Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Use Insider Sales Without Tanking the Stock
Transcript
- Lucas: If these conversations are useful for what you're building or running, there's a small way to keep them ad-free and independent. Luna: Yeah, it's literally a couple of dollars a month. Makes a real difference. Lucas: Buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo — that's it. No pressure, just if you've gotten something out of the show. Luna: Exactly. Alright, so we talk a lot about lockup expirations and secondary offerings, but today I want to get into the actual mechanics of how insiders sell without crashing the stock. Lucas: Great angle. Because the perception is always that insider selling is a signal of doom. But the reality is far more nuanced. Just last week, Airbnb — ticker a b n b — had a secondary offering where existing shareholders sold about 13 million shares. Luna: Right, and the stock barely moved. It was down like two percent on the day, then recovered within a week. Lucas: Exactly. That's not an accident. When you're a post ipo company with a large insider base — founders, early employees, VCs — you have to plan this stuff like a military operation. The key tool is Rule 10b5-1 trading plans. Luna: Those are the pre-arranged plans where insiders commit to selling at certain times or prices, right? So they can't be accused of trading on inside information. Lucas: Right. But the strategic layer is how you layer them. A well-designed plan has multiple tranches, spaced out over quarters, often with volume limits. So you're not dumping 500,000 shares in one day. Luna: And the company itself often coordinates this. I remember reading that Palantir — ticker P-L-T-R — which trades around 128 dollars today, had a massive lockup expiration last year. They worked with underwriters to structure a block trade. Lucas: Block trade is exactly the mechanism. The company or a selling shareholder hires an investment bank to buy the entire block of shares at a discount — typically two to four percent — and then the bank sells them into the market over days or weeks. That absorbs the supply shock. Luna: So instead of the market seeing a sell order for a million shares at once, the underwriter dribbles it out. The stock never sees the full pressure. Lucas: Right. And there's another subtle tactic: timing around earnings. Most companies have blackout periods where insiders can't trade — typically the 30 days before earnings. So you see a lot of 10b5-1 plans that execute in the window right after earnings, when liquidity is highest and volatility is lower. Luna: Because everyone's just processed the news. The stock has already adjusted to whatever the quarter showed. Lucas: Precisely. And the smartest companies do what's called a 'blended' approach: they have the company itself do a buyback at the same time. So while insiders are selling, the company is buying. That sends a powerful signal that the selling isn't about lack of confidence. Luna: That's a great point. I remember Apple doing that back in the day — massive buybacks while insiders were selling. But for a post ipo company, cash is tighter. Lucas: Right, so they use other tools. One is the 'accelerated share repurchase' — they borrow money to do a big buyback all at once. Another is using the proceeds from the secondary offering itself. Some companies structure the secondary so that the company sells new shares, not just existing ones, and uses the cash to fund operations. Luna: That's actually dilutive, though. You're issuing new shares, so existing shareholders get diluted. But if the cash is used for growth, the market often rewards it. Lucas: Right. The market is surprisingly rational about this. Look at Shopify — ticker s h o p — which trades around 109 dollars. They did a secondary offering in 2021 that was a mix of insider selling and new shares. The stock didn't crater because investors believed the cash would fuel expansion. Luna: So the key is communication. You have to tell the story: why are insiders selling? Is it diversification? Tax planning? Or is it because they see the end of the road? Lucas: Exactly. And that's where the narrative on earnings calls matters. A lot of CEOs will say 'our founders are selling a small portion of their holdings for estate planning' — that's a signal that the selling is pre-planned and not opportunistic. Luna: But what about the red flags? What should a retail investor look for? Lucas: First, look at the volume relative to the average. If an insider sells more than 20 percent of their holdings in one quarter, that's a yellow flag. Second, look at the price. If they're selling at the peak of a huge run-up, that's more concerning than selling after a dip. Luna: And the pattern: if multiple insiders are selling at the same time, that's different from just one. A coordinated selling program is usually pre-planned. But if the CFO and the CEO both file unexpected sales within a week of each other, that's worth digging into. Lucas: Yeah. And the timing relative to news. If an insider sells right before a big earnings miss, that's obviously illegal if they had knowledge. But you see that pattern sometimes with 'accidental' timing — which is why the SEC has been cracking down on 10b5-1 plan abuses. Luna: There was a big rule change in 2022, right? The SEC mandated a cooling-off period of 90 days for 10b5-1 plans for corporate insiders. Lucas: Right. Before that, an insider could adopt a plan and sell the next day. Now they have to wait 90 days before the first trade. That has actually reduced the number of opportunistic plans. Luna: So overall, it sounds like insider selling is less of a signal and more of a logistical puzzle. The companies that do it well barely make news. Lucas: Exactly. And the ones that do it poorly — like WeWork, or Nikola — they become case studies in how not to manage the process. The difference is all in the planning. Luna: Alright, so practical takeaway: if you see an insider sale, don't panic. Check if it's part of a 10b5-1 plan, check the volume, and see if the company is doing a buyback at the same time. Lucas: And check the narrative on the last earnings call. If management talked about 'liquidity for founders' or 'estate planning', that sale was likely telegraphed. If it came out of nowhere, that's when you ask questions. Luna: Thanks, Lucas. Good stuff.