Latest / Murder Files Unsealed / 9 Notorious Michigan Men Who Terrorized and Killed Women

Transcript

9 Notorious Michigan Men Who Terrorized and Killed Women · Murder Files Unsealed

0:00
Speaker 1: The deep dive is open. We are embarking on a
0:03
really focused examination today, looking at materials that detail some
0:07
truly dark chapters in Michigan's modern history.
0:10
Speaker 2: Yeah, we often think of Michigan, you know, the Great
0:12
Lakes state, beautiful shore lines, the auto industry, resilient people.
0:17
Speaker 1: Absolutely, that's the image, right, But the sources we've gathered,
0:20
they force us to look at something else, what we're
0:22
calling the Michigan paradox.
0:24
Speaker 2: Exactly. Beneath that surface of sort of Midwestern reliability, there's
0:30
this really consistent, devastating history male violence targeting women, leaving
0:36
deep scars over what six decades.
0:39
Speaker 1: Now, it's a long time, and we're tracing this pattern
0:41
of predation that well, it moved all across the state.
0:44
Speaker 2: It really did. From college towns you know, ann Arbor Ipsilante, Yeah,
0:48
places you think of as progressive hubs.
0:50
Speaker 1: Right to the big industrial centers like Detroit, Lancing right
0:53
and even out into quieter rural areas like Muskegon. It
0:57
wasn't confined to one type of place.
0:58
Speaker 2: And when you look at the victim as you see
1:00
this chilling pattern emerged. The killers were examining, they ruthlessly
1:04
exploited specific vulnerabilities.
1:06
Speaker 1: How so, what kind of vulnerabilities are we talking about?
1:09
Speaker 2: Well, sometimes it was the perceived anonymity of college students,
1:14
maybe hitchhiking co eds back in the day. Other times
1:17
it was the deep marginalization of sex workers, especially in
1:20
areas hit by urban decay.
1:22
Speaker 1: And sometimes it wasn't even about as specific vulnerability like
1:25
that was it. It was just women living their.
1:27
Speaker 2: Lives exactly, jogging, working a late shift at a gas station,
1:32
even sleeping in their own homes. They were just there.
1:35
Speaker 1: And the core insight here, the thread running through all
1:37
these sources, it's this consistent, almost mechanical dehumanization of women,
1:43
reducing them to targets objects of violence. It's deeply disturbing.
1:47
Speaker 2: It is so our mission today. It's pretty clear we're
1:50
doing a deep dive into the documented cases of nine
1:52
of Michigan's most infamous male killers who specifically targeted women.
1:56
Speaker 1: And let's be clear, this isn't about, you know, sensationalizing Crome.
2:00
Speaker 2: No, not at all. It's about extracting the systemic lessons.
2:04
We're looking for, those overlooked warnings, the biases maybe in
2:07
how investigations were handled, the failures in the justice system,
2:10
the parole system, things that allowed these horrific sprees to
2:14
happen or to continue for so long.
2:16
Speaker 1: And the guiding principle for us and hopefully for you listening,
2:20
is that the names of the victims Mary, Jane, Martha, Jessica, Rebecca,
2:23
and so many others, they deserved the focus. Their memory
2:27
is what matters far more than the perpetrators.
2:30
Speaker 2: Absolutely, And to really understand where this kind of widespread
2:33
public panic, particularly in certain eras, came from, we kind
2:36
of have to start back in the late nineteen sixties
2:39
early seventies, right where.
2:40
Speaker 1: That seemingly safe, idyllic image first started to crack the
2:44
college towns precisely.
2:45
Speaker 2: That's where the facade really shattered first.
2:48
Speaker 1: Okay, let's start there. Then the Ipsilente Ripper, also known
2:51
as the co ed killer, John Norman Collins. His crimes,
2:55
they didn't just solve murders. They created this atmosphere of
2:58
terror that really changed things, didn't especially around campus life.
3:01
Speaker 2: Oh completely. It marked the end of a certain kind
3:04
of perceived safety, particularly for young women in higher education.
3:08
And what's so crucial about Collins is the sheer deception. Mean, well,
3:13
here's this guy, John Norman Collins, twenty two years old,
3:16
studying at Eastern Michigan University, studying elementary education.
3:20
Speaker 1: Of all things, wow, elementary education, Yeah, clean cut kid,
3:24
fraternity member.
3:25
Speaker 2: By all the social cues of the time, he looked
3:27
completely trustworthy, non threatening, and that facade that was his
3:32
most powerful weapon.
3:33
Speaker 1: But behind that facade, between July nineteen sixty seven and
3:37
July and nineteen sixty nine, he carried out what became
3:40
known as the Michigan Burders that's.
3:41
Speaker 2: Right, a spree that claimed at least seven young women,
3:44
mostly college students, are recent high school grads, abducted, usually
3:48
at night. Ages range from what thirteen to twenty.
3:51
Speaker 1: One so young, and his method it was.
3:53
Speaker 2: Calculated and brutal abduction, rape, and the murder usually strangulation
3:57
or stabbing. The bodies were often utilated and then dumped
4:01
in rural parts of Washingtaw County, oh is in that area,
4:03
almost always within a pretty specific fifteen mile radius of
4:07
the EMU and UM campus areas. And finding them, you know,
4:10
farmers or just residents stumbling upon them, that just amplified
4:14
the shock and the fear.
4:16
Speaker 1: The sources mentioned specific cases that really show that shift
4:19
from maybe a missing person worry to outright terror. Mary Flesser,
4:24
nineteen years.
4:25
Speaker 2: Old, Right, She vanished just walking home and when her
4:27
remains were found weeks later, decomposed, partially skeletonized, signs of
4:32
a severe beating.
4:33
Speaker 1: It was horrific, and the crime seemed to get more complex, Yeah,
4:37
or maybe more brazen like j Mixer.
4:39
Speaker 2: Yeah. Jane Mixer twenty three, a University of Michigan law student.
4:43
Her murder scene was different. It seems staged. She'd been shot,
4:46
which wasn't his usual method up to that point, and
4:48
stockings were placed around her neck like a message. It
4:51
felt like it a direct, almost theatrical assault on the
4:53
community's sense of security. It shattered any illusion that you know,
4:57
being smart or coming from a certain background could protect you.
5:00
Speaker 1: And the reaction you mentioned panic.
5:03
Speaker 2: Seismic is the only word for it. The whole culture
5:05
on campus and really in the surrounding towns, it changed.
5:08
Overnight hitchhiking that was common, then it stopped completely oka
5:13
just like that, campuses became ghost towns after dark. The
5:17
sources talk about students creating buddy systems. Women started carrying
5:22
weapons for self defense, mace, knives, whatever they could get.
5:26
Speaker 1: You could see the fear.
5:27
Speaker 2: You could literally see it. There was graffiti showing up
5:29
warnings like another woman will die tonight. The fear was palpable.
5:33
Speaker 1: And behind this panic you mentioned an institutional failure. What
5:37
was that?
5:38
Speaker 2: Well, here's the really critical part, the systemic lesson. Collins
5:42
had actually been interviewed by police quite early on after
5:44
the second murder, and they dismissed him. He didn't fit
5:47
their profile of what a killer like this should look like.
5:50
Too clean cut, too normal.
5:52
Speaker 1: The wholesome student facade worked on the police too.
5:54
Speaker 2: It absolutely did. This instant dismissal based on a biased
5:58
profile allowed him to continued killing unchecked for months. It
6:02
speaks volumes about the investigative assumptions of that era.
6:06
Speaker 1: Assuming the predator has to look like some kind of
6:08
I don't know, obvious outsider I'll get next door.
6:12
Speaker 2: Exactly so his eventual arrest it didn't come from the
6:16
main investigation figuring it out. It came from a tip
6:19
from who his own uncle, who happened to be a
6:21
state trooper. The uncle noticed some scratches on Collins after
6:25
the murder of Karen Sue Beinnemann. She was the last victim,
6:29
eighteen years old, lured from a whig shop she worked
6:32
at the uncle put two and two together.
6:34
Speaker 1: So it was family intervention, not police work that stopped him.
6:37
Speaker 2: Essentially. Yes, Collins was convicted in nineteen seventy got a
6:41
life sentence. But that early failure, the failure to see
6:44
past the facade because of profiling bias, that remains a
6:48
huge systemic flaw highlighted by this case.
6:51
Speaker 1: It cost lives, and that pattern, the lethal facade, it
6:53
doesn't end there. We see it again just a few
6:55
years later, late seventies with Donald Don Miller, the East
6:59
Lansing strangle.
7:00
Speaker 2: Yeah, it's almost like a mirror image of Collins in
7:02
some ways in terms of that deceptive presentation. Miller was,
7:06
if anything, even more embedded in the respectable community. Also,
7:09
he was a graduate of Michigan State University in nineteen
7:12
seventy three, his degree criminal justice.
7:15
Speaker 1: You're kidding, criminal justice.
7:16
Speaker 2: The irony is just staggering. And he worked as a
7:19
youth pastor, used this incredibly wholesome, trustworthy image to hide
7:24
profound psychopathy.
7:25
Speaker 1: And his victims. What is he active.
7:27
Speaker 2: Nineteen seventy seven to nineteen seventy eight, he murdered four
7:30
women in the East Lansing area. It actually started with
7:32
his ex girlfriend, Martha Young, who was twenty one, which.
7:35
Speaker 1: Adds another layer. Right, The link between domestic issues and
7:38
potential serial.
7:39
Speaker 2: Violence absolutely a terrifying precedent. His other known victims were
7:43
Marita Choquette, who worked for the local TV station WKAR,
7:47
and another twenty one year old Christine Heath, But.
7:50
Speaker 1: The sources suggest he might have admitted to more.
7:52
Speaker 2: Miller himself hinted at more victims beyond the four he
7:55
was charged with, and this brings us to the really
7:58
controversial part of his case. The plea deal.
8:00
Speaker 1: Okay, tell us about that, Because four murders, you'd expect
8:04
multiple murder convictions, right, not manslaughter.
8:07
Speaker 2: You would, But it was a bargain accountability, or rather information.
8:12
In exchange for leniency, He struck a deal plead guilty
8:16
to manslaughter for two of the killings, and in return
8:19
he would lead police to the bodies of his victims.
8:21
Speaker 1: Why would they offer that?
8:22
Speaker 2: To give the families closure? Finding the remains is incredibly
8:26
important for grieving families. It's a common, though often agonizing
8:30
calculation prosecutors make. But the result was a sentence of
8:33
only thirty to fifty years which means which means Don Miller,
8:37
despite killing at least four women, becomes eligible for parole
8:41
in twenty thirty one.
8:42
Speaker 1: That's astounding. So the system effectively prioritized closure in a
8:47
couple of cases over ensuring maximum accountability for four homicides.
8:52
Speaker 2: That's certainly the critique raised in the sources. It questions
8:55
how we value cooperation versus the severity of the crime,
8:58
especially when the perpetrator fits a certain model model. The
9:02
idea maybe unconscious that because Miller was educated, articulate, seemed remorseful,
9:07
and cooperated with finding the bodies, the system perhaps give
9:10
him a degree of leniency It might not have offered
9:12
someone else.
9:13
Speaker 1: Even though he committed multiple murders.
9:15
Speaker 2: Right his parole has been denied several times, thankfully, but
9:19
the fact that release is even a possibility in the
9:21
near future it stands as a constant reminder and indictments
9:25
of that initial deal and the failure to prosecute fully.
9:28
Speaker 1: Okay, so we've seen these killers who operated within specific
9:32
communities using deception, But now we need to shift gears
9:36
right to the killers whose violence was more transient.
9:41
Speaker 2: Spread out exactly, the ones who crossed state lines, sometimes
9:44
national borders, making them incredibly difficult to track and connect
9:47
the dots. The scale just explodes with some of these individuals.
9:51
Speaker 1: And the first name that comes up here in terms
9:53
of sheer scale has to be Coral Eugene Watts, the
9:56
Sunday Morning Slasher.
9:58
Speaker 2: Yeah, Watts is arguably Mischi Megan's most prolific killer, maybe
10:01
one of the most prolific in the US period. He
10:04
eventually confessed to over eighty murders.
10:06
Speaker 1: Eighty That number is just it's hard to process. Eighty lives.
10:10
Speaker 2: It is spread across several states, Texas, California, Canada, and
10:14
of course Michigan roughly between nineteen seventy four and nineteen
10:17
eighty two. And we know for sure at least a
10:20
dozen of those were here in Michigan, probably more.
10:22
Speaker 1: What did the sources say about his motivation, his methods?
10:27
Eighty murders, There has to be some pattern.
10:29
Speaker 2: His stated motivation was bizarre and terrifying. He claimed he
10:33
had these violent visions, which he said started after he
10:35
had meningitis as a kid around age twelve. These visions
10:39
supposedly drove him to target women he just decided were evil, parpartrarily,
10:44
completely arbitrarily, his attacks were characterized by extreme frenzied violence. Stabbings,
10:51
usually non sexual, often carried out as the nickname suggests,
10:54
on Sunday mornings.
10:55
Speaker 1: Any other red flags in his background?
10:57
Speaker 2: Oh yeah, classic precursor docus men at History of Animal Cruelty.
11:01
It's a pattern we see flagged in the sources repeatedly
11:04
with these types of offenders.
11:05
Speaker 1: Can we ground that staggering number eighty with some specific
11:09
Michigan victims. It helps understand the reality of it absolutely.
11:12
Speaker 2: Helen Dutcher thirty six years old in Ferndale. She was
11:15
stabbed thirty three times in her own home back in
11:18
nineteen seventy nine. Her toddler daughter witnessed the attack, and
11:22
Gloria Steel, a student at Western Michigan University in Kalamazoo,
11:26
attacked slashed viciously in her apartment in Gaylsburg, just outside Kalamazoo.
11:31
These weren't random street attacks always sometimes he invaded Holmes.
11:35
Speaker 1: Now the Watts case. It also involves a really controversial
11:39
legal decision. Yeah, like Miller, but on a much larger.
11:42
Speaker 2: Scale, hugely controversial. The nineteen eighty two Texas Plea deal.
11:47
Texas authorities were grappling with a string of unsolved murders.
11:50
They suspected Watts committed to close those cases, they offered
11:54
him a deal. What was the deal immunity immunity for
11:57
twelve murders he confessed to committing in Texas in exchange
12:00
for pleading guilty to burglary with intent to murder in
12:03
another case, which carried a sixty years CenTra wait.
12:05
Speaker 1: Immunity for twelve murders to get a conviction on burglary.
12:08
That seems like a desperate gamble.
12:10
Speaker 2: It was an unbelievable gamble with public safety. They essentially
12:13
traded accountability for a dozen homicides to guarantee some prison time.
12:17
But the fallout was almost catastrophic because of parole rules.
12:20
Exactly because of Texas sentencing laws at the time, combined
12:24
with good behavior credits, that sixty year sentence meant Watts
12:28
was going to be released. In two thousand and six,
12:30
a man.
12:30
Speaker 1: Who confessed to eighty murders was about to walk free.
12:33
Speaker 2: He was literally weeks away from release. The only reason
12:37
he didn't get out was a last ditch effort by
12:39
Michigan prosecutors.
12:40
Speaker 1: I did you.
12:41
Speaker 2: They managed to find and use the testimony of Joseph Foy,
12:45
who had been a key witness, though not initially used
12:48
effectively in the Hell and Dutcher murder back in seventy nine.
12:51
Foy's identification decades later was strong enough to finally secure
12:55
a murder conviction and a life sentence for Watts here
12:57
in Michigan, just before Texas released him.
13:00
Speaker 1: So one witness testifying about a decade's old crime was
13:03
the only thing preventing a confessed serial killer from being
13:06
released back onto the streets.
13:08
Speaker 2: That's the terrifying reality. It highlights how these interstate deals
13:12
aimed at closing cases can create massive loopholes. Justice in
13:17
one state doesn't always equal justice overall, especially with transient killers.
13:21
Speaker 1: And even though Watts died in prison in two thousand
13:23
and seven, the suspicion lingers doesn't it that his real
13:27
count in Michigan is higher.
13:28
Speaker 2: Definitely the sources point to three unsolved stabbings in ann
13:33
Arbor in nineteen eighty. Surely Small Glenda Richmond Rebecca grierhuff
13:38
All found dead on Sunday mornings. Fitz his pattern perfectly
13:41
fits it perfectly. The odds are very high Watts was responsible,
13:45
but the evidence maybe dispersed across jurisdictions back then wasn't
13:49
strong enough for charges. His true Michigan toll is likely
13:53
much higher than twelve.
13:54
Speaker 1: Okay. Another case involving transient violence and system failure is
13:59
Gary Ata Taylor, nicknamed the bus stop Phantom.
14:02
Speaker 2: Yeah, Taylor's story is less about plea deals and more
14:05
about a catastrophic failure of institutional custody. His violence stretches
14:09
way back, how far back the nineteen fifties in Florida,
14:12
he was suspected of bludgeoning over a dozen women in
14:15
attacks that got him that bus stop Phantom name in
14:18
the press.
14:19
Speaker 1: But he was acquitted down there.
14:20
Speaker 2: He was, which is how he ended up back in Michigan.
14:22
His violent history eventually led to him being committed to
14:25
the Ionia State Hospital in nineteen sixty one. That should
14:28
have contained him, but it didn't. No, this is where
14:31
the system completely failed. In nineteen seventy two, Gary Addison
14:35
Taylor escaped from Ionia State Hospital.
14:37
Speaker 1: He just walked out. How long was he gone?
14:39
Speaker 2: He was on the run for three years, and during
14:42
that time, while he was supposed to be safely institutionalized,
14:45
he killed.
14:46
Speaker 1: Again how many people?
14:48
Speaker 2: At least four more people that we know of, a
14:50
young couple and two housewives in separate incidents.
14:54
Speaker 1: So his escape directly led to four preventable deaths directly.
14:58
Speaker 2: It's a horrifying example of violent and spanning decades, crossing states,
15:03
and then being actively compounded by a failure of the
15:05
state to securely hold someone they knew.
15:07
Speaker 1: Was dangerous what happened to him? Eventually he was.
15:10
Speaker 2: Finally recaptured in nineteen seventy five. He confessed to the
15:13
murders committed while he was escaped, received a life sentence.
15:17
He was eventually deported. I believe that the damage four
15:20
lives lost because the doors weren't locked properly.
15:23
Speaker 1: Metaphorically speaking, it underscores the immense responsibility and the potential
15:27
consequences when institutions fail in their basic duty of security.
15:31
Speaker 2: Absolutely, and that theme the system failing to keep dangerous
15:35
people locked up connects directly to Victor Malone, the Southfield Strangler.
15:39
Speaker 1: Okay Malone operated mainly in the Detroit area right in
15:43
the eighties, targeting sex workers.
15:45
Speaker 2: Yes, primarily Detroit and the suburb of Southfield in the
15:48
nineteen eighties, and his case is a textbook example of
15:52
the revolving door problem in the justice.
15:54
Speaker 1: System, meaning he was let out too soon tragically.
15:56
Speaker 2: Yes, Malone was actually convicted of killing two women back
16:00
in nineteen eighty You'd think that would be a life sentence,
16:03
but it wasn't.
16:04
Speaker 1: No.
16:04
Speaker 2: The critical detail from the sources is that, for reasons
16:07
that aren't entirely clear but point to system loopholes or
16:10
perhaps sentencing guidelines of the time, Malone was released from
16:13
custody after serving time for those two murders, and then
16:18
in nineteen eighty six he murdered a third woman. Witnesses
16:21
described him as having this kind of manipulative charm, but
16:24
underneath was this incredibly volatile, destructive rage. He often beat
16:29
his victims brutally, even after they were dead.
16:32
Speaker 1: His case has come up again recently, hasn't it.
16:34
Speaker 2: It has. That's what makes it so relevant now. In
16:36
twenty twenty three, Malone came up for parole again at
16:39
age seventy, and the attempt spark massive completely justified public outrage.
16:44
Speaker 1: Because people remembered the third victim killed after he'd already
16:48
been convicted of two murders exactly.
16:51
Speaker 2: It brought the whole issue roaring back. His decades old
16:54
crimes became exhibit A in current debates about parole boards,
16:57
risk assessment, and the concept of rehabilitation for serial violent offenders.
17:02
Speaker 1: Can someone like that truly be rehabilitated to the point
17:05
where public safety isn't a gamble?
17:08
Speaker 2: That's the core question. His case forces us to ask
17:11
the sources use Malone to challenge just how effective our
17:14
risk assessment tools really are when dealing with deep seated,
17:17
repeat violent behavior. The outrage suggests the public has very
17:21
little faith in those assessments in cases like his.
17:23
Speaker 1: So if we connect these three Watts Taylor, Malone, we
17:26
see different kinds of systemic failure allowing transient or repeat
17:30
offenders to continue a bad plea deal with Watts, an
17:34
institutional escape with Tailor, and a premature release or parole
17:37
failure with Malone.
17:38
Speaker 2: Precisely three different pathways, same tragic result, more victims who
17:43
shouldn't have been victimized.
17:44
Speaker 1: Okay, let's shift focus now from the transient killers to
17:48
those whose crimes seem deeply intertwined with the environment of
17:53
urban decay, particularly in places like Detroit and Lansing.
17:57
Speaker 2: Yeah, this is where systemic neglect of certain communities and
18:01
populations becomes a major factor almost enabling the violence.
18:04
Speaker 1: And the first case we have to discuss here is
18:06
Benjamin Atkins, the Woodword Corridor.
18:09
Speaker 2: Killer, right, and the context is crucial. This is Detroit
18:12
in the early nineteen nineties, the Woodward Avenue Corridor, parts
18:16
of it were really struggling urban decay, the crack cocaine
18:19
epidemic hitting hard. It created a specific.
18:23
Speaker 1: Kind of environment and Atkins himself.
18:25
Speaker 2: Atkins fit a certain profile often found in these environments,
18:28
high school dropout, history of addiction, prior arrests for violence.
18:31
Between nineteen ninety one and nineteen ninety two, just a
18:34
single year, he strangled eleven women.
18:36
Speaker 1: Eleven women in one year. And the victim profile here,
18:40
it's key to the critique.
18:41
Speaker 2: Isn't it absolutely central? His victims were almost all marginalized women,
18:45
vulnerable Black women, many involved in sex work in areas
18:48
like Highland Park in Detroit's East Side that were already
18:50
facing significant challenges.
18:52
Speaker 1: Did he have a signature something linking the crimes.
18:55
Speaker 2: A horrifying one. He often stuffed a sock into the
18:58
victim's mouth, either before or after killing them by asphyxiation.
19:03
We know some names like Wanita Jones and Martha Griffin.
19:06
But eleven victims in such a short time, it screams
19:10
that something was wrong with the initial response.
19:12
Speaker 1: And this is where the sources really critique the policing
19:15
y the idea of urban neglect.
19:17
Speaker 2: Unavoidably, the sources are blunt. Police initially dismissed many of
19:22
these deaths. The term used was prostitute killings, which.
19:26
Speaker 1: Sounds like blaming the victim or at least devaluing their lives.
19:30
Speaker 2: That's exactly the implication and the devastating effect when investigators
19:34
use language like that. Even internally, it signals that these
19:37
cases aren't the highest priority. Resources might be slower, the
19:40
investigation less intense, and the killer gets more time, more victims.
19:45
Speaker 1: So the failure to quickly connect the dots based on
19:47
the location, the method, the signature, it's stemmed partly from
19:51
devaluing the victims themselves.
19:52
Speaker 2: The sources strongly suggest that bias played a significant role.
19:57
The system failed to protect the most vulnerable decisely because
20:00
they were vulnerable and marginalized.
20:02
Speaker 1: How was he caught?
20:03
Speaker 2: Then? It wasn't until a witness actually saw Atkins dragging
20:07
a body that the investigation finally got the traction it needed.
20:10
He was arrested, he confessed quickly got multiple life sentences.
20:14
But the tragedy is how many died before the system
20:17
treated their deaths with the urgency they deserved.
20:20
Speaker 1: And that failure sadly echoes later in Lancing with Matthew Macon.
20:24
His crimes two thousand and four to two thousand and
20:26
seven seemed like a clear case of parole failure.
20:29
Speaker 2: A textbook example. Really, Macon had a long rap sheet
20:33
going back to at least two thousand and one robbery assault.
20:37
There were clear warning signs in his record.
20:38
Speaker 1: But he was paroled anyway.
20:39
Speaker 2: Paroled in two thousand and six despite those warnings. The
20:42
sources call it a catastrophic failure of institutional oversight. The
20:45
parole board had the information but made the wrong call.
20:48
Speaker 1: And what happened after his release.
20:50
Speaker 2: He immediately began preying on community vulnerabilities again, but escalated dramatically.
20:56
He targeted elderly and middle aged black women in Lancing,
21:00
often tragically he got in through unlocked doors or windows,
21:04
exploiting a sense of neighborhood trust or maybe just forgetfulness.
21:07
How many victims he bludgeoned and strangled seven women, including
21:11
Ruth Hallman who is seventy six years old.
21:13
Speaker 1: The audacity of his crimes is striking in the source
21:16
material too, like the attack on Professor Cronenberg.
21:19
Speaker 2: Yeah, Carolyn Cronenberg, sixty years old. He attacked and raped
21:23
her inside a classroom at Lansing Community College. It shows
21:27
a predator operating with incredible impunity, seemingly completely unchecked by
21:31
his parole status or any community awareness.
21:34
Speaker 1: So his eventual confession and life sentence they exposed flaws
21:37
not just in the parole decision itself, but in how
21:40
high risk offenders were monitored or not monitored after release.
21:44
Speaker 2: Exactly seven lives demonstrably lost because the system failed to
21:48
adequately assess and manage a known danger. It's a failure
21:52
of judgment with irreversible consequences.
21:54
Speaker 1: Then we come to perhaps the most frustrating case in
21:59
terms of bureaucratic failure, the Angela Martin in Detroit vacant
22:04
house horror.
22:05
Speaker 2: Yeah, the duration of his terror is just staggering. Fourteen years,
22:09
from roughly two thousand and four to twenty eighteen, he
22:11
was active on Detroit's East Side fourteen years.
22:14
Speaker 1: How is that even possible?
22:16
Speaker 2: It's a perfect storm of systemic failures. Converging. Martin targeted women, again,
22:21
often sex workers or transience people living on the absolute margins.
22:25
He'd lure them into one of the thousands of abandoned,
22:28
decaying houses that unfortunately characterized parts of Detroit's landscape due
22:32
to economic hardship in blight. Then there he would rape
22:35
and strangle them and then just leave their bodies behind
22:38
in these vacant structures, often to decompose for weeks or
22:41
months before being found.
22:42
Speaker 1: But fourteen years, surely there were clues leads DNA there were,
22:47
and this.
22:47
Speaker 2: Is where the system failure becomes almost infuriating. An Associated
22:51
Press investigation cited in our sources dug into this. They
22:54
blamed the incredibly long duration of his spree squarely on
22:57
systemic breakdowns within the police department, specifically leads getting lost
23:03
DNA matches sitting unprocessed or unreported, largely due to repeated
23:08
clerical errors and bureaucratic disorganization.
23:11
Speaker 1: Not lack of evidence, but paperwork failures.
23:14
Speaker 2: Essentially, yes, for fifteen years, potential connections, potential DNA hits
23:19
that could have stopped him years earlier were apparently buried
23:23
in paperwork, lost in communication gaps between units, or simply
23:27
not followed up on due to administrative chaos.
23:30
Speaker 1: So you combine a victim population that's already somewhat invisible
23:34
to the system, marginalized, with a physical environment the thousands
23:37
of vacant houses providing perfect hidden crime scenes disposal sites. Yeah,
23:41
and then you layer on top just basic bureaucratic.
23:44
Speaker 2: And confidence, and you create the conditions for a predator
23:47
like Martin to operate almost unbelievably for nearly a decade
23:51
and a half before being stopped.
23:53
Speaker 1: How did they finally get him?
23:54
Speaker 2: It was actually an assault in twenty nineteen where the
23:56
victim survived and identified him that finally led to his arrest.
24:00
He was convicted and sentenced to life in twenty twenty three.
24:03
But the question hangs heavy. How many of those women
24:07
died because a file wasn't processed correctly. How many lives
24:10
were lost to a clerical error.
24:13
Speaker 1: It's deeply troubling. Okay, let's move into the more modern era.
24:16
One case really stands out because it highlights not just
24:19
the predator but also the impact of technology and crucially,
24:23
survivor bravery. Jeffrey Willis, the Muskiggan Monster.
24:27
Speaker 2: Willis is a different kind of case in some ways
24:29
a factory worker from Eskegan, seemingly unremarkable on the surface,
24:33
but his case really turned on the incredible courage of
24:36
one young woman, Madison Nigard Mais Nyguard.
24:38
Speaker 1: Yes.
24:39
Speaker 2: In twenty sixteen, when she was just sixteen, Willis tried
24:42
to kidnap her at gunpoint. She fought back, escaped from
24:44
his van, and immediately recorded it. Her bravery was the
24:47
key that unlocked everything.
24:48
Speaker 1: How so what did her report lead to?
24:51
Speaker 2: Her detailed description and the circumstances led police to Willis,
24:54
and investigating him cracked open two major cold cases they
24:57
hadn't been able to solve Gowen's once, Jessica Hearing, a
25:00
twenty five year old gas station clerk who vanished from
25:03
her job in Norton Shores in twenty thirteen. Her body
25:06
has still never been found, but the evidence pointed overwhelmingly
25:09
to Willis and Rebecca Bletch thirty six, who was shot
25:13
and killed while jogging on a rural road in twenty fourteen.
25:16
Speaker 1: So Nyguard's escape directly linked him to two earlier murders.
25:20
Speaker 2: It gave police the probable cause they needed to search
25:23
his home and vehicle, and what they found there was chilling.
25:26
It revealed this whole secret life, what.
25:29
Speaker 1: Kind of things?
25:30
Speaker 2: Willis was obsessed with violence, with guns, with torture fantasies.
25:34
They found illegal weapons, child pornography, and critically, a computer
25:38
hard drive, and on that hard drive meticulous files, victimless
25:42
videos apparently related to Bletch's murder, folders labeled with victims'
25:45
names or descriptions, tools for abduction, chains, restraints. It concerned
25:50
he wasn't just fantasizing, he was planning and acting.
25:53
Speaker 1: That digital evidence must have been crucial for the.
25:55
Speaker 2: Convictions, absolutely undeniable. It provided the direct forensic link needed
25:59
to convin him for both hearing, his kidnapping and murder.
26:02
Despite no body and Bletch's murder, he got life without
26:05
parole and.
26:06
Speaker 1: The legacy of this case besides bringing him to justice.
26:10
Speaker 2: The legacy is really twofold. First, it's a powerful testament
26:13
to survivor bravery. Madison Niagard didn't just save herself, she
26:18
potentially saved countless future victims by unmasking him. Second, her actions,
26:23
combined with the digital evidence and the clear links between
26:26
the cases, spurred real tangible improvements in DNA processing protocols
26:31
and investigative standards for missing persons and homicide cases across Michigan.
26:36
Speaker 1: So a terrible tragedy, but one that forced positive systemic change.
26:40
Speaker 2: Yes, sometimes it takes that kind of breakthrough, the kind
26:43
of shock, to force the system to adapt and improve.
26:45
Speaker 1: Okay, let's step back for a moment and try to
26:47
synthesize all this. We've covered nine individuals, Collins, Miller, Watts, Taylor, Malone, Atkins,
26:53
make and Martin Willis. The confirmed death toll across just
26:57
these nine, it's over fifty.
26:58
Speaker 2: Women, right over fifty, And as we discussed with Watts
27:02
and potentially others, the true number is almost certainly higher.
27:05
Unsolved cases victims these disappearances were never linked. The full
27:09
scope is likely larger.
27:10
Speaker 1: And the common threat the pattern we kept seeing, it's.
27:13
Speaker 2: That consistent marginalization of the victims, or at least the
27:16
perception of their vulnerability being somehow their fault. The college
27:20
students hitchhiking back in the sixties viewed as risky, the
27:23
sex workers in Detroit in the nineties, their deaths initially
27:26
dismissed as just part of the life.
27:28
Speaker 1: The system reacted differently based on who the victim was.
27:31
Speaker 2: Often yes, yeah, The initial urgency, the resources allocated the
27:35
benefit of the doubt given it wasn't always equal, and
27:38
that inequality costs lives.
27:41
Speaker 1: But you also mentioned there have been positive outcomes, however
27:43
hard won.
27:44
Speaker 2: There have. We saw the DNA protocol improvements after Willis
27:48
the Michigan murders, despite the initial failures, did eventually lead
27:51
to better cold case units, more focus on interagency communication.
27:56
It's often reactive change spurred by tragedy, but change.
27:59
Speaker 1: Does have and the fact that these cases are still discussed,
28:02
analyzed in true crime documentaries and shows today, it keeps
28:05
them relevant, doesn't it.
28:07
Speaker 2: It does. They aren't just history lessons. They're active, cautionary tales.
28:11
They remind law enforcement, the justice system, and frankly all
28:15
of us that the potential for this kind of violence
28:17
exists and prevention has to be the absolute focus.
28:21
Speaker 1: So let's try to crystallize those systemic failures we identified
28:25
across these cases. What are the main categories of breakdown?
28:30
Speaker 2: I think we can group them into three main types. First,
28:33
there's that profiling bias and the dismissal of vulnerable.
28:36
Speaker 1: Victims like with Akins, the prostitute killing's idea or Collins
28:40
being overlooked because he was a clean cat student exactly.
28:43
Speaker 2: The system often looks for the stereotype, the obvious monster,
28:46
and misses the danger hiding in plain sight, or dismisses
28:50
victims who don't fit the ideal mold.
28:52
Speaker 1: Okay, what's the second type?
28:53
Speaker 2: Second is the failure to heed clear institutional warnings. This
28:57
covers Magan getting parole despite his record, Taylor escaping from
29:00
the state hospital, Malone being released after already killing two people.
29:04
These are internal system failures, not listening to the data,
29:08
not maintaining security, making bad judgment calls on.
29:11
Speaker 1: Release, failures of oversight and containment.
29:13
Speaker 2: Precisely, and the third type, which is maybe the most
29:16
maddening because it seems so.
29:18
Speaker 1: Preventable, bureaucratic incompetence.
29:20
Speaker 2: Yeah, simple devastating clerical errors like DiAngelo Martin's DNA matches
29:25
getting lost in the shuffle for years, or maybe poor
29:29
initial evidence handling in the Collins or Watts cases that
29:32
made later prosecution harder. These aren't failures of investigation strategy.
29:37
They're failures of basic organization and procedure.
29:39
Speaker 1: And they turned solvable cases into tragedies that stretch on
29:43
for years or decades.
29:44
Speaker 2: Exactly, So the call to action that seems to emerge
29:47
from all this source material. It's really about prevention on
29:50
multiple levels, like what empowering women, teaching self defense, raising awareness,
29:55
but also critically properly funding investigations, especially for cold cases
29:59
and case This is involving vulnerable populations, giving investigators the
30:03
resources and the mandate to treat every victim's life as equally.
30:06
Speaker 1: Valuable, and addressing root causes.
30:08
Speaker 2: And addressing the root causes that create vulnerability in the
30:11
first place, poverty, lack of mental health services, addiction, systemic inequality.
30:18
These things create environments where predators can thrive and victims
30:22
are more easily targeted and forgotten. The echoes of all
30:25
this terror, they demand constant vigilance right now.
30:28
Speaker 1: Okay, So that leads us to our final provocative thought
30:31
for you, the listener. Drawing directly from this analysis.
30:35
Speaker 2: We've seen how several of these notorious killers Collins, Watts,
30:38
Miller Malone clearly benefited from major systemic loopholes bad plea deals,
30:44
being dismissed early on, getting released when they shouldn't have been.
30:47
These were high profile cases eventually, so.
30:49
Speaker 1: The question is if these kinds of failures happened in
30:52
cases that eventually got massive attention. What's the impact of
30:55
those same kinds of systemic failures, the clerical errors, the
30:59
profiling bias, is the resource shortages on the countless smaller
31:02
scale investigations happening right.
31:04
Speaker 2: Now, the cases that don't make headlines, the local assaults,
31:08
the disappearances that don't get national media. Are those same
31:11
silent failures occurring today? Are victims falling through the cracks
31:15
because of a lost file, a biased assumption, an overworked detective.
31:20
Speaker 1: And maybe the most critical part, are those silent failures
31:23
truly preventable, not just through outrage after the fact, but
31:27
through better processes, better funding, more equitable attention before tragedy escalates.
31:33
Speaker 2: That's the uncomfortable question. These histories force us to confront
31:36
what aren't we seeing and what could we be doing
31:39
better right now?
31:40
Speaker 1: Something to definitely think about, a critical thought to carry forward.
31:43
Speaker 2: Thank you for joining us for this pretty intense dip dive.
31:46
Speaker 1: Yes, thank you. Until next time.