Latest / Situational Awareness Tactics / THE HISTORY OF FIRE AND HOW IT INFLUENCED HOW WE EAT AS HUMANS
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to Situational Awareness Tactics Podcast. This podcast provides the crucial art of understanding
- 0:09current elements in an environment to increase your safety and survival. Here's your host,
- 0:15forensic psychologist and consultant, doctor Carlos. Welcome back everybody. Today we
- 0:32have a great guest, doctor Richard Rangham w r A n g h A
- 0:36M. He is the Ruth Moore Professor of Biological Anthropology at Harvard University and
- 0:41Curator of Probamate Behavioral Biology at the Pea Buddy Museum. You're probably asking,
- 0:45well, what are you going to talk about? We're gonna talk about catching
- 0:48fire, how cooking made us human. That's right, it's a fascinating read.
- 0:52We're also going to read his newest book called The Goodness Paradox. Actually,
- 0:56we're gonna talk about it, the strange relationship between virtue and violence and
- 0:59human evolution. So I can't wait to start talking about this. I want
- 1:03to see what is this all? This deal about fire? The last time
- 1:06I remember talking about fire, or at least things that I pop in my
- 1:10head was the Jungle Book movie. If you remember that, folks, you
- 1:12probably remember the chimpanzee who says I want the power of Man's red flower.
- 1:17He might have been onto something. We're gonna find out about that in a
- 1:19minute before we get started. You know what to do, share or subscribe
- 1:23and hit that like but you know, we like it. Let's not wasting
- 1:25more time walking to the show, Professor Rangam, Welcome, sir, well,
- 1:27thank you so much. It nice to be here. Thank you very
- 1:30much for doing this. It's a fascinating book. I've been kind of journeying
- 1:34myself through a lot of the books of the Carnivore Code and the Carnivore Diet,
- 1:40and they reference you in it, and then when I started looking at
- 1:42your book, I thought, well, this is a very intriguing topic.
- 1:46I guess my first question is what motivated you to write this. I was
- 1:51appointed to lecture pumptly about human evolution, and thus was kind of awkward for
- 1:59me because I didn't know much about it. And the reason I didn't know
- 2:00much about it was that I was hired actually on the basis of the fact
- 2:06that I studied chimpanzees. So I've lived for for many years with chimpanzees in
- 2:13Uganda, living in a in a forest and national park. Gold Kibali,
- 2:19and my job was mostly thinking about how it is that chimpanzees run their lives
- 2:24and have their societies and their loves and dangers and all that sort of thing.
- 2:30And then I'm asked to start thinking about human evolution. And you know,
- 2:36obviously we're looking at up one of our closest relatives, chimpanzees. You
- 2:38know, they're one of our two equally close relatives with bonobos, and so
- 2:45you've got to start thinking about similarities and differences. And I'm I'm sitting in
- 2:50my sitting room one evening thinking about the next lecture, which is of the
- 2:55origin of the genus Homo about two million years ago, and I'm I'm lying
- 3:01in front of the fire, and I'm thinking, you know, there was
- 3:07a wood fire. It was sparkling wood fire with flames and that sort of
- 3:10thing, you know, And you know, I've often been in the bush
- 3:13with camp fires, and so it took me back into the bush and I
- 3:17was thinking, now, how long ago is it that you have to go
- 3:21back in human evolution before we get to the point where our ancestors would not
- 3:28have lain bound down by the fire. And as I started thinking about this,
- 3:32it started thinking about the differences between us and chimpanzees. You know,
- 3:38I've eaten everything that chimpanzeez eat, right, you know, all the different
- 3:40kinds of fruits and leaves and stems and that sort of thing that they eat.
- 3:46You know, I try, and you know I even tried, tried
- 3:49sort of you know, could I survive or what chimp sea? You know,
- 3:52the answer is absolutely not, you know, I mean it's it's okay,
- 3:55you know, you can eat most of it, but you're not going
- 3:58to fill your stomach with it. And as I was thinking all these thoughts,
- 4:02I thought, you know, there's no way that that any of our
- 4:08ancestors who looked like us, who you know, had the relative his small
- 4:13bellies, unlike you know, a gorilla or a chimpanzee. It's got a
- 4:15great swollen belly to accommodate all that raw food. And there's and there's no
- 4:21way that an ancestor of ours who was committed to sleeping on the ground because
- 4:27they were not good enough at climbing to be able to go up into the
- 4:30trees. I could never imagine that they would feel comfortable just sleeping on the
- 4:33ground in an area where there were lions and leopards and hyenas and elephants and
- 4:42anything that could disturb them in the middle of the night. You know,
- 4:45I've often camped out. I would never camp out without a fire, because
- 4:49you'd be absolutely terrified. You just just wouldn't know what was happening. And
- 4:55so these two thoughts brought me to the idea that, um, that you
- 5:00have to go back beyond the first homo, the first human called Homo erectus,
- 5:08about two million years ago, before you would get to any of our
- 5:12ancestors that would dare sleep without fire on the ground, and that could eat
- 5:18um food like a chimpanzee rather than you know, us who cook our food.
- 5:26And I went into the lab the next day and said to my students
- 5:30and colleagues, you know, I don't get it. It's so obvious that
- 5:33cooking must have made us, you know, human and the control of the
- 5:39fire. Do people talk about this? And the answer was no, no
- 5:43one's ever already sort of thought about that. And so I then spent you
- 5:46know, ten or fifteen years reviewing the data and catching up with all the
- 5:51sort of physiological information so on. And that's what led to that that book,
- 5:57Catching Fire fascinating story. It is amazing how sometimes those things just happen
- 6:01like just drops in front of us. Nobody sees it for so long.
- 6:04That's amazing. Well, you see, I mean they fascinating thing is that
- 6:09almost everything that we do cook we can eat raw. And I think for
- 6:15that reason. And then you know, also people are very keen on saying
- 6:18you know, humans were animals and animals eat their food raw, so you
- 6:24know, and we can eat our food raw. So cooking. The idea
- 6:29was that cooking is just something that gives you nice flavors and makes life a
- 6:33little bit easier and makes life a bit, food a bit safer because it
- 6:38doesn't have so many toxins that you know, you can destroy the bacteria,
- 6:42you can destroy the poisons by cooking it. And nobody had really said,
- 6:46but you know, can we actually live on raw food at all? Or
- 6:51is cooking ready vital? It? Does cooking make a difference to us?
- 6:56And and in fact, you know, if you ever remember that, the
- 7:00French social anthropologist Claude Levy Strouss, who's quite famous, he wrote a book
- 7:05called the Raw and the Cooked, And I thought, well, okay,
- 7:09raw and the cook let's go find out what he says, Well, you
- 7:12know what he says. He says, every culture distinguishes between humans who cook
- 7:19and animals who eat their food raw. And he said, but that doesn't
- 7:25matter from the point of view of physiology. He said, this is just
- 7:29a symbolic way of humans telling us that we are different from the rest of
- 7:33nature. And when you said this, I mean, you know, you
- 7:39could sort of say, well, that was a funny old frenchman, you
- 7:41know, how absurd, But nobody disagreed with him. This was the nineteen
- 7:46sixties. Nobody said no, actually that's wrong. You know, humans really
- 7:50need cooked food. And amazingly, it was not until my colleagues and I
- 7:57started publishing and I wrote that book that people apreciated that actually, you know,
- 8:01there is this fundamental physiological difference between humans and the rest of life,
- 8:05which is that we are adapted to eating our food cooked, meaning we cannot
- 8:11survive in the wild on raw food. We've changed, we've evolved in different
- 8:16ways for other animals. And then once he's not thinking that, well,
- 8:18my goodness, you know, then that pinpoints when the control of fire happened,
- 8:22and what a huge thing it did to just radically change the whole course
- 8:28of our revolutionary history. I can't remember where I read it. They were
- 8:33talking about the different physiologies in the size of the small intestine versus the size
- 8:37of the coal and in certain animals. Did you see that in chimpanzees?
- 8:41And do you survise that as the same thing as humanists started developing and cooking
- 8:46their food, that physiologically they changed in their intestine. Yeah, no,
- 8:50I mean you may have read it in Catching Fire, you know, because
- 8:54this is one of those sort of fascinating things that it turns out that,
- 9:00you know, obviously, bigger animals have got bigger guts because they're bigger.
- 9:03But if you look at the size of the gut as a proportion of your
- 9:07body size, then we have the smallest gut of any primate, you know,
- 9:15any any of the whatever it is sixties species of primates that have been
- 9:18looked at carefully and and the and we know where the difference is. It's
- 9:22not in the small intestine, you know. The so called small intestine is
- 9:26that the long, digesting, long bit of intestine that links your stomach to
- 9:33your colon to your large bowel, and that is the same size in us
- 9:37as it is in other animals, and that's related to the fact that what
- 9:41it's doing is absorbing the food. It's it's absorbing the digestive particles of food,
- 9:46and we need to absorb our food just as as every other animal does.
- 9:50The big difference is in the large bowl the colon, and there ours
- 9:58is something like tooth birds of the size or less that you would expect if
- 10:03we were a great ape. And what's going on here, Well, you
- 10:07know, partly what the large bowl does is to extract water from your food
- 10:11and that sort of thing. But the important thing from this perspective is it
- 10:16is the place where you have all of those gut flora, all of the
- 10:22bacteria that are responsible for fermenting, and the food that has gone through your
- 10:30small intestine without being fully digested. And then so what it does, it's
- 10:35the kind of you know, the second digestive process. It's getting the maximum
- 10:39out of the rest of the rather difficult to digest food. And the reason
- 10:46that it is small in us they colon is because we don't need to do
- 10:52a lot of that stuff because the fact that we eat our food cooked means
- 10:56that it very little of it goes through the small intestine. Without being already
- 11:01digested, whereas if you're a chimpanzee or an orangutan, then a lot of
- 11:05it gets gets through without being digested because it's it's raw. And we now
- 11:11have you know, all sorts of good, excellent experiments that show what the
- 11:16difference is. So, for instance, there are experiments with people who have
- 11:24got the misfortune of having lost part of their gut so that they have a
- 11:28stoma where the gut right is brought to the surface of the abdomen, and
- 11:33then you can actually, you know, what a stoma patient has to do
- 11:37is to empty the gut from a gut bag where the contents of your intestine
- 11:43are coming out every few hours or a day, and you can give that
- 11:46to the researcher, and the researcher can say, okay, let's find out
- 11:52how well digested starch grains are when they're cooked versus raw. And if they're
- 11:58cooked, then about one hundred percent of them, you know, percent of
- 12:03them are fully digested by the time they end up going through the small intestine.
- 12:09If it's raw fifty I mean, this is a massive difference. Yeah,
- 12:15And so it's not surprising that if you look at people who for one
- 12:20reason or another, commit themselves to eating their all their food raw. Then
- 12:24they are very often starving. Yeah, they are on the edge of coloring
- 12:31satisfaction. They're just not getting enough calories to be able to sustain them properly.
- 12:37And that, you know, that's that's people who are living in an
- 12:45incredibly luxurious world from the point of view of what we ordinarily think of of
- 12:50you know, nature, because they're reading food that has been domesticated compared to
- 12:56its wild ancestors. So you know, you're not so I mean gnawing every
- 13:00little bit of available pulp off a tiny little apple. Youstad munching into an
- 13:05apple with it's just the whole thing is digestible. Um. And they're eating
- 13:13food that is available all year because it's coming from around the world. You
- 13:18know, in winter, you don't have to just survive on on rotten cabbages.
- 13:22You've got things coming in from you know, the tropics, um and
- 13:28uh. And they're able to eat things that have been processed without cooking like
- 13:31oil and even under all these you know, great conditions. Oh, by
- 13:37the way, they're also using electrical blenders very often to make smoothies. Now
- 13:45you're making smoothies, you know, with electrical blenders of domesticated food available all
- 13:50year, adding a nice concentration of oils, and what happens you lose weight
- 13:58and you are so desp really hungry all the time that you find it very
- 14:05difficult to continue surviving on raw food. And I take my hat off to
- 14:09people who do you know, I mean they raw foodists have very often very
- 14:13sort of you know, pure philosophical reasons for being royal foodists, and sometimes
- 14:18it's because of some kind of health problem. And I'm a huge admirer of
- 14:24them because it's very, very difficult. So I know, I don't mean
- 14:30to make fun of them. I just think it's it's a wonderful sort of
- 14:33illustration of the real physiology of humans, which is what different from every other
- 14:41animal on earth. That's fascinating. I know. The first person that comes
- 14:45to mining to me, it's not pejorative in any way, folks, but
- 14:48I think about the liver King, and he's made a living out of this
- 14:52now where he promotes a lot of stuff eating it raw. He does cook
- 14:54other things too, but you know, he recommends highly eating raw liver for
- 14:58an stance, and I guess that was fascinating. I got to reading more
- 15:03about it just because of my curiosity and listening to him and reading some of
- 15:07the research. I oddly enough, I never thought liver, gizzards, chicken
- 15:13hearts or hearts and all this stuff and actually is really good for you.
- 15:15Got a lot of nutrients there, and it's kind of surprising. But I
- 15:18guess my question to you, as one of the comments that us made was
- 15:22we've a lot of these individuals used to eat. The individuals being the original
- 15:26humans that you're referring to with fire and all that we're nose to tail type
- 15:30of eaters. They would eat a lot of different components of the body compared
- 15:35to now where we only tend to eat the good parts, the rib,
- 15:37eyes and things of that nature, the muscular parts, the high fatty content
- 15:43parts. Did you see that as well in your research? Well, you
- 15:50know, I'm I'm interested in in the whole diet, and I haven't really
- 15:56been focused on people who choose to eat some things or other things cooked,
- 16:00you know, because to me, that's a cooked diet with a little bit
- 16:03of extra of the raw. But if you think about the meats that people
- 16:07eat, the animal products that's put it that way, then it is no
- 16:14surprise from a digestive point of view that the items that are eaten raw are
- 16:19the ones that, in sort of ordinary palance are soft, because there is
- 16:26a huge difference in the digestibility of something like a raw muscle and a raw
- 16:33liver. You know, even chimps with the big teeth and strong jaws compared
- 16:41to us, find it difficult eating meat. They love it. Yeah,
- 16:48they catch monkeys and eat them whenever they can. And when they do so,
- 16:56then the first parts they eat, you know, just like just like
- 17:02you know the people you're citing, are the soft bits. You know,
- 17:06they'll they'll tear out the liver, they'll eat the heart. Sometimes there are
- 17:11places where they know how about cracking the skull and eating the brain. Then
- 17:17the next bits they'll eat will be the hands and feet. So the hands
- 17:22and feet to tend to have a quality of fat in them that is more
- 17:29oily than really solid fat, so it's a lower melting point and and that
- 17:37is again easier to digest. But then they're they're into the meat, and
- 17:42that takes a long time, and in fact, when they're chewing the meat,
- 17:47the estimates that then I published have been that the rate of calorie gain
- 17:55when they're eating just raw muscle is about the same as when they're eating fruit.
- 18:00So even though it's incredibly dense and they can choose great gobules of it,
- 18:07and the density of calories per gram of food is much higher in meat
- 18:14than it is in fruit. Nevertheless, the fact that they're eating meat so
- 18:18slowly compared to the fruit means that it it bounces out to be about the
- 18:22same thing. So I think when you know, when I hear about somebody
- 18:27who is eating raw liver or advocating eating raw liver, then that takes me
- 18:33back to the forest and seeing chimps, you know, brutally tear out the
- 18:40liver of a of an innocent monkey. Um, they're pretty horrendous, these
- 18:45predation scenes and eating that. And by the way, when when they do
- 18:51eat the muscle, when they when they're eating the meat, then the way
- 18:56that they eat it, it's almost invariably is to get some leaves of whatever
- 19:02neighboring tree they're you know, they're in, or you can grab some mature
- 19:07leaves, and they eat those leaves with the meat. They chew it up
- 19:11together. And I'm pretty sure although we haven't got really convincing evidence, but
- 19:18they choose any old leaf. So it's not the chemical composition. But all
- 19:22of these leaves, the thing they share in common is not the chemistry,
- 19:26but it's the physics. They're all tough leaves that tend to be sort of
- 19:34broken up and become involved with the meat. And I think it's easier to
- 19:41chew this rather slippery stuff of raw meat if you've got something something gives it
- 19:48a bit of purchase. And in fact, you know, I even did
- 19:51a little sort of informal experiment with half a dozen friends in a in a
- 19:55party where we gave some of them raw goat meat and um to chew it
- 20:03up a minute and inspit it out, and then others at the royal goat
- 20:07meat with an avocado leaf, and and it suddenly it made a big difference
- 20:11to the rate of which they the meat particle got reduced. So it's kind
- 20:17of like a wrap Bridgie's chimpanzees. Yeah, a little tortilla rapp burrito T
- 20:22like that. That's right. Yeah, how unusual. I guess I don't
- 20:26want to straight too far as I'll ask this cool one quick question that we'll
- 20:29go back there's other parts points of the book that are really interesting too.
- 20:32When you talk about pair bonding and marriage and things of that nature. How
- 20:34that derived from fires. I've never even thought about um. But before I
- 20:38get to that, do they have different enzymes? They be in the chimpanzees
- 20:41and we do like in our mouth and our saliva, you know, there's
- 20:44light pace and amlas and breaks down different parts. Do they have the same
- 20:47thing as well? Yeah, so as some as we know, they have
- 20:49the same UM. But actually it's it's a relatively uninvestigated area. UM.
- 20:56The the um the enzymes that have been investigated differ. Sorry, they are
- 21:03same in form. They differ in the number of genes we have that are
- 21:11producing these things and therefore the rate at which you can produce them. And
- 21:18so one the example that's been best understood there is that amlaise, which is
- 21:26involved in the breakdown of starch that occurs at higher we have duplication of genes
- 21:34for that in humans and a higher ability to produce amalaise. And that's associated
- 21:40with the fact that we have become very committed to eating starches, and that
- 21:45you know, when exactly that happened is is not quite clear. It seems
- 21:53quite likely that throughout human evolution in the last two million years, there's been
- 22:00in a really important use of underground plants, your roots and tubers and that
- 22:06sort of thing, which are full of starch, and that may have been
- 22:11important. Then when you get to agriculture and there's an increasing focus on grains
- 22:18like rice, again a tremendous amount of starch being eaten. So between those,
- 22:29yeah, freezing