Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Industrial-Organizational Psychology: What Organizational Behavior Studies & Why It Matters
Transcript
- 0:00If you want to build the perfect machine, the
- 0:03blueprint is usually pretty straightforward.
- 0:05You just need the right parts. Yeah, exactly.
- 0:07You put a gear here, a piston over there, you
- 0:09calibrate the timing, and it just runs. It runs
- 0:12exactly as predicted. It's a completely rational,
- 0:15closed system. Right. I mean, it follows the
- 0:17laws of physics. There's really no ambiguity
- 0:19to it. But the moment you take that exact same
- 0:21mechanical blueprint and try to, you know, apply
- 0:24it to a business, everything just completely
- 0:26breaks. Oh, it absolutely shatters. Because you're
- 0:28taking hundreds of incredibly complex, totally
- 0:31irrational humans, stuffing them into a building
- 0:34and asking them to generate profit together.
- 0:36And suddenly that predictable machine just explodes.
- 0:39It is, uh, it's the absolute definition of chaos.
- 0:43Welcome to the psychology undergrad. And that
- 0:47chaos is exactly what we are nerding out over
- 0:49today. As two undergrad psychology students,
- 0:52we are taking a deep dive into the modern workplace
- 0:55through the lens of human psychology. Yeah, today
- 0:58we are focusing on the foundational concepts
- 1:00of organizational behavior. Our mission for this
- 1:03deep dive is to explore how individuals, groups,
- 1:06and overarching organizations all function together.
- 1:10We're going to look at the psychological friction
- 1:11that happens when these layers interact and how
- 1:15researchers actually measure these dynamics without
- 1:17being fooled by our own human biases. Which is
- 1:20super hard to do, by the way. Seriously hard.
- 1:22And then we'll apply those insights to the massive
- 1:24ethical and technological trends that are basically
- 1:27disrupting the entire workplace right now. And
- 1:30honestly, whether you're a student right now
- 1:32or just an employee trying to survive the daily
- 1:34grind, or maybe you're a future CEO, understanding
- 1:37these psychological levers is going to help you
- 1:40navigate your own career. Definitely. You need
- 1:42to know how to avoid burnout and spot a toxic
- 1:45dynamics before they just drag you down. So let's
- 1:48establish our baseline here. What happens when
- 1:51we view the workplace not just as this, you know,
- 1:54economic engine, but as an actual psychological
- 1:57ecosystem? Well, that right there is the core
- 2:00of organizational behavior, or OB. It is the
- 2:04systematic study of how individuals and groups
- 2:06act within the organizations where they work.
- 2:09Okay, so how do they actually study that? To
- 2:11make sense of it, the field uses three different
- 2:13levels of analysis. You've got the individual,
- 2:16the group, and the organization. You really can't
- 2:18understand workplace behavior without looking
- 2:20at how those three levels constantly interact.
- 2:23I actually like to picture this framework as
- 2:26kind of like a set of nested Russian dolls. We
- 2:29can call it the IGO model. for individual group
- 2:32organization. Oh, I like that idea. So the individual
- 2:35is that tiny core doll right in the center. Then
- 2:37the group or the team is the next doll wrapped
- 2:40around it. And the organization is the big outermost
- 2:43shell. Right. And the thing is, you cannot fix
- 2:46a crack in the outermost doll if the core individual
- 2:49doll inside is fundamentally shattered. You have
- 2:52to analyze all three layers to see the full picture.
- 2:54And we actually see the power of that IGO dynamic
- 2:57when really entrenched systems get completely
- 3:01disrupted. Like, our reading brings up this fascinating
- 3:03case study about flat world knowledge or FWK.
- 3:07Oh, right, the textbook guys. Exactly. So these
- 3:10two textbook publishing veterans, Jeff Sholstad
- 3:12and Eric Frank, they looked at the traditional
- 3:15college textbook market and realized that the
- 3:17psychological contract between the industry and
- 3:20the student was just completely broken. Yeah,
- 3:22because students were paying what, like an average
- 3:24of $1 ,000 a year just for their first year textbooks.
- 3:27Which is insane. It really is. And from an organizational
- 3:30behavior perspective, that pricing model created
- 3:33massive psychological resentment. The traditional
- 3:36publishers were just extracting premium prices.
- 3:38And the students, you know, the individuals at
- 3:41the core of our Russian dolls, they felt entirely
- 3:44alienated. Right. They were frantically searching
- 3:46for pirated copies or Cooper substitutes just
- 3:49to survive the semester. So Shelstad and Frank
- 3:51recognized that the outermost doll the organization
- 3:54needed to completely change to serve the individual.
- 3:57Yeah, so they initially offered digital textbooks
- 4:00for free and then eventually shifted to this
- 4:02free -to -fair model where the entry point for
- 4:04a student was just like $19 .95. Wow. Yeah, and
- 4:08by 2012, they had secured $30 million in funding
- 4:12and reached over 600 ,000 students. They completely
- 4:17rewired the organizational structure to remove
- 4:20that friction and resentment at the individual
- 4:22level. Because the structural rules of an organization
- 4:25completely dictate the psychological reality
- 4:28of the people inside it. I mean, Whole Foods
- 4:30provides another brilliant example of this. Oh
- 4:31yeah, their compensation policy. Right. They
- 4:33utilize an open compensation policy, meaning
- 4:36literally everyone's salary is visible. But the
- 4:39real mechanism at play there is their salary
- 4:42cap. The maximum cash compensation paid to anyone
- 4:45even the CEO, is capped at 19 times the company
- 4:49-wide average salary. Which is such a stark architectural
- 4:52choice, especially when you compare it to the
- 4:54broader corporate landscape. Like if the average
- 4:56worker makes $30 ,000, the Whole Foods CEO maxes
- 4:59out at $570 ,000. And our texts contrast that
- 5:02with figures like Larry Ellison at Oracle making
- 5:05$192 .9 million. That is just great. Or Steve
- 5:10Jobs at Apple with 14 .6 million. So Whole Foods
- 5:14is using this cap to architect a very specific
- 5:17psychological culture. You can look at it almost
- 5:19through the lens of moral equity or like the
- 5:23religious concept of tithing. Oh, that's an interesting
- 5:25way to frame it. Yeah, it's an organizational
- 5:27rule designed to mitigate resentment and basically
- 5:30prevent the perception of extreme greed. By capping
- 5:34that ratio, the organization treats excessive
- 5:37pay gaps as a cultural toxin. It maintains a
- 5:40sense of moral fairness within their corporate,
- 5:43you know, congregation. I mean, they're actively
- 5:45managing the psychological distance between the
- 5:48inter -level employee and the executive. When
- 5:50that gap becomes too wide, it just triggers alienation.
- 5:53Okay. But I actually have to push back here for
- 5:55a second, specifically because the reading brings
- 5:57up Steve Jobs. Oh, here we go. No, seriously.
- 6:00There's a quote from Jobs where he says, It's
- 6:03about the people you have. But isn't that a massive
- 6:05paradox? Well, historically, Apple under jobs
- 6:10used incredibly aggressive, sometimes straight
- 6:13up brutal tactics to drive cutthroat innovation.
- 6:16He's notoriously tough on individuals. So is
- 6:20it actually possible for a company to have a
- 6:22brilliant, highly successful organizational culture?
- 6:26Terrible individual interactions. I mean, yeah,
- 6:29it is entirely possible But you have to understand
- 6:31the psychological trade -offs happening there
- 6:34Apple under jobs had an organizational culture
- 6:36that rewarded extreme excellence, right and that
- 6:39acted as a magnet for top -tier talent Okay,
- 6:41but the individual level of analysis like The
- 6:44daily psychological toll, the stress, the burnout
- 6:46was notoriously high. You can build a thriving
- 6:49economic machine with a punishing individual
- 6:51environment. But as a student of OB, the question
- 6:53isn't just, does it make money? Right. The question
- 6:56is, is that psychological cost sustainable? And
- 6:58what happens to the culture when that visionary
- 7:00leader finally leaves? That makes a lot of sense.
- 7:03So if people are an organization's greatest asset,
- 7:06but they are this complex and contradictory,
- 7:09how do we actually figure out what makes them
- 7:11tick? Because here's the problem with trying
- 7:13to measure the eye geodynamic picky. Human beings
- 7:17are terrible at objectively evaluating themselves.
- 7:21We really are. Our basic human intuition is just
- 7:23often completely wrong. Yeah, we have to actively
- 7:26unlearn our reliance on... common sense. And
- 7:30I think the first step in doing that is understanding
- 7:32the actual mechanics of how we process information.
- 7:36The tax breaks down these VAK learning styles.
- 7:38VAK, right. Visual, auditory, kinesthetic. Exactly.
- 7:41Visual learners process things through pictures
- 7:43and diagrams. Auditory learners absorb information
- 7:46best through lectures and discussion. And then
- 7:48kinesthetic learners require tactile engagement.
- 7:50They need to be moving, doing, learning by trial
- 7:53and error. And knowing this is so crucial because
- 7:55misaligned communication breeds organization
- 7:58conflict. Like if a highly visual manager keeps
- 8:01giving rapid -fire auditory instructions to a
- 8:04kinesthetic employee. Oh that's a disaster. Right.
- 8:06Both of them are gonna end up so frustrated and
- 8:09neither will understand why. But the underlying
- 8:12psychological mechanism of how we learn is just
- 8:15fascinating. Take flashcards for example. The
- 8:18text actually notes that flashcards are universal
- 8:20effective because they trigger all three styles
- 8:23simultaneously. Really? All three? Yeah. Auditory
- 8:26learners benefit from speaking the answers out
- 8:28loud. Visual learners process the written words
- 8:32and the spatial arrangement on the card itself.
- 8:34And then kinesthetic learners cement the knowledge
- 8:37through the actual physical act of writing, flipping,
- 8:40and sorting the deck. That is super clever. But,
- 8:43okay, if our own brains are this idiosyncratic,
- 8:46how do researchers actually study organizational
- 8:48behavior without being manipulated by the subjects?
- 8:51Because, I mean, people lie on surveys. They
- 8:53tell researchers what they think the boss wants
- 8:56them to hear. Totally. And that is the central
- 8:58friction of OB research. You have to design methods
- 9:00that completely bypass human bias. Surveys are
- 9:03useful for, like, time sampling, you know, pinging
- 9:06an employee's phone at random intervals to get
- 9:08a dynamic map of their mood throughout the day.
- 9:10Right. But they still rely on self -reporting.
- 9:13Exactly. So to bypass that, researchers use field
- 9:15studies. They actually go into a real workplace
- 9:18and introduce an experimental variable to one
- 9:21group while keeping a control group unchanged.
- 9:24That way they're measuring actual behavior, not
- 9:26just opinions. But even a field study has its
- 9:29flaws, right? I mean, you run into the Hawthorne
- 9:32effect, where people literally change their behavior
- 9:34simply because they know they're being observed.
- 9:37Yeah, which is super annoying for researchers.
- 9:39So then they turn to lab studies to gain absolute
- 9:42control over the variables. They might simulate
- 9:44a hiring process in a highly controlled room
- 9:47to see exactly how specific pressures affect
- 9:49decision -making. Right, but the trade -off there
- 9:52is a severe drop in realism. You can simulate
- 9:55a deadline in a lab, sure, but you cannot ethically
- 9:58simulate the genuine psychological dread of a
- 10:01looming corporate layoff. A lab study isolates
- 10:04the mechanism, but it completely strips away
- 10:06the messy office politics that define real behavior.
- 10:09Which is why researchers also use case studies.
- 10:12These are deep, immersive looks into a single
- 10:15company's culture. But again, a case study is
- 10:19just one data point. It's incredibly hard to
- 10:21generalize from that. So what's the solution?
- 10:24To find the overarching truth, you really need
- 10:26meta -analysis. This is where researchers aggregate
- 10:30the data from multiple distinct studies to find
- 10:32the undeniable three line. Like the text highlights
- 10:36Judge and his colleagues. They ran a meta -analysis
- 10:39of 300 different studies to finally prove definitively
- 10:44that there is a moderately strong relationship
- 10:46between job satisfaction and job performance.
- 10:49Wow, 300 studies. But I guess all of these methods
- 10:52are completely useless if you don't understand
- 10:54the psychological distinction between reliability
- 10:56and validity. Oh yeah. That is one of the most
- 10:59crucial concepts in the text. And I think the
- 11:01best way to internalize the difference between
- 11:02reliability and validity is this broken clock
- 11:06mnemonic. Imagine a broken analog clock whose
- 11:09hands are stuck at exactly two o 'clock. That
- 11:11clock is perfectly reliable. Every single time
- 11:14you look at it, it gives you the exact same output.
- 11:17But it is only valid, meaning it actually reflects
- 11:20the objective truth of the world twice a day.
- 11:23That makes total sense. The text actually uses
- 11:26the analogy of a trucking scale. If a scale gives
- 11:29you the exact same weight for a truck three times
- 11:31in a row, the scale is highly reliable. Right.
- 11:34But if that scale is calibrated to read in kilograms
- 11:37and your organization charges its customers by
- 11:40the pound, well, your perfectly reliable measurement
- 11:42isn't entirely invalid for your business purpose.
- 11:44You are measuring the wrong reality. And we measure
- 11:47the wrong reality all the time because we just
- 11:49rely on our intuition. We assume that because
- 11:52we are human, we naturally understand human behavior.
- 11:55The reading includes a quiz that completely shatters
- 11:58that illusion. Oh, the true or false quiz. Yeah.
- 12:01For example, true or false. Brainstorming in
- 12:03a group is more effective than brainstorming
- 12:05alone. I mean, common sense screams that this
- 12:07is true. Synergy, right? Many brains are better
- 12:09than one. Right. But the psychological fact is
- 12:12that it's false. Brainstorming alone is demonstrably
- 12:15more effective. And when you look at the mechanism
- 12:18behind that, it makes perfect sense. But wait,
- 12:21wait. I have to push back on this. OK, shoot.
- 12:24If brainstorming alone is objectively better,
- 12:28doesn't that render the group layer of our Russian
- 12:31dolls completely useless? Like, are all these
- 12:35mandatory corporate group meetings just an illusion
- 12:38of productivity? Well, um, they often are an
- 12:41illusion. Yeah, but not because the group itself
- 12:43is useless It's because organizations constantly
- 12:46conflate idea generation with idea execution
- 12:49always generating ideas is a highly vulnerable
- 12:52deeply individual process When you force people
- 12:56to brainstorm in a group setting you immediately
- 12:58trigger evaluation apprehension That's the psychological
- 13:01fear of being judged by your peers or your boss.
- 13:03Oh, yeah You also trigger social loafing where
- 13:06individuals subconsciously exert less effort
- 13:08because they just feel like the group will carry
- 13:10the weight. As a result, group brainstorming
- 13:13yields fewer ideas and the ideas are usually
- 13:15less original. Because everyone is just self
- 13:17-censoring to avoid looking stupid. Precisely.
- 13:20But once the individual has generated the ideas
- 13:22in a safe, isolated environment, you absolutely
- 13:25need the group for the next phase. You need them
- 13:27for consensus, refinement, and execution. So
- 13:30the group meeting isn't useless. It's just being
- 13:33deployed at the wrong stage of the cognitive
- 13:35process. OK, that makes a lot of sense. So we
- 13:37have this IGO framework. We know how to bypass
- 13:39our flawed common sense. And we understand the
- 13:42research methods used to uncover the truth. Now
- 13:45we need to apply these psychological tools to
- 13:48the massive tectonic shifts that are currently
- 13:50reshaping the modern workplace. Yeah, the landscape
- 13:53is fundamentally changing, and I think it starts
- 13:55with the concept of corporate ethics. For sure.
- 13:58The reading touches on the fallout from massive
- 14:01corporate scandals like Enron and WorldCom, which
- 14:04led government regulators to create the Cervantes
- 14:06-Oxley Act. Right. The government basically tried
- 14:08to enforce ethical behavior through strict financial
- 14:11compliance. But as students of organizational
- 14:13psychology, we know that genuine ethics cannot
- 14:16be legislated by a rule book. Real ethics emerge
- 14:19from the day -to -day cultural norms of the organization.
- 14:21And the health of that culture is directly tied
- 14:25to employee engagement. The Gallup data shared
- 14:28in the text is honestly just chilling. Oh, it
- 14:30really is. 75 to 80 percent of employees are
- 14:33either disengaged or actively disengaged at work.
- 14:36Think about the psychological drain of that.
- 14:38Four out of five people are mentally checking
- 14:41out or actively sabotaging the company while
- 14:44physically occupying a desk. It's staggering.
- 14:47Gallup estimates that if 100 % of employees were
- 14:50fully engaged, customers would be 70 % more loyal
- 14:53and profits would jump by 40%. It is a catastrophic
- 14:57waste of human potential. And this crisis of
- 15:00engagement is colliding head on with rapid technological
- 15:03change. We are operating under Moore's law, where
- 15:06computing power doubles roughly every two years.
- 15:08This is so fast. Right. We are experiencing the
- 15:11psychological fatigue of hyperconnectivity. The
- 15:15cognitive load of constant context switching
- 15:17is so severe that companies like Intel have actually
- 15:20instituted no email Fridays just to give their
- 15:23employees brains a chance to engage. deep work.
- 15:26Because as Thomas Friedman argued, the internet
- 15:28has completely flattened the world. A 14 -year
- 15:31-old in Romania now has access to the exact same
- 15:34information and tools as a seasoned executive
- 15:37in New York. Yep. And this flat world is facing
- 15:40a massive demographic time bomb. According to
- 15:44the reading, 76 million baby boomers are retiring,
- 15:47and there are only 46 million Gen X and Gen Y
- 15:51workers stepping up to replace them. Which isn't
- 15:54just a labor shortage. It is a profound psychological
- 15:57shift in the workplace. The psychological contract
- 16:00that a boomer had with their employer, an expectation
- 16:02of long -term loyalty and hierarchical respect,
- 16:06is completely different from a younger worker
- 16:07who has watched companies routinely lay off staff
- 16:10to meet quarterly goals. Exactly. And furthermore,
- 16:12when those 76 million boomers leave, they take
- 16:15decades of tacit knowledge and institutional
- 16:17memory with them. And right in the midst of all
- 16:20this demographic and technological upheaval,
- 16:23organizations are also facing intense pressure
- 16:25regarding sustainability. Companies are increasingly
- 16:28judged on the triple bottom line. Right. Meaning
- 16:30they must demonstrate performance, not just economically,
- 16:33but socially and environmentally as well. Yeah.
- 16:36But the psychological trap here is greenwashing.
- 16:39The text warns against companies that aggressively
- 16:42market their products or initiatives as green
- 16:45just to capture market share without actually
- 16:48engaging in sustainable systemic practices behind
- 16:51closed doors. Yeah, that's a huge issue. And
- 16:53going back to our moral and religious connections,
- 16:56greenwashing is essentially the modern corporate
- 16:58equivalent of bearing false witness. Yeah. You
- 17:00are projecting this righteous moral image to
- 17:03the public, but you were refusing to do the hard
- 17:07systemic moral work required to actually care
- 17:10for the environment. You're just manipulating
- 17:12the consumer's desire for ethical consumption.
- 17:14Wow, yeah. The true triple bottom line aligns
- 17:17much closer to the concept of stewardship found
- 17:19in many world religions. It's the moral duty
- 17:22to care for the earth and the community as a
- 17:24whole, rather than simply extracting resources
- 17:27for the self. The text actually provides a really
- 17:30complicated but inspiring case study of a company
- 17:32attempting this. Now. Oh right, now. They were
- 17:35a Portland -based clothing company explicitly
- 17:38founded to use business as a vehicle for environmental
- 17:41and social change. Unfortunately, they couldn't
- 17:44secure the necessary funding and went bankrupt
- 17:46in 2008. Just sad. It is. But here's the fascinating
- 17:50OB twist. They were acquired by a larger company
- 17:53called Hornytoad. Now his workforce shrank drastically,
- 17:58dropping from 65 employees down to just 15. That's
- 18:01a huge cut. Massive. Yet they managed to maintain
- 18:04their decentralized autonomy, they kept control
- 18:07of their sustainable supply chain, and they still
- 18:10donate 2 % of every sale to organizations like
- 18:13Mercy Corps. See, that is a powerful testament
- 18:15to organizational resilience. It proves that
- 18:17a company can undergo massive structural trauma
- 18:20-like bankruptcy, a buyout, a huge reduction
- 18:23in force, and still maintain the integrity of
- 18:25its core culture if the psychological foundation
- 18:28is strong enough. Yeah. But there is another
- 18:30major trend that deeply threatens that kind of
- 18:33cohesive culture. And that's the rise of outsourcing
- 18:35and what Charles Handy calls the shamrock organization.
- 18:38This concept is just wild. A shamrock organization
- 18:42is composed of three distinct equal leaves. One
- 18:45-third are regular core employees, one -third
- 18:48are temporary or gig workers, and one -third
- 18:50are external consultants and contractors. It
- 18:53represents the ultimate decentralization of the
- 18:55workforce. Companies offshore significant portions
- 18:59of their operations to places like India and
- 19:01China, and they rely heavily on temporary workers
- 19:04to remain economically agile. But as psychology
- 19:07students, this is where the alarm bells should
- 19:09be ringing. because a shamrock organization sounds
- 19:12exactly like a mercenary army compared to a loyal
- 19:14standing army. Oh, that's a good comparison.
- 19:17Right. Psychologically, how can you possibly
- 19:19maintain that culture of consistent ethical behavior
- 19:22we just talked about when two -thirds of your
- 19:24workforce are transient gig workers? Like, how
- 19:27do you build deep cultural trust with a mercenary
- 19:30who knows they are basically disposable? It is
- 19:32arguably the single biggest challenge in modern
- 19:34organizational behavior. When an individual is
- 19:37separated from the core organization by a cult
- 19:38- culture, language, time zones, and precarious
- 19:40employment status, you just cannot rely on traditional
- 19:43mechanisms of loyalty. No, you can't. You have
- 19:46to completely redefine leadership. You have to
- 19:48shift from demanding long -term allegiance to
- 19:51building systems of extreme transparency and
- 19:55mutual short -term value. That makes a lot of
- 19:57sense. So let's summarize the incredible landscape
- 20:00we've covered today. We started by looking at
- 20:02the nested Russian dolls of the IGO model. understanding
- 20:06that the individual, the group, and the organization
- 20:09are inextricably linked. Right. We learned that
- 20:12we have to bypass our flawed intuition, recognize
- 20:15our VAK learning styles, and rely on rigorous
- 20:18research methods to understand the truth of human
- 20:21behavior. And we took those tools and applied
- 20:23them to a modern workplace that is actively navigating
- 20:26ethical landmines, technological burnout, shifting
- 20:29demographics, and the fragmentation of the shamrock
- 20:32organization. Which brings us entirely back to
- 20:34you, the listener. Because in that IG model,
- 20:37you are the individual at the core. You're not
- 20:39a passive gear in a predictable machine. You
- 20:42have the agency to audit your own daily ethics,
- 20:44to understand your own learning style, and to
- 20:47consciously decide how you want to engage with
- 20:49the organization around you. Absolutely. You
- 20:51can use these psychological levers to better
- 20:53understand your manager's behavior, to lead your
- 20:56own team with more empathy, or even to recognize
- 20:59when a company's structural culture is just fundamentally
- 21:01misaligned with your own moral compass. which
- 21:04leaves us with one final provocative thought
- 21:07to chew on. Building on this whole idea of the
- 21:11transient shamrock organization and the massive
- 21:14demographic shift occurring right now, if the
- 21:17future of work means that we are increasingly
- 21:19just temporary isolated nodes in a giant decentralized
- 21:23network, does the concept of corporate loyalty
- 21:26even exist anymore? Or in the end, are we psychologically
- 21:30rewiring ourselves to be purely free agents,
- 21:33responsible to absolutely no one but ourselves?
- 21:35That is a profound question about the future
- 21:37of our cycle. with the world of work. We open
- 21:39the show by talking about how easy it is to build
- 21:42a perfect machine with predictable parts. But
- 21:45the workplace isn't a machine, and you aren't
- 21:47just a gear. You are a complex, unpredictable
- 21:51human being, and that chaos is exactly what makes
- 21:53the study of organizational behavior so absolutely
- 21:56fascinating. Thanks for joining us today on The
- 21:58Psychology Undergrad.