grace message, the new covenant focused message where, you know, everything's weighed against against that scale, man. and and it's it's been Randy: What I'm just curious, does that Bible gateway does that have the NASB version? Can you switch over to that? And the reason why I say that is because that's the version that Andrew Farley uses. And so I've been reading that one more because I do think that you know, we've talked about this before. You know, there have, you know, slight slight differences in translations do make sometimes the scriptures say Pj Verdin: And Randy: slightly different things that you know are important. And in in in in my opinion, the different translations don't necessarily come from errors as much as it maybe comes from assumptions. And like when's you know when the interpretation is happening, you know, assuming that the word that's being interpreted means something when it actually has multiple meanings. So I this version is a is a different version that I think it probably is not a lot different, but it it It might add more clarity. Pj Verdin: I got you. So I mean I'll I'll start here and reread, and this is the the NASB. It says, And when you were dead in your wrongdoings and the uncircumcision of your flesh, he made you alive together with him, having forgive us all our wrongdoings, having cancelled the certificate of death consisting of decrees against us, which was hostile to us, and he has taken it out of the way, having nailed it to the cross. When he had disarmed the rulers and authorities, he made a public display of them. Randy: Mm-hmm. Pj Verdin: a public display of them, having triumphed over them through him. Therefore, no one is to act as your judge in regard to food and drink or in respect to a festival or new moon or a Sabbath day. Things which are only a shadow of what is to come, but the substance belongs to Christ. Take care that no one keeps defrauding you of your prize by delighting in humility and worship of the angels, taking his stand on visions he has seen inflated without cause by his fleshly mind and not holding firmly to the head, from whom the entire body being supplied and held together by the joints and ligaments grows with the growth which comes from God. So yeah man it's just Randy: Yeah. Any did you d was there anything anything that was different in this version that jumped out at you? Pj Verdin: I mean, I i i not not necessarily. I I do I I do kinda like how it it says, th this is I I feel like this happens all the time and especially, you know, unfortunately in in the pulpit. Take care that no one keeps defrauding you of your prize by delighting in in humility and the worship of the angels, taking his stand on visions he has seen inflated without cause it inflated without cause by his fleshly mind. Like that's I'm like, man. Randy: Mm-hmm. Pj Verdin: You know, I can Randy: Yeah. I I yeah, I I don't I I didn't see anything that was like dramatically different, but but just you know, the message that I'm hearing from this is basically, you know, pretty simple. It's basically saying, look, you're st there's people out there who are still getting hung up on the shadow. You got the real thing now and you're still focusing on the shadow. you know, the sh I matter of fact I heard Andrew Farley use this analogy this just this past week. He's like, you got you got Jesus walking around the corner and you see a shadow on the ground before he gets there and you're trying to hug the shadow. Meanwhile, he's walking around the corner. It's like it makes no sense, especially when he's already walked around the corner and now he's there. Why would you still focus on the shadow? And that's exactly what we do when we focus on these rituals and ceremonies and all these new these things under the old covenant. And when it mentions the angels there and worshiping of angels, I don't know if it's talking about sacrifices because we know, you know In other parts of the Bible, you know, it it's a big deal eating meat sacrificed to false gods because in some cases those false gods are actually real fallen angels that they're sacrificing to. So I don't know if it that's the reference, but we we know what he says there. He says the same thing. He's like, basically, don't let anyone judge you for eating that meat either. Pj Verdin: Well well. Right. And and look, man, I you know what, I should've and I don't know why I I do this, I I guess. but let me let me reshare this and and I'm just gonna finish this out because I mean it it is it's just in my opinion, it's that good, man. It it's it's worth worth the share. So so you know, ligaments grows with growth, which is from God. If you have died with Christ to the elementary principles of the world, why, as if you were living in the world, do you submit yourself to the To the decrees such as do not handle, do not taste, do not touch, which all refer to things destined to perish with use, in accordance with the commandments and teachings of man. These are matters which do not have the appearance of wisdom and self-made religion and humility and severe treatment of the body, but are of no value against fleshly indulgence. So like that I I I guess that's the part that I remember. It's like here here here's all this the this evidence. Christ is is the evidence that that he is enough. Jesus plus nothing. He did it all. There's nothing that you can do. So why is it that you're allowing your relationship with him to suffer because of of the the teachings of man? You're gonna let a man tell you, and and it to me it goes right back to the same thing. You have Jesus himself saying, you know, my I my sacrifice paid it all sufficient. And and through that, you can receive grace through your faith, right? That's it. And then that that's like God saying, Hey, do not eat of this sh fruit, for the day you do, you'll surely die. And then man comes over here and says, No, man, you still gotta do all kinds of things. You know, you gotta you gotta make sure you and it's like, well, okay, I'm gonna you know what that that does sound more in alignment with my fleshly mind. So I'm gonna do that instead of what Jesus said. And it's like repeating the same cycle all over again. Randy: Right. Well, so I think this is the perfect w conversation in in concluding our discussion of mega church and mega church pastors. Because if you remember previously we talked about we talked about Stephen and what Stephen was martyred for, right? Well, the Jews accused Jesus of the same thing. They basically said, look, if we just let this guy go on Doing what he's doing, there's not gonna be any need for us. There's not gonna be any need for the temple. There's not gonna be any need for the priests, for the Levites, for the rabbis. Then, you know, what did they accuse Stephen of? Basically the same thing. They accused him of saying, Hey, like we don't need to be going to temple. We don't need to be sacrificing these animals anymore. Jesus, you know, sacrificed, paid it all. So what were they concerned about? The same thing these pastors are concerned about, they were concerned about their jobs. The Pharisees, the Sadducees, the Levites, the rabbis, they were concerned about their jobs. They rejected the Messiah because it was gonna hurt their job and their income. And, you know, these megachurch pastors out here preaching this prosperity gospel, they don't wanna preach the truth. They don't want to preach the true simplicity of the new covenant and the fact that our yoke is easy and our burden is light, you know, in in Jesus because that hurts their bottom line, that hurts their bottom dollar. And so there's a big similarity there between these megachurch pastors that are preaching this prosperity gospel and challenge God with your tithing and then he'll owe you. You know, he'll owe you like a business partner. You know, if you just if you just you know create that debt, build up this debt where God owes you, and then he's gonna have to bless you. And if you just speak it, then health is gonna come looking for you, and wealth is gonna come looking for you. Pj Verdin: That's wow. That's wow. Randy: And if you don't have food to in to eat and you can't buy school supplies for your kids, you better make sure that you tithe. You still better make sure that you tithe. And this is the kind of stuff that we reviewed over these three, these three episodes, looking at this top 10. And it's just so contrary to what we actually see in the gospel and and and from you know the new the perspective of the new covenant. And so I'm glad you brought this up. Pj Verdin: Yeah. Randy: And I'm glad you brought up Andrew Farley. The only other thing I would say is also check out Aaron Budgeon, who is the person who actually first introduced me to the concept of the new covenant. those are two really good pastors that are very unique. But I think for the vast majority of Christians who really do have the spirit of God inside of them, they're gonna discern that when they listen to these two, that they're speaking the truth. Pj Verdin: Well, and and here's s something that I just wanted to note, going back to you know, your reference to T D. Jakes thing. make I'm gonna make God owe me. You know, that's the same mentality that is so dangerous that you know, the verse of the Bible that everybody's so afraid of, you know, whenever Jesus talking about on that day, people are gonna come to and they're gonna say, Lord, Lord, I did all these things in your name and he's gonna say, Depart from me, I never knew you. Well, i i if you get into the the The deeper side of that is because that's exactly what Jesus is saying. Like you're coming in here acting like you have a claim to heaven because of what you've done. Like I don't owe you nothing. So having this mentality of like I'm gonna tithe until God owes me. God don't know, God gave you what you have. You're just stewarding stewarding it. How can God ever owe you anything? To have that kind of mentality is not only absurd, but I I would say that that's closer to heresy. Randy: Yeah, yeah. Pj Verdin: Then then it are just as close as anything else. Like come on, man. God owes you. The the whole fact is. Randy: Right? Yeah. A hundred percent comes a hundred percent comes from God. We give him the ten percent, but he owes us if we give him eleven. Pj Verdin: Right. Yeah, man. And it's and it's ridiculous. And the whole point of the gospel is that we don't deserve anything but hell, death and hell. And Jesus said, You're not getting that because I love you too much. All you you know what I mean? So it's it's just wild, man. I'm sorry. That that was just it just it's it's it's so wild to see these things, you know, and and then that's the thing. You you're you'll have somebody out there who who will take this gospel, actually make you good news, make Randy: Yeah. Pj Verdin: in alignment it it it causes your yoke to be easy and your burden to be light and people will be like no no they they can't be talking about this stuff it's it's it's that's heresy or they're they're you know what what's the word that I'm I'm looking for, you know, they're they're corrupt in the gospel. I don't it's it's dangerous, yeah. Yeah, it is. It is. And it is dangerous in the best way. Randy: It's dangerous. It's a dangerous gospel. Yeah. Any anytime you anytime you actually, you know, believe what Jesus said, that that his yoke is easy, his burden is light, and that the work is to believe, and that we're called to rest. And you actually believe those things, then you're you're you're being accused of, you know, preaching something that's dangerous, giving people a license, you know, all these different things, man. You know, it's e easy believism. Well, didn't Jesus say it was gonna be easy? Yeah, I mean, it's it's all those things, but at the end of the day, I'd rather listen to pastors like Aaron Budgeon and Andrew Farley. those would be the only two, honestly, that I would recommend. Now, not to say that there aren't others who align with them, but they're the only two that I've found to this point in my walk that I tend to agree with 90 plus percentage of the time. And it's mainly because They do fully understand and teach the new covenant. Pj Verdin: Amen. Amen. Randy: Amen. All right, man. Well, hey, I think with that that about does it. You got anything else? Pj Verdin: no, I I would do just like to say, listen, if y'all y'all been following the show and y'all made it this far and you have not subscribed, man, y'all don't know how much of a blessing that is to not only us, but but to other people who may be reached by the the the message and and the conversations and and starting their own conversation. So if you haven't subscribed, I know sometimes it's easy to forget, just hit that subscribe button. Randy: Yeah, I agree. Definitely subscribe if you haven't already. leave us a comment, even if it's just one word. Just give us the first word that comes to mind when you listen to this episode. yeah. And thank you guys so much for following the show. God bless. Pj Verdin: God bless. Randy: Alright man, we gotta get this uploaded.