Latest / Ego and Other Things / Is Discourse Getting Worse?
Transcript
- William: Is public discourse getting worse? Or does it just feel that way because you're exposed to it more often? What my in what my intuition tells me about this question is that actually public discourse is, in one sense, getting better because it is being so publicly exposed. And in one sense because it's been democratized. Particularly with the rise of the internet, everybody now gets a chance to get on here, like myself, and just speak their mind about whatever. And lots of people do. views and thoughts and opinions that might have been reserved for I suppose private conversations now often happen in online spaces and they happen a lot of the times in anonymous ways. And so we're exposed a lot more to the opinions of random people. And most people of course are not trained in thought, let alone trained in articulating thought. I certainly wasn't trained. Part of the reason I'm doing this is to to practice thinking out loud and to practice articulation and to practice Increasing the quality of my thought. But that's in one sense because the bar for quality I believe has raised so much because there's in one sense a lot more judges and a lot more qualified judges. Because not only do people share their opinion a lot more frequently than they used to, but they but there's a lot more people who are exposed to those same kinds of opinions. And so there's a bit of a social evolution that's going on. Maybe even kind of a a a social arms race, I would say, where ideas are exposed and criticized and the people behind the ideas are exposed and criticized in ways that they simply would have been they wouldn't have been even in the nineties and in the eighties, really before the rise of the internet. But personally I think that's something that that's benefited me. Much more than it's harmed me. I mean a lot things were just hidden before. Particularly what I'm thinking right now, child abuse. Corruption in government. Manipulation of people through media. These are the kinds of things that come to my mind. But there are a lot of just crappy things in the world that have been able to be exposed because of the age of the internet. Because, in one sense, there's cameras everywhere. And the internet allows us to access a lot more information than we otherwise would. And not just The specialists accessing that information, not just those who are in power and have an incentive. to mold information in accordance with what benefits their position of power. But it's something which has allowed everybody a tremendous amount of access to information. Even if a lot of that information is not good. or low quality. But there it is, right? I mean, you have i there are these sort of I wanna say social or intellectual evolutions that are going on because of that kind of conflict, right? It's not as though, for instance, when it comes to you know misinformation or disinformation or bad information, I love the conversation around that kind of question, right? There's so much information on the internet. And ever since the internet's come about, people have begun to recognize That a lot of the information out there is basically crap. And they've had to i i and the the crappy information has been so in their face that if you want to know anything of quality at all, you have to be particularly, particularly more rigorous about the information that you're getting. And you have to have a more critical and skeptical mindset towards that information than you would have had for the average person 50 years ago, or even I would argue in the 90s or the 80s. Because the reality of crappy information has come to the forefront. But or it's so in your face nowadays, or it's so accessible to the average person. But the funny thing is that crappy information is not something that is unique to the internet. It's not something that's unique to the modern age. It's something that has plagued mankind for the majority of its history. Even so-called scholarly or philosophical, scientific, psychological information and theories. The the information and the theories that were articulated and defended in the universities, a lot of that information was crap. And you can know this because now you can go back and look at the kinds of arguments or the kinds of statements that people were talking about and realize how much crappy information was floating around in the intellectual circles. That was floating around in you might say the circles of authority. Well, the average person didn't have any access to it. They sort of just accepted the validity of this knowledge on the basis of the authority of the figure. So I'm trying to think of an example here. But one I one I can think is something like psychoanalysis. You know, Freud, as a respected academic, writer, and intellectual, had a lot of authority. With his clients. So they would his clients, his patients, would come in with these problems. And because of Freud's authoritative position, and because of their own lack of access to information, text tests, cases, academic circles, or whatnot, they really had little choice but to accept what Freud was telling them about their own illness, and to, in one sense, believe that. Freud was right and they had that he had their best intentions. But of course Freud was kind of a maniac. I mean Freud made up the sexual theory of psychosis, to obscure the fact to his colleagues and to the powerful members of A Viennan society that the hysteria among the women that Freud was treating was caused not by made-up sexual fantasies that these these women were just sort of making up in their heads, but was due to to the rampant sexual abuse and incest that was being perpetrated by women in that society. by the men in their lives, by their their brothers and their fathers and their uncles and their clergy and by city officials. Freud was a coward and he he didn't want to have his reputation destroyed by exposing the sexual violence that was going on around him. which is not just documented in the letters that Roy that Freud wrote to his friends, but also is documented in something like The Conspiracy of Silence by Sandra Butler, where this kind of rampant sexual abuse of children, particularly young girls, has been something that's been going on at astronomical rates. In societies all over the world for a very long time. In Sandra Butler's book, I think she cites the sist the statistic that one in four girls are sexually abused before reaching puberty and one in three women One in three one in three girls are sexually abused before they they reach the age of eighteen. And there are similarly f similarly frightening frightening statistics for for boys as well. Not as high, but still way too high than what it should be. Which it should be zero. But You know, if there was a Freud today, if there was a Freud today who sort of just made up their own theory, but had the authority of academia, you know, had some sort of degree, had some sort of office where they were treating clients, maybe they had the respect of the people around them, the patients that would go into Freud's office today would have a far better ability to push back against what Freud was saying, both in in terms of their ability to articulate because of their level of education, as well as access to information. Meaning that, you know, they could take a look at what Freud was saying, analyze it critically themselves, analyze their own experience, and also turn to the bevy of alternative explanations, most of which are which are far more compelling. for psychiatric illness that exists today. And I view that as an elevation of discourse. I view that as an elevation of discourse. I view the fact that people have access to a much more wide variety of information today. than they did in the past. Because of what it l allows them to push back on. And Not only that, but if someone is really interested in being Critical and getting to the truth, it really forces you to think. It really forces you to be critical. It really forces you to sort through your information. It really forces you to not simply accept what people are saying to you, whether they are a quote-unquote authority or not, because of the access to information that you have. Now, of course, there's going to be downsides, because there's going to be a whole host of people who are in one sense or another. Uninterested in the truth. Uninterested in the truth and and ye and willing to try to manipulate people. with misinformation, disinformation, that kind of stuff, right? There's a cost to the fact that we have such ready access to information that everybody can talk about their opinion. And that we can get access to pretty much any anybody's opinion about anything. There are costs to that. And the cost is that the people who are not all that interested in the truth are gonna be blindsided. are on the one sand on the one hand going to be able to be manipulated pretty easily and are gonna be the kinds of people who try to manipulate disinformation because you know, for their own purposes, mostly out of traumatic repetition and trying to produce the same kinds of feelings that they've experienced as a child of onto other people. But I think if you're a person who's interested in the truth, I think if you're a person who's interested in critical thinking, I think if you're a person Who is curious? The challenges of a lot of information, or the challenges of many people's opinions, from which you have to sort through, not on the basis of authority, not on the basis of a piece of paper, not on the basis of someone telling you, yeah, this guy knows what he's talking about, not on the basis of this being the only person within a a given profession who has access to this kind of information, but You are interested in the truth and getting to the bottom of the truth on the basis of your own mind and respect for your own ability to think about things, then I think access to people's opinions and access to information, even if the majority of it isn't quality, can really only be a benefit to you. Because you have more information to work with. And you have more and more opportunities to spot the good from the bad. Now, does this raise the discourse of society in general? As a whole I think it does. As a whole I think it does. I think it does even among even among the I don't know, the average person, right? The the the so-called unthinking person. Because I don't think that their their conversation was as necessarily elevated or more elevated, you know, before the advent of the internet. You can't really know, and the little that you can know is is known through studies that academics did within these cultures and there's always always the the sort of observer effect in regards to that. But I can't imagine that they were having incredibly rich and intelligent and deep and critical conversations with one another on a day-to-day basis because they sitting simply didn't have the access to the information or the training in order to do so. What they had was intuition What they had was what's called common sense, and oftentimes there is a strong creative element. Among them. In a certain you might say a practical wisdom. But how much they actually How elevated the discourse was is I can't imagine that would been very great. And if I I don't know, if I go down the street and I talk to a random person and I'm Especially if I set it up as like a deeper conversation. I get a lot out of them. They understand I guess much of what I'm talking about. Though at this point I'm setting myself up as like I don't know. My discourse is elevated, which I I have no idea if that's even I I don't know. This is a tricky one. It it's a tricky one to answer, whether or not the the discourse is elevated. I feel as though I have benefited very much from the modern day access to information and the recognition that authority one's authority does not convey their ability to to know the truth. And I've benefited that I've benefited from that very personally. I think that if I had not had had access to those things that my discourse would have been ha would be severely diminished. But and my intuition to say is to say that I'm not a particularly different person from the average person. I mean maybe I'm curious more curious about certain things, but I don't really view myself as particularly elevated above the average in some way. So I have to imagine that other people, whether they explicitly recognize it or not, that the access to information and the recognition that authority doesn't always mean truth at a cultural level And the training really that one gets in having to sift the information, sift through the bullshit, so to speak, has had to have had a greater positive effect than a negative effect. It doesn't mean there hasn't been a negative effect. Because everybody thinks that, you know, they know what's they know what's true and best. You know, and the the classic example is something like the Google Doctor, right? Where somebody Googles their symptoms and they think they know how to diagnose themselves better than a trained professional doctor who has done, you know, ten years of Of work. It's when they this person comes off the street and tries to tell the doctor In their own opinion, it's a a little laughable, right? It's a little laughable. And yet, as many women would attest to, access to alternative information in the sphere has actually helped them to advocate for themselves in their own bodies with the medical professionals who are in charge of caring for them. And so there are certainly costs and benefits, but I think the benefits outweigh the costs. And what we really have to focus on is what can we do individually to elevate the discourse. And I think that really comes down to a kind of curious openness. And a willing to tolerate a w a willingness to tolerate views which are challenging to us and challenging to our own world views that we've established. So But anyway, I gotta go. So Thank you guys for listening and I'll talk to you next time.