Latest / Gabriel Ellis, PhD | The Curious Mind Podcast / Therapy Recording Sessions - "Anna", part 5/6
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Curious mind podcast.
- 0:02My name is Gabriel Ellis and today we have the third session
- 0:06with my client Anna, who is exploring her relationship with
- 0:10her family of origin and how to reconnect with them living as an
- 0:16expert in Europe, trying to connect with a family that lives
- 0:21in the US and where they has developed a disconnect over the
- 0:27past years. At the beginning of the session,
- 0:31I give a summary of my impression so far.
- 0:36And when you listen to this episode, please keep in mind
- 0:38that we have limited ourselves to three sessions in total and
- 0:44that this is a far shorter than a normal therapy would be.
- 0:50I usually do provide short-term therapy so a more frequent
- 0:58duration of therapy sessions with questions like these life
- 1:03issues, family issues and so forth.
- 1:06Would be about seven to ten sessions which is considered
- 1:10short therapy and yet, it is remarkable the progress that my
- 1:18client has made. And this And throughout this and
- 1:24Following last episode, you will hear how she starts to approach
- 1:29her family in a new way, integrating the insides and
- 1:35Reflections from our conversations and thus having a
- 1:39better explicit understanding of the complexity of the situation
- 1:43and how to approach it enjoy. So this is our third session
- 1:50that we record and by this we with the session we end our
- 1:57recording cycle so it will be interesting to we capitulate
- 2:07your development. What is left to do.
- 2:11Of course to get engaged also on the further conversation but
- 2:16maybe towards the end of our economy.
- 2:17Ation to build a little bit of an arc and to help all this to
- 2:23understand what this very short, journey of three shows sessions
- 2:28meant to you both in terms of the topic that we have been
- 2:32discussing but also for you as an Insight of what a possible
- 2:37journey of therapy or counseling, would look like
- 2:41because I don't know if we have pointed that out in the
- 2:44beginning. You did not have any previous
- 2:46experience. So for you, you As a newcomer
- 2:48and this was kind of a glimpse into it.
- 2:53If I may summarize, what I have learned so far and my
- 2:58Impressions that I have had so far.
- 3:00One of the there are for me important elements, which are
- 3:09the family Dynamic, where you come from, the style that it has
- 3:14given both you and your Your siblings and your parents, you
- 3:20handled that last time a little bit.
- 3:22And then, as a third component, what it leaves the task that
- 3:27leaves you with the big disruptor in the family.
- 3:32Dynamic was you moving away? That is probably probably
- 3:37something that has not been done much.
- 3:40Certainly not in your core family.
- 3:44Plus you have been the oldest sibling which means that with
- 3:51all the tasks that you had and growing up even though the age
- 3:55difference was not that big one year to your brother.
- 3:59And for years to sister still, you had a designated role in
- 4:05many ways and you express it. So you are the one where you're
- 4:09the one person that uses siblings confided in had Trust.
- 4:13And I guess there were many more aspects where it was palpable
- 4:18and the dynamic, the family Dynamic that you were the oldest
- 4:21one. So, in that sense, to be the one
- 4:26who breaks apart in a family, that is so close.
- 4:32Where it's so difficult to be included in to be regarded, as
- 4:38included him and to have done something, that was Certainly
- 4:43not foreseen and the family structure. and then, to set this
- 4:49precedence, Is part of what brought you into the miserable
- 4:55position in terms of the family that you are right now where you
- 4:59are? The one who has to complicate
- 5:02contemplate. How the hell can I get back in?
- 5:07In terms of the family, Dynamic, we heard of some of the
- 5:10consequences, right? Apparently, your sister took
- 5:13over the position that you had. She is the connecting tissue
- 5:18between the, at least, the remaining family.
- 5:21She's not been a connecting tissue towards you.
- 5:24You had to be the one who reaches out to her.
- 5:28I got the sense that the women are particularly strong anyway
- 5:33in your family, when you That's a little bit how the, your dad's
- 5:39family had difficulties to get integrated.
- 5:42It means that you took the position, the point of view of
- 5:46your your mom's family. She is portrayed by your
- 5:51description as the one who is in the center and the other ones
- 5:55have to be accommodating. They have to prove their worth
- 6:00from which are just deduce that your mother had a particularly
- 6:04strong part in this. Emily dynamic or your mom's
- 6:07family, and it would make sense that after your mom.
- 6:12You are, you were the strong one when you left your sisters, the
- 6:16strong one. So that there is there a
- 6:20particular nodes kind of to pay attention to, when thinking
- 6:24about the family Dynamic which is your mom and your sister.
- 6:27When it comes to the style of the family Dynamics, what is the
- 6:30most standing out for me is a combination of two things which
- 6:35is an avoidance of conflicts. And connected with that and
- 6:40direct result of that is not expressing too much or into
- 6:45clear terms my needs, because expressing once needs needs are
- 6:50always in conflict with the needs of others, right?
- 6:53If I is a teenager, I have the need to spend more outside.
- 6:56That's certainly not the need of my mother and my father, right?
- 6:59They would want me to continue to take charge of the household
- 7:02and, and so on, and be responsible and all these
- 7:06things. So in order to do, Do the thing
- 7:09that I need to do as a teenager or afterwards, it somehow, the
- 7:13avoidance of conflict somehow implies that I don't make a big
- 7:17deal out of expressing what I actually want and to somehow go
- 7:21a silent route. If I do that the ones in power
- 7:27will always be the one who have the check on the situation
- 7:31because they would count on the others.
- 7:34Not making too overly clear how they diverge and their needs in
- 7:40comparison to the family needs. Which means, I put air quotes
- 7:45there for the ones who are listening, the family needs,
- 7:48which are the parents needs or the parent Dynamic needs.
- 7:53So we have explicitness as the theme, or the lack of
- 7:57explicitness. I encourage you last time to
- 8:00invest some thought into, how would I want things to be as who
- 8:04do? I want to approach my siblings
- 8:08and my parents when I want to have a closer contact to
- 8:13reconnect with them and thus to overcome the, the avoidance.
- 8:20And then we had a third theme that It emerged out of the last
- 8:25conversation which is especially you as the oldest one might be
- 8:31perceived as the one who checked out, who very conveniently got
- 8:38rid of her responsibilities, but just moving away, which might be
- 8:44an obstacle for reconnecting with your siblings.
- 8:50As you mentioned, your parents have moved in with your brother.
- 8:52So he has some share and the burden your sister is
- 8:56organizationally and maybe emotionally the connective
- 8:59tissue. Who are you in that, right?
- 9:03What we don't know so far. And maybe you can share
- 9:06afterwards a little bit about that and how your parents
- 9:09perceive that. So if there is a theme of
- 9:13Abandonment of conveniently getting rid of responsibilities,
- 9:18but is projected You, who is the driving force of this narrative?
- 9:25Is it Yamada through needs through some gestures, through
- 9:29some comments by which the children who might might be used
- 9:36to hint reading? So to say, because maybe it's
- 9:40not that explicit culture in the family.
- 9:43So they would create an image of what your mom thinks about you
- 9:48through her comments. It's and then take that position
- 9:52over and that would be a main factor for excluding you
- 9:56excommunicating you or is it that would mean that basically
- 10:03all the family members have a very similar idea about you and
- 10:07your potential betrayal, or do they all carve out their own
- 10:12image of you, which would mean that you would have?
- 10:16You would need separate strategies for your mom, your
- 10:18parents? It's for your sister and for
- 10:20your brother. Okay.
- 10:23These are the questions on the observations that I've had
- 10:26throughout our two, previous conversations and with that,
- 10:32basically for you. But also for the audience with
- 10:35that long introduction, I would hand it over to you to your
- 10:39thoughts to exercises to changes that may have occurred.
- 10:45It's great summary, it's not and I'm actually impressed.
- 10:52Oh, well, you were able to summarize specially my family
- 10:55and you know, I never really thought about it.
- 10:59But I think that my family it is all about the women and, you
- 11:07know, maybe that's why like my brother and I we don't have such
- 11:11a strong relationship because he's an outlier as it is, he's a
- 11:14boy. So it's kind of like he can just
- 11:16do his own thing and he doesn't feel the obligation to to
- 11:21connect. Family, like I do because it was
- 11:25like, my grandmother was like The Matriarch and very, very
- 11:30strong presence in our family and then she passed away over a
- 11:34decade ago and then from there it just went on to my aunt's in
- 11:40the family and then and then I'm the eldest cousin of the family.
- 11:46So I grew up with them when some of my aunts and uncles were
- 11:49still teenagers so I'm still like Like up there with them,
- 11:55and I think that's why, when I left it was much harder.
- 12:01Maybe if I were a boy, it wouldn't have been as hard for
- 12:06the figure to say, yeah. For the family, I think they
- 12:09would have, they could have wrap their brain around it better.
- 12:13Like when we moved when I was younger out of state in a
- 12:18different state, my dad's side of the family, they were very
- 12:21supportive. And it was like natural a my
- 12:25mom's side of the family, it was like it was a bad thing and they
- 12:31put all this pressure on my mom. And my mom went through
- 12:33depression with that move. So, yeah, I think that's
- 12:39unconsciously. Of course, she kind of like
- 12:42projects that on to me now. Yes, not knowing that's like
- 12:47doing the same thing that your family did to you.
- 12:52And it's not fair, you know? And when she was going through
- 12:57that depression, I was there to support and to help and take
- 13:02care of my brother and sister while she was dealing with that
- 13:06with those times. And we had to move back because
- 13:08it was just too hard just, and we moved back to and we moved
- 13:12back. Literally, in with the family
- 13:15in, with my grandmother, in with everybody, we went as close as
- 13:19we could be, which was just, Crazy.
- 13:23Yes. So basically the whole family
- 13:25witnessed an event when you Decor family moved away and they
- 13:31saw the consequences and emotional punishment from the
- 13:34rest of the mother's family's. Yeah.
- 13:38Yeah. And then you had the audacity to
- 13:42do something very similar than afterwards even though.
- 13:45Yeah, good have known better. The consequences of it, right?
- 13:51Right. And I did even worse.
- 13:53I went like across an ocean so it has a very dramatic.
- 13:58Yeah. And I took my child, you know
- 14:01they they can't see my son and that's like you know if I talked
- 14:06to my mom and in fact I did the other day and we made a
- 14:11reference to my son's early home videos, right?
- 14:15And she has some and she said to me, she can't watch them because
- 14:20it hurts she cries. Sighs too much.
- 14:23Yes, and I said, okay Mom, I don't know what to say and she's
- 14:27like, well, I'm just telling you my feelings.
- 14:28I'm allowed to tell you my feelings and I said, yes, you
- 14:31are. But I don't know how to respond
- 14:33to that. Like it's just like kind of
- 14:36hanging there like this guilt. You know, like instead of
- 14:41talking about fun things about my son when he was younger than
- 14:44it's just like a reminder of why I don't get to enjoy him anymore
- 14:48because of you. Okay, that's it.
- 14:51That's all. Ready.
- 14:52An interesting topic because what I've heard your mom saying
- 14:56was not yet, the guilt. It might be an implication on
- 14:58and of course I didn't know her at all.
- 15:00Maybe this is how she makes you feel guilty and she knows that.
- 15:05But basically she did what is at the root of blaming?
- 15:13Others is there's pain, first of all, right.
- 15:16And in this specific case and where we talk about family
- 15:18Dynamics, it's the pain of separation.
- 15:21And it's it's it's nice that you let it hang there, basically?
- 15:29I think so whether or not there is an implication from her side
- 15:34that you should feel guilty about it because well, who
- 15:36caused the pain you did. Whether I not I pick up that
- 15:40implication, I can respond to the pain, I don't have to
- 15:42respond to the guilt implication.
- 15:45Yeah. Which means is she.
- 15:47She is pained by the Operation, from her grandson.
- 15:54I can make that better by connecting them more.
- 16:00Yeah. And to offer that and to not to
- 16:03respond to the other implication that well you're to blame too.
- 16:07That if you didn't want me to feel that pain, you should have
- 16:10stayed do not respond to that. Because that is a popular
- 16:14pointless argument, right there, choose, right?
- 16:16Yeah. I didn't even go into it with
- 16:18her. I was just like, well, I
- 16:20understand like you know, what can I say?
- 16:23Say yes. Is it possible for you?
- 16:27Is that something desirable for you at all to use?
- 16:31I don't know what tax have either.
- 16:33Your mom is, but I'm sure she has some people around who could
- 16:36show her videos. We could do Skype calls with
- 16:40with your son and all. Yeah, yeah, we spent the past
- 16:47week or so, we've spoken twice now and I hope to talk to her
- 16:53again later this week. In, that's good.
- 16:59And she can see my son for a few minutes and they talk, we do my
- 17:02son's at an age to where he does.
- 17:05It's he's like a little, like a preteen, so he's very polite,
- 17:11very nice. But he doesn't know how to he's
- 17:13not sophisticated enough to have, you know, a conversation.
- 17:17So after a few minutes is kind of like, okay.
- 17:20I wanna so she gets a little bit of that and that's fine.
- 17:27I try to send pictures whenever I can, but last time I sent her
- 17:33and my dad pictures on Facebook, she got, this is very strange.
- 17:39She got a like offended that I just sent it that I sent it to
- 17:43her and my dad at the same time and she wants her own Message
- 17:49with the pictures, it was so strange, she wasn't like that
- 17:53before and I don't know what like that's that was something
- 17:56different. So I had to like resend the
- 17:59pictures but she got, I'm like, Mom.
- 18:03It doesn't matter if it's with you and Dad in the same message
- 18:07versus just you. And the must like, you, the
- 18:09pictures are yours, but it was just, I think her trying to show
- 18:13me like, I want it. I want to feel more personally
- 18:18connected. Yes, and it's good to try to
- 18:21make sense out of that. Now, as implicit as your family
- 18:26or maybe your mother side specifically is, it's good to
- 18:31try to extract some meaning out of that.
- 18:34So obviously she wants a special treatment.
- 18:38Hmm, right? Yeah, because there is a gun,
- 18:42some feeling of neglect or pain. When yeah he is tossed onto a
- 18:48group with your dad. Yeah.
- 18:51And you reflect a little bit more knowing her.
- 18:54What that could mean? Yeah, on what she grew up in a
- 19:00big family, nine, brothers and sisters and he's one of the
- 19:03oldest and her mother. My grandmother was an alcoholic
- 19:08and my grandfather who I didn't really know him my life, he left
- 19:13them when they were young, so she or she was this vulnerable
- 19:17little girl who had to grow up really quickly.
- 19:19In this environment taking care of her her sibling, she was the
- 19:25one who was always. She was like, always a mom.
- 19:28She was never like not a mom. She was on her siblings as well.
- 19:33No, no. She was the, I think number
- 19:36three, but of nine. So yeah.
- 19:39She's number three. So she was like, it might.
- 19:44I had Uncle, he's the oldest but, you know, that's done.
- 19:49It's a man. So, the men don't really have to
- 19:52take care of the others as much. He was responsible though.
- 19:56And then my older Aunt who helped, but she was, she had
- 20:02some other things going on and then my mom.
- 20:04It's so really was about my mom, taking care of everybody.
- 20:09And I think that, you know, that was great because she became
- 20:13really good at taking care of children.
- 20:15And that's why I have a really nice childhood because my mom,
- 20:20she knew how to have stability on to take care of kids, but I
- 20:25think that She didn't have enough care for herself and she
- 20:29kind of imposed that on me. As I got older in my teens I was
- 20:35it was like she was looking for more of that like I would help
- 20:38her when she was going through a depression, like Rob her back,
- 20:42or I would make dinner for the family or, you know, to defend
- 20:46her against my brother and sister who were like rebelling
- 20:50or whatever. I would always take her side
- 20:51like always because I didn't want her to feel upset.
- 20:55So I was kind of of taking on. I think the role that she had
- 20:58taken and yes and there is that's it's interesting because
- 21:05many families with alcohol issues And other issues as well.
- 21:12They have a certain Dynamic aspect of a dynamic, which is
- 21:16called parent defecation, which means the children have to take
- 21:20on responsibilities of the parents because they can now
- 21:24yours. We're not actively in an
- 21:27alcoholic household, but given your mother comes from that.
- 21:29So probably this is a position that she had to take.
- 21:35You should was aware of where you yeah, as a child, you cannot
- 21:39be that Innocent. You can't be that naive to grow
- 21:44up in a household where there is potential danger, whatever that
- 21:48is using parents or loud arguments the threat of a
- 21:54divorce. All those kind of looming
- 21:58potential dangers on the family, that always forces children to
- 22:03in a position where they feel that they have a responsibility
- 22:07of stabilizing and pacifying. Yeah, so assuming that your mom
- 22:13was forced into a similar to position like that, it would
- 22:16make sense that she she automatically brought that into
- 22:21the Next Generation so that you were the one who supported her
- 22:29and that's a very specific thing with caretakers who are bad and
- 22:34showing that they need help. They find other ways, or they
- 22:39have unrealistic expectations of others.
- 22:41Just somehow seeing or mind reading that they need help.
- 22:45But they have not developed the skills of saying.
- 22:48Look, I am in need. I'm going to Barlow place right
- 22:51now. I need your support and you can
- 22:53show support by just listening or maybe you can help me out
- 22:57with something. And so on, people like that are
- 22:59not particularly good at this. They have to learn this later
- 23:02on. And your mom is a good example
- 23:05for that. And you are an example for them,
- 23:08and maybe now might be an example for that, as well.
- 23:11I'm, I don't know what she has kind of grown into that
- 23:15situation. Now, the situation has changed
- 23:19now, your mom is older and maybe now it's more appropriate for
- 23:25her to for you, to support her. More than it might have been in
- 23:28the past where it's unfair. In many ways dumped on a
- 23:34developing child, a teenager the position of okay?
- 23:37You support me my depression. It shouldn't have been your
- 23:41thing to do your responsibility. But now you know, coming back to
- 23:46you are our current situation with the question of just
- 23:50brainstorming what would have been a potential reason for her
- 23:53to say look, I want special treatment when it comes to
- 23:58Getting pictures and contact and so on might be.
- 24:03I hope I don't read too much into that, but I want to be
- 24:06taken care of. I want to see that.
- 24:08I'm special. Yeah, not just parent your mom.
- 24:12I want to feel that I want to see that.
- 24:16Does this resonate with you but that makes sense.
- 24:19Yeah, I mean my first response to that was like well God she's
- 24:24ridiculous. She's acting like a child, you
- 24:26know and How dare she? But after some time I've been
- 24:30reflecting on that thinking, oh, that was just her like a cry for
- 24:35help in a way like like please just just make me feel special
- 24:41or connected. Yes, you know, she's not a diva,
- 24:45you know, so I maybe I should just let it go and just, you
- 24:51know, be the like more empathetic to it and just say,
- 24:56okay, She needs that like is it not a real big deal for me to
- 25:00resend some pictures? You know, it's not, I can do
- 25:04that. Like I tell her news now.
- 25:10If I have something big happening in my life, she knows
- 25:14first time letting her know first like, no, I did this just
- 25:19happen is Project just happened for me or whatever and we, my
- 25:24son accomplish this and I am because I'm trying now to think
- 25:29like, oh yeah, she she wants to feel like The Matriarch because
- 25:33she's been, you know, given that roll through our our family
- 25:40structure. And in a way I have to kind of
- 25:43honor is that this she's not a bad person, you know, she means
- 25:48well it's just she doesn't she's never been taught.
- 25:51How to express her emotions things, come out, my mom were
- 25:57I'm like, wow, you need therapy because I canceled and she'll
- 26:01she'll XO. Nonchalant about it, you know,
- 26:06like once I remember yes, I remember a few months ago, we
- 26:11were talking about how my sister was pained at one time, as a
- 26:17young girl, because of some situation that happened with the
- 26:20neighborhood boy, it didn't go too far but it was still an
- 26:23uncomfortable situation, right? And I was just like, oh yeah,
- 26:28that's I feel bad, you know, for her and my mom said, oh, she'll
- 26:32be fine. You know, when I was a little
- 26:34girl my my uncle took me in the room and and did things with me.
- 26:40And I was like, what, why you just drop that?
- 26:44Like, it was so, and she's like, but, you know, you just move on
- 26:49Vanessa. It's just like, you know, things
- 26:51happen in life and I'm like, Mom that's something quite serious.
- 26:56Like, we didn't talk. About it again after that.
- 26:58But I still like weighs on me like cheese.
- 27:00She she really went through hard stop and she you know she should
- 27:07learn how to deal with that. I think like I want to help her
- 27:13too, right? It's indicative of how she felt,
- 27:16you had to deal with it and you know, wrap it up in a situation
- 27:20where she was taking responsibility anyway.
- 27:23Yeah, good things for children and so on, you don't have the
- 27:27luxury to take emotional care of abuse.
- 27:30Yeah, you have to, you have to, you know, you have to make life
- 27:36happening and so on. So at least this is how she
- 27:39perceived it. I think now, in our generation,
- 27:41we have a better understanding that we need more of a balance,
- 27:46but we need to show the space to Emotional Self Care More in
- 27:51order to Execute the organizational pod cutter.
- 27:56Yeah, the previous generation was very often not the case and
- 28:01your mom unfortunately is an example of that now.
- 28:04Yes, does it hurt you to give her a special treatment?
- 28:09It doesn't still, you know, talking about yourself care.
- 28:13The question is that I have for you is do you want to get into a
- 28:17place where you understand her knee?
- 28:20Or is it important for you to contribute?
- 28:27To a less special treatment of your mom or is she in an age on
- 28:32the point of life? And okay, she has to learn many
- 28:36different difficult things. Anyway, the more she is aging.
- 28:41I'm not interested to, you know, educate or her or to change the
- 28:45dynamic or self-perception. Yeah.
- 28:51I have to navigate that, I think a lot, you know, like when it
- 28:57comes to politics and things, I think I can have a friendly
- 29:02conversation with her, but I've learned to just let things go.
- 29:05Like this is, you know, she needs to.
- 29:09That's who she is. That's fine.
- 29:12Was it painful as a difficult? It's okay.
- 29:19You know a bit like maybe a times where I'm just like, you
- 29:24know, Mom, okay. Just see this one thing and you
- 29:28know but whatever that's the whole other conversation about
- 29:32politics, that's also happening in right now in our culture with
- 29:38yes, you know, different Dynamics.
- 29:43But when it comes to family stuff I want and I want to help
- 29:47her, you know. I want to do to be there for
- 29:51her, it's it. Yeah, it was not cool to do to a
- 29:55teenage girl but she didn't do it intentionally but like I
- 29:59picked up the slack I didn't have to.
- 30:02Also I put of rebelled but I didn't because it's just not in
- 30:06my nature to rebuild like that and I feel like now I'm a little
- 30:12more stable emotionally than I was before I I'm happier in my
- 30:19life. I'm at a place in my life where
- 30:20I feel peace. So why not, you know, why not
- 30:25help this woman who, who loves being and is a good person.
- 30:31Can you describe if you took a different approach last week?
- 30:35So you emphasize that you called twice?
- 30:39Apparently, is that it change to previous weeks and months and
- 30:45did you do it with a different attitude with a different
- 30:48intent? Talking with my mom.
- 30:51Yes, yeah, yeah. I was just more relaxed with
- 30:57her. You know.
- 31:01I just listened a lot more than speaking.
- 31:06Just letting her talk. It talking about her sisters or
- 31:09whatever family stuff. And I'm just, like, just kind of
- 31:12like nodding and just being there to just just to listen.
- 31:15And whereas before I was like, oh, come on or I was like, yeah.
- 31:19You know, more demented to yeah. And this time it was like, okay,
- 31:24you know, just you just tell me and um, I think that she liked
- 31:29that she needed that and that's why should we talked I think
- 31:34twice this week so far. And maybe we'll talk again,
- 31:38maybe she needs that she has more time on her hands by the
- 31:41way, she's retired. And so it's just like, you know,
- 31:45sometimes you need something like that.
- 31:50Please join us for the second part of the third session in our
- 31:53next episode, where we will summarize the development so far
- 31:58and where my client gives a summary and a request section
- 32:03from her perspective, both on how the journey has been so far
- 32:07with her family as well as her understanding of the therapeutic
- 32:11process to which she was a newcomer as well.
- 31:50Please join us for the second part of the third session in our
- 31:53next episode, where we will summarize the development so far
- 31:58and where my client gives a summary and a request section
- 32:03from her perspective, both on how the journey has been so far
- 32:07with her family as well as her understanding of the therapeutic
- 32:11process to which she was a newcomer as well.