Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Elizabeth Warren Demands Answers from NCUA Board Chairman Kyle Hauptman on Actions Since Trump Firings
Transcript
- 0:00Hey everyone.
- 0:00This is Mark Kel with another episode of With Flying Colors.
- 0:03You're either listening on your favorite podcast app or you're watching on YouTube.
- 0:08Today I am going to have a podcast about.
- 0:11The Donald Trump firing Tanya Otsuka and Todd Harper, and the ramifications
- 0:17that is having on NCUA and which triggered a couple letters coming from
- 0:22Elizabeth Warren and Maxine Waters.
- 0:25I.
- 0:27Kyle Houtman.
- 0:27First it a letter to the N-C-A-I-G and talk about good timing.
- 0:32NCAA's IG retired just before this letter came out, and they
- 0:36have a person that is the acting ig who had to respond to Warren.
- 0:42And then when they got that letter that triggered a letter from Warren
- 0:47to NCA Board Chair Kyle Halman about the state of affairs at NCUA.
- 0:53Without further ado, oh, by the way and the devil's in the details and
- 0:57the devil is in the footnotes, so there's some really good footnotes
- 1:00here that I'm gonna dive into.
- 1:04I'll just kinda walk through the letter here and give my
- 1:06commentary as I go through it.
- 1:07Kyle Halman.
- 1:08Dear Chairman, Halman, we write today to request information regarding the
- 1:12operation of the National Credit Union Administration and CA Board In the Wake I.
- 1:17Of the illegal firings of the NCA Board members, Todd Harper and Tanya Ska.
- 1:21Specifically, we seek clarification on the board's legal authority to conduct
- 1:25standard NCA business in the absence of a quorum and request additional
- 1:29documentation to better understand the NCA board's recent actions.
- 1:34So here they're saying it was the illegal, that's to be determined.
- 1:37That's the position Har Harper notes gonna have taken.
- 1:40We'll see what the judges say, but they want some information about
- 1:44the actions that have happened.
- 1:46And I've got podcasts on this.
- 1:47We'll walk through it again here 'cause there's some updated information.
- 1:50We now have a list of what actions they actually took.
- 1:54And next paragraph.
- 1:55Despite the critical importance of a fully staffed board to the NCA
- 1:59operations President Trump unlawfully fired NCA Board members Todd
- 2:03Harper and Tanya Ska on April 16th.
- 2:05As a result, you are the only board member remaining at the NCA.
- 2:10In response, we wrote to the NCA Officer of the Inspector General
- 2:13requesting an investigation of your authority to continue full agency
- 2:17operations with only one board member.
- 2:20Our latest request.
- 2:22Requested information on what legal analysis, if any, the
- 2:25NCA or other administration officials conducted to assess the
- 2:29firings impact on the NCA Board.
- 2:31Copies of all written communications and documents between NCA officials, the
- 2:35White House, and other administrative administration officials regarding
- 2:39the decision, and a list of actions taken by the NCA Board on.
- 2:44Or after April 16th, 2025, the IG response included a troubling, troubling
- 2:52information that suggests neither the NCA or the White House understands what
- 2:56actions the agency can lawfully take in the wake of the firings according
- 3:00to documents provided to us by the ig, when there is only one NCA board
- 3:04member serving on the board, individual board members may carry out any
- 3:08essential function on the NCA Board.
- 3:11You may recall that delegation went into play in the early two thousands.
- 3:16I've had a podcast about this, but I was the deputy executive director
- 3:20at the time, and there was only one board member, Dennis Dollar.
- 3:24Dennis Daher asked the general counsel, what things can I do?
- 3:27And they said you probably shouldn't vote on anything because there's
- 3:31a question about what a quorum is.
- 3:33They decided what he could do was have briefings.
- 3:36That's when the N-C-U-S-I-F quarterly briefing was born and he did
- 3:40another briefing, and then there, I think there were two meetings,
- 3:42and then he was joined by two.
- 3:44Additional board members Joanne Johnson and Debbie Matts who filled out the
- 3:49full compliment and then they could move forward with their full agenda.
- 3:52But by the end of that year they said, Hey, we should clarify some of this.
- 3:56And they put into NCAA's delegations that if there's only one board member, they
- 4:00can take essential actions and carry out any essential functions for the board.
- 4:06So what is essential, in the eye of the beholder, and that's what part of what
- 4:11the Democrat's problems are with what's going on at NCUA at this point in time.
- 4:16However, the IG was unable to produce any documentation that delineates
- 4:20between essential and non-essential.
- 4:22I.
- 4:22Functions, and I, that's consistent with what I said.
- 4:25There was never any definition of essential when I was at NCUA, and it
- 4:30doesn't sound like they've added that.
- 4:33So it's really what's in the eye of the beholder now.
- 4:37What is the definition of essential absolutely necessary.
- 4:40Extremely important, a thing that is absolutely necessary.
- 4:45You need a budget to conduct business at NCO eight.
- 4:48You could argue that is essential.
- 4:50They liquidated a credit union.
- 4:52The debt authority had already been placed with the regional directors for years.
- 4:56You could argue that in order to reduce the cost of the insurance fund.
- 5:00And unsafe and unsalted actions at that credit union.
- 5:02They needed to liquidate that credit union and live by the old delegations.
- 5:07Now, this is a new delegation or was 25 years ago, where they said that
- 5:12essential actions can be taken by the NCUA when there's only one board
- 5:16member, but they're trying to get to the bottom of what actions have taken.
- 5:20Then they have a paragraph of, the agency is responsible
- 5:22for the safekeeping of the 2.3
- 5:24trillion in assets in the credit union system, most of which are the deposits of
- 5:28hardworking Americans, saving for college to buy a home or saving for retirement.
- 5:33Credit Unions currently serve more than 142 million members, and the absence
- 5:37of any meaningful description of what the agency can do during the period
- 5:40of time when it has one board member raises serious concerns and questions.
- 5:44Yeah, this is politics politics 1 0 1, but, you may recall, or you may
- 5:48not be aware, but Elizabeth Warren was the architect of the CFPB.
- 5:52The CFPB has one person in charge of it.
- 5:55She was comfortable with it there, but she's not comfortable with it at NCA.
- 5:58Now that doesn't go to the fact that Congress established
- 6:00the Federal Credit Union Act.
- 6:02Congress said, you do need to have a full board.
- 6:04But little disingenuous 'cause sh Warren was comfortable with
- 6:10the CFPB being led by one.
- 6:12She just doesn't want NSU a led by one because it's an R right now,
- 6:15and it flies in the face of the lawsuits that Harper Osca have put
- 6:20in place the actions that Trump has taken here and at other agencies.
- 6:24But in any event, they have a hat tip to you know what's going on.
- 6:28You only have one leader.
- 6:30Moreover, there is a significant evidence to suggest that the NCA Board cannot
- 6:34fully function with only one board member.
- 6:36By statute, the NCA Board shall consist of three members.
- 6:38Yep.
- 6:39And a majority of the board shall con constitute a quorum.
- 6:42The board has brought authority to oversee federal credit unions, including the
- 6:46power to prescribe rules and regulations.
- 6:48The board regulations make it clear that the agreement of at least
- 6:51two of the three board members is required for any action by the board.
- 6:56The regulation also provides, a board cannot hold regular meetings
- 6:59if a quorum is not available.
- 7:01So their own regulation is probably, to me, their Achilles heels.
- 7:04In this, they say they need two people to do anything.
- 7:07That's a regulation.
- 7:08And if you wanted to say a regulation was essential, how can
- 7:11you do it if there aren't two now?
- 7:14They have, I think, internally opined that a quorum is one.
- 7:18If there is only one.
- 7:19So you can meet the quorum.
- 7:21I've done some research on that.
- 7:22You can argue a quorum.
- 7:23You need at least two.
- 7:24If you have a, if you have a a homeowner's association that's
- 7:28supposed to have five board members and you only have two board members.
- 7:31What's a quorum of two?
- 7:33It would be two if everybody resigned.
- 7:35But one, you still need to, you still need to go on, you still need to carry on at
- 7:38NCUA at any organization with the board.
- 7:41So I would argue, and they are arguing that with one board
- 7:45member, you need to be able to do certain things and those things.
- 7:49As previously established by delegations approved by a full board, would
- 7:53be that those things would have to be essential things, but they go
- 7:55back to have you defined essential.
- 7:57What is essential, what have, what actions have you taken, and again,
- 8:00we'll get to that here shortly.
- 8:02The IG provided documents showing the delegations of
- 8:05certain authorities to the chair.
- 8:06For example, the chairman of the board was given the authority to
- 8:09act unilaterally during emergencies.
- 8:11In an emergency situation, the NCA board chair may temporarily revoke
- 8:15certain delegations of any staff person, exercise all HR authorities
- 8:19retained by the board place.
- 8:20Certain senior officials on administrative leave and the chair in a state of
- 8:24national emergency may also act exercise.
- 8:26All authorities retained by the board, by the way, state of national
- 8:29emergency is what it sounds like.
- 8:32It has to be that the federal government whether it's Homeland Security or the
- 8:37President, I'm trying to remember who actually makes that determination.
- 8:40If there isn't a state of national emergency defined elsewhere, NSU
- 8:43A cannot use that de delegation.
- 8:46I.
- 8:47What else?
- 8:47There was something else here unilaterally during emergencies and emergency, we
- 8:51may temporary revoke by the way, that regulation, that delegation about
- 8:55revoking delegations is redundant.
- 8:57Because when I was there, we added some language to the delegations
- 9:02that said the delegations flow through the chain of commands.
- 9:05When I was the executive director, if I didn't like how a regional director
- 9:08was doing on their delegations I could revoke it and do that action myself.
- 9:13It flows all the way back to the board.
- 9:15Now, I never did that.
- 9:16I never wanted to do that.
- 9:18I never needed to do that.
- 9:19'cause the rds were doing a fabulous job.
- 9:21But the authority to do that is there, but I digress.
- 9:25Notably, however, the NCA is not currently in a state of emergency and
- 9:28outside of emergency situations, board members' ability to act is more limited.
- 9:33Agreed.
- 9:35According to the ig, the board has acted on 11 board action
- 9:39memorandums on or after April 16th.
- 9:42The IG found that former board member Todd Harper, voted yes on
- 9:46one of the 11 items prior to his.
- 9:51Firing on April 16th.
- 9:53Pretty sure that's the one that authorized their buyouts at NCA, which
- 9:57is a good thing because to me, at first, I thought when I saw the list
- 10:01and the buyout program was on there.
- 10:02By the way, NCA folks, if you're listening, I think your
- 10:05buyouts are safe 'cause Todd.
- 10:06Todd voted on him.
- 10:08They don't say that's the one here that he voted on, but I have it from
- 10:11good intel that's the one he voted on.
- 10:14How?
- 10:14How otherwise, however, you appear to have acted on bams unilaterally again, without
- 10:19any consideration of whether these actions are essential functions of the NCUA board.
- 10:24So it's interesting they are arguing.
- 10:26That the delegations allow for essential functions.
- 10:30But there are only three and beyond essential functions you can't really act.
- 10:34And I don't think you can have it both ways.
- 10:36I think it's smart that NSU A has this essential functions that I helped put it
- 10:40in place back in the early two thousands.
- 10:42But, at what juncture who's to define what essential is,
- 10:45the act doesn't talk about it.
- 10:47Regulations don't talk about it.
- 10:49You clearly need to go on in the scenarios that exist, but let's say.
- 10:54An accident happened and all three board members were together and they were gone.
- 10:57They have delegations that allow the executive director to act for the board.
- 11:00I wouldn't have felt very comfortable having been the executive director
- 11:03having to do those things.
- 11:05And that would've been thrust upon me in my days, had that happen.
- 11:08Thank god it didn't happen.
- 11:10But it's not consistent with the Federal Credit Union Act, and
- 11:12even this essential thing is not consistent with the Federal Act.
- 11:15Do you need something in place that allows you to do it?
- 11:17Sure.
- 11:18I agree with that, but.
- 11:19They're getting into the weeds on what is essential, and I think
- 11:21it's a wise discussion to have.
- 11:24So to help us better understand the legit legitimacy of the board's
- 11:28activities during this time, we request the following no later than July 7th.
- 11:32So I'm looking forward to when they reveal this July 7th information.
- 11:36And oh, by the way one of the things that could happen from
- 11:38this is because this is happening.
- 11:40You could see Donald Trump move quicker to replace those two board members.
- 11:44Will he do it before a court case is decided on the lawsuits?
- 11:48Not sure.
- 11:49But in the court cases, the government argued that even if you determine I could
- 11:54not have fired them, the solution to put them back is not the right solution.
- 11:57So Har so the judge could say.
- 12:00Trump was right.
- 12:01The judge could say, Harper Osco were right, but even though they
- 12:04were fired, they can't, they, the next president can't do this.
- 12:08We're not gonna put the people in.
- 12:09And then theoretically, Harper, excuse me, Trump could put his own people
- 12:14in which would be another Republican.
- 12:16At least, and possibly a d maybe they just put an rn and then all of this would
- 12:21resolve itself except for the actions that may or may not have TA been taken
- 12:25in compliance with the delegations.
- 12:27Oh, and or in compliance with the Federal Credit Union Act.
- 12:30By the way, I mentioned I did a podcast about a conservatorship.
- 12:35Conservatorship requires a board action that cannot be delegated to staff.
- 12:39So Halman had to sign off on that delegation, excuse
- 12:43me, that conservatorship.
- 12:45Was that essential?
- 12:45The argument would be if we didn't do it there would've been
- 12:48losses to the insurance fund.
- 12:50That's bad for everybody.
- 12:51I could make an argument if the essential delegation is true and indeed legit.
- 12:56I would like, you could argue that could be done.
- 12:58You could also argue that there is no quorum if which is what?
- 13:02Which is what?
- 13:04Is being argued here by Warren.
- 13:07In addition, since they haven't defined what essential is, you can do A, B,
- 13:10C, X, Y, ZI don't believe they had.
- 13:12I know we never had.
- 13:13And they're implying here.
- 13:14The IG said they hadn't.
- 13:15And they're throwing some gasoline on a fire saying, Hey, you haven't defined
- 13:18what essential is, but you're taking all these actions, what's essential, what
- 13:21isn't essential, et cetera, et cetera.
- 13:23So what they've asked for.
- 13:24What constitutes an essential function of the NCA Board?
- 13:26Please provide the statutory provision this authority is based on.
- 13:29There is none.
- 13:30And provide copies of all documents that include any official definitions
- 13:34or description of this term.
- 13:35There is none or there was none when I was there or which seems
- 13:38consistent with what the IG has said.
- 13:40As I just summarized, if no documents exist, please provide examples of past
- 13:45actions of the NCA Board that have been deemed an essential function and why.
- 13:50For each of the 11 bams, the ID g identified as having been acted on.
- 13:56Please explain whether any qualify as an essential function.
- 13:59Of course, they're all gonna qualify, right?
- 14:01'Cause if they haven't built this, they're gonna build it retroactively to show that
- 14:04the actions he took fit the definition.
- 14:09Retrofit, I think is what we'll call that as identified in question one.
- 14:12You.
- 14:13If you identify any of the bams as an essential function, please explain why.
- 14:17Please provide any contemporaneous legal analysis justifying this
- 14:21determination, including on what statutory provision this analysis is based on.
- 14:26Number three, what constitutes an emergency situation under the
- 14:29in Sue's delegation of authority?
- 14:31What constitutes a state of national emergency?
- 14:33Please provide copies of all documents offering official definitions
- 14:36or descriptions of these terms, including what statutory provision
- 14:39this authority relies on it.
- 14:40Don't document exists.
- 14:41Please provide examples.
- 14:42When this emergency authority was invoked, I'm pretty sure I'm the
- 14:46one who presented that change to the NCA board at a board table.
- 14:51And there would have been a bam and no preamble 'cause it wasn't a
- 14:56regulation, but, this is my recollection that the emergency was linked to the
- 15:01outside government definitions of it.
- 15:03And ey, if you're listening, go back to when that delegation was put in place.
- 15:07My recollection is I presented it and there might have been questions
- 15:11relative to it hey maybe my statements about what it means will be, make its
- 15:14way to Elizabeth Warren as they're weaving their way through this.
- 15:19Is the NCA currently operating in an emergency situation?
- 15:22The answer is no.
- 15:23Or a state of national emergency.
- 15:24The answer is no, based on what I just previously said.
- 15:27If so, please provide all written communication and documents, including
- 15:29but not limited to meeting schedules, records analysis, and the correspondence
- 15:33between NCA officials and between NCA officials and other administration
- 15:37officials regarding the emergency situation or state of national emergency.
- 15:44Trump just bombed Iran and that isn't, hasn't led to a
- 15:48state of national emergency.
- 15:50So clearly NCA is not in a state of national emergency.
- 15:53Okay.
- 15:54I digress.
- 15:55Are there additional delegations authority, if any, at the NCA,
- 15:58relevant to the chair's ability to act individually in the absence of a quorum?
- 16:02If so, please provide a detailed description of those delegations
- 16:07along with any legal analysis.
- 16:09The IG was informed that.
- 16:11No one at the NCA, including the board chairman, chief of Staff knew about the
- 16:15removals until they occurred, so there was no communication between NCA officials
- 16:19and the White House or the administration officials in advance of the firings.
- 16:24Please confirm this.
- 16:25Additionally, what communications between NCA officials and the White House.
- 16:29Or other administrative officials regarding the firings
- 16:32occurred on or after April 16th.
- 16:34Please provide copies of all written communications and documents,
- 16:37including, but not limited to meeting schedules, records
- 16:40analysis, and other correspondence.
- 16:43I need a sip of water.
- 16:44I.
- 16:46Given the independent agencies like NCA are now required by a presidential
- 16:50executive order to submit draft regulations for approval by an office
- 16:54within the White House Office of Management and Budget, A-K-A-O-M-B,
- 16:59have you or your staff had any communications with such White House
- 17:03officials about whether NCOA is able to issue regulations as a one member board?
- 17:08They've argued that they can, a leaked email from NCA executive,
- 17:12Larry FAO said, remain calm.
- 17:14We can do whatever we want.
- 17:15So not sure if what they're asking for here has happened, but that is
- 17:20NNC a's current position apparently.
- 17:22If so, please provide copies of all written communications and documents
- 17:26in an email to the NCA General Counsel and Deputy General Counsel on
- 17:30April 16th, the NCA Chief of Staff.
- 17:33Indicated that she wanted to talk briefly about any risks we might face
- 17:37going forward related to the firings.
- 17:39What risks did the chief of staff general counsel, deputy General
- 17:43Counsel, and any other officials identify as facing the NCA?
- 17:49In the wake of the firings, I argued in my conservatorship podcast that
- 17:54maybe Helpmann didn't have the authority to conserve a credit union,
- 17:57and there's a 10 day window for someone to contest a conservatorship.
- 18:01I believe they could have made that argument and possibly
- 18:04had the conservatorship.
- 18:06Reversed, but that's a high legal threshold.
- 18:09You have to prove that it was arbitrary and capricious.
- 18:12Not arbitrary or capricious.
- 18:14Arbitrary and capricious.
- 18:16Two complicated legal words.
- 18:17Those are the types of risks that could be pointed to here.
- 18:21So there's the ig.
- 18:23Response that went back to Warren and Waters on May 6th.
- 18:27That was a footnote by the Acting Inspector General.
- 18:31And what really caught my eye was the fact that they had a list that was a footnote
- 18:40of all the actions Halman had taken.
- 18:42And here's what they are.
- 18:44There was a vote on.
- 18:48April 18th to establish the semi-annual agenda.
- 18:52I have not seen what that agenda is, but they took a vote by notation.
- 18:55Vote with notation vote.
- 18:57Typically, if you have three board members, all three
- 19:00board members can decide.
- 19:01It doesn't need to go to a board meeting.
- 19:03There's open board meetings that have to be done in the open.
- 19:05There's closed board meetings that have some confidential
- 19:08issues like personnel or appeal.
- 19:10For example, a notation vote any, if there's three board members,
- 19:15any board member can bring.
- 19:17Can trigger that saying, Hey, I don't I may vote for this, but I wanna
- 19:21have a discussion on the record.
- 19:22And NCA has gotten notoriously, I don't wanna say.
- 19:26Lazy, 'cause that's not the right word.
- 19:28They don't take things to close board meetings.
- 19:30They do it all by notation vote, because it's easier for them, it's easier for
- 19:33staff, and it's not on the record.
- 19:35There's no dialogue that happens.
- 19:37But I think they've driven a truck through the delegations that say
- 19:40what you can do by notation vote.
- 19:42There should be some things that are probably done by notation vote that
- 19:45should be done at a meeting and there should be some level of discussion.
- 19:49But hey, if they're getting along so well and they can
- 19:51work it out behind the scenes.
- 19:53Nudge, nudge, wink, wink.
- 19:55Why not do it by notation vote Clearly if I was there as a staff member, I would
- 19:59prefer notation vote 'cause it's simpler.
- 20:01All right, so what happened?
- 20:02They had the semi-annual agenda approved on April 18th.
- 20:05Also on April 18th, they had the board appeal request for oral heal
- 20:10hearing appeal of a denial of a credit union change and officials.
- 20:13So somebody.
- 20:14Who was in a troubled institution, meaning a four or a five was denied the
- 20:18ability to serve, and somebody appealed that and Halman voted on that himself.
- 20:25Was that essential?
- 20:27It was essential probably because the person had due process.
- 20:30That would be my argument if I was in COA and he had to provide
- 20:33that due process notation, vote on the schedule policy career.
- 20:38Petition to OPN on April 21st.
- 20:41That's a little wonky of a subject, I'm gonna guess that relates to
- 20:45something they had to provide to OPM in order to do their buyouts note.
- 20:50So this is where I could get complicated if someone wanted to
- 20:53say, you didn't have the authority to do this, and there were pieces that
- 20:55Helpmann approved after Harper left.
- 20:58Theoretically, you could argue that somebody could say you didn't have
- 21:02the authority to do the buyouts.
- 21:04I don't think that'll happen.
- 21:05'cause who will wanna make that?
- 21:06Who would wanna make that statement?
- 21:08And it would be a heavy burden to prove anyway, but that's
- 21:10theoretically a possibility.
- 21:12Notation vote.
- 21:13The NCA Deferred Resignation Program approval or request.
- 21:16S SP's.
- 21:17Postponed paid administrative leave.
- 21:19So this is an instance where Harper had approved the plan with Helpmann
- 21:24and they've decided that they wanted to weave in approval to request SSPs,
- 21:29postpone paid administrative leave.
- 21:31So they were requesting staff to.
- 21:33Who were put on leave, they were creating a carve out saying, Hey,
- 21:37we'd like you to stay longer.
- 21:38And they wanted to make that request as part of of the plan notation
- 21:43vote, SSP, performance standards.
- 21:44So they changed something in NCAA's performance appraisal system.
- 21:48My guess is Helpmann wanted to put something in that.
- 21:53The White House said needed to be in, or OPM seated said they needed
- 21:58to be in and it needed to be fixed, or it was just something that
- 22:01Hoffman wanted, probably not that.
- 22:03So this was probably deemed essential because OPM or Trump
- 22:08asked for it, a change in the Alleg NCA delegation revisions.
- 22:12It's possible I would love to see that document.
- 22:15The April 25th changed to NCA delegations, but those are revisited on occasion.
- 22:19For example, there's asset thresholds on a loss.
- 22:22If a loss to close a credit union is gonna be over a certain threshold, two or $3
- 22:27million don't have them in front of me.
- 22:29The regional director can do it themselves.
- 22:31There's a loss threshold where it has to be the regional director with
- 22:34concurrence of the office of examination of insurance, and then there's a lost
- 22:37threshold where it has to come to the nsu.
- 22:39A board.
- 22:40There are similar thresholds for buying a bank.
- 22:43Which is something that they were very close to changing at one point in time.
- 22:46Hopefully that's a change they made.
- 22:48But they tweaked the delegations was that essential, I guess that really
- 22:52would determine what changes were made.
- 22:53But clearly they said it was essential.
- 22:56'cause he took the action, they revised the examination schedule policy.
- 23:00So this they had to do this.
- 23:02I.
- 23:03Because they're getting rid of 25% of their staff due to the buyouts.
- 23:07They don't have the staff to do the old policy.
- 23:09By the way, they couldn't do the exams on time when they were fully staffed.
- 23:13They tweaked their policy at the beginning of the year, and then the firings
- 23:16happened, and then the buyouts happened.
- 23:17So it went from bad to worse.
- 23:19And they're in a triage state right now.
- 23:21So this makes sense that they had to do this.
- 23:23But be, again, arguing that because Trump said, do buyouts, we had to do buyouts.
- 23:28We need to change our policies.
- 23:30Therefore it's essential that I vote on this.
- 23:32That would be the argument that I would make.
- 23:33Makes sense.
- 23:34Notation, vote.
- 23:35Simplification of the share.
- 23:36Insurance and succession planning rules.
- 23:38Solicitation of comments.
- 23:40So they requested comments on those two rules.
- 23:43Rules that were finalized under Harper.
- 23:44They came out and said they're taking taking comments on these regulations.
- 23:48Now, this is where it gets to that regulation that says the regulations, the
- 23:51regulation on how to do regulations, which says they have to have two board members.
- 23:56You could argue that they, that he doesn't have the authority.
- 23:59Is it essential that they change succession planning?
- 24:02They could do succession planning via a rule.
- 24:04They, which they did.
- 24:05They could do succession planning via guidance.
- 24:08They could argue that they wanna do that.
- 24:10But is it essential that they made these two change?
- 24:13I think that's a weak argument, but hey that's just me.
- 24:17Notation vote number nine.
- 24:20Action.
- 24:20Number nine.
- 24:21Personnel acting appointments and reassignments.
- 24:24They have delegations of authority on who can select who for what positions.
- 24:28So for example, the executive director, the regional directors, the
- 24:32inspector general, those positions can only be approved by the board.
- 24:35The ss, which is an SSP three position.
- 24:39The SSP ones and twos, theoretically lower level.
- 24:43Executive positions, those can be approved by the exec, the executive director.
- 24:47They weren't always done that way.
- 24:49The boards typically would actually vote on those.
- 24:51And so there were some things that needed to be done to put people in
- 24:55place, like the acting inspector general, which is the next item appointment
- 24:58of an acting inspector general.
- 25:00You need an inspector general.
- 25:01You can only act in the short term.
- 25:05120 days without be putting into a PI position or rotating it in other people.
- 25:10And again, they're in tri triage mode.
- 25:13They need to follow the rules to the best they can.
- 25:15And I'm guessing there are some temporary promotions tied to
- 25:19this, and I'm trying to remember.
- 25:21OPM has established some things the agencies can do in these scenarios,
- 25:24but hopefully these people who are stepping up are getting paid for it.
- 25:29They approved an open board meeting transcript for the January 16th, 2020.
- 25:34So he reviewed the transcript and approved it.
- 25:38Is that essential?
- 25:39I don't know.
- 25:39Maybe the reg says they have to do it.
- 25:41That would be the argument.
- 25:42So they've taken 11 actions some of 'em interesting, some of them benign.
- 25:47And then the 12th action was that conservatorship, which
- 25:49again I have a podcast out there called, it's a, was a bold move.
- 25:52Why was it bold?
- 25:53Because you could argue.
- 25:55As is waters and elizabeth Warren, I don't know why I can't remember her name.
- 26:00I can see her in my head.
- 26:02Elizabeth Warren and Maxine Waters.
- 26:04As they're arguing, you are doing things you don't have the authority to do.
- 26:07You are doing things under a definition of essential, which hasn't been defined.
- 26:12So we'll see where this goes.
- 26:14We'll see if the lawsuits of Harper and Ska are decided
- 26:18before this letter goes out.
- 26:19But interesting times in Credit Union Land, and again, we have
- 26:22Warren and Waters versus Trump.
- 26:24We have Warren and Waters supporting Harper and Ska.
- 26:27And by the way, this letter reads too good for it, having been
- 26:31written by somebody on the hill too.
- 26:33Good for it to have been written by.
- 26:34Warren or Waters or their staff, in my opinion, this was written by Harper
- 26:39Otsuka and their law firm, and they are that connected, both Harper and Ska.
- 26:43Otsuka came from Sherrod Brown staff on the banking committee.
- 26:47Harper was with Senator Sarbanes.
- 26:49I.
- 26:50Had the juice to get the ability to serve as a board member for 11 years
- 26:54in two terms and get that definition of what a full term is swapped.
- 26:58So those two folks have the juice.
- 27:01They have a law firm.
- 27:02I think those three people worked together to get this letter
- 27:04into war and water's hands.
- 27:05Did they tweak it and did they sign it, making it their letter?
- 27:08Of course they did, but I think it came from somebody very close to
- 27:12the the system and probably Harper was a huge architect of this letter.
- 27:18All right, I'm losing my voice here on a Sunday morning.
- 27:21I hope you enjoyed this POS podcast.
- 27:24As more information becomes available on this, I will update you here and
- 27:28on LinkedIn and via my mailing list.
- 27:31As always, I appreciate you listening.
- 27:33I hope you'll listen or watch again soon.
- 27:36This is Mark Kel signing off with flying colors.