Latest / The Bitcoin Way Podcast / $1M Bitcoin Is Already Locked In | Nik Bhatia
Transcript
- 0:00I think Bitcoin is going to a million dollars in the 2030s simply by the passage of time.
- 0:05Besides something more extreme like a 6102 attack, what are the other risks at play for something like this?
- 0:12It's not a coincidence that Fidelity and BlackRock have 1 to 3% target allocations for Bitcoin in multi-asset portfolios.
- 0:20And now suddenly it's not 8 billion people who need access to better money.
- 0:25It's 8 billion people plus humanoid bots or whatever it ends up looking like.
- 0:29Things don't grow linearly. They grow in this power law relationship.
- 0:34What the mathematicians have observed about Bitcoin is that...
- 0:46Today on the show, I have Nick Bhatia. Nick is an awesome guy and a wealth of knowledge.
- 0:52We talk about MicroStrategy, Strategy, Sailor, all of the stacking, the capital raising that
- 0:57they're doing, what it means for Bitcoin. We dive into some macroeconomic trends he's watching.
- 1:02And of course, we have to touch on AI. He has a very interesting thesis on how AI is going to
- 1:07impact Bitcoin. And he's got some good unpopular opinions at the end. So stick around for that.
- 1:12You're going to really enjoy the show. Hey, everyone. Like I said in the intro,
- 1:15I have Nick here. Nick, welcome to the Bitcoin Way podcast.
- 1:19Hey, Michael. Great to be here.
- 1:20Let's talk about strategy. Everyone's talking about it at this moment,
- 1:23the capital accumulation, the Bitcoin that they're buying, their stretch product in particular
- 1:29is sort of the hot topic. Would you share your assessment of what is going on? How does this
- 1:36work? And the thing I'm particularly curious about is, do you view this as people waking up
- 1:43to the power of Bitcoin versus things like government bonds as a means of fixed income?
- 1:49Is this like the new retirement vehicle, the new fixed income vehicle that people are going to start flocking to?
- 1:55It's a great question, Michael.
- 1:56And actually, it was the number one question that I got last summer on my book tour when I went to D.C., New York, Chicago and San Francisco.
- 2:06The number one thing people wanted to know was, is STRC specifically the new government bond, the new risk free rate?
- 2:17So I'll give you my answer then.
- 2:19And now. My answer then was definitely not yet, because if it was, you would see these yields
- 2:30start to converge. That's what arbitrage does, is you sell one thing and you buy the other
- 2:36because you believe that they're of equal value. So you try to capture that spread.
- 2:42And that arbitrage trade drives yields together. It compresses them. We haven't seen that for the
- 2:49last year or since the summer, last summer when I was telling people that. So from that perspective,
- 2:55I feel comfortable in that answer. It's not really behaviorally driving that shift from
- 3:03government bonds to STRC. With that being said, there's something really special about strategy
- 3:10and STRC and what's happening there. And I think that there is a marginal awareness
- 3:17of what people can achieve with STRC versus government bonds and the risk that they perceive
- 3:27that they are taking. That's really the key because the world views government bonds or
- 3:32US treasuries as risk-free. You can put it in air quotes or not. It doesn't really matter.
- 3:39It is the risk-free instrument of the dollar world, nominally speaking, which means you're
- 3:44always going to get your money back that is stated on the security that you're buying.
- 3:50Now, the certainty in STRC is definitely less. People don't buy STRC thinking 100%,
- 4:00I'm going to get this coupon and par back. They know that they're taking a risk beyond government
- 4:06bonds. That risk, though, that they're taking is awarding them a compensation that is outsized
- 4:15right now. Outsized meaning that it's more than really any yield that you can get in any safe
- 4:22bond. And that is what is driving the capital toward STRC. The volume numbers, the accumulation
- 4:29numbers, they're monstrous. So there is awareness there that the risk that they're taking
- 4:37is being more than compensated for with that huge yield.
- 4:42Could you describe what the risks are? Obviously, strategy doesn't, technically speaking,
- 4:47at least have a money printer. And so they cannot guarantee the nominal returns that
- 4:52government bonds can. Besides something more extreme like a 6102 attack and the government
- 4:58says, we're taking all your Bitcoin strategy, which, by the way, nothing would surprise me
- 5:04from the federal government at this point. But aside from something like that, what are the other
- 5:08risks at play for something like this? And why might people not be driven to something like
- 5:13Stretch? It does come down to the Bitcoin price and the math around its maturity schedule on its
- 5:20securities. So when a company takes in money, they're either issuing equity or they're issuing
- 5:25debt, the equity or preferred equity. So I think that that's an important asterisk. But the equity
- 5:32doesn't have a maturity. The preferred equity doesn't have a maturity. It means you don't have
- 5:37to pay the money back. The debt side of things, those all have a maturity. So when they borrow
- 5:42money in the debt market, there is a maturity date and they're going to have to pay back US dollars.
- 5:47So the risk in owning parts of the strategy capital stack are if you buy the equity, it's not whether you'll be paid back, it's whether that equity is worth anything in the future.
- 6:03And that's going to be tied to the Bitcoin price.
- 6:06If you buy the debt, your risk is that the US dollars are not there to pay you back when that instrument matures.
- 6:14That is also going to be a function of the Bitcoin price.
- 6:20So their ability to either issue at the money equity to buy Bitcoin or any cash flow dynamics
- 6:30that they have.
- 6:30So there is a risk.
- 6:32There's always a risk for the investors in the equity or the debt.
- 6:36Is the company going to pay me back?
- 6:38And if I own equity, is that equity worth anything after all the debt is paid back?
- 6:44And with strategy specifically, that is all based off of the value of their Bitcoin. And not just the value, but the energy around the Bitcoin asset class, because their ability to issue equity to buy Bitcoin in the spot market is dependent on the market.
- 7:05So energy, bullish energy, interest in the market, and all of that. So the risk is that Bitcoin goes down, stays down, and loses investor interest. In that case, it's likely that owners up and down the stack of strategy will get taken out at a loss that's maybe more than if Bitcoin went down, let's say, 75% and stayed there for five years.
- 7:31If you own Bitcoin, you'll be down 75%. If you own parts of strategy stack, you'll probably be wiped out 90% or taken out. So the risk is obvious in that it's tied to Bitcoin. And it doesn't have the same risk as Bitcoin because you're owning a company that owns Bitcoin or is promising coupons based off of Bitcoin performance one way or the other.
- 7:59So I hate to put you on the spot like this, but if you were to pull out a crystal ball and look five years into the future and you're looking at U.S. national debt is probably at that point well into the 40 trillions.
- 8:14I have to imagine that this risk-free rate that we take for granted today, or that many investors take for granted today, is – I think at some point, the can is no longer kicked forever.
- 8:27And people do begin to be wary of, I need real returns, not nominal returns.
- 8:32Do you think the landscape of what we're discussing right now changes immensely?
- 8:36Do you think strategy does become, or maybe their STRC product or whatever else they've engineered at that point becomes maybe more influential and you do see those yields converge?
- 8:49How do you anticipate this playing out over just the coming years?
- 8:53Well, I do see STRC's yield coming down nominally because I think the perceived risk will decline over time.
- 9:00So I do see the yield going down.
- 9:03But on the Treasury front, the U.S. Treasury front, I really do have a different view on the absolute value of Treasuries in today's world and even over the next 5 to 10 years as debt goes to $40 and even $50 trillion and beyond.
- 9:21It really does come down to, Michael, the delta between the size of the Treasury market and the size of global debt.
- 9:28Right now, the size of global debt, $350 trillion.
- 9:32The size of US Treasury debt, $39 trillion. And a lot of it isn't even marketable debt. So let's call it less than 10% of global debt is Treasury debt. That means 90% of global debt is not US Treasuries.
- 9:49So that balance of 10 to 1 or 10% or 90% in less than treasury quality fixed income assets, because every debt is also somebody else's asset.
- 10:04It does start to make sense why treasuries are so valued, why they're not 5%, 6%, 7% yield, why they're not close to the yields of emerging market government bonds.
- 10:19And they do keep interest rates on the US dollar borrowing universe low because if you
- 10:30didn't have all that risky debt available, you would flood into treasuries.
- 10:37And so there's always an embedded bid in the market for treasuries because the things
- 10:46that can go wrong in the 90% are infinite compared to things that can go wrong for the treasury,
- 10:54which can print its own money. Like you said, yes, people need real yield. I understand that.
- 10:59But that doesn't mean that the nominal yield of treasuries will rise necessarily to give people
- 11:07that real yield. In fact, what we have seen during the 2010s was negative real yields.
- 11:14and what you might continue to see or what you might see again are negative real yields.
- 11:21So let's say inflation goes back to 3.5%, 4%.
- 11:25The front end of the curve is at 3.5% right now, more or less.
- 11:30So you're going to be getting possibly negative real yields again
- 11:36here in the United States sometime in the next couple of years, possibly.
- 11:40As an American and someone who's not analyzing the macro picture at large,
- 11:44I tend to just see these numbers of $37, $38, $39 trillion and think, why does anyone have any
- 11:53faith in any of this? And that question for me still remains. I mean, that's how I found Bitcoin
- 11:58is beginning to understand some of how this works. But I can see why US debt still looks attractive
- 12:04to many people who do not have the conviction in Bitcoin. They don't even know that Bitcoin is
- 12:10something that might fix a problem that they have. And so maybe until then, until the Bitcoin
- 12:16conversation at least becomes ubiquitous, that people are analyzing it as a form of money,
- 12:22as an alternative, as an opt-out, as whatever you perceive it to be. Will there come a day then,
- 12:28in some near future perhaps, where then it's not even strategy versus US debt.
- 12:36But it's I can have the real risk free rate is just the appreciation of Bitcoin, because
- 12:42there is no there's no I can't be printed.
- 12:48I can't be seized.
- 12:49Right.
- 12:49We've seen the weaponization of U.S. debt, all of these things.
- 12:53Is that a conversation that you think is going to start becoming more mainstream, where at
- 12:58the moment it feels like we're talking about this on Bitcoin podcasts and on Bitcoin Twitter?
- 13:02Yes. And I would answer your question by asking you, you referenced $39 trillion and who would
- 13:10own it. So let me ask you a question. You have three options. You have to buy something and hold
- 13:16it for 30 years. You can't sell it. You have a 30-year US treasury, you have the S&P 500,
- 13:23and you have Bitcoin. So let's start with the S&P 500 versus the 30-year treasury.
- 13:28and you step into the shoes of a life insurer.
- 13:31So they have death benefits 30 years from now.
- 13:35They can either buy stocks or they can buy treasuries.
- 13:39As a risk manager, you cannot put 100% of your money in stocks.
- 13:48You can't because there's too much risk to do that.
- 13:54So you have to balance with some stocks and some treasuries.
- 13:59You're forced into that decision because of risk.
- 14:02And part of the risk of owning the treasuries is that the real return is negative or zero,
- 14:11that you don't actually get any return beyond inflation.
- 14:15That is a real risk, and that's why you have to buy some stocks.
- 14:19You can't put 100% in treasuries.
- 14:21That shows you that there is a balance there.
- 14:24And both are needed for long-term capital allocators.
- 14:28This is called Asset Liability Management, ALM, or Liability Driven Investing, LDI.
- 14:34These are insurance players and pensions.
- 14:36They buy a ton of treasuries, long-term treasuries.
- 14:40They are the natural buyer, and they are not going anywhere.
- 14:44So now you fold in Bitcoin and you ask mom and pop or life insurer,
- 14:51hey, you ask them the same question.
- 14:53Would you own 30 treasury stocks or would you own Bitcoin And that where Bitcoin becomes more and more obvious is that if you not a life insurer with a guaranteed liability in 30 to 40 years
- 15:11that reduces your need to balance your portfolio with treasuries.
- 15:16Right. And so what is Bitcoin competing with? Over a 30-year time horizon, is it competing with
- 15:25a 30-year treasury or is it competing with the S&P 500? And that's where the question starts to get
- 15:31interesting. And I think that it's a little bit of both, but it's definitely the 30-year treasury,
- 15:38which I think is what you were originally thinking about is that how could I buy a 30-year treasury?
- 15:45me as a 30-year-old person. That doesn't make any sense for me. And I think that question is
- 15:53being answered in a similar way. All around the world, the ETF inflows are evidence of this,
- 16:01that long-term capital is ready to come in, buy Bitcoin, park it there, and understand why it's
- 16:10part of, it's not a coincidence that Fidelity and BlackRock have 1% to 3% target allocations for
- 16:17Bitcoin in multi-asset portfolios. That's insane versus where we were five to 10 years ago before
- 16:25ETFs. Now it's like, yeah, if you have a global portfolio, up to 3% should be in Bitcoin.
- 16:30That's an enormous amount. And River just did a study where they actually compared that target
- 16:37allocation to how much is actually invested. And I can't remember the number, but there's like 400x
- 16:44capital that needs to come into Bitcoin to get it there. Like an insane amount of money that needs
- 16:49to flow into Bitcoin to just get the target allocation to a place where a balanced portfolio
- 16:57is weighing the pros and cons of 30-year treasury stocks and Bitcoin appropriately.
- 17:05That process, they've identified the target allocation, I think, well, like zero is not the right answer. 1% is probably too low. So you don't need them to come out and say 5% to 10%. That will happen naturally over time. But just getting them to say 3% gets people off of zero and gets them above one. They're not at one yet. They're really not at 1%. The world is not at 1% yet, Bitcoin.
- 17:31If you look at global balance sheet studies and wealth studies, the numbers are somewhere between $600 and $1,200 trillion in global wealth.
- 17:47So that's maybe up to $1 quadrillion in global wealth.
- 17:53Bitcoin is $1.7 trillion, right?
- 17:56So less than 1,500th.
- 17:59Going from 1 500th to 1 100th, it's five times the capital that's already in there.
- 18:08And Bitcoin really has an enormous room to grow in terms of the capital that's in other
- 18:15asset classes finding its way.
- 18:17What is going to be required then to take us from 1 500th of global wealth to 1 100th?
- 18:26Is it just people tuning into our podcast, reading your newsletter?
- 18:30Is there a, and this is maybe where I get into sort of our next topic.
- 18:34Is it a macro event that unfolds where people recognize the necessity for sound money, for
- 18:42something that's censorship resistant?
- 18:45They don't need permission to use.
- 18:46Like, what do you think the catalyst is?
- 18:48It's a great question.
- 18:49I would actually argue that a macro event is low on my probability in terms of what will drive it.
- 18:58So I think that things happen naturally and slowly and not triggered by a macro event.
- 19:06So my answer to your question is time.
- 19:10And I'll fold in the fact that we're doing this podcast together in a second.
- 19:14Because that's part of it, but it's actually downstream from the time and the answer that I'm about to give you.
- 19:23So maybe people have heard of the idea of Bitcoin following a power law.
- 19:28So let me explain to people what this means.
- 19:32When something grows, whether it's an organism or a city, when it grows, it's going to follow a growth path.
- 19:46So the pace of growth.
- 19:48And when things grow on this planet, they don't grow linearly.
- 19:55And here's one way to think of that.
- 19:57If a mouse requires 100 calories a day and an elephant is a thousand times the size of the mouse and it was a linear relationship, that would mean that the elephant requires 1,000 the amount of calories that the mouse does.
- 20:21But it doesn't.
- 20:22It's only 100.
- 20:25The numbers are an approximate.
- 20:26I mean, not even approximation, I'm using arbitrary numbers, but the point stands here.
- 20:32And I do actually believe it's 10,000.
- 20:35The elephant is 10,000 times the mass of the mouse, but it only needs 1,000 times the amount of calories.
- 20:42So it's nonlinear.
- 20:45And if you actually, I'm citing a book called Scale by Jeffrey West, if people want to get into the science of this.
- 20:53But if you plot mammals on this curve, this metabolic curve of mass versus calories required, you can see that it follows a power law relationship where the determinant, it's somewhere in an exponent.
- 21:10It's nonlinear.
- 21:11And that exponent can be above one or below one, basically sublinear or above linear scaling.
- 21:19So the amount of calories, it's sublinear in that you need less the quantity as the animal gets bigger.
- 21:30The mammals are efficient.
- 21:32They get more efficient as they grow.
- 21:34Now, let me give you another example, which is cities.
- 21:39So in cities, when the population grows by 10 times, the amount of university graduates, for example, grows by more than 10 times non-linearly, with an exponent above one.
- 22:00So why is it that when cities grow in size, they graduate even more people per hundred people or per thousand people? It's because knowledge collects and compounds in a city.
- 22:18where smart people come together and it makes everyone smarter and it grows at more than a
- 22:26one-to-one relationship in terms of the benefit to society. Now, homelessness also grows at
- 22:31more than one on the exponent there. So it's pros and cons, of course. So more college graduates,
- 22:41but more homelessness in bigger cities. So things don't grow linearly. They grow in this power law
- 22:49relationship naturally on earth. It's just something that we can observe. Now, what about
- 22:56Bitcoin? What the mathematicians have observed about Bitcoin is that as time passes, the number
- 23:04of addresses grows with a power law relationship and an exponent above one. So as time goes,
- 23:13the network grows, but even faster than the time that has passed. Because people love Bitcoin,
- 23:22they love to use it. They love to come to it. And so the network is growing. Not only is the
- 23:28network growing, but as the network grows, the price grows once again non-linearly in a power
- 23:38law relationship with an exponent above one. So what you have in Bitcoin is two power law
- 23:45relationships. As time passes, the network grows, and as the network grows, the value grows.
- 23:51And what we observe looking at 16 years of Bitcoin data is that this relationship, even though the price varies enormously, it is following a path.
- 24:05Now, some people will call this voodoo, modeling, pure theory, and that's fine. And it is backwards looking and projecting into the future. But I've been sold on this for at least a year. I've interviewed Dr. Stephen Perrineau and Dr. Giovanni Santastasi, two astrophysicists that have written extensively about the power law, the Bitcoin power law.
- 24:33I read Jeffrey West's book, Scale, because of them.
- 24:38And I'm sold.
- 24:39So now I'll answer your question.
- 24:42How does Bitcoin get there?
- 24:44It's simply the passage of time.
- 24:46And the fact that you and I are doing this pod is a result of that network growing and
- 24:51strengthening and value accruing to it.
- 24:53We are here because of that growth path, that it will continue to scale.
- 24:59The number of people that listen to this pod will be according to this moment in history
- 25:07relative to six months, 12 months ago, three years ago, five years ago, 10 years ago.
- 25:16So it might be less than six months ago because six months ago we were in a bull market and
- 25:21today we're not, but it's definitely more than three years ago when the ETFs were introduced
- 25:28And that's because more people have joined the network.
- 25:30There's ups and downs.
- 25:32There's overshoots and undershoots.
- 25:34The model isn't the fair value.
- 25:39It's a way to understand the growth path.
- 25:43Okay.
- 25:43So I think Bitcoin is going to a million dollars in the 2030s simply by the passage of time.
- 25:52and I'll just say one last thing,
- 25:56which is that the 16 years of data
- 25:58that make people conclude
- 26:01that Bitcoin is following a power law relationship,
- 26:04it's basically assuming that human beings
- 26:07have adopted this technology and it's here to stay.
- 26:11So that's why it's not a macro event per se,
- 26:14but just the macro environment that we're in
- 26:16has made Bitcoin be awarded this...
- 26:22new great asset class and growth path into the future that is highly unlikely to change
- 26:29through a massive change in human behavior all around the world.
- 26:35Governments getting disciplined, central banks not going on, you know, getting off fiat or,
- 26:40you know, everyone going on to a Bitcoin standard. In fact, not being on a Bitcoin standard for the
- 26:49world locks in the path of Bitcoin to keep growing in dollar terms versus the rest of the world.
- 26:56I think if Bitcoin became the standard today, government stopped using fiat or the credit
- 27:04system, that would abruptly change maybe the Bitcoin path. But I see the opposite. I see more
- 27:12of a steady growth path that's locked in because of the way that the world works.
- 27:19And it's not going to pivot suddenly to something different.
- 27:23So is there anything with the exception of an obvious and apparent break from that path
- 27:30that would make you reconsider that thesis?
- 27:32Because I'll be honest, I haven't studied the power law deeply.
- 27:35I've heard more and more folks like yourself who I respect and have learned a lot from
- 27:39who have been sold on this.
- 27:42And it does seem reasonable.
- 27:44I mean, sort of the crazy bull in me wants to imagine, no, we're going to 10 million by 2030 or whatever.
- 27:51But, you know, I'm open minded on what it could be.
- 27:54So I guess back to the question, is there anything besides like an obvious break from the path that you'd say, oh, you know what, maybe this model will be broken?
- 28:02I mean, of course, anything, anything can happen.
- 28:05And I think understanding what your expectation is, is important so that if it starts to go to, let's say, Bitcoin is at $400,000 next year.
- 28:22Then at that point, you have to wonder, okay, is this just another overshoot or have the fundamentals changed?
- 28:30You do the same thing when Bitcoin goes from $120,000 down to $60,000 earlier this year. You think, okay, is this just another overshoot? Or is Bitcoin broken? Is the quantum fund right? Is Claude going to break Bitcoin? Or something like that.
- 28:52And you ask yourself and that's part of investing, that you always do have to challenge your thesis. But I'm going to keep my thesis simple. I'm going to continue to watch Bitcoin oscillate between what I think is this fair value based on this power law scaling path.
- 29:18and you just never know, right?
- 29:24Bitcoin is, you know, technology, it uses cryptography.
- 29:28So there are dynamics around that
- 29:29that we probably just have to watch.
- 29:32And I think that the market always speaks the truth.
- 29:35So, you know, watching how Bitcoin behaves at 60
- 29:40when it gets really cheap is important.
- 29:42Like if it breaks 60 and then goes to 30,
- 29:45you have to think about,
- 29:47hey, why did that happen?
- 29:49Versus, okay, Bitcoin reached 60,
- 29:52but it been trading at or above 70 for two months now What does that say about Bitcoin And really and that like a lot of what I do too is I look at the short price short price action
- 30:04medium-term price action. Hey, what has Bitcoin done since it crashed 50%? And half the mainstream
- 30:11media was like, Bitcoin is dead again. Quantum is going to break it in three years. It's over.
- 30:18gold is, you know, gold won the whole time. And that's what everyone was saying two months ago.
- 30:25So what did the price do from that point? It went sideways, leaked a little higher,
- 30:33has performed pretty well over the last two months, despite the fact that we're in
- 30:39quite a large war, relatively speaking. There's so much information in that, Michael.
- 30:46like the 20% bounce we've had since first week of February.
- 30:51There's so much information in there.
- 30:54And so is Bitcoin dead?
- 30:56No.
- 30:56Like I'm using the last couple months of evidence.
- 30:59The market is telling you, no, it's not.
- 31:02It's not dead.
- 31:03And so you want to do that on both sides.
- 31:07And, you know, some of my readers are coasting to a million
- 31:12and others just really want to get involved every day.
- 31:15like, well, what's it going to do now? What's it going to do now? And I have fun with both
- 31:22readers, both types of readers, for sure. I can imagine the questions you must get.
- 31:28So Nick, what are some of the other, what are some macro trends, maybe just one or two that
- 31:32you're following closely? And what are you observing? What does it mean for anyone listening?
- 31:38Yes. The move index and the dollar index, those are two things that I'm watching pretty closely.
- 31:45So at the Bitcoin layer, we have a proprietary index.
- 31:48It's called TBL liquidity.
- 31:50And we've manipulated that index and its rate of change to give us a beat on risk markets.
- 31:57We basically designed a quant for your pocket, a model that will tell you a macro is supportive
- 32:03or it's not.
- 32:04And then we have a Bitcoin native metric called our state quadrant saying Bitcoin is either
- 32:10cheap or not or trending or not.
- 32:13And right now, Bitcoin isn't trending up yet. So that indicator is still on the red side of things. But our macro indicators switch green at the beginning of April. And by the way, today, stocks reached an all-time high on the S&P 500, if you can believe it. One of the most legendary bounces I've ever seen in the stock market. And trust me, I've seen a bunch.
- 32:41but the way that the stock market has come back.
- 32:45And what we have done is we've designed a framework and a metric
- 32:50that makes it very understandable why these things are happening.
- 32:55Well, you can actually trace the day that bond volatility topped out
- 33:00the last week of March and line it up exactly with the bounce in Bitcoin and stocks.
- 33:08So volatility and the dollar index are two financial conditions on risk markets.
- 33:15As vol goes up and as the dollar goes up, the ability of the system to take leverage,
- 33:23to trade, and to pay back debt, it gets damaged.
- 33:28And the opposite is true.
- 33:29When vol comes down and the dollar comes down, everything gets easier.
- 33:34Market makers get more active.
- 33:37Investors can take more leverage.
- 33:39Investors can buy.
- 33:41The fear goes away.
- 33:42The desire to buy insurance goes away.
- 33:45The price of insurance goes down.
- 33:48That's volatility coming down.
- 33:49Option prices come down and everything is good again.
- 33:53So we've tried to make it really simple for our readers, but for us too.
- 33:59I designed this for myself.
- 34:02I've actually designed everything that we've done quantitatively for myself.
- 34:07And I'm giving that to the readers.
- 34:10You guys can see how I analyze it.
- 34:13Well, instead of looking at bond vol rates, dollar, everything, you know, and then trying
- 34:19to calculate it, I have one metric.
- 34:21And then I've taken that metric and I've swung it on an indicator to tell you green or red.
- 34:28and try to make it really easy for me and the readers.
- 34:37And what am I watching?
- 34:40I'm watching vol and I'm watching the dollar.
- 34:43And if they're calm, all is good.
- 34:46Okay, interesting, interesting.
- 34:48Let's transition to a topic
- 34:49that seems unavoidable for me these days,
- 34:52and that is AI.
- 34:53I've had a handful of people on.
- 34:55No one so far has been bearish on AI.
- 35:00I think there's more enthusiasm for what is to come.
- 35:04We had, I guess, a number of ways we could take this.
- 35:07First of all, you wrote in one of your articles recently a bit on AI.
- 35:13And I would love to know, so part of the way I read it is this, maybe this, correct me if this is a misframing or if it's just something you don't agree with.
- 35:23But maybe Bitcoin is migrating from like this hedge or this opt out to the obvious de facto base layer of money as we move into a world maybe more and more dominated by AI.
- 35:37Is that a way of framing sort of the way that you might see things?
- 35:41And could you share your comments on that or perhaps elaborate?
- 35:44Yes, I do think that that's a good way to frame it.
- 35:47Bitcoin has always been a counter free money akin to gold, a base layer type of money. It's always
- 35:55been that. However, it has almost always traded like a beta on the stock market. And because of
- 36:07the volatility of Bitcoin, the risk is associated with things that move with high volatility,
- 36:14like tech stocks. And so it's been grouped in. So that break, that proverbial decoupling that
- 36:23every Bitcoiner has prayed for, recognized when it happens briefly, then pretends like they never
- 36:31celebrated the fact that it had decoupled when it recouples with the stock market. I mean, we all
- 36:38do this. So when is it going to trade? Not like a tech stock? When is it going to be recognized
- 36:46more of a base layer money? This is why AI matters is it shakes up everything in terms of
- 36:57what matters, what people should put their money in, what can be profitable, and what might be,
- 37:03literally killed by AI. And in that chaos, Bitcoin starts to emerge with more of its properties,
- 37:13counter free money, scarce, not a company, not a debt structure, no funding required.
- 37:20If you buy shares in a leveraged hedge fund that buys mortgages, let's say super safe
- 37:28assets. This is actually the first shop I worked at, mortgage hedge fund. They bought a bunch of
- 37:34safe-ish mortgages, but levered it two to three to one by funding it in the repo market.
- 37:41So if Barclays, Merrill Lynch, Goldman Sachs, and Deutsche Bank, when you call them next month,
- 37:47and they say, sorry, I need to return your bonds to you, and I can't lend you the money next month.
- 37:55I mean, the hedge fund has to liquidate half of its holdings.
- 38:00It can't pay for it.
- 38:02It funded the purchases.
- 38:04So if the funding stops, you have to sell the bonds.
- 38:07So Bitcoin isn't any of that.
- 38:11It's not a leveraged mortgage fund.
- 38:12It's not a tech stock.
- 38:14It's not a government bond.
- 38:16It's not a perishable commodity.
- 38:19It's not an energy commodity.
- 38:21It really is only closest to gold.
- 38:25but is never traded with a strong correlation to gold.
- 38:29If it did, the gold, the Bitcoin gold chart would look like this,
- 38:32but instead it looks like this.
- 38:35Right?
- 38:36So it is the holy grail for Bitcoin to trade more like gold and less like stocks.
- 38:41It is the holy grail for Bitcoin to decouple and AI and the changes that AI is forcing on the world,
- 38:53which by the way includes like get all the metals get all the oil build a semiconductor plant
- 39:00and build robots and you need metals you need energy you need electricity to do all of that
- 39:08so what is the cost of things or what what are people spending money on it's stuff it's materials
- 39:16commodities and they're they need all the stuff well 10 years ago what did they need they needed
- 39:22a great software that replaced a thousand workers or that made them efficient, that made them reach
- 39:29more customers. That's like a very different world than a scramble for resources world.
- 39:36And what is the trigger? It's AI. It's the AI race. The AI race is this trigger that moves capital
- 39:45out of software equities, for example, and into oil and gas producers and rare earth
- 39:53miners and manufacturers and like steel, for example, or a lumber company.
- 40:02So if that's what's happening and AI is the trigger, does Bitcoin win or lose in that?
- 40:09And I think it wins because then people have to reassess what is Bitcoin?
- 40:14Is it like a software or is it closer to a steel plant?
- 40:18They have to make that reassessment in this new AI world.
- 40:24And that's why it's important.
- 40:25It's this trigger, Michael.
- 40:27So you're saying it becomes a reassessment from an investment perspective because where
- 40:32my head goes to, and I talked with someone recently on the podcast about this, is AI
- 40:38agents adopting Bitcoin as the form of money.
- 40:43And now suddenly it's not 8 billion people who need access to better money.
- 40:49It's, you know, 8 billion people plus, you know, humanoid bots or whatever it ends up looking like.
- 40:56So you're saying it becomes more of a re-evaluation from investors.
- 41:02And perhaps you agree that there's a play for agentic AI to use Bitcoin.
- 41:08And that's a piece of the puzzle.
- 41:09But you're saying it becomes a reassessment from investors.
- 41:13How do I, in my mind, categorize these different things and what is needed?
- 41:17Because coders and code is abundant, software companies, software in general, becomes less appealing.
- 41:25And the actual stuff that makes the world move and enables what we need in order for an AI world to exist, that becomes much more interesting, the commodities.
- 41:37And then Bitcoin is sitting there and they're saying, well, it's not software. It seems like it's more of a commodity. So that seems like an allocation. I need some. And we've kind of left this tech stock world behind where everyone's focused on Facebook and all the others.
- 41:56That's exactly what I was trying to say.
- 41:59So the couple words that you said that were perfect, one is the categorization.
- 42:03You have to figure out what category Bitcoin is in.
- 42:06And the other word you said, which I completely agree with, is only a piece of the puzzle.
- 42:11The agentic AI using Bitcoin because it's the best digital currency.
- 42:16That is incredible.
- 42:18It's incredibly fascinating.
- 42:20It is so interesting.
- 42:21but I think that it's a danger to think of it as the main event.
- 42:28It's a kicker.
- 42:30And it could be the main event.
- 42:33I don't want to dismiss that.
- 42:35I think people that think it's the main event too, God bless them.
- 42:38I think that there's something there.
- 42:40And I see a path, right?
- 42:43But I can't say that that's the path, that's the main event.
- 42:46But I can see a path that that is a big kicker in the future.
- 42:50It is, though, about investors recategorizing what Bitcoin is and how it plays.
- 42:57Would you rather own, so five years ago, would you rather own Bitcoin or the S&P 500?
- 43:03Would you rather own Bitcoin or the tech sector within the S&P 500?
- 43:07Or would you rather own Bitcoin versus banking stocks?
- 43:12All those decisions five years ago versus today, it's a new conversation.
- 43:17Just wipe the slate clean.
- 43:19Think about the effect of LLMs on each and every single company and rethink whether it's investable or not.
- 43:29Rethink whether any of these companies will do well or not over the next five to 10 years.
- 43:34Every investor is having that conversation right now.
- 43:38Forget about if they're talking about Bitcoin or not.
- 43:41They are reassessing every equity that they own.
- 43:44So the software fall, it's bounced a lot this week as we've gone through this epic bounce.
- 43:53I mean, truly an epic bounce in the stock market.
- 43:57But yes, investors are reassessing all of this.
- 44:01So Bitcoin jumps into the conversation at a great time because the ETFs are already there.
- 44:08Morgan Stanley just went live.
- 44:10Goldman Sachs is coming online with theirs.
- 44:13everyone wants to get involved.
- 44:15And everyone is aware that that target allocation of 1% to 3% is common sense,
- 44:21but they were probably off of zero.
- 44:24So if they were in 8% software, take the 8% software down to 2%.
- 44:29And with the 6%, you can put 4% in the rest of equities and put 2% in Bitcoin.
- 44:37And boom, you've gone from 0% to 2% on a reallocation strategy
- 44:41because AI has changed the way that you think about the software sector. That's the main event
- 44:48to me in terms of AI being an accelerant to Bitcoin But even with that being said I still think it going to follow a similar pace to the way that the power law has played out over the last 16 years
- 45:04because you had insane growth in the early years. You have modestly strong growth still today
- 45:11that will taper off over time. But maybe we've overshot to the downside. So now the next
- 45:18move is to overshoot, Bitcoin will trade at 400K. I just can't tell you when or how quickly,
- 45:24or if that point will be an overshoot or just par for the course, right? It's an overshoot if it
- 45:32happens next year, par for the course if it happens in three or four years. And what I love
- 45:39about my job is that I don't have to come out and predict everything. I can give you some
- 45:45medium term and some long term predictions but just tell you that you know nobody knows if i knew
- 45:52i'd be trading it not on a pod uh being interviewed and writing a newsletter so um there's a special
- 45:59type of person also that can be a fiduciary and take these bets and also being able to stomach
- 46:05downside right because even if you're right you can be wrong for a really long time you remember
- 46:10Michael Burry in his basement playing the drums and screaming when he was down 18%.
- 46:16And his wife calls down, are you okay? He's like, I'm great. I'm great, honey. He's like yelling
- 46:23with his drum set. So that's not for everyone. It's not for me.
- 46:29Yeah, I hear you. So one other thing that came to mind, I do not know much about the energy
- 46:35markets, but my understanding is we need a lot more energy to fuel our AI ambitions.
- 46:42And I can imagine too, a place where the actual utility providers need to beef up their
- 46:50infrastructure.
- 46:51And the reason, as I understand it, the reason why they haven't historically done that is
- 46:55because there's only so much demand.
- 46:56They can meet peak demand almost all the time, except for in rare cases or perhaps in just
- 47:03poor infrastructure environments. But do you see Bitcoin mining as a load balancing tool
- 47:11to help incentivize that expansion that sort of along with agentic AI adopting Bitcoin,
- 47:20along with investors reassessing Bitcoin in what category it falls into, also the energy producers
- 47:27or the utility companies by necessity, because of the demand for AI, building out infrastructure
- 47:35that they say, we can't have this just sit in idle. It can't just be charging electric cars
- 47:40overnight. We need to be utilizing all of the energy that are a much higher percentage of the
- 47:47energy that we're producing. Do you think that could be another catalyst for, I don't know,
- 47:53I guess, Bitcoin adoption. And again, I know you think it's going to continue to follow the power
- 47:58law, but do you think that's going to be one of the potential effects? And could it be a
- 48:02significant one of the adoption of more AI? I think that the load balancing is an important
- 48:09concept and utility providers are recognizing that. So they like Bitcoin miners being involved.
- 48:18I think that's an important part of adoption that will continue. But the electrification that we
- 48:23need that you mentioned. Well, do you think that Google and Facebook are going to wait for
- 48:30some random city to build a power plant or they're going to build it themselves?
- 48:35They've already told us they're going to build it themselves. I think NVIDIA said that they're
- 48:40going to have their own mini nuclear reactors in the next seven years for some of their chip
- 48:46making facilities that they're going to build in the United States. That's a big deal because
- 48:52if they need energy for their own compute, they will realize that Bitcoin mining can fit in to
- 49:03their risk mitigation strategies on excess cost or capturing stranded energy and being able to
- 49:15turn stranded energy into revenue or balancing the compute demand. Right now, they're balancing
- 49:21their own compute in terms of the LLMs, they have to either buy compute to process or buy
- 49:31compute to train.
- 49:33So they have to make that decision right now, not between Bitcoin and compute, but between
- 49:38compute for revenue or compute for growth in the future just to train your models to
- 49:45get better.
- 49:45But my answer is that if the tech companies like ExxonMobil and like Royal Dutch Shell have recognized already that they can use Bitcoin to capture some stranded energy, to balance their, to mitigate risks, if tech companies do the same thing with their own power plants, then that takes the adoption curve of Bitcoin another step forward in terms of retail, then the hedge funds, then traditional
- 50:15investors, 401ks, Royal Dutch Shell, ExxonMobil, NVIDIA, Apple, right? Those types of big steps
- 50:27are, yes, I expect them. But just because I believe in the power law doesn't mean you don't
- 50:35want to see the steps happen. And those are the types of things that will confirm. So when I see
- 50:40the Morgan Stanley headline, Morgan Stanley coming in with a Bitcoin ETF, I say, yes, checkmark.
- 50:48That's right on time. And so when I see NVIDIA in three years saying, yeah, we're mining Bitcoin
- 50:56too, it's going to be like, wow. But it'd also be like, yes, this is the path that Bitcoin needs to
- 51:02be on. And this shows me that we're heading for that adoption. And by the way, you're waiting for
- 51:0810 million, a million becomes 10 million quickly. And it's just another zero at that point, right?
- 51:1510,000 to 100,000, 100,000 to a million, million to 10 million, they'll happen quickly, but you do
- 51:22have to get to the next order of magnitude before you get to the next one. So we'll get to 10.
- 51:29On what path? I don't know. But right now, I'm focused on getting to a million, right?
- 51:35five to six years. Yeah. I'm patient, man. Bitcoin has brought me a lot and it's not been
- 51:43purchasing power. I've only been in for four years, but it's opened my eyes to a lot of things.
- 51:48And I get to have fantastic conversations with people like you because of it. So,
- 51:52Nick, I appreciate your time. I got one more question for you and you know it's coming. What
- 51:56is an unpopular opinion that you have? You get some bonus points if you offend Bitcoiners with it.
- 52:01Well, I have never believed in or liked the word hyper-Bitcoinization.
- 52:09I believe in Bitcoinization, the slow adoption process that happens naturally instead of the
- 52:16world going into panic and Bitcoin forcing itself on the world.
- 52:22The world is stable enough that hyper-Bitcoinization is not my base case scenario.
- 52:28If the world was completely unstable, then perhaps. But I am privileged in that I live in the United States, a very stable society, you know, with everything that's going on today, still a very stable society.
- 52:47I also am privileged that I get to travel around the world to Europe and non-European countries as
- 52:55well. I've spent time in India. I've spent time in the Middle East recently. I've spent time in
- 53:01other parts of Asia. I've spent time in Western Europe. I've spent time in Eastern Europe. I've
- 53:06spent time in different parts of the United States as well. The world is stable. And I know a lot of
- 53:12Bitcoiners think that the world is so chaotic and so crazy that hyper-Bitcoinization is inevitable.
- 53:20And I completely disagree with that. Maybe it's a naivete, maybe it's just an optimism,
- 53:27but I think that the stability in this world is enough for Bitcoin to have a slow adoption process
- 53:34where it just slowly chips away as a store of value across the world doesn't really replace
- 53:41the hand-to-hand currency that people use on any grand scale anytime in the next 10 to 20 years.
- 53:47And it can get to a million absolutely just fine. So just to be clear, the distinction you're
- 53:54making, it probably has more to do with the pace and the relative amount of chaos that might ensue
- 54:01based on your scenario versus like you think that the quote unquote hyper Bitcoinized world
- 54:08is coming, but it's not going to happen in a hyper fashion? Like 50 years from now,
- 54:15do you think Bitcoin will be ubiquitous, use as money, the base layer money of the economy?
- 54:22It's just a matter of following this longer progressive arc toward that future versus,
- 54:29look kind of your point earlier, it's not a macro event where everyone says, oh,
- 54:32I have to have Bitcoin today. It goes to 10 million overnight, that kind of thing. Is that
- 54:37the distinction you're drawing or is it more than that? I think it's more than that because I think
- 54:41that governments need currencies for stability. They need to have their own currency to have
- 54:51any control and control leads to stability, right? If they're able to have a controlled environment,
- 55:00there can be stable economic activity. There can be economic activity if everyone agrees on the
- 55:05currency. And if everyone, if the government allows or basically sends its currency out into
- 55:14the world, then that is a currency that people will use. So I'll answer your question like this.
- 55:2010 years ago, when I got into Bitcoin research, I had the thought exercise because I do travel
- 55:25internationally, is that in how many years will I go through a duty free shop and the prices are in
- 55:31Bitcoin. The prices are in sats. And it's the lead price, not underneath the dollar price or the
- 55:39price, but the lead price. How many years until I see it? Not until it's every airport, every item
- 55:48for sale in every corner of the world, but how long until I actually see it for the first time
- 55:53or the second time, or I'm in an airport where everything is starting to be priced in Bitcoin.
- 55:5810 years ago, I would have thought maybe in 10 years.
- 56:02Well, I would have been wrong because I've gone through a bunch of duty-free shops this
- 56:06year.
- 56:07There is no Bitcoin pricing.
- 56:09There's Bitcoin ads like in the Istanbul airport.
- 56:12There's Bitcoin, huge Bitcoin exchange ads everywhere you go.
- 56:16I was just in Heathrow.
- 56:18There's a, you know, in the British Airways terminal, there's a big crypto ad with a Bitcoin
- 56:23logo on it.
- 56:25It's everywhere.
- 56:26Okay.
- 56:27It's not like it's not present in the airport, but it is not being used for transactions in
- 56:33international airports. I would have been somewhat wrong 10 years ago, but now I look and I say,
- 56:39okay, well, what about the next 10 years? Am I going to be walking through an international
- 56:43airport and see Bitcoin pricing in the duty-free store? I don't think it's more likely today than
- 56:51what I thought 10 years ago, 10 years into the future. If it's not in 10 years, well,
- 56:57what about in 20 years? I don't know that Bitcoin gets to that hyper-Bitcoinization role that it is
- 57:04the currency that everyone uses. Because government currencies are so useful to governments.
- 57:12And so don't discount the power of these incumbents, like the United States of America,
- 57:17the European Union, the People's Republic of China. Don't discount how long these institutions
- 57:27can last or how powerful they are or their willingness and ability to use their currency
- 57:32to accomplish their objectives. So Bitcoin, is it the store of value role for the next 20 years
- 57:40still and not the global medium of exchange role? Even though it might break into more corners of
- 57:45the internet for online commerce, it's not going to compete with the US dollar for the medium of
- 57:52exchange function, for the funding currency function, for the banking role, for deposit lending.
- 58:00It's not. Well, I'll tell you, I think your opinion will be unpopular with money, obviously.
- 58:07Nick, I think this was a fantastic conversation. Always good chatting with you. Thank you so much.
- 58:11Why don't you tell people where they can find out about you, follow you, read your sub stack, anything else you want to share?
- 58:17Yeah, thebitcoinlayer.substack.com is where we are writing all of our work.
- 58:22And thebitcoinlayer.com, you can see everything that we're doing there.
- 58:26The YouTube channel, our socials, and our new standalone terminal, which is called TVL Pulse, gives you all of our liquidity metrics without the additional writing.
- 58:38But we really want people to see the data.
- 58:41And so it's a great new product that we have.
- 58:43The BitcoinLayer.com for everything.
- 58:45And I'm on X at time value of BTC.
- 58:50Perfect.
- 58:50Nick, thank you so much for your time, man.
- 58:51Great chatting.
- 58:52Thanks, Michael.
- 58:53And that's a wrap again.
- 58:55I hope you enjoyed my conversation with Nick.
- 58:56I know I sure did.
- 58:57Always learn a lot when I listen to him.
- 58:59And it was a pleasure getting to chat with him.
- 59:01Go follow his sub stack.
- 59:02Go check out his podcast.
- 59:03Everything that he's working on.
- 59:04He puts so much time and energy behind all of it.
- 59:06And of course, do me a huge favor before you leave. Make sure you are subscribed to our channel. Give us a like, comment, share it with someone who you think might be interested. We would really, really appreciate your help feeding the algorithm and getting the pure Bitcoin signal out to the world. Of course, if you need help with proper 100% self-custody of your Bitcoin, go to thebitcoinway.com slash podcast. Schedule a free 30-minute introductory call with a member of our team. We can also help you with online privacy, setting up your privacy phone. We have a Plan B residency option in Tropical Panama.
- 59:36It's a freedom loving jurisdiction that you should consider as a plan B.
- 59:39Again, it's thebitcoinway.com slash podcast.
- 59:42Until next time, stay safe, stay sovereign.
- 59:45And remember the yield on Bitcoin is freedom.