Latest / It's Only In Trying / S2 Ep. 8 - Perfect Was Never The Point
Transcript
- 0:06Tara: Okay.
- 0:07Tara: Good grades, check.
- 0:09Tara: Athlete, and a pretty good one if I do say so myself, check.
- 0:13Tara: Great friends, check.
- 0:14Tara: College degree, job, check, check, check.
- 0:18Tara: Then back to law school, another job, married, a baby, check, check, check again.
- 0:23Tara: I did it all right.
- 0:25Tara: And I did it in the right order.
- 0:28Tara: And then I got divorced.
- 0:31Tara: This is its only in trying.
- 0:34Tara: A place to stop asking and start being.
- 0:37Tara: Let's go.
- 0:40Tara: So today we're talking about perfectionism, and I'm gonna be very vulnerable.
- 0:45Tara: I was raised by wonderful parents.
- 0:48Tara: They gave me everything I could ever need.
- 0:50Tara: They were supportive, they made me feel like I could make my own choices.
- 0:54Tara: So this is not one of those episodes where I blame my parents.
- 0:56Tara: Hi, mom and dad.
- 0:58Tara: But somewhere along the line, I lost my tether to what I wanted.
- 1:02Tara: And I started living for what I was supposed to want.
- 1:06Tara: I truly have no idea where it came from, but I worked my ass off to do everything right.
- 1:13Tara: And for a long time, it looked like it was working.
- 1:17Tara: I built this shiny armor of perfection around myself, one gold star at a time.
- 1:23Tara: Now, I'm not saying I never made mistakes.
- 1:26Tara: I made a lot.
- 1:28Tara: But they were the kind I could fix or hide or just ignore.
- 1:34Tara: The divorce was the first one I couldn't.
- 1:37Tara: It was the first chink in the armor, and everyone could see it.
- 1:42Tara: It's a strange thing to do everything the way it's supposed to be done and have it not work out.
- 1:49Tara: I went through the whole shame cycle.
- 1:51Tara: What did I do wrong?
- 1:52Tara: What could I have done differently?
- 1:54Tara: Is there something wrong with me?
- 1:56Tara: Which gets me to the question I really want to dig into.
- 2:01Tara: Why do we feel so much pressure to be perfect in the first place?
- 2:06Tara: Well, it's not just you.
- 2:09Tara: Turns out it's in the air.
- 2:12Tara: Two researchers, Thomas Curran and Andrew Hill, looked at perfectionism scores from more than 41,000 college students in the US, Canada, and the UK from 1989 to 2016.
- 2:23Tara: Every type of perfectionism went up.
- 2:26Tara: But the one that jumped the most was what they call socially prescribed perfectionism.
- 2:32Tara: That's the feeling that other people and society in general expect you to be perfect.
- 2:37Tara: That one went up about 33%.
- 2:40Tara: And this year, they updated it with 35 years of data and almost 83,000 students.
- 2:46Tara: That same feeling didn't just keep climbing, it sped up, starting in the early 2000s.
- 2:54Tara: Now, these are college students in three countries, and it shows a trend over time, not one single cause.
- 3:01Tara: But think about what that means.
- 3:04Tara: A lot of the pressure we feel isn't something anyone actually said to us.
- 3:08Tara: It's an expectation we picked up from everywhere at once.
- 3:12Tara: And honestly, that explains so much about me.
- 3:16Tara: Nobody sat me down and told me to do everything right and in order.
- 3:20Tara: I just absorbed that that's what we do.
- 3:24Tara: So, okay, back to me sitting in the rubble.
- 3:27Tara: After the dust settled and I was in my new normal, I started asking a different question.
- 3:34Tara: Not what did I do wrong, but what do I actually want from this life?
- 3:40Tara: There's a line from Stephen Pressfield's The War of Art that I first came across in Britt Frank's book, The Science of Stuck, and it stopped me cold.
- 3:50Tara: He said, our job in this life is not to shape ourselves into some ideal we imagine we ought to be, but to find out who we are already and become it.
- 4:01Tara: That was me.
- 4:03Tara: I'd spent years shaping myself into the ideal.
- 4:07Tara: So if I did everything the right way and it all still broke, what else was I doing the right way or the safe way?
- 4:16Tara: What wasn't I doing that I wished I was?
- 4:20Tara: So I started small.
- 4:23Tara: I put myself out there in my new community and made some friends.
- 4:27Tara: I traveled with my besties, and then I started seeing all the things I'd put on hold to live the life I thought I was supposed to want.
- 4:37Tara: So I trained for and ran my second half marathon.
- 4:40Tara: I tried knitting.
- 4:42Tara: I took voice acting classes, a hip-hop dance class.
- 4:45Tara: Yes, really, a hip-hop dance class.
- 4:48Tara: I started this podcast.
- 4:49Tara: I joined a writing program, and now I'm in the masterclass executive program, learning alongside some seriously impressive people.
- 4:59Tara: And it wasn't just new skills.
- 5:01Tara: I started advocating for myself.
- 5:04Tara: I spoke up at work, and I believe I'm seen as a leader now.
- 5:07Tara: I even got a raise.
- 5:09Tara: I share my opinions more freely.
- 5:14Tara: And here's the thing about perfection: it has this allure, like only the best of the best can get there.
- 5:25Tara: But it's a trap.
- 5:27Tara: It locks you in and throws away the key, and the worst part is that it doesn't even make you special.
- 5:33Tara: It leaves you just like everyone else, and nothing like who you actually want to be.
- 5:40Tara: So here's the next lesson.
- 5:44Tara: That visible scar, being someone who can't claim her life is perfect anymore, is actually what set me free.
- 5:53Tara: And it made me more relatable.
- 5:56Tara: I'm not sitting up on my high horse of prestige anymore, fending off anyone who might pull me down from my tower.
- 6:02Tara: The worst already happened.
- 6:06Tara: And instead of being separate from everyone, I'm one of the whole again.
- 6:13Tara: And turns out there's research on this.
- 6:17Tara: Psychologists, Anna Brooke, Sabine Scholl, and Herbert Bless ran seven studies on what happens when people show vulnerability, like admitting a mistake or being the first to say how you feel.
- 6:30Tara: Over and over, people judged their own vulnerability as weakness, embarrassing, a mess.
- 6:39Tara: But when they watched someone else do the exact same thing, they saw courage.
- 6:46Tara: These wonderful psychologists called it the beautiful mess effect.
- 6:51Tara: From inside, it feels like a mess.
- 6:55Tara: But from the outside, it looks like courage.
- 7:00Tara: And in a follow-up study, the people who were kinder to themselves, the more self-compassionate ones, mostly didn't fall into that gap.
- 7:10Tara: They could see the beauty in their own mess, not just everyone else's.
- 7:15Tara: And that tracks for me.
- 7:18Tara: My first instinct now is to consider things from the other person's point of view.
- 7:24Tara: And as you know from last week, to actually ask them what it is.
- 7:29Tara: There's no longer one single right way to do things.
- 7:32Tara: There might be other paths.
- 7:36Tara: I still have ups and downs, plenty of them, but I bounce back so much faster now.
- 7:43Tara: And honestly, that's become my favorite way to measure progress.
- 7:47Tara: The question isn't whether I fall, it's how fast I get back up.
- 7:54Tara: So the checklist: good grades, athlete, college, job, law school, married baby.
- 8:00Tara: I'm not knocking any of that.
- 8:02Tara: I'm actually really proud of all of it.
- 8:05Tara: But it isn't because it was in the right order.
- 8:10Tara: Now, this might sound strange, but here's what I hope for you.
- 8:16Tara: I hope you have a setback.
- 8:19Tara: Not a big one, just one big enough to show you that it isn't that serious.
- 8:25Tara: And that the better way to do this experiment called life is to love yourself, respect others, and try it your way one mistake at a time.
- 8:36Tara: So this week, pick one thing you've been doing the right way or the safe way, and do it your way instead.
- 8:44Tara: Sign up for the class, say the thing in the meeting, let it be messy.
- 8:51Tara: Because whoever's watching is probably going to call it courage.
- 8:56Tara: And just remember, you're doing better than you think.