Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP303: Ecommerce Unplugged - An Ecommerce Consultant's View On Five Key Trends Impacting Ecommerce Businesses Today
Transcript
- 0:00The date the stats they came up with the innovation related to
- 0:03AI could display 6 to 7% of the US workforce if it's widely
- 0:06adopted. But the impact is most likely
- 0:09transitory because new job opportunities will be created by
- 0:12the same technology to put people into work in other
- 0:15capacities. You listen to Inside Commerce, a
- 0:20weekly ecom strategy, technology and CX Focus podcast hosted by
- 0:23experienced digital consultants and RE platform specialist James
- 0:26Get and Paul Rogers. Get insights into ecom strategy,
- 0:28leading brands, Hear from industry thought leaders and
- 0:31leading tech vendors with practical advice to help you
- 0:33improve your online CX. This episode is sponsored by
- 0:38Shopify is a talking head today with myself and Paul.
- 0:42We've been talking about doing this for a few weeks and it's
- 0:45one of those kind of sit, sit, take some time out, have a think
- 0:49about the state of the industry and what is happening.
- 0:51What are the things we're seeing?
- 0:51What are the things we're hearing?
- 0:53What are our clients currently most obsessed about?
- 0:55What are the big trends? And also, what's some of the
- 0:58noise out there that we don't particularly agree with and
- 1:00wants to dispel some of the myths that might be circulating?
- 1:04So the key areas we're going to focus on today, we've got one.
- 1:08The first one is our strategic partnerships with local delivery
- 1:11companies. So one of the examples is the
- 1:14recent John Lewis and Uber Eats announcement on payments,
- 1:19payment diversification and I guess the mainstreaming of like
- 1:22buy now, pay later and the acceptance of that into more
- 1:24premium brands, but personalized shopping.
- 1:28And where is personalisation? Because personalisation is like
- 1:31tomorrow's always been coming, but it's never arrived.
- 1:35Structured data and the criticality of it and how that's
- 1:37going to be hot news. Again, with the growth in
- 1:40agentic traffic to websites which need structured data and
- 1:44why they they base why the fundamentals of technical SEO
- 1:47are more important than ever. Then we're going to look at the
- 1:50agentic side of customer service and how that's been adopted in
- 1:53the benefits of that. Then we're going to come onto
- 1:56the the chat that AI is still basically being massively hyped.
- 2:00And some of the some of the articles out there saying that
- 2:02if ecom brands aren't rapidly adopting AI into their
- 2:06day-to-day work, that they are going to become obsolete and
- 2:09fail. Is we think that sort of
- 2:11bollocks. But talking about what the
- 2:13reality is, what's actually happening and where it's
- 2:15starting to embed itself. Are those the main sort?
- 2:18Have I missed anything? Paul I.
- 2:20Don't think so. No, not out of the things that
- 2:23we've got here, although you've got voice activated search at
- 2:27the bottom. Other than that.
- 2:30Oh yeah. And that kind of links in from
- 2:31the AI stuff. So and there are of course there
- 2:35are lots of other things being talked about in the industry.
- 2:37There are vertical specific, there are regional specific, but
- 2:40we're trying to pick out some of the core trends and and also
- 2:42like reflect on a lot of the conversation that we're seeing
- 2:46out in social specific in places like LinkedIn.
- 2:49So let's start with strategic partnerships.
- 2:52I found this really interesting and I, I, I know boots and
- 2:56delivery had a partnership earlier and you referenced that
- 2:58to me when we're prepping for this call.
- 3:01I read an article shortly after John Lewis has announced it's,
- 3:05it's collab with Uber Eats. Martin Newman shared a post
- 3:07about it on LinkedIn. And I found that really
- 3:10interesting because John Lewis has faced it.
- 3:13The the brand heritage, the brand reputation and the size of
- 3:16the John Lewis Partnership business is huge.
- 3:20And one of the big challenges of business of that size and
- 3:22complexity with this sheer product range it's got is how
- 3:25can it maintain a competitive advantage in the customer
- 3:30experience piece in the delivery bit across this product range
- 3:33and stay relevant. And Uber Eats, see it offers
- 3:36quite a wide local delivery network and speed of delivery
- 3:40for smaller items. So really interesting to see
- 3:42them piloting that in a couple of specific areas on specific
- 3:47product categories and targeting those product categories based
- 3:49on what sells well in those those regional areas.
- 3:52So I'm intrigued for me, this is, this is a sign of, of, of
- 3:56where larger organisations should be moving to in terms of
- 3:59their collabs, not just like brand mash ups where they get
- 4:03together with, you know, other designers and pro owners, but
- 4:06actually service mashups where they can start to be competitive
- 4:10with, you know, the likes of an Amazon, but through localized
- 4:14partnerships. So this this is actually remind
- 4:17a bit of a few things. So I, so I'm, I would say I'm a
- 4:20delivery super user. So I use delivery constantly,
- 4:24like use it at least once once a day.
- 4:27And I've been using it for grocery shopping for a long
- 4:30time. And I think basically there's
- 4:32loads of people that are trying to copy that model.
- 4:34But I was just thinking how interesting it'd be to see like
- 4:39store level data on delivery and Uber Eats versus like in store
- 4:47traffic or revenue, etcetera. But yeah, I think it'd be really
- 4:51interesting to see some numbers around the growth of it,
- 4:54particularly as you get into more central London.
- 4:56But I think that I think the primary reason for this is a new
- 4:59customer. So it's been a few times where
- 5:02I've been in the office and I've forgotten my football boots or
- 5:05I've forgot my gym stuff. And I've tried to use delivery
- 5:09to find products and I've not been able to.
- 5:11But I do think, I think we'll get a lot more retail stores
- 5:15using these like channels, I guess primarily to target a new
- 5:22customer, but also as you've written down here, like you
- 5:26know, better manage inventory, etcetera, etcetera.
- 5:30But the other thing I was going to say is something that I
- 5:32noticed last week and I'm trying to remember the product it's
- 5:35for, but I, I, it's for, are you vodka actually who we've just
- 5:41started working with. I was searching for some of
- 5:44their, for searching for their brands, some of their product
- 5:47names, etcetera. And I noticed that Uber Eats are
- 5:50super prominent on Google Shopping.
- 5:52And I assume it's all geographic, but I thought it was
- 5:57quite interesting where they've got basically a little PDP and
- 6:00they've then got all of the options that you can buy it
- 6:02from. But I thought that was
- 6:03interesting, particularly on desktop.
- 6:07Yeah, that they're basically essentially trying to target
- 6:11people via Google Shopping. Intra I mean, there's there's
- 6:14quite a few conversation strategies that come out of this
- 6:16also with the recent Amazon's decision around it's paid media
- 6:21as well and the potential advantages that opens up for
- 6:25other people to to to get, you know, greater visibility in the
- 6:29in the bidding. But for me, I, I think it's a,
- 6:32it's also a potential, it's not just a customer service play for
- 6:35lives of journalists being able to offer speedy delivery to
- 6:38specific areas for particular product ranges.
- 6:40That might be like you are alluding to distressed purchases
- 6:44or everyday essentials, but it's also the cost potential cost
- 6:49benefit because tapping into last mile delivery and speedy
- 6:53delivery and fast delivery slots from traditional couriers or
- 6:56with your own fleets can be quite challenging and costly to
- 7:01make the unit economics work. Whereas deliveries Ubers already
- 7:05have that set up and they have a relatively lean cost more.
- 7:08So it's I'd imagine there's probably a lens on this within
- 7:13those businesses of can we actually get the cost lower than
- 7:16we currently can in order to offer more competitive service
- 7:19so that the the barriers to the customer using it are lower than
- 7:22ever before? I think, I think this does take
- 7:25off and people like Boots see decent volume.
- 7:30I think what we'll probably start to see because at the
- 7:32minute I think it's all still driven by retail stores and like
- 7:37the inventory available in the store.
- 7:40I think so with the top volume restaurants and delivery,
- 7:45they've now got their own little kitchens.
- 7:46I don't know if you've seen this, but like so like I noticed
- 7:51probably about 18 months ago that all of of the big name
- 7:54chain or not chains, but like Deshume and a decent sushi
- 7:58restaurant and a few other places started selling to where
- 8:00I am, which is zone 4 N London. And they basically have started
- 8:04opening up these hubs in like like the bottom of the zone 3
- 8:09where they've basically just got kitchens for their their places
- 8:12with the most demand and then their delivery only essentially.
- 8:16So it'd be interesting to see if delivery start driving demand
- 8:22for like in CTCS basically where they can like install inventory
- 8:27for key product and maybe make it a bit more cost effective or
- 8:33operationally effective I guess for the brands or the retailer.
- 8:38Yeah. The the bit where I'm really
- 8:40keen to see 2 bits #1 is where other collaborations come up
- 8:45because you've already seen this with, I guess, brands alignment
- 8:54between big retails where you like Argos is in home bases, for
- 8:57example. Then you've got, you know,
- 8:59connectivity between brands within groups on the John Lewis
- 9:02Partnership between John Lewis, Waitrose, etcetera.
- 9:04You've got all all of the others.
- 9:06But but seeing where this goes in terms of product targeting
- 9:10and smart inventory management for, for ECOM stock and being
- 9:14able to stock quickly. Because I guess one of the big
- 9:17plays here is that ability to be able to be tactically be able to
- 9:21focus promotions incentives around the product areas, you
- 9:25know, that are easy to ship. They've got demand in that area,
- 9:27but that actually you've got quite large stock holdings of
- 9:30and want a free up stock space for.
- 9:33Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I think it'd be interesting to
- 9:35see how this goes actually, because I feel like, and I was
- 9:38thinking about this the other day.
- 9:39So when we did Post New York, one of the speakers was from
- 9:45Dick's Sporting Goods and she was talking about, I want to say
- 9:50it was 80% of their orders are fulfilled from stores, which has
- 9:55been like insane for them in terms of the speed of delivery
- 9:59and like customer satisfaction, etcetera, etcetera.
- 10:02But I feel like there's a massive theme.
- 10:04Oh, I like there's a big trend that people were, you know,
- 10:08investing in last mile and also doing a lot more ship from
- 10:12store. And then I think it completely
- 10:13disappeared and then now it's kind of come back a little bit.
- 10:17And some of that's driven by like Harper and Ingrid, who kind
- 10:20of bought solutions into the market.
- 10:22That's kind of where I've seen it.
- 10:23But yeah, I feel like that whole area, it feels like more, I
- 10:29guess like a lot of our clients probably wouldn't be equipped to
- 10:32start doing that. But yeah, it feels like there's
- 10:35still more, a lot of room to provide a better service and
- 10:39also like, convert people better probably if you're able to
- 10:43fulfill orders like way quicker. So yeah, it'd be interesting to
- 10:46see where it goes. What do Mattel, Victoria
- 10:50Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier all have in common?
- 10:55They power their businesses with Shopify.
- 10:59Shopify is the most innovative and scaled commerce platform on
- 11:02the planet. It also happens to have the best
- 11:06converting checkout on the planet, Shopify, powering the
- 11:11future of enterprise commerce. Find out more at
- 11:14shopify.com/enterprise. Yeah, it's the US was especially
- 11:20a hot place for for the last mile investment and it was a big
- 11:23retailers like the Walmarts and Targets reacting to Amazon who
- 11:27have loved them or hate them and are on the latter camp have
- 11:31always set the standard for that customer service piece.
- 11:36Because no matter what you think about them, they are incredible
- 11:40at getting product to people quickly men low cost.
- 11:46Yeah. So yeah, it's interesting to
- 11:48see. Yeah, I, yeah, I completely
- 11:51agree. And I think there's a lot of
- 11:53people again, like me without positioning myself in this kind
- 11:57of shallow convenience first customer that I mean, I buy so
- 12:05much from Amazon just because I know that I can get it.
- 12:07If I order it now, it'll be with me up worst tomorrow morning.
- 12:13So yeah, I think there's a lot of people like that.
- 12:15And I think Amazon are probably trained at least a proportion of
- 12:19consumers to be like that. So yeah, there's there's
- 12:22definitely opportunity here. Yeah, that one and and to be
- 12:26fair, they were the they were the first company to make people
- 12:30realise that gay guess what? People will pay a subscription
- 12:33for a delivery service when it was ridiculed as launch.
- 12:36And I've actually, you know how I don't know when Prime
- 12:38launched, but I don't know, maybe 15 or so years ago.
- 12:44I'm I, you know, there's brands now that I would never expected
- 12:47to even consider something like that or planning services around
- 12:51this as well. And every time you sit in a
- 12:53meeting, the reference point is. Well, Prime does this.
- 12:59Yeah. I mean, I do feel, I mean it's
- 13:00really interesting. I think that would be a really
- 13:04interesting topic to unpick if you had the right day.
- 13:06Because we've had some clients basically launch a paid
- 13:09membership and the whole there is proof behind the principle of
- 13:14like skin in the game, driving order frequency and volume.
- 13:19And we've had quite a few clients that have wanted to do
- 13:21it and never done it. But yeah, that's an interesting
- 13:25because ASOS was the the other one that did it quite famously
- 13:30and I think ended up net that benefiting from it.
- 13:34But yeah, it's an interesting topic in itself.
- 13:38Let's move on to to payments then, like what's been going on?
- 13:41So there was for those of you listening to the Reader Inside
- 13:45Commerce newsletter there, we put a section in this week's
- 13:49one. Was it last week?
- 13:50I can't remember. No, it was last week about
- 13:53payment trends for well pages landed there 2025 global
- 13:56payments rules. I recommend people downloading
- 13:59it. You've got to fill out form, but
- 14:01it's free. It's got lots of interesting
- 14:02data and it's also got regional specifics.
- 14:04So if if you're operating a specific part of the world or
- 14:07you're considering expanding into it's got some useful
- 14:09regional data in there. But the bits that stood out for
- 14:13me, I'll it is that buy now, pay you later, which was adopted
- 14:18initially by I guess a lot of mass market brands and not so
- 14:26prominent in premium space where it was considered to be not for
- 14:30premium customers, not be reflective of the brand values.
- 14:34But actually by now pay late has gone really mainstream and it's
- 14:36considered as a default option. Now.
- 14:39It's I I've not been in a business and I've quite, I know
- 14:42you work with more premium than I do, but I've not worked with a
- 14:45premium business in the last like three to five years where
- 14:49there isn't a serious either. They are, are using it or they
- 14:53are intended to introduce you there, but the, the brand
- 14:56reticence about it has gone and the stigma around it has gone.
- 14:59And actually when viewed with a strategic lens about how do we
- 15:02use it to benefit the customers, not just let's stick it on as a
- 15:04payment method because it gets us cash.
- 15:07It's amazing. And the, and the data behind it
- 15:09is insane. The the as a as a payment
- 15:11method, it's grown more explosively than the other one.
- 15:15Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I think I agree with everything
- 15:18you just said. I think the only bit of negative
- 15:21feedback I hear now is still the like creative director not
- 15:26liking a little pink clown icon, for example, and maybe not
- 15:31wanting to call it out, etcetera.
- 15:32But yeah, I think it's it's been, it's super mainstream now.
- 15:36The other one that we talked a bit about was Harper, which I'm
- 15:40seeing more brands test out. They're like they call it try
- 15:43for five, but I tested it the other day.
- 15:46So I was buying something on Paul Smith, who are a client of
- 15:49ours, and I was using the discount code and I just want to
- 15:55point that out just so I don't look like I'm there trying to
- 15:58suggest I've got loads of money or anything.
- 16:00Anyway, So they I, I decided to use it on there and it's quite
- 16:06interesting how it's presented and how it's comes to someone
- 16:11that we have never heard of it before.
- 16:13But essentially you I ordered a pair of jeans and then I from
- 16:18that point of ordering the product arise have been two days
- 16:21and then I've got 7 days from the point of ordering of five
- 16:23days from receiving them to essentially decide if I want
- 16:28them or I can just send them straight back before any payment
- 16:31is taken, which I think if he comes out in the right way, it
- 16:35is quite a nice proposition. And the other thing that it
- 16:40essentially promotes is the idea of ordering multiple items.
- 16:45So I could order five different styles of jeans and then I could
- 16:50return. I might then be more likely to
- 16:52buy 2 if I've seen them, felt them tries on, etcetera.
- 16:55So that's kind of part of the value proposition.
- 16:58I think the only question mark I'd have would be because I
- 17:01think one of the biggest issues a lot of the fashion brands we
- 17:03work with have is the buyer that buys 3 sizes and then sends 2
- 17:09bag. And I think this would
- 17:11definitely promote that a little bit.
- 17:14But equally from what I when I've spoken to them, I think
- 17:18there's a good, there's quite a lot of data to kind of back up
- 17:21the incremental value in order order, average order value and
- 17:26kind of basket size. But yeah, I thought that was
- 17:29interesting and I am starting to see it pop up a bit more now.
- 17:32It's, it's real, it's a real dilemma for, for the e-commerce
- 17:36industry because like sustainability is a massive
- 17:39discussion point about the fact that how sustainable can
- 17:43e-commerce truly be? Because at the end of the day,
- 17:45you've got technology running on servers, you've got delivery
- 17:49fleets going all around the country, you've got returns
- 17:51coming back and, and it's the people are always going to buy
- 17:55online, aren't they? How do you, I'd be, I'd be, I'm
- 17:58going to be really intrigued to watch this data evolve and what
- 18:02impact it has on reducing returns.
- 18:04Because that's where it could be a massive win instead of because
- 18:07there will be a percentage of people who would have ordered
- 18:10stuff, decided it's not quite right, sent it back and there's
- 18:14a full return and nothing's been kept versus those who order.
- 18:18And actually, do you know what? That delivery had to be made
- 18:21anyway. But they're keeping something.
- 18:23So the to and from there hasn't created any extra carbon
- 18:26footprint. But actually it's, it's reduced
- 18:28an additional journey. Yeah.
- 18:31Yeah, absolutely. Yeah.
- 18:32Yeah, I think that's a good a good point.
- 18:36The other, the other discussion about that came about that World
- 18:38Pay report. I think it's a bit interesting.
- 18:40It's about this whole concept of cash for society.
- 18:42And again, a lot of people say it's like, you know, we will
- 18:45soon be a cash for society. Everything's moving to digital
- 18:47wallets. More payments are moved into
- 18:49wallets onto smartphones because smartphone proliferation is
- 18:53huge. But quite interestingly well
- 18:59play say it's saying that the cash usage is only predicted to
- 19:03decline at 2% and annual decline decline between now and 2030,
- 19:09which is not a rapid decrease in use of cash when cash was.
- 19:14I'm trying to find the the stat at it here that yeah, at present
- 19:20cash and cards to say in it's in Ecom's about 34% and it's
- 19:25expected to only drop to 21% by 2030.
- 19:30So I'll intrigue you. Do you think we'll ever get to
- 19:36cashless? Do you ever think it's going to
- 19:38be possible for? I mean, I think that's a really
- 19:40hard one to answer. But is that in relation to
- 19:42ecoms, is that like markets like the Middle East where people
- 19:47they're still like a lot cash on delivery is, is it in relation
- 19:51to e-commerce or is it physical retail?
- 19:54Included it's split out, so there's physical retail split
- 19:59out pause separately where it's 38% digital payments, which is
- 20:03anything that's done through like smartphone and non content
- 20:07basically and then cash and cards handing something physical
- 20:11over tapping with a card is 62% in pause and expected to drop to
- 20:1747%. So yeah in E com.
- 20:19Predominantly that is cards, but there are yes, cash based
- 20:24options. As there is, it's interesting,
- 20:26isn't it? Because I mean, obviously I
- 20:29think it'd be really interesting to see that data over a what, 6
- 20:34year period. So you can see the impact of
- 20:36COVID as well and see kind of like, yeah, how quickly it's got
- 20:42to a certain point. But I think that'll probably be,
- 20:44for the time being, whilst places still accept cash and
- 20:49certain industries are still like cash heavy, they'll
- 20:52probably be like a level where it'll get to and then it'll
- 20:57probably stay around because the other thing is tourism.
- 21:00So I think tourism is one of the biggest drivers of cash.
- 21:04And then obviously it's still a big part of like services and
- 21:07people trying to avoid tax ultimately.
- 21:12So, yeah, I think that it's difficult to know and I don't
- 21:15feel like I'm super educated on it, but I don't, I think, yeah,
- 21:19I think the biggest issue would be or the biggest driver change
- 21:22would probably be like people's policies changing around it.
- 21:25So I know there are a lot more retail stores now that are
- 21:29cashless, like you see the signs on the windows.
- 21:33But yeah, it's interesting. I mean, I haven't touched cash
- 21:36for so long. I don't know if you have, but I
- 21:40can't fit like because I'm about to get married and everyone is.
- 21:44I'm getting married abroad and every vendor that we're using is
- 21:49insisting on cash payment without outing them too much and
- 21:55that that'll be the first time that I've got cash out for.
- 21:58So long I think my personal use is I can't be asked to have cash
- 22:03on me because it's another thing I can lose.
- 22:05And I think a lot of people it's the if you go out with cash, you
- 22:10need a wallet. If you go out of your phone with
- 22:12your card on your phone, you don't.
- 22:14You just need one, one thing when you're out.
- 22:17And if you lose it because of like the, the encryption and
- 22:20stuff, you the, the risk is less.
- 22:22You lose a wallet of £100 and it's gone and you lose a wallet
- 22:25with your bank card. Someone can contact us.
- 22:27You go and tap the crap out of it, which has happened to me for
- 22:30but I am weird when I go abroad. I've just been to France for a
- 22:34good friend's wedding, a bloody love foreign currency.
- 22:38I really, it reminds me of being a kid going into shops with like
- 22:42French francs and going, oh, look, I'm paying for it in a
- 22:44funny note. So yeah, I I still have that.
- 22:46But in in terms of E com, there are markets where cash on
- 22:49delivery. As you said, you talk about
- 22:51Middle East, but Germany as well.
- 22:53I think the interesting bit is going to be when when the
- 22:57legislation changes that makes people have to offer that
- 23:01service to the customers because it's a legal requirement in that
- 23:04country versus when it's no longer a legal requirement.
- 23:08And that's where because it's not, you know, the processes
- 23:11exist, but I don't think many retailers would want to offer
- 23:14like cash on delivery if they didn't have to.
- 23:16Yeah, the other one I did very quick one before we go on to the
- 23:21inevitable talk of of AI stuff, is this the shift to payment
- 23:26being made out away from the E Comm store?
- 23:29And we've had the PayPal we're talking about, you know, PayPal
- 23:34buy buttons in ads. So they create shoppable ads
- 23:37where you can basically pay a PayPal or Venmo directly through
- 23:40the ad rather than going to a retail store.
- 23:42Which very smart for PayPal to position against shop pay.
- 23:47Given that how many Shopify stores default to shop pay and
- 23:50PayPal don't get the same potential transactions anymore.
- 23:53So that I thought was smart but the one I was interested in.
- 23:56So is your SO Josh, your Co founder of Avon posted about
- 24:01Google's plan to use agentic AI to add items to your cart on a
- 24:04merchant's site. So it it's going to through the
- 24:08interface, enable you to, to, to search, command, find and or add
- 24:12it to the car. And you can then complete that
- 24:14check out with Google Pay. What, what was your take on
- 24:17that? Because Google Pay tried to
- 24:19establish yourself as a mobile wallet several years back and
- 24:21Apple Pay smashed it out of the park.
- 24:23Because iOS is the primary driver for it and Google Pay
- 24:28struggled to get meaningful growth.
- 24:30So I'm I'm fascinated by whether anyone still cares about Google
- 24:33Pay. I mean I I think people use
- 24:35Google pray Google Pay via Chrome.
- 24:38So like I use it Chrome only purely because I use Chrome.
- 24:43So if I'm paying on duster and I've got the option and quite
- 24:46often not in the shop fire checkout, but in other
- 24:49checkouts, it'll like it will kind of Chrome or pre prompt it
- 24:54as a way of paying. So I use it quite a lot of that.
- 24:57And I think, to be perfectly honest, the more the industry,
- 25:01with all the recent change in the industry is just becoming
- 25:03clearer and clearer how big an asset to Google Chrome is.
- 25:07Because it has actually, I'd actually say like, you know, you
- 25:11look at open AI and ChatGPT rivaling Google search.
- 25:15But you know, Chrome is so valuable to them for like, yeah,
- 25:20for various reasons. So I'd say that's how I see
- 25:25Google Pay. And I think people probably do
- 25:27still use it, but almost entirely as a result of Chrome.
- 25:30Apple Pay obviously really benefits from Safari.
- 25:33I was actually going to talk about I mean, it's interesting.
- 25:37So what you just described, I actually, so I wrote a LinkedIn
- 25:40post this morning about Shopify and how well they've done
- 25:43recently everything else. And then Liam Quinn, now
- 25:47official staff formula for Vaughn, made a comment about the
- 25:53only people that could compete with Shopify.
- 25:55Like there's quite a lot to the comment, but it was then about
- 25:58like someone coming in and out pricing shop fire And I was
- 26:02basically thinking about the I don't I feel like Shopify is
- 26:06playing again. I don't want to talk too much
- 26:08about Shopify is volume low borrowed time tree.
- 26:12So I can't see that happening. But the one thing I could see
- 26:15happening as everything changes, I could see payment providers
- 26:21potentially creating a very cost effective route.
- 26:26And there's obviously been quite a few plays on the pay by bank
- 26:30where you're essentially transacting directly with your
- 26:32bank and then you're not paying the processing fee.
- 26:36And I think that I could see a world where actually payments is
- 26:40commoditised quite a bit. And if you look in the world of
- 26:43subscriptions and you see a lot of these brands that are looking
- 26:46at moving shop, I like the really high volume subscription
- 26:48bandits. A lot of them build their own
- 26:51subscription platform on top of Stripe.
- 26:54And actually the total customer ownership is super low because
- 26:58they'll negotiate a super low rate with Stripe because all
- 27:01they're doing is using it for the, you know, the, the payments
- 27:05And then the software development costs are a lot
- 27:08lower if you're doing hundreds of 1,000,000 via a subscription,
- 27:12buy a subscription and paying the Shopify rates or you know,
- 27:17Shopify plus subscription vendor, etcetera.
- 27:20So I do wonder, it'll be interesting to see where
- 27:23payments goes and how that could help payments.
- 27:27Like as an example of all the open AI stuff, there's a lot of
- 27:30rumours about Shopify, but in theory if open AI build a check
- 27:34out that isn't Shopify and then go with a very low rate payment
- 27:39provider, there could be a lot more kind of margin for that
- 27:44potentially. So, yeah, I think it's going to
- 27:45be interesting basically that where how payment companies
- 27:50could potentially play a different role as the role of
- 27:54commerce potentially changes or the current E COM experience.
- 27:59Yeah. And I'm going to pause on the
- 28:01payments one because I think we could we could talk about this
- 28:03for quite a long time. Maybe we should on the payment
- 28:05specific one. But there are there are such
- 28:07regional variations as well in terms of which payment methods.
- 28:10So like you're talking about banks about real real time
- 28:13account to account payments A to a which are very low here have
- 28:17grown really rapid in places like Brazil and India.
- 28:19So you got all of these nuances about about where the where the
- 28:23the market's going. But let's move on to our next
- 28:25discussion point, which is let's, I was going to do
- 28:30personalized shopping. But I think given the fact that
- 28:33that we've already spoken to about 20 minutes and we could
- 28:35speak for hours on this particular episode, everyone's
- 28:38to hear about our, our ranty views about AI because that's
- 28:42the topic that's everywhere. And we want to come into this
- 28:46topic of, of like, what is what, you know, what's the future of
- 28:50AI from the point of view of, of what's important right now?
- 28:54And then what's a bit hyped and not necessarily relevant, but
- 28:57the structure product data for me is the really big one.
- 29:00And this has come up in in with three clients in the last six
- 29:04months. And this is the fact that there
- 29:08is a rise in use of AI agents and people will continue to be
- 29:11more agentic solutions that give interfaces to ask questions, put
- 29:18commands to retrieve information or even to execute tasks.
- 29:23We're not, you know, we don't yet know how far in advance
- 29:27these agents will get and how quickly.
- 29:29But we've already got things like, you know, chat bot
- 29:33interfaces where you can into you can get information back on
- 29:37orders, you can pre access and print returns labels directly
- 29:41from where lots of stuff you can do in terms of like product
- 29:46discovery. What it's meaning is that you
- 29:49know the the website has to be rigorously structured in order
- 29:54to have data semantically right for agents to understand and for
- 30:01it to be easily accessible. Which comes back to the fact
- 30:04that if you go back to the the original tenets of technical
- 30:08SEO, that's exactly what it was trying to do to websites, which
- 30:11was have have the data clean, accurate, readable, legible,
- 30:16have it structured, use markup, ensure that it's indexable and
- 30:21readable. Don't hide it behind loads of
- 30:24JavaScript. You know that don't embed
- 30:28important information in images, so it's not read.
- 30:30It's got to be live. They're all of these
- 30:33foundations. Technical SEO, which it almost
- 30:36feels like technical SEO over the last few years hasn't been
- 30:38having as much limelight as it should have had.
- 30:41But this now is bring it right back.
- 30:42Because if you do that right, then the agents should be in a
- 30:46good position to read your site and retrieve information.
- 30:50Yeah. Absolutely, Yeah, yeah.
- 30:52I think it'll be interesting to see why this one goes because
- 30:57yeah, you everyone is talking about optimizing towards ChatGPT
- 31:01and like this chunking piece and like collect or like extracting
- 31:06more data around like what people are searching for and
- 31:08using that within content extra etcetera, etcetera.
- 31:12But I also think they'll be I think it would develop and I
- 31:16think they'll probably be feeds used more.
- 31:21And I think yeah, there'll be a lot more information provided
- 31:23hopefully at some point like the equivalent of Google Search
- 31:26Console so that people can have got better like tooling readily
- 31:30available to optimize towards this stuff.
- 31:33But yeah, completely broke. And yeah, I think it'd be really
- 31:36interesting to see how this side does develop.
- 31:40And I think the, because Josh has been talking quite a lot
- 31:42recently about the Google side of this and how more people are
- 31:47starting to use AI mode and how there's like a bit more to
- 31:50optimising feeds and all that kind of stuff.
- 31:53But yeah, I think there's just a lot of room for change in this
- 31:57space. So like, yeah, it'd be
- 31:59interesting keeping an eye on it.
- 32:01Where do you think it it will end up?
- 32:03I know this is like crystal, crystal ball and there's no
- 32:06guarantees, but do you think it be, do you think people will
- 32:09create specific data feeds for agents?
- 32:13So that is, go and retrieve it and you know, rather than having
- 32:16to go to a, have a connection to a site and then interpret for
- 32:21themselves. I mean, I think all of what
- 32:23we've described, I could see it being a mix of all of it, to be
- 32:26perfectly honest. I think in terms of where it's
- 32:28likely to end up, like at the minute, there's a lot of people,
- 32:32you know, that are predicting that everyone's going to shop
- 32:34via, you know, via a conversation and via or via an
- 32:37agent. And I don't, I can't see a world
- 32:40where that's how like everyone's going to approach purchasing.
- 32:44I think it's always going to be a bit of a mix.
- 32:46I also think when you see these like really bold comments on
- 32:50LinkedIn about how that is the way it's definitely going to go,
- 32:52people have completely forgotten that like a huge proportion of
- 32:57purchases are originally discovered via TikTok or Meta,
- 33:04etcetera, etcetera. So I think, you know, they play
- 33:06a much bigger part in all of this.
- 33:07And I think people are, I guess it's just because Google's so
- 33:12big and they're going to be the most impacted by this.
- 33:14Everyone's just kind of forgetting about, you know, that
- 33:17proportion of traffic and commerce and discovery.
- 33:22But yeah, so I think it's going to be interesting.
- 33:24I think they'll definitely be some new ways that people shop.
- 33:30But equally, I don't think it'll be a case of like the two, you
- 33:34know, biggest journeys to finding product are just,
- 33:39they're like dead. I think it's just that, yeah,
- 33:42there'll be there'll be additional ways that people find
- 33:47information, find new product and ultimately buy.
- 33:51But in terms of the feed space, again, I mean, I think it's hard
- 33:53to tell that obviously Google have gone down that route for
- 33:58product related stuff. But realistically all of these
- 34:04solutions are going to need to do some level of crawling.
- 34:08It's more just about if they can, if they benefit from having
- 34:12a feed submitted maybe with slightly richer data.
- 34:17I think the other thing that people forget about is that
- 34:19inventory isn't always readily available.
- 34:23And you know, that's a big, that's a big part to this as
- 34:26well. And particularly if people want
- 34:28to start transacting within kind of, you know, the Allylands and
- 34:33everything curls that'll need to be factored in and that all of
- 34:36those orders will need to be passed through to different
- 34:39systems. So yeah, I think overall, I
- 34:42think that they'll probably be a place for feeds if with all the
- 34:48other kind of LLMS outside of just Google, but I think it'll
- 34:53probably end up being a mix personally.
- 34:55Yeah, and it's there. There have been so many semi
- 34:59false dawns in e-commerce where a new bit of tech or a new way
- 35:04of engaging with customers and all of a sudden people are like
- 35:08everyone's going to be using. I remember virtual shopping
- 35:10malls and that was probably about 10 years ago.
- 35:14And this is like well before web 3:00 and all these virtual
- 35:19worlds, but a virtual shopping mall where you could have all
- 35:22your products and see people could walk around like they're
- 35:24in a shop rather than being on a website and a catalog and a
- 35:27hierarchy. And, and there were technology
- 35:29vendors pushing that as a future.
- 35:30And there was hype around it and a few people tried it and it was
- 35:33all right. And actually where it ended up
- 35:35was very, very different. End up in just the UX of E com
- 35:39websites evolving to make it easier for people to do product
- 35:41discovery. And we're still in that cycle.
- 35:44I'm very cynical about this whole everyone's I'm with you.
- 35:48Everyone's going to end up ordering identically.
- 35:50I just don't buy it either. I can see it working
- 35:53exceptionally well in some verticals where it's a, there's
- 35:59a complex process to selecting a product and therefore the
- 36:03ability to interrogate and refine and have an agent that
- 36:06can intelligently go off and do the donkey work for you.
- 36:09Like travel would be a classic example for me where I can see
- 36:11agents being so important in the future of ability to go right.
- 36:15I've got a budget of £1000 and I need to get a, a minimum three
- 36:19star hotel which has da, da, da, da, da and it needs to be on
- 36:21these dates. And there's a that I can see,
- 36:25but I can't see if somebody wants to buy a T-shirt.
- 36:27And I'm not convinced of a basic purchases.
- 36:30People are going to go to that trouble because the, the value
- 36:34add is not really there. And I think I might, my advice
- 36:37to people at the moment is don't worry about that.
- 36:40We're, we're not there yet to know how that is going to work
- 36:43technically process and, and, and what use cases.
- 36:46But the structured product piece is big and it will have an
- 36:49impact. And the bit where it's most
- 36:52going to have the biggest impact quickly if you don't get it
- 36:54right is on product discovery in these in these LLMS and these
- 36:58agents where you might actually not be found.
- 37:01And even things like Google's AI overviews and getting that one
- 37:07year. We did that episode with Sam
- 37:08from Novos recently and talking about, you know, how you win
- 37:11that space. So for me at the moment, I think
- 37:14it's less obsession about how do I get my products sellable in
- 37:17that, but more about how do I get them discoverable.
- 37:22Yeah, completely agree. Yeah.
- 37:23I think we obviously talked a bit about Sam about that and I
- 37:26think the obviously we all coming at it from a commerce
- 37:30angle. But I think it's important to
- 37:32remember like the non commerce content as well, because that's
- 37:38going to be a lot less likely to be feed based.
- 37:41And yeah, that's an important part of all this as well.
- 37:46The where let's let's now go on to the the one of the big things
- 37:50we talked about and one of the reasons we want to do this
- 37:52episode is about AI is being massively hyped and there is
- 37:55some self-interest around doing that.
- 37:57Yeah, there are we've both seen it some conversations around and
- 38:01you know, if e-commerce teams aren't adapting and embracing AI
- 38:05in their roles and their business, and now they'll be
- 38:07obsolete, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, which don't agree
- 38:10with I'm I was going to say, oh, I'm going to say bollocks.
- 38:14Actually, let's just, let's just get a word out there.
- 38:16I don't agree with it because a business doesn't, doesn't become
- 38:19unviable overnight just because it hasn't adopted the latest
- 38:21technology. Might, might mean that there has
- 38:24some inefficiencies and there maybe it has some, some cost
- 38:27inefficiency in it that it could avoid if it, if it embraced it
- 38:31further. But it doesn't mean it's
- 38:32suddenly going to be a non viable business.
- 38:34Let's talk about, there's a few strands here.
- 38:37The, the area that I, I personally see and speak to my
- 38:42clients are most about and where I've seen good wins is focusing
- 38:46on from a customer service point of view and helping customer
- 38:50service teams to not have to repetitively answer the same
- 38:53questions or do low value tasks for customers.
- 38:58You know, things that are constantly asked like where's my
- 39:00order? Or, you know, can I cancel my
- 39:03order or you know, what's my order tracking on?
- 39:05But all of those things which actually if you have the date,
- 39:08if you have the data in the right place, you can give that
- 39:11an age, a chat bot access to that to be able to then go and
- 39:14find that information and return it within the chat interface.
- 39:16So I've seen, I've seen one, one of my clients have they reduced
- 39:20their inbound ticket account by over 50% in the first three to
- 39:23four weeks by dinner. It was mainly order related.
- 39:27That's the area for me where I think if people are wanting to
- 39:30take tangible, get tangible benefits without over
- 39:34complicating their business, that's where they go.
- 39:37Yeah. So I think I've definitely seen
- 39:39the same. And one of the solutions that we
- 39:41talked a little bit about a second ago was Digital Genius
- 39:44was I think most of our clients definitely like kind of using AI
- 39:52in this area now, some of which are a bit more simple and then
- 39:57some of which have gone down the road of investing in a solution
- 39:59like Digital Genius. So it's a bit more.
- 40:01Control over it, a bit more room to kind of train, a bit more
- 40:05room to kind of integrate with order management, etcetera,
- 40:09etcetera. So that's been something that
- 40:12I've had pretty much entirely positive feedback on.
- 40:14I think the other area across our clients is translation.
- 40:18So even when it's not perfect, even when people have manual
- 40:22translations, like a lot of our clients now are using
- 40:26particularly ChatGPT with some level of like training and then
- 40:32manually intervening, whatever the right term is, but basically
- 40:37then manually optimising after. And that's been really
- 40:40efficient. And then maybe on top of that,
- 40:44just contact generation. I think the other thing where
- 40:46there's a lot of scaremongering is in the media space creative.
- 40:50So you see a lot of people who are like, we're creating 10,000
- 40:54assets a month purely via AI and you know, if you're not doing
- 40:59the same, you're wasting your time or you're, you know, not
- 41:02hitting the numbers you should be, blah, blah, blah.
- 41:04And whilst I do think, I mean, in all of this, there's so much
- 41:07opportunity, but it's definitely not.
- 41:10I just think there's, like you said, there's so many people
- 41:12shouting on LinkedIn and kind of trying to force people to, you
- 41:18know, go a certain way. But I think the biggest thing
- 41:21that I've I've seen and learnt so far within the AI space is
- 41:25that, you know, if you go and build something or if you go and
- 41:29double down and, you know, invest all your time and yeah,
- 41:32creating a solution in AI, realistically there'll be a
- 41:35better solution that, you know, someone with a lot more money
- 41:39and time than you who has created very, very quickly.
- 41:43And I think most of our clients are outside of translations,
- 41:47information processing and customer service.
- 41:52I think the majority are, you know, buying a new vendor.
- 41:55So an equivalent of a digital genius as an example or, or
- 42:00relying on, you know, their ecom platforms, the Clavio or
- 42:04equivalent. And the other one I talked about
- 42:06that I, I think the one that I've been most impressed with,
- 42:09I've actually seen people using on a day-to-day basis is
- 42:12probably triple Whale where our team, it is constant using their
- 42:16MOBI solution, you know, using their agents, etcetera,
- 42:19etcetera. And whilst I think, you know,
- 42:22there's, if you've got the right team and resources available,
- 42:25it's great to, you know, build on top of solutions or build
- 42:30your own kind of solutions around your individual needs.
- 42:34I think there's a lot of, you know, our average kind is
- 42:36definitely not doing that. They're buying software based on
- 42:41their AI capability and their road map, which I think is is
- 42:44probably what most are doing right now.
- 42:47Yeah, exactly. It's it's I don't, I currently
- 42:50don't work with any business where there is a competitive
- 42:54advantage to build their own AI capability.
- 42:58It's about it's about using the appropriate tools to help gain
- 43:01efficiency and that is across customer service number one, it
- 43:06is internal process. So a lot often this is like
- 43:10this. Look at it more in the operation
- 43:11side of the business, such as in middle wares where AI capability
- 43:15can help with things like routing, it can help things with
- 43:18enrichment of data before it's passed between systems so that
- 43:23there's no manual processes doing it.
- 43:26And it's about content. And so one example, which is a
- 43:30great example is a client who had a an SEO fail in an audit
- 43:37because they had, they had just, they hadn't done alt tags on
- 43:39images. It was an oversight as our
- 43:42Christ, you got 2 1/2 thousand images to add to our result tags
- 43:46to you're not doing that manually unless you want to just
- 43:49waste a week of your life. But actually there's there's an
- 43:53app and we Rd. test. I Rd. tested 3 apps and found
- 43:56one which actually came up with with with accurate might not be
- 43:59100% perfect, but accurate, relevant, contextually relevant
- 44:02stuff. That's $50 to do that across the
- 44:052 1/2 thousand versus how many, how many days and how much cost.
- 44:09So there's all these elements where I think fundamentally AI
- 44:11is right. But yeah, it's not about
- 44:14strategically pivot to be an AI driven business.
- 44:16It's tactically use AI to improve efficiency and get cost
- 44:20gains. Yeah, completely agree.
- 44:26The one I'm interested about and final discussion performing on
- 44:29this, because I know again, we could go off into lots of
- 44:31different tangents on AI, is AI replacing jobs and what do you
- 44:36think about it? Because I saw really, I've read
- 44:38quite a few articles again, mainly on LinkedIn in the hype
- 44:41cycle that it's in about, you know, you got you got to protect
- 44:46yourself in the future. Jobs are going, AI is replacing
- 44:49humans, you've got to reskill, blah, blah, blah, apocalypse
- 44:52bollocks. And it's hard to find really
- 44:56good data out there to validate what impact is having and at
- 44:58what scale. But there's a really good report
- 45:01from Goldman Sachs, they've researched in the US across all
- 45:04lots of different industries, roles that could be impacted,
- 45:08how they would impact it, and how AI is currently impacting
- 45:11and what it's doing to the job market.
- 45:14And the, the date, the status they came up is that innovation
- 45:17related to AI could display 6 to 7% of the US workforce if it's
- 45:21widely adopted. But the impact is most likely
- 45:24transitory because new job opportunities will be created by
- 45:27the same technology to put people into work in other
- 45:30capacities. What's what's your take?
- 45:32Are you seeing anything where roles are going or are you
- 45:35seeing more about like repurposing of roles?
- 45:38I think, I think, I think the risk is there for roles to be in
- 45:42part of it in our industry. I don't think it'll be as
- 45:46aggressive as in some other industries.
- 45:49I do think the risk is there, but equally I think and is more
- 45:53about how people use AI and like you say, I haven't as the
- 45:56opportunity to kind of like supplement rather than replace.
- 45:59I didn't know as the opportunity for yeah, just investing in
- 46:04investing more in different areas etcetera.
- 46:08I mean, it is, it is interesting with the AI stuff because I'm
- 46:10really critical of like how everyone's talking about.
- 46:12It is obviously still relatively early, but I do think it's going
- 46:17to change a lot. But I like you say, I think that
- 46:22I mean, customer service is probably a good example where
- 46:25when you, you know, there might be companies that have 20
- 46:27customer service agents now that have four in the future.
- 46:30They actually, they've got additional roles around there
- 46:33who are like monitoring effectiveness or yeah, other
- 46:38other kind of roles that might exist around it.
- 46:41But yeah, I think, I think my view is that in five years time,
- 46:44I think a lot of like manual work will be automated.
- 46:47And, you know, they'll probably just be additional roles
- 46:52alongside kind of what we have now where people are to use and
- 46:55budget more effectively, you know, where it is.
- 46:58The, the big change that I can foresee coming is a, it is fewer
- 47:03reasons to say, oh, we don't have the time to do that.
- 47:05And, and I know that there are genuine reasons why we all
- 47:09either as consultants, agencies or people who are running econ
- 47:12teams have a genuine reason, say we don't have the time to do
- 47:16that or we can't ship that on the road map because of the
- 47:17priorities. But if we, if we increase
- 47:21automation and reduce unnecessary manual tasks or
- 47:26complexity for people so that 20% of the time is freed up
- 47:29because we have an agent or a process that's running, it's
- 47:33done it doing it for you. That time can be spent on being
- 47:36more proactive. And I'll give you 11 tangible
- 47:39example, a client who reduced number of inbound enquiries and
- 47:45tickets in their customer service system by introducing
- 47:49that AI agent. So they had fewer order
- 47:52enquiries. Where's my order?
- 47:54They had fewer requests for like, oh, I want to add
- 47:59something because they would because based on the order
- 48:03status, it would say your order is no longer able to be edited,
- 48:08contact customer service. Then some people would, some
- 48:10people wouldn't. They've reduced some enquiries
- 48:11on that, but actually wouldn't enable them to see the area
- 48:14where they were falling down and they were getting lots of
- 48:16complaints, which was then impacting reviews and ratings
- 48:18was when someone, when there was a major problem or someone's
- 48:21pissed off, their speed of response to resolve it was
- 48:24really slow because they were drowning under the volume of
- 48:27inbound enquiries. So actually stripping those out,
- 48:30all of a sudden you've got a sharper process of customers
- 48:34pissed off. What's the issue?
- 48:36OK, that's something we need to step on, right?
- 48:38Let's proactively resolve that. I can call that customer and you
- 48:41get this proactivity and it becomes a more satisfying job as
- 48:44well because you're not just dealing with I, right, Check all
- 48:48the status, send it, check all, it's OK, I've got a real human
- 48:51connection here. I've got a relationship.
- 48:53I can build a customer. I've got something to do that's
- 48:55going to add value to the business and the customer and
- 48:57me. So that's where I that for me is
- 48:59a great opportunity. Well, I think let's bring that
- 49:03to an end. I know Paul and I could chat for
- 49:05hours about this as opinionated consultants.
- 49:09If there's anything in the podcast that's feature interest,
- 49:12you want to talk to us more, Anything you disagree with?
- 49:14Do you reach out? Do you tell us you disagree?
- 49:16We love our conversations and hopefully you found it
- 49:19interesting you know where to find us.
- 49:20If you want to chat more, you're listening to the Inside Comments
- 49:25podcast. Hosted by experienced
- 49:26consultants James Gert and Paul Rogers.
- 49:29Inside Commerce is your fast track to digital knowledge,
- 49:31featuring interviews with leading e-commerce retailers,
- 49:34industry thought leads and the C-Suite, key tech companies to
- 49:37explore the latest digital strategy, customer experience
- 49:40and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 49:42really mean and get practical advice based on the experience
- 49:45to help fine tune your e-commerce strategy and tech
- 49:47stack. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 49:50out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an e-commerce
- 49:52project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 49:54episode.