Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Hertz Shutters Car Sales Stores, Honda's $3B Hybrid Bet, Waymo Bus Probe
Transcript
- 0:00[laughs] Wrong button. Uh, good morning. It is Tuesday, November 10th. This is the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly, that's Kyle Mountserre.
- 0:09Today, we're talking about Hertz closing its physical locations. Honda, $3 billion in a hybrid bet, which we think is gonna go good, and Waymo still getting in a little bit of trouble.
- 0:18We have some first-hand experience with the Waymos, more than we did anyway. That is true. No, more than we did. That's okay. I know. It is. What day... It's Tuesday. It's a Tuesday to me- It is a Tuesday...
- 0:29that feels like a Wednesday. Every day that, like- Why does it feel like a Wednesday? How does that happen? I just feel like I've been, I feel like I've been working two days already- That's true... in one day. Okay.
- 0:37Yeah, yeah, yeah. I feel like so much happened yesterday, and already this morning, that I feel like it's like, it should be hump day. [laughs] Man, at 5:00 this morning, I was already just, like,
- 0:48there were things happening. Zip. [laughs] You know? Yeah. I don't even know how to describe other than, like, there were things happening at 5:00 AM and, and- I believe this... it was great.
- 0:56It's just, like, that's the type of day that I get to, you know, three and a half hours in and I'm like, ah, you know, everybody else just getting started, but.
- 1:03You know, there's this whole thing about people saying, like, waking up early. And whenever I've made the effort, and I've tried and, like, woke up at 4:30, 5:00, 5:30, I love it.
- 1:13There's nothing better than those morning hours. However, I'm gonna put this out there. Put some- When you have a family- [laughs] When you have a family, it's just, you can say, "Well, wake up earlier," but you can't...
- 1:26You, eventually you sleep so little that you're no longer good to anybody. That's right, yeah.
- 1:30And so, like, you end up having to take those hours away from your family at the end of the day, which is, if you have teenagers, right? Like, that's prime time. That's prime time. Right.
- 1:38And if you have- Yeah, if you have teenagers, they're, like, they're up a little bit later. You wanna hang. Yeah, I get it. I get it. And if you have a seven-year-old, prime time is when they go to bed, right? Right.
- 1:45They finally go to- Yes... right? So it's like- [laughs]... that, and you know- And then that seven-year-old doesn't respect your wishes to be alone for an hour in the morning They do. They cer- if you, if you...
- 1:53It's like you know me. [laughs] It's like you know me, right? [laughs] And so, so it's complicated out there. It's complicated. It's complicated. But when things get going in the morning, it's unbelievable how...
- 2:03We want to thank our friends at Automobility. Look, we're not saying you should go to an event just 'cause Asoda's gonna be there, but, eh, [laughs] that would be, uh, pretty, uh, you know, self-sufficient.
- 2:14But, uh, we're going to L- Automobility LA, the official median industry day of the LA Auto Show, on November 19th. So that's the day after Asodacon West. Yeah.
- 2:23We are taking our little posse, and we're moving just a little bit down the road to go to the convention center. So we're gonna be alongside automakers, innovators, people shaping the future of automotive.
- 2:33We saw a bunch of incredible things last year when we were there, and a lot of that stuff kind of played out throughout the year. It was good to be there.
- 2:39They make a lot of big announcements, um, you know, hosted happy hours, et cetera. You can register for that if you're not going to Asodacon West.
- 2:46You can go to automobilityla.com, and you can use code MTC149, More Than Cars 149. You get 100 per- you get $100 off your registration. Or you can go to asodaconwest.com. Go to asodaconwest.com.
- 3:01You get in both days, two for the price of one. And, and look, Asodacon West is shaping up to be... It's just gonna be such a good day.
- 3:09I, I actually got a text last night, this is crazy, from a dealer friend about an hour away, um, that got to sit at dinner last night next to Jack Hollis. Oh, no way.
- 3:22And just was saying, like, "Jack was telling me he's gonna see you twice in the next week." [laughs] And she, she was like, uh, she was like, "The...
- 3:31It was so good to sit next to dinner with him, and I'm, and I'm so glad that you're bringing him into the ecosystem that you guys are a part of."
- 3:38Uh, and she's a former Toyota dealer, and so she know- she knew Jack well, and then they were sitting next to dinner. I'm like, man, there's... You know. So if you wanna sit next to Jack Hollis- Yes, and you do...
- 3:49and Nick Keller and Ed Roberts and Steve Greenfield and, uh, and Jimmy Douglas and, and, well, Mitch Hatarana, and the list goes on and on. It's gonna be true. I mean, you already had your panel prep call. Yeah.
- 4:00I've got mine today. I did. I did. Like, the list is just so deep. It's so rich. Yes. You wanna be in the room with these people. DM us if you wanna know. Like, d- don't even go to Asodacon West. I'll- Just DM your boys.
- 4:12You know what I mean? Yeah, DM. If you got our number, text us. We'll make sure you get there. Um, asodaconwest.com. Check out all the things. And then come to Automobility with us the next day. Yeah.
- 4:21'Cause it's, we're just gonna hang out for two days. Have a rip around. But if you can only have one day, you can fly in and fly out for either of these, so. Yep. All right. Oh, my gosh. All right. I, where are we?
- 4:29Let's get into it. Where we at? We're two minutes- Let's do the thing... and 24 seconds in. No, I, we gotta do the thing. We have to do the thing. There are things to do. Hertz is go, doing the thing.
- 4:36They're going full digital on its retail business, closing all- [laughs]... of its Hertz car sales locations.
- 4:41The closures are reportedly set to be final November 20th through Her- though Hertz has not confirmed the date. Buyers can still purchase through hertzcarsales.com, Amazon Autos, eBay, and Test Drive Plus.
- 4:53Now at more than 300 rental locations. They can buy some cars there, too.
- 4:57Hertz became the first fleet dealer on Amazon Autos back in August of 2025 with, uh, you could pick up your car in Dallas, Houston, LA, or Seattle, and then they opened an eBay digital showroom in May.
- 5:08CEO Gil West said on last week's earnings calls that Hertz is prioritizing, quote, "higher-yielding digital channels."
- 5:15Hertz didn't say how the Amazon and eBay deals are performing or what happens to Hertz car sales staff, but they are making the change. It's been confirmed across, you know, some employee profiles, et cetera.
- 5:25Car Dealership Guy, uh, did a great job, you know, kind of like fleshing the details out on this one, but, uh, some changes coming. Don't tell me you can't buy a car online.
- 5:33This is really, it's the first time that we've seen s- honestly, since Amazon, uh... Well, no. I'm trying to think.
- 5:44This is the first time that we've seen a story in the last four years that went the other way from heading back to retail locations. Into retail, like physical stores, yeah. Right.
- 5:53Like, even Carvana's like, "Ah, you know what? Physical stores sound like a good plan." [laughs] "Let's try and do some of those," you know? Yeah.
- 5:59And this is the first time going the other way, so it's very interesting to me. Obviously, you know- Profitability stands on like, "Hey, we don't have to have people interacting."
- 6:08Um, but this, this seems really- I know, you think about the eco-... strange to me. Okay, now that you're saying that, I'm thinking about the economics. Like, why would a company decide to close all the physical stores?
- 6:17Obviously, there's a fis- fixed expense there. They can sell the locations. They can get some cash back. Um, they obviously have to staff it. But I'm like, where is...
- 6:26They, they must just think that it is less expensive for them to lean into digital- I guess so... because nothing's stopping them from leaning into digital and still having the physical locations.
- 6:36Which, which like you just pointed out, seems to be a popular or winning formula. You know what I've never seen though? Hertz, like, advertise hyper locally like a dealership would. Yeah. You know? Interesting.
- 6:50And it's almost like, you know, they've always played, like, this umbrella brand and like, "Oh, you can buy stores here if you drive by EC." But I've never seen them play the ground game in a local area, you know?
- 6:59Which, which would make sense that they wouldn't be good at that, so they wouldn't do it. But, uh, that's a conundrum. Yeah. It's a little bit of a conundrum. You know what's so interesting?
- 7:06This is the, this is random, and I just checked to make sure that this is still true. I, you know, all of, like, the Carvanas, the CarMax, they build their own web platforms, right? Mm-hmm. Hertz uses dealer.com.
- 7:17There you go. Interesting. Yeah, they don't have some magic edge. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah, I, I tell you what- I'm, I'm so intrigued by this story- If-... and this whole business model...
- 7:25if I'm a dealer and there's a Hertz location in my area, I would immediately be thinking- Scoop that sucker up and sell used cars... independent, independent car brand. Yeah. Independent used car brand.
- 7:33Great time to stand a new one up. It's gonna get some attention. You're gonna have- Genius... a fresh little perspective. You can do it. Probably do it. Wow, you should offer advice sometimes.
- 7:40[laughs] Every once in a while. Maybe someday someone will pay me for it too. [laughs] Oh, man. Speaking of paying for it. Stop. Segway. Time.
- 7:47[upbeat music] Honda says they'll be investing $3 billion in a new hybrid h- uh, Ohio hybrid plant, and raise its full year profit forecast to 20- up, up 20% because of strong US hybrid demand.
- 8:02The plant between Marysville and East Liberty opens in 2029 with 2,000 jobs and capacity for 240,000 vehicles a year, lifting Honda's US capacity to 1.3 million.
- 8:12Upgrades in Alabama, Georgia, and Ontario, uh, support 15 new Honda and Acura hybrids planned by 2030. That used to be a joke we would make, 2030, but it's about to be 2027. Yeah. So, like, we're- Yeah...
- 8:24we're in striking range now to make a real decision. We're doing it, yes. Um, American Honda EVP Bob Nelson said, quote, "This decision wasn't based on any tariff."
- 8:33Fiscal Q2 operating profits still down 39%, um, about $3 billion in EV charges still showing up on those reports, earnings reports.
- 8:41US sales rose 9%, but Honda cut its global sales forecast 7% because of weakness in China. Yeah. So Honda is just, like, juggling everything right now.
- 8:50This wasn't about tariffs, it was more about the Chinese eating their lunch everywhere else in the world. Yeah. I, uh, I- Make the money where you can make it...
- 8:56I have to feel like this is somewhat related to, I think, I think it was a Bloomberg article, Steve Greenfield highlighted it as his first article- Saw it, yeah...
- 9:03in his, uh, just the, the idea that the US is basically the, the last profit center for non-Chinese automakers. Last place to make money. Yeah, that's right. Yeah.
- 9:12And, and so I think, you know, automakers are starting to make bets that that's contin- gonna continue to be the case. Um, and I think Honda is a part of that.
- 9:22All the Japanese brands have obviously, clearly kind of gotten together and said, "Yep, we're gonna be a part of that." Mm.
- 9:27Um, the US just has the opportunity there and, uh, the scary thing is, is, like, if, you know, China ever gets let, let in, that becomes the, the, uh, a potentially- Boy... no more.
- 9:37But right now, I think that's where the bets are is, is we're losing to the Chinese elsewhere, let's lean in on the US market. US market's- Which I think is fine with me...
- 9:44the last place we can make money selling car- Hey. Yeah.
- 9:46Like, I think everybody welcomes more Honda hybrid models, and we've seen, like, Chevy making the move saying, "Hey, like, we're gonna be releasing all these hybrid drivetrains for our big vehicles." Yep.
- 9:55So, I mean, the re- They're all like- If, if you open the receipt tracker- 'Cause it, 'cause it worked for Toyota, so why not work for us?
- 10:01I mean, if you open the receipt tracker, probably, like, three years ago, there's a couple of guys in beards and black hats- Given the playbook... for free. Every- Just for free... yeah, no one listened. All right.
- 10:10It's fine. [laughs] Speaking of it's fine. Stop. Is it though? Segway. Time. I don't know if it is. Is it fine?
- 10:18Uh, NHTSA, N-H-T-S-A, opened a recall query into 2,800 Waymo robotaxis to determine whether last year's software fix stopped them from illegally passing stopped school buses. Uh-oh.
- 10:29Waymo recalled more than 3,000 vehicles in December 2025, but reported incidents happened after it said the remedy was complete.
- 10:36The Austin School District documented 19 violations, including a robotaxi that stopped briefly, then proceeded while a student, a student was crossing. Oh, my gosh. Uh, Atlanta Public Schools logged six more.
- 10:47Uh, NHTSA opened a separate probe in January af- after Waymo struck a child near a Santa Monica elementary school.
- 10:54Waymo says it has made significant improvements around school buses and has not received a citation since March. Okay. So, uh, now that we've ridden a number of driverless vehicles in the last several days,
- 11:07you do kinda get the vibe where it's like it's pulling up and you're supposed to get in it, and then it creeps forward five feet, and then it creeps forward five more feet, and you're like, "What is this car doing?
- 11:16I have no idea what it's doing." It's still got a long way to go. Now I can understand how it might do that. Yes. It seems to get confused in situations when things are moving slowly. You know what I mean? Ah.
- 11:26Yeah, yeah, yeah. Yep. It's like when things are moving quickly, it feels like it knows what to do, but when as soon as it's, like, you know, walk speed and, and, like, weird areas.
- 11:34So I can definitely see how this would happen. It's terrifying to think about, like- Terrifying... a Waymo that struck a child.
- 11:40You know, I wonder what the numbers are on, like, human drivers that pass school buses and things, 'cause I have a friend here who's a for- Oh, I've seen them...
- 11:47former district attorney, and he ac- his job is to actually, when people dispute that they passed a school bus, 'cause they have the little cameras on the little thing that goes out. Sweet.
- 11:55His job is to, like, he, he just does it, like, you know, I think he just does it for fun now. He just is the one that's gotta be like, "No, look, you did pass a school bus while it was stopping."
- 12:02Yeah, look, there's the video. There's the video. It's easy. [laughs] There's a kid crossing. There's your car. That's you. Wave. Stop sign is out. So- There's where the video camera is. Yeah...
- 12:09so I wo- I wonder what the, what the comparison is for the humans that do it versus the robots that do it.
- 12:13I bet the robots do it much less, but at the same point, it's kinda more terrifying to think about a robot car- Right... violating that. You- Yeah.
- 12:20Like, I feel like there should be zero tolerance for that, which it sounds like there is, and now they're working on a solution, so.
- 12:25We're, we're only, we're only a, the, a year, maybe two out from so many of these little kinsy... Uh, like, this is a big deal from, like, a, from a human perspective- Yeah...
- 12:37but from a software perspective, it's actually fairly, I think it's probably solvable. Yeah. Oh, yeah. And my guess is that Waymo has already been solving for it- Yep... and other things like it. Yep.
- 12:45Um, but yeah, it is funny, like, when Waymos and Zooks and things like that are going slow, like, trying to find that last little place to stop. [laughs] And you're just like, "I don't know. Is this, this-" Here?
- 12:54"No, this isn't right." How about here? "Ah, no." How about here? "No, that's not right."
- 12:57[laughs] One of our videos is so funny, where you, it's, like, a, a little herd of me, you, Nathan, Spencer, just, like- Just trying to catch it... cha- chasing a Zooks through, like, the, the pickup area.
- 13:06Like, "Is it here?" And, "Oh, maybe it's not ours." And then it pulls in, it stops, and then it pulls forward. So funny. It's like, I used to do that to my friends. You know what I mean? Right.
- 13:13Maybe it's just a na- Just, just to mess with them. Yeah, just to mess with them. Maybe they are just messing with us. I don't know. It's a social experiment. Maybe they're just like, they, they sized us up.
- 13:18We're like, "We're gonna mess with them. Hey, whatever's going on today." Remember, you can affect the most you can affect by taking care of the people around you. Go do that and we'll figure out the software later.
- 13:27[upbeat music]