Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Debating State Budget Priorities
Transcript
- 0:08Kentucky. Tonight, I'm Renee
- 0:09Shaw and we thank you so much
- 0:11for joining us this evening. We
- 0:12continue following negotiations
- 0:14in Frankfurt over the roughly
- 0:16$30 billion, two year state
- 0:18budget. Today, key House and
- 0:19Senate negotiators announced
- 0:21they had a deal to reconcile
- 0:23the separate state budgets
- 0:24passed by the two chambers.
- 0:26It's expected lawmakers will
- 0:27vote on the budget deal
- 0:29tomorrow or Wednesday. If
- 0:30passed, a final version of the
- 0:32budget would then go on to
- 0:34Governor Andy Beshear for him
- 0:35to sign or line item veto to
- 0:36discuss the budget. We have
- 0:38three guests in our Lexington
- 0:39studio. State Senator Chris
- 0:41McDaniel, a Republican from
- 0:42Ryland Heights and chair of the
- 0:44Senate Appropriations and
- 0:45Revenue Committee. State
- 0:48Representative Lindsey Burke, a
- 0:49Democrat from Lexington and
- 0:50House Minority Caucus chair,
- 0:52and Anne Tyler Morgan, an
- 0:54attorney and member of the law
- 0:56firm McBrayer PLLC. And in our
- 0:58Louisville studio, we have
- 0:59state Senator Cassie Chambers
- 1:02Armstrong, a Democrat from
- 1:03Louisville, Senate Minority
- 1:04Whip and a member of the Senate
- 1:06Appropriations and Revenue
- 1:08Committee. We certainly want to
- 1:09hear from you tonight. You can
- 1:10send your questions and
- 1:11comments by X, formerly Twitter
- 1:14at Pub Affairs KET, or send an
- 1:16email to KY tonight@ket.org, or
- 1:20use the web form at KET dot
- 1:22Johnny Nash KY tonight. Or you
- 1:24can simply give us a call at
- 1:26one 800 4947605. Well, welcome
- 1:30to all of our guests and what
- 1:32timing we certainly have
- 1:34tonight because chairman
- 1:35McDaniel, just today, around
- 1:37three ish, you all announced a
- 1:40budget deal for House Bill 500,
- 1:42which is the executive branch
- 1:43budget. Can you give us the nut
- 1:45graph of what's in the budget
- 1:46and perhaps what isn't?
- 1:47>> Sure. Absolutely. Renee. So
- 1:49thank you for having me tonight.
- 1:50And yes, absolutely. We've
- 1:52largely finished the work. I
- 1:54should start out by saying the
- 1:56free conference committee
- 1:57report is not actually
- 1:58published and signed yet. And
- 1:59so until that happens,
- 2:00obviously there's there's there
- 2:02are potentials, but by and
- 2:03large, the budget is finished.
- 2:05And so I would say some of the
- 2:06biggest highlights are the
- 2:08ongoing success that we've been
- 2:10able to see through a
- 2:11disciplined budgeting process.
- 2:13Last time around, we were able
- 2:14to make record investments in
- 2:16countless areas as well as
- 2:19continue to to put in place and
- 2:20work on the reduction of state
- 2:22income tax. And you see some of
- 2:24those same themes come around
- 2:25this time. So the the top thing
- 2:27that people always want to know
- 2:28about is what happens in
- 2:29education, right? And inside of
- 2:31the K-12 space, the biggest
- 2:33area is what's called the SEEK
- 2:35formula. And we increased the
- 2:37funding inside of the SEEK
- 2:38formula by 2% per year over the
- 2:41course of the biennium.
- 2:42>> That's going back to the
- 2:43House plan.
- 2:44>> That's going back to the
- 2:45House plan. Correct. And at the
- 2:46same time, inside of of that
- 2:48budget unit, we were able to
- 2:50fully fund the health system at
- 2:52the at the way that the
- 2:54governor had requested for the
- 2:55state's teachers and also for
- 2:56the state's employees. We also.
- 2:58>> Know employment contribution
- 3:00cap. Correct?
- 3:01>> That's correct. A lot of
- 3:02those things that had caused
- 3:03some concern earlier, we did
- 3:05not address those this time
- 3:07around. So it will be just like
- 3:08the governor had had it in his.
- 3:10We also were able to fully fund
- 3:12the state's pensions. Both the
- 3:13state police and the
- 3:15Nonhazardous plans. And then
- 3:17inside of higher education, you
- 3:19know, by and large, most
- 3:20universities will see the same
- 3:22base as last time. There will
- 3:23be a few miscellaneous cuts
- 3:24here and there, but in the
- 3:26performance funding we put
- 3:27another $5 million per year.
- 3:29That is our financial
- 3:31accountability mechanism for
- 3:32the Commonwealth. And, you know,
- 3:34we were proud to be able to
- 3:35continue to invest there so
- 3:38that those are the biggest
- 3:39areas that we saw. We saw some
- 3:41additional plussing up inside
- 3:42of Medicaid. We have a
- 3:45specialty Medicaid fund with
- 3:47$290 million in the event of
- 3:48cost overruns and and countless
- 3:50other areas as well.
- 3:52>> Yeah, that was referred to
- 3:53as a lock box. So explain a
- 3:55little bit more in depth what
- 3:56this concept is.
- 3:58>> Yeah. So in essence, we, you
- 4:00know, there is no area of the
- 4:02state government where the
- 4:03costs are increasing nearly as
- 4:05quickly as they are in the
- 4:06Medicaid space. And we really
- 4:08need to bring some cost control
- 4:10into that space. And so what we
- 4:12did is we put that $290 million
- 4:14there for the administration to
- 4:16be able to return to us and,
- 4:18you know, hopefully work on
- 4:20some cost containment measures.
- 4:22But if they aren't able to
- 4:23fully contain them there, there
- 4:25is some available funds for
- 4:26them to come to us and to at
- 4:28the beginning of the 2027
- 4:30session. So just keep in mind,
- 4:32you know, right now there will
- 4:33only be six months into the
- 4:35fiscal year. Ideally, they're
- 4:37able to find some savings. And
- 4:38that really should be the
- 4:39challenge that this
- 4:41administration takes up is how
- 4:42do we make Medicaid a more
- 4:44affordable program in the
- 4:46Commonwealth. And so there will
- 4:47be this fund there for them to
- 4:49come back to the General
- 4:50Assembly. If they're not able
- 4:51to figure out how to to execute
- 4:53some savings and ask to get
- 4:55into it.
- 4:55>> Representative Lindsey Burke,
- 4:56you were there during the
- 4:58budget conference committee
- 5:00session this afternoon when all
- 5:01of this was announced, and you
- 5:02had asked about that $290
- 5:04million Medicaid lockbox. Do
- 5:05you understand that clearly?
- 5:07And does that give you some
- 5:09consolation that the services
- 5:10will be there for those who
- 5:11need those Medicaid services?
- 5:13>> Well, thank you, Renee. I
- 5:14think the lockbox is an
- 5:16interesting concept, and I'm
- 5:17glad to know that there are
- 5:19earmarked funds available.
- 5:20Should we run into budget
- 5:23issues with Medicaid? I don't
- 5:25think it's really a question,
- 5:26though, if we're going to run
- 5:28into those budget issues. The
- 5:29question is not so much if, but
- 5:32when. And I hope, just as
- 5:35Senator McDaniels has said,
- 5:36that we'll be able to contain
- 5:37the cost of the Medicaid
- 5:39program. But unfortunately, not
- 5:42to sound too radical here, as
- 5:44long as we have multiple Mcos
- 5:47and we are not moving toward a
- 5:49single payer system, the costs
- 5:51are just going to continue to
- 5:53increase. The federal
- 5:54government is not doing us any
- 5:55favors either. The cuts from
- 5:57the federal level through HR
- 5:59one are going to be felt in
- 6:02Kentucky. And so I think we
- 6:03need to be really ready with
- 6:04that lockbox and have very
- 6:06clear standards by which it can
- 6:08be opened.
- 6:09>> I want to ask Miss
- 6:10Anne-Tyler Morgan, because you
- 6:11I often have you on programs
- 6:13specifically about Medicaid,
- 6:14because you've been around this
- 6:15particular field for a long
- 6:16time. How do you interpret this?
- 6:18And do you think that that $290
- 6:20million Medicaid lockbox is a
- 6:21good idea?
- 6:22>> Yes. Renee, thanks so much
- 6:23for having me on again. And
- 6:24thanks to Chairman McDaniel and
- 6:26my fellow panel members for
- 6:27everything that you've done to
- 6:28make this budget happen in this
- 6:30session. I know it's a lot of
- 6:32work. I do think the $290
- 6:34million is obviously very
- 6:35helpful to have. Obviously, the
- 6:36budget is not the only
- 6:38legislation this session that
- 6:39is addressing Medicaid costs.
- 6:41We have House Bill two, which
- 6:42I'm sure we'll talk more about.
- 6:44That's up for committee
- 6:46tomorrow. And I know that that
- 6:48addresses a lot of cost
- 6:49containment measures as well.
- 6:51And there are also a lot of
- 6:52workforce bills that touch the
- 6:53Medicaid space and to get
- 6:55people back into the workforce,
- 6:56because really, I think the
- 6:58main driver of Medicaid cost
- 6:59containment will be getting
- 7:01people into the workforce and
- 7:03allowing Medicaid to be a true
- 7:04support for those who still
- 7:05need it. So I think we'll get
- 7:07more into that. But I think
- 7:09that the $290 million certainly
- 7:11shores up the potential for
- 7:13additional costs down the road.
- 7:14>> Senator Cassie Chambers
- 7:16Armstrong in Louisville, I'll
- 7:17come to you and ask you for
- 7:18your reaction about that
- 7:19particular provision.
- 7:23>> Thanks, Renee. I agree with
- 7:25chairman McDaniels that, of
- 7:26course, it's important that we
- 7:28make sure that Medicaid is
- 7:30spending tax dollars in a way
- 7:31that's efficient and in a way
- 7:33that is being a good steward of
- 7:35those. It's also really
- 7:36important that we think about
- 7:37accessibility to Medicaid,
- 7:38because we know our most
- 7:39vulnerable populations rely
- 7:41upon it, and it can literally
- 7:42be a matter of life and death.
- 7:44And the reason I just want to
- 7:45explain for the folks at home
- 7:47that it's so important that we
- 7:49fully fund Medicaid, is every
- 7:50dollar we put in as a state is
- 7:52matched by $3 from the federal
- 7:53government. And so the risk
- 7:55that if we underfund Medicaid
- 7:57is not just that we miss out on
- 7:58that dollar, it's that we miss
- 8:00out on the other three that
- 8:01come down through the federal
- 8:03government. And so I'm
- 8:04interested in learning more
- 8:05about the lock box. I think
- 8:07it's a creative idea. My main
- 8:10concern is going to be, are we
- 8:11able to access it in a way that
- 8:13makes sure those vulnerable
- 8:14populations have access to that
- 8:16critical care when they need it?
- 8:17>> And so while we have you and
- 8:19I should say to our viewers at
- 8:21home, we have a little bit of a
- 8:23delay between us and Senator
- 8:24Cassie Chambers Armstrong, who
- 8:25is in our Louisville studio. So
- 8:26that accounts for the little
- 8:28bit of lag in the communication.
- 8:29But get your overall thoughts,
- 8:31Senator, about what you think
- 8:32of the budget compromise as it
- 8:33stands now, and what is missing,
- 8:35in your view that should be
- 8:37included?
- 8:41>> Well, I'm going to start
- 8:42with the positive. I was so
- 8:44thrilled today to learn that
- 8:46Imagination Library is in the
- 8:47budget with its same full
- 8:48funding and with the 50% match.
- 8:50I think this is one of the most
- 8:52important programs that we
- 8:53invest in as a state. The
- 8:55outcomes for kindergarten
- 8:56readiness are just off the
- 8:57charts. It actually performs
- 8:59even better than some pre-K
- 9:01programs in terms of getting
- 9:02kids ready on those
- 9:03kindergarten readiness metrics.
- 9:04And so I was just so thrilled
- 9:06to see that and also thrilled
- 9:07to see language that's
- 9:09hopefully going to direct our
- 9:10cabinet to work on prioritizing
- 9:12foster families and low income
- 9:14families for enrollment. The
- 9:16cabinet has access to a lot of
- 9:17information and resources to
- 9:18reach vulnerable families, and
- 9:20bringing those resources to
- 9:21bear to partner with this
- 9:23program to make sure that every
- 9:24single vulnerable child has
- 9:26access to books, I think is one
- 9:28of the best things that we
- 9:29could be doing as a
- 9:31Commonwealth and something that
- 9:32will absolutely end up changing
- 9:33lives. While we're talking
- 9:34about early childhood education,
- 9:35I have to say I am always
- 9:37disappointed when I don't see
- 9:38pre-K funding in the budget,
- 9:40but that is something we'll
- 9:41continue to talk about, and I
- 9:43will always continue to
- 9:44champion early education.
- 9:45Broadly defined, there are a
- 9:46lot of ways we can invest in
- 9:48families.
- 9:48>> I want to go to you,
- 9:50Chairman McDaniel, because you
- 9:51made a joke during today's
- 9:52announcement about Dolly Parton.
- 9:53And even though she is not a
- 9:55Kentuckian and who knows what
- 9:56her party affiliation is, she's
- 9:58probably the most popular
- 9:59person in Kentucky, hands down.
- 10:01And even if it's not even her
- 10:03thing, you know anything with
- 10:05her name attached to it.
- 10:07Certainly you get a lot of
- 10:07feedback on because we know
- 10:09that, that the funding for that
- 10:10has kind of gone back and forth.
- 10:12Are you satisfied with where
- 10:14it's landed?
- 10:14>> Yes, absolutely. You know,
- 10:15and Senator Chambers Armstrong
- 10:17and I had a conversation very
- 10:18early in this process about one
- 10:19of the things she was really
- 10:21looking for was to see foster
- 10:22children being serviced more
- 10:24via this program. And as that
- 10:26advanced through it, it was it
- 10:27was her advocacy that really
- 10:29led to that additional line or
- 10:31two that trying to ensure that
- 10:34they were kind of getting first
- 10:36call on some of these things.
- 10:37>> Right. So a couple of
- 10:39questions about just
- 10:41logistically, there's House
- 10:41Bill 500, which is a state
- 10:43executive executive branch
- 10:46budget. Then there's House Bill
- 10:47900. That's one time. And then
- 10:49there's House Bill 757. That's
- 10:52revenue. Okay. Can you sort out
- 10:53the other two for us and where
- 10:55they fit into the puzzle of
- 10:56House Bill 500?
- 10:57>> Sure. And this is always one
- 10:59of the complicated parts about
- 11:00state budgeting, because people
- 11:01think that there's a single
- 11:02document relative to that, and
- 11:04there's actually 5 or 6
- 11:05documents. Once you begin to
- 11:06throw in the road plan and some
- 11:08of the supplemental things that
- 11:09go along with it. So the
- 11:11state's budget is, is very
- 11:12complicated and has many, many
- 11:13parts. You referenced two of
- 11:14them, first of all, House Bill
- 11:16757. So this is something that
- 11:17we do every budget cycle. It's
- 11:19the revenue bill, which
- 11:20actually enables the tax code
- 11:22and makes changes to the tax
- 11:24code that are necessary for the
- 11:25collection of the revenues to
- 11:27be able to be implemented on
- 11:30behalf of the spending plan.
- 11:31Then you reference House Bill
- 11:33900. That's our one time
- 11:34spending bill, where we will
- 11:36take up many, many items, some
- 11:38very big and some very small
- 11:40across the Commonwealth. And
- 11:41those items will represent,
- 11:43like we said, one time
- 11:45investments as a result of the
- 11:47disciplined budgeting process
- 11:48that we have engaged in, we
- 11:50have found ourselves with a
- 11:51rainy day fund, which is the
- 11:53states Commonwealth or the
- 11:54Commonwealth's savings plan,
- 11:56with an incredible balance. And
- 11:59the fact is, when people pay
- 12:00taxes, they don't pay it so
- 12:02that it can just sit in a
- 12:04savings account for people to
- 12:05feel good about. It needs to be
- 12:07returned to the citizens of the
- 12:08Commonwealth in long term
- 12:09investments on their behalf.
- 12:11And so House Bill 900 is a is
- 12:13the result of a lot of
- 12:15discipline. And the results of
- 12:16it will be long term benefit
- 12:18for the citizens.
- 12:18>> And that's around $800
- 12:20million, right?
- 12:21>> It will probably well.
- 12:22>> Over $800 million.
- 12:23>> Well over how much is well
- 12:25over, Mr. Chairman.
- 12:26>> We'll find out shortly.
- 12:27>> Okay. So that is that still
- 12:28in progress or has that been
- 12:30decided at.
- 12:31>> This juncture? There's still
- 12:32a few tweaks to be made to that
- 12:33bill.
- 12:34>> And when it comes to House
- 12:36Bill 500, is are we at a final
- 12:37document? And could a vote come
- 12:39on that as early as tomorrow?
- 12:41>> A vote could come very, very
- 12:42soon. Once the free conference
- 12:44committee signs off on the
- 12:45report, you could expect a vote
- 12:46in very short order.
- 12:48>> Or is there still some
- 12:49conversation about what else
- 12:50could be included in that or
- 12:51stricken from that at this
- 12:53juncture?
- 12:53>> Well, there's always until
- 12:54there's a final vote, there's
- 12:56always conversation.
- 12:56>> I know you know that very
- 12:58well. Representative Burke.
- 12:59>> Yes, absolutely.
- 12:59>> Yeah. And go ahead.
- 13:01>> I am really interested to
- 13:03see what we'll be doing with
- 13:04House Bill. 757, the revenue
- 13:06bill, because I thought that
- 13:08there were still a few pieces
- 13:10of low hanging fruit available
- 13:12and brought those to Chair
- 13:13Petrie to discuss. I filed them
- 13:15in the form of floor amendments,
- 13:18and I hope that perhaps some of
- 13:19them could be included, because
- 13:21I think Kentucky needs every
- 13:22dollar we can get. The
- 13:26particular amendments that were
- 13:28proposed dealt with things like
- 13:30trusts that are kept out of
- 13:31state or directed trusts,
- 13:34foreign income from business
- 13:37done overseas, the kinds of
- 13:39things that average Kentuckians
- 13:42don't even know exist and
- 13:44wouldn't understand if I tried
- 13:45to explain them, because
- 13:46they're really complicated. And
- 13:48frankly, they only really would
- 13:51matter to a small handful of
- 13:53Kentuckians. So HR one opened
- 13:56several opportunities, and we
- 13:59had the opportunity to either
- 14:01follow suit or do what's called
- 14:03decoupling. And there are some
- 14:06opportunities for us to
- 14:07decouple, which would yield
- 14:08more money for Kentucky. So
- 14:10I'll be really interested to
- 14:11see what we do with that.
- 14:13>> Interesting. Well, this
- 14:14question from Martin Rivers and
- 14:15Lexington. He says quote or
- 14:17asks quote, why is there such
- 14:18secrecy in the creation of the
- 14:20budget? Senator McDaniel and
- 14:21Representative Petrie keep the
- 14:22legislature's most important
- 14:23activity every two years in the
- 14:25dark, and only the last couple
- 14:26of days of the legislative
- 14:28process does it slowly become
- 14:29evident. Your response, Mr.
- 14:30Chairman.
- 14:31>> I would argue that we, since
- 14:33I've been here between Chairman
- 14:35Petrie and I, we probably have
- 14:37the most transparent, most
- 14:39participative process that I've
- 14:40dealt with. We have committee
- 14:42hearings throughout the course
- 14:43of the interim. We have
- 14:44committee hearings throughout
- 14:45the course of the regular
- 14:47session. We present our budgets
- 14:50in public. We allow them to sit
- 14:52on the floor. We have free
- 14:55conference committees where we
- 14:56air our differences somewhat in
- 14:58public. And then certainly like
- 15:00any negotiation, there are
- 15:02things that go on outside of
- 15:04the public eye. But by and
- 15:06large, I. I have never dealt
- 15:08with a house that was as open
- 15:12and in a Senate that is as open
- 15:14as chair. Petrie and I are in
- 15:16this process.
- 15:18>> Senator Chambers Armstrong
- 15:19do you care to comment on the
- 15:21negotiation process and the
- 15:24transparency of these budget
- 15:25talks, and how involved is the
- 15:27minority party in crafting the
- 15:29final version of the budget?
- 15:34>> So I think the chairman is
- 15:36right that by the time the
- 15:38budget clears both chambers,
- 15:40most folks have an
- 15:41understanding of what are the
- 15:42programs and the issues where
- 15:43you're going to see
- 15:45disagreement and you're going
- 15:45to see conversation. What the
- 15:47public doesn't necessarily get
- 15:49are some of those last minute
- 15:50decisions that are being made
- 15:52as we approach the veto
- 15:53deadline, and we're sort of
- 15:54struggling to get everything in
- 15:56and through under the radar, I
- 15:58will say just one difference
- 15:59I've noticed between serving on
- 16:01Metro Council and local
- 16:02government and serving in
- 16:04Frankfurt is in Louisville and
- 16:06local government. We had a rule
- 16:08that you could not have a
- 16:09majority of any committee or a
- 16:12caucus meeting that wasn't open
- 16:13to the public, and I think that
- 16:14that was really good, that we
- 16:16saw some of those conversations
- 16:17happening in public in ways
- 16:18that were open to folks and
- 16:20open to the press. And of
- 16:21course, we don't have those
- 16:23same rules in in Frankfurt, the
- 16:26minority party. I am very
- 16:27grateful to the chairman. He
- 16:28does come and he briefs our
- 16:30caucus. He meets with our
- 16:32members about our concerns and
- 16:34about our priority projects.
- 16:35And so I'm really grateful for
- 16:36the way that he makes real
- 16:38efforts to include us in the
- 16:40process.
- 16:40>> Questions about what
- 16:42agencies still would get the 4%
- 16:44or 3% cuts. Can you elaborate
- 16:46on that?
- 16:47>> Sure. So by and large, most
- 16:48executive branch agencies would
- 16:50find cuts like that. Where you
- 16:52won't see those occurring are
- 16:54things like the Kentucky State
- 16:55Police Department of
- 16:57Corrections. As I referenced,
- 17:00the SEEK formula will not see
- 17:01those cuts. The post-secondary
- 17:03education will not see those
- 17:05cuts. But most of the executive
- 17:06branch agencies will see those
- 17:09cuts applied.
- 17:10>> Yeah. A question from Kenton
- 17:12County. Mr. Chairman. Have
- 17:14there been any scientific
- 17:15studies conducted to assess the
- 17:17causes of the increases in
- 17:19Medicaid spending? And if yes,
- 17:20what have been the results? And
- 17:22maybe Anne-Tyler Morgan could
- 17:23comment on this as well. I'll
- 17:25let either one of you go first.
- 17:27>> You know, it's very, very
- 17:28interesting. There are
- 17:30countless studies that are
- 17:32ongoing related to Medicaid,
- 17:34and the results are all over
- 17:36the place in in a budget that
- 17:38is that big, the there's plenty
- 17:41of blame to go around. Now.
- 17:44There are some things that just
- 17:46are naturally happening.
- 17:48Medical inflation costs are are
- 17:50tremendous in this nation, and
- 17:51we can't deny that. But there
- 17:53are things about the
- 17:54utilization of care or not
- 17:55utilizing care. There are
- 17:56things about individual
- 17:58behavior inside of there. There
- 17:59are things about insurance
- 18:00companies inside of there. But
- 18:02at the end of the day, every
- 18:04day, Kentuckians are paying
- 18:07more than twice into Medicaid
- 18:09than they were ten years ago.
- 18:12And that's a real problem.
- 18:13>> And Tyler, what can you
- 18:15expand on that?
- 18:16>> Well, Renee, a lot of the
- 18:17usual suspects are what are
- 18:19behind Medicaid costs. And when
- 18:21I say usual suspects, I do mean
- 18:23utilization patterns. Of course,
- 18:25emergency room usage is a very
- 18:27high Medicaid cost driver, and
- 18:31unfortunately, Kentucky is
- 18:32still seeing poor health
- 18:33outcomes among a lot of its
- 18:35population. That's a really
- 18:36unfortunate fact. And of course,
- 18:38when you have an unhealthy
- 18:40population, you have high
- 18:41medical costs. And so when you
- 18:43pair a large population that is
- 18:45utilizing the Medicaid system
- 18:47and needing services that are
- 18:48very expensive to provide, more
- 18:50and more expensive as time goes
- 18:52on, unfortunately, we are where
- 18:54we are with the cost of
- 18:56Medicaid.
- 18:56>> And while we're here, let's
- 18:57just put a pin in it and talk
- 18:59about House Bill two. We know
- 19:01the representative, Ken Fleming,
- 19:02had been on this program 2 to 3
- 19:04weeks ago, and we talked for an
- 19:06hour about House Bill two. Give
- 19:07us kind of the nut graph of
- 19:09what House Bill two does in
- 19:10terms of that cost containment.
- 19:12>> Sure. Renee. When I think of
- 19:13House Bill two, I think it's a
- 19:15continuum of the conversation
- 19:16that the legislature has been
- 19:17having for some time now with
- 19:19regard to its desire to oversee
- 19:20the Medicaid program in a lot
- 19:22more detail. Of course, we have
- 19:23seen the establishment of Mo.ab,
- 19:25the Medicaid Oversight and
- 19:27Advisory Board, and now we see
- 19:29House Bill two giving Mo.ab
- 19:32more oversight mechanism and
- 19:37requiring a lot of specifics of
- 19:38both the Department for
- 19:39Medicaid Services and the
- 19:41managed care organizations that
- 19:42implement the Managed Care
- 19:44Medicaid program, which of
- 19:45course, is the majority of
- 19:47Medicaid beneficiaries
- 19:48mechanism for accessing that
- 19:50program. So House Bill two goes
- 19:53into a lot of detail, and I
- 19:55know there are a couple of
- 19:56points that have been talked
- 19:57about on your program
- 19:59previously, so I'll try to
- 20:00avoid those since those have
- 20:01been discussed. But I think
- 20:03that some interesting things in
- 20:05House Bill two really relate to
- 20:07the reporting that would go on
- 20:10by the legislature. I know
- 20:11there is also legislation
- 20:14regarding a centralized health
- 20:15data system, but that's also
- 20:17encompassed in House Bill two
- 20:19for a lot of the Department for
- 20:21Medicaid Services programs, the
- 20:24data on which it runs to be
- 20:26directly accessible to LRC and
- 20:29to the legislature. And I think
- 20:30we just see that the
- 20:32legislature wants more
- 20:33information to be able to make
- 20:34those budgetary decisions,
- 20:35which makes sense considering
- 20:37the vast amount of the budget
- 20:39that Medicaid takes up. And I
- 20:41think the legislature has been
- 20:42fairly frank in saying that
- 20:43they don't always trust the
- 20:45numbers that the department has
- 20:47provided to the legislature. So,
- 20:48right or wrong, this is the
- 20:50legislature's way of saying,
- 20:51we're coming in and we're we're
- 20:53going to access that data
- 20:54ourselves. We're going to make
- 20:56our own decisions about
- 20:57Medicaid. Obviously, there are
- 20:59some squeezes that House Bill
- 21:00two puts on certain companies
- 21:03that operate within the
- 21:04Medicaid system. And those
- 21:06companies, the managed care
- 21:08organizations primarily have,
- 21:09of course, been vocal about
- 21:12what that might cause them. But
- 21:14I think something that's
- 21:15interesting and something
- 21:16that's difficult with Medicaid
- 21:17is that the capitation rates
- 21:18that are paid to the managed
- 21:20care organizations have to be
- 21:22actuarially sound. It's a very
- 21:24complicated capitation rate
- 21:26system. And so we do need to be
- 21:28cautious when legislating
- 21:29Medicaid that we are complying
- 21:31with federal requirements. And
- 21:33I think it will be interesting
- 21:34to see whether tomorrow's
- 21:35committee meeting addresses any
- 21:36of those concerns that we have
- 21:38to be federally compliant.
- 21:39>> And folks can watch that on
- 21:41KET, on air and online. I want
- 21:43to go to Representative Burke
- 21:44about because there was a lot
- 21:45of conversation about House
- 21:46Bill two, particularly the
- 21:47determination and
- 21:48redetermination process and the
- 21:49amount of reporting. I think
- 21:50maybe either you or other of
- 21:52your Democratic colleagues
- 21:53raise that as a big point of
- 21:54contention. Tell us more.
- 21:56>> Yes. There are several
- 21:57elements of House Bill two that
- 21:59were concerning to us, and I'll
- 22:01be very curious to see where
- 22:02the Senate lands on some of
- 22:03those things, because I
- 22:05understand that there may be
- 22:06changes coming. We were
- 22:08concerned about co-pays. Of
- 22:09course, we're concerned about
- 22:10going further than what's
- 22:12required by HR one. And then
- 22:14also.
- 22:15>> And that's the one big,
- 22:16beautiful bill in Congress that
- 22:17they enacted last year. Just to
- 22:19clarify. Yes, yes.
- 22:20>> That put requirements in
- 22:21place that Kentucky needs to
- 22:22meet. And obviously that is
- 22:24something we should do. But one
- 22:25of the things I wasn't so sure
- 22:27about was making a long term
- 22:29commitment to that strategy.
- 22:31And essentially decoupling
- 22:35ourselves from the federal
- 22:36government in that way, because
- 22:38if Congress changes their minds,
- 22:40which we know they do, I don't
- 22:42want to be stuck with harder
- 22:45things for Kentuckians. And
- 22:47that's kind of what it's
- 22:48looking like if we stick to a
- 22:50higher standard with more
- 22:51regular certifications, higher
- 22:54co-pays than what is required,
- 22:56and then the federal government
- 22:57chooses to walk that back. I
- 22:59really don't want to see
- 23:00Kentuckians stuck with the
- 23:01higher and harder things.
- 23:03>> Yes. Senator Cassie Chambers
- 23:05Armstrong, I'll let you chime
- 23:06in here about House Bill two.
- 23:08And this is the Medicaid reform
- 23:10effort.
- 23:14>> Sure. So there are a couple
- 23:15of things in House Bill two, as
- 23:17it came to our Chamber that
- 23:19concerned me. Co-Pays always
- 23:20concern me, even when we're
- 23:21talking about low co-pays, $20,
- 23:25$35 for low income folks who
- 23:27are trying to decide whether or
- 23:29not to take a sick child to the
- 23:31doctor, $20.30 $5 can
- 23:33absolutely influence that
- 23:34choice, and sometimes not
- 23:35seeking that care can lead to
- 23:37higher costs in the long run.
- 23:39Also, I just believe that any
- 23:40parent dealing with a sick
- 23:41child shouldn't have to make
- 23:42choices about whether or not to
- 23:44seek medical care for that
- 23:45child based on their financial
- 23:47situation, and being worried if
- 23:48they're going to be able to
- 23:49afford that care or not. Also
- 23:51worried about the
- 23:52self-attestation provisions,
- 23:53the fact that it can be really
- 23:55hard when you don't have
- 23:56anything to prove a negative,
- 23:58to be able to say, I, I have
- 24:00nothing, but you can't produce
- 24:02documentation to show a lack of
- 24:04assets. And so that was a
- 24:05provision that concerned me. I
- 24:06will say we're at the point in
- 24:08session where bills are
- 24:10changing very, very quickly.
- 24:12And so I expect that when we
- 24:13see House Bill two tomorrow, we
- 24:15will see it change. And I just
- 24:17don't know if we're going to
- 24:18see it change in ways that I
- 24:20think are better or in ways
- 24:21that I think are worse. And so
- 24:23one of the challenges when we
- 24:25get to this point in session is
- 24:26trying to make those decisions
- 24:28on these big, impactful bills
- 24:29without the ability to consult
- 24:30with experts and consult with
- 24:32community and consult with all
- 24:34the different folks that we
- 24:34would normally like to sit down
- 24:36and have those conversations
- 24:37with. We have to make decisions
- 24:39really quickly, and it's
- 24:40challenging.
- 24:41>> Miss Morgan.
- 24:42>> Sure. Thanks, Renee. As to
- 24:43the Self-attestation
- 24:45requirement, I do think there's
- 24:46some help in House Bill two
- 24:48with regard to the department's
- 24:49ability and requirement under
- 24:50the legislation as it stands,
- 24:52to actually seek other sources
- 24:54to determine folks ongoing
- 24:57eligibility. I know there would
- 24:58be a partnership with the
- 25:00Social Security Administration
- 25:02to check that database, and
- 25:03there are countless others they
- 25:05are required to check, for
- 25:06example, lottery systems,
- 25:08correction systems, the Paris
- 25:10system to see if people are
- 25:12enrolled in other states. I
- 25:13think those are good measures.
- 25:15You know, ultimately, if there
- 25:16are people on the Medicaid
- 25:18rolls who shouldn't be there
- 25:19because they're living in
- 25:20another state, and yet the
- 25:22taxpayers are paying a
- 25:23capitated payment for that
- 25:25person, you know, that really
- 25:26is taking money from people who
- 25:28are on the Medicaid system, who
- 25:30are beneficiaries of that
- 25:31system and really need that
- 25:33payment. So I think those are
- 25:35really important parts of the
- 25:36bill. There are also some kind
- 25:38of intricate pieces that I
- 25:40think are helpful to the system.
- 25:42For example, for our waiver
- 25:44programs, our waiver programs
- 25:46often operate on waitlists, as
- 25:48anyone who's gone to utilize
- 25:49those services know, those
- 25:51waitlists are long. They're
- 25:53difficult. When you have
- 25:54someone who really is in need
- 25:55of waiver services to wait for
- 25:57those spots to open up. And
- 25:59House Bill two creates a tiered
- 26:00system so that there would be
- 26:02an emergency status available
- 26:05to people to utilize those
- 26:06waiver slots and create some
- 26:09requirements for utilizing
- 26:10those slots that really should
- 26:11be beneficial to that program,
- 26:13which often stays logjammed. So
- 26:15I would caution anyone who's
- 26:17discussing House Bill two to
- 26:18not throw the baby out with the
- 26:20bathwater, because there's a
- 26:21lot in here that's really
- 26:22helpful, even including a
- 26:23Medicaid impact statement on
- 26:26new legislation that might
- 26:27impact the cost of the Medicaid
- 26:29system or even enrollment
- 26:30within the Medicaid system,
- 26:31that people really have to
- 26:33consider the system as a whole
- 26:34when they touch Medicaid. And I
- 26:36think it's particularly
- 26:37interesting, having worked at
- 26:38Medicaid, there's a requirement
- 26:40that new administrative
- 26:41regulations would have to go
- 26:42before mo.ab, 30 days before
- 26:45they're filed with the regs
- 26:46compiler, which honestly should
- 26:47help regulations move along
- 26:50more quickly. If that input or
- 26:53insight is already taken into
- 26:54account by the time a
- 26:56regulation is filed.
- 26:57>> Along those lines of public
- 26:58assistance, we've gotten this
- 27:00question has the Kentucky
- 27:01General Assembly addressed
- 27:02funding and cost sharing
- 27:03concerns related to
- 27:04administering Snap funding for
- 27:06programs like Summer E, B, t
- 27:08and senior meals, especially
- 27:09after last year's challenges
- 27:10with federal funding and
- 27:12disruption of services. Mr.
- 27:14chairman.
- 27:14>> Yes, I think that I'll touch
- 27:15on the the first piece first,
- 27:17and then what they're talking
- 27:18about is the SNAP
- 27:19administration costs. And
- 27:20there's two components to this.
- 27:21The first is the administrative
- 27:23fee. So the federal government
- 27:24has changed the amount of
- 27:25reimbursement they will provide
- 27:26to the state for administering
- 27:28it. That was fully funded in
- 27:30the House budget. That's also
- 27:31fully funded in the Senate
- 27:32budget, and you'll see it
- 27:34emerge fully funded. And this
- 27:35one, the second portion of this
- 27:36is what's called the SNAP error
- 27:38rate. And this is a calculation
- 27:40from the USDA regarding how
- 27:42much an over or under payment
- 27:44that we're making throughout
- 27:45the system based off of an
- 27:46audit that they will conduct.
- 27:48The current audit places us in
- 27:50a very problematic space,
- 27:51because we have too much error
- 27:53inside of our SNAP system.
- 27:54We're assured from the
- 27:56administration that they have
- 27:57corrected those problems and
- 27:58that they are getting the error
- 27:59rate under control prior to it
- 28:01actually being implemented. The
- 28:02good thing is, it appears that
- 28:04it won't hit inside of this
- 28:06biennial budget. But if they
- 28:08are not correct and they have
- 28:09not brought it under control,
- 28:11then in the next biennial
- 28:12budget, it could be very
- 28:13problematic because you could
- 28:15be looking at several hundred
- 28:16million dollars in expense to
- 28:18the Commonwealth. But frankly,
- 28:21it's a program that the federal
- 28:22government needs to bring under
- 28:24control. And the fact that you
- 28:26can have states with error
- 28:27rates, some as high as 20%
- 28:29inside of this program, really
- 28:31speaks volumes to the lack of
- 28:34controls that are existing. And
- 28:36frankly, these are taxpayer
- 28:37dollars. And in the federal
- 28:39government's case, these are
- 28:41taxpayers, children and
- 28:42grandchildren's dollars before
- 28:43they even start paying taxes.
- 28:44And so, you know, the idea of
- 28:46bringing accountability and
- 28:48responsibility into the system
- 28:49isn't a bad one. And sometimes
- 28:50that gets painful on state
- 28:52budgets, but nothing will
- 28:54influence people more quickly
- 28:55than to begin to have to pay
- 28:57out of their state budget. And
- 28:58I think that you're seeing that
- 29:00across the nation right now.
- 29:01>> Where is Kentucky's error
- 29:03rate?
- 29:03>> I think that we were around
- 29:048%. But my understanding is I
- 29:06believe we're down under six
- 29:08now is what the administration.
- 29:09>> Burke, I think you mentioned
- 29:11this or talked about the error
- 29:12rate. It could be underpayment
- 29:14overpayment. Not exactly sure
- 29:15where the error is coming.
- 29:17Right, right.
- 29:17>> It can be so many different
- 29:20things. The rate that was just
- 29:22quoted is higher than what I've
- 29:23heard. And so that makes me
- 29:25concerned that.
- 29:27>> Who's giving that rate,
- 29:28who's, who's making that
- 29:29determination and where that
- 29:31where is that number coming
- 29:32from?
- 29:32>> Well, the USDA is doing so
- 29:35at the federal level, but then
- 29:36we also have to have internal
- 29:38controls so that we're not
- 29:39sitting ducks getting terrible
- 29:41news. So within the state, the
- 29:44office of the State Budget
- 29:45director keeps an eye on that,
- 29:46making sure that C, h s is
- 29:49operating that program
- 29:51efficiently. So I hope that the
- 29:53number I'm hearing, which is
- 29:55closer to 4%, is where we are.
- 29:57If it's not, we need to
- 29:59definitely get that under
- 30:00control.
- 30:01>> Let's talk about the senior
- 30:02Mills. That was the second part
- 30:04of the question. How is that
- 30:05being addressed in this budget?
- 30:06As we understand it right now.
- 30:08>> We're optimistic that the
- 30:09budget that we put out fully
- 30:11funds senior meals. You know,
- 30:12we had a very a difference with
- 30:14the administration in the last
- 30:15budget. And we went with their
- 30:17recommendation. And it turned
- 30:18out that the higher number that
- 30:19we had was the correct number.
- 30:22And so we think that that's
- 30:23been corrected. And we think
- 30:24that it's fully funded at this
- 30:26point.
- 30:26>> Any comment on that? And,
- 30:28Senator Chambers Armstrong,
- 30:28I'll have you jump in here on
- 30:30either the SNAP or the senior
- 30:32meals.
- 30:35>> I think it's really great to
- 30:37hear that we're going to fully
- 30:39fund senior meals. It's
- 30:40obviously so important. I just
- 30:42believe that one of the things
- 30:43we should do as government is
- 30:45make sure that anyone who is at
- 30:46risk of going hungry has food.
- 30:49If there are programs that we
- 30:50can participate in at the
- 30:51federal level, let's do that.
- 30:52If there are ways we can
- 30:54deliver meals to seniors, let's
- 30:55do that. It does concern me the
- 30:57way that we see the federal
- 30:59government attacking a lot of
- 31:00these programs that so many
- 31:01Kentuckians depend on, and my
- 31:04hope is that we stand up for
- 31:06Kentuckians. We make sure that
- 31:07when the federal government is
- 31:08doing things that are going to
- 31:10hurt Kentuckians that we say
- 31:11that and we say that loudly.
- 31:13One thing that has concerned me
- 31:14in recent years is I've seen
- 31:16this General Assembly move
- 31:17towards giving a lot of its
- 31:19authority away to Washington,
- 31:21D.C. passing rules that say, we
- 31:22won't make any workplace safety
- 31:24regulations that are more
- 31:25strict than what Washington, DC
- 31:27says. We won't do anything
- 31:29beyond what Washington, DC says
- 31:31in this particular field. It
- 31:33worries me because I think this
- 31:35body is the best situated to
- 31:38know what Kentuckians need and
- 31:39how to meet those needs. That's
- 31:41why I'm really grateful for the
- 31:42budget process. It's a way for
- 31:44us to talk about the needs we
- 31:45see in our communities and make
- 31:47investments in those. And so my
- 31:48hope is that we, as the
- 31:50Kentucky General Assembly,
- 31:51continue to stand up for
- 31:52Kentuckians, stand up to
- 31:53Washington, DC when we need to
- 31:54do that and make sure we're
- 31:56meeting the needs that we see
- 31:57in our communities.
- 31:58>> This question from Adam
- 32:00Haley in Louisville. He says
- 32:02much has been made about
- 32:03attempts to grow Kentucky's
- 32:04workforce participation rate
- 32:05through benefits reform. What
- 32:07ideas are being implemented to
- 32:08encourage people to enter the
- 32:10workforce while mitigating or
- 32:11avoiding the benefits? Cliff
- 32:13effect that many low wage
- 32:15workers experience? Has that
- 32:16come up this session, Mr.
- 32:17Chairman?
- 32:18>> Yeah, absolutely.
- 32:19Particularly in the childcare
- 32:20space and some of the things
- 32:21that we're doing to help ensure
- 32:23that as people come off of
- 32:25public assistance, that they
- 32:26can move into the workforce
- 32:27because, frankly, it's an
- 32:29unfortunate reality where the
- 32:30federal government has created
- 32:31a system whereby for a lot of
- 32:33people, it makes more sense to
- 32:35not work. And that is a
- 32:37fundamental problem. Work gives
- 32:39balance to life. It gives
- 32:41meaning to life, it gives
- 32:42people purpose. And, you know,
- 32:43and there's a certain pride and
- 32:46self-sufficiency. And when the
- 32:47government provides such an
- 32:49economic incentive to not go to
- 32:51work every day, to not be
- 32:52economically self-sufficient,
- 32:54we do things to the population
- 32:55that are frankly unconscionable.
- 32:57And so helping people break
- 32:59that cycle, to get off of that
- 33:01dependency and into the
- 33:03workforce is very much on our
- 33:04minds. We do lots of things
- 33:05related to job training and
- 33:07helping people scale up so that
- 33:09they can earn more money. We do
- 33:10things related to childcare,
- 33:12trying to work around solutions
- 33:13related to the health care
- 33:14space and all those things to
- 33:16make sure that people can
- 33:18successfully transition into
- 33:19the productive employment space
- 33:21of society.
- 33:22>> Yeah, Miss Tyler, and maybe
- 33:23give us a working definition of
- 33:24what a benefits Cliff is.
- 33:26Perhaps.
- 33:27>> So the benefits, Cliff Renee,
- 33:28is when someone is coming up in
- 33:31their working life to the point
- 33:33where they're earning so much
- 33:35that they have to come off of
- 33:36benefits, but they're still not
- 33:38earning enough to really get by
- 33:39in today's economy. And so they
- 33:41fall off what we call a
- 33:43benefits click. They're making
- 33:44just enough to where they don't
- 33:46qualify for benefits, but they
- 33:47really still need some support
- 33:50because they're not making
- 33:51enough to sustain themselves to
- 33:52the level that we would like
- 33:54for them to be able to in
- 33:55today's economy. I do think
- 33:57there are several bills that
- 33:58are aimed at workforce. To
- 34:00Adam's point, we do have House
- 34:02resolution 126 right now, which
- 34:04is aimed at asking the federal
- 34:06government to provide
- 34:07flexibility to a state like
- 34:09Kentucky in addressing the
- 34:11benefit cliff, which I think
- 34:12would be incredible for
- 34:13Kentucky to be able to do.
- 34:14Obviously, we are somewhat
- 34:16pinned in by the federal
- 34:17government on certain health
- 34:19care programs. So seeking
- 34:22flexibility to allow us to be
- 34:23innovative would be great. We
- 34:25have a lot of workforce bills
- 34:27in the health care space,
- 34:30including we have the expansion
- 34:32of the health care credential
- 34:33for the workforce program, and
- 34:36that was for particularly
- 34:38speech language pathologists
- 34:40and audiologists. And I think
- 34:43it's really important to think
- 34:44about the spectrum of people
- 34:46who are able to benefit from
- 34:49that health care workforce
- 34:50program. I know we also have
- 34:53you spoke of SNAP. We had
- 34:56unanimous approval of this SNAP
- 34:58employment and training program,
- 35:00which creates individualized
- 35:02plans for people who are
- 35:03benefiting from the Snap
- 35:04program to be able to enter the
- 35:07workforce and to be able to
- 35:08utilize the Snap program
- 35:10effectively. So I've seen a lot
- 35:11of legislation coming through
- 35:13that isn't discussed as often,
- 35:14but is really important when it
- 35:16comes to our state's workforce.
- 35:17>> We've gotten a couple of
- 35:18questions about the 13th check,
- 35:20Mr. Chairman, or a cost of
- 35:22living adjustment for state
- 35:25retirees, public workers. Tell
- 35:26us about what's what's there.
- 35:27>> Yeah. So, you know, the
- 35:29conversation about what to do
- 35:30with state employee retirement
- 35:32plans that have been working on
- 35:36recovery for quite a long time
- 35:37now continues to go along. I
- 35:39would say the 13th check will
- 35:40probably be more one of the
- 35:42more problematic issues as this
- 35:44rolls out. It is an ongoing
- 35:47conversation. It's something
- 35:47that I think every member of
- 35:49the General Assembly wants to
- 35:50do something about. And so we
- 35:51have varying approaches as to
- 35:53what that looks like. Some
- 35:54folks would advocate for a Cola
- 35:56or a cost of living adjustment,
- 35:57which is very, very expensive.
- 35:59Some advocate for a 13th check,
- 36:01you know, and those
- 36:02conversations I would
- 36:03anticipate will continue on as
- 36:05we move forward.
- 36:06>> And you only really have two
- 36:07more days, Mr. Chairman. So you
- 36:09see reconciliation on that.
- 36:10>> I you know, it probably will
- 36:12not be something that you see
- 36:13included in a final product.
- 36:15>> And so that means it's dead
- 36:16if it's not included in a final
- 36:18project product.
- 36:19>> Quite possibly.
- 36:20>> So. Quite possibly. So do
- 36:21you have any comment on that?
- 36:23Representative Burke.
- 36:24>> I do, I think it's a real
- 36:25shame that we won't be able to
- 36:27use the Budget Reserve Trust
- 36:28Fund to at least do a one time
- 36:3113th check for retirees with
- 36:33the cost of living being what
- 36:35it is right now, I was I'm
- 36:36driving to Frankfurt all the
- 36:38time. So $4 a gallon gas is
- 36:41eating up our budget, and then
- 36:43we go to the grocery store. And
- 36:45what used to be a $200 a week
- 36:47spend is now closer to $300 a
- 36:49week. And that's not any
- 36:51different for retirees. So the
- 36:53fact of the matter is they
- 36:54haven't had an adjustment in
- 36:56more than a decade. And right
- 36:58now, they're really the ones
- 37:00that were balancing our budget
- 37:02on the backs of that's not fair,
- 37:04because they've done their
- 37:05service for the state of
- 37:06Kentucky, and they really
- 37:08deserve that 13th check. I
- 37:10believe that of the $2.5
- 37:12billion it seems we're going to
- 37:13have remaining in that budget
- 37:15reserve trust fund that we
- 37:17could afford. Is it 80 million?
- 37:19I think, for the 13 million
- 37:22check? So we have it. And our
- 37:25decision not to spend it, I
- 37:26think is disrespectful to
- 37:28retirees.
- 37:29>> So that could come in the
- 37:30form of House Bill 900. If
- 37:32using it as one time money, is
- 37:34that a likely avenue for a 13th
- 37:37check if it can even get there?
- 37:38>> Well, I think I have to
- 37:40disagree with the fundamental
- 37:41mischaracterization of
- 37:42balancing the budget on the
- 37:43backs of this, because there is
- 37:45no area inside of the budget
- 37:47outside of Medicaid that is
- 37:48seen as much investment from
- 37:50the Kentucky General Assembly
- 37:51as the underfunding of the
- 37:53retirement systems, both both
- 37:54the teachers retirement system
- 37:55and the Kentucky Retirement
- 37:57System. When when I came to
- 37:59Frankfort, you know, 12 years
- 38:01ago, this Commonwealth was
- 38:04bordering. If there was one
- 38:05financial anomaly, we very well
- 38:07might have defaulted on pension
- 38:10payments to the pensioners. And
- 38:12we had to do some very, very,
- 38:13very difficult things on the
- 38:15front end and also on the
- 38:17financial end and the the rapid
- 38:20acceleration of the funding of
- 38:21those pension plans is
- 38:23something that we should all be
- 38:25very proud of and making sure
- 38:26that the base level pension
- 38:28that was committed can still be
- 38:29paid. And so while it might not
- 38:33be everything that everyone
- 38:34wants, the Commonwealth's
- 38:35budget is certainly not
- 38:37balanced on that necessarily.
- 38:39And the additional dollars that
- 38:40we are putting in are taking us
- 38:42into a place where someday we
- 38:43will be able to have these
- 38:45conversations and ideally, more
- 38:46regularly. I think everyone
- 38:47would like to see us where we
- 38:48can return to a point of having
- 38:51regular cost of living
- 38:52adjustments. But part of the
- 38:53reason that we ended up in this
- 38:55space in the first place is
- 38:57General Assembly's. Prior to
- 38:58either of us showing up in
- 39:00Frankfurt. Granted Colas
- 39:02without ever preparing to pay
- 39:03for those colas, and they left
- 39:05an absolute mess for us to have
- 39:08to deal with. Which we have.
- 39:10And while people may not like
- 39:11every decision that we have to
- 39:13make, they have to realize that
- 39:15those are the hard decisions
- 39:16that we have to make. And
- 39:19truthfully, but for the modern
- 39:21version of the Kentucky General
- 39:22Assembly since about 2014, we
- 39:24very well could have been in a
- 39:26position of not making pension
- 39:28payments. And that's the real
- 39:29story here.
- 39:30>> Yeah. Senator Chambers
- 39:31Armstrong, do you care to
- 39:32comment on Colas or the 13th
- 39:34check for state retirees?
- 39:40>> Sure. I thought the Senate
- 39:41proposal made a lot of sense. I
- 39:43thought it was a nice, balanced
- 39:45approach with sort of different
- 39:49gradations of a 13th check
- 39:50based on when folks retired.
- 39:51I'm sad to hear that it's not
- 39:53in the final budget, but I hope
- 39:55that we'll continue the
- 39:56conversation and will continue.
- 39:57I will continue to advocate for
- 39:59that in future budgets.
- 40:00>> I do want to make a pivot
- 40:02now. The time flies so fast.
- 40:03Senate Bill 185 that this is
- 40:06the. I want to ask you to
- 40:08characterize it, Mr. Chairman.
- 40:09Is it a rescue plan for
- 40:11Kentucky State University or is
- 40:13it a state takeover? Because
- 40:14I've heard both descriptions.
- 40:16How would you describe this
- 40:17plan for Kentucky State
- 40:19University?
- 40:19>> I would describe this plan
- 40:21as the most optimistic, forward
- 40:25looking plan that Kentucky
- 40:26State University has seen in a
- 40:28generation. I would describe
- 40:30this as a transformational plan
- 40:34to ensure that the students who
- 40:36receive a degree from Kentucky
- 40:37State University are receiving
- 40:38a degree that when they walk
- 40:40out, that workforce will bring
- 40:43them the maximum earnings
- 40:45potential that they can
- 40:46possibly have. And I would say
- 40:49that Senate Bill 185 will be
- 40:51something that we will look
- 40:52back on and say, that was the
- 40:55day that Kentucky State really
- 40:58took a turn for the positive.
- 40:59And I could not be more excited
- 41:01about what Senate Bill 185 is
- 41:03going to do. On behalf of the
- 41:05students of Kentucky State
- 41:06University.
- 41:07>> So this would transition the
- 41:08mission to be a polytechnic
- 41:11institution, which focuses on
- 41:12work study programs and science
- 41:15technology engineering type
- 41:17programs. Some are concerned
- 41:18that it puts the HBCU
- 41:20designation in jeopardy. Will K
- 41:22State, as we call it, remain a
- 41:24historically black college
- 41:26university?
- 41:26>> Absolutely. Kentucky State
- 41:27will be an HBCU in this General
- 41:30Assembly, since I have been
- 41:32here, has maintained its
- 41:33commitment to a public HBCU
- 41:36inside of the Commonwealth. It
- 41:37is important. It is important
- 41:39that we have a vibrant and
- 41:41successful HBCU in the
- 41:43Commonwealth and Senate. Bill
- 41:45185 not only will ensure that
- 41:47we have an HBCU, but it will be
- 41:49the best HBCU in the nation.
- 41:51>> What are the benchmarks that
- 41:52you'll be using to grade its
- 41:54progress, and will there be a
- 41:55time determined where you'll
- 41:56say, time is up for K State to
- 41:58be what we know it to be now?
- 42:00>> Sure. So this is a five year
- 42:02plan to transition into a
- 42:04polytechnic institution. And so
- 42:06there there will be teach outs
- 42:07for the existing on campus
- 42:09liberal arts programs. But K
- 42:11State has to its been to its
- 42:15credit, invested very heavily
- 42:16in online learning, and they're
- 42:18beginning to see some success
- 42:19in that space. They're
- 42:20beginning to see some revenue
- 42:21driven in that space. And we're
- 42:23going to help them double down
- 42:24in the online learning space.
- 42:25>> Because that's where all the
- 42:27liberal arts program offerings
- 42:28will be. They'll be moved to
- 42:29online. Is that correct?
- 42:30>> With the exception of the
- 42:32education program, yes. Now
- 42:33there will still be liberal
- 42:34arts offerings on campus as it
- 42:36relates to the attainment of a
- 42:38degree inside of the
- 42:39polytechnic mission. But yes,
- 42:41the the actual degree
- 42:43completion will move online for
- 42:44liberal arts. And this is not
- 42:46necessarily atypical in
- 42:48university spaces around the
- 42:50nation. And really in Kentucky,
- 42:51you need to look no further
- 42:52than the University of the
- 42:54Cumberlands and the success
- 42:55that they have seen. I mean,
- 42:56they really are driving a
- 42:59vibrant on campus experience
- 43:01via their online offerings. And
- 43:04I believe that Kentucky State
- 43:05will do the same.
- 43:06>> There was some concern that
- 43:08was mentioned by one of your
- 43:09colleagues, Democrat Couture
- 43:10Heavrin, about some of the
- 43:12academic entrance requirements,
- 43:13the GPA of 2.5 and the college
- 43:17entrance exam composite of of
- 43:2018. Concerned that that might
- 43:22lock some kids out perhaps who
- 43:23do not test well. Do you want
- 43:25to comment on why those
- 43:26academic standards were
- 43:28instituted?
- 43:28>> Absolutely. Because if
- 43:30you're going to produce the
- 43:32best, you need to recruit the
- 43:33best. And that's what Kentucky
- 43:34State is committed to doing
- 43:36their leadership. The
- 43:37leadership of the Council on
- 43:38Post-Secondary Education is
- 43:40committed to making sure that
- 43:41we recruit the best into
- 43:42Kentucky State University,
- 43:44because the. Via that we will
- 43:46produce the best. We have a
- 43:48robust system to help young
- 43:50people to achieve high
- 43:52standards, both in the K-12
- 43:54system and then afterwards. So
- 43:56if people are finding
- 43:57themselves not able to meet
- 43:58those standards, then there
- 43:59will be opportunities for them
- 44:00to raise themselves up and do
- 44:02it. But we but to get into an
- 44:04institution of a higher
- 44:06institution of higher learning,
- 44:08there should be high standards
- 44:10and Kentucky State should not
- 44:11be relegated to an institution
- 44:13that accepts mediocrity. I
- 44:14don't think that they will, and
- 44:16I don't think they will produce
- 44:17it either.
- 44:18>> Senator Chambers Armstrong,
- 44:19I want to come to you to ask
- 44:21your opinion about Senate Bill
- 44:22185, on which you voted just
- 44:23last week on because some have
- 44:25also described Kentucky State
- 44:26University not just as a land
- 44:28grant and not just as an HBCU,
- 44:30but also Frankfurt's higher ed
- 44:33institution that the city takes
- 44:34pride in. Kentucky State
- 44:35University, your thoughts about
- 44:37this measure?
- 44:40>> Yeah, I think we all take
- 44:42pride in Kentucky State
- 44:43University, and I am rooting
- 44:45for K state. I think everyone
- 44:47is rooting for Kentucky state.
- 44:50I'll be honest, when I first
- 44:51saw the bill, I had a lot of
- 44:53questions. I was not as
- 44:55familiar with some of the prior
- 44:56conversations and the work of
- 44:57this General Assembly, and
- 44:58really the question at one
- 45:00point as to whether it was
- 45:01going to continue as an
- 45:02educational institution in the
- 45:04Commonwealth. But I had
- 45:07conversations with our leader,
- 45:09Senator Neal, who is the
- 45:10biggest advocate for Kentucky
- 45:12State that you will find. He is
- 45:13an alumni. He is dedicated to
- 45:15the program, and I know that he
- 45:18worked closely with Chair
- 45:19McDaniel, and he worked closely
- 45:20with all of the stakeholders.
- 45:21And I think when you see
- 45:23everyone coming to the table,
- 45:24all the different stakeholders
- 45:25from the administration, from
- 45:27Kentucky, State, you had Louder
- 45:29Neal from the Democratic Caucus,
- 45:31you had chair McDaniel all
- 45:33working together in good faith
- 45:34to figure out what can we do to
- 45:37help Kentucky State continue
- 45:38into the future? There are
- 45:40still some things in the bill
- 45:42that, you know, I have
- 45:46questions about, and a lot of
- 45:47it's going to be how are they
- 45:49implemented? But I believe that
- 45:51this is going to lead to
- 45:54Kentucky State continuing as an
- 45:56educational institution, as an
- 45:58HBCU. I'm really glad that this
- 46:00bill also came with a
- 46:02commitment of funding for
- 46:03Kentucky. State. And so I'm
- 46:06excited to see how all of this
- 46:08plays out.
- 46:09>> So the President of Kentucky
- 46:11State University, President
- 46:12Akakpo, he actually sent out an
- 46:13email to alumni who have been
- 46:16voicing a lot of their concerns.
- 46:17And he says, and this is
- 46:19emboldened in the letter he
- 46:20sent, he said, let me be clear,
- 46:22no current student will be
- 46:23forced to transfer. All current
- 46:25majors will continue for
- 46:26enrolled students. We are not
- 46:28becoming a community or two
- 46:30year institution. We will have
- 46:32more than 1000 students, maybe
- 46:33more on that. Our band,
- 46:36athletics, student
- 46:37organizations, fraternities and
- 46:38sororities will remain. I want
- 46:40some clarity on that. And our
- 46:42HBCU culture remains central to
- 46:44who we are. A couple of those
- 46:46points when it comes to
- 46:47sororities and fraternities,
- 46:49there is some language that
- 46:50would require them to reapply,
- 46:52so perhaps you can clarify
- 46:54where that stands.
- 46:55>> Yeah. So I mean, the they
- 46:57will have to reapply. I think
- 46:59that President Akapo is
- 47:01genuinely committed to, I think
- 47:03seeing all of them return. But
- 47:05some of the issues that we saw
- 47:06surrounding Kentucky State
- 47:07dealt with some off site
- 47:09fraternity parties. President
- 47:10Akapo has already removed that
- 47:12fraternity from the campus, and
- 47:13we just want to make sure that
- 47:15there are maximum there is
- 47:16maximum flexibility to weed out
- 47:18bad actors because we will not
- 47:20tolerate anything less than
- 47:21excellence. And President Akapo
- 47:24is committed to that. The
- 47:25General Assembly is committed
- 47:26to being president, his partner
- 47:28in that. And if there is a
- 47:31problematic area, we're going
- 47:33to give him the ability to
- 47:34address it, and we don't want
- 47:36there to be we want there to be
- 47:38a vibrant fraternity and
- 47:39sorority life that is part of
- 47:41the overall environment. But if
- 47:42there are some who cannot abide
- 47:44by the standards that are
- 47:46expected, then we want to give
- 47:47them the ability to deal with
- 47:48that.
- 47:49>> On the thousand student. Is
- 47:51that a threshold? Is that the
- 47:53floor or the ceiling?
- 47:54>> It's actually just a marker
- 47:56because the there was a there
- 47:57was an amendment that we put on
- 47:58there saying that the the
- 48:00faculty and staff that we
- 48:01retained would be retained with
- 48:03a target of 1000 students or
- 48:05more. So as the restructuring
- 48:08of the university must occur,
- 48:11you have to have some type of a
- 48:13marker from the General
- 48:14Assembly. So certainly right
- 48:16now it's our understanding
- 48:17there's about 1000 residential
- 48:19students engaged, although
- 48:19there are more going to school
- 48:21on campus, but about 1000
- 48:23residential students right now.
- 48:24So look, I would like to see
- 48:26Kentucky State grow and thrive
- 48:27well beyond that number, but we
- 48:29have to be realistic about what
- 48:31a transition looks like and
- 48:32provide some targets. And that
- 48:33was the target we chose.
- 48:35>> I want to have you,
- 48:36Representative Burke, to weigh
- 48:37in on this. I'm sure you've
- 48:39seen, or at least you've read
- 48:40enough about Senate Bill 185 to
- 48:42get the gist of it. What are
- 48:43your thoughts?
- 48:44>> Well, I'm glad to hear that
- 48:46the Divine Nine will be able to
- 48:47re-apply to come stay on Ksuz
- 48:50campus, because one of the
- 48:51things that attracts students
- 48:52to an HBCU is the network. It's
- 48:55being able to be part of a
- 48:56community that's larger than
- 48:57just the students who are there.
- 48:59And joining a fraternity or
- 49:01sorority is how you gain those
- 49:03lifelong relationships that
- 49:04help you succeed as a
- 49:06professional. Additionally, I
- 49:07was really glad to see that the
- 49:09Thoroughbred Marching Band is
- 49:10staying in place. I was a band
- 49:12nerd myself, and I know that
- 49:13that's a huge part of many
- 49:16students enjoyment of college.
- 49:18So those are all good things as
- 49:21far as I can tell. I also was
- 49:23really happy with the
- 49:25commitment to teach out
- 49:26students whose majors may be
- 49:28coming to an end. So I didn't
- 49:29know what Teach Out meant. But
- 49:31that means that if you've
- 49:32started a degree program, you
- 49:34can finish that degree that
- 49:35you've started, you're not
- 49:36going to be forced into some
- 49:37different area of study. I
- 49:39think that really matters. The
- 49:41one thing I would push back on
- 49:43is the issue of Act scores. The
- 49:46best countries, sorry, the best
- 49:48schools in the country are
- 49:49going away from standardized
- 49:51testing. So it's not a
- 49:53benchmark that lots of schools
- 49:55are using across the nation.
- 49:57We're seeing many of the most
- 49:59elite institutions step away
- 50:00from that. And so I'm not sure
- 50:02that it's going to yield the
- 50:04result that we're hoping for.
- 50:06But we'll see with further
- 50:08analysis.
- 50:09>> And there's quite a bit, I
- 50:10think most $100 million and
- 50:11more funding to K State may not
- 50:13all be reflected in House Bill
- 50:15500, but in other ways.
- 50:16Proposed $50 million for the
- 50:18Health Sciences Facility. 3
- 50:19million for expanded academic
- 50:20and workforce alignment
- 50:22programs. 50 million in
- 50:23infrastructure and asset
- 50:24preservation funding, 2 million
- 50:25for growth and online and
- 50:27innovative program delivery.
- 50:29>> Yes. So two of those items
- 50:30are still being finalized.
- 50:32That's the asset preservation.
- 50:33So you'll see a very large
- 50:35asset preservation number that
- 50:36will occur in House Bill 500.
- 50:40But we're still finalizing the
- 50:41list of what asset preservation
- 50:42actually looks like at Kentucky
- 50:44State. So it will have some
- 50:45variance there. And then also
- 50:46the money for the polytechnic
- 50:48transition, just getting our
- 50:49arms around what that looks
- 50:50like. Exactly. But the General
- 50:52Assembly intends to be a
- 50:52partner with Kentucky State.
- 50:54And that that means in ensuring
- 50:57that they have high standards,
- 50:58but also ensuring that they
- 50:59have the funding to meet those
- 51:01high standards. And I very much
- 51:02agree with Representative Burke
- 51:03one of the best things that can
- 51:05happen in college is for a
- 51:06young person to engage in an
- 51:08activity outside of the
- 51:09academic environment that
- 51:10forces them to learn teamwork
- 51:11and time management and
- 51:14self-discipline and all of
- 51:15those things that are essential,
- 51:16that aren't taught necessarily
- 51:17in the classroom. But they come
- 51:19by challenging yourself to do
- 51:21things outside of the classroom.
- 51:22And, you know, Doctor Akapo has
- 51:24maintained his commitment to
- 51:26those things throughout, and
- 51:28I'm very glad for it.
- 51:30>> Pivoting now, another
- 51:31question for you, Senator
- 51:32McDaniel. Where do we stand on
- 51:33reducing property tax for
- 51:35homeowners? What happened to
- 51:36that? There was such
- 51:37conversation about that before.
- 51:38Well.
- 51:38>> I think the real momentum in
- 51:40the General Assembly has
- 51:41remained around the idea of
- 51:42what do we do with income taxes?
- 51:44And we have absolutely
- 51:45maintained a focus on it. While
- 51:47it cannot be the sole focus of
- 51:49the budgeting process, it is
- 51:50certainly a focus because
- 51:52really that affects the the
- 51:54largest number of Kentuckians
- 51:58is the income tax, and we
- 51:59maintain our focus on that.
- 52:01>> Okay. A lot of questions
- 52:02about home housing and
- 52:04affordable housing. And is
- 52:05there additional money going to
- 52:07housing?
- 52:07>> Yes. You will see additional
- 52:08money in housing.
- 52:09>> Care to say how much? We'll
- 52:11see an additional money for
- 52:12housing. Do we.
- 52:13>> Know what it will be north
- 52:15of $20 million?
- 52:15>> Okay. Do you think that's
- 52:17adequate?
- 52:17>> I think it's absolutely
- 52:18better than zero. So I'm happy
- 52:20to hear that there is an
- 52:21earmark for some housing needs.
- 52:23The Budget Reserve Trust fund,
- 52:25hopefully is where we're going
- 52:26to put that 20 million. If we
- 52:28could do ten and ten, that
- 52:29would be great. I would
- 52:31absolutely love to see Senate
- 52:33Bill nine come to full fruition.
- 52:36I think that that was a really
- 52:38thoughtful piece of legislation.
- 52:40>> Senate Bill.
- 52:40>> Nine, Senate Bill nine is
- 52:42about matching infrastructure,
- 52:43infrastructure, dollars with
- 52:44housing developments, because
- 52:46one of the most expensive
- 52:47things about building
- 52:48neighborhoods is putting in
- 52:50fire hydrants and all the
- 52:52utilities that are necessary.
- 52:54So that, I think, was a stroke
- 52:55of genius. I wish we could have
- 52:57built out further and had a
- 53:00much more robust housing
- 53:02package. I think we just didn't
- 53:03quite get there this session.
- 53:04And the few things that we're
- 53:06doing are great, and I'm glad
- 53:07we're working on them. But we
- 53:09need about ten more tools in
- 53:10the toolkit.
- 53:11>> Yeah, okay. And three
- 53:13minutes remaining. And I hate
- 53:14to shortchange this, this topic,
- 53:16but we have had some questions
- 53:17about the judicial branch
- 53:18budget, House Bill 504. And
- 53:21there's been some concern about
- 53:22possible furloughs, some
- 53:25layoffs, the elimination or
- 53:26reduction of specialty courts,
- 53:28whether that's the drug, mental
- 53:29health or veterans courts. What
- 53:31can you tell us about that,
- 53:33Chairman McDaniel?
- 53:34>> Well, you know, I think that
- 53:35you will see some changes in
- 53:37the final product that the
- 53:39courts will like, but it won't
- 53:41be everything that they like.
- 53:42We think the courts really need
- 53:43to take a hard look. We've
- 53:45heard a lot of complaints,
- 53:46frankly, from within the court
- 53:47system about administrative
- 53:48bloat, and they're going to
- 53:49need to take a hard look at
- 53:51those. We've also heard that
- 53:52there's a reluctance to
- 53:54implement cost saving
- 53:55technologies. And finally,
- 53:56we've heard complaints that
- 53:58potentially they're delving the
- 53:59courts into areas that they're
- 54:00not statutorily enabled. And so
- 54:03we really hope that the court
- 54:05system will take a hard look at
- 54:07those, be a partner with the
- 54:08General Assembly and helping
- 54:09for the provision of justice.
- 54:11There is nothing more important
- 54:13that a society does than
- 54:14provide for justice for its
- 54:16citizens. And the courts are at
- 54:17the front line of that, and we
- 54:19really want to be partners with
- 54:20them in that. But we want them
- 54:22to be efficient partners in
- 54:23that. And we're optimistic that
- 54:24this budget will reflect our
- 54:26commitment, but also our
- 54:27challenge to the courts of
- 54:29meeting us there.
- 54:30>> Senator Chambers Armstrong,
- 54:31I'll give you a minute or so to
- 54:33chime in on your thoughts about
- 54:34House Bill 504 and what you'd
- 54:36like to see the final product
- 54:37look like.
- 54:41>> Yeah, I think fully funding
- 54:42our judicial system is one of
- 54:44the most important things that
- 54:45we can do as a legislative body.
- 54:47Most people don't realize how
- 54:48important the court system is
- 54:50until you are facing something
- 54:52in the courts, like losing your
- 54:53home, like possibly losing your
- 54:55children, like trying to get a
- 54:56domestic violence protective
- 54:57order to keep yourself and your
- 54:59family safe. I'm particularly
- 55:01hopeful that we will be able to
- 55:02fully fund our specialty courts.
- 55:04For folks who don't know what
- 55:05those are, those are courts
- 55:06designed to administer justice,
- 55:09specifically targeted at, say,
- 55:11veterans and people with
- 55:12substance use disorders, family
- 55:14courts, domestic violence cases.
- 55:17There's a variety of ways that
- 55:18courts are innovating. And what
- 55:20we see when courts innovate is
- 55:21they deliver justice more
- 55:23effectively, more efficiently.
- 55:24It's a better experience. We
- 55:25get better outcomes. And so I'm
- 55:27really hopeful that we can fund
- 55:28those vitally important
- 55:30programs. I think it's the way
- 55:30that justice is headed in the
- 55:32future.
- 55:32>> Well, we thank you, Senator
- 55:35Cassie Chambers Armstrong, for
- 55:36being with us from Louisville,
- 55:37and we appreciate our panelists
- 55:38here tonight. And thank you so
- 55:40very much for being here. We'll
- 55:41be watching the budget as it
- 55:43continues to evolve, and you
- 55:44can watch all that coverage on
- 55:46k e t, either online at ket.org
- 55:49or on the Kentucky channel. We
- 55:50are here for you. You won't
- 55:52have to miss a thing. We will
- 55:54give it to you unfiltered and
- 55:55then join us again tomorrow
- 55:56night at 630 eastern, 530
- 55:58central on Kentucky edition,
- 55:59where we're going to break down
- 56:00what happens in the Kentucky
- 56:01General Assembly. I'll be
- 56:02reporting from Frankfort
- 56:03tomorrow and Wednesday as we
- 56:05enter the final days of the KY
- 56:08GA 2026. And then, of course,
- 56:10Bill Bryant and a team of
- 56:11working journalists will be
- 56:12here on Friday night to discuss
- 56:14the news of the week, including
- 56:15what happened in Frankfort that
- 56:16comes at you at eight eastern,
- 56:18seven central right here on KET.
- 56:19I'm Renee Shaw, thank you for
- 56:21watching and have a great rest
- 56:22of the week.
- 56:23[MUSIC]
- 56:23So long.