Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How to Use the Benjamin Franklin Effect at Work
Transcript
- Lucas: So let me start with a story. In the 1730s, Benjamin Franklin was a state legislator in Pennsylvania, and there was a rival legislator who had publicly opposed him — gave a long speech against him, the whole thing. Luna: Sounds like a pretty direct political enemy. Lucas: Exactly. Franklin knew he needed this guy's support, but he also knew that trying to win him over with flattery or favors would look transparent and probably backfire. So he did something counterintuitive. He heard that this rival had a rare, valuable book in his library — a specific volume that Franklin wanted to borrow. Luna: So he asked to borrow it? That's the move? Lucas: Yep. The rival sent the book, Franklin returned it a week later with a polite thank-you note. And from that point on, the rival became one of his most reliable allies in the legislature. And Franklin wrote about this — he said, 'He that has once done you a kindness will be more ready to do you another than he whom you yourself have obliged.' Luna: So the psychology is that doing a favor for someone makes you like them more, not less. Because your brain has to justify why you did something nice for someone you supposedly disliked. Lucas: Right. It's cognitive dissonance. Your mind goes: 'I am a rational person. I just helped this person. Therefore, I must actually like them.' And that feeling is genuine — it rewires your attitude. Luna: So we're calling this the Benjamin Franklin Effect, I assume? And it's the opposite of the old advice that says you should do favors for people to make them like you. Lucas: Exactly. The conventional wisdom is 'give to get.' But Franklin's insight — and later research backs this up — is that getting someone to do a small, low-stakes favor for you can be more powerful. There's a 1969 study by Jecker and Landy where students who were asked by the researcher to return a favor ended up rating the researcher more favorably than students who received a favor. Luna: Wow. So the key is that the favor has to be genuine, not manipulative — and it has to be small enough that the person doesn't feel used. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the line we need to walk at work. So today, I want to talk about how to use the Benjamin Franklin Effect strategically in an office environment. When it works, when it backfires, and how it's different from the reciprocity stuff we covered in episode 94. Luna: Okay, let's start with an example. You have a colleague in a different department who seems skeptical of your team's project. You want their buy-in. What's a Franklin-style move? Lucas: You ask them for advice. Not about your project — about something they genuinely know. Maybe they're known for their data analysis skills. You could say, 'Hey, I'm putting together a presentation on Q3 trends, and I'm struggling with how to visualize the customer retention data. I know you're great with that. Could I look at a past deck you made for reference?' Luna: That's a small ask. They share a deck or give a tip. Now they've invested in your success. Their brain starts rationalizing why they helped you — and suddenly they're more open to your project. Lucas: Right. And notice: you didn't ask them to do your work. You asked for a small piece of their expertise. That's respectful. It signals that you value their opinion. And it's a low-cost way for them to feel good. Luna: What about a manager or a senior leader? Is it smart to ask them for a favor? Lucas: Yes, but you have to be careful. The default power dynamic is that you do favors for them, not the other way around. But if you ask for something that's easy for them — like 'Could you suggest one book that shaped your leadership style?' — that's a small mental favor. They answer in thirty seconds. Now they've invested in your development. And that can actually strengthen the relationship. Luna: I like that. It's almost like asking for mentorship in micro-doses. But let me push back — doesn't this risk looking incompetent if you keep asking for help? Lucas: Great point. That's the pitfall. The key is that the favor must be a favor, not a dependency. If you ask someone to fix your spreadsheet every week, you become a burden. But if you ask for a recommendation once, or for feedback on a specific idea, that's a one-time thing. You can even follow up later and say, 'Hey, that advice you gave me really helped — the client loved the approach.' That reinforces their positive feeling. Luna: So it's about the quality of the ask, not the quantity. One well-chosen favor can build a bridge. But if you overdo it, you're just the person who always needs something. Lucas: Right. And there's another version of this that works in negotiation or conflict. Say you and a coworker disagree on a strategy. Instead of trying to convince them, you could ask them to help you understand their perspective better. 'Can you walk me through your assumptions? I want to make sure I'm not missing something.' Luna: That's still asking for a favor — their time and attention. And it's disarming. They lower their defenses because you're not attacking them; you're asking to learn. Lucas: Exactly. And once they've explained their view, they've invested in you understanding it. That makes them more likely to listen to your counterpoints later. It's a subtle shift from adversarial to collaborative. Luna: You know, this episode is making me think about how I've actually experienced this from the other side. There's a junior analyst in my old team who used to ask me to look over her reports. At first I was like, 'Ugh, more work.' But after I helped her a few times, I actually started rooting for her. I wanted her to succeed because it would reflect well on my mentoring. Lucas: That's exactly the effect. You rationalized: 'I'm helping her, so she must be worth helping.' And you started to see her potential more clearly. That's the Benjamin Franklin Effect in action. Luna: But what about the flip side? If someone does a favor for you, does that always make them like you more? Or can it backfire? Lucas: It can backfire if the favor feels coerced or if the person resents doing it. Like, if you ask someone to cover your shift last minute and they say yes but they're clearly annoyed — they might actually like you less because they associate you with a negative experience. So the favor has to be something they can easily say yes to, and it should feel like a choice. Luna: So you want the person to feel good about helping. Which means you need to be thoughtful about timing and the size of the ask. Lucas: Exactly. And you also want to express genuine gratitude. A sincere thank-you reinforces that their help mattered. It's a small investment that pays dividends in goodwill. Luna: I want to bring up something that might feel unrelated, but actually I think it connects. You know, episodes like this one — where we dig into a counterintuitive idea that can genuinely change how you navigate work — that's the kind of thing that makes me glad this podcast exists. Lucas: Yeah, I feel the same way. And we're able to keep doing it because of listeners who find value in it and choose to support the show. If today's episode helped you think about a situation at work in a new way, that's the exact kind of moment where the smallest gesture makes a difference. Luna: Honestly, if today was worth a coffee to you, that's the link — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, no perks, just knowing that what we do here matters to people. Lucas: And it really does matter. That support keeps us ad-free and focused on the psychology and strategy that actually works. So thank you to anyone who's ever chipped in. Luna: Alright, back to the effect. So we've talked about asking individuals for favors. Can you apply this to a team or group? Lucas: You can, but it's trickier because groups have diffusion of responsibility. One approach is to ask the team as a whole for input on a problem — 'I'd love the team's perspective on this challenge' — and then individuals volunteer their help. That way, the people who step forward are already primed to feel invested. Luna: And then you follow up with specific thank-yous to those individuals. That reinforces the bond one-on-one, even within a team context. Lucas: Exactly. And there's a bigger strategic play here. If you're new to an organization, or you're trying to build influence across silos, the Franklin Effect can be a faster path than trying to prove your value first. Because proving your value requires people to notice you, which takes time. But asking for their help gets them to notice you in a way that makes them feel good about you. Luna: It's almost like a shortcut to rapport. But you have to be genuine — if people sense you're just using a tactic, it backfires hard. Lucas: Absolutely. The principle only works if the ask is authentic. You have to actually need or value their input. If you fake it, people pick up on that. So the skill is finding real things you can learn from others and then being willing to ask. Luna: I think the takeaway for today is: next time you're facing a skeptical colleague or a potential ally, instead of thinking about what you can do for them, think about what small thing they could do for you. A question, a piece of advice, a borrowed resource. Lucas: Exactly. And if you're already using reciprocity — doing favors for others — that's great. But the Franklin Effect is a different tool for a different situation. Use it when you need to turn a neutral or cool relationship warmer, and you want the other person to feel invested in you. Luna: Alright, I'm going to try this. I have a colleague who's been distant since a project disagreement. I think I'll ask him to recommend a book on a topic he's passionate about. Lucas: Let me know how it goes. I bet you'll see a shift. And if not, you've at least got a book recommendation.