Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Secrets Mediators Don't Want to Tell You with Robert Cohen, Jeffrey Kravitz
Transcript
- 0:02This is Jeff Kravitz, and I am joined by Bob
- 0:06Cohen today for the ADR section. And by brief
- 0:11introduction, Bob and I have been doing these
- 0:15meetings for about a year and a half now. And
- 0:18we sat down and we thought it would be fun to
- 0:21have a discussion on what mediators don't tell
- 0:24you. In other words, what's behind the curtain
- 0:26that you may not see as a litigant. Or if you
- 0:31are a mediator, what is it that's rolling around
- 0:34in your head as the parties are knocking their
- 0:37brains out trying to persuade you of their position?
- 0:42As I mentioned, I'm joined by my colleague and
- 0:44friend, Bob Cohen. He is a mediator with ARC,
- 0:48the Alternative Resource Centers, and with MCLA,
- 0:52the Mediation Center of Los Angeles. He received
- 0:55advanced training from the late Jeff Krivitz.
- 0:58and from Forrest Woody Moslin. Before mediating,
- 1:02he was litigated with Cohen, Slimpert, and Ford,
- 1:06a boutique real estate and general litigation
- 1:08firm. Bob, to you. Okay. I'd like to introduce
- 1:13my good friend and colleague, Jeffrey Kravitz.
- 1:17Jeffrey and I went to UCLA. I'm going to go a
- 1:20little off script because that's my nature. Jeffrey
- 1:24and I both went to UCLA exactly at the same time.
- 1:28He was a philosophy major trying to learn as
- 1:32much as he could. I was trying to get the best
- 1:36grades I could and was into social kind of student
- 1:39body things and working in the media. And I took
- 1:45five years to graduate and I ended up at Loyola
- 1:51a year after him. But Jeff Kravitz is also a
- 1:55mediator with ARC. the Alternative Resolution
- 1:58Center, and he's an arbitrator with the AAA.
- 2:02He has a career as a very successful litigator
- 2:07and trial attorney. He started off at the AG's
- 2:10office, I believe, and he cut his teeth there
- 2:13and got his head beaten a few times. Through
- 2:17that process, he became a very capable trial
- 2:20lawyer. He was with some different major law
- 2:23firms. He has a trial lawyer. He has extensive
- 2:27experience in the entertainment industry and
- 2:29intellectual property and insurance disputes.
- 2:32And he ended up before moving into mediation
- 2:36full time as a partner. And I believe he was
- 2:39at least a managing partner for a few years with
- 2:43Fox Rothschild. And he and I have been working
- 2:46together. We are in sync pretty much. We see
- 2:50the world the same way, but from different perspectives.
- 2:53And I think that I just have to say it's a real
- 2:55pleasure to work with them. And I think in today's
- 2:58world of chaos, that's why we have much to talk
- 3:03about today as to how to come up with secret
- 3:07solutions that we don't share with other people
- 3:09that we're now going to try to share to get these
- 3:12cases settled, because people are angrier than
- 3:14ever and the chaos is greater than ever. And
- 3:18I think we all need, you know, a secret weapon.
- 3:21And it may be not so aggressive a weapon. It
- 3:25may be a nice weapon. But we need to think deeply
- 3:28as to how we can get things done in a chaotic
- 3:30world. So Jeff, why don't you start off? This
- 3:34was your idea. That sounds fine. I'm going to
- 3:37go off script a little bit as well, which is
- 3:40you mentioned the profound anger that's out there.
- 3:43And as a mediator, I do sense it. I have any
- 3:49number of tools. try to break the ice. But I'll
- 3:54tell you one of them that is a hard stop. No,
- 3:57which is I'm not there to talk politics with
- 4:00anybody. One of the best mediators that I know
- 4:04years ago, my client was from Florida and the
- 4:10mediator trying to break the ice said, Oh, my
- 4:13assumption is that you're supporting Senator
- 4:17Rubio for president of the United States. And
- 4:20my client said, no, he was supporting the guy
- 4:23who eventually became our president. And we were
- 4:28off sync for a good half hour because the door
- 4:32had been opened to that third rail, which is
- 4:36politics. Bob, does that discussion ever crop
- 4:39up when you're doing mediation or is that? No,
- 4:43you know, I haven't had that happen yet, but
- 4:45you can read people's facial expressions and
- 4:49eyes. And you can tell when they think you're
- 4:52coming from a different universe and they're
- 4:54uptight. And I think, you know, one point that
- 4:58you've made, I think, in our discussions is you've
- 5:01got to let the parties speak, because if they
- 5:05don't get their feelings out, they're ultimately
- 5:08not going to be a an active participant in the
- 5:13mediation process. And their lawyers will really
- 5:16take command. And I think that When I started
- 5:20off mediating and I started mediating in the
- 5:2390s and I didn't know what I was doing. Then
- 5:25I started again after I did the Pepperdine course
- 5:29with Jeff Krivitz and I knew what I was doing.
- 5:32But at that point, I was telling people what
- 5:36was going on and what the law was and what they
- 5:39should do. I do that very little now. I try to
- 5:43let them talk and express their feelings and
- 5:46then try to ask questions. that kind of leads
- 5:50them in the direction that I think they should
- 5:52go or with regards to what's missing. So I think
- 5:56that letting the parties talk and showing empathy
- 6:02and, you know, people can read you from a monitor.
- 6:06They really can if they're a student. And you've
- 6:09got to get to the point where you're empathetic
- 6:11and they feel you care about them. And I think
- 6:14that helps a lot to diffuse anger and anxiety.
- 6:18That's my take on it. Well, I think that's important.
- 6:22During the course of my litigation career, interviewing
- 6:27thousands of witnesses, I used to initially start
- 6:31out with a series of questions and notes and
- 6:37try to get their story out sequentially to make
- 6:42sure that it made sense. But what I found was
- 6:45that until you get the emotional component out
- 6:48there, you're really going nowhere. And my most,
- 6:52quote, sophisticated, end quote, question became
- 6:55my go -to question was simply to say, what happened?
- 7:00And at that point, the floodgates would open
- 7:04up regardless of the type of case it was. It
- 7:07could be a wrongful death case. It could be a
- 7:10complex intellectual property. matter. It didn't
- 7:13matter because people are invested in their litigation.
- 7:19And as a mediator, simply asking the question
- 7:22to the client, not to the lawyer, what happened
- 7:25produces all sorts of interesting responses.
- 7:29Right. No, I agree with you. So we have a fairly
- 7:32large audience today, and I think they were drawn
- 7:35here because they want to find out about our
- 7:37secrets. So I'm going to talk about one of my
- 7:39secrets. that I don't really ever tell the attorneys
- 7:44or parties. That is, when I have really long
- 7:48briefs that come in at the last second, I do
- 7:53AI summaries. I do them and I look at them and
- 7:57that gives me a quick cliff note overview of
- 8:02what the case is about. Then I spend my time
- 8:05skimming slowly the briefs. and confirming that
- 8:11the cliff notes are correct. And then it really
- 8:14sinks into my head. And it saves me just a tremendous
- 8:18amount of time. I find that AI is getting better
- 8:22and better. I've done this probably about 30
- 8:27times so far on bigger briefs. And only one had
- 8:31a mistake where a case citation just came out
- 8:35of left field. So you do have to. double check
- 8:37these things and of course I don't tell the parties
- 8:41that I've done this but what I do is go over
- 8:43the case in a bullet point type of manner at
- 8:47the beginning and that makes them feel comfortable
- 8:50like I've read their brief which I have I didn't
- 8:53take an hour and a half to go through it, which
- 8:55I might have to do if I didn't have the summary,
- 8:58maybe I spent half an hour, but I read the brief
- 9:00and that gives them a comfort level and they're
- 9:03relaxed and they have a lot more respect for
- 9:05me. In today's hectic world, getting briefs at
- 9:08the last second that are lengthy, maybe 20 pages
- 9:12with 100 pages of exhibits from three different
- 9:16parties, three different attorneys, it becomes
- 9:20difficult. mediations that I do for MCLA. I love
- 9:26MCLA. It's wonderful. The founders are absolutely
- 9:29brilliant guys. And it pays, but not enough for
- 9:34me to stop my work from the day before to spend
- 9:37four or five hours prepping for the mediation.
- 9:39So in that situation, it really helps me and
- 9:42it increases my ability. to guide them to a resolution
- 9:49and to make them feel comfortable. So I think
- 9:51AI, if you understand its weaknesses, can be
- 9:55very helpful. And there's a new AI program from
- 9:58Google called Notebook LM that is different from
- 10:02Chat GPT that confines itself to just the four
- 10:07corners of your document. Chat GPT goes through
- 10:11the world and can throw in crazy stuff. Notebook
- 10:15LM. And I've only used that once. My brother,
- 10:18who's a screenwriter, uses it, sticks within
- 10:21the four corners of the document. And that's
- 10:24great. So from a security and ethical point of
- 10:27view, I think that that may be the way to go.
- 10:29But the point is, there's technology out there
- 10:31and we should utilize it to do a better job and
- 10:35save time. Well, I'm not a tech guy, but I do
- 10:39like to hear from the clients. And let me give
- 10:41you a couple of examples as to that which I heard
- 10:46from the clients, which I wouldn't have heard
- 10:50from the briefs or from AI. One was in the IP
- 10:53world, and one was a personal injury lawsuit.
- 10:59The commercial case was one that involved two
- 11:03merchants in the jewelry district of Los Angeles,
- 11:07and they were diamond merchants. One of them
- 11:11was of Chinese extraction. One was from one of
- 11:15the Russian republics. And I asked my what happened
- 11:20and they started coming at each other in a combination
- 11:25of English and their chosen language. And I said,
- 11:29no, no, let's let's sort this out. And I actually
- 11:31brought in two translators. The issue was about
- 11:36a diamond. And I said, I'm not mediating unless
- 11:38I see the diamond. It was a whopper. And one
- 11:43of the merchants thought he had made a sale.
- 11:46And the other guy thought that it was on consignment.
- 11:50And sorting it out with the translators, not
- 11:55the lawyers, but the translators, we were able
- 11:57to reach resolution where they walked out hugging
- 12:01each other. And believe me, that doesn't happen
- 12:04a lot in mediation. That's the one from the commercial
- 12:09world. The one from a personal injury lawsuit
- 12:14was involving a state mental facility where one
- 12:21of the patients had died. Part of what we do
- 12:27as mediators is test the theses of each side.
- 12:33And I went in wonkishly with the mother of the
- 12:38woman, of the guy who had died. And I said, you
- 12:41know, look, I'm sure you loved your son, but
- 12:44you know, he wasn't employed. He wasn't housed.
- 12:48And she looked at me, and this was a woman who
- 12:51was on public assistance. And she said, you know,
- 12:54Mr. Kravitz, do you have children? And I said,
- 12:58yes. And she said, well, then hopefully you have
- 13:01learned. that you don't have them for them to
- 13:05be commercial successes. You have them to love
- 13:09and to cherish them. And at that point, we worked
- 13:13our way towards resolution. Trust me, that was
- 13:16nothing that appeared in the brief of the gentleman
- 13:20who was representing them. And by the way, he
- 13:24was a really good lawyer, but he didn't have
- 13:26that touch that the client brought to the situation.
- 13:31Interesting. Now we have a couple of questions
- 13:33already. One from Judge Bacigalupo. And hello,
- 13:40Judge. And he wants to know, how do you deal
- 13:42with an attorney who doesn't want their clients
- 13:44to talk? And that's a very significant question.
- 13:48And that is a problem occasionally. How do you
- 13:51deal with that? Very directly. I put on my big
- 13:57boy pants. And I say, look, part of the reason
- 14:00that you go to mediation is so that the clients
- 14:04can understand what's going on, what the process
- 14:08is, hopefully resolve it. But if they don't resolve
- 14:11it, at least they're going to understand what
- 14:15the process is and where their case lies coming
- 14:17out here. And then I look at him or her very
- 14:20directly and I say, chalk this one up to my ignorance.
- 14:25I am not going to understand your case unless
- 14:29I hear from your client. And then I pause and
- 14:34I say, now, I am sure that you have absolute
- 14:37confidence in your client, which they don't necessarily.
- 14:41And I need to hear what they have to say if we're
- 14:46going to resolve the situation. Bob, how about
- 14:49you? Well, in that situation, as I've become
- 14:54a little bit more sophisticated in the last four
- 14:56and a half years, I will go to a separate breakout
- 14:58room with the attorney and talk to him or her
- 15:02and say, we really need to get your client to
- 15:05open up and feel like he or she has been heard.
- 15:08And most of the time that works. A few times,
- 15:11it usually isn't a problem. And when it is, I
- 15:15would say that works 90 % of the time. And there's
- 15:18always one or two attorneys that are just very
- 15:21much in your face. And they're the boss, and
- 15:24they're not going to let the client deal with
- 15:28the mediator directly, even if they're there
- 15:31in the room. Now, another question that was raised,
- 15:34and it's a very good question. It's made me think
- 15:36about this. And I'm not perfect. I make mistakes
- 15:40all the time, every day. I just admit it, maybe
- 15:44more than some. Regarding the use of AI. The
- 15:50question is from Heather Atkinson. It's owned
- 15:54by Google. Are you concerned with privacy or
- 15:57first getting the client or attorney permission
- 15:58before putting their information in AI? Now,
- 16:00I think that's a good question, but my understanding
- 16:03is it, and that's made me think. And that I don't
- 16:08think applies to Notebook LM the way I understand
- 16:11it, but I will check that out. But I think it
- 16:12does apply to Chat GPT. And based on that, I
- 16:16think I probably should stop using Chat GPT.
- 16:19I don't think that's going to be a problem. I
- 16:21haven't done it that many times, although I've
- 16:26been doing it more regularly in the last half
- 16:28year. And I think that's a very good point. Another
- 16:31question is, is there a catharsis value to a
- 16:35planet being able to be heard for the first time?
- 16:37And I would say, just before you comment, absolutely.
- 16:44Oftentimes, clients and parties are timid. or
- 16:50their feelings and thoughts are suppressed by
- 16:52the lawyer who doesn't want to get into their
- 16:54feelings and thoughts, yet they're the ultimate
- 16:56decision maker. If you can get into that zone,
- 17:00that's very helpful. I have an example, maybe
- 17:04I'll discuss later of where the lawyer was in
- 17:06total control and wouldn't let the client talk.
- 17:09There's nothing I could do about it and it was
- 17:10a busted mediation. Jeff, what do you think?
- 17:14Is catharsis good or does that just create more
- 17:19I think it's essential. I don't think it's good.
- 17:23I think it's essential. And it is from a couple
- 17:26of respects. I mean, I gave you two examples
- 17:29that turned out quite well. But the more common
- 17:34situation is clients who are, I don't want to
- 17:41say overly invested, but let's just say super
- 17:43invested in their case. to the exclusion of everything
- 17:48else that life has to offer. And I try to hear
- 17:55the client, but as diplomatically as I can, I
- 17:59then try to find out what else is going on in
- 18:04their lives. For example, if I'm sensing the
- 18:11situation correctly, I'll say, gee, My son and
- 18:16his whole brood and family are about to show
- 18:18up at my house. And while I'm thrilled, I'm a
- 18:22little bit concerned. You know, how would you
- 18:27handle the situation? And at that point, you've
- 18:31taken them out of the mode of 100 % being invested
- 18:35in their case and making them realize that there's
- 18:40a whole life out there to be enjoyed. I try to
- 18:46steer them away from the sense that they're going
- 18:49to destroy the other side and to the sense that
- 18:54if they resolve the situation, they will be able
- 18:58to once again, 100 % be able to enjoy those grandkids
- 19:03because they're not going to be spending their
- 19:05time on the lawsuit. They're going to be on the
- 19:07playground with those little rugrats. No, I agree
- 19:12with you and completely and I have a case situation
- 19:17that I might share later if time permits where
- 19:20that became the whole focus of the mediation
- 19:23for the grandparents that were fighting over
- 19:27past child support from a divorce from 30 years
- 19:30before and who owed who and allowing the the
- 19:38father, the grandfather to suddenly see the grandchildren
- 19:42again. So there was money involved in grandchildren
- 19:44and we worked out a very interesting solution
- 19:48that satisfied everybody and stopped the crazy
- 19:51litigation. Now, Ben Williams mentions that Notebook
- 19:56LLM can be open. and scour the Internet or closed
- 20:00to the files uploaded. And you have to choose
- 20:02that option, he believes. And I think he's right.
- 20:05And I think that's a really good point. And also,
- 20:09you know, we make mistakes and, you know, maybe
- 20:14I've made a mistake. And you know what? When
- 20:16I make a mistake in a mediation, I apologize.
- 20:20And should mediators apologize? And my position
- 20:23is yes, if the clients feel that you've insulted
- 20:28them or haven't listened to them or interrupted
- 20:31them, I think an apology is the good thing to
- 20:34do. I have a very funny case example along those
- 20:38lines. I was doing an HOA case, and those are
- 20:41some of the toughest. I know a lot about HOAs
- 20:45because I've lived in different ones the last
- 20:4715 years. There's nothing easy about common ownership
- 20:53in terms of disputes. there was a dispute and
- 20:57the number one HOA law firm was representing
- 21:00the board charging a lot of money probably more
- 21:03than my hourly fee and there were three board
- 21:09members there and they were very uptight and
- 21:13very angry about the way that this owner was
- 21:16literally driving them crazy and the owner did
- 21:20not want to come to a resolution and I kept going
- 21:23back and forth and doing my very best to make
- 21:25it happen. And out of total frustration, after
- 21:29about two hours, two of the board members said
- 21:32to me, you're not working hard enough for us.
- 21:36We need to get this case settled. You need to
- 21:39do better. And they went on and on and they excoriated
- 21:43me. And my response was unfortunate. I said,
- 21:47because I have this strange sense of humor. I
- 21:50said, what do you want me to do? Hit her on the
- 21:52head with a stick? At that point, the attorney
- 21:56who was very full of herself with the big HOA
- 22:01firm statewide said, that is absolutely inappropriate.
- 22:06You've insulted my clients. You've insulted me.
- 22:09I'm thinking of terminating this mediation right
- 22:12now. Now, I could have said, well, go ahead and
- 22:17do it or whatever. But I said, no, I want to
- 22:20make this mediation work. So I said, I am so
- 22:23sorry. That was absolutely inappropriate. I apologize.
- 22:27And you're right. And I, you know, genuflected
- 22:30and all that stuff for about a minute. Probably
- 22:32did it a little bit too much. But the point is
- 22:35we got over that and then went on with the mediation.
- 22:38We did get a resolution finally after about five
- 22:40hours. So. You know, we make mistakes and I think
- 22:44there's nothing wrong with an apology. And Peter
- 22:46Robinson over at Pepperdine is like the expert
- 22:49on apologies and mediation. And I think it works
- 22:53for everybody, for the mediators and the parties
- 22:55and even the lawyers, although not everyone is
- 22:59willing to do that. But I think it has a lot
- 23:01of power. And you got to be able to read the
- 23:03room. I mean, I won't mention who it was, but
- 23:06one of the really. giants of the ADR field was
- 23:12known for laying F -bombs out. Two cases that
- 23:16I had before him, the first involved two producers
- 23:20in the entertainment world and they were frenemies.
- 23:25They did everything together, including suing
- 23:27each other. The mediator walks in, takes a look
- 23:33at the two of them. and says, do you think my
- 23:36people downtown are going to give a blankety
- 23:38blank about you to blankety blank producers?
- 23:43Well, that was needed because these guys had
- 23:46egos the size of a football field. And we ended
- 23:49up resolving the situation. The guy was a powerhouse.
- 23:54He was wonderful. Take a second mediation to
- 23:57him. This involved a real estate partnership.
- 24:01My clients were 30 -somethings, and the guy on
- 24:06the other side was 80. And the mediator comes
- 24:12in, lays out a couple of F -bombs, and at that
- 24:16point, the 80 -something basically said, I'm
- 24:19out of here. I'm not here to be insulted like
- 24:21that. Right. The mediator took a deep breath
- 24:25and said, you know, you're right. I tend to do
- 24:29that. It's not my most attractive quality. I'm
- 24:33really sorry. I flat out apologize to you. And
- 24:37at that point, we ended up and we ultimately
- 24:39resolve the situation. I've never done that as
- 24:44a mediator, but as a litigator, I did once as
- 24:46a mediation advocate with my clients and it wasn't
- 24:50really directed toward them per se. But I did
- 24:54use the word about ignorance, not understanding.
- 24:57And what I didn't realize is these people were
- 25:00deeply religious. And, you know, evangelical.
- 25:09And they took that as a total insult. And about
- 25:12a week later, I was subbed out of the case. And,
- 25:17you know, tell me who's perfect. I don't know.
- 25:20But I think that I think you need to really be
- 25:23careful when you're a mediator, because you are
- 25:26being watched by all sides. And you have to keep
- 25:29that in mind. And Jeff, I have a question for
- 25:32you. What do you think about likeability? Is
- 25:36it significant that the parties and the attorneys
- 25:38like the mediator, or is that irrelevant? What
- 25:44do you think about that? Different folks, different
- 25:47strokes. I don't have to be their friend. I don't
- 25:52have to be the anthropomorphic god sitting on
- 25:56high. I try to read the room and determine in
- 26:01this particular case, what's going to work? I
- 26:05mean, Turing, we've got a question which kind
- 26:07of segues into this, which is what are the key
- 26:10differences between the role of mediator and
- 26:13arbitrator? And I like to say that mediation
- 26:19is one third law, one third psychology, and one
- 26:25third magic. But I am a persuader. I'm not a
- 26:29decider. When I am an arbitrator, I am the judge.
- 26:35And particularly when I am an arbitrator, I do
- 26:39not feel any need to be their best buddy. And
- 26:44I think that detracts from the dignity of that
- 26:48which we are doing. I must say I have never had
- 26:51a mediation where I walked out and became friends
- 26:54with either the lawyers or the contestants. That's
- 26:58not what we're there for. Right. I agree with
- 27:00that. And yet on the mediation side, they don't
- 27:04have to think you're their best friend. But I
- 27:06think if you can get a rapport with them where
- 27:09they are comfortable with you and to a certain
- 27:12extent, even like you, I think that's very helpful.
- 27:17And Cialdini has his seven principles of persuasion,
- 27:21which are very powerful and very interesting.
- 27:23And one of the ones is likeability because If
- 27:27you like someone, you will do things for them
- 27:30that you might not do for someone else. I used
- 27:33to think when I was in high school that it would
- 27:38be nice to be, you know, school president or
- 27:40class president and all those things. And I did
- 27:43some stuff, but not I was not I was not class
- 27:47president, not school president. I analyzed who
- 27:50was getting elected over and over again. I said
- 27:53there are people that everybody just likes. They're
- 27:57just comfortable with that person. They're generally
- 28:00bright, not the brightest necessarily, but they
- 28:04get along with everybody. Everybody feels comfortable
- 28:07with them and then they want them to be the school
- 28:10president. I've seen that with even mediators.
- 28:14I know mediators, one of whom was a very successful
- 28:17judge and one of whom was a very successful big
- 28:21law. litigator, primarily for the defense, handling
- 28:25really big national cases. And I noticed that
- 28:30they were just incredibly likable and at ease
- 28:33when they were mediating. And we talked about
- 28:36it. And one of them, I was even involved with
- 28:40writing an article or two. And I said to them
- 28:42just off the top of my head, I said, what high
- 28:45school did you go to? Oh, so -and -so. One was
- 28:48in Hawaii. One was in the Valley. I said, You
- 28:52were school president, weren't you? And they
- 28:54said, yes, I was. And then one of them, I said,
- 28:59you know, would you go to college and university?
- 29:01I said, did you happen to be school president?
- 29:04He said, yes, I was. And I think that that's
- 29:09I mean, you know, I'm not 100 percent likable.
- 29:13Some people really get irritated by my candor
- 29:16and. whatever, whatever, my personality. But
- 29:20I think that the more you can go in that direction,
- 29:23if you can work on that, it's helpful. It's very
- 29:27helpful to get the people to calm down, use their
- 29:30rational, logical brain, and try to find a solution.
- 29:36And people want to please those that they like.
- 29:40So Jeff, what about dressing and appearance and
- 29:47things like that. Is that significant or not?
- 29:51You and I are both wearing ties. I don't wear
- 29:53a tie during the week. I used to. I grew up in
- 29:58the 70s. I was a lawyer in the mid 70s and it
- 30:01was wingtip shoes and white shirts and ties and
- 30:04all that. But that's certainly not the way it
- 30:06is now. Is that important or is that irrelevant?
- 30:10Well, first of all, we're living in a era where
- 30:12we have a U .S. senator who shows up on the Senate
- 30:14floor in a pair of shorts. Things have clearly
- 30:18changed. I came from a given perspective. My
- 30:22father had a dry cleaning store. Father -in -law
- 30:26sold men's suits. And so initially, when I started
- 30:30out in mediation, I was in the, quote, dress
- 30:32for success mode in terms of the parties. And
- 30:38I've modified that. I now tell people to dress
- 30:42for comfort. And the reason is litigation is
- 30:47stressful enough as it is. I don't need the litigants
- 30:53to be dressed a certain way in order to work
- 30:58with them. I did an arbitration about a week
- 31:02ago involving a tech guy. And he pleased me.
- 31:07He wore a black t -shirt the first day and he
- 31:10wore a white t -shirt the second day. That was
- 31:13fine because he was comfortable with the presentation.
- 31:17And I think that's probably more important than
- 31:22the dress for success rule. I think that's a
- 31:26shibboleth that has outlived its usefulness.
- 31:31Ron, we got a couple of questions, one from Ron
- 31:33Reitstein. Maybe you could field it. Let's see.
- 31:37Got to move my cursor down. Why don't you say
- 31:44what it is? Because I can't find it on my unit.
- 31:46It says, do you use penalty time leaving parties
- 31:49alone in their separate room? That is conference
- 31:53rooms in advance or do you redirect the process?
- 31:56I'm sorry. I missed the first part. When they're
- 31:58in separate rooms. Do you use penalty time leaving
- 32:02parties alone in their separate box? OK, I got
- 32:06it. I got it. No, I never do that. In fact, I
- 32:09try to do the reverse. I try to impress upon
- 32:15them that I'm here to work just as hard as I
- 32:17want them to work. And I constantly communicate
- 32:21with clients and say it's going to be another
- 32:2410 minutes, another five minutes. And I don't
- 32:28let clients stew over things. You see penalty,
- 32:31I think maybe it's the wrong word to use. Do
- 32:33I use time out or time for them to consider stuff?
- 32:37Yes. But I don't punish them for being uncooperative.
- 32:42I try to talk it through with them. And, you
- 32:46know, again, it's about a 50 -50 situation. But
- 32:50I try to be in a kind way. Very engaged with
- 32:56them which some people might call in their face
- 32:59but I don't think that's what it is because if
- 33:02I come with an empathetic sympathetic approach
- 33:04and They can tell that and if they think that
- 33:08I care more about them than my mediation fee,
- 33:12which oftentimes is I think that Parties are
- 33:16not sure about that. I'd make try to make that
- 33:18clear I think it helps so the idea of penalty
- 33:22time for them to straighten out no However, again,
- 33:27I impress upon them that if we go over a little
- 33:30bit, 15, 20 minutes, 30 minutes, I'm not going
- 33:33to bill them for it. And I've had mediations
- 33:36that have been continued many times where I turn
- 33:38the clock back a half hour or 45 minutes so that
- 33:41they have more time. And I'll tell you something,
- 33:44maybe I'm losing a few bucks, but they then have
- 33:49buy -in because they see that I have skin in
- 33:51the game and I care about them, I think. The
- 33:55more the parties recognize that you care about
- 33:58them in mediation, the more likely it will result
- 34:02in a good result. Now there are some parties
- 34:06and attorneys more particularly that just don't
- 34:09care. They don't care. I call them fullbacks.
- 34:13They just run up the middle, run up the middle
- 34:15and that's it. So you can be as nice as you want
- 34:18to be to them and do everything in the world
- 34:20and they just don't give a damn. But for most
- 34:23people, they respond to it, and that includes
- 34:26attorneys. So I don't know if I've answered Ron's
- 34:29question, but Ron, thank you. I have a question
- 34:34for you. I'm going to disagree with you on that
- 34:36one. OK. There are times where a party will get
- 34:42so worked up, they may even be hyperventilating.
- 34:46And I don't want to use the expression Penalty
- 34:51box, because I don't look at it that way. I prefer
- 34:54the expression that they use in child wearing.
- 34:57And believe me, I'm not infantilizing anybody.
- 34:59But the expression is a timeout. Right. Well,
- 35:03that's what I said. That's what I said earlier.
- 35:04So we're not in total disagreement. Right. Right.
- 35:10OK. Well, here's here's another question for
- 35:14you. What do you do when there is disparity?
- 35:18between the level of lawyering or when there's
- 35:22a pro -per on one side and a lawyer on the other
- 35:25side in mediation. Now, this is not arbitration.
- 35:28What do you do? And I know that, you know, the
- 35:31very successful and esteemed Jeff Kitchhaven
- 35:34makes it very clear that his position is hands
- 35:37off. It's not my job to help anybody. What do
- 35:41you do in situations like that? Because there's
- 35:43another school of thought, too, which I'm more
- 35:45likely to subscribe to. Well, this is one that
- 35:48mediators talk about over a couple of drinks,
- 35:51because it's not easy. And the reason it isn't
- 35:55easy is because, and I'm not being tongue in
- 35:59cheek, any number of lawyers went into lawyering
- 36:02because they wanted to do justice in one fashion
- 36:05or another. And you can be looking at a situation
- 36:08where there is that disparity and there is an
- 36:14urge to try to put your finger on the scales
- 36:17of justice. And it's a problem. And the reason
- 36:22it's a problem is because if the case goes to
- 36:27trial, that disparity may or may not be noticeable,
- 36:34which may mean the skills of one lawyer may transcend
- 36:37the skills of another. But that doesn't mean
- 36:41the jury is going to side with a better lawyer.
- 36:46There have been a number of wonderful lawyers
- 36:47who have lost cases to people with half their
- 36:50talent because either the facts don't merit that
- 36:55result or the jury went kind of crazy. And I
- 37:01must say that I err on the side of keeping hands
- 37:05off because I don't know what the dynamic is
- 37:07going to be. if it goes to trial. So I just let
- 37:10it play out. The more difficult situation is
- 37:14the pro -per. And the reason is most pro -pers
- 37:19I have found come in with a large degree of cynicism
- 37:24about the process. On the one hand, they divide
- 37:29into two clamps. Those who are incredibly cynical
- 37:31and those who are incredibly naive. And what
- 37:35I do think my role is is to explain as best I
- 37:41can how the process works, and not only how it
- 37:44works, but how it works in their particular case.
- 37:48But what I will not do is to make myself the
- 37:52lawyer for one side or the other. Interesting.
- 37:56I want to go back to Ron's question, because
- 37:59I've thought a little bit more about that, and
- 38:01I don't think my answer was really that great.
- 38:04But here's what I was trying to explain. And
- 38:07Ron, of course, is a very competent divorce lawyer.
- 38:10And I can't even imagine when he's doing a divorce
- 38:13mediation, how angry and out of control people
- 38:15get. I mean, I can hypothesize about it, but
- 38:19I've never really experienced it other than maybe
- 38:22a couple of situations in my life. So I think
- 38:26the way you phrase your action or what you want
- 38:33them to do is very significant. And I think that
- 38:37people need empathy, especially in divorces.
- 38:42They need to feel validated. You're having an
- 38:47awful experience. This is so bad. But, you know,
- 38:50why don't we let you go back into your room for
- 38:52a while and we'll come back. Instead of saying
- 38:55jokingly, which I certainly would have done years
- 38:57ago, you know, it's time for you to be in the
- 38:59penalty box. And we'll come back when things
- 39:02calm down. Now, the difference between those
- 39:05two statements, I think with the right person
- 39:07can be night and day. And I think you only learn
- 39:11how to communicate that way by having what I
- 39:14call flight time, being a mediator and actually
- 39:17making the little mistakes and then seeing how
- 39:20you correct yourself. I think that's what we
- 39:22all do. But that's my take on the penalty box
- 39:24versus an empathetic response and saying, we'll
- 39:28come back, go get some Kleenex. That leads us
- 39:32into one of the questions that we're getting
- 39:33from the assembled. The question reads, in employment
- 39:37mediation, how do you move the case forward when
- 39:41documented facts and all witnesses refute workers'
- 39:45claims, yet the employee continues to demand
- 39:48hundreds of thousands or more? That's just a
- 39:53great question. Part of how I approach it, is
- 40:00to come in with an understanding that people
- 40:06sue largely for two reasons. The first is about
- 40:09the Benjamins, but the other is about dignity.
- 40:14Particularly in employment situations, oftentimes
- 40:19the dignity question transcends seeking a lot
- 40:25of money. What I try to do is to say to this
- 40:32imaginary employee, not, you've got a terrible
- 40:37case, but something more along the lines of,
- 40:40you've got a tough road to hoe. Pause, see if
- 40:48I get a reaction and say, look, I really understand
- 40:53that you feel terrible about this situation.
- 40:57because you feel that your dignity has been assaulted.
- 41:05Sometimes I met with just a wall of anger, but
- 41:11sometimes there are situations where that employee
- 41:17will then have a recognition that the task is
- 41:23maybe to get him some dollars, but also that
- 41:27each side emerges with a sense of dignity about
- 41:30the situation. Yeah, no, I agree with that. And
- 41:34I've had the situation not with parties, but
- 41:37with lawyers in particular, where there are statutory
- 41:41legal fees and they want just a tremendous amount
- 41:46of lawyers fees as a part of the settlement.
- 41:49And I had one case where The case had not yet
- 41:53been filed, but there was a statutory requirement
- 41:55for a pre -filing mediation, again, in an HOA
- 42:00situation. And the attorney who chose me, because
- 42:06I've written about HOA mediations and disputes,
- 42:10came in with a request. Part of his damage package
- 42:13of $500 ,000 or more was, I think, $150 ,000
- 42:17or $200 ,000 legal fees. yet there had not yet
- 42:21been a lawsuit filed. And it was over, you know,
- 42:25typical stuff, water damage and all sorts of
- 42:29things to the unit because of alleged negligence
- 42:32on the part of the HOA, which may have been true.
- 42:35But instead of handling it in a kind and sympathetic
- 42:41way and validating, even though I felt his claim
- 42:46was completely preposterous. I told him he was
- 42:49wrong. He wasn't going to get it. And I also
- 42:53did another no -no. I said, you know, you're
- 42:57a young lawyer, and I know you feel very passionate
- 42:59about this. I'm sure there's many points that
- 43:01you have that are correct. But the other attorney
- 43:04has been doing this for 35 years. That's all
- 43:07he does is defend HOA claims. And I don't think
- 43:11you're ever going to get anywhere near that,
- 43:14even above the low to mid five figures. And he
- 43:18was so upset. He was incensed. And I don't usually
- 43:22get complaints, but that was one of the few that
- 43:24I did receive because he felt that I was belittling
- 43:28him. And that becomes a difficult issue. You
- 43:31know, do you buy into their insanity or their
- 43:36ridiculous posturing and make them feel better
- 43:40when you know that it's going to be a busted
- 43:42mediation? Or do you tell them straight? that
- 43:47they're wrong and that they're being foolish.
- 43:49And I think as an beginning mediator, I was tempted
- 43:54to do the latter. And as a more experienced mediator
- 43:58now, I go with the former because I think the
- 44:04ride, the process is almost as important as the
- 44:07destination. And it's that way for two reasons.
- 44:13One, you can get them to calm down. and hear
- 44:18and think logically about what's happening. Two,
- 44:23they don't have a sour taste in their mouth when
- 44:27the mediation is done and they feel like they've
- 44:31been heard and maybe the case didn't settle,
- 44:33but at least they're making some progress. Had
- 44:39I had the ability to do it over again, do them
- 44:44all again. I would get the attorneys together.
- 44:47And I would say, gee, you know, X, you want 150
- 44:50,000 or 200 ,000. There's been no filing. Y,
- 44:54you don't believe he's entitled to anything other
- 44:57than maybe a couple thousand bucks. Why don't
- 44:58you guys talk about it? And then I would let
- 45:01them do it that way. But by taking charge and
- 45:04telling them what I thought was the result, I
- 45:07became the enemy. And it made them feel like
- 45:11it was a waste of time. So. That's something
- 45:14I learned. It can happen. We do have an interesting
- 45:17question, which is, do you put people in separate
- 45:19rooms? Do you put everybody together? And I have
- 45:23kind of a unique perspective on that, which is
- 45:26there's an statewide organization called California
- 45:29Lawyers for the Arts. And unlike traditional
- 45:33mediation, they put everybody together in one
- 45:37room. And I got to tell you, Bob, sometimes it's
- 45:41like a food fight. It can be difficult and I
- 45:50think it works in the arts because forgive me,
- 45:54my experience dealing with the entertainment
- 45:56industry is that people have pretty thick skins
- 45:58and they can yell and scream and get it all out
- 46:01and still come to resolution on matters. Not
- 46:05to say I haven't had busted mediations when that
- 46:08technique is used, but that's the preferred modality
- 46:13for California lawyers for the arts. Short of
- 46:17that, I put people in separate rooms. And the
- 46:19reason is I have just found that that leads to
- 46:23more productive results. If they were going to
- 46:29be able to be in the same room together, they
- 46:31wouldn't be here with us in mediation in most
- 46:34cases. But what are your thoughts? Where do you
- 46:36put people together or do you ever do so? Well,
- 46:39I do on occasion. more often with attorneys than
- 46:43the parties, I find that backfires if I get the
- 46:47parties and the lawyers all together. Although,
- 46:50you know, and that's the California model to
- 46:53have separate breakout rooms. But I violate that
- 46:56model if I think that we're not going to settle.
- 46:58I don't just say, well, we've gone for M .C .L
- 47:02.A. We've gone two hours and it's clear that
- 47:03there's an impasse. So I want to thank you very
- 47:06much. And there's nothing more that we can do.
- 47:08I never do that. At that point, I might say to
- 47:13the attorneys, you know, how about just we boys
- 47:19or we boys and girls go into a separate breakout
- 47:23room without the parties and let's talk about
- 47:26the disparities and where you guys are at loggerheads.
- 47:30And most of the time they will agree to do it,
- 47:33sometimes reluctantly, but invariably at least
- 47:36one or even both of them feel that it's been
- 47:39somewhat productive, more productive than if
- 47:42we had just stopped because they can really get
- 47:45a better sense of where the lawyer is at. And
- 47:47what happens is because of the emotion, even
- 47:51on the part of the lawyers, they're less likely
- 47:53to withhold their feelings or their strategies
- 47:57and they will start talking turkey. They'll say,
- 48:00I'm going to do this and you're going to lose
- 48:01on that. And they may not have done that in their
- 48:04brief and they wouldn't do it necessarily without
- 48:07that. joint meeting after two or two and a half
- 48:10hours. And I think that that's a good thing because
- 48:14it's a reality check for the lawyers. I have
- 48:16not had a single lawyer complain to me. Why did
- 48:22you put me in the room with that person? I agreed
- 48:25that I was mistaken. You shouldn't have done
- 48:27that. I think it's a communication is everything.
- 48:31That's really a great approach. And a couple
- 48:34of things that you get out of doing that, number
- 48:36one, I've had situations where the clients can't
- 48:41stand each other, but the lawyers get along perfectly
- 48:44fine. Sometimes it isn't until you put the lawyers
- 48:48together in a separate room that that dynamic
- 48:53comes out. That's number one. Number two, I'm
- 48:58sure that you have had situations as well where
- 49:02the lawyer needs the mediator to be an ally.
- 49:07against their client. And they're not going to
- 49:09be able to do that because they have to be a
- 49:11warrior with their client present. But you put
- 49:15the lawyers together in a room and one or both
- 49:19of them will say, you know, look, I'm dealing
- 49:21with a maniac. I need your help. How do we get
- 49:23there? I agree. And by the way, what that is
- 49:27all about is communication. And speaking of communication,
- 49:30I've got a pet peeve. So often. Council refused
- 49:36to exchange mediation briefs. And I wrote an
- 49:39article about that several years ago. So when
- 49:41I do my convening package, I include that and
- 49:44I really promote the fact that they must exchange
- 49:49or should I don't say I never say must that they
- 49:51should exchange mediation briefs. And it helps
- 49:54a little bit. And I think that that saves a lot
- 49:57of wasted time in the mediation process. What
- 50:00do you think? I think that's critical. And Most
- 50:04of the time when a party says, I'm not going
- 50:06to give my brief to the other side, it's because
- 50:09they have a secret that they don't want the other
- 50:13side to know about going into the mediation.
- 50:17And I got to tell you, Bob, I don't know what
- 50:19your experience has been, but I have found there
- 50:21are very few secrets by the time that you get
- 50:25to mediation. Well, yeah. A few years ago, yes,
- 50:30I think at this point, with early mediations
- 50:33that are court referred, they're not ordered,
- 50:35by the way. They're court referrals. Oftentimes,
- 50:38there are secrets. But they can always withhold
- 50:43that stuff. I think it's obvious that exchanging
- 50:47a mediation brief would be helpful. And quite
- 50:51frankly, I think the court should require, just
- 50:54like they do for MSCs, that in a court -referred
- 50:58mediation, they must submit and exchange mediation
- 51:02briefs. And then if they want to withhold something,
- 51:05they can do that as you can in an MSC. You can
- 51:08do a separate statement for the judge that is
- 51:13confidential. And I don't know why you can't
- 51:16do that all the time in mediation, why it can't
- 51:20be referred. or maybe not ordered, but a part
- 51:23of the referral process, it should be you will
- 51:25exchange briefs. And the way that I handle that
- 51:29is to try to get a middle path, which is to say,
- 51:33OK, fine, I understand there are certain things
- 51:35you don't want the other side to know going into
- 51:38the mediation. And what I would ask that you
- 51:41do is that you submit a brief to me, which will
- 51:45have black type set for that which you have shared
- 51:49with the other side. And anything that you want
- 51:53to be a secret, put it in red so that I can see
- 51:58it, but the other side is not going to see it.
- 52:01That's a good, good, good strategy. On the issue
- 52:06of exchanging briefs, there was another point
- 52:09that I wanted to make. I'm losing track of that
- 52:11now, but I just think it's so important and so
- 52:16obvious. And I don't know. Oh, I know what I
- 52:19want to say. And that is. When they have not
- 52:22exchanged briefs and we're in mediation, I say,
- 52:26gee, the other side's brief is very interesting
- 52:29and I think it should be exchanged. Would you
- 52:33be willing to exchange your brief with them if
- 52:35they sent their brief over to you? About 25 percent
- 52:39of the time or even a third of the time, they
- 52:41agree. That now directs the mediation in a much
- 52:45better direction because now there is you know,
- 52:49some reciprocity, which is one of the seven Cialdini
- 52:52elements of persuasion. They feel like, OK, the
- 52:56guy's being a decent guy or gal. And they start
- 53:01to be more relaxed and more positive about the
- 53:05process. That's my take. So I try. I try. I don't
- 53:08let up after they don't exchange briefs. I even
- 53:12approach them directly on that point at the mediation
- 53:15and about a third of the time they do. One of
- 53:19the questions that we have from the assembled
- 53:20is, do you require that a plaintiff submit a
- 53:25demand in advance of the mediation? And this
- 53:30is very current with me. I've got a civil rights
- 53:32case that I'm going to be mediating on Friday.
- 53:36I've specifically solicited a demand in advance.
- 53:41And part of the reticence from plaintiffs' lawyers
- 53:43is, well, geez, this figure is going to seem
- 53:46extraordinarily large and harsh and may hurt
- 53:51rather than advance the mediation? Well, my answer
- 53:54to that is, well, then come in with a realistic
- 53:56figure, number one. Number two, there's no harm
- 53:59in asking. Sometimes what may look to a plaintiff's
- 54:04lawyer as being an unreasonable demand may not
- 54:06be considered an unreasonable demand in the other
- 54:08room. You're not going to suss that out until
- 54:12you give me a demand in advance. And it certainly
- 54:17saves one heck of a lot of time when we go to
- 54:21mediation and at least have a starting point.
- 54:24And everybody understands that a starting point,
- 54:26that's no secret. What are your thoughts? I'm
- 54:31thinking about it right now, actually, and I
- 54:34think it cuts both ways. Sometimes when the demands
- 54:38are outrageous, it does get the defense attorneys
- 54:42ticked off and then they respond in kind. if
- 54:45not in their briefs, in the negotiations. And
- 54:50other times they appreciate it. And I think probably
- 54:56if they're going to make an outrageous demand,
- 54:59it should be confidential to the mediator so
- 55:01he understands or she understands where that
- 55:05attorney is at so as not to inflame the other
- 55:08side. And that's an interesting point that I
- 55:12just kind of am considering now. But again, all
- 55:15of this takes time. You have to talk to the council
- 55:19and time is such a precious thing. None of us
- 55:22seem to have it and nobody wants to pay for it
- 55:27unless you're, you know, with one of the major
- 55:29leading mediation services, which I will not
- 55:32mention the charge, you know, 10 ,000 or more
- 55:36a day. So I think that communicating with the
- 55:41council. maybe even in the convening letter saying,
- 55:46I invite your demand, but if you want to keep
- 55:50it confidential to me, something along those
- 55:52lines, that might be a good thing. The other
- 55:55reason that I like a demand is it really depends
- 55:58on the kind of case that we're talking about.
- 56:01If it is an auto versus auto case, the demand
- 56:06is going to consist of lost of wages, medicals,
- 56:10I don't want to say simple situations because
- 56:13obviously personal injury cases can be very involved,
- 56:16but they don't involve a continuing relationship.
- 56:18If I am dealing with a business situation, it
- 56:23may well be that the non -monetary terms will
- 56:27equal or transcend the monetary terms. I'd like
- 56:33to look ahead of time and see what I can get
- 56:39my creative juices going on before the mediation,
- 56:43because we may be talking about not just X number
- 56:47of thousand or million of dollars, we may be
- 56:49talking about credits on a production, we may
- 56:54be talking about residuals, we may be talking
- 56:56about future royalties, and those don't come
- 57:01off the top when you're in mediation. It is very
- 57:04helpful to the defense side. to take a look at
- 57:07those things in advance so that they can meet
- 57:10with their clients and not get caught flat -footed
- 57:14at the mediation itself. I think that's a good
- 57:17point, and I think it's critical in the bigger
- 57:20cases that you handle. I seem to handle smaller
- 57:23or more mid -sized cases than you, which is fine.
- 57:27I mean, there's a lot more small and mid -sized
- 57:31cases out there than the large ones, but I think
- 57:34it's tricky And it requires thought and probably
- 57:40requires a pre -mediation conference where you
- 57:43get into some of those issues if you're concerned.
- 57:46We're coming up at the end of an hour. We could
- 57:48spend hours on these things. But I do want to
- 57:50take up one question, which we got from David
- 57:53Wong, which is, what do you think of a mediator
- 57:56strategy to put each side in a separate breakout
- 57:59room and wear them both out, telling each side
- 58:03they're wrong on their case? and that they should
- 58:05compromise by pointing out the facts and case
- 58:08law against each side under what circumstances
- 58:12does that strategy backfire. Listen, I went into
- 58:14mediation because I didn't like that approach.
- 58:19And if you take that approach, frankly, you lose
- 58:21credibility in the broader field of mediation
- 58:24very, very quickly. I tell people that I analyze
- 58:28risk as best I see it and that I'm going to give
- 58:32them my unbridled opinion. And the reason that
- 58:35I do that is that you have to establish Bobby,
- 58:39the credibility. And there is no credibility
- 58:41where you go into each side and tell them they
- 58:44have a terrible case. Right. But what are your
- 58:48thoughts? Yeah, pretty much the same. And that's
- 58:52the old style. Judge Tanner, may he rest in peace.
- 58:56He was kind of that way. He was kind of a force
- 58:59of nature in the 80s and 90s. And I remember
- 59:03being in a mediation where, you know, he just
- 59:06said, this is the most you're going to ever get
- 59:09and you need to take it or you better try the
- 59:12case. And it didn't feel very good. And it didn't
- 59:16feel like he was trying to make the case resolved.
- 59:21It was basically his rule. And it just didn't
- 59:24feel good. And I agree with that. That's not
- 59:27what mediation is about. And especially in today's
- 59:30angry world. especially today, compared to 25
- 59:35or 30 years ago, that's not what people need
- 59:38to hear. Because even if they agree to it, they
- 59:42end up with a terrible bitterness. And the process,
- 59:48I think, loses so much of its potential. So I
- 59:52think that that's something that maybe happened
- 59:54in the past frequently, but I don't see it as
- 59:58a good solution today. Well, and I try to tell
- 1:00:01people, look, this is not a Scientology meeting
- 1:00:04where you have only a limited number of bathroom
- 1:00:09breaks and you can't eat an apple and cheese.
- 1:00:13I am there to try to make people feel as comfortable
- 1:00:17as they can under the circumstances. And the
- 1:00:20reason is what you don't want to have is a settlement
- 1:00:24with buyer's remorse on either side. Right. Right,
- 1:00:28I agree. And that's why, you know, kumbaya is
- 1:00:32a wonderful concept and it's rarely reached,
- 1:00:35but I think you have to try to seek it. And you
- 1:00:38don't do that by making people feel defensive
- 1:00:42at all. I agree. As I mentioned, we're coming
- 1:00:47to the end of the hour and we could spend an
- 1:00:50awful lot of time, but any final thoughts for
- 1:00:52this session? Yeah, when you get down to it,
- 1:00:58mediation in the more sophisticated sense is
- 1:01:03really an art. You need to get the tools. That's
- 1:01:07true. You need to understand what's happening.
- 1:01:09But it's only after you do it and have failures
- 1:01:13and successes and you start analyzing what worked
- 1:01:16and what didn't work and what your personality
- 1:01:18is about. You know, everybody has different personalities.
- 1:01:21The mediator, Tony Piazza, who was very famous
- 1:01:25in the early 2000s and still is, I think, very
- 1:01:28active, he just lays it out, take it or leave
- 1:01:32it, and people like him and they respect that.
- 1:01:35So you have to be true to yourself, but you have
- 1:01:38to be aware of the temperature in the room, I
- 1:01:43think. Reading the room is more important than
- 1:01:46ever now. And my final thought is, kind of akin
- 1:01:52to yours, which is that mediation is a process.
- 1:01:55And particularly on the more complex cases, I
- 1:01:59find that we don't necessarily settle in the
- 1:02:02first session. It may well be that it takes a
- 1:02:05couple of follow -up phone calls before the parties
- 1:02:09have absorbed all the information that they need
- 1:02:12in order to settle the case. I agree, and I'm
- 1:02:16going to hopefully stop talking after this, but
- 1:02:18that leads me to another thought. And that is,
- 1:02:22historically, when I was doing mediations after
- 1:02:26my time with Crivas, voluntary stuff with Spirit
- 1:02:29Court and some pay panel stuff, if I felt there
- 1:02:33was an impasse, I would just say, you know, we
- 1:02:35can't go any further. I don't do that now. I
- 1:02:38say, gee, this has been great. I'm a salesman.
- 1:02:42We've really learned a lot, but we've also learned
- 1:02:44all sorts of things that we don't know. So why
- 1:02:47don't we continue this? We've gone two hours
- 1:02:51and it's supposed to be three or we've gone four
- 1:02:55hours or three hours and it's supposed to be
- 1:02:57four. I'll give you another hour and a half.
- 1:03:00I give them an extra half hour. Go do some discovery,
- 1:03:03do this. Let's have one or two status conferences
- 1:03:06maybe in between the time that we reconvene and
- 1:03:09then let's reconvene. They like that. They appreciate
- 1:03:12that. I think you need to keep working at it.
- 1:03:16The idea of stopping the mediation because the
- 1:03:19parties are too far apart is not the solution
- 1:03:23in today's world. And it is amazing how, after
- 1:03:28a little reflection, the parties can come together
- 1:03:32after that first session. Right. Speaking of
- 1:03:35which, we've reached the end of our time. I want
- 1:03:37to thank everybody who has joined us. I'm sorry
- 1:03:40that we didn't get to all of the questions. It
- 1:03:42may be that it's worthwhile for us to do a part
- 1:03:46two on this. I've really enjoyed this, and thank
- 1:03:48you for sharing that first cup of coffee with
- 1:03:50Bob and me. Yeah, have a good day, everybody,
- 1:03:53and wherever you are. I hope this gave you some
- 1:03:58insight into the way we think, and maybe you'll
- 1:04:00get some ideas from it. Bye now. Bye.