Latest / The Team House / Syria Deep Dive w/ CIA Analyst Turned Author | David McCloskey | Ep. 234
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, folks, I just want to take a minute to ask you to
- 0:03go in rate this podcast, let the Team House know how you think we're
- 0:07doing. Go and rate us on whatever platform you're listening to this on,
- 0:11whether it's iTunes or Spotify or whatever else. Those ratings really help us out
- 0:16and we really appreciate the feedback to let us know what you like and what
- 0:19you don't like. And if you do like the Teamhouse and you'd like to
- 0:23support us, go check out our Patreon page and you can actually support the
- 0:27stream and well as get access to our bonus segments and bonus episodes. Yeah,
- 0:32if you're gonna give us a great review, please do. And if
- 0:35you're going to give us another secret review, why don't you just send us
- 0:37an email. We'll talk about special operations covert. Ask me in the Team
- 0:51House with your hopes. Jack Murphy and David Park. Hey everyone, welcome
- 1:03to episode two hundred and thirty four of The Team House. I'm Jack Murphy
- 1:07here with David Park and our guest on tonight's show is David Mukoloski. He
- 1:11is a reformer CIA analyst. He is the author of Damascus Station. This
- 1:19one was very well reviewed came out a lot like two years ago. Two
- 1:23years ago. Now this is the new one that's coming out in October Moscow,
- 1:27X. So next month this one will be out. I read an
- 1:30advanced copy that your publisher was nice enough to send me really good book,
- 1:36and so we're excited to talk to you about your work and your career in
- 1:40the intelligence community as well. So thank you for joining us, David,
- 1:42and I gotta let people know about our sponsor upfront, Augusta Precious Medals.
- 1:49If you guys text Team to six eight five nine two or go to Augusta
- 1:53Precious Metals dot com. They are one of our sponsors. I hope you
- 1:57guys will check them out. So thank you for doing that. So,
- 2:02David, I want to jump right into it with you. Tell us a
- 2:07little bit about sort of like what you're upbringing was like, and what your
- 2:10career track was like, what took you towards a you know, the intelligence
- 2:15community. Yeah, sure thing, and thanks for having me, guys.
- 2:20It's fun to be here. So I grew up in the Midwest, mostly
- 2:24in Minneapolis. I as a kid just read tons of thrillers and spy fiction
- 2:32and you know, devoured all kinds of non fiction books about the world,
- 2:38and you know, I kind of had it from an early age. I
- 2:42think, a sense of like and there's no sense that I wanted to join
- 2:45CI, but the sense of like, I'm interested in the world, I
- 2:46want to travel, I want to understand how things work. Right. I
- 2:52went to college at a small place outside of Chicago, and we had a
- 2:59guy come through who at the who ran at the time the Middle East Analytics
- 3:02shop. So he was like coming through the University of Chicago doing recruiting stuff,
- 3:07and he was in a lum of my school. It's called Wheaton College,
- 3:10and he came through kind of just to like talk to an IR one
- 3:14oh one class, which I was in, and I ended up kind of
- 3:19getting in in a way that I'm sure would make a lot of our you
- 3:22know, oss Fourbears turnover in their graves. But it was basically a guy
- 3:25showing up at a small liberal arts, you know, midwestern school and saying,
- 3:30hey, you know, here's what the CIA is, here's what a
- 3:32CIA analyst does, and talking to a class, and I thought it sounded
- 3:38awesome. I mean it felt at the time like literally my work experience was
- 3:45I've been I've been digging holes for a sprinkler system company, and I had
- 3:50been a cashier at Wendy's. Like that was literally the resume, like no
- 3:53joke, that was the resume that got turned in. And so in the
- 3:57CIA comes to campus, it's like, all right, this seems pretty interesting.
- 4:00I'm sure I won't get in, but let me just apply. And
- 4:03I ended up going through the process and I think, you know, it
- 4:05turns out one of the things that if you go into a small liberal arts
- 4:10midwestern Protestant school, you know, you're pretty good at passing polygraphs because you've
- 4:14got like you haven't done anything really wrong, and you've got this kind of
- 4:16baseload level of guilt going that's really helpful for the polygraphers, so they know
- 4:20you're not a sociopath. And I got in. So I actually joined as
- 4:27an undergrad intern, so I took the poly and the full lifestyle poly and
- 4:31all the medical and all that kind of stuff, the psych exams, interviews,
- 4:34all that at nineteen. I showed up the summer when I was twenty
- 4:40as an intern and they threw me. You know, I kind of describe
- 4:44it this way, like the CI, at least from an analytic standpoint,
- 4:47basically hires for kind of two major profiles, again oversimplification, but helpful.
- 4:53One is like somebody who is extremely knowledgeable on a particular topic, like they
- 5:00lived in Russia for fifteen years and they did their dissertation on blah blah blah
- 5:03and like that. That's they speak the language, and okay, bring that
- 5:08person on, put them on Russia, and then the agency goes after really
- 5:13you know, pretty young people who they think they can you know, make
- 5:16into good analysts and get them pretty pretty early. Right, So I fell
- 5:20into that group, got in and you know, quickly realized that it was
- 5:25a pretty big step up from Wendy's and I was. I loved it.
- 5:29I worked the first summer they put me on Syria. Still to this day,
- 5:32I don't really know why. It's pretty random, I think, and
- 5:35mostly just because the guy who came to recruit was you know, running the
- 5:40Middle East shop at the time. And the first summer I was there was
- 5:44the thirty four day war between Israel and Hezbollah, which you know, this
- 5:48was two accounts two thousand and six, that's right. So the account you
- 5:53know, at that time it was pretty small. There just weren't that many
- 5:56people working on Syria or on Lebanon, and so I had the opportunity to
- 6:00you know, participate in a lot of briefings and to write stuff that like,
- 6:02you know, I probably had no business doing. But it's one of
- 6:05those things where you've got a team of like five or six and you're short
- 6:09on people and there's a war on. So you know, the intern is
- 6:13a member of the team, right, And I was fully cleared in working
- 6:15So got hooked on it dead And then the next summer I came back,
- 6:17so I go to school, you know, come back for my second summer,
- 6:20and that was the run up to when the Israelis bombed alkey Bar,
- 6:25and so I was thoroughly hooked. After those two summers, it felt like,
- 6:29man, this is exciting. I kind of am getting a sense of
- 6:31like how does the world actually function, how do government's work, how does
- 6:34this how does this region work? Right? And that was really addictive to
- 6:38me. So did deaf for two summers, got the full time offer and
- 6:42jumped in and I pretty much worked on Syria the whole time I was there.
- 6:46That is like pretty wild. I don't think I've heard on this show.
- 6:50I don't think we've heard of somebody who like walked through the door quite
- 6:54that young. Yeah, I was, I was very young. Yeah,
- 6:58A lot a lot of people who are like they had graduate degrees, or
- 7:00they had a military career, or they had a law a law career,
- 7:04or their lawyers or something. I mean coming in as a as an internet
- 7:09What did you say nineteen when you first started. Yeah, that's wild,
- 7:13Yeah, but great. Yeah, it felt it felt like you know,
- 7:17it was one of those things where even at that age, I was kind
- 7:19of thinking, this seems like a mistake too. You know, I'm too
- 7:26young to be doing this. But you know, I think I think there's
- 7:29a logic to getting people in the pipeline young get Frankly, they are looking
- 7:32back on it. You know, there's an element here if like, the
- 7:35further you get into a four year degree, the less likely it is that
- 7:39you're going to pass a lifestyle polly. And so if the agency can kind
- 7:42of give you, you know, a pathway early, it creates incentives to
- 7:47not do things that make you flunk out. You know. So for folks
- 7:53out there watching, and I know that they're you often are a lot of
- 7:58young people watching these shows that are interested in pursuing a career in the intelligence
- 8:01community, Can you kind of lay out what your job as an analyst was
- 8:07for people who just have like no knowledge and just you know, they maybe
- 8:09they understand we have spies out there meeting in cafes with people and trying to
- 8:13get information, But what's what's the analyst side of it? Yeah, so
- 8:20I think, you know, there's some flaws in this analogy. I but
- 8:22I think it's helpful to explain it to people who don't understand the inner workings
- 8:26of the agency. Like I think about it in a way as clanestant journalism.
- 8:31Right, there's a story, uh, that you're writing for and the
- 8:35job is primarily you know, writing and briefing. Right, You're you're answering
- 8:41a question story for a consumer of that information. And that could be the
- 8:46president, that could be the director of the CIA, that could be you
- 8:50know, the Secretary of Defense, that could be people on the National Security
- 8:52Council. You know, people who are making policy right or informing policy.
- 8:58We're sort of we're not doing that right. We're providing an input to the
- 9:03policy making process that is trying to answer a particular question about what's going on
- 9:07in the world and why does it matter for us? And what might we
- 9:11be able to do to shape that you know thing to be more amenable to
- 9:16our interests. So you're taking in as part of that process, you're taking
- 9:20in all different kinds of information. Right, So you might have let's take
- 9:24Syria as an example. You know, we might have human sources that have
- 9:28access to people inside the government who are providing us information secrets. Right,
- 9:31They're providing us with secrets from Syria that help us understand better and you know
- 9:37what the Syrians are thinking are doing about a particular topic. There's satellite imagery,
- 9:41there's you know, open source press stuff, there's academic field work.
- 9:45There's signals, intercepts, phone calls, faxes, emails, things like that.
- 9:50You're taking all that information in and trying to make sense of it to
- 9:54answer that question for the policymaker, so that you know, the parallels to
- 10:00journalism are Okay, you've got sources, right, you have people. Let's
- 10:05take the case of you know, human sources as an example, Like,
- 10:07you've got people who are providing this information that maybe they shouldn't be. So
- 10:11if you're writing a story about you know, corporate misdeeds, in the United
- 10:15States, you might have sources inside that company who are providing you with,
- 10:18you know, with with email records or things like that from inside the corporation.
- 10:22They shouldn't be. You have to think about asset protection and how you
- 10:26actually communicate with that person all that kind of stuff, you know. But
- 10:30in this context, it's information that's you know, highly classified and obtained in
- 10:35ways that were that those sources and methods known, people would get killed or
- 10:41valuable collection programs would be compromised. So you're you're putting all this stuff together
- 10:45and you know, frankly, the output of it, you know, is
- 10:48a little bit underwhelming in some cases, because it's like you might take a
- 10:52very serious, complicated topic like what's going to happen next in Syria, right,
- 10:56which is the thing we were constantly trying to answer twenty eleven and twenty
- 11:01twelve and twenty thirteen, and you boil it down to like a page or
- 11:05two and that goes to you know, whatever that you know, whoever that
- 11:09senior policymaker is, and it's one piece of the information that they receive on
- 11:13that topic. But you're sort of feeding you're feeding that consumer base with with
- 11:18information about these questions that that are important to the policy making process. And
- 11:22that's that's pretty much what you're doing as an analyst, you know, and
- 11:26it's distinct from other aspects of you know, the primary other job inside CEA,
- 11:33although there are many is you know, the folks who are actually trying
- 11:37to recruit, develop, you know, and spot human assets and actually collect
- 11:43that information. So I'm I'm distinct from a collector of information and that I'm
- 11:48analyzing the information that the collectors provide. But you guys could assist them in
- 11:52finding like, hey, this guy in this ministry would be a prime target
- 11:58for you to try to pitch. Yeah, exactly, like we would help
- 12:01in the process of Now you know, oftentimes, uh, there's a lot
- 12:07of stovepiping in this business, right, these are big bureaucracies that don't always
- 12:09function particularly well. But in an ideal world, yes, you know,
- 12:13we were providing input to the collectors on where there might be gaps there.
- 12:20You know, are particular are analysts with like targeting specialties who do a lot
- 12:24of the work that you're describing there, which is like here's the fifteen people
- 12:28you know that we'd be interested in, you know, in knowing more about
- 12:31inside the Syrian mod right, and here are the gaps that we have about
- 12:37you know, the Syrian militaries plans and intentions and capabilities and kind of feed
- 12:43that stuff to the collectors and the hopes that they can go and find people
- 12:46who actually have that information. What what was that that communication pipeline like for
- 12:50you as a junior analyst and then as you know, as you grew and
- 12:56became known or became sort of got your bona feedees in the sense of first,
- 13:01you're receiving information and you're always receiving information right where there's the message traffic
- 13:07that's coming through, but you're putting your analysis, you know, on it.
- 13:11But were there I know that there are specific people for taskings, but
- 13:16how much input would you have in those tasks? Could you reach out to
- 13:20a case saucer and say, hey, these are some other pieces of the
- 13:24puzzle. Not necessarily this is a person you should target, but in these
- 13:28sources are these assets that you have, you know, these are the pieces
- 13:33that were sort of missing. Yeah, yeah, you know, that was
- 13:41very hit or miss, depending on the personalities involved. I think I can
- 13:46think of a number of examples where you know, it felt like we just
- 13:50couldn't really get close to the collectors on things. And then others where you
- 13:54know, we would actually be in the meetings with the assets because we you
- 14:01know, knew a ton about the particular topic that that asset was feeding and
- 14:05you know, sort of the assets reporting on and we're a helpful partner for
- 14:07the case officer in conducting that meeting right to get the information. Because ideally
- 14:13you'd say we're in lockstep with the collectors because we're you know, really the
- 14:20most downstream part of the process before we get to the consumer, right,
- 14:28So there's a lot of value in the analysts and the collectors being really linked
- 14:31up. But I found it was pretty pretty spotty how solid that connective tissue
- 14:39was. And you know, I think that's you know, we're talking a
- 14:43little bit before the show about modernization. I think that was you know,
- 14:45one of the primary uh you know, sort of problem statements in that in
- 14:50that bit of a reorg was like, can we create better connection between you
- 14:56know, analysts and operations and the tech folks to make sure that this place
- 15:01actually you know, does espionage better. But it was it was all over
- 15:07the place, truly, well, I mean as you know, as sort
- 15:11of the shop, you know, whatever shop you're in, as sort of
- 15:16the shop as the subject matter experts. I mean, were there ever instances
- 15:22where you could turn around to like a case officer and go, hey,
- 15:26none of this fits, Like your source is absolutely full of shit, you
- 15:33know. I would say there was a slightly different tinge to that conversation when
- 15:41when we felt like this source was producing stuff that was bizarre. It was
- 15:46less direct than that. I think that when you go to the operational side
- 15:50and they're doing the vetting, that conversation can be that blunt, you know,
- 15:56not in cable traffic but in person. But on the analytics side,
- 16:02it's a little bit more anodyne. It'd be like, hey, these five
- 16:04reports, like they don't track with the second right, like what's going on?
- 16:11You know, or just frankly, it's maybe some a stream of reporting
- 16:17from from an asset that's like this isn't particularly valuable, yea, you know,
- 16:22so we would we would not do it that that bluntly because we're frankly,
- 16:27you know, especially on the analytics, on the analytics side, when
- 16:32you're not talking about like CT like we're sort of removed enough from it where
- 16:34we're like not capable of making as you know, sort of direct and harsh
- 16:40eva. So you never said that, but you never sent a cable back
- 16:42saying, hey, the taliband, do not have that sixteens. Get your
- 16:47ship together and and fire this source. No, I mean well we would.
- 16:51We would, you know, be like hey, this piece of like
- 16:53third hand human that you collected here is like this is crazy, like what
- 16:59is this? You know? And and that then kind of filters back into
- 17:03the DA side of things where they try to piece together like, Okay,
- 17:07the analyst said, this is garbage. Here's ten pieces of contradictory information.
- 17:11Did this person make it up because they wanted us to pay them or did
- 17:14they Is this a game a telephone or is this an effort to sort of
- 17:18you know, is this a more systematic effort to sort of mislead us on
- 17:22a particular topic and we need to cut this person loose so that would get
- 17:26kicked back to the to THEDO side to sort of work through that. Yeah,
- 17:30So can you tell us about the you know, we've talked about the
- 17:33farm. You know, people talked about you know, sort of their case
- 17:37offts or training. Can you tell us about what the the analysts pipeline.
- 17:41How do they train somebody to be an analyst? So they I think it
- 17:48took us. It's probably changed, but at the time, you know,
- 17:52more than ten years ago, they basically took you off your account for somewhere
- 17:56between four and six months and put you at a you know, you're still
- 18:02like you weren't living away from your family, but you were going to it,
- 18:04you know, one of these sort of outbuildings and like herned in or
- 18:08rest in or one of these other places, and you know, the DC
- 18:11urbs. And you had a class of people who are with you, all
- 18:15other analysts from all over the d I uh, you know, maybe twenty
- 18:19twenty five of us, and they basically walk you through, you know,
- 18:27a very excruciating deep dive and how you actually think critically, which you know
- 18:32low and behold a lot of people coming out of before your university are really
- 18:34smart but don't actually know how to think critically. How do you write clearly
- 18:41and you know, without value judgments or colorful language or any of this kind
- 18:45of stuff that you know if you've been again you know, writing papers and
- 18:49in I our program, you know you have there there's a you know,
- 18:52a voice that you might have that they try to stamp out and turn into
- 18:56something that's like, hey, you're writing stuff as You're not writing as David
- 19:00McCloskey, right, you're you're the CIA, So like, what how do
- 19:04you strip everything down? This isn't an article in the New Yorker. Correct
- 19:10correct, So it's really this kind of like down, you know, take
- 19:15the thing down to the studs, like how do you think? How do
- 19:18you write? How do you take in? We're going to give you a
- 19:21lot of the exercises. We're like, here's a packet with like six hundred
- 19:25pieces of information. You have to write an article on this, and it's
- 19:30like a page and you know, and like how how do you put together
- 19:33the what, the why and so what, substantiate it, rite it clearly
- 19:37you know, and do it in like you know, a page and hand
- 19:41that off. It's really hard, you know. That's that's that is not
- 19:45something you know, it's not a skill that's really taught in most most undergrad
- 19:51programs. And frankly, if someone's coming a lot of analysts, you know,
- 19:53particularly the kind of analysts who might come in more like mid career,
- 19:57are coming out of academic backgrou sounds they're not doing that for the most part.
- 20:02You know, you can learn it, but a lot of people haven't
- 20:03been practicing that. So it's a lot of that, a lot of briefing
- 20:08practice. So like you sit down, I mean a lot of a lot
- 20:11of the customers, you know, down at the White House or DD or
- 20:15certainly in Congress or like really unpleasant to deal with, surprise, surprise,
- 20:19and so you know, how do you actually engage with somebody who you know
- 20:25you need to brief them, but they're also you might hate the CIA,
- 20:29it might be a dick. You know, how do you interact with people
- 20:32like that? And it's a lot of role playing and a lot of writing,
- 20:37So you kind of you do that for almost half a year. You
- 20:41end up doing also as part of that, at least you used to a
- 20:44rotation where like they take you and actually put you in a different part of
- 20:48the agency, so they kind of you get a different perspective on how the
- 20:52place works that's not on your team, which I think is pretty valuable.
- 20:57And then they put you back in and you're you're kind of on the line.
- 21:02But that's more or less the art of it is there for people who
- 21:04might be interested in this and know if they have what it takes to be
- 21:08an analyst. Is there like an industry standard textbook out there that you can
- 21:12get on you know, your favorite bookseller or whatever. Is there? You
- 21:17know? Are there any sources question? I though, there's a book that's
- 21:26escaping me. There was a book we used, It's gonna bug me.
- 21:30There's a book we used about intelligence analysis and sort of how you think about
- 21:37how you manage different kinds of cognitive biases when you're when you're writing and thinking.
- 21:45That is kind of the It was the foundational text in the program because
- 21:52so much of it is like stripping out those biases so that you actually provide
- 21:56objective and clear information. It's going to drive me nuts. Data. No,
- 22:00I'll have to I'll have to double back with you on that. But
- 22:03there's a there is a good book that's publicly available that would give people a
- 22:06sense of like here's here's if you're going through that. You know that program
- 22:11at CIA, like everyone's going to read this and go through it. Take
- 22:14take two minutes to think about it. If you want, I have to
- 22:18do this. Ad read here real quick. Start to interrupt you but if
- 22:22you think of it, I'd love to take a look at it myself.
- 22:25So our first sponsor for tonight's show Augusta Precious Metals. If you're like me,
- 22:30you've wanted to buy gold for years. Lots of commercials out there,
- 22:33but who can you really trust. I didn't want a bad investment. Uh.
- 22:37I didn't want to miss the boat either. Does that sound familiar?
- 22:41Fortunately, we've got great news. If you have an IRA or A four
- 22:45oh one K and want to buy physical gold, eliminate fear and uncertainty from
- 22:48the process by using the new Gold IRA Company Integrity Checklist that helps you evaluate
- 22:53and choose the best gold IRA company. I use it to vet august Precious
- 23:00Metals and they're absolutely phenomenal. Use the checklist to choose the best gold IRA
- 23:04company. To get your free Gold IRA Company Integrity Checklist today, text Team
- 23:10t e A M to six eight five nine two. Again text t e
- 23:15A M to six eight five nine two. That's Team to six eight five
- 23:18nine two, or go to Augusta Precious Metals dot com. And our second
- 23:22spots for the night is our favorite sports drink, Vitamin One, created by
- 23:30veteran you know business created by former guests and s F legend Mike Taylor.
- 23:34Uh, if you haven't watched this episode, watch it right after you watch
- 23:38this. It's Friday night, you've got nothing better to do. But vitamin
- 23:42one is fantastic. It's honestly the best sports drink out there. It's light,
- 23:48it's flavorful, it's not syrupy or heavy. There's no sugar like a
- 23:52lot of other sports drinks. Vitamins B one, B five, B six,
- 23:56P twelve by it to nyasin, electrolytes everything you know, it's got
- 24:02what the body needs. Electrolytes. Yeah, we drink it here in the
- 24:04office all the time, NonStop. It's fantastic. But vitamin one you can
- 24:10find it on Amazon. Uh, and the link is down the description.
- 24:14Is there also a website drink dot com drink vitamin one dot com. You
- 24:22go to the Amazon Okay, yeah, so yeah, you can get it
- 24:26off Amazon. But it's a fantastic drink. Highly recommend it. So back
- 24:30to you, Back to you, David. Yeah, it's Uh. Now
- 24:38with with the analysis and when they're training you that you know in this craft,
- 24:48is it just a matter of like eliminating your cogn and bias and how
- 24:51to write is there because obviously you guys are using you know, things,
- 24:56you know, these I don't know if it's if it's classified, but i'll
- 25:00but these programs, you know, to create link change and things like that,
- 25:06are they also teaching you sort of how to put these puzzles together and
- 25:10stuff. Well, I am sure that the trading has become much more rigorous,
- 25:18like in the types of probably software programs that are used, and frankly,
- 25:25like now in a world where you're talking about you know, AI assistant
- 25:29search and things that I don't I couldn't speculate exactly as to what they've you
- 25:33know, how they've updated it. But you're hitting on something which you're right,
- 25:37that I've missed, which is like there's a there's a weighing of which
- 25:44I think is still true even in the you know, the world that we're
- 25:48living in now. A skill in learning how to weigh the information that you
- 25:52have in front of you, and frankly, so much of it as contradictory.
- 25:55It's like what do you do with you know, you take my example
- 25:57of like here's a packet of six hundred sources of information, Well, you
- 26:02know, one hundred and fifty of them are crap, but they're not going
- 26:03to say they're crap. You're gonna have to figure out that their crap.
- 26:07And you know, another hundred are going to contradict the ones that you actually
- 26:11need to use to write, Like, so, how do you sort of
- 26:11sort through that? Because it's not all just going to point in one direction,
- 26:15right, There's going to be stuff that points you or sends you down
- 26:18different rabbit trails, And so I think, yeah, you're right, it's
- 26:22not just the sort of elimination of bias, but it's also like how do
- 26:25you figure out what's good information and what's bad information? Right? That is
- 26:33easier said than done, and it's often very unclear, you know, which
- 26:38is another reason why, like we use a lot of it. It drives
- 26:42policymakers freaking nuts. They hate it because it's we use this sort of probabilistic
- 26:48language. Now we're like, hey, we have you know, medium confidence
- 26:55in something, right, Well, what the hell does that? You know?
- 26:56What does that mean? I mean we we we wrote stuff was like
- 26:59we have low confidence in this assessment. And you know sometimes these like you
- 27:03know, briefing where you're forced to go in with that kind of line.
- 27:07I mean, you just get this like eye roll from the from the person
- 27:11across the table where they're like geez, I mean that's like, this is
- 27:14the most useless piece of garbage you could bring. You know, Obama said
- 27:18about the Ben Widen raid when they were briefing him, and at some point
- 27:22he was like, just stop making up the numbers, guys, Like it's
- 27:23a flip of the coin, right, Yeah, no, that's I mean,
- 27:27that's you know, that's true. And I mean I think if I
- 27:33were across the table, I would have wanted to maybe reach across and strangle
- 27:37a younger version of me multiple times while delivering those kind of mealy mouthed assessments.
- 27:41But you there is a there's a logic to it, which is like,
- 27:45we are providing the CIA's assessment. It's not my own personal opinion.
- 27:49You know, if I'm a think tanker and I go down and I talked
- 27:52to a bunch of people on the hill, like I'm not speaking for brook
- 27:55Hangers or the American Enterprise Institute or whatever, you know, the International Crisis
- 27:59Group, Like I'm I'm speaking for myself, right. Agency analysts aren't doing
- 28:03that, and so it's a lot more. There's a you know, pretty
- 28:07big rigamarole to go through to like actually get a piece of paper that has
- 28:11the ci AS judgment on it, and if you stray from that, you
- 28:14know, it doesn't go so well for your career. And the thing is
- 28:17is that, even though it's probably frustrating to the people hearing it, even
- 28:22if something's low probability, if it's if it's you know, it's like you
- 28:26know, and it's sort of the carbon methodology of you know, target assessment.
- 28:32Even if it's low probability but it's high like high consequence, you have
- 28:38to tell somebody, right, you can't, you can't, you can't go,
- 28:42well, we know they're going to be you know, asked up at
- 28:45us if we go and say this is a low probability you know, or
- 28:48low confidence sort of. Because the flip side to that is like if you
- 28:55have intelligence of appending terror attack, but you're you think this is all the
- 29:00sources bus it's almost certainly not going to happen. But if it does happen
- 29:04and you were sitting on that intelligence, right, oh boy, right,
- 29:10that's right, yeah, And I think yeah, the most direct you know
- 29:14that the CT example would be the best one where there's a I think you
- 29:18know, it's like a duty to Warren, right, it's what it was
- 29:19called. Like inside CTC, you would sometimes get you know, pieces that
- 29:25were written, or you know, briefings that were done, or it's like,
- 29:27I mean the ct analysts would say like, yeah, probably not.
- 29:30But what am I you know, I can't what am I supposed to be?
- 29:33I'm supposed to just kind of I can't off and go home without telling
- 29:37you about this. I mean, yeah, you can't do that. And
- 29:40there were there were a number of instances on you know, on Syria and
- 29:44even more sort of strategic topics where you know, it felt like, okay,
- 29:48the impact of this is such that we need to share the sort of
- 29:52low confidence assessment with you, you know, but less less so when you're
- 29:56not talking about like, you know the impact of this being people might die.
- 30:03Yeah, So let's uh, let's jump into that. Because I'm continually
- 30:07fascinated with with Syria and our involvement in it. It sounds like you were
- 30:12there, you were from the very beginning. You were Syria before Syria was
- 30:15cool, right, right, Yeah, it was not cool at the time.
- 30:18Yes, that's right, it was. It was a solid one PDB
- 30:22a year account prior to the war and no more. There wasn't a whole
- 30:26lot of attention on it. I mean there wasn't a few things, but
- 30:30it was. Yeah, it just spiked obviously once the uprising started. Yeah.
- 30:33Yeah, So like maybe we want to talk a little bit about the
- 30:37prologue to it. I mean, the Arab spring Gadaffi goes down in twenty
- 30:41eleven and then this thing migrates over to Dara and Syria. As an analyst
- 30:48sort of what are you seeing, What's what's the vibe in the office around
- 30:51this time? For time frame, Yeah, you know, I would say
- 30:56basically every analyst once too Knee just started, which would have been December,
- 31:04I think of twenty ten. It was before the new year, and Ben
- 31:10Aley goes I think in like January or something like that, and every analyst
- 31:15I know who was working on any sort of Middle Eastern autocracy had like a
- 31:21piece in drafts about why it wasn't going to happen in their country, and
- 31:26it was said in like slightly It wasn't said that directly, but everybody had
- 31:30good reasons, low probability or you know, I think the way we ended
- 31:37up framing it was like, here's all the different obstacles to a protest movement,
- 31:41right, and let's tick through those, which was an intellectually honest way
- 31:44of saying, like, yeah, there's a lot of obstacles to it,
- 31:45but you know, it was it was a fascinating time to be on the
- 31:52account. I mean, I was actually in the region in January and February,
- 31:56and I watched like that Night of the Camels and when you know,
- 32:01when Bark brought in those those goons on like literally riding camels through the protesters
- 32:07and like schwhacking them with clubs and like polo stick. It was crazy.
- 32:10I remember watching that in Davascus and like you could just kind of see people
- 32:19in Syria watching this stuff and realizing that there was a very profound shift occurring
- 32:27that wasn't predictable, right, but like you just you don't know when these
- 32:31kind of things would happen, but it was. It was akin to I
- 32:35think what happened in you know, Eastern and Central Europe in eighty nine,
- 32:37where all of a sudden, it's just like things are changed and there's this
- 32:44mass psychological shift that occurs in Syria, they you know, Syrians called it
- 32:52like the wall of fear, right, that there was this barrier to any
- 32:55kind of political activity or action or resistance to the security services and the regime
- 33:02apparatus. And very quickly people realized, you know, maybe it doesn't have
- 33:08to be this way, and there was a lot of dry you know,
- 33:14there was a lot of kindling. Obviously in the country. You had pretty
- 33:19significant socioeconomic deprivation. You had the linger and effects of a drought that had
- 33:23been going on in the east for four or five years at that point,
- 33:28had led to these crazy migrations of people around these shanty towns, you know,
- 33:32around Damascus and Aleppo. You had you know, really predatory regime patronage
- 33:39networks that extracted from the country and from ordinary people and didn't disperse, you
- 33:45know it in any way. Equally, you had security services that were really
- 33:52the only effective arm of the state at that point, you know, I
- 33:54mean most of the rest of the regime's institutions had been pretty hollowed out out
- 34:00and were ineffective. Like the only ones that worked really were like the four
- 34:05major security services in Syria. And so the population, like the surface area
- 34:09with the population was happening through the security services, which are Alai dominated,
- 34:15and you know, you have these kind of guys who don't make a lot
- 34:22of money and have to extract it through graft and corruption from the population.
- 34:27And it was you know, you have a youth bulge, you have you
- 34:30have all the things right, like, so this is a place that's pretty
- 34:32primed for and I mean at that point, the outside family had been in
- 34:37power for forty years, you know, so you're dealing with a pretty ossified
- 34:43structure that's lost a lot of its legitimacy, right, And then all of
- 34:50a sudden people thought it could be different. And there was in Thera down
- 34:55south there was a group of teenagers who put up some graffiti. They got
- 35:00arrested. And there's a whole bunch of different varying accounts on this, but
- 35:05we're probably tortured and certainly significantly mistreated. And there was sort of a back
- 35:09and forth between some of the elders in the city and the security services,
- 35:15and the kids probably got killed, a few of them, I believe,
- 35:20And there were protests and then you sort of had this cycle start of like
- 35:23protests, people get killed by the security services, there's funeralals. Moore protests
- 35:29breakout and just sort of spiraled from there. One of the interesting things is
- 35:35that those kind of incidents like between the population the security services had been going
- 35:38on for a number of years prior. You know, we tend to think
- 35:43of it as like, oh, nothing happened, and then all of a
- 35:45sudden this happened. Well, not really like these kind of things had been
- 35:47happening, It was just that this was the first time it happened in this
- 35:52new context of you know, we can push for something to be different,
- 36:00and maybe the regime won't kill us, you know, maybe we can get
- 36:02away with it. And that's how it started, you know, And it
- 36:07started really and truly as a pretty peaceful protest movement for a while, and
- 36:13then the dynamics change, which we can talk about you guys like to,
- 36:15but it you know, that first bit of the of The one other thing
- 36:21I would say which I think is important, is that that first year or
- 36:27so of the uprising, you know, a lot of the press, like
- 36:31if you go back and read the regional press, or if you read a
- 36:34lot of the American press, you would think that the regime had started a
- 36:38kind of scorched earth military campaign, like right, off the bat, and
- 36:43it's just not true. The regime's response initially was more waffling than anything.
- 36:47It was the sort of haphazard use of force so that it wasn't effective,
- 36:52and then giving concessions too little and too late so that they wouldn't actually appease
- 36:58people. And they really failed in that first year, I think from a
- 37:04lack of decisiveness more than anything. And then you know, as things became
- 37:07more militarized, they started, you know, in early twenty twelve, to
- 37:12do a much more kind of score shirt military campaign, which was like we're
- 37:16just going to destroy places in order to suppress the opposition. And then you
- 37:22had, you know, you mentioned that you were you were living in Damascus
- 37:24around this time frame. I could you talk a little bit about like your
- 37:28personal experience as well as like some of your observations, either work wise,
- 37:32but also just sort of that experience of living there and interacting with the people.
- 37:37Yeah, so, look, I I was there before the uprising started,
- 37:44Okay, I I mean it was a absolutely beautiful city filled with people
- 37:52who you know, were incredibly generous to most Americans that they met. It
- 38:01is a you know, wonderfully especially in the center I mean, wonderfully cosmopolitan
- 38:07place, exceptional food, exceptional cult. Like, it's just I loved it,
- 38:10and it had a very kind of undefiled feel to it because it hadn't
- 38:17been you know, it hadn't really been open to a lot of sort of
- 38:21Western consumerism because of the sanctions. Yeah, that's right, and it just
- 38:28it was pretty a magical place, you know, and it was filled like
- 38:35at the time, any Syrian even though you could kind of see that people
- 38:38were watching what was going on in the region and starting you could kind of
- 38:43almost see the gears turning when you would talk to them. But if you
- 38:45ask them the question of like, hey, could this happen here, They're
- 38:50like, no, you know, there's no way, Like it won't happen
- 38:52here, but you could you could also tell that like something is shifting it
- 38:58profoundly in the way that that people pausing with a cigarette held between two fingers,
- 39:02looking just kind of looking off into the distance. Yeah, there's a
- 39:07certain like a certain wonder I think to seeing something like that happen, right,
- 39:13But I love I love the city, and you know, it was
- 39:19interesting though, like being in Damascus and then like I went down, I
- 39:22mean, I drove down to a month before things started, because there's this
- 39:28really beautiful Roman amphitheater down there, and that city you could just like,
- 39:35the vibes are so different to city. You get out of the car and
- 39:39was that Paul Mira you know, no, no, oh okay, yeah,
- 39:46you know, I just did like a day trip down there, And
- 39:50as soon as you get out of the car, it's like this feeling of
- 39:52hey, people are looking at you like they don't want you here, you
- 39:57know. And and it had a very different and feel to it that when
- 40:01I look back and kind of think about the way the protest movement started,
- 40:06but you can just kind of it's one of those places where you can kind
- 40:07of feel the the suffering, you know, and the fact that this is
- 40:12a this is a people who are being excluded from the cultural life, the
- 40:15economics and the politics of the state, right and and we're pretty we're pretty
- 40:21primed for something. It felt very different from Damascus, and I mean,
- 40:28we can we can we move the timeline forward if you want to talk about
- 40:30how how it developed from there. What of course stands out in my mind
- 40:36that I'd like to hear your your thoughts on, is how how the protest
- 40:42movement led to an armed insurrection, and then how that became specifically Islamized.
- 40:49I think it's it's probably the topic to hit well. So, you know,
- 40:59the the regime had an interest from early days in militarizing the conflict because
- 41:07it could not figure out how to deal with, you know, a large,
- 41:13pretty peaceful protest movement which was like, hey, people are just out
- 41:15in the streets on Friday in large numbers, demanding significant political change, like
- 41:22it's very This was not a government that could deal with them, and so
- 41:28they did have an interest in creating and helping to create an armed opposition to
- 41:35itself so that it could fight it and it could create fault lines that are
- 41:42already existed in the society around largely ethnic and sectarian lines, but it could
- 41:47sort of firm those up and use them as a way to divide and kind
- 41:52of conquer the political system. And one of the things that the regime did
- 41:59was they released Joddi's from Sadnaia in April I think of twenty eleven. They
- 42:07released a number of guys who had fought in Iraq and who had come back
- 42:12and who had been arrested, probably by SMI Syrian military intelligence, you know,
- 42:19for for activities in Syria, and a lot of those guys you know
- 42:22from I LIB up in the northwest, and they became the founders of a
- 42:29number of very successful salapigiatist groups that fought against the regime, and they were
- 42:35let go in April of twenty eleven. So I think the regime fed some
- 42:40of this. At the same time, you also had people, and many
- 42:43of them were Iraq war veterans who had foughts and you know, against US
- 42:49in Iraq and then had gone back to Syria. You know, you had
- 42:52people who very reasonably saw that the regime wasn't going to ansel itself and who
- 43:02you know, hated the security services with a passion for good reason in many
- 43:07cases, and who were very excited about the prospect after a few months of
- 43:12protests and the realization of like, hey, Jem's not going to do anything
- 43:15to go out and kill security services officers, right, many of whom are
- 43:22are ALOI and most of the study insurgent, most of the insurgents were Sunni
- 43:25Arap you know. So there was a dynamic that started really, I mean,
- 43:32I think it was by spring of twenty eleven, we were starting to
- 43:37see like, hey, there are some low levels of violence here that could
- 43:43get out of control pretty quickly. And from there it just kind of you
- 43:47know, you had the dynamic of just that that sort of spiral internally,
- 43:53but then you started to have you know, external actors getting involved, to
- 43:59sort of equipment, you know, fund to train it first of all in
- 44:01a very haphazard way, but you know, the sort of fuel those dynamics
- 44:07internally and it became violent. And are you talking about like the two thousand
- 44:10and eleven to like two thousand and twelve thirteen time frame where yes, that's
- 44:15right. How was what was American policy like at that time? Because it
- 44:21initially initially like we were saying that uh Assad was a reformer, uh you
- 44:30know, we were you know, all on you know, his side,
- 44:36and then then then our policy is saying he's got to go, and right,
- 44:42and how one, how did that influence if it did you guys?
- 44:47And to do you like if if if if the US says Assad has to
- 44:57go, do people in the country who are against his regime, do they
- 45:01feel like that's the wink wink we got jaboo of attitude? Yeah? I
- 45:09think that's bought on. I mean, you know, I would say,
- 45:13And there were different sort of phases to the way we engage with this,
- 45:15but one thing that was consistent throughout was the chasm between our rhetoric and what
- 45:23we actually did. You know, there was just a tremendous gap the entire
- 45:29time between what we would say and and what happened actually on the ground and
- 45:34what we did. And that made everybody confused. Not in a good way.
- 45:43It wasn't it was people in Syria. Say that again, when you
- 45:47say every made everybody confused? Do you mean people in Syria? Do you
- 45:51mean people people people in Syria? Allies in the region. You know,
- 45:54I think we had you know, Syrians who thought, okay, if you
- 45:59say which I think I believe President Obama in like the late summer of twenty
- 46:05eleven said ASA, it needs to step aside, said I don't know if
- 46:10Obama said I know, and you know Syrians took that to mean, okay,
- 46:17they're gonna the Americans are gonna help us make him step aside for the
- 46:22most part, and you know Arab partners Sauby's, George's you know, sort
- 46:30of said okay, that means you're gonna help to you know, fund and
- 46:35back and maybe equipment, train and opposition, right, And I think that
- 46:39we we just sort of got half pregnant on that. You know. It
- 46:45was like, we're gonna do some things kind of in a very tepid way,
- 46:51We're not really gonna get involved, and we never provided any kind of
- 46:57clarity. And I think the regime pretty quickly figured this out and sort of
- 47:01used it to its advantage. But we just never were able to muster.
- 47:07And you know, there's a good conversation we could have about whether it would
- 47:10have been in the cards for us to really be involved in a much more
- 47:15robust way, to like effectively create, you know, an alternative to ASSAD.
- 47:21I'm not sure if that would have ever been possible. But we didn't
- 47:24do ourselves any favors by you know, getting totally over our skis with what
- 47:30we said what was going on in the ground. And I think, you
- 47:35know, honestly, what was going on with a lot of the stuff we
- 47:38were writing and with our engagement with the NSC was like they had watched they
- 47:45meeting the White House had watched Kay Tunisia goes Mubar, it goes now his
- 47:50regime doesn't go, but like he's gone, good daf he's gone. Never
- 47:54Mind that we acted as the air force for that, but let's put that
- 47:59aside for us second. And so there was this sort of narrative of like,
- 48:02this is predetermined, he's gone. It's just a matter of the circumstances.
- 48:08And so I think the I think that the Obama administration thought that they
- 48:14could kind of step to the side, say whatever they wanted, and in
- 48:19like six to eight months he would be gone and that would be a win
- 48:23for US policy. And so it was really a policy of sort of strategic
- 48:28communications above all else. And then he stepped to the side and sort of
- 48:31let history do its work. And the Syrian regime is a lot more resilient
- 48:37and determined than any of these other sort of you know, political systems that
- 48:43had gone down. So they didn't, but that was the dynamic at the
- 48:46time. So anything we put out as analysts, they would talk about outside
- 48:51staying power or some of these sort of violent dynamics and the conflict, like
- 48:54there wasn't there wasn't a receptive audience, you know, downtown for that kind
- 49:00of stuff. It and it's weird that, you know, after like Tito
- 49:06and Yugoslavia, after Saddam, you know, after Ghadafi and the violence and
- 49:12you know, reactivation of the slave trade and all this other stuff that that
- 49:15like America still hasn't learned that lesson is, yes, there are some really
- 49:21shitty people running these countries. But then when you eliminate this shitty person who's
- 49:25just shitty for the for the fact of being shitty, that you know,
- 49:31these randomly drawn countries breakdown into sectarian tribal like warfare and we have no solution
- 49:40for it. Right, We're like, we don't like you, so you're
- 49:44gone and everybody left over. Sorry about that, but hey, you don't
- 49:49have a dictator anymore. Right. Yeah. I've struggled with this too,
- 49:53because I am I think it's probably pretty challenging to like look back at the
- 50:00past generation of US foreign policy decision making and think that we've done a good
- 50:04job. You know, it's been not great and significantly worse than the generation
- 50:10of foreign policy making decisions that that sort of came before it. And so
- 50:17I don't quite know why that is. And I think, I mean,
- 50:21Sirio is symptomatic of that, where you look at you say Okay, well,
- 50:23guys, you know, you don't have to be a genius to look
- 50:27at that and the con sectarian makeup of this country and to do a quick
- 50:30breeze through how the security services are organized to kind of understand that, like,
- 50:37this thing isn't going to break well. You know, so maybe we
- 50:43should be more thoughtful about, you know, or at least more cognizant that
- 50:49it's been designed that if you break it, it's going to explode and destroy
- 50:53the country. You know, that was a thing that was known inside you
- 51:00know, the intelligence community at the time, was like, you can't rip
- 51:02this thing apart without a significant amount of bloodshed. Now we could debate whether
- 51:07that's worthwhile to you know, achieve some political outcome, but like it's not
- 51:12going to go well. I mean, all you had to do is look
- 51:14at the way that rock broke and say like, well, okay, this
- 51:17is going to be a huge mass. And there's some sort of willful blindness
- 51:21to that that I I'm still not quite sure where it comes from or why
- 51:24it's persistent for so long as you as you talk about this, you know,
- 51:30I have to wonder if there isn't an aspect the cynical as I am
- 51:34about about you know, the real politic of things, but that there's maybe
- 51:38an ideological bent at the White House. I mean, you're you know,
- 51:42Obama would give that quote about you know, the arc of history moves towards
- 51:46truth or something like this, and it sounds like that's what you're saying,
- 51:51that there's this this idea that we could step aside in history would move in
- 51:53the right direction towards democracy. Yeah. I think that was a significant part
- 52:00of it. I also think, you know, you look at the I
- 52:04think you know that that administration and particular came in and said like, we
- 52:07don't want any more problems in the Middle East, please know, And uh,
- 52:15I think there was this sort of this like knee jerk, like you
- 52:19know, like let's just do nothing. Well we had just pulled out of
- 52:23a rack too, which right, right, yeah, And and there was
- 52:29probably you know again it's like, yes, we should not be spending you
- 52:36know, we should not be spending eighty percent of our national security decision making
- 52:42time on this region. That's a mistake. We're over rotated, right.
- 52:47But you also, but that doesn't mean that we can just sort of and
- 52:53I think, I mean ultimately where I where I fault them, because I
- 52:57wouldn't you know, I don't envy the decisions they had to make, and
- 53:00I don't think that Syria like there was no clinging answer here from the get
- 53:06go period. But you know, it's it's sort of willful ignorance to just
- 53:12basically run the policy as a communications policy and kind of let everything else Jesus
- 53:20drag behind it in a really sort of, you know, incoherent and flaccid
- 53:27manner, like you just can't drag all the other elements of policy behind combs.
- 53:31That's I think what the mistakes. So as that that incoherent, flaccid
- 53:36policy played itself out, you have the rise of Isis they bust across an
- 53:40international border into Iraq, wager genocide against the Yazdes and sing Jar start moving
- 53:47towards Baghdad. Now we have what we would probably call in the military a
- 53:53clusterfuck a full blow signical term, cluster a shit sam which once again in
- 54:01that region. And as we discussed this, I think one of the other
- 54:07important things to talk about is I don't know what your view is, I'd
- 54:13like to ask you, but I get the sense that there was some conflicting
- 54:16missions because there was, on one hand, the removal of the Assad regime.
- 54:22There's a regime change program, but there was also a counter Isis program,
- 54:28and so now we are trying to remove the government, but also the
- 54:32group that is also trying to remove the government, like, whoa, what
- 54:36the hell are we doing here? And I mean, I want to copy
- 54:38at that by even saying, you know, and to some degree we could,
- 54:46because you mentioned the Salafis right that that the regime had released and suddenly
- 54:52these people who ostensibly orchestrated nine to eleven, right, this, this group
- 55:00of Islamic fundamentalists are now our allies in the region, and we're and this
- 55:07is pre isis, and we're arming them and giving them the weaponry that you
- 55:14know, that to to overthrow a side or bashir and they're like, oh,
- 55:21maybe we'll go this direction instead, Right That that I mean, is
- 55:28that is that accurate? That that? I think I think we were.
- 55:35I mean, look, you know, it's it's a it's a war zone,
- 55:38it's a civil war, so there's going to be mess around where things
- 55:44end up and all of that. All Right, that said, I think
- 55:49we were careful about ensuring that we were not linked up with you know,
- 55:58salafijihatas of the global bent let's say, which I think in this context in
- 56:01Syria is an important distinction, and it is one that is often kind of
- 56:07lost in the conversation. It was like there was a distinction between groups that
- 56:15were of that, you know, a very sort of conservative studdhism is bent.
- 56:20But we're you know, not at all thinking about attacking Europe, our
- 56:27allies, US, you know, outside of Syria, like they were prosecuted,
- 56:30that there would be Islamic nationalists like the Muslim Brotherhood or even the shaban
- 56:35As opposed to waging external loops, and those groups existed in Syria, right.
- 56:40That was That's that was a real dynamic in the war from you know,
- 56:45pretty early on. But I do think that and this and this is
- 56:51you know, just the reality of this conflict was like, I mean,
- 56:57was there ever an opportunit community to really create an alternative to ASA that would
- 57:04have been palatable to us though that could have taken power Intomascus controlled most of
- 57:08the country and administered the place in a way that was like friendlier to our
- 57:13interests, you know, I mean, man, that is it's hard for
- 57:17me to imagine it really is. And you know, you know, I
- 57:24think Jack, to your point, like the the ct I actually give us
- 57:30higher marks on the ct mission, right, because we were much more coherent.
- 57:37Like the Syria policy when Isis started to become a much more significant issue,
- 57:44sort of broke into two pieces. Was like, you know, sort
- 57:46of the anti regime policy, which was an incoherent mass, and the anti
- 57:53Isis campaign, which you know, we you know, you talk about all
- 57:58kinds of problems there, but like was much more coherent in its objectives and
- 58:02in its resourcing. We had, you know, a tremendous gap between rhetoric
- 58:07and resourcing on the regime side, the anti regime side. I think on
- 58:12the counter Isis side, that gap was much narrower, Right, We were
- 58:16resourcing a fight to achieve an objective of diminishing the territory and influence of the
- 58:22Islamic state. But the series of policy effectively kind of became a kind of
- 58:29risis policy, and the regime stuff just kind of pilled away in my opinion,
- 58:34over that period of time, because it was also getting to the point
- 58:37where it's like you know, as you know, that sort of corresponded with
- 58:40the Russian intervention in the fall of twenty fifteen, Asad starts to retake ground
- 58:47on the backs of Russian air power, and it becomes pretty clear by you
- 58:52know, sixteen or seventeen that he's not going anywhere, in my opinion,
- 58:57and that's why the counter regime program's kind of you're saying, they just sort
- 59:00of faded away naturally over time as this became sort of an unrealistic option.
- 59:07I think. So, I don't know, and again I don't think we
- 59:08ever really said that, right, I mean, you know, it just
- 59:12sort of became more or less a fact of our policy that like, okay,
- 59:17we're just gonna I honestly think something collectively happened in said the National Security
- 59:22BROCNCY, where everyone just kind of threw their hands up and said, you
- 59:24know what, like it's too hard, Well, I mean, anything with
- 59:30it. The big inflection point, I mean, didn't it come after Gauda
- 59:35and some of the chemical weapons attacks and Obama was talking there's there's this talk
- 59:39about the red line, and and there were things that got there. There
- 59:44were the machinery of the US government in the Department of Defense. I was
- 59:47ready to go in and drop the hammer. Yeah, and I mean Obama
- 59:52took that kind of like famous walk in the Rose Garden with his National security
- 59:57advisor and came back and said, no, we're not going to do it.
- 1:00:00Yeah, that's right. Yeah, I do think that that was an
- 1:00:04inflection point for sure. I mean I think there was that August of August
- 1:00:08or September of thirteen after the attack in Duma, and yeah, you know
- 1:00:15that that is another great example of just the sort of hey, here's that
- 1:00:20is the primary example of we said this thing, and we did just just
- 1:00:23like we just didn't. We just didn't do anything. And you know that
- 1:00:28one is I think particularly agree just to me, because we didn't have to
- 1:00:34remove the regime. We we could have just punished it, which is what
- 1:00:38militarily Trump ended up doing early in his presidency. Yeah, like we could
- 1:00:43have done that, you know, multiplied by ten and said this is what
- 1:00:49happens, don't do it again. You know, you it again. It's
- 1:00:52going to be five times worse than this, And we chose not to for
- 1:00:58reasons I still I still struggle with. And so I let's see pushing the
- 1:01:06conflict forward, we get to that twenty sixteen twenty seventeen time frame, now
- 1:01:12the US military is in northeastern Syria, linked up with the the SDF,
- 1:01:19you know, the Kurds that we've cobbled together into this Arab alliance. How
- 1:01:24did things start to you know, move how did this conflict evolved from an
- 1:01:29American foreign policy in even you know, defensive strategy standpoint. Well, I
- 1:01:37mean, so at that point things were pretty cantonized, right, I mean,
- 1:01:43you effectively had like the idea that Syria would sort of be reconstituted in
- 1:01:47the near term as like a functioning political entity was basically gone. The regime
- 1:01:53was still very weak relative to you know, pre uprising, but kind of
- 1:02:00coalesced into you know, the most powerful militia in the country. And you
- 1:02:07had what i mean five external powers that were you know, intervening in some
- 1:02:15form or fashion on the regular you know, US, the Israelis, the
- 1:02:20Iranians, the Turks, the Russians. So you know you ended up,
- 1:02:29i mean, my frame for the conflict at some point sort of became like
- 1:02:34this is just a bunch of warlord fiefdoms and it's not useful. It's like
- 1:02:42the concept of Syria like is ceasing to be a useful analytic construct, Like
- 1:02:47it's just a bunch of you know, mafioso groups that are fighting over populations
- 1:02:54and resources with the help of different foreign backers. And you know, we
- 1:03:05you know, I think our presence there in that time periods still made some
- 1:03:08sense in the counter Isis mission. And you know, this is maybe not
- 1:03:14a help, like there's probably some problems with this analytical frame, but like
- 1:03:17I kind of look at the very small number of Americans that we had an
- 1:03:22Afghanistan that sort of supported this broad there was this broader architecture of like elite
- 1:03:29cohesion and political will to do things that was bucked up by having us there.
- 1:03:32And I think having a small number of Americans up in the Northeast like
- 1:03:37sort of does the same thing for many of our partners. So there,
- 1:03:39you know, I sort of see their being continued value in that. But
- 1:03:45you know, we effectively came to a point where the Syria policy is articulated
- 1:03:51by really both the you know, sort of the Trump and the Biden White
- 1:03:55houses kind of became you know, at some point I saw something it was
- 1:04:00like five or six different kind of policy objectives and it's like this, there's
- 1:04:03almost so much here that there's nothing and it's just on this kind of autopilot
- 1:04:09of let's make sure, let's make sure there isn't some kind of like catastrophic
- 1:04:15terror attack in Europe or in the United States that emanates from this place,
- 1:04:20be at Isis or be at some of the sort of you know og al
- 1:04:24Qaida guys who took up roots there in the Northwest, and you know it
- 1:04:31it really just kind of sputtered, It sputtered out of the headlines. I'm
- 1:04:34sure it has sputtered out of like significant you know, the number of like
- 1:04:41Deputies Committee and Principles Committee meetings in the White House on Syria in the past,
- 1:04:45you know, a few years. I'm sure it's has gone down to
- 1:04:46nothing. It's it's really I don't know, it's it's on one sense,
- 1:04:53it's just it's sort of like analytically very difficult to come up with anything useful
- 1:04:58to say on like what we should you And you know, it's just like
- 1:05:00it's everything is just kind of sputtered out in a very sort of profoundance into
- 1:05:05a status quo. Yeah, yeah, exactly where I you know, I
- 1:05:11think at some point the regime, you know, the regime will probably continue
- 1:05:14to CLAWBAXT some parts in like the northwest and whatnot, and maybe eventually in
- 1:05:18the northeast, you know, if we decide to leave, and if they
- 1:05:20can reach some kind of deal with you know, with the Kurds up there,
- 1:05:26which both of those things would would feel pretty reasonable to me. But
- 1:05:30I think that, you know, the Syrian regime is a very patient entity,
- 1:05:35or the militia that used to be known as the Syrian regime, it's
- 1:05:39a very patient entity, and they'll just kind of wait. I mean,
- 1:05:41I think it's a generation of waiting for them, and I mean I think
- 1:05:46you touched upon it. But before moving on, I mean, is that
- 1:05:49how you see our presence? Why are continued American military presidence presence in northeast
- 1:05:56Syria? To your mind, it's about maintaining that at this quote, about
- 1:06:00assuring some of our allies, and about ensuring that there aren't external ops directed
- 1:06:05out of Syria. Yeah, that's how I see it at this point.
- 1:06:09Yeah, you know, I think, and I think relative to the amount
- 1:06:15of you know, blood and treasure that's been expended, it feels to me
- 1:06:19like it's a pretty reasonable invest But at this point, and it's kind of
- 1:06:25I don't know, it's one of those things where you look at it and
- 1:06:27you say, well, it could be a lot worse. Right, There
- 1:06:30could be a lot you know, there could be external attacks plan from Syria
- 1:06:34regularly right there. You know, you could have a situation where, you
- 1:06:39know, the Islamic state or rumb elements of it begin to take more tears.
- 1:06:43So there's there's all kinds of sort of bad outcomes that I could imagine
- 1:06:47if we did not have a small presence there. That to my mind,
- 1:06:50sort of if I'm putting my you know, my policy maker shoes on,
- 1:06:55it probably continues to justify us have that presence there. I also think that
- 1:07:00I bet if you took a poll amost Americans and asked them, you know,
- 1:07:03do we have troops in Syria right now? I do wonder if people
- 1:07:10my senses, most people, I mean, they wouldn't know where Syria was
- 1:07:12in the map. And then B would probably say say no, they're all
- 1:07:15they're all in Ukraine now or something crazy like that. You know. So,
- 1:07:19And as for you personally, as your career went on in the in
- 1:07:23the agency, how did you feel about all these developments one thing after the
- 1:07:29next as we slide into this sort of from this sort of fantastical thinking about
- 1:07:33regime change and democracy to the sort of like status quo. I don't want
- 1:07:39to use the term frozen conflict. It's not that, yeah, but it
- 1:07:42is a status sort of a status quo conflict from an American point of view.
- 1:07:46Yeah, you know, it made me really sad actually mostly, and
- 1:07:51it honestly, it was one of the reasons why I started writing the thing
- 1:07:55that became Damascus Station the first book, was because you know, I had,
- 1:08:00like I had lived there at that point. I'd spent most of my
- 1:08:02young adult life at that stage working on this country and thinking about it,
- 1:08:06and a lot of friends who were Syrian and like, it just made me
- 1:08:11really sad because the human elements of it. You know, we talked about
- 1:08:16that analytic trading up front and our conversation, like you're sort of conditioned when
- 1:08:23you're writing at the agency to like strip a lot of the humanity out of
- 1:08:27things and to just report report things from a higher level, right, Like,
- 1:08:31like that human element the emotions that come with it are not you know,
- 1:08:35they're they're they're not encouraged in the writing. And when the war became
- 1:08:44this kind of when it became clear it was going to be this long,
- 1:08:46bloody kind of grind, and that you know, we were more interested in
- 1:08:54prolonging the suffering of the Aside regime than we were in resolving the conflict.
- 1:09:00I mean, I don't think we were in a position to resolve the conflict,
- 1:09:04but I think we got to a point where effectively we said, look,
- 1:09:08there needs to be more violence, so the regime comes to the table
- 1:09:11to stop. You know, just as a person as a human, I
- 1:09:15kind of, you know, with some skin in the game in the country,
- 1:09:17and obviously a lot less skin than any Syrian had, but with more
- 1:09:21than most Americans. Man, I was just like pretty frustrated and really kind
- 1:09:30of wrecked by it. And so when I left, you know, I
- 1:09:33just kind of started to I started to write as a way to kind of
- 1:09:38deal with that, because at the at the kind of heart level, it
- 1:09:42just didn't really it stops kind of sitting well with me. And there was
- 1:09:45a point where it became a little hard to kind of just maintain that you
- 1:09:49know, thirty thousand foot view, like just the facts kind of perspective,
- 1:09:55because it just felt like, oh, well, you know, we're going
- 1:09:58to have just millions and millions of people who are to get displaced in this
- 1:10:00whole country is going to get rec all, the infrastructure is going to be
- 1:10:02destroyed, It's gonna get taken over in pieced out by the worst warlords and
- 1:10:09psychopaths in the game here. And you know, the people who suffer going
- 1:10:13to be all the normal people who are like, hey, I just want
- 1:10:15to go and work at the bakery and you know, sell cars and like,
- 1:10:20you know, just do all the normal stuff and go to school.
- 1:10:23And like it's just all those people who are the ones who end up being
- 1:10:28you know, the sort of the collateral damage and these kind of conflicts,
- 1:10:31and it just kind of made me sick. And what you're with that that
- 1:10:35you you left? I left in fourteen Okay, yeah, now out of
- 1:10:42curiosity, like not defending a sad because a sad like Saddam like Tito,
- 1:10:50like they're they're shitty human beings, right, They're like they're not good people.
- 1:10:56But were those people in those you know, villages and those outlying areas
- 1:11:00outside of the regime terror were were were they still able to like live their
- 1:11:06lives prior to the warlords, like before the uprising started? Or yeah,
- 1:11:15yeah, I mean, it was it kind of like it wasn't. I
- 1:11:24mean, for a lot of people, it was pretty desperate, right,
- 1:11:29But it wasn't this. It wasn't And that's not being off in the town
- 1:11:33square, right, right, And well, and yeah, you didn't have
- 1:11:38half the population displaced, and you know, you didn't have a ninety percent
- 1:11:42poverty rate, and you didn't have you know, two hundred and fifty billion
- 1:11:45dollars of infrastructure damage or any of these kind of things. But you know,
- 1:11:51the thing that I I think one of the most sad things about this
- 1:11:57is that you look at the way society was sort of divided, and you
- 1:12:02look at the way the regime was constructed, and there is a certain inevitability
- 1:12:11to the violence and chaos and the destruction of like you can't you know,
- 1:12:16hafe Zalasa designed his government so that you couldn't just like exercise him and the
- 1:12:21family and the country continues to function and you put better people in and then
- 1:12:27you're rolling Like he designed it so that you couldn't do that without an extreme
- 1:12:31level of violence, and that most people understood that, so that they didn't
- 1:12:36do it right. So, you know, but I struggled with this idea
- 1:12:42of like there was a certain inevitability to the way this went down, or
- 1:12:46at least you would have said it's probably the most likely outcome, right,
- 1:12:53And on the one hand, and then on the other hand, you look
- 1:12:56at the people who came out to protest early on, who were essentially asking
- 1:13:06for dignity in a system that deprived them of that, and that kind of
- 1:13:13contrast is just, I think, really a devastating one because you look at
- 1:13:18the reasonableness and the humanity of a lot of those of those people right who
- 1:13:24are like, hey, I just don't want to have to get approval to
- 1:13:29get married from the local head of the political security directorate, or I don't
- 1:13:33want to pay bribes to add a second floor to my home that will impoverish
- 1:13:40my family and I need that space in order to sort of house my kids.
- 1:13:44Like you could not legally work, you can not get a passport,
- 1:13:50yeah, I mean, yeah, it's so, you know, and we
- 1:13:56see this and again, I mean, I think Iraq as a great example
- 1:14:00in the sense of Saddam was horrible, his sons were horrible. Like the
- 1:14:05things that they've done to the courage to their own citizens. It's well documented.
- 1:14:12We know about it. And then you know, when we look at
- 1:14:16a regime like Assad, when we look at these regimes like what particularly in
- 1:14:25the Arab world, I think because we do have the Salafi kind of hanging
- 1:14:30out in the wings right, like ready the salafis what like for you,
- 1:14:39with your experience and your knowledge, if we were to rewind time and you
- 1:14:45were the king of America and could make the decisions, do you do you
- 1:14:50think there were right or wrong decisions to make in that area? Yeah,
- 1:14:57I think think that we Boy, you know it is it's the absolute hardest
- 1:15:03question to answer. I think there was probably a period of time that was
- 1:15:11like the first six months where and again, you know, I think from
- 1:15:17a I struggle with I struggle with answering the question because on a geostrategic level,
- 1:15:21when you look at serrior, like not from a human level, but
- 1:15:27from the strategic like, is it worth it? Right? Like, is
- 1:15:30it worth the amount of attention that we pay on a country that at the
- 1:15:34time, you know, it's twenty two million people, they don't have mucleately
- 1:15:36weapons, they don't have oil. They have geography that matters, right,
- 1:15:41But that's that's kind of it. So I struggle with whether we would ever
- 1:15:46be able to really effectively resource something that's like, hey, let's help create
- 1:15:49a political alternative to the to the regime that exists. But I think there
- 1:15:56was a period in those first six months where we may have had an opportunity
- 1:16:04too, you know, more effectively support the protest movement and to create try
- 1:16:15to create you know, some kind of coalition inside the region and in Europe
- 1:16:21that could have done more to support peaceful protest in the country and to try
- 1:16:29to create you know, some kind of you know concession, some kind of
- 1:16:35structure where there might have been concessions from the regime or you know, at
- 1:16:40least cultivating that protest movement. I think we could have done more. But
- 1:16:45as soon as it went violent and started to get really violent, kind of
- 1:16:50that fall into the you know, early twenty twelve, so like eight to
- 1:16:55twelve months down the road from when the protests first started, you know,
- 1:17:00there just weren't there weren't institutions. There weren't institutions in the country, groups
- 1:17:04in the country. That's that that we could have really probably affect, like
- 1:17:10supported to affect change that would have been amenable with our interest, that would
- 1:17:15have been really hard, and it's hard for me to imagine what that could
- 1:17:16have looked like for sure, But I think more could have been done early
- 1:17:20on. But would it have led to a different outcome? I don't know.
- 1:17:25I just think that we could have done more well. And you know,
- 1:17:29like sometimes when I look at these situations, I wonder where why Assad
- 1:17:34and not Mugabi? Like why aren't we going? Like you know, why
- 1:17:40why do we pick one day? But if they had a substantial protest movement
- 1:17:44against Mugabi, maybe we would have, you know, maybe. But the
- 1:17:48thing is, is it it's it's just a question why do we pick?
- 1:17:53Yeah? Right, you know, why not? Why not me? And
- 1:17:57right? One? One dictator over another, you know, to say,
- 1:18:01oh, this person is a shitty person. Uh, you know, I
- 1:18:06mean look at Gadafi, right, Gadafi was playing ball with us essentially well,
- 1:18:14And you know, I think I think that if Gadafi, if the
- 1:18:16dominoes had gone down in a different order, we I think we might have
- 1:18:21done to Asade what we did to Gadafi or something that that was a sads
- 1:18:26fear, wasn't it? Well it was, and I wasn't the fact that
- 1:18:30Libya wasn't going so well that you know, pretty early that spring was kind
- 1:18:35of like, hey, we're already over rotated here, guys. We can't
- 1:18:39go and do something in Syria. You know, if if Syria had gone,
- 1:18:43if the order had been Tunisia, Egypt, Syria and not Libya in
- 1:18:47there, you know, we might be looking at a very different region right
- 1:18:50now. But yeah, I mean, you know, you're you're points a
- 1:18:56good one, like why why Asad? And you know, why not others?
- 1:19:02And you know, I think I do think there was an element here
- 1:19:06of he was vulnerable. He's vulnerable, and you know there's there are always
- 1:19:14these kind of fever dreams of you know, we're gonna roll back Iranian influence,
- 1:19:19and you know, with him with us that being such a critical Irani
- 1:19:25An ally, I think there was a sense of like, well, we
- 1:19:26can deal the Iranians a blow here, which that that mattered too. I
- 1:19:33think a lot of the people making policy that season for sure. But yeah,
- 1:19:39that when you go back to the Bush administration and say sort of the
- 1:19:43same thing, is it like Iran has never been a friend of ours,
- 1:19:46and Saddam, for for all of his evils and faults, was always an
- 1:19:51opponent of Iran, and yet and yet we're like, oh screw you,
- 1:19:57and and somehow our policy makers because I don't want to see the analysts,
- 1:20:01because analysts I think are brilliant. Like analysts I think see this stuff.
- 1:20:06And whether people pay attention to them or not is you know, is another
- 1:20:13issue. But the whole idea, you know, you talk about our recent
- 1:20:19history, right, our recent administrations, you know, in World War Two,
- 1:20:26it's like if you break it, you buy it. Like we're not
- 1:20:28leaving Germany until Germany is self sufficient. We don't just hand it over like
- 1:20:32in a rock. You go, you go in, you break it,
- 1:20:35and you go, here are you guys? We're not occupiers. We don't
- 1:20:39want to be occupied. This gift of democracy is the gift of democracy.
- 1:20:43We're just going to hang out and help you, but we're not gonna rebuild
- 1:20:46all of the infrastructure. That's right. Well, And I think, you
- 1:20:49know, I think if you dug like Metternick out of his grave, or
- 1:20:55you took some of the guys who helped build the system after World War two,
- 1:20:59you know, and you sat them down and you're like, hey,
- 1:21:01I'm gonna give you like a two hour briefing on us policy in the Middle
- 1:21:05East over the past twenty five years. I mean they would probably leave that
- 1:21:12and be like, you guys are morons, Like what, I don't understand
- 1:21:16fundamentally what you've done, and like it is it's hard. I'm over drastically
- 1:21:26oversimplifying. But you know, as you kind of look back at the ark
- 1:21:28of all this and think about the way that Syria fits into it, you're
- 1:21:30just like, I don't understand, like I do not, I don't get
- 1:21:36it has to be the case that there is some combination here of like this
- 1:21:44region doesn't matter all that much to us. Really, we can't be you
- 1:21:50know, I would say low marks for the sort of humans who have been
- 1:21:55making most of the policy over the past two generations on this, you know,
- 1:21:59so like or the past generation on this, like they haven't done a
- 1:22:01good job. And you know, we're also sort of profoundly enamored with this
- 1:22:08region, so there's sort of these fantasies about it that make us behave in
- 1:22:15very irrational way stop and go irrational ways of like we're disengaged or you know,
- 1:22:21we've got we're fighting, you know, told time, Yeah, right,
- 1:22:27make up our mind. Yeah, So David, you left in twenty
- 1:22:30fourteen. And what I mean, did you have this idea that you wanted
- 1:22:35to go and be a spy novelist right off the bat, or was there
- 1:22:39another another job? I mean, presumably you didn't go back to being a
- 1:22:43cashier at Wendy's. I mean, what what was what was the next step
- 1:22:45off for you? Dust off the old red apron and go back into the
- 1:22:49business. I no, I left and took a consulting job and the thing
- 1:23:00that became Damaska Station. I started writing, like I basically had three months
- 1:23:04after I left the agency, four months after I left the agency to when
- 1:23:08I started that job, and that's when I was just kind of processing stuff
- 1:23:13and writing and it was all very unstructured. It was very poorly written.
- 1:23:19It wasn't I wasn't writing it to be a book, you know, I
- 1:23:24was just kind of writing for me. And you know, I took because
- 1:23:30at the jobs started, I kind of just put that away. And but
- 1:23:33but in that time period I had found like I really love this, Like
- 1:23:36I actually loved writing and I found it and you know, again we kind
- 1:23:41of we talked about that kind of an adyne analytical writing that you do at
- 1:23:45the agency. I felt really like freed from that, you know, for
- 1:23:48the first time in a long time off like I can I can actually write
- 1:23:53with emotion and color, and like I can play around with language, and
- 1:23:56I can play around with I can find my voice and figure out what works.
- 1:24:00And that to me was this wonderfully freeing, fun process where I felt
- 1:24:05like I was really kind of, you know, in in tune with the
- 1:24:11universe. And I loved it. And so I ended up having an opportunity
- 1:24:15after about five years of consulting to take some time off, and I was
- 1:24:19just I was just burned out. And I went back to the manuscript and
- 1:24:25I reread it, and I'm like, Okay, this sucks, but you
- 1:24:30know, I want to rediscover that magic. And I think I would like
- 1:24:33to write a spy novel, like I'd like to actually try, Like it's
- 1:24:36just all to see if I can do it right, like write something that
- 1:24:41I want to write, and write something that somebody else might want to read.
- 1:24:44And so I kind of came back to it, I think, with
- 1:24:45space, with maybe more maturity on the writing side, to think about how
- 1:24:50do I actually craft a story that someone wants to consume? And then frankly,
- 1:24:54some distance from Syria, where I wasn't just like dealing with it.
- 1:24:59I could, I could kind of harnessed that emotion that was still there,
- 1:25:03but I could use it in service of the characters in the story. And
- 1:25:09so I you know, in those six months, I just started to go
- 1:25:14back to the to the writing, and Damascus Station, you know, kind
- 1:25:16of by hook and by crook came out of it. So, I mean,
- 1:25:21the in the book really is beautifully written and has this sort of like
- 1:25:26authenticity that really I think could only come from somebody who you know, lived
- 1:25:30in Syria and also has an intimate familiarity with the Central Intelligence Agency that really
- 1:25:36comes through in this book. Do you want to tell the folks out there
- 1:25:42you know what your book, what Damascus Station is about? Yeah? Sure.
- 1:25:46So it's a story about a CIA case officer named Sam and Hysyrian recruit
- 1:25:55Mariam, who they break a kind of fundamental rule of espionage and and fall
- 1:26:01into this forbidden relationship. They go into Damascus to hunt down the killer of
- 1:26:05another CIA case officer, and in so doing really kind of come face to
- 1:26:11face with the tension and the conflict and the passion and their own relationship,
- 1:26:15but also into conflict with a really pretty brutal pair of Syrian brothers, one
- 1:26:19of whom is also much more than than meets the eye, and these guys
- 1:26:26are kind of guarding this very dark secret at the heart of the Syrian regime.
- 1:26:29So, you know, it became I think, as I wrote,
- 1:26:32obviously it's a Spine novel, so it's about espionage, and I'm trying to
- 1:26:34deal pretty pretty realistically and authentically where possible with you know, the kind of
- 1:26:40not just the tradecraft with the agency, but it's it's ethos, it's culture,
- 1:26:44or what it's actually like to be ACI you know, officer. But
- 1:26:49I hope it's also about kind of love and loyalty and and also like what
- 1:26:54it means to be a human in the middle of a really awful conflict.
- 1:26:58You know. I told the story through the lens of multiple Syrian that took
- 1:27:02multiple Syrian perspectives on this, because I really wanted to try to get down
- 1:27:08to the humanity of like what are actual people doing and experiencing in the war
- 1:27:13and kind of get away from you know, for me, one of the
- 1:27:15cleansing things was kind of getting away from like I don't have to come up
- 1:27:18with the answer on Syria policy or say what we should have done. I
- 1:27:21can just tell a story from the standpoint of different different Syrians in the conflicts.
- 1:27:27So you know, I hope in some sense it's that too. And
- 1:27:30yeah, no, I mean now that you say that, it does jump
- 1:27:33out there. You know, the sort of Syrian protagonist of the book is
- 1:27:39a member of the elite class, maybe doesn't even understand how much privilege she
- 1:27:44has. There's that interesting scene where her and her friend break down on the
- 1:27:46side of the road and are helped out by people who are literally dirt poor,
- 1:27:51and you kind of played that that that culture clash out very well.
- 1:27:58Yeah, no, it's it's funny. That's one of my favorite scenes in
- 1:28:04the novel, because I think that there's this kind of class, you know,
- 1:28:11in central Damascus who they're in a bubble. They're they're all connected to
- 1:28:15the regime in some way, shape or form, and you know, you're
- 1:28:18sort of some of them, are, you know, presumably coming face to
- 1:28:25face with this reality that like there are elements of this being sort of a
- 1:28:29slave society that they're running here, you know, And and how do you
- 1:28:33in the character in the book, you know, like how do you deal
- 1:28:36with that as this very privileged daughter of the elite, who's like not necessarily
- 1:28:42doing anything wrong wrong, you know, but who is elevated above these people
- 1:28:48and in control of them in some way. What do you do when you
- 1:28:54were just sort of dumped into direct, you know, direct direct face to
- 1:29:00face kind of confrontation with them where you're forced to see them as people,
- 1:29:04you know, and not just as the other or these you know, we
- 1:29:08can sort of put them out of these shanty downs and not think about them.
- 1:29:13So, you know, a lot of the book, I mean,
- 1:29:15there's you know, another Syrian protagonist who's a security officer who kind of is
- 1:29:20all be having to wrestle with some of the same questions, but who I
- 1:29:24think comes to a very different set of answers, you know, And something
- 1:29:30that I think our our listeners will be interested in. What caught my interest
- 1:29:34in your book is that part of the plot, without giving too much away,
- 1:29:42part of the plot is that their president gives a lethal finding on somebody
- 1:29:46in Syria word that David's not allowed to use assassination. It's not an assassination,
- 1:29:54it's just a lethal finding. And I thought it was fascinating reading the
- 1:30:00novel about that, like you kind of like detail that entire process, and
- 1:30:06it's a work of fiction, folks, but it was very fascinating. I
- 1:30:11thought to read as you kind of like walk through step by step how that
- 1:30:15takes place from the legal side, from the policy side, and how a
- 1:30:20finding like that gets pushed through to how out in uh you know, the
- 1:30:26Premier Intelligence Services secret facility that we're not allowed to name, where the rehearsals
- 1:30:33for that plot are acted out, and how this conspiracy takes shape and ultimately
- 1:30:40is enacted in Syria. I thought that whole sequence of events was a very
- 1:30:44interesting part of this novel. I had a lot of fun doing that.
- 1:30:48And I think, you know, one of the things that one of the
- 1:30:53things I wanted the book to be again without it becoming boring or pedantic,
- 1:30:58was was a bit of an intelligence perceive droll. You know, I think
- 1:31:00you don't there isn't and this isn't This isn't a knock on the genre in
- 1:31:06the least, but just there's just not a lot of spy fiction that does
- 1:31:11that, you know, And and I when I come across it, you
- 1:31:15know, I enjoy that a lot. So I was kind of writing this
- 1:31:20for my own, you know, nightstand in a lot of ways of like
- 1:31:24I like, I like books that get under the hood a little bit and
- 1:31:27give us the inside baseball and kind of make us wait for the payoff and
- 1:31:30the action because they kind of build to it, and and so I wanted
- 1:31:36to go through those steps because I thought, I think it's really interesting how
- 1:31:43this thing of like okay, okay, we're gonna we're gonna kill somebody.
- 1:31:46There's a whole system and there's there's a whole system of legality and bureaucracy and
- 1:31:54then just sort of like machining like and production that goes into this. It's
- 1:32:00like technicians that have this hyper specific job that we're focused on this one thing
- 1:32:05that's right. And I thought it was I just think it's fascinating. So
- 1:32:09I kind of wanted to do that, do that end to end, and
- 1:32:12I was I was glad they didn't edit too much out. Yeah, I
- 1:32:16mean you did. Uh, you know, people like you that served in
- 1:32:19the agency and even you know, some people might not realize we've read a
- 1:32:23novel that has to go through the PRB, the Public Review Award's right,
- 1:32:27Well, what was that process like for you was it difficult. It was
- 1:32:30actually pretty straightforward. Yeah, you know, I've heard from colleagues who have
- 1:32:35to go through the d D process that it's much harder and just like much
- 1:32:42more disorganized and chaotic and slow. The agency is actually pretty streamlined at this,
- 1:32:46Like I think, you know, I like to think it's because the
- 1:32:48person reading the books maybe just really loves them, but they read them pretty
- 1:32:54quickly and get them back to me, you know, in I don't know,
- 1:32:58under two weeks with pretty reasonable edits both times, like and I source
- 1:33:03them because I'm a little bit OCD, so like Damasca Station went to them
- 1:33:08with like three hundred footnotes or something like that, like, hey, here's
- 1:33:13you know, I because because I worked on Syrian, so with that one
- 1:33:15in particular, I wanted to be buttoned up. So I just said,
- 1:33:18okay, here's you know in this book, this page, here's where I
- 1:33:20got this. So don't you don't have to do a specific thing, like
- 1:33:25you don't have to think it came out of my you know, the classified
- 1:33:28regions in my brain, right and so, and I'm sorry I interrupt you,
- 1:33:30but when you say source, you mean you show them like open source.
- 1:33:36Yeah, you know, the open source like references, so that it's
- 1:33:42I, look, this is already out there in like the public uh,
- 1:33:46you know, in the public knowledge. So I'm saying something that hasn't been
- 1:33:53reported on or that's right. And like one one fun example that I think
- 1:33:57I actually had the book back here, like there's a there's a there's a
- 1:34:00being in the yeah it is. So there's a book by Sam Dagger called
- 1:34:03Asad or We Burned the Country, which is a good history of the war
- 1:34:10and has he's got some great sources inside the Syrian game. And there's a
- 1:34:15thing in there about how assa because Asad's a philanderer and he sleeps with the
- 1:34:19wives of other members of the Syrian elite to kind of demonstrate his his control
- 1:34:26over the system, and that that's sort of been a pattern and that's a
- 1:34:30specific fact. It's referenced in the book. And I wanted to make sure
- 1:34:35that, like the PRB isn't like, oh my gosh, where did this
- 1:34:38you know, where did this come from? And so it's like, okay,
- 1:34:41well it's on you know, page one hundred and thirty five of Sam
- 1:34:43Dagger's book footnote you know, you can find the book here's here's the page
- 1:34:48number, here's the title. All that and that tends to that that's an
- 1:34:53effective way to kind of make sure that, like I'm separating the classified regions
- 1:34:58of my brain from what's available in that was actually like a major plot point
- 1:35:01in one of Mark Granny's books about about Syria. Was it really yeah,
- 1:35:08as Melvis true, as Melbrook says, it's good to be the king and
- 1:35:15the other the other thing. You know, So I read your your forthcoming
- 1:35:17novel as well. We'll talk about in a moment, but I wanted to
- 1:35:21talk for a moment about the commonalities between these two books because when I think
- 1:35:26of your work, at least that I'm familiar with so far, the one
- 1:35:29thing that really jumped out at me that where you're really strong is in describing
- 1:35:34the life of a person, like an actual human being living and existing in
- 1:35:41an authoritarian regime. And it's a view that I think is so alien to
- 1:35:46Americans. You know that there there are the views are going to be very
- 1:35:51black and white, not not a lot of nuance in there. You really
- 1:35:56describe these people who are part of the regime, are part of the predominant
- 1:36:00system. They're not necessarily bad human beings, but they are part of the
- 1:36:06system for all the good or all the bad, whatever you think about that,
- 1:36:11they're a part of it, and they're trying to find a way to
- 1:36:15exist in it, just a scape, you know, with without having their
- 1:36:17heads chopped off. Right, Yeah, no, it's I think that that
- 1:36:24is true thematically across both books. And I'll say that neither of them started
- 1:36:29with any intent around doing that. It was just sort of discovered the process
- 1:36:33of discovering these characters and writing them like that, that reality started to become
- 1:36:42very clear to me. So, like in the Syrian example, you know,
- 1:36:45there's two primary characters, Mariam and Ali, who are having to deal
- 1:36:50with this idea of like, hey, I don't I might actually be very
- 1:36:54privileged. There might be a lot of things that I have in the system,
- 1:36:58but my level of sort of age and see, it's pretty limited,
- 1:37:02and my ability to sort of exist as a human like morally is compromised before
- 1:37:14I've done anything, you know, before I've before I've actually made a choice.
- 1:37:18There's that line in the book that like we're chained to Asad's throne or
- 1:37:23something like that, right, yeah, yeah, no, And I think
- 1:37:28I think that is true in the Syrian system. And you know it was
- 1:37:33when I when I came to Russia for Moscow X. Like again, I
- 1:37:39didn't start with this idea of like I'm going to tell a story about living
- 1:37:42in an authoritarian system. But my my major Russian character named Anna is a
- 1:37:47Russian intelligence officer. She works for the SVR, Russia's Foreign intelligence service,
- 1:37:51and she works effectively as a knock for the SVR. What they would call
- 1:37:56there all butcher of the Russian if I say it, but they call it
- 1:37:59the apparatus of attached employees. So it's basically she's a an SBR officer who's
- 1:38:04a banker. And I was really struck as I just started to kind of
- 1:38:12do research on not on like high level questions of Russian policy and history and
- 1:38:17whatnot, but like what is it what's it like to be a Russian?
- 1:38:20You know? And I was really struck by this concept of like the wily
- 1:38:28man. I don't know if you've heard about this, this way of characterizing
- 1:38:31kind of Russian interactions with the state of It's just so the parallels to Syria
- 1:38:40were very profound because again it's it's it's an authoritarian system. Same as Syria.
- 1:38:45It's obviously a different cultural context and a different system in a lot of
- 1:38:47ways, but you have this feeling of like how the state sort of just
- 1:38:53is. It's both extremely predatory but also worthy and eternal, and you know,
- 1:39:05I sort of especially in Russia, you have this idea of like,
- 1:39:10Okay, well, I'm not really going to protest. I'm going to be
- 1:39:13very patient, I'm not going to resist. I'm just going to kind of
- 1:39:16adapt to the system. And i have kind of a passive displeasure or even
- 1:39:25like a mockery of the system, but I'm not going to demand kind of
- 1:39:30like full rights and freedom in the way that we would define it. And
- 1:39:35I think there was like there's like just this idea of I'm trying to eke
- 1:39:42out for myself inside this very messed up kind of double speak, double think
- 1:39:48world, and I'm going to try to get what I can, and that's
- 1:39:57kind of it. So so you have these little moments where people are asserting
- 1:40:01their own dignity and their own humanity, but it's far short of how we,
- 1:40:10you know, as Americans, would define kind of a full measure of
- 1:40:13freedom an agency, and so the character you know, especially this on a
- 1:40:18character in Moscow X is like she's coming at the world with that as her
- 1:40:24starting point, like like she's not trying to be free in the way that
- 1:40:29we are. She's actually there's a line in the novel about how when she
- 1:40:32finally sort of I don't want to spoil anything, but she basically says,
- 1:40:35like, you know, I've stolen from a thief and I'm going to get
- 1:40:39away with it, and like that's the win, Like I you know,
- 1:40:43like you're a thief, I'm taking from you. That's my victory. Right,
- 1:40:48everybody's getting their own, so I'm going to get mine too. That's
- 1:40:53right. That's right, And fundamentally, in a system that's unjust and a
- 1:40:57moral is there any such thing as breaking the law? Like like like breaking
- 1:41:02the law like that? Like is that is that? Is it a moral
- 1:41:05to break the law in an a moral system? You know? Tough questions.
- 1:41:12I mean, you know, the one day in the life of Ivan
- 1:41:14Denis the Bitch, they're asking those questions, you know, in the Gulag.
- 1:41:17But but I feel like that's an ethical question for every citizen of every
- 1:41:20country, Like when ye right, wouldn't you believe that laws or certain laws
- 1:41:28are immoral or whatever else. The rather commonality between the two books is that
- 1:41:33the character Artemis, yes, who is in So these books exist in the
- 1:41:40same in the same world very much. Uh So Artemis in Damascus Station is
- 1:41:45like, in my opinion, a batshit cos uh you would not want to
- 1:41:49work for which? Which? Which is a real thing? Yes? Yes,
- 1:41:53fair, fair, fair, that's fair. And then in Moscow X,
- 1:41:57she's leading this you know, this special access program called Moscow X that
- 1:42:00you guys will read about when the book comes out. Who is Artemis based
- 1:42:06on? I mean, I'm not I'm not looking for a name, but
- 1:42:10here you are spilled the team, we got it. We can handle it.
- 1:42:16So initially, like all all my characters have started, like when I
- 1:42:23start to write them, I write, I write scenes, and I write
- 1:42:28Baxter and dialogue stuff that I know is probably not going to be in the
- 1:42:30finished product, to like just kind of get to know the character. And
- 1:42:34most of them start as composites of actual people. And I will not give
- 1:42:40the names because if I gave the names for Artemis Proctor, I know I'm
- 1:42:44not asking down and I would be hunted down and murdered and I want to
- 1:42:47stay alive. But there are a couple case officers that informed her character,
- 1:42:55uh and and kind of started like as I was initially crafting her and initially
- 1:43:00writing her, like I was thinking about them, and so I just kind
- 1:43:03of started riffing with with that a compositive a couple female case officers that I
- 1:43:09knew, and like any good character that's gonna work in fiction pretty quickly,
- 1:43:17Yeah, that composite got left behind. She became her own entity with her
- 1:43:23own voice, and we were just kind of off to the races. But
- 1:43:29she was a character you couldn't deny. That's right, Yeah, exactly.
- 1:43:33I mean, and most of the most of the good ones are because they
- 1:43:35just start to like, Okay, I can kind of hear I know what
- 1:43:40she sounds like, I know what she says, you know, like I'm
- 1:43:44I'm in communion with with wherever she exists in the universe, so like I'm
- 1:43:47moving her onto the page. That But but she is a good vessel for
- 1:43:56a lot of great stories that I have gotten from DO colleagues over the years,
- 1:44:01like like the most unshamed crazy stuff that you get, you know,
- 1:44:08from listening to stories from these guys, Like and there's a lot of crazy
- 1:44:12stuff she is because she is so she's some combination of like competent and also
- 1:44:18deranged. She's a great sort of you know, mouthpiece for a lot of
- 1:44:24that stuff. So talk to us about Damascus X, the book is coming
- 1:44:29out next month. What is what? What is this novel about? Because
- 1:44:32it's a totally different subject than Damascus Station. Did I say Damas So?
- 1:44:38Yeah, that Freudian set. Damascus X was a real thing in real life
- 1:44:42when you guys got booted out of Syria and you were living in another place
- 1:44:45for a little while. Moscow X the book that's coming out in October.
- 1:44:51What what's that? What's this novel about? Yeah? So I am.
- 1:44:57I started with a concept and you know, we can talk about how real
- 1:45:00events have sort of I mean made writing this thing very hard because I started
- 1:45:06and I said, okay, what what would it look like if from a
- 1:45:11covert action standpoint, the CIA really took off the gloves against Putin. That's
- 1:45:15kind of where it started, is like, what's from a from a CIA
- 1:45:17standpoint? What what can we do? So the book, you know,
- 1:45:20Moscow X is a fictional component inside the real Russia house that's kind of charged
- 1:45:25with this outside the box pretty aggressive approach to dealing with Russians, and the
- 1:45:30idea that comes out from some measure of sort of you know, geopolitics,
- 1:45:35but also pro Artemis Procter's personal green events, is to convince Vladimir Putin that
- 1:45:44a coup is a flipped when one is not, and to destabilize or sort
- 1:45:49of weekend, you know, his regime. Accordingly, so the agency taps
- 1:45:56two officers under non official cover, commercial cover. One one is a lawyer
- 1:46:00in Europe. The other one runs a family thoroughbred horse sort of breeding and
- 1:46:06dealing operation in Mexico to go and actually target and recruit one of Putin's money
- 1:46:14men to get access to some of his personal funds. The money man is
- 1:46:17married to a woman named Anna who we talked about her earlier, who is
- 1:46:23an intelligence officer at the CIA. Doesn't know that, and she's also just
- 1:46:26sort of playing her own game entirely. And the book is really the cat
- 1:46:30and mouse between the agency and between Anna and Vadi and her husband. And
- 1:46:38you know, as I wrote it, it kind of became the story of
- 1:46:40like vengeance and what does it mean to tell the truth? What does identity
- 1:46:48look like in a world where you're most of the most of the intelligence officers
- 1:46:54in the book are under pretty exotic forms of cover that are very demanding on
- 1:46:59humans, and so like what does identity look like in that world? And
- 1:47:02then you know, what does what does all of that look like in kind
- 1:47:05of the real context of the sort of covert war between Washington and Moscow.
- 1:47:12So that's that's what the book's about. And again, our listeners out there
- 1:47:16will be very interested in this book that it's about Knox people who are working
- 1:47:20on a nonofficial cover and again the it's fictionalized, but the procedural aspects of
- 1:47:27that and like maybe how something like that kind of sort of works, including
- 1:47:31like the national resources side of it, how you bring American citizens into maybe
- 1:47:38a COVID action program. I mean, there's a lot of stuff in this
- 1:47:41book that I think people will be interested to read. Yeah, I am,
- 1:47:46I agree, I hope so. And you know, it was it
- 1:47:50was it was fun to deal with the commercial side of the house, the
- 1:47:54commercial cover side of the house here. You know, for a couple of
- 1:47:56reasons. One was just the reality of trying to write. You know,
- 1:48:00the demands of a story and fiction are such that like if you have if
- 1:48:04a big point at the novelist a relationship between the intell pace officers and assets,
- 1:48:10like they need to spend time with each other. And if you're writing,
- 1:48:14if you're writing a story about agency operations in Russia and you're using officers
- 1:48:20who are under like embassy cover, you know you're not spending a lot of
- 1:48:24FaceTime with Russian assets inside Russia in that context. Right when you strip away
- 1:48:31the sort of you know, diplomatic cover side of it and talk about Knox,
- 1:48:35like, you know, from standpoint of fiction, you're in a much
- 1:48:39more flexible world where things that wouldn't be possible in kind of the world of
- 1:48:44Damascus Station fast forwarded to Russia are all of a sudden possible. And then
- 1:48:49you know kind of more I guess technically as you kind of look at the
- 1:48:55way that human intelligence is being collected and will be collected in the future because
- 1:49:00of you know, ubiquitous technical surveillance all that kind of stuff, Like it's
- 1:49:02increasingly challenging for people who are under sort of official forms of cover to even
- 1:49:08do this stuff anywhere. So you're you're starting to, you know, see
- 1:49:12this kind of flexibility or a need for this kind of flexibility in the way
- 1:49:15the CI runs human intelligence gathering operations, and I think playing around with that
- 1:49:18and this book was was a lot of fun. So the book comes out
- 1:49:23next month. I assume it's got to be up for pre orders now if
- 1:49:26people want to go and grab it, I think it's gonna be. I
- 1:49:30think it's gonna be a big hit. I enjoyed Moscow X more than I
- 1:49:33enjoyed Damascus Stations, So that's good. I think I'm glad to hear that.
- 1:49:38Yeah, yeah, yeah, it uh, it was harder to write.
- 1:49:45It nearly killed me, but I'm I'm really happy with how it with
- 1:49:51how it turned out. And I think I don't know, I don't know
- 1:49:56who talked about Jack. I think there was some like gunplay. I think
- 1:49:59in Damascus Station that that sort of broke you towards the end, because I
- 1:50:01just I you know, there were some moments I was wondering, this has
- 1:50:05come up on our show before, and I was wondering if if Jack sent
- 1:50:09you any hate mail about about weapons. He didn't send me any hate mail,
- 1:50:14No, he just he was He gave an honest he gave an honest
- 1:50:16review of Damaska Station. If I recall yeah. I mean, I thought
- 1:50:19it was a really good book. There are there's a couple scenes of the
- 1:50:24female protagonist going rambo that were a little bit I was like, oh my
- 1:50:28gosh, those are fun to write. Though. Yeah, no, that's
- 1:50:31yeah, that's fair, And I think there's probably marginally less of that in
- 1:50:38this novel. I think my sort of sensibility when it comes to these stories
- 1:50:41as I like, I like to push that a bit like I'm trying.
- 1:50:46I'm not trying to do the full shoot him up thing, which is wonderfully
- 1:50:50entertaining but totally divorced from reality. And I'm also not trying to do the
- 1:50:55full kind of you know, well many procedures. I will I will.
- 1:51:00I will also say, you know, David, because I mean, you
- 1:51:02are really a really talented author, and if you were to do a book
- 1:51:05that was more looking at either the agency, paramilitary arm and that side of
- 1:51:12things, I would be very very interested to read that as well. Like
- 1:51:15if you were to write a book more in that direction or the or the
- 1:51:19Jaysock Agency collaboration, like I would be I would be all in for that.
- 1:51:24If you will just make sure Jack gets a chance to look at it,
- 1:51:27because you will get the hate mail about the wrong caliber of weapon,
- 1:51:31like I hit up Mark Rainey. Yeah, that's that's what I was thinking
- 1:51:34about again, that was that was an advanced copy. I was like hoping
- 1:51:38he could fix it before it was published. Yeah, Well, do you
- 1:51:43have a writing process? Did you develop one? Do you know the end
- 1:51:46of your book when you start? So, uh, it's been you know,
- 1:51:54I feel like my process is a total mess, and I just don't
- 1:51:58I don't think there's a better, a better way for me to do it,
- 1:52:00because I've experimented with like outlining, and I found that doesn't work for
- 1:52:04me at all. So what I've done, or where I've sort of landed
- 1:52:11is I usually start with an image in my head of the climactic scene in
- 1:52:17the novel, like where all of the tension is going to build too and
- 1:52:21sort of where it's going to explode. With Damasca Station, it started with
- 1:52:28an image of people. It literally started with an image of a couple sort
- 1:52:32of face to face in a serial interrogation center, which is what happens in
- 1:52:38the book. And then in Moscow X, it started with the image of
- 1:52:42a woman riding away from a burning house on horseback, and that was it,
- 1:52:47And so I was like, how do I get there? And the
- 1:52:51whole process of writing the book was like trying to get to that scene.
- 1:52:59And I didn't know, Like the woman on horseback, I didn't know what
- 1:53:01her name was, I didn't know she was Russian, I didn't know whose
- 1:53:04house it was. But I was like, I felt that that was where
- 1:53:09the book should get to, and I started to write with that in mind.
- 1:53:15The story actually started. This is why it's such a mess. The
- 1:53:17story started in Texas, and it was gonna the whole novel was going to
- 1:53:20take place in Texas. And I wrote about seventy five hundred pages of that
- 1:53:27and it didn't work, and I just threw it away and started over.
- 1:53:30I guess I wasn't right, So I usually start with that image. I
- 1:53:36started to play around with the characters, you know, and try to understand
- 1:53:41voice and kind of who they are and all of that. But then I'll
- 1:53:45just kind of Usually what I do is I try to get about two thousand
- 1:53:48to three thousand words in a day, and I'll show up with the coffee
- 1:53:54shop. I always write from a coffee shop, same coffee shop, usually
- 1:53:58the same table, same cup coffee, and I'll sit down after drop the
- 1:54:03kids off in school, all right until lunch. I'll eat lunch, I'll
- 1:54:08get another cup of coffee, all right in the afternoon, get those three
- 1:54:12thousand words in. It's a good day, and you know, I just
- 1:54:16you just knock it out that way I usually end up writing. I would
- 1:54:20say, if the novels are somewhere around one hundred and twenty five thousand words,
- 1:54:26I probably write about five hundred thousand words to get the novel. And
- 1:54:32you know, I don't know how to do it another way. The comparison
- 1:54:36I like, or the sort of analogy I like to use is like,
- 1:54:42if you're gonna put together a thirteen or fourteen track album, you know you
- 1:54:46didn't write thirteen songs. Probably you wrote thirty, right, those were the
- 1:54:53tracks that made it, you know, And so it's it's hard to know
- 1:55:00what the final thing is going to be unless you write a lot more.
- 1:55:02And like, you know, I sort of play around with it that way
- 1:55:04and figure out where I'm going to get the most punch, and it's it's
- 1:55:11you know, I've sort of I've finished the third one now and and I'm
- 1:55:16kind of putting the final touches on that and you know, like I have
- 1:55:23started each of them thinking it will be easier this time because I've already written
- 1:55:26books and it hasn't gotten easier yet. Let's just put it that way.
- 1:55:30What's KEYTS book three at all? Yeah, it's it's a sort of modern
- 1:55:35homage to Tinker Taylor. So it's a legit mull Hunt in the CIA.
- 1:55:43It's Proctor in the sort of George Smiley role, and uh yeah, it
- 1:55:51was. It was. It was very fun to write because it's really it's
- 1:55:56really more her like, it's kind of her story. And the working title
- 1:56:02right now is the seventh Floor, so the you know, CI executive floor.
- 1:56:08But that one is pretty much done and hopefully cool. Have some news
- 1:56:14on when that will come out, you know, hopefully pretty soon. That's
- 1:56:17awesome, man, we'll have you on when when that book is out or
- 1:56:21coming out? Great. Anything else that you want to tell people about,
- 1:56:28anything that we failed to cover here tonight, I don't think so. I
- 1:56:32mean we hit a lot. This is fun, guys, This is really
- 1:56:35fun. Thanks thanks for having me on. It's fun to I'll go back
- 1:56:39and relive Syria and talk about the books. This is great. Where where
- 1:56:43can people find you, where should they go and look for your books?
- 1:56:46Yeah, so you can. You can find me at David McCloskey books dot
- 1:56:50com. That's my site. You can find the books pretty much anywhere.
- 1:56:55I mean, you know, you can put m on Amazon and get them
- 1:56:58on Target, Walmart. If want to support your local indie bookstore, which
- 1:57:00is always something I recommend, and go to Indie Bound and find a local
- 1:57:04indie near you and they'll hook you up with the book. You can get
- 1:57:09it on you know, Apple Books, and you can get it anywhere.
- 1:57:11The audio book is not up for pre order yet, which is kind of
- 1:57:15frustrating, but it'll be up very soon and it'll be out, you know,
- 1:57:18shortly after the release. So for those of you know, those listeners
- 1:57:24who just do audio books, that's that's coming and you'll be able to pre
- 1:57:27order that really soon. And for our viewers and listeners, they'll be able
- 1:57:30link down the description for people want to go and check out his books.
- 1:57:33I also want to give a quick shout out to our friends at Kassa Karabeo
- 1:57:40who make gave us some really awesome cigars that don Nello Torpedoes are really good.
- 1:57:45If you go to Kassa Karabeo dot com. You'll be able to check
- 1:57:48them out really enjoying their stuff. I'm we have a few questions, op.
- 1:57:55Actually, first off, the sent me an email that he picked up
- 1:57:58and chat. Someone chat asked if the book you were referring to is called
- 1:58:03Psychology of Intelligence Analysis by Richard J. Howard. There you go, There
- 1:58:10you go, that's it. Yes, somebody nailed it. Somebody nailed it,
- 1:58:15is there. There's got to be another analyst out there watching or something
- 1:58:17like that. That's exactly right. That's exactly right, Paul, Thank you
- 1:58:24very much for the genation. I don't see a question if there If there
- 1:58:27was a question to ask that, please just type in the chat right now
- 1:58:30and we'll pick it up olms. Thank you very much. Cheers. And
- 1:58:35a couple from our patron subscriber subscribers. How would you explain TikTok to the
- 1:58:42everyday person and why they should be worried? Oh? Man, Uh,
- 1:58:50I don't know if I feel qualified to answer that question. Uh so,
- 1:58:57I don't. I mean, I guess everyone should probably be worried in large
- 1:59:03part because it's highly addictive and it's like wrecking people's brains and capacity to focus
- 1:59:09on information. So that's one element of it, I mean, on the
- 1:59:13other side of it, And again I don't. You know, there are
- 1:59:16far more authoritative sources than I on this, but you know, I don't
- 1:59:21have a great sense of like how much of this information. I mean,
- 1:59:25maybe you guys know the answer better than I do. It was like actually
- 1:59:27harvestable by the Chinese, and uh, you know, you have to think
- 1:59:32about who you're giving that information too. But I don't have a I don't
- 1:59:34have a highly educated answer on this other than I don't. I don't.
- 1:59:39My reasons for not using it are purely because I already find my attention fragmented
- 1:59:44and I feel like I would prefer to not give it to cat videos and
- 1:59:48other such nonsense. I mean, friends don't let friends do communism. Folks
- 1:59:53are great, but yeah, I think that like one of the discoveries about
- 1:59:58TikTok. Obviously, Facebook and Google they're all they're all horrible in terms of
- 2:00:03what they collect personally, But I think TikTok was actually you were getting it
- 2:00:10wide wide permissions to access a lot of shit on your phone that it wasn't
- 2:00:14even connected to. Yeah, and look, I mean it's it's like it's
- 2:00:19like twenty three. Well, I won't say any genetic information, but you
- 2:00:25know, it's like, you know a lot of these, you know my
- 2:00:30heritage tests, you know where you can get your genetics. It's like the
- 2:00:33Chinese own most of those. And you can say, I'm a nobody,
- 2:00:38it doesn't matter. But at the end of the day, maybe it matters
- 2:00:42to your grandkids, you know that that Yeah, that's that's right, that's
- 2:00:47right. I mean, yeah, yeah, I'm just I'm glad I don't
- 2:00:55have I I have not. I know. It's a number of authors who
- 2:00:59use them for like book promo and stuff like that, and I've so far.
- 2:01:03I mean, maybe it's more out of sheer laziness, but I have
- 2:01:05so far stayed off the stayed off the talk. Yet do it call me
- 2:01:11Ishmael. Do you think that the Intelligent community correctly managed to start of the
- 2:01:16Russo Ukrainian War or do you think there was a credibility problem that led to
- 2:01:20missed opportunities? I mean, with the caveat that, I you know,
- 2:01:31I haven't been reading any of the actual intel on that, right, I'm
- 2:01:34just sort of reading what kids leaked out and what's available publicly. I don't
- 2:01:39know. I mean, it felt to me like I would give the administration
- 2:01:45and the I see pretty high marks from the standpoint of we knew it was
- 2:01:51coming and we effectively, you know, I think largely effective sort of leaked
- 2:02:00information or provided information into the public sperience allies to like demonstrate that that was
- 2:02:05going to occur. So relatively high marks there from sort of a plans and
- 2:02:12intentions standpoint, Like, it seems like the assessments were pretty good. Again,
- 2:02:16I'm not reading them. What I have seen again from leaks about like
- 2:02:24our assessment of the Russian military's capabilities and the Ukrainian you know, military's capabilities,
- 2:02:30doesn't seem like the analysis there has held up so well. That's an
- 2:02:34inherently harder question to answer, right because you're talking about the dynamics of a
- 2:02:40war. But that feels like it was sort of missed. But again,
- 2:02:45you know, I'm I'm looking at this from way on the outside, and
- 2:02:47I'm coming at a lot of this from the standpoint of, you know,
- 2:02:49researching a novel, right, not not writing policy papers for a think tank.
- 2:02:56But so I think I'd say relatively high marks on kind of what's putin
- 2:03:01up to and then not as great on what will the dynamics of the conflict
- 2:03:06actually end up being. I mean, it seems like we dramatically underestimated the
- 2:03:11Ukrainians capacity to resist and organize and fights, and we overestimated the Russians.
- 2:03:17You know. I think there's sort of this kind of tendency. It's as
- 2:03:21either of you the Russians is like completely incompetent or all knowing and all capable
- 2:03:29and you know, the answers you know, somewhere in between U. And
- 2:03:33it seems like we didn't. We didn't get that right out of curiosity as
- 2:03:39an analyst, Uh, you know, were you did you ever feel as
- 2:03:44though you were ever that you were ever under political pressure, whether it was
- 2:03:47from an administration or from internally in the agency to provide answers that somebody else
- 2:03:57wanted? You know? The first thing I'd say on this one is like
- 2:04:05the agency, at least on the analytics side, I think we're generally really
- 2:04:10does take politicization seriously, or at least it did. I don't know now,
- 2:04:16but like they beat that into you right off the bat of like you're
- 2:04:20speaking truth to power, You're going to speak up if you know, someone
- 2:04:25you know says something that's wrong, Like and I was in meetings with you
- 2:04:29know, director Portrayus where like very junior people would like contradict him, you
- 2:04:34know, and say things that that he didn't agree with, and you're like,
- 2:04:41that's that's positive. Right. There's something in sure sort of bloodstream of
- 2:04:44the organization that's that's pushing people to do that. So you know, that
- 2:04:50was always very serious, and like if someone raised issues around politicization like that
- 2:04:55got noticed, like that you didn't want to be involved as a manager and
- 2:04:59like a comp linked about that. I do think that there were sort of
- 2:05:02subtle forms of it, Like it was because of that overarching structure, the
- 2:05:12way that policy, the way that the you know, the White House would
- 2:05:16sort of influence things was a little bit more of like, okay, let's
- 2:05:23take this, let's take us out staying power as an example, Like,
- 2:05:27it wasn't that a piece would be rewritten to say that he will fall.
- 2:05:32It was that things would get watered down through the writing of the PDB,
- 2:05:38and oftentimes when things got to like the DNI kind of level, they would
- 2:05:42be mushified to either say nothing or to sort of soften the analysis so that
- 2:05:51you could kind of ignore it or interpreted in different ways, or things would
- 2:05:58just be kind of maybe more omit, like pieces that were very clear and
- 2:06:01hard hitting and I think substantiate it would sort of be like, oh,
- 2:06:04well, you know, maybe that's just not going to go into the PDB.
- 2:06:08Yeah, because there's only like ten articles that'll get in anyway, and
- 2:06:12there's always something else that could rise to the top. So maybe that's just
- 2:06:15not going to be there. Maybe that's going to go to you know,
- 2:06:17the senior director for the Middle East and North Africa. But you know,
- 2:06:20it's it's it's not going to go to the president, you know, that
- 2:06:24kind of thing. So it's and trying to understand why that was being done
- 2:06:31was impossible, you know, like, is it is it? Is it
- 2:06:33really because we got bumped because there was a more important China piece that needed
- 2:06:38again in the book, or are you looking at this and saying, oh,
- 2:06:42this is a stinker. Like I don't want to go into the oval
- 2:06:44with this thing, because then someone's gonna yell at me or we're gonna have
- 2:06:47an argument, and I don't want to do that because I want to continue
- 2:06:50to get invited into the oval. It was always hard to tell, you
- 2:06:55know, as an analyst, so you had to tread very carefully before you
- 2:06:59started to say, okay, that's that's politicization. But I think I think
- 2:07:02there were I think in total you saw that on the serious side of things,
- 2:07:10there were We knew that there were analytic lines that the administration just didn't
- 2:07:15want to hear well and not and maybe not just the administration, you know,
- 2:07:18not pointing it, you know, any president or their administration, but
- 2:07:23even and even inside the because the agency isn't this monolithic thing. It's made
- 2:07:29up people who want to get promoted, yeah, and and have different motivations
- 2:07:35for why they're doing what they're doing. So yeah, I'm not necessarily like
- 2:07:42calling out the administration for anything, just that I was just curious as to
- 2:07:48was there, Like you said, you know, there was there. Things
- 2:07:51might be get watered down. Somebody didn't want to be the very bad news.
- 2:07:56I mean, even with Channa. Now we hear that either on the
- 2:07:59bank of they're on the brink of bankruptcy and b they are ready to take
- 2:08:03over Taiwan and create but it's also two things can be true. Yes,
- 2:08:13yeah, that's right, that's that's absolutely right. Two things could be true,
- 2:08:16and you know, like you have you can have people who just for
- 2:08:24very like it's it's not like a nefarious right, I'm trying to silence the
- 2:08:28analysts like that wasn't going on. It's more like, hey, you know,
- 2:08:33if I'm the you know, d d N I, and I'm the
- 2:08:37one who's kind of in charge of the PDB, and I'm the one going
- 2:08:39and I'm the one giving the briefing man, you know, and there's some
- 2:08:43real human tension there between bringing bad news and having access. You know,
- 2:08:48like you sort of have you have to be really thoughtful about how you kind
- 2:08:52of meter that out because you can't you can't be bringing pieces every day that
- 2:08:56are like slapping the administration Syria policy and the you know, like there's just
- 2:09:01gonna be a limited tolerance for that, and eventually they're gonna be like,
- 2:09:03we don't want this guy to come here anymore, like send us somebody else,
- 2:09:07you know. So I you know, I think when you get down
- 2:09:13to that human level, it starts to become less nefarious and much more just
- 2:09:16like someone someone's trying to do their job and kind of get by you.
- 2:09:24What is your perspective on sportwashing by Saudi Arabia. Should US sports fans attempt
- 2:09:28to push back and Saudia Saudia influence or control over domestic league's teams, or
- 2:09:35just except that it's that it's inevitable. Well, I mean I could.
- 2:09:41I don't know what we do about it. I can tell you that I
- 2:09:43just I find it sort of kind of gut wrenching and sicketing in general,
- 2:09:50just to have them buy all this stuff off. I don't really have like
- 2:09:54much of an analytic basis behind any of that, other than just you know,
- 2:09:58I'd preferred not have all these like wonderful athletes purchased by Saudi Arabia.
- 2:10:05Yeah, but I don't know. I mean, what do you do about
- 2:10:09it? I don't. I don't know. I haven't. I haven't thought
- 2:10:11about it much. It just kind of gives me a knee jerk sick reaction
- 2:10:16to see it happening. Yeah, like I'm all fault any of the athletes
- 2:10:20for doing it, because it's like this is crazy amounts of money and all
- 2:10:22this kind of stuff. But yeah, it's just it's frustrating. It kind
- 2:10:26of actually gives me the same sickening feeling like and there's a minor analogy,
- 2:10:31but but it sort of says it speaks to the same thing of like when
- 2:10:35I look at I'm a big baseball fan, right, and when you look
- 2:10:41at what's happened to the game with just things like the name, the way
- 2:10:48that stadiums and ballparks are named now and all have corporate, corporate names attached,
- 2:10:52or the way that sort of gambling has now totally infused the life of
- 2:10:58the sport. Like there you're watching LabTV and they've got all these like parlays
- 2:11:01up on the screen and stuff like that. It's like, I don't like
- 2:11:05this stuff intruding into the game. And I understand why it's doing this,
- 2:11:13and I understand that it's important to the economics game, but you kind of
- 2:11:16wish at some point that like some corporation would be like, it's our civic
- 2:11:20duty to help sponsor this stadium, but it doesn't mean that we have to
- 2:11:24call it, like, you know, Progressive Field, Like we can continue
- 2:11:28to it can continue to be called Jacob's Field, but we're going to support
- 2:11:31it because like we're a citizen of this city, right, And I think
- 2:11:35I feel a similar sort of like nature of like I want to see the
- 2:11:37Saudi stuff of, Like I understand why this is the case, and I
- 2:11:43really wish that these like beautiful games weren't just bastardized by you know, corrupt
- 2:11:48corporate and political entities. Yeah, and then why do you think Arab spring
- 2:11:56fell short? And judging by events in the could the same spring happened here
- 2:12:03but for the wrong reasons? I don't know if I want to touch that
- 2:12:07the latter part of that one. I think, I mean, the Arab
- 2:12:22Spring didn't I mean it? Yeah, I think failure is probably right,
- 2:12:28although I would say that it was very like the way it came out was
- 2:12:31very uneven, and it depended a lot on the sort of political context in
- 2:12:37the system and the structure of the society in which those sort of mass kind
- 2:12:41of uprisings occurred. Right. Things shook out very differently in sort of you
- 2:12:48know, one man or one family sort of presidential republics quote unquote than they
- 2:12:52did in like constitutional monarchies. Right, So things came out very differently and
- 2:12:58like Jordan, you know, and and in Bahrain even than they did in
- 2:13:05like Syria, right, and in Libya. But what I would say is
- 2:13:11like in terms of just not getting to really any kind of solid kind of
- 2:13:16democratic outcomes in any major Arab state. I mean, I would say,
- 2:13:20look, you're talking about generating a couple of generations now of a region that
- 2:13:26is extremely uninstitutionalized, dealing with massive socioeconomic issues, youth bulge, you know,
- 2:13:39issues with educating and just kind of getting people into jobs, like all
- 2:13:43these kind of major systemic problems. You have a tremendous amount of sort of
- 2:13:48you know, geopolitical rivalry inside this region between different between largely like a sort
- 2:13:54of Saudu led camp and a Irani and camp. So you have all these
- 2:13:58like structural problem It's like those things like trying to get to some kind of
- 2:14:05stable democratic order in a system like that is like almost impossible. So you
- 2:14:13know, that'd be what I'd say, Like, it's just the deck was
- 2:14:18completely stacked against any country getting to a much better outcome, and not not
- 2:14:26by like millennia of history, but just by like the last couple of generations
- 2:14:31of the way this this region has developed. Yeah, I mean basically since
- 2:14:33since Westerners redrew the or drew up the country lines. So a lot of
- 2:14:39times, yeah, I mean drew up the country lines, like I mean
- 2:14:43the way that, uh, it's an extremely militarized region that also lacks a
- 2:14:48lot of like institutional structures and processes that kind of limit conflict and things like
- 2:14:52that. So it's like, you know, you're not You're not in a
- 2:14:56and it's a it's a region that has that has dealt with a huge jimahana
- 2:15:00of external and intervention by great powers too, So you're like, you're not,
- 2:15:03You're not dealing with like a great Petrie dish here for a for a
- 2:15:07democratic experiment. You know. A couple more questions came in Jackson, thank
- 2:15:13you very much. Ever interact with ground branch guys, any plans for ground
- 2:15:18ground branch specific novel? Do it? I mean like I'd be interested in
- 2:15:24doing it. I didn't have much interaction with them when I was on the
- 2:15:28inside, to be honest, So it would be I would have to I'd
- 2:15:33have to lay some real groundwork in source networks and things like that to actually
- 2:15:37understand how it all functions. But I would, I mean, I would
- 2:15:41be very open to doing doing a book that that focused there. I imagine
- 2:15:46there'd be a tremendous amount of material and it'd be a lot of fun to
- 2:15:48do, so very open to it, but no plans as of now.
- 2:15:52Uh and M Corbyn, thank you very much. Thoughts on CCP's means of
- 2:15:56waging war by ever means up to actual confrontation with US military apparatus, Oh,
- 2:16:07the idea that the way the CCP is waging war on the US,
- 2:16:13do you think it'll ever mean or lead up to an actual confrontation with your
- 2:16:18military? And just whatever your answer is, if we ever do or don't
- 2:16:26go to war with the CCP, people will quote this saying you people will
- 2:16:30go back. Yeah, this is going to be a very important piece of
- 2:16:33the historical records. I need to think, well, we'll live in shame
- 2:16:43or on or based on your answer right now? Man, I feel like
- 2:16:46this has been a very casual and fun interview up to this point and now
- 2:16:50it's not anymore. It always gets here though, like where we are,
- 2:16:56got you journalists at the best three drinks later here we are Oh, man,
- 2:17:01I mean I like, uh, I mean, I guess the answer
- 2:17:05is I don't know. But then beyond that very useful answer, I would
- 2:17:09say it would seem it would seem to me like there will be some like
- 2:17:18if I were, if I had to put money on it, right,
- 2:17:20it seemed like we're headed that direction, right, And you're not talking about
- 2:17:24in the next five years or twenty years or one hundred years, but it's
- 2:17:28it seems it's going there. It's going there. Yeah, like it just
- 2:17:33think structurally, you have a country that's like, hey, we would prefer
- 2:17:39to write more of the rules, and East Asia you're doing that right now.
- 2:17:45And how is that conflict going to be resolved? You know? So
- 2:17:50it seems like it's probably coming And I don't know, I don't have no
- 2:17:54concept of what form it will take or anything like that. But you know,
- 2:18:01if I had to, if I had to wage or I would think
- 2:18:03that would happen in the next you know, generation or so for sure.
- 2:18:09And that is the end of the questions. Uh, somebody asked about a
- 2:18:15chicken. No, I'm just kidding. No, Uh, that's it all
- 2:18:22right. So yeah, thank you David for coming on the show. Man.
- 2:18:26I appreciate it. Yeah, thanks for having me, guys, this
- 2:18:30was fun. I really appreciate you having me on. And next Friday we're
- 2:18:33gonna have Brent Tucker on the show, former Delta operator, So we hope
- 2:18:37to see you guys. Then Monday, we don't we have some Monday d
- 2:18:43We have a Patreon bonus episode sometime next week. We're gonna figure out a
- 2:18:46day. Okay, Yeah, I'm not gonna be able to come in Monday.
- 2:18:52And uh uh Moscow relation and Damascus X Damascus Station or Damascus Station of
- 2:18:58Moscow. Uh sorry, the MASCO Station of Moscow X. Yeah, but
- 2:19:03but read them. Uh you'll get the nitty gritty like real stuff from real
- 2:19:09people. I mean, that's what more can you ask for? All Right,
- 2:19:11guys, Amen, So we will see all of you next Friday.
- 2:19:16Take care of everyone.