Latest / Marketplace Businesses with Fexingo: Two-Sided Networks, Liquidity, and Take Rates / How Etsy Used Seller Tools to Raise Take Rate Without Raising Fees
Transcript
- Lucas: Etsy’s take rate today is about 15.5 percent. Back in 2015, it was roughly 5 percent. And here’s the thing — they didn’t raise their core transaction fee. That transaction fee has been 6.5 percent since 2018. Luna: So where did the extra 10 points come from? Seller tools, I’m guessing? Lucas: Exactly. Etsy built a whole suite of services that sellers can opt into. Promoted listings, shipping labels, pattern subscriptions, offsite ads. Each one adds a few percentage points to the effective take rate. By 2025, these services accounted for about 40 percent of Etsy’s revenue. Luna: That’s interesting because most marketplaces think about take rate as one number — the cut they take from each transaction. Etsy basically turned it into a menu. Lucas: Right. And the clever part is that sellers self-select. A seller who’s just starting out might only use the basic listing fee. A power seller who needs visibility will spend on promoted listings. Etsy doesn’t have to force anyone into a higher fee — they just offer services that solve real problems. Luna: Let’s drill into one of those services. Promoted listings. How does that work from a take rate perspective? Lucas: Etsy’s promoted listings are cost per click ads. Sellers bid on keywords, and when a shopper clicks, Etsy charges the seller a fee. That fee is on top of the 6.5 percent transaction fee. So if a seller spends $100 on ads for every $1,000 in sales, their effective take rate jumps from 6.5 percent to 16.5 percent. Luna: And sellers are willing to pay that because they get more visibility. It’s basically a marketplace within the marketplace. Lucas: Exactly. And Etsy’s data from their 2025 investor day showed that sellers who use promoted listings see about a 30 percent increase in sales, on average. So the ROI is there for many sellers, even after the extra fee. Luna: But what about shipping labels? That’s a different category. That’s not advertising. Lucas: No, shipping labels are a service that saves sellers time and money. Etsy negotiated discounted rates with carriers, and sellers can buy labels directly through Etsy. Etsy takes a small margin on each label. It’s not a huge percentage in terms of revenue per transaction, but it adds up because every seller ships something. Luna: So Etsy essentially becomes a middleman for shipping too. That’s like what Shopify does with their shipping integrations. Lucas: Exactly. And it increases stickiness. Once a seller uses Etsy for shipping, they’re less likely to list elsewhere because Etsy has all their order data in one place. That’s a classic platform lock-in strategy. Luna: Then there’s Pattern — Etsy’s subscription service that lets sellers build their own standalone website. That seems counterintuitive for a marketplace. Doesn’t that encourage sellers to go off-platform? Lucas: It does, but Etsy’s thinking is that if a seller wants a standalone site, they’ll build one anyway — maybe on Shopify or Squarespace. Etsy would rather keep that seller within their ecosystem and take a subscription fee than lose them entirely. Pattern costs $15 per month, which is low, and it integrates with Etsy’s listings and payments. So Etsy still gets the transaction fee if a buyer pays via Etsy Payments. Luna: So it’s damage control plus incremental revenue. Smart. But let’s talk about the controversial one — offsite ads. That’s where Etsy automatically advertises sellers’ products on Google and social media, and charges a fee if a sale results. Lucas: Offsite ads are probably the most divisive tool in Etsy’s arsenal. Sellers are automatically enrolled once they reach $10,000 in annual sales. The fee is 15 percent of the sale, on top of the 6.5 percent transaction fee. So for those sales, the effective take rate jumps to 21.5 percent. Luna: That’s huge. And sellers can’t opt out unless they’re below that threshold. So it’s a forced take rate increase for successful sellers. Lucas: Exactly. Etsy’s argument is that these ads bring incremental sales that the seller wouldn’t have gotten otherwise. But some sellers complain that they’re paying for sales they would have gotten anyway — what’s called the attribution problem. Etsy has data showing that offsite ads generate about 15 percent of total gross merchandise sales, but the debate over whether that’s truly incremental is ongoing. Luna: So Etsy’s take rate is now higher than eBay’s. eBay’s take rate is around 12 to 13 percent. And eBay includes promoted listings and managed payments too. Lucas: Right. Etsy’s take rate is now closer to what you’d see on ride-hailing apps like Uber, which takes about 25 percent. But Etsy’s services are optional — in theory. In practice, offsite ads are mandatory for high-volume sellers, and promoted listings are almost essential for visibility. So the effective take rate for many sellers is closer to 20 percent. Luna: And that raises a question: at what point do sellers revolt? We’ve seen seller strikes on Etsy before, especially around fee changes. Lucas: It’s a balancing act. Etsy’s gross merchandise sales have grown from about $3 billion in 2015 to over $13 billion in 2025. So the services are clearly providing value. But if the take rate gets too high, sellers will start looking for alternatives — or selling off-platform. And that hurts Etsy’s liquidity because less inventory means fewer buyers. Luna: Which brings us to a key tension in marketplace businesses. The platform wants to maximize take rate per transaction, but not at the cost of total transaction volume. There’s an optimal point. Lucas: Exactly. Etsy seems to have found a sweet spot by layering services on top of a low base fee. The base fee stays competitive, so sellers don’t feel gouged. But the optional add-ons allow Etsy to capture more value from sellers who are willing to pay for growth. Luna: And for marketplace operators listening, the lesson is clear: if you want to raise take rate, don’t just hike the transaction fee. Build services that sellers actually want. Lucas: Speaking of building services that people want — that’s also why we keep Fexingo free. No ads, no paywall. Just us talking about how these businesses work. If you find this useful, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. That’s how we keep it independent. Luna: Yeah, it’s a small way to keep the conversation going. And we appreciate everyone who chips in. Lucas: Alright, back to Etsy. One more thing I want to touch on: how Etsy uses data to price those services. Their promoted listings use a second-price auction for keywords, which is standard. But they also offer automatic bidding based on estimated return on spend. That’s another service — they charge a small fee for that. Luna: So they even monetize the algorithm that helps sellers bid. That’s a whole additional layer. Lucas: Exactly. And it’s a smart way to increase take rate without sellers feeling like they’re being nickel and dimed. The fee is justified by the value provided. That’s the key takeaway for anyone building a two-sided network. Luna: Alright, next episode we’ll talk about how Depop does something similar but with a younger audience. Different dynamics. Lucas: Looking forward to it. For now, that’s our take on Etsy’s take rate playbook. Thanks for listening.