Latest / Tech IPO Conversations with Fexingo: Public Software Companies and Capital Markets / How Post-IPO Companies Are Hedging with Derivatives
Transcript
- Lucas: So it's been a rough week for tech stocks — we're sitting here on June 26th, and over the past five days Apple is down 7.7 percent, Microsoft down 7 percent, Amazon down 7.1 percent, and Palantir — wow — down 16.5 percent. When a stock drops that fast, the company itself starts to feel the pain. Luna: Because employees hold equity, the balance sheet might hold stock — it's not just investors who lose. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why a growing number of post ipo companies are using derivatives — specifically options and swaps — to hedge their own stock exposure. The old model was 'we're a growth company, we don't hedge, we ride the volatility.' But the last couple of years have changed that calculus. Luna: You know, this conversation — understanding how these tools work — is exactly the kind of practical knowledge that keeps this show interesting for people who are building or running companies. If you find these deep dives useful, we'd love your support to keep the show ad-free. You can help at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Lucas: And it genuinely helps us keep going without sponsors. So back to hedging — let's look at a specific structure that's become popular: the zero-cost collar. Luna: A collar — that's selling a call and using the premium to buy a put, right? Lucas: Right. So say a company just IPO'd six months ago. They have a large share position — maybe from a secondary offering or from the IPO itself — and they're worried about a downturn. They can sell a call option, say at 20 percent above the current price, and use that premium to buy a put option at 10 percent below. Net cost: zero. Luna: So they cap the upside but lock in a floor. In this market, that floor looks pretty appealing. Lucas: Exactly. And we've seen this in practice. Take Airbnb — ABNB is down only 0.4 percent this week, which is remarkable given the broader selloff. That could be partly because they've been active in the options market. They filed a disclosure last quarter about entering into capped call transactions. Luna: Capped calls are a bit different — that's more about managing convertible debt dilution. But the principle is the same: they're using derivatives to smooth out risk. Lucas: Right. And then you have companies like Palantir, which has been very open about using equity swaps. They did a big swap deal with a bank a couple of years ago to hedge their employee stock purchase plan. Basically, instead of issuing new shares, they pay the bank the return on the stock, and the bank delivers shares to employees. It's a synthetic share position. Luna: So the bank takes the actual equity risk, and Palantir pays a fee. That keeps their share count more stable. Lucas: And it avoids the dilution that would come from issuing new shares. The downside is complexity — and disclosure. The SEC has been paying close attention to how companies report these positions. If you're using a big options strategy, you have to tell investors, and that can spook them. Luna: I remember when Tesla first disclosed a collar strategy back in 2021 — the stock dropped because people thought Elon was preparing for a crash. But he was just hedging compensation. Lucas: Exactly. The market can misinterpret. And that's the bind: if you hedge and disclose, you might signal fear. If you don't hedge, you're exposed. So companies are getting creative with how they structure these trades. Luna: One innovation I've seen is the 'equity forward' — a company agrees to sell shares in the future at a fixed price, locking in a minimum. It's like a collar but without the option premium. Lucas: And those are popular with companies that have a large tax exposure — they can defer the tax hit. But the accounting is tricky. Under US GAAP, these derivatives have to be marked to market, which can create earnings volatility. Luna: So you're hedging stock price volatility but introducing earnings volatility. That's the trade-off. Lucas: Precisely. And that's why you see companies like, say, Coinbase, which is down 12.7 percent this week, probably wishing they had a stronger hedging program. But they're in crypto — they're used to volatility. Luna: Though crypto companies have started hedging too. I think the broader trend is clear: post ipo companies are becoming more sophisticated about risk management. Lucas: And it's not just the big names. We're seeing this with smaller IPOs too. The 2024 and 2025 IPO classes — a lot of them are putting hedging programs in place before they even list. It's part of the pre ipo prep now. Luna: What's the simplest structure a newly public company should consider? Lucas: Probably a plain-vanilla put option on a portion of their stock — say 10 to 20 percent of the float. It costs money, but it's straightforward. The board can understand it, and the auditors can audit it. Collars and swaps are more efficient but require a lot of explanation. Luna: And the cost of puts right now — with the VIX elevated — is high. Implied volatility is expensive. Lucas: That's the rub. Timing matters. If you buy puts after a selloff, volatility is high and puts are expensive. The time to hedge is when volatility is low. But that's when you feel invincible. Luna: Classic risk management problem — you buy insurance when you don't need it. Lucas: So the companies that are doing this well are the ones that have a systematic program. They layer in hedges gradually, month by month, using a dollar cost average approach. That way they avoid timing the market. Luna: And they likely use a bank or a derivatives advisory firm to run it. Internal teams usually don't have the expertise. Lucas: Right. I think we'll see more of these programs, especially if the macro environment stays choppy. The Fed is still on hold, inflation is sticky, and the election is coming. Volatility isn't going away. Luna: So for investors, the takeaway is: if a company you own announces a hedging program, don't automatically panic. It might be a sign of prudent management, not a bearish signal. Lucas: And for companies, the lesson is: have a plan before you need it. The worst time to design a hedging strategy is when the stock is falling 16 percent in a week. Luna: Well said. That's all for this episode of Tech IPO Conversations. We'll be back next week with another angle. Lucas: Thanks for listening.