Latest / Shiny New Object - a Marketing Podcast / Episode 277 / Zahra Hemraj / Citizen Watch Canada / Director, Marketing & Data Integration
Transcript
- 0:00Zahra Hemraj: Maybe it actually was a horrible investment, and
- 0:02that campaign just isn't successful, and we should never
- 0:05do it again, but without actually critically evaluating
- 0:07that data and sharing all of the results, you'll never get to the
- 0:11bottom of it, and you'll never have real results.
- 0:19Speaker: Are you a fitness loving foodie. Then defy snacks
- 0:22is for you. Defy offers real high quality chocolate you love,
- 0:25combined with functional ingredients, giving you as much
- 0:27as 26 grams of protein per bag. So you can be both a little bit
- 0:31bad and a little bit good at the same time as a female owned
- 0:34brand, defy dedicates a portion of its profits to other women
- 0:38owned businesses currently sold in the US. You can find us on
- 0:41defy with an eye snacks.com and follow us on social at defy
- 0:46snacks.
- 0:52Tom Ollerton: Hello and welcome to the shiny new object podcast.
- 0:56My name is Tom Ollerton. I'm the founder of automated creative,
- 0:59the creative effectiveness, ad tech platform, and this is a
- 1:03almost weekly podcast about the future of data driven marketing.
- 1:08Every week or so I get the privilege and the pleasure of
- 1:11interviewing one of our industry's leaders, and this
- 1:13week is no different. I'm on a call with Zahra Hemraj, who is
- 1:16director marketing and data integration at Citizen Watch
- 1:20Canada. So Zahra, for anyone who doesn't know who you are and
- 1:23what you do, could you give us a bit of background?
- 1:25Zahra Hemraj: Yes, of course. Hi Tom, and hi to everyone
- 1:27listening. I am currently at Citizen Watch Canada, as Tom
- 1:31mentioned as the director of marketing and data integration.
- 1:35I actually started my career in IT, totally different. I worked
- 1:39in IT and telecom. From there, I did an MBA in luxury brand
- 1:44management, and then I shifted over to the art industry, where
- 1:48I focused on CRM at Christie's. And then from there, I left that
- 1:53and am now at Citizen watch Canada.
- 1:56Tom Ollerton: So in that varied career, what have been the bad
- 2:01recommendations that you've been given, you've told or you've
- 2:05heard?
- 2:05Zahra Hemraj: Sure. So I mean, I my career as I as I mentioned,
- 2:10this has been quite diverse, starting from somewhere very
- 2:13different, and then ending up in what I do now, which encompasses
- 2:18from end to end, any side of marketing, including PR and
- 2:21communications, including data, including kind of the look and
- 2:24feel of the website building catalogs. So it's very different
- 2:28than where I started, which was project management and testing.
- 2:31And what I often hear in my career or in marketing is that
- 2:37you either can't get ahead without a network, or that you
- 2:40have to have a very linear career. And to me, I think this
- 2:43is absolutely wrong, because I think that while having a
- 2:47network helps, it's not a requirement for success. You can
- 2:50only build a network through starting your career to begin
- 2:53with. And secondly, about having a linear career path, I mean if,
- 2:58if anything, I'm an example that you don't have to have a linear
- 3:01career path, and you can get to where you ultimately want to get
- 3:04to, or where you're inspired or passionate for through different
- 3:08steps. And a good hiring manager or a good, you know, a good
- 3:13agency or a good company will actually value and understand
- 3:19your different career paths or your your steps to get to where
- 3:22you were, to be able to to be able to contribute to your role.
- 3:26Because through all of that, you're able to actually have a
- 3:29different mindset. For me, it's been, I mean, I was, I was born
- 3:33in Canada. I started my career in Toronto. I then worked in
- 3:37London, in Paris, in New York. I've done projects in the UAE,
- 3:42and I'm back in Canada now. So while also my industries have
- 3:48varied, my, you know, the cultures that I've worked with
- 3:52and the focus has been very different, and that's all helped
- 3:56me be able to contribute to the work I do and have a different
- 3:59perspective than other people that I work with, and I think
- 4:02it's really important that people are aware that you really
- 4:05don't have to have a linear career path to be successful.
- 4:08Tom Ollerton: I'm gonna drag you back a little bit to saying that
- 4:12you don't need a network, because, like, I, for me, I'm
- 4:16just one of those people that really believes in that. And I'd
- 4:19love to hear more about the counter opinion there, because
- 4:23when anyone asked me that question, I'm like, get a
- 4:25network. Get to know everyone, because you never know what will
- 4:27happen and when those those like nodes will connect.
- 4:30Zahra Hemraj: Absolutely so I will say that yes, networking is
- 4:33important. Networking is important, but having a network
- 4:37to start your career or to be successful in your career is not
- 4:41something that I think is a crucial step, because, again, I
- 4:45mean taking my own career or my own experiences. Most of the
- 4:48jobs I've gotten have not been through people that I know it's
- 4:52been through literally applying on LinkedIn as an example, being
- 4:56at Christie's, everyone that would reach out to me once I was
- 5:00there, was like, how did you get in, or who did you speak with,
- 5:04or what was your, you know, like, what was your connection
- 5:08to be able to get into that role? And I didn't have a
- 5:11background in art history, I didn't have anyone that I knew
- 5:15that was there, and I really just applied on LinkedIn, and I
- 5:19was able to get through the door. And I think if it's the
- 5:23right moment, if it's the right step for you, and if you're in
- 5:27the right position, you end up being able to step into that
- 5:30like in that you're present in the right moments, the network
- 5:34is important in that it helps you learn more about what you
- 5:38know, what's going on out there about keeping current with your
- 5:42with your industry, so speaking to other peers and having that
- 5:46connection. But I don't think that it's crucial to getting a
- 5:50role or to achieving success in your career, because I don't
- 5:54think that the network can really take you that far like
- 5:57it. They might provide you some insights, but at the end of the
- 6:01day, it comes down to you and your experiences and who you are
- 6:05as a person presenting yourself to the company that you're
- 6:09looking to get into or to the business that you're looking to start.
- 6:19Tom Ollerton: Indeed. So be good. Be really good. Be
- 6:22brilliant. And you don't really need a network, okay, maybe
- 6:25that, maybe that's why I'm so focused on having a network. But
- 6:27anyway, there you go, moving very quickly along. So what is
- 6:32your best bit of advice that you have for data driven marketers?
- 6:36What is that silver bullet bit of knowledge that you find
- 6:40sharing with your team?
- 6:42Zahra Hemraj: Yeah. I mean, I'm sure it's been said before, but
- 6:45I think that the key to better data driven marketer is really
- 6:51looking beyond the data. So while the data tells one story,
- 6:55it doesn't provide the context, and it doesn't always show you
- 6:58where you started from, and data can also be biased depending on
- 7:02what type of data you're pulling, which brings me to kind
- 7:05of the expansion of that in terms of being a better data
- 7:08driven marketer, and is to not be afraid of negative results.
- 7:12So too often I'll see people in my industry using data to prove
- 7:15something was successful or to show progress, and they hide the
- 7:20data that doesn't support how things are actually doing, but I
- 7:24think that I mean from my IT background, for instance, I
- 7:28learned the importance of actually looking for negative
- 7:30results. Because when I used to head QA for an enterprise
- 7:33project, one of the things that we always kind of ingrained in
- 7:37our testers was that if you're not finding an error, then you
- 7:40aren't doing your job. Nothing is perfect, no system, no code
- 7:44or no data is ever perfect, and no campaigns ever going to be
- 7:47perfect. So if you're not willing to show the mistakes or
- 7:50the errors, then you're never going to improve the system, and
- 7:53you're never going to improve on your campaigns. You're never
- 7:56going to grow your brand's presence or impact. If you're
- 7:59saying that everything you're doing is perfect, then where's
- 8:02the room for improvement? So I think that that's really key to
- 8:07becoming a better data driven marketer, because you know
- 8:11something, having a negative result doesn't always mean that
- 8:14it's not worth doing again, but it does mean that you can look
- 8:17at ways to improve it, or perhaps your data capture
- 8:20mechanisms aren't accurate and they're not capturing the data
- 8:24that you need. Or maybe you didn't achieve X and you're
- 8:27actually trying to achieve Y, or maybe it actually was a horrible
- 8:32investment, and that campaign just isn't successful, and we
- 8:35should never do it again, but without actually critically
- 8:37evaluating that data and sharing all of the results, you'll never
- 8:42get to the bottom of it, and you'll never have real results.
- 8:45Tom Ollerton: Gosh, I absolutely love that. I think that's such,
- 8:48and you're right, but as a supplier, that just kind of
- 8:51fills me full of dread, you know, because you want to, you
- 8:53want to tell the best story, you know, you want to go, you know,
- 8:56look, you employed us to do this. And, like, you know, and
- 8:59here's all these amazing things, but don't worry about these,
- 9:01like, not so amazing things over here. But actually, here. But
- 9:03actually, I hadn't, I hadn't thought about that as being a
- 9:04real positive so, yeah, these things didn't work right? What
- 9:07we're gonna do about next time like this is, this is our
- 9:09opportunity to learn. So that is brilliant advice. Thank you. So
- 9:14we're now, we're now going to come on to your shiny new
- 9:17object, which is the psychology behind the data. So what is
- 9:23that? And why is it your shiny new object?
- 9:25Zahra Hemraj: So I think that we often forget that behind the
- 9:30data, behind what we're looking at and what we're analyzing,
- 9:34there are people that are helping us get that data. So I
- 9:38and what I mean by that is not the people like gathering the
- 9:43data, but the people that are doing the actions that result in
- 9:48the data that we're receiving. So there are people that are
- 9:50clicking on stuff, there are people that are opening emails,
- 9:54or that are visiting certain websites or so forth, and or
- 9:58that are transacting. Those people, there's a psychology
- 10:02behind that. There's a reason that that happens. There is a
- 10:06reason that certain metrics exist. And we need to look
- 10:11beyond what we're seeing in terms of just numbers or just
- 10:14the ones and zeros that we're looking at. And what does it
- 10:17actually mean? What is the actual reason that something is
- 10:22happening. So why do people act in a certain way? Why did we get
- 10:26these results, and digging into that reason and the psychology
- 10:30behind it, so what's the context behind Why did someone, you
- 10:35know, why did we get X number of impressions on a particular ad
- 10:39that ran digitally, like, what made us get those impressions,
- 10:44or what made us get those click throughs? Is it because that ad
- 10:48was just that successful, and if so, then, what about that ad?
- 10:52Was it the color scheme? Was it the, you know, the message that
- 10:57was there? Was it the time that we ran that campaign? What is it
- 11:01about that that enticed someone to be able to do that? What made
- 11:06a person behave in a particular way? And I think that that often
- 11:10gets lost when we're just looking at data, because kind of
- 11:14back to what I was saying earlier. We end up wanting to
- 11:16show results, and we don't think about the psychology behind it.
- 11:25Tom Ollerton: This episode of the shiny new object podcast is
- 11:28brought to you in partnership with madfest. Whether it's live
- 11:31in London or streamed online to the global marketing community,
- 11:35you can always expect a distinctive and daring blend of
- 11:38fast paced content, startup innovation pitches and
- 11:41unconventional entertainment from madfest events, you'll find
- 11:44me causing trouble on stage, recording live versions of this
- 11:47podcast and sharing a beer with the nicest and most influential
- 11:50people in Marketing. Check it out at www dot madfest
- 11:54london.com.
- 12:02So there's this idea, I can't remember where it was in the in
- 12:06the book of writing that they came up, this idea that what we
- 12:10all get drawn towards is, is the, the easiest data to
- 12:14collect, like, what the most abundant, easy thing we can just
- 12:18get by, like clicking on a link or looking at a dashboard where,
- 12:21in reality, there's, there's some data that that we might not
- 12:25even be able to get at all, but there's assumption, just because
- 12:28we can't get it, that it's not important, and there's a kind of
- 12:30range between those things. So I you know, because we discussed
- 12:34this before, I think you're right that you have to
- 12:36understand that. Why? Like, Well, why did that ad work? But
- 12:40what are your techniques and methods for getting to that?
- 12:44Why? Because I like that. I'd work. Oh, is it because we
- 12:47should have, should have that after midday, or because it
- 12:50actually had, like a 25% off or whatever? What could if you're
- 12:53talking about psychology, then you're talking about people.
- 12:55You're talking about qual there, really. So how do you bring a
- 12:59qual approach to data driven quant?
- 13:02Zahra Hemraj: Exactly. So I think that that that is the
- 13:06essence of it. So for me, with with the work that I do, or with
- 13:09what I try to understand, I mean, there's a variety of
- 13:12different things that go into it. So it could be looking at
- 13:15the trends in the market right now and understanding why
- 13:19certain things are popular, or what's, you know, if you're
- 13:22talking about, like, certain, I don't know, like, a Tiktok trend
- 13:25that's going on, and you created an ad that kind of was similar
- 13:29to that, maybe that'll attract more attention. And maybe that's
- 13:31why that did that ad did well. But it could also be about
- 13:36things like, understanding, you know, like, it comes down to a
- 13:42lot of things. It could be color, like, you know, the the
- 13:44psychology behind color, and the colors that you use in your ads,
- 13:46and did that cause a certain reaction, and thinking through
- 13:48that. It could also be things, what we try to assess, and what
- 13:52I try to look at, is what, so if I'm trying to understand, if it
- 13:56had to do, for instance, with the time or the day, or, you
- 14:00know what was going on? What are the cultural moments of
- 14:02significance that are happening right now, or certain National
- 14:06Days, or certain things that are happening in current affairs
- 14:09that might make a certain caption or a certain type of
- 14:13product more attractive to a consumer? Does that have
- 14:16anything to do with what we're showing or, you know, the type
- 14:21of ad that's existing, is that creating that kind of reaction?
- 14:25Or does it come down to maybe, if we're looking at different
- 14:29times, if we're thinking about, okay, let's do some AB testing,
- 14:34which is always very important, to see if that makes an impact.
- 14:38And if so, then we can try to make certain assumptions that
- 14:43maybe this is based on that at the end of the day, that that
- 14:47type of understanding ends up being more assumption driven
- 14:50than actual, like there's not anything particularly tangible
- 14:56that I can show you to say this is the actual end result. Of why
- 15:00this happened, but it's based on assumptions, and it's based on
- 15:03understanding the market. It's based on understanding what
- 15:07exists out there, and it's also based on conversations with
- 15:10people. So I do a lot of face to face conversations with media or
- 15:16with end consumers at various different types of events that
- 15:20we hold, because I try to hear a little bit more and listen to
- 15:24what they're saying, like, why, why did this exist? Or, you
- 15:27know, why does this appeal to you? And they'll often tell me
- 15:30what they're thinking, and that gives me some insight into why
- 15:34certain people might react to a particular product in a
- 15:36particular way, and the other the other way. That's always a
- 15:40really good way of hearing what consumers think is looking at
- 15:45the types of calls that come into a if you have a call center
- 15:48or a customer relations team, kind of understanding what is
- 15:52the feedback that we're getting or what what are people calling
- 15:55about? And maybe that's kind of relevant to what we're seeing in
- 16:00terms of our results, but if we just stay tunnel visioned into
- 16:04this is what's happening in marketing and in data, and we
- 16:06don't think about our other departments or what's going on
- 16:09out there, then we won't really get to hear that other ways
- 16:13again, other departments to hear from our sales teams when
- 16:16they're going out to some of our retailers, to understand a
- 16:19little bit more about what they're hearing out in the
- 16:21market. And we don't do, I haven't done official focus
- 16:26groups here, but, like, indirectly, you're speaking to
- 16:31people, and you're kind of getting some feedback that then
- 16:34ties back to what you're actually seeing as your results,
- 16:38right?
- 16:38Tom Ollerton: So can you give me an example of a specific moment
- 16:42when that happened, when you did that, when you had, you had your
- 16:45ones and zeros, you had your alpha numerical data, and then
- 16:48you heard something from a call center or someone in the field.
- 16:52I understand it theoretically, but would you be loved to see an
- 16:54example in practice?
- 16:55Zahra Hemraj: Yeah. I mean, I'll give you an example of
- 16:58something. Okay, so if we looked at, there was a particular
- 17:01product that we released, and the actual sales figures for
- 17:05that product, as we saw them, were not, were not positive,
- 17:08like they weren't. They weren't. It wasn't performing at the
- 17:12level that we wanted to see. And the feedback that we were
- 17:16hearing from the feedback we were hearing from the retailers,
- 17:19from the sales team, what they were hearing was that, oh, you
- 17:23know, it's, we're not, we're just not seeing people coming in
- 17:27for that. Either it had to do with, you know, it's, it's not
- 17:31something that they felt was current, or they weren't
- 17:34interested in it for a variety of reasons. But on the other
- 17:38hand, when we looked at our data, the data showed that for
- 17:41our marketing campaigns that we were running, that that that
- 17:44Tom Ollerton: That's a great story. So unfortunately, we're
- 17:45product was performing above and beyond anything else that we had
- 17:49launched in in, like, the months surrounding that product, and it
- 17:53was the best click throughs, the best, you know, the best like
- 17:57interest in a variety of ways. Like, there was the clicks,
- 18:00there was the likes, there was the the conversion wasn't quite
- 18:04there, because, again, we weren't seeing the sales result
- 18:08from a transactional perspective, but we were seeing
- 18:11the conversion in terms of that linking through to our website,
- 18:15and seeing that type of conversion that we were getting
- 18:18out of it. So it was performing really well from a from a data
- 18:22perspective and what we were seeing, but our sales results
- 18:26were not aligned with that. So we were trying to understand
- 18:29what the difference was there. And the thing that was
- 18:32interesting is that the product was amazing for the people who
- 18:36were because it was based on, you know, there was some history
- 18:40behind it, and it had a historical aspect behind that
- 18:43product. So it tied back to kind of the people that were reacting
- 18:47to it were true lovers of the brand, and they were true lovers
- 18:51of watches in particular at that point. So they were really,
- 18:55really into what this stood for. But they just were not like they
- 18:59loved the story behind it, so it really spoke to them. So in
- 19:03speaking with media, and in speaking with, you know, with
- 19:06consumers out there, they loved the watch. They would come in
- 19:10and they would look at it, and they wanted to learn more about
- 19:14it, and they were like, you know, liking all of the ads that
- 19:18we were doing about it, all of our social posts. They were
- 19:21enamored by this watch, but it wasn't translating with our
- 19:25retailers, and that's just based on the price point that it was
- 19:29at, and it wasn't something that people were able to purchase at
- 19:33that particular time. So it was, you know, it was, it was really
- 19:36interesting to understand what was creating that positive data,
- 19:40but the negative results from the sales department
- 19:43perspective, right? And I just, I think that that was so
- 19:47interesting to us.
- 19:57kind of coming to the end of the podcast now, but I just wanted
- 19:59to ask you. See, you've got lots of experience, and it's so great
- 20:05to hear someone articulate the balance between the hard data
- 20:09and the soft stuff, because I've been reading so much about it
- 20:13recently. But I'm curious to know where now that you know all
- 20:16of this stuff, now you've, like, cracked the code. What's the
- 20:19pain point? What is the thing that you're within data driven
- 20:21marketing where you're like, Ah, if only this problem would go
- 20:25away.
- 20:26Zahra Hemraj: I think that often the pain point goes back to
- 20:29people accepting negative data. To me, that's a big pain point,
- 20:33because not just like, not just within my team, but when we're
- 20:40speaking to anyone at an executive level, when we're
- 20:44speaking to retailers, trying to express that, yes, we're not
- 20:47seeing that, but actually it's really positive, because it
- 20:49helps us understand x, y, z, that doesn't always get
- 20:53translated across. And wanting to showcase where we can
- 20:56improve, or things that we can do differently is a bit of a
- 21:00pain point for me.
- 21:01Tom Ollerton: All right, then, so, so let's, let's do a 101, on
- 21:04that, right? You know, so, so imagine you're speaking to your
- 21:08suppliers now and and you don't want them to bury the negative
- 21:12data, like, what is, what is the way to really make those
- 21:16negative outcomes work positively for you?
- 21:19Zahra Hemraj: I mean, a, it's again, back to psychology, but
- 21:22it's very simple by instead of calling it negative results,
- 21:25here's areas of opportunity, or things that we think that you
- 21:29could really improve on, or that would really improve your brand,
- 21:33or new, you know, approaches. Let's try this, this and this,
- 21:36and therefore that's going to help you, because we're seeing
- 21:40in putting some further what, what I like to do is put some
- 21:43further research behind it. So we're seeing that, I don't know
- 21:47like this particular type of product doesn't perform well and
- 21:50it didn't get the right results. But what we're seeing is, out in
- 21:54the market, your competitors are doing X and Y, and therefore you
- 21:58might want to do this, which would really help. So we want to
- 22:02try this now as our next step.
- 22:03Tom Ollerton: That is a lovely, practical way to end the
- 22:06podcast. Zahra. Thank you so much for your time. If someone
- 22:09wants to get in touch with you about any of the things we've
- 22:12discussed today, where's the best place to do that? But
- 22:15crucially, what needs to go into a message to get you to respond
- 22:19to them?
- 22:19Zahra Hemraj: I'm actually, I will say I'm usually pretty good
- 22:22at responding to messages, but if they do add that they heard
- 22:25me on the podcast, that they heard the podcast and they had
- 22:28some questions from what I was speaking about, sending me a
- 22:32message on LinkedIn would definitely get my attention, and
- 22:35I'd be happy to answer that.
- 22:36Tom Ollerton: Brilliant. Zahra, thanks so much for your time,
- 22:39and we'll see you all next week.
- 22:41Zahra Hemraj: Thanks. Tom.
- 22:48Tom Ollerton: hi. Just before you go, I'd really appreciate it
- 22:52if you could take the time to write a review of the shiny new
- 22:55object podcast on Apple podcasts or iTunes, or whatever it's
- 22:58called these days, or whichever podcast provider you use, we're
- 23:03at any podcast, so it would go a long way for us. If you could
- 23:06just share the Word and give us a bit of a support on those
- 23:09channels. That'd just be fantastic. If you haven't got
- 23:11time. That's also cool. And yeah, if you could tell your
- 23:14colleagues about the podcast, and also, if possible, don't
- 23:17forget to subscribe. And I'd love to hear your feedback. If
- 23:21you'd like to speak on the podcast. I'll be a guest. Or you
- 23:24think I'm asking the wrong questions. Anything. I'd be
- 23:26super interested to hear what you think. So please email me.
- 23:30Tom at, automated creative.net, that's Tom at, I'm not going to
- 23:36bother spelling it anyway. You'll work it out. Thanks so
- 23:39much.